id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| text
stringlengths 190
2.08k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18312v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18312v1 | AI-native Memory: A Pathway from LLMs Towards AGI | 2024-06-26T12:51:37 | 2024-06-26T12:51:37 | Jingbo Shang, Zai Zheng, Xiang Ying, Felix Tao, Mindverse Team | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated the world with the sparks of
artificial general intelligence (AGI). One opinion, especially from some
startups working on LLMs, argues that an LLM with nearly unlimited context
length can realize AGI. However, they might be too optimistic about the
long-context capability of (existing) LLMs -- (1) Recent literature has shown
that their effective context length is significantly smaller than their claimed
context length; and (2) Our reasoning-in-a-haystack experiments further
demonstrate that simultaneously finding the relevant information from a long
context and conducting (simple) reasoning is nearly impossible. In this paper,
we envision a pathway from LLMs to AGI through the integration of
\emph{memory}. We believe that AGI should be a system where LLMs serve as core
processors. In addition to raw data, the memory in this system would store a
large number of important conclusions derived from reasoning processes.
Compared with retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) that merely processing raw
data, this approach not only connects semantically related information closer,
but also simplifies complex inferences at the time of querying. As an
intermediate stage, the memory will likely be in the form of natural language
descriptions, which can be directly consumed by users too. Ultimately, every
agent/person should have its own large personal model, a deep neural network
model (thus \emph{AI-native}) that parameterizes and compresses all types of
memory, even the ones cannot be described by natural languages. Finally, we
discuss the significant potential of AI-native memory as the transformative
infrastructure for (proactive) engagement, personalization, distribution, and
social in the AGI era, as well as the incurred privacy and security challenges
with preliminary solutions. | AI-native Memory: A Pathway from LLMs Towards AGI: Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated the world with the sparks of
artificial general intelligence (AGI). One opinion, especially from some
startups working on LLMs, argues that an LLM with nearly unlimited context
length can realize AGI. However, they might be too optimistic about the
long-context capability of (existing) LLMs -- (1) Recent literature has shown
that their effective context length is significantly smaller than their claimed
context length; and (2) Our reasoning-in-a-haystack experiments further
demonstrate that simultaneously finding the relevant information from a long
context and conducting (simple) reasoning is nearly impossible. In this paper,
we envision a pathway from LLMs to AGI through the integration of
\emph{memory}. We believe that AGI should be a system where LLMs serve as core
processors. In addition to raw data, the memory in this system would store a
large number of important conclusions derived from reasoning processes.
Compared with retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) that merely processing raw
data, this approach not only connects semantically related information closer,
but also simplifies complex inferences at the time of querying. As an
intermediate stage, the memory will likely be in the form of natural language
descriptions, which can be directly consumed by users too. Ultimately, every
agent/person should have its own large personal model, a deep neural network
model (thus \emph{AI-native}) that parameterizes and compresses all types of
memory, even the ones cannot be described by natural languages. Finally, we
discuss the significant potential of AI-native memory as the transformative
infrastructure for (proactive) engagement, personalization, distribution, and
social in the AGI era, as well as the incurred privacy and security challenges
with preliminary solutions. | [
0.0641116574,
0.0580641367,
-0.0434283502,
0.0353890024,
-0.0346714519,
-0.0207084864,
0.0206467733,
-0.0275378823,
0.0534948967,
-0.0236995779,
-0.0092641339,
-0.0440726206,
-0.014428284,
0.0521501824,
-0.0002601421,
-0.013085587,
0.0365698226,
-0.0146437651,
0.0346792452,
-0.00170614,
-0.0176900066,
0.018166611,
0.030671712,
0.0311543383,
-0.0303506963,
0.0007230401,
-0.0356683619,
-0.0109077059,
0.003849112,
-0.0301492792,
-0.0321442783,
-0.0025736939,
0.0457127914,
0.0325033031,
0.0000023685,
-0.0813021436,
0.0030223676,
-0.0019789839,
-0.0508481227,
-0.0159600191,
0.0120483888,
0.0531761348,
0.0057960236,
-0.0119539872,
-0.0603862554,
-0.0149774235,
0.0376050323,
0.0133817038,
0.0166366845,
0.0466303378,
-0.0153218666,
-0.0787590891,
0.0267626643,
-0.0240180604,
0.0495152324,
-0.0721336454,
0.012881388,
-0.0551332608,
0.0188581496,
0.0015295015,
0.0050878879,
0.0372743309,
0.0514789037,
0.0076353718,
0.0182089116,
0.0159432366,
-0.0133721502,
-0.0185049959,
-0.0089951791,
0.0435839668,
0.0466782972,
-0.0130118625,
0.0180559102,
0.0280374624,
0.0253848638,
0.0075168018,
-0.0219669603,
0.0764293,
-0.0451057777,
0.0050437413,
0.0224982165,
0.0101529509,
0.0365871042,
0.0326884463,
-0.0544601567,
0.0742663145,
-0.0207518358,
-0.0236692652,
0.0063173044,
-0.0120621743,
0.0123048862,
-0.0453786142,
0.0306069627,
0.0686870366,
-0.0053042881,
0.0302097797,
-0.0463014729,
-0.0040589268,
0.0087801293,
-0.044767499,
0.0058607743,
0.0261398535,
-0.0146641955,
0.0453122891,
-0.000755319,
0.0305930935,
-0.0351804495,
0.0000520962,
-0.0259332359,
-0.0506874584,
-0.0438615307,
-0.0228284579,
-0.0316976644,
0.0985480845,
-0.0254338142,
-0.023420142,
-0.0376705341,
0.0584261417,
-0.0231771301,
0.0236543734,
-0.0483692065,
0.0531346351,
-0.0304386802,
-0.0052793482,
-0.0676364154,
-0.0337598957,
-0.0800259039,
0.0013248718,
0.0338089727,
-0.0667266026,
0.0171876568,
-0.0011703178,
0.0275350437,
-0.0050179609,
0.0092746411,
0.0766500905,
0.0229496341,
-0.04004886,
-0.0835019425,
-0.0706228912,
0.0171020254,
-0.0743462294,
0.0037983956,
-0.0485275351,
0.0353846401,
0.0068902969,
-0.0279594269,
-0.071605213,
-0.00930099,
0.0304063447,
-0.0420771949,
0.0327042677,
0.0139571624,
-0.0005166855,
0.0602062121,
0.0433039367,
0.0501229167,
0.0121716568,
0.0353671722,
0.0557857044,
0.0514923781,
0.019885499,
0.0227322355,
-0.0152717512,
0.0213842299,
-0.0325807333,
-0.0127873141,
0.0108188819,
-0.0404463261,
-0.0041286135,
-0.0192653481,
0.0648584813,
0.001838588,
-0.0188923832,
0.0481692702,
0.1205351204,
-0.012953124,
0.0391781181,
0.0480351597,
0.0004535777,
0.0017695784,
-0.0162784047,
-0.0388930961,
0.0285214279,
-0.0589337423,
-0.0107091917,
0.0410960577,
0.0305866916,
-0.0432227924,
-0.0351092741,
0.018612247,
-0.0346503295,
0.0458635464,
0.0498153083,
0.0207831841,
0.0074743773,
0.0122078257,
-0.0125073278,
-0.0041458826,
-0.0474612489,
0.0132128354,
-0.0783535168,
0.042136997,
0.0956930295,
0.0330963656,
-0.0170640238,
0.0009931847,
0.0321344733,
-0.0286133345,
0.0314170048,
0.0235896148,
0.0070922673,
0.0128314449,
-0.0283208005,
-0.0000247423,
-0.0312928408,
0.0138008455,
0.0385210626,
0.0161853973,
0.026811637,
0.0266952217,
0.0111058662,
0.0104482016,
-0.0154327517,
-0.0318153128,
-0.0259596668,
-0.0038236727,
0.0235150456,
0.0227256007,
0.0409072191,
0.0159669593,
0.0086920904,
0.0332180224,
-0.0209805481,
-0.0351352505,
-0.0018176644,
-0.0477313735,
0.0641432032,
-0.0024199903,
-0.0037550931,
0.034272857,
-0.0183357522,
-0.0019714267,
-0.0570226349,
0.0366269313,
-0.0383047089,
0.0570017397,
-0.044259198,
0.0035666553,
-0.0085296268,
0.0154901771,
-0.0146864541,
0.0829657838,
-0.0111568244,
-0.0643283427,
-0.0043145274,
0.0379964449,
0.0272487737,
-0.0645878837,
-0.0221979953,
0.0075913775,
-0.0029563769,
0.0157335252,
0.0542680584,
-0.0197264161,
-0.0398119576,
0.0169711336,
-0.0917288288,
0.0189303178,
-0.0027993659,
-0.009001215,
-0.0171835292,
0.0458377972,
0.0170412604,
-0.0115989251,
-0.0651669651,
0.0353084467,
0.014816843,
0.02583028,
0.0302935261,
0.0498639792,
-0.002090252,
-0.0294163655,
0.0002606845,
-0.0102228234,
0.0274398308,
0.0217133984,
-0.0257595312,
-0.0208562668,
0.0098873628,
-0.0665372461,
0.0355703793,
-0.0180258546,
-0.0087488461,
0.0201859009,
-0.0399834141,
0.0132874968,
0.1092118472,
0.0046247859,
0.0468138941,
-0.0022191431,
-0.0126229003,
-0.0412287153,
0.0110331131,
-0.0131838424,
-0.0251405276,
-0.0243055634,
0.0095147211,
0.0199838113,
0.0521308705,
0.0162938088,
-0.0058836406,
-0.0531318486,
0.0514884591,
0.0108284121,
-0.0402554013,
-0.0256477781,
-0.0106255133,
-0.0007293736,
0.0596322976,
-0.0067944201,
-0.0608691275,
0.1023470759,
0.0193191711,
0.0346514843,
-0.0019267146,
-0.042774789,
-0.0350229815,
0.1002544239,
-0.0119078336,
0.0404348411,
-0.0130089726,
-0.0018783734,
-0.0249319058,
-0.0071612354,
-0.0233526304,
-0.0402760915,
0.0266504847,
-0.056387879,
0.0017940449,
0.0326393731,
-0.0525883362,
-0.0528700501,
-0.0033372766,
-0.0446855612,
-0.0110631166,
-0.004482931,
-0.0395402387,
-0.0362515338,
-0.0322816186,
0.0383767374,
0.0362548977,
0.0013180691,
-0.0199503247,
-0.0086213807,
-0.0230172221,
0.0246948265,
-0.0034937612,
-0.0125096347,
0.0155431023,
0.0235278346,
0.0728851035,
0.0322081409,
-0.0217492208,
0.0175351035,
-0.0065614963,
0.0149242319,
-0.0117398901,
-0.0582511164,
0.0455290228,
0.0214234199,
-0.0666066334,
-0.0482073091,
0.0836002156,
0.0281389616,
-0.0537387058,
-0.0060686837,
-0.0059605683,
0.0001311203,
0.0122733377,
0.035041213,
-0.0790769681,
-0.0070911334,
0.0055900263,
0.003123149,
-0.0373461209,
-0.0388167053,
-0.0281994287,
-0.1171124652,
-0.0064942902,
0.0036731677,
-0.0309588313,
-0.010239928,
-0.0169790257,
-0.0345819779,
0.0461240597,
-0.0051222369,
-0.0010420018,
0.0127486642,
-0.0315675028,
-0.0441866778,
-0.008955718,
-0.0056358851,
0.0282657929,
-0.0453717932,
0.0365632214,
0.0595404953,
0.0388689525,
0.0237584226,
-0.0418929681,
0.0162256006,
0.0101413252,
0.0473693199,
-0.0025180562,
0.0480518043,
-0.0188740492,
0.0209719352,
-0.0203899872,
0.0409166217,
-0.0317387693,
-0.0161269642,
0.0209748577,
0.0549689084,
-0.0553318001,
-0.0008901589,
-0.0360652097,
-0.0196470656,
-0.0052977391,
0.0697159618,
-0.0186483786,
-0.0469797701,
-0.0398170836,
-0.0372822881,
0.0065023531,
-0.0255251396,
-0.0155648077,
0.0288070906,
0.0066261874,
-0.0258607026,
-0.040739622,
-0.0502392761,
-0.0017934565,
0.0305485558,
0.025102349,
-0.0221472736,
0.0137516661,
0.0004877574,
-0.059548445,
-0.0028820042,
-0.0772936046,
-0.0221810285,
-0.0275602546,
-0.0089469673,
0.0328218602,
-0.0495888963,
0.0140311103,
0.0260727499,
-0.0388370305,
-0.0492598452,
0.0094138198,
0.0548666939,
0.0382107645,
0.0476100072,
-0.0045580715,
-0.0617205128,
0.0509805903,
0.0079122745,
-0.0423372686,
0.0276176203,
0.0068159248,
0.0378414057,
0.0090147909,
0.0257693958,
-0.0675720945,
0.0098244352,
0.0110759949,
-0.0202927478,
-0.0092077116,
-0.0380212851,
0.0167907514,
0.0285587367,
-0.0033375628,
0.0166286472,
0.0177678708,
-0.0035096367,
0.0200855825,
-0.0354090668,
0.008815092,
-0.0142426919,
-0.0002311138,
0.0201491378,
0.0168527663,
0.030182926,
-0.0196331386,
0.0221826807,
0.0102846893,
-0.0190590564,
-0.0551451072,
0.0137834344,
0.0180083551,
-0.0049418616,
0.0185999963,
-0.0351283289,
0.0351301879,
-0.0058891037,
0.0701883882,
-0.0440425165,
0.0674849898,
-0.0042931838,
-0.0161514897,
-0.0245639011,
0.0388979167,
-0.068583414,
-0.0839750841,
0.0406030566,
0.0511369891,
0.0217338149,
0.0167614818,
-0.0410334133,
-0.0453587845,
0.0143499123,
-0.0123685589,
0.0074322829,
0.0325271674,
-0.0803290978,
-0.0500029586,
0.0341203623,
-0.0317607485,
0.0271419305,
0.0499606989,
-0.0169135239,
0.0405495279,
-0.0263947863,
-0.0157770794,
-0.0449883938,
-0.0213260539,
-0.0076349443,
0.0659543425,
-0.0006587,
-0.0151572619,
-0.0696310252,
-0.0504355542,
0.0183322392,
0.0055072671,
0.0057041934,
-0.0276995804,
0.0489612073,
0.0524147749,
-0.0032408938,
-0.0410855561,
-0.024995828,
0.0231666807,
-0.0897360593,
0.0046455637,
-0.0079310704,
-6.640509382e-33,
-0.0144628864,
-0.035951551,
0.0245263688,
-0.0202920698,
-0.0041169217,
-0.0218163002,
-0.0256848708,
-0.0101963701,
-0.02787452,
-0.0273377653,
-0.0313893706,
0.0266268179,
0.0026001674,
0.0305132139,
-0.0152930468,
-0.0254275948,
0.0383696444,
0.0283873416,
0.0056369985,
0.0589154661,
0.0782587454,
0.0159813985,
-0.002083763,
-0.0944847018,
0.026751101,
-0.0018211892,
0.0044057984,
0.027626995,
-0.0363934599,
0.049513083,
-0.0229591094,
0.0514143817,
0.0179924555,
0.009283537,
0.0192975104,
0.060502205,
-0.0802938417,
-0.0455374494,
0.0051760203,
-0.0247694682,
-0.0287857391,
-0.070598796,
0.0230281446,
-0.0246869996,
-0.0059581981,
0.0278489739,
0.0360797271,
-0.02315416,
-0.0078188935,
-0.0393411852,
-0.0336677581,
-0.0183730591,
-0.0013125538,
0.0225219522,
-0.0190477613,
0.0034786882,
-0.0085131992,
0.0245466921,
-0.0418753885,
0.0280929077,
-0.0348694846,
-0.0298042689,
0.0432167128,
0.0052272547,
0.036333397,
0.0462451205,
0.0561994128,
0.0376487635,
-0.0631472766,
-0.024647072,
0.0071935742,
0.0353029743,
-0.0186078232,
0.0377538726,
0.028612107,
-0.0299262442,
-0.0542857014,
0.016191531,
0.0321404412,
0.0374685302,
0.0467236117,
0.0023223616,
-0.0780986473,
-0.0286473483,
-0.0253653992,
0.009957673,
-0.045871906,
-0.0245598126,
0.0369972624,
0.0050938134,
-0.040765956,
-0.0055321371,
0.0156198014,
-0.049173411,
0.0393882729,
0.035272561,
0.0216874331,
-0.0220907237,
-0.0095945699,
0.019126948,
-0.0172017533,
-0.0293824058,
-0.0272406489,
-0.0046980851,
0.0144085269,
0.0382938981,
0.0077593001,
0.0409289747,
-0.0198413748,
-0.0077556437,
-0.0293901395,
0.0184381045,
0.0014679192,
-0.0365358815,
0.0320710726,
0.0371757895,
-0.0034422362,
0.0658534616,
0.0398868471,
0.0289846919,
-0.0403830707,
-0.0103259301,
-0.0073918705,
-0.0129067218,
-0.0095653525,
-0.0008434963,
-0.0502368845,
0.0255847052,
0.0490743555,
-0.0590689145,
0.0041468935,
-0.0017032949,
3.17e-7,
-0.0341869183,
-0.0055999598,
0.0298298784,
-0.0167308953,
0.0041553448,
0.0244594105,
0.0554982834,
0.0331754349,
-0.0002649577,
-0.0261256695,
-0.0051598535,
0.069637388,
0.0134324078,
0.0109732151,
-0.0689481869,
0.0247614421,
-0.0195264574,
-0.0018204855,
-0.0675642043,
0.0484362207,
0.0378419161,
0.0824200958,
0.0550197177,
-0.0181590095,
0.0098606376,
-0.0795691088,
0.0574872755,
-0.0252135377,
0.0123175662,
-0.0002851292,
0.0012609483,
0.0852427408,
-0.0306866337,
-0.0074262433,
0.0122629171,
0.0116908597,
-0.0531626418,
0.0613761619,
-0.0053638155,
-0.0456508994,
-0.0220209043,
-0.0510707609,
-0.0043467553,
-0.0197203644,
0.0681848004,
-0.0504100919,
-0.0525153913,
0.0052687749,
0.044639755,
-0.0238491744,
-0.0315225199,
0.0006420434,
0.0067096213,
-0.0258426815,
-0.0063843792,
-0.011257234,
0.0296910442,
-0.1129518747,
0.0044378252,
0.0076238126,
-0.0245624315,
-0.0262802206,
-0.0421915203,
0.0172567945,
0.0380698815,
-0.0417359285,
0.0298971087,
2.793213579e-34,
0.0086173909,
0.0116837565,
0.0010980774,
0.0142007982,
0.0540433191,
0.0049521714,
-0.0247392394,
0.031434644,
0.0673209578,
-0.0685736388,
-0.0318676345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18305v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18305v1 | S3: A Simple Strong Sample-effective Multimodal Dialog System | 2024-06-26T12:45:43 | 2024-06-26T12:45:43 | Elisei Rykov, Egor Malkershin, Alexander Panchenko | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this work, we present a conceptually simple yet powerful baseline for the
multimodal dialog task, an S3 model, that achieves near state-of-the-art
results on two compelling leaderboards: MMMU and AI Journey Contest 2023. The
system is based on a pre-trained large language model, pre-trained modality
encoders for image and audio, and a trainable modality projector. The proposed
effective data mixture for training such an architecture demonstrates that a
multimodal model based on a strong language model and trained on a small amount
of multimodal data can perform efficiently in the task of multimodal dialog. | S3: A Simple Strong Sample-effective Multimodal Dialog System: In this work, we present a conceptually simple yet powerful baseline for the
multimodal dialog task, an S3 model, that achieves near state-of-the-art
results on two compelling leaderboards: MMMU and AI Journey Contest 2023. The
system is based on a pre-trained large language model, pre-trained modality
encoders for image and audio, and a trainable modality projector. The proposed
effective data mixture for training such an architecture demonstrates that a
multimodal model based on a strong language model and trained on a small amount
of multimodal data can perform efficiently in the task of multimodal dialog. | [
0.0514015891,
0.092367135,
-0.0128529277,
0.0437224209,
-0.0014756359,
0.0008982614,
0.0408712812,
-0.0293932073,
-0.033736378,
-0.089324221,
-0.0663861856,
-0.0138560375,
-0.0360643119,
0.0852366686,
0.0502515286,
-0.076252237,
0.0277221091,
-0.0640073419,
-0.0013914033,
0.002553961,
0.0573258102,
0.0100092264,
-0.0495383143,
0.0361227468,
-0.0583669245,
-0.0048455424,
-0.046162352,
-0.0034835036,
-0.0244508348,
-0.0530950539,
-0.0116926031,
0.0416704565,
0.0689137504,
0.0081642279,
0.0000017465,
-0.0254573785,
0.0240191631,
-0.0159954131,
-0.0198504776,
-0.0282195713,
0.0262911748,
0.0023805848,
0.0154178701,
0.0121532576,
-0.0217421167,
-0.0171581488,
0.0498909689,
0.082956098,
0.0994793698,
0.0652486831,
-0.0346482508,
-0.0165420063,
0.0164916944,
-0.0165896546,
0.0301417597,
-0.0424653962,
-0.0257351138,
0.0248351172,
0.0146788452,
0.0253082458,
-0.0269654021,
0.027694324,
0.0089552188,
-0.0336257257,
-0.0280359723,
0.0121872611,
-0.0011861526,
-0.0314113311,
-0.051195208,
0.1252182871,
0.0256785862,
0.0479692966,
-0.0118974727,
0.0012861881,
-0.0042005102,
-0.0356384143,
-0.060925331,
0.0363492817,
0.0104172565,
-0.0162434727,
-0.0570873879,
0.0315988623,
-0.0010512728,
0.0151061155,
0.0116801308,
-0.0178409237,
0.0095427232,
-0.0040861052,
0.0074649756,
-0.0111641772,
-0.0038991338,
-0.0606287457,
0.0010911886,
-0.0036961637,
-0.0610789433,
-0.0036506401,
-0.035131637,
-0.0079331128,
-0.0142734479,
-0.0203380771,
0.0070709861,
0.0212698355,
-0.0271445867,
0.0713465959,
0.0302386489,
0.0230926163,
-0.0090660257,
0.0268178359,
-0.0052376874,
-0.0373216458,
-0.0412410162,
0.0060703917,
-0.0436240658,
-0.0016880848,
-0.0660362095,
-0.0592779964,
0.0037137151,
0.0296106469,
-0.0146737974,
0.007560668,
0.0186102372,
0.0308936369,
-0.0382179469,
-0.0097489813,
-0.0356537998,
0.0573174395,
-0.0303206462,
0.0500166751,
0.0088125039,
-0.057708282,
0.0175327007,
0.0645606518,
0.0056771664,
-0.017514633,
-0.0009092904,
0.09775839,
-0.0648604333,
-0.0389765315,
-0.0024609519,
-0.0112161441,
-0.0404669866,
-0.0569283962,
0.0183568913,
-0.0215604007,
0.0587221682,
-0.0108579127,
-0.0022607301,
0.0077072624,
0.0124231176,
-0.0200521685,
0.0254007634,
0.0724537298,
0.0172488298,
-0.0082189739,
0.0566626117,
0.0181914605,
-0.0403340384,
0.0746001154,
0.040110711,
0.0357424095,
0.039234437,
0.0046820212,
0.0171983372,
0.0450671725,
-0.0324645415,
0.00816694,
0.0154600907,
0.0032606455,
-0.0281046405,
0.031853646,
0.0363364369,
0.0758516416,
-0.043879129,
-0.0304344837,
0.0720434338,
0.0200675335,
0.0027159338,
0.0058965054,
0.0109012136,
0.0120851165,
0.0044970461,
-0.0473116301,
-0.0268740766,
0.0485723205,
0.0136500867,
-0.0177618377,
0.0468912683,
0.0311674904,
-0.0428213179,
-0.0101582194,
0.050314974,
-0.0288896225,
-0.0137468958,
0.0052850097,
0.0366829447,
0.0007382626,
-0.0603069812,
0.0355780646,
-0.0116119832,
-0.0470108688,
-0.001054337,
0.0023076704,
0.0214244891,
0.0251446739,
0.0115871457,
-0.0033612144,
-0.011770145,
-0.040615622,
0.0235357434,
0.0315305926,
0.0217196699,
-0.031315092,
0.064192161,
-0.0797924846,
-0.0460496806,
-0.0156821143,
-0.0126309153,
0.0163062271,
-0.0366908871,
-0.0020475665,
0.0141096171,
-0.0061941287,
0.0689820424,
0.0017921565,
0.0471423082,
0.0142585859,
-0.0157383475,
-0.0017429979,
0.0652965233,
0.0081133191,
-0.0399388336,
-0.0165326931,
0.0098991841,
-0.0286481027,
0.0204240959,
0.0459116995,
-0.0799278691,
-0.0465634502,
0.0219814833,
-0.0561940745,
-0.0008875227,
0.0078295637,
-0.0476032346,
-0.0436012931,
0.019412268,
-0.0579416119,
-0.0106503107,
-0.0490252674,
-0.001612476,
0.0270814206,
0.0126973474,
-0.02733678,
0.0173138417,
-0.004555285,
-0.0365782157,
0.0252151303,
0.0289146043,
0.0376615077,
-0.0433627367,
-0.040338818,
0.0278714318,
-0.0057649002,
0.0303583629,
0.006201786,
-0.0127118388,
-0.0356373824,
-0.0400285311,
-0.132952854,
-0.031674657,
-0.0000605025,
-0.0276825372,
-0.004707878,
0.0139305238,
-0.0031890036,
-0.0373163633,
-0.0380951762,
0.0225905981,
0.0623694621,
0.0070864786,
0.0129668191,
0.0392455459,
0.0146701755,
-0.0417311415,
0.0026263292,
0.0167435277,
0.0514037199,
0.0029882817,
-0.0070673642,
-0.0148349861,
-0.0155844092,
-0.0362591483,
0.0663151518,
-0.0171483681,
-0.0567365587,
0.0249609035,
-0.0118158031,
0.0752394423,
0.0102929166,
0.026911974,
0.0180841796,
-0.0095631974,
-0.0256626569,
-0.0340647362,
0.0334612466,
0.0064015999,
0.0158071369,
-0.0369400568,
0.0032204119,
0.0137571888,
0.0282541309,
0.0337154344,
0.0487572514,
-0.0276393574,
0.0171708353,
0.0357402265,
-0.0820448101,
-0.0242102351,
-0.0065743998,
-0.0088234609,
0.0310136806,
-0.0277691819,
-0.0170830116,
0.023984246,
-0.07941062,
-0.0354386866,
-0.0066459412,
0.0027063712,
-0.0110022286,
0.0623084754,
-0.018294692,
0.0356281251,
-0.0171555262,
-0.0119322091,
-0.0501944274,
-0.0273848902,
0.0308125522,
-0.0060115186,
0.0379642732,
-0.0289427917,
0.0133486595,
-0.0148857012,
-0.0829701945,
-0.0236324929,
-0.0404138602,
-0.0318797193,
-0.0408352576,
-0.0085837757,
0.0029878414,
-0.0437447466,
0.0115837855,
0.0344176665,
0.0300149433,
0.0059049684,
-0.0037851825,
-0.0243679341,
0.0545075573,
0.053890463,
0.0661409423,
-0.0445820354,
-0.0669925138,
0.0320293494,
0.0309196115,
0.0380707346,
0.0057864566,
-0.0602100007,
0.0249127541,
-0.0007875569,
0.0602498278,
0.0011119813,
0.0235148445,
0.0516025499,
-0.029150771,
0.008700707,
0.0727152005,
-0.0181158856,
-0.0339345299,
-0.0222223271,
0.0146999583,
0.0040799826,
0.0195814651,
0.0004201831,
-0.0794737339,
-0.0738023371,
-0.0123994481,
-0.0328144692,
0.0136113092,
0.0121086501,
0.0099598849,
-0.0626872703,
0.041253902,
-0.0103939082,
-0.0175262336,
-0.0375105627,
0.0062987674,
-0.0115661016,
-0.0047587906,
0.0012310199,
-0.0133158788,
0.020172799,
0.0054833023,
0.0101095075,
0.0412709117,
-0.0424964912,
0.0151647059,
-0.0310377758,
0.0581324399,
0.0481288135,
0.0074739424,
-0.0175246578,
-0.0382401645,
0.0175104327,
0.0286030695,
-0.0074040876,
0.0129052652,
0.0578212738,
-0.0387018286,
-0.0378468446,
-0.02996324,
0.003930998,
0.006471076,
-0.0197750516,
0.0062809372,
0.0581727251,
-0.0375845619,
0.0234794356,
-0.0247682314,
0.0248010177,
0.0427887812,
0.0472580381,
0.0064349291,
-0.0547073223,
-0.0236837473,
-0.0136041762,
0.015560789,
-0.023903681,
0.0071568047,
0.0109472107,
0.0351539366,
0.0338294245,
-0.0599331371,
-0.020539796,
0.0123441769,
0.0550006591,
-0.0091156894,
-0.0255323872,
-0.0178089608,
0.0334652252,
-0.0188828316,
0.0418224335,
-0.0054860045,
0.0090144612,
-0.0642976984,
0.0025191149,
0.0512578972,
-0.0195150319,
-0.0177801158,
0.0301276576,
-0.0521996878,
-0.0211023148,
-0.0507710204,
0.0907416269,
0.0129421148,
0.0324778594,
0.0277935211,
-0.0426785834,
0.0228133481,
-0.0123100784,
-0.0277177021,
-0.0092190448,
0.0483781584,
0.0156383123,
-0.0159407463,
0.0091417683,
-0.0474003442,
0.0106073972,
-0.0114534227,
0.0260985345,
-0.0085997833,
-0.0568879433,
-0.0219900161,
-0.02368409,
0.0172406435,
-0.0054515488,
0.003522034,
-0.0391644798,
0.0193002522,
0.0085717225,
-0.0090666469,
-0.0870158151,
0.0215943754,
0.0038000643,
0.0131771853,
0.0289197657,
-0.0005585394,
0.0014830836,
0.0419779271,
-0.0141283069,
0.0382314287,
0.0559158213,
-0.0249026977,
-0.0206011776,
0.0086500226,
0.0010745201,
0.0347135998,
0.0018201793,
0.0098150717,
-0.0144954193,
0.1348132342,
0.0069399676,
-0.0481240265,
0.0081669576,
0.0534135923,
-0.0128026493,
-0.0029143423,
-0.0261103753,
0.0456288047,
0.0228739586,
0.0274125189,
0.0161688402,
0.0058359508,
0.0097675482,
-0.0146473283,
0.0776871666,
-0.0126403552,
-0.0222185086,
0.0453971736,
0.0203569047,
0.0041955011,
0.0221191011,
0.0466017984,
-0.0247075073,
0.0288319997,
-0.0052212649,
0.0181566235,
-0.0686851963,
-0.0231601652,
0.0401021205,
0.04291014,
-0.0074094231,
0.0298346765,
0.008464695,
-0.0361787751,
-0.0195809659,
0.0115515133,
-0.0146139888,
0.0181277562,
0.072796613,
0.0706511065,
0.0038965286,
-0.014883073,
-0.0149458768,
-0.0118659344,
0.0170820579,
0.0001132548,
-0.0166309401,
-5.57196665e-33,
-0.0127363587,
-0.0143616274,
0.0349584632,
-0.0493784733,
-0.022305591,
-0.012026717,
-0.0418228246,
0.0130869411,
-0.0054223775,
-0.0049987794,
0.0198730361,
-0.0068314881,
-0.0023426993,
0.0729202107,
-0.0137995109,
0.0181874558,
0.0461933725,
-0.0127974134,
-0.0328929611,
0.0216412656,
0.0373770446,
0.0034379084,
0.02933635,
-0.0826886147,
-0.0268481467,
0.0307092424,
-0.0506423265,
0.0130791832,
0.0195628237,
0.0754337609,
-0.0236978885,
0.0365781523,
0.0050314665,
-0.0334012061,
-0.0131394025,
0.0315151885,
-0.044126302,
-0.0211331304,
0.0222498979,
0.0297324024,
-0.0537693873,
0.0215589907,
0.0048980848,
-0.0487531424,
0.0343804322,
-0.0008727855,
0.0216461401,
0.0140174069,
0.0094357543,
0.0006701733,
-0.0530281067,
0.0232190508,
-0.0380111746,
-0.0269545205,
0.0206168834,
0.0514177121,
0.0395941585,
-0.0307828002,
-0.0105069363,
0.0365520194,
-0.0174718928,
-0.0095313983,
0.0471129604,
0.0301263407,
-0.0124184089,
0.0768577084,
0.0355291478,
-0.0343180485,
-0.0161744338,
-0.0132393455,
-0.0056293579,
0.063019447,
0.0280103106,
0.0932218805,
-0.029421445,
0.011114276,
-0.0307183396,
0.0182272401,
0.0216257852,
0.0252466872,
0.0096709076,
0.0251789875,
-0.0064842156,
0.0067349961,
-0.0586667918,
-0.0176502559,
-0.0213631485,
-0.0477312095,
0.0644248128,
0.0339829102,
0.0143781481,
0.0107595352,
0.0990894139,
-0.0177010838,
-0.0217341501,
0.0007562385,
-0.0056729121,
0.0457631312,
-0.0113199027,
-0.0125015806,
-0.0303257499,
-0.0252115261,
0.0852202252,
-0.0094127208,
0.0298121125,
0.0064794673,
-0.0068385783,
0.0374388173,
-0.0375104174,
-0.0162477698,
-0.0223855302,
0.0097618718,
-0.0163553692,
0.053822007,
0.0072198701,
-0.0139928851,
-0.0831456482,
0.0352779366,
-0.0559624694,
0.0046197306,
-0.0374694504,
-0.0981409103,
-0.0172980167,
0.0114519643,
-0.0527874157,
0.0071020792,
-0.0482017137,
-0.0892469212,
0.038451992,
-0.0588230416,
0.0013540583,
0.0147120934,
2.446e-7,
-0.0197997857,
0.0170676038,
0.0028607182,
-0.0008631377,
0.0294010248,
0.0632493421,
-0.0226210151,
0.0190074723,
-0.0064115385,
-0.0404958837,
0.0029903171,
0.0307370443,
0.0102236038,
0.0172332041,
-0.0384011343,
-0.0170646273,
-0.0466772877,
-0.0163666345,
-0.0464853235,
0.0278403852,
0.0764798597,
0.1483282894,
-0.0094371475,
-0.0150525533,
0.0021249047,
-0.044926174,
0.0730368569,
-0.021432735,
-0.0126771666,
-0.0068868571,
0.0412163511,
-0.0178108253,
-0.0214300975,
0.0112707419,
0.0075282925,
-0.0031108754,
0.033181835,
0.0465027094,
-0.0086307647,
-0.0515322909,
-0.0054195002,
0.0489508361,
-0.029014254,
-0.0086585116,
0.0575146489,
-0.0203684475,
-0.0537128337,
-0.0636054873,
-0.02108174,
-0.0243802853,
-0.0078014182,
-0.0234931875,
-0.0419881381,
0.0067372541,
0.0227816589,
-0.0207534917,
-0.0107601723,
-0.0884350091,
0.0080962507,
-0.0348877311,
-0.0424065217,
-0.0343972966,
-0.0424902886,
-0.0537507385,
0.0458745807,
-0.0364497378,
-0.0155970259,
1.636315228e-34,
0.0268331803,
-0.0145175643,
0.0240225587,
0.010180464,
0.0519500896,
0.0008475478,
0.011261154,
-0.0263949577,
0.0041910582,
-0.0683220476,
-0.0323557667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18301v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18301v1 | MSR-86K: An Evolving, Multilingual Corpus with 86,300 Hours of Transcribed Audio for Speech Recognition Research | 2024-06-26T12:35:12 | 2024-06-26T12:35:12 | Song Li, Yongbin You, Xuezhi Wang, Zhengkun Tian, Ke Ding, Guanglu Wan | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Recently, multilingual artificial intelligence assistants, exemplified by
ChatGPT, have gained immense popularity. As a crucial gateway to human-computer
interaction, multilingual automatic speech recognition (ASR) has also garnered
significant attention, as evidenced by systems like Whisper. However, the
proprietary nature of the training data has impeded researchers' efforts to
study multilingual ASR. This paper introduces MSR-86K, an evolving, large-scale
multilingual corpus for speech recognition research. The corpus is derived from
publicly accessible videos on YouTube, comprising 15 languages and a total of
86,300 hours of transcribed ASR data. We also introduce how to use the MSR-86K
corpus and other open-source corpora to train a robust multilingual ASR model
that is competitive with Whisper. MSR-86K will be publicly released on
HuggingFace, and we believe that such a large corpus will pave new avenues for
research in multilingual ASR. | MSR-86K: An Evolving, Multilingual Corpus with 86,300 Hours of Transcribed Audio for Speech Recognition Research: Recently, multilingual artificial intelligence assistants, exemplified by
ChatGPT, have gained immense popularity. As a crucial gateway to human-computer
interaction, multilingual automatic speech recognition (ASR) has also garnered
significant attention, as evidenced by systems like Whisper. However, the
proprietary nature of the training data has impeded researchers' efforts to
study multilingual ASR. This paper introduces MSR-86K, an evolving, large-scale
multilingual corpus for speech recognition research. The corpus is derived from
publicly accessible videos on YouTube, comprising 15 languages and a total of
86,300 hours of transcribed ASR data. We also introduce how to use the MSR-86K
corpus and other open-source corpora to train a robust multilingual ASR model
that is competitive with Whisper. MSR-86K will be publicly released on
HuggingFace, and we believe that such a large corpus will pave new avenues for
research in multilingual ASR. | [
-0.0256809425,
0.0503706038,
-0.0106096528,
0.0501827635,
-0.0319331139,
0.0086256126,
0.025403345,
-0.0128059965,
0.0029331294,
0.0122095952,
-0.0885717869,
-0.0391371772,
0.0248462856,
0.0104136178,
0.0334812365,
-0.0665962398,
0.0273681302,
-0.0878105089,
0.0163261071,
-0.02485043,
0.0188638605,
0.0320702046,
-0.0496385433,
0.0344165787,
-0.0230099838,
0.0137427812,
0.0137168244,
-0.0103786057,
0.0323030055,
-0.0008771882,
-0.0368678197,
0.0188605506,
0.0231347363,
0.0413729288,
0.0000018314,
-0.0308051854,
-0.0008887743,
0.0145889567,
-0.0331566371,
-0.0100002103,
-0.0017735731,
-0.0169331729,
-0.0169688519,
0.055736281,
-0.0229457952,
-0.0148381237,
0.0372600257,
-0.027250262,
0.0232020784,
0.042961739,
-0.0189726856,
-0.0454194993,
0.0323850326,
-0.0139600011,
-0.0083018327,
-0.0447823331,
-0.0279016457,
-0.0282180253,
-0.003609325,
-0.0226826631,
-0.0296611898,
0.0624343306,
0.0054666344,
-0.0153101906,
-0.0420503542,
-0.0033305485,
-0.0612285733,
-0.0802634656,
-0.0072794463,
0.0581252538,
-0.0238572806,
-0.0017562198,
0.0415350385,
0.0207642466,
-0.0528666489,
-0.0638720393,
-0.025611911,
0.0291301869,
-0.0066092592,
-0.0122516137,
0.0046400372,
0.0155242886,
0.0255114976,
-0.0289336368,
0.0414613448,
-0.007683333,
0.0256297458,
-0.0353825539,
0.0385877825,
-0.0217274874,
0.024354307,
0.0026794735,
0.0678397417,
-0.0057814955,
-0.0157027282,
0.0114902882,
-0.0147806639,
-0.025222294,
0.0145662017,
-0.0655565709,
0.0155772269,
0.0722016692,
-0.0558838025,
0.0335019194,
-0.0075762155,
0.0523484573,
-0.0078936983,
-0.0127861444,
-0.0204752386,
-0.0343351997,
-0.0298934579,
0.0131594054,
-0.0304504111,
-0.0147884209,
-0.0312919058,
-0.038404163,
-0.0230563767,
0.013744778,
-0.0011892268,
0.0140592298,
0.0012107696,
-0.0378220379,
-0.0187818259,
-0.005268848,
0.0473367572,
0.022072209,
-0.0033943572,
0.0351831615,
-0.0207275432,
-0.0875933096,
-0.0114397956,
0.0351133794,
0.0263360776,
-0.0140755353,
0.0246426556,
0.0555456057,
-0.0335245468,
-0.0347852334,
-0.0161817931,
0.0163182244,
-0.0209618155,
-0.0407694466,
0.0063322922,
-0.0420306139,
0.0964975581,
0.013031831,
0.0098923352,
-0.0147924237,
0.0007577323,
-0.0178158432,
0.0082060723,
0.0699913278,
0.012114333,
0.033340428,
0.0385445245,
-0.0151152862,
-0.0167660881,
0.0622541755,
0.0569759794,
-0.0268629771,
0.0614918396,
-0.0240115467,
-0.0002974275,
0.0895910263,
-0.0423377939,
0.0249888748,
0.0215926692,
-0.0236672834,
0.0113562159,
0.0116512952,
0.0184404179,
0.060080044,
-0.0089852158,
-0.0575439669,
0.0283036027,
0.0574804954,
-0.0104820943,
0.0274613071,
0.0693362132,
0.0147764003,
0.0063379696,
-0.0039404836,
0.0324716307,
0.0123122828,
0.0149420528,
0.0272302199,
0.0352596603,
0.062119361,
-0.0559018366,
0.0158555713,
-0.0255501289,
-0.0453757867,
0.0007413567,
0.0523478501,
0.0534077697,
-0.0103779873,
-0.0298133828,
0.031031562,
0.0295691844,
-0.0562451854,
0.0307151917,
-0.0478251651,
-0.0030124278,
0.0448199026,
-0.0035704018,
-0.0277028661,
-0.0391733088,
-0.0352289304,
-0.0142993722,
0.0524500348,
0.0193713903,
-0.0253631081,
0.0793798342,
-0.0855712369,
0.0049747117,
0.0375993215,
-0.0105578518,
0.0808567405,
-0.0320132822,
0.0455837809,
0.0048835701,
-0.0198833924,
0.0168706272,
-0.0190609004,
-0.053960003,
0.0115988692,
0.0175039507,
0.0102130724,
0.0794512555,
0.0554510243,
-0.0449437909,
-0.0264711175,
0.0334648415,
-0.0276810564,
0.0340751596,
0.0783106238,
-0.0353525579,
-0.0091566835,
0.0551303253,
-0.0293665379,
0.0030248398,
0.0329863466,
0.0158666354,
-0.0671050623,
0.0671183988,
-0.0033818746,
0.048166994,
-0.05532033,
0.0529839173,
0.0294596981,
0.0343106501,
0.0542361215,
-0.0357806981,
0.0234745108,
-0.0091949925,
0.0048282603,
-0.030285269,
0.0530094691,
-0.0828238577,
-0.0325583443,
0.0523699485,
-0.0302485973,
0.0108516095,
0.0325807743,
0.0029963448,
-0.0088843061,
-0.015745027,
-0.0770761445,
-0.0187326595,
-0.0368222222,
0.039997384,
-0.045784764,
0.0346176215,
-0.0239676833,
-0.0445708074,
-0.0123957833,
-0.0161413606,
0.0152518693,
0.0183225684,
-0.0553933345,
-0.0167699419,
-0.0020814198,
-0.0224142242,
-0.0230349507,
0.0239509791,
-0.0113335149,
-0.0229203179,
-0.0565383062,
-0.0463148244,
-0.0173530616,
-0.0035443115,
0.0279715601,
-0.0246622581,
-0.0422414765,
-0.0084376158,
0.0247966573,
0.0366100706,
0.0238048416,
-0.0324498862,
0.0031999757,
0.0128124347,
0.003410999,
-0.0358844325,
0.012270865,
0.0329803787,
-0.0145236719,
-0.0230047926,
0.0161910709,
-0.0257123727,
0.0108895628,
0.0182753447,
0.0315221287,
-0.049398832,
-0.066274032,
-0.0324184336,
-0.0354590677,
-0.0061331671,
-0.0092049036,
-0.0467155315,
0.028499458,
0.0177414343,
-0.0046742694,
0.0410711803,
-0.0754235312,
-0.0555116273,
-0.0373845287,
-0.039818082,
-0.0394370072,
0.0249462221,
-0.0310318936,
0.0219522808,
-0.0257437583,
-0.0527890846,
-0.0089405831,
0.0212180614,
0.0203475188,
-0.0230445173,
0.0161771514,
-0.0497009121,
0.0002244815,
-0.0091871209,
-0.0705123469,
0.0039296327,
0.0163000301,
-0.0338352248,
0.0226338804,
0.0138711939,
-0.0164482109,
-0.0449798554,
0.029033713,
0.037152268,
0.0612801425,
0.0160415936,
0.0598591454,
-0.0105121545,
0.0335417874,
0.0160374995,
-0.0100911334,
-0.0404961705,
-0.039770864,
0.0436941981,
-0.0172755066,
0.0657810643,
-0.0219443422,
-0.0248771813,
0.000716728,
0.0668275356,
0.0105263609,
-0.0147241009,
-0.0214555934,
0.0405828767,
-0.0028326495,
0.0357319415,
0.0884969831,
-0.0121083716,
-0.0540127866,
-0.0245577693,
-0.0189912971,
0.0014934728,
0.0150740556,
0.011469231,
-0.0888561308,
-0.0061666933,
0.050773222,
0.0142764132,
0.0411800183,
0.0233047716,
-0.0138930734,
-0.0835212469,
0.0132398363,
0.0074047623,
-0.0534051396,
-0.0352012925,
-0.055138126,
-0.0370968916,
-0.0685604513,
0.0348443985,
-0.0302451029,
0.0101124942,
-0.0330030993,
0.0511750244,
-0.044414524,
-0.0700554177,
0.0298788957,
-0.0404827967,
0.080723308,
0.0294075087,
0.0437513255,
-0.04544615,
-0.0450079031,
0.0070262114,
-0.005158097,
0.000634503,
-0.0159865562,
0.0013766548,
0.0153869884,
-0.0382163897,
0.0354527347,
0.0167252012,
-0.0122516099,
0.0112267761,
0.0386450738,
0.0633418038,
-0.016561076,
0.0031154309,
0.0305291452,
-0.0105777048,
0.0228415504,
0.0449945703,
-0.0111752301,
-0.0368001945,
0.0390435047,
0.0184930842,
0.0037324291,
-0.0140034761,
0.0122662298,
-0.0085939383,
-0.0127102816,
-0.0344158895,
-0.0269632749,
-0.020757135,
0.0190688111,
-0.0090179127,
0.0318310186,
-0.0132528981,
0.0177203733,
0.0425793342,
-0.0187652446,
0.0127744749,
0.0178314596,
0.018948786,
-0.0794191062,
-0.0447236486,
0.0264023114,
-0.0561850145,
-0.0149871111,
0.0086748023,
-0.0361034833,
-0.0777201802,
0.0126748653,
0.0414722338,
0.0179640017,
0.0650037453,
-0.0510062762,
-0.0172382928,
0.021562025,
-0.0058603743,
-0.0443723798,
-0.0105931489,
0.0574473031,
0.0039711739,
-0.0296666473,
0.020185085,
-0.0462924801,
0.0216686614,
-0.0329937302,
0.0032484063,
-0.0450730547,
-0.0525388569,
-0.0454570055,
0.0275154058,
0.0458795987,
-0.0411434285,
-0.0158771668,
-0.0715137795,
-0.0024201039,
0.0039198264,
0.0644376501,
-0.0439696163,
0.0164555311,
0.0375786759,
0.0191071797,
-0.0276120305,
0.0199877732,
-0.0136187989,
-0.0644449592,
0.0009378426,
0.0586260483,
0.0401698574,
-0.0062728953,
0.0030930443,
0.0311416127,
-0.0190699268,
0.0754966065,
0.0084460331,
0.0127256727,
-0.004914131,
0.0176236015,
-0.0311660264,
0.0092800148,
0.05995268,
0.0427151509,
-0.0140992925,
-0.0186428744,
0.0108018834,
0.0565554649,
0.0671361536,
-0.0048089097,
0.0960024521,
-0.004661432,
0.0107440073,
-0.0336679891,
0.0487199686,
-0.0232328027,
-0.029347267,
0.001702221,
-0.0067195864,
-0.031197181,
0.0437019467,
0.0793590695,
-0.0335133448,
0.0231553875,
0.0164533295,
0.0300466307,
-0.0224651918,
-0.0327813886,
0.0053684958,
-0.0096064676,
-0.038336128,
-0.0010506416,
0.0099352282,
-0.0812224001,
0.0070004668,
-0.0078427959,
0.0167820826,
0.0016645093,
-0.001804604,
0.0582271852,
-0.0313400328,
0.0223021004,
-0.0271537192,
-0.0802426413,
-0.0390675962,
-0.0257609449,
0.0357747227,
-5.827407082e-33,
0.0151878083,
0.0515062101,
-0.0055983299,
0.0380501188,
-0.0215671416,
-0.0201222971,
-0.0103754308,
0.009888933,
-0.0208895914,
-0.0160901006,
-0.0273860916,
-0.0135004427,
0.0365346447,
0.000038994,
0.0557392575,
-0.0035346467,
0.0658567473,
-0.0014604754,
0.0261863861,
0.016674364,
0.0400063992,
0.0636951625,
0.0777778849,
-0.0629165322,
-0.0042388239,
0.023312293,
0.0033888884,
-0.0044292486,
0.0154969329,
0.0841938555,
-0.0170765053,
0.0466721542,
-0.0132848611,
-0.0098174969,
-0.0188364312,
0.0005233408,
-0.0619382635,
0.0106124431,
-0.0014927591,
0.0935868472,
0.019795686,
-0.0113070579,
-0.0152873946,
-0.0327241495,
-0.0185839199,
-0.0015045895,
0.0257441718,
-0.0110882167,
-0.0043975487,
-0.03226199,
-0.0355301164,
0.0417158529,
-0.0262628347,
-0.0474303961,
0.1002355218,
0.0546385013,
-0.0176876821,
-0.0471435525,
-0.053109616,
0.0342266709,
-0.0618849993,
0.0201950166,
0.0670711026,
0.0100491112,
-0.0083970642,
0.0122081256,
0.0351481214,
-0.0940238833,
0.0554066785,
-0.0187657718,
0.019121768,
0.0301548373,
0.0003403508,
0.0329673961,
0.0139621841,
-0.0654482618,
-0.0257908888,
-0.0513048284,
0.0701415613,
0.0196681824,
0.0096683297,
0.0100828111,
-0.0303727388,
0.0062876721,
-0.0474023186,
-0.0544239283,
-0.0215629395,
-0.0265176408,
0.0229400285,
0.0105662951,
0.0370670892,
0.0228327513,
0.0759697482,
0.0009850294,
0.0195087921,
0.0018884703,
0.0016690862,
-0.0179090686,
0.0062102424,
0.0578815527,
-0.0614708886,
-0.0231735427,
0.0027256315,
0.008660269,
0.0172943883,
-0.0191378146,
0.0117469663,
0.0822617635,
-0.058146853,
0.0114167463,
-0.0142050255,
0.0215130616,
0.0111436099,
0.0359697305,
0.0389668494,
-0.0013700663,
-0.0235776398,
0.0544201806,
0.0122503359,
0.0506718867,
-0.0095046172,
-0.0355714783,
-0.0395367555,
0.0081792837,
-0.0422510803,
0.0198629629,
-0.018358713,
-0.0346718766,
0.012151625,
-0.0300178025,
-0.0054844576,
0.0137084322,
2.718e-7,
-0.0440277047,
0.0244997442,
0.0113446387,
-0.0004684378,
0.0170417726,
0.0117360111,
-0.0473661982,
0.0140552027,
-0.0097528119,
0.0385704488,
-0.0106614893,
-0.0052047474,
0.1000409499,
0.0384058096,
-0.1042164937,
-0.0549531318,
-0.0794412345,
0.0040760119,
-0.0232182313,
0.0069901259,
-0.0213244725,
0.1011574119,
-0.0121693956,
-0.0056859343,
-0.0107091339,
-0.0250344388,
0.0353610367,
-0.0086049205,
-0.0386796966,
-0.0307963472,
0.019556867,
-0.013176119,
-0.0198464263,
-0.0165769737,
-0.041773323,
0.0401131846,
0.0414371789,
0.0548347495,
-0.003494198,
-0.0552037321,
0.0186201297,
0.045129545,
-0.0634267926,
-0.0148440944,
0.0470685884,
0.0445039496,
-0.032154005,
-0.03570351,
-0.0084999939,
0.0030662576,
0.0476726219,
-0.0335994363,
0.0141880838,
0.0420602709,
0.0284855645,
-0.0424797721,
-0.0179614071,
-0.0379089117,
0.0229572542,
-0.0209175237,
-0.0354109257,
0.0095447209,
0.0112288967,
-0.0050149621,
-0.0076519875,
0.0007101455,
0.0046858997,
1.492925006e-34,
0.0469464697,
-0.023661349,
0.0178090483,
-0.0181720201,
0.013197585,
-0.0449946672,
0.0114433113,
0.0265649986,
-0.0198758319,
-0.0103485677,
-0.0405579805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18297v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18297v1 | FactFinders at CheckThat! 2024: Refining Check-worthy Statement Detection with LLMs through Data Pruning | 2024-06-26T12:31:31 | 2024-06-26T12:31:31 | Yufeng Li, Rrubaa Panchendrarajan, Arkaitz Zubiaga | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid dissemination of information through social media and the Internet
has posed a significant challenge for fact-checking, among others in
identifying check-worthy claims that fact-checkers should pay attention to,
i.e. filtering claims needing fact-checking from a large pool of sentences.
This challenge has stressed the need to focus on determining the priority of
claims, specifically which claims are worth to be fact-checked. Despite
advancements in this area in recent years, the application of large language
models (LLMs), such as GPT, has only recently drawn attention in studies.
However, many open-source LLMs remain underexplored. Therefore, this study
investigates the application of eight prominent open-source LLMs with
fine-tuning and prompt engineering to identify check-worthy statements from
political transcriptions. Further, we propose a two-step data pruning approach
to automatically identify high-quality training data instances for effective
learning. The efficiency of our approach is demonstrated through evaluations on
the English language dataset as part of the check-worthiness estimation task of
CheckThat! 2024. Further, the experiments conducted with data pruning
demonstrate that competitive performance can be achieved with only about 44\%
of the training data. Our team ranked first in the check-worthiness estimation
task in the English language. | FactFinders at CheckThat! 2024: Refining Check-worthy Statement Detection with LLMs through Data Pruning: The rapid dissemination of information through social media and the Internet
has posed a significant challenge for fact-checking, among others in
identifying check-worthy claims that fact-checkers should pay attention to,
i.e. filtering claims needing fact-checking from a large pool of sentences.
This challenge has stressed the need to focus on determining the priority of
claims, specifically which claims are worth to be fact-checked. Despite
advancements in this area in recent years, the application of large language
models (LLMs), such as GPT, has only recently drawn attention in studies.
However, many open-source LLMs remain underexplored. Therefore, this study
investigates the application of eight prominent open-source LLMs with
fine-tuning and prompt engineering to identify check-worthy statements from
political transcriptions. Further, we propose a two-step data pruning approach
to automatically identify high-quality training data instances for effective
learning. The efficiency of our approach is demonstrated through evaluations on
the English language dataset as part of the check-worthiness estimation task of
CheckThat! 2024. Further, the experiments conducted with data pruning
demonstrate that competitive performance can be achieved with only about 44\%
of the training data. Our team ranked first in the check-worthiness estimation
task in the English language. | [
0.0281821247,
0.0563504472,
0.0181530528,
0.0407276414,
-0.0616867691,
0.0081377029,
-0.0172804426,
0.0133102005,
0.0214996208,
-0.0469894595,
0.0185855329,
-0.0153538482,
-0.0102797775,
0.0154339094,
0.0037098352,
0.0173772816,
0.0813762248,
0.0109061105,
0.0757082105,
-0.0260097142,
0.0110038556,
0.0266959015,
-0.0464721136,
0.0097716898,
-0.0414648801,
0.0140846707,
0.0455171727,
-0.004435665,
0.0554458909,
-0.0230648853,
0.0024350467,
0.048005417,
-0.0069637639,
0.0678254068,
0.0000018085,
-0.0474208631,
-0.0167495999,
0.0256809723,
-0.0391665287,
0.0460973494,
0.0635452196,
0.0170284323,
-0.0390117541,
0.0207442753,
-0.0067049195,
-0.0102363927,
0.029557161,
0.0357639715,
0.0943155885,
0.100048773,
0.000915698,
-0.0010561384,
0.0286871716,
-0.0095447507,
-0.0133955311,
-0.0439614914,
0.0646856874,
-0.0102082901,
-0.0294461288,
0.0239332877,
0.0188617799,
0.0460145101,
0.0071356297,
-0.0067374669,
-0.0452286601,
0.0113769751,
-0.085010998,
-0.0141694508,
-0.0178028215,
0.0288750622,
0.0197185036,
-0.0565830395,
0.0152605409,
-0.0331416801,
0.0058204425,
0.0264525805,
-0.0055298018,
0.0368984304,
-0.0425357074,
0.0124056935,
0.0134839574,
-0.0250451192,
0.0230494812,
0.0425468236,
0.009402914,
0.0782741308,
-0.0135870231,
-0.0652851313,
0.0489088073,
0.0073005119,
0.0017688399,
-0.0431606211,
0.0189740043,
-0.0169422887,
0.0003137097,
0.0152273541,
-0.0202235281,
0.0122591155,
0.0685978383,
-0.0442312956,
-0.0186542645,
0.0084394533,
-0.0565817878,
0.0812968761,
-0.0118816402,
0.0503482558,
0.0211724564,
-0.0039568269,
0.022303097,
-0.0234285817,
-0.0245585442,
0.0135198953,
-0.0020722302,
0.0441726446,
-0.0174535848,
0.0208087061,
-0.0560321547,
-0.0392903537,
-0.0275780559,
0.0405974165,
0.0158011168,
-0.0390597284,
0.0119873229,
0.0065060989,
-0.0672631413,
0.030496832,
0.0075991652,
0.014267765,
-0.041749876,
-0.0789755732,
0.0050151097,
0.0271357168,
0.0113759348,
-0.0201985873,
0.0083049778,
-0.0282983854,
0.0095455712,
-0.0340492167,
-0.0427495204,
-0.0057486575,
-0.0381694399,
-0.0656240582,
-0.0007809863,
-0.0572101697,
0.0062544523,
-0.0364141092,
0.0234951712,
-0.0159459822,
0.0012999737,
0.0488920063,
-0.0250281785,
0.0245964155,
0.0127609326,
0.0217489786,
0.0062847962,
-0.006975905,
0.0421851687,
0.0646308064,
0.0448996462,
0.0270254109,
0.0734021589,
0.0037434467,
0.0247243494,
0.032491792,
0.0268966127,
0.0356562734,
0.0348008014,
0.0140621196,
-0.0222619958,
-0.0201275274,
-0.007960475,
0.0598417521,
0.0000092767,
-0.0077383579,
0.0814854875,
0.0096133584,
0.0171389915,
-0.0248118173,
0.0386050679,
0.0454702266,
0.0281078853,
0.0079574641,
-0.0370293893,
-0.002096893,
-0.0401609689,
-0.0281312894,
0.0308788586,
0.0788901597,
-0.0075681792,
-0.0391652547,
-0.0400068015,
0.0155823641,
-0.0131341545,
0.0337607674,
0.0048792977,
-0.0171952192,
-0.0564433858,
0.0540816262,
0.0457333885,
-0.080615215,
-0.0143163083,
-0.0707645193,
0.0378174223,
0.0046293531,
0.0309827626,
-0.0223681126,
0.0041490509,
-0.0362933353,
0.0500862151,
0.045868434,
0.0804374963,
-0.0068231262,
-0.0043878281,
-0.0190518238,
-0.020781273,
0.0152326925,
0.0456606634,
-0.0384288393,
0.0664085522,
0.032174632,
0.0021719011,
-0.0479231887,
-0.0609848239,
0.0375225879,
0.0233321916,
0.0110093616,
0.0097241467,
0.018304076,
0.0258914661,
0.0171367861,
-0.005093094,
-0.0323820375,
0.0391411595,
0.0021677504,
0.008262693,
-0.0291701499,
0.0204112232,
-0.0158100631,
0.0301310159,
-0.0387225151,
-0.0306501742,
0.0698778555,
-0.0580008216,
-0.0109778373,
-0.0489870608,
-0.0356066488,
-0.0241209418,
-0.0493725799,
-0.0075701037,
-0.0389656536,
0.0136368806,
-0.003928469,
0.0706711933,
-0.0239292309,
0.0140710715,
-0.0187802557,
-0.0225649402,
0.0340428464,
-0.0339666121,
-0.0400706045,
0.0195421223,
-0.0112020038,
0.0255998373,
0.0320590697,
0.0022239147,
-0.0372799002,
-0.0264039077,
-0.0528137796,
0.0081406971,
-0.018999625,
0.0203105025,
0.0115205254,
-0.0390623845,
-0.0131682698,
0.0169257484,
-0.0125248143,
-0.0247378889,
0.0429594256,
0.0065742242,
0.0445879549,
-0.0335063189,
-0.0150041124,
-0.0050991457,
0.0173721332,
-0.0252474342,
0.0146823032,
0.0389176942,
-0.0501488596,
-0.0149102965,
0.0455853008,
-0.0609585978,
-0.0033929392,
-0.0095815929,
-0.0220949296,
-0.004110116,
0.0354350954,
-0.0171191022,
0.0312653482,
0.021730626,
0.0042260671,
0.0356376693,
0.0218785126,
-0.015049289,
0.0117864572,
-0.0264148954,
-0.0193611477,
-0.0062250164,
-0.0558917411,
0.0559761785,
0.0186087266,
0.023747284,
-0.0211085472,
-0.0487774387,
0.020864144,
-0.0306370296,
-0.0055710757,
0.0096824542,
0.0109270848,
-0.0200582836,
0.0473264791,
-0.0328146107,
-0.0305706672,
0.0669826269,
-0.0324235223,
0.0422210135,
-0.039992284,
-0.0133884409,
-0.0269326065,
0.0184346791,
0.0000999704,
0.0047097309,
0.0193024911,
0.0138902003,
0.0091680922,
-0.0364233591,
0.0508715771,
-0.0495106056,
0.0212341808,
-0.0364894904,
0.0386533812,
0.0023208039,
-0.0480422825,
-0.0315577388,
-0.0918938443,
-0.0325482972,
-0.0008034918,
-0.0401552022,
-0.0150918113,
-0.0652790293,
-0.0109354034,
0.0462482162,
0.0398434661,
-0.0010039861,
0.0259556454,
0.0060631065,
0.0153138498,
0.0145529294,
0.003827268,
0.0483662449,
-0.0010452195,
-0.0231360756,
0.0481341146,
-0.0133501943,
0.0249619912,
-0.0038311931,
-0.0498225391,
0.0111124478,
-0.047114186,
0.0024644437,
-0.0104540512,
0.0389211699,
-0.048477903,
0.0058332672,
0.091252394,
0.0107733021,
0.0071877502,
-0.0059527475,
0.0392762311,
0.0015729779,
0.028041508,
-0.0009250938,
-0.1272762418,
-0.0157207064,
0.0046332139,
-0.0055722003,
-0.0392417163,
-0.0182983857,
-0.050798282,
-0.1246545613,
0.0724790916,
-0.0144222081,
0.009724318,
-0.040028356,
-0.0547376275,
0.0186566152,
-0.042112343,
-0.0192516278,
0.0246410538,
0.0019259447,
-0.0073853252,
-0.0018590239,
-0.0586236268,
-0.0847878084,
0.057321433,
-0.0007310089,
0.0117096603,
0.0387960859,
0.0480475314,
-0.0277581755,
-0.0653613359,
0.0308308937,
-0.0169033986,
-0.0553039089,
-0.0048708939,
0.0653480217,
-0.0304058082,
0.0056272461,
-0.0122133791,
0.0149109941,
0.035721533,
-0.003332023,
0.0213081744,
0.0767911747,
-0.0023927155,
-0.0392202511,
0.0018941602,
0.0424924754,
0.0228118058,
0.0999977961,
0.0075442954,
0.0183757991,
-0.0083532883,
-0.0197457951,
-0.0245257542,
-0.0388804264,
-0.0317523144,
0.0581443943,
-0.0082434183,
-0.0290711429,
-0.0579292141,
0.0058714794,
0.0025962899,
-0.0042312467,
-0.028472513,
0.0083847903,
0.0477449372,
0.0221335273,
-0.0094431685,
0.0201812182,
-0.0704877749,
0.0321715511,
-0.0466163307,
-0.0054106684,
0.0457321815,
-0.0064064572,
-0.0258988664,
0.0434945151,
-0.0935158059,
-0.0435984842,
-0.0117640086,
-0.0021550988,
0.0265772212,
0.0292453133,
-0.036872644,
-0.0183503497,
0.0231788587,
0.0736471415,
-0.0501570292,
0.0293391477,
0.0186423007,
-0.0220540483,
0.0016950313,
0.0099927904,
-0.015938269,
0.0319497474,
0.0215253904,
-0.0033049211,
-0.0218291506,
-0.0297345351,
0.0288456269,
0.0727301314,
0.0458302833,
0.0025633131,
-0.0378602296,
-0.0555933528,
0.0030893479,
0.0215676054,
-0.0428484045,
-0.0008861679,
0.0462318212,
0.0029327208,
-0.0297629107,
-0.0458257385,
0.0106683858,
-0.0333154537,
0.0397845283,
-0.0514737591,
0.0233142991,
-0.0096614622,
0.013236546,
0.0049023889,
-0.0534565076,
-0.0391166769,
0.0194789357,
0.0091958782,
0.0147390179,
0.0131868832,
0.0070033171,
0.0116319256,
0.0019372239,
0.0435493812,
-0.0190845616,
-0.0644894019,
-0.0074670822,
-0.0443148054,
0.0166585054,
0.0435506552,
0.0161793493,
0.0454803556,
-0.0110004935,
-0.0425764732,
-0.0217303224,
0.000005264,
0.013796214,
-0.0101716891,
0.035988424,
0.0010331565,
-0.0440169051,
0.0186017249,
0.0394912846,
0.008141906,
0.0491676144,
0.0382584967,
-0.0537693091,
-0.0646066964,
-0.0793144107,
-0.0589114614,
-0.0100932177,
-0.0086525474,
-0.005363218,
-0.0766615495,
-0.0372204743,
0.0405713245,
0.0309545379,
0.0319497772,
-0.000851333,
0.0015019306,
0.0682732612,
-0.0037097873,
0.0072022635,
-0.0545894392,
-0.0354161225,
0.0059938799,
-0.001854014,
-0.001800721,
-6.237267065e-33,
-0.0178272855,
-0.0370385982,
0.0182056725,
-0.0051122522,
-0.0233086515,
0.0349080339,
-0.0258057527,
-0.0451856703,
-0.0496324599,
0.040903084,
0.0005721689,
0.0343862139,
0.0237961151,
-0.0017792328,
-0.0408867747,
-0.0073401919,
0.0653696358,
0.0031102621,
-0.0525663309,
0.0203193724,
0.0276181288,
-0.011240934,
0.0600147247,
-0.0440073647,
0.0284636505,
0.0182123482,
-0.0590358898,
0.0266137067,
-0.0594843775,
0.0525707975,
-0.006005425,
0.0387908369,
0.0291065164,
-0.0386698097,
0.0232702158,
0.0166404545,
-0.0656718686,
0.0090714647,
0.041245643,
-0.0207404848,
0.0294474736,
0.0137669481,
0.0370742306,
-0.0195927918,
-0.041953627,
0.0107844761,
0.0268638786,
-0.0384608358,
0.0083232559,
-0.0333153531,
-0.0350787006,
0.0636359155,
0.0051740622,
0.0085701821,
-0.0280275606,
0.0530957095,
0.0021317946,
0.0460435897,
-0.0543541387,
0.0562431291,
0.0240027308,
0.0030994685,
0.0473420657,
-0.0719284415,
-0.0309307911,
0.0673486441,
-0.0176743623,
0.0114702499,
-0.0301482286,
-0.0165243298,
0.004845663,
0.0268561933,
0.0491539165,
0.1279854476,
0.0141342217,
-0.0672993511,
-0.0983195305,
-0.0057676816,
0.0430698916,
0.0173647627,
0.0319065265,
-0.039313104,
-0.0328009799,
-0.0116311284,
-0.037704438,
0.0092191156,
-0.0366849974,
0.0435635671,
0.006406629,
0.0310195275,
-0.0322182067,
0.0309538115,
0.0071575241,
-0.0350518972,
0.006228447,
0.0465829186,
-0.0457943007,
0.000136698,
-0.0076836287,
0.0229663681,
-0.0744867027,
0.0176267531,
-0.0140983975,
0.0169225559,
0.0073831584,
-0.0110336952,
0.0528712682,
0.0049889181,
-0.0797439516,
0.0406333543,
-0.0181935597,
0.0385790281,
-0.0307082906,
-0.0023779103,
0.0292007849,
0.007820488,
0.0111197503,
0.0144043071,
0.0096117118,
-0.0140633518,
-0.0219350625,
0.0075346273,
-0.0062918747,
0.0381052494,
-0.0139964474,
-0.0070182444,
-0.0109087313,
0.0335689522,
0.0081980983,
-0.0499244668,
0.0244352594,
0.0161720421,
2.596e-7,
0.0153247174,
0.0571617633,
-0.0288346987,
-0.0074009835,
-0.0009048248,
0.0243325364,
-0.0019225343,
-0.0148845259,
-0.0171330944,
-0.0466040075,
-0.0199474543,
0.0256847199,
0.0548981242,
0.0395183302,
-0.0746222734,
-0.0028413171,
-0.0691868886,
-0.0306086186,
-0.0563910417,
-0.0093272384,
-0.0077229417,
0.0436734371,
0.0397356153,
-0.0265534315,
-0.0160613731,
-0.0249081179,
0.0277508646,
-0.0045272373,
-0.0623065494,
0.027399024,
0.0702435523,
-0.0090808477,
0.017954668,
0.047997985,
-0.0281639975,
0.0131371683,
-0.0158467777,
0.0935845748,
0.0472714603,
0.0013669407,
-0.0323364586,
0.0023657889,
-0.010070744,
-0.0486335792,
0.0751217753,
-0.0042340634,
-0.0292637348,
-0.0637289733,
-0.0281999502,
-0.031387195,
0.039292112,
-0.0306016114,
-0.0224333294,
-0.0122860251,
-0.0248344652,
-0.0020956867,
-0.0209613945,
-0.0211918298,
0.019723976,
-0.0090445783,
-0.0428217202,
-0.0966328606,
0.0352000967,
-0.0136113279,
0.0197325181,
-0.0686886981,
0.0244400464,
2.388836635e-34,
0.0405286662,
-0.0146803427,
0.0032511631,
-0.0654714555,
0.0670780763,
0.0513810627,
-0.0131110419,
-0.0163492858,
-0.0168021396,
-0.0232400093,
0.0045168763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18294v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18294v2 | Hierarchical Context Pruning: Optimizing Real-World Code Completion with Repository-Level Pretrained Code LLMs | 2024-06-26T12:26:16 | 2024-06-27T04:40:52 | Lei Zhang, Yunshui Li, Jiaming Li, Xiaobo Xia, Jiaxi Yang, Run Luo, Minzheng Wang, Longze Chen, Junhao Liu, Min Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Some recently developed code large language models (Code LLMs) have been
pre-trained on repository-level code data (Repo-Code LLMs), enabling these
models to recognize repository structures and utilize cross-file information
for code completion. However, in real-world development scenarios, simply
concatenating the entire code repository often exceeds the context window
limits of these Repo-Code LLMs, leading to significant performance degradation.
In this study, we conducted extensive preliminary experiments and analyses on
six Repo-Code LLMs. The results indicate that maintaining the topological
dependencies of files and increasing the code file content in the completion
prompts can improve completion accuracy; pruning the specific implementations
of functions in all dependent files does not significantly reduce the accuracy
of completions. Based on these findings, we proposed a strategy named
Hierarchical Context Pruning (HCP) to construct completion prompts with high
informational code content. The HCP models the code repository at the function
level, maintaining the topological dependencies between code files while
removing a large amount of irrelevant code content, significantly reduces the
input length for repository-level code completion. We applied the HCP strategy
in experiments with six Repo-Code LLMs, and the results demonstrate that our
proposed method can significantly enhance completion accuracy while
substantially reducing the length of input. Our code and data are available at
https://github.com/Hambaobao/HCP-Coder. | Hierarchical Context Pruning: Optimizing Real-World Code Completion with Repository-Level Pretrained Code LLMs: Some recently developed code large language models (Code LLMs) have been
pre-trained on repository-level code data (Repo-Code LLMs), enabling these
models to recognize repository structures and utilize cross-file information
for code completion. However, in real-world development scenarios, simply
concatenating the entire code repository often exceeds the context window
limits of these Repo-Code LLMs, leading to significant performance degradation.
In this study, we conducted extensive preliminary experiments and analyses on
six Repo-Code LLMs. The results indicate that maintaining the topological
dependencies of files and increasing the code file content in the completion
prompts can improve completion accuracy; pruning the specific implementations
of functions in all dependent files does not significantly reduce the accuracy
of completions. Based on these findings, we proposed a strategy named
Hierarchical Context Pruning (HCP) to construct completion prompts with high
informational code content. The HCP models the code repository at the function
level, maintaining the topological dependencies between code files while
removing a large amount of irrelevant code content, significantly reduces the
input length for repository-level code completion. We applied the HCP strategy
in experiments with six Repo-Code LLMs, and the results demonstrate that our
proposed method can significantly enhance completion accuracy while
substantially reducing the length of input. Our code and data are available at
https://github.com/Hambaobao/HCP-Coder. | [
0.009151618,
0.0930035636,
-0.0421765707,
0.0023219844,
0.0005203794,
0.0099442806,
-0.0244821459,
0.0360025242,
0.0008118962,
0.044878263,
-0.0539044179,
0.036867056,
0.0325152613,
-0.0171447378,
0.0050364141,
-0.0106877154,
0.0390214324,
-0.0172366817,
-0.0425020568,
-0.0134036103,
-0.0376481265,
0.016569959,
0.0383396819,
0.0538668856,
-0.0006641299,
-0.0537356883,
0.004087097,
0.0367514826,
-0.032597106,
-0.0026002955,
0.0312989801,
0.0410772003,
0.00017789,
0.0187371317,
0.0000023954,
-0.0256574601,
-0.0094623612,
-0.0141774109,
-0.0268712081,
0.0290145744,
-0.0172330551,
-0.0181936678,
0.0065940763,
0.0008659941,
-0.0087354593,
0.0016471804,
0.0332803242,
-0.0121439286,
0.0227420889,
0.0195697639,
0.0292358696,
-0.0178082772,
0.0059877597,
-0.0126361297,
0.0735821277,
-0.0150760291,
-0.0017036148,
0.0487116352,
0.0424267836,
0.0075675012,
0.0010779225,
0.0187809393,
0.0466339774,
0.0166344494,
0.0297282021,
0.0546765178,
0.0041979137,
-0.0291826073,
0.0315041468,
0.0544964969,
-0.0741818473,
-0.0335021205,
0.007005536,
-0.0343503654,
-0.0535774194,
-0.0501559973,
-0.0288534183,
-0.0029879787,
-0.0232741814,
-0.0020094814,
-0.038893234,
-0.031054955,
0.0226715393,
0.0082451273,
-0.035797786,
0.0581395812,
-0.0026887706,
-0.0034877369,
0.0046952148,
-0.0273447484,
-0.0132872509,
-0.0629024357,
0.0016526926,
0.0414311923,
-0.0284805335,
0.0183510445,
-0.0160055924,
-0.0093858251,
0.0631138384,
-0.0304901004,
-0.0543748029,
0.0518911369,
-0.0686581507,
0.0134052597,
-0.0474140234,
0.0752784759,
-0.0304368753,
-0.0420114808,
-0.0376223698,
-0.0069043026,
-0.0232528336,
0.0006502028,
-0.056245517,
0.0393816568,
-0.0409874283,
0.0204741955,
-0.0368130915,
0.0242018588,
0.0076953089,
0.0578393601,
-0.0328986458,
-0.0152940117,
-0.0499700084,
-0.001817262,
0.0279471911,
-0.0298502836,
-0.0415617153,
-0.0299467947,
-0.0480532087,
-0.0149916047,
0.0071150712,
0.0062218956,
-0.0457462333,
-0.0546760485,
0.0326849967,
0.0433564112,
0.0504329875,
0.0084048957,
-0.0267169308,
-0.0339403674,
0.0080948118,
-0.0247823596,
-0.0311531536,
-0.0915891007,
-0.0427791961,
0.0274547692,
-0.0007486705,
-0.0819944069,
-0.0253704581,
-0.0010521875,
-0.0049440316,
0.0175636057,
-0.0645753816,
0.0282474682,
0.061634738,
0.0297494959,
-0.0369215608,
0.0354537703,
0.0169497281,
0.0543758795,
-0.0006830316,
-0.0630902648,
0.0256834626,
0.0152809899,
-0.0177792199,
0.0077695423,
0.0123432809,
0.0325683057,
0.0322433785,
-0.0221911799,
0.0604358651,
0.0137811285,
-0.0093030771,
0.0012393002,
0.0078065312,
0.0191295892,
0.0832698718,
0.0272278655,
0.0241456497,
0.0589572005,
0.0076672472,
0.0031639922,
-0.0669889003,
0.038321808,
-0.0231833886,
0.0218687057,
-0.018207334,
0.0360998251,
0.0041643209,
-0.0517293476,
0.0096321478,
-0.051942315,
-0.0436185785,
0.034760464,
0.034208253,
-0.0169900395,
-0.0243066568,
0.011632666,
0.0479571,
-0.0351743326,
-0.0037481717,
-0.008017811,
0.053159181,
0.0455503948,
0.0352483988,
-0.0679286569,
-0.0196137615,
-0.0045070658,
0.0174077637,
-0.0698098466,
-0.0084908912,
-0.0133046415,
0.0236767512,
-0.0370275751,
-0.0468475111,
-0.0311211515,
-0.030038666,
0.0492209308,
0.0193704814,
-0.0426741019,
0.0143593745,
0.0099399937,
-0.031342037,
0.0470483303,
0.0138785057,
0.032810349,
0.0264639799,
0.0154844886,
0.0212917347,
-0.0354121737,
-0.0382828414,
-0.035310775,
0.0589543395,
-0.0031935056,
-0.0188795663,
-0.0507116579,
-0.0486136377,
-0.0158593338,
0.015909614,
0.0001229325,
-0.0159986969,
-0.0191055574,
-0.0181364678,
0.0035620388,
-0.023288466,
-0.0230971798,
0.0588762648,
0.0102391783,
0.0286090653,
-0.0433880128,
0.0063167131,
-0.0494279452,
0.0539103895,
0.0243527237,
0.050943993,
0.0513135195,
0.0802915469,
0.0532523729,
0.0178838689,
-0.0173402578,
0.021604307,
-0.0331542157,
-0.0013236743,
0.0182358734,
0.0445583574,
-0.0180248339,
-0.0483118854,
-0.0858510286,
0.0074544228,
-0.0088451765,
-0.0014231468,
-0.0054585277,
0.0300780013,
-0.0107230628,
-0.0420712605,
0.0284196418,
0.0215958133,
-0.0299864579,
-0.0018727698,
0.0340783074,
-0.004695585,
-0.0452953577,
-0.0292601306,
-0.0183711573,
0.0036762774,
0.0439969376,
-0.0286250953,
-0.0471795164,
-0.0499113463,
0.1017275453,
0.0224750228,
0.032133311,
-0.0157669913,
-0.0299855098,
0.0064297891,
0.0154413218,
0.097277984,
0.0350382999,
-0.0172647778,
-0.0499085076,
0.0851113796,
0.0315089896,
-0.0686892197,
0.0184419341,
0.0400730968,
-0.0575389415,
-0.0262643509,
-0.0005980924,
0.020927893,
0.0345987044,
0.0047897543,
-0.0073192278,
-0.021814717,
-0.0494038388,
-0.0108614191,
0.0024486603,
0.0149920909,
-0.050190784,
-0.0131953442,
0.0763168111,
-0.0296798833,
-0.1108090207,
0.0376652926,
-0.0614958704,
-0.047559835,
0.0049666008,
-0.0153398942,
-0.0528683998,
0.0689400285,
0.0312455352,
-0.0021609075,
-0.0025583266,
-0.0634046718,
-0.0237415005,
0.0348649882,
-0.0637686551,
0.0123904711,
0.0402964316,
-0.0311714597,
0.0044136797,
-0.01216779,
-0.0271077044,
-0.0273449477,
-0.0020392819,
0.0006682642,
-0.0075489753,
0.0169356596,
-0.006933569,
0.0589618795,
0.0081604943,
0.0262217969,
0.0609307624,
0.0676585585,
-0.0448681489,
-0.0164051689,
-0.0485901497,
-0.0107556116,
-0.0295365769,
0.0067573786,
0.0270660948,
-0.0095172906,
0.0009480233,
0.0760862827,
0.0619276315,
-0.0592328236,
-0.012460527,
0.0503593907,
-0.0229154266,
-0.0964626372,
0.0633729771,
0.0499046817,
-0.0387277752,
0.0127303638,
0.0911342353,
0.0415625796,
-0.0658199638,
0.0114598908,
0.0076363538,
0.041166842,
0.0764091611,
0.0548008457,
-0.0922297686,
0.0059818113,
0.0034674627,
-0.0156410076,
0.021642914,
0.002549883,
0.0040371409,
-0.0474917777,
0.0295290612,
0.006893306,
-0.0096860984,
-0.0171452332,
-0.0286219623,
0.0180060416,
0.0267299954,
-0.046338141,
0.0357921571,
-0.0061088502,
-0.0057324446,
-0.007672179,
-0.0755273402,
0.035853412,
0.0610010549,
-0.0223953705,
-0.0076919259,
0.1039014608,
0.0068334728,
0.0169307534,
0.02332443,
0.0279928613,
-0.0170158241,
0.0281176623,
-0.0398848392,
0.031181626,
0.0168916658,
0.0074773729,
0.0602866076,
-0.0026228514,
-0.0252920445,
-0.0362527519,
0.0369237922,
0.0725501701,
-0.0406135768,
-0.0220245328,
-0.0075564631,
-0.0153069571,
-0.0125662852,
0.0147450268,
0.0641442612,
-0.0247489829,
-0.0141626177,
-0.0407464579,
0.0035054623,
-0.0161343589,
0.0572615601,
-0.0182067342,
-0.0243726969,
-0.0107682599,
-0.0132889086,
-0.0074310862,
0.0358141996,
0.0275205094,
0.0161992218,
0.0036791936,
-0.014539741,
0.0074174646,
-0.0301253498,
0.0172091816,
-0.0123079019,
0.029046176,
-0.0488992408,
-0.0206585806,
0.0296721309,
-0.0330599956,
-0.0240632948,
-0.0275330413,
-0.05946986,
-0.0176137649,
-0.0453106277,
0.0273855738,
0.0125931744,
0.0286508258,
-0.048244372,
-0.1193911359,
-0.0329658575,
-0.0083570378,
-0.0819741711,
0.0412500091,
0.0318095572,
0.0022803429,
0.0074496102,
0.0021044104,
-0.0724110827,
-0.0001528235,
0.0311226621,
-0.0380547084,
-0.022341365,
-0.007739245,
0.0191943329,
0.0017084673,
0.0329868048,
0.0200806763,
-0.0188309532,
-0.0145295225,
0.0331678502,
0.033572007,
0.0012699923,
-0.0105868429,
0.0109973606,
0.0256475322,
-0.0008051258,
0.0481176972,
-0.003651286,
-0.012637849,
0.0297722351,
-0.0133376643,
0.0345365852,
0.0160295554,
0.0417696945,
0.0989737883,
0.0260416828,
-0.0233845133,
-0.0117056388,
0.007470456,
0.0199891683,
-0.033357203,
0.019367205,
-0.0041137077,
0.0296256803,
-0.0001071673,
-0.0142114712,
-0.0250367355,
-0.057163246,
-0.0249664895,
0.0267676804,
0.0451350324,
0.0426514149,
-0.006410805,
-0.0079771541,
0.0193765555,
-0.0455889404,
0.031321235,
0.0113830604,
-0.07018134,
-0.0013011139,
0.0117195845,
-0.0382960774,
-0.011087765,
0.0891797021,
-0.0055518821,
0.0317430161,
-0.0348640904,
-0.0011215252,
-0.0151457135,
0.0206815619,
0.018637158,
0.0187584199,
-0.0616945401,
-0.0263566896,
-0.0169232991,
-0.0407763124,
0.055215735,
0.0073758345,
-0.0151143735,
0.00524254,
0.0239042193,
0.1005618423,
-0.0020001396,
-0.050299339,
0.0024723548,
-0.0148759913,
0.029967647,
-0.036924012,
-0.067915611,
-5.282744346e-33,
-0.0278729461,
-0.0458274782,
0.0137474118,
0.0103111621,
0.0043513207,
-0.0016983333,
-0.0350428671,
-0.0121217705,
0.0064327717,
-0.0692132264,
-0.0134902624,
0.0071327533,
-0.015218663,
-0.0491413102,
0.0616134293,
0.0632462651,
0.0623268597,
0.0417560413,
-0.0363588594,
0.0478143655,
-0.0631062388,
0.0639642924,
-0.0021833756,
-0.0443734787,
-0.0570874736,
0.0070043704,
0.0601305887,
-0.0176150631,
0.0217060801,
0.0541188084,
-0.0167704746,
0.0096665183,
-0.003529212,
0.0005367557,
-0.0458891094,
-0.0010737871,
-0.0596166588,
-0.0405913964,
0.0066659306,
0.0309932847,
0.0279552657,
-0.0714199468,
0.0763738006,
0.0087433131,
-0.0006349681,
0.0037259914,
0.0285596829,
-0.0114900777,
-0.0425976478,
-0.0172365848,
-0.0530139655,
0.0372441225,
-0.0104140723,
0.0207271855,
0.0166844446,
0.0214182734,
0.0148507357,
0.0726803616,
0.0145424884,
-0.0226361789,
-0.0040620742,
0.0779952109,
0.0593870021,
-0.013114403,
0.0053172363,
-0.0114619434,
0.0523904152,
0.0160980541,
-0.0062440005,
0.0045451811,
0.0459259115,
0.0448399037,
0.0043410594,
0.0005104874,
0.0289241578,
-0.0321797654,
-0.0254464857,
0.0153714437,
-0.0146682551,
0.0619635582,
-0.01898643,
0.0706709027,
-0.0169784594,
-0.0012790543,
-0.035110347,
0.0235770978,
-0.0159625933,
-0.0611099452,
0.0208393112,
-0.0047252281,
0.0074595576,
0.0289533846,
0.0043008239,
-0.0299552623,
0.001190725,
0.0307807978,
-0.0473973379,
0.0548056252,
0.0020530608,
0.0289264005,
-0.0171141867,
-0.011948796,
0.0154194729,
-0.0464761443,
0.0704770237,
-0.0010271757,
0.0312617421,
0.0175558366,
-0.0590693951,
0.0031897626,
-0.0365245491,
-0.0550010204,
0.0002190132,
0.0084195379,
0.0046869991,
-0.0096905334,
0.0240747705,
0.0325167961,
-0.0308134165,
-0.0259018857,
-0.0881396011,
-0.0062568681,
-0.0020542424,
0.010549197,
-0.0257771164,
-0.0600907095,
-0.0272536017,
0.056103617,
0.0515852198,
0.0080409683,
-0.0566326082,
0.0382085443,
2.974e-7,
-0.012296496,
0.028214816,
0.0053759357,
0.0169066302,
-0.0270044934,
-0.019073857,
-0.0224782471,
-0.0360540226,
-0.0003164972,
-0.0156463366,
0.0062155668,
-0.0222432278,
0.0467858873,
0.0266295709,
-0.0808581784,
-0.0118579781,
0.0059282319,
-0.0101788342,
-0.0929445475,
-0.008269093,
-0.0015549943,
0.0755584836,
0.0043484229,
0.0011209452,
0.0345342308,
0.001791165,
-0.0079528941,
-0.0255544521,
0.0376747996,
0.0584527068,
-0.057904806,
-0.0080748592,
-0.0168838836,
-0.0215038117,
0.0106074708,
-0.023420047,
-0.0066126641,
0.0482951738,
0.0088881971,
0.0310589857,
0.0248995963,
-0.0113187404,
-0.0344247594,
-0.0481328927,
0.0292991046,
-0.0339578353,
0.0463081524,
0.004950881,
-0.006488251,
-0.0340320244,
0.0122453533,
-0.0037656203,
0.0324502513,
-0.0050612823,
0.0024850185,
-0.0510960743,
-0.0438016206,
-0.0471300557,
-0.0095602591,
0.0370275192,
-0.0522015207,
-0.0239745416,
-0.0655533895,
0.0048579229,
0.0261820853,
-0.0126508391,
0.0170486774,
2.707112521e-34,
0.0053278646,
-0.0539368317,
0.0093819527,
0.018392561,
0.0404624678,
-0.018670354,
-0.0103111882,
0.0440037549,
-0.0060844584,
-0.01791583,
-0.0253803153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18276v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18276v1 | Sanskrit Knowledge-based Systems: Annotation and Computational Tools | 2024-06-26T12:00:10 | 2024-06-26T12:00:10 | Hrishikesh Terdalkar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SE | We address the challenges and opportunities in the development of knowledge
systems for Sanskrit, with a focus on question answering. By proposing a
framework for the automated construction of knowledge graphs, introducing
annotation tools for ontology-driven and general-purpose tasks, and offering a
diverse collection of web-interfaces, tools, and software libraries, we have
made significant contributions to the field of computational Sanskrit. These
contributions not only enhance the accessibility and accuracy of Sanskrit text
analysis but also pave the way for further advancements in knowledge
representation and language processing. Ultimately, this research contributes
to the preservation, understanding, and utilization of the rich linguistic
information embodied in Sanskrit texts. | Sanskrit Knowledge-based Systems: Annotation and Computational Tools: We address the challenges and opportunities in the development of knowledge
systems for Sanskrit, with a focus on question answering. By proposing a
framework for the automated construction of knowledge graphs, introducing
annotation tools for ontology-driven and general-purpose tasks, and offering a
diverse collection of web-interfaces, tools, and software libraries, we have
made significant contributions to the field of computational Sanskrit. These
contributions not only enhance the accessibility and accuracy of Sanskrit text
analysis but also pave the way for further advancements in knowledge
representation and language processing. Ultimately, this research contributes
to the preservation, understanding, and utilization of the rich linguistic
information embodied in Sanskrit texts. | [
0.0374806188,
-0.0555517785,
-0.0492420867,
0.0893947929,
-0.0203987937,
-0.0056908894,
-0.0570229031,
0.0323709995,
0.0248383135,
-0.0393331535,
0.0095771905,
0.0126093002,
-0.0233046748,
-0.0165108219,
0.0134451166,
-0.0335220844,
0.0256767608,
-0.0227236897,
0.0515659973,
0.0094050076,
0.0738159791,
0.0378773585,
-0.0277514402,
0.0066583599,
-0.0419301391,
-0.0327237919,
0.0065386649,
-0.0443221703,
0.0182664674,
-0.013302274,
-0.0405422114,
0.0339095928,
-0.0214024223,
0.0251187906,
0.0000014437,
-0.0727265552,
-0.0474889912,
-0.0000166395,
-0.0279673841,
-0.0239826273,
0.0101089897,
0.0167155396,
0.0461658016,
0.0008052278,
-0.056624949,
0.0339762159,
0.0763986483,
-0.0535216145,
0.0442803651,
0.03268224,
-0.0236512665,
-0.0009813331,
0.0312248692,
0.0345246308,
-0.0084281974,
0.022665387,
0.0075222887,
0.061139334,
0.014085955,
-0.0286603589,
-0.0273714233,
0.0449441858,
-0.0255409274,
-0.0180667769,
0.0343234241,
-0.0369536988,
-0.0611806139,
-0.0058478578,
0.0254265741,
-0.0024746577,
0.066718027,
-0.031848561,
-0.0013834352,
0.0275464393,
-0.0504600331,
-0.0055416967,
-0.0381612442,
0.013185055,
-0.0589049272,
0.0196882822,
0.0567808561,
-0.0064790794,
-0.0380625837,
0.0152898645,
0.0585685521,
0.0227443781,
-0.003198318,
-0.0130981272,
-0.0054689953,
-0.0248546377,
-0.0600289591,
-0.0351692252,
0.0279782917,
0.0826626644,
-0.0037900172,
0.0694046319,
0.0052825832,
-0.0796995312,
0.0317103676,
-0.0231191386,
-0.0077286833,
0.0234380662,
0.0026386238,
0.000241653,
0.0067600207,
0.0316130109,
0.0390226804,
0.011707915,
-0.0273450874,
-0.0426844321,
0.0164747424,
-0.0717444941,
-0.0758230537,
0.014091,
0.004399918,
0.0362250134,
-0.0337780304,
0.0229944345,
-0.0216796007,
-0.0087056896,
0.0167411882,
-0.0235188901,
0.0095511535,
-0.0052264961,
-0.0409697667,
0.007133841,
-0.0162080564,
-0.0116330376,
-0.0200937781,
-0.0272364896,
0.0259507131,
0.0059530591,
0.013536986,
-0.0060473206,
-0.0367542319,
0.0217798427,
0.0235927068,
-0.0225996431,
-0.0386159681,
-0.0109311761,
-0.0247813724,
-0.0310371537,
-0.0126788411,
-0.0790922642,
0.0577849075,
0.0604084507,
-0.0332675166,
-0.0591455773,
0.0465743318,
0.0040364284,
-0.0169549026,
0.0663111731,
-0.057415247,
-0.0188238993,
0.0154760415,
0.0043115299,
0.0185600612,
-0.0236380007,
0.0362139791,
-0.0075454777,
0.0900139585,
-0.0041227685,
0.0131474268,
0.0161901861,
-0.0045055202,
-0.032506492,
0.00470777,
0.0666217878,
-0.0194572024,
0.0265197866,
-0.0494407974,
0.046049159,
0.0196662229,
0.0284222048,
-0.0136310784,
0.0753256157,
-0.0047522285,
0.0623265877,
0.0023353202,
-0.0021212883,
0.058252383,
-0.0190958157,
-0.0157130677,
0.0354157351,
0.0101781003,
0.0154654766,
-0.0141481971,
-0.055514507,
0.0109176654,
-0.0460522287,
-0.0650985315,
-0.0339218639,
-0.027856987,
-0.0269367043,
0.0504165106,
0.0019685505,
0.0047665946,
0.0121156443,
0.0540968403,
-0.0563940778,
0.0460282639,
-0.0283643249,
0.0663557053,
0.0588318408,
0.0224545151,
-0.0733867735,
-0.0118078217,
0.0694968924,
-0.0064895051,
0.0361306779,
0.0079559823,
-0.0354381241,
-0.0610456392,
-0.0159485377,
0.0381769091,
0.0218934771,
-0.0199671462,
0.0126633458,
-0.0129277641,
0.01514214,
-0.0090728831,
-0.0450415239,
-0.0188462231,
0.025731273,
0.0362183414,
0.0025047385,
-0.0459871665,
0.0113811539,
0.0389079712,
0.0154541861,
0.0192212779,
0.0264808219,
0.0413318351,
0.0057550892,
-0.0158856567,
0.0003859033,
0.0573732443,
-0.0159808062,
0.0281443801,
-0.0369644724,
0.0149010746,
0.010993707,
0.0179798882,
-0.0482948348,
-0.0046412055,
-0.0399041437,
0.0508459732,
-0.0339488387,
0.0025420287,
0.0461014509,
-0.0237722509,
-0.049250789,
0.0404977016,
0.0462654792,
0.0258536469,
-0.0185423028,
-0.0703071877,
0.0434257276,
-0.0443507768,
-0.024801543,
-0.0004125651,
0.0249076467,
0.0069402209,
-0.0065582097,
-0.0283293314,
-0.0400409177,
0.0202496089,
-0.1237587929,
0.0042510862,
0.0017690253,
0.0672950894,
-0.0094077727,
0.0286312159,
-0.0116293291,
-0.0260932464,
-0.018146785,
0.0372324735,
0.070584394,
-0.0244220849,
0.0266673453,
-0.0002364834,
0.0148990126,
-0.0560897589,
-0.0122832041,
-0.031960547,
0.0190419853,
0.0078396928,
-0.0754878893,
-0.00912691,
-0.0108326031,
-0.0744023696,
0.0281258672,
-0.0014023564,
-0.0081839645,
-0.0345210992,
-0.0109174894,
-0.0199861489,
-0.0200513303,
-0.0044654068,
0.0084772334,
0.0245629288,
-0.0277247299,
0.0033575606,
-0.0092404196,
0.0125045432,
0.0195529275,
0.0071591046,
0.006112319,
-0.007463797,
0.005845719,
0.0197525565,
-0.0173981059,
0.0046380353,
0.0060444381,
-0.0691128075,
0.046644561,
-0.0126542877,
0.0111062275,
-0.0390933417,
0.0630212203,
0.0076630055,
-0.0283568259,
0.0666260794,
-0.0178817939,
0.0064152344,
-0.0620737001,
0.0326088108,
-0.0328461267,
0.0534823053,
-0.0076416368,
0.0190284252,
0.0043336395,
0.0070034065,
-0.025263967,
0.0023744272,
0.0376936086,
-0.0524325222,
0.010898686,
-0.0467617698,
0.0504340641,
-0.0407426134,
0.0287097655,
-0.0110794259,
0.0331183262,
-0.0180724598,
-0.0029011904,
0.0462256931,
0.0207498427,
0.0753957927,
0.0640898943,
-0.0278817955,
-0.0302121658,
-0.0128985895,
0.014308366,
0.0050693569,
0.053490594,
0.0526393279,
0.0311284736,
0.0156165836,
0.0799176022,
0.0124040702,
0.0094117429,
0.0111357439,
-0.0318381451,
0.0314447768,
-0.0283783097,
0.0352019817,
-0.0765891671,
-0.0049681794,
-0.0170325059,
-0.0196306463,
-0.0346815027,
0.0340081453,
0.0594972149,
0.0844406188,
0.0025554916,
-0.0098589212,
-0.0780525655,
-0.0487320386,
0.0110078007,
0.0408668816,
-0.1365463585,
-0.0009116434,
-0.025881175,
0.0010328564,
0.0103048021,
-0.0187473055,
-0.0062352545,
-0.064235203,
0.000693984,
-0.0423556268,
-0.0397670716,
0.0096396552,
0.01540446,
-0.024433149,
-0.0099264449,
-0.0395474881,
0.0277066175,
-0.0408868231,
0.019099839,
0.0247842651,
0.0074163168,
0.0559747778,
0.0070418688,
-0.0238711797,
-0.0055782683,
0.0128755374,
0.0524294227,
-0.0097067049,
-0.006487919,
-0.0343411043,
-0.0115023879,
-0.0052768281,
-0.0359557122,
0.0287431944,
-0.0038111401,
-0.0142081399,
-0.0466039963,
0.0017846643,
-0.0181194395,
-0.0256853215,
0.0810954869,
0.0881498083,
-0.0092615932,
0.0046366476,
-0.0016837625,
-0.007247753,
-0.024614092,
0.021978559,
-0.0194036644,
0.0447448529,
-0.0195965823,
-0.0401866175,
0.0304091908,
-0.0103906477,
-0.0538744703,
0.0096366499,
-0.0471206941,
-0.0013260838,
-0.0628346875,
-0.041944623,
0.0726151019,
-0.0111270072,
0.0329688229,
0.0431085601,
0.0328102484,
0.0579857826,
-0.0776206478,
-0.049147442,
-0.0406544171,
0.0083032642,
0.0047029816,
-0.0145564554,
0.0208313074,
0.0014785908,
0.0001262371,
0.0119201085,
0.0363475494,
-0.0250274763,
-0.013419616,
0.0386030152,
0.0201483257,
-0.0128451074,
-0.0435111821,
-0.0261463001,
-0.0049606576,
-0.014099081,
-0.0553146116,
-0.0052349074,
0.0214857925,
0.0069477088,
-0.024069868,
0.0326583274,
-0.0386138111,
-0.0265395977,
-0.0479412153,
-0.0028408123,
0.0050859586,
-0.0111863557,
0.0618369915,
0.0583967231,
-0.0169354994,
-0.0686655566,
-0.004414707,
-0.0116225472,
0.002630719,
-0.0255434066,
-0.0422177911,
-0.0160338841,
0.0149530843,
-0.0284912139,
0.0259912536,
-0.0278057959,
0.021639647,
0.0086955912,
-0.0055226777,
0.034119226,
0.0534948669,
0.0736834779,
0.031849727,
-0.0130106295,
0.0041850405,
0.0003373485,
-0.0069616721,
-0.0167010296,
0.0013186316,
-0.0106391096,
0.0519111007,
-0.0193791222,
-0.0298345406,
0.0311446935,
0.0058747754,
0.0421096981,
-0.0008046622,
0.0163128898,
0.022596309,
0.0549202338,
0.0134458411,
0.0465398952,
-0.0632930845,
0.0035528655,
0.012985711,
0.0054007,
0.0179560483,
0.0077300584,
0.0331975855,
0.016742928,
0.0244037304,
-0.0116616627,
0.0671116188,
-0.0537633263,
0.0141187645,
0.0293411631,
-0.0895549282,
-0.0266386364,
-0.0612328388,
-0.0395469218,
0.0241258983,
0.036678385,
-0.0203159507,
-0.0701980069,
-0.0596841425,
-0.0131427916,
0.0145792235,
-0.0078549264,
-0.0233174972,
0.0502773672,
0.0301250499,
0.0645209253,
-0.0330124237,
-0.0481527559,
0.0484942943,
-0.1135489792,
-0.0066241054,
0.0231623519,
-4.187087368e-33,
-0.0661089197,
0.0013814901,
0.0089493515,
0.0729545578,
0.0183907486,
-0.0074633225,
-0.0481511839,
0.0015481896,
-0.0233023744,
0.021082947,
-0.0239651371,
0.0020225225,
0.0093544861,
-0.0297147296,
0.0108179236,
-0.0179261919,
-0.049370978,
0.0136099653,
0.0072282283,
-0.0153076947,
0.0784664825,
-0.0357931964,
0.0824938789,
-0.0099503072,
0.0797383934,
-0.028983159,
-0.0150878578,
0.0428898782,
-0.0334654972,
0.0537370145,
-0.0548403971,
0.0808848515,
0.018819876,
0.001398716,
0.0093434975,
0.0124270646,
-0.0910294279,
-0.044132106,
0.0727662668,
0.038404882,
-0.0371513851,
-0.0222614612,
-0.0195333455,
0.0057763848,
0.0186993647,
0.0667394325,
0.0556155369,
-0.0136078261,
0.0089741126,
-0.0729848593,
-0.0619603097,
0.0209653694,
-0.031040011,
-0.0229137838,
-0.0032080477,
-0.0151734836,
0.0192342494,
-0.0300178807,
-0.0326306336,
-0.0095343124,
0.0022664883,
0.0260463431,
0.0294170119,
0.0041765398,
-0.0510275327,
-0.0415325463,
-0.0128007969,
-0.086021319,
0.0439694896,
0.0649092644,
-0.0193756241,
0.0443652794,
0.0610445663,
0.0324957706,
-0.0032910933,
-0.0131661482,
-0.0344441272,
-0.013387247,
-0.0281131919,
0.0447687469,
-0.0177641753,
-0.0143118668,
-0.0164105333,
-0.0292081703,
0.0118791629,
-0.0284840334,
-0.0276745167,
-0.0240481868,
0.0232532043,
-0.054356344,
-0.0264126845,
0.0454220511,
-0.0084216874,
-0.0470137484,
0.0346252173,
0.0391708091,
0.0116393548,
0.0308819842,
-0.0213809218,
0.0286062919,
-0.030965725,
0.0181869939,
-0.0221610777,
-0.0285685547,
-0.0199450087,
-0.0174289364,
0.0125236074,
-0.0149729438,
-0.025589535,
0.0153214885,
0.007285614,
0.0487031005,
-0.0410740301,
-0.0100992834,
-0.008479449,
0.0425485,
0.0287205577,
-0.0063062753,
0.065503791,
0.0380943678,
-0.0528482758,
0.0177492145,
0.0150656607,
-0.0510360934,
0.0035505674,
0.0183881037,
-0.0253822319,
0.0336679332,
-0.0127398288,
-0.0184225943,
0.0394153967,
0.0245455001,
2.217e-7,
0.0838552415,
0.0265676603,
0.0455732718,
-0.0163311176,
-0.0008082524,
-0.0275945179,
0.0097838454,
-0.0221121404,
-0.009739629,
0.0157917328,
0.0132110659,
0.0358639695,
-0.0047150571,
0.0803923309,
-0.0810831785,
-0.0316743664,
-0.0275994968,
-0.0907611027,
-0.0544121005,
0.0522694141,
0.0159656312,
0.0188396759,
0.0458027385,
0.0029741144,
-0.0611873306,
-0.033510115,
0.0251445603,
0.0299473293,
0.0345485173,
0.0453384183,
0.0089969197,
-0.0559406541,
-0.0008106875,
0.0226126574,
0.0150844352,
0.0296666864,
0.0181919057,
0.0306592043,
-0.0179434735,
0.014641243,
0.0123708537,
-0.016005436,
0.0537353307,
-0.0346870013,
0.0701540932,
0.01629664,
0.004463478,
0.02777211,
0.0157460924,
-0.0018440377,
-0.0336162709,
-0.0031727867,
-0.019695038,
-0.0046447758,
0.0026612463,
-0.0590496771,
-0.0121328849,
-0.0345280059,
-0.0097150123,
0.0642307922,
0.0254807957,
-0.0680825859,
0.007382934,
-0.0129120359,
0.0264673568,
-0.0771039724,
0.005474587,
1.29838425e-34,
0.0150066856,
0.0004457294,
0.0164234042,
0.005812957,
0.0055018817,
-0.0129040349,
0.0008362889,
0.0351813398,
0.0187310409,
-0.0519995205,
-0.0225061011
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18266v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18266v2 | "Vorbeşti Româneşte?" A Recipe to Train Powerful Romanian LLMs with English Instructions | 2024-06-26T11:39:51 | 2024-06-27T20:30:47 | Mihai Masala, Denis C. Ilie-Ablachim, Alexandru Dima, Dragos Corlatescu, Miruna Zavelca, Ovio Olaru, Simina Terian, Andrei Terian, Marius Leordeanu, Horia Velicu, Marius Popescu, Mihai Dascalu, Traian Rebedea | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved almost human-like
performance on various tasks. While some LLMs have been trained on multilingual
data, most of the training data is in English; hence, their performance in
English greatly exceeds other languages. To our knowledge, we are the first to
collect and translate a large collection of texts, instructions, and benchmarks
and train, evaluate, and release open-source LLMs tailored for Romanian. We
evaluate our methods on four different categories, including academic
benchmarks, MT-Bench (manually translated), and a professionally built
historical, cultural, and social benchmark adapted to Romanian. We argue for
the usefulness and high performance of RoLLMs by obtaining state-of-the-art
results across the board. We publicly release all resources (i.e., data,
training and evaluation code, models) to support and encourage research on
Romanian LLMs while concurrently creating a generalizable recipe, adequate for
other low or less-resourced languages. | "Vorbeşti Româneşte?" A Recipe to Train Powerful Romanian LLMs with English Instructions: In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved almost human-like
performance on various tasks. While some LLMs have been trained on multilingual
data, most of the training data is in English; hence, their performance in
English greatly exceeds other languages. To our knowledge, we are the first to
collect and translate a large collection of texts, instructions, and benchmarks
and train, evaluate, and release open-source LLMs tailored for Romanian. We
evaluate our methods on four different categories, including academic
benchmarks, MT-Bench (manually translated), and a professionally built
historical, cultural, and social benchmark adapted to Romanian. We argue for
the usefulness and high performance of RoLLMs by obtaining state-of-the-art
results across the board. We publicly release all resources (i.e., data,
training and evaluation code, models) to support and encourage research on
Romanian LLMs while concurrently creating a generalizable recipe, adequate for
other low or less-resourced languages. | [
0.0031976947,
0.0522010326,
-0.0010537537,
0.0552376546,
-0.0214062408,
0.0245311316,
-0.0012293118,
0.0130275255,
0.0128840115,
-0.0343461521,
-0.0570191517,
-0.0613981336,
-0.0058697597,
-0.0346041098,
0.0522052534,
-0.0311663914,
0.0614646114,
-0.0387083329,
-0.0529650711,
-0.0106310332,
-0.0019838361,
-0.0064543094,
-0.033778131,
-0.001651578,
-0.0001278678,
0.0163105931,
0.0149642369,
0.0181981605,
0.0267073289,
-0.0109435916,
0.0117750578,
-0.0026221077,
0.0325000994,
0.036290504,
0.0000017314,
-0.0569058061,
-0.0005906658,
-0.0247526728,
0.0161115248,
0.0279533938,
0.0525358021,
-0.0495702848,
-0.0332397819,
0.0142027792,
-0.0362966694,
-0.0147208525,
0.0233462714,
0.0247625168,
0.0366403423,
0.0992462784,
-0.004663635,
-0.0372040905,
0.0180677343,
-0.0566941388,
-0.0283639114,
-0.0268770624,
0.0254046582,
0.0128458664,
-0.0011582564,
0.013717832,
-0.0035330751,
0.054819908,
-0.0034889563,
0.0037311094,
-0.0501652099,
0.0126020256,
-0.0357299596,
-0.0172414873,
-0.0456072651,
0.053890802,
0.0217535738,
0.0015971912,
0.0335063636,
0.0335936137,
-0.0421268493,
-0.0268910322,
-0.0585408919,
0.055507794,
0.0241894126,
0.022706436,
0.0208504293,
0.001076901,
0.0292960275,
0.0115650138,
0.0272733346,
0.0568187721,
0.0388440229,
-0.0316908956,
0.050269261,
0.0003775753,
0.0277200956,
-0.0228210706,
0.0216466468,
0.0752629787,
-0.0111931954,
0.0291114543,
-0.0163194593,
-0.0037263103,
0.0561592467,
-0.050775826,
0.0296230782,
0.0412995927,
-0.0237743221,
0.0522725433,
-0.0410134085,
0.0692037195,
-0.0213895384,
0.0219702646,
-0.0398176946,
-0.0176735986,
-0.028540954,
0.026566755,
-0.0410140045,
-0.0187885221,
-0.0306680072,
0.007455098,
-0.0780941918,
0.0158079527,
0.0491490886,
0.0338518284,
0.0220562462,
-0.0289967973,
-0.0420142785,
-0.0017108367,
-0.0297638923,
0.0381453894,
-0.0192828998,
0.0093147662,
-0.0509446636,
-0.0473883748,
-0.0085125146,
0.0352511071,
-0.0316772833,
-0.0256872959,
0.0561410673,
0.0646630824,
-0.0345016755,
-0.0219769999,
-0.0377274416,
0.0105642229,
-0.0042253798,
-0.098799862,
-0.0159317628,
-0.0664705113,
0.0302866995,
-0.0080171786,
0.0214844067,
-0.0668220297,
0.0169040933,
0.0419018343,
-0.0374510027,
0.034466017,
-0.0127186077,
-0.000373871,
0.0036819119,
0.0157587361,
0.011962614,
0.0632486492,
0.0293999631,
0.0498746596,
0.0444689505,
0.0161624178,
0.0022440059,
0.076937072,
0.0055553303,
0.0278223269,
-0.041164428,
0.0515923016,
0.0163374878,
0.0355461501,
0.0616236776,
0.0923552364,
-0.0008634555,
0.0043835081,
0.0594211482,
0.0374061055,
0.0323192738,
0.0373601131,
0.0644102097,
-0.0302966684,
0.0158373155,
-0.022745356,
-0.0473762453,
-0.024182884,
0.0126547841,
0.0137300426,
-0.019660525,
0.0267163087,
-0.0340261646,
-0.0236852467,
-0.0147246551,
-0.0439575166,
0.0177815016,
-0.0237777419,
0.0682027042,
0.0075591635,
-0.0466072038,
0.0638906583,
0.0498065241,
-0.0671940669,
0.0115357423,
-0.0250736605,
0.0656936541,
0.0482244752,
0.0218375381,
-0.0418023951,
0.0006347821,
-0.0095827496,
0.0521028936,
0.0465238094,
0.0577177256,
-0.0285969023,
0.0035156368,
-0.091942355,
0.0230255481,
0.0049250461,
0.0079377871,
0.0374650955,
-0.0053053005,
0.040873453,
0.0267325994,
-0.0044094352,
-0.0374339297,
0.0430266336,
-0.0541762337,
-0.0113377459,
-0.0231464785,
-0.0161094312,
-0.0039242026,
0.0243506655,
0.0113284355,
-0.0218643341,
0.0622050948,
-0.051074788,
0.0266811065,
-0.0112417806,
-0.0054548527,
-0.0127959484,
0.0739343986,
-0.0303272158,
-0.0344103761,
0.0214694552,
-0.033196222,
-0.0338893607,
0.0354783572,
-0.0333016291,
-0.0069128424,
-0.0363784842,
0.036454346,
0.0079867253,
0.0104691042,
-0.0400196612,
0.0578214042,
-0.0246812645,
0.0123068318,
0.0611744896,
-0.028010888,
0.0190102272,
-0.0387357064,
-0.0453346893,
0.0177159794,
0.0039702039,
0.0004467223,
0.0007532858,
0.0525952354,
-0.0178502928,
-0.0259642228,
-0.101761274,
0.054092709,
-0.0530484356,
0.0354814306,
0.004433346,
-0.0045807785,
-0.0283379238,
-0.034819141,
-0.0652526617,
-0.0205269977,
-0.012230779,
-0.0118726091,
0.0278243832,
0.0201579928,
-0.0194871686,
-0.0482696146,
0.0080222553,
0.0094137248,
-0.0140262209,
-0.0208027195,
-0.0152537739,
-0.061032705,
0.0496047214,
-0.0511986502,
0.0322890803,
-0.0593655221,
-0.0505407825,
-0.0132180713,
0.0090541681,
0.0728742778,
0.0296775289,
-0.0173338186,
0.0151688233,
0.047142487,
0.0053079328,
-0.0481477901,
0.0154257957,
-0.0190972127,
-0.0230630357,
-0.0986391231,
-0.0482205041,
-0.0218207687,
0.0524485856,
-0.0272921994,
0.0222874135,
-0.0272876117,
-0.0247234292,
-0.0281555988,
-0.0117527805,
-0.0079724835,
0.0051555787,
-0.0251860712,
0.0395389311,
0.01637212,
-0.0326453857,
0.0273445472,
-0.0537683517,
-0.0187946074,
-0.0237885918,
-0.0431109853,
-0.0784107074,
0.0183876697,
-0.004491115,
0.0044249799,
-0.0501698405,
-0.015300421,
-0.0417838618,
-0.0194612481,
0.0042156829,
-0.0399296433,
0.0920988396,
-0.0550246499,
-0.0041215029,
-0.0276414528,
-0.0274683014,
-0.0345017873,
-0.0164391082,
-0.0342069902,
0.0121758142,
-0.0018014901,
-0.0230135769,
-0.0251059234,
-0.0028791171,
0.0138067473,
0.052736681,
-0.0149843078,
0.0258041862,
-0.0233057775,
0.0028462114,
0.037356779,
0.0176614709,
0.0233097523,
-0.0407510027,
-0.0065575908,
0.0453748144,
0.0529292934,
-0.0444832034,
-0.0372668803,
-0.0153566366,
0.041127529,
-0.0513085201,
-0.0214414503,
-0.0232710447,
0.0237954985,
-0.0339709669,
-0.019073125,
0.0941758528,
0.015501976,
-0.0605883934,
-0.0047698864,
-0.018037444,
0.021886982,
0.0298141185,
0.037182875,
-0.0845518783,
-0.0126283839,
-0.0099018933,
0.0159468241,
0.0117217842,
0.0077133179,
-0.0162950791,
-0.0969794691,
0.0103383372,
0.0049436674,
-0.0027272988,
-0.0229324866,
-0.0224641487,
-0.0088241724,
-0.0514351353,
0.0272123665,
0.0141670648,
-0.0593421869,
-0.0332765393,
0.0262538996,
-0.0247880407,
-0.0513371155,
-0.0103077544,
-0.0290747881,
0.0718296245,
0.0428026021,
0.0261063445,
-0.0372015834,
-0.0293778703,
0.0726491585,
-0.0121067995,
0.0092049604,
-0.0338808373,
0.0456043929,
0.0135987131,
-0.0156307798,
0.0093947593,
0.0097739641,
-0.019266719,
-0.0038358842,
0.0489543341,
0.0537768491,
-0.0121651078,
-0.0151361423,
0.017546365,
-0.0020225157,
0.0328585692,
0.0591458566,
0.0128566185,
-0.0036813822,
-0.0121816201,
-0.0198823344,
-0.0432228781,
-0.0282316897,
-0.0767048597,
0.0063956408,
-0.0400535055,
-0.0251504947,
-0.0636107549,
-0.0547103211,
0.032524921,
0.0229985528,
0.0308328532,
-0.0046713469,
0.0032077772,
-0.0015904496,
-0.0356782973,
0.0444243997,
-0.0407572612,
0.0226299912,
-0.0782355219,
-0.0208851639,
0.0573938526,
-0.0163589697,
-0.0120352227,
0.0223811492,
-0.097077392,
-0.0643773973,
-0.0078800479,
0.0695101395,
0.0223334078,
0.0701694861,
-0.0065404596,
-0.059525989,
0.0313225202,
-0.0247094873,
-0.0122699076,
0.0177999288,
0.0423293337,
0.0077478471,
0.0029768392,
0.044394251,
-0.0309808571,
0.0281123854,
0.0169650987,
0.0414724201,
-0.0453802273,
-0.012981547,
-0.0046938793,
0.0152788544,
0.0177848879,
-0.0527963713,
-0.0127911568,
-0.025082672,
0.0457099825,
-0.0542344339,
0.008422832,
-0.0090407664,
0.0232582595,
0.0332068875,
-0.0073989145,
-0.0312427785,
-0.0214278009,
-0.0216949489,
-0.0059540817,
-0.0453750938,
0.0312211048,
0.0016004094,
0.0345387235,
0.0350734256,
0.0238020103,
-0.0148109524,
0.0670856386,
-0.0014648669,
0.0550147183,
-0.0188265722,
0.0312803052,
0.0083206911,
-0.0161408279,
0.0155969355,
0.0221820604,
-0.0158562753,
-0.0116556687,
0.017732881,
0.0108781699,
0.0890425965,
0.003137693,
0.1189477593,
-0.0370397717,
-0.0014552635,
-0.0166583732,
0.0291445944,
-0.0085497489,
0.0023950813,
0.0139597282,
0.007163649,
-0.0258993562,
0.0334221497,
0.0499601215,
-0.0006396774,
0.0207736921,
0.0222159121,
0.0065326551,
-0.0380081311,
-0.0449665897,
-0.0018111625,
-0.0500679798,
-0.0394659825,
-0.0352520794,
-0.0499104373,
-0.0479089171,
0.0355119109,
0.042571269,
-0.0367284566,
-0.010452956,
0.0378142186,
0.0227187462,
0.0107854363,
0.0325760357,
-0.0738123879,
0.0229647104,
-0.0041170367,
-0.0384398885,
-0.0422103368,
-5.347071071e-33,
-0.0352815427,
0.0090782987,
0.0577030629,
-0.0005857535,
-0.0372052118,
-0.0300999992,
-0.0201326925,
-0.0047408519,
0.0019719056,
0.01839705,
-0.0060323677,
-0.0124702798,
0.0315035172,
-0.0002062728,
-0.0081565715,
-0.0173852704,
0.0146076977,
0.009868715,
-0.004560682,
0.0259496737,
0.0067248386,
0.0380185992,
0.0926551148,
-0.0700233057,
0.0064163269,
-0.0327691846,
-0.0161850043,
0.0540127568,
0.0345440991,
0.08714284,
-0.0236726701,
0.0181330051,
0.0073993225,
-0.0180717614,
-0.0063981526,
-0.0007866613,
-0.0561704822,
-0.0159439351,
0.0491377078,
0.0486633889,
-0.0017069598,
-0.0403371677,
0.0162837431,
-0.0229612943,
-0.0313145779,
0.0171478856,
0.0357358009,
-0.041346807,
-0.0156186847,
-0.0329276808,
-0.0566936135,
0.0276785735,
-0.0036600688,
0.0049444111,
0.0278927144,
0.0373445004,
0.0077455905,
0.0066942517,
-0.0603654273,
0.0230002105,
-0.0235780273,
0.0403537787,
0.0635391474,
-0.0238663014,
-0.0161149912,
0.0375266671,
0.0056356415,
-0.0159207936,
-0.0038780472,
-0.0094035231,
0.0426798984,
0.0282965098,
0.0415363349,
0.0544391908,
-0.0103437575,
-0.0106618172,
-0.0970611945,
0.0054220785,
0.05894088,
0.0362121426,
-0.0079542156,
-0.0264800303,
-0.0374024846,
-0.0031916813,
-0.0096293138,
0.008173706,
0.0040453663,
-0.0288483221,
0.0387738347,
0.004982864,
0.0123000154,
0.0055458806,
0.0097152861,
-0.0332055911,
-0.041147247,
0.0031425718,
-0.0079151103,
0.0167364068,
-0.0188317318,
0.049729377,
-0.0537035763,
-0.0383524485,
-0.0168503914,
0.0024282702,
0.0346538089,
-0.010485718,
0.0440336876,
0.0241211038,
-0.0668812022,
0.0080720214,
-0.0169537012,
0.0227517188,
-0.0005069114,
0.0391965136,
0.0102641387,
-0.0028680356,
-0.0063380529,
0.052257143,
0.0132796243,
-0.0323269814,
-0.0178052671,
-0.0417632014,
0.0457763039,
0.0355122648,
-0.0374827832,
0.0244854502,
-0.0203310549,
0.0597333871,
0.0391355343,
-0.0229467526,
0.012138023,
0.0142559083,
2.348e-7,
0.0613150671,
0.051244285,
-0.0006271905,
0.0411643945,
-0.0164540261,
-0.0116172619,
-0.0766431615,
0.0215091985,
-0.0205584224,
0.0291893315,
0.0345274024,
0.0406844057,
0.0707655102,
0.0147848306,
-0.0983678252,
-0.0041702571,
-0.0529437214,
-0.0222360175,
-0.0535767488,
-0.0068458943,
-0.0221083388,
0.0863674432,
0.017315438,
-0.018912524,
-0.0492791981,
-0.0218379423,
0.0667302758,
-0.0360925123,
-0.0321288183,
0.0578939542,
0.032369744,
0.0336380862,
-0.0391906388,
-0.022276368,
-0.0017250641,
0.0291691646,
-0.0005752353,
0.1025223583,
0.0127580091,
-0.0260341708,
0.047995165,
-0.0313717015,
-0.0219884422,
0.0016612842,
0.035450168,
0.0092816083,
0.0177081302,
-0.031320747,
-0.0100904964,
0.0158044305,
0.0140941124,
-0.0190293137,
-0.0038263733,
0.0364454389,
0.0481308699,
-0.0316049978,
-0.0436481908,
-0.0842869654,
-0.0290871318,
-0.0112178857,
-0.0342172273,
-0.0501433536,
-0.0068649985,
0.0134813786,
-0.0478735641,
-0.0559349917,
-0.0143805742,
2.107817032e-34,
0.04804774,
-0.019566115,
-0.0160674546,
0.0532114245,
0.025248358,
0.000521772,
0.000685146,
0.0075468379,
-0.0052411482,
-0.0655375123,
0.0057192487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18259v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18259v1 | Detecting Machine-Generated Texts: Not Just "AI vs Humans" and Explainability is Complicated | 2024-06-26T11:11:47 | 2024-06-26T11:11:47 | Jiazhou Ji, Ruizhe Li, Shujun Li, Jie Guo, Weidong Qiu, Zheng Huang, Chiyu Chen, Xiaoyu Jiang, Xinru Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As LLMs rapidly advance, increasing concerns arise regarding risks about
actual authorship of texts we see online and in real world. The task of
distinguishing LLM-authored texts is complicated by the nuanced and overlapping
behaviors of both machines and humans. In this paper, we challenge the current
practice of considering LLM-generated text detection a binary classification
task of differentiating human from AI. Instead, we introduce a novel ternary
text classification scheme, adding an "undecided" category for texts that could
be attributed to either source, and we show that this new category is crucial
to understand how to make the detection result more explainable to lay users.
This research shifts the paradigm from merely classifying to explaining
machine-generated texts, emphasizing need for detectors to provide clear and
understandable explanations to users. Our study involves creating four new
datasets comprised of texts from various LLMs and human authors. Based on new
datasets, we performed binary classification tests to ascertain the most
effective SOTA detection methods and identified SOTA LLMs capable of producing
harder-to-detect texts. We constructed a new dataset of texts generated by two
top-performing LLMs and human authors, and asked three human annotators to
produce ternary labels with explanation notes. This dataset was used to
investigate how three top-performing SOTA detectors behave in new ternary
classification context. Our results highlight why "undecided" category is much
needed from the viewpoint of explainability. Additionally, we conducted an
analysis of explainability of the three best-performing detectors and the
explanation notes of the human annotators, revealing insights about the
complexity of explainable detection of machine-generated texts. Finally, we
propose guidelines for developing future detection systems with improved
explanatory power. | Detecting Machine-Generated Texts: Not Just "AI vs Humans" and Explainability is Complicated: As LLMs rapidly advance, increasing concerns arise regarding risks about
actual authorship of texts we see online and in real world. The task of
distinguishing LLM-authored texts is complicated by the nuanced and overlapping
behaviors of both machines and humans. In this paper, we challenge the current
practice of considering LLM-generated text detection a binary classification
task of differentiating human from AI. Instead, we introduce a novel ternary
text classification scheme, adding an "undecided" category for texts that could
be attributed to either source, and we show that this new category is crucial
to understand how to make the detection result more explainable to lay users.
This research shifts the paradigm from merely classifying to explaining
machine-generated texts, emphasizing need for detectors to provide clear and
understandable explanations to users. Our study involves creating four new
datasets comprised of texts from various LLMs and human authors. Based on new
datasets, we performed binary classification tests to ascertain the most
effective SOTA detection methods and identified SOTA LLMs capable of producing
harder-to-detect texts. We constructed a new dataset of texts generated by two
top-performing LLMs and human authors, and asked three human annotators to
produce ternary labels with explanation notes. This dataset was used to
investigate how three top-performing SOTA detectors behave in new ternary
classification context. Our results highlight why "undecided" category is much
needed from the viewpoint of explainability. Additionally, we conducted an
analysis of explainability of the three best-performing detectors and the
explanation notes of the human annotators, revealing insights about the
complexity of explainable detection of machine-generated texts. Finally, we
propose guidelines for developing future detection systems with improved
explanatory power. | [
0.0640406236,
0.016996596,
-0.0218053926,
0.0356285498,
-0.0176689923,
0.034294717,
0.0652968287,
0.0346772559,
0.0154058421,
-0.0237192474,
0.0187262371,
0.0126809068,
-0.0231263544,
0.0393744446,
0.0410520919,
0.0123817949,
-0.0072776154,
-0.0083458759,
0.0489247963,
0.0310173128,
0.0250811204,
0.0479256064,
-0.0027195495,
0.0194764808,
-0.0169432685,
-0.0305418428,
-0.0043859193,
0.00814512,
0.0180846192,
-0.0064501627,
-0.0116191534,
0.0381470099,
0.0059348368,
0.085103564,
0.0000019018,
-0.0368628167,
-0.0304349679,
-0.0005774388,
-0.0692522749,
-0.0199632831,
0.0274004806,
0.0099297594,
-0.0217512585,
0.024112545,
-0.0178562962,
0.0602467172,
0.0331230164,
0.0585476756,
0.0448689908,
0.0690785944,
-0.0272532962,
-0.0125013608,
0.0339813456,
0.0315898098,
0.0259209741,
0.0109946439,
-0.0014582981,
-0.0438770391,
-0.0207481962,
0.0382041559,
0.0301851239,
0.0139731113,
0.0006500442,
-0.0533017665,
0.0061853137,
0.0167017225,
-0.0040477966,
-0.039086815,
0.0043104906,
0.0247019306,
0.0134981479,
-0.0466636121,
0.065140374,
-0.0134170102,
0.0034778072,
0.0463829674,
0.0140907792,
0.0555629954,
-0.0492548645,
-0.0032505293,
0.0225712098,
0.0094500585,
0.0117961708,
0.0460356884,
-0.0103079015,
0.0356726311,
-0.0356177054,
-0.0259650964,
-0.0248431135,
-0.002630831,
0.019699635,
-0.0607474633,
0.0438737758,
0.0397670679,
0.0037960946,
-0.0041994499,
-0.0365628526,
-0.0392314605,
0.0263805725,
-0.0454428084,
0.0459742509,
-0.0169882774,
-0.0411261618,
0.0525396131,
-0.0593032688,
0.0505796112,
-0.0028036144,
0.0425712876,
0.0012801616,
0.0039662328,
-0.0234512649,
-0.0341607407,
-0.0076433932,
0.0028610667,
0.0191898476,
0.0170958079,
-0.0211497229,
0.0408793464,
0.0064663119,
0.0186624881,
-0.0209427327,
-0.0250914544,
-0.0017423742,
-0.014400214,
-0.0328527093,
-0.0237120874,
-0.0293955989,
0.0246156454,
-0.0118716648,
-0.0477087796,
0.0147712296,
0.0852990523,
0.0421509333,
-0.0050564506,
0.0137230568,
0.0504558645,
-0.0073186397,
-0.0266846158,
-0.0435132347,
-0.0799618885,
-0.0124338176,
-0.047783453,
-0.0294697192,
-0.0111095943,
-0.0331922621,
0.0191997327,
-0.0110355159,
-0.0193490703,
-0.0136868674,
0.0202031806,
0.0031717513,
0.0536189266,
-0.0725865364,
-0.003720843,
0.0529114455,
-0.0041740341,
-0.0440476201,
-0.0055812299,
0.0479218513,
0.0963158458,
0.0642043874,
-0.0028450277,
0.0746296272,
-0.0014334281,
0.005626386,
0.0032243468,
0.0292118602,
-0.0188178755,
-0.0839037299,
0.0013528115,
0.0255168788,
0.0302844513,
-0.0056218076,
-0.0096045621,
0.0754293054,
0.0582633391,
0.0083622979,
0.029375365,
0.0417222008,
0.0293312091,
0.0007112178,
0.0468503647,
-0.0035121418,
0.0232536569,
-0.0428833105,
-0.0233439226,
0.001458531,
-0.0235988963,
0.0055955644,
-0.0644113272,
-0.0079175131,
-0.0188218039,
0.0191318952,
-0.0176417269,
0.0261097904,
0.0001036223,
-0.0385621563,
-0.0031255081,
-0.0341569036,
-0.0735302418,
-0.0016882181,
-0.0894059241,
0.0898436457,
0.0785232633,
0.0308019239,
-0.0320213027,
0.0372127816,
-0.0464010648,
0.0395805351,
0.0491923504,
-0.0282988399,
0.0176278967,
-0.0014479393,
-0.030119665,
-0.0289076008,
-0.0156071661,
0.006487722,
0.0038886357,
-0.004714089,
-0.0223470647,
0.0131204268,
-0.0249322932,
-0.0472461097,
0.0472210757,
-0.0016308038,
-0.0391698703,
-0.0076702083,
0.0403728746,
0.0077810767,
0.0376987495,
0.0037565429,
0.0055863056,
0.0276785884,
-0.0298255123,
-0.0451072641,
0.0034846282,
0.0367535129,
0.0265168548,
-0.0017024269,
-0.0221776143,
-0.0353321359,
0.0065560238,
-0.0214501247,
-0.0253040008,
-0.0289125368,
-0.0617712215,
-0.0180530883,
-0.0661634132,
0.0012380519,
-0.0094168782,
0.0076113795,
-0.0219129212,
0.0712494776,
0.001600804,
-0.0009823228,
-0.0248651206,
-0.0321808681,
0.0600876287,
0.0154965511,
0.0304952618,
-0.0098303026,
-0.0351709574,
0.0051516523,
0.0126939742,
0.0046107797,
-0.0091837626,
-0.0326071642,
-0.0560304262,
-0.018714007,
-0.0176248103,
0.0338895954,
0.021078134,
-0.0433584452,
0.0070910561,
0.0045628115,
-0.0327689983,
-0.0141296256,
-0.0015121066,
0.0091786245,
0.0888791978,
-0.0286895335,
-0.0108466893,
-0.0087964293,
0.0141068455,
-0.0289660431,
0.0488733351,
0.0739738569,
-0.0496154651,
-0.0791875571,
0.0308299623,
-0.0084142182,
-0.0574957766,
-0.0162956771,
-0.0151848905,
0.0198525153,
-0.0079014078,
-0.0399439894,
0.059712667,
0.0292036384,
0.0574139655,
0.0093552442,
0.0594778545,
-0.0005579657,
-0.0311158765,
-0.0012277954,
0.0128116338,
0.0059939688,
-0.0705370307,
0.0346402936,
0.0304278601,
-0.0175674912,
-0.0019024318,
-0.0226103347,
0.0164892003,
0.0171797536,
-0.0132798366,
-0.0071580051,
-0.0671237931,
-0.0195719432,
0.0953535438,
-0.0096175065,
-0.0784749761,
0.0639725327,
-0.0369426683,
-0.0042047948,
-0.0119651593,
-0.0319337398,
-0.0303167496,
0.0381788835,
-0.007363148,
0.0290796682,
0.0299829096,
-0.0252799969,
-0.013314764,
-0.0043957122,
0.0705139562,
0.0124522196,
0.0091175959,
-0.0129257357,
0.0022928326,
-0.0102048134,
-0.0167628955,
-0.0142961685,
-0.0672895759,
-0.0109589659,
-0.0144094732,
0.0306853764,
-0.0433603413,
-0.0142963929,
-0.0246223994,
0.0434928462,
0.0411771536,
-0.0105045317,
-0.0253827609,
-0.0394288339,
0.0361399278,
-0.0032595079,
0.0050524301,
0.0247097928,
-0.0400417261,
-0.0040544048,
0.0448373891,
-0.0155794732,
0.0110174334,
-0.004927949,
-0.021401599,
-0.0178634562,
-0.0389398523,
-0.0223231725,
0.0024487828,
0.0315413885,
-0.0462484658,
0.0393770337,
0.0953055546,
0.0242658556,
-0.015577253,
-0.0092113307,
-0.0206082109,
-0.0323492363,
-0.0107027991,
-0.0025674871,
-0.0897487029,
-0.0158029459,
-0.0057469313,
0.0229835752,
-0.0502010323,
-0.0079567693,
-0.0158191845,
-0.0184303857,
0.0328679755,
-0.0112809185,
-0.0326427519,
0.0064634588,
-0.0622971505,
-0.0461590737,
0.0086684749,
-0.0554430559,
-0.0124471169,
0.0000430975,
0.0152693493,
0.0115519194,
-0.0305319168,
-0.0092175556,
-0.0128740398,
-0.0264370367,
-0.0024109194,
0.0447525568,
0.0732372031,
-0.0125126913,
-0.0277954061,
-0.0001537716,
0.0025653993,
0.0210904554,
-0.0120093599,
0.1078340635,
-0.0122981677,
0.0150460918,
-0.0617817566,
0.0384096801,
-0.0129319588,
0.0044663427,
0.0041017937,
0.0476279147,
-0.022300927,
-0.0186901707,
0.0040380904,
-0.0100937495,
0.0083356034,
0.0530721359,
0.0312889814,
-0.02738446,
-0.0652084425,
-0.0414066873,
0.0398976766,
-0.0527164638,
-0.0039151562,
-0.0409954749,
-0.0306015667,
-0.051627636,
-0.0731678158,
-0.035426341,
-0.045231577,
-0.009236251,
0.0165960211,
0.0284442585,
-0.0056156456,
-0.0026017593,
-0.0387772955,
-0.0297581758,
0.0001590744,
0.0386524275,
-0.0328182764,
0.0012253789,
0.0143843489,
-0.0470036231,
0.0083358912,
-0.0024097469,
-0.0211020038,
-0.0070443233,
-0.0317421257,
-0.012880628,
0.0259940997,
-0.0059307651,
-0.0073613646,
-0.0839981735,
0.0604890361,
0.0610539541,
-0.0241511129,
-0.0013009659,
0.0427075773,
0.0181588437,
-0.0221472774,
0.0235934816,
-0.015461158,
0.0135565046,
-0.0101473508,
-0.0677522346,
-0.0876059756,
0.0007168395,
-0.009931122,
0.0149279563,
0.0151609806,
-0.0292742513,
0.0077712587,
-0.0271268412,
0.0006460647,
-0.0049736677,
-0.0037709246,
-0.0219051167,
0.0151600065,
0.0056119692,
-0.0304847937,
-0.0090053827,
0.021563042,
-0.0240593888,
0.030408686,
-0.0030719347,
0.0468457714,
0.0001652476,
0.1038699001,
-0.0339703374,
0.0153742824,
-0.0025269045,
0.0325627774,
0.0096861692,
0.048581291,
0.0172997098,
0.0593813807,
0.0001262875,
-0.0029474662,
0.0239204466,
0.0342067927,
-0.0744241849,
-0.0126236714,
-0.0095408168,
-0.0092453761,
0.0366699211,
0.0245668758,
0.0659282953,
-0.0163374785,
-0.0128724845,
-0.0054692305,
0.0610215589,
0.0112467613,
-0.0106283491,
-0.0602219477,
-0.0020554473,
-0.0505610332,
0.0014785292,
0.0799996331,
0.0458959639,
-0.0107958177,
-0.0068826377,
-0.0672427416,
-0.0339110605,
-0.0173174776,
-0.0006828839,
0.0250015818,
0.0218689963,
-0.0129313739,
-0.0402644128,
-0.0308939833,
0.0473995097,
-0.0210445691,
0.0340087637,
-0.0168314818,
-0.0199765228,
0.070091188,
-0.0057606502,
-0.0179389324,
-0.0737942979,
0.0256576948,
-0.0105256215,
-0.0053425939,
-0.0297590531,
-5.510058138e-33,
0.0143587328,
-0.1332232952,
-0.0285561755,
0.0033645136,
0.0211748611,
0.0401591621,
-0.0467106067,
-0.0197221115,
-0.0003534724,
0.0262497608,
-0.0121158753,
0.0211599395,
0.0092207929,
-0.0047823093,
-0.0152996732,
-0.0286666974,
0.0334245674,
-0.002785885,
-0.0382763632,
0.0406199768,
0.0613357201,
0.008412201,
0.0105278818,
-0.1336231381,
0.0822141618,
-0.0270919502,
-0.0651212558,
-0.029172916,
-0.0475225449,
0.0581179857,
0.0024853372,
0.0262087453,
0.0443685725,
0.0148294671,
0.0023055421,
0.0460068136,
-0.0435642637,
-0.0274158884,
-0.0053874827,
0.025482703,
-0.0062037511,
-0.0871529654,
0.0383322872,
-0.0528095812,
-0.015313914,
0.023470562,
0.0881151631,
-0.0190529935,
0.0000347548,
-0.0635944158,
-0.0352069102,
0.0242665336,
-0.0107500032,
-0.0096534444,
0.0469507873,
0.0436564796,
0.0258853193,
0.0107879313,
-0.0857202038,
0.0131592918,
0.0134104323,
-0.0270734355,
0.0334772281,
-0.005581703,
-0.0404062197,
0.0429223701,
0.0489174724,
0.0168061368,
-0.0453354679,
0.0046841991,
-0.0236749612,
0.050278727,
0.107415475,
0.0833490565,
0.034553282,
-0.012030012,
-0.0463937297,
0.0520804487,
-0.0038055668,
-0.0333119184,
0.0396388993,
-0.0067905686,
-0.0706325322,
-0.0181906838,
0.0087123988,
-0.0678968653,
-0.0527313091,
-0.0064002997,
0.0013719177,
-0.0264949892,
-0.0506158546,
-0.0153022334,
0.0052515697,
-0.0633776411,
-0.0188082345,
0.0058333296,
-0.0220020805,
0.0411332548,
0.0115597052,
-0.0301818736,
-0.0063391584,
-0.0154650565,
0.0231778938,
0.0178834461,
0.0436266065,
-0.0000336647,
0.0707356706,
0.0212779026,
-0.041976463,
0.0102707893,
-0.0110500241,
-0.0175426546,
0.0038221623,
0.0119817005,
0.0092742126,
-0.0193633828,
-0.0033934154,
-0.0031583786,
0.0233180784,
0.0258551128,
-0.0268048216,
-0.0316417255,
-0.0664545894,
0.0044117854,
-0.0200234298,
-0.0099738641,
0.0031167788,
0.0124637615,
0.0267291702,
-0.0631070137,
0.0156171853,
-0.0399211235,
2.472e-7,
0.0346620865,
0.0303372648,
0.0401891954,
-0.0481389426,
0.0435966402,
0.0634961724,
0.0573908128,
0.0006120087,
-0.034920305,
0.0050699939,
0.0256358776,
0.0073444471,
0.0737670511,
0.0125981849,
-0.0212574489,
-0.014574497,
-0.0483648665,
0.0062740822,
-0.0741443112,
0.0467525683,
0.1197619215,
0.0040701111,
0.0331401005,
-0.0380031653,
0.0091978004,
-0.0699991882,
0.0200476553,
-0.0116197625,
0.056831032,
0.0123184379,
0.0552088208,
-0.0112781562,
0.0099658649,
0.0257500336,
-0.0277944226,
-0.0330835022,
-0.0139423143,
0.0663847476,
0.0147109376,
0.0081693372,
0.0111441743,
-0.0313477442,
0.0344434604,
-0.0413747989,
0.057645984,
0.0564699546,
-0.0302299447,
0.020809792,
-0.0170499031,
-0.0807809234,
0.0139838979,
-0.0183297824,
-0.0074510719,
0.0255645495,
-0.0161370225,
-0.0161448792,
-0.0065006162,
-0.0573457293,
-0.0210841056,
-0.03154625,
-0.0215602387,
0.0006281202,
-0.0573193319,
0.0171872396,
0.0732513443,
-0.0646611154,
0.0240367744,
2.363365831e-34,
0.0059466399,
-0.0176515896,
-0.0094666686,
0.0136357127,
0.0503650829,
0.0543818958,
-0.0045336708,
0.0238228794,
0.0405566469,
0.0006763691,
0.0357709341
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18256v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18256v1 | LLaMIPa: An Incremental Discourse Parser | 2024-06-26T11:08:17 | 2024-06-26T11:08:17 | Kate Thompson, Akshay Chaturvedi, Julie Hunter, Nicholas Asher | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper provides the first discourse parsing experiments with a large
language model (LLM) finetuned on corpora annotated in the style of SDRT
(Asher, 1993; Asher and Lascarides, 2003). The result is a discourse parser,
LLaMIPa (LLaMA Incremental Parser), which is able to more fully exploit
discourse context, leading to substantial performance gains over approaches
that use encoder-only models to provide local, context-sensitive
representations of discourse units. Furthermore, it is able to process
discourse data incrementally, which is essential for the eventual use of
discourse information in downstream tasks. | LLaMIPa: An Incremental Discourse Parser: This paper provides the first discourse parsing experiments with a large
language model (LLM) finetuned on corpora annotated in the style of SDRT
(Asher, 1993; Asher and Lascarides, 2003). The result is a discourse parser,
LLaMIPa (LLaMA Incremental Parser), which is able to more fully exploit
discourse context, leading to substantial performance gains over approaches
that use encoder-only models to provide local, context-sensitive
representations of discourse units. Furthermore, it is able to process
discourse data incrementally, which is essential for the eventual use of
discourse information in downstream tasks. | [
0.0079549598,
0.0531854294,
-0.0058052894,
0.0312751867,
-0.0148743503,
0.012582927,
-0.0011739391,
-0.0425985977,
-0.048385825,
-0.0710578561,
0.0026928722,
0.0089596743,
0.0017258873,
0.0371309891,
-0.0053191907,
-0.0313571915,
0.0335577764,
-0.0436487496,
0.0532787219,
-0.0132676922,
0.0045493785,
-0.0097870072,
-0.0102357995,
0.0253068022,
-0.000137898,
-0.0485359393,
-0.0171019901,
-0.0256143566,
0.0079791872,
-0.0407926142,
0.0428437516,
0.0066420049,
0.0389793739,
0.0106547233,
0.0000021325,
-0.0275331382,
-0.0139750279,
-0.0167811289,
-0.0386389941,
0.0251728278,
0.0355904661,
-0.0198513512,
-0.0187545773,
-0.0000137581,
-0.0343746059,
-0.0046716817,
-0.0135032982,
0.0507621765,
0.0611226782,
0.0475203581,
-0.0220170282,
-0.0739397407,
0.0376029387,
0.0012677618,
-0.1042219624,
-0.041715268,
0.0106928311,
0.0580374897,
-0.000056436,
0.0708277896,
-0.0032723465,
0.0528530292,
0.0173054002,
-0.0062758769,
0.0197920129,
0.032146126,
-0.0002447542,
0.0187381227,
-0.0229407307,
0.0277835522,
0.0457630269,
0.0021927326,
0.0002387713,
0.0189666897,
-0.0224462431,
-0.0260472316,
-0.0438733436,
0.0230619907,
-0.0409770198,
0.0652645528,
0.0528737083,
-0.0077282488,
-0.0184061024,
0.0010589457,
0.0011201641,
0.0603426956,
-0.0181623772,
-0.0269886646,
0.0040590931,
0.0164662469,
-0.0355610661,
-0.0480344594,
0.0538307652,
0.0515789799,
-0.0265384391,
0.002883363,
-0.0111501664,
-0.0075321845,
0.0352858156,
-0.1141994968,
0.0378168635,
0.0339612067,
-0.027014697,
0.0308592115,
0.004013923,
0.0664573386,
-0.0489085615,
-0.0513582565,
-0.0229634494,
-0.0205498356,
-0.0435071699,
-0.0429405086,
-0.0376752988,
0.0618661717,
-0.1366886199,
-0.0301217996,
-0.0269505884,
0.0570407547,
0.0299550388,
0.0158274584,
0.0201884061,
-0.0160837937,
-0.0259450376,
0.0498742685,
-0.0343205482,
0.0481918342,
-0.0429953784,
0.0311084986,
-0.0208669752,
-0.0382404439,
-0.0289235413,
0.0135829588,
0.0036927764,
-0.0206198692,
-0.0320422836,
0.0395548791,
-0.0251680035,
-0.0208793227,
-0.0111435205,
-0.0240629911,
0.0030219632,
-0.0238350928,
0.015550144,
-0.0635829717,
0.0017872341,
0.0039481083,
0.0257620197,
-0.0367383212,
0.0106848227,
0.0277489182,
0.0023606527,
0.0373877399,
-0.0076812645,
0.0020145313,
0.073364079,
-0.0221128184,
0.0435680859,
0.0865108296,
0.0437131748,
-0.0123478118,
-0.0023613081,
0.0213357657,
-0.039254453,
0.0381166562,
-0.0290712882,
-0.0154263405,
-0.0193891712,
0.0358395875,
-0.0246281084,
0.0156284887,
0.0588003919,
0.0606306195,
-0.0422441922,
-0.011113557,
0.0083610145,
0.0527081415,
-0.0636065751,
-0.0172495767,
0.0370852388,
0.0282204971,
0.0008207776,
0.0233123172,
-0.0007484197,
-0.0018710663,
0.0299653076,
-0.0204225555,
-0.0020268322,
-0.0038129436,
0.0031564119,
-0.0339833163,
0.0119842775,
-0.009489377,
0.0122544589,
-0.0348717384,
0.0328653231,
0.0141491713,
-0.0315555334,
0.0399423763,
0.0523582473,
-0.0168275125,
-0.0412533507,
-0.0406262986,
0.008250976,
0.0306781325,
0.0413740203,
-0.0329168253,
-0.0365386941,
-0.0372019522,
0.0539059639,
0.0656763464,
-0.0236308984,
-0.026301289,
-0.0177924428,
-0.0282305088,
-0.0129631115,
-0.0434460863,
0.0271697026,
0.0335912667,
-0.0277316812,
-0.0163357873,
-0.0104915155,
0.0439110994,
-0.0050591705,
0.0195132643,
-0.0359567255,
-0.0081536295,
-0.0156759843,
-0.0234432947,
0.0496420898,
0.0274665467,
-0.0094935643,
-0.0096530644,
0.0398346446,
-0.0651518181,
0.0145235825,
0.037258029,
-0.0575876348,
-0.0520494469,
0.0350904576,
-0.0152525557,
-0.0296321362,
-0.0317082405,
-0.0218719821,
-0.0329802297,
0.0099780569,
-0.0575919412,
0.021644678,
-0.0279655941,
-0.0011225905,
-0.005734148,
0.0019432053,
-0.0214509536,
0.0660094693,
-0.0214022696,
-0.008770409,
0.0440206788,
-0.0194841772,
-0.0018290386,
-0.0436026268,
-0.009423269,
0.0262331814,
0.0341425315,
-0.0394416265,
0.0173459966,
-0.0129479375,
-0.0020029095,
-0.0337901041,
-0.1279220879,
-0.0061275065,
-0.0280804578,
0.0577967949,
0.0276806112,
-0.0055426629,
-0.0016327965,
-0.008259506,
0.0241751038,
-0.057098832,
-0.0062311599,
0.0257779397,
0.044481609,
0.0042092055,
0.003443535,
-0.0449355058,
-0.0040284409,
-0.0199324042,
0.045237653,
0.0085996287,
-0.0567456335,
-0.0660937801,
-0.0085232742,
-0.0062772292,
0.0068753455,
-0.0173662659,
-0.0416823924,
0.0354857035,
0.0327182338,
0.0852515325,
0.0383430794,
-0.0052559283,
0.0878039971,
0.0056071626,
-0.0563538782,
-0.0408628359,
0.0285901967,
0.0128113655,
0.0223103557,
-0.0837629586,
0.0058416086,
-0.0037343539,
0.0978593454,
-0.0058754073,
0.0437862128,
-0.0039801011,
0.0276884045,
-0.0497807488,
-0.0194533411,
-0.0006276687,
-0.0552156307,
-0.0333613902,
0.011461067,
-0.0164298154,
0.0261931904,
0.0323251896,
-0.050691627,
-0.0112142721,
-0.0430687368,
-0.0004057724,
-0.0281907804,
0.0541581213,
0.0048791468,
-0.0122363679,
-0.0192151666,
-0.0651143566,
0.0296768826,
0.0098498752,
-0.0050794897,
-0.0278335381,
0.0689181238,
-0.0769194886,
0.0235202312,
-0.0091392957,
-0.0422925465,
-0.0368394479,
-0.0645492598,
-0.0299104173,
0.0478624627,
-0.0319091529,
0.0318277478,
-0.0232756585,
0.01382815,
-0.0268710181,
0.049340371,
-0.0213591997,
0.01080216,
-0.0674963593,
0.0566796213,
0.024725223,
0.0166316312,
-0.0084221642,
-0.0019637137,
0.0335437171,
0.050771974,
-0.0483873673,
-0.0197361596,
-0.0370338559,
0.0019702024,
-0.0263995733,
-0.0323357843,
-0.0307625998,
-0.053678114,
0.0897916704,
-0.0583808646,
-0.0439273044,
0.1265826672,
0.0208150372,
-0.0087284138,
-0.0084681371,
-0.0453199781,
0.0038628674,
0.0256092437,
0.007391626,
-0.0598630235,
-0.0117405262,
0.0252484959,
0.0017856789,
-0.0171836298,
-0.0488543734,
0.0281252488,
-0.0541041121,
0.0188249927,
-0.0100141549,
0.0379692204,
0.0279585663,
-0.0573001355,
0.000498545,
0.0006609763,
0.0454979464,
0.0251044314,
-0.0231386982,
0.0169522632,
0.028027771,
0.0143428855,
-0.0292624868,
-0.0003060774,
-0.002581066,
0.045074828,
0.0302785262,
0.049818933,
-0.010675245,
0.0164305456,
0.0642799735,
-0.0426393338,
-0.0029761859,
-0.0087266406,
-0.0203130525,
0.0132077402,
-0.0140137784,
-0.0152570577,
0.0201862641,
-0.0283255987,
-0.0031109715,
0.0300033446,
0.0378090739,
-0.0537046939,
0.0451156758,
-0.0123293027,
-0.0250030383,
-0.0168929324,
0.0285194274,
0.0511897318,
-0.0001179724,
-0.0369498283,
-0.0455020145,
-0.0195475593,
0.0103965625,
0.0255921055,
-0.0158156902,
0.0323874019,
0.0215736292,
-0.0559792854,
-0.0497587733,
0.008169475,
-0.0250149872,
-0.0047807083,
0.0042606043,
0.0624861605,
-0.0211042427,
-0.0530440584,
-0.0083269998,
-0.0223140549,
-0.0067044026,
-0.0389671847,
-0.0118782884,
0.0852316096,
0.0149659477,
-0.0453677848,
0.000875407,
-0.0462219641,
-0.0467073545,
0.0067476379,
0.0387093239,
0.0160806663,
0.0325857736,
-0.0304713268,
-0.0159753729,
0.0373928212,
0.0240182094,
-0.0383979417,
0.0611029565,
0.0052852766,
0.0444234349,
0.0046578404,
0.0176872052,
0.0214629602,
0.0429407097,
-0.0526410192,
0.0437306166,
-0.0395168923,
-0.0181607753,
0.0199430641,
-0.0078536319,
0.0569397248,
0.0248435922,
0.0160025395,
-0.0187830813,
0.0314671211,
-0.0554966368,
0.0029586293,
-0.032641463,
0.0274668224,
-0.0127905263,
-0.0221030451,
-0.0227259025,
0.0013650607,
-0.0175746121,
0.0474953018,
-0.0456535183,
0.0441698506,
0.0150233442,
-0.0038385505,
-0.0144875171,
0.0053525376,
-0.0238243099,
0.0243744757,
0.0048531215,
0.0426641516,
-0.0369209982,
0.0398047604,
0.0034689973,
0.0241936855,
-0.0089688376,
0.0276278201,
-0.0308615472,
0.0346819125,
0.0188056957,
0.0199795067,
0.0489695705,
0.0039755208,
0.0913854092,
0.0096903071,
0.0181552302,
-0.0216879044,
0.056042064,
0.0011192139,
-0.0411477201,
0.0308138784,
0.0122400653,
-0.0317955166,
-0.0025206574,
0.0585011989,
-0.0388555974,
0.0424525626,
0.0336988717,
0.0156450048,
-0.0490936451,
-0.0889131203,
-0.0613954812,
0.0094006499,
0.0132883834,
0.0262730438,
0.017962411,
0.001606568,
0.042195037,
-0.016384542,
-0.0250805374,
-0.0486070924,
0.0348596908,
0.0265503302,
-0.0086193699,
-0.0307590552,
-0.0344497934,
0.0198910162,
-0.0148684978,
-0.0232539847,
-0.0248416848,
-6.428089471e-33,
-0.0921708047,
-0.0138123631,
0.0434863381,
0.0299896207,
-0.049802877,
0.0177557785,
-0.0774706006,
-0.0040855384,
0.0353589319,
0.0353767909,
-0.0187993273,
0.018913703,
0.0221617334,
0.0181245189,
0.0300010312,
-0.0248500519,
0.0769639611,
-0.0020877097,
0.0138371782,
0.0109818494,
0.093806982,
0.0366147421,
0.0577723607,
-0.0354431607,
-0.0109551763,
-0.008331052,
0.0077118999,
0.0297867116,
0.0261375066,
0.0548487268,
-0.0257542953,
0.0059971632,
0.0347653627,
0.0071330643,
-0.0160817243,
0.0262053888,
-0.1007430553,
-0.0054675862,
0.0286747683,
0.030102035,
-0.0194167215,
-0.0588634834,
0.0370186195,
0.0206184518,
-0.0128878988,
0.0302069653,
0.0283336975,
-0.032818079,
-0.0134694828,
-0.0158155933,
-0.0610534474,
0.0239104256,
-0.0211219788,
0.0037464211,
0.0367203951,
0.0090658031,
0.0165862087,
-0.0487041399,
-0.0302502718,
-0.015584765,
-0.0046135504,
0.0344263949,
-0.0124376267,
-0.0246135872,
0.0280207805,
0.0618986189,
-0.030302627,
-0.0507040434,
-0.0599128269,
0.0279845744,
-0.0002121719,
-0.0022870225,
-0.0402423218,
-0.0436774641,
-0.029493738,
-0.0009441305,
-0.0525136441,
-0.0295040961,
0.0498504937,
0.077883929,
0.0333442837,
0.009977703,
0.0105192401,
-0.0156557672,
-0.0267869905,
-0.0227799602,
0.0286533423,
-0.0161943175,
0.0116875423,
-0.0134282997,
0.0129247876,
0.0118283909,
0.0459622294,
-0.0218608603,
-0.0418442115,
0.0154163875,
0.0079084579,
0.0201689117,
-0.0052497359,
0.0371611528,
-0.0266714655,
-0.0219906308,
-0.014852413,
-0.0093839448,
0.0208527893,
-0.0053050951,
-0.0076761674,
0.0027477846,
-0.0397990681,
0.0167504568,
-0.0443950109,
0.0357219763,
-0.0497826077,
0.105786927,
0.0332643241,
0.0225301757,
-0.0096014794,
0.0837438554,
-0.0155381151,
0.000149213,
-0.0521342568,
0.0114111975,
0.003710255,
0.0474428572,
-0.0438148119,
-0.0039147716,
-0.0165031999,
0.0706886575,
-0.019937668,
-0.0457888097,
0.0106707197,
0.0226143505,
2.645e-7,
0.0198577717,
0.0715401173,
0.0492739789,
-0.040081434,
0.0669929683,
-0.0294606239,
-0.0027452267,
0.0414138101,
-0.0009876946,
-0.0347427912,
-0.036866121,
0.036406491,
0.0153609822,
0.0412677936,
-0.1049301699,
-0.0361446664,
-0.0870374292,
-0.0376564749,
-0.0466326997,
0.0027492377,
0.0426932126,
0.0624516793,
-0.0301596317,
0.0269076042,
-0.0246683508,
0.0146164084,
0.0693687499,
0.0225211531,
0.002283327,
0.0404052548,
-0.0231886078,
0.0006003177,
-0.0097700041,
-0.0148031805,
0.0347440466,
0.0466172993,
-0.0179743879,
0.0960770771,
0.0044687479,
-0.0028362607,
-0.0014470583,
-0.0016131833,
-0.0004858143,
0.0114593469,
0.0354069509,
-0.0532946661,
-0.0429270267,
-0.0101912627,
-0.0420507416,
-0.0036771849,
-0.0080667064,
0.0209334902,
0.0100511285,
0.0310155712,
0.0069981115,
-0.0322944969,
-0.0222091693,
-0.0714653954,
0.0054064635,
-0.0089022443,
-0.0728616863,
-0.0143426107,
-0.0149774347,
-0.0045747682,
0.0028571195,
-0.028533984,
0.000707293,
2.01205465e-34,
0.049724821,
0.0069714016,
-0.003175949,
0.0768955871,
0.015011291,
0.0021401145,
0.0140767861,
0.0382206254,
-0.0141224731,
-0.1003911197,
0.0124165155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18245v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18245v2 | Weak Reward Model Transforms Generative Models into Robust Causal Event Extraction Systems | 2024-06-26T10:48:14 | 2024-06-27T10:19:55 | Italo Luis da Silva, Hanqi Yan, Lin Gui, Yulan He | cs.CL | cs.CL | The inherent ambiguity of cause and effect boundaries poses a challenge in
evaluating causal event extraction tasks. Traditional metrics like Exact Match
and BertScore poorly reflect model performance, so we trained evaluation models
to approximate human evaluation, achieving high agreement. We used them to
perform Reinforcement Learning with extraction models to align them with human
preference, prioritising semantic understanding. We successfully explored our
approach through multiple datasets, including transferring an evaluator trained
on one dataset to another as a way to decrease the reliance on human-annotated
data. In that vein, we also propose a weak-to-strong supervision method that
uses a fraction of the annotated data to train an evaluation model while still
achieving high performance in training an RL model. Our code is available at
https://github.com/oyarsa/event_extraction/tree/causal-event-extraction. | Weak Reward Model Transforms Generative Models into Robust Causal Event Extraction Systems: The inherent ambiguity of cause and effect boundaries poses a challenge in
evaluating causal event extraction tasks. Traditional metrics like Exact Match
and BertScore poorly reflect model performance, so we trained evaluation models
to approximate human evaluation, achieving high agreement. We used them to
perform Reinforcement Learning with extraction models to align them with human
preference, prioritising semantic understanding. We successfully explored our
approach through multiple datasets, including transferring an evaluator trained
on one dataset to another as a way to decrease the reliance on human-annotated
data. In that vein, we also propose a weak-to-strong supervision method that
uses a fraction of the annotated data to train an evaluation model while still
achieving high performance in training an RL model. Our code is available at
https://github.com/oyarsa/event_extraction/tree/causal-event-extraction. | [
0.0009898614,
0.0835860595,
0.0126949959,
0.0283023678,
-0.0146010164,
0.0447953604,
-0.0206507333,
-0.0110982694,
-0.0093576014,
-0.0004821142,
0.0096464157,
0.0382750221,
-0.0625306219,
0.0178534649,
-0.0115772728,
-0.0833471045,
0.0490502529,
-0.0083851302,
0.0465780906,
0.0340333357,
-0.0010662002,
-0.0220608767,
-0.0107587948,
0.0167630464,
-0.0223541744,
0.0078875748,
-0.0004337361,
-0.0088803638,
0.0518591814,
-0.038517978,
-0.0083701303,
0.0178204998,
0.0176691897,
0.0411739722,
0.0000019821,
-0.0159486327,
-0.034523312,
0.0179952942,
0.0142102735,
-0.0418714806,
-0.0269253962,
-0.0077453097,
0.0057941661,
-0.0247711036,
-0.0209829416,
-0.0425975285,
0.0277183615,
0.0804798752,
0.0262935758,
0.0900327191,
-0.0163714532,
-0.0430404171,
0.0009350023,
-0.0418819003,
0.047888469,
-0.0590116754,
0.0318630189,
0.0019275108,
0.0139428256,
-0.0556133986,
-0.0377638638,
-0.0048211934,
0.0369406156,
-0.0135425515,
0.0234199185,
0.0324931182,
0.002035764,
-0.0206252001,
0.0021290742,
0.069245249,
0.0216689222,
0.009417681,
0.0567146577,
-0.0210571159,
0.024646135,
0.0207842942,
-0.0370136835,
0.0114761684,
-0.0173229575,
0.0095605515,
0.0141635099,
0.0370778479,
0.0229303818,
0.0188331548,
-0.0002943828,
0.047340326,
0.008429979,
-0.0406116433,
-0.0247954801,
0.0311656836,
-0.0063473703,
-0.0266769435,
-0.0081965122,
0.0153927635,
-0.0549629182,
0.0160797443,
-0.0167729687,
-0.0003848611,
-0.0196285937,
-0.0409045182,
-0.0048517431,
-0.0048581688,
-0.039181456,
0.0771691129,
-0.019386109,
0.0435352102,
0.0014390787,
0.0806254894,
0.0120432377,
0.0049730036,
-0.051740434,
0.0319294631,
0.0034096895,
0.0052241087,
-0.0205329843,
0.0031878566,
-0.0482111797,
0.0048440844,
-0.0509403162,
0.00340648,
-0.0059299073,
0.0317299403,
-0.0506573878,
0.037628103,
-0.0318879411,
0.0032164203,
-0.0865944028,
0.0357746668,
0.0281250756,
-0.0205683708,
-0.0200152602,
0.0127552068,
0.0381639078,
-0.0358737893,
0.0007880304,
0.075455457,
0.0099384151,
-0.0264603402,
-0.0582683347,
-0.0371411704,
0.000957294,
-0.0283696726,
-0.0103475275,
-0.0361272059,
0.0111911567,
-0.02748104,
0.0040956279,
-0.0366808288,
0.0061667226,
-0.0479633175,
-0.0362368263,
0.0509201623,
0.0097391987,
-0.011141167,
-0.0183545966,
-0.0076491246,
-0.0266719367,
0.0338330641,
0.0390234478,
0.0710801706,
0.0217497814,
0.032227017,
0.0089366483,
-0.0069137248,
0.0289714169,
-0.0083567789,
-0.0059037274,
-0.0295773223,
-0.020912515,
0.003749046,
0.0584431328,
-0.0008386369,
-0.0433796905,
0.029577842,
0.0372585505,
-0.0162987877,
0.0003488645,
-0.0286895577,
0.0640339628,
-0.0319293179,
-0.019699771,
0.0258798189,
-0.043054834,
0.0251345988,
0.0099676894,
-0.0006562117,
-0.0129517429,
-0.0382037982,
-0.0057640108,
-0.0474984832,
0.0315866992,
-0.005442915,
-0.017203493,
0.0282880682,
0.0935371667,
0.0164435543,
-0.0220351573,
-0.0212606434,
0.0357097611,
-0.0251139626,
0.0255271625,
-0.035785079,
0.0814236552,
0.0561237074,
0.0441939905,
-0.0467112921,
-0.0055259173,
-0.0117630726,
-0.0139825772,
-0.0157045443,
0.0033418038,
-0.0571821257,
0.0154095944,
0.0039479178,
-0.0704782382,
0.0033701095,
0.0254895352,
0.0299736969,
0.0340760723,
-0.0409307927,
-0.0130088348,
0.0141241606,
-0.0248704646,
0.0452711582,
0.0056862948,
-0.0509124137,
-0.0273234509,
0.0235859361,
0.0592334606,
-0.0044341935,
-0.0419990905,
-0.0017307154,
0.0331544541,
-0.0281832553,
-0.0376884602,
0.0524571352,
-0.0234584548,
-0.0310738813,
-0.0098467004,
-0.051993113,
-0.0472060814,
0.0358251669,
-0.06145503,
-0.0485567078,
0.0160955563,
0.006289307,
0.0033351232,
-0.0336814187,
-0.0139146661,
0.0140443156,
-0.0531646833,
-0.0509074144,
0.0895522311,
0.0154417735,
0.0091095725,
-0.0137177082,
0.0139856543,
0.005152097,
-0.04926477,
-0.0193391703,
-0.0017748374,
-0.0246015266,
-0.0203487277,
0.0728567615,
0.0026471475,
-0.0538237281,
-0.0182970334,
-0.0374164172,
0.0049582208,
-0.0203984883,
0.0197749436,
0.0214882866,
0.0163286831,
-0.0156871025,
-0.0194427278,
-0.0050230455,
-0.0587831289,
-0.0139590809,
0.0048302785,
0.0206686854,
0.0367243998,
0.019058127,
-0.0623294301,
0.0169398133,
-0.0269832108,
0.0357069559,
0.0703968406,
-0.0127708316,
-0.0116391378,
-0.007759918,
0.0121110454,
0.0172906741,
-0.0128418198,
-0.0189892463,
0.0126365162,
-0.0381026827,
0.0246145856,
0.0848237798,
-0.0097593302,
0.0785176978,
0.0050913077,
-0.0429535322,
-0.0620697327,
0.0138503741,
-0.0599276572,
0.0083442917,
-0.0144135645,
0.0020203632,
0.0056363223,
0.0737986043,
-0.0028274963,
0.0165276751,
-0.0582965948,
-0.0115609029,
-0.0189805925,
-0.0531774759,
-0.0207102764,
0.0031518622,
-0.0360756367,
0.0152192377,
-0.0698095709,
-0.0436671264,
0.0794360563,
0.0380285382,
0.002885524,
-0.0156901293,
0.0203484539,
-0.0323677287,
0.0593107492,
0.0170610026,
0.0087508392,
-0.0067893369,
-0.0272563118,
-0.0371023007,
-0.0229006894,
0.0480031781,
0.0152752092,
-0.0067668017,
-0.0588457957,
0.0331610814,
0.0000660511,
-0.032444708,
-0.0638685748,
-0.0432644561,
0.0331734419,
0.0150391115,
-0.0052008531,
-0.0057598082,
-0.0389135033,
-0.009280541,
0.031613525,
0.0445756726,
-0.0327994227,
-0.0063783764,
-0.0214090496,
0.0093545485,
0.0684862211,
-0.0689129755,
-0.0284724813,
-0.0428060666,
-0.0031993545,
0.0318218395,
0.0603683479,
0.0051062508,
-0.0432644077,
0.0397667922,
-0.0231973697,
-0.0400453135,
0.0398965925,
0.0256126001,
0.0315164365,
-0.0528177023,
-0.0250757355,
0.0805541053,
0.0120722437,
-0.0122185703,
-0.0016895018,
0.0122337174,
0.0118665779,
0.0248375796,
0.0113857118,
-0.0553980395,
-0.0233813133,
-0.0129637159,
0.0559316315,
-0.0013335596,
-0.0517501831,
0.060042996,
-0.0760755688,
0.0421912633,
-0.014780771,
-0.0611787662,
-0.0182819981,
-0.0359921306,
0.0310362335,
-0.0529251285,
-0.0659006685,
0.0090338327,
0.0162004121,
0.0166024417,
0.0393649228,
0.0123666823,
-0.071110934,
0.0319418572,
-0.0522965863,
0.0176307186,
0.1036811993,
0.0144664235,
-0.0078919511,
-0.0092029748,
-0.0080987168,
0.0167320054,
-0.0254166592,
0.0159116965,
0.0656473041,
0.0035772235,
-0.017573446,
-0.0095486231,
0.0729049668,
0.0270117819,
-0.0264399443,
-0.0018336424,
0.0800908208,
-0.0204835851,
-0.0040094154,
-0.0031566704,
-0.0366345979,
0.0185678378,
0.0619024113,
0.0278513171,
-0.0229760371,
-0.0634424165,
0.0261680372,
-0.0163676869,
-0.0849672705,
-0.0208093282,
-0.0188989844,
-0.0411897413,
-0.0823352411,
-0.0780683681,
-0.0737140924,
0.0134885842,
0.0345784836,
-0.0218581744,
-0.0289263148,
0.0133907106,
0.0049778465,
-0.0264863316,
0.08422295,
-0.0266314242,
-0.0006022014,
-0.0273456816,
-0.0370562263,
0.0006739087,
0.0113723762,
-0.0371770561,
0.057037808,
-0.0324928313,
-0.013582306,
0.0126962047,
0.0557616316,
0.0164812841,
0.0849517435,
-0.0259450395,
-0.0153303286,
-0.0049409866,
-0.0006691758,
-0.0267430022,
-0.0248289406,
0.0376959853,
-0.0196424052,
-0.0184290558,
0.0050367587,
-0.0602339879,
0.05723897,
0.0160244815,
0.0393254459,
-0.0303945318,
0.0389805622,
0.0411688797,
-0.0272501111,
0.0933844298,
-0.0369789712,
-0.0362194777,
-0.063186422,
-0.0366723649,
-0.0058972607,
-0.0186311658,
-0.0440037772,
0.0255449042,
0.0138523839,
0.0348727778,
-0.0216560531,
-0.024748005,
-0.008707202,
0.0444121584,
-0.0958061963,
0.0245027523,
0.0675186217,
0.0212420914,
-0.0277884752,
0.0184261762,
0.0070913807,
-0.0061208494,
0.0206175987,
0.0343306623,
-0.0114369867,
0.0345786437,
0.052673351,
0.0438455157,
0.0262494814,
-0.0333951265,
-0.0911419615,
0.0475676097,
-0.0153396623,
0.0226723086,
0.070305571,
-0.0240229294,
0.0244900826,
-0.0127375545,
0.0024801851,
0.0042083338,
0.031512145,
0.0138114439,
0.0101687219,
0.0215206631,
0.0368538871,
0.0021810723,
-0.0226599537,
0.0405001491,
0.0031887214,
0.0805201679,
-0.0633455664,
-0.0268639214,
-0.0340896398,
-0.0497126468,
0.0433866866,
-0.0057229358,
-0.0296764374,
-0.0214356072,
-0.0425722972,
-0.0095506599,
-0.0142203085,
0.0231899209,
0.0181277338,
0.0109044714,
0.0475085713,
0.0297423303,
-0.0351883024,
-0.018948406,
-0.0455606952,
0.0000833966,
0.0127251437,
-0.033196345,
-0.0211494267,
-6.272263736e-33,
-0.0416088179,
-0.0131509127,
0.0176612828,
0.0083780643,
-0.0049416604,
0.0177339502,
-0.0578584149,
-0.0376760066,
0.0204199255,
0.0434481502,
0.0225236155,
-0.0005836642,
0.0208631046,
0.0041134339,
0.0504299439,
-0.0284848344,
0.0509751141,
0.0114769908,
-0.0091189733,
0.0390438773,
0.0656125173,
0.0323897824,
0.0165985264,
-0.1279200912,
0.0550147928,
0.0145769371,
-0.0362313688,
-0.0096945632,
0.0163374767,
0.0467668734,
0.0249203555,
-0.0295002405,
0.0123165157,
-0.0844299942,
-0.0098290155,
0.0036990626,
-0.1368454546,
-0.0077325492,
0.0194522012,
-0.0105891582,
-0.0599808171,
-0.0309473183,
0.0246467814,
-0.0014188399,
0.0290772542,
0.0123937558,
0.056809254,
-0.0289665982,
-0.0037290833,
-0.0734231621,
-0.0696093887,
0.0418114401,
-0.0181661993,
-0.0122234114,
0.0269818474,
0.008100668,
0.0137172239,
0.0359391496,
0.0237839669,
-0.0081308875,
0.0118717439,
0.0094598504,
0.0333149359,
0.0618736856,
-0.0159464255,
0.063447088,
-0.0363729335,
-0.0327782407,
0.0013232722,
0.001729586,
-0.0154084945,
0.0978671238,
0.0230035726,
0.0339222066,
0.0164232701,
0.0521200374,
-0.1002888903,
0.0607745983,
0.0098939352,
0.043996729,
-0.0060236743,
0.0256731603,
-0.0352810435,
0.0209541954,
-0.0265335366,
-0.0104395701,
-0.0164681524,
0.0045829075,
0.0429086871,
0.0376737006,
-0.010100944,
0.0322100595,
0.02949946,
-0.0262202024,
0.0209910236,
0.016158171,
-0.0272296593,
0.0184772722,
-0.0197728071,
-0.0365229435,
-0.0460981689,
-0.0283664726,
0.048925247,
0.0035352584,
0.0444505364,
0.0214148164,
0.0604865439,
0.0002466589,
-0.0039675212,
0.0079548443,
-0.0378603078,
-0.0017123071,
-0.0267728213,
-0.0089019006,
0.0216698032,
0.016728634,
-0.0282557309,
0.0367707573,
0.0132755814,
0.061650075,
0.0181032121,
-0.0445939526,
-0.0105401287,
0.0120425178,
-0.0245024879,
-0.0182077009,
-0.0060758214,
0.0259871595,
-0.0248981509,
-0.0311904065,
0.017391881,
0.0031340825,
2.681e-7,
0.0197222363,
0.0099701378,
0.0604605004,
0.0153716225,
0.01033244,
0.0187695418,
-0.0083129043,
0.024720883,
-0.007157024,
0.0291814469,
0.0419766568,
0.0073886733,
0.0389304981,
0.0014490975,
-0.0539968759,
-0.031783767,
-0.0789753571,
-0.0264228508,
-0.0393871367,
-0.0180370584,
0.0938912705,
0.0660145208,
0.0610884055,
0.0049266191,
0.0174628515,
-0.020579664,
0.0443204753,
-0.012564159,
-0.0110546555,
0.0041779494,
0.0240608696,
-0.0103863776,
-0.0217734519,
0.019867884,
-0.0263932776,
0.0034294687,
-0.0017921372,
0.0550484098,
-0.0355684198,
-0.0063933269,
-0.0252408776,
-0.001151,
0.051941406,
-0.0195997357,
0.0487619936,
-0.0557117425,
-0.0152576612,
0.0409880169,
-0.0512926169,
0.0193420518,
-0.048370406,
0.0049005677,
0.0115590291,
0.0128174964,
-0.006883976,
0.0057499064,
-0.0326705463,
-0.0654782057,
-0.0167269669,
0.0271208491,
-0.0093806703,
-0.0505767912,
-0.0081897173,
0.0291521288,
-0.0075916033,
-0.0791193098,
-0.0379406959,
2.30869042e-34,
0.0141766705,
0.046271462,
-0.0573712625,
-0.014683513,
0.0433315709,
0.0085108951,
-0.047708381,
0.0250074733,
0.0189857967,
-0.0130938003,
-0.0069823917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18239v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18239v1 | Zero-shot prompt-based classification: topic labeling in times of foundation models in German Tweets | 2024-06-26T10:44:02 | 2024-06-26T10:44:02 | Simon Münker, Kai Kugler, Achim Rettinger | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Filtering and annotating textual data are routine tasks in many areas, like
social media or news analytics. Automating these tasks allows to scale the
analyses wrt. speed and breadth of content covered and decreases the manual
effort required. Due to technical advancements in Natural Language Processing,
specifically the success of large foundation models, a new tool for automating
such annotation processes by using a text-to-text interface given written
guidelines without providing training samples has become available.
In this work, we assess these advancements in-the-wild by empirically testing
them in an annotation task on German Twitter data about social and political
European crises. We compare the prompt-based results with our human annotation
and preceding classification approaches, including Naive Bayes and a BERT-based
fine-tuning/domain adaptation pipeline. Our results show that the prompt-based
approach - despite being limited by local computation resources during the
model selection - is comparable with the fine-tuned BERT but without any
annotated training data. Our findings emphasize the ongoing paradigm shift in
the NLP landscape, i.e., the unification of downstream tasks and elimination of
the need for pre-labeled training data. | Zero-shot prompt-based classification: topic labeling in times of foundation models in German Tweets: Filtering and annotating textual data are routine tasks in many areas, like
social media or news analytics. Automating these tasks allows to scale the
analyses wrt. speed and breadth of content covered and decreases the manual
effort required. Due to technical advancements in Natural Language Processing,
specifically the success of large foundation models, a new tool for automating
such annotation processes by using a text-to-text interface given written
guidelines without providing training samples has become available.
In this work, we assess these advancements in-the-wild by empirically testing
them in an annotation task on German Twitter data about social and political
European crises. We compare the prompt-based results with our human annotation
and preceding classification approaches, including Naive Bayes and a BERT-based
fine-tuning/domain adaptation pipeline. Our results show that the prompt-based
approach - despite being limited by local computation resources during the
model selection - is comparable with the fine-tuned BERT but without any
annotated training data. Our findings emphasize the ongoing paradigm shift in
the NLP landscape, i.e., the unification of downstream tasks and elimination of
the need for pre-labeled training data. | [
0.0322009735,
0.0003520919,
0.0186987314,
-0.0183550138,
-0.0318113677,
0.0436610021,
0.0298580918,
-0.0144568589,
0.0105845062,
-0.0912301391,
0.0241907984,
-0.0256491005,
-0.0505229086,
0.0220346861,
-0.003421417,
-0.0616241172,
0.0431958735,
0.0042798407,
0.0425809547,
0.0103337644,
0.0175891519,
0.0149916569,
-0.0193646774,
0.0248807818,
-0.0112614725,
0.0401547775,
-0.0116264755,
-0.0136710862,
0.0016155241,
-0.0184490271,
0.0147019252,
0.1005994827,
0.0310936458,
0.052363053,
0.0000016759,
-0.0702910125,
-0.0291432366,
-0.0229851175,
-0.0054503474,
-0.0315599442,
0.0425143875,
-0.0373608284,
0.009442932,
0.0165314041,
-0.0393432155,
-0.0054881372,
0.0448831059,
0.0682411939,
0.0584160015,
0.0868528187,
-0.0236037858,
-0.0156324077,
0.0266708247,
-0.0334821716,
0.0024128614,
-0.0490424745,
0.0322558917,
-0.0490480848,
-0.0027377002,
0.0353467278,
0.0276256166,
0.020787647,
-0.0169280935,
0.0033717563,
0.0328170173,
0.0233124271,
-0.0345933251,
-0.0579291061,
-0.0192305464,
0.048550874,
0.030152455,
-0.0406228006,
0.0229552034,
-0.0165309925,
-0.0101503413,
0.0166660696,
-0.014199933,
0.0299304593,
-0.0265746526,
0.0043738713,
0.061640285,
-0.0189877711,
0.0055788197,
0.0485738032,
0.0300930999,
0.0883042514,
-0.019562196,
-0.0567515269,
0.0489660725,
0.0670659915,
-0.0237061698,
-0.0814109668,
-0.0082084546,
0.0285455566,
-0.0172607768,
0.0058259661,
-0.0515042506,
-0.0438568816,
0.0051570544,
-0.0413467623,
-0.0143655669,
0.0332596563,
-0.0155860009,
0.0708324611,
0.0383090228,
-0.0379137062,
0.0103784911,
-0.0221728459,
0.0086402055,
0.0036610942,
-0.0831336826,
0.0344193392,
-0.0590786375,
-0.0011769707,
-0.0223983806,
0.005539353,
-0.0079257693,
0.0244107842,
0.019432256,
-0.0131283989,
-0.0304559451,
-0.0447915085,
-0.0561061502,
0.0288407765,
-0.008821018,
0.0382373519,
-0.0558986366,
0.0048889141,
-0.0156458858,
-0.0188940112,
-0.0004343992,
0.010701918,
0.0220897049,
-0.0271322504,
-0.0037078969,
-0.0091619985,
-0.0273629744,
-0.0499861762,
-0.0603263862,
-0.003022155,
-0.0017009625,
-0.0059891678,
0.0078785894,
-0.0655469447,
0.0124137318,
0.0343493856,
-0.0199145507,
0.0034161771,
0.0141185056,
0.0185191724,
-0.0619050488,
0.0520479307,
-0.0858003125,
0.0093762148,
0.0574947558,
-0.0233455822,
-0.0322277509,
0.0941870511,
-0.0099961273,
0.0272401925,
0.0655336305,
0.0085796975,
0.0102422005,
0.0447485484,
0.0028904758,
0.0436596088,
-0.0017688441,
-0.0027526065,
-0.0208841879,
-0.0064542596,
-0.0102128498,
-0.021572927,
0.0007388997,
0.0401763581,
0.053180255,
0.044082962,
0.0081690717,
0.0071365917,
0.0185051709,
0.0373318493,
0.0373132601,
-0.014041041,
-0.0298722386,
-0.0182159804,
-0.0503005013,
0.002909973,
0.0100069968,
-0.0233155899,
-0.0186090525,
0.0017396931,
-0.019578496,
-0.0158118047,
0.0004425278,
-0.0246207416,
0.0629269704,
-0.0010194927,
-0.0021172245,
0.039158009,
0.041632127,
-0.0222987626,
0.0010602921,
-0.0243393667,
0.0312917046,
0.027796546,
0.001635546,
-0.0601665415,
-0.0385555662,
-0.0497761965,
0.1003308296,
0.0654455498,
0.0449955501,
-0.0088929692,
-0.0127009451,
0.0114252875,
-0.0337328427,
0.0055924142,
0.0316467583,
0.0055408236,
0.0249463804,
-0.0196273178,
-0.0154128103,
-0.0168580431,
-0.0148244649,
0.0362008661,
0.0034551255,
-0.0369815938,
0.0135953892,
0.0073371395,
-0.0087603899,
0.0448541194,
-0.0233728625,
-0.0276612025,
-0.0024146207,
-0.0138798254,
-0.0276114661,
-0.0230696406,
-0.0039576855,
0.012782027,
0.0000804766,
0.0217397138,
-0.0522658937,
-0.0131823318,
-0.0633090213,
-0.0225146245,
-0.0145374546,
-0.0039017785,
-0.0123813823,
-0.0442447588,
-0.0179620199,
-0.056856215,
-0.0152147245,
-0.0326903947,
0.080183506,
0.0227737669,
0.0053359605,
-0.0090381308,
-0.0259612687,
0.0117104286,
-0.022966817,
-0.0263921171,
0.0068889442,
-0.0017952377,
0.0154812178,
0.0577956624,
0.0291750096,
-0.054570917,
0.0135164503,
-0.1301018149,
0.0417818055,
-0.041839581,
0.0273280963,
0.0412221998,
0.0400189757,
-0.0259456653,
-0.0173974931,
-0.0047308835,
-0.0126414886,
0.000611253,
0.0327836387,
0.0537295863,
0.003984544,
0.0216967724,
-0.0215459075,
-0.001219146,
-0.0591169745,
0.0138268154,
0.0646993443,
-0.0682272166,
-0.0248473436,
-0.0028776519,
0.004965832,
0.0240254086,
0.0206136145,
0.0068915542,
-0.0059176479,
-0.0252426956,
0.0055442923,
0.0242495034,
0.0220578276,
0.0568066351,
0.0100890072,
0.0338933878,
-0.0183568913,
0.0127792368,
-0.0373009965,
-0.0188212208,
-0.0141755519,
-0.0147371795,
0.039220687,
0.0840538666,
-0.0362002887,
0.0134095661,
-0.0543859303,
0.0033390324,
-0.0433184355,
0.0236628894,
-0.0582374409,
0.006518221,
-0.0017954879,
0.0300473478,
-0.0161309708,
-0.0155917564,
0.049321156,
0.0168873016,
0.0300303288,
-0.0667669922,
-0.0703940988,
-0.0296072643,
0.0125600966,
0.0003848628,
-0.0043225079,
0.0413892418,
-0.0018709614,
0.0033618945,
-0.0141199566,
0.0304885488,
0.0135476673,
0.0251656286,
-0.0280596539,
0.0362836905,
-0.0132953711,
-0.0276082661,
-0.0098440247,
-0.113352932,
-0.0545036383,
0.0240542982,
-0.030026501,
-0.0209379476,
-0.0236233361,
0.0041763787,
0.0309790876,
0.0384110622,
-0.0167148896,
-0.0263313204,
-0.0115229916,
0.0421812534,
-0.0098509211,
-0.01098435,
-0.0472388193,
0.0005078801,
0.0306807216,
0.0089899637,
0.0696175992,
0.0222748313,
-0.0349407643,
-0.0017301093,
0.0101901237,
-0.0767191947,
-0.0251815338,
-0.0074287928,
0.0445477366,
-0.0124529088,
0.0170446318,
0.1397732049,
0.0454343371,
-0.0452124551,
-0.0292048659,
0.0133855045,
0.0062552183,
0.0238869861,
0.0362829827,
-0.0849560425,
-0.0341198258,
0.0082738847,
0.0639306828,
-0.0236022845,
-0.0624816529,
-0.0016126173,
-0.0850004479,
0.0123444078,
-0.0309797041,
-0.0315236598,
0.0332836136,
-0.1048115343,
0.0409808382,
-0.0443297885,
-0.0511634722,
-0.0428398103,
-0.0064095482,
0.0390140638,
0.0306419805,
-0.033277832,
-0.0768407509,
0.0126566002,
-0.0394966938,
0.0306434352,
0.0195411425,
0.0131690288,
-0.0087871933,
0.032641951,
0.0502797328,
0.0069328425,
-0.0031357196,
-0.0309600513,
0.0646462142,
-0.0183166508,
0.0038787613,
0.0292907692,
0.0060742451,
-0.0198400132,
-0.0257105771,
0.005538193,
0.0498935282,
-0.0096789598,
0.032157965,
0.0125258053,
-0.0003069084,
0.0504992194,
0.0694958866,
0.0157256667,
-0.0672160015,
0.0040309071,
-0.0406883247,
0.0247845128,
-0.0352600217,
-0.0179564282,
0.0016407127,
-0.0818070695,
-0.0957017392,
-0.0341605991,
-0.0328646936,
0.0566210561,
0.0302781034,
0.0081066415,
-0.0294997469,
0.0251989719,
0.0096086273,
-0.0449571535,
0.0530535281,
-0.0228666514,
0.0033968524,
-0.0568104908,
-0.0329193324,
0.0309648253,
0.0048836316,
-0.0190801024,
0.0081436383,
-0.0458543301,
-0.0414529406,
0.0353010967,
-0.0215484276,
0.0243996475,
0.0181842875,
-0.0212091189,
-0.0548565164,
0.0077330279,
0.0744117275,
-0.0237818658,
-0.0185662657,
0.0185836405,
0.018427806,
-0.0062807724,
0.0162815861,
-0.0500115976,
0.0515874736,
-0.0034181273,
0.0116601111,
-0.0325672701,
0.0063216798,
0.0035329601,
0.0217884406,
0.1149986014,
0.0015583549,
-0.0658446103,
-0.0566729903,
-0.0536573082,
0.0213952959,
-0.032848563,
-0.0166572426,
-0.0004933694,
0.007490966,
-0.0053024236,
-0.0186767504,
0.0547824539,
-0.0387254432,
0.0473911501,
-0.0616420992,
0.0100352829,
0.0211233366,
0.056136366,
-0.0092034107,
-0.0206913203,
-0.0231768358,
0.011258048,
0.0548331067,
0.0093150642,
-0.0246687997,
0.0498497672,
0.0108461352,
-0.0030123298,
0.0241582971,
0.0083487006,
-0.0797903091,
-0.0120944092,
-0.051560536,
0.0628853664,
0.0427652411,
-0.0354249179,
0.0338161439,
-0.0428128764,
-0.0392236635,
0.0028811391,
0.0017791478,
-0.001212543,
-0.0261566639,
0.0025425812,
-0.0048776614,
-0.0347361974,
0.0394762121,
0.0306941345,
0.0017038595,
0.0364678539,
0.04503024,
-0.0237869676,
-0.0251762494,
0.0215060003,
0.0226641335,
0.0009081053,
0.0127682779,
0.0149392784,
-0.0450338051,
-0.0126131065,
0.0532285795,
-0.0562750138,
-0.0433734693,
0.0063012051,
0.0419773683,
0.0795101151,
0.0021703301,
0.0372215509,
-0.0571628027,
0.0322131589,
0.0200448278,
-0.054249052,
-0.0374546126,
-6.712332087e-33,
-0.0040507643,
-0.0150103709,
-0.0150019825,
0.0012875322,
0.0186124034,
0.0019389328,
-0.0029138816,
0.0159691535,
0.0013911946,
0.0176150016,
-0.0183674097,
0.0218613241,
0.0194719695,
0.0094684409,
0.0014729649,
-0.0320204943,
0.030038571,
-0.0318534523,
-0.0499721356,
0.0368748941,
0.0381472893,
0.0196157787,
0.0421147011,
-0.0984209403,
0.0486255884,
0.001415398,
0.0055537494,
0.0315273702,
0.0986592397,
0.0179801397,
0.0098605966,
0.0706382915,
0.057750918,
-0.0657491088,
0.032614395,
0.0824239701,
-0.0591949821,
-0.0504977554,
-0.0306594726,
-0.0113837635,
-0.0122310491,
-0.0104297427,
-0.0151320165,
0.0100531895,
-0.0044322819,
0.0239018165,
0.0458035991,
0.0168742463,
0.0140998876,
-0.0284092035,
-0.0560034811,
0.0532483831,
-0.0145370057,
-0.0231907498,
0.0062796427,
0.0701377019,
0.0241785105,
0.0127255023,
-0.0260521192,
0.0245040022,
0.0142758032,
-0.009255603,
0.0145696215,
-0.0355790369,
-0.0429085828,
0.0199238546,
-0.0011737957,
0.0617560409,
-0.0226568803,
-0.0165420696,
-0.0217949934,
-0.0096422546,
0.0061620665,
0.0418468118,
0.0273950342,
-0.0029226625,
-0.0603210367,
0.0501562767,
0.0598290563,
-0.0075562843,
-0.0136987325,
-0.0218026396,
-0.0151841389,
-0.016556887,
-0.0239678007,
-0.037471734,
-0.030907141,
0.0138820745,
-0.004227059,
-0.009268255,
-0.0187350623,
0.0317600556,
0.0312385038,
0.0136207528,
0.0134983091,
-0.0160902254,
-0.0074459617,
0.0584920831,
-0.0006751217,
0.0222794246,
-0.068760559,
-0.0517391078,
0.0151222777,
0.0367247388,
0.030582279,
-0.0108859111,
0.0357762761,
0.0137399854,
-0.0429614112,
0.0002845889,
-0.0058584958,
0.0442632101,
-0.027187502,
0.0396891646,
0.0066858977,
0.0182044562,
0.0218668245,
0.0472607389,
0.0667549372,
-0.0001292567,
0.0104554808,
-0.0245250482,
-0.0206443015,
-0.0079052085,
0.0162013788,
0.0017836477,
0.0133704022,
0.0446197838,
-0.0002976096,
-0.0584000833,
-0.0154274348,
-0.0079145236,
2.646e-7,
0.0638331994,
0.1003044546,
-0.0158969015,
-0.024086671,
0.0225438997,
0.0638603568,
-0.001456399,
0.0378182456,
0.0019823667,
-0.0109454058,
0.0021338426,
-0.0139876539,
0.0427363291,
0.0430530757,
-0.0774786472,
-0.0669244975,
-0.0550261922,
0.049281694,
-0.0758878812,
0.0390954837,
0.0483166762,
0.0575217418,
0.028104987,
-0.0008282633,
-0.0360544957,
-0.0625526235,
0.0400851108,
-0.0136095621,
-0.0204141699,
0.0205687899,
0.0433847383,
0.0237037633,
-0.0019789853,
0.0414448045,
-0.0330263413,
-0.0006162477,
-0.0109105865,
0.0352566876,
-0.0017518032,
0.0093028201,
0.0023116202,
-0.0268534981,
0.0275981817,
-0.0189568307,
0.0686719343,
-0.096163474,
-0.0301237367,
-0.0247552134,
-0.0145286778,
0.0023594568,
0.0126949754,
-0.0082224999,
-0.0461736582,
0.0143353716,
0.0102356793,
0.0111788763,
-0.0326417275,
-0.0323772803,
-0.0038805744,
0.0231591798,
-0.0102580097,
-0.0459066145,
-0.0137874912,
0.0005148606,
0.022330543,
-0.053569112,
0.0585877337,
2.315513568e-34,
0.0182989351,
-0.0150481686,
-0.018478388,
-0.0030222782,
0.0192744862,
0.0272539482,
-0.0286124703,
-0.0126454048,
0.0045932513,
-0.050496567,
0.0212973077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18227v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18227v1 | GUIDE: A Guideline-Guided Dataset for Instructional Video Comprehension | 2024-06-26T10:24:00 | 2024-06-26T10:24:00 | Jiafeng Liang, Shixin Jiang, Zekun Wang, Haojie Pan, Zerui Chen, Zheng Chu, Ming Liu, Ruiji Fu, Zhongyuan Wang, Bing Qin | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | There are substantial instructional videos on the Internet, which provide us
tutorials for completing various tasks. Existing instructional video datasets
only focus on specific steps at the video level, lacking experiential
guidelines at the task level, which can lead to beginners struggling to learn
new tasks due to the lack of relevant experience. Moreover, the specific steps
without guidelines are trivial and unsystematic, making it difficult to provide
a clear tutorial. To address these problems, we present the GUIDE
(Guideline-Guided) dataset, which contains 3.5K videos of 560 instructional
tasks in 8 domains related to our daily life. Specifically, we annotate each
instructional task with a guideline, representing a common pattern shared by
all task-related videos. On this basis, we annotate systematic specific steps,
including their associated guideline steps, specific step descriptions and
timestamps. Our proposed benchmark consists of three sub-tasks to evaluate
comprehension ability of models: (1) Step Captioning: models have to generate
captions for specific steps from videos. (2) Guideline Summarization: models
have to mine the common pattern in task-related videos and summarize a
guideline from them. (3) Guideline-Guided Captioning: models have to generate
captions for specific steps under the guide of guideline. We evaluate plenty of
foundation models with GUIDE and perform in-depth analysis. Given the diversity
and practicality of GUIDE, we believe that it can be used as a better benchmark
for instructional video comprehension. | GUIDE: A Guideline-Guided Dataset for Instructional Video Comprehension: There are substantial instructional videos on the Internet, which provide us
tutorials for completing various tasks. Existing instructional video datasets
only focus on specific steps at the video level, lacking experiential
guidelines at the task level, which can lead to beginners struggling to learn
new tasks due to the lack of relevant experience. Moreover, the specific steps
without guidelines are trivial and unsystematic, making it difficult to provide
a clear tutorial. To address these problems, we present the GUIDE
(Guideline-Guided) dataset, which contains 3.5K videos of 560 instructional
tasks in 8 domains related to our daily life. Specifically, we annotate each
instructional task with a guideline, representing a common pattern shared by
all task-related videos. On this basis, we annotate systematic specific steps,
including their associated guideline steps, specific step descriptions and
timestamps. Our proposed benchmark consists of three sub-tasks to evaluate
comprehension ability of models: (1) Step Captioning: models have to generate
captions for specific steps from videos. (2) Guideline Summarization: models
have to mine the common pattern in task-related videos and summarize a
guideline from them. (3) Guideline-Guided Captioning: models have to generate
captions for specific steps under the guide of guideline. We evaluate plenty of
foundation models with GUIDE and perform in-depth analysis. Given the diversity
and practicality of GUIDE, we believe that it can be used as a better benchmark
for instructional video comprehension. | [
0.0308309123,
0.0033243338,
-0.0008863953,
0.0451488942,
0.0077636847,
0.0288856365,
0.0102445325,
-0.033835493,
-0.0400295071,
-0.0485712811,
-0.0081558358,
0.017725192,
0.0005193803,
0.0062454557,
-0.0155426078,
-0.125841558,
-0.0078100995,
0.0058385869,
-0.0069682389,
0.054387033,
0.02618053,
0.0030563851,
-0.0448878556,
0.045038078,
-0.0134316627,
-0.0116554685,
-0.0055776453,
-0.0058578318,
0.046521388,
-0.037473131,
0.0051432182,
0.0320000015,
0.0611947104,
-0.0424499996,
0.0000017624,
0.0036811859,
0.005364297,
-0.0274735745,
-0.0295997094,
0.0290288702,
0.0016263287,
-0.0079977084,
0.0267806612,
0.0163887627,
-0.0315699317,
0.0206578337,
0.019642232,
0.0237333868,
0.0552799515,
0.0536618456,
-0.0070316293,
-0.0372489132,
-0.002246659,
0.0019692795,
0.0207556728,
-0.0308007319,
-0.0131473206,
0.0912542269,
0.0265610646,
-0.0038248166,
-0.0461604632,
0.035725113,
0.0325218402,
-0.0067444658,
0.0038886103,
0.0299762879,
-0.0161767546,
-0.0347079821,
0.0100340331,
0.1001872569,
0.0232731942,
0.0392866805,
0.009260118,
0.007791304,
0.0256134998,
0.0376942828,
-0.0763767511,
0.0497776493,
-0.0166792981,
-0.0070875618,
-0.0153680108,
0.0371687338,
0.0034879863,
-0.0141371451,
0.0704857334,
-0.035457626,
-0.0142037366,
0.0150750326,
-0.0263059754,
-0.0102435732,
-0.0465045422,
-0.0312707797,
0.05384022,
0.0274631791,
0.0081438562,
0.0283346381,
-0.0522794016,
0.0363780744,
-0.0201823246,
-0.0374904722,
0.0770185739,
0.0559023544,
-0.0371418037,
0.071655564,
-0.0249532871,
0.0542435683,
-0.0047820415,
0.0337420143,
-0.0628285781,
0.0383421518,
-0.0965459347,
0.0287842266,
-0.0536814965,
0.0321267508,
-0.0275654923,
-0.012497182,
-0.0329857282,
0.0035504024,
-0.0255569275,
0.0402126387,
-0.0264416374,
0.0321983919,
0.0126531953,
0.0038775152,
-0.0154625326,
-0.0172743611,
-0.082242988,
0.0462749563,
0.0061835833,
-0.0432059541,
-0.0082011661,
-0.0020470193,
0.0085418848,
-0.0008378077,
0.022967536,
0.015629055,
-0.060051024,
-0.0330095552,
-0.0417146757,
-0.0356533341,
0.0092180539,
0.0091998549,
0.0296380762,
-0.0392553173,
0.019749783,
-0.0145314131,
0.0099172201,
-0.0237316191,
-0.0056084674,
0.0266940221,
-0.0118875299,
0.0636450574,
0.0301344767,
0.0285136923,
0.0257097315,
0.0645890385,
-0.0639268085,
0.0458580069,
0.0303143244,
0.0165295601,
0.0633354932,
0.0127656329,
0.0348867998,
0.0116521856,
-0.0021904835,
0.0132297203,
-0.0339420848,
0.0453641675,
0.0067762542,
0.0349567942,
0.0313446037,
0.0167028699,
-0.0187828373,
-0.00729784,
0.0370974168,
0.0314227566,
-0.0307665281,
-0.004286197,
0.0871017203,
0.0525551476,
0.0335130692,
0.0492728353,
-0.026821712,
0.0509018488,
-0.0007953264,
0.0097860014,
-0.0042975745,
-0.008555416,
-0.0692880005,
-0.0672482327,
-0.0078926682,
0.0003259655,
-0.0022670827,
-0.0228174031,
0.0175425243,
0.0277468357,
-0.0788810998,
0.0320914611,
-0.0217198059,
-0.0281147733,
0.0361819565,
-0.009985147,
0.0086264769,
0.0482901856,
0.0108592371,
-0.021097675,
-0.0395002775,
0.0084642097,
0.0990919173,
-0.0327905938,
0.0197781809,
-0.0612752736,
0.0368210375,
-0.0810511559,
-0.050879471,
-0.0130125135,
0.0159910824,
0.0079597281,
0.0118871387,
0.0081343809,
0.0385596529,
-0.0323942453,
-0.0561431423,
0.0605000146,
0.0001241845,
-0.0278476197,
-0.0169812515,
0.0108261881,
0.0139783798,
0.0431331806,
-0.0060765883,
-0.0196188502,
0.011456619,
-0.0214111656,
0.0084846988,
0.0373580903,
-0.0604419485,
-0.0368823744,
0.0257962551,
-0.1029157564,
-0.0005018361,
0.0482897833,
-0.0366757102,
-0.0454520583,
0.0048103132,
-0.0015988562,
-0.018274432,
-0.0094122663,
-0.007905608,
0.0476024151,
-0.0322779343,
0.0153637277,
0.02388441,
-0.0041600615,
0.0196096115,
0.0467392989,
-0.0029392019,
-0.0103346445,
-0.0538297966,
0.0122949984,
-0.0318882465,
-0.0444889776,
0.0013454623,
0.0245021544,
0.0241807494,
-0.0881763548,
-0.0165913831,
-0.0410159752,
0.0159005728,
-0.0114109498,
0.0052056368,
0.0232506022,
-0.0272409413,
-0.0217996296,
-0.0555776507,
0.0114667267,
-0.0223150402,
-0.0206556153,
-0.0042250114,
-0.0148167871,
0.0680609047,
-0.0262945984,
-0.046956528,
-0.0072578089,
0.0002318361,
0.0118894475,
0.0470243096,
0.0297867134,
-0.0168764703,
0.0180711951,
0.017679235,
-0.0076364297,
-0.0188376456,
-0.0213762615,
0.0143396249,
0.0060784854,
-0.0118691586,
0.0504629575,
-0.0077471924,
0.0514297262,
0.0072112419,
-0.0391627178,
-0.0254551824,
0.0200104117,
0.0093981614,
-0.0193837099,
-0.0165267717,
-0.045642145,
-0.0194636043,
0.0107368585,
0.0063364389,
0.0358126462,
-0.0674541146,
0.0056021791,
-0.0260837413,
0.0183859766,
-0.0473760478,
0.0003258307,
0.0154465698,
0.0089747347,
-0.0233139601,
-0.0288762357,
0.047424987,
-0.0271552615,
-0.035722848,
-0.0140899876,
-0.0040407758,
-0.0216446817,
0.0521913134,
0.001665361,
0.0120633729,
0.0004026887,
-0.0386103727,
-0.0510400087,
0.0068416926,
0.0720803589,
-0.0044863308,
0.0589921288,
-0.0801251456,
-0.0292971358,
-0.0278629512,
0.0117211994,
-0.0511192046,
0.0013882833,
-0.0147533184,
-0.0184908863,
-0.0273569655,
-0.0060322927,
-0.0625245646,
-0.0105886916,
0.0109722093,
0.0520001985,
-0.011153237,
-0.0049706092,
-0.0042946837,
0.0319092534,
0.0408621579,
0.0309208557,
-0.0608367622,
-0.0513599478,
0.0979962274,
0.0217577107,
0.029876044,
-0.0636620969,
-0.0278217457,
0.026515156,
0.0120639298,
-0.0467343815,
0.0034903681,
0.0720243305,
0.0529627427,
-0.0755962431,
0.0246552378,
0.1168534309,
0.0160605758,
-0.0228399802,
-0.0095771775,
0.0303500425,
-0.0182233397,
0.0522609688,
-0.0118396319,
-0.0584857017,
-0.0455480739,
-0.0158227682,
0.0390126593,
0.0288615599,
0.0082847355,
-0.0179118589,
-0.0595267378,
0.0631615445,
0.0292505622,
-0.0427301154,
-0.0288609099,
-0.0335407443,
-0.0169566423,
-0.046629034,
-0.0069871149,
-0.0152867893,
-0.047954157,
0.0443079136,
0.0467030741,
-0.0241203308,
-0.0741692483,
0.0319325514,
-0.0349415503,
0.0426966213,
0.0259057861,
0.0075535607,
-0.018591132,
0.0007943062,
0.0067020901,
-0.0275875814,
-0.0068210321,
-0.0131972907,
0.0872605667,
-0.0132962763,
-0.0066260798,
0.0169893038,
0.0647282153,
-0.0326552726,
-0.0381018855,
0.0565872379,
0.0470122173,
0.0062630153,
0.0182496514,
-0.064838618,
0.0338889249,
0.0227423366,
0.1063061431,
0.0152188791,
0.0114530679,
0.0320736691,
0.0128806578,
-0.0066206777,
-0.0764152408,
-0.0063434509,
-0.0144683141,
0.0142896511,
0.0488726161,
-0.0688091516,
-0.0412712619,
0.0761562958,
0.0229958557,
0.0064998115,
0.0115385856,
0.0288856607,
0.0469038263,
-0.0739140734,
0.0488295108,
-0.0119018154,
-0.0172789451,
-0.1015055478,
-0.0416984521,
0.0346239656,
-0.0274388473,
-0.0222573392,
0.0368704125,
-0.0176787693,
0.0033672254,
-0.0284710303,
0.058028996,
0.0188615844,
0.0573992506,
0.0320102088,
0.0175744575,
-0.0316614099,
-0.0276957266,
0.0019444952,
-0.0169067662,
0.0144577408,
-0.0179005228,
-0.0195052531,
0.0039735609,
-0.0372159183,
0.0136106256,
-0.0475450531,
0.0280924886,
-0.0498412848,
-0.0378175415,
0.0201772172,
-0.0487184897,
0.0243278407,
-0.0003456127,
0.0115417782,
-0.0429684557,
0.0128227267,
0.0105215935,
0.0291375145,
-0.0634402856,
0.0534623452,
0.045876883,
-0.0012769813,
0.0005702659,
0.0439557359,
-0.0294192843,
-0.0025928677,
-0.0612858199,
0.0028212522,
-0.0310711209,
0.0125800911,
-0.036679972,
0.011107604,
0.0048058825,
0.0061405613,
0.0183590595,
0.0267768465,
0.0483553559,
0.0902250931,
0.0163512528,
0.0255131312,
0.0157684553,
0.0420806184,
-0.0104128718,
-0.0182433203,
-0.0387180671,
0.0098551596,
0.0250426903,
-0.0667236447,
-0.0025214825,
-0.0079317763,
0.0129481535,
-0.0343137346,
0.0491732135,
-0.0362483598,
-0.0593945161,
0.0403656214,
0.0147289233,
0.0215371232,
0.0079144305,
0.1003496051,
0.0046000252,
0.0448119789,
0.010764705,
-0.023496205,
-0.0358468816,
-0.0256132521,
0.0217603482,
0.0201730039,
-0.0399156213,
0.0191804431,
-0.0331234336,
-0.0462793484,
-0.0527364686,
-0.027910227,
0.0205319747,
0.0233319905,
0.0749000236,
0.0125644561,
-0.0345450826,
-0.020275278,
-0.0192269292,
-0.0305878595,
-0.0638343692,
-0.0059782723,
-0.0294802189,
-5.168284257e-33,
-0.0463222116,
-0.0069341059,
0.0172053166,
0.0265593026,
0.0287887324,
0.0221774094,
-0.0398540199,
0.0412059575,
-0.0223644711,
0.044129584,
0.0299107563,
0.0143664377,
0.0209751278,
0.0370377377,
0.0298446044,
-0.0330766104,
0.0628532544,
-0.0229124334,
-0.0308495276,
0.0357856862,
-0.000626117,
0.0077726734,
0.0297121704,
-0.0754888654,
-0.0175741222,
-0.0182510763,
-0.0469878428,
0.0071729901,
0.0337589383,
0.0746406913,
-0.0021498851,
-0.0594019666,
0.0188197214,
-0.0435038581,
-0.0372171104,
-0.0152491638,
-0.079515785,
0.0011487105,
0.0134605244,
0.0264248904,
-0.0631272867,
-0.0246520713,
0.0084153749,
-0.0142355738,
-0.0084593622,
-0.0229970906,
0.0868918821,
-0.0450165719,
0.0337440893,
0.0139508629,
-0.0121668167,
-0.0062216655,
-0.0659532174,
-0.1027056426,
0.0205586925,
0.0253474899,
0.0180361066,
-0.0282320399,
-0.0488019846,
0.0122181326,
0.0102729676,
0.0421415046,
0.0930869952,
-0.0111184185,
-0.023010999,
0.0402896442,
-0.0118242884,
-0.0542150289,
0.0050949291,
-0.0147809442,
-0.014879195,
0.0888844579,
-0.0017309359,
-0.0215130504,
0.0498519093,
0.0441414006,
-0.0344914198,
0.1013067216,
-0.0342647135,
0.0400486253,
-0.0120254317,
0.0036706978,
-0.0328168571,
0.0408035927,
-0.0287304744,
-0.0023792887,
0.0040511596,
-0.0153170107,
0.0325375833,
0.0089222481,
-0.0038669596,
-0.0277764574,
0.032979086,
-0.0321253911,
0.0271554161,
0.0068761171,
-0.0278125275,
0.0290318932,
0.0118419835,
0.0030585476,
-0.0807797909,
-0.0340662524,
0.0394563638,
-0.0084798187,
0.0130260903,
-0.001507719,
0.0228320938,
0.0532202125,
-0.0153994272,
-0.0009399807,
-0.0070757223,
-0.0142739071,
-0.0399120525,
0.0213854611,
0.015371725,
0.0404435843,
-0.0855160132,
0.0579117797,
-0.0364305712,
-0.00208778,
-0.0141063286,
-0.026142925,
0.0198372602,
0.0107206497,
-0.0264812652,
-0.0059167328,
-0.040975716,
-0.009603492,
0.0387757346,
-0.0301090796,
-0.001171625,
0.0337649249,
2.38e-7,
-0.0198214483,
-0.0124517754,
0.0122350231,
0.0037161761,
-0.0070546069,
0.057801228,
-0.0363359153,
-0.0057051806,
0.0019163286,
-0.048476126,
0.0512089431,
0.0474831648,
0.0147271734,
-0.0105558187,
-0.0555529743,
-0.0473124944,
-0.0183205791,
-0.017885806,
-0.0286409575,
-0.0185028911,
0.0281272121,
0.0597462431,
0.0101931384,
0.0066621285,
0.0008847417,
-0.0534410886,
0.0480584055,
-0.0132393166,
-0.0095016686,
0.0064243488,
0.054744035,
0.0369654149,
-0.0460992083,
-0.0037028533,
-0.0304284431,
-0.016551381,
0.0587682761,
0.0638610497,
0.0172576886,
-0.0110883666,
-0.0408795774,
0.0344470665,
-0.0115203811,
0.000719059,
0.0241231415,
-0.0250548441,
-0.0247300696,
0.021030331,
-0.0294784922,
0.0275398064,
-0.0256444849,
0.0298141688,
-0.005818957,
0.0124237062,
0.0073155425,
-0.0226553548,
-0.0418487862,
-0.0635369271,
0.0072208592,
0.003717314,
-0.0274136644,
0.0024713089,
-0.0493998341,
-0.003664135,
-0.0098925531,
-0.0212029405,
-0.0525105707,
1.662610256e-34,
0.0144377695,
-0.0034605132,
0.0050324625,
-0.0146374144,
0.0176505763,
-0.0049670665,
-0.0749069005,
0.0074946014,
-0.0088662459,
-0.0248900782,
-0.0055910409
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18221v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18221v1 | Enhancing Data Privacy in Large Language Models through Private Association Editing | 2024-06-26T10:08:47 | 2024-06-26T10:08:47 | Davide Venditti, Elena Sofia Ruzzetti, Giancarlo A. Xompero, Cristina Giannone, Andrea Favalli, Raniero Romagnoli, Fabio Massimo Zanzotto | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) are powerful tools with extensive applications,
but their tendency to memorize private information raises significant concerns
as private data leakage can easily happen. In this paper, we introduce Private
Association Editing (PAE), a novel defense approach for private data leakage.
PAE is designed to effectively remove Personally Identifiable Information (PII)
without retraining the model. Our approach consists of a four-step procedure:
detecting memorized PII, applying PAE cards to mitigate memorization of private
data, verifying resilience to targeted data extraction (TDE) attacks, and
ensuring consistency in the post-edit LLMs. The versatility and efficiency of
PAE, which allows for batch modifications, significantly enhance data privacy
in LLMs. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of PAE in
mitigating private data leakage. We believe PAE will serve as a critical tool
in the ongoing effort to protect data privacy in LLMs, encouraging the
development of safer models for real-world applications. | Enhancing Data Privacy in Large Language Models through Private Association Editing: Large Language Models (LLMs) are powerful tools with extensive applications,
but their tendency to memorize private information raises significant concerns
as private data leakage can easily happen. In this paper, we introduce Private
Association Editing (PAE), a novel defense approach for private data leakage.
PAE is designed to effectively remove Personally Identifiable Information (PII)
without retraining the model. Our approach consists of a four-step procedure:
detecting memorized PII, applying PAE cards to mitigate memorization of private
data, verifying resilience to targeted data extraction (TDE) attacks, and
ensuring consistency in the post-edit LLMs. The versatility and efficiency of
PAE, which allows for batch modifications, significantly enhance data privacy
in LLMs. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of PAE in
mitigating private data leakage. We believe PAE will serve as a critical tool
in the ongoing effort to protect data privacy in LLMs, encouraging the
development of safer models for real-world applications. | [
0.0315022096,
0.1154447868,
-0.0240769517,
0.0835983604,
-0.034967877,
-0.0194263849,
0.0623105615,
-0.0059271432,
0.0102836275,
-0.0162161775,
-0.0271275844,
-0.0235526524,
0.0218127817,
0.0016257963,
0.0491319709,
0.0287220534,
0.0573213436,
-0.0436584912,
0.0005931275,
-0.0286942385,
-0.0170251541,
-0.0235465094,
0.0297028404,
-0.008224953,
0.0188422687,
-0.0234375391,
-0.0177247152,
-0.0264435243,
0.0237118918,
-0.0137506109,
-0.0106648151,
0.0700728968,
0.000566324,
0.0731672272,
0.0000021392,
-0.0357972421,
-0.0767137781,
0.0538189262,
-0.0459742583,
0.0637825951,
-0.0268010367,
0.0095628873,
-0.0167976469,
-0.0002689244,
-0.0197075363,
0.0124674551,
0.0447387211,
0.0236385558,
0.0936271846,
0.0719651505,
-0.0080187051,
-0.028433118,
0.0325861759,
-0.0262408033,
-0.0043283952,
-0.0439411774,
0.0612344742,
-0.042756781,
-0.054310903,
0.0012992594,
-0.0007764671,
0.030234864,
-0.0056094895,
0.0000696754,
-0.0294865295,
0.0076834601,
-0.017217312,
0.0018822798,
0.011679505,
0.0233881138,
0.0213654581,
-0.0249804389,
0.0312017724,
0.0191802103,
0.0220993515,
0.0194612369,
0.0113129746,
0.0403316468,
-0.005871383,
-0.009928368,
0.0178198293,
-0.0503881387,
0.0421251878,
0.0002133126,
-0.0091974726,
0.0191529021,
0.0381617509,
-0.020659769,
-0.0358075127,
-0.0541658401,
0.0277629513,
-0.0628994852,
0.0437726751,
0.0105267214,
0.0460933037,
0.0348157808,
-0.075967744,
-0.0526875779,
0.0086800745,
-0.0475204512,
0.0330921337,
0.0191796273,
0.0207476672,
0.0253587645,
-0.0115407519,
0.0467116833,
-0.01238144,
0.0420935862,
0.0498426259,
0.0284686685,
-0.0238378253,
-0.005971822,
-0.0097301761,
0.0656543374,
-0.008992563,
0.0500990264,
-0.0075190268,
0.0429543965,
-0.0166345667,
0.0604184493,
-0.0019206228,
-0.0262408797,
-0.0020286872,
-0.024350632,
-0.005685077,
-0.0441563167,
0.0206953213,
-0.0194706451,
0.0015757809,
-0.0468507484,
-0.0131840538,
-0.0539312698,
-0.0108403238,
-0.0292394273,
-0.0258109178,
0.0734068081,
0.0211066622,
-0.0094992639,
-0.0668199733,
-0.093877852,
0.0321845599,
-0.0254685599,
0.0051916363,
-0.0614085272,
0.0043596905,
-0.0307295639,
-0.0201067831,
-0.107992813,
-0.0054112487,
0.0162252337,
-0.0369303003,
0.0492485166,
0.0008270711,
-0.0014404313,
0.0175802428,
0.0467391014,
-0.0015876197,
0.006585049,
0.0264488533,
0.0310992263,
0.0690306276,
-0.0209387969,
0.0491061546,
0.0482204258,
0.0225606225,
0.0014689171,
-0.0408105217,
0.0370048545,
0.0318767913,
-0.0741856098,
-0.0200065654,
0.0413121656,
-0.0144693376,
-0.0646093786,
0.1067450792,
0.0377158038,
-0.0189667158,
0.0594181903,
-0.0609752089,
0.0120584164,
0.0119148577,
-0.0131576862,
-0.0574255921,
-0.0053588981,
-0.0789655522,
-0.0247977842,
0.0022714692,
0.0114507545,
0.0055050249,
0.0157899,
0.020738529,
-0.0462808385,
0.0333458744,
0.018437814,
-0.0020457609,
0.0272993557,
0.0238678306,
0.0695355311,
0.0241775401,
-0.0630644411,
-0.0200926196,
-0.0717050731,
-0.0055345669,
0.0623447299,
0.0533615015,
0.0004316549,
-0.0065871147,
-0.0420601964,
-0.0556663163,
-0.0020527293,
0.0069020349,
-0.0009913705,
0.0633449256,
-0.0163113344,
-0.0324093662,
0.0287762303,
0.0245780386,
0.0164362341,
0.0249739569,
-0.0368706696,
0.0191379562,
-0.0166496467,
-0.0118958009,
0.0073363185,
-0.0314528309,
-0.051381655,
0.043590527,
0.0353371352,
0.0029441256,
0.0309671201,
-0.0291483197,
0.0136462897,
0.0196463391,
0.04866568,
0.0406837873,
-0.0312227793,
0.0031891228,
0.0240893047,
0.0001809895,
-0.0106207523,
-0.0026322501,
0.053125035,
-0.0009328014,
-0.0047293031,
0.0060484549,
-0.0265092403,
0.0444700383,
-0.011390077,
0.0391208977,
-0.0180013292,
0.014712302,
-0.0026405021,
0.0018453432,
-0.033926148,
-0.0436371192,
-0.0406552218,
-0.0019271898,
-0.0037384774,
-0.0552275889,
-0.0221223813,
0.0206648801,
0.0019456472,
0.0130231455,
-0.0015805386,
-0.0135799525,
-0.0289277341,
-0.0285369065,
-0.0070093484,
0.0083417138,
0.0118887993,
0.0395728871,
0.0162317269,
0.0203129798,
-0.0395967662,
-0.0219418164,
-0.0370177627,
-0.0359534547,
-0.0577192418,
0.0306228958,
0.0203743596,
0.0192019399,
-0.0453384258,
-0.0048479978,
-0.001517039,
-0.0000397823,
0.0347439684,
-0.053501606,
-0.052817408,
-0.0300328583,
0.032278195,
-0.0489550233,
0.0244599357,
0.0089734225,
-0.0252851397,
-0.0097667733,
0.0012810504,
-0.0014385515,
0.0414025187,
-0.0060623847,
-0.0202504043,
0.0423605852,
-0.0337944068,
-0.0369265191,
-0.0264568236,
0.0269292258,
-0.0133481463,
-0.0206994303,
-0.0159929618,
-0.0029196902,
0.0292670224,
0.0228206888,
-0.0225895848,
0.0052363868,
0.036624033,
0.0233172085,
-0.0207066853,
-0.0030921523,
-0.0430964716,
-0.0191522501,
0.0000025312,
-0.0309332814,
-0.0546573699,
0.0666537732,
-0.0194513611,
0.0443229638,
-0.0228495076,
-0.0299693961,
0.0220204126,
0.0756363049,
0.0074495981,
0.0367262736,
0.0577475987,
-0.0544990413,
-0.032469213,
-0.0349890515,
0.0251103304,
-0.053389255,
0.0289769564,
-0.0443504229,
-0.0412095599,
0.0138793001,
-0.0090820128,
-0.0567200519,
-0.053098321,
-0.0132350624,
-0.0177125819,
-0.0087487856,
-0.0496043898,
0.0019013248,
-0.0439579152,
0.0570442043,
0.0183427893,
-0.0211116355,
0.0209765993,
-0.017931683,
-0.020952858,
0.01552564,
-0.0739058107,
-0.0248851739,
-0.0337734818,
-0.0112301176,
0.0843409896,
0.0589917377,
-0.0268463325,
0.0077426927,
-0.0319952108,
0.0101638418,
-0.0432658345,
-0.0121209128,
0.0272640586,
-0.0102626961,
-0.0619946644,
-0.013286721,
0.0671070814,
0.0187184252,
-0.070564568,
-0.0019822826,
0.0267588161,
-0.0124276932,
-0.006888771,
0.012790842,
-0.0901030824,
0.0108933821,
0.0134160938,
0.0312107299,
-0.0285729263,
-0.0469697788,
-0.0441990346,
-0.0952237993,
-0.0243891366,
0.0404007435,
-0.0275052581,
-0.0229533948,
-0.0368213654,
0.0161089413,
0.0152451079,
0.0124643305,
-0.0266665164,
0.0121844029,
-0.0127523821,
-0.0066702403,
-0.0326180309,
-0.0229640119,
-0.0186313987,
-0.0285702106,
0.0635775179,
0.0538164563,
-0.003133473,
-0.027885912,
-0.0120681059,
0.0216346234,
0.0694645047,
-0.0225802995,
-0.0000085151,
0.0449795499,
0.0119412616,
0.0012699183,
0.0217493661,
0.0322208516,
0.0481087491,
-0.0196753033,
0.046631135,
0.0404403619,
-0.0268031806,
0.0351093411,
0.0232235771,
-0.0512775294,
0.0131877698,
0.055322241,
0.0016126495,
-0.0133977393,
0.025767684,
-0.0670879185,
0.0224291086,
-0.0112632969,
0.0101393303,
-0.0179201998,
-0.0208173506,
-0.0517961048,
-0.0291000269,
-0.0023658937,
-0.0160472151,
-0.001715149,
0.0754356161,
0.007193936,
0.0487313047,
-0.0011516394,
-0.041087307,
-0.0193247907,
-0.102187857,
0.0202545188,
-0.0499389134,
-0.0132526541,
-0.0029974906,
-0.0039619538,
-0.0057580676,
-0.0049316185,
-0.0630406439,
-0.0933557525,
0.0401974916,
0.0500314645,
0.0200809259,
0.0418474004,
-0.0033604871,
-0.1029401645,
0.0685485378,
0.0146631878,
-0.0464531183,
0.0049616676,
0.0614074469,
-0.033096049,
0.0103600956,
0.018609887,
-0.0231837705,
-0.0409762673,
0.0705832615,
-0.0438511707,
-0.0466850139,
-0.0394647233,
-0.0345059149,
0.0723424777,
0.01400756,
0.0290370956,
0.0339004621,
-0.0365952253,
0.0638967305,
-0.0617672652,
0.0041700602,
0.0140453866,
0.0155631462,
0.0377787985,
0.0089064669,
0.04484367,
-0.0581141859,
0.0030387717,
0.0275483839,
-0.011008217,
0.0210114941,
0.0209731944,
0.0274528265,
0.0312103312,
0.0096822074,
-0.0130848261,
0.0447983369,
0.0542658269,
0.0330534466,
-0.029712338,
0.0527793802,
-0.0137985274,
-0.02439503,
-0.0355080627,
0.0330059417,
-0.0344788656,
-0.0038166451,
-0.00130067,
0.052825395,
-0.0178983156,
0.0116135674,
-0.0034656511,
-0.0312629305,
0.00502053,
-0.0404140949,
-0.0227924995,
-0.0137426481,
-0.0329170525,
-0.0235592127,
-0.0184098128,
-0.0074038729,
0.0571642891,
0.0565242358,
-0.0196884591,
0.0530614853,
-0.0321970023,
-0.0205092132,
-0.0736769438,
-0.0165250935,
0.0338206887,
0.0113859279,
-0.0669521615,
-0.0532133617,
-0.0332964212,
-0.0634274557,
-0.0159245227,
-0.0130980806,
0.0282735899,
0.0041947062,
-0.0196721125,
0.0099104112,
-0.0088473242,
-0.0016910079,
-0.0903770328,
0.0247321203,
0.0304904915,
-0.0366326235,
0.0052770567,
-5.484526033e-33,
0.0164426342,
0.0069758925,
-0.0270300694,
0.0285570454,
0.0257167425,
0.0268445779,
-0.0331257544,
0.0176356789,
-0.0074682306,
-0.0308349561,
-0.0460856408,
-0.0079105161,
0.0152795361,
0.0151716201,
-0.0164585933,
0.0020787821,
0.0361161493,
0.0013802856,
-0.012768914,
0.0264740512,
0.0365367681,
0.0298260562,
0.0573365167,
-0.0948287398,
0.0607268028,
-0.0171701144,
-0.0455105752,
0.0177251846,
-0.0536698066,
0.0761775598,
0.005605862,
-0.0357274897,
-0.011373587,
0.00667318,
-0.0179108884,
0.0197292361,
-0.0340097174,
-0.0159093421,
0.0013386981,
0.0070734904,
0.0490832031,
-0.0784338191,
0.0226270165,
-0.0376581587,
-0.0212622974,
0.0065794005,
-0.0156220105,
-0.0214203689,
-0.0037063819,
-0.0058823545,
0.0130877346,
0.007173209,
-0.0124794571,
0.0130715016,
0.0833168775,
-0.0403838679,
0.024219688,
-0.0451409295,
-0.060072355,
0.0554402359,
0.0783440843,
0.0041716942,
0.0460776351,
0.0185347907,
0.0292798113,
0.0387211815,
0.0485275798,
0.0389601476,
0.0536285676,
0.0178331248,
-0.0088356109,
0.0226666462,
-0.0170011241,
0.037108209,
0.0231519118,
-0.0301046167,
-0.0152858896,
0.0219505019,
-0.0218343455,
0.0090458626,
0.038758155,
0.0198780578,
-0.063772358,
0.0241017621,
-0.0431722738,
0.016890673,
-0.0473201908,
-0.0097582517,
-0.0196243227,
-0.010545671,
-0.0675636008,
0.0170982648,
0.010949376,
-0.0596610047,
-0.0313531831,
0.036661014,
0.0455771089,
-0.0303642284,
-0.0108347982,
-0.0025505342,
-0.0193234161,
0.0029847529,
0.0060860557,
-0.0427809507,
0.0156265907,
0.0137834176,
0.0357497893,
0.021840442,
-0.0999265015,
-0.0273053832,
-0.0253117792,
0.0187575947,
0.0322766118,
0.0102597978,
0.0162489694,
-0.0011557175,
0.0165426582,
0.0192297325,
0.058319848,
0.0165897366,
-0.0507759079,
0.055828914,
0.0000360067,
0.0096953437,
0.0312277395,
0.0005020247,
0.0422527343,
0.0326720998,
0.1037614569,
0.0036112021,
0.0200431701,
-0.0367869586,
2.865e-7,
-0.0103297234,
0.0248779468,
0.0000575811,
-0.016180886,
0.0237722658,
0.0755645931,
-0.0006768323,
0.0504916273,
0.0238725524,
0.0164876413,
-0.011121518,
-0.0035418386,
0.0365363099,
0.0386476666,
-0.038203802,
0.0257830061,
-0.0169076566,
-0.0056155492,
-0.0611204244,
0.0124026658,
0.0157888848,
0.0751640871,
0.061477948,
-0.0271093491,
-0.0385811999,
-0.0364348441,
0.0138550615,
-0.0332288183,
-0.0504616462,
-0.0024967124,
0.0236580577,
0.0660673603,
0.035063535,
0.0087828198,
-0.0591695234,
0.0181175638,
-0.0658968389,
0.0792330056,
0.0099811796,
0.0004670117,
0.0039916802,
-0.0642906129,
-0.0172889046,
0.0005887641,
0.0416343547,
0.0227587428,
-0.015144676,
0.0011144807,
0.0116863139,
-0.0495372266,
0.0228407253,
-0.0192105286,
-0.0097407484,
0.0239222888,
-0.0010695662,
0.0132266032,
0.0048537315,
-0.0404815637,
-0.0560954697,
-0.0554503128,
-0.0121643292,
-0.0336743481,
0.0204696227,
0.0091596041,
-0.0147594381,
-0.0435009599,
0.0525304489,
2.672447606e-34,
-0.0298465397,
-0.0356343873,
-0.0268574245,
0.0375882722,
0.0595514104,
-0.0098800259,
0.0191800389,
0.0333530679,
-0.006989622,
-0.0428536162,
-0.0333793275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18219v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18219v1 | A Closer Look into Mixture-of-Experts in Large Language Models | 2024-06-26T10:07:57 | 2024-06-26T10:07:57 | Ka Man Lo, Zeyu Huang, Zihan Qiu, Zili Wang, Jie Fu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Mixture-of-experts (MoE) is gaining increasing attention due to its unique
properties and remarkable performance, especially for language tasks. By
sparsely activating a subset of parameters for each token, MoE architecture
could increase the model size without sacrificing computational efficiency,
achieving a better trade-off between performance and training costs. However,
the underlying mechanism of MoE still lacks further exploration, and its
modularization degree remains questionable. In this paper, we make an initial
attempt to understand the inner workings of MoE-based large language models.
Concretely, we comprehensively study the parametric and behavioral features of
three recent MoE-based models and reveal some intriguing observations,
including (1) Neurons act like fine-grained experts. (2) The router of MoE
usually selects experts with larger output norms. (3) The expert diversity
increases as the layer increases, while the last layer is an outlier. Based on
the observations, we also provide suggestions for a broad spectrum of MoE
practitioners, such as router design and expert allocation. We hope this work
could shed light on future research on the MoE framework and other modular
architectures. Code is available at
https://github.com/kamanphoebe/Look-into-MoEs. | A Closer Look into Mixture-of-Experts in Large Language Models: Mixture-of-experts (MoE) is gaining increasing attention due to its unique
properties and remarkable performance, especially for language tasks. By
sparsely activating a subset of parameters for each token, MoE architecture
could increase the model size without sacrificing computational efficiency,
achieving a better trade-off between performance and training costs. However,
the underlying mechanism of MoE still lacks further exploration, and its
modularization degree remains questionable. In this paper, we make an initial
attempt to understand the inner workings of MoE-based large language models.
Concretely, we comprehensively study the parametric and behavioral features of
three recent MoE-based models and reveal some intriguing observations,
including (1) Neurons act like fine-grained experts. (2) The router of MoE
usually selects experts with larger output norms. (3) The expert diversity
increases as the layer increases, while the last layer is an outlier. Based on
the observations, we also provide suggestions for a broad spectrum of MoE
practitioners, such as router design and expert allocation. We hope this work
could shed light on future research on the MoE framework and other modular
architectures. Code is available at
https://github.com/kamanphoebe/Look-into-MoEs. | [
0.0724910796,
0.0707233921,
0.001186475,
0.0371967517,
-0.0287535023,
-0.0045648101,
0.0428110436,
-0.0128656449,
-0.0382816195,
-0.011674582,
-0.058836475,
-0.0352468938,
-0.0001394138,
0.0149993198,
0.042634856,
-0.034138009,
0.0143964794,
-0.0553087369,
0.0059464467,
-0.0276063811,
0.0025942978,
0.0013505116,
-0.0082583176,
0.06474033,
-0.0023010944,
0.037165083,
0.0091933981,
-0.0258957837,
-0.0086369384,
0.0293198023,
0.0042146966,
0.0652513131,
0.0347899608,
0.0523170978,
0.0000018764,
0.0001725784,
0.0169847328,
0.0116029698,
-0.0173587855,
0.0061900271,
0.0187347457,
0.0012073237,
-0.0063832388,
-0.0002364398,
0.0019093005,
-0.0330138803,
0.066116266,
0.0478373058,
0.0032192471,
0.1218123138,
0.0106221847,
-0.0215120334,
0.0745067969,
-0.0410430618,
0.0098006651,
-0.0171443783,
0.0196032524,
-0.0123399254,
0.0014224657,
0.0229475349,
-0.0290429238,
0.0122420862,
0.024726538,
0.0391888618,
0.0418821871,
0.0530247465,
0.0495079793,
-0.0301005114,
-0.0128246518,
0.0388276204,
-0.0620806515,
-0.004172944,
0.0022592272,
-0.0008354703,
-0.0163502973,
0.0247431044,
-0.0402392931,
0.0207652412,
0.0089453831,
0.0213018712,
0.0186035838,
0.0237035248,
0.0550905578,
0.0235413667,
-0.0731767789,
0.0304449983,
0.0216994118,
0.0000352515,
-0.0191665702,
-0.0147869317,
-0.0316704288,
-0.046590887,
0.0230133086,
0.0283045135,
-0.0169646256,
-0.0055135284,
-0.0234876722,
-0.0255438648,
-0.0143008595,
-0.0016184911,
0.025833888,
0.0423097201,
0.0092461724,
0.0614691265,
-0.0298163388,
0.0218972713,
-0.0363719836,
0.0278811604,
-0.0336233601,
-0.0194963962,
-0.0518583357,
-0.0063337055,
-0.0180710517,
0.0311845131,
0.0057533006,
-0.0391438417,
-0.0298693273,
-0.0028162245,
-0.0109725017,
-0.0013332341,
0.0207427591,
0.0029873995,
-0.0357054621,
-0.0420633443,
-0.0219625607,
0.03620122,
-0.0488620028,
0.0287667532,
0.0371371172,
-0.0383733287,
0.0114895608,
0.0422231443,
-0.0179173443,
-0.020545641,
0.0257316306,
0.0516900085,
-0.0437022448,
-0.0375417098,
0.0018290586,
0.0166952796,
-0.0339639485,
-0.0810819268,
0.0161600616,
-0.0943888426,
0.0635831431,
0.0091700898,
0.0278533194,
-0.0450906791,
-0.0090043172,
-0.0145953968,
-0.054360453,
0.025509024,
-0.0332121961,
0.0109855849,
0.0164571032,
0.0135231121,
-0.0475400724,
0.0574990883,
0.0182959847,
0.0234940015,
-0.001581579,
-0.0032531221,
0.0189942829,
-0.0030823371,
-0.0129321143,
-0.0112082809,
-0.0195700135,
-0.0236191712,
-0.0220152941,
0.0199005455,
0.0436237678,
0.0768005475,
-0.070723772,
-0.0201426595,
0.0554333553,
0.0328904241,
0.0278342757,
0.0647105053,
0.0616196543,
-0.0284110941,
0.0326719694,
0.0358339623,
-0.0424523987,
0.0130981477,
-0.0335933156,
-0.0088953432,
0.0289445389,
0.0684608668,
-0.0577378087,
-0.0316011794,
0.0202828944,
-0.0066470113,
-0.0495672449,
0.0190322939,
0.0744363964,
-0.0339422934,
0.0091268485,
0.0035962642,
0.039833691,
-0.0037497703,
0.021280231,
-0.0795962363,
0.0285691693,
0.059210062,
0.0237214528,
-0.0319580398,
-0.0088962298,
-0.0021762967,
-0.0348458812,
-0.0100685116,
0.0316830538,
0.0124039194,
0.0117051844,
-0.0784050301,
-0.0102583775,
-0.0281008296,
0.0352361761,
0.0397626162,
0.021535363,
-0.0008387326,
0.0188775696,
-0.0254959892,
-0.0080929743,
0.0215484649,
-0.0260765851,
0.020275984,
0.0112793455,
0.0056096627,
0.0293406844,
0.0004542638,
-0.0412266031,
0.0389227755,
0.0003836788,
-0.0462265611,
-0.0184658393,
-0.024109818,
-0.0770139918,
-0.0163503308,
0.0429417267,
-0.0100706778,
0.0135163506,
-0.0195008311,
-0.0125198485,
-0.0576494709,
0.0237965547,
-0.0338846594,
0.0339701846,
-0.0458865091,
-0.0150207793,
0.0157156866,
0.0241521075,
-0.0195953529,
0.0772003233,
-0.0294455495,
-0.008856752,
0.015909465,
0.0149640292,
-0.008594485,
-0.0098710069,
-0.0300508291,
-0.0092633488,
0.0087795639,
0.0580697283,
0.0092366626,
-0.0214694291,
0.0037321339,
-0.1169217899,
-0.1096547544,
0.0166191161,
-0.0441635028,
-0.0174502153,
0.0007602156,
-0.0022870174,
0.0007319707,
0.0336471759,
-0.0154118622,
0.0165741798,
-0.0058038863,
0.0171843823,
-0.0203088764,
0.0204851534,
-0.0266943537,
-0.03238298,
-0.0722451657,
-0.0035495139,
0.0602561906,
-0.0462462753,
-0.0180714447,
-0.0410131067,
-0.0189962368,
-0.0415844843,
0.020071201,
-0.033734601,
-0.0194599163,
0.0061281468,
-0.0653625429,
0.0941839516,
0.0604634807,
-0.0029528488,
0.0508425497,
0.0527949706,
-0.0094332127,
-0.0115225697,
0.0209559258,
-0.0214404259,
0.0317161418,
-0.0581217594,
-0.0024484347,
-0.0325507559,
0.0634319857,
0.0025866635,
-0.0467069633,
-0.0518357307,
0.00376103,
-0.0017004956,
-0.0452623256,
-0.0036281545,
-0.0010141219,
0.016319247,
0.0362954922,
-0.0260656774,
-0.0315446593,
0.0451357961,
-0.0060334667,
0.0006102319,
-0.0055438941,
-0.0534651428,
-0.0390205644,
0.014695758,
0.0310133453,
0.0330935605,
-0.0356671028,
-0.0061654337,
-0.0465214103,
0.0082490463,
-0.0059771198,
-0.0076155672,
0.0276376437,
-0.018592149,
0.0148351872,
0.0033370042,
-0.0329266936,
0.0200199261,
-0.0161875561,
-0.0442538895,
0.0586738586,
0.0489877686,
-0.0459882431,
-0.0491650663,
0.0277492572,
0.0258288607,
0.0546032824,
-0.0407075509,
0.0168616343,
-0.037880525,
0.0367918722,
0.017300589,
0.014862204,
0.0323276632,
-0.0666266158,
0.0153698325,
0.0145125603,
0.0503667966,
-0.0321364813,
-0.0538637191,
0.0051778383,
0.0060927751,
0.00006918,
-0.0320202298,
0.0183418449,
0.0558816493,
-0.0522280708,
0.007475026,
0.100640133,
-0.0158466697,
-0.0663488284,
-0.0098885158,
0.0421135947,
0.0492384806,
0.0038154777,
0.0377338529,
-0.0164007228,
-0.0114797382,
0.0048110075,
-0.0254326947,
0.0073271948,
-0.0164342746,
0.0118327849,
-0.0755695105,
0.0230283178,
0.0195810143,
-0.047676973,
-0.0437246934,
-0.0145341149,
-0.0147148827,
-0.0263010319,
0.0251932628,
0.0064017042,
0.0052925344,
-0.0156724863,
0.0331858508,
0.0178978425,
-0.0597034208,
0.0210185926,
-0.056551706,
0.083525151,
0.0250211637,
-0.0201226175,
-0.015744498,
-0.0011034256,
0.0208053421,
0.0021535431,
0.0165181886,
0.0043355417,
0.0136001976,
-0.0224730112,
-0.0206911284,
-0.0004240216,
0.0130402138,
0.0026466034,
-0.0015128178,
-0.0288858302,
0.0778639391,
-0.0120545728,
-0.0425935946,
-0.0110007636,
-0.0266617201,
-0.0319197737,
0.0545484014,
0.036098171,
-0.0464132205,
-0.0251031984,
-0.0180356819,
-0.0348423123,
0.0061603882,
0.0050278138,
0.0161572658,
0.0246406589,
-0.0850966871,
-0.0156562794,
-0.0116400719,
0.052894637,
0.0642219707,
-0.0043435888,
0.0072907866,
0.0024607438,
-0.0012026121,
0.008256319,
0.0203679744,
-0.0269190967,
-0.0015558252,
-0.0887361467,
-0.0291861724,
0.0417713113,
-0.0231860597,
-0.0103278989,
-0.0343092829,
-0.095527038,
-0.0840057284,
-0.0178320426,
0.0807803199,
0.0209602062,
0.0333884843,
-0.0167313423,
-0.1046627909,
0.0815327391,
0.0323780999,
-0.0536694601,
0.0050170748,
0.0205616616,
-0.0307071637,
-0.001200394,
0.0305653028,
-0.0084849661,
0.0090403929,
0.0497776605,
0.022244839,
-0.0484929569,
0.0168005526,
-0.0028242471,
-0.0450331122,
0.0234909412,
0.0037824877,
0.0336293131,
-0.0545120351,
0.0073723681,
0.0054242574,
-0.000601758,
-0.0514177792,
-0.0130541576,
0.0555561036,
0.0181678329,
0.0175759681,
0.0127613693,
0.0678713918,
0.0318901837,
0.0011275082,
0.0115743596,
-0.0067509282,
-0.018152874,
0.0224257521,
0.005916879,
-0.0228369087,
0.0271935761,
-0.0129763279,
-0.002997404,
-0.0208605025,
0.035820391,
0.0013799081,
-0.0258259811,
-0.0428993367,
0.0191267151,
-0.1023337916,
-0.0774046183,
-0.0025271417,
0.0772177055,
0.0601798631,
-0.0164755322,
0.0299662743,
-0.0126634762,
-0.0158089902,
-0.0367507301,
0.0061872602,
-0.0147873303,
0.0202057362,
0.0140597885,
0.0357679501,
0.0142240217,
-0.0068175234,
0.074303627,
0.0372365266,
0.0096722515,
0.0216337275,
0.0079604108,
-0.031619817,
-0.003011178,
0.019647738,
0.0326565653,
-0.0511513688,
0.0164561607,
-0.021267565,
-0.0466849543,
-0.0344712809,
-0.0034814882,
0.0169883203,
0.0046293531,
0.0191084072,
0.0416986048,
-0.0417285487,
-0.0017983522,
-0.0210837778,
-0.0153410668,
0.0338800661,
-0.0007382539,
-0.0061310134,
-6.566450299e-33,
-0.0046085287,
0.0008195708,
0.0301571544,
-0.0657246336,
0.0185774341,
-0.0184152946,
-0.0045204242,
0.0197437946,
-0.0342639722,
0.0074071735,
-0.0388231091,
0.005235007,
0.0041126329,
0.0321452096,
0.0142169911,
0.0159885027,
0.0655080974,
-0.0142311836,
0.0159171931,
0.0370848961,
0.0045052152,
0.0093747908,
0.0542962514,
-0.0337090269,
-0.039100185,
0.031738434,
-0.0230314136,
0.0333974399,
-0.0378916152,
0.0745810345,
-0.0235145837,
0.0244150385,
0.0320249945,
0.0086031267,
-0.0308885444,
-0.0373799503,
-0.0522450916,
-0.028407827,
0.0063389116,
-0.0304942522,
-0.0113176005,
-0.0399781317,
0.0777825788,
0.003842236,
0.0131299496,
-0.0327021517,
0.0327209495,
-0.0050179497,
-0.0535339378,
-0.0049428828,
-0.0267766174,
0.0396848135,
0.0079855006,
0.0112600308,
0.0188084859,
-0.0360638872,
-0.0155522786,
-0.0059892694,
-0.0033138967,
0.0044096303,
0.0412255116,
0.0819242895,
0.0043546101,
0.0492284633,
0.0091740219,
0.0325650908,
0.0661690086,
0.0252733082,
-0.0316526107,
-0.0165417716,
0.043845769,
0.0624207929,
0.0591674261,
-0.0273909494,
0.0388729945,
0.002757299,
-0.0437245294,
-0.0263719242,
0.0477569774,
0.0406795479,
0.0671771392,
0.0209180713,
-0.0204416011,
-0.0155303515,
-0.0283087622,
-0.0554504953,
-0.0531431101,
-0.0300683081,
0.0001818968,
0.0480898954,
-0.0207639989,
-0.0353206284,
0.0407797471,
-0.0505064242,
-0.0104661798,
0.00563872,
-0.0115023898,
0.0403700434,
0.0084417546,
0.0338977836,
-0.1161245704,
-0.0579544194,
0.0035646807,
-0.0146989953,
-0.0371914171,
0.011346316,
0.0261679683,
0.0307528079,
-0.0524302274,
-0.0210747365,
-0.0318345763,
-0.0002587953,
0.0308944415,
0.0781358406,
0.0330410153,
0.0105118016,
-0.0047556129,
0.0010235051,
-0.0046452088,
-0.0063576791,
-0.0075774421,
-0.0081685642,
0.0077220416,
0.008475991,
-0.0116480049,
0.02095473,
-0.0762035251,
-0.0510250814,
0.0342133157,
-0.0179759096,
-0.0101002492,
0.0166160539,
2.594e-7,
0.0003502619,
0.0398030914,
-0.0122461664,
-0.0265069269,
0.0274798479,
0.0064163501,
-0.0270558968,
0.0082319975,
0.0034469489,
-0.0370843038,
0.0388249606,
0.0676485598,
0.02259106,
0.0116182426,
-0.076542221,
0.0127530228,
-0.0356502905,
0.0353026092,
-0.0427348614,
-0.0189365689,
0.0088479426,
0.1371036321,
0.0277131386,
-0.01143914,
0.0070052012,
-0.0342745408,
0.0583703071,
-0.0246982835,
-0.0057565318,
0.0432410762,
0.0813886598,
0.0288815591,
-0.0075421198,
0.0353326909,
0.0392597765,
0.0605632067,
0.0247668419,
0.0834068805,
-0.0271388106,
0.0059519052,
0.0452902429,
-0.0063681607,
-0.0103707379,
-0.0507871695,
0.0549176373,
-0.0187286306,
-0.0196174532,
-0.0357718989,
0.0130406534,
-0.0173921678,
0.0074855527,
-0.0478493534,
-0.0455265567,
0.014301382,
0.0116538219,
-0.021354951,
0.0093869166,
-0.0757474229,
0.0099748187,
-0.0006192673,
-0.0797348991,
-0.0694376007,
-0.0331698433,
0.0000428687,
0.0704825372,
-0.0250928458,
-0.0136629883,
2.5048065e-34,
0.0614622943,
0.0058537545,
0.0037061118,
0.0185681302,
0.0365827829,
-0.0223699231,
-0.0658717826,
-0.00370358,
0.0059254295,
-0.104552269,
-0.0608532541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18200v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18200v1 | SEED: Accelerating Reasoning Tree Construction via Scheduled Speculative Decoding | 2024-06-26T09:33:41 | 2024-06-26T09:33:41 | Zhenglin Wang, Jialong Wu, Yilong Lai, Congzhi Zhang, Deyu Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate remarkable emergent abilities across
various tasks, yet fall short of complex reasoning and planning tasks. The
tree-search-based reasoning methods address this by surpassing the capabilities
of chain-of-thought prompting, encouraging exploration of intermediate steps.
However, such methods introduce significant inference latency due to the
systematic exploration and evaluation of multiple thought paths. This paper
introduces SeeD, a novel and efficient inference framework to optimize runtime
speed and GPU memory management concurrently. By employing a scheduled
speculative execution, SeeD efficiently handles multiple iterations for the
thought generation and the state evaluation, leveraging a rounds-scheduled
strategy to manage draft model dispatching. Extensive experimental evaluations
on three reasoning datasets demonstrate superior speedup performance of SeeD,
providing a viable path for batched inference in training-free speculative
decoding. | SEED: Accelerating Reasoning Tree Construction via Scheduled Speculative Decoding: Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate remarkable emergent abilities across
various tasks, yet fall short of complex reasoning and planning tasks. The
tree-search-based reasoning methods address this by surpassing the capabilities
of chain-of-thought prompting, encouraging exploration of intermediate steps.
However, such methods introduce significant inference latency due to the
systematic exploration and evaluation of multiple thought paths. This paper
introduces SeeD, a novel and efficient inference framework to optimize runtime
speed and GPU memory management concurrently. By employing a scheduled
speculative execution, SeeD efficiently handles multiple iterations for the
thought generation and the state evaluation, leveraging a rounds-scheduled
strategy to manage draft model dispatching. Extensive experimental evaluations
on three reasoning datasets demonstrate superior speedup performance of SeeD,
providing a viable path for batched inference in training-free speculative
decoding. | [
0.0354654938,
0.0510721244,
-0.0068561719,
0.0225629266,
-0.0503505692,
0.0237316955,
-0.0222291239,
-0.0351965316,
-0.0230378546,
-0.0199615266,
0.022843441,
-0.0732704401,
0.0074073495,
0.0252464078,
-0.0335558541,
-0.0356248803,
0.0295971539,
-0.0753278807,
0.0339827426,
-0.014014639,
-0.0322943702,
0.0381735452,
-0.0252163727,
0.0279686879,
0.0093247602,
-0.042409569,
-0.0601513572,
0.0074368254,
0.0013226286,
-0.0441259891,
-0.0472744964,
0.0332993232,
0.0249079131,
0.0474010594,
0.0000022405,
-0.0308989082,
-0.0207750294,
0.0009304957,
-0.0386648886,
0.0051248963,
0.010631307,
0.0238156449,
-0.0171062574,
0.0276917797,
-0.0274770483,
-0.0232524052,
0.0296349693,
-0.0207456462,
0.0003242138,
0.0187464561,
-0.0078034392,
-0.0330652334,
0.0036381641,
0.0126662925,
0.0078195343,
-0.0496255271,
-0.0000479801,
-0.002532006,
-0.0199477095,
-0.0183278266,
-0.015297248,
0.0234605316,
0.0469563082,
-0.0005803216,
-0.031620618,
0.0382818058,
0.0116266478,
-0.0492098629,
-0.0294609312,
0.0125763947,
-0.0262373146,
-0.0448086187,
-0.0174341463,
-0.0030635609,
-0.0436976328,
-0.0598191209,
-0.0087078512,
0.0909534097,
-0.0708337203,
0.0112195611,
0.110860981,
0.00549964,
0.0239949785,
0.0151780434,
-0.0535040759,
0.0977391601,
0.030429557,
-0.0214071181,
-0.0100816078,
0.0106749581,
-0.0067158793,
-0.072011672,
0.0244959481,
0.0396343321,
-0.056662105,
0.0385169648,
-0.0430814475,
-0.024428241,
-0.0167084783,
-0.000915183,
0.0286746472,
0.0958460793,
0.0206337906,
0.0230981018,
-0.025922846,
-0.0076648281,
-0.0154085169,
0.0146244606,
-0.043661464,
0.0138744805,
-0.0306143258,
-0.0076129041,
-0.0530067794,
0.0305239707,
-0.0593413673,
-0.0167388003,
-0.0084401807,
0.0397028029,
0.0132408142,
-0.0036282197,
0.0418676697,
0.0133456271,
-0.0085140895,
0.0005996519,
-0.0257341992,
-0.0101209283,
-0.0358718373,
0.0035934127,
0.0117494296,
-0.0426542424,
-0.0149098188,
0.0031718214,
-0.0117886113,
-0.0021192455,
0.001883234,
0.0299605764,
-0.0491030924,
-0.0163509995,
-0.0552745089,
-0.0334919803,
0.0266374089,
-0.0731214732,
0.0096339211,
-0.0444496833,
0.0243118331,
0.012381237,
-0.0094335023,
0.02951416,
0.0105472822,
0.0320729092,
-0.0002076197,
0.050593745,
-0.0392726474,
0.0028295009,
0.0102434112,
0.0147782816,
0.0182496458,
0.0917361975,
0.0415563658,
0.0450843796,
-0.0163252745,
0.0228268746,
-0.0144644259,
0.038110707,
0.008691798,
-0.0306310132,
0.0211167149,
0.0211484395,
-0.0384862274,
0.0539594479,
0.0066811917,
0.0442332886,
-0.0298840143,
0.0209482908,
0.0284357872,
0.060782034,
-0.0370263867,
0.0330939777,
0.0719763562,
0.0008552099,
-0.0130227804,
-0.019096626,
-0.025188867,
0.018920077,
-0.0494221374,
0.0250493195,
-0.0078576915,
0.0499410294,
0.0055129803,
-0.0033142304,
-0.0106402747,
0.0284087695,
0.017837096,
0.026598841,
0.0620571747,
0.0193004217,
-0.0596191846,
0.0324816853,
0.0043548523,
-0.0078580258,
-0.0695226416,
-0.0531733707,
0.030025389,
0.0810852423,
0.0400401056,
0.0164783765,
-0.0428964943,
0.0290659238,
-0.0145522738,
0.0387309082,
-0.0118863042,
-0.0228706487,
0.0195871964,
-0.0456856154,
-0.0088632405,
0.0422064625,
0.0036362465,
0.0452753603,
0.0443166085,
-0.0041675903,
-0.0262129325,
-0.0069143367,
-0.0253725071,
0.0164855905,
0.0054438235,
-0.014418887,
0.010324914,
0.011000609,
0.0114092398,
-0.0163291339,
0.0064716656,
0.0160092637,
0.0286042541,
-0.0388046056,
-0.0021490154,
0.0174844023,
-0.0653780475,
-0.0510732345,
0.0204747263,
0.0265294891,
-0.0203040522,
-0.0163278244,
-0.0341631509,
-0.0351330191,
0.0224104635,
-0.0271657612,
0.0558167323,
-0.0389909595,
0.0411423929,
-0.0000901402,
-0.028773658,
-0.0053216978,
0.0753427744,
-0.0469374843,
-0.0197561625,
0.0436378606,
0.0368126296,
0.0026087561,
-0.027722111,
0.0187793951,
0.0262601171,
-0.0276333019,
-0.026761882,
-0.0296217371,
0.0064819329,
-0.0291903578,
0.0196712725,
-0.0753120631,
0.0095430696,
-0.0143553512,
0.0272584297,
0.0122744776,
0.0039158161,
-0.013677693,
0.0022760038,
0.0171502326,
0.0483831614,
0.0028481255,
0.0197659433,
-0.0107024787,
-0.0048283166,
-0.0506768972,
0.0022017958,
-0.0090552531,
-0.0333744511,
0.0403551348,
-0.0048478842,
-0.0470557809,
-0.054108344,
0.0533621646,
0.0011473916,
0.0251400471,
-0.0030260619,
-0.0006191307,
0.0308128949,
-0.0341855735,
0.0270547252,
0.045551993,
-0.0133518307,
-0.0100064632,
0.0650354773,
-0.0174514167,
-0.0253543016,
0.0302108023,
0.0027720437,
-0.0107152835,
-0.0191915985,
-0.027097838,
-0.0340552144,
0.0896086246,
0.0088633774,
0.0060713915,
-0.0605571531,
0.0112705128,
-0.0005872685,
-0.0553326532,
-0.0260496158,
-0.0253459439,
0.0049150367,
0.0803743973,
-0.031551417,
-0.0655768737,
0.0798257738,
-0.0494332463,
-0.0064603528,
-0.0461708605,
0.0067058131,
-0.0114878239,
0.0997706428,
-0.0146207195,
0.0118483799,
0.0041659107,
-0.026752973,
0.0013301763,
0.0329558104,
0.0093139708,
-0.0318578966,
0.0170372259,
-0.0558098815,
0.016984025,
-0.0238276199,
-0.0344593301,
-0.043287497,
-0.0034365579,
-0.0678511411,
-0.0129714301,
0.0788614601,
-0.0336109921,
0.0192023236,
0.0144372303,
-0.0366448089,
0.0593957119,
-0.0008424907,
-0.0225282814,
0.0033645416,
-0.0123584941,
0.0357815139,
-0.0212296396,
0.0308662355,
-0.0073864427,
0.0682144165,
0.0601633079,
0.0549190938,
-0.0265594982,
-0.0671282187,
0.0246887058,
0.0229521636,
0.0224658884,
0.0102894502,
0.0413585529,
0.0296248253,
-0.0912641734,
-0.0596366487,
0.0893802494,
0.0451210253,
-0.0514183939,
-0.0033291739,
-0.0365415514,
0.0728680715,
0.0065913028,
0.0550048798,
-0.1082508639,
-0.0398690887,
0.0412216261,
0.0049990108,
-0.0272428412,
-0.0516262539,
-0.0285489932,
-0.109439455,
0.046633359,
-0.0118600596,
0.0075572454,
0.0168147385,
-0.0163130611,
-0.0455981605,
0.0365656018,
-0.0581038892,
0.0357448049,
0.0262741093,
0.0250419863,
0.002826425,
-0.0146738542,
0.0046231928,
0.0557205677,
-0.0012502015,
0.0022488297,
0.0413780734,
0.0044374876,
0.057079874,
-0.0498117916,
-0.0243215486,
-0.0049642278,
0.0090611866,
-0.0632406771,
-0.0052024438,
-0.0228276514,
0.0262883939,
-0.0212018639,
0.0252103116,
-0.0477576405,
-0.039111279,
0.0133975018,
0.1065455377,
-0.0500647351,
-0.0443797559,
-0.0103776371,
-0.0112192547,
0.0327602737,
0.0637418851,
0.000517758,
-0.0205694754,
-0.0545555986,
-0.0546660498,
-0.027665399,
-0.094616808,
-0.0101691848,
-0.0023280096,
0.0723605305,
0.0161649603,
-0.0190362651,
0.0079496745,
0.0578504279,
0.0520259328,
-0.0144459335,
0.0026882438,
0.0073195347,
0.0085480707,
-0.093016386,
-0.0112318862,
-0.0022848747,
0.0137906428,
-0.0115675526,
-0.0148687596,
0.0132057508,
-0.0280852374,
-0.0174722262,
0.0520231761,
-0.1173035875,
-0.0277787335,
-0.0116883619,
0.0355687104,
0.0252025295,
0.0470933206,
-0.0267692246,
0.0009426802,
0.0234661028,
0.003973674,
-0.0191273,
0.0060556377,
0.004456121,
-0.0089865234,
0.0168483518,
0.0370293893,
0.0003916537,
0.019261606,
0.0095801037,
0.0410290621,
0.0139566958,
0.0122431358,
0.0183703396,
0.0255453344,
-0.0006722556,
-0.0472573377,
-0.0259061512,
-0.0094073955,
0.0497105755,
-0.0080041885,
-0.0243640337,
-0.0309587996,
0.0427131988,
0.0242260229,
-0.0208730493,
-0.0095110424,
-0.0439488627,
0.0470012724,
-0.0247314703,
0.0281768981,
-0.0319024138,
0.0504425466,
0.0147349881,
0.0438921414,
-0.0248406995,
-0.0121092228,
0.006374374,
-0.0146776522,
0.0552944206,
-0.0198715236,
0.0592969321,
0.0253549777,
-0.0043987315,
-0.0332452878,
-0.0095930612,
-0.0520333573,
-0.1053349376,
-0.0176499188,
-0.0288847834,
0.0504564643,
0.0294409283,
0.0124825304,
-0.0403488278,
0.0134284412,
0.018908279,
0.0120477621,
0.0013134169,
-0.052534245,
0.0378216654,
0.0223464761,
-0.0148556,
-0.0049811481,
0.022977259,
0.0062275426,
0.0422346443,
0.042474743,
-0.0376212038,
-0.0273940563,
-0.04364888,
-0.0960864723,
0.0354135409,
-0.0148076778,
-0.0039110635,
-0.0430357642,
-0.039536614,
-0.0016297265,
0.0407940596,
0.0041778339,
0.0046844874,
0.0384410284,
0.057135053,
0.0105545688,
-0.0493414328,
0.0009656748,
0.0300683752,
-0.0113806846,
0.0034869448,
-0.0446745865,
-6.585178128e-33,
-0.0040344954,
-0.0302414671,
0.082805112,
-0.0438257344,
-0.0067120343,
-0.0130111808,
-0.0554789603,
0.0001925966,
0.0105496859,
0.0166755114,
-0.0298636071,
0.0314815715,
0.0238643177,
0.0385697074,
0.0308806133,
0.0179636106,
0.0330889374,
-0.018633252,
-0.0136478292,
0.0192237999,
0.0371473134,
0.0394236445,
0.0102135707,
0.0054522911,
-0.0437954925,
0.0215102937,
0.0201267879,
0.0184218287,
-0.0514162146,
0.0189596005,
-0.0354453065,
-0.0055880817,
0.0261261109,
-0.0201585293,
-0.0197029542,
0.0135057587,
-0.0868539587,
-0.0077781328,
0.0403860807,
-0.0073346896,
-0.0723080635,
-0.0028915666,
-0.0474341698,
0.0421574935,
0.0216828827,
-0.0403715931,
-0.0491259247,
-0.0206869654,
-0.005217934,
-0.042979762,
-0.0646290481,
0.0255442876,
0.0247075632,
0.0098345084,
0.0616269074,
-0.0073342593,
-0.025859464,
0.0064259926,
-0.0228351112,
0.0090176212,
-0.0172783677,
0.0234931037,
0.0890944228,
0.019177258,
0.007915535,
0.033869341,
0.0229357183,
-0.0090248939,
-0.0676099136,
0.0481201746,
0.0059861061,
0.0375213027,
-0.0203763545,
0.0022270118,
0.0795102417,
0.0225954261,
-0.0613949932,
-0.0180156995,
0.0321221389,
0.0384374708,
0.0621513017,
0.0161208808,
0.000364728,
-0.0457076095,
-0.0380910747,
-0.0249921344,
-0.0350447036,
-0.0034123294,
0.0445899516,
0.0252676606,
-0.0341814198,
-0.0006657999,
0.0379904993,
-0.0025583175,
0.0378165729,
0.0215727985,
-0.0007055041,
0.0200661402,
-0.0086509455,
0.057158757,
-0.0137130599,
-0.0303428434,
0.0124270907,
-0.0069233142,
0.0233732145,
0.015688803,
-0.0189747233,
0.0088893073,
-0.0502163023,
-0.0073583056,
-0.0684273019,
0.0415291227,
-0.0081782751,
0.0510402992,
0.053562291,
0.0243978184,
0.0056948671,
0.0217514113,
-0.004036393,
0.0474097989,
-0.0326474421,
0.0126713626,
-0.0052415226,
0.0215108339,
0.0017029732,
-0.009495154,
-0.0364712067,
-0.0271274932,
0.0150185637,
-0.0968181267,
-0.0130194267,
0.0801337808,
2.945e-7,
0.0146338353,
0.0481906645,
0.0128548369,
0.0200205334,
0.0273854863,
-0.0108774789,
0.0287253205,
-0.0339842178,
0.0459815413,
-0.0397871286,
0.0042775576,
0.0299819261,
0.0447445288,
0.0401126444,
-0.0883639529,
-0.0402558595,
-0.0294155423,
0.0116255637,
-0.0472562686,
-0.017981831,
0.0272278301,
0.0997704118,
-0.0194462165,
-0.0291214101,
0.0508529991,
0.0097397799,
0.0019833865,
0.0073274686,
0.0182254426,
-0.0109333275,
-0.0162550956,
0.0103566516,
-0.0080748796,
0.0441857241,
-0.0069612483,
0.013445708,
-0.076822117,
0.0344676487,
-0.0108196503,
0.0124373175,
-0.0050403331,
-0.04181014,
-0.005485429,
-0.03594587,
0.0594017208,
-0.0327595659,
-0.0172209702,
0.0076496592,
0.0238983482,
-0.0016151076,
-0.044869259,
0.0102809928,
0.0426220261,
0.0159646887,
0.0128362123,
-0.0262213405,
-0.0061019291,
-0.0783160031,
-0.0139021706,
-0.0037185473,
-0.0493115187,
-0.0398908444,
-0.0587601513,
0.0107925227,
0.0297335777,
-0.0589091256,
-0.0008661965,
3.197913785e-34,
0.0385197252,
0.0241025835,
0.0045110597,
0.0660147071,
0.0241723582,
-0.0009011799,
0.0481540114,
0.0028632646,
0.001340832,
-0.1067744046,
-0.0392374955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18192v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18192v2 | Methodology of Adapting Large English Language Models for Specific Cultural Contexts | 2024-06-26T09:16:08 | 2024-06-27T02:17:19 | Wenjing Zhang, Siqi Xiao, Xuejiao Lei, Ning Wang, Huazheng Zhang, Meijuan An, Bikun Yang, Zhaoxiang Liu, Kai Wang, Shiguo Lian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The rapid growth of large language models(LLMs) has emerged as a prominent
trend in the field of artificial intelligence. However, current
state-of-the-art LLMs are predominantly based on English. They encounter
limitations when directly applied to tasks in specific cultural domains, due to
deficiencies in domain-specific knowledge and misunderstandings caused by
differences in cultural values. To address this challenge, our paper proposes a
rapid adaptation method for large models in specific cultural contexts, which
leverages instruction-tuning based on specific cultural knowledge and safety
values data. Taking Chinese as the specific cultural context and utilizing the
LLaMA3-8B as the experimental English LLM, the evaluation results demonstrate
that the adapted LLM significantly enhances its capabilities in domain-specific
knowledge and adaptability to safety values, while maintaining its original
expertise advantages. | Methodology of Adapting Large English Language Models for Specific Cultural Contexts: The rapid growth of large language models(LLMs) has emerged as a prominent
trend in the field of artificial intelligence. However, current
state-of-the-art LLMs are predominantly based on English. They encounter
limitations when directly applied to tasks in specific cultural domains, due to
deficiencies in domain-specific knowledge and misunderstandings caused by
differences in cultural values. To address this challenge, our paper proposes a
rapid adaptation method for large models in specific cultural contexts, which
leverages instruction-tuning based on specific cultural knowledge and safety
values data. Taking Chinese as the specific cultural context and utilizing the
LLaMA3-8B as the experimental English LLM, the evaluation results demonstrate
that the adapted LLM significantly enhances its capabilities in domain-specific
knowledge and adaptability to safety values, while maintaining its original
expertise advantages. | [
0.0487638041,
0.0087474547,
-0.0345802978,
0.0282128938,
-0.0124724004,
0.0337785892,
0.0202198103,
-0.0312877223,
-0.003225876,
-0.0309516396,
-0.0678492561,
-0.0503319614,
-0.0193364136,
0.0127135087,
0.0156283434,
-0.0427160747,
0.0509420298,
-0.031619519,
0.0098941531,
-0.0128660435,
0.0186944269,
0.0082448311,
-0.0137929143,
0.0329530053,
-0.0002811034,
0.0028183432,
0.0165024288,
0.016283825,
0.0433889143,
-0.0372249223,
0.0344975889,
0.0168953631,
0.0346769579,
-0.0060303151,
0.0000021322,
-0.0609787479,
0.0091973217,
-0.0431702696,
0.0089099156,
0.0286390185,
0.0781809613,
-0.0123516135,
-0.052639097,
0.031543538,
-0.0454740338,
0.0114461193,
0.034950234,
0.0416009091,
0.0333890431,
0.0790389851,
0.004593567,
-0.0221739989,
-0.0046797963,
0.0083180936,
-0.0352037251,
-0.0540587232,
0.0343836471,
0.0661805943,
0.0448131561,
-0.0034323784,
-0.0549866818,
0.0267533548,
0.0286667496,
-0.0008695302,
-0.044341363,
-0.002199227,
-0.0269653294,
0.0133614466,
-0.0280701444,
0.0514919199,
-0.0141401561,
-0.006948472,
-0.0152603723,
-0.0143973511,
-0.0175625402,
-0.0296152439,
-0.034656167,
0.0295449141,
0.0087857787,
0.0080309594,
0.0559135489,
-0.0202075504,
0.0264368784,
0.0395957641,
0.0009416438,
0.0810397938,
-0.0085476525,
-0.0185244195,
-0.0010181367,
-0.0243777782,
0.0019653912,
-0.014359518,
0.0432407334,
0.0602970459,
-0.0118093854,
0.0429399051,
-0.0151819922,
-0.0076061343,
0.0132991197,
-0.0910767466,
0.0455760434,
0.0529214703,
-0.014925668,
0.0124472557,
-0.0091837477,
0.0518774018,
0.0029050962,
0.0296839327,
-0.0745236054,
-0.0000644847,
-0.0577004403,
0.0037012433,
-0.0190687291,
-0.0035186002,
-0.0105459457,
-0.0032507142,
-0.0768575817,
0.0349416621,
-0.0041078422,
-0.0130852945,
0.0058219763,
-0.0216419324,
-0.0365859233,
-0.0078554861,
-0.0124538131,
0.0379704088,
-0.0373089649,
0.0331460014,
-0.0329463929,
-0.0402690247,
0.0410259888,
0.0184523929,
-0.0309193507,
-0.0164412856,
0.0162522923,
0.0650546923,
-0.0282071158,
0.0033224893,
-0.0861039385,
0.0455435216,
-0.014333792,
-0.0308556426,
0.0333670676,
-0.0438063592,
0.0104431361,
-0.0207705405,
0.015987305,
-0.0569925383,
0.0103416182,
0.0075630588,
-0.0079086451,
0.0221251547,
0.00443738,
0.0251221433,
0.0468783863,
0.0137918349,
-0.0052380334,
0.1035771891,
0.0613263585,
0.019212354,
0.0411142223,
-0.0271538608,
-0.0404208302,
0.0595891364,
-0.0229348801,
0.0128753334,
-0.0512504652,
-0.0063605625,
-0.0152473236,
-0.0033086862,
0.0205029361,
0.0340211391,
0.0246271752,
0.0307466164,
0.0412264168,
0.027037384,
-0.0038991245,
0.0300440788,
0.0622730516,
0.0031716966,
0.0157425776,
-0.014225808,
-0.0561782308,
-0.0024339776,
-0.0610647798,
-0.0063690511,
-0.0577053763,
0.0633400157,
-0.0306732375,
-0.0492521822,
-0.0268236417,
-0.0059381509,
0.0418767147,
0.0169831477,
0.0302826818,
-0.0182723477,
0.017140381,
0.0239119455,
0.0356340222,
-0.0138929198,
-0.0147911841,
-0.0491078384,
-0.007382819,
0.1109391376,
0.0050495523,
-0.0131710554,
-0.0602946915,
0.0250787772,
0.0201354623,
0.0304683913,
0.0570656359,
-0.0260517839,
-0.0120552527,
-0.0576261654,
-0.0208290089,
0.022657223,
-0.0032596961,
0.0178455859,
0.0388595089,
0.032304883,
0.0052954238,
-0.0009565879,
-0.0767398104,
0.0125735644,
-0.0777225271,
-0.0267919637,
-0.0204992965,
0.0109266071,
0.0281926431,
0.0276580621,
-0.0024690835,
-0.0161018763,
-0.0040893294,
-0.0380028524,
-0.0079012383,
0.0259995591,
-0.0567830727,
0.0315971896,
0.0477368571,
-0.0237539187,
-0.0076652449,
0.0244383495,
-0.0433044359,
-0.0279194582,
-0.0109773241,
-0.0299508441,
-0.001528025,
-0.0352509692,
0.0313100964,
-0.0493255332,
0.0135229453,
-0.0300258733,
0.0569858886,
-0.0255944934,
-0.0442756154,
-0.0228738319,
0.0272636805,
0.0012434336,
-0.0246515516,
-0.0546169542,
0.0057818014,
0.00375978,
0.0543392822,
0.0147850048,
0.0695604458,
-0.0431937315,
-0.0155624459,
-0.0639499649,
-0.0109553616,
-0.0181019846,
0.0236512646,
0.0171548985,
-0.0234623272,
-0.0455578342,
-0.0085522216,
-0.0563830696,
0.032370314,
-0.0208649784,
0.0251712371,
0.0038202198,
0.00052062,
-0.0439556353,
0.0066062114,
-0.0090074074,
-0.0231021848,
-0.0076596765,
-0.0151863648,
-0.051868286,
-0.0723800212,
0.0459602773,
-0.0339309312,
0.015918931,
-0.0002433568,
-0.0674757287,
0.0004683269,
0.0288231634,
0.0844090432,
0.0631441176,
-0.0093738567,
0.0079704085,
0.0762941316,
-0.0019295488,
-0.0188425742,
0.0120435031,
0.018354468,
-0.0296311118,
-0.032862056,
-0.0651755705,
-0.0227508415,
0.0581576005,
-0.0319261365,
-0.0064017614,
-0.0504191741,
-0.0068828692,
-0.0632595569,
-0.0492153354,
-0.0034639298,
-0.0190110933,
-0.012364191,
0.033892747,
-0.0181016345,
-0.0241140816,
0.061023891,
0.0108571863,
0.0342975855,
-0.0649540275,
-0.0278323945,
-0.0228970516,
0.0328441896,
-0.0338361859,
0.0492187925,
-0.0047916248,
-0.0219256468,
-0.041336149,
-0.0031264294,
-0.0072524641,
-0.0525772721,
0.0493879095,
-0.0703990906,
-0.021202758,
-0.0119926063,
-0.0259003155,
-0.0344000645,
0.0239338223,
-0.0280693006,
0.043884825,
0.0048898882,
0.0041604633,
-0.0275759865,
0.0194030404,
0.0372314006,
0.003650472,
-0.013237345,
0.0400327146,
0.0027092621,
-0.0586349629,
0.0518338196,
0.0207278132,
0.016531935,
-0.032385271,
0.062439695,
0.0274013095,
0.0565815568,
-0.0444189645,
-0.0243367925,
0.031912636,
0.0252537448,
-0.026320355,
-0.013514067,
0.0562880002,
0.0587222464,
-0.0720513985,
0.0064208158,
0.0747082829,
0.0078613376,
-0.0201366823,
0.026932558,
-0.0500389561,
-0.0175531674,
0.0217642263,
0.0565866828,
-0.0622702427,
0.0029797058,
-0.0084910644,
0.0186736546,
-0.0050214208,
0.0031243868,
0.0131736137,
-0.1045574099,
0.0246228538,
0.0146045899,
-0.0618755408,
-0.0407117382,
-0.0019920326,
-0.0084319022,
0.0010303597,
0.0741092563,
-0.0141348131,
-0.0372320972,
-0.0549631268,
0.0211615749,
-0.0259274058,
-0.0966583043,
0.0386305228,
-0.0279727578,
0.075013414,
0.0481382199,
-0.0001298261,
-0.0251073223,
-0.0187988263,
0.0031345144,
0.0187266786,
0.0203922782,
-0.0214594062,
-0.0172129516,
-0.0003469748,
0.000159039,
0.0070807631,
-0.0107830772,
0.0058250753,
-0.0105057275,
0.0437816046,
0.0665932149,
-0.0177125186,
-0.0068546631,
-0.0320287719,
0.0126926759,
0.004264602,
0.0517006442,
0.0166680608,
-0.0786892995,
0.0100317607,
-0.0266698431,
-0.0695347711,
-0.0358348116,
-0.0553495735,
0.0642425567,
-0.083173275,
-0.0406853855,
-0.0578732006,
-0.035714101,
0.0113347033,
-0.0050284979,
0.0710735321,
-0.0186557304,
0.0369333476,
0.0080758324,
-0.0431448407,
0.0099849608,
-0.0287234224,
0.0310661774,
-0.0500836,
0.0078976676,
0.0512215681,
-0.0394024588,
0.0208498389,
0.0096998662,
-0.0038733438,
-0.0439675413,
0.0411341712,
0.0584176816,
0.0068575479,
0.0032111497,
-0.0066818749,
-0.0603301935,
0.0528406948,
-0.0202168338,
0.0046319063,
0.0093300119,
0.0157484543,
0.0062599871,
-0.0021767637,
0.0174902994,
-0.0586686581,
0.059056405,
0.0415395498,
0.0553784482,
-0.049902942,
-0.013046233,
-0.0029519626,
0.0487825945,
-0.0317664221,
-0.0270064939,
-0.0132347178,
-0.0351211764,
0.0389044918,
-0.0216458291,
-0.0230610538,
-0.0012321114,
-0.0199350286,
0.0219529141,
-0.0201366302,
0.012718237,
0.005723068,
0.0104208654,
-0.0133932959,
-0.0256792251,
0.0767017081,
0.0032754764,
0.0894435123,
-0.003703211,
0.0349517576,
-0.0383348987,
0.0140871499,
0.0262266994,
0.031068692,
0.0103082489,
0.0946612954,
-0.0165064,
-0.0079647787,
-0.0207259227,
0.0571096428,
-0.0139219873,
-0.0234078728,
-0.0225644838,
0.0207598358,
0.0606912076,
-0.0092642186,
0.050260298,
-0.0234945994,
0.0005798966,
-0.0325057395,
-0.0029436392,
0.0138927773,
-0.0429599024,
0.0342142917,
0.0135930981,
0.0096748257,
-0.0326529741,
0.0429910421,
0.000650794,
0.0443672948,
0.0196228269,
-0.0119463364,
-0.024465343,
-0.0303708538,
0.0718319416,
-0.0224544331,
-0.062914975,
-0.0083129704,
-0.0640112236,
-0.0608413629,
-0.0163717642,
0.0093599577,
-0.0077510416,
-0.0149569558,
0.0092504676,
0.0496008061,
-0.0021295666,
-0.0560503006,
-0.0270734485,
-0.0274016578,
-0.0151280295,
-0.000154355,
0.0377516635,
-6.414639612e-33,
-0.0284872856,
-0.006168223,
0.0429061428,
-0.0234261528,
-0.0112560168,
-0.0128507018,
-0.002580499,
0.00551986,
-0.0392948911,
-0.0009517104,
-0.0207312517,
0.0103406832,
0.0139303887,
-0.003596816,
0.0183356386,
0.0238835644,
0.0079894876,
-0.0004134249,
0.0065630581,
0.0070646838,
0.0269416012,
0.0321347266,
0.0807713345,
-0.0795512944,
0.0081695141,
0.0236781538,
-0.0031960765,
0.0162178893,
0.0004766023,
0.0841975808,
-0.0045720115,
0.0485846065,
0.0346243978,
-0.0380303152,
-0.0219493788,
-0.0035978835,
-0.0609819479,
-0.0302074943,
0.0384737179,
0.028893942,
0.0289346501,
-0.0908687338,
0.0463808589,
-0.0244954675,
-0.0316511169,
0.0091175614,
0.0298009347,
-0.0658900514,
0.018114537,
-0.011832267,
-0.0844318867,
0.0182058029,
0.0112034166,
0.0182156842,
0.0013665447,
0.0321502388,
-0.0288726818,
-0.0458606519,
-0.0179111492,
0.0191883557,
0.047454007,
0.0193897523,
0.0935082585,
0.0292791408,
-0.0232335348,
0.0222309958,
-0.0074261082,
0.0224952232,
0.002612181,
-0.0550089404,
0.0416679084,
0.0535464212,
0.0096658878,
0.0622687228,
-0.0036391094,
-0.0209447779,
-0.1057281122,
0.0383655876,
0.0330999941,
0.0677592605,
0.0316358209,
-0.0013552904,
-0.0663186759,
-0.0181820188,
0.0030304089,
0.064907752,
-0.0155279981,
-0.0610999092,
0.0430338047,
-0.0171390548,
-0.0516111255,
-0.0161229596,
0.0089359377,
-0.0527172387,
0.02240007,
-0.0002816204,
0.0155666489,
-0.0085501475,
-0.0059902738,
0.0377584025,
-0.066296801,
-0.0651021898,
-0.0197187997,
-0.0173266195,
0.00898109,
0.0031378618,
0.0235028211,
0.0513819121,
-0.0477464832,
0.009346419,
-0.0093044285,
-0.0180272721,
0.0437303632,
0.0034903367,
0.0254659113,
-0.0001370406,
-0.0056950073,
-0.0025554553,
0.0638495684,
-0.0384979323,
-0.0192713886,
-0.0592028983,
-0.026556829,
0.0413481295,
-0.0427856259,
0.0255056359,
-0.0342699327,
0.0433257334,
0.0035787013,
-0.0568870679,
-0.0231776237,
0.0155721493,
2.829e-7,
0.0381940417,
0.0703518316,
-0.0189448688,
0.0469423085,
-0.0021074843,
-0.0066562556,
-0.0380369499,
0.0250387266,
0.0094071394,
0.0352203958,
0.0457617491,
0.0553602688,
0.0526965037,
0.0465505868,
-0.0640946254,
-0.0260886643,
-0.0178987943,
0.0411097333,
-0.0571559705,
0.0344644263,
0.0259469431,
0.0764719248,
-0.0232370365,
-0.0211126227,
-0.0397134721,
-0.0364174917,
0.0144396704,
-0.0513212681,
-0.0001815424,
0.0438352525,
0.0116404081,
0.0542072095,
-0.0136164781,
0.0274689384,
0.0135881575,
0.0120457504,
0.0137170032,
0.1045833677,
-0.0156542938,
0.0080911219,
0.0336046703,
0.0013162086,
-0.0067879618,
-0.0647002235,
0.0401264951,
-0.0160223953,
-0.020920163,
0.0134227788,
0.0026966401,
-0.0046159001,
-0.0024119129,
-0.0410446376,
0.0060704681,
0.0013482054,
0.0261869002,
-0.0062749269,
-0.0396943465,
-0.02031748,
-0.0059783435,
0.0114874523,
0.0241224039,
-0.0720782727,
-0.0233936626,
-0.0064000832,
-0.0459658876,
-0.0453471988,
0.0292004067,
2.096678305e-34,
0.0067808586,
-0.0275115464,
-0.0094441753,
0.0194263421,
0.0335492864,
0.0182070564,
-0.0037183645,
0.0255726185,
-0.0029979688,
-0.0652800128,
-0.0221727248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18187v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18187v1 | Selective Prompting Tuning for Personalized Conversations with LLMs | 2024-06-26T09:03:52 | 2024-06-26T09:03:52 | Qiushi Huang, Xubo Liu, Tom Ko, Bo Wu, Wenwu Wang, Yu Zhang, Lilian Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In conversational AI, personalizing dialogues with persona profiles and
contextual understanding is essential. Despite large language models' (LLMs)
improved response coherence, effective persona integration remains a challenge.
In this work, we first study two common approaches for personalizing LLMs:
textual prompting and direct fine-tuning. We observed that textual prompting
often struggles to yield responses that are similar to the ground truths in
datasets, while direct fine-tuning tends to produce repetitive or overly
generic replies. To alleviate those issues, we propose \textbf{S}elective
\textbf{P}rompt \textbf{T}uning (SPT), which softly prompts LLMs for
personalized conversations in a selective way. Concretely, SPT initializes a
set of soft prompts and uses a trainable dense retriever to adaptively select
suitable soft prompts for LLMs according to different input contexts, where the
prompt retriever is dynamically updated through feedback from the LLMs.
Additionally, we propose context-prompt contrastive learning and prompt fusion
learning to encourage the SPT to enhance the diversity of personalized
conversations. Experiments on the CONVAI2 dataset demonstrate that SPT
significantly enhances response diversity by up to 90\%, along with
improvements in other critical performance indicators. Those results highlight
the efficacy of SPT in fostering engaging and personalized dialogue generation.
The SPT model code (https://github.com/hqsiswiliam/SPT) is publicly available
for further exploration. | Selective Prompting Tuning for Personalized Conversations with LLMs: In conversational AI, personalizing dialogues with persona profiles and
contextual understanding is essential. Despite large language models' (LLMs)
improved response coherence, effective persona integration remains a challenge.
In this work, we first study two common approaches for personalizing LLMs:
textual prompting and direct fine-tuning. We observed that textual prompting
often struggles to yield responses that are similar to the ground truths in
datasets, while direct fine-tuning tends to produce repetitive or overly
generic replies. To alleviate those issues, we propose \textbf{S}elective
\textbf{P}rompt \textbf{T}uning (SPT), which softly prompts LLMs for
personalized conversations in a selective way. Concretely, SPT initializes a
set of soft prompts and uses a trainable dense retriever to adaptively select
suitable soft prompts for LLMs according to different input contexts, where the
prompt retriever is dynamically updated through feedback from the LLMs.
Additionally, we propose context-prompt contrastive learning and prompt fusion
learning to encourage the SPT to enhance the diversity of personalized
conversations. Experiments on the CONVAI2 dataset demonstrate that SPT
significantly enhances response diversity by up to 90\%, along with
improvements in other critical performance indicators. Those results highlight
the efficacy of SPT in fostering engaging and personalized dialogue generation.
The SPT model code (https://github.com/hqsiswiliam/SPT) is publicly available
for further exploration. | [
0.0500583053,
0.0212575216,
-0.0197476782,
0.0256850552,
-0.0070617311,
-0.0149587849,
0.0064090597,
-0.0366082974,
0.007016093,
-0.0210404005,
-0.0409590825,
-0.0258729644,
0.0129937753,
0.0873595774,
0.0118570244,
-0.0756979138,
0.04371012,
-0.030163398,
0.0405878611,
-0.0094325459,
0.0051304526,
0.0219853725,
-0.0130510796,
0.0523315147,
-0.0100382697,
-0.0338422433,
-0.0446277298,
0.0323464051,
0.0313658901,
-0.0252902824,
0.0628496781,
0.052706603,
0.0271462034,
0.013792349,
0.0000022065,
-0.0532291122,
-0.0101815695,
-0.0321105048,
-0.0095276106,
-0.0231525581,
0.0236588959,
0.0438501872,
0.0110209137,
0.0367833562,
-0.0521212555,
0.0407593735,
0.0289544631,
0.0539678633,
0.0585264266,
0.0658017918,
-0.0085043255,
-0.0072444989,
0.0010318647,
-0.0282937363,
0.0018943422,
-0.0198936705,
-0.0309604313,
-0.0558481254,
0.0130900899,
0.0421003811,
0.0049436362,
0.0136304526,
0.0237842873,
-0.0165231843,
0.0357750654,
0.0532936454,
-0.0241592843,
-0.0287652072,
-0.0323701985,
0.1107803658,
0.06659922,
0.009977608,
-0.0059418799,
-0.0082165524,
0.0319963954,
-0.0457816683,
-0.0391597897,
0.0177369192,
-0.0071054422,
0.0128441509,
-0.0066265385,
0.0434962325,
-0.0134335971,
0.0229400862,
-0.0292637926,
0.0179354902,
0.0080020223,
-0.0236178972,
-0.0083726197,
0.0005029961,
0.0105806608,
-0.0730892196,
-0.0077362163,
0.0384636894,
-0.0970679,
0.0113626691,
-0.0607115552,
0.0110460147,
0.0344091132,
0.0337642394,
0.0183429848,
0.0465203039,
-0.0469133705,
0.0250630639,
0.0130815459,
0.02079257,
0.0179853998,
0.0034015733,
-0.0182960611,
-0.0158916265,
-0.0342378765,
-0.0147574581,
-0.0235759635,
0.0360946842,
-0.0567332879,
-0.025747912,
-0.0209047087,
0.0591608137,
-0.0075931875,
0.0251239538,
-0.0080783395,
0.0282184724,
-0.0498014279,
0.0198452752,
-0.0504636057,
0.0165973343,
-0.0613574386,
-0.0097436821,
0.0515337549,
-0.0731366053,
-0.0256236717,
0.0150834341,
0.0225033369,
-0.0293519385,
-0.0076620714,
0.0123837031,
-0.0451511964,
-0.0662580058,
-0.0263495687,
-0.0264565293,
-0.0482954346,
-0.0647304356,
-0.037561588,
-0.0340869129,
0.0365883708,
0.0071463711,
-0.0112366285,
-0.0274900366,
0.0063412311,
0.0039883573,
-0.0112712262,
0.039162375,
-0.026352169,
0.0046745879,
0.0317539535,
0.0170403235,
-0.0306389406,
0.0411204249,
0.0119506093,
0.0255143214,
0.0187126137,
0.0122685824,
0.0055581755,
-0.0045539234,
0.0141285788,
0.0113692731,
0.0100700203,
0.0187771637,
0.0000517041,
0.0057746326,
0.0458600596,
0.0617157742,
-0.0303562265,
-0.0004793288,
0.0766466483,
0.0250251461,
-0.0189002156,
0.035728097,
0.0491745397,
0.0499352142,
-0.01261207,
0.0305860732,
-0.0377117544,
0.0443282127,
-0.0272572059,
-0.0022658312,
0.0686781108,
0.0422374569,
-0.0417566523,
-0.0514472239,
0.04864401,
-0.0125608779,
0.0243561547,
0.0299761929,
-0.005818862,
0.0156630892,
-0.0608827509,
0.0350901745,
0.0298433173,
-0.0688881651,
-0.0281620044,
-0.0207837597,
0.0635356605,
0.0922965556,
0.033645086,
-0.0111608161,
-0.0440065525,
-0.0218222551,
-0.0076848678,
0.0576416105,
0.05033838,
-0.0085545089,
0.057454925,
-0.0540785603,
-0.0149724102,
-0.0547255278,
-0.0162811819,
0.0519088991,
0.0118821738,
0.0043664202,
0.0115428632,
0.0383250751,
0.0141926324,
0.0029528276,
-0.0466968007,
-0.0136679476,
0.0402872935,
0.0185292047,
-0.0007316939,
0.0477703512,
0.0067164944,
-0.0046670316,
0.026615655,
-0.0151276952,
-0.0009247129,
0.0122920731,
-0.0905090049,
-0.0376503877,
0.0200033095,
0.0080265161,
-0.0332505107,
-0.0153322006,
-0.0124961948,
-0.0558766648,
0.0229741037,
-0.0191031937,
0.0156317856,
-0.0489793606,
0.0103365425,
0.0278109089,
0.0338664353,
-0.0313537531,
0.0600391887,
0.0106158461,
-0.0189703945,
0.065878123,
0.0593684241,
-0.0081430916,
-0.0804612264,
-0.0083691906,
-0.0081757708,
0.0049345461,
-0.0163548738,
0.0243438352,
0.0224538278,
-0.0638365,
-0.0652182326,
-0.1021725833,
0.0123640895,
-0.0170706082,
-0.0339328051,
0.0093451459,
0.0521500185,
-0.0197650529,
-0.0177529734,
-0.0739861503,
-0.0163712595,
0.0396099575,
0.0060334429,
0.0500917286,
0.0186502915,
-0.0024957671,
-0.0498139821,
0.0327345654,
0.0226027649,
0.0135741513,
-0.0305419266,
0.0088386126,
-0.0378922075,
0.024929041,
-0.0386997312,
0.0230397005,
-0.0352472179,
-0.019959854,
0.0390972756,
-0.005676385,
0.076609917,
0.0624817237,
0.0473429151,
0.0291082822,
-0.0023691184,
-0.0134846922,
-0.0644976571,
0.0530871339,
-0.0169225205,
0.0020714437,
-0.0117024602,
-0.0223026369,
0.0316434763,
0.0202882644,
0.0088333022,
0.0110727735,
-0.0869500935,
0.0219460148,
0.0463733859,
-0.0474449061,
0.0080328444,
-0.0015811982,
-0.02369681,
0.0366048217,
-0.0250125062,
-0.0395679586,
0.071566999,
-0.0204084329,
-0.0322715603,
-0.0395332389,
-0.0272199251,
-0.0504547469,
0.0190425366,
-0.0301941764,
0.0128811356,
0.0009955246,
-0.0111212377,
-0.0490704775,
-0.0379461236,
-0.0191461984,
-0.0220277365,
0.0635807142,
-0.0258016624,
-0.0136383632,
0.0092428215,
-0.0699359402,
-0.0794145465,
-0.0456900783,
-0.0044659232,
0.0059674238,
0.0218622331,
-0.0272479076,
-0.0024489795,
-0.0367942899,
0.0248775762,
0.0298744049,
-0.0465125144,
-0.0090081692,
-0.0393127352,
0.0260851383,
0.066756174,
0.0529071167,
0.0171753448,
-0.0364244953,
0.0618714765,
0.0402470045,
-0.0051135868,
-0.0237813164,
-0.0265218485,
0.0059071672,
0.0267640594,
-0.0030839781,
-0.0206391495,
0.0251925681,
0.0850377232,
-0.0088101355,
-0.0452991799,
0.1321919858,
0.0185516961,
-0.0627821237,
-0.0002844902,
-0.0234763548,
0.0662384331,
0.0143876718,
0.0305117313,
-0.0488325506,
-0.0326850079,
-0.0098976344,
0.0312665291,
-0.0125268633,
-0.0194152985,
-0.0326892883,
-0.1260169744,
0.0288827587,
0.0045424146,
-0.0229863357,
-0.0102193337,
0.0005609798,
0.0146646546,
0.0138519667,
0.0352212861,
-0.0094026718,
0.0106590996,
0.0142620113,
0.0008929512,
0.0251083225,
-0.0409686938,
-0.0186053123,
-0.0269637089,
0.0725773424,
0.0696356744,
0.0379082076,
0.0160252098,
-0.0310566779,
0.0019350632,
-0.0118329311,
0.0122010456,
-0.0249929242,
0.0422822051,
-0.0150987795,
0.0127743417,
-0.0186154675,
0.0536441319,
-0.0112794042,
-0.0352090932,
0.029832501,
0.0048944312,
-0.0454616025,
0.0192734096,
-0.0159312822,
0.0319140665,
0.0457454398,
0.0832269415,
0.0431948639,
-0.0550202392,
-0.0064531597,
-0.0274092238,
0.0195046999,
-0.0507918559,
0.0240167268,
-0.0015488139,
0.0059729205,
0.0072355168,
-0.0627736449,
-0.0649094805,
0.0205858201,
0.0052840714,
-0.0062138727,
0.0028584495,
-0.0518256649,
0.0150418431,
0.001844813,
0.0324627534,
-0.0302474871,
0.0223542638,
-0.0777561441,
-0.038087476,
0.0233061742,
-0.098236993,
0.0018005988,
0.0087027894,
-0.0457471758,
-0.0744787604,
-0.0300597399,
0.0563106164,
0.0189220179,
0.080978252,
0.0048497142,
-0.0482300147,
0.0108197713,
0.0333220437,
-0.0174278561,
0.0137282768,
0.0164407417,
0.0732119232,
-0.0080859279,
0.031057125,
-0.031261351,
-0.0040283613,
0.0021264525,
0.0334312916,
-0.0148949809,
-0.1140116826,
0.0054340051,
-0.0050997837,
0.0257018711,
0.0051991898,
0.0104611292,
-0.0175364241,
0.0027526999,
-0.0043093087,
-0.0232351832,
-0.0523472913,
-0.0164111461,
-0.011706871,
0.0006299538,
0.0004132171,
-0.0318611301,
-0.0441411808,
0.0648790598,
-0.0548024252,
-0.016132243,
0.0162117016,
0.0012405777,
0.0067187948,
-0.0148279546,
-0.0172082465,
0.0427991115,
0.0085482914,
0.0302774496,
0.0054723793,
0.0940431654,
0.0173842087,
-0.0269357674,
-0.0057524261,
0.0520829335,
-0.0547463782,
-0.0129825603,
0.0215655323,
0.0469018929,
0.0104316762,
0.0235319864,
0.0455044694,
-0.0130971111,
0.0259081852,
-0.0092713414,
0.0421478562,
0.0325834677,
-0.0267024618,
0.0328197032,
0.0140980249,
-0.03343229,
0.0092331339,
0.0544440895,
-0.0623037964,
0.0052710064,
0.0123750726,
0.0379911102,
-0.0508787706,
-0.0048216041,
0.0265309308,
0.0349849351,
-0.003119101,
0.0181582235,
-0.0363013707,
-0.0163747799,
0.0484138057,
0.0012391109,
-0.0249810331,
-0.020411158,
0.0298788734,
0.0401833542,
-0.0182152484,
-0.0200916957,
-0.0433983542,
0.011700388,
-0.0011975217,
-0.04072069,
-0.038121134,
-6.808745399e-33,
-0.0377963595,
-0.0175918862,
0.0110385669,
-0.0128686614,
-0.0514065847,
-0.0208675805,
-0.064810887,
0.0016460365,
-0.0160650574,
-0.0243012961,
-0.0503801443,
0.0087796757,
0.0060340306,
0.0476805642,
-0.0293796789,
-0.0242816675,
0.0668216497,
0.0375631079,
-0.0252116416,
0.0682731122,
0.0367793739,
0.0317889005,
-0.0095267482,
-0.0646489263,
0.0296968874,
-0.0158154536,
-0.0108725764,
0.0322619453,
0.0063782753,
0.0546110421,
-0.0230959672,
0.0225801151,
0.0059534251,
0.0130769154,
-0.0184736997,
0.0651552379,
-0.0666064546,
-0.0453606844,
0.0195558742,
-0.0168189276,
-0.0525414459,
-0.07301341,
-0.0043459749,
-0.0250335261,
0.0039509661,
0.0081951423,
0.021647647,
-0.011056928,
-0.0168479979,
-0.0044197896,
-0.0379121676,
0.0047106426,
-0.03314263,
-0.0419090278,
-0.0263392124,
0.0522079542,
0.0169461612,
0.049487412,
-0.0349814706,
0.0411389321,
0.0078060841,
-0.0119494023,
0.0130343055,
0.0330922082,
-0.014423768,
0.0430072732,
0.034418121,
0.0338959992,
-0.0119203366,
-0.0336555466,
-0.0069317049,
0.0391134061,
-0.0011268733,
0.0808379874,
-0.0102686426,
-0.0065932022,
-0.0065750368,
0.0596915856,
0.0343309231,
-0.0194625277,
0.0378691517,
0.0057217255,
-0.0327898562,
-0.0124142375,
-0.0227262694,
-0.0198086742,
-0.0306340829,
-0.0181535464,
0.0281460229,
0.0260561276,
-0.0413177684,
-0.0522498451,
0.0231094118,
-0.0191813223,
0.0024372304,
0.0336344503,
-0.0467473567,
-0.0111434683,
0.0025365707,
-0.0042825476,
-0.0467009656,
-0.0319040604,
0.0664693266,
-0.0108544342,
-0.0100496532,
0.0451061055,
0.0100108953,
0.0132275987,
-0.0397389755,
0.0056927563,
-0.0287674405,
0.0828379318,
-0.0423050448,
0.031119192,
-0.0003974744,
0.0118748415,
-0.0346007757,
0.0636715963,
-0.0009663171,
0.0089799045,
-0.0604893304,
-0.0580577031,
0.0047501852,
-0.0015806251,
-0.0368181765,
0.011400261,
-0.0101245502,
0.0085146623,
0.0188071281,
-0.031781666,
-0.0209026448,
-0.002106871,
2.834e-7,
-0.0405111164,
0.0084054507,
0.0131136496,
0.0294291656,
0.0166865755,
0.0587928779,
-0.0036119234,
0.0323891491,
0.0224750005,
-0.0249835402,
0.0108956825,
0.0468584113,
0.0606759638,
-0.0016919656,
-0.0969343483,
-0.0145924268,
-0.0631455779,
-0.007556173,
-0.0526645184,
0.0120944325,
0.090160951,
0.0523529276,
0.0187681876,
-0.0095500527,
0.0185505487,
0.022593474,
0.0423945002,
-0.0326923616,
-0.0184791107,
0.0171892904,
0.0264772009,
-0.0251647998,
0.0076975366,
-0.0099359006,
0.0048029814,
0.0453249738,
-0.0266246237,
0.0624660477,
0.0230229963,
-0.0727293715,
0.020126082,
0.031452205,
0.0135462293,
-0.0399270393,
0.0629778355,
-0.0174879562,
-0.0231803488,
-0.0144820306,
-0.017209379,
-0.0220165569,
0.0188586861,
-0.0297382828,
-0.0436571836,
0.0307767298,
0.0025039273,
-0.0050873547,
-0.0077853939,
-0.0827826709,
-0.0022119544,
-0.0165468547,
-0.0609086193,
-0.0518188663,
-0.0464620702,
0.017195167,
0.0080833407,
-0.0369611755,
0.0303868931,
2.766070451e-34,
0.0193891712,
-0.0062171216,
0.0285308305,
0.0291716214,
0.0203739461,
-0.0043938798,
-0.015324356,
0.0024360137,
0.0584366582,
-0.0754018277,
-0.0323576704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18173v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18173v1 | UIO-LLMs: Unbiased Incremental Optimization for Long-Context LLMs | 2024-06-26T08:44:36 | 2024-06-26T08:44:36 | Wenhao Li, Mingbao Lin, Yunshan Zhong, Shuicheng Yan, Rongrong Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Managing long texts is challenging for large language models (LLMs) due to
limited context window sizes. This study introduces UIO-LLMs, an unbiased
incremental optimization approach for memory-enhanced transformers under
long-context settings. We initially conceptualize the process as a streamlined
encoder-decoder framework where the weights-shared encoder and decoder
respectively encapsulate a context segment into memories and leverage these
memories to predict outputs of the subsequent segment. Subsequently, by
treating our memory-enhanced transformers as fully-connected recurrent neural
networks (RNNs), we refine the training process using the Truncated
Backpropagation Through Time (TBPTT) algorithm, which incorporates innovative
incremental optimization techniques. These techniques not only diminish time
complexity but also address the bias in gradient computation through an
unbiased optimization process. UIO-LLMs successfully handle long context, such
as extending the context window of Llama2-7b-chat from 4K to 100K tokens with
minimal 2% additional parameters, while keeping the inference cost nearly
linear as context length increases. | UIO-LLMs: Unbiased Incremental Optimization for Long-Context LLMs: Managing long texts is challenging for large language models (LLMs) due to
limited context window sizes. This study introduces UIO-LLMs, an unbiased
incremental optimization approach for memory-enhanced transformers under
long-context settings. We initially conceptualize the process as a streamlined
encoder-decoder framework where the weights-shared encoder and decoder
respectively encapsulate a context segment into memories and leverage these
memories to predict outputs of the subsequent segment. Subsequently, by
treating our memory-enhanced transformers as fully-connected recurrent neural
networks (RNNs), we refine the training process using the Truncated
Backpropagation Through Time (TBPTT) algorithm, which incorporates innovative
incremental optimization techniques. These techniques not only diminish time
complexity but also address the bias in gradient computation through an
unbiased optimization process. UIO-LLMs successfully handle long context, such
as extending the context window of Llama2-7b-chat from 4K to 100K tokens with
minimal 2% additional parameters, while keeping the inference cost nearly
linear as context length increases. | [
0.0280601308,
0.0749914795,
0.0205439851,
0.054225862,
0.0015904781,
-0.0155159719,
0.002322193,
0.0034803101,
-0.0405224226,
-0.022989776,
-0.0580163077,
-0.0527066663,
0.0167626832,
-0.0147719001,
0.0002527425,
-0.0213235654,
0.0188757516,
-0.0203882176,
-0.0087832287,
-0.0110421823,
-0.0044388105,
-0.0016040795,
-0.0021093199,
0.0291456617,
0.0051781447,
-0.0247077942,
-0.0068145203,
0.0052919174,
-0.0094455639,
-0.0501038954,
-0.0027868897,
-0.0012244387,
0.0057817223,
0.0346052609,
0.0000021849,
-0.0412902609,
-0.0105900886,
-0.0411196947,
-0.0362410285,
0.0339358747,
0.0560850427,
0.0097251106,
-0.0113727143,
0.0291725397,
-0.008363585,
0.0132523514,
0.0400408953,
0.0379945636,
0.0439443439,
0.0724180788,
0.0067745368,
-0.0332215056,
0.0363008194,
-0.0609954707,
0.0099716112,
-0.029962305,
0.0050140228,
-0.0388131663,
-0.0240674689,
-0.0146326181,
-0.0384721085,
0.0508292727,
0.0550210066,
-0.0009911988,
-0.0070280479,
0.0247415155,
-0.0221316777,
0.0163935982,
-0.0052294726,
0.0640810132,
-0.0260266811,
-0.0120964255,
-0.0176829025,
-0.0081956983,
-0.0310660657,
-0.0762604177,
-0.0369640142,
0.0153080262,
0.0243118778,
0.04226055,
-0.0028713206,
0.0202474017,
0.0543615893,
0.0144341039,
-0.0508401431,
0.050608065,
0.0115731927,
0.0009463216,
-0.0151173864,
-0.0107094571,
0.0017717283,
-0.0246730577,
0.0316150226,
0.0825055838,
-0.0104565416,
0.0352807119,
-0.0073862453,
-0.02882291,
0.0016780739,
-0.0504580662,
-0.0163707975,
0.0663985834,
0.0034982236,
0.0057269051,
-0.0076117045,
0.0217584707,
-0.0493582338,
-0.0133053996,
-0.0380361862,
-0.0210586675,
-0.0356127173,
-0.016486926,
-0.0261367876,
0.0220919922,
-0.036118079,
0.0043390142,
-0.0636032745,
0.0397935845,
0.0384929702,
-0.0416304581,
0.0506002381,
0.0087854797,
-0.0548685826,
-0.0056960266,
-0.0179500114,
0.0397257172,
0.0056948918,
-0.010550024,
-0.0071365205,
-0.0419052914,
-0.0403227769,
0.0283131767,
0.0009843328,
-0.0306249019,
-0.0083138049,
0.092158176,
-0.0172433201,
-0.056373775,
-0.0476643331,
-0.0079313535,
-0.0265982803,
-0.0468407534,
0.0376405045,
-0.0555233769,
0.0389192253,
-0.0336407013,
0.0020961752,
-0.0296851303,
-0.002746552,
0.0270783957,
-0.0051032053,
0.0439404137,
0.0141423522,
-0.0443626605,
0.0543963872,
0.0077354047,
0.0563322082,
0.0643539429,
0.0679046959,
0.0382659249,
-0.0078607025,
0.0235651564,
-0.0152804814,
0.0557196103,
0.0525693521,
0.0009388179,
-0.0599561036,
-0.0182673465,
0.0024959545,
0.0440925434,
0.037989337,
0.0496855155,
-0.0195730235,
-0.0106680449,
0.0428744964,
0.0137216169,
0.0304053817,
0.018674871,
0.0300031696,
-0.0190987382,
-0.0096592726,
-0.0168730356,
-0.0263428427,
0.0457226373,
0.0278710146,
0.0222281758,
0.0380241387,
0.0378687344,
-0.0482902341,
-0.0430318266,
-0.0038797352,
-0.0391185023,
0.0114950268,
0.0036921392,
0.0416408516,
0.0195382796,
-0.0663555712,
0.1119872481,
0.0094628492,
-0.0144983362,
0.0050007189,
-0.0426554419,
-0.0138633279,
0.0537774339,
0.0422042161,
-0.0189080518,
-0.0327582657,
-0.0224090014,
-0.0050526708,
0.0524248108,
-0.0476955585,
0.0076605389,
0.0407069512,
-0.0682916939,
-0.000656967,
0.0207579732,
-0.0064991834,
0.0127068926,
0.0206483975,
0.0483275503,
0.021357175,
-0.0084031299,
0.0325374454,
0.0341835618,
-0.0414541513,
-0.0333585739,
0.0307238493,
0.0062484024,
0.0534466207,
0.0211349037,
0.0336527005,
0.0000675356,
0.0287199728,
-0.064007543,
-0.0281811394,
0.0193073489,
-0.132514149,
-0.074737072,
0.0507188179,
0.0182467811,
0.0177382305,
0.0229415949,
-0.0547191128,
-0.0532808229,
0.0402306691,
-0.0495455116,
0.0828348994,
-0.0345681906,
0.017117206,
0.0064892615,
0.0345018692,
-0.0080557829,
0.0195754822,
-0.0518828928,
-0.0196376238,
0.0211790595,
0.0085388394,
-0.0143933902,
-0.02479163,
-0.0158156678,
0.0573389381,
-0.0119662061,
-0.0114923697,
-0.0025933848,
0.0246143714,
-0.0088440087,
-0.0342069454,
-0.1006442979,
0.0097334217,
-0.0341025107,
0.040416602,
0.0115495753,
0.0351678915,
0.0258483849,
-0.0093791159,
-0.0058671231,
0.001079516,
-0.0152521078,
0.0065583149,
0.0316941775,
0.0114117749,
-0.03486811,
-0.0357423313,
-0.0363957211,
0.0249153115,
0.072160095,
-0.0278904792,
-0.0464623421,
-0.0430680998,
0.0144223124,
0.0013783585,
0.0171790533,
-0.0283927545,
-0.0489260666,
-0.0245963577,
0.0121644642,
0.0577353574,
0.0336653404,
0.0263107866,
0.0150338076,
0.0348326862,
-0.0079633286,
-0.0349650234,
0.0189247727,
-0.0234441515,
-0.0441543236,
-0.0236668922,
0.0036005285,
0.0044499873,
0.0860493481,
-0.0434860066,
0.0104021495,
-0.0383184925,
-0.0427306183,
-0.0159022976,
-0.0174201727,
-0.0089358613,
-0.0290462766,
-0.0439621322,
-0.0074100336,
0.0091825807,
-0.0379261039,
0.0446117111,
-0.0423423909,
0.0114907976,
-0.0439131074,
0.0054276311,
-0.0602804497,
0.0496767424,
0.0056849043,
-0.0053215362,
-0.0341612212,
-0.0478726402,
-0.0314735174,
0.0149678299,
-0.0334976576,
-0.0094757872,
0.0421848446,
0.0004852359,
0.0122247869,
-0.0187217817,
-0.0244729053,
-0.0453190729,
0.0069006891,
-0.0128559824,
-0.0050697527,
0.0283623338,
0.0022029139,
-0.0244807191,
0.0147776911,
-0.0126412455,
0.0747984126,
-0.0077269063,
0.0033171792,
-0.0047559082,
0.0366991274,
0.0153545719,
-0.0000038873,
0.0188188814,
-0.0310025141,
0.0107481163,
0.0314691216,
0.0445155837,
-0.004606443,
-0.0274757091,
-0.0172190927,
0.0023696036,
-0.0104861641,
0.0078220041,
0.0129952747,
0.0332010202,
-0.0711226836,
-0.0126454849,
0.1057019159,
0.0250794087,
-0.0997547507,
-0.006448383,
-0.0066885939,
0.0091864159,
0.0097981635,
0.009494368,
-0.0594717003,
-0.0415026248,
0.0246257037,
0.0164084379,
0.0208968166,
-0.0202004332,
-0.0408840477,
-0.0933788344,
-0.0246932227,
0.0159511715,
-0.0486389771,
-0.0013381991,
-0.0553049445,
-0.0541832894,
-0.0053044101,
0.0510310866,
0.0456468649,
-0.0182283707,
-0.0202462431,
0.0182990059,
-0.0508487411,
-0.0294466615,
0.0130884359,
0.0018730013,
0.029248219,
0.045357503,
0.0239739828,
0.0227971748,
-0.0153334644,
0.0777697861,
-0.0410441905,
0.0035156226,
-0.008926047,
0.0258648768,
-0.0291668829,
0.0049389228,
0.0089792768,
0.0398429036,
-0.0329847373,
-0.0052700909,
-0.0159039497,
0.0622683875,
-0.0028063313,
0.0013514747,
0.000736563,
-0.0433931574,
0.0003645717,
0.0450943895,
0.0267140213,
-0.0456223711,
-0.0356915146,
0.0011598467,
-0.000960596,
-0.0312814564,
0.0229318943,
-0.00365512,
-0.0033924906,
-0.0365411378,
-0.0712510794,
-0.0296548884,
-0.0018547827,
-0.0001454076,
-0.0087451953,
0.0048228125,
0.0155645236,
0.0225104075,
-0.0819952264,
-0.0053438479,
-0.0483206213,
0.0031616976,
-0.0667852089,
0.0482196808,
0.039251741,
-0.0208499078,
0.0009574378,
0.050088685,
-0.1214654669,
-0.0513956025,
0.0173644796,
0.0153236249,
0.0114652375,
0.0699830055,
0.021597527,
-0.0296560898,
0.092231907,
0.029285498,
-0.0142847616,
0.0395918414,
0.0312633291,
0.0451043658,
0.0177666806,
0.0238173585,
-0.0516572781,
0.0313829184,
0.0156726222,
0.0102493186,
0.0189894177,
-0.0043217232,
-0.0323723406,
0.0067201867,
0.027271349,
-0.0190182179,
0.0163115729,
-0.0050234911,
0.0757301673,
-0.0113450922,
0.0473002121,
-0.0365798511,
0.0348709188,
0.0114483265,
-0.0173725877,
-0.0047967923,
-0.0078082918,
0.0499586612,
-0.0281992648,
0.0269997586,
0.0427385941,
-0.0473879911,
-0.01401834,
0.0236005187,
0.0387635715,
-0.0237853955,
-0.0045589157,
0.0075248056,
0.0131586548,
-0.048048228,
0.0237316154,
0.0259917174,
0.0283533223,
-0.0687383637,
0.0309951734,
-0.0348665155,
0.0118728885,
-0.0377942882,
0.0129573904,
0.0439044908,
0.0182207245,
0.0306060389,
-0.0045244624,
0.0216025449,
-0.0244668126,
0.0352967866,
-0.0155291408,
-0.0217005853,
0.0375344455,
-0.0031195029,
-0.0277031865,
0.0337950289,
0.0818527266,
0.0047775963,
0.0540594608,
-0.0059045646,
0.0462624952,
-0.0236991066,
-0.0135312257,
-0.0220546834,
0.0218625814,
0.0055194693,
-0.0279798731,
0.0186753739,
-0.053539224,
0.0417992957,
-0.0417505763,
0.0006791864,
-0.0231139716,
0.045840662,
0.0273709651,
0.0072780754,
0.0092933923,
0.0207479112,
-0.0109773427,
0.0094562247,
-0.0232424997,
-0.0135470694,
-6.833942855e-33,
-0.0215422269,
-0.0211488456,
0.029010389,
0.0059967153,
-0.0723928884,
0.004728415,
-0.0491134934,
-0.0390102826,
0.0043280548,
-0.0319987684,
-0.0521427877,
0.0190198384,
0.0119272266,
0.0750788823,
-0.0081731007,
-0.0353191495,
0.0716857538,
-0.0102109453,
0.0028428244,
0.0435937308,
0.0600435212,
0.0521788038,
0.0637551844,
-0.007183691,
-0.0173193924,
0.0063246214,
0.0166585334,
0.0356938094,
0.0282152444,
0.0508696102,
-0.0635078698,
0.0480303317,
0.0343121849,
-0.0748113692,
-0.0235124864,
0.0157267097,
-0.1042399183,
-0.0190763287,
-0.0140058091,
0.0319421142,
-0.0344082601,
-0.0615659803,
0.0480738431,
0.0305771939,
-0.0165409036,
-0.0218040459,
0.0098481178,
-0.0223919582,
-0.0337020271,
-0.0502972119,
-0.0366136953,
0.0068704272,
0.0022482099,
-0.0022773738,
0.0388114415,
-0.0011042443,
-0.0143777179,
0.0441300422,
-0.0963580757,
-0.023262877,
-0.008661624,
0.0469252951,
0.0584180914,
0.0235859174,
0.0259436592,
0.0240054224,
0.0218105055,
-0.013236952,
-0.0465369672,
-0.0235019531,
0.0348434933,
-0.0197101068,
0.0187118631,
-0.0077647488,
0.0691433847,
-0.0679899678,
-0.0868255422,
-0.0378055684,
0.0323962905,
0.0593813062,
0.0428962484,
0.0294819959,
-0.0002025013,
-0.0263558105,
-0.0181284659,
0.0225012042,
-0.0127603142,
-0.0241880212,
0.0209765844,
0.051447995,
-0.0004696774,
-0.0187803339,
0.0509025492,
-0.0179864336,
0.0106660314,
0.0335749201,
0.0000612316,
0.0170939248,
0.0036896823,
0.0212681405,
-0.0458541699,
0.0159149393,
-0.0094949277,
-0.0040200455,
-0.0042734924,
-0.0310661644,
0.0277104322,
0.0468514599,
-0.0754106417,
-0.0035124482,
-0.0449951999,
0.042264495,
-0.0038645288,
0.0508631319,
0.0482521579,
0.0023333351,
-0.0167277846,
0.0817029104,
-0.0016816206,
-0.0009602156,
-0.0046760566,
-0.007732443,
0.0207776558,
0.0286640804,
-0.0417257659,
-0.0077570276,
-0.002984138,
0.0223526936,
0.0231236834,
-0.0827605724,
-0.0091458634,
0.0317069776,
2.915e-7,
0.0169196464,
0.0502121113,
0.0591586754,
-0.0169630405,
0.0557610504,
-0.0128291445,
0.0223253779,
0.0119237872,
-0.0125648333,
0.002267347,
0.0119344052,
0.0041282861,
0.0407220833,
-0.0042786822,
-0.1158615872,
-0.0277470797,
-0.0859728679,
-0.0026464872,
-0.0143908234,
-0.0464100242,
0.0147252008,
0.1179645434,
-0.0003435905,
-0.0187835488,
-0.0158107933,
-0.0015199929,
0.0486925729,
-0.0193624999,
0.0102018341,
0.0293467529,
0.0191060714,
0.0147894146,
-0.0194540769,
-0.0508392304,
-0.0026832875,
0.0328957178,
-0.0544339418,
0.0570924282,
0.0073690135,
-0.0789256468,
0.0374829918,
0.0314112641,
-0.0348267406,
0.0030172584,
0.0536116958,
-0.0760347247,
-0.0317183807,
-0.0256298073,
0.0118404292,
-0.0070610368,
0.0123339696,
0.0163386203,
0.0090026008,
0.0296682939,
-0.0043629156,
0.0020037415,
-0.0115712686,
-0.1241470128,
-0.0137801701,
-0.0252567269,
-0.0672275499,
-0.0295107625,
-0.0733738244,
-0.0007250933,
0.034181565,
-0.0518792719,
0.0037921688,
2.484701873e-34,
0.0457410999,
-0.0410543233,
-0.0060923439,
0.0552205704,
-0.0097638043,
-0.0259898417,
0.018123053,
0.014945766,
0.0164038744,
-0.0690131932,
-0.019673761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18164v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18164v1 | NeBuLa: A discourse aware Minecraft Builder | 2024-06-26T08:24:44 | 2024-06-26T08:24:44 | Akshay Chaturvedi, Kate Thompson, Nicholas Asher | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | When engaging in collaborative tasks, humans efficiently exploit the semantic
structure of a conversation to optimize verbal and nonverbal interactions. But
in recent "language to code" or "language to action" models, this information
is lacking. We show how incorporating the prior discourse and nonlinguistic
context of a conversation situated in a nonlinguistic environment can improve
the "language to action" component of such interactions. We fine tune an LLM to
predict actions based on prior context; our model, NeBuLa, doubles the
net-action F1 score over the baseline on this task of Jayannavar et al.(2020).
We also investigate our model's ability to construct shapes and understand
location descriptions using a synthetic dataset. | NeBuLa: A discourse aware Minecraft Builder: When engaging in collaborative tasks, humans efficiently exploit the semantic
structure of a conversation to optimize verbal and nonverbal interactions. But
in recent "language to code" or "language to action" models, this information
is lacking. We show how incorporating the prior discourse and nonlinguistic
context of a conversation situated in a nonlinguistic environment can improve
the "language to action" component of such interactions. We fine tune an LLM to
predict actions based on prior context; our model, NeBuLa, doubles the
net-action F1 score over the baseline on this task of Jayannavar et al.(2020).
We also investigate our model's ability to construct shapes and understand
location descriptions using a synthetic dataset. | [
0.0259588063,
0.0150331371,
-0.0227043126,
0.0340230167,
-0.0188784413,
0.0121327015,
-0.0263096411,
0.0077232416,
-0.0104590412,
-0.046545364,
-0.0513316356,
-0.0216241106,
0.0041288105,
0.0504480638,
0.0240012426,
-0.0521865599,
0.0186010301,
-0.0547681451,
-0.0077897091,
0.0201267041,
-0.0144666741,
0.0003629318,
-0.0274609774,
0.0552715808,
-0.0143377036,
0.0038611232,
-0.0727086216,
0.0116737839,
0.0033240705,
-0.0330320857,
-0.0082837744,
0.0433370918,
0.0000533291,
-0.0151535962,
0.0000019334,
-0.0170111824,
0.0866148993,
-0.0436124615,
0.0133151421,
-0.0644909963,
-0.0197449531,
0.0069590965,
-0.0017451617,
0.019171454,
-0.0665074214,
0.017339563,
0.049430564,
0.0327208228,
0.0241597332,
0.0435475968,
-0.0160900261,
0.0157142896,
-0.0324141458,
-0.020224968,
0.0201855432,
-0.027737774,
-0.0236148499,
0.0546612255,
0.0327598788,
0.0619267598,
-0.034684021,
0.0376159549,
0.0103980806,
-0.0374509245,
0.0353664197,
0.0492265224,
-0.0057705445,
-0.0251773223,
0.0156173389,
0.0923326835,
0.0367592126,
-0.0160908066,
0.0480116755,
0.0048812851,
0.0385922231,
-0.0005208641,
-0.0346556939,
0.0093773687,
-0.0130481739,
-0.0102844955,
-0.0100749228,
-0.0035073219,
0.0093379598,
0.0006347477,
0.080176577,
0.0614098534,
-0.028490914,
0.0259139519,
-0.0555605516,
0.0062777307,
0.0111325718,
-0.0798280835,
-0.0208367631,
0.0370585173,
-0.0727993697,
0.0193223022,
-0.0267847851,
0.062353123,
0.0047765933,
-0.0532790944,
0.0464234054,
0.0302326418,
0.0315959044,
0.0560717024,
-0.0093099307,
0.0035062975,
0.0152349835,
0.0155612146,
-0.0481830277,
0.0086547872,
-0.0461395644,
-0.0120546063,
-0.0096613774,
0.0255782492,
-0.094097659,
-0.0476941243,
-0.002674612,
0.0587033927,
-0.0131861931,
0.0096454015,
0.0462095141,
0.0309609976,
-0.0187890008,
-0.0007809994,
-0.0282330867,
-0.0354283862,
-0.009990124,
0.0309444275,
0.0112610469,
-0.0634799898,
-0.0114451377,
0.0156825669,
0.0115216738,
0.0034639658,
-0.0112330941,
0.0862566158,
-0.0262229014,
-0.0161515027,
0.0051846998,
-0.0252840035,
-0.0107000638,
-0.0627895668,
0.0314172879,
-0.0652638748,
0.0071224226,
-0.0004336429,
-0.0118625974,
-0.0119027505,
0.0179421026,
-0.0086865313,
0.0084797507,
0.0704393834,
-0.00807516,
0.0312436838,
0.0540240854,
0.0392556265,
0.0230191238,
0.063743189,
0.0537944064,
0.0213642046,
-0.0081800865,
0.0230515655,
0.0085702315,
0.0466937274,
-0.0416680872,
-0.0093264654,
0.0327372402,
0.0039463523,
-0.0246056933,
0.0162918679,
0.0250888616,
-0.0101925097,
-0.0268653557,
0.0051758382,
0.0717036948,
0.0850325003,
-0.0073596146,
0.0488206558,
0.0180596281,
0.0318222269,
-0.0460427999,
-0.0508333929,
-0.0228112787,
0.0762284622,
-0.0037705826,
-0.0228115208,
0.0071328618,
0.0063789254,
-0.0472449921,
-0.0572923236,
0.0116883758,
-0.031540934,
0.0616559908,
-0.0150432289,
0.0049193399,
-0.0023902415,
-0.0534666777,
0.0219468903,
-0.0066304109,
-0.0623730086,
0.0061193909,
-0.0201013926,
0.0269858036,
0.056733612,
-0.0059045046,
-0.0125357891,
-0.0291688591,
-0.0007780195,
0.0101799006,
0.051950369,
-0.0023532638,
-0.0299239419,
0.0491971113,
-0.0070037008,
-0.0270932559,
-0.017198449,
0.01322289,
0.0584243648,
0.0248468742,
-0.0282095596,
-0.0034000925,
0.0102593442,
0.0064012902,
0.0121349795,
-0.0126153249,
-0.0123657212,
-0.0231545642,
-0.0065503796,
0.046442721,
-0.0077255717,
0.0180649236,
-0.0151114482,
0.0341393016,
-0.0296006706,
-0.0176670458,
0.0880244449,
-0.0615674891,
-0.0419535562,
0.017300833,
-0.0246151965,
-0.0153524028,
0.0107247448,
0.0112476973,
-0.0324668847,
0.072301425,
-0.0515796281,
0.0536085106,
-0.0105177732,
-0.0004067586,
-0.0126653416,
-0.0159978867,
-0.0175463054,
0.0209877715,
0.0033110406,
-0.0191645157,
0.0153553905,
0.009495168,
0.0219140239,
-0.0407525115,
0.0372152403,
0.0553705581,
-0.0088354107,
0.0206778403,
0.0305423941,
0.0202170722,
-0.0908188596,
-0.0517486148,
-0.1188716516,
-0.0682189092,
-0.0081561683,
-0.0012464867,
0.0281941555,
-0.002610872,
-0.0179829113,
-0.0125669511,
-0.0367999114,
-0.0233181491,
0.0261268411,
-0.0073959352,
0.0418589041,
-0.0001136382,
0.0112078441,
-0.0434223898,
0.016005585,
0.0019983493,
0.0190869346,
0.0324609093,
-0.0379710793,
-0.0537421219,
0.0721288249,
-0.028092565,
-0.0053918818,
-0.0443353802,
-0.0363465883,
0.0367716961,
-0.0311932899,
0.0822129548,
0.0587734953,
-0.0089183282,
-0.0008423704,
0.0384610891,
-0.0452970862,
-0.08353962,
0.0150382258,
-0.00980586,
0.0187190659,
-0.0659104884,
-0.0476666689,
0.0378629006,
0.0713028684,
-0.0179148428,
0.0387118757,
-0.0704848096,
-0.0086191231,
0.0362477787,
-0.0567453615,
-0.0054204348,
-0.0357205234,
-0.0303813946,
0.0579398684,
-0.027582569,
-0.0338290408,
0.0213393029,
-0.0295756962,
-0.0512782633,
0.0137575418,
0.0002323229,
-0.0181315374,
0.0715802535,
0.0155528961,
-0.0040441472,
0.0215798039,
-0.0335474797,
-0.002743372,
-0.0211988296,
0.0229348373,
-0.0155472541,
-0.0072915591,
-0.0631863549,
0.0020020581,
0.0066907392,
-0.0163863078,
-0.0126785701,
0.0199728925,
-0.0199689772,
-0.0017957184,
0.0053854343,
-0.0231105406,
-0.0208545327,
0.0218033679,
0.0183530338,
0.0122567201,
0.0084232884,
-0.0171347819,
-0.0299363732,
0.0163033511,
0.031428922,
0.0715451464,
-0.047662098,
-0.0159218498,
0.0040873387,
0.0536723696,
-0.0051292852,
-0.0221201573,
-0.0222153626,
0.017137453,
0.050794851,
0.0517010875,
-0.0417625271,
0.0593030229,
0.0966956913,
-0.0009295203,
-0.0481537059,
0.0803551376,
0.0206806492,
0.0068742689,
-0.007837995,
-0.0318737514,
0.043572966,
0.0230714995,
0.0136959562,
-0.0055576675,
-0.0334118381,
0.0101074111,
-0.0343941264,
0.0040431111,
-0.0458697528,
0.0130742183,
-0.1044024974,
0.0381452069,
-0.000226602,
-0.0085939169,
-0.0078759482,
-0.0320886858,
0.0257315822,
0.0208694935,
-0.0480801836,
-0.0189046524,
0.0089788111,
-0.002297723,
0.0139563484,
-0.046003785,
-0.0111701665,
0.0243105888,
-0.0113832699,
0.0832205489,
0.037832424,
0.0703856945,
0.0208150316,
0.0153283775,
0.0090128938,
0.0487445667,
0.0148370406,
-0.0487708859,
0.0336026512,
0.0346041061,
0.0008946266,
0.0137550924,
0.0226771552,
-0.0511474162,
-0.0548985824,
-0.0014386969,
0.0310520791,
-0.0514876172,
-0.0073201461,
-0.0090633053,
0.0662631467,
0.041962605,
0.0041005923,
0.0185106229,
-0.0198748875,
-0.025104085,
-0.0468027033,
-0.0093358709,
-0.0504428707,
-0.0441817418,
-0.0659492686,
0.0470726825,
0.0302196648,
-0.0689495876,
-0.0454836041,
0.0250200927,
0.0172688048,
0.0032085667,
0.0113367131,
0.0048284833,
0.0244020317,
-0.030095201,
0.0199338198,
0.0039896341,
0.0253748894,
-0.0307256524,
-0.050177291,
0.0362311602,
-0.0735198706,
0.0248049572,
0.0529674962,
-0.052253969,
-0.0666843131,
-0.040396858,
0.0628422648,
0.0196156707,
0.0414965935,
0.0111188414,
-0.0192767214,
-0.0022856093,
0.012589342,
-0.042627994,
0.0346102603,
0.021326486,
0.0593658015,
0.0021935056,
0.008833182,
-0.003127038,
0.0138136577,
0.0194475595,
0.0452925228,
-0.0867963284,
-0.0691590309,
-0.0111636929,
-0.0284843091,
0.0195183195,
-0.016072087,
0.005183355,
-0.0090599684,
-0.0171514805,
-0.0177021977,
0.0206125658,
-0.063097693,
0.0147065679,
0.002213683,
-0.0032523246,
0.030190561,
0.0416631252,
-0.0557699092,
0.0363584384,
0.0286834165,
0.0484906808,
0.0033709733,
0.011726588,
0.0056997808,
0.0468505882,
0.0095631685,
-0.0010725434,
-0.0014145295,
0.0499448068,
0.0122020049,
0.0397511981,
0.0115355337,
-0.0270287376,
0.0051234621,
0.0488155074,
-0.0537010618,
-0.0210905131,
-0.0141636766,
0.0451872535,
0.0498383082,
-0.0130234025,
0.028269235,
-0.0638965368,
0.0339550301,
-0.0074903877,
0.0762799159,
-0.0139869265,
-0.0691176206,
0.050307706,
0.0418752357,
-0.0139782829,
-0.039358642,
0.0210861024,
0.0067849723,
0.0017109845,
0.0215516668,
0.0053289915,
-0.0573600754,
-0.0487175696,
0.0252987668,
0.0422879532,
-0.0299519096,
0.0258804709,
-0.0189999826,
-0.0433847047,
0.0087564643,
0.0348299444,
0.0207997151,
-0.0675514042,
0.0513571464,
0.0437257737,
0.0146075431,
-0.0210958291,
-0.0647637993,
-0.0182446372,
0.0185903963,
0.0052356417,
-0.0741414279,
-5.407195403e-33,
-0.0454487987,
-0.0797492713,
0.0465302281,
0.0585192293,
0.0060784658,
-0.0209127311,
-0.0846685767,
0.0507871509,
-0.0085046645,
-0.0163512249,
-0.0213876348,
0.0277716946,
0.0039535118,
0.0110250358,
0.0305455383,
-0.0025831158,
0.0270815231,
0.0053959643,
-0.0188019946,
0.023764953,
-0.0003653252,
-0.0178098772,
0.0277842749,
-0.0726497546,
0.0112997638,
0.0134239066,
-0.0310134869,
0.0078498628,
0.0152892508,
0.0052812602,
-0.0098089539,
0.0012041157,
0.0210776106,
0.0236605424,
-0.0101525616,
0.025700815,
-0.0476903915,
-0.0021115104,
0.027008554,
-0.0053620399,
-0.0490242653,
-0.0302153733,
-0.0126569644,
0.0103956433,
-0.0493526123,
-0.0273091178,
0.053943716,
-0.0085505247,
-0.0434193574,
0.012042488,
-0.074404642,
0.0008452576,
-0.0593650304,
-0.0586174093,
0.0453546979,
0.0544902161,
-0.0000432313,
-0.0164679773,
-0.0482631065,
0.1156168506,
-0.0435643159,
0.032054171,
0.0566533841,
0.0592931211,
0.0361655913,
0.0785474032,
0.0340727977,
0.0384136327,
-0.0091032833,
0.0110682417,
0.0194241554,
0.0704569295,
0.002414559,
0.0437293351,
-0.0210762583,
0.0364274643,
-0.0217992235,
0.0465634763,
-0.0419788025,
0.0256907903,
-0.0126577914,
0.033983089,
0.0031530857,
-0.0298557561,
-0.026351219,
-0.0120451292,
0.0121910209,
-0.0197676681,
0.0075054793,
0.0071920604,
0.023059763,
-0.0269321091,
0.0393246897,
-0.0259078238,
-0.0055656768,
-0.0105868122,
-0.0173873063,
0.029829612,
-0.0041741757,
-0.0112022096,
-0.0508239716,
-0.0277180299,
0.0177315753,
0.047950536,
0.0242537186,
0.0196540691,
-0.0286363866,
0.0210938398,
-0.0336533189,
-0.0275644101,
-0.0471822917,
0.0134564014,
-0.0243854765,
0.0099580018,
-0.002771606,
-0.0418754406,
-0.0410858169,
0.0140557382,
-0.0278346948,
-0.019909339,
-0.0521009192,
-0.0302114822,
-0.0398752391,
0.0052177408,
-0.030315889,
-0.0222618524,
-0.0805057138,
0.0329360999,
0.0893747211,
-0.0291206706,
-0.0133240055,
0.0017040233,
2.743e-7,
0.0037601043,
0.0537012219,
-0.0058697923,
0.0043826406,
-0.0037826663,
0.0587310158,
-0.0424325019,
0.0263822991,
0.0490759276,
-0.0033717614,
0.0290016886,
0.0453805663,
0.039798975,
0.0000688719,
-0.099302873,
0.0411374271,
-0.0316381566,
-0.0386790968,
-0.0018495998,
0.0031358807,
0.0056847762,
0.0116096893,
-0.0218076855,
0.0032668768,
0.0040078377,
-0.0258173402,
0.0494803302,
-0.0927618295,
0.005434901,
0.034358412,
-0.0391715877,
-0.0502115116,
-0.0365785137,
-0.010409629,
-0.0287493952,
-0.03538936,
-0.0097294226,
0.0625589788,
-0.0216340721,
-0.0318627842,
-0.0149580166,
0.0190066621,
0.0035507334,
0.0058937054,
-0.0136735989,
-0.0617585219,
-0.0333511867,
0.045269344,
0.0040392093,
0.0187684521,
-0.0172618814,
0.0075141992,
-0.022229882,
-0.022706721,
-0.0003189448,
-0.0287017636,
0.0223089401,
-0.0441736877,
-0.0511057191,
-0.034016028,
-0.0843211934,
-0.0626287684,
-0.0339092314,
-0.0049875905,
-0.0026983074,
-0.0018352456,
-0.0015571609,
1.880146506e-34,
-0.0194314513,
0.0355227217,
0.0091595575,
0.0547467098,
0.0287367608,
-0.0028990181,
0.0238878913,
0.0506781638,
0.0529468805,
-0.0437218063,
-0.0159883574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18139v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18139v1 | LOOK-M: Look-Once Optimization in KV Cache for Efficient Multimodal Long-Context Inference | 2024-06-26T07:44:24 | 2024-06-26T07:44:24 | Zhongwei Wan, Ziang Wu, Che Liu, Jinfa Huang, Zhihong Zhu, Peng Jin, Longyue Wang, Li Yuan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Long-context Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) demand substantial
computational resources for inference as the growth of their multimodal
Key-Value (KV) cache, in response to increasing input lengths, challenges
memory and time efficiency. Unlike single-modality LLMs that manage only
textual contexts, the KV cache of long-context MLLMs includes representations
from multiple images with temporal and spatial relationships and related
textual contexts. The predominance of image tokens means traditional
optimizations for LLMs' KV caches are unsuitable for multimodal long-context
settings, and no prior works have addressed this challenge. In this work, we
introduce LOOK-M, a pioneering, fine-tuning-free approach that efficiently
reduces the multimodal KV cache size while maintaining performance comparable
to a full cache. We observe that during prompt prefill, the model prioritizes
more textual attention over image features, and based on the multimodal
interaction observation, a new proposed text-prior method is explored to
compress the KV cache. Furthermore, to mitigate the degradation of image
contextual information, we propose several compensatory strategies using KV
pairs merging. LOOK-M demonstrates that with a significant reduction in KV
Cache memory usage, such as reducing it by 80% in some cases, it not only
achieves up to 1.5x faster decoding but also maintains or even enhances
performance across a variety of long context multimodal tasks. | LOOK-M: Look-Once Optimization in KV Cache for Efficient Multimodal Long-Context Inference: Long-context Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) demand substantial
computational resources for inference as the growth of their multimodal
Key-Value (KV) cache, in response to increasing input lengths, challenges
memory and time efficiency. Unlike single-modality LLMs that manage only
textual contexts, the KV cache of long-context MLLMs includes representations
from multiple images with temporal and spatial relationships and related
textual contexts. The predominance of image tokens means traditional
optimizations for LLMs' KV caches are unsuitable for multimodal long-context
settings, and no prior works have addressed this challenge. In this work, we
introduce LOOK-M, a pioneering, fine-tuning-free approach that efficiently
reduces the multimodal KV cache size while maintaining performance comparable
to a full cache. We observe that during prompt prefill, the model prioritizes
more textual attention over image features, and based on the multimodal
interaction observation, a new proposed text-prior method is explored to
compress the KV cache. Furthermore, to mitigate the degradation of image
contextual information, we propose several compensatory strategies using KV
pairs merging. LOOK-M demonstrates that with a significant reduction in KV
Cache memory usage, such as reducing it by 80% in some cases, it not only
achieves up to 1.5x faster decoding but also maintains or even enhances
performance across a variety of long context multimodal tasks. | [
0.009991671,
0.0543595962,
0.0114146871,
0.0829629824,
-0.0264241043,
0.0240195449,
0.0264376495,
-0.0032655182,
0.0000866324,
-0.0640965253,
-0.0341650173,
-0.0585643202,
0.0338846222,
-0.0099136587,
0.0348003656,
-0.0277623888,
0.0494920611,
-0.0713990256,
-0.0205329116,
-0.0023678041,
0.0007587709,
0.0171853509,
0.0027000762,
0.0219162181,
-0.0342016295,
-0.0284444168,
-0.0481558479,
0.0304739308,
0.0028919289,
-0.017171273,
-0.0183640514,
0.0434551127,
0.0178792551,
0.0040499517,
0.0000020552,
-0.0373674259,
0.0174767282,
-0.01276429,
-0.0159087386,
0.0338577405,
0.0674123392,
-0.0251052566,
-0.0212054737,
-0.0234233476,
0.0150673343,
-0.0358868167,
0.0791493207,
0.0126019055,
0.040133208,
0.0232983846,
-0.015139983,
-0.0412862152,
-0.0156623498,
-0.0232048966,
0.0488248765,
-0.0775575861,
0.0379871204,
-0.0262381025,
-0.0283740032,
-0.0119775971,
-0.0312023442,
0.0697548985,
0.0293925703,
0.0044641709,
-0.0028973096,
0.0612007938,
0.0109513896,
-0.0295063071,
-0.0225768872,
0.0613309182,
-0.0061992309,
-0.0042434493,
-0.0000238474,
0.0105038946,
-0.0044556796,
0.0046934094,
-0.0304632206,
0.0308727175,
-0.0288968906,
-0.0154807186,
-0.0040440657,
0.0030072788,
0.0185457543,
0.0361850746,
-0.0464488231,
0.0016319121,
0.0469112992,
0.0117139099,
-0.032124579,
-0.0053660823,
-0.0198945049,
-0.0701267719,
-0.0112497937,
0.0331298895,
0.0068565411,
-0.0022015814,
-0.0459666774,
-0.0182896797,
0.0129929716,
-0.0518518612,
0.0157446917,
0.0316101089,
-0.065782927,
0.0684563592,
-0.0232264716,
0.0219912902,
-0.0519186556,
-0.0272200014,
-0.0456836298,
-0.0270622689,
0.0124915056,
-0.0124661662,
-0.0042923484,
-0.0214395802,
-0.0190780312,
-0.0335427523,
0.0072575402,
0.0343771987,
0.0172493979,
-0.0163651388,
-0.0213901624,
0.0203466862,
-0.0135408677,
-0.0016520341,
0.0040142667,
0.0684223995,
-0.0091836825,
-0.0167704858,
-0.0401057117,
-0.0480558686,
-0.0125933634,
0.047607094,
0.0237185694,
-0.0666304231,
-0.0075034234,
0.0854361579,
-0.0284350011,
-0.0250281636,
-0.0245213602,
-0.0307978559,
-0.0481191985,
-0.0509391837,
0.0435101986,
-0.0431113243,
0.0468150564,
-0.0031967235,
0.0017309495,
0.0162799079,
-0.0235018283,
0.0181132574,
-0.0371139236,
0.0856496841,
0.0413317941,
0.0021617208,
0.0451150984,
0.0118583376,
0.0143933203,
0.0740369782,
0.0004494359,
0.0493462794,
0.0137005411,
-0.0170429945,
-0.0220355261,
0.070183441,
0.0158493184,
0.0209082384,
-0.0146304108,
0.0012263656,
0.0654190481,
0.0068971859,
0.065435715,
0.0488078631,
-0.0467589088,
-0.0289804209,
0.0539051481,
0.0302204005,
0.0217373185,
-0.0445727482,
0.0191920921,
-0.0085253101,
-0.018795481,
-0.0019153183,
-0.0734714121,
0.0808223784,
-0.0286539309,
0.0252939258,
0.0560414158,
0.0644318014,
-0.027418036,
0.0293882117,
-0.0176004879,
-0.0315338857,
-0.0027610634,
0.0269033276,
0.0346768126,
-0.0131280851,
-0.0439825915,
0.0392544977,
0.0037712373,
-0.0224953741,
-0.0224735755,
-0.0306389481,
0.0145528549,
0.0711392388,
0.0272524916,
0.0446176305,
-0.0125160581,
0.0319690071,
0.028769983,
0.0194497965,
0.0011971178,
-0.000979633,
0.0445674844,
-0.0617400296,
-0.0367339849,
0.0068638129,
-0.024148602,
0.0296233743,
0.0164123103,
0.0189039558,
0.0258562453,
0.0239609387,
0.0690430552,
0.0016734638,
0.0121756978,
0.003607237,
-0.0255320147,
0.0256231315,
-0.0014297715,
-0.0088054817,
-0.0090318313,
0.0047233147,
0.0335087702,
-0.0280009173,
0.0424046405,
0.0111680673,
-0.0892866924,
-0.0739750043,
0.0204486232,
0.0163958538,
-0.0145057151,
-0.0240947027,
-0.0244638976,
-0.0067797019,
-0.0172952302,
-0.0092949774,
0.0546368398,
-0.0301794391,
0.0016599682,
0.0322906971,
0.0290820375,
-0.0166185964,
0.0535967089,
-0.0441013761,
-0.0117746284,
0.0449500568,
0.049787011,
-0.0144621311,
-0.0177688245,
-0.0232591759,
0.0399928167,
0.0012484831,
-0.0087725194,
-0.0078052166,
0.01583042,
-0.0299715251,
-0.0065957601,
-0.1221252307,
-0.0072683659,
-0.0169304218,
-0.0026733968,
-0.012756858,
0.0210190229,
-0.000168205,
-0.026425356,
0.0060880575,
0.0054912427,
-0.0045168577,
0.0595128573,
-0.0210700706,
0.0088031748,
0.0130320638,
-0.0015495187,
-0.0411000773,
0.0162928328,
0.0872251913,
-0.0400959998,
-0.0527698137,
-0.0141927386,
0.0425913185,
-0.0241246503,
0.0069410042,
-0.0404847227,
-0.0256537776,
-0.0010067902,
-0.0640559047,
0.0725715384,
0.062763758,
0.0278825928,
-0.0319373272,
0.0147850439,
-0.0692002922,
-0.042225197,
0.0043466045,
0.0248997379,
-0.0458943024,
-0.001661755,
-0.0132660978,
-0.0556366295,
0.0586767793,
-0.0125708953,
0.0048216544,
-0.0228009447,
-0.0330871306,
0.0145295961,
-0.0447986126,
-0.05981021,
0.0024014506,
-0.0024618795,
0.003137239,
-0.0436746962,
-0.0449629314,
0.0479670838,
-0.0661746189,
-0.0205731969,
0.0212408211,
0.0081413649,
-0.0187219679,
0.064217262,
0.008476329,
0.0149975233,
-0.024360925,
-0.0052631274,
-0.0153297279,
0.0070855008,
-0.0028664817,
-0.0247536115,
0.0627896339,
-0.0323160365,
0.029726943,
-0.0359340124,
-0.0176089518,
-0.0166110061,
-0.016826259,
-0.0310994722,
-0.063320443,
-0.0201427806,
-0.0064878319,
0.0179728866,
0.0473514572,
0.0140107879,
0.0397229902,
-0.0144049767,
0.0171228275,
-0.0228876919,
0.0431824997,
0.0566308461,
0.0271984767,
-0.0300368369,
-0.041896604,
0.0170354098,
0.0844563991,
0.0448561646,
-0.0046551386,
-0.035669338,
0.0464691259,
0.0401265286,
0.0724897236,
-0.0200888701,
0.0365630351,
0.0359673947,
-0.0634068176,
0.0335691869,
0.0607602708,
0.0019133461,
-0.0863569304,
-0.0458045006,
0.004390717,
0.033305537,
0.000077159,
-0.0001456412,
-0.0919923708,
-0.077772975,
0.0383489691,
-0.0335955396,
0.0259667523,
-0.0005488762,
-0.0271620434,
-0.1019583866,
0.017712051,
0.0115683526,
-0.0183838606,
0.0016848767,
-0.0249363463,
-0.0180510301,
0.0182621572,
0.0153414998,
0.030647194,
-0.0064349524,
-0.0235828087,
-0.0122166993,
0.036229115,
-0.0236101355,
0.0271844137,
-0.0330745168,
0.0103809722,
0.0311612971,
0.0016379758,
0.0373225249,
-0.0264861379,
0.0432139523,
-0.0024938218,
0.0105920266,
-0.0340061039,
0.0050015147,
-0.0578397736,
-0.0104819257,
-0.0188776571,
0.0148680182,
0.0013540279,
-0.0356914103,
-0.0128082903,
0.0451093167,
-0.0014746103,
0.0031574185,
-0.0307322182,
-0.0175053254,
0.0013099546,
0.0612984151,
0.016130615,
-0.017459901,
-0.0174581185,
-0.0055884575,
-0.0163590387,
-0.0278330557,
-0.0230160933,
0.0073227314,
-0.0007675138,
-0.026779674,
-0.0209652092,
-0.0120281298,
0.0052202437,
0.0406666361,
-0.0417482555,
0.0144743407,
-0.0288032778,
0.0046063405,
-0.0855506286,
0.0649782047,
-0.0447058119,
0.0412206315,
-0.0386949889,
0.0331982188,
0.0373049602,
-0.0306678042,
0.0054894239,
0.0625941902,
-0.1261573285,
-0.0558745041,
-0.0280264691,
0.0455028899,
0.0097189033,
0.0687373281,
0.0197043661,
-0.055014804,
0.0256894007,
0.0254241657,
-0.0262043197,
0.0602656156,
-0.0105101727,
0.0217678454,
0.0074466863,
0.0114766601,
-0.0479014255,
-0.0089743994,
-0.0127359536,
0.0091140112,
0.0066959658,
-0.0316531211,
-0.0328325815,
-0.008843773,
0.0230434798,
-0.0215314794,
0.0045750085,
0.0100830533,
0.037168812,
-0.005143831,
-0.017022673,
-0.029069541,
0.0222123116,
-0.0143992184,
0.0086951014,
0.0253060199,
0.0035823791,
0.0639217794,
0.0107112247,
-0.0293303356,
-0.0073584653,
0.0138224913,
-0.0216370374,
0.0313016921,
0.016042674,
-0.0114116762,
0.0213049874,
-0.0074711582,
0.0115447966,
-0.0502832979,
0.047556594,
0.0204511527,
-0.0288781654,
-0.0190686956,
0.0300827194,
-0.0278409068,
-0.007031003,
-0.0136573203,
-0.0080351736,
0.0746703371,
-0.0160015989,
0.0439441614,
-0.0087411143,
-0.0102198096,
-0.0409363322,
0.0324576497,
0.0201302934,
-0.0460503995,
0.0486149006,
0.029263543,
0.0173828136,
0.0306820758,
0.0385730341,
0.0241862275,
0.0369145051,
-0.0145541588,
0.0094967959,
-0.0057878164,
-0.0250383168,
0.0031407252,
0.0139927063,
-0.0058921711,
-0.0182803068,
-0.024451565,
-0.0773871243,
0.0131349815,
-0.0063145687,
-0.0455940887,
0.0148402406,
0.0432853736,
0.0345126726,
0.0313513204,
-0.0420510955,
0.0064905174,
0.018727269,
-0.0061836392,
-0.0020327994,
0.0191892274,
-6.564569508e-33,
-0.0288771018,
-0.0437014215,
0.0351694413,
-0.0487262756,
-0.0377495475,
0.0382043608,
-0.0216263104,
-0.0274713244,
-0.012485506,
-0.0323005579,
0.0078228917,
0.0044406629,
0.0212769061,
0.0230295453,
-0.0210687146,
-0.0116204508,
0.0181599353,
0.0136177205,
0.0128934393,
0.0183448121,
0.0248626601,
0.0346750878,
0.017552061,
-0.0198163874,
-0.0078328615,
0.0026110304,
0.0181746557,
0.0081283981,
-0.0014083205,
0.0577848814,
-0.0668658838,
0.0131523544,
0.0169463214,
-0.0181804895,
-0.0285887253,
0.047328338,
-0.0830586031,
0.0185960606,
0.0378933102,
0.0277481824,
-0.0357697681,
-0.0448823124,
0.010422335,
0.0220995694,
0.0097251497,
-0.0254590698,
0.0051239412,
-0.0008728747,
-0.0559699908,
-0.0075875754,
-0.020567907,
0.0202552732,
0.0141363721,
-0.0058856751,
0.0662538931,
0.0213481169,
0.0390423499,
0.0673798695,
-0.0814382136,
0.0197527539,
-0.0343775749,
0.0586425737,
0.1052762121,
0.0594800524,
0.0181213971,
0.0358864255,
0.0369262509,
-0.0424520671,
-0.0588605106,
0.0049107452,
0.0274733379,
0.0451004468,
-0.0137564614,
0.0684688017,
0.0250992682,
-0.001239993,
-0.0218822844,
-0.0136439307,
-0.011539463,
0.0453615524,
0.0393922254,
0.0205223057,
0.0082274228,
-0.0275639948,
-0.0528990477,
0.0251314826,
-0.06358435,
0.009808749,
0.0456318744,
0.0360003933,
0.001167801,
0.0110792648,
0.1240593344,
-0.0150186345,
-0.0078597609,
0.0329864211,
-0.0009295609,
0.054799147,
-0.0142680956,
0.0509021245,
-0.0136133591,
-0.0130850188,
0.0525926948,
-0.0198642276,
0.019756332,
0.0200392157,
-0.0168555249,
0.0264085103,
-0.049496036,
-0.0276200715,
-0.041131217,
-0.0349231027,
-0.0126230372,
-0.0021300756,
0.0525466539,
-0.0039449511,
-0.0068426779,
0.0861599892,
0.0034355731,
0.0153377866,
-0.0177383758,
-0.0764731541,
0.008223691,
0.0145102087,
-0.0102991434,
0.0257539935,
-0.0311083216,
-0.043181058,
0.0408004522,
-0.0538072325,
-0.0174833219,
0.0694090128,
2.702e-7,
0.0131613435,
0.019681273,
0.0384374931,
-0.0003647044,
0.0227920748,
0.0445394814,
0.0120216962,
0.0204468388,
0.0049975142,
-0.0574319437,
-0.0232871287,
0.052178327,
0.048323825,
0.0051146355,
-0.045750834,
0.0095156701,
-0.0430548862,
-0.0053040618,
-0.0664426535,
-0.0103031676,
0.0434849896,
0.0844801143,
-0.0357780159,
-0.0343243256,
0.053061761,
-0.0141470423,
0.0641111732,
-0.0190753099,
-0.0334278941,
-0.0218172073,
0.0013806311,
-0.0240943078,
-0.0106450999,
0.0025180937,
0.0117518483,
-0.0502399132,
-0.0033453929,
0.0552559383,
-0.0042531318,
-0.0788015798,
-0.0044237738,
0.0000695453,
-0.0640463755,
-0.0414240882,
0.1083256528,
-0.018706996,
-0.0082510794,
-0.050121773,
0.0016605246,
-0.0304891206,
-0.0166984294,
0.0030013025,
-0.0141858244,
0.046433147,
0.0328554288,
-0.0257302169,
-0.0515730195,
-0.1172764525,
-0.0551299378,
-0.012068266,
-0.0680258721,
-0.0314675979,
-0.0679822415,
-0.0428799503,
0.0752249807,
-0.0701003671,
-0.0416060016,
2.466318243e-34,
0.017860068,
-0.0305894706,
0.0212215912,
0.0315590352,
0.0253459383,
-0.0191685539,
-0.0398039781,
0.0325336419,
-0.014450714,
-0.0895194262,
-0.0454614088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18135v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18135v1 | Automatic Speech Recognition for Hindi | 2024-06-26T07:39:20 | 2024-06-26T07:39:20 | Anish Saha, A. G. Ramakrishnan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Automatic speech recognition (ASR) is a key area in computational
linguistics, focusing on developing technologies that enable computers to
convert spoken language into text. This field combines linguistics and machine
learning. ASR models, which map speech audio to transcripts through supervised
learning, require handling real and unrestricted text. Text-to-speech systems
directly work with real text, while ASR systems rely on language models trained
on large text corpora. High-quality transcribed data is essential for training
predictive models. The research involved two main components: developing a web
application and designing a web interface for speech recognition. The web
application, created with JavaScript and Node.js, manages large volumes of
audio files and their transcriptions, facilitating collaborative human
correction of ASR transcripts. It operates in real-time using a client-server
architecture. The web interface for speech recognition records 16 kHz mono
audio from any device running the web app, performs voice activity detection
(VAD), and sends the audio to the recognition engine. VAD detects human speech
presence, aiding efficient speech processing and reducing unnecessary
processing during non-speech intervals, thus saving computation and network
bandwidth in VoIP applications. The final phase of the research tested a neural
network for accurately aligning the speech signal to hidden Markov model (HMM)
states. This included implementing a novel backpropagation method that utilizes
prior statistics of node co-activations. | Automatic Speech Recognition for Hindi: Automatic speech recognition (ASR) is a key area in computational
linguistics, focusing on developing technologies that enable computers to
convert spoken language into text. This field combines linguistics and machine
learning. ASR models, which map speech audio to transcripts through supervised
learning, require handling real and unrestricted text. Text-to-speech systems
directly work with real text, while ASR systems rely on language models trained
on large text corpora. High-quality transcribed data is essential for training
predictive models. The research involved two main components: developing a web
application and designing a web interface for speech recognition. The web
application, created with JavaScript and Node.js, manages large volumes of
audio files and their transcriptions, facilitating collaborative human
correction of ASR transcripts. It operates in real-time using a client-server
architecture. The web interface for speech recognition records 16 kHz mono
audio from any device running the web app, performs voice activity detection
(VAD), and sends the audio to the recognition engine. VAD detects human speech
presence, aiding efficient speech processing and reducing unnecessary
processing during non-speech intervals, thus saving computation and network
bandwidth in VoIP applications. The final phase of the research tested a neural
network for accurately aligning the speech signal to hidden Markov model (HMM)
states. This included implementing a novel backpropagation method that utilizes
prior statistics of node co-activations. | [
0.01841061,
-0.0049691792,
-0.010211518,
-0.0063577355,
-0.0535048768,
-0.0270162728,
0.0107636154,
0.004554159,
0.0120672435,
-0.0417970978,
-0.0333051533,
-0.0120590869,
0.0758139864,
0.0435211547,
0.0061588027,
-0.0251142532,
0.0094955619,
-0.0298232399,
0.0271859486,
0.0006937227,
0.0123297581,
0.0263257492,
-0.0824543238,
0.0295224618,
-0.0464689061,
-0.0139185702,
-0.0160565488,
-0.007940338,
-0.0146029051,
-0.015578934,
-0.062896654,
-0.0002707585,
-0.0008355366,
0.014846717,
0.0000017416,
-0.0361974165,
-0.0062147044,
0.0253442843,
-0.0155922677,
-0.0138511453,
0.0206868295,
0.0764221773,
-0.048444014,
0.0682120845,
0.0168979876,
0.0392856188,
0.0771374255,
-0.0062862528,
0.0057402919,
0.0585031398,
-0.0246293191,
-0.0148319062,
0.056789767,
0.0351739153,
-0.0389767587,
0.0015401621,
0.0161138289,
0.00191539,
0.0240546465,
-0.0536074825,
0.0057527148,
0.0090017989,
-0.0347374044,
-0.016516123,
0.017412534,
0.0036252013,
-0.0460759327,
-0.0494312048,
0.0029170548,
0.0274343472,
0.0135882171,
-0.0127588408,
0.0570292994,
0.0140594412,
-0.0489871129,
0.0185481329,
-0.0086435387,
0.0174711756,
-0.0349079743,
0.0097799832,
0.0194057301,
0.0086670704,
0.0060580778,
-0.0061666765,
0.0943764299,
-0.029704744,
0.0069404133,
-0.036851421,
-0.0181863327,
-0.0471261553,
0.0487175882,
-0.0018454157,
0.1052108929,
0.0208051503,
0.0023048944,
0.0227186531,
0.0165772326,
-0.0576103888,
0.00873629,
-0.0872981921,
0.0303902272,
0.0290314313,
-0.0335812643,
-0.0022215752,
0.0058777877,
0.0387651213,
0.0044902898,
-0.0457377583,
-0.0108711645,
0.0209729113,
-0.0071171727,
-0.034700837,
-0.0070331455,
0.0216449555,
-0.0012671944,
-0.0174329448,
-0.0509889573,
0.0168032441,
-0.0155660436,
-0.0080990521,
0.0675074384,
-0.0327846371,
-0.029156832,
-0.0185945109,
0.0421991721,
0.0265158266,
-0.0016404106,
0.0408766083,
-0.0020276031,
-0.1044212133,
0.0352666713,
-0.0026525704,
0.0407685004,
0.0222470406,
-0.0080314679,
0.0460563265,
0.008027602,
0.0021339171,
-0.0614305399,
0.012843404,
-0.0222090017,
-0.0251043215,
-0.0132498499,
-0.0535794757,
0.0464204736,
0.0128600337,
-0.0302073825,
0.0035870264,
0.0082639139,
0.0065570693,
0.0280593708,
0.0687502697,
-0.0082166288,
0.0261965152,
0.0981728509,
-0.0079529937,
0.0356655344,
0.0177381411,
0.0433632806,
-0.0174840577,
0.0215593185,
-0.05049688,
-0.0008522971,
0.0515635945,
-0.0518254749,
-0.0290537588,
-0.0341346152,
-0.0052187047,
-0.0329147652,
0.0391975641,
-0.0160021279,
0.0390841812,
0.0283525474,
0.0259002335,
0.0664866418,
0.0881286785,
-0.00384164,
0.0523382053,
-0.0079481965,
0.0098087583,
0.0132186487,
-0.0175989717,
0.0203560479,
0.0211809315,
-0.0259931404,
-0.0005407472,
0.015033232,
0.0085235015,
-0.0046977545,
-0.0010392817,
-0.0203759652,
-0.0479520485,
-0.0183473025,
0.0195088573,
0.0485766828,
-0.0230614562,
-0.0419058278,
-0.0162734482,
0.0258797053,
-0.0568961576,
0.0099987946,
-0.0558224022,
-0.0077060512,
0.0314952694,
0.02463823,
-0.0407127552,
-0.0059388843,
-0.0240003169,
-0.0724359602,
0.010804317,
-0.0045209033,
0.0059815864,
-0.0081122611,
-0.0599353984,
0.0027969328,
0.0817581117,
-0.0130910119,
0.042851083,
-0.07299833,
0.040530324,
0.017095428,
0.0139425052,
0.0031435271,
-0.0061171143,
-0.0176716708,
-0.0004995537,
-0.0360464826,
0.0200151615,
0.102153182,
0.0115923705,
-0.0210906323,
-0.0012074404,
0.030609915,
0.0060206177,
0.0262270048,
0.0363661647,
-0.0152300205,
-0.0042927465,
0.0639616475,
-0.0452429429,
0.0306633562,
0.0741476044,
0.0481833369,
-0.0914069638,
0.0457022004,
-0.0520084463,
0.0041582086,
-0.040441215,
0.0461233407,
0.0120941941,
0.0047983471,
0.0344520919,
-0.0332161672,
0.0365355574,
-0.0095375441,
0.0124128098,
-0.027365841,
0.0340902098,
-0.050566528,
0.004343858,
0.0415274426,
-0.0534716658,
0.0348579474,
0.0103772851,
-0.0266254973,
-0.0384336933,
0.0083304588,
-0.1268511415,
-0.0048334966,
-0.0002006434,
-0.0062633669,
-0.0111940168,
0.0733236074,
0.0079122279,
-0.0582367815,
-0.0262050573,
0.0097873108,
0.0162245519,
-0.0087115988,
-0.0083650909,
-0.0370445661,
-0.0461819097,
-0.0353991464,
-0.033611346,
-0.0084856497,
0.0168118905,
0.0094461441,
-0.0749888048,
-0.0158446021,
-0.0271346197,
0.028668439,
0.0482552722,
-0.0082175033,
-0.0402461849,
-0.0198107585,
0.0037367342,
0.0372292213,
0.0360691622,
0.0114442362,
-0.0274007637,
0.0009322069,
-0.0045711622,
-0.0355521366,
-0.003366305,
0.0390689783,
0.0503473803,
-0.013907575,
-0.0139759248,
-0.0160601735,
0.0212666877,
0.0499466732,
0.0253938995,
0.0115882196,
-0.0844642743,
-0.0473121107,
0.0165763497,
0.0060700858,
-0.0287286509,
-0.0946198702,
0.0246033128,
0.0248120315,
-0.0344814174,
0.0207165238,
-0.0560026579,
-0.0162897166,
-0.0719845444,
-0.0469201691,
0.0103016952,
-0.0082165739,
-0.0171988327,
0.0022396652,
-0.0348358639,
-0.0741289631,
-0.0274397638,
0.0154108359,
0.0110015078,
-0.0789072439,
-0.0651549995,
-0.01785836,
0.0247350093,
-0.0203501079,
-0.0032831079,
-0.0204644632,
-0.0260691568,
-0.0198362432,
0.0343924239,
0.0086453538,
0.0195053238,
0.0367709361,
0.0740344524,
-0.0152974846,
0.050799273,
0.0037699365,
0.0284154322,
-0.006244882,
0.0237198044,
0.0415510647,
0.0037608778,
-0.047256317,
0.034057837,
-0.009331842,
-0.0358508937,
0.025590308,
-0.0000972832,
-0.0423085839,
-0.0156591684,
0.0246641636,
-0.0454992391,
-0.019654613,
0.0423349999,
0.0193975475,
-0.017516084,
0.0148637528,
0.0549377576,
0.0177360494,
-0.0436934419,
-0.0635146499,
-0.0299886372,
-0.0419893041,
-0.0124514122,
0.0216746964,
0.0049452288,
0.0053667682,
0.0735578239,
0.0316706747,
0.0251573417,
0.0503080226,
0.0114215892,
-0.0570478551,
0.0126242666,
-0.0019571104,
0.0066887867,
-0.0077955746,
-0.0506599322,
-0.0160789397,
0.0103365211,
0.0360543132,
0.0142973419,
-0.0157959834,
-0.0491068512,
0.0615628995,
-0.0905316994,
-0.026575515,
0.0076727532,
-0.0333120748,
0.0815055966,
0.0781645849,
0.0381432399,
-0.02423211,
-0.0268424861,
0.0159521773,
-0.0073085562,
0.0139657026,
0.0244053639,
-0.0019712162,
0.0234668404,
-0.0016675341,
-0.0042767236,
0.0233457759,
-0.0140160965,
0.0168187413,
0.0099687846,
0.0593288988,
-0.0243959669,
0.013945898,
-0.0117943101,
0.0632125884,
0.0216124337,
0.0120855467,
0.0107386876,
-0.0325716771,
-0.029870009,
0.030290857,
0.0473491251,
0.011065824,
0.0103624472,
0.0078581544,
-0.0173535012,
-0.0644790679,
-0.0154549684,
0.0010232117,
-0.0017187109,
0.0050233034,
0.0749513283,
0.0491036288,
0.073404707,
0.0395278931,
-0.0476201996,
-0.0375774242,
-0.0145599367,
0.0500933789,
-0.0535076894,
0.0015152429,
0.0361824818,
-0.0811980963,
0.000696374,
-0.0276321024,
-0.0146475974,
-0.0172340721,
0.0551080778,
-0.0174618978,
0.0208590552,
0.0516367778,
-0.0689632595,
-0.0433734022,
0.0315425619,
-0.0124639627,
-0.0744422153,
-0.0317200013,
0.0366083607,
-0.0022477016,
-0.0167772919,
-0.0198804978,
-0.05034687,
0.0169395339,
-0.0398947969,
-0.0248623416,
-0.0108070103,
-0.053527005,
0.0085731512,
0.0610139817,
0.0509898961,
-0.0394613147,
0.0305765402,
-0.0278152917,
-0.0041479012,
0.0377793498,
0.0500531159,
-0.0114841834,
-0.0080492208,
0.0419901498,
0.0450498424,
0.0022314442,
-0.0059517841,
-0.0385673828,
-0.0805005282,
0.0100136874,
0.1102742031,
0.0408188552,
0.0365329608,
0.0141102159,
0.0021967585,
-0.019778613,
-0.0026083549,
0.0495861769,
0.0101843588,
-0.0144621572,
0.0269572865,
-0.0210148934,
-0.0111131221,
0.0182906445,
0.0148123698,
0.0118618794,
0.0452472009,
-0.0099663045,
0.0603548735,
0.0541577004,
0.0148380091,
0.0229794495,
-0.0128069045,
0.0394090749,
-0.0409865156,
0.0519956909,
-0.0417381302,
0.047733292,
0.0188379064,
-0.0034189876,
-0.0379289761,
0.0291330572,
-0.0070338999,
0.0108721461,
-0.0259086266,
0.0059643923,
-0.0297305044,
-0.0277189389,
-0.0063166702,
-0.0405105278,
0.0411176793,
-0.0303989965,
-0.0288411062,
0.0179958772,
-0.0640580803,
-0.0014426623,
-0.014229957,
0.0549786203,
-0.0380586274,
0.0132537605,
-0.0182815306,
-0.0150128379,
0.0322756134,
-0.0117211407,
0.005106722,
-0.0177417062,
-0.0036643727,
0.0112977149,
-5.483399028e-33,
-0.0136538073,
0.0192621462,
-0.0115018599,
0.0272111706,
-0.0361656807,
-0.0093866121,
-0.0235581659,
0.0011007824,
0.0148361623,
-0.0102948071,
-0.0479929894,
0.010372756,
0.0333080441,
-0.0104249921,
0.0343153663,
-0.0017591905,
0.0535744838,
-0.0200838577,
0.0574735515,
-0.0222057309,
0.0331703499,
0.0521192737,
0.0454110876,
-0.0402276888,
-0.0460695401,
-0.0308196638,
-0.0212976728,
-0.0437662564,
0.015225145,
0.0068000914,
0.0028118838,
0.0309006739,
-0.0104460027,
-0.0085680205,
0.0109178973,
0.0374722518,
-0.1001096666,
0.0167978555,
0.0040255152,
0.1233802214,
-0.0250407327,
0.0172685236,
0.0365785696,
0.0173412301,
-0.0571512692,
0.0322893374,
0.0356574878,
-0.0286996588,
-0.0549300388,
-0.0569954962,
-0.0113440966,
0.0414754748,
-0.0365438685,
-0.0184928272,
0.0581150465,
0.0472368188,
-0.0237541758,
-0.0719448552,
-0.0527142696,
0.0160789099,
-0.0156535245,
0.0139108924,
0.0251428261,
0.0753511488,
-0.0156430639,
0.0000906058,
0.0482448079,
-0.1109298542,
-0.0042611039,
0.0136886807,
0.0214374736,
0.0144646084,
-0.007323883,
-0.043862544,
0.0572740398,
-0.0766318887,
-0.0310154781,
0.0166883767,
0.0503977314,
-0.0040891967,
0.0195275843,
0.0291705523,
-0.0649405047,
-0.0207805466,
0.0065418226,
-0.0296265297,
-0.0473322384,
-0.0218823962,
0.0552728809,
-0.0178462025,
-0.0068771592,
0.0161366221,
0.0146444552,
-0.0310300924,
0.0383893549,
0.0054536401,
-0.0380480066,
0.0062911883,
-0.0121773491,
0.007369637,
-0.0348863564,
-0.0356574133,
-0.0093524186,
0.0445943847,
0.0395302251,
-0.0014771682,
-0.0085068289,
0.035559468,
-0.0581234731,
-0.0029698673,
0.017285157,
0.0300737508,
0.0228745844,
0.0401437506,
0.0244627539,
-0.0493922234,
0.0051031136,
0.0358718187,
0.003758274,
0.0281555783,
0.0153860524,
-0.0003663625,
-0.0167191289,
-0.0123908166,
-0.0552313291,
0.0274781846,
-0.0131610176,
0.0573896654,
0.0197020043,
0.0033988825,
-0.0023173604,
0.0211628601,
2.74e-7,
-0.0550161563,
0.0455392748,
0.0378658101,
-0.062216673,
0.0182476006,
0.0062579201,
-0.0446821563,
-0.0034167857,
0.0224036518,
0.0538459942,
0.0099176141,
-0.0573501438,
0.0994106457,
0.0364648551,
-0.0837595239,
-0.0622378625,
-0.1012005806,
0.0414033979,
-0.0273838341,
0.06669835,
-0.0276448205,
0.0457389839,
0.0125287697,
-0.0472197942,
0.0127396453,
-0.0249130372,
0.0117612565,
-0.0086277211,
0.0173637103,
-0.0109688621,
-0.0014934832,
-0.0191553086,
-0.0231480896,
-0.021870207,
-0.0540622845,
0.0311760809,
0.0253889132,
0.0460514612,
-0.0233515706,
0.0155249089,
0.0365819223,
0.0359876864,
-0.0072745774,
0.0369291417,
0.03874157,
0.0356461816,
-0.0672289059,
-0.0230834913,
-0.0483269989,
-0.0300042313,
0.0019594454,
0.0063266996,
0.0166587103,
-0.0327064134,
-0.0319761038,
-0.0564516261,
-0.0384541191,
0.0083960388,
0.0030945197,
-0.010217228,
-0.041383557,
-0.0187213682,
-0.0000924857,
0.0114262775,
0.0424414724,
0.0310633667,
0.002328336,
1.95864634e-34,
0.0127465436,
-0.0338737555,
0.0092942026,
-0.0107443938,
0.0059161512,
-0.0125574619,
0.0278594345,
0.0405551903,
0.0202278644,
-0.0243084673,
-0.0545905381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18134v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18134v1 | Assessing "Implicit" Retrieval Robustness of Large Language Models | 2024-06-26T07:38:24 | 2024-06-26T07:38:24 | Xiaoyu Shen, Rexhina Blloshmi, Dawei Zhu, Jiahuan Pei, Wei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval-augmented generation has gained popularity as a framework to
enhance large language models with external knowledge. However, its
effectiveness hinges on the retrieval robustness of the model. If the model
lacks retrieval robustness, its performance is constrained by the accuracy of
the retriever, resulting in significant compromises when the retrieved context
is irrelevant. In this paper, we evaluate the "implicit" retrieval robustness
of various large language models, instructing them to directly output the final
answer without explicitly judging the relevance of the retrieved context. Our
findings reveal that fine-tuning on a mix of gold and distracting context
significantly enhances the model's robustness to retrieval inaccuracies, while
still maintaining its ability to extract correct answers when retrieval is
accurate. This suggests that large language models can implicitly handle
relevant or irrelevant retrieved context by learning solely from the
supervision of the final answer in an end-to-end manner. Introducing an
additional process for explicit relevance judgment can be unnecessary and
disrupts the end-to-end approach. | Assessing "Implicit" Retrieval Robustness of Large Language Models: Retrieval-augmented generation has gained popularity as a framework to
enhance large language models with external knowledge. However, its
effectiveness hinges on the retrieval robustness of the model. If the model
lacks retrieval robustness, its performance is constrained by the accuracy of
the retriever, resulting in significant compromises when the retrieved context
is irrelevant. In this paper, we evaluate the "implicit" retrieval robustness
of various large language models, instructing them to directly output the final
answer without explicitly judging the relevance of the retrieved context. Our
findings reveal that fine-tuning on a mix of gold and distracting context
significantly enhances the model's robustness to retrieval inaccuracies, while
still maintaining its ability to extract correct answers when retrieval is
accurate. This suggests that large language models can implicitly handle
relevant or irrelevant retrieved context by learning solely from the
supervision of the final answer in an end-to-end manner. Introducing an
additional process for explicit relevance judgment can be unnecessary and
disrupts the end-to-end approach. | [
0.0637866259,
0.0484694578,
-0.0221835077,
0.031572286,
-0.0278004128,
-0.0235915836,
-0.0218353104,
0.0177982561,
-0.0030334624,
-0.0705785602,
-0.0297070239,
-0.0247442238,
-0.0333563648,
0.0031294352,
0.0320084579,
-0.012664835,
0.0732079446,
-0.0374061055,
0.0147640398,
-0.0034465452,
-0.0162488073,
0.0028367452,
0.0319472812,
0.046780996,
-0.0071181534,
0.0084466487,
0.008540825,
0.0111300135,
-0.0133581208,
0.0004544743,
0.0269014761,
0.0333568268,
-0.0193660576,
0.0613168329,
0.000001852,
-0.0337830074,
-0.0293215718,
0.0084724221,
-0.0225508306,
0.0136207761,
0.0163601004,
0.0230040234,
0.0048133023,
0.0226830412,
-0.0518873967,
0.0266978554,
0.0500048883,
0.0388094932,
0.0399376228,
0.0468927324,
0.012213368,
0.0099941809,
0.0098612243,
-0.0310638417,
0.0128656765,
-0.0671819746,
0.0211828779,
0.010309522,
0.0126513643,
0.0460237339,
0.0016038112,
0.0659688637,
0.0144703761,
-0.029037945,
0.003452047,
0.0199547578,
-0.065689072,
-0.0012458026,
0.0031395531,
0.0374421887,
0.0343700871,
-0.0162678342,
-0.0194312707,
-0.0049425773,
0.0122522665,
0.0273598917,
-0.0463857502,
0.0169317927,
0.0075120428,
-0.0108552389,
0.0009461119,
0.0023012431,
0.0280259307,
0.0337567739,
-0.0079507995,
0.0435515121,
0.0392101035,
-0.0238770135,
-0.0334934965,
0.0195509177,
-0.0525229238,
-0.0462807044,
-0.0062476541,
0.0563246943,
-0.0343179107,
0.0447102338,
-0.0213993546,
-0.015398128,
0.047425732,
-0.0468996949,
0.0383773409,
0.054136131,
-0.0460540019,
0.0411587134,
-0.0510328338,
0.0307454709,
-0.0384136587,
-0.0182680469,
-0.0424198136,
-0.0295762271,
-0.0048577567,
-0.0428511649,
-0.0420164168,
0.0593937896,
-0.0348156132,
-0.0200401209,
-0.0267787799,
0.0235278159,
-0.0118462387,
-0.0055846386,
-0.0187464934,
0.0416368246,
-0.0756100267,
-0.0183726698,
-0.0164167248,
0.0194518305,
-0.0390949734,
0.0116643906,
0.0389736556,
-0.0772902817,
-0.0058861217,
-0.0150227258,
-0.0002342513,
-0.0399667174,
-0.0260788891,
0.0866928399,
-0.0145578934,
-0.0360746346,
-0.0461217277,
-0.0579869449,
-0.0487093143,
-0.0465103984,
-0.0010695169,
-0.0384623706,
-0.0033893713,
0.0192215592,
-0.0221835375,
-0.033310838,
0.0259388536,
0.0387957022,
-0.0181149207,
0.0288628675,
0.0129589327,
-0.0017838844,
0.0359348319,
0.020492807,
0.0030155454,
0.0793279856,
0.0008181338,
0.025339365,
0.0560755059,
-0.0025335148,
-0.0079717953,
0.0178892184,
0.0380537063,
0.0145855639,
-0.0459352545,
0.0227894336,
0.0248764157,
-0.0086697154,
-0.0150277643,
0.0810348094,
-0.0340015329,
-0.009671188,
0.0593563542,
0.0131295323,
0.009020119,
0.010746656,
0.0615023039,
-0.0228295717,
0.0038666956,
0.0453093313,
-0.0551599041,
0.0314245932,
-0.1004171968,
0.0126839643,
0.0485705249,
0.0101913083,
-0.0171019919,
-0.0464133658,
-0.0088276984,
0.016120635,
0.006063411,
0.026693495,
0.0703864396,
0.0270009637,
-0.0377346985,
0.0455443822,
0.0234094094,
-0.0459510796,
0.013897174,
-0.0803044215,
0.0476725772,
0.0342007577,
0.0773501098,
-0.0175213292,
-0.0031988472,
0.0346976444,
0.0029845345,
0.0327860974,
0.0600635484,
-0.0133610852,
0.0059245587,
-0.0356826708,
-0.0240047257,
-0.0121909818,
0.0302297473,
0.0132890139,
0.0612132959,
-0.0051236232,
0.0499681719,
-0.0150925266,
0.0144016631,
0.0273149293,
-0.0454881564,
-0.0580426455,
-0.0085648624,
-0.0178832803,
-0.0088741817,
0.0045217122,
-0.0102955084,
0.0430005752,
0.0265901089,
-0.0053425077,
-0.0296092536,
-0.0362260565,
-0.0708643496,
0.0207423214,
0.0210972391,
0.0373699479,
0.0007328123,
0.0044064173,
-0.006356502,
-0.03059089,
0.0367557853,
-0.0512628667,
0.0793031752,
-0.0546292365,
0.0163620207,
0.0083203455,
0.0095837861,
-0.0495189466,
0.06243724,
-0.001741722,
0.0202103406,
0.0316109769,
0.0427656174,
0.0066016992,
-0.0762603581,
-0.0215384029,
0.0175257958,
-0.0210029837,
0.0318238959,
0.064566426,
-0.0264303461,
-0.0438628793,
-0.0287354365,
-0.0716189146,
-0.014348763,
-0.0258177798,
-0.0295956526,
0.0182373971,
0.0267547201,
0.0061773648,
-0.0172464699,
-0.001906881,
0.0047557838,
0.0342846066,
0.0433350876,
-0.0088923359,
0.0344700404,
0.007596245,
-0.0642661154,
-0.0352831595,
0.0155693972,
0.053957846,
0.0010099675,
0.005279304,
-0.0326082073,
0.0308814477,
-0.0709075555,
0.0417359322,
-0.0024802506,
-0.0290050264,
0.014742245,
-0.0532619208,
0.0228896309,
0.0509607904,
0.0338491946,
0.006247228,
0.0525855981,
-0.0478017889,
-0.0797030702,
0.012930573,
-0.0294628795,
-0.0929230079,
0.0070435344,
-0.0053025214,
-0.0134349186,
0.0439772494,
0.0086788237,
-0.012408969,
-0.0590272658,
0.0346246585,
-0.0375780277,
-0.0547422022,
-0.0394141227,
-0.0263565257,
-0.0243969988,
0.0567980856,
-0.0283016767,
-0.0607383065,
0.0748794228,
-0.0193755403,
0.0167788044,
0.002406999,
0.0034509716,
-0.0143826464,
0.0538097844,
-0.0333738141,
0.0346981511,
-0.0143600376,
-0.0173513833,
-0.0534218289,
-0.045472458,
0.0297990069,
-0.0678262413,
0.0720042214,
-0.0468899459,
0.0307063982,
0.003105964,
-0.0407201275,
-0.0785257071,
-0.0316896476,
-0.0011817085,
0.0362587832,
-0.013396061,
-0.0037616491,
-0.0361181386,
0.0023660953,
0.0488110818,
0.0153006036,
-0.03071866,
-0.0212903284,
-0.0087981867,
0.0519231893,
0.0800660104,
-0.0043235812,
0.0198540296,
-0.040429458,
0.0015420779,
0.0626782775,
0.0075155832,
-0.0209465623,
-0.0068525826,
-0.0026191974,
0.0437828079,
-0.0130906906,
-0.0182486344,
0.0380862206,
0.03156377,
-0.0661758259,
-0.0516900867,
0.0618551113,
0.0397208966,
-0.0352448635,
-0.0095919119,
-0.0494429171,
0.0139422631,
0.0249807872,
0.0504340827,
-0.0411029346,
-0.0166577213,
0.034261886,
0.0372127667,
-0.0146132531,
-0.021678865,
-0.0183945671,
-0.1632450372,
0.0315887183,
0.0062434967,
-0.0295609608,
-0.0341145806,
-0.0179344807,
0.0229315627,
0.0264996421,
0.0351854227,
0.0497527085,
-0.0027956055,
-0.0124983983,
0.0065035177,
0.0394680724,
-0.0497367494,
0.0153575595,
0.0040808651,
0.0280713737,
0.0877607539,
0.0020415005,
0.0192414429,
-0.0019533578,
0.0608247519,
-0.0420985483,
0.0204997603,
-0.0039153034,
0.0334363766,
0.008649555,
0.004298964,
-0.013680283,
-0.0142801646,
0.0274900217,
-0.0208807345,
-0.006395,
0.0428153425,
-0.0068302276,
0.0112432195,
-0.0457805283,
0.0033890624,
0.0286405552,
0.0629645884,
0.0217254087,
-0.0093186572,
-0.0177061763,
-0.0277451985,
0.0043325112,
-0.0218934435,
-0.0363963321,
0.0109386379,
0.013106944,
0.0285120029,
-0.0696611032,
-0.0445299335,
-0.0200249907,
0.0207815878,
-0.0033895567,
0.0065673864,
-0.0532680899,
0.004123345,
-0.0215028077,
0.0304839555,
-0.0600427538,
0.0028807572,
-0.0356108993,
0.0106289051,
0.0186953843,
-0.0601258427,
-0.0129246321,
0.0623410493,
-0.017306963,
-0.0657094792,
0.0097095482,
0.0522569343,
0.0323476084,
0.0403490439,
-0.0180132054,
-0.0601035133,
0.0318130814,
0.0167627465,
-0.0605822466,
0.0201851279,
0.0084419409,
0.0050978907,
-0.0137414224,
0.0479712375,
-0.0968196988,
0.0249623749,
0.0178422667,
0.0756326094,
0.0178326517,
-0.0384190381,
0.0410280898,
0.0213873107,
0.012630498,
0.0024101238,
0.0127554778,
-0.0090071214,
0.0136106452,
-0.0442854948,
-0.0263215005,
-0.0283905584,
0.0314517803,
-0.000015827,
-0.0173639823,
0.0057782847,
-0.0177222695,
0.0100813741,
0.0787117407,
-0.0371886045,
-0.0227984749,
0.0022948636,
-0.0004458348,
0.0280023105,
0.016953934,
-0.0311106388,
0.0162273087,
0.0007363259,
0.0584380813,
-0.0353046805,
0.0588567555,
0.0194096249,
-0.0158798955,
-0.0322937854,
0.0034793192,
-0.0935699716,
-0.0325319804,
-0.0473451726,
0.0116051584,
0.0464373045,
-0.027778551,
0.0457294621,
-0.0152798966,
-0.0403905585,
-0.0308321435,
-0.0033331816,
0.0508920699,
-0.0599234253,
0.014404282,
0.0313011222,
0.0070708659,
0.0388578251,
0.0464960746,
-0.0209427215,
0.0366114937,
-0.0518477,
-0.0046488503,
-0.0238838363,
-0.0352502391,
0.0211096872,
0.028531149,
-0.020069804,
0.0133565944,
-0.0624487735,
-0.0969160348,
-0.0231530294,
0.0149575835,
-0.0123130735,
-0.0177724306,
0.0304016154,
0.0893177316,
0.0226827133,
-0.0204963312,
-0.0489382595,
0.0250025727,
-0.0517205931,
0.0231125113,
-0.0472052172,
-6.567278288e-33,
-0.0599010661,
-0.0370650664,
0.0113456827,
-0.0636719316,
-0.0136728594,
0.0304945447,
-0.0782734379,
-0.0017483353,
-0.0336745791,
-0.0157616138,
-0.0305838566,
0.0227268673,
0.0054168291,
0.0089636371,
0.0117105013,
-0.0051673548,
0.0387218595,
0.0141694816,
-0.0380723886,
0.0326613523,
0.054593727,
0.0151518667,
0.0170908831,
-0.060192436,
0.0318854824,
0.0010302782,
0.0037503135,
0.017815154,
-0.0244000796,
0.0887215808,
-0.0237766597,
0.0570210218,
-0.0028976745,
-0.003224208,
-0.0246739499,
0.0023520929,
-0.0646867007,
-0.0248516072,
0.0139076905,
-0.0353290103,
-0.0360427089,
-0.0248101018,
0.0240121633,
-0.0179079566,
-0.0156352445,
-0.0114734489,
0.0221879706,
-0.0180647187,
-0.0314372331,
-0.0246143006,
-0.0659405366,
0.0208886638,
0.0198943,
0.0015219693,
-0.0021465905,
0.05538892,
0.0287552532,
0.0367168225,
-0.0027294676,
0.0240746345,
0.0147851435,
0.0549770407,
0.0463769659,
0.0363558382,
-0.0183272231,
0.0410020649,
0.0072656395,
0.0109988526,
-0.0063014068,
-0.0891805962,
0.0151387062,
0.0231570527,
0.0473016128,
0.0630016848,
0.015163634,
-0.0052883271,
-0.0308563057,
0.0025005557,
-0.0078779077,
0.0397667699,
0.0633148551,
0.006213563,
-0.0337904952,
-0.0084218243,
-0.0501307547,
0.0067290822,
-0.0619506538,
-0.02817812,
0.0633532703,
0.0397484601,
-0.0225724932,
-0.0126216579,
0.0408552326,
-0.0445489362,
0.0087237535,
0.0541004986,
-0.018901227,
-0.0073894602,
-0.0158510376,
0.0362844579,
-0.0102014365,
-0.0146970572,
0.0163557287,
-0.0180948488,
-0.0443121977,
0.0111951167,
-0.0083431611,
0.0225583464,
-0.0558456592,
0.0171402395,
-0.0426887125,
0.0389091745,
-0.0079097198,
-0.0384489857,
0.0415055864,
0.0138811413,
-0.0051830062,
0.0525129735,
0.0344937891,
0.0296637975,
-0.0117020998,
-0.0283609461,
0.0205692723,
0.0069248751,
-0.0255162548,
0.0189960487,
-0.0190131906,
0.0623949356,
0.020384144,
-0.0089002214,
-0.0183422789,
0.0172689836,
2.634e-7,
0.0576716587,
0.0137982508,
0.0269836746,
0.0170572996,
-0.0076608532,
0.0140982978,
-0.0126480572,
-0.0019275605,
0.05455992,
0.0141200218,
-0.0194426812,
0.0353262164,
0.0457272381,
0.0241442602,
-0.0375442989,
0.0115255769,
-0.0770479888,
-0.0016540758,
-0.0155974953,
-0.0130671645,
0.050236918,
0.0759602785,
-0.0095584048,
0.0032526043,
-0.0375857092,
-0.0838722363,
0.0856659114,
-0.01251119,
-0.004157647,
0.0062015667,
0.0299022533,
0.0470403582,
0.022706233,
-0.0235962756,
-0.0086550834,
0.016877614,
0.0080650691,
0.0486004688,
0.003711794,
-0.047926303,
-0.0228536129,
-0.0114411954,
0.0206718538,
-0.0606751144,
0.0581561886,
-0.0525242165,
-0.0102619128,
-0.0245598573,
-0.0316158645,
-0.0086097922,
-0.0053279204,
-0.0182410888,
-0.0399862826,
0.007224285,
-0.0028515025,
0.0515294373,
-0.0089420974,
-0.0996159762,
-0.0479449704,
0.0129642794,
-0.0442187563,
-0.0595819391,
-0.0257905927,
0.0169010572,
-0.0275827684,
-0.0601570308,
0.0155995358,
2.469057237e-34,
0.0431611277,
0.0028628069,
0.0151047977,
0.0103612086,
0.03899597,
0.0009704345,
0.004885097,
0.0256470796,
0.0391152427,
-0.0843251646,
-0.0427396931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18133v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18133v1 | ConvoCache: Smart Re-Use of Chatbot Responses | 2024-06-26T07:35:10 | 2024-06-26T07:35:10 | Conor Atkins, Ian Wood, Mohamed Ali Kaafar, Hassan Asghar, Nardine Basta, Michal Kepkowski | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present ConvoCache, a conversational caching system that solves the
problem of slow and expensive generative AI models in spoken chatbots.
ConvoCache finds a semantically similar prompt in the past and reuses the
response. In this paper we evaluate ConvoCache on the DailyDialog dataset. We
find that ConvoCache can apply a UniEval coherence threshold of 90% and respond
to 89% of prompts using the cache with an average latency of 214ms, replacing
LLM and voice synthesis that can take over 1s. To further reduce latency we
test prefetching and find limited usefulness. Prefetching with 80% of a request
leads to a 63% hit rate, and a drop in overall coherence. ConvoCache can be
used with any chatbot to reduce costs by reducing usage of generative AI by up
to 89%. | ConvoCache: Smart Re-Use of Chatbot Responses: We present ConvoCache, a conversational caching system that solves the
problem of slow and expensive generative AI models in spoken chatbots.
ConvoCache finds a semantically similar prompt in the past and reuses the
response. In this paper we evaluate ConvoCache on the DailyDialog dataset. We
find that ConvoCache can apply a UniEval coherence threshold of 90% and respond
to 89% of prompts using the cache with an average latency of 214ms, replacing
LLM and voice synthesis that can take over 1s. To further reduce latency we
test prefetching and find limited usefulness. Prefetching with 80% of a request
leads to a 63% hit rate, and a drop in overall coherence. ConvoCache can be
used with any chatbot to reduce costs by reducing usage of generative AI by up
to 89%. | [
0.042297367,
0.052087009,
-0.00990922,
-0.0195653047,
-0.0210927557,
-0.0234667417,
0.0384964906,
-0.0074972976,
0.0587018579,
-0.0198166184,
-0.0051700594,
-0.0372155868,
-0.028010536,
0.0667610243,
-0.015606028,
-0.0534453616,
0.0445494913,
-0.0200503059,
0.0219876468,
-0.0195069648,
-0.0081437165,
-0.0134353871,
-0.0141545627,
0.0781571195,
-0.0665963665,
-0.0494297221,
-0.0413839035,
0.0274001658,
-0.0000696364,
-0.0138037922,
-0.0128750373,
0.0178621039,
-0.019910166,
0.022992922,
0.0000022169,
-0.044013001,
-0.0215429496,
-0.0122219464,
-0.0765406415,
-0.0018083997,
0.0150916176,
0.0439207479,
-0.0589573421,
0.0454899631,
-0.0307893269,
0.0421984866,
0.0453416184,
-0.008295333,
0.0621110126,
0.0843140632,
-0.0227994528,
0.0028065457,
0.0218585059,
0.0125753433,
0.006741839,
-0.0640356019,
-0.0346821621,
0.0029273271,
0.0025423821,
-0.0391032062,
-0.0221008789,
0.0467694253,
0.037296664,
-0.0328216441,
0.0029798048,
0.0170362927,
-0.0503895208,
-0.0432456471,
-0.017624924,
0.0529091172,
-0.0015202941,
0.0058640093,
0.0192491617,
0.0058077089,
0.0142156351,
-0.032434009,
-0.0205541924,
-0.0014095168,
-0.036644578,
-0.0181666669,
-0.0462378487,
-0.0048487489,
-0.0219660718,
-0.018154392,
-0.0155775808,
-0.0352819934,
0.0209797025,
-0.0143736117,
-0.044972524,
-0.0025589759,
0.0288986303,
-0.0682414323,
0.0064906767,
0.0582821593,
-0.0809125677,
-0.0008493111,
-0.0608138405,
0.0059816749,
0.006210696,
-0.0194964055,
0.0035160591,
0.0561930239,
-0.0425453037,
0.0049426816,
-0.008175238,
0.0477129482,
0.0024221258,
-0.0369763933,
-0.0332239717,
-0.0267178789,
-0.0400328562,
-0.0149044842,
-0.0629696622,
0.0428138897,
0.019835664,
-0.0461978763,
-0.055761639,
0.0605593994,
-0.0177312773,
-0.0013346878,
-0.0087094223,
0.0274301954,
-0.0369175449,
0.0150431069,
-0.0235352702,
-0.0029036738,
-0.0410731472,
-0.0041466039,
0.0181162395,
-0.1416526437,
-0.006305811,
0.002509447,
0.0201858934,
0.0215233322,
0.0072208513,
0.0694490075,
-0.0219428726,
-0.0260056313,
-0.0134938341,
-0.061115101,
0.0292200707,
-0.0630600974,
-0.0244527739,
-0.0394753292,
0.0008355248,
-0.031136889,
-0.0002892095,
0.0170460753,
-0.0230509043,
0.0046594432,
0.0026934212,
0.0051700561,
0.0088342577,
0.0366753042,
0.028923599,
0.0086163851,
0.0132381096,
0.0270077735,
0.031579148,
0.0175235253,
0.030659413,
-0.027313726,
0.0327157453,
0.0077453093,
0.0141497515,
-0.0156477373,
0.0184483081,
-0.0017106921,
-0.0185763892,
0.0397790894,
0.0211383402,
0.0191963799,
-0.0445319563,
-0.0111366715,
0.0616949201,
0.0596705042,
-0.0001299437,
-0.0025228949,
0.0353291444,
0.0344557837,
0.0264243763,
0.004359873,
-0.0246839151,
0.033897236,
-0.022346966,
0.0107033709,
0.0262872651,
0.0228674449,
-0.0646316037,
-0.0337670408,
0.0425655395,
-0.0372440442,
-0.0136644188,
0.0298105385,
0.0061568972,
0.0137752388,
-0.0505646616,
-0.0253076125,
-0.0290891994,
-0.0749787837,
-0.0696584284,
-0.0513449684,
0.0156677328,
0.117616564,
0.0473900549,
0.0227784105,
-0.038268134,
0.0274866503,
-0.0209376346,
0.0300537795,
0.0359961428,
-0.0083136298,
0.0343409628,
-0.0239187554,
0.0005106286,
0.0173821282,
-0.0169603787,
0.0516331755,
0.0080230404,
0.0218621995,
-0.0135945342,
0.0900944546,
0.0581182986,
-0.0080668377,
-0.0086237192,
-0.0057070092,
0.001467062,
-0.0033047164,
0.0730031729,
0.027546512,
-0.0205294844,
-0.0066440748,
0.0045021367,
-0.0106226485,
-0.0191711392,
0.0545217767,
-0.0696885884,
-0.0220783837,
0.0299060009,
-0.0146865742,
-0.0077393027,
0.0296335984,
-0.0147332903,
-0.0499655716,
0.0428155959,
-0.0377530567,
0.0683347434,
-0.0233442429,
0.0377846099,
-0.0041512814,
0.0263537113,
0.0254099835,
0.0154592646,
0.0151904188,
-0.0201517679,
0.0379578769,
0.0794920623,
0.0010325037,
-0.0682948455,
0.0309538543,
0.0403684974,
-0.026675947,
0.0327764824,
0.0085703833,
0.01320644,
-0.0549376421,
-0.0197916701,
-0.1135748178,
-0.0031125932,
0.0229328424,
-0.0443885401,
-0.0082928324,
0.003264958,
-0.0122631369,
-0.0348626003,
-0.0334124565,
0.0304356404,
0.0353219919,
0.0320265703,
-0.0183575284,
-0.0386469699,
-0.0537179075,
-0.0481211357,
0.0226224922,
0.0496734828,
0.0050489986,
-0.0027430046,
-0.0080080507,
-0.0278040711,
0.0068788049,
-0.0371424146,
0.0296866,
0.0036558891,
-0.0625898466,
0.0384859107,
0.0088401018,
0.0410970263,
0.0590730272,
0.0506649539,
-0.0098120803,
0.0023703824,
-0.0142309209,
-0.0801803097,
0.0181658138,
0.0086185979,
-0.0351481847,
-0.0117310798,
-0.0121139446,
0.0077406932,
0.0362359248,
0.0212864839,
0.0111388629,
-0.0402695313,
0.0251334198,
0.0278269891,
-0.0561508462,
-0.013109819,
0.001981911,
-0.053300567,
0.023821814,
0.0150195062,
-0.0588805936,
0.0318976864,
-0.0111374706,
-0.0092391828,
-0.0003012336,
-0.0422100984,
0.0045728218,
0.0524896309,
-0.017762756,
0.0286468267,
0.0186404642,
-0.0191769414,
-0.0315635838,
0.0023404749,
0.0136574833,
-0.0771695152,
-0.0083900224,
0.0052176928,
0.003511868,
0.0099060843,
-0.0477266014,
-0.0879783556,
-0.0090692881,
-0.0378861092,
-0.0080114091,
0.0405591168,
-0.0426780879,
-0.0297355931,
0.0061060051,
-0.0074467734,
0.042137064,
-0.0021004134,
-0.0216312483,
-0.0101291696,
-0.0067909313,
0.038128227,
0.0720116571,
-0.0063447799,
0.0385687165,
0.0684500784,
0.0622357279,
0.0608534366,
-0.0140665863,
-0.0371942669,
-0.0036265024,
0.0213903915,
0.0226990934,
-0.0038419864,
0.020366827,
0.0319055319,
-0.0408307761,
-0.0122290952,
0.0782185495,
-0.0072072563,
-0.0063592247,
0.0117979906,
-0.0128589282,
0.042029608,
0.0150527488,
0.0332320817,
-0.0701638982,
-0.043725457,
0.0644469261,
0.0418296009,
-0.0519700013,
-0.0102505684,
-0.0207346082,
-0.1297663301,
0.0238435064,
-0.0142282983,
0.0040805666,
0.0012759614,
-0.0254562572,
-0.028215792,
0.0127675114,
0.0009835272,
0.0112689091,
0.026412122,
-0.0108001847,
0.0030159319,
-0.0456966422,
0.0150509933,
0.0177866314,
-0.0157534629,
0.1002192497,
0.0747507289,
0.0591260456,
0.05983942,
0.0027754877,
0.0155677386,
0.0231966693,
0.0120454943,
0.0042831413,
0.0372664817,
0.0259691272,
-0.0168308485,
-0.0125720818,
0.0286806319,
-0.00361257,
0.0062088878,
0.0197834522,
-0.0077490821,
-0.0423640236,
-0.0065348805,
-0.024982905,
0.0441024788,
0.0284210499,
0.0551034957,
0.0265552886,
-0.0381417833,
-0.0603156202,
-0.011725123,
0.0153239863,
-0.0453603119,
-0.0636228323,
-0.0138675468,
-0.00759529,
-0.0390676968,
-0.0764698684,
-0.015105919,
-0.0446241647,
0.0440390408,
0.0023460665,
-0.0086808428,
0.012224392,
0.0332888365,
0.0030806619,
-0.0192939546,
-0.0323191024,
-0.0088135423,
-0.0779411048,
-0.0225482993,
0.0282018129,
-0.05092711,
-0.0195710454,
0.0467529818,
-0.0384007879,
-0.0447352342,
0.0278551914,
0.0269516855,
0.0288195256,
0.0404188335,
-0.0051542013,
-0.0178006589,
0.0312613957,
0.0573746264,
-0.0691331252,
0.0282587763,
0.0634330958,
0.0442460515,
-0.0084451251,
0.0252084211,
-0.0758958906,
0.0567671284,
-0.029792374,
0.0312491562,
-0.0085313683,
-0.0609575659,
0.0087113595,
0.0552978218,
0.0042001358,
0.0081521524,
0.0248752981,
0.0149998916,
0.0544841997,
-0.0005894556,
0.0232373998,
-0.0502123274,
0.0064182524,
-0.0131856333,
-0.0270125754,
0.0225971639,
0.0148444287,
-0.0244215578,
0.0196771696,
0.0238779373,
-0.0374228135,
-0.0164742172,
-0.0056388718,
0.0107567711,
-0.0105230641,
-0.000801302,
0.0385574177,
0.0149411727,
0.0082530072,
0.0036306735,
-0.0094909482,
-0.0038108355,
0.0059209676,
-0.0099646216,
0.0199365821,
-0.0877277032,
-0.1001562998,
0.0276818015,
0.0430671461,
0.0405189246,
0.0280095004,
0.0468965769,
-0.0246654917,
0.0382110626,
-0.0430050753,
0.0430287234,
0.0340992995,
-0.0259180386,
-0.0387402959,
0.0066995556,
-0.035280481,
-0.0031031903,
0.0562207848,
-0.0595546514,
0.0688666627,
-0.0424622111,
0.0046345056,
-0.0513304658,
-0.0509842187,
-0.0346924476,
-0.0046855109,
0.0201112386,
-0.0322369374,
-0.0425582901,
-0.0289344303,
-0.0316769183,
0.0008887121,
-0.0021860262,
-0.0166482832,
0.0431627966,
0.019418668,
-0.0063206013,
0.0028463409,
-0.0316975303,
0.0120234052,
-0.0362795219,
-0.0134314904,
0.0348090567,
-6.671868632e-33,
-0.0178967677,
-0.0051239068,
0.0299636535,
-0.0070998757,
-0.0399569534,
0.0213197507,
-0.0556195453,
-0.0039897272,
-0.0234980229,
-0.0289699193,
-0.0390702337,
0.0227296613,
0.0321411677,
0.0035225118,
-0.0227571893,
-0.0028634847,
0.0816059634,
-0.0177524164,
-0.0104787378,
0.0560805127,
0.0813356638,
0.0276107509,
-0.033434812,
-0.0724421516,
-0.0436975211,
-0.0184340812,
0.0126273455,
-0.0087683676,
0.0318309665,
0.0229242388,
-0.0065115723,
0.0430847071,
-0.0168501735,
-0.0268199462,
-0.0266904477,
0.034369573,
-0.0529184043,
-0.0333079174,
-0.0133433519,
-0.0066250502,
-0.0048094848,
-0.0350121446,
-0.0116966292,
0.0254650749,
-0.0387892537,
0.0056060203,
0.0118365474,
-0.0138842538,
-0.0324959382,
-0.0241000038,
-0.0633766428,
0.012503067,
-0.0358970687,
-0.0655581132,
0.004312058,
0.0928729922,
0.0090928646,
0.0065605803,
-0.0292677861,
0.0450527668,
-0.0259768795,
0.0215393156,
0.0148457391,
0.0158627145,
0.0395432487,
0.0735634267,
0.0710446239,
-0.0000571414,
-0.0265022777,
0.0057167346,
0.0273442455,
0.0268919393,
0.0142890764,
0.0307802539,
0.0658911839,
-0.0646174327,
0.000997415,
0.0221945681,
0.0601383038,
-0.000411051,
0.0409274139,
0.0152309621,
-0.0378839672,
0.0175741203,
-0.0216082819,
0.0362852067,
-0.0113271037,
-0.0364531465,
0.0303952992,
0.0471790954,
-0.0062374091,
-0.0640881211,
0.064363189,
-0.0212780591,
0.038451992,
0.0441914015,
-0.0290617868,
0.0145466095,
-0.0064906804,
0.0164298583,
0.0102426773,
-0.0253347382,
0.0816877186,
0.0178288519,
0.0395790562,
0.0153587209,
-0.0063621877,
0.0444341153,
-0.0480143912,
0.0007020804,
-0.0371517316,
0.0504257195,
-0.0092814993,
-0.0329086743,
0.0223254412,
-0.0099563235,
-0.0213322826,
0.0419909097,
-0.0216514524,
0.0108479857,
-0.0383474864,
-0.0309024304,
0.0065488606,
-0.0049675545,
-0.0391094126,
0.0293260161,
-0.0510109626,
0.015803108,
0.02676351,
-0.0694296956,
-0.0422897562,
-0.0240686052,
3.028e-7,
-0.0741809532,
0.0090365699,
0.0251795575,
0.0367001593,
0.0360606015,
0.0432470553,
0.0099327574,
0.0256298725,
-0.019220341,
0.0049916268,
-0.0136346593,
0.0243327748,
0.0818542764,
0.0167171787,
-0.0802821666,
-0.0180865414,
-0.0954768881,
-0.0206357427,
-0.0276375841,
0.0020497255,
0.0314936191,
0.0674776435,
0.0182506386,
-0.0504739285,
0.0825833157,
0.0114814136,
0.0094029577,
-0.0344542414,
-0.0005362374,
0.0168507099,
0.0515873544,
0.035609141,
0.025950104,
-0.0181836206,
-0.0094654104,
-0.0376065224,
-0.0088419812,
0.0395664237,
0.0291885938,
-0.0787735209,
0.0235953312,
0.0034995864,
-0.0048677358,
0.0161479749,
0.0619008653,
0.0041800872,
-0.0297216438,
-0.0577629358,
0.0055020889,
-0.0188701544,
0.0157945156,
-0.0216843244,
-0.0074573336,
0.0162762124,
-0.0158365015,
-0.0052819946,
0.0166983232,
-0.0636825785,
-0.001430257,
-0.0107015269,
-0.0659138113,
-0.057037428,
-0.0416239016,
-0.0029998259,
0.0337957777,
-0.0078212386,
0.0186734404,
2.418856052e-34,
0.0297720786,
0.0215634927,
0.0261789728,
0.0711520165,
0.0177611429,
0.0023938171,
0.0763394013,
0.0059383428,
0.0350028723,
-0.0207803752,
-0.0370906554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18125v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18125v1 | ResumeAtlas: Revisiting Resume Classification with Large-Scale Datasets and Large Language Models | 2024-06-26T07:25:18 | 2024-06-26T07:25:18 | Ahmed Heakl, Youssef Mohamed, Noran Mohamed, Ali Sharkaway, Ahmed Zaky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | The increasing reliance on online recruitment platforms coupled with the
adoption of AI technologies has highlighted the critical need for efficient
resume classification methods. However, challenges such as small datasets, lack
of standardized resume templates, and privacy concerns hinder the accuracy and
effectiveness of existing classification models. In this work, we address these
challenges by presenting a comprehensive approach to resume classification. We
curated a large-scale dataset of 13,389 resumes from diverse sources and
employed Large Language Models (LLMs) such as BERT and Gemma1.1 2B for
classification. Our results demonstrate significant improvements over
traditional machine learning approaches, with our best model achieving a top-1
accuracy of 92\% and a top-5 accuracy of 97.5\%. These findings underscore the
importance of dataset quality and advanced model architectures in enhancing the
accuracy and robustness of resume classification systems, thus advancing the
field of online recruitment practices. | ResumeAtlas: Revisiting Resume Classification with Large-Scale Datasets and Large Language Models: The increasing reliance on online recruitment platforms coupled with the
adoption of AI technologies has highlighted the critical need for efficient
resume classification methods. However, challenges such as small datasets, lack
of standardized resume templates, and privacy concerns hinder the accuracy and
effectiveness of existing classification models. In this work, we address these
challenges by presenting a comprehensive approach to resume classification. We
curated a large-scale dataset of 13,389 resumes from diverse sources and
employed Large Language Models (LLMs) such as BERT and Gemma1.1 2B for
classification. Our results demonstrate significant improvements over
traditional machine learning approaches, with our best model achieving a top-1
accuracy of 92\% and a top-5 accuracy of 97.5\%. These findings underscore the
importance of dataset quality and advanced model architectures in enhancing the
accuracy and robustness of resume classification systems, thus advancing the
field of online recruitment practices. | [
0.07708361,
0.0724467635,
-0.0141169736,
-0.0418792516,
-0.0144148571,
-0.0076582255,
0.0064482698,
0.031351652,
0.0182192773,
-0.0748523846,
0.0108159399,
-0.0397926793,
0.0165927447,
-0.0344133675,
-0.0087752901,
0.0174208358,
-0.0017559879,
0.0306077208,
-0.0113873184,
0.0075125573,
-0.0320330523,
0.0835129544,
0.0141774965,
0.0845582411,
0.0133139417,
-0.0275614168,
0.0461424328,
0.023233043,
0.0235203654,
0.0334212333,
0.0607751831,
0.0487110056,
0.0013408862,
0.0375973433,
0.0000016445,
-0.0350695886,
0.0045176046,
0.021321075,
-0.0595995337,
-0.0362647995,
0.044819098,
0.0116575072,
0.0192066226,
0.0375566632,
-0.0287801046,
0.0127738323,
0.0283907466,
0.0000553594,
0.0478639901,
0.0532665178,
0.0065940791,
-0.0403595902,
0.0149307931,
-0.0135811409,
0.0233756583,
0.0069253868,
0.0516319983,
-0.0901454613,
0.0101486687,
-0.0125839226,
0.0198007692,
0.0006182001,
-0.0773367062,
-0.0596111231,
0.0101761576,
0.0078692846,
-0.0538816378,
-0.0143817542,
0.0347672105,
0.0105268536,
-0.0200517718,
-0.0357611515,
-0.0196959078,
-0.0297796093,
0.0355181545,
0.0257023405,
-0.0125379264,
0.0365112387,
-0.0450215973,
-0.0167749319,
-0.0241164006,
-0.0065687858,
0.0156148449,
0.028177578,
0.0055276346,
0.035886392,
-0.0178902969,
-0.024807876,
0.0441610478,
0.0154093793,
0.0705379471,
-0.0490544625,
0.0539024547,
-0.0013305161,
-0.0324396975,
-0.0093948338,
-0.0227651577,
-0.0095778313,
0.0528116189,
-0.0485737808,
-0.0115029672,
-0.0120538566,
-0.0359246843,
0.0309113823,
-0.0080725159,
0.0259983055,
0.0209250208,
-0.0173723344,
0.0073001957,
-0.012631014,
-0.1131870821,
-0.0289330408,
-0.0196081661,
0.0066140071,
0.0219911505,
0.0396528617,
-0.0793964937,
0.0139601193,
-0.0335741453,
0.0062694033,
0.0565937422,
0.010652123,
-0.0168203562,
0.0323723592,
-0.0603781044,
-0.0418934338,
0.0633598492,
-0.0026746965,
-0.0272850636,
-0.052237317,
0.0650736019,
-0.0075217239,
0.0217477176,
-0.0314133428,
0.0322017819,
0.0079276701,
0.0481641777,
-0.0317621008,
-0.0364521891,
-0.0225843024,
0.0266205296,
-0.0463854447,
-0.0453865752,
-0.0118193179,
0.0357884951,
0.0038147795,
-0.0193186663,
-0.0551080257,
0.0331116319,
0.0407162644,
-0.0061299801,
0.0342317037,
0.0071169389,
0.010306525,
0.0760439038,
-0.026547147,
-0.0091300383,
0.0251969676,
-0.0010038512,
0.0784483999,
0.04099999,
-0.0318783186,
0.0615539029,
0.0632092282,
-0.0285947323,
-0.034652181,
-0.025116479,
0.0704069659,
-0.0056784167,
0.0140807265,
0.013614485,
-0.0001952965,
-0.0117842136,
0.0029305785,
0.0437153056,
0.0540285967,
-0.0082908254,
0.0206346586,
0.0364794023,
0.0619014911,
0.0034805438,
-0.0739533231,
-0.0118288854,
-0.0143007506,
-0.0158437286,
-0.0506333448,
-0.0374540389,
0.0323402397,
-0.0348284766,
-0.0072458023,
-0.0194992535,
-0.0379355736,
-0.0209021736,
0.0312764943,
0.0036553475,
-0.006246774,
-0.0330362804,
0.0085776122,
0.0264025889,
-0.0389563851,
-0.0126954783,
-0.0608898588,
-0.0069690179,
0.0780083686,
0.0464158021,
-0.0332653634,
-0.0389366932,
-0.076881513,
-0.0152183129,
0.0114617208,
0.0549118668,
-0.0254142024,
0.0266140103,
-0.0288344268,
-0.0270601101,
0.0593639687,
-0.0099157514,
0.013814101,
0.0309915151,
0.0223261267,
0.032706961,
-0.0273974538,
-0.0493551791,
0.0406938903,
0.0043889582,
-0.0325991213,
0.0712075382,
0.0447423384,
-0.0115993628,
0.0162267014,
-0.0074320962,
-0.0032579985,
-0.0067401682,
-0.0055232085,
-0.0202330519,
-0.0341718234,
0.0351369195,
0.0072165374,
-0.0206804518,
0.0491166636,
-0.0552546158,
0.0350811034,
-0.0302447416,
0.0059410469,
-0.0409248173,
0.0111608561,
0.0253831986,
-0.0614010245,
0.0279366616,
-0.0426475406,
0.0302933156,
-0.0455610342,
0.0654507875,
0.0400937498,
0.0341591872,
-0.0063934745,
-0.0675677732,
0.0130473124,
-0.1199088097,
-0.0092332829,
-0.0179551914,
-0.0208705254,
0.0104989847,
-0.0039742752,
0.0078535061,
-0.028593732,
-0.0444171093,
-0.0799847543,
0.0352074169,
0.0256548356,
0.0233423878,
-0.0339502394,
-0.0023435103,
0.0060785022,
-0.004931896,
-0.0468190014,
-0.0201174356,
0.0070950417,
0.0210243613,
0.0347952917,
-0.0396254808,
-0.0349316485,
-0.0181827508,
-0.0337376744,
-0.0012007087,
0.0363801979,
0.0203074925,
0.002072752,
-0.0577390753,
-0.0326668769,
-0.0168197583,
0.0073801666,
0.0327976272,
-0.0174463373,
-0.0493810885,
-0.0152072171,
-0.0337271504,
0.0419559702,
-0.0029307383,
0.0175158381,
0.0207417067,
0.0609015748,
0.0066564865,
-0.0051303934,
0.0085933954,
0.0129506495,
-0.0312469341,
-0.0422250442,
-0.0345822684,
-0.0484764352,
0.0191664975,
-0.0390079431,
-0.0101407785,
0.0263935477,
0.0045951786,
0.0039359913,
-0.0739081427,
-0.014315797,
-0.0106219705,
0.0115475086,
0.0027561297,
-0.0123180468,
0.0090434626,
-0.0055168895,
0.0266103353,
0.0069475393,
-0.0819947794,
-0.0420663245,
0.0596692786,
-0.0021679588,
0.0096729416,
-0.0064578885,
-0.0366783403,
-0.0174067412,
-0.0292504765,
-0.0174774919,
-0.045695059,
-0.0383495763,
0.0215780232,
0.0165894162,
0.0159263927,
-0.0318740159,
-0.0678297281,
-0.0614786148,
-0.0280130934,
0.0286224112,
-0.0026401361,
0.0020092647,
-0.0813598633,
-0.0261266548,
-0.0287661813,
0.0392150916,
-0.0121525545,
-0.0470549166,
-0.0096350638,
0.0437949412,
-0.0002703127,
0.020822145,
0.002808491,
-0.0056673884,
-0.0268136635,
-0.0032269908,
0.0039177099,
0.0252967197,
0.0091195405,
-0.0319445133,
0.0464416817,
-0.1019066721,
-0.0437856279,
0.0043587624,
-0.0388846435,
-0.0692790374,
0.0231933743,
0.0723366365,
0.0082266433,
-0.0538375452,
0.0061183339,
0.0354759432,
-0.054525435,
0.0225978103,
0.0655643046,
-0.0002813259,
-0.0069542904,
0.0012208741,
0.0274883304,
-0.0183652975,
-0.0041369344,
-0.0106943781,
-0.0593056716,
0.0843698755,
-0.034857586,
-0.0278570615,
-0.0125420438,
-0.0531957559,
-0.0138340043,
-0.0291220807,
-0.0431842469,
-0.0403907113,
-0.050774157,
-0.0108732944,
0.0111581702,
-0.034072455,
-0.032125663,
0.0621566698,
-0.0230819993,
0.0078910338,
0.0376185887,
0.0695437044,
-0.0258197132,
-0.0332807004,
0.0367858633,
-0.0129098529,
-0.015750587,
0.0367077552,
0.0487551689,
-0.0122565608,
0.0017167539,
-0.0040672892,
-0.0284549911,
-0.0365518481,
0.027125949,
0.0367419124,
0.0815289691,
-0.0356759131,
-0.0149877584,
-0.0274448451,
-0.0355940685,
0.0313679352,
0.0752978623,
-0.0318198279,
-0.0939092636,
-0.0020202703,
-0.0054091113,
0.0066877007,
-0.0040498232,
-0.0033561552,
0.0451727435,
-0.0202885922,
0.0315871425,
-0.0091764741,
-0.0426844396,
0.0011044715,
-0.0172533523,
0.0251164827,
0.0358743258,
-0.0119556105,
0.0055406648,
-0.0513303168,
0.0275299754,
-0.0246338043,
0.0702169612,
-0.044981163,
-0.0040973919,
-0.0355425589,
-0.0560169145,
-0.0561506301,
-0.0730377808,
-0.0602108315,
0.019345317,
-0.0262332689,
-0.0261391085,
0.0194302443,
-0.0228415914,
0.0028449653,
-0.0816514269,
0.075087361,
0.0551520139,
-0.0140016917,
-0.0179263521,
0.0080908872,
0.0077709267,
-0.0493435673,
0.0313189812,
-0.0379446708,
-0.0015805071,
0.0334363058,
-0.0602631308,
0.042858839,
-0.011945121,
-0.0237421691,
0.0133896898,
0.0132134473,
0.0175015721,
-0.0354439244,
-0.0548627079,
0.0313639268,
0.0012739617,
-0.0298514199,
-0.0102191186,
-0.0177471135,
0.0827161744,
0.0171803776,
-0.0122922854,
-0.0235101636,
-0.0161983427,
0.053119082,
-0.0660332739,
0.040443942,
-0.0298679564,
0.0593493022,
0.0175285581,
0.0025072426,
-0.0273089167,
0.025342511,
0.0494959354,
0.0204370879,
-0.023859717,
-0.0076586194,
-0.0288563352,
0.0370924622,
-0.0102802888,
0.0328063443,
-0.0125269881,
-0.0581302606,
0.0031909815,
0.0311714578,
0.0163287297,
-0.0587410629,
0.0148018664,
-0.0090392139,
-0.0135359,
-0.0384740792,
-0.0007473134,
0.0375025161,
-0.0126505811,
-0.0028663916,
-0.0064063552,
-0.0220537204,
0.040546976,
0.0139072137,
0.0248059649,
0.0183812473,
-0.03267207,
-0.0226848833,
-0.0302132517,
-0.008134447,
0.073235862,
0.036830537,
-0.0178225655,
0.0197101925,
-0.0401826836,
-0.0359485932,
0.0383032188,
-0.0382933691,
-0.0138860522,
0.0134639284,
0.0189532433,
0.0411058515,
0.0075618192,
-0.0033008778,
-0.0831606612,
0.0054699774,
-0.0125844413,
0.0094660409,
-0.061737746,
-4.962880211e-33,
0.0197722781,
-0.0107975286,
0.0112537453,
0.0193401314,
0.0130347582,
0.0246167462,
0.0713646561,
-0.0638416335,
0.0099073965,
0.0080993371,
-0.0389104001,
0.0224842206,
0.0143954437,
0.0530648082,
0.0267209206,
0.0421146601,
0.0403262228,
0.0110821938,
-0.0124655729,
0.0081318486,
0.0191874523,
0.0429796726,
0.0431848653,
-0.0525136478,
0.0306133702,
-0.0026685407,
-0.0213956852,
0.0441343002,
0.008666859,
0.084726207,
-0.0111850752,
0.0392722487,
0.0454399884,
0.0077364524,
0.0530812182,
0.0350130424,
-0.0318542011,
0.0065820538,
-0.0129491398,
0.042426534,
0.0421510972,
-0.0281774979,
-0.0051494502,
-0.0255744811,
-0.0136700673,
-0.0108626699,
0.083127223,
-0.0039603505,
0.0051414645,
-0.0222869124,
0.0084234392,
0.0226895008,
-0.0343580991,
0.0103361299,
0.0141922729,
0.036176119,
-0.0068266806,
0.0572289601,
-0.118330203,
-0.0071969219,
-0.0418592766,
0.0113441423,
-0.0289486498,
-0.0126951719,
-0.0419373401,
0.0499310046,
0.0728637055,
0.037066143,
0.0372406989,
-0.0235747378,
-0.0159951355,
0.0422528163,
-0.0124232881,
-0.0019621691,
0.0236355066,
-0.0529432073,
-0.0356919877,
0.0320405401,
0.0295520872,
-0.000251453,
0.014730446,
-0.005126643,
-0.0246147811,
0.0088520283,
-0.0104877139,
-0.0351843871,
-0.0115660485,
0.0418788604,
0.0343567096,
-0.0104096066,
0.0219792537,
0.0063905716,
-0.032306876,
-0.0406229049,
-0.0203737523,
0.0327049531,
-0.019091988,
-0.0131694013,
0.0191302579,
-0.0033460085,
-0.0275241695,
-0.0239652377,
-0.0111112837,
-0.042694293,
0.0253842268,
0.0484412387,
0.0534607507,
0.0454282053,
-0.0763034225,
-0.0052065128,
0.0150036085,
0.0246156827,
-0.0253690556,
0.0502885506,
0.0377341323,
0.0062632053,
0.0340712108,
0.0346282534,
0.0497087538,
0.0390627049,
0.0062482147,
-0.0856335536,
0.0356162302,
0.0042868629,
-0.0002049299,
-0.0070865974,
-0.0292843077,
0.0208242964,
0.0197644681,
-0.0328184776,
0.0175098386,
-0.0289859045,
2.238e-7,
0.0452797636,
0.0260626432,
-0.0713976845,
0.0025102831,
0.0329795144,
-0.0008585604,
0.0056396616,
0.0355271101,
0.0217454117,
0.051150281,
0.0022502469,
-0.0044040643,
0.0342289284,
-0.0251483526,
-0.0877459496,
-0.0142313084,
-0.0233023539,
-0.0276626088,
-0.0582424887,
0.0327691585,
0.0781655163,
0.0907522365,
0.0859027281,
-0.0602546856,
-0.0346714035,
-0.0109125869,
0.0236303341,
0.0010042348,
-0.0114236409,
0.0430402532,
0.0708121434,
0.0057513998,
0.0030562845,
0.0557001121,
-0.047298789,
0.0378251523,
0.0369826667,
0.0540021919,
-0.0445369706,
0.0476588421,
0.0294287968,
-0.0104031954,
-0.0082574077,
-0.0113414321,
0.0604013167,
-0.0163246654,
-0.0098984083,
-0.0124168396,
-0.0314250849,
-0.0155894794,
0.0550047271,
0.0119920606,
-0.0121232802,
0.0136262858,
0.0439010821,
-0.0329218172,
-0.065695174,
-0.0668835938,
0.0094823921,
0.0086231157,
-0.0325614698,
-0.0301640891,
0.0468199737,
0.0101342313,
0.0372786149,
-0.0333658569,
0.0133068748,
1.974271461e-34,
0.0178076383,
0.0334892832,
0.0115957074,
-0.0156136788,
0.0340426601,
0.0129517922,
0.0638634413,
0.0131323617,
-0.0292987451,
-0.0330784358,
0.00513697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18122v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18122v1 | Poisoned LangChain: Jailbreak LLMs by LangChain | 2024-06-26T07:21:02 | 2024-06-26T07:21:02 | Ziqiu Wang, Jun Liu, Shengkai Zhang, Yang Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the development of natural language processing (NLP), large language
models (LLMs) are becoming increasingly popular. LLMs are integrating more into
everyday life, raising public concerns about their security vulnerabilities.
Consequently, the security of large language models is becoming critically
important. Currently, the techniques for attacking and defending against LLMs
are continuously evolving. One significant method type of attack is the
jailbreak attack, which designed to evade model safety mechanisms and induce
the generation of inappropriate content. Existing jailbreak attacks primarily
rely on crafting inducement prompts for direct jailbreaks, which are less
effective against large models with robust filtering and high comprehension
abilities. Given the increasing demand for real-time capabilities in large
language models, real-time updates and iterations of new knowledge have become
essential. Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG), an advanced technique to
compensate for the model's lack of new knowledge, is gradually becoming
mainstream. As RAG enables the model to utilize external knowledge bases, it
provides a new avenue for jailbreak attacks.
In this paper, we conduct the first work to propose the concept of indirect
jailbreak and achieve Retrieval-Augmented Generation via LangChain. Building on
this, we further design a novel method of indirect jailbreak attack, termed
Poisoned-LangChain (PLC), which leverages a poisoned external knowledge base to
interact with large language models, thereby causing the large models to
generate malicious non-compliant dialogues.We tested this method on six
different large language models across three major categories of jailbreak
issues. The experiments demonstrate that PLC successfully implemented indirect
jailbreak attacks under three different scenarios, achieving success rates of
88.56%, 79.04%, and 82.69% respectively. | Poisoned LangChain: Jailbreak LLMs by LangChain: With the development of natural language processing (NLP), large language
models (LLMs) are becoming increasingly popular. LLMs are integrating more into
everyday life, raising public concerns about their security vulnerabilities.
Consequently, the security of large language models is becoming critically
important. Currently, the techniques for attacking and defending against LLMs
are continuously evolving. One significant method type of attack is the
jailbreak attack, which designed to evade model safety mechanisms and induce
the generation of inappropriate content. Existing jailbreak attacks primarily
rely on crafting inducement prompts for direct jailbreaks, which are less
effective against large models with robust filtering and high comprehension
abilities. Given the increasing demand for real-time capabilities in large
language models, real-time updates and iterations of new knowledge have become
essential. Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG), an advanced technique to
compensate for the model's lack of new knowledge, is gradually becoming
mainstream. As RAG enables the model to utilize external knowledge bases, it
provides a new avenue for jailbreak attacks.
In this paper, we conduct the first work to propose the concept of indirect
jailbreak and achieve Retrieval-Augmented Generation via LangChain. Building on
this, we further design a novel method of indirect jailbreak attack, termed
Poisoned-LangChain (PLC), which leverages a poisoned external knowledge base to
interact with large language models, thereby causing the large models to
generate malicious non-compliant dialogues.We tested this method on six
different large language models across three major categories of jailbreak
issues. The experiments demonstrate that PLC successfully implemented indirect
jailbreak attacks under three different scenarios, achieving success rates of
88.56%, 79.04%, and 82.69% respectively. | [
0.0772217661,
0.0781198516,
-0.0214172099,
0.0477085449,
-0.0623150133,
-0.0286847558,
0.0000200419,
0.0063758772,
0.0782114342,
-0.0506623536,
-0.0145220095,
-0.0086236447,
-0.0016957085,
0.0151042137,
0.0510025769,
0.0034853353,
0.0594954826,
-0.0140391132,
-0.0011365126,
0.0088427942,
0.0268203486,
0.004516012,
0.0296331011,
0.0316657834,
0.0009516911,
-0.0046364986,
-0.0254577342,
0.0081543149,
0.0023530347,
-0.0331723243,
-0.0005458574,
0.0355086327,
-0.002417295,
0.0577642098,
0.0000022337,
-0.0383742638,
-0.0417383127,
0.0325405374,
-0.0375323966,
0.0194705818,
0.0145690469,
-0.0431612246,
-0.0364999361,
0.0171253663,
-0.0528338067,
0.026053967,
0.0228859391,
0.0570926853,
0.0787853822,
0.0707584396,
-0.0034670548,
-0.0238053743,
0.0575229079,
0.0004908199,
0.0246034302,
-0.0396004803,
0.0218947493,
-0.0204555802,
-0.0019644981,
0.0428849906,
0.0288392715,
0.0101125399,
0.0205774475,
-0.0288677812,
-0.0343358181,
-0.0269315038,
-0.0380487442,
-0.0367916077,
-0.0009408598,
0.0337115042,
-0.0144000798,
-0.0174213462,
0.0066060871,
0.0245302971,
0.0238662828,
0.0406904742,
-0.0231092349,
0.0455849022,
-0.0137010096,
-0.0076871011,
0.0456498079,
-0.036908336,
0.0630761757,
-0.001636013,
0.006330939,
0.0306275561,
0.018851975,
-0.047741048,
-0.0086393319,
-0.0597650968,
-0.0034391347,
-0.0421912894,
0.0094636343,
0.0052245785,
0.0128101539,
0.0395059213,
-0.0727821141,
-0.0357332677,
0.0436759926,
-0.0592260621,
-0.0028177623,
0.0322738588,
-0.0099132452,
0.0111786416,
-0.005665984,
-0.0044835554,
-0.0302919131,
0.0093153389,
0.0049364073,
0.0008386634,
-0.0190829374,
-0.0406738371,
-0.0105238874,
0.0510132387,
-0.020692734,
0.0073869703,
-0.0061808145,
0.0298137758,
-0.0317825899,
0.0420953222,
-0.0510126203,
0.0200916938,
0.0055945772,
0.0314334892,
0.0197383668,
-0.0165612958,
-0.0012881043,
-0.0128388265,
0.0090439282,
-0.075698778,
-0.0235153642,
0.0056381468,
-0.0610969253,
-0.002759055,
-0.0205324497,
0.109126471,
0.0188520327,
-0.0190074276,
-0.1096752584,
-0.1184396222,
-0.0204553548,
-0.0220995676,
0.0070565375,
-0.0834543034,
-0.0336425006,
-0.0201297831,
-0.0294649638,
-0.067441754,
0.0280806553,
0.0285718627,
-0.054835733,
0.0397700667,
-0.0131455492,
-0.0290302094,
-0.0080239298,
0.0455240905,
0.0418973565,
0.0734222233,
-0.0041164439,
0.0455645211,
0.0629600808,
-0.0034002268,
0.0219669063,
0.051104296,
0.0115199117,
0.0155986873,
-0.0298936907,
-0.0042409096,
0.0356973521,
-0.0212786086,
-0.0510126911,
0.0410834998,
-0.0183399487,
-0.0062683374,
0.0784396455,
0.0441236235,
-0.0236152299,
0.0529435202,
0.0155270472,
-0.0206386112,
0.0068737231,
0.0141422078,
-0.0605730787,
-0.015080737,
-0.1043861955,
-0.0300997403,
-0.0109350784,
0.0287431069,
0.0088036004,
-0.0083562816,
0.0128213502,
-0.0009430199,
0.0114472099,
0.0053725406,
0.0017273746,
0.0694397911,
0.0116594881,
0.0721294433,
0.0226156786,
-0.0529062636,
-0.0265630465,
-0.0777899697,
-0.02922149,
0.0677064657,
0.0773630738,
-0.0129785314,
-0.0053933691,
0.0025595382,
-0.0473078713,
0.0186403412,
-0.0141311456,
0.0056675072,
-0.0166014973,
0.0057602837,
-0.001319636,
-0.0067323679,
0.0402438119,
0.0036804995,
0.0090840319,
-0.0009980204,
0.017724622,
-0.0194708146,
-0.034626212,
0.0098223584,
-0.0231633391,
-0.0221504234,
0.0214041099,
0.0221032891,
0.0103460075,
0.0470857359,
-0.0256384742,
0.0261714142,
0.0810579732,
-0.0030757042,
0.0196585841,
0.002906908,
-0.0378588401,
-0.0247694943,
0.0201418567,
-0.0125438366,
0.0152277527,
0.0706783757,
-0.0072745085,
-0.0272642933,
0.0692517757,
-0.0514582805,
0.0605317131,
-0.0237577967,
0.0047115767,
-0.0099936137,
0.002738684,
-0.0343698673,
0.0150845796,
-0.0249221474,
0.005531624,
-0.0069555282,
0.0238667876,
0.0092399102,
0.0128920535,
-0.0370827951,
0.0213868879,
-0.0340651646,
0.0172624812,
0.0418725833,
0.0218163002,
-0.0263975244,
-0.0480436608,
-0.0533848293,
-0.0176315568,
-0.0273631997,
0.0318500176,
0.0401146039,
0.0427473858,
-0.0154124806,
-0.0205724593,
-0.0254707709,
-0.0216878336,
0.0142739033,
0.0286354292,
-0.0137975542,
-0.0092496369,
-0.0513714887,
-0.0176295992,
-0.0009974125,
0.0118876211,
0.0595924556,
-0.0269395877,
-0.0286087431,
-0.0102320854,
0.0149813052,
-0.0142653659,
0.0169329792,
-0.0172361098,
-0.0316777378,
0.0425400622,
-0.0115936249,
-0.0197291151,
0.0554675795,
0.0123195061,
0.0668274984,
0.0683733299,
-0.0214474853,
-0.0449043065,
-0.0274570063,
0.0327373557,
-0.0346266143,
-0.0474865362,
-0.0328502506,
0.0272046197,
0.0401318744,
0.0486713126,
-0.0056477739,
-0.0127784945,
0.0356786475,
0.0068841153,
-0.0339573286,
0.007911332,
-0.0368805751,
-0.0469309613,
-0.0109990016,
-0.0170177482,
-0.0852995813,
0.0549422614,
-0.0533379912,
0.0336284824,
-0.0367556848,
-0.0434847735,
0.0013808964,
0.0554516241,
-0.0063557909,
0.0279261582,
0.0442056246,
-0.0343519635,
-0.0341941379,
-0.0050846464,
0.0377185643,
-0.0368493833,
0.0330708921,
-0.0518167578,
-0.0040533151,
0.0032851903,
-0.0163059235,
-0.0790835395,
-0.0445907488,
0.0067392723,
-0.0060943342,
0.0545866303,
-0.0466876067,
0.0016767107,
-0.0515269525,
0.0660791472,
-0.0057120221,
-0.0023656378,
-0.0132938828,
-0.0331433751,
0.0444872864,
0.0297161285,
-0.0700601786,
0.0052110516,
0.0114161475,
0.0565905944,
0.1019054726,
0.0482188947,
-0.0057339757,
0.0183968283,
0.0350144729,
0.0184102673,
0.0132893119,
-0.025551606,
0.0282003768,
0.022681348,
-0.0495254472,
-0.0254455972,
0.0567861684,
0.0479512289,
-0.0249067992,
0.0070819478,
0.0000314586,
0.0290999319,
0.0240000319,
0.0360476114,
-0.0557943508,
-0.0162578542,
0.0297690835,
0.065385282,
-0.0539907403,
-0.0393729508,
-0.0505855419,
-0.1165702119,
-0.0037841324,
0.0285164751,
-0.0171356797,
0.011339305,
-0.0439329036,
-0.0386499651,
0.0557725988,
0.0162839107,
-0.0175854955,
-0.0006419133,
-0.0032326218,
-0.0204108246,
-0.0555917956,
-0.0038257106,
0.009363655,
-0.015108509,
0.0507846661,
0.0877701491,
-0.0027022602,
-0.0371068269,
0.0411278233,
0.0483115017,
-0.0212234799,
0.0000653699,
-0.010898185,
0.0025682973,
0.0285223536,
-0.0010210797,
-0.005148916,
0.0553183071,
0.0010056606,
-0.0424784906,
0.0207427219,
0.0511804335,
-0.0123773227,
0.0104396259,
-0.0237244107,
-0.012296618,
0.0409323312,
0.0410162657,
0.0223232768,
-0.0378281288,
-0.0147736566,
-0.0812593922,
-0.050318189,
-0.0290934965,
-0.0493145324,
0.0376231447,
0.0188691244,
-0.012350197,
-0.0672272891,
0.0097926473,
-0.0323055424,
0.0404012129,
0.0475475974,
0.0123333773,
0.0142145827,
-0.0157763641,
-0.0216623768,
-0.0117614018,
0.0008312311,
0.0222911704,
-0.0501822568,
0.0182964765,
-0.0033407791,
-0.0295078047,
0.0052130711,
0.031672135,
-0.0420566835,
-0.0908769071,
0.0141396103,
0.0519942679,
0.020958595,
0.026414996,
-0.0273805466,
-0.0477004424,
0.0433322899,
0.0853249505,
-0.0755785927,
0.0157614965,
0.0507752672,
-0.0107863648,
0.0126800323,
0.0259576626,
-0.0563982651,
-0.0181053989,
0.0459444113,
0.0056549981,
-0.0251953956,
-0.0061363797,
0.035940811,
0.0656976402,
-0.0046386542,
0.0150762396,
0.0198927391,
0.0160139278,
0.0188209135,
-0.0229869243,
-0.0486700386,
-0.0122608375,
0.0266488846,
0.0044105179,
-0.0379691496,
0.0394411236,
0.0252220184,
0.0033042936,
-0.0013123502,
0.0023265511,
0.011610223,
0.0218192432,
0.0259122774,
0.0710794479,
0.0209509786,
-0.0241183639,
0.0414539576,
-0.0281926394,
0.0416890308,
-0.0250409693,
0.0476750135,
-0.0122832246,
-0.0267335903,
-0.0222050976,
0.0358532444,
-0.0818461627,
-0.0291228704,
0.0119659249,
0.0660112053,
0.0016701728,
-0.0136453342,
0.0345105156,
-0.0248447992,
0.0151807936,
-0.0320056044,
-0.0234607421,
-0.017943209,
-0.0822990909,
0.0044725649,
-0.0004762195,
-0.0133011397,
0.0401517525,
0.0608471334,
-0.0052873129,
0.053911332,
0.0154066775,
-0.021574866,
-0.0370398425,
-0.0081908032,
0.0586750992,
0.0179794785,
-0.0497716218,
-0.0296848193,
-0.042868115,
-0.0756336078,
-0.0156843793,
-0.010625666,
0.0155556705,
0.0022385367,
-0.0232369956,
0.0645938069,
0.0138030965,
0.0266291443,
-0.0666710436,
0.0402312018,
-0.0124853877,
-0.0692145228,
0.0334314704,
-6.170175725e-33,
0.0166801475,
-0.0530413873,
-0.0352102295,
-0.0321737938,
0.0040254318,
-0.0112281572,
-0.0254024938,
0.0164133459,
-0.0201014541,
-0.0272017792,
-0.0220444091,
-0.0028016367,
-0.0064955242,
0.0325212441,
-0.0319631323,
-0.0125184851,
0.0100556621,
0.0116798896,
-0.0026493885,
0.0502736568,
0.0911742523,
0.0166339632,
0.0157141928,
-0.049533233,
0.0591237508,
-0.031827379,
-0.023278594,
0.0300790258,
-0.0475239679,
0.0638480559,
0.0131624136,
0.043273814,
0.0002638286,
-0.0415198281,
-0.0147751449,
0.0520897694,
-0.0010968641,
-0.0089384653,
0.0125291338,
-0.0064061191,
-0.0047254106,
-0.047295846,
0.0408351384,
-0.0116914054,
0.0044681537,
0.0179749671,
-0.0126246968,
-0.0223689936,
-0.0198005997,
-0.0185992736,
-0.0187381487,
-0.001821203,
-0.0303212125,
0.0028085548,
-0.0125679979,
0.0058885464,
0.0259090737,
-0.0212643128,
-0.040113505,
0.036054723,
0.027554024,
0.0239538532,
0.0236423444,
-0.0183312204,
0.0058662235,
0.0631839857,
-0.0316084847,
-0.01774293,
-0.0029101009,
0.0112621346,
-0.002275375,
0.0662681311,
0.0461524092,
0.066064015,
0.0540571325,
-0.032935068,
-0.0612070151,
-0.0114771901,
0.0022875087,
0.0427582264,
0.0202731248,
-0.0168095082,
-0.0330618471,
-0.010016541,
-0.0242340267,
-0.0081276549,
-0.0326703824,
-0.0431870036,
0.024996398,
0.0132046258,
-0.0186409764,
-0.0729283914,
-0.0072033093,
-0.0764710456,
-0.012167302,
0.0402573943,
-0.0230440721,
-0.0266731549,
-0.0187382232,
0.0211190283,
0.0041496279,
0.0111414036,
0.0159638561,
-0.0692028478,
0.016852593,
0.0089076413,
0.0305685233,
0.016918784,
-0.0785080567,
-0.0097021991,
-0.0133646009,
0.0665919408,
0.0193715896,
0.0027189201,
0.0232425127,
-0.0101757888,
-0.0024624912,
0.0145754414,
0.0439669862,
0.0113819744,
-0.0551995747,
0.0143680489,
-0.0261128396,
0.0293659326,
-0.011298175,
0.019699201,
-0.0139532043,
0.0337553285,
0.042889718,
-0.0521861017,
0.0080925561,
-0.0072620464,
3.095e-7,
-0.0250025988,
0.0017371436,
0.0160642453,
-0.0096491771,
0.0386145003,
0.0637819171,
0.0035377408,
0.0556055009,
-0.0272361431,
-0.0764526948,
-0.0692582354,
-0.0310749933,
0.0627902523,
0.0451108851,
-0.0866604671,
0.0449500531,
-0.066691339,
-0.0194385238,
-0.0586316735,
0.0027045142,
0.0511183254,
0.0786313117,
-0.0125252632,
-0.0399244837,
-0.0260210689,
-0.0715056583,
-0.0018184468,
0.0102185225,
-0.041265212,
-0.0334833488,
0.0511624999,
0.0447704941,
0.026198281,
0.0097212251,
-0.0540025383,
-0.0058379686,
-0.0689499304,
0.0080903238,
0.008843231,
-0.0074013313,
-0.022215005,
-0.0395386666,
-0.0106105246,
-0.0292011872,
0.0828898996,
0.0168857481,
-0.0085507818,
-0.0148599604,
0.0257914104,
-0.0473541394,
-0.0112010315,
-0.0449175723,
0.0005589658,
0.0119685531,
0.0232180152,
0.0148509452,
0.0406767093,
-0.0679224581,
-0.0159299057,
0.0027768924,
-0.0133468434,
-0.0131393885,
-0.0283211097,
0.0238071568,
0.0102825519,
-0.0332824588,
0.0086727422,
3.26486829e-34,
-0.0063121673,
-0.0422377586,
0.031441085,
0.0056973309,
0.0371808633,
0.0109885763,
0.0047875852,
0.0374860168,
0.0077152415,
-0.0727372169,
-0.0285701081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18120v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18120v1 | ArzEn-LLM: Code-Switched Egyptian Arabic-English Translation and Speech Recognition Using LLMs | 2024-06-26T07:19:51 | 2024-06-26T07:19:51 | Ahmed Heakl, Youssef Zaghloul, Mennatullah Ali, Rania Hossam, Walid Gomaa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Motivated by the widespread increase in the phenomenon of code-switching
between Egyptian Arabic and English in recent times, this paper explores the
intricacies of machine translation (MT) and automatic speech recognition (ASR)
systems, focusing on translating code-switched Egyptian Arabic-English to
either English or Egyptian Arabic. Our goal is to present the methodologies
employed in developing these systems, utilizing large language models such as
LLama and Gemma. In the field of ASR, we explore the utilization of the Whisper
model for code-switched Egyptian Arabic recognition, detailing our experimental
procedures including data preprocessing and training techniques. Through the
implementation of a consecutive speech-to-text translation system that
integrates ASR with MT, we aim to overcome challenges posed by limited
resources and the unique characteristics of the Egyptian Arabic dialect.
Evaluation against established metrics showcases promising results, with our
methodologies yielding a significant improvement of $56\%$ in English
translation over the state-of-the-art and $9.3\%$ in Arabic translation. Since
code-switching is deeply inherent in spoken languages, it is crucial that ASR
systems can effectively handle this phenomenon. This capability is crucial for
enabling seamless interaction in various domains, including business
negotiations, cultural exchanges, and academic discourse. Our models and code
are available as open-source resources. Code:
\url{http://github.com/ahmedheakl/arazn-llm}}, Models:
\url{http://huggingface.co/collections/ahmedheakl/arazn-llm-662ceaf12777656607b9524e}. | ArzEn-LLM: Code-Switched Egyptian Arabic-English Translation and Speech Recognition Using LLMs: Motivated by the widespread increase in the phenomenon of code-switching
between Egyptian Arabic and English in recent times, this paper explores the
intricacies of machine translation (MT) and automatic speech recognition (ASR)
systems, focusing on translating code-switched Egyptian Arabic-English to
either English or Egyptian Arabic. Our goal is to present the methodologies
employed in developing these systems, utilizing large language models such as
LLama and Gemma. In the field of ASR, we explore the utilization of the Whisper
model for code-switched Egyptian Arabic recognition, detailing our experimental
procedures including data preprocessing and training techniques. Through the
implementation of a consecutive speech-to-text translation system that
integrates ASR with MT, we aim to overcome challenges posed by limited
resources and the unique characteristics of the Egyptian Arabic dialect.
Evaluation against established metrics showcases promising results, with our
methodologies yielding a significant improvement of $56\%$ in English
translation over the state-of-the-art and $9.3\%$ in Arabic translation. Since
code-switching is deeply inherent in spoken languages, it is crucial that ASR
systems can effectively handle this phenomenon. This capability is crucial for
enabling seamless interaction in various domains, including business
negotiations, cultural exchanges, and academic discourse. Our models and code
are available as open-source resources. Code:
\url{http://github.com/ahmedheakl/arazn-llm}}, Models:
\url{http://huggingface.co/collections/ahmedheakl/arazn-llm-662ceaf12777656607b9524e}. | [
0.0262527578,
0.0490271971,
-0.0210837796,
0.0538118295,
-0.055967439,
0.0387913026,
0.038952142,
0.0316529311,
-0.016650388,
-0.050089296,
-0.0571307763,
-0.027436018,
0.0602046438,
0.0246781223,
0.0542993881,
-0.00724778,
0.0215229988,
-0.1006459892,
-0.0238489602,
0.0045238519,
0.0314570703,
0.0303136557,
-0.0215213113,
0.0067841737,
0.0183318574,
-0.0018771151,
-0.0282401182,
0.0314758681,
0.009777924,
0.035700541,
-0.0264585502,
0.0112458291,
-0.0089516854,
0.0520313047,
0.0000020932,
-0.0516194664,
-0.0434283577,
-0.0212647263,
-0.0296473522,
-0.0156275835,
0.0642890856,
-0.0527811795,
-0.0441457517,
0.0123044308,
-0.0234648753,
0.029096676,
0.0566433296,
-0.0031813579,
0.0422043242,
0.0650272667,
-0.0004805795,
-0.0618168637,
0.0054223617,
0.0007500968,
-0.0212130267,
-0.0704377666,
0.0096350648,
-0.0264314935,
-0.0293208044,
0.0115875136,
-0.0231632572,
0.0658373162,
-0.0286376849,
-0.0360164829,
-0.0249706693,
-0.0257316604,
-0.0369495191,
-0.0464946926,
-0.0320188031,
0.0326999947,
-0.0349319465,
-0.0181692876,
0.0316563137,
-0.0061647776,
-0.0317939371,
-0.0419376791,
0.0001925464,
0.0217250679,
-0.025759032,
-0.0043022763,
-0.0000683831,
0.0455474518,
0.0180224013,
-0.0158078317,
-0.0552060939,
-0.0140126264,
0.0079175187,
-0.0319909006,
0.0174937323,
-0.0290297996,
0.0339576639,
-0.0218780525,
0.0741899461,
0.0175787713,
-0.0169988275,
-0.0097710695,
0.0018363973,
-0.0338736326,
-0.0153901521,
-0.0563369095,
0.0266439393,
0.0930487141,
-0.0380328223,
0.0317319073,
-0.0291113853,
0.0630417317,
0.0090125874,
0.0127707887,
-0.0367682762,
0.0329814889,
-0.0149497073,
0.033960674,
-0.0434847027,
0.0079962481,
-0.0468835235,
-0.0211269595,
-0.0411083326,
-0.0143108936,
0.0246604979,
0.0251681115,
0.0084155397,
-0.0704152137,
-0.0213590339,
-0.0103154676,
0.0320355594,
-0.0150198201,
0.0389754884,
0.0123123918,
-0.0361878462,
-0.0680051073,
0.0186286792,
0.0202380978,
0.0091220019,
0.045717936,
-0.0228785779,
0.0805774257,
-0.0335645825,
-0.0247664079,
-0.0542191938,
0.0376052223,
-0.0128736943,
-0.0486669391,
-0.0289051645,
-0.0307041667,
0.0475138761,
0.0277025867,
0.0149027361,
-0.0397808179,
-0.0015351108,
-0.0149892205,
0.0455989279,
0.0846020505,
0.0311356392,
0.0223107226,
0.0797003359,
0.0032474895,
-0.0132089779,
0.0884617344,
0.0688913912,
-0.0177942496,
0.0024520305,
-0.0042422223,
0.0015978313,
0.0750812292,
-0.02495021,
0.0062695481,
-0.0127665093,
-0.0359948501,
0.0720910206,
0.0460315458,
-0.0151880216,
0.0644063354,
-0.0218111631,
-0.0339938216,
0.0225670859,
0.0332864039,
-0.0125960689,
0.0540551208,
0.0185240675,
0.0237595867,
0.0311290286,
-0.0085143978,
0.0386804119,
-0.006971465,
0.0014051354,
-0.0225165822,
0.0423415154,
0.0540704541,
-0.0182343181,
-0.034014836,
-0.0163848605,
-0.020108141,
0.0385903381,
-0.0071963225,
0.0545155741,
0.0044955239,
-0.0678892583,
-0.008487328,
0.0081335753,
-0.0396737717,
-0.0010584086,
-0.0754862204,
-0.0554154254,
0.0633116215,
0.0123857055,
0.0045179874,
0.0278050639,
-0.0289334357,
-0.000158976,
0.0589895174,
0.0217928793,
-0.0009861892,
0.0383471437,
-0.0747429654,
0.0112845954,
0.0595230311,
-0.0153285004,
0.0255395379,
0.0051307273,
0.0560206696,
0.0163320899,
0.0261902716,
-0.0259866994,
0.0095373001,
-0.0755669251,
0.0272377115,
0.0090316441,
0.0060324124,
0.0244572386,
0.0278785974,
-0.0187718309,
0.0174104683,
-0.0060188086,
-0.0330416895,
0.007215919,
0.0308673661,
-0.0300305076,
0.0026762949,
0.0339286327,
0.0160060767,
0.0334593616,
-0.0017752,
0.0141227199,
-0.0702342987,
0.0716628209,
-0.0571600832,
0.0754896328,
-0.0054071001,
0.0998697951,
0.010202935,
-0.0044940729,
-0.0079127923,
-0.0087454161,
-0.0016569917,
-0.0307303537,
-0.0041526873,
-0.0226115044,
0.0116296178,
-0.0209475048,
0.0107203014,
0.0427328721,
-0.0093473131,
0.0221382789,
0.0131503642,
0.0029000817,
-0.0162578393,
-0.0815543532,
-0.0464226902,
-0.0206457246,
-0.0243363306,
0.041281525,
-0.0300016645,
0.0247667581,
-0.0209434889,
-0.0119410837,
-0.0335014202,
-0.0020660951,
-0.0194675233,
-0.0163356978,
-0.005732147,
-0.0177565813,
-0.0474830456,
-0.0351736322,
0.0188314002,
0.0279346853,
0.028129803,
0.0315615013,
-0.0483504646,
-0.065223515,
0.0033556779,
0.0167296194,
-0.0038225842,
-0.0049563604,
-0.0253565516,
0.0307970215,
-0.0213011056,
0.0179605186,
0.0031659072,
-0.0191185866,
0.0067483941,
-0.0091026062,
-0.0220977012,
-0.066867575,
-0.0324121043,
0.0188697688,
-0.0363054425,
-0.0495116748,
-0.0431493483,
-0.0315471329,
0.0292138904,
0.0183576476,
0.0346880667,
-0.0468669385,
-0.0157287885,
-0.0219465811,
-0.0097295688,
0.0413544029,
-0.0088452771,
-0.0006420349,
0.0925773308,
-0.0066780266,
-0.0319088809,
0.0021999339,
-0.0623499341,
-0.0099556958,
-0.0330291502,
0.0097281989,
-0.0518929698,
-0.0152598144,
-0.0616928488,
0.017731091,
0.0124419341,
-0.0730082318,
0.0078800032,
-0.005822666,
0.0014407554,
-0.0439390242,
-0.0156158209,
-0.0456580147,
0.0288018044,
-0.0103687514,
-0.0319793932,
0.0039763441,
0.0278938692,
-0.0680010542,
-0.0079054739,
0.0472900756,
-0.0357431695,
-0.0289998986,
0.0548538081,
-0.0134495599,
0.0485755876,
0.0225328486,
0.0240553431,
-0.0057046302,
-0.011641467,
-0.0319792069,
-0.0018330259,
-0.0145999212,
-0.0083007915,
0.0483948439,
0.0131278988,
-0.005298323,
0.0050937603,
-0.0736413598,
-0.0118070478,
0.0750631914,
-0.0180515982,
-0.0209068395,
-0.0342428461,
-0.0056303386,
-0.0177124199,
0.0325865597,
0.082924448,
-0.0013967323,
-0.0585382916,
-0.0208970066,
-0.0276640337,
0.0079722349,
-0.0008932949,
-0.0180269666,
-0.0949183926,
0.0118412133,
0.0530186929,
0.051575873,
0.0183644146,
0.0377237611,
0.0182843413,
-0.0464012958,
0.0166658983,
0.0447716527,
-0.0863273963,
-0.0582080483,
-0.0113573167,
-0.0140602831,
-0.0276112948,
-0.0192429647,
-0.0142224235,
-0.0037777962,
-0.0207170751,
0.0479144007,
0.0001137523,
-0.0079521956,
-0.0137616135,
-0.0112984236,
0.0496602096,
0.0589570925,
0.0303552654,
0.0088797053,
-0.0383678302,
-0.0052652974,
0.0041110413,
-0.0188542921,
-0.0355295688,
-0.0131781437,
-0.0148562407,
-0.0122856451,
0.0315930396,
-0.0093945842,
-0.0285399035,
0.0101368148,
0.0113455439,
-0.0161008164,
-0.0319244973,
0.0288085528,
0.0469679832,
0.0327778533,
0.0086210836,
0.0103536304,
0.0019389209,
-0.0256812293,
-0.0172718,
-0.0270769596,
0.0175294448,
-0.0169813037,
-0.0424363911,
-0.0183489844,
0.0199686792,
-0.0193259325,
-0.0741087198,
0.0136271995,
0.0058312756,
0.0433011092,
0.0536620878,
0.0277549811,
0.0346730426,
0.0449430682,
-0.0256609712,
-0.0786715075,
-0.0219900049,
0.0198631659,
-0.0670393333,
-0.0448856242,
0.043343123,
-0.0864781961,
0.0324151441,
-0.0132520888,
-0.1108837426,
-0.0611112863,
0.0218080897,
-0.0000347052,
0.0294723511,
0.0142257269,
-0.0229232218,
-0.0370574482,
-0.0116657605,
-0.0643396676,
-0.0304472428,
0.0228576362,
0.0552840978,
0.0497291386,
-0.03170719,
0.0295382477,
0.009834487,
-0.0084186913,
0.0076609184,
-0.0014088731,
-0.0579329953,
-0.0796016082,
-0.0302474424,
-0.0222646501,
-0.0106136706,
-0.0109772114,
-0.0561327524,
-0.0101233199,
0.0387161747,
0.0014108388,
0.0475854464,
-0.0316185616,
-0.0095199645,
0.0095892502,
0.0318620577,
0.0010190197,
-0.027968483,
-0.0383842029,
-0.0446882136,
0.0074350536,
0.0642526373,
0.0184739903,
0.0112843979,
0.0211162996,
0.0191734079,
-0.00572378,
0.0342130885,
0.005621505,
0.0117233712,
-0.0191001277,
0.0124599244,
-0.0058847712,
0.013396265,
0.0439394042,
0.0450988822,
-0.0146306632,
-0.050275702,
-0.0102154026,
0.0653291866,
0.0281372499,
0.0273133237,
0.1066895053,
0.0369688645,
0.0158271585,
-0.0071226647,
0.0469500311,
-0.0214320272,
-0.0133715803,
-0.0354803838,
-0.0056756749,
-0.0069131046,
0.0663688406,
0.0165334176,
-0.0034239066,
-0.0154505735,
0.0290556438,
0.0064943205,
-0.0133903315,
-0.0151393609,
0.0380673409,
-0.0436561778,
-0.0352335833,
-0.0138166239,
-0.0161393434,
-0.0703889877,
0.0498460978,
0.021218149,
0.0350361243,
-0.0256945025,
0.0100957677,
0.0750859976,
0.0023932979,
0.0197061133,
-0.0593195073,
-0.0068306662,
0.0415423252,
-0.0626683831,
0.0025645862,
-5.727043007e-33,
0.0150479125,
-0.0223798715,
0.0037884505,
0.0393803045,
-0.0057604727,
-0.0350789241,
-0.0354388729,
0.0069612288,
0.0076027303,
-0.0613668934,
-0.0352018848,
0.0158744883,
0.0430649407,
-0.0297256466,
0.035126362,
0.0124088116,
0.0442650132,
-0.0126887299,
-0.0268464219,
0.0355669372,
0.0206084307,
0.0423748903,
0.0479632467,
-0.0574351065,
0.0115088783,
-0.0377749838,
-0.0348636918,
-0.0248650499,
0.0027839167,
0.0551919527,
-0.0172473639,
0.0077809249,
-0.0095995199,
0.0029071884,
0.0068581421,
0.0011925278,
-0.0435031205,
0.064441368,
0.0189677048,
0.0891254842,
0.051880043,
-0.0464759432,
-0.0016031009,
-0.0322374403,
-0.0698117688,
0.0370840095,
-0.0199582893,
-0.0420776717,
-0.0183026195,
-0.0211046822,
-0.0995128378,
0.0506205745,
-0.0281153973,
-0.0254429076,
0.1115036681,
0.0490916371,
-0.0245498959,
-0.0303785987,
-0.0615510419,
0.0508818813,
0.0303204991,
0.0283626709,
0.0535574555,
0.041160807,
-0.0674738511,
0.001255648,
0.0540289171,
-0.0430820361,
0.0676037669,
0.0100734122,
0.0400425978,
-0.0362707935,
0.0033025818,
0.0137242209,
-0.0089048957,
-0.0397529602,
-0.0276300441,
-0.0238545518,
0.0201910865,
0.0135106081,
0.0217299201,
0.0469611734,
-0.0543274917,
-0.0123760747,
-0.0303416532,
-0.0657065362,
-0.0152552985,
-0.0147408536,
0.0110226376,
0.0064356127,
-0.0181974191,
0.0376372747,
0.0435870998,
0.0070251222,
0.0096967453,
-0.0390694365,
0.0111758085,
0.0143083688,
-0.0144947618,
0.0649084598,
-0.0328481644,
-0.0574868843,
0.0352987275,
0.019643819,
0.0477365516,
-0.0301363617,
-0.0022800048,
0.0619809851,
-0.0463192053,
-0.0028697136,
-0.0090818275,
0.0072451364,
0.011321798,
0.0237121414,
0.0017514363,
-0.0315956548,
0.0114072654,
0.0160382427,
0.0002186362,
-0.0134720234,
-0.0326943435,
0.0270807967,
-0.0159081351,
0.0160332676,
-0.0641764924,
0.022992909,
-0.0223691203,
0.0144351581,
0.0295289773,
-0.023060279,
-0.020004198,
0.0118339648,
2.893e-7,
0.0084018307,
0.0268840045,
0.0081435712,
-0.0165396947,
0.0105347717,
-0.0092800241,
-0.0221713874,
0.0087591195,
0.039204061,
0.027450718,
-0.0114692114,
0.0014205979,
0.1317580193,
0.0065717562,
-0.0841206908,
-0.0579683036,
0.0250663552,
0.0348102786,
-0.038590204,
0.0068432121,
0.0400593691,
0.1147982627,
-0.0594107397,
0.0150020178,
-0.0498124175,
0.0111840107,
0.0312670283,
-0.0429012068,
0.0190105233,
-0.0143860113,
0.0063290466,
-0.0338350795,
-0.0216306373,
0.0012421897,
-0.0145095438,
0.0027364669,
0.0683392212,
0.0829960033,
0.0092576519,
-0.0041670627,
0.007165215,
0.0079358807,
-0.0342313573,
-0.0392084531,
0.0275259446,
0.036874827,
-0.0040821745,
-0.0063139284,
-0.0036792797,
0.0304592922,
0.0016238483,
-0.0411856137,
0.015261163,
0.0406896919,
0.0527926795,
-0.0103358086,
0.0074714259,
-0.0206951927,
0.0034445634,
-0.0570639633,
-0.0003991894,
-0.0228083376,
-0.0072336458,
-0.0116796335,
-0.0003665002,
0.0147634698,
0.0002811846,
2.185472209e-34,
0.0503713489,
-0.0337103792,
-0.002241628,
0.0610278212,
0.0499623865,
-0.0208385494,
-0.0009144825,
0.053766977,
-0.0045741415,
-0.0239347015,
-0.0272247549
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18118v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18118v2 | SafeAligner: Safety Alignment against Jailbreak Attacks via Response Disparity Guidance | 2024-06-26T07:15:44 | 2024-06-28T06:06:59 | Caishuang Huang, Wanxu Zhao, Rui Zheng, Huijie Lv, Shihan Dou, Sixian Li, Xiao Wang, Enyu Zhou, Junjie Ye, Yuming Yang, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL | As the development of large language models (LLMs) rapidly advances, securing
these models effectively without compromising their utility has become a
pivotal area of research. However, current defense strategies against jailbreak
attacks (i.e., efforts to bypass security protocols) often suffer from limited
adaptability, restricted general capability, and high cost. To address these
challenges, we introduce SafeAligner, a methodology implemented at the decoding
stage to fortify defenses against jailbreak attacks. We begin by developing two
specialized models: the Sentinel Model, which is trained to foster safety, and
the Intruder Model, designed to generate riskier responses. SafeAligner
leverages the disparity in security levels between the responses from these
models to differentiate between harmful and beneficial tokens, effectively
guiding the safety alignment by altering the output token distribution of the
target model. Extensive experiments show that SafeAligner can increase the
likelihood of beneficial tokens, while reducing the occurrence of harmful ones,
thereby ensuring secure alignment with minimal loss to generality. | SafeAligner: Safety Alignment against Jailbreak Attacks via Response Disparity Guidance: As the development of large language models (LLMs) rapidly advances, securing
these models effectively without compromising their utility has become a
pivotal area of research. However, current defense strategies against jailbreak
attacks (i.e., efforts to bypass security protocols) often suffer from limited
adaptability, restricted general capability, and high cost. To address these
challenges, we introduce SafeAligner, a methodology implemented at the decoding
stage to fortify defenses against jailbreak attacks. We begin by developing two
specialized models: the Sentinel Model, which is trained to foster safety, and
the Intruder Model, designed to generate riskier responses. SafeAligner
leverages the disparity in security levels between the responses from these
models to differentiate between harmful and beneficial tokens, effectively
guiding the safety alignment by altering the output token distribution of the
target model. Extensive experiments show that SafeAligner can increase the
likelihood of beneficial tokens, while reducing the occurrence of harmful ones,
thereby ensuring secure alignment with minimal loss to generality. | [
0.0329220779,
0.0562441871,
0.0122979265,
0.0306081865,
-0.0424689762,
-0.0171145126,
-0.0027163352,
-0.033442542,
0.0100423135,
-0.0243762583,
-0.0006120637,
0.007572067,
-0.0240653399,
0.0277761165,
0.0386278965,
0.0258413833,
0.0838408694,
-0.060035035,
0.0199744534,
0.0106874006,
0.0144717963,
0.0053707263,
0.0245855805,
0.034367308,
-0.0239944849,
0.0017294915,
-0.0298899896,
0.0537770651,
0.0273449831,
-0.0402674861,
0.0156629477,
0.0491223708,
-0.0170114506,
0.0388172753,
0.0000021193,
-0.0153985238,
-0.0447803773,
0.0391249396,
-0.024361968,
0.0298238397,
-0.0117243836,
-0.0705512166,
-0.0282790549,
0.0267735384,
-0.028120989,
0.0027082432,
0.042649772,
0.0306845177,
0.0705095977,
0.0380660109,
0.0183906276,
-0.0004822353,
0.0497639477,
0.0025328221,
-0.024642732,
-0.060618069,
0.0050314134,
-0.0428864025,
-0.0254126098,
0.0355854407,
-0.0069314893,
-0.037832249,
0.0305904504,
-0.0101382844,
-0.0215337723,
-0.00354604,
-0.0490322523,
-0.0193919614,
-0.0443417951,
0.0126206605,
-0.0589703098,
-0.0396550782,
-0.00133047,
-0.0025897077,
0.015998235,
0.0029978075,
0.0161807835,
0.0051751635,
-0.0070304018,
0.0024866683,
0.0348242484,
0.0007404395,
0.0412392914,
-0.0142644923,
-0.0299496856,
0.0600263253,
0.0289309863,
-0.0229901113,
-0.011909768,
-0.0458006747,
0.0081086773,
-0.0547060557,
-0.0062070913,
0.0065487223,
-0.0086776856,
0.007232361,
-0.0841607004,
-0.0294446871,
0.0372677408,
-0.0427519158,
-0.0604472533,
0.0505342446,
-0.0340279303,
0.0015393321,
-0.0212483797,
0.0019317359,
-0.0131362658,
0.0456484146,
0.0095867999,
-0.0040049669,
-0.0070587178,
-0.0215247367,
-0.0017115725,
0.0524851792,
-0.0157894362,
0.0075648208,
-0.0428446606,
0.0165679827,
-0.0093535241,
0.0187210571,
-0.0275984239,
0.0101712411,
-0.0038833248,
0.0187269542,
0.0578610301,
-0.0054937666,
-0.0283436179,
-0.0203637183,
-0.0066661639,
-0.0694847107,
-0.0168573558,
0.0029246423,
-0.089061752,
-0.029424144,
-0.0197757315,
0.1395939142,
0.0380621701,
0.0108833723,
-0.0912547782,
-0.0822156817,
-0.0333927721,
-0.0227069445,
-0.0063161151,
-0.0766955912,
-0.0359712876,
0.0063410271,
0.0049189231,
-0.0677118301,
0.008297598,
-0.0157797746,
-0.060740266,
0.0268949308,
0.0145677645,
-0.0257582292,
-0.0349443369,
0.0296838842,
0.0267176628,
0.0561588779,
-0.0086704604,
0.0544765964,
0.0431738868,
-0.033005435,
0.0357667282,
0.0337465815,
-0.0125986189,
0.0125030102,
-0.0165014938,
-0.0082577374,
0.061969243,
-0.0437829196,
0.011607185,
0.0338830613,
0.0086622918,
-0.0332982875,
0.0721106082,
0.0809944123,
-0.0519204587,
0.0609660335,
-0.0328350626,
-0.0288189631,
-0.0161566045,
-0.0282549132,
-0.0830745101,
0.0176291279,
-0.0743246004,
-0.0146407317,
-0.0116114765,
0.0471760742,
-0.0061423052,
0.0219858773,
0.0055771032,
-0.0163285322,
-0.0134071307,
0.0128427157,
0.0121120512,
0.0076060272,
-0.001227924,
0.0708804354,
0.0270143319,
-0.0196742099,
-0.0385263264,
-0.0838713795,
0.0085249962,
0.0672764927,
0.0208406523,
0.0225931238,
-0.0023528645,
0.0172095094,
-0.0054503004,
0.0122248204,
-0.0188162681,
0.0342852436,
0.0454783328,
-0.0197703317,
0.0066914051,
-0.0046938467,
0.0375085287,
0.0351262949,
-0.0027212824,
-0.0083279479,
0.0072354483,
-0.0143030668,
-0.0408875607,
0.0377769843,
0.0315591991,
-0.0041116658,
0.0371082649,
0.0117787961,
-0.0001359763,
0.0145707596,
-0.0230681878,
0.0274138525,
0.0545127466,
0.0056737927,
0.060172841,
0.0041599781,
-0.0360743999,
0.0104401838,
0.03616881,
-0.0157778729,
0.0072753816,
0.0611979999,
-0.0464350693,
-0.0266204048,
0.0901299939,
-0.025798481,
0.0418299846,
0.0141708599,
0.0391849317,
-0.0045947805,
-0.0126393931,
-0.0227465108,
-0.0017210662,
-0.0166530367,
-0.0151784923,
-0.0336084962,
0.0309115406,
0.0233976748,
0.0204836782,
-0.0512280315,
0.0115735708,
-0.0649519116,
0.0350783281,
0.0179639924,
0.016903704,
0.0009080497,
-0.032944981,
-0.0129480781,
0.015058443,
-0.0436990149,
0.0448476747,
0.049514275,
0.043169383,
-0.0197078977,
-0.041891966,
0.0061060064,
-0.0356496759,
0.0126570193,
-0.0076595121,
-0.0144900065,
-0.0482394621,
-0.0452770479,
-0.0315359421,
0.0026981691,
-0.0260077585,
0.0450565778,
-0.0521281138,
-0.0113592036,
-0.0245803688,
-0.0256411266,
0.0297660325,
-0.0062692212,
-0.0099328775,
-0.0472320095,
0.0512247011,
0.0204118453,
-0.0074714068,
0.0375262499,
0.0215167142,
0.0355989486,
0.0684649125,
0.007448399,
-0.0426061787,
-0.0332288593,
0.0473181717,
-0.0573427677,
-0.0516026691,
-0.071619451,
0.0189493187,
0.0784783661,
0.0293181669,
0.0125566246,
-0.0349159017,
-0.0086475201,
0.011111578,
-0.0257001929,
0.0108964751,
-0.0248105787,
-0.0459694937,
-0.0139906472,
-0.0316346884,
-0.0683678985,
0.0564050302,
-0.0479893014,
0.0313792489,
-0.0295182727,
-0.049113337,
0.0014619797,
0.0188983772,
-0.0374603644,
0.0278232843,
0.0376247391,
-0.0389996879,
-0.0117104836,
-0.0496986695,
0.0036365613,
-0.0147884265,
0.0358753018,
-0.0436538123,
-0.0163484868,
-0.0089049982,
-0.0188237876,
-0.0253822189,
-0.0500167012,
-0.0368227921,
-0.0178867336,
0.0229131989,
-0.0402406603,
-0.0109157292,
-0.0083493805,
0.0086306129,
-0.0033134217,
-0.0284823943,
0.0027629437,
-0.0363442153,
0.0043708063,
0.0144872973,
-0.0980419293,
-0.0291726273,
-0.0073838271,
0.0390824117,
0.0793223232,
0.0420880765,
0.0257733203,
-0.050226599,
0.0062331283,
0.0312487632,
0.0007126709,
0.0154655157,
0.0673793629,
0.0645085871,
-0.007051365,
-0.0438772254,
0.0476291403,
0.0300066043,
-0.0017750644,
0.0401856564,
-0.0347168744,
0.054876104,
0.008241808,
0.0183016025,
-0.0157187656,
-0.0232989248,
0.0250646546,
0.0686051697,
0.0070881215,
0.0213748701,
-0.0141124995,
-0.0480902456,
0.0058373515,
0.0603694096,
-0.0459525362,
-0.0277277846,
-0.0433625802,
-0.0334647931,
0.0043937573,
0.0221703816,
-0.0002775088,
0.0238372423,
0.0089956354,
0.0235803071,
-0.06357418,
0.0057479632,
0.007425935,
-0.0604486577,
0.0572500639,
0.0917859375,
-0.0282410327,
-0.0206988566,
0.0346212685,
0.0255645979,
0.0037817501,
-0.0052580857,
0.0304008182,
-0.0276579186,
0.0095423758,
0.0189048667,
-0.0048541226,
0.0488451496,
-0.0217211209,
-0.062584199,
0.0418123305,
0.0198212415,
-0.000149835,
0.0106608169,
-0.0448199101,
-0.017762972,
0.0221894905,
0.0190640073,
0.0307470169,
-0.0239004474,
-0.0476833768,
-0.0845146775,
-0.0147048179,
-0.0923978463,
-0.0151554979,
0.0347855724,
0.0366094783,
-0.052916687,
-0.0086761741,
0.0271571446,
-0.0530836582,
0.043675229,
0.0438223071,
-0.01310552,
-0.0150528178,
0.0010129601,
-0.0286122244,
-0.0106686512,
-0.0162108652,
0.0568645932,
-0.0489693955,
0.0485158339,
-0.0289242472,
0.0117495907,
-0.0338627212,
0.0102197174,
-0.0584614798,
-0.0953977481,
0.0190826356,
0.077320531,
0.0287050642,
-0.0158241522,
-0.0701230988,
-0.047921963,
0.0559479445,
0.0940593928,
-0.075576134,
-0.0168864541,
0.0502247363,
-0.0582580864,
0.0077762045,
-0.022898145,
-0.0336509161,
-0.0209291317,
0.0911301002,
0.0184883308,
-0.0346765928,
-0.0079013212,
0.0285806991,
0.0319202468,
0.0078228535,
-0.0200359337,
0.015392852,
0.0511965379,
0.0132771404,
0.0042141918,
-0.026409192,
0.0343401618,
0.0232218262,
0.0520329326,
-0.0338332653,
0.0262136329,
-0.0046627345,
0.0038093422,
0.0320505463,
0.0235226136,
0.0235848557,
0.0194423515,
0.0914194211,
0.0444855988,
0.0017273552,
-0.0436887331,
0.0453673229,
-0.0205965005,
0.0242334735,
-0.0219134279,
0.0298388619,
-0.0200757701,
-0.0021461118,
-0.0321026742,
0.0510889143,
-0.0711695999,
-0.0486836918,
-0.034716256,
0.0733842477,
0.0047209393,
0.0393111706,
-0.0056505078,
0.0016751245,
0.0141878817,
-0.0514266305,
0.0022843361,
-0.0061879652,
-0.0431888737,
0.018079998,
-0.0050885584,
-0.0015962588,
-0.0183611643,
0.0514820181,
0.0107363472,
0.0476167202,
0.0172269382,
-0.0277538467,
-0.0277443007,
0.0101959864,
0.0704746544,
0.0325182751,
-0.082527101,
-0.0568700805,
-0.0529034249,
-0.0809543356,
-0.0075978879,
0.0240782108,
0.0638466552,
0.0286833774,
-0.0458517745,
0.0473693386,
-0.0118502779,
-0.001214777,
-0.0462426133,
0.0155775007,
0.0175672527,
-0.0456106514,
-0.0104057835,
-5.533316028e-33,
0.0249495693,
-0.0003405141,
-0.0671440735,
-0.0442890301,
0.0116322441,
-0.0258903243,
-0.0352495983,
0.0218567606,
-0.0035672914,
-0.0553897507,
-0.0000303578,
-0.005669645,
0.0169800892,
0.0127388109,
-0.0224511046,
-0.0205037985,
0.0175950341,
0.0337216742,
-0.0318396389,
0.0404941514,
0.0462759137,
0.0341386758,
0.0008390957,
-0.0525264032,
0.0341693088,
-0.0338818096,
-0.0146381101,
0.0044696662,
-0.0323443376,
0.0621551611,
0.0171194226,
0.007661344,
-0.0061867405,
-0.016662322,
-0.0015172489,
0.0542351566,
0.0192361455,
0.0066639162,
0.0140680261,
0.0087803295,
0.0134787206,
-0.0767190382,
0.0002194874,
0.0068204631,
-0.0191331599,
-0.0188650582,
-0.0115883946,
0.0100437673,
-0.0299634989,
-0.012066626,
-0.0200152881,
-0.0041364548,
-0.0371743627,
-0.0074595306,
-0.0069813584,
-0.0055056522,
-0.0141932303,
-0.0201857779,
0.0071429051,
0.0427652784,
0.0079416428,
0.0063767387,
0.0529024452,
0.0306234062,
-0.0583205819,
0.0305468533,
-0.0228404924,
-0.0635305792,
0.020482365,
-0.0155357951,
0.0000574156,
0.0589546897,
0.0515282415,
0.0854632109,
0.0720757172,
-0.0464439504,
-0.0741080716,
0.0036872234,
0.0074273651,
0.0278656203,
0.038028542,
0.0182457156,
-0.0290590525,
0.0123469355,
-0.0211712345,
-0.0169146154,
-0.0091253761,
-0.0663071275,
0.0268481988,
-0.0179113019,
-0.0487904102,
-0.0364916995,
0.0141915614,
-0.058725521,
-0.0036729816,
0.0394917056,
0.0168705694,
-0.0143587431,
-0.0505110845,
0.040365018,
0.0163612347,
-0.0343825854,
0.0371310711,
-0.0618870147,
0.0372525081,
-0.0157475881,
0.0424485579,
0.0031729147,
-0.0637941211,
-0.0142226331,
-0.0174457841,
0.0308742933,
-0.0019251246,
0.0111613134,
0.0052739284,
-0.0144958086,
0.0133069931,
-0.0104119126,
0.0061045988,
-0.0093164127,
-0.0348801799,
0.0419562533,
-0.0205461103,
0.0392208844,
0.0186854675,
0.0279673692,
-0.0039254092,
0.018148236,
0.0045893774,
-0.0266068168,
-0.0059961132,
0.0161681715,
2.874e-7,
-0.0209545232,
-0.0208481047,
0.0423695371,
-0.0272865146,
0.0056466395,
0.0587951764,
-0.0209599417,
0.1151165068,
-0.0003444589,
-0.0508065335,
-0.0416171439,
-0.0230766442,
0.0702236667,
0.0512980893,
-0.0165706147,
0.054239668,
-0.0786758289,
-0.0017413431,
-0.0572299138,
0.0066718473,
0.039304588,
0.0742088333,
-0.026405884,
-0.0215310827,
0.0006360617,
-0.0460469276,
-0.006892777,
0.0131658558,
-0.0062569156,
-0.0280291401,
0.0082696071,
0.0256065484,
0.0322247669,
0.0406212546,
-0.0325119793,
-0.0007087584,
-0.0600290224,
0.0267071947,
-0.0110283829,
-0.0093661128,
-0.0620296113,
0.0080687376,
0.0059219236,
-0.0432957485,
0.0215092395,
-0.0026493168,
-0.0207814202,
-0.0373196788,
-0.0156141873,
0.0117148459,
-0.0256508496,
-0.0192443412,
0.0091224564,
0.0105735138,
0.0497253053,
0.042445641,
0.0190450866,
-0.0550328977,
-0.0310322046,
0.0163757913,
-0.0103799067,
-0.0385855362,
-0.0108676134,
0.0731900558,
0.0482150018,
-0.0278340429,
0.0416632295,
2.693166383e-34,
0.0040296097,
-0.0548637025,
0.0220056474,
0.0454160571,
0.0278283898,
0.0215609577,
0.0185771808,
0.0414748825,
0.0083702048,
0.0145669654,
-0.0200449917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18116v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18116v1 | BADGE: BADminton report Generation and Evaluation with LLM | 2024-06-26T07:07:52 | 2024-06-26T07:07:52 | Shang-Hsuan Chiang, Lin-Wei Chao, Kuang-Da Wang, Chih-Chuan Wang, Wen-Chih Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Badminton enjoys widespread popularity, and reports on matches generally
include details such as player names, game scores, and ball types, providing
audiences with a comprehensive view of the games. However, writing these
reports can be a time-consuming task. This challenge led us to explore whether
a Large Language Model (LLM) could automate the generation and evaluation of
badminton reports. We introduce a novel framework named BADGE, designed for
this purpose using LLM. Our method consists of two main phases: Report
Generation and Report Evaluation. Initially, badminton-related data is
processed by the LLM, which then generates a detailed report of the match. We
tested different Input Data Types, In-Context Learning (ICL), and LLM, finding
that GPT-4 performs best when using CSV data type and the Chain of Thought
prompting. Following report generation, the LLM evaluates and scores the
reports to assess their quality. Our comparisons between the scores evaluated
by GPT-4 and human judges show a tendency to prefer GPT-4 generated reports.
Since the application of LLM in badminton reporting remains largely unexplored,
our research serves as a foundational step for future advancements in this
area. Moreover, our method can be extended to other sports games, thereby
enhancing sports promotion. For more details, please refer to
https://github.com/AndyChiangSH/BADGE. | BADGE: BADminton report Generation and Evaluation with LLM: Badminton enjoys widespread popularity, and reports on matches generally
include details such as player names, game scores, and ball types, providing
audiences with a comprehensive view of the games. However, writing these
reports can be a time-consuming task. This challenge led us to explore whether
a Large Language Model (LLM) could automate the generation and evaluation of
badminton reports. We introduce a novel framework named BADGE, designed for
this purpose using LLM. Our method consists of two main phases: Report
Generation and Report Evaluation. Initially, badminton-related data is
processed by the LLM, which then generates a detailed report of the match. We
tested different Input Data Types, In-Context Learning (ICL), and LLM, finding
that GPT-4 performs best when using CSV data type and the Chain of Thought
prompting. Following report generation, the LLM evaluates and scores the
reports to assess their quality. Our comparisons between the scores evaluated
by GPT-4 and human judges show a tendency to prefer GPT-4 generated reports.
Since the application of LLM in badminton reporting remains largely unexplored,
our research serves as a foundational step for future advancements in this
area. Moreover, our method can be extended to other sports games, thereby
enhancing sports promotion. For more details, please refer to
https://github.com/AndyChiangSH/BADGE. | [
0.0320475847,
0.0107657006,
-0.0020404954,
0.065466173,
-0.0138052506,
0.0073774322,
-0.0466389842,
0.0276565049,
-0.0012263061,
-0.0371600688,
-0.0129505349,
-0.0380311161,
-0.00087545,
0.0509290695,
0.0254035108,
-0.0734892264,
-0.0142227802,
-0.0409196801,
0.0533650406,
0.0149339354,
0.0324325338,
-0.0007921123,
0.0057924152,
0.0365805961,
-0.017352581,
-0.0171754304,
-0.0576503053,
-0.0005709204,
-0.0053844485,
-0.0738133639,
-0.03812702,
0.0258024111,
0.0208065007,
-0.0162096657,
0.0000017825,
-0.0451840051,
0.0268458333,
-0.037584126,
0.0183351859,
0.0327822864,
0.017105978,
-0.0150668574,
0.0105390754,
0.0015725178,
-0.0313797966,
-0.0108535327,
0.0397675857,
0.0130846715,
0.089564316,
0.0696583837,
-0.0107130902,
-0.0345076099,
0.008478282,
-0.0141517334,
0.0168099422,
-0.0598715618,
0.0130610913,
0.0293830168,
-0.0102650793,
0.0192553382,
-0.0188059825,
-0.0143630402,
0.0054116859,
0.0046834606,
0.004699056,
0.0278956406,
-0.0369678661,
0.02143397,
0.0111069772,
0.0427445397,
-0.0319225676,
-0.0129202874,
0.0078536561,
-0.0128370766,
0.0288680028,
-0.0485618114,
-0.0556385517,
0.0435305797,
0.0090444041,
0.0234302711,
0.0051063057,
0.007810785,
0.0030901053,
0.0052040527,
-0.00251458,
0.013598131,
-0.003462685,
-0.0289337263,
-0.0611007698,
0.0402970575,
0.0359871984,
-0.1226657033,
0.0224605817,
0.0454924293,
-0.0509754978,
0.0267753731,
-0.0049079228,
-0.028744163,
0.0057866122,
-0.0475796163,
0.0564677939,
0.0204664096,
0.0277262758,
0.0163671058,
-0.0187764242,
0.0105178691,
0.0340215862,
0.0059831003,
-0.0462815501,
0.0092916116,
-0.0512158759,
-0.004624574,
0.0039237808,
0.0441223122,
-0.0097868079,
0.0009064375,
-0.0595693327,
0.0414761193,
-0.0045783916,
0.0390369669,
0.0402382538,
0.0019137315,
-0.0016431457,
-0.0098465364,
-0.0408697426,
-0.0124586979,
-0.0622410141,
-0.0059769289,
0.0579181314,
-0.0318318903,
0.0222895145,
-0.0038456072,
0.0089492276,
0.0145308068,
0.0281698294,
0.0339026377,
-0.0085384138,
-0.0008687687,
-0.0283409432,
-0.0347824506,
-0.0101867281,
-0.0745042711,
-0.0284642763,
-0.1087467745,
0.0027859583,
0.0005032443,
-0.0065784189,
0.0015017346,
0.023007663,
0.0417560674,
-0.0029232677,
0.0840640441,
-0.0098312087,
0.02457528,
0.0003702998,
0.006702031,
0.0194187295,
0.0385567769,
0.0309641883,
0.0440079011,
0.0082239043,
0.0266464557,
0.0566151962,
0.0390436463,
-0.0180681273,
-0.0179395508,
-0.0480095968,
0.0220784899,
-0.0378303342,
0.0527164228,
-0.0146017969,
0.0509387739,
-0.0015627482,
0.0501830615,
0.0826288313,
0.0562817752,
0.0300517119,
0.0162234344,
0.0728618801,
-0.0144579066,
0.0136185931,
0.0049008685,
-0.018554043,
0.0394469649,
0.0035209931,
0.0659361109,
-0.0054636979,
0.0056301304,
-0.0360022672,
-0.0866020471,
0.0011525429,
-0.0196861587,
0.0172319319,
0.0138236815,
0.0632174388,
-0.0126572168,
-0.0262722634,
0.0261302441,
-0.0192955937,
-0.0522502549,
0.0340941399,
-0.0505756326,
0.0424727388,
0.0698161796,
0.0137897395,
-0.0367758125,
-0.000282682,
-0.0117805135,
0.0041229944,
0.0347249582,
0.0330137536,
-0.0283016358,
-0.0095280856,
-0.0359135158,
-0.0009808285,
0.0091900667,
0.0337437093,
0.0101888543,
-0.0222297907,
0.0201112945,
0.0115609253,
0.0040055378,
-0.0819970891,
0.0414839461,
0.0360528901,
-0.0673437938,
0.0177084766,
-0.0168643314,
0.0023643896,
0.0509176664,
0.0080086775,
0.0191950258,
0.0472466946,
0.0058972295,
-0.0072041834,
0.0257581938,
0.0018504992,
-0.0362183116,
0.0368592106,
-0.0470715687,
-0.0066578812,
0.0142895542,
-0.0412317552,
-0.0366781838,
-0.022872664,
0.0192956366,
0.0508791506,
-0.0365187749,
0.0273650903,
0.0244115293,
-0.051162634,
0.0020651433,
0.0678817332,
0.0330670215,
-0.0017290682,
0.0040246435,
0.0162695423,
0.0105820578,
-0.0669798404,
-0.0240692794,
0.0559772179,
-0.0147291003,
0.0184551571,
0.0438189246,
0.0504598469,
-0.0771990716,
0.001597185,
-0.1167905033,
0.0112486919,
-0.0167237837,
0.0053911731,
0.0235885028,
-0.0016788235,
-0.0221663825,
-0.0032361355,
-0.0592240766,
-0.0186169688,
0.0497803986,
0.0056786528,
0.0267459396,
0.0136796366,
0.0356035344,
-0.0343314484,
-0.0066092764,
-0.0068378067,
0.0454222299,
0.0279920213,
-0.0061922921,
-0.1019657701,
0.0445256941,
-0.0576827563,
0.0062008281,
0.0235396195,
-0.0008826755,
0.0357237123,
-0.0225783493,
0.0287231077,
0.0677774101,
0.0247761887,
0.0067298096,
0.0421341769,
-0.0740706325,
-0.0152506791,
-0.0045710206,
-0.0146654416,
-0.0330465659,
-0.0418997593,
-0.0404593013,
0.0639514625,
0.0070482208,
0.0003549599,
0.0144953355,
-0.0490114503,
0.0282200724,
-0.0129324151,
0.0161181558,
-0.0660513639,
-0.0337573476,
-0.0432097316,
0.0168606993,
-0.0111594601,
-0.0262380634,
0.0471114926,
-0.0013073555,
0.0344583727,
-0.0551635586,
0.0018275377,
-0.0245010722,
0.1021847352,
0.0097466856,
0.0377510265,
-0.0158292893,
-0.0359283015,
-0.0055557331,
-0.0023705373,
0.0385086723,
-0.0432326607,
0.0409958772,
-0.0195151847,
-0.0073758746,
0.0043251477,
-0.0427834541,
-0.0226429831,
0.0071257376,
-0.0234731771,
-0.0255620759,
0.0266077649,
0.0117487311,
-0.0374290496,
-0.0032733744,
0.0153703708,
-0.0054718275,
-0.0278878007,
-0.0400326215,
0.0227669124,
0.0604314357,
0.0219489802,
-0.0109067457,
-0.0244215112,
-0.0538633727,
-0.001637943,
0.0520444587,
0.0518056341,
0.0261881426,
0.0258360822,
0.0005130876,
0.0162904877,
-0.0393650234,
-0.0370734818,
0.0556303859,
0.0672957376,
-0.0737315565,
0.0008688028,
0.1401822567,
0.060092885,
-0.0752620697,
-0.001420392,
0.0107424762,
-0.0324174054,
-0.0007839212,
0.027355263,
-0.0697727129,
0.0003590798,
0.0193999391,
0.0021447877,
-0.0254271794,
-0.0240140427,
-0.0284756068,
-0.1265297234,
0.0201496929,
0.0113377413,
-0.0183370672,
-0.0816176161,
0.0028251954,
0.0040684217,
-0.0180407707,
-0.0281501561,
0.0328717977,
-0.0113946302,
0.0396900661,
0.0113488613,
-0.0477682948,
-0.0429097041,
0.0265155509,
-0.0920128599,
0.0577975959,
0.064962104,
0.0492867008,
-0.0221729539,
-0.0288518015,
-0.012862674,
0.0141509064,
-0.009053492,
-0.0255303755,
0.050178811,
-0.0226453729,
-0.0080345552,
-0.0446796566,
0.022409169,
0.0287364386,
-0.0108955065,
0.0694304109,
0.0705681369,
0.0357195362,
-0.0000463261,
0.0142860711,
-0.0463926941,
0.0205398723,
0.0538816564,
0.0208401885,
-0.0480748489,
-0.0079034027,
-0.0595581941,
0.0267209746,
-0.0466576368,
-0.0624156147,
-0.0481297486,
0.0198446643,
-0.0217066668,
-0.0542997532,
-0.0645451397,
0.0559596308,
0.0300921649,
0.0093282862,
0.0571386032,
-0.0429876037,
-0.0147683816,
-0.059802305,
-0.001492881,
-0.0089198695,
0.0022489484,
-0.0520632379,
-0.0112800067,
0.0445836112,
-0.023026621,
-0.009430211,
0.0412247963,
-0.0136932814,
-0.0226570312,
-0.0165642779,
0.0564467944,
0.0264643282,
0.0108330771,
0.0155914873,
-0.0073121311,
-0.0289886575,
0.0201467238,
0.002576153,
-0.0113461427,
-0.0263869595,
0.013019097,
0.0144486548,
0.0034432074,
-0.0102858944,
0.0193827096,
-0.0036042356,
0.0598941743,
-0.0566798225,
0.0033162662,
0.053723406,
0.0273283366,
0.0563480034,
-0.0275849011,
-0.0695843771,
-0.0044453484,
-0.0335351117,
-0.0657348931,
-0.0224307012,
-0.0346332788,
-0.0122035788,
0.0027594166,
0.0242383052,
-0.0291719195,
0.0079617389,
-0.0443342812,
0.0152973281,
-0.0585292391,
0.0354721472,
0.0309620313,
0.0072146794,
0.0039435644,
-0.0009988174,
-0.0128043685,
-0.0116331726,
0.0110495929,
0.0054562534,
-0.0106211817,
0.01023807,
0.0273568314,
-0.0084350742,
0.0351360105,
0.0156315528,
-0.0056047388,
0.0587407611,
-0.0387804918,
0.0430077501,
0.0995910615,
-0.0059940447,
-0.0080226045,
-0.0293611903,
-0.0086532487,
0.001619602,
0.0254054368,
-0.006174447,
-0.0579059273,
0.0118757291,
0.0181193091,
-0.0021231016,
-0.0390904993,
0.0453158543,
0.0180781577,
-0.0081750751,
0.0101523194,
-0.0721260458,
-0.0491977669,
0.025093412,
0.0240026545,
0.0225937888,
-0.0425535478,
-0.0243569743,
-0.0730564967,
-0.0309187323,
-0.0003478161,
0.0395873003,
0.0294046234,
-0.0003517928,
0.0223888531,
0.0642774478,
-0.0047760033,
-0.0028274062,
-0.0377717428,
0.0179769713,
-0.0222376008,
-0.0482708625,
-0.0335184075,
-5.555675767e-33,
-0.0381396301,
-0.072247766,
0.0345098861,
0.0467747413,
-0.0496342778,
-0.001127601,
-0.0527932905,
-0.0001345383,
0.014854393,
0.0029758252,
-0.0215508249,
0.0039025589,
0.011612419,
-0.0120712714,
0.0788610876,
-0.0528988913,
0.0569659248,
-0.0269619599,
-0.0290130265,
-0.0112311766,
-0.0129715428,
0.0362339467,
0.0317151323,
-0.0673136264,
0.0505975261,
-0.0304099023,
-0.0539530702,
-0.0094555998,
0.0206161831,
0.0255590547,
0.0042886208,
0.0059585581,
0.0346814953,
-0.0167177096,
-0.0141493687,
0.0426953621,
-0.0314593352,
-0.0324528329,
-0.0099013969,
0.0087681375,
0.0016470795,
0.0115391901,
0.0569932163,
-0.0319999047,
-0.0251144152,
-0.0189043563,
0.044806812,
-0.0492024831,
0.0160079915,
-0.0713819265,
-0.0570915043,
0.0245146398,
0.0265760813,
-0.0016408238,
0.0370069146,
0.001178203,
-0.014068312,
-0.0052188714,
-0.049906224,
0.0579257123,
0.0164854061,
0.0507988557,
0.0362387821,
0.0400622524,
0.0006467405,
0.0088850716,
0.0334673561,
-0.0148906009,
-0.0491376296,
-0.0062072226,
0.0173233412,
0.0297526494,
0.0677384883,
0.0008260196,
0.0349723548,
0.0011060607,
-0.0530748591,
0.0312313456,
0.0556139313,
0.0325122699,
-0.0409982614,
0.0103248162,
-0.0242387652,
0.0096312575,
-0.0218139868,
0.0002442191,
-0.0285696853,
-0.0685239881,
0.0378464162,
-0.0149061847,
0.0127238911,
0.0204392411,
-0.0015533289,
0.0305389613,
-0.057037238,
0.0210096575,
-0.0031385552,
0.0866575539,
-0.0315625034,
-0.0129122613,
-0.0673552603,
0.0148661872,
-0.0291944332,
0.0406241976,
-0.0129929176,
0.0045894454,
0.0100403298,
0.0606395975,
-0.0565657988,
-0.0002345616,
0.0011463199,
-0.0066475654,
0.0080493828,
-0.0112917237,
0.0049288706,
-0.0068894844,
-0.0092852488,
0.0174947698,
0.0179532766,
-0.0653284788,
-0.0391349234,
-0.0050453749,
0.012834915,
0.0182475504,
-0.0000578127,
-0.0061458391,
-0.0380676948,
0.0511689372,
0.0392089002,
0.0025061783,
-0.0121431006,
0.0088105993,
2.599e-7,
0.0226467475,
0.0806647092,
-0.0529656224,
0.0212521572,
-0.0294526145,
0.0259214342,
-0.0535425022,
0.031075038,
0.063262552,
0.0450681001,
0.0448268168,
0.0240819026,
0.0243542176,
0.0513830185,
-0.1250981539,
-0.0222909302,
-0.0531049483,
-0.0318348669,
-0.0582620203,
0.0371239893,
0.0459789634,
0.0294003505,
0.0442433916,
0.0224469267,
0.0270737056,
-0.0446717814,
0.065614678,
-0.001240171,
-0.0202850234,
0.0035571901,
0.0202307981,
0.0045287441,
-0.0526576079,
0.0054352283,
-0.0280015822,
-0.0174607225,
0.0350246467,
0.0288792085,
-0.0154441791,
0.0621286221,
-0.0052742823,
0.012375026,
-0.0283192415,
-0.0434546359,
0.0405164585,
-0.026799025,
-0.0104338098,
0.005506631,
-0.0438409857,
-0.0203280374,
-0.0124557111,
-0.0448836274,
-0.048523277,
0.0195686799,
-0.018585952,
0.0183136966,
0.0141421305,
-0.0314878486,
-0.0257648677,
-0.0183394179,
-0.0198736135,
-0.0130708553,
-0.0305983573,
0.0339985564,
-0.0377175957,
-0.0795121044,
0.0077252164,
2.244426236e-34,
0.0182666425,
-0.0031743152,
-0.017087739,
-0.0262841973,
-0.0053721061,
0.0283770226,
-0.012624247,
0.0382108241,
0.037596494,
-0.0362787135,
-0.0227565244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18108v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18108v1 | Token-Weighted RNN-T for Learning from Flawed Data | 2024-06-26T06:48:11 | 2024-06-26T06:48:11 | Gil Keren, Wei Zhou, Ozlem Kalinli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | ASR models are commonly trained with the cross-entropy criterion to increase
the probability of a target token sequence. While optimizing the probability of
all tokens in the target sequence is sensible, one may want to de-emphasize
tokens that reflect transcription errors. In this work, we propose a novel
token-weighted RNN-T criterion that augments the RNN-T objective with
token-specific weights. The new objective is used for mitigating accuracy loss
from transcriptions errors in the training data, which naturally appear in two
settings: pseudo-labeling and human annotation errors. Experiments results show
that using our method for semi-supervised learning with pseudo-labels leads to
a consistent accuracy improvement, up to 38% relative. We also analyze the
accuracy degradation resulting from different levels of WER in the reference
transcription, and show that token-weighted RNN-T is suitable for overcoming
this degradation, recovering 64%-99% of the accuracy loss. | Token-Weighted RNN-T for Learning from Flawed Data: ASR models are commonly trained with the cross-entropy criterion to increase
the probability of a target token sequence. While optimizing the probability of
all tokens in the target sequence is sensible, one may want to de-emphasize
tokens that reflect transcription errors. In this work, we propose a novel
token-weighted RNN-T criterion that augments the RNN-T objective with
token-specific weights. The new objective is used for mitigating accuracy loss
from transcriptions errors in the training data, which naturally appear in two
settings: pseudo-labeling and human annotation errors. Experiments results show
that using our method for semi-supervised learning with pseudo-labels leads to
a consistent accuracy improvement, up to 38% relative. We also analyze the
accuracy degradation resulting from different levels of WER in the reference
transcription, and show that token-weighted RNN-T is suitable for overcoming
this degradation, recovering 64%-99% of the accuracy loss. | [
0.0362308882,
0.0487010442,
0.0227384418,
-0.0304446872,
0.0079037594,
0.0466002263,
0.0093600415,
0.012119432,
-0.0194059946,
-0.005943906,
-0.022276653,
-0.0376982912,
0.0363572724,
-0.0165620297,
0.0468266308,
-0.0176887605,
0.0382353961,
0.0113886753,
0.0390801802,
0.0051302579,
0.0122052282,
-0.0090806549,
-0.0320183188,
0.0432385989,
-0.0901302472,
0.0208073743,
0.0363770053,
0.026948981,
0.0252234191,
-0.0180552676,
0.0173941832,
0.0339563191,
0.0084508592,
0.0688890517,
0.0000017785,
0.0017085532,
-0.0244845748,
0.003695173,
-0.0110483794,
-0.0219386034,
0.0271447506,
0.0127182966,
-0.0268389434,
0.0350906216,
0.0141715119,
-0.0744743571,
0.0802919939,
0.1117039621,
0.0235237908,
0.0686146095,
0.0092601888,
0.0040351725,
0.0009796341,
-0.03870482,
0.0352912433,
-0.0454126149,
0.0335715227,
-0.0261612386,
-0.0139082698,
-0.0490079485,
0.0004620003,
0.002729615,
0.0470428392,
-0.0021898276,
0.0018899768,
0.0258844383,
-0.0541889966,
-0.0418298244,
0.0006869971,
0.0338506252,
-0.015589173,
-0.0404396281,
0.0219007023,
-0.0145355202,
-0.0030746658,
-0.0517232791,
0.0084656719,
0.0084745362,
0.0135700488,
0.028091969,
-0.0129797729,
-0.0044213925,
0.0675635487,
-0.0073762191,
-0.0263772998,
0.0358191729,
-0.0080457442,
-0.0520466752,
-0.011933051,
0.0024607705,
-0.0113373855,
-0.0307824928,
0.0282122288,
-0.0010359896,
-0.0164202359,
-0.0025208048,
-0.0046005622,
-0.0393056162,
0.0379692167,
-0.029073745,
-0.0042279619,
0.0025656493,
-0.0626037046,
-0.0008680677,
-0.0208193883,
0.0503262207,
0.0359440893,
0.0630021691,
-0.0113629485,
-0.0143812606,
-0.0420595258,
0.0051205773,
-0.0256600138,
0.072530888,
0.0125672454,
0.0086640827,
-0.087894842,
-0.0134560261,
-0.0237930324,
0.0084378673,
0.0564702228,
-0.0038991857,
-0.0734872296,
0.0206561219,
0.0177428592,
0.0022800458,
0.0381684788,
0.0131122489,
0.0142716197,
-0.0570505075,
-0.0225183088,
0.0160995759,
-0.0043766219,
-0.0286963843,
-0.0052891984,
0.0753670633,
0.042891793,
-0.0411908738,
-0.0284955092,
0.0095363334,
-0.0560180843,
-0.0332777537,
-0.0594500229,
-0.0294388942,
-0.0227035005,
-0.0284644831,
-0.0076220394,
-0.0161617063,
0.007170476,
-0.0163124762,
0.0154718757,
0.0457533225,
-0.0343087167,
-0.042002175,
0.0089770369,
-0.0045033311,
-0.0197673347,
0.0295774527,
0.0351919271,
0.0242304932,
-0.0206874162,
-0.006992579,
-0.0176490843,
0.0072270948,
0.0444102995,
-0.0445252955,
-0.0045223455,
-0.0540647432,
0.0265191123,
0.056991104,
0.0532238409,
0.072292015,
-0.0458437987,
-0.0006153435,
0.018199319,
0.008475096,
0.014380971,
0.0377728939,
0.0315380804,
-0.0150901135,
-0.0415789932,
0.026438361,
-0.037518464,
0.0157256778,
0.0028653811,
0.020821197,
0.0719321519,
-0.0189103857,
-0.0255138911,
-0.0572325885,
-0.0272257496,
-0.0019468084,
-0.0325968638,
0.011114466,
0.0542924106,
0.0067335311,
-0.0519713387,
0.0287050344,
0.0058431919,
-0.0409350432,
0.0283061303,
-0.0189340487,
-0.0150950383,
0.0376313999,
0.0235696826,
-0.0755016655,
-0.023562137,
-0.014569141,
-0.0296662413,
0.0343349315,
-0.0013206375,
0.0073932428,
0.0253518652,
-0.0292950906,
-0.009427486,
0.0766085237,
0.0045290985,
0.0564702973,
-0.0572945215,
-0.0022229685,
0.0270547029,
-0.0712190121,
-0.0423527211,
0.0442770794,
0.0091609387,
-0.0200606231,
0.0372978263,
0.0203888938,
0.0666100755,
0.0412718207,
-0.0564293005,
0.0135679897,
0.0391601324,
-0.0222002715,
-0.042669788,
-0.0157225151,
-0.0826545805,
-0.0455182232,
0.0479548164,
-0.0327107534,
-0.0367194191,
0.0224426612,
-0.030103853,
-0.0659774318,
0.036029879,
-0.0379868224,
0.0628546849,
-0.0711798221,
0.0044101197,
0.0417387448,
-0.0284482036,
-0.0396255255,
0.0198155195,
0.0069482685,
0.0836338103,
-0.0318576656,
-0.0744988471,
-0.0133144045,
-0.08620435,
0.005352289,
-0.0052320082,
-0.046664577,
-0.0047522918,
0.0258369818,
-0.0089624757,
0.0080625182,
-0.0044455985,
-0.067748569,
-0.0432228632,
-0.0369501114,
0.0221357439,
-0.037210051,
0.0307921674,
0.006794468,
-0.0214061532,
-0.0297612399,
-0.0535790883,
-0.0202715397,
-0.014730148,
0.0180259589,
0.0141964201,
-0.0082704769,
-0.0167294722,
-0.0045612506,
-0.0321972892,
0.0028096244,
0.0012049172,
-0.0248866435,
-0.05833349,
-0.0056071798,
0.0063614119,
0.0083617242,
0.0232353378,
-0.0326543264,
0.0164046623,
0.0192560442,
0.0158769321,
-0.0188683569,
-0.0145620741,
-0.0077015678,
0.0019603597,
0.0088659218,
-0.0488240235,
-0.0047855526,
-0.0088742916,
0.0369357765,
0.0258997418,
-0.0306931231,
-0.0007718701,
0.0623232946,
-0.003854163,
-0.0038576976,
-0.0571618825,
-0.0252795983,
-0.0058594267,
-0.0428844988,
-0.0012718093,
-0.0309123788,
-0.0186899323,
-0.0067598713,
-0.0023340122,
0.0091001531,
0.0760672763,
-0.0356137045,
-0.0079312446,
-0.0358051211,
-0.0226197802,
-0.0168236308,
-0.0388640426,
0.0242790077,
0.0273596309,
0.0588465482,
-0.0685063675,
0.0044401241,
0.0031268473,
-0.0169303361,
-0.0020923261,
0.0133275855,
-0.0052646515,
0.0490396433,
-0.0103728296,
-0.0297408421,
-0.0128818899,
0.0038825118,
0.002471234,
-0.0036854963,
-0.001481354,
-0.0333064198,
-0.0149083454,
-0.0301250871,
-0.0096423589,
0.0949647427,
0.0012072303,
0.0150696952,
-0.0231167506,
0.0118115572,
0.0187117159,
-0.0285351705,
0.0383215696,
-0.0142598357,
-0.0026544728,
0.030094482,
0.055660814,
0.0051047211,
-0.0170964357,
-0.0082680266,
0.0179309007,
-0.0401739776,
0.0350320637,
0.0368778445,
0.0197800305,
-0.0015130051,
-0.0307638273,
0.1019982249,
0.0225182064,
-0.0374231525,
0.0012666599,
0.000648567,
0.0398019031,
0.0017739314,
-0.0075388374,
-0.0607115924,
-0.0187522545,
0.0442510359,
0.0371737294,
-0.0289252531,
-0.033267729,
0.0634111464,
-0.0552387126,
0.0298121218,
0.0339604802,
-0.0971615911,
-0.0309606437,
-0.0708318129,
-0.0315377116,
-0.0803041905,
0.0747318417,
0.0291037504,
0.0038141569,
-0.0083970986,
0.0960505009,
-0.0411277302,
-0.0772977546,
-0.0116888396,
-0.0438100062,
0.0703475624,
0.0870266706,
0.004347235,
-0.0091316309,
-0.0601003021,
0.0412305035,
0.0023309498,
-0.0159535967,
-0.0187182259,
0.0187538881,
0.0215722099,
-0.0226870235,
-0.0144733749,
0.0125609385,
-0.0471424162,
-0.0078746369,
-0.0696426779,
0.071006462,
-0.013643737,
0.0059735179,
0.0286652315,
-0.0260611605,
0.027947057,
0.0468853749,
0.0467595123,
-0.0138460789,
-0.0262493156,
-0.0248595271,
0.0865135863,
-0.0724779889,
0.0140643343,
-0.013725847,
-0.0340680294,
-0.098232843,
-0.0916762874,
-0.0183655489,
-0.0051503526,
0.0457087234,
-0.0017541171,
0.0015851553,
0.016061252,
-0.0151957478,
-0.0208664406,
0.00679194,
-0.0187251028,
0.023562951,
-0.0686286986,
0.0052634901,
0.0188271515,
-0.0104864901,
-0.0022438918,
0.0159518309,
-0.0383856185,
-0.0706171915,
0.0390326865,
0.0190936942,
0.0131953619,
0.0212617833,
-0.01383969,
-0.0371947922,
0.0660329908,
0.0711485744,
-0.0085342871,
-0.0313517116,
0.0402490571,
-0.0529502109,
-0.0215781033,
0.0192843359,
-0.0553857498,
0.0187902004,
0.0269539952,
0.0620645881,
-0.0314368531,
0.0019541527,
0.0465668663,
0.022139186,
0.0910134539,
-0.0117589422,
-0.0216983464,
-0.0190492254,
0.028472472,
0.0021059918,
0.021856375,
-0.0095072165,
0.0222725179,
0.0184299983,
0.0248415396,
-0.0364891812,
0.018879462,
-0.0583447218,
0.0028088004,
0.0122044627,
0.0227807909,
-0.0167831425,
0.046448864,
-0.0188449696,
-0.0166628323,
-0.012060415,
0.0060231164,
0.0342600383,
0.0329050533,
0.0122646438,
-0.0405019633,
0.0129418857,
0.0562139899,
0.0191483889,
-0.0067919898,
-0.0501486994,
0.0443893671,
-0.0596479103,
0.0112968422,
0.0521237738,
-0.0005593934,
0.0061097564,
0.0066319034,
0.0139836054,
-0.0401706807,
0.0046502254,
-0.0248771664,
-0.0118340952,
0.0227796156,
0.0187959503,
0.0045995116,
0.0126507469,
0.0628253669,
0.0498912074,
0.0817392394,
-0.049407877,
-0.0149132265,
-0.0139671071,
-0.0163724516,
0.0037643053,
-0.0122319534,
-0.0504751839,
-0.0364544429,
-0.0162214357,
-0.1031108052,
0.0546651557,
0.0391484164,
0.0459197797,
0.0133761484,
0.0129572144,
-0.0232098792,
-0.0011755766,
0.0097357072,
-0.0181146562,
-0.0218441822,
0.064912729,
-0.0556831062,
0.0153190931,
-6.61918371e-33,
0.0079588043,
-0.0130540319,
-0.0135596227,
-0.0031363827,
-0.0374880619,
0.0135619985,
-0.0139698582,
0.0088162031,
0.0257049259,
0.0052051046,
-0.0031664835,
0.0014329706,
0.0271674395,
0.0236492362,
0.0080204932,
-0.0069888677,
0.0552071109,
0.0076446747,
0.009342582,
0.0018121004,
0.0591177903,
0.0403852127,
0.0551277697,
-0.0486352667,
0.0171916503,
0.0479550585,
-0.0046707485,
-0.0003586568,
-0.0041957255,
0.0081595946,
0.0166452546,
0.0262986869,
-0.0087789614,
-0.0353075638,
-0.0222405791,
-0.022797456,
-0.0738113075,
-0.0260084663,
-0.0112625184,
0.0476187915,
0.0147311231,
-0.054634396,
0.0761420801,
-0.0179808177,
-0.0712587088,
0.0176430028,
0.0284436382,
-0.0066831736,
-0.0491484068,
-0.0653785244,
-0.0241424907,
0.0421834812,
-0.0192329604,
0.0006703281,
0.0309505425,
-0.0006304674,
-0.0102905808,
0.0101247635,
-0.101074785,
-0.0069315834,
-0.0300559904,
0.0620152019,
0.0134684537,
0.0171457306,
-0.0254558828,
0.0295965765,
0.0562878698,
-0.0249878615,
-0.0036761558,
-0.0031756978,
-0.002647355,
-0.029635191,
0.0608660281,
0.0199428089,
0.0823135525,
-0.0433922783,
-0.0676110983,
0.0326690376,
-0.0402201228,
0.0611801483,
0.0027172682,
0.0603875555,
-0.0215884149,
0.0257039908,
-0.0163104292,
-0.0329527408,
-0.0357257426,
0.0077956985,
-0.0094998851,
0.0288847964,
0.0121121695,
0.0541284829,
-0.0071960944,
0.0086754262,
-0.0031794945,
-0.0223271269,
0.0826940313,
-0.008581222,
-0.0149996858,
0.0200404041,
-0.0635447204,
-0.0245858971,
0.0796148628,
0.0293526705,
0.0338009037,
-0.0484127775,
0.0799390823,
0.0252367016,
-0.0471892767,
-0.013255598,
0.017519692,
0.0519488044,
0.0027142973,
-0.0274771024,
0.0280438215,
-0.0338913202,
0.0081875613,
0.002066883,
-0.0097977426,
0.0088227475,
-0.010638494,
0.0654050112,
-0.0068601714,
0.0136634884,
-0.0358153023,
-0.0369132496,
0.0421637818,
-0.005892213,
-0.0055760094,
-0.0461649522,
-0.0304208696,
0.0302761588,
2.721e-7,
-0.0176846422,
0.0238749441,
0.0738258064,
-0.064181909,
0.015021408,
0.0306366384,
-0.0407317169,
0.0221128911,
0.0115632769,
0.0063706078,
0.043983452,
-0.0386808068,
0.0530354977,
0.0109395832,
-0.1001160517,
-0.0238707047,
-0.0667506754,
0.041601073,
0.02546525,
0.0138667757,
0.0078147016,
0.1191440672,
-0.0044107656,
-0.0530258231,
0.0380376391,
0.0003485159,
0.0337431729,
0.0160816833,
0.0092948386,
-0.0153643694,
0.0223176349,
-0.0148516977,
0.0248819049,
0.0270376522,
-0.0340344198,
-0.0303787589,
0.0460862443,
-0.0190221425,
-0.0393383615,
-0.0523584634,
0.0129055614,
0.0645990074,
0.0486536473,
0.0013537869,
0.0105021307,
-0.0069654034,
-0.014913247,
-0.0195273701,
-0.0366306044,
0.0254740883,
0.0246583316,
-0.0160406809,
-0.0201363768,
0.0387352444,
0.0330406651,
0.0154455518,
-0.0110861911,
-0.0350678042,
0.0143179568,
0.0080329431,
-0.0412808172,
0.0092325546,
-0.0401182175,
0.0456983857,
0.0052300347,
-0.0527311154,
-0.0144658731,
1.964326365e-34,
0.0334860869,
-0.056579601,
-0.0105541628,
-0.0007173607,
0.0223046467,
0.0191776268,
-0.0167505555,
0.0278294887,
-0.0217719283,
-0.0299798343,
-0.0354099944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18094v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18094v1 | Shimo Lab at "Discharge Me!": Discharge Summarization by Prompt-Driven Concatenation of Electronic Health Record Sections | 2024-06-26T06:10:20 | 2024-06-26T06:10:20 | Yunzhen He, Hiroaki Yamagiwa, Hidetoshi Shimodaira | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we present our approach to the shared task "Discharge Me!" at
the BioNLP Workshop 2024. The primary goal of this task is to reduce the time
and effort clinicians spend on writing detailed notes in the electronic health
record (EHR). Participants develop a pipeline to generate the "Brief Hospital
Course" and "Discharge Instructions" sections from the EHR. Our approach
involves a first step of extracting the relevant sections from the EHR. We then
add explanatory prompts to these sections and concatenate them with separate
tokens to create the input text. To train a text generation model, we perform
LoRA fine-tuning on the ClinicalT5-large model. On the final test data, our
approach achieved a ROUGE-1 score of $0.394$, which is comparable to the top
solutions. | Shimo Lab at "Discharge Me!": Discharge Summarization by Prompt-Driven Concatenation of Electronic Health Record Sections: In this paper, we present our approach to the shared task "Discharge Me!" at
the BioNLP Workshop 2024. The primary goal of this task is to reduce the time
and effort clinicians spend on writing detailed notes in the electronic health
record (EHR). Participants develop a pipeline to generate the "Brief Hospital
Course" and "Discharge Instructions" sections from the EHR. Our approach
involves a first step of extracting the relevant sections from the EHR. We then
add explanatory prompts to these sections and concatenate them with separate
tokens to create the input text. To train a text generation model, we perform
LoRA fine-tuning on the ClinicalT5-large model. On the final test data, our
approach achieved a ROUGE-1 score of $0.394$, which is comparable to the top
solutions. | [
0.0526900701,
0.0091706309,
0.0040654461,
-0.0788339972,
-0.0088894488,
0.0238967966,
0.0178263281,
0.0143379914,
0.0208864622,
-0.0010184563,
0.0253491066,
-0.0280800853,
0.0347143188,
0.0916703269,
0.0308186188,
-0.0687616244,
0.0215592198,
0.0221156627,
0.019597413,
0.0142513709,
0.0008011576,
0.0003485927,
-0.0324145667,
0.0454928987,
0.0357282721,
-0.010457512,
-0.0162106622,
0.0361627713,
0.0431146733,
-0.0662010983,
0.007109344,
0.013907304,
-0.0215670113,
-0.0371257104,
0.000002051,
-0.0500863791,
-0.0205292515,
0.0317828842,
-0.0765237361,
-0.0309715718,
0.0111156385,
-0.0432166494,
0.0021442368,
0.0265400726,
0.0139664477,
-0.030836815,
0.0188405439,
0.0485063493,
0.0699084178,
0.0686235428,
-0.0203492921,
0.0328480601,
-0.0185815096,
-0.0440675355,
0.0412376486,
0.0210196767,
-0.0071970061,
-0.0267977826,
0.0481531732,
-0.0627637729,
0.0022305057,
0.0216512922,
0.0193554405,
0.017376259,
0.0370422676,
0.0741263479,
0.0126859266,
0.0101659847,
-0.0174546484,
0.047538843,
0.036052756,
0.0204478726,
0.0706761479,
-0.0155828418,
0.0033538661,
-0.032323949,
-0.0567960516,
0.0188109241,
-0.0391932316,
-0.0100877527,
0.0055577182,
0.0203836989,
-0.0042668097,
-0.0267347358,
-0.0097598629,
-0.0236285739,
0.0221472215,
-0.0426869243,
-0.0043526636,
-0.0049557872,
0.0252385363,
-0.0687348992,
0.0554096587,
0.0598707385,
-0.0534607507,
-0.0195295922,
-0.0320246667,
-0.0309699569,
0.0893804133,
0.0207013637,
0.0272793639,
0.0010100156,
0.0455362126,
0.0101166032,
-0.0136372326,
0.0249028411,
0.0009832272,
-0.006933731,
-0.0380297638,
0.0274065714,
-0.0291278716,
-0.0223366208,
-0.0134431422,
0.0471406654,
-0.0232536085,
-0.0035417839,
-0.0958931521,
-0.0234276094,
0.0272497889,
0.0362249054,
0.0633023605,
0.022719834,
-0.0367258899,
0.0215800349,
-0.003000201,
0.0039587417,
-0.0159163885,
-0.0238269158,
0.0208486207,
-0.0247011427,
-0.0034362962,
0.0132860178,
0.010660707,
0.0039470959,
0.0109191053,
0.0659028217,
-0.0234725215,
0.0001649133,
-0.0092913248,
-0.0743093416,
-0.0316682123,
-0.0335638821,
0.0103551205,
-0.0479487814,
0.03660018,
-0.0082618417,
-0.0135079138,
-0.0243723933,
0.0205107313,
0.0366950557,
-0.0161849987,
0.0097413519,
-0.0813126639,
-0.0043628281,
0.0476348735,
0.0053829029,
0.0066720708,
-0.0184281636,
0.03476597,
0.033698611,
-0.0206445567,
-0.0039027734,
0.0277976077,
0.0164115857,
0.0188949946,
-0.047194086,
0.0492929518,
-0.0068987012,
0.0020641517,
0.041890718,
0.0073208455,
0.0806138813,
-0.0093301125,
0.056733802,
0.0281715952,
0.0585553944,
0.0310546942,
-0.04644344,
0.049077712,
-0.0194376651,
-0.0215004031,
-0.0065586311,
-0.0222889632,
0.0175832342,
0.0414033122,
0.0442897826,
0.0554969758,
0.0199907571,
-0.0406498723,
-0.058399681,
-0.0108566554,
-0.0165639967,
-0.0260402206,
-0.0062432042,
0.0210353024,
-0.0020844564,
-0.054848101,
0.0536584146,
0.0474949032,
-0.0620487891,
0.0137288822,
-0.0624069646,
0.0049833115,
0.1050842479,
0.0519478805,
-0.0073301541,
-0.0511750057,
-0.0532207415,
0.0024117809,
0.0355822705,
0.0321267769,
-0.0114914859,
0.0037502479,
-0.0649753809,
-0.0255633574,
0.0220513642,
-0.0185713843,
-0.0051851557,
-0.0231904853,
-0.0048866863,
0.0250100419,
-0.0083989901,
-0.0724226832,
0.0505623743,
-0.0707886219,
-0.0267195478,
0.020575745,
0.0054862462,
0.0363248587,
0.0432441756,
0.0058219936,
0.047599256,
0.0433350988,
-0.030364776,
0.0065152864,
0.0204812791,
-0.0377328098,
-0.0325538442,
0.0075065512,
-0.0288937185,
0.0148385847,
-0.0321586616,
-0.0125959832,
-0.0360847563,
-0.0440476872,
-0.0553393029,
-0.0064890203,
-0.0241921302,
0.0399600416,
0.088540189,
-0.0330794938,
-0.0392199308,
0.0401280075,
-0.0107752457,
0.0245842244,
0.0421747491,
-0.0069693066,
0.0116901835,
-0.0509630069,
0.0092618549,
0.0045601898,
-0.0220662057,
-0.0127118668,
0.0280879233,
0.0308278278,
-0.0478241481,
-0.0243210923,
-0.1214301437,
-0.0019833057,
0.0059969267,
0.0183707662,
0.0340129621,
0.0179956127,
-0.0170496237,
-0.0180425458,
-0.047608234,
-0.0337396227,
0.0383244529,
0.0109057892,
0.0339390039,
0.0363003239,
0.0042694132,
-0.0082468009,
-0.0192724466,
-0.0276938267,
0.0247220416,
0.0338374227,
-0.0156110311,
-0.031048879,
0.0014540224,
0.0046101329,
-0.0350593068,
0.0134587362,
-0.0124019887,
0.0256175846,
-0.0030853201,
0.103658773,
0.0227864385,
0.0183621775,
0.0152157331,
0.0242102351,
-0.0148660038,
-0.0268566478,
0.0114663858,
-0.0234285612,
0.018397795,
0.0330442451,
-0.0895222276,
0.0480909497,
0.038069915,
0.0443445556,
0.0360996574,
-0.0442432202,
-0.0336199775,
-0.0171537157,
0.0011136367,
-0.0195770431,
0.0102347219,
-0.0511793457,
0.0208214,
-0.0134924063,
-0.0167201161,
0.0601608679,
-0.009040649,
0.0261368547,
-0.0531200618,
-0.0145147648,
-0.0465098508,
0.0282021314,
-0.0158512574,
0.0145580396,
0.0465187952,
-0.0506377779,
0.0132411709,
0.0062118205,
-0.028492175,
-0.0360284634,
0.0345715284,
-0.0254469644,
-0.001416527,
-0.0099649355,
-0.0493812189,
-0.0213390924,
-0.0238307379,
0.0024136298,
0.0013209647,
-0.007010079,
0.0150249172,
-0.0637357384,
0.0228670873,
0.0085343737,
0.0637105703,
-0.0121967196,
-0.0139738536,
0.0015892051,
0.0483440682,
0.0559330173,
-0.0231720693,
-0.0090779243,
-0.087413989,
0.0099800564,
0.0586033762,
0.0410543866,
0.0485689044,
0.0394446515,
-0.0063852188,
-0.016543109,
-0.0891852677,
-0.0279623102,
0.0457064137,
0.0607407354,
-0.0406982116,
-0.0104028517,
0.1153815836,
0.0272074342,
-0.0402863845,
0.0196831692,
0.0092933057,
0.0110617178,
0.0069099013,
0.0220881216,
-0.0204110593,
-0.0074854312,
0.0144107211,
0.0807753727,
-0.0260564163,
-0.0295544062,
-0.0064700651,
-0.0607184395,
0.0322703086,
0.0008790356,
-0.0409258679,
-0.0565805845,
-0.0288599022,
-0.0054776534,
0.0068384381,
-0.0266644284,
0.0163729619,
-0.0389782488,
0.0067215073,
0.0398140177,
-0.0528490283,
-0.0371150933,
-0.0140912151,
-0.019737782,
0.0537859835,
0.0777901709,
0.0214632303,
-0.0043603005,
-0.0090101175,
0.0174633935,
-0.0390649997,
0.0142891193,
-0.0071667871,
0.0895120502,
0.008478079,
0.0051426119,
-0.0653801486,
0.0546246916,
0.0012179802,
-0.0430984385,
0.0330033861,
0.0265908167,
-0.0156545546,
-0.0356810465,
-0.0425574668,
0.0497300848,
0.0147004845,
0.0460061915,
0.0350789465,
-0.0239881482,
-0.0424940996,
0.0028509197,
0.0435001813,
-0.0323235132,
0.0273884051,
-0.021489922,
-0.054751832,
-0.0300197583,
-0.0699997172,
-0.0603102259,
0.0904851332,
0.0241327938,
0.0061120563,
-0.0077181961,
-0.014363002,
0.0031310138,
-0.0517140515,
0.0116812708,
0.0006566132,
0.000276422,
-0.0930821076,
-0.0594230071,
0.0176924691,
0.0081133414,
-0.0184140466,
0.0486291684,
-0.0322133638,
-0.0195351727,
0.0115953889,
0.0451603867,
0.0276352037,
-0.0125933709,
0.0333197229,
0.0156837013,
0.0464100651,
0.0606394857,
-0.030623395,
-0.0127347084,
-0.0512566976,
0.0258779768,
-0.0289003775,
-0.0229565371,
-0.0235215072,
0.012196104,
0.0228788629,
0.0544353127,
0.0076408866,
-0.0164886601,
0.0142270979,
0.0602730624,
-0.0119376238,
-0.0526969954,
-0.0497865044,
-0.0582147911,
0.0133321891,
-0.0166430101,
0.0077006542,
-0.0039116549,
0.0042162868,
-0.0277889874,
-0.0015852005,
0.02060722,
0.0306877438,
-0.0465821251,
-0.006807561,
-0.0765924975,
-0.0262494199,
0.0092719272,
0.0260417573,
0.0310283266,
-0.0378456265,
-0.0272148512,
0.0217161234,
-0.0115505755,
0.0065066023,
-0.0167311374,
0.0553234331,
-0.0060565895,
0.0374161154,
-0.0006737719,
0.0581591949,
-0.0443218015,
-0.0081650028,
-0.0389062464,
0.024634853,
0.0118052876,
0.0351436585,
0.0254801866,
-0.0309138559,
0.0113403024,
-0.0382355638,
0.0367911048,
-0.0039098281,
0.0215360057,
-0.0003976954,
0.0131815141,
-0.0011445237,
-0.0522876494,
0.0733997971,
-0.007511762,
0.0353958309,
0.0255650971,
-0.0165406559,
-0.0811165422,
-0.0147928745,
0.0411823615,
0.013874013,
-0.0350584127,
-0.0413166881,
-0.0701471716,
-0.0097787958,
0.0722705424,
0.0212419555,
-0.0046504852,
0.0162738487,
0.0692903772,
0.000001406,
-0.0126702143,
-0.0235635471,
-0.025645474,
0.0463756882,
0.0164917726,
-0.0178612918,
0.0042860964,
-5.866654267e-33,
-0.0414762981,
-0.0440915674,
0.0162643567,
0.0084170075,
-0.0320844613,
0.0081495047,
-0.0645942464,
-0.0186737664,
0.0530131646,
-0.009295282,
-0.0262719169,
-0.0374815278,
0.0297494009,
0.0370640717,
0.0181382149,
-0.0122301504,
0.0615423582,
0.009380023,
-0.0555003732,
0.0541429669,
-0.0076278374,
0.0456401668,
0.0185144562,
-0.0249604098,
0.0326539017,
-0.009036934,
-0.0175951868,
-0.0383341908,
-0.0057742749,
0.0460758395,
-0.037866313,
0.0177634414,
0.046950534,
-0.0314445309,
-0.0227323454,
0.0383689478,
-0.0853726119,
-0.0239573587,
0.0084985662,
-0.0650314316,
-0.0539853647,
-0.0921362638,
0.0405841805,
-0.0296383761,
-0.0209818929,
-0.0271728262,
0.0373443663,
0.0016403544,
-0.018679373,
-0.0795834586,
-0.0174921397,
0.0299680158,
-0.0139144817,
-0.0165751558,
-0.0349873342,
0.0336709246,
-0.0365568362,
-0.0103911199,
-0.0284054559,
0.0367484689,
0.0476100631,
0.0351299085,
0.0096235257,
-0.019792052,
-0.0095709376,
0.0479252748,
0.0263791233,
0.0151325408,
-0.0349038467,
0.0359021202,
-0.0465108156,
-0.0101995822,
0.0242105611,
-0.0062704291,
0.0482445136,
-0.0249417201,
-0.0702722371,
0.0769570991,
-0.045338124,
0.0313485526,
0.0372812338,
-0.0512282439,
-0.0248556659,
-0.0225379895,
-0.0116890026,
-0.0069387089,
-0.0094300993,
-0.032601282,
0.0347655676,
0.0289040152,
-0.0208774135,
-0.0215320494,
-0.0193389114,
0.0298085921,
0.0415044166,
-0.002475085,
0.0619120225,
0.0147973243,
-0.0466707088,
-0.0332808755,
-0.0413828939,
-0.0058174971,
0.0527070388,
0.0015111043,
0.0347376764,
0.0283620339,
-0.0106009552,
0.0035744687,
-0.0712746531,
0.0081207044,
0.0355698727,
0.0574583635,
-0.0026777559,
0.0160400588,
0.019783061,
-0.0029273934,
0.0072781299,
0.0412927642,
-0.0216114577,
-0.0266415868,
-0.0330283344,
0.0044356333,
0.0480505601,
0.0303908624,
-0.0288863331,
0.0323655307,
-0.0493007228,
0.0621190965,
0.0169118661,
0.0211402308,
0.0141963707,
0.0148258042,
2.681e-7,
0.0296506956,
0.0168570932,
0.0659810007,
-0.0112160724,
-0.0068841903,
-0.0167132858,
-0.0129079204,
0.002033964,
-0.0012003026,
0.0088021299,
0.0486744866,
-0.0204163194,
0.0402696095,
0.0237623919,
-0.0898196623,
-0.0366513655,
-0.0577238724,
-0.0394220464,
-0.0446254499,
-0.0051769861,
0.0750921741,
0.0270319153,
-0.0440722853,
-0.030597657,
-0.0066029304,
0.0374347419,
0.0093280161,
-0.0061967229,
-0.0260856561,
0.0300570037,
0.0111118592,
-0.0573782921,
-0.0120603461,
0.0071119261,
-0.0041607618,
-0.0460798778,
0.0039681154,
0.1038277149,
-0.0080846902,
-0.0086989515,
0.0439593159,
0.0052215164,
0.0121077644,
0.0057909703,
0.0404599532,
-0.0318405814,
-0.0296264756,
0.0100665418,
-0.0628347993,
-0.0104613323,
0.0464184098,
-0.0225112289,
-0.051510293,
0.0389146022,
-0.003148979,
0.0053259414,
-0.0181029327,
-0.0420134589,
-0.0263235979,
0.0064032096,
-0.0476345494,
-0.0456703044,
0.0084269308,
0.0051920707,
-0.0301435441,
-0.0883204713,
-0.0103505701,
2.822837644e-34,
0.0315141939,
-0.0052652904,
-0.0034024806,
0.0016502483,
0.0184517764,
-0.0280244015,
0.0061663347,
0.0369039178,
0.027128851,
-0.0794867724,
-0.0471280552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18088v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18088v2 | LLM-Driven Multimodal Opinion Expression Identification | 2024-06-26T05:52:47 | 2024-06-29T09:55:50 | Bonian Jia, Huiyao Chen, Yueheng Sun, Meishan Zhang, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Opinion Expression Identification (OEI) is essential in NLP for applications
ranging from voice assistants to depression diagnosis. This study extends OEI
to encompass multimodal inputs, underlining the significance of auditory cues
in delivering emotional subtleties beyond the capabilities of text. We
introduce a novel multimodal OEI (MOEI) task, integrating text and speech to
mirror real-world scenarios. Utilizing CMU MOSEI and IEMOCAP datasets, we
construct the CI-MOEI dataset. Additionally, Text-to-Speech (TTS) technology is
applied to the MPQA dataset to obtain the CIM-OEI dataset. We design a template
for the OEI task to take full advantage of the generative power of large
language models (LLMs). Advancing further, we propose an LLM-driven method
STOEI, which combines speech and text modal to identify opinion expressions.
Our experiments demonstrate that MOEI significantly improves the performance
while our method outperforms existing methods by 9.20\% and obtains SOTA
results. | LLM-Driven Multimodal Opinion Expression Identification: Opinion Expression Identification (OEI) is essential in NLP for applications
ranging from voice assistants to depression diagnosis. This study extends OEI
to encompass multimodal inputs, underlining the significance of auditory cues
in delivering emotional subtleties beyond the capabilities of text. We
introduce a novel multimodal OEI (MOEI) task, integrating text and speech to
mirror real-world scenarios. Utilizing CMU MOSEI and IEMOCAP datasets, we
construct the CI-MOEI dataset. Additionally, Text-to-Speech (TTS) technology is
applied to the MPQA dataset to obtain the CIM-OEI dataset. We design a template
for the OEI task to take full advantage of the generative power of large
language models (LLMs). Advancing further, we propose an LLM-driven method
STOEI, which combines speech and text modal to identify opinion expressions.
Our experiments demonstrate that MOEI significantly improves the performance
while our method outperforms existing methods by 9.20\% and obtains SOTA
results. | [
0.0072719012,
0.1124599501,
0.0066968342,
0.0374459438,
-0.0312733315,
-0.0080780406,
0.0389023423,
-0.0135465711,
-0.0154487574,
-0.0608288907,
-0.085143283,
-0.0352993272,
-0.019370662,
0.051806204,
0.0128053511,
-0.020640431,
0.0198089499,
0.0084927361,
0.0331099853,
-0.0095264548,
0.0504361093,
0.0480298847,
-0.053929396,
0.033380948,
-0.0624211356,
-0.0431364998,
0.0210451297,
-0.0028608204,
0.015960468,
-0.0448594578,
0.0179249328,
0.0385620482,
0.03774257,
-0.0201501343,
0.0000018578,
-0.0129407393,
0.0051810984,
-0.0005693269,
0.0262156893,
-0.0075017167,
0.1086449176,
0.0118598752,
0.0029273112,
0.0085407319,
-0.012283789,
-0.0150202103,
0.0528000481,
0.0833410025,
0.0862571448,
0.0612698682,
-0.0297413189,
0.0024556536,
-0.0107261427,
0.0086778635,
-0.007323124,
0.0083643151,
0.0040501324,
-0.0034706865,
-0.0070334929,
-0.027116945,
0.0048352019,
0.0453994684,
-0.0555704311,
-0.0128432279,
-0.0286155492,
-0.0079324059,
0.0182686523,
-0.0157915708,
-0.034095943,
0.1191934645,
0.0631604865,
0.0223746076,
-0.0132952938,
0.016337784,
-0.0441832431,
0.0082662459,
-0.0234378036,
0.0212193895,
0.0087369997,
0.038461335,
-0.0232923776,
0.0444888063,
0.0116069755,
0.0074279313,
0.0093517872,
0.0297613814,
-0.0093538249,
-0.0195826627,
0.0256874785,
-0.005218612,
-0.0532736517,
0.0206964351,
-0.0041371407,
-0.0041337078,
0.0050168503,
0.0064344862,
-0.0151767535,
-0.0306314249,
-0.0298356656,
-0.0357425511,
0.041561991,
-0.0022837142,
-0.0809681565,
0.05018837,
0.0030968608,
0.000395305,
-0.008734501,
-0.0163454004,
-0.0029809903,
-0.0258755274,
-0.064778313,
0.0011787652,
0.0401250087,
0.0408999883,
-0.0689450875,
-0.0728444681,
-0.0417098179,
-0.0133905141,
-0.0521825813,
0.0016536592,
0.0121823922,
0.0146626486,
0.0431311503,
0.010388121,
-0.0266163126,
0.0592984259,
0.0099868793,
0.0707460344,
-0.0510088429,
-0.0433575138,
0.029374199,
0.0729838908,
0.0236383807,
0.0003780291,
0.0362601317,
0.0595694967,
-0.001842249,
-0.0293886121,
-0.0301366355,
-0.0305659659,
-0.0607493371,
-0.0494510271,
0.0204507019,
-0.0436782725,
0.0336115621,
-0.0082956739,
-0.0147432918,
-0.0358184576,
0.025963489,
-0.0104708811,
0.0062096673,
0.0678063706,
-0.0002697519,
0.0395276025,
0.0035314604,
-0.0070415945,
0.0271373279,
0.0468157381,
0.0369824469,
0.0172858592,
0.045360513,
-0.0187817384,
0.0343205705,
0.0504183993,
-0.0230092127,
0.0081437062,
-0.0031289668,
-0.027208101,
-0.0557313785,
0.0308320466,
0.0451812819,
0.0871569291,
0.014444856,
-0.0088943727,
0.0936070606,
0.031172052,
-0.0345647633,
0.0304912739,
-0.0192888137,
0.0127074681,
0.0025002602,
-0.027840415,
0.0160889309,
0.0335014388,
-0.0153015703,
-0.0187781006,
0.0455505699,
0.0098410817,
-0.0354214348,
-0.0303329416,
-0.038490206,
-0.0233729761,
-0.0312711373,
0.024233697,
0.0185807366,
-0.01381227,
-0.0459964015,
0.0196575578,
0.0322170667,
-0.0805181041,
-0.0161553007,
-0.0370059386,
0.0466858372,
0.0439445674,
0.0112800226,
-0.0309717506,
-0.0052923788,
-0.0288127791,
0.001025549,
0.066819489,
0.0175840091,
-0.0129123796,
0.0217903946,
-0.0485947616,
0.0139206173,
0.0060939118,
-0.0029661753,
-0.0058369036,
-0.0125673916,
0.0112403799,
-0.0149142388,
-0.060380917,
0.023410311,
0.0143835796,
0.0378773771,
-0.0321793109,
0.0238175951,
0.0222996585,
0.050148014,
0.0370458029,
-0.049788624,
-0.0062009441,
0.0287372135,
-0.0332802609,
-0.0308809485,
0.031247355,
-0.0308840815,
-0.0470481813,
0.0172522627,
-0.0345560424,
-0.0056475955,
0.0384352766,
-0.031044215,
-0.0100280941,
0.0315768383,
-0.0215370059,
-0.007357107,
-0.0704443529,
-0.0264923275,
0.0190512426,
0.0285382383,
-0.0142028611,
0.0252125263,
-0.0047863475,
-0.032600183,
0.0057521281,
-0.0165284071,
0.0105157681,
0.0053891623,
-0.0540769994,
-0.0047041499,
0.0248680394,
0.0112032546,
-0.0124386065,
-0.0128605412,
-0.004833316,
-0.0465805568,
-0.1202741638,
-0.0253150128,
0.0182390139,
0.0175816845,
0.0213732049,
-0.0145738525,
-0.0102913855,
0.0263141301,
-0.0501531251,
-0.0141023016,
0.0473311953,
0.0111181913,
0.014887657,
-0.020041585,
0.0192783456,
-0.0384548381,
0.029441908,
-0.023083616,
0.0348935649,
-0.0324474387,
-0.0300347209,
-0.0125293974,
-0.0082197171,
-0.0577827953,
0.0494112223,
-0.0051707197,
-0.0318789668,
-0.0012874271,
-0.0091100223,
0.0503557213,
0.0117940241,
0.0051355632,
0.0412769057,
0.0342140645,
-0.0032159274,
-0.0194188487,
0.0153692868,
-0.0270754918,
0.0172924679,
-0.0145417796,
-0.0357508138,
0.0099546975,
0.0321917385,
0.0446875654,
0.0164563861,
0.0047695818,
-0.0043386305,
0.0153445853,
-0.0370939784,
0.0073118689,
-0.0097708823,
-0.0304362141,
-0.0058006141,
0.0138727613,
-0.0211311821,
0.0339379571,
-0.0340780877,
-0.0255069677,
-0.0554249994,
-0.0179076008,
-0.0592725985,
0.0674446002,
-0.0700670779,
0.0158040617,
-0.0040140445,
0.0136193857,
-0.0108227143,
-0.029637564,
-0.03624513,
-0.0449567288,
0.0243846998,
-0.0081947437,
0.0146482661,
0.0361085497,
-0.0477250144,
-0.0055151968,
-0.0630450249,
-0.0435716547,
-0.0183894504,
0.0111250738,
-0.0227749906,
-0.0018569086,
-0.0004288312,
0.0274257734,
-0.0500889905,
0.0092613436,
0.0251804125,
0.0097863721,
0.0603391044,
0.0748944432,
0.0305489991,
0.0070060659,
-0.0074718464,
-0.0018702849,
0.0383147784,
0.0064748023,
0.0175793748,
-0.0474992543,
-0.0225504693,
0.0266137961,
0.0664098933,
0.0110313697,
-0.0258315485,
0.0415224768,
0.0056385295,
0.048188027,
0.1423469484,
0.0008534009,
-0.055335667,
-0.0030189797,
0.0194755457,
-0.015210011,
0.0134041058,
-0.0072363988,
-0.0610465705,
-0.0712637827,
-0.0286118593,
0.0267266184,
-0.0222633965,
0.0112336306,
0.0043240483,
-0.1195890382,
0.0267268606,
-0.0147948368,
0.0243684556,
-0.029825259,
-0.0090432214,
0.0276333597,
-0.0091181556,
-0.0041281837,
-0.0439240746,
-0.0082593244,
-0.0146664018,
0.0266005285,
-0.0470330939,
-0.0573520139,
0.0558075309,
-0.0131011233,
0.0609622002,
0.0347296186,
0.0468997993,
-0.0295640603,
-0.0454146564,
0.041595567,
0.0088969441,
-0.0070222579,
-0.0145002026,
0.0546632893,
-0.0564313754,
-0.0198966432,
-0.0083917119,
0.0364424139,
-0.0174223706,
0.0241100639,
-0.0097960122,
0.0448738746,
-0.0309011023,
-0.0221007764,
-0.0349569134,
0.0543337986,
0.0446290597,
0.0668992475,
0.0009180293,
-0.0746736377,
-0.0129771987,
0.0276563205,
0.0154840443,
-0.0021178967,
-0.0177253969,
-0.0297815204,
0.0113528278,
0.0158001464,
-0.0745669976,
-0.0115976259,
0.0071950518,
0.0221936963,
0.0200409498,
-0.0148662841,
-0.0039290995,
0.021729771,
-0.0436985046,
0.0431544185,
0.0062390426,
0.0326106139,
-0.0310782772,
-0.0048573781,
0.0673584789,
-0.0194189679,
-0.020209223,
0.028650213,
-0.0627255216,
-0.0390376821,
-0.0219694506,
0.015708372,
0.0054808203,
-0.0230544247,
0.041984275,
-0.0457027406,
0.0382543951,
0.0469585843,
-0.0062306663,
0.0315985568,
0.0308662355,
0.0617684461,
-0.0106681064,
0.0185226072,
-0.0141999023,
0.0602062158,
0.0095717981,
0.0222507138,
0.0052280868,
-0.0420147814,
-0.0279912017,
0.0102349641,
0.0579135977,
0.0072303261,
0.0095739514,
-0.0540818907,
-0.0267609134,
0.0081234202,
-0.0089504505,
-0.0739803165,
-0.0008609743,
0.0144422781,
0.0333617665,
-0.0560191646,
-0.0138265491,
0.0069217104,
0.0425491519,
-0.033824347,
0.0712455437,
0.0283722691,
-0.0418254919,
-0.0351020694,
0.0221791025,
-0.0362125859,
0.0304752849,
-0.0181107707,
-0.0378109366,
0.0140982866,
0.0597739443,
-0.000508438,
-0.0343174376,
-0.0171638448,
0.0374290124,
0.018585328,
0.0142912241,
-0.0351532511,
0.0393917784,
0.018613195,
0.0006319028,
0.040588364,
-0.0259276796,
0.0133013008,
-0.0477426797,
0.0390841179,
-0.0504703782,
0.0013119993,
0.0483208038,
-0.0078806998,
-0.0265857112,
-0.0079603763,
0.0472768806,
-0.0401286855,
0.0305406507,
0.0099333087,
-0.0026683242,
-0.0574891195,
-0.0218089074,
0.0450610109,
0.0044186241,
0.0027301088,
0.0329694934,
-0.018843146,
-0.0533618405,
0.0558591485,
-0.0297282841,
-0.0062887971,
-0.0258744191,
0.0147298183,
0.0412069634,
0.0094366036,
0.0440227315,
-0.0571139604,
-0.0327807963,
-0.0503371209,
-0.0217522364,
-0.0283640064,
-5.780324493e-33,
0.0029278041,
-0.0224609002,
-0.0245398656,
0.022764165,
-0.0342773907,
0.0138999745,
-0.0178196598,
0.0332518071,
0.008962038,
0.0252256934,
0.0265891701,
-0.0284049567,
-0.0041528987,
0.048580952,
-0.009681467,
-0.0100218691,
0.0327992253,
-0.019227013,
-0.0102747427,
0.005805843,
0.0568935387,
0.0221917424,
0.0537698641,
-0.1214790195,
0.0182237215,
0.0127689419,
-0.0516611189,
0.0055976696,
0.0388636962,
0.0593744777,
-0.0538077019,
0.0969142765,
0.010444981,
0.0178297143,
0.0138917966,
0.0476092324,
-0.0135025429,
0.0211546365,
0.0239708051,
-0.0082435794,
-0.0468607917,
-0.0013818711,
0.0021486504,
-0.0029920007,
-0.0823326334,
-0.0032754294,
0.0494966283,
-0.0162878335,
0.0396687873,
-0.0657447949,
-0.0461233035,
0.0109129352,
0.0035196147,
-0.0395448916,
0.0414665751,
0.0377902947,
0.0010221801,
0.0189865921,
-0.0423243865,
0.0528868623,
-0.0644011199,
0.0008030849,
0.0259257462,
-0.0026355388,
0.0235135425,
0.1047230363,
0.0163335204,
-0.0414873324,
-0.044907134,
0.0187376402,
0.025679443,
0.0388610102,
0.0217294022,
0.0599501692,
-0.0293571614,
-0.0234479178,
0.000494985,
-0.006368184,
0.0340191163,
-0.0268710144,
0.0778041556,
-0.00988416,
-0.0357642397,
0.0077421782,
-0.0256632362,
-0.0142275207,
-0.0438267179,
-0.0062780008,
0.0327212624,
0.0005136147,
-0.0115272934,
0.0006191151,
0.0397799164,
-0.0283101499,
-0.0174200032,
0.0091134096,
-0.0212465897,
0.0686006323,
0.0062991856,
0.0035312171,
-0.0519187786,
-0.004554362,
0.0233309232,
0.0070549026,
0.0505002365,
-0.0328150205,
0.0053310823,
0.0434202105,
-0.0735940859,
-0.0078166341,
0.0045972466,
0.0042750509,
-0.0267467629,
0.0405583382,
-0.0255791321,
-0.0087512163,
-0.0306032635,
0.0161346998,
-0.0247039087,
0.073980093,
-0.0187010486,
-0.0703170002,
-0.0141909635,
0.0056335563,
-0.0542483367,
-0.0091351308,
0.0186892282,
-0.0797385052,
-0.0356206633,
-0.0352941528,
0.0186368879,
0.0264358725,
2.665e-7,
0.0239152927,
0.0464603193,
-0.0182615258,
0.0115199136,
0.0319429301,
0.0357935391,
-0.0140015483,
0.0111280465,
0.0113490717,
-0.0457224548,
0.025605401,
0.000466418,
0.0732664838,
0.0021185393,
-0.0814221501,
0.0257291049,
-0.008621648,
0.0169932786,
-0.0347990841,
0.0342534482,
0.080194816,
0.0920856595,
0.0042910166,
-0.0340316296,
-0.0179228764,
-0.0102820825,
0.0609023795,
-0.022673225,
-0.0252840314,
0.0044413181,
0.0264422745,
-0.0299696214,
-0.0035079108,
-0.0340619311,
0.0052138008,
-0.0144539224,
0.0176758785,
0.0539858192,
0.0204932131,
-0.1086676344,
-0.0107276682,
0.0747688711,
-0.0129180048,
0.0266028717,
0.0673382208,
-0.00944228,
-0.039919924,
-0.1144355685,
-0.0070520984,
-0.0124243861,
0.018833939,
-0.0228108633,
-0.0047175097,
0.0108030131,
0.0153530268,
-0.0529563837,
-0.0566843934,
-0.0665062442,
-0.0060220403,
0.0061299875,
-0.072869055,
-0.0351963565,
0.0099664507,
-0.0082260435,
0.0147998584,
-0.0659708753,
-0.0120607084,
2.144498884e-34,
0.0392255448,
-0.0311476495,
-0.0207118671,
0.0241423938,
0.0330202468,
0.0041369526,
-0.0454349481,
-0.0348587781,
0.0192001257,
-0.0569789745,
0.0062893052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18087v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18087v1 | EHR-Based Mobile and Web Platform for Chronic Disease Risk Prediction Using Large Language Multimodal Models | 2024-06-26T05:51:08 | 2024-06-26T05:51:08 | Chun-Chieh Liao, Wei-Ting Kuo, I-Hsuan Hu, Yen-Chen Shih, Jun-En Ding, Feng Liu, Fang-Ming Hung | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | Traditional diagnosis of chronic diseases involves in-person consultations
with physicians to identify the disease. However, there is a lack of research
focused on predicting and developing application systems using clinical notes
and blood test values. We collected five years of Electronic Health Records
(EHRs) from Taiwan's hospital database between 2017 and 2021 as an AI database.
Furthermore, we developed an EHR-based chronic disease prediction platform
utilizing Large Language Multimodal Models (LLMMs), successfully integrating
with frontend web and mobile applications for prediction. This prediction
platform can also connect to the hospital's backend database, providing
physicians with real-time risk assessment diagnostics. The demonstration link
can be found at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oqmL9DEDFgA. | EHR-Based Mobile and Web Platform for Chronic Disease Risk Prediction Using Large Language Multimodal Models: Traditional diagnosis of chronic diseases involves in-person consultations
with physicians to identify the disease. However, there is a lack of research
focused on predicting and developing application systems using clinical notes
and blood test values. We collected five years of Electronic Health Records
(EHRs) from Taiwan's hospital database between 2017 and 2021 as an AI database.
Furthermore, we developed an EHR-based chronic disease prediction platform
utilizing Large Language Multimodal Models (LLMMs), successfully integrating
with frontend web and mobile applications for prediction. This prediction
platform can also connect to the hospital's backend database, providing
physicians with real-time risk assessment diagnostics. The demonstration link
can be found at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oqmL9DEDFgA. | [
0.0094233928,
0.0665947944,
-0.0188552868,
-0.0418096893,
0.0295001585,
0.0113684693,
0.0204817895,
0.0261826105,
0.0461694375,
0.0025784771,
0.0272550154,
-0.0282444526,
0.0181926396,
0.0545988977,
0.0075100753,
-0.0575620793,
0.0049890801,
0.0035744223,
0.0249345209,
0.0252640061,
0.0185168739,
0.0052686781,
-0.0079486202,
0.0673931465,
-0.0401181839,
-0.0296636764,
-0.0139587577,
0.0022222514,
0.0061533018,
-0.0772711486,
0.0108107915,
0.0010102604,
-0.0101139015,
-0.037421748,
0.0000022071,
-0.0499078147,
-0.051514864,
0.018017767,
-0.0173578076,
-0.0818092003,
0.070620358,
-0.0365174413,
0.0115593104,
0.0154199759,
-0.025244901,
-0.0216382332,
0.0414696112,
0.0477089584,
0.0362592861,
0.0192200188,
-0.0302297585,
0.0214072131,
0.0474454723,
-0.0057841083,
0.0276172366,
-0.0473318882,
0.0121920733,
-0.0153932776,
0.0280046649,
-0.062810041,
-0.0051736855,
0.0278762728,
0.0029608961,
0.0731501728,
-0.0251417924,
0.0217688233,
0.0314383358,
-0.0329856239,
-0.0343316533,
0.0600177161,
-0.0069495193,
0.0047148177,
0.028672386,
0.0140798837,
-0.0235600471,
0.0261516161,
-0.0238612015,
-0.018895369,
-0.0489333384,
0.0002410515,
0.0007320795,
-0.0242638662,
0.0339598507,
0.0054589566,
-0.003908196,
0.0207892749,
0.016745979,
-0.0121998712,
-0.0092833629,
-0.049008213,
0.0433278792,
-0.0300857108,
0.0193040632,
0.0540589169,
-0.0679940209,
-0.0235621408,
0.0015929397,
-0.0039951378,
0.065166004,
-0.0532102734,
0.048033081,
0.0270119235,
0.0014701828,
0.0257909391,
0.0134075992,
-0.0112501532,
-0.0395045094,
-0.0093854424,
-0.0297751538,
-0.0115558449,
-0.0309041291,
0.0007762522,
0.0108918622,
0.0086597875,
0.0101817958,
-0.0323109515,
-0.0939862058,
0.0040591415,
0.0048608407,
-0.0018873963,
0.0143823689,
0.0432689935,
0.0041157161,
0.028867593,
-0.0573059916,
0.040880505,
0.0293985046,
0.0070379255,
-0.0006619756,
-0.0517884679,
0.0835328996,
0.0033516802,
0.0163157023,
-0.0168030448,
0.0339688882,
0.0900921971,
0.0234844778,
0.0002393892,
-0.0209198371,
-0.0629403368,
-0.0087787146,
-0.0311166048,
-0.0012960203,
-0.0649519786,
0.0146460794,
0.0148114637,
0.0228658747,
-0.0491491035,
0.0269050766,
0.0140351132,
-0.0133733712,
0.0320971012,
-0.0511009879,
0.0065901494,
0.0449003577,
0.0121140396,
-0.0009285935,
0.0384558812,
0.0357572138,
-0.0004126181,
0.0198149085,
-0.048390571,
0.0319310129,
0.0462091267,
0.0044114981,
-0.0508226529,
-0.000538972,
-0.0234746765,
-0.011565865,
0.0397191197,
-0.0532743037,
0.0414066017,
0.0346185341,
0.0219073463,
0.0747167021,
-0.0011637381,
0.0362760536,
0.0099760657,
0.0002830335,
-0.0524871908,
-0.0285619944,
-0.0676690415,
-0.0025091146,
0.0463889278,
-0.0437476039,
-0.0191098861,
-0.004084493,
0.0177961364,
-0.0313555002,
-0.0471633077,
-0.0387680903,
-0.0420492068,
0.0300844144,
-0.0006389436,
0.0417578928,
-0.0573589616,
0.0061046295,
0.0295847896,
0.0354318619,
-0.0100693023,
-0.0420671366,
-0.0551148988,
-0.0108079202,
0.0915206894,
0.0031763301,
-0.0093406262,
-0.0269933604,
-0.006131486,
-0.0089041907,
-0.063252531,
0.024064837,
-0.0074461633,
0.0389751196,
-0.0240972657,
-0.0157982856,
0.0593845583,
0.0294019263,
-0.0402178429,
-0.0244144294,
0.0747066736,
-0.0236494225,
-0.0376629122,
-0.0140944524,
0.0043854672,
-0.063719064,
0.0108517706,
0.0193704944,
0.0538601279,
0.04599116,
0.0190043394,
0.0349327885,
0.0203779172,
0.0229036659,
-0.0413220339,
-0.035367921,
0.0291189719,
0.0177273788,
0.020688517,
0.0371691249,
-0.0071471934,
0.0316739529,
-0.0219414625,
-0.0238474067,
-0.0158398133,
-0.0084285717,
-0.0553764999,
0.0106053604,
0.0023906056,
-0.0198161136,
0.0758506358,
0.0362218842,
-0.0080981022,
0.0012818453,
-0.0034311106,
-0.0254021417,
0.002742596,
-0.056403175,
-0.0039161113,
-0.0303863026,
-0.0041799494,
-0.0094893379,
0.0006687263,
0.0235086828,
0.0063574766,
-0.010873789,
-0.0272385795,
0.0247511379,
-0.1405617148,
-0.0039416431,
-0.0030746593,
-0.0160580054,
0.0261847135,
0.0481407382,
-0.0072659613,
-0.0489144959,
-0.0013769431,
0.0259424839,
0.0015049884,
0.0267201997,
0.0193797853,
0.0443655998,
0.0239493344,
0.0015125956,
0.0124644367,
-0.0660087988,
0.0494134761,
-0.0046680616,
-0.0182927772,
0.0115012759,
-0.0809887424,
-0.056662973,
0.009128009,
0.023211034,
-0.0125843408,
-0.0231626071,
-0.0413142927,
0.0314200558,
0.0343814529,
-0.0224417988,
0.0409754999,
0.0330043845,
-0.0124200182,
-0.0158901177,
0.0202643014,
-0.0399771556,
-0.0029789554,
0.0072757225,
-0.0577345416,
-0.0242815297,
0.0527098291,
0.0461149551,
0.0383353047,
-0.0038846831,
0.0135836927,
-0.0189278219,
0.0322556309,
-0.0715892836,
0.073499538,
-0.0307952613,
0.0421740711,
0.0006612078,
-0.0209558569,
0.0559929125,
0.015283633,
0.0549998842,
-0.0222514737,
-0.0594786778,
-0.0307697244,
-0.0082515916,
-0.0032657662,
0.0328695141,
-0.0254363641,
0.0141130453,
0.0120136812,
0.0022985511,
-0.0301129092,
-0.0581663288,
0.0191790257,
-0.0247566234,
-0.0174582526,
0.0127359452,
-0.0317616686,
-0.0068685599,
0.0000563976,
-0.0595021658,
0.0085668983,
-0.0510501675,
0.0454617105,
-0.0351931229,
0.0109960288,
-0.0240919441,
0.061853461,
0.0194484629,
-0.0139561919,
0.0334455557,
0.0155525943,
0.0545473769,
-0.0033576617,
-0.0381574146,
-0.0237887446,
0.04253437,
0.0397386067,
-0.0065435441,
0.0163991936,
-0.0388669372,
0.0424469486,
-0.0032236872,
0.009950377,
-0.0248387083,
0.0599295385,
0.0107113961,
-0.0541534759,
0.0614897646,
0.0675610527,
0.0001159666,
-0.0532887205,
0.0114470199,
-0.0046321498,
-0.0327150449,
-0.0076407683,
-0.0098147588,
-0.0723430589,
-0.0590632632,
-0.0036444038,
0.0110880984,
-0.0065961145,
-0.0277620554,
0.0389967524,
0.0180235952,
0.0214920174,
-0.0032642793,
-0.0311995298,
-0.0207052417,
-0.0378070883,
0.0292603094,
-0.0300831292,
-0.0232231095,
-0.038070444,
-0.0137924915,
-0.0235740058,
-0.0019707677,
-0.1160960495,
-0.0611282587,
0.0282019731,
-0.0045900908,
-0.011139039,
0.0793213248,
0.0535249263,
-0.017662257,
-0.0332511067,
-0.0077151619,
0.0410546288,
0.0422160514,
-0.0606771931,
0.0520031564,
0.0198731832,
0.0093245842,
-0.0570106059,
0.0550966449,
-0.0262791943,
0.0023582957,
0.0226715747,
0.1148285493,
-0.0307454821,
-0.0272182655,
-0.0788403004,
-0.0241199434,
0.0600740574,
0.0140745714,
-0.0196879692,
-0.0756338835,
-0.0473859981,
0.0100318985,
0.0345559269,
0.0527323037,
-0.0045455405,
0.0277595241,
-0.030965697,
-0.0446278602,
-0.031338647,
-0.0082874158,
0.0145103261,
-0.0409800783,
0.0245818775,
0.0555013977,
0.0412272438,
0.025995722,
-0.047225859,
0.0095907534,
0.0502090454,
0.0577076189,
-0.0571266189,
-0.0110962689,
0.0429659598,
-0.046346046,
0.0190111659,
-0.0088487221,
-0.054464031,
0.0335375331,
-0.0133999242,
0.0586158186,
0.0148296887,
-0.0202076938,
0.0107331825,
-0.0252140686,
0.0120739462,
0.0109752733,
-0.0372366831,
-0.0223659296,
-0.0237706285,
0.0010610817,
-0.0160379205,
-0.0067058648,
-0.024776062,
0.0019552251,
-0.0179175977,
-0.0123622147,
-0.0212758463,
-0.0201454517,
0.0152897891,
0.0432234667,
0.0762950405,
-0.0170203689,
-0.0557433218,
0.0058077346,
0.0366120413,
-0.0062170499,
-0.0001906722,
-0.0271243546,
0.0136389304,
-0.0185161792,
0.0281332433,
-0.0016262393,
-0.0153259495,
0.0276092067,
-0.071098946,
-0.0659194291,
0.1026349738,
0.0184827708,
0.0038187096,
0.0474079326,
0.0076330109,
0.0230599679,
0.0381328091,
-0.0100027211,
0.0001789541,
-0.0187418405,
0.0766709447,
-0.0425990187,
0.0153507497,
-0.0029180462,
0.0593837388,
0.0118623665,
-0.0304684453,
-0.0136866029,
0.031701155,
0.0410243981,
0.0286302082,
0.0138506349,
-0.0239157192,
0.0084544132,
-0.059764266,
0.0262493417,
-0.0099113239,
-0.0036074677,
0.066027455,
-0.0165453125,
-0.0162367728,
-0.019684568,
0.0672523975,
0.0090156496,
0.0292395297,
0.0091013284,
-0.0537161008,
-0.0452565216,
0.0358718447,
0.0888553783,
0.0212689862,
-0.0842134058,
-0.0031032958,
-0.03041091,
-0.0767690614,
0.0629572719,
-0.025307294,
-0.0272291861,
-0.0245184805,
0.0181871094,
0.0389981717,
-0.0011746099,
0.0141809918,
-0.0474887639,
0.0268675648,
-0.0643187016,
-0.007881552,
0.0030849443,
-6.255163967e-33,
0.0298932437,
-0.0227635149,
0.0086105801,
-0.0373248979,
0.0325947367,
0.004732816,
-0.0210984293,
0.0054365289,
0.0260168687,
0.0073251608,
0.0111053512,
-0.0455717146,
0.008483408,
0.0419822931,
0.014274206,
-0.0378712378,
0.0129305702,
0.01862658,
0.0076516634,
0.0066917618,
-0.0054638828,
0.0442052819,
-0.0016114194,
-0.0899773613,
-0.038247671,
0.025788974,
-0.0278599206,
0.003043887,
-0.0318807885,
0.0774253383,
-0.0361325778,
0.0807348788,
0.0483530127,
-0.0117157074,
0.0015147143,
0.0316162221,
-0.0633951351,
-0.0302138682,
-0.02673853,
-0.0019128438,
-0.0376966186,
-0.0331185162,
0.0416199118,
-0.0316053256,
-0.0326265916,
0.0034122884,
0.0552369282,
-0.0542231277,
-0.0145104183,
-0.0553100742,
0.026215503,
0.0267419182,
0.0003217878,
0.0227114018,
-0.0038472333,
0.0216161981,
-0.02968763,
-0.0038610757,
-0.0624775887,
0.0011650926,
-0.0265841838,
-0.0154752852,
-0.0104906438,
-0.0089878868,
-0.0260917339,
0.0467277691,
0.0092428895,
-0.0795503929,
-0.0268284827,
0.0265465621,
-0.054869134,
0.0622159205,
0.0017805403,
0.026023645,
0.004512331,
-0.0487642065,
-0.0870495811,
0.0666209161,
-0.0304429643,
0.0084882844,
0.0200596675,
-0.0172988772,
-0.0253441073,
0.0093262335,
-0.0241715368,
0.0240141898,
-0.0557100624,
-0.0432617664,
0.0342156142,
0.0120622003,
0.0392237194,
0.0170640741,
0.0201667808,
-0.0286778305,
-0.0370222852,
0.0120548718,
0.034465611,
-0.0043862872,
-0.0130802039,
0.0132514667,
-0.0177021399,
-0.0011202835,
-0.0255542751,
-0.0122442637,
0.0463158339,
0.0036312744,
0.0183580406,
0.0076526743,
-0.0516001061,
-0.0061828922,
0.0469514616,
0.0024642427,
-0.0025491114,
0.0143898251,
0.0472973771,
-0.0127326772,
-0.0103764012,
0.0921255574,
0.0028941147,
0.0296970159,
-0.0752333626,
-0.062882565,
0.0075676823,
-0.0186212771,
-0.0515211932,
-0.0042330241,
-0.0746605247,
-0.0008249083,
0.0190772079,
-0.0570211373,
-0.0084534446,
0.0034752402,
2.915e-7,
0.0451162122,
0.0489340052,
-0.0549967363,
-0.0350021422,
0.0507118814,
0.017476907,
-0.030440405,
0.0044411737,
0.0034981889,
0.0036092808,
0.0425951369,
-0.0083710263,
0.041768983,
0.0497654006,
-0.0086344955,
-0.0089391703,
-0.0485891439,
0.0165059231,
-0.0359885767,
0.0564474352,
0.0575483255,
0.0840215981,
-0.0206630472,
-0.0404542796,
0.0470031537,
0.0456312113,
0.0269196369,
-0.0319447927,
0.0082322173,
-0.0240108706,
0.003008228,
0.011235889,
0.0236666594,
0.0209109765,
-0.0327487364,
-0.0426436029,
0.00659568,
0.0644153431,
-0.0633197874,
0.0341795161,
0.0397028886,
0.0019229815,
0.0197320171,
-0.0190123674,
0.0986128673,
-0.0069391257,
-0.0524650551,
-0.0190333389,
0.0006583302,
0.0090987328,
0.0338397436,
-0.0127608869,
-0.0488320254,
0.0102677755,
0.0302790664,
0.0357052349,
-0.0091559933,
-0.0345263481,
-0.0345324241,
0.0334925726,
-0.0065406687,
-0.0361333862,
0.0135677774,
-0.0462416969,
0.0109151937,
-0.0960729048,
0.0089720665,
2.510464714e-34,
0.0166832004,
0.0502730682,
-0.0054398435,
-0.0020394633,
0.0290638451,
-0.0375955664,
0.0513047688,
-0.007081551,
0.0017303657,
-0.0550935604,
-0.0498853475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18085v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18085v1 | Multilingual Knowledge Graph Completion from Pretrained Language Models with Knowledge Constraints | 2024-06-26T05:46:35 | 2024-06-26T05:46:35 | Ran Song, Shizhu He, Shengxiang Gao, Li Cai, Kang Liu, Zhengtao Yu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual Knowledge Graph Completion (mKGC) aim at solving queries like
(h, r, ?) in different languages by reasoning a tail entity t thus improving
multilingual knowledge graphs. Previous studies leverage multilingual
pretrained language models (PLMs) and the generative paradigm to achieve mKGC.
Although multilingual pretrained language models contain extensive knowledge of
different languages, its pretraining tasks cannot be directly aligned with the
mKGC tasks. Moreover, the majority of KGs and PLMs currently available exhibit
a pronounced English-centric bias. This makes it difficult for mKGC to achieve
good results, particularly in the context of low-resource languages. To
overcome previous problems, this paper introduces global and local knowledge
constraints for mKGC. The former is used to constrain the reasoning of answer
entities, while the latter is used to enhance the representation of query
contexts. The proposed method makes the pretrained model better adapt to the
mKGC task. Experimental results on public datasets demonstrate that our method
outperforms the previous SOTA on Hits@1 and Hits@10 by an average of 12.32% and
16.03%, which indicates that our proposed method has significant enhancement on
mKGC. | Multilingual Knowledge Graph Completion from Pretrained Language Models with Knowledge Constraints: Multilingual Knowledge Graph Completion (mKGC) aim at solving queries like
(h, r, ?) in different languages by reasoning a tail entity t thus improving
multilingual knowledge graphs. Previous studies leverage multilingual
pretrained language models (PLMs) and the generative paradigm to achieve mKGC.
Although multilingual pretrained language models contain extensive knowledge of
different languages, its pretraining tasks cannot be directly aligned with the
mKGC tasks. Moreover, the majority of KGs and PLMs currently available exhibit
a pronounced English-centric bias. This makes it difficult for mKGC to achieve
good results, particularly in the context of low-resource languages. To
overcome previous problems, this paper introduces global and local knowledge
constraints for mKGC. The former is used to constrain the reasoning of answer
entities, while the latter is used to enhance the representation of query
contexts. The proposed method makes the pretrained model better adapt to the
mKGC task. Experimental results on public datasets demonstrate that our method
outperforms the previous SOTA on Hits@1 and Hits@10 by an average of 12.32% and
16.03%, which indicates that our proposed method has significant enhancement on
mKGC. | [
0.0349740088,
0.0532990061,
-0.0066379798,
0.0490576811,
-0.0209717844,
0.0038852312,
-0.0274775401,
0.0042125843,
0.0645103529,
-0.004391463,
-0.0102475761,
-0.0177923702,
-0.0320902541,
-0.0026482814,
0.0283546876,
-0.0203196555,
0.0326710753,
-0.0067801583,
-0.0157916341,
-0.0782895684,
0.009977066,
0.0608416162,
0.0024265666,
-0.005058093,
-0.0093408078,
-0.0170939919,
0.0197431017,
0.0068735853,
-0.0066484683,
0.0236618165,
0.0036283238,
0.0485676974,
-0.0151965916,
-0.0212498102,
0.0000020955,
-0.0495357923,
-0.0306080319,
-0.0137691684,
-0.0098915016,
-0.0386386476,
-0.0227538701,
-0.0202017203,
0.0475576185,
0.0139258048,
-0.0465896428,
-0.0109171914,
0.0205734428,
0.0172992535,
0.0195273086,
0.0335325524,
-0.0076100943,
-0.0251571741,
0.000690236,
-0.0358927213,
0.0284394566,
-0.0614462532,
0.0325913392,
0.033497896,
0.0190871377,
-0.0378740169,
-0.0348534845,
0.0435616896,
0.0119278366,
0.0129039446,
-0.0266409088,
0.0070985756,
-0.0157252774,
0.0050114375,
0.0503958017,
0.0645901486,
-0.0242640972,
-0.0061333152,
-0.0149283148,
0.0085947551,
-0.0251626801,
0.0155915646,
-0.0151056601,
-0.0186854191,
-0.0297181308,
0.0030663419,
-0.0116682108,
-0.0271218698,
0.0327781364,
-0.0063891066,
-0.0542298853,
0.1073396206,
0.0276048668,
-0.0072018025,
0.0194850899,
0.031734433,
-0.0155742895,
-0.0343286246,
0.0144684874,
0.0150720216,
-0.0407751724,
0.0588528737,
-0.0169465374,
-0.0173565783,
0.0236826129,
-0.0454554409,
-0.0585674644,
0.024668688,
-0.0095021222,
0.072476685,
-0.0286084712,
0.0113230953,
-0.0113630714,
0.0043311524,
-0.0617361814,
-0.0769086853,
-0.0282945205,
-0.0149090178,
-0.049319692,
0.0148503948,
-0.0487422198,
0.0086339023,
-0.0412069522,
0.0144321509,
0.0012802088,
0.020699909,
0.0279266071,
-0.0000139701,
-0.0190520734,
-0.0409646668,
-0.0334364772,
0.0472030491,
-0.0509135202,
-0.000338435,
-0.0492150448,
-0.0208970774,
0.0065619834,
0.0063171545,
0.0229435377,
-0.0521341823,
0.0330552086,
0.0376267098,
-0.0137336664,
0.001318855,
-0.0658495054,
-0.0280597564,
0.0121124135,
-0.0597241148,
-0.0133926738,
-0.0635003448,
0.0971385539,
0.034989018,
0.002332686,
-0.0362643525,
0.0075982586,
-0.0076530771,
-0.0529282764,
0.0698792711,
-0.0211148337,
0.0199746881,
0.0069157444,
-0.0113806194,
0.0053208661,
0.0880841315,
-0.0039061303,
-0.0078126285,
0.0741216242,
-0.0138889132,
-0.0235187672,
0.0540807769,
0.0555519871,
0.0170087218,
0.0131875053,
0.0271342322,
-0.0159803834,
-0.0087585282,
0.0265585855,
0.0394343324,
-0.0186812859,
-0.0030538868,
-0.0073402254,
0.0039163511,
0.0164570566,
0.0163326059,
0.0308327749,
-0.023648316,
-0.0256932173,
0.0207333248,
-0.0150111234,
-0.0071030906,
-0.0385546722,
0.0301727932,
0.0065343822,
0.0483242646,
-0.0299414694,
-0.0210068878,
0.0315845795,
-0.0220457446,
-0.0037841566,
0.0692328587,
0.1067611799,
0.0107365903,
-0.0228170417,
0.0484333411,
0.0382713415,
-0.0333966762,
0.0612264238,
0.0217367616,
0.0027201783,
0.0463138297,
0.0332356617,
-0.0331035145,
-0.0532476082,
0.0255166721,
-0.0171997398,
0.0079165408,
0.0106693879,
-0.0288981795,
0.0092208209,
-0.0424164496,
-0.0470230691,
0.0289222375,
-0.0238253362,
0.0364281721,
0.0300383214,
0.0493851565,
0.0171743389,
-0.1188129634,
0.0077314852,
-0.0041931388,
-0.0410678238,
0.0252706893,
0.0133366277,
0.0341742188,
-0.0101987431,
0.0364737958,
0.0186170898,
0.0114933848,
0.0074775908,
-0.0354780592,
-0.0222659372,
0.0148956552,
-0.0049985717,
-0.0611703582,
0.0441695489,
-0.0209793653,
-0.0019538198,
-0.036008358,
-0.0133199235,
-0.0624751449,
0.0092469845,
0.0182543229,
0.0690114275,
-0.0501006581,
0.0053801103,
0.0101035153,
-0.0290150195,
-0.0172193497,
0.0772388056,
0.0132401912,
0.0534531176,
-0.0035228203,
-0.0469488241,
0.0608909279,
-0.0235912707,
-0.0509389937,
0.0312908366,
0.0200661439,
0.0087646348,
0.0490529537,
-0.0030199322,
-0.0518482886,
0.0311180968,
-0.0991975293,
-0.0104346042,
-0.0056535881,
0.0219499804,
-0.0237296578,
0.0418726057,
-0.012909228,
-0.046563793,
-0.0588370189,
-0.0160751976,
0.0308969878,
0.0371374227,
0.0010829619,
0.0084089255,
0.0142996088,
-0.0165581573,
-0.0274253488,
-0.001166482,
0.0365778394,
-0.0232212674,
-0.0209470298,
-0.0130452374,
0.0465558693,
-0.0748832598,
0.058556132,
-0.0246697795,
-0.0008355185,
-0.0092229275,
-0.0220484734,
0.0509155504,
0.0038543129,
-0.0352318883,
-0.0580407307,
0.031642057,
-0.0100562116,
-0.0589306466,
0.0308253411,
-0.0487652496,
-0.0250212718,
-0.0361059718,
-0.0237676576,
-0.0101536429,
0.0161212794,
0.0050563719,
-0.0607752092,
-0.0817093849,
-0.0375119559,
-0.0038149257,
0.0012635286,
-0.0623532534,
0.0355964266,
0.0484654605,
0.0560654663,
-0.0207180828,
0.005641168,
0.0913973898,
-0.0134570617,
-0.0069274935,
-0.0112002548,
0.029466942,
-0.0294052884,
0.0487308316,
0.0171823651,
0.0494058914,
-0.0035252289,
-0.0373045206,
-0.0556426719,
0.0085212914,
0.034306068,
-0.0155062163,
-0.0003693408,
-0.0035192273,
0.0096791806,
0.0214017667,
-0.0142756375,
-0.016422743,
0.011432902,
-0.0138930865,
-0.0021480042,
0.0339511298,
0.0011740102,
0.0126637956,
0.0145994574,
0.0321456678,
-0.0106741413,
0.0043678307,
0.0150748221,
-0.0164431632,
0.017045157,
0.0565425791,
-0.0163555294,
-0.025977239,
-0.0135932779,
-0.0057537733,
0.024977766,
0.0416745916,
-0.0779228359,
0.0433885865,
0.0174833126,
0.0638986155,
-0.0417973027,
-0.0436115302,
-0.0270598717,
0.0076573309,
0.0085454835,
0.0374259464,
0.0803328827,
0.0131961647,
-0.0270971861,
-0.0145512456,
-0.0127620045,
0.0123857977,
0.0418216661,
0.0632108226,
-0.1204875186,
0.008499587,
-0.030192269,
0.0118541056,
0.046081841,
-0.0543271601,
-0.0123713613,
-0.1227808446,
-0.019916635,
0.000103225,
-0.0502054505,
-0.050622113,
-0.0270957258,
-0.0244496521,
-0.0134504056,
-0.0278069675,
0.0006733878,
0.032309927,
0.0070077018,
0.0035885428,
-0.0103672389,
-0.0390328839,
0.0311484728,
-0.0501674339,
-0.0065762908,
0.0166611504,
0.0306381099,
-0.0019955011,
0.0011898865,
-0.022716403,
0.0028377825,
-0.0176840201,
-0.0142139094,
-0.0004261043,
-0.011424901,
-0.0296241939,
0.0233584028,
-0.0126556326,
-0.0463041924,
0.0044541443,
0.03307027,
0.1185687631,
0.0284527261,
-0.0197583288,
0.004018175,
-0.0293708872,
-0.0009064889,
0.0603931583,
0.001801089,
0.000338329,
-0.0123134758,
-0.0276326519,
0.0392116681,
-0.0458787568,
0.0223274976,
0.0475841425,
-0.0508951396,
0.0101131527,
-0.0326031148,
-0.0588655099,
0.0702436045,
0.0205073953,
0.0101075089,
0.0508431569,
0.0241949707,
-0.0116226096,
-0.0225504544,
-0.0090884389,
-0.0465949178,
-0.0021004337,
-0.0390368588,
-0.0094783381,
0.0146095436,
-0.0365180671,
-0.0139185498,
-0.0264459588,
-0.0143916607,
-0.0550218932,
-0.0696898326,
0.0380874015,
0.0091482149,
0.0564110056,
-0.0633673072,
-0.0537009947,
0.0026704338,
0.0219549481,
-0.0341186672,
-0.0232662968,
0.0269423779,
-0.0170643087,
-0.0123545229,
0.0524557978,
-0.0603917129,
0.0098380735,
0.0026882696,
0.0891207978,
-0.0487664752,
-0.0456990376,
0.0414617248,
0.0539470315,
-0.0012837782,
-0.0337659642,
0.002155592,
-0.0601475351,
0.0184569173,
-0.045893345,
-0.041414652,
-0.0298374239,
-0.0165438689,
0.0250697639,
-0.0343980268,
0.018359093,
-0.0504548028,
-0.0101775862,
0.0106954202,
-0.0278006401,
-0.0264059901,
0.0404067338,
-0.0152809452,
0.0772735178,
0.0104956161,
0.0059340643,
0.0256129634,
0.0309697278,
0.0268087536,
-0.0408263579,
0.0201513134,
0.0061861398,
-0.0167141836,
-0.0141254738,
-0.0381352901,
0.0022264188,
-0.0249940604,
-0.0135126309,
0.0272949003,
0.1060412377,
-0.0047783367,
0.0296749752,
0.0007424897,
-0.0166602954,
-0.0067950371,
0.0350318886,
0.0490367338,
-0.0467612073,
0.0332076736,
0.0174380541,
-0.0126419626,
0.0333596393,
0.1049819216,
0.0186093152,
0.05313766,
-0.0114663858,
-0.0430725627,
-0.0181761291,
-0.0381678678,
-0.0035263819,
0.0238676053,
-0.0450468808,
0.0432758965,
-0.0297998972,
-0.1151567101,
-0.0086307144,
-0.0111285541,
-0.0596453361,
0.0263967123,
0.0263526682,
0.0854268447,
0.0313847363,
-0.04069978,
-0.0541383997,
0.0186976735,
-0.0259185154,
-0.0001421842,
0.0543057173,
-6.050193017e-33,
-0.0112870838,
-0.0214096494,
0.0354948342,
-0.0149877509,
0.0265157484,
-0.017906785,
-0.0238292236,
-0.0077121314,
-0.0541688837,
0.0075757727,
-0.0311458912,
-0.011318963,
0.0117198639,
0.0283475108,
0.0024698311,
0.0110700633,
0.0044679451,
0.0191102549,
0.0419547409,
0.0206315871,
0.0470594727,
0.0522955097,
0.092309542,
-0.0356390849,
0.0459534153,
-0.0351662077,
-0.0012047829,
0.0499063395,
-0.0087126372,
0.0544862375,
-0.0132218674,
0.0613787286,
0.0227824692,
-0.0162556823,
-0.0035840995,
-0.0350886956,
-0.1030373126,
-0.0676927865,
0.049854178,
0.0381526686,
-0.0273021441,
-0.0066391751,
0.0250837207,
-0.0330177359,
0.0526209176,
0.0143221337,
0.0391539335,
-0.0108848484,
-0.0551600717,
-0.0566191971,
-0.0350765809,
0.019423591,
0.0133863306,
0.0246674679,
0.0274384264,
0.0682310686,
0.0094992816,
-0.0254801512,
-0.0403311141,
0.0369030274,
0.0065263109,
0.0042739292,
0.0466133691,
0.0012358271,
0.0114708608,
-0.0169685055,
-0.0044011055,
-0.0103700068,
-0.0094013168,
0.0393044762,
0.0174088534,
0.0329232812,
-0.0075297682,
0.065587759,
-0.0364536382,
-0.0241162442,
-0.082329832,
0.0225293655,
-0.0192624312,
0.0250227936,
-0.0114283869,
-0.019046735,
-0.0381626301,
-0.075261116,
-0.049579531,
-0.0166435409,
-0.0371452682,
-0.0447048023,
0.0135155721,
-0.0144773573,
-0.0067843171,
-0.0154931992,
0.0126528516,
-0.0389319882,
-0.0312342159,
0.0629898906,
0.0136238439,
-0.0215613395,
0.00230952,
0.0874244124,
-0.041640792,
-0.0127712842,
-0.0203029551,
-0.0661217719,
-0.0277087297,
0.0307815634,
-0.0014870628,
0.0064155762,
-0.0133676119,
0.0058881501,
-0.030598972,
-0.0010191527,
-0.0260933433,
-0.0110648992,
0.0489130393,
0.0298067648,
0.0159236919,
0.0342183821,
0.0706083775,
0.0108887376,
-0.0242243335,
-0.0073625688,
0.0255014356,
0.0307778344,
-0.0095583145,
-0.0046457145,
-0.0095082689,
-0.0195015669,
0.0234573577,
-0.0024386758,
-0.0023333374,
0.0137743549,
2.789e-7,
0.0638517514,
-0.0076374304,
0.0056281011,
0.0594260208,
-0.0310088359,
0.006489581,
0.0031495627,
-0.0018709025,
0.0214295294,
0.0017130157,
0.0360360183,
0.0007272869,
-0.0049557751,
0.0630613863,
-0.0917111486,
-0.0044757044,
0.010178973,
-0.01750491,
-0.0423787609,
-0.0030114313,
0.0376700945,
0.0248803012,
0.0207152385,
0.0116788112,
-0.0505203791,
-0.0559968911,
0.068879202,
-0.0021693171,
-0.0483097248,
0.0478205383,
0.0337735936,
0.0391662195,
0.0184253156,
0.0700895637,
-0.0328594856,
0.0176624022,
0.0501450226,
0.0332739875,
0.0076082624,
-0.0305155143,
0.0139324041,
-0.021031199,
0.004786477,
-0.0694415197,
0.0939709023,
0.0068076323,
0.0250457134,
0.0616995357,
-0.0271456167,
-0.0165904686,
0.0151889026,
-0.032659512,
-0.0355139077,
-0.0108821662,
0.0453190655,
0.013973698,
-0.0080354372,
-0.0550016314,
0.0054923329,
0.0407043546,
-0.0091925431,
-0.0237102695,
0.0260705911,
-0.0349688381,
-0.0190747101,
-0.022045223,
0.0250083357,
2.368350432e-34,
0.0292665213,
0.0148844337,
0.0079022935,
0.0111244088,
0.0483023711,
-0.041250933,
-0.0419603698,
0.0244580545,
0.0211398322,
-0.0732031912,
-0.0498618782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18082v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18082v1 | Octo-planner: On-device Language Model for Planner-Action Agents | 2024-06-26T05:40:10 | 2024-06-26T05:40:10 | Wei Chen, Zhiyuan Li, Zhen Guo, Yikang Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | AI agents have become increasingly significant in various domains, enabling
autonomous decision-making and problem-solving. To function effectively, these
agents require a planning process that determines the best course of action and
then executes the planned actions. In this paper, we present an efficient
on-device Planner-Action framework that separates planning and action execution
into two distinct components: a planner agent based on Phi-3 Mini, a 3.8
billion parameter LLM optimized for edge devices, and an action agent using the
Octopus model for function execution. The planner agent first responds to user
queries by decomposing tasks into a sequence of sub-steps, which are then
executed by the action agent. To optimize performance on resource-constrained
devices, we employ model fine-tuning instead of in-context learning, reducing
computational costs and energy consumption while improving response times. Our
approach involves using GPT-4 to generate diverse planning queries and
responses based on available functions, with subsequent validations to ensure
data quality. We fine-tune the Phi-3 Mini model on this curated dataset,
achieving a 97\% success rate in our in-domain test environment. To address
multi-domain planning challenges, we developed a multi-LoRA training method
that merges weights from LoRAs trained on distinct function subsets. This
approach enables flexible handling of complex, multi-domain queries while
maintaining computational efficiency on resource-constrained devices. To
support further research, we have open-sourced our model weights at
\url{https://huggingface.co/NexaAIDev/octopus-planning}. For the demo, please
refer to \url{https://www.nexa4ai.com/octo-planner}. | Octo-planner: On-device Language Model for Planner-Action Agents: AI agents have become increasingly significant in various domains, enabling
autonomous decision-making and problem-solving. To function effectively, these
agents require a planning process that determines the best course of action and
then executes the planned actions. In this paper, we present an efficient
on-device Planner-Action framework that separates planning and action execution
into two distinct components: a planner agent based on Phi-3 Mini, a 3.8
billion parameter LLM optimized for edge devices, and an action agent using the
Octopus model for function execution. The planner agent first responds to user
queries by decomposing tasks into a sequence of sub-steps, which are then
executed by the action agent. To optimize performance on resource-constrained
devices, we employ model fine-tuning instead of in-context learning, reducing
computational costs and energy consumption while improving response times. Our
approach involves using GPT-4 to generate diverse planning queries and
responses based on available functions, with subsequent validations to ensure
data quality. We fine-tune the Phi-3 Mini model on this curated dataset,
achieving a 97\% success rate in our in-domain test environment. To address
multi-domain planning challenges, we developed a multi-LoRA training method
that merges weights from LoRAs trained on distinct function subsets. This
approach enables flexible handling of complex, multi-domain queries while
maintaining computational efficiency on resource-constrained devices. To
support further research, we have open-sourced our model weights at
\url{https://huggingface.co/NexaAIDev/octopus-planning}. For the demo, please
refer to \url{https://www.nexa4ai.com/octo-planner}. | [
0.0264776889,
-0.0079462109,
-0.0062274989,
-0.0298971944,
-0.0138132945,
-0.0038048706,
0.0347914882,
-0.0178565271,
0.0226947907,
-0.0345070362,
-0.0328278318,
-0.0028891801,
-0.0246406626,
0.0449838564,
-0.0049496614,
-0.028868638,
0.0251017977,
-0.0022547676,
0.0047547161,
-0.0082420502,
-0.0118044196,
-0.0010042727,
0.0179650635,
0.0547613837,
0.0010865119,
0.0050190478,
-0.0532017462,
0.0420856848,
0.0177546553,
-0.0404550172,
0.0167460181,
0.0139630055,
0.0340750292,
0.0218974017,
0.0000021932,
-0.0375405513,
-0.0455953069,
-0.0248884279,
-0.0009219166,
-0.0526607186,
0.0196819697,
-0.0168853682,
-0.005509648,
0.0539219528,
-0.075888373,
0.0180725809,
0.0119723445,
0.0460641198,
0.0253705475,
0.0969111919,
-0.0103668403,
-0.0023312559,
0.0138240438,
-0.016344076,
-0.0207110494,
-0.0503280051,
-0.0286923535,
-0.0577487573,
0.0153292688,
-0.0246186387,
0.026888283,
-0.0143567203,
0.044886332,
0.0533123799,
-0.0473230034,
0.0005358216,
-0.019894341,
-0.0293945391,
-0.0311984085,
0.0308032464,
-0.0476471037,
-0.0071096797,
0.0690247715,
0.0013034885,
-0.0329591222,
-0.0245677345,
-0.0103018098,
-0.0196563657,
-0.0140412664,
-0.0142023787,
-0.0180670507,
-0.0358477272,
0.0266209953,
0.005348213,
-0.0255944449,
0.0992538854,
-0.0103590181,
-0.0123572145,
0.0081166374,
-0.0311312638,
0.0014499432,
-0.0669741482,
0.0291941892,
0.0873601437,
-0.0780169591,
-0.0044215154,
-0.0393590704,
0.0053214333,
-0.012716095,
-0.0296726897,
0.0671341419,
0.0374198556,
0.037961565,
-0.0039754021,
-0.0066301934,
0.038388852,
0.0008322199,
0.0185570512,
-0.0404874831,
0.0317991152,
-0.0426954404,
0.0313302092,
-0.0292858705,
0.0486864373,
-0.0637522042,
-0.0277531594,
-0.0168418158,
0.0129299136,
0.0037633611,
0.0166280977,
0.0143073425,
0.0218773149,
-0.0036095395,
-0.0279084817,
-0.0469820648,
-0.0187006108,
-0.0360212773,
0.0588790663,
-0.0049270457,
-0.0496880263,
-0.0000052873,
0.0097600417,
-0.0114878844,
0.0016857146,
-0.0004595996,
0.0772571117,
-0.0126566114,
-0.0544723123,
-0.0399162173,
-0.0670689568,
0.0412502177,
-0.0978202596,
0.025216205,
-0.048826009,
0.032996878,
-0.0421866812,
-0.0135959862,
-0.0216264967,
0.024459213,
0.0275388733,
0.0436586253,
0.0281755049,
-0.0089461822,
0.0278856419,
0.0326754041,
0.0068254904,
0.0046390146,
0.0739231855,
0.0681904703,
0.0519359857,
-0.0174672119,
0.0100811627,
-0.0109540466,
0.0345012732,
0.0080720307,
-0.020349253,
0.0517412834,
0.0051416634,
-0.0061726938,
0.039156042,
-0.0230398476,
-0.003896825,
-0.0163924433,
0.0184958111,
0.0352323353,
0.0216975696,
0.0252820179,
-0.0057205344,
0.0200205315,
0.0103586474,
-0.0097501101,
-0.0709176213,
-0.072817333,
0.036158666,
-0.0134575339,
0.012147638,
-0.015913412,
0.0281111486,
-0.017380422,
-0.0475246422,
-0.0121437693,
-0.0262319297,
-0.0051923045,
0.0350796133,
0.0101804519,
0.0008366537,
-0.0912872776,
0.0233707447,
-0.0154050617,
-0.0321342982,
-0.0386187397,
-0.0692011043,
0.0488058999,
0.0757978186,
0.0187125187,
-0.0393645354,
-0.0782057941,
0.009999766,
0.0290416144,
0.0174665917,
-0.0000242395,
-0.0156810321,
0.0360821448,
-0.0496046729,
-0.0486197956,
0.0061862799,
0.0164703671,
0.0164526459,
0.0434346348,
0.0231246147,
-0.0139564108,
-0.0125488583,
-0.0132973231,
0.0178330988,
-0.016075043,
-0.0546735823,
0.0208228342,
0.0338170491,
0.0321542397,
-0.0034406325,
0.0022768914,
-0.0195088349,
0.0477534495,
-0.0323736593,
0.0225938279,
-0.0310743693,
-0.0439648442,
0.0354081988,
0.0399640389,
0.0172114205,
0.0191959087,
0.0480798781,
-0.0406489968,
-0.0620720163,
-0.0077620451,
0.005127877,
0.0417138115,
0.0092659835,
0.0154508362,
0.0404693,
-0.0166833811,
0.0087365694,
0.0352224335,
0.0156008247,
-0.0325894989,
0.0060236254,
0.0288739484,
0.0261916108,
-0.029627895,
0.0380302258,
-0.0168548059,
-0.0162420757,
0.0232960656,
0.0153730651,
0.0519357175,
0.0031459993,
-0.0506373681,
-0.1046575457,
0.0227008332,
-0.065262951,
-0.0016453764,
0.0005823061,
0.0377703086,
0.0073969122,
-0.0270252377,
0.0105935475,
0.0516496859,
-0.0179866683,
0.0276535228,
-0.0338680074,
0.019132996,
-0.04375007,
-0.0411939658,
0.0168518759,
-0.0154641559,
-0.0130440062,
0.0023157692,
0.0128269522,
-0.0226587206,
0.0083504934,
-0.0432672091,
0.0231417343,
-0.0174843892,
-0.0287491884,
0.0420951918,
-0.0191788189,
-0.0030389915,
0.0521168709,
-0.0215749182,
-0.0097777992,
0.0666146725,
-0.008245986,
-0.0578168407,
0.0523239896,
-0.027749449,
-0.0251964349,
-0.0706527159,
0.0138715459,
0.0081358086,
0.0534457229,
-0.0290043447,
0.0239412673,
-0.0535220988,
-0.0352444276,
0.0307913851,
-0.0526660532,
0.0361146219,
0.0350226052,
-0.024677055,
0.0670785755,
-0.0176932737,
-0.022405263,
0.0249032751,
0.0156702548,
-0.0012477476,
-0.0213515777,
-0.0409236401,
-0.0265822578,
0.0748452544,
0.0036777009,
0.0166922379,
0.007066512,
-0.0190027803,
-0.0261653811,
-0.0121343229,
-0.0122985691,
-0.031193817,
0.0351840146,
-0.0564367287,
0.007213877,
-0.0113175791,
-0.0779563934,
-0.0045607262,
0.0137204034,
-0.0381662324,
0.0225015711,
-0.0524043702,
-0.0335089639,
-0.0608281754,
-0.006934721,
-0.0163472313,
0.0879355296,
-0.0187204629,
-0.0090845712,
-0.0348425433,
-0.0086192489,
0.0523827001,
0.0721799061,
-0.0452063531,
0.0308905095,
0.0281397421,
0.0059860139,
0.0821255445,
-0.0290765241,
-0.064318791,
0.058566235,
0.0495574139,
-0.0196559653,
-0.0064414376,
0.077516228,
0.0640368983,
-0.0559461601,
-0.0153552229,
0.0811363831,
0.0184234604,
-0.0279861167,
-0.0003522524,
-0.03786394,
0.0477366187,
0.0292972401,
0.0582767874,
-0.0264285263,
-0.0615446083,
0.0119230645,
0.0196359511,
0.0196579453,
-0.0160150956,
-0.0161085203,
-0.096290648,
0.0381409526,
-0.0046212412,
0.0142981801,
-0.0030303416,
-0.0464058705,
0.0049862498,
-0.0167448428,
0.0055692764,
0.0010163322,
0.0051554614,
-0.0199299883,
0.0002283953,
-0.0215294529,
-0.0108569441,
0.0380123183,
-0.0046113352,
-0.0063369344,
0.0884395316,
0.0219982509,
0.0202486273,
-0.0055291429,
0.0310880356,
0.0543860272,
0.0221819356,
-0.0301882066,
-0.030695159,
-0.0091994414,
0.0217330791,
0.007258466,
0.0365116671,
-0.032950338,
-0.0442931578,
0.0336903743,
0.0971688032,
-0.0129398992,
0.0189018827,
-0.0271295384,
-0.0126250153,
0.0355293341,
-0.0049335314,
-0.0457732342,
-0.0195859671,
-0.0737339258,
-0.0071588489,
-0.0442462228,
-0.0363545306,
-0.0080525968,
-0.0146905789,
-0.0055715637,
-0.0237704311,
-0.0364800468,
-0.0330775939,
0.0620614477,
0.0411644615,
0.0423097052,
-0.038904652,
0.0088070873,
0.0664222687,
-0.0404829532,
-0.0232895371,
0.0131433029,
0.0347394086,
-0.045874659,
-0.0061007636,
0.0515221097,
-0.0499988906,
0.0134402988,
0.051169876,
-0.0496981703,
-0.0513163432,
-0.0050860718,
0.079187654,
0.0244494881,
0.0226705093,
-0.0113004427,
-0.0167519674,
0.0360246375,
0.062736243,
-0.0593932644,
0.0438033938,
0.0267286822,
-0.0019267006,
0.0031810021,
0.0527645051,
-0.0942999944,
0.0160373412,
0.0034765408,
0.0520120896,
-0.0988137946,
-0.029965248,
0.0187228806,
-0.0143562239,
0.0201737676,
-0.0125268875,
-0.0250121672,
0.0072186063,
0.0510280766,
0.0201923028,
0.017001858,
-0.0483775139,
0.0157283135,
-0.0447189063,
-0.0292561725,
0.061992377,
0.0284045674,
0.0354284756,
-0.0411471538,
-0.0083808135,
0.0160383172,
0.0075952811,
0.0068322294,
0.0049466593,
0.0157261621,
-0.0006055619,
0.0301162414,
0.0130080236,
0.0147638498,
-0.0227754936,
0.0123386895,
-0.0133070322,
0.0352594927,
-0.0467884354,
0.0199112594,
-0.0376435146,
-0.1035066471,
-0.0009035363,
0.0073643094,
0.0316772386,
0.0109326961,
0.0164039005,
-0.0498343818,
0.0141672567,
-0.0254441779,
-0.0113950158,
-0.0291513279,
0.0101156887,
0.0384441465,
0.0242148414,
0.0018716191,
-0.0215162933,
0.0524806194,
0.023097543,
0.0836546272,
0.0141002918,
0.0055143978,
-0.0624106489,
-0.0624362119,
0.041277986,
0.0515958145,
-0.0000329606,
-0.0332290344,
-0.0179844499,
-0.0274409112,
0.0211860258,
0.0086457571,
-0.0072336164,
-0.048330307,
0.0444117524,
0.0320971906,
-0.0154691488,
-0.0515380315,
-0.019032184,
-0.0829264596,
-0.0563989356,
-0.0068133329,
0.008241985,
-5.8301908e-33,
-0.0110687111,
-0.0131678749,
0.0708522201,
-0.0322159231,
0.0062051686,
-0.0221150257,
-0.0166237,
-0.0053673857,
-0.0334828198,
-0.0142089678,
-0.0553187728,
0.0163784567,
0.0263239592,
0.0022900682,
0.0070111793,
-0.0011842801,
0.0392646007,
-0.0426855609,
-0.0407771654,
-0.0043822699,
0.0244451743,
0.0288075656,
-0.0055935793,
-0.0094522759,
-0.0525445901,
0.0274208076,
-0.0401064903,
0.0015002416,
-0.0446660146,
0.0383721218,
0.0055060592,
0.0012277098,
0.0160663426,
-0.0068332893,
-0.0121530062,
0.0327094495,
-0.0585012026,
-0.0602377951,
0.0119472118,
0.0249908864,
-0.0487901345,
-0.0460730866,
0.0364243314,
0.0237053558,
-0.0677404925,
-0.0044434252,
0.0367059782,
0.0123578953,
-0.0506939366,
-0.0204391014,
-0.0334437788,
0.0113938274,
0.0357430652,
-0.0469603129,
0.0500465967,
0.0273000635,
-0.0218906756,
-0.0205070246,
-0.0542725287,
0.028406458,
-0.0667303726,
0.0464828908,
0.0175960939,
0.0229295008,
-0.0061011021,
0.0507411174,
0.0413183495,
-0.0054394514,
-0.001641516,
0.0317189023,
-0.0196114685,
0.1138628572,
-0.0317578427,
0.0170754511,
-0.0033481834,
-0.0323898867,
-0.0513649583,
0.0253376644,
0.0070867869,
0.0359379463,
0.0108913509,
-0.0046486934,
-0.0230485257,
0.0170611031,
-0.0053246906,
0.0007152594,
-0.0267137475,
-0.0255418681,
0.0371720903,
0.0565355793,
0.0187132936,
-0.0191667583,
0.03594964,
-0.0154240718,
0.0466208868,
-0.0123383971,
0.007668904,
0.0347765461,
0.017898431,
0.037329413,
-0.0410984233,
-0.0625697151,
-0.0288432334,
-0.0040803412,
0.0369532853,
-0.002036646,
-0.0145633854,
0.1006619632,
-0.0482902452,
-0.0114287101,
-0.0317448117,
0.0348135829,
0.0189720038,
0.0185138825,
0.0512962751,
-0.0199463367,
0.0033984969,
0.0421093181,
-0.0530693009,
-0.0899900943,
0.0022594328,
-0.0009921381,
0.0184999108,
0.0175025202,
-0.0249412935,
-0.0064460356,
-0.0852368474,
0.0142809674,
-0.0176289827,
-0.0111721372,
-0.0195463374,
0.0636078119,
3.093e-7,
-0.063514784,
0.0051243743,
-0.0466932654,
0.0462157056,
-0.0027402304,
0.0445016399,
0.0312095955,
0.0217256919,
-0.0238654725,
0.0055606216,
0.0184412878,
0.032633394,
0.0328839049,
-0.0052626315,
-0.084608607,
0.01170089,
0.0254891273,
0.0082353158,
-0.0525064021,
0.0130423848,
0.0172422584,
0.0875333175,
0.0198981557,
-0.0118394867,
0.0346406661,
-0.0065155323,
0.0087954439,
-0.007851515,
0.0289163142,
-0.0059367856,
-0.0456995443,
0.0054308609,
-0.0554930046,
0.0019350155,
-0.0075181723,
0.0248340853,
-0.0308142155,
0.1014172286,
-0.0146191996,
-0.0545680299,
0.0126664937,
-0.0364210159,
-0.0086581241,
-0.0296861771,
0.0461439937,
0.0434548147,
-0.0217524748,
0.0351475142,
0.034449093,
-0.0196388122,
-0.0210181866,
0.0086210035,
0.0224974975,
-0.00984977,
-0.0077804201,
-0.0256533865,
-0.0069721323,
-0.0663466081,
0.0343239009,
0.0427815504,
-0.0128173893,
-0.0386489071,
-0.0628535151,
0.0375520773,
0.0390415564,
-0.0667079613,
-0.0070551662,
2.871255384e-34,
-0.0095579941,
-0.0127337584,
0.0132132685,
0.0789709464,
0.0145887043,
0.0245988108,
-0.0022592642,
0.0267441068,
0.0509871356,
-0.0625177845,
-0.0281194095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18078v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18078v1 | Self-Training with Pseudo-Label Scorer for Aspect Sentiment Quad Prediction | 2024-06-26T05:30:21 | 2024-06-26T05:30:21 | Yice Zhang, Jie Zeng, Weiming Hu, Ziyi Wang, Shiwei Chen, Ruifeng Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Aspect Sentiment Quad Prediction (ASQP) aims to predict all quads (aspect
term, aspect category, opinion term, sentiment polarity) for a given review,
which is the most representative and challenging task in aspect-based sentiment
analysis. A key challenge in the ASQP task is the scarcity of labeled data,
which limits the performance of existing methods. To tackle this issue, we
propose a self-training framework with a pseudo-label scorer, wherein a scorer
assesses the match between reviews and their pseudo-labels, aiming to filter
out mismatches and thereby enhance the effectiveness of self-training. We
highlight two critical aspects to ensure the scorer's effectiveness and
reliability: the quality of the training dataset and its model architecture. To
this end, we create a human-annotated comparison dataset and train a generative
model on it using ranking-based objectives. Extensive experiments on public
ASQP datasets reveal that using our scorer can greatly and consistently improve
the effectiveness of self-training. Moreover, we explore the possibility of
replacing humans with large language models for comparison dataset annotation,
and experiments demonstrate its feasibility. We release our code and data at
https://github.com/HITSZ-HLT/ST-w-Scorer-ABSA . | Self-Training with Pseudo-Label Scorer for Aspect Sentiment Quad Prediction: Aspect Sentiment Quad Prediction (ASQP) aims to predict all quads (aspect
term, aspect category, opinion term, sentiment polarity) for a given review,
which is the most representative and challenging task in aspect-based sentiment
analysis. A key challenge in the ASQP task is the scarcity of labeled data,
which limits the performance of existing methods. To tackle this issue, we
propose a self-training framework with a pseudo-label scorer, wherein a scorer
assesses the match between reviews and their pseudo-labels, aiming to filter
out mismatches and thereby enhance the effectiveness of self-training. We
highlight two critical aspects to ensure the scorer's effectiveness and
reliability: the quality of the training dataset and its model architecture. To
this end, we create a human-annotated comparison dataset and train a generative
model on it using ranking-based objectives. Extensive experiments on public
ASQP datasets reveal that using our scorer can greatly and consistently improve
the effectiveness of self-training. Moreover, we explore the possibility of
replacing humans with large language models for comparison dataset annotation,
and experiments demonstrate its feasibility. We release our code and data at
https://github.com/HITSZ-HLT/ST-w-Scorer-ABSA . | [
0.0422653221,
0.0595722422,
0.0237011481,
0.0324650854,
0.0167903099,
0.0061978824,
0.0052596061,
0.0012423536,
-0.0138576375,
-0.0188793503,
-0.1055848822,
-0.0061940043,
-0.0445337892,
0.0576477163,
-0.0167377405,
0.0001211011,
0.0315147564,
0.0216851495,
0.009749148,
-0.0115196751,
0.0135789001,
0.0216412731,
0.0063019851,
0.0083876513,
-0.0281840619,
-0.0124060847,
0.027655853,
0.0057278504,
0.0263148099,
-0.0282158107,
0.0365205966,
0.0717884153,
-0.0048821238,
0.0241961684,
0.0000020307,
-0.0123394588,
-0.0180421341,
-0.0254055336,
0.0401036516,
-0.0092133693,
0.0678401142,
-0.0075273709,
0.0257630926,
0.0141714513,
-0.0626992583,
-0.0846990794,
0.0245875549,
0.0835018232,
0.0456900373,
0.0565823466,
-0.0301335063,
-0.0357008204,
-0.0216805451,
-0.0540342294,
-0.0095917284,
-0.0707109421,
-0.0040708994,
0.0186315831,
-0.0346367769,
0.083947733,
0.0090790438,
-0.005383777,
0.0303110648,
0.0009777856,
0.0325636864,
0.0269062445,
0.0156797804,
0.0345663354,
-0.0043008551,
0.0521791279,
0.0426378772,
-0.0433583632,
0.0006771907,
-0.0132910674,
-0.0007999793,
0.0064684483,
0.0280842204,
-0.0264562201,
0.0107110962,
0.0475769565,
0.0497290269,
0.0553464107,
0.0126085142,
0.0031476247,
0.0375483744,
0.0315482765,
-0.01366679,
-0.033113949,
0.0262107197,
0.0825556591,
0.0333446562,
-0.0471424721,
-0.0025945543,
-0.0171383191,
-0.0199066531,
-0.0020857868,
-0.0153020276,
0.0362939648,
0.0134589029,
-0.0593392327,
0.0390451811,
-0.0274448507,
-0.0113985231,
0.0370157994,
0.0089452509,
-0.01047544,
0.0424560979,
0.0090400251,
-0.0511255935,
0.0404473282,
-0.0940198228,
0.0179662239,
-0.0100969505,
0.028298391,
-0.0100963861,
0.0357882939,
-0.0879221708,
-0.0234795976,
-0.0253532752,
-0.0031070861,
0.0607837327,
0.0032823898,
-0.0171645693,
0.0170662161,
-0.0329979956,
0.031324219,
-0.0462625623,
0.034710627,
-0.0475374088,
0.0170108099,
-0.0040608151,
-0.0015917587,
-0.0108915158,
-0.0349569768,
0.0206183791,
0.0183250662,
0.0267376136,
-0.0399668142,
0.0136871981,
-0.0222945362,
-0.0179855991,
-0.0623498447,
-0.0292552784,
-0.0783535838,
0.0446127728,
-0.0238539074,
-0.0135284001,
-0.0150367757,
0.0112262229,
0.0182946753,
0.0101730023,
0.0600642189,
-0.0519475341,
-0.0229930431,
-0.0166466422,
0.001457066,
0.0223048404,
0.0497879609,
-0.0418870747,
0.006730638,
0.0152233271,
-0.0029561978,
0.0480912589,
-0.0046973778,
-0.0019025324,
0.0075775301,
0.0072059599,
-0.0059187319,
-0.0162023418,
0.0084745176,
0.0303892568,
0.0048361346,
-0.0066139149,
-0.0636623949,
0.0174484272,
-0.0234181266,
0.0088547999,
0.0699818283,
-0.0007663002,
-0.0004754872,
-0.000328239,
-0.0054600071,
-0.0069143977,
0.0421466641,
-0.0193107314,
-0.0204700921,
0.0195483211,
-0.0085016219,
-0.0460577086,
-0.0716313347,
-0.0101736067,
-0.0071740439,
-0.0252133273,
-0.025941737,
0.0680926591,
0.0396923274,
-0.0264208857,
-0.0435536802,
0.0463383384,
-0.0359863974,
-0.0316292457,
-0.0436525419,
0.0230175219,
0.0728832558,
0.0209862217,
-0.0420925543,
-0.0236805286,
0.0007349902,
-0.059160769,
0.0215664655,
0.0603536777,
-0.0437365957,
-0.0314178169,
-0.0116178142,
-0.0195386391,
-0.0114920419,
0.0012020895,
-0.0029234628,
0.0149088334,
0.0362501591,
-0.0174615793,
-0.0538821109,
-0.0330384746,
0.0178106185,
0.0080769975,
-0.0383513048,
0.0463835336,
-0.0087342849,
0.0385831296,
0.0531579591,
-0.0073507591,
-0.0062184865,
0.0536476485,
-0.0288187731,
-0.0701742321,
0.0150496326,
-0.0360337123,
-0.0548265874,
0.0317809843,
-0.003361146,
-0.0057544126,
0.0234636515,
-0.0659897253,
-0.0267595444,
0.0193060972,
0.0190346632,
0.011877941,
-0.0363517925,
-0.0335589685,
0.0348317139,
-0.0267020389,
-0.0098522883,
0.0691522956,
-0.005452401,
0.0284789987,
-0.0828629211,
-0.0136917429,
-0.0033667409,
0.0292183664,
-0.0313057713,
-0.0061342595,
0.0139998971,
0.0203887206,
0.0350817852,
0.0185604673,
-0.0253333747,
-0.0250313804,
-0.1138856113,
-0.0002747276,
0.0223461855,
0.0242977273,
0.0489088185,
-0.0430713072,
0.0094349924,
0.0060460484,
-0.0411826819,
-0.0151294991,
-0.0161660891,
0.0048297658,
0.0335620716,
0.0364769623,
0.0441634096,
-0.062564902,
-0.0238918699,
-0.0278718732,
0.0362419412,
0.0172193907,
-0.0014563923,
-0.0371680818,
0.0409112163,
-0.0287554841,
0.0120242862,
0.0156404991,
-0.0272691846,
-0.0230382103,
0.0056689866,
-0.0147083811,
0.0117952535,
0.0158296246,
0.0145060997,
0.0415231921,
0.0160756297,
-0.0299120899,
0.0218127556,
-0.0600366145,
-0.0178443529,
-0.0130506782,
-0.0406082496,
-0.0115348492,
0.0904004946,
-0.0073065376,
-0.0052618189,
-0.0512643717,
0.0368412808,
-0.0348918214,
-0.0180323552,
0.0057237586,
0.0223933198,
0.0197548009,
0.0073402068,
-0.0068756687,
0.0115858121,
0.0696220398,
0.0292071346,
0.0346962102,
-0.0644206107,
0.018317841,
-0.0227369368,
0.0839392394,
-0.0408132747,
0.016079532,
-0.0026120935,
0.0516868345,
0.0079582464,
-0.0460135788,
0.001292065,
-0.015925521,
0.0013811913,
-0.0021388466,
0.0276025105,
0.0133848442,
-0.0695085377,
0.0107674915,
-0.0300309043,
-0.0569472574,
-0.0300562643,
-0.0433668345,
-0.0001428816,
0.031181559,
-0.0042778659,
-0.0491957664,
0.0276949164,
-0.0275690351,
-0.0310307853,
0.0339417495,
0.0516763404,
0.0499630496,
-0.0723486617,
0.0091027403,
-0.0270607546,
0.0045491238,
0.05122637,
-0.0144621199,
0.0067942166,
-0.0026576156,
-0.0335898213,
0.0287057664,
0.0015029204,
-0.010047893,
-0.0441732705,
0.0686792657,
-0.0422184914,
-0.0285716057,
0.1158523709,
0.0457840078,
-0.0620263107,
-0.0147794187,
0.0214142576,
0.0011064801,
0.0426735096,
0.029105546,
-0.0865515769,
-0.030559713,
-0.035681244,
0.0469736643,
-0.0066949609,
-0.0042350744,
0.0075400756,
-0.1030430049,
0.0256777126,
-0.0291042347,
-0.052469071,
-0.0638263822,
-0.041691523,
0.008105102,
-0.0669238344,
-0.0359859578,
-0.0135095483,
0.0069037247,
0.0377499014,
-0.0042101499,
-0.0101290829,
-0.0167838503,
0.0714009777,
-0.0173891019,
0.0545777678,
0.0411274433,
0.0446625575,
-0.0065019466,
-0.0478139706,
0.0263233446,
-0.0695869178,
-0.0062205591,
-0.0291514713,
0.0942812711,
-0.0401410386,
-0.0204420965,
-0.0108275507,
0.0281669069,
-0.0434155464,
0.0064704553,
0.0092314454,
0.0072506899,
0.0209541768,
-0.0319956169,
-0.0000100136,
0.0307705104,
-0.0020576753,
0.0654572099,
-0.0157373194,
-0.0745690018,
-0.0165867973,
-0.0058021676,
0.0192910321,
-0.0691798627,
-0.0759335309,
-0.0247448739,
0.0120407743,
-0.0776337683,
-0.0829526857,
-0.0492354594,
-0.0066797007,
0.0356417671,
-0.0167363603,
0.0127701228,
-0.0098397052,
-0.0025681695,
-0.0433806628,
0.0144900205,
-0.0212788451,
-0.0166292097,
-0.0049540228,
-0.031863559,
0.1068058982,
-0.0178554468,
-0.0178240556,
-0.0012679427,
-0.0510276332,
-0.024182966,
-0.005901352,
0.0721665174,
0.003730569,
0.0279489215,
0.0035245761,
0.0102911582,
-0.0378894992,
0.0735487044,
-0.01749097,
-0.0066551417,
0.0526315793,
0.0256601274,
0.0242985487,
0.0354929194,
-0.0241873637,
0.0641696304,
0.0304291341,
-0.0051693623,
-0.0431886427,
-0.0238609202,
0.0380347371,
-0.0338712148,
0.0629597008,
0.0027528242,
0.0024679455,
-0.0452448018,
-0.0077980473,
-0.0203561112,
-0.0274548009,
-0.0312676616,
0.0136799244,
0.0058145691,
0.009063215,
-0.0493041091,
0.0407392383,
-0.0316469483,
0.0636477023,
-0.0542318784,
0.0258017592,
0.0132606057,
0.0062005352,
-0.0549830459,
-0.004444737,
-0.0052499077,
-0.044707574,
0.0356592648,
0.026300827,
0.0034076741,
0.0375586189,
0.0389980748,
0.0334679633,
-0.0001352169,
0.02615151,
-0.0338168927,
0.0479466245,
-0.0599843189,
-0.012121547,
0.0108117992,
-0.0234010611,
0.0276353639,
-0.0328335278,
-0.0096605588,
-0.0067667416,
-0.0006433271,
-0.0362575427,
0.0079517374,
0.0266793165,
0.0117017664,
-0.008713793,
0.002965071,
0.0690578818,
-0.0526600555,
0.0373041779,
0.0412649103,
-0.0081266072,
-0.0126323551,
0.0050938493,
-0.023767164,
-0.0207222942,
0.0197802074,
0.0017393164,
-0.052174136,
-0.0441982299,
0.0328378603,
0.011459955,
0.0134457592,
0.037731763,
0.0277720019,
0.035616748,
0.0235749502,
0.041093342,
-0.0654729679,
-0.0317849927,
0.0298497286,
-0.0268302765,
0.0002499812,
-6.594017846e-33,
-0.0332791582,
-0.0212365966,
-0.0164337792,
0.000277534,
-0.0017412431,
-0.0006792599,
-0.0080971634,
0.0095598996,
0.0298664421,
0.0413148999,
0.0081985798,
0.0123852277,
-0.0036117651,
0.010812765,
0.0518092848,
-0.0068993797,
0.0548592135,
-0.02624413,
0.0146714747,
0.0438466519,
-0.0089692585,
0.0061340146,
0.0647484213,
-0.1208339334,
0.0153138731,
0.002107705,
-0.0427136309,
0.0125826867,
0.0013824842,
0.0410630852,
-0.0120138824,
0.0384172685,
0.0340081714,
-0.0422804691,
0.0056401649,
-0.0190186128,
-0.0451351069,
-0.0166400541,
-0.0187865682,
-0.0174092166,
-0.013932744,
-0.0061868192,
0.0074826558,
-0.0136670386,
-0.0648724809,
-0.0119533278,
0.0259423982,
-0.0196350608,
0.0261266623,
-0.112810187,
-0.0101784868,
0.01703896,
0.0002284049,
-0.0279458109,
0.0128735825,
0.0658759028,
0.0255155619,
0.0113106305,
-0.0505003482,
0.0442554466,
-0.061012771,
0.0606400408,
-0.005256529,
-0.000783799,
0.0194892045,
0.0693907365,
0.0184683092,
0.01887412,
0.0052403156,
0.0144274784,
-0.0085454797,
-0.0038495595,
0.0193072222,
0.0423794203,
0.0473996215,
-0.0524369217,
-0.0384364538,
0.0426064506,
0.0052173259,
-0.0630603358,
0.0478635468,
0.0048634359,
-0.0354594365,
0.0055071223,
0.0034982921,
-0.0623812787,
-0.0376775153,
-0.0124211712,
0.0016351605,
0.0298754722,
-0.0261685569,
-0.0028731485,
-0.0357977301,
-0.0651186183,
-0.0220397692,
-0.0117637692,
-0.0391593687,
0.0262813959,
0.0102711553,
-0.0068148985,
-0.0637215748,
-0.0209004357,
-0.0047337241,
0.0437232293,
0.0256061759,
-0.0214766543,
0.1002990529,
-0.0108553283,
-0.106661655,
-0.0041892403,
-0.0148385549,
0.0437242575,
-0.0072497427,
0.0217315052,
0.008762042,
0.0215859488,
-0.0190987904,
0.0892428607,
0.0141646806,
0.0441772677,
-0.0255969148,
0.0271957517,
-0.004741285,
0.0264034681,
0.0340344943,
-0.0086777611,
0.0127792051,
-0.0039747804,
-0.042704314,
-0.0372603089,
-0.0362763256,
0.0271688234,
2.728e-7,
0.0541928671,
0.0562123619,
-0.0019009059,
-0.0210205931,
0.0129417647,
0.0646097884,
-0.0000107995,
0.0283404496,
0.0237247907,
-0.0209513791,
0.0510800593,
0.0278780721,
0.0121797891,
0.0469248071,
-0.0734753311,
0.068652302,
-0.0321081765,
0.0048154406,
-0.0123966001,
-0.0235239211,
0.0666132793,
0.0908819884,
0.0260796696,
0.0046249344,
0.0024061657,
0.0381977074,
0.0362499356,
-0.0027956641,
-0.0299145393,
0.0039561093,
-0.0211212803,
0.0047089783,
-0.0207566433,
-0.0078246426,
-0.0311813913,
0.0113616567,
0.0045990217,
0.0378099307,
0.0041309074,
-0.0756051019,
0.0392828211,
0.0523861125,
0.027071923,
-0.004357195,
0.050992161,
-0.0302545298,
-0.0283144545,
-0.0841678753,
-0.0269563161,
0.0478014387,
0.043587476,
-0.0001122754,
-0.0293627847,
0.0580527633,
-0.0094518401,
-0.0306499917,
-0.0392244533,
-0.0283056255,
-0.0153897768,
0.0673245639,
0.0165621042,
-0.0275807567,
0.0115400841,
0.0203385167,
-0.0464690402,
-0.0299071353,
0.0192401372,
2.098169484e-34,
0.0569510832,
0.0029475153,
0.0052931877,
-0.0332600623,
0.0155766951,
-0.0084165325,
-0.0630563945,
-0.0160094909,
0.0140610626,
0.0295967348,
0.0157380439
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18069v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18069v2 | Large Language Models for Cuffless Blood Pressure Measurement From Wearable Biosignals | 2024-06-26T04:54:45 | 2024-06-27T03:58:25 | Zengding Liu, Chen Chen, Jiannong Cao, Minglei Pan, Jikui Liu, Nan Li, Fen Miao, Ye Li | eess.SP | eess.SP, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have captured significant interest from both
academia and industry due to their impressive performance across various
textual tasks. However, the potential of LLMs to analyze physiological
time-series data remains an emerging research field. Particularly, there is a
notable gap in the utilization of LLMs for analyzing wearable biosignals to
achieve cuffless blood pressure (BP) measurement, which is critical for the
management of cardiovascular diseases. This paper presents the first work to
explore the capacity of LLMs to perform cuffless BP estimation based on
wearable biosignals. We extracted physiological features from electrocardiogram
(ECG) and photoplethysmogram (PPG) signals and designed context-enhanced
prompts by combining these features with BP domain knowledge and user
information. Subsequently, we adapted LLMs to BP estimation tasks through
fine-tuning. To evaluate the proposed approach, we conducted assessments of ten
advanced LLMs using a comprehensive public dataset of wearable biosignals from
1,272 participants. The experimental results demonstrate that the optimally
fine-tuned LLM significantly surpasses conventional task-specific baselines,
achieving an estimation error of 0.00 $\pm$ 9.25 mmHg for systolic BP and 1.29
$\pm$ 6.37 mmHg for diastolic BP. Notably, the ablation studies highlight the
benefits of our context enhancement strategy, leading to an 8.9% reduction in
mean absolute error for systolic BP estimation. This paper pioneers the
exploration of LLMs for cuffless BP measurement, providing a potential solution
to enhance the accuracy of cuffless BP measurement. | Large Language Models for Cuffless Blood Pressure Measurement From Wearable Biosignals: Large language models (LLMs) have captured significant interest from both
academia and industry due to their impressive performance across various
textual tasks. However, the potential of LLMs to analyze physiological
time-series data remains an emerging research field. Particularly, there is a
notable gap in the utilization of LLMs for analyzing wearable biosignals to
achieve cuffless blood pressure (BP) measurement, which is critical for the
management of cardiovascular diseases. This paper presents the first work to
explore the capacity of LLMs to perform cuffless BP estimation based on
wearable biosignals. We extracted physiological features from electrocardiogram
(ECG) and photoplethysmogram (PPG) signals and designed context-enhanced
prompts by combining these features with BP domain knowledge and user
information. Subsequently, we adapted LLMs to BP estimation tasks through
fine-tuning. To evaluate the proposed approach, we conducted assessments of ten
advanced LLMs using a comprehensive public dataset of wearable biosignals from
1,272 participants. The experimental results demonstrate that the optimally
fine-tuned LLM significantly surpasses conventional task-specific baselines,
achieving an estimation error of 0.00 $\pm$ 9.25 mmHg for systolic BP and 1.29
$\pm$ 6.37 mmHg for diastolic BP. Notably, the ablation studies highlight the
benefits of our context enhancement strategy, leading to an 8.9% reduction in
mean absolute error for systolic BP estimation. This paper pioneers the
exploration of LLMs for cuffless BP measurement, providing a potential solution
to enhance the accuracy of cuffless BP measurement. | [
-0.0173057653,
0.0278067756,
0.0101025198,
-0.0018825373,
-0.0260041375,
0.0000627678,
0.0539831407,
0.0162267387,
0.0177215301,
0.0160769317,
0.0041099424,
-0.0347788855,
0.047895994,
0.0474164784,
-0.0098463614,
-0.0460868813,
-0.0131180696,
-0.0059706736,
0.0888855308,
0.0122124115,
0.0323126055,
-0.0218210481,
-0.0316994116,
0.0451612286,
0.0125694769,
-0.0136921341,
-0.0062760888,
-0.0265506692,
0.0015232938,
-0.0815142244,
-0.0401954502,
0.0472004935,
-0.0301773753,
0.0018188067,
0.0000021141,
-0.0390884019,
0.012304225,
0.0547824092,
-0.0271714311,
-0.0618515015,
0.0651283562,
-0.0253428929,
0.0204171035,
0.0052712909,
-0.0397703461,
-0.0497206114,
0.0548223294,
0.0555569567,
0.0203446429,
0.0142401792,
-0.0272569358,
0.0711912662,
-0.0365852155,
-0.0604253672,
0.0434567221,
-0.0605624169,
0.0334353186,
-0.0554103069,
0.0843917057,
0.0295609981,
-0.0189089142,
0.0529132187,
-0.0054718354,
0.0605217405,
0.0312668085,
0.0158047024,
-0.0189264752,
-0.0228690282,
-0.0303223096,
0.0521109998,
0.0067158425,
0.0230996311,
0.0362385623,
0.0084821628,
-0.0011066053,
-0.0163050033,
-0.0740846172,
-0.0409244001,
-0.0255478639,
0.0084294491,
-0.0443021916,
0.0103005553,
0.0230914261,
-0.0375718959,
-0.0375940464,
0.0382445008,
0.0078749098,
-0.0129767591,
0.0153566562,
0.0180931687,
-0.0348822437,
-0.0576621778,
0.0419350043,
0.019614609,
-0.0331697427,
-0.0180721767,
-0.0365557782,
-0.0029521321,
-0.0021394691,
-0.0428192653,
0.0160803273,
0.0461491011,
0.0235692561,
0.0370970629,
0.0065845069,
0.0177761745,
-0.0283690672,
-0.0314156078,
-0.0430182666,
0.0183225144,
-0.0310540106,
-0.0036896188,
0.0102256089,
0.0131731872,
-0.0315491855,
-0.0137250638,
-0.0902895555,
-0.032216955,
-0.014955366,
0.0066604665,
-0.0320931002,
0.0134013528,
0.0203173421,
-0.0088123018,
-0.0064248098,
0.0268825144,
0.0356421284,
0.0162073132,
-0.0158886258,
-0.0500417911,
0.0271006972,
-0.0189621281,
0.0397616215,
0.0102420105,
-0.0031408847,
0.0402937867,
-0.0020213514,
0.0245020315,
-0.0271514915,
-0.0501912832,
-0.0200611521,
0.0266802758,
-0.0147378687,
-0.0522070453,
0.0392488204,
0.017922055,
0.0210453961,
-0.0295597631,
0.0163419079,
0.0317382701,
-0.0280739237,
0.0616874211,
-0.0490184166,
0.0124614462,
-0.0102224778,
0.0086442968,
0.0178354047,
0.0497665964,
0.0386555158,
-0.0681994408,
0.0272680596,
-0.0299870446,
0.0006585316,
0.0554592721,
0.0095102945,
-0.0706239194,
-0.050091397,
-0.0163982566,
0.0448117182,
0.0353304781,
-0.0068843025,
0.0493330397,
0.0418495238,
0.0326640494,
0.0776662529,
0.0584226772,
0.0480747595,
0.0226426851,
0.016472131,
-0.0394567624,
0.0049611791,
-0.0309561007,
-0.0652100667,
-0.0217372309,
-0.0319871269,
0.0209042784,
-0.0396840274,
-0.026394764,
-0.0288213994,
-0.0566797741,
-0.0554745756,
-0.0363186523,
-0.0113016386,
0.0073372638,
0.0808561742,
-0.0512578934,
-0.0019361334,
0.0295189358,
0.0230895076,
-0.0401762687,
-0.0042919889,
0.0152134029,
0.0029364948,
0.0774594098,
0.0162472464,
-0.021041153,
0.0660103336,
-0.0216138158,
0.0415743403,
0.0173582733,
0.0231034737,
-0.0006054355,
0.0256258808,
-0.0537689477,
-0.0340796076,
0.0595481507,
-0.0220635887,
-0.001562268,
-0.0607123189,
0.0504047051,
0.0173924249,
-0.001243889,
-0.0323934257,
0.024055142,
-0.0775434375,
-0.0413869433,
0.0271347836,
0.0193843916,
0.0182155501,
0.0248031933,
0.012372301,
0.0256638434,
0.0164282005,
-0.0651352108,
-0.023805093,
0.0032077834,
-0.0370579027,
0.0134560205,
0.0436875671,
-0.0270443112,
0.0409862138,
-0.050530985,
0.0011430548,
-0.0410253741,
-0.0488617979,
-0.029158311,
0.0459729284,
-0.0044212211,
-0.0191345979,
0.0199857131,
0.002905075,
-0.0162419695,
-0.0280140135,
0.0417447612,
0.0197790079,
0.0165693015,
-0.0127471313,
0.007749462,
-0.0259126425,
-0.0350992233,
-0.0188774653,
-0.0183228087,
0.0070531759,
0.0258624703,
0.0389695019,
-0.0106820725,
-0.0005291713,
-0.1385159492,
-0.009402642,
0.0268030744,
0.0146459434,
0.0171286333,
0.0783084631,
-0.0182905793,
-0.0117792645,
-0.0308416691,
-0.0375247337,
-0.0016869566,
0.0240295269,
-0.0242501404,
0.0160783138,
0.0082607372,
0.0210801233,
-0.0103301965,
-0.0527630411,
0.0518046543,
0.0024759059,
-0.003428424,
0.0323288776,
0.0020058593,
-0.0325159691,
0.0227950048,
0.0404689722,
0.0045330357,
0.0193689615,
-0.0166849699,
0.0385157056,
0.0358670205,
-0.0155439675,
-0.0239879973,
0.0328499004,
-0.0197530556,
-0.0095213819,
-0.0053009903,
-0.0457798764,
0.0188664459,
0.0175980851,
-0.0295314174,
-0.0335536823,
0.0650045052,
0.0392942205,
0.0148322089,
-0.0127037931,
0.0159681812,
-0.0463252217,
-0.0058095199,
-0.1048693284,
0.0303607453,
-0.0309415776,
0.0405401886,
0.005883038,
-0.0335800275,
0.0404391699,
-0.0215494223,
0.0072982684,
-0.0010854868,
-0.032491032,
-0.0209787264,
-0.013788905,
-0.0301484764,
0.0056418777,
0.0117942225,
-0.0042584948,
0.0273788869,
-0.0014109819,
-0.0233034752,
-0.0637856871,
0.0156652275,
-0.0521756038,
0.0106313126,
0.0138075659,
-0.0408994369,
-0.0502813049,
-0.0043928097,
-0.069597587,
0.0046275104,
-0.0290797576,
0.0131763667,
0.0101330644,
0.0377697721,
0.0088955453,
0.0202645306,
-0.0014461493,
-0.0095038172,
-0.0083111245,
0.0095787439,
0.0356337391,
-0.0263821874,
-0.0006395709,
-0.0075383941,
0.0590672232,
0.0422851369,
0.0593782179,
-0.0012108287,
-0.0294780619,
0.0121077579,
-0.0092604291,
-0.0012138464,
-0.0243048221,
0.0335581005,
0.0161916111,
-0.0142461266,
0.0139101176,
0.1510569602,
0.026906481,
-0.0590974838,
-0.0025730438,
-0.0198634509,
-0.0263238214,
0.001707449,
-0.0483182408,
-0.0464836843,
-0.0318883508,
0.0141231734,
0.0889017805,
0.0058016875,
-0.020590296,
-0.0350683667,
-0.0391650163,
0.0088029047,
0.0427169502,
0.0017183766,
-0.0020561784,
-0.0672787726,
0.0666219145,
-0.043568857,
0.0217811596,
-0.0114985071,
-0.0321708806,
0.0098065576,
0.0246045366,
-0.1024015024,
-0.0658092648,
0.0130864317,
0.0039759954,
0.0151313292,
0.0611108243,
0.0102589075,
-0.0128209507,
0.0061403788,
0.0226942617,
-0.0256031528,
-0.0141484896,
-0.0563300513,
0.0069155935,
0.074044697,
-0.007062946,
-0.0278264359,
0.0998318568,
-0.0469388068,
0.0118070357,
0.0346028246,
0.0575090721,
-0.0025528176,
-0.0157617424,
-0.0435881689,
0.0072063613,
0.0421673991,
0.0570903569,
0.0076290574,
-0.0707682222,
-0.0112006059,
-0.0135716368,
-0.0092530111,
0.0405080952,
-0.0560623072,
-0.026163049,
-0.0279264692,
-0.0474140868,
-0.0175311416,
-0.0155518893,
0.0371764973,
0.0685540438,
0.0464579165,
0.0604566075,
0.1131873429,
0.0193315893,
-0.0247620549,
0.0352815092,
-0.0242531765,
0.0401446708,
-0.0313166194,
0.0532634482,
0.0095768925,
0.0119668515,
-0.0255662072,
0.058686506,
-0.0378289111,
-0.0196478236,
0.0344220325,
0.0563199669,
0.0321770534,
-0.0209380351,
-0.055099342,
-0.0245749131,
0.0199829321,
0.0492016226,
-0.0404185504,
0.0409679525,
-0.0386089943,
0.0348146968,
-0.0004372565,
0.0071063838,
0.001750715,
0.028289929,
-0.0185241867,
0.0377079286,
-0.0100533403,
-0.0585217588,
0.0260092765,
0.0443439148,
0.0480768979,
0.0183376987,
0.0014319402,
0.0060407817,
-0.0177135281,
-0.0649955794,
-0.0056130919,
-0.0395221338,
0.0439100191,
-0.0364417359,
0.0213223323,
0.0099444222,
-0.0444750302,
-0.05181133,
-0.0519687533,
-0.0740346536,
0.0540996939,
-0.0066032042,
0.0224261973,
0.0406789556,
-0.0189605914,
0.0125376256,
0.013533894,
0.0139104705,
-0.0051562851,
0.0087115653,
0.0727377683,
-0.0237688944,
-0.0022486076,
-0.0322857015,
0.0177595094,
-0.03249586,
0.0442245752,
0.0142691769,
0.0861818269,
-0.0035626236,
0.0034176663,
-0.0113430955,
0.0151592707,
-0.0027804514,
-0.0744198337,
0.0282889996,
-0.0045691989,
0.0474155694,
0.0673976392,
-0.0038364858,
-0.0086571453,
-0.0006556126,
0.0702353939,
-0.0111874314,
-0.0174911562,
0.0183328521,
-0.0938715041,
-0.0179159995,
0.0372881405,
0.0498534925,
0.0113660004,
-0.0580226257,
-0.0036113574,
-0.072769329,
-0.0486393273,
0.0736775398,
0.031139167,
-0.0287285745,
-0.0453687347,
0.010401424,
0.0371327661,
-0.0711670071,
0.0049307193,
0.0095925368,
0.0589340553,
-0.0570530109,
-0.0315939561,
-0.0354544967,
-5.963967935e-33,
0.011468973,
-0.0400455445,
-0.005348267,
-0.0250823237,
-0.0026341865,
0.0593895838,
-0.0400548242,
0.0423107184,
0.0383125767,
0.0365659073,
-0.0172914695,
-0.0505026281,
0.0371840596,
-0.0080511719,
0.0183138922,
-0.0510893278,
0.0352227762,
0.0142560489,
0.0110148378,
0.0197143238,
0.0322666503,
0.0348792449,
-0.0183747746,
-0.10104727,
0.0107925963,
0.0159517862,
-0.0324594192,
-0.0078692837,
0.0229927078,
0.0363852195,
-0.0317194089,
0.0732770339,
0.0130627099,
0.0142614814,
-0.0161612444,
0.0659156367,
-0.0648334175,
-0.0164687019,
0.0275269095,
-0.0163154379,
0.0342766568,
-0.0197011176,
0.028766619,
-0.0117814681,
-0.0585114248,
-0.0103147812,
0.0224146098,
-0.0779429227,
-0.0217650533,
-0.0256147273,
0.0353488848,
0.0027546191,
0.0027073715,
-0.0038430202,
0.0294583123,
0.0161763299,
-0.0537859537,
-0.0296681989,
-0.0655071139,
0.0075446549,
0.0643187836,
-0.0014853715,
0.0127880089,
0.0270909648,
0.0014253814,
0.0030115347,
0.0098999087,
-0.0578640103,
0.001813427,
0.0456488989,
-0.0129893925,
0.0461588092,
0.0598059855,
0.0280103777,
0.0123384334,
-0.0232001878,
-0.0699160323,
0.0244866721,
-0.0159031749,
-0.041169513,
-0.0131920027,
0.0025927206,
-0.0464042909,
-0.0214776658,
-0.0032557782,
-0.0032200601,
-0.0425360836,
-0.025039807,
0.0112982923,
-0.0090422826,
0.0079167886,
0.0131869381,
0.0113811409,
-0.0329508856,
0.0085652061,
-0.0311106108,
0.0454660356,
-0.0209986139,
0.0183310956,
-0.0450188778,
-0.0326140411,
0.021705687,
0.0271914732,
0.0490107499,
0.0341334976,
-0.0265174899,
-0.0178216435,
0.0176570304,
-0.0388804078,
-0.0315367766,
0.0109699033,
0.0094416784,
-0.0196691155,
-0.0244259257,
0.0677987039,
-0.0337337218,
-0.0009879953,
0.0836257935,
-0.0279290248,
-0.0127173439,
-0.0052198619,
0.0327930041,
0.016722355,
0.0221768487,
-0.0414147712,
-0.0307509229,
-0.0174985602,
0.0185830947,
0.0253423043,
0.0064782295,
-0.0249670502,
0.0038264839,
2.881e-7,
0.0121904286,
0.0096639944,
0.0043290728,
-0.0356729887,
0.0194921959,
0.048264429,
-0.0376808718,
-0.012317026,
0.0141706727,
-0.0368341655,
0.0219701789,
-0.0094549684,
0.0673421919,
0.0183375571,
-0.0204253867,
-0.0672367662,
-0.0054810308,
-0.0033610447,
-0.0311477613,
0.0009177297,
0.0659635812,
0.0244868845,
-0.0312347226,
-0.0153741241,
0.0310790967,
-0.0006551773,
0.0312539302,
-0.0405957922,
-0.0268808138,
-0.0191222541,
0.0026134241,
-0.0042325864,
0.0346760675,
-0.0005417228,
0.0035355408,
-0.0167937018,
0.0375806652,
0.0857304037,
-0.0415812656,
0.0503547713,
0.0158828478,
0.0282067116,
0.0194343626,
-0.0302469581,
0.0820963159,
-0.0465124287,
-0.0369208306,
-0.0615930073,
-0.0190175157,
-0.0019293618,
0.0096350927,
-0.0032816979,
-0.0252425838,
-0.0142543567,
0.0141823459,
0.0140109444,
-0.030232653,
0.0247811917,
-0.0201659054,
0.0409721509,
-0.0103307245,
-0.0359166376,
-0.009098256,
0.0622215793,
-0.006577333,
-0.0860429853,
0.0061742645,
2.461122191e-34,
0.0093995649,
-0.0108976001,
-0.0126961023,
-0.0234171785,
0.0145884026,
-0.0291305408,
-0.0249172021,
0.02598105,
-0.0001382885,
-0.0928258747,
-0.0085662426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18067v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18067v1 | Exploring Energy-Based Models for Out-of-Distribution Detection in Dialect Identification | 2024-06-26T04:52:48 | 2024-06-26T04:52:48 | Yaqian Hao, Chenguang Hu, Yingying Gao, Shilei Zhang, Junlan Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | The diverse nature of dialects presents challenges for models trained on
specific linguistic patterns, rendering them susceptible to errors when
confronted with unseen or out-of-distribution (OOD) data. This study introduces
a novel margin-enhanced joint energy model (MEJEM) tailored specifically for
OOD detection in dialects. By integrating a generative model and the energy
margin loss, our approach aims to enhance the robustness of dialect
identification systems. Furthermore, we explore two OOD scores for OOD dialect
detection, and our findings conclusively demonstrate that the energy score
outperforms the softmax score. Leveraging Sharpness-Aware Minimization to
optimize the training process of the joint model, we enhance model
generalization by minimizing both loss and sharpness. Experiments conducted on
dialect identification tasks validate the efficacy of Energy-Based Models and
provide valuable insights into their performance. | Exploring Energy-Based Models for Out-of-Distribution Detection in Dialect Identification: The diverse nature of dialects presents challenges for models trained on
specific linguistic patterns, rendering them susceptible to errors when
confronted with unseen or out-of-distribution (OOD) data. This study introduces
a novel margin-enhanced joint energy model (MEJEM) tailored specifically for
OOD detection in dialects. By integrating a generative model and the energy
margin loss, our approach aims to enhance the robustness of dialect
identification systems. Furthermore, we explore two OOD scores for OOD dialect
detection, and our findings conclusively demonstrate that the energy score
outperforms the softmax score. Leveraging Sharpness-Aware Minimization to
optimize the training process of the joint model, we enhance model
generalization by minimizing both loss and sharpness. Experiments conducted on
dialect identification tasks validate the efficacy of Energy-Based Models and
provide valuable insights into their performance. | [
0.017423179,
0.0453409627,
0.0257431194,
0.0620901808,
0.0234664734,
0.0253013093,
-0.0396624841,
-0.0113015668,
-0.0523551628,
-0.0184500311,
-0.0365652591,
-0.0376596786,
0.0193576459,
-0.0189093687,
0.0256831497,
-0.0151831508,
0.0431858413,
-0.010739712,
0.0203573927,
-0.0326295272,
0.0112207793,
-0.0098563051,
-0.0070636198,
0.0113802124,
-0.0889427736,
0.0428325757,
0.003502636,
0.0924868435,
0.0532855466,
0.0095447013,
0.0465259738,
0.0262941383,
-0.0367153287,
0.0312634408,
0.0000019915,
-0.0433154069,
-0.0345428512,
-0.0246695746,
-0.0192187708,
0.0021111765,
0.0313398726,
0.0001389602,
-0.0584399141,
-0.0130641134,
0.0240770858,
-0.012396019,
0.1181958243,
-0.0109727299,
0.0125088478,
0.0777270198,
0.0098457756,
-0.0358091593,
0.0229447149,
-0.0118198218,
-0.0315252319,
0.0100404946,
0.013023708,
-0.0610730723,
-0.1054164618,
-0.0815690234,
-0.0031922364,
0.0294117481,
-0.0211049542,
0.0393879563,
-0.0048350575,
0.0043419623,
-0.0760893598,
0.0165559221,
-0.0088810902,
0.0502932146,
-0.0638609305,
-0.0174743142,
-0.0048515452,
-0.0115451785,
-0.0513382442,
0.0256263018,
0.0143250208,
0.0049394178,
0.0021742256,
0.0554511733,
-0.0319357663,
0.0101661514,
0.0401599221,
0.0046050884,
-0.0112311663,
0.0492904522,
0.0368515849,
-0.0171184279,
0.0243396014,
0.0265268404,
-0.0997306928,
0.015532176,
0.0139687713,
0.0224654488,
0.0256163981,
0.0014929015,
-0.0068297833,
-0.0288563706,
0.0080769258,
-0.0462197922,
0.0424318016,
0.007920715,
-0.0438144542,
0.0005917198,
-0.0083707348,
-0.0054910122,
-0.0114454236,
0.0163463634,
-0.0216020066,
-0.0325663984,
-0.0392887779,
0.020674441,
-0.0278665628,
-0.0000397072,
0.0262421835,
-0.0041534593,
-0.0151993548,
-0.033873383,
-0.0416798629,
0.0033095009,
0.0393498763,
0.0096991314,
-0.0443269536,
-0.0447760783,
0.0477974899,
0.0483302474,
0.0051616267,
0.005677165,
-0.0390587635,
-0.0746776238,
-0.0237476602,
0.0337304249,
0.019734161,
-0.0012626672,
0.0166398715,
-0.0025483801,
0.0181788728,
-0.0296672489,
-0.1033855975,
-0.0221195016,
-0.070551075,
-0.0484548733,
-0.0130098676,
-0.0803494006,
-0.0263668895,
-0.0298838317,
0.0427879132,
-0.0507452562,
0.0174497776,
-0.0351723768,
0.0255709924,
0.0202505775,
-0.0321210586,
0.0198867433,
0.0515920259,
-0.0197268259,
0.0027256226,
0.1124995351,
0.0327746123,
-0.0303287655,
0.0120386789,
0.0276745893,
-0.02123948,
0.0677172467,
0.0032096361,
0.0413405448,
-0.1022602171,
-0.0593205653,
0.0228902176,
-0.0021687928,
0.0700014904,
0.0522898026,
0.0035568238,
-0.0089961151,
0.0740249902,
0.0044887136,
0.0319612361,
-0.0144370478,
0.020755792,
0.0101606473,
-0.0231118388,
0.0149450274,
0.0352799445,
-0.046300292,
-0.032106407,
-0.0082469089,
0.0169535577,
0.0584616363,
-0.0519345291,
-0.0014857945,
-0.0342018083,
-0.0828248113,
-0.0263296515,
0.0072403778,
0.0840456188,
-0.0117676267,
0.0015167653,
0.06647221,
0.0497293733,
-0.0032618102,
0.0000054127,
-0.0352309309,
-0.0139832413,
0.003308954,
0.0030765785,
-0.0068680607,
0.0386558957,
0.0143906614,
-0.0262155086,
-0.0057420344,
0.0455618203,
-0.0050428296,
0.0576823503,
-0.0551329851,
-0.0094435802,
0.0163461324,
0.0447900891,
0.0011304256,
-0.0452709459,
0.0329978168,
0.0294025447,
-0.0625815317,
0.0085914955,
-0.0015027146,
0.0444959849,
-0.013924283,
0.0303504132,
0.0327859037,
0.0131722912,
0.0357412212,
-0.0194269102,
-0.0069635315,
0.0029763246,
-0.0579945706,
0.0425442718,
0.0025055485,
-0.0377845988,
-0.0469654873,
0.0584204793,
-0.0077278963,
0.0019526969,
0.0175182819,
-0.0012019095,
-0.0581450649,
0.0353635624,
-0.06668365,
0.058256112,
-0.0827701464,
0.0157914478,
-0.0073814015,
0.0118935686,
-0.0042623798,
0.1046995595,
-0.0022357299,
0.0298116915,
0.0132324258,
-0.0350388177,
0.0490997061,
-0.0924439728,
-0.0096069369,
0.0338674188,
-0.0084505826,
-0.0054411762,
-0.0165722128,
-0.027524557,
-0.0167388003,
-0.0289754719,
-0.0658257976,
-0.0168249365,
-0.0531264655,
0.0221698638,
0.0241093561,
-0.0092813885,
-0.0316779055,
-0.0089893695,
0.0053427499,
0.000485218,
-0.0038679044,
-0.0011612729,
-0.035099335,
0.0251962151,
-0.0193902664,
-0.0114387944,
-0.0178535488,
0.0081445081,
0.0430891439,
-0.0559662208,
-0.031594649,
-0.0328433365,
-0.0137581835,
-0.0014649973,
0.0375347286,
0.0326684825,
-0.0570060723,
-0.0488603935,
-0.0268340092,
0.0812969729,
0.0524854511,
-0.0104808221,
-0.0381948501,
0.054228723,
-0.0635444224,
-0.0122091258,
0.0047663464,
-0.0372589529,
-0.0090904171,
-0.0088705476,
-0.0455569439,
-0.0274217632,
0.0606728792,
0.0294605214,
-0.000863593,
-0.0161996651,
0.0007463399,
-0.0080253603,
0.0112300012,
0.0192396678,
0.0202836227,
-0.0335096568,
0.0169725399,
-0.0439831465,
-0.0184135865,
0.0649279356,
-0.0795688033,
-0.01776563,
-0.0371838398,
-0.0281153545,
0.0062029082,
-0.0302471984,
-0.0103908191,
0.037701197,
0.0023067843,
-0.0460957363,
0.005554067,
-0.0241162162,
0.0229815487,
-0.0145736998,
0.0400406718,
-0.0363802686,
-0.0051096133,
0.0069242171,
0.0263201967,
-0.0018649711,
-0.0117080957,
-0.0454440601,
0.0332371518,
-0.0065959431,
-0.0126061263,
0.04632603,
0.0282253455,
-0.0106269531,
0.0515574403,
-0.0264219381,
0.0279865973,
-0.0041521476,
0.0669629797,
0.039298404,
0.0202297699,
-0.0153509863,
-0.0373951495,
0.0076545193,
-0.02190727,
-0.0190194976,
0.0381896086,
-0.0115639446,
0.0146582089,
0.031205168,
0.0144095402,
-0.0200686362,
0.0354280584,
0.0641638413,
-0.024252601,
-0.0086555574,
0.0814561024,
0.0084823165,
-0.0225119404,
0.0030330154,
-0.005509031,
0.053489238,
0.0013765506,
-0.0311952047,
-0.0054330737,
-0.045363266,
0.0362191871,
0.0549892448,
-0.0019364507,
0.010460984,
0.0052023763,
-0.0802890211,
0.0077482262,
0.050682921,
0.0074406164,
-0.0166492146,
0.004348536,
0.0251785405,
-0.026403632,
-0.0246031694,
-0.02394199,
0.014066631,
-0.0384884588,
0.0727959126,
0.0014947827,
-0.0911171883,
-0.0280694198,
-0.0713164732,
0.0289476365,
0.0302408356,
-0.0326607563,
-0.0278007668,
-0.0872714669,
0.0326793976,
-0.1013592556,
-0.0236603245,
-0.0240079705,
-0.0008821813,
0.0406728834,
-0.0272135716,
0.0147131924,
-0.0068399454,
-0.0207037982,
0.0168426912,
-0.0321779884,
0.0563796237,
-0.0283093061,
0.0076690726,
0.0415362418,
-0.0066920081,
0.0608241297,
0.0301052537,
0.0381700248,
-0.0036064943,
-0.0228035338,
-0.0133110723,
0.0276830681,
-0.0079198871,
0.0163690001,
0.0596628413,
0.0369326137,
-0.1019840911,
-0.0295402817,
-0.0308051705,
-0.0368963927,
0.0268162675,
0.0280030221,
-0.0218847394,
-0.0211178008,
0.0153158512,
-0.0188562963,
0.0456558801,
-0.0236298367,
0.014424691,
-0.0653638169,
-0.0453176796,
0.0468720309,
-0.0178047344,
-0.0018241015,
0.006457401,
-0.0614181608,
-0.075033918,
0.014709793,
0.0189935472,
0.0220472254,
0.0303137191,
-0.0404120609,
-0.0322046205,
-0.0192276258,
0.0192878395,
0.0256742407,
0.0194788612,
0.0504337028,
-0.0327492915,
-0.01836426,
0.0403643064,
-0.026677439,
0.035068728,
0.0123208221,
0.0229793862,
-0.0598074608,
-0.0716220066,
0.0213422198,
-0.0516526327,
0.047104653,
-0.0074268649,
-0.0482340939,
-0.0579815619,
0.0117279543,
0.0481831133,
0.0378358923,
-0.0302997641,
-0.0278683808,
0.0577069223,
0.0179034099,
-0.0011155918,
0.0725535303,
-0.0149500631,
0.0252893623,
-0.0190328546,
0.0349504463,
0.0530279614,
0.032783553,
0.0156099629,
0.0261577442,
-0.0601954237,
0.0526871085,
0.0214706361,
0.0058377907,
0.0117090084,
0.0219150763,
0.0012518809,
-0.027840754,
-0.0145841986,
-0.0173494425,
0.0382881202,
0.0076213148,
-0.0610174648,
-0.0125071099,
0.0504230298,
-0.0253552012,
0.0254298747,
-0.0091598853,
-0.0081298556,
-0.058142744,
-0.0036919003,
-0.0004554145,
-0.0215739887,
0.0434862822,
0.0018494645,
-0.001371634,
0.0198175404,
0.0659798533,
0.0124231726,
0.0509003028,
-0.0342464522,
0.0003434917,
-0.0031198936,
0.0129281078,
0.0332110487,
-0.0008199772,
-0.0374063104,
0.0351511277,
-0.0031788223,
-0.0492196679,
0.0078095798,
-0.0279674456,
0.0190998726,
0.0284787063,
0.0474916212,
0.0201825853,
-0.0581848137,
-0.0296928566,
0.004296605,
-0.0332565159,
0.0098994793,
0.0189011302,
0.0050229565,
-6.692084931e-33,
-0.0023682609,
0.0066174041,
-0.0488678999,
-0.0264057945,
-0.0140349101,
0.0073459866,
-0.0302478969,
0.0331584178,
-0.0359808728,
-0.0078766141,
0.0317258015,
-0.0130042713,
0.0319922566,
0.0281198211,
-0.0319500715,
-0.0042593363,
0.0612354837,
0.0044406601,
0.0099669825,
-0.0023930105,
0.0310536679,
0.031063173,
0.0927255377,
-0.0361634344,
-0.0222996194,
-0.013145024,
-0.0467722565,
0.0401571989,
0.0348201469,
0.0414376296,
-0.0363917574,
0.0756834522,
0.0018340971,
-0.0250814334,
-0.0091704195,
0.0042620208,
-0.039374467,
-0.0141994758,
-0.0485013053,
0.0448271222,
0.0413913913,
-0.0496111885,
0.0381908417,
0.0023967999,
-0.0184949357,
0.0076292595,
0.0382211693,
-0.055755645,
-0.006102928,
-0.0248347968,
-0.0215044413,
0.0569796301,
-0.0001628326,
-0.0472293645,
0.049701076,
-0.0070166877,
0.0053878231,
-0.0254160929,
-0.0337464362,
-0.0027809611,
0.0708206967,
0.0497663133,
0.0480771363,
0.0290647037,
-0.0425059237,
0.022284437,
0.0035904017,
-0.0435254574,
0.0345095061,
-0.0424160808,
0.0657430515,
0.0258818381,
0.0099934852,
0.0052226656,
0.0406608805,
-0.02714785,
-0.0672096536,
0.0012536276,
0.025499342,
-0.0087664174,
-0.0190309137,
0.0021494313,
-0.0026014894,
-0.0362062566,
-0.0016835427,
-0.0557498001,
-0.0205895882,
-0.0053567328,
0.0104202889,
0.0055810288,
0.0053791348,
0.0117170811,
0.0371331647,
0.0023698232,
0.0384763069,
0.0253424067,
0.0181208905,
0.0172832943,
0.0025783309,
0.0051475032,
-0.04518288,
-0.0292884167,
0.0194576439,
0.038695801,
-0.0016911938,
-0.0129037946,
0.0489945337,
0.0456389189,
-0.0284673404,
0.0316909552,
-0.0423429757,
0.0141469957,
-0.0290705562,
0.0837465152,
0.0401004069,
-0.0272876732,
0.0127066802,
0.0806377307,
0.002793327,
0.0489725433,
-0.0031089715,
0.0128645534,
0.0154842045,
0.0695109591,
0.0128003564,
0.0214753002,
0.0370010696,
-0.0328971781,
-0.0152835567,
0.0072724074,
0.0037999251,
0.0278894026,
2.744e-7,
0.0273172222,
-0.0231849179,
0.0158582181,
-0.0458643138,
0.0288820621,
0.0093116062,
-0.0307575949,
-0.0523930639,
-0.0100799808,
-0.0643612444,
0.0370633043,
0.0017739797,
0.0802118629,
0.0549825989,
-0.083027944,
0.0177972987,
-0.0544452816,
0.0244477559,
-0.0253092628,
-0.0495412312,
0.012513225,
0.0664198846,
-0.0212513264,
-0.0279115345,
0.0228357632,
-0.0470181927,
0.0411016308,
-0.010690351,
0.0499895997,
-0.0039774459,
0.0354072116,
-0.0346508957,
0.0121253664,
0.0002250591,
-0.0219252035,
0.0278936848,
0.0057023275,
0.0378628522,
-0.0214782581,
-0.0835155919,
0.0181048792,
0.0565452687,
-0.0339063667,
-0.0373787247,
0.053947892,
0.0021109919,
0.0011116617,
0.0230152365,
-0.0346199311,
-0.0046358518,
0.0140747391,
-0.0339095779,
-0.0022542838,
-0.0039678691,
0.0192520227,
-0.0237851795,
-0.0369224511,
-0.0329320505,
-0.0105376495,
0.0954980627,
-0.0604819804,
-0.0330512896,
0.0313119367,
-0.0185213611,
-0.0100523904,
-0.0180453341,
0.0050058765,
2.103786831e-34,
0.0167265758,
-0.0118064769,
-0.0060681659,
-0.0037294445,
-0.0060635079,
0.0171599463,
-0.0657814518,
-0.0171005297,
-0.0219515394,
-0.0249817222,
-0.0148741528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18064v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18064v1 | Evaluating Quality of Answers for Retrieval-Augmented Generation: A Strong LLM Is All You Need | 2024-06-26T04:49:41 | 2024-06-26T04:49:41 | Yang Wang, Alberto Garcia Hernandez, Roman Kyslyi, Nicholas Kersting | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a comprehensive evaluation of answer quality in
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) applications using vRAG-Eval, a novel
grading system that is designed to assess correctness, completeness, and
honesty. We further map the grading of quality aspects aforementioned into a
binary score, indicating an accept or reject decision, mirroring the intuitive
"thumbs-up" or "thumbs-down" gesture commonly used in chat applications. This
approach suits factual business settings where a clear decision opinion is
essential. Our assessment applies vRAG-Eval to two Large Language Models
(LLMs), evaluating the quality of answers generated by a vanilla RAG
application. We compare these evaluations with human expert judgments and find
a substantial alignment between GPT-4's assessments and those of human experts,
reaching 83% agreement on accept or reject decisions. This study highlights the
potential of LLMs as reliable evaluators in closed-domain, closed-ended
settings, particularly when human evaluations require significant resources. | Evaluating Quality of Answers for Retrieval-Augmented Generation: A Strong LLM Is All You Need: We present a comprehensive evaluation of answer quality in
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) applications using vRAG-Eval, a novel
grading system that is designed to assess correctness, completeness, and
honesty. We further map the grading of quality aspects aforementioned into a
binary score, indicating an accept or reject decision, mirroring the intuitive
"thumbs-up" or "thumbs-down" gesture commonly used in chat applications. This
approach suits factual business settings where a clear decision opinion is
essential. Our assessment applies vRAG-Eval to two Large Language Models
(LLMs), evaluating the quality of answers generated by a vanilla RAG
application. We compare these evaluations with human expert judgments and find
a substantial alignment between GPT-4's assessments and those of human experts,
reaching 83% agreement on accept or reject decisions. This study highlights the
potential of LLMs as reliable evaluators in closed-domain, closed-ended
settings, particularly when human evaluations require significant resources. | [
0.080101423,
0.0225383155,
-0.0230173152,
0.0039026241,
-0.0393909924,
-0.015013014,
-0.0297701936,
0.0039200122,
0.0165132638,
-0.0503195971,
-0.0150626563,
-0.0492960811,
-0.0019326835,
0.0138948662,
0.0082671568,
0.012953531,
0.0367214419,
0.011159515,
0.0286546163,
-0.0065691886,
0.0260156412,
0.0238408893,
0.0125357341,
0.0531695224,
-0.0169347636,
-0.0013946303,
0.0084880255,
0.0106422426,
0.0130558768,
-0.0117810136,
0.0039242492,
0.0531162843,
-0.0374013893,
0.0188815985,
0.000002047,
-0.0616709813,
-0.0000760876,
0.0071372306,
-0.0235514119,
0.0361943319,
0.0265146829,
0.073669374,
-0.0068831723,
0.048085466,
-0.0569527,
0.0076433616,
0.0226835907,
0.0037123121,
0.1157982647,
0.0395275429,
0.013249049,
0.0032769751,
0.0255399998,
-0.0124831945,
0.0522343554,
-0.0377641916,
-0.0198499002,
0.0614932105,
0.0280195903,
0.0115900002,
0.0422191471,
0.0506027229,
0.013322372,
-0.0367714018,
0.0158923343,
0.0234840047,
-0.0469474718,
-0.0181899406,
0.0160109997,
0.0411445089,
0.0541822501,
-0.0068519129,
-0.02533466,
-0.0076314136,
0.0319895446,
0.0321843289,
-0.0475018919,
0.0105580324,
-0.017618997,
-0.0041255332,
-0.0361350439,
-0.0020321559,
0.0013211106,
0.0070699039,
0.0325593688,
0.063674055,
0.0084488895,
-0.0241904333,
-0.0267980453,
0.0123781096,
-0.0021114342,
-0.0318070464,
0.0028094002,
0.0463186651,
-0.0227256194,
0.0245531332,
-0.0034580203,
-0.0067220288,
0.0771481618,
-0.0297962334,
0.0324823298,
0.0151889371,
0.007342909,
0.0095071038,
-0.0296772122,
0.0557086319,
0.018934248,
-0.0165367778,
-0.0510811694,
-0.0154920341,
-0.0458096117,
-0.0264473073,
0.0063138395,
0.0529963486,
-0.0117627718,
0.0136408964,
-0.064782232,
-0.001738948,
-0.025500644,
0.0032239524,
0.0222301651,
0.0392061174,
-0.006823651,
0.0146588758,
-0.0495386869,
0.0244334191,
-0.03474053,
0.0131940702,
0.0296120178,
-0.0940950513,
0.0261945352,
0.002001687,
0.0086549604,
0.0092930952,
0.0162779763,
0.0569881313,
0.0024695941,
-0.0064048916,
-0.0164636094,
-0.0627492294,
-0.018530298,
-0.0446674302,
-0.0357289463,
-0.0843688324,
0.0169284977,
0.0287308171,
-0.0427333266,
0.0119318217,
0.027019294,
0.0567540862,
-0.021013042,
-0.0035487323,
-0.0240260568,
0.0412427373,
0.0386519581,
0.0286164898,
0.0083582439,
0.0226946864,
0.0145566454,
0.070970647,
0.0502279289,
-0.0101673398,
0.0616608821,
0.015739413,
-0.0032647068,
0.0066950582,
0.0269339215,
0.0453987047,
-0.0168386661,
-0.0083798142,
-0.0137216151,
0.0778757706,
-0.0403963365,
-0.0110571319,
0.0562670678,
0.0284802262,
0.0257500559,
-0.0016158856,
0.0154949054,
0.0234037228,
0.0223967526,
0.0181022026,
-0.0063358643,
0.043443691,
-0.0661875904,
0.0034798463,
0.0572352335,
0.0330815129,
0.0128607266,
-0.0631169677,
-0.0239845421,
0.0245752688,
0.0139040397,
0.0228781123,
-0.0115076099,
-0.0177155025,
-0.0323957838,
0.0190020129,
-0.0079709236,
-0.0748470053,
0.0213839281,
-0.07250572,
0.0493884906,
0.0454412401,
0.0853921771,
0.030341588,
-0.0016115818,
-0.0067293425,
-0.0377233624,
0.0182095282,
0.0536138266,
-0.0108616576,
-0.032209903,
-0.0368371606,
-0.0148807876,
0.0148442406,
-0.0159106795,
0.0100003779,
0.0035120735,
0.0287298802,
0.0447802395,
-0.046282243,
-0.0466094576,
-0.0021330549,
0.042731341,
-0.0284092911,
-0.0063869148,
-0.0098361885,
0.0157446899,
0.0506402962,
-0.0266714487,
0.0617786087,
-0.0024928185,
0.0049240468,
-0.0315096304,
-0.0489249304,
-0.006519591,
0.0311397482,
0.0242680963,
-0.0414763764,
0.0127641093,
0.0190922134,
-0.0059342268,
-0.0305390786,
-0.0186664108,
-0.0654332489,
-0.0018806936,
-0.0778435469,
-0.0058330158,
0.0093426788,
-0.0142114274,
-0.0608957782,
0.0521702692,
-0.0019229624,
0.0537043326,
0.0182365496,
-0.0337755233,
0.0427157171,
-0.0496755093,
-0.0293365661,
0.0369241275,
-0.0087041343,
0.048802983,
0.084095493,
0.0305246189,
-0.0523677766,
-0.0214406811,
-0.0994553566,
-0.0162239987,
-0.0100210514,
0.0432584248,
0.0171206519,
-0.0088601168,
0.0008872219,
0.0095615201,
-0.0951687321,
-0.0113891643,
0.0736636892,
0.0281110443,
0.0233600419,
0.0012616437,
0.002719505,
-0.0551618487,
-0.0129956994,
0.0150356917,
0.0070274379,
0.0526008345,
0.029481139,
-0.0574788377,
0.0109643973,
-0.0837808475,
-0.0229202472,
0.0281995907,
-0.0663651526,
0.0256895944,
-0.0010435012,
-0.0039931769,
-0.0107717104,
0.0347658917,
-0.021030575,
0.030242499,
-0.0225647129,
-0.0833220258,
-0.0219863858,
-0.0233741179,
-0.0390049629,
0.0120201027,
-0.0836708024,
0.0402712375,
-0.0051511377,
0.0443323217,
-0.0049072565,
-0.0540574305,
0.0178951696,
-0.0136981867,
-0.034605328,
-0.0303740967,
-0.0251958221,
-0.0203947891,
0.056959372,
0.0079246182,
-0.0599334054,
0.0631699488,
-0.05235333,
0.0066377711,
-0.0277934521,
-0.0039502853,
-0.0244005304,
0.0284673218,
-0.0289927851,
0.0317021981,
-0.0120990053,
0.0092302049,
-0.0395411327,
-0.0080725839,
0.0324287377,
-0.0995154753,
0.0029019632,
-0.035058856,
-0.0030845762,
-0.0029583939,
0.0034191266,
-0.0456170179,
-0.0459174551,
0.0144974757,
0.0168141834,
0.0124303112,
0.0070578032,
-0.0043036686,
-0.0031006881,
0.0442285053,
-0.0221471805,
-0.0370173939,
-0.0191317219,
0.0184515696,
0.0547986254,
0.0750874057,
0.0138042578,
0.0527184792,
0.0127993645,
-0.0335951485,
0.0816239342,
0.0166507941,
0.0095555056,
0.0338718332,
-0.0376592502,
0.0527205803,
-0.0225133933,
-0.0444196165,
0.0299865305,
0.0224943236,
-0.0387694798,
-0.0132533843,
0.0672773868,
0.0435909964,
-0.0072952583,
-0.0229211021,
-0.0330035537,
0.0123074157,
0.0096952794,
0.0593742244,
-0.0917186812,
-0.0019505692,
-0.019677341,
0.0575339198,
-0.0222583693,
-0.0164778512,
-0.0032982233,
-0.1284004301,
0.056397181,
0.0011314714,
0.0050383084,
-0.0147147551,
-0.0348264314,
-0.0006501608,
0.0292774849,
-0.0049634599,
0.0406802744,
0.000588842,
0.02614001,
0.0117174406,
-0.0017001454,
0.0022702904,
0.0449780263,
-0.0180942174,
0.0425911061,
0.0833732858,
0.025571214,
0.0071191117,
-0.1025435701,
-0.0056366432,
-0.0475001372,
0.0270008463,
0.0081789037,
0.0168037098,
0.0021422186,
0.0245643258,
-0.0467001498,
-0.0300593022,
-0.0196061675,
0.0035950597,
0.0032860965,
0.0599174611,
-0.0208602548,
-0.0019293809,
-0.0609796457,
0.0071781026,
0.00788486,
0.0771751478,
0.0321737602,
-0.0273464099,
-0.035257604,
-0.0193473194,
0.0344588533,
-0.0316672176,
-0.0469804481,
0.0118357819,
0.0030734341,
-0.0124178892,
-0.0997159332,
-0.0491009876,
-0.0100967223,
0.0158765912,
-0.0246237796,
-0.0136438608,
-0.0410831831,
0.0172883775,
-0.0087549547,
-0.0107644247,
-0.0299575813,
0.0288952608,
-0.0557137989,
0.0152948713,
0.0105366753,
-0.0521400832,
-0.0130899986,
0.0023034588,
-0.0138141057,
-0.0370415077,
-0.0042514768,
0.0452987291,
0.0299015567,
-0.0223774649,
-0.01294633,
-0.0323745571,
0.0271835364,
0.0303229392,
-0.055448778,
0.0247161724,
0.0021684659,
0.0021492927,
-0.0103413388,
-0.0035626779,
-0.0831161514,
0.0324905403,
-0.0077319364,
0.0501988083,
0.0340778641,
-0.078113243,
0.0228823815,
0.0825393051,
-0.0051726825,
-0.0028411313,
0.0098243877,
0.0017122612,
-0.0032929005,
-0.0169405621,
-0.0120519213,
-0.0389468633,
-0.0148539068,
-0.0158699881,
-0.0272570793,
0.0117999893,
0.0006170304,
-0.0552203543,
0.0667589977,
-0.0230787266,
0.0129909059,
0.0030224361,
-0.001228264,
-0.0163238626,
-0.0134565439,
-0.0469144173,
-0.0265058614,
-0.0099313008,
0.0497171432,
-0.0058656177,
0.0692462176,
-0.0178404655,
-0.0191050824,
0.0677374974,
0.0491554141,
-0.0621323511,
-0.0535352677,
-0.0351097696,
0.014257892,
0.0126279872,
0.0405584648,
0.0689616203,
-0.0140258484,
0.0114924423,
-0.0204388611,
-0.0054289941,
0.0344233662,
-0.0286859684,
0.0153947175,
0.0173187647,
-0.025834756,
-0.0016815744,
0.0426236279,
-0.0446571,
-0.0232215226,
-0.0712162256,
-0.0420158803,
-0.0204715133,
-0.0516724959,
-0.0125722392,
0.0080373855,
0.0005337285,
-0.0309930854,
-0.0932205319,
-0.0371769741,
-0.037889652,
0.0654523447,
0.026599396,
-0.0156326443,
0.0243741702,
0.0886849165,
0.0194658469,
-0.0076726642,
-0.0761258826,
0.0112740817,
-0.0681924,
0.0257767923,
-0.0516731367,
-6.550375414e-33,
-0.012339347,
-0.0516976044,
0.0107816514,
-0.0402617492,
-0.0093393419,
-0.0032824946,
-0.0153672369,
0.0174032785,
-0.022779271,
-0.0262531266,
-0.015709646,
-0.0028474466,
0.0058430303,
-0.0088298097,
0.0033077474,
-0.0044438839,
0.036025513,
-0.0012275699,
-0.0607013442,
0.0406968035,
0.0326715,
-0.0324361958,
0.0421998277,
-0.0505501814,
0.0522786528,
-0.0285749566,
-0.0253983513,
0.0058033476,
-0.0127041526,
0.0677857324,
0.004168232,
0.0520818755,
0.0249361955,
-0.039272245,
0.0160634313,
0.0041319067,
-0.0288699567,
-0.0317856595,
0.0423683301,
-0.0261067562,
-0.0483901761,
-0.0033713703,
0.0378936231,
-0.0235468112,
-0.0492288172,
0.0274794046,
0.0245113187,
-0.0138153154,
0.0089759314,
-0.0581731722,
-0.0171101317,
0.0244713034,
0.0200243611,
-0.0094458647,
-0.038180206,
0.0854370147,
-0.0018548153,
0.0029580991,
-0.0446796007,
0.0251841601,
0.0030812414,
0.0314665809,
0.0831664801,
-0.038242314,
-0.0203485992,
0.0622030385,
0.0173182394,
-0.0161295198,
-0.010520637,
-0.0513097681,
0.0057227644,
0.020154722,
0.0608016327,
0.0720529631,
0.0325909741,
-0.0236632116,
-0.0082884636,
0.0908129066,
0.0249657705,
0.0530787669,
0.0100461598,
-0.0203628372,
-0.052703727,
0.0027649791,
-0.0359331444,
0.0226691253,
-0.0662191659,
-0.0759916753,
0.0444136076,
-0.0020765872,
-0.0337423645,
-0.0409710072,
0.0412923284,
-0.0266540553,
-0.0122679854,
0.0307327099,
-0.0359782465,
0.0080459686,
-0.0109671233,
-0.0052691414,
-0.0029530937,
0.0526000075,
0.0250335392,
0.0074341367,
-0.0057049477,
0.0099668577,
-0.0175972767,
-0.0064180312,
-0.0573427714,
0.0198899768,
-0.024037607,
0.0434655659,
-0.0190921538,
-0.0545737855,
0.0139117585,
-0.0106775304,
-0.0162547417,
0.042658221,
-0.0091834906,
0.0260928515,
-0.050262101,
-0.0460827947,
0.0285218004,
0.0058282004,
-0.041871164,
0.0279409438,
-0.0010064533,
0.0223837681,
-0.0137553327,
0.0080989832,
-0.0167688224,
0.0043077017,
2.822e-7,
0.0393793918,
0.0145822112,
0.0095231161,
0.0343921892,
-0.0078935968,
0.0337841883,
0.0231822655,
0.0105197197,
0.0468943119,
-0.0078806439,
-0.0000122675,
-0.0214587878,
0.0370340236,
0.0661009252,
-0.0381956808,
0.0063486374,
-0.0655059367,
-0.0051349211,
-0.0156926587,
0.0009556094,
0.1092028916,
0.0279472228,
-0.020474067,
-0.020979492,
-0.0306308698,
-0.0104526198,
0.0377607606,
-0.0029845207,
-0.0138685089,
0.032020025,
0.0977102667,
-0.019297421,
0.0465907268,
-0.0146842469,
-0.0105512543,
-0.0203027986,
0.0339253955,
0.0326365605,
-0.0009289848,
-0.0561679192,
0.0001739332,
-0.0432963148,
0.0401408821,
-0.0673340484,
0.0679983795,
0.0041704588,
-0.0087806266,
-0.0350162983,
-0.0708052889,
-0.0286680441,
0.0155266598,
-0.015596183,
-0.0447310656,
0.0334478877,
-0.0228208601,
0.0157148186,
-0.0066495696,
-0.0160237439,
-0.032198485,
0.0095349234,
-0.0127619933,
-0.0726346523,
-0.0189864561,
0.0043476787,
-0.0453003272,
-0.055879619,
0.0103094857,
2.59536709e-34,
0.0241011344,
-0.0123682069,
0.0290189441,
0.0043482636,
0.0437488705,
0.0463885963,
0.0015750817,
0.0149383927,
0.0216115545,
-0.0474864431,
-0.0244314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18060v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18060v1 | AdaZeta: Adaptive Zeroth-Order Tensor-Train Adaption for Memory-Efficient Large Language Models Fine-Tuning | 2024-06-26T04:33:13 | 2024-06-26T04:33:13 | Yifan Yang, Kai Zhen, Ershad Banijamal, Athanasios Mouchtaris, Zheng Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Fine-tuning large language models (LLMs) has achieved remarkable performance
across various natural language processing tasks, yet it demands more and more
memory as model sizes keep growing. To address this issue, the recently
proposed Memory-efficient Zeroth-order (MeZO) methods attempt to fine-tune LLMs
using only forward passes, thereby avoiding the need for a backpropagation
graph. However, significant performance drops and a high risk of divergence
have limited their widespread adoption. In this paper, we propose the Adaptive
Zeroth-order Tensor-Train Adaption (AdaZeta) framework, specifically designed
to improve the performance and convergence of the ZO methods. To enhance
dimension-dependent ZO estimation accuracy, we introduce a fast-forward,
low-parameter tensorized adapter. To tackle the frequently observed divergence
issue in large-scale ZO fine-tuning tasks, we propose an adaptive query number
schedule that guarantees convergence. Detailed theoretical analysis and
extensive experimental results on Roberta-Large and Llama-2-7B models
substantiate the efficacy of our AdaZeta framework in terms of accuracy, memory
efficiency, and convergence speed. | AdaZeta: Adaptive Zeroth-Order Tensor-Train Adaption for Memory-Efficient Large Language Models Fine-Tuning: Fine-tuning large language models (LLMs) has achieved remarkable performance
across various natural language processing tasks, yet it demands more and more
memory as model sizes keep growing. To address this issue, the recently
proposed Memory-efficient Zeroth-order (MeZO) methods attempt to fine-tune LLMs
using only forward passes, thereby avoiding the need for a backpropagation
graph. However, significant performance drops and a high risk of divergence
have limited their widespread adoption. In this paper, we propose the Adaptive
Zeroth-order Tensor-Train Adaption (AdaZeta) framework, specifically designed
to improve the performance and convergence of the ZO methods. To enhance
dimension-dependent ZO estimation accuracy, we introduce a fast-forward,
low-parameter tensorized adapter. To tackle the frequently observed divergence
issue in large-scale ZO fine-tuning tasks, we propose an adaptive query number
schedule that guarantees convergence. Detailed theoretical analysis and
extensive experimental results on Roberta-Large and Llama-2-7B models
substantiate the efficacy of our AdaZeta framework in terms of accuracy, memory
efficiency, and convergence speed. | [
0.019506108,
0.0597144701,
0.0002742128,
0.0176635012,
0.0069130743,
0.0337005779,
-0.0056393566,
0.0120048905,
-0.0040329592,
-0.0290170498,
-0.0462414548,
-0.0738393366,
0.009258206,
-0.0064684879,
0.0052194893,
-0.0025142874,
0.0070982208,
-0.049424585,
0.0111896442,
-0.0109018292,
-0.0188236963,
0.0258570593,
-0.0143819656,
-0.0082888985,
0.0359697528,
-0.0000043418,
-0.0088785309,
-0.0005795437,
-0.0055763004,
-0.0163802337,
-0.0102048647,
0.0633997172,
0.0195519459,
0.0597088337,
0.0000019107,
-0.0120007396,
-0.0115171243,
-0.0058785318,
0.0119503103,
0.0058574276,
0.0450428016,
-0.0554008484,
-0.0242409278,
0.019052349,
0.0051462492,
-0.0277875531,
0.0561840534,
0.0401462652,
0.0387814231,
0.0939652771,
-0.0155095924,
-0.0168570336,
0.048977159,
-0.0396881476,
-0.0200422835,
-0.0824259073,
0.0504127964,
-0.0530313142,
-0.0288587734,
-0.0022515245,
-0.0038546836,
0.0271744262,
-0.0342535935,
0.0189079978,
-0.009076071,
0.0316375606,
-0.0162778925,
-0.0115467729,
-0.0166379847,
0.0744984448,
-0.0254169255,
0.014169991,
-0.0037563825,
0.0009281151,
-0.0403673239,
-0.0053583249,
-0.0427065715,
0.0092567196,
0.0494790338,
0.012829328,
0.0070170895,
-0.0607891753,
0.0258503389,
0.0341646634,
-0.0862762406,
0.0451839045,
0.0471913368,
-0.0050429478,
0.023943197,
-0.0092847412,
-0.0309977345,
0.0033943185,
-0.0061034774,
0.0079570329,
-0.0181358065,
-0.021426389,
-0.0362461843,
-0.118784219,
-0.0097353859,
-0.048904974,
0.1127542481,
0.0510424264,
-0.0078466069,
0.0526877008,
-0.057982035,
0.0282007623,
-0.0177439358,
-0.0328990854,
-0.0417922251,
-0.0271797366,
-0.0079247933,
0.0238504279,
-0.0553181954,
0.0081046289,
-0.0458900928,
-0.0375297256,
-0.0504278354,
0.0159783605,
-0.0047386829,
-0.0472309254,
0.0061269049,
0.0086716907,
-0.0027259279,
-0.0022923511,
-0.0190913789,
0.0764708221,
0.009008673,
0.0083108135,
-0.0857789442,
-0.019635668,
-0.0265370272,
0.0321456045,
0.0387512334,
-0.0349525996,
0.0368125103,
0.025708694,
-0.0152990865,
-0.0466874465,
-0.0206702948,
0.0379555561,
0.0136929983,
-0.0823110566,
0.0193083119,
-0.0308981687,
0.0438622944,
-0.0098453285,
0.0310503691,
-0.0294894632,
-0.0056213913,
-0.0005009004,
-0.1040291414,
0.050103616,
0.0100158053,
0.0117602842,
-0.0256111752,
-0.0093896994,
0.0885332376,
0.0651171431,
0.0361809097,
-0.0124982931,
0.0075203637,
-0.0159392748,
-0.0601089187,
0.0429540537,
0.0341833085,
0.0208921321,
-0.0440550782,
-0.0016633524,
0.0086389109,
0.0518510379,
0.0351103283,
0.0376284122,
-0.047222808,
-0.0186045095,
0.0339479037,
0.0398946106,
0.0659065694,
0.0102737341,
-0.0062572919,
-0.0386291556,
-0.0271141157,
-0.0479260944,
-0.0575947985,
0.0429903828,
-0.0405567512,
-0.0054568592,
0.0654703379,
0.0498451628,
-0.0320279486,
-0.0048704916,
-0.0015618507,
-0.0041928361,
-0.000921146,
0.0007428969,
0.0706197098,
-0.0132087152,
-0.0283453744,
0.0318382457,
0.0304613318,
-0.0320401862,
-0.0176512171,
-0.0445525199,
0.0132749472,
0.0687265769,
0.0233448092,
-0.036034219,
-0.0201079082,
0.0166712478,
0.0370308422,
0.00879806,
0.0083356816,
0.0245597716,
0.0423063487,
-0.0595215745,
-0.0084790699,
0.0266720541,
0.0088566598,
-0.0031201863,
-0.003510959,
0.052311942,
0.0330454297,
-0.0137498323,
-0.0230364092,
0.0308159124,
-0.0312153995,
-0.0442011803,
0.0359988324,
0.0089536095,
0.0026530158,
0.044044625,
-0.0008806035,
-0.00727128,
0.0374695994,
-0.0342058614,
0.0018975287,
-0.0768453553,
-0.0262023862,
0.0119640585,
0.0468220077,
0.0181722436,
0.0421353653,
0.0125925103,
-0.0532065481,
-0.0549311787,
0.0955339596,
0.0090059079,
0.0221031234,
-0.0439235009,
0.0093671801,
0.0148230875,
0.0634550974,
-0.0175503641,
-0.0022459556,
-0.0112281451,
0.0064047072,
0.0231005456,
-0.0295858029,
-0.0064151688,
-0.0061531425,
-0.0659122765,
0.0573036298,
0.0422467254,
0.0310117584,
-0.0002226063,
0.007886067,
-0.0037614417,
-0.0299116652,
-0.1024891287,
0.0247857105,
-0.0463754199,
0.0065087541,
0.0308152661,
0.0116280001,
-0.0011784276,
-0.0074855089,
0.010604335,
0.0420239307,
-0.0296792425,
0.0274140015,
-0.0055121863,
-0.0075766877,
-0.0138496226,
-0.0034964662,
-0.0455764607,
0.0043168026,
0.0388374999,
-0.0544584766,
0.0060027549,
-0.0308335386,
-0.0383162163,
-0.0441133454,
0.0627107918,
0.0028379729,
-0.0088397283,
0.0061520301,
-0.033516854,
0.0470321365,
0.0554990098,
0.0058493637,
0.0245571379,
0.0573731624,
0.0135872243,
0.0040772995,
-0.0090085715,
-0.0463933349,
-0.0626908913,
-0.0245499704,
-0.0254334584,
-0.0273933038,
0.0637887493,
-0.0290469658,
-0.0151124801,
-0.0426231809,
-0.0237717684,
0.0057895114,
0.012295776,
-0.0048264479,
0.0307388492,
-0.009219043,
-0.0034239597,
0.0181685071,
0.0075509697,
0.0352893621,
-0.0337636806,
-0.0088129872,
-0.0352980494,
-0.0242832508,
-0.0431490988,
0.0019025378,
0.0170184206,
0.0415507071,
0.008365849,
0.0161036383,
-0.0127245951,
-0.0293822382,
0.0247222092,
-0.0222916752,
0.0356317125,
-0.0095966291,
0.0157089084,
-0.0309955329,
-0.0022747996,
0.0103957709,
-0.0221914016,
-0.0163617712,
0.04803418,
-0.0207167435,
-0.053352803,
-0.0283507593,
0.0368867628,
0.0039604683,
0.0630553216,
-0.0334382653,
0.0057580909,
-0.0147744799,
0.0428488441,
0.075754188,
0.0288399216,
0.0164516885,
0.0064782156,
-0.0072191004,
0.0529488027,
0.0729270875,
-0.0089696413,
-0.0444270372,
-0.0127641885,
0.0503391884,
-0.0193480235,
0.0017831621,
0.00038086,
-0.011305932,
-0.0358651392,
0.0177352708,
0.1093422845,
0.0047378591,
-0.0524617247,
-0.0067844945,
0.0363284163,
0.0503362194,
0.0253131203,
0.0335214175,
-0.0612914935,
-0.0296461117,
-0.0137598692,
0.057138972,
0.0052414741,
-0.0418712981,
-0.0112089841,
-0.0939037204,
0.0074264877,
0.0207391903,
-0.0166169014,
-0.0074029467,
-0.061647296,
0.034672115,
-0.0268078372,
0.0434920639,
0.0254802443,
-0.004471275,
-0.0399055518,
0.0221668966,
0.0697040781,
-0.0213226806,
-0.0108336043,
-0.0222063735,
0.0566204228,
-0.0219604298,
0.0299055818,
-0.0040160287,
0.0063329106,
0.0429961868,
-0.0210443158,
-0.0008354694,
-0.0178483538,
0.0207938198,
-0.0215261783,
-0.0001851434,
0.00417588,
0.0412093401,
-0.0328870825,
0.0104433186,
-0.0408223011,
0.076460585,
0.0193192735,
-0.0293018986,
-0.0253720656,
-0.0185389724,
-0.0311065428,
0.0549815185,
0.0066617201,
-0.0535533167,
-0.0381211489,
0.0410865583,
-0.0015601697,
-0.013844477,
0.0113203228,
-0.0387491994,
-0.0205446258,
-0.0423068851,
-0.021169303,
0.0556560382,
0.0112041356,
0.0384324007,
0.0029474273,
0.0149728721,
0.0177699067,
-0.0305884797,
-0.0173420925,
0.0622544996,
-0.0343313292,
0.0158667509,
-0.0658251941,
0.0017699436,
0.0380438305,
0.001177705,
-0.0000878089,
0.0137184495,
-0.0836575106,
-0.0782092959,
-0.0074936263,
-0.0011292755,
0.008650152,
0.0199445225,
0.0089661647,
-0.0825759098,
0.0577106476,
0.027312519,
-0.0548951514,
0.0574822128,
0.0227390565,
-0.0373283289,
-0.0088231089,
0.0438301712,
-0.0187095068,
-0.0002620241,
0.0306544453,
0.0347074755,
-0.0009650656,
-0.0502322838,
-0.0260451771,
0.0224898718,
0.0525246821,
-0.0010723833,
0.0295430869,
-0.0401307717,
0.0475712121,
0.0072132437,
0.016729068,
-0.0298788808,
-0.0066890204,
0.0394884832,
0.0076164966,
-0.0420436971,
-0.0164639447,
0.0199637394,
0.0054510571,
-0.0403420702,
-0.0037137892,
0.0077717477,
-0.0262708422,
0.0571291968,
0.0038770691,
-0.0056459694,
0.0272451378,
0.0029234339,
0.061970789,
-0.0533568487,
0.0406720378,
0.0098643377,
-0.0085964054,
-0.0809813812,
0.0540756248,
-0.0160376113,
-0.0845510215,
-0.0153490556,
0.0290913247,
0.0481132902,
-0.0116121192,
0.0600123145,
-0.0081839571,
-0.0194474068,
-0.0099712266,
0.0130199753,
-0.0261713453,
0.0269447826,
0.0122714257,
0.0001611948,
0.0081905462,
0.0701841041,
0.0489228591,
0.0480894968,
0.0278024469,
-0.014639535,
-0.001612911,
-0.0053190519,
-0.0237170309,
0.0107983928,
0.0638979226,
-0.0449436083,
0.0188182238,
-0.0093443124,
-0.0641473606,
-0.0209984239,
-0.0740678757,
-0.0376956016,
-0.0515708365,
0.0206873138,
0.0204038881,
-0.0124833779,
0.0296371225,
-0.0106828045,
-0.0164183341,
-0.0076116864,
-0.0327266864,
0.0239231288,
-6.566315117e-33,
-0.0318958163,
0.0358268395,
0.0012705507,
-0.0412256345,
-0.0272593126,
-0.0208310131,
-0.0152338622,
0.0040819086,
-0.0232022107,
-0.0225422792,
-0.016994819,
-0.0131015228,
-0.0049602934,
0.0095504476,
-0.0145725617,
0.0472215973,
0.0450145379,
-0.0468170717,
-0.0277180634,
0.0308533739,
0.0386937968,
0.0307250097,
0.0693378225,
-0.049226515,
-0.0299145821,
0.0088489829,
-0.0025224285,
0.032947924,
0.0252044778,
0.0176978167,
-0.0203838609,
0.0372142531,
-0.0013586831,
-0.050244242,
0.0111115547,
-0.0115555432,
-0.0982439294,
-0.0135622965,
0.040403679,
-0.0108185709,
0.0075058057,
0.0069054761,
0.0174522791,
0.0389381796,
-0.010773032,
-0.0294146203,
0.0015656486,
-0.0024800515,
-0.0587419532,
0.0134713817,
-0.0429939665,
0.0288207978,
-0.0099684028,
-0.0029291327,
0.0687131435,
-0.0064270762,
-0.0180684607,
0.0424338616,
-0.0543148182,
0.0030675954,
0.0183376018,
0.0337104164,
0.0417055488,
0.0345835648,
-0.0016669456,
0.0171296764,
0.0422042198,
-0.0068023889,
0.0097645093,
-0.0119294999,
0.0438853092,
0.0090812938,
0.0196194164,
-0.0107662007,
0.0090925694,
-0.0414228216,
-0.0685475916,
-0.0535727181,
0.0150744207,
0.0349948481,
0.06137174,
0.0142470738,
-0.0344030671,
-0.030513281,
-0.0446682833,
-0.0211620275,
-0.059782777,
0.0139107993,
-0.0116255339,
0.0334992595,
-0.0606897101,
-0.0584717765,
0.0310272258,
-0.0631948486,
0.0358925574,
0.036648307,
-0.0242121834,
-0.0112266913,
0.0087629668,
0.0305635259,
-0.093615599,
-0.0498993881,
0.0020881684,
-0.0540634207,
-0.0064090998,
-0.0129289124,
0.0311548412,
0.0400574133,
-0.0816743821,
-0.0318239741,
-0.0393276997,
0.0067531094,
0.0173366461,
0.0959298387,
-0.0203639902,
0.0029457523,
0.006792746,
0.0651928112,
0.0417711921,
0.0306671802,
0.0133576831,
-0.0345699154,
0.0538701117,
-0.015757395,
-0.0355769247,
0.0087259682,
0.0132732568,
-0.0108655877,
0.0522318371,
-0.0541180708,
-0.0410153419,
0.0364295579,
2.756e-7,
0.011613695,
0.0297379345,
-0.0348177217,
-0.001003294,
0.0316463336,
0.0386890769,
-0.0061248979,
0.0215292573,
0.0483477488,
0.0514731184,
0.0357525125,
0.0269421302,
0.007247203,
-0.0259492751,
-0.0555904806,
-0.0214686263,
-0.0287431236,
0.0296667218,
-0.0547003411,
-0.0265626907,
-0.027497787,
0.092299968,
0.025301937,
-0.0171098448,
0.0135128302,
-0.0617757626,
0.0429397225,
-0.0059561045,
0.0245507136,
0.0248915907,
0.0252874587,
0.0639017373,
-0.00826653,
-0.0052036364,
0.0014376098,
0.0750389099,
-0.012281986,
0.0645070076,
-0.0404975824,
-0.0345485099,
0.0514509976,
-0.0115981465,
0.0044233766,
-0.0579170994,
0.0781484246,
-0.0055903047,
-0.0144540528,
-0.064523913,
0.0003174699,
-0.0254983027,
0.0382602736,
-0.0288833603,
0.0328253321,
0.0290873032,
0.0564721487,
-0.0250737835,
-0.0266339369,
-0.0647219121,
0.0057095666,
0.0212450083,
-0.0134267686,
-0.0576560348,
-0.0314663313,
-0.0238940809,
0.0165839382,
-0.0241181105,
-0.0032389062,
2.125664572e-34,
0.0464235246,
-0.0203996673,
0.002073688,
0.0204154942,
0.0257545765,
-0.0323357433,
0.0043684295,
0.0100257564,
-0.0055877734,
-0.1345548332,
-0.0409772247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18616v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18616v1 | Towards Large Language Model Aided Program Refinement | 2024-06-26T04:29:27 | 2024-06-26T04:29:27 | Yufan Cai, Zhe Hou, Xiaokun Luan, David Miguel Sanan Baena, Yun Lin, Jun Sun, Jin Song Dong | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, K.6.3 | Program refinement involves correctness-preserving transformations from
formal high-level specification statements into executable programs.
Traditional verification tool support for program refinement is highly
interactive and lacks automation. On the other hand, the emergence of large
language models (LLMs) enables automatic code generations from informal natural
language specifications. However, code generated by LLMs is often unreliable.
Moreover, the opaque procedure from specification to code provided by LLM is an
uncontrolled black box. We propose LLM4PR, a tool that combines formal program
refinement techniques with informal LLM-based methods to (1) transform the
specification to preconditions and postconditions, (2) automatically build
prompts based on refinement calculus, (3) interact with LLM to generate code,
and finally, (4) verify that the generated code satisfies the conditions of
refinement calculus, thus guaranteeing the correctness of the code. We have
implemented our tool using GPT4, Coq, and Coqhammer, and evaluated it on the
HumanEval and EvalPlus datasets. | Towards Large Language Model Aided Program Refinement: Program refinement involves correctness-preserving transformations from
formal high-level specification statements into executable programs.
Traditional verification tool support for program refinement is highly
interactive and lacks automation. On the other hand, the emergence of large
language models (LLMs) enables automatic code generations from informal natural
language specifications. However, code generated by LLMs is often unreliable.
Moreover, the opaque procedure from specification to code provided by LLM is an
uncontrolled black box. We propose LLM4PR, a tool that combines formal program
refinement techniques with informal LLM-based methods to (1) transform the
specification to preconditions and postconditions, (2) automatically build
prompts based on refinement calculus, (3) interact with LLM to generate code,
and finally, (4) verify that the generated code satisfies the conditions of
refinement calculus, thus guaranteeing the correctness of the code. We have
implemented our tool using GPT4, Coq, and Coqhammer, and evaluated it on the
HumanEval and EvalPlus datasets. | [
-0.0248057991,
0.0716641992,
-0.0125206886,
0.0364422314,
-0.0101864832,
-0.0086787567,
-0.0579825863,
-0.0277496632,
-0.0029434136,
-0.0086768679,
0.0112043293,
0.0083627636,
0.0236807056,
0.0442799814,
0.0067828102,
-0.0107714869,
0.0454992391,
-0.043644052,
0.0047477908,
0.0242253207,
-0.0097716944,
0.0214641578,
0.0417940877,
0.0354853608,
0.0239010677,
-0.0322591625,
-0.004501686,
0.0426375717,
-0.0310694259,
-0.0216246787,
0.0093598254,
0.0589363724,
0.0073005646,
-0.003960595,
0.0000024411,
-0.0612398386,
-0.0353833437,
0.0569160245,
0.007897147,
0.071089536,
-0.0038023842,
-0.0017057781,
-0.0020493416,
0.0241412148,
-0.0486901179,
-0.0438395068,
0.0196289923,
-0.0263551343,
0.1168448254,
0.0593328252,
0.0116466656,
-0.0629876778,
0.0079279197,
0.0349930823,
-0.0124008162,
-0.0281984787,
0.0289722811,
0.0176478047,
0.0011895059,
0.0044421977,
0.0299453773,
0.0015794077,
0.0435304828,
-0.0334495269,
-0.0256993063,
-0.0101187052,
-0.0515081398,
-0.0224399101,
-0.0095524499,
0.019866446,
-0.0034328473,
-0.0569675714,
0.0107259341,
0.0189165808,
-0.0199351422,
-0.0499168634,
-0.0298868325,
0.0277474448,
-0.0067923316,
0.0238209683,
0.0069299899,
-0.0528766029,
0.0300528705,
-0.0132108843,
-0.0247354973,
0.0895710364,
0.0233101584,
-0.0250388719,
-0.0349449106,
-0.0438585877,
-0.0204122812,
-0.0420579389,
0.0246717371,
0.0416406989,
-0.0325276256,
-0.0143013615,
-0.0267444011,
0.0017460785,
0.0391326621,
-0.00637687,
0.0287806168,
0.0384908579,
0.0030351048,
0.0140912067,
-0.0320348665,
0.0556891002,
0.0017091867,
-0.0258270912,
-0.0258668736,
0.024053216,
-0.0164522268,
-0.012155734,
-0.0785855874,
0.0060981037,
0.0076318509,
0.0865417719,
-0.0350531451,
0.0514016189,
-0.0258642584,
0.0911100954,
-0.0140690776,
-0.0536047295,
0.0143139157,
-0.001236948,
0.0263012815,
-0.0240239408,
-0.0061166212,
-0.0456138439,
-0.036773473,
-0.0574789792,
0.0114748282,
0.0179472249,
-0.0621860474,
-0.006277448,
0.0087205004,
0.0466224067,
0.0042430125,
0.0461079143,
-0.0483568422,
-0.0562030897,
0.0333976522,
-0.0255724676,
-0.0245337673,
-0.1153130308,
-0.0211452916,
0.0003700251,
-0.0102173304,
-0.0307727475,
-0.0203404874,
-0.0232720505,
0.0201492738,
0.0457515828,
-0.0685474724,
0.0287090875,
0.0204233006,
0.0255262032,
0.0272203758,
0.0217833295,
0.0381556153,
-0.0372112021,
0.0185698513,
-0.0525181182,
0.023564823,
0.0520256385,
-0.0353112333,
0.0112613924,
-0.0291733481,
0.0306688696,
0.0245013088,
-0.0157722458,
-0.0293325763,
0.0399538241,
-0.0096743535,
0.0141960159,
-0.0186373331,
0.0202751011,
0.0021302772,
0.0219845586,
0.0724190697,
0.056846343,
0.0050519919,
-0.0070604449,
-0.0368487164,
0.0007996103,
-0.0175634101,
0.0128839063,
-0.0147106424,
0.0483211577,
0.0011367593,
-0.0785406604,
-0.0019060263,
0.0323406011,
0.02645972,
-0.0287699997,
0.0170850772,
0.0165675674,
-0.0232689623,
0.030105941,
0.009972333,
-0.0703293979,
-0.0302941315,
-0.029282093,
0.0536035635,
0.0555739589,
0.0401430689,
-0.0472852997,
-0.0443861336,
-0.0011803814,
-0.0148197813,
0.0015332878,
0.0435735025,
-0.0189580712,
-0.0250671841,
-0.0227956399,
0.0023373864,
0.0104815578,
0.0385606363,
0.0241331104,
0.0242976267,
-0.028177442,
0.034285605,
0.0096263075,
-0.0643708408,
0.0385560505,
0.0241113082,
-0.0361843593,
0.019506041,
0.0021303291,
0.0222466774,
-0.016254494,
-0.0410531797,
0.0260510929,
0.0761161223,
0.0346727408,
0.0133690499,
-0.0563730486,
-0.0025493165,
-0.0058608721,
0.0460426919,
-0.0102154445,
-0.0520991683,
0.012916985,
-0.064363271,
-0.0006742051,
0.0439706594,
0.0265896227,
0.0128672086,
-0.020728657,
0.059754815,
-0.0537568443,
-0.0260704234,
-0.0231594499,
-0.0059466967,
0.0541669279,
-0.0179750659,
0.0066340407,
0.0111289453,
0.000669149,
0.0273972135,
-0.0384430289,
-0.0202199053,
-0.0094622811,
0.0347460546,
0.0016412825,
0.0989617184,
0.0036831943,
-0.0009552557,
-0.1028385684,
0.0606659055,
-0.0069158385,
0.0133083733,
0.0196526647,
0.0281814616,
-0.0153050851,
0.0071809608,
0.0147778047,
-0.0103022028,
0.0084043574,
0.0099175842,
0.0381076485,
-0.0146309193,
-0.0917469412,
0.0129938331,
-0.0055086268,
-0.0339741148,
0.0258897264,
-0.0008613096,
0.016716281,
-0.0877332911,
0.0406196788,
-0.0071519115,
0.0253369156,
0.0008027504,
-0.0107601667,
0.0264133047,
-0.0281703454,
0.0085653206,
0.0132890809,
-0.0136969294,
-0.0174680855,
0.0634103715,
0.0098592341,
-0.0358458571,
0.0225746725,
0.0390643515,
-0.0498917513,
0.0051249168,
-0.0183999874,
0.0366589725,
0.060942784,
-0.0289870501,
-0.0166635141,
-0.0193309449,
0.0187062714,
0.0125865415,
0.0302486513,
-0.0164541695,
-0.0585622564,
-0.0163060874,
0.0281729642,
-0.003481379,
-0.0724255964,
0.0771720186,
-0.0693133399,
-0.0375513434,
-0.0060302909,
-0.0424356274,
-0.0284550041,
0.0480499007,
-0.01678502,
-0.0046714456,
0.0094732996,
0.0052777152,
0.0130005451,
-0.0197586361,
0.0170578621,
-0.0263086297,
0.111837171,
-0.0691509172,
0.0087356893,
-0.015900271,
-0.0224518403,
-0.0311897304,
-0.0145199783,
-0.0045778938,
0.0127776619,
0.0140648251,
-0.0077168355,
0.0591896102,
0.0117711667,
-0.0279874839,
0.0457737297,
0.0155709786,
-0.0393519364,
0.0089499978,
-0.0562978946,
-0.0271794647,
-0.0337256379,
-0.0196958669,
0.0062073539,
0.0099657606,
0.0256693605,
-0.0126752257,
0.0032560325,
-0.0848962814,
-0.020357715,
0.0338124707,
-0.0139105115,
-0.0078590401,
0.0552864783,
0.0287570283,
-0.0888318792,
-0.02026687,
0.0711589828,
0.0179626383,
-0.0283916164,
0.0160679873,
-0.0078690611,
0.0583063401,
0.0483132564,
0.066635929,
-0.0914749876,
-0.0259160437,
-0.003102741,
0.0286626685,
0.013698048,
0.0121200783,
-0.0439570583,
-0.0932272971,
0.0707578063,
0.0293609053,
-0.0372016802,
0.0193762127,
-0.0246900227,
-0.0283522159,
0.041520834,
-0.0199960433,
0.0718434751,
0.0156256892,
-0.0073417625,
-0.0204000827,
-0.0356387906,
-0.0048011704,
0.0446640477,
-0.0253657866,
0.0187742747,
0.055490911,
-0.0063361772,
0.0003264633,
-0.0096790921,
0.0890223533,
0.0178931355,
-0.005894226,
-0.0631209314,
-0.0440573134,
0.0127731031,
-0.002610588,
0.0238716155,
-0.0035975301,
-0.0289236624,
-0.019669354,
0.0549504422,
0.0704097301,
-0.0144153684,
-0.0436562821,
0.0121649755,
-0.0174751878,
-0.0094746575,
0.0365838073,
0.0122260498,
0.0135855963,
-0.0291560832,
-0.0500857532,
-0.0685797632,
-0.0173675213,
-0.0095762257,
-0.0471812561,
-0.0311067458,
0.0016020049,
-0.0110250209,
0.0703908652,
0.039408952,
0.0188964531,
0.0274693519,
-0.0357831307,
0.047631301,
-0.0334037505,
-0.0744029284,
0.0436736718,
-0.049254518,
0.0106880842,
-0.020561995,
-0.0053053675,
0.0033056,
-0.0040592183,
-0.0183025636,
0.0607824549,
-0.0345694982,
-0.0508266762,
-0.040695224,
0.0794584081,
0.0226207301,
0.0273452085,
-0.0541145653,
-0.0385473184,
-0.0487209819,
0.0271365587,
-0.0426994488,
0.0040476643,
-0.0018745363,
-0.0091632027,
0.0105480421,
-0.0253687501,
-0.0509215035,
-0.0048174947,
-0.0002391778,
-0.0329321064,
0.0121096671,
-0.0266820807,
0.0445477478,
0.0888344571,
0.029339226,
-0.0077097039,
-0.0095457826,
0.0005187761,
-0.0103996601,
-0.0047528245,
-0.0626952648,
-0.0618849732,
0.0606875382,
-0.0017028019,
-0.0421839356,
0.0189465974,
-0.0261335298,
-0.0611741133,
0.0453696847,
-0.0108670676,
0.0321053304,
-0.0153104123,
0.0022211333,
0.0931808352,
-0.0258514695,
-0.0019647186,
0.0283398125,
-0.0016601271,
0.0304906983,
-0.0253496878,
0.0083599947,
0.0166352112,
0.0667760372,
-0.0266155023,
0.0211670082,
0.0150341773,
-0.0578515455,
-0.0070915665,
0.0455923826,
0.0177571662,
0.0585829243,
0.0316635333,
-0.0376460478,
0.0037986466,
-0.0400411375,
0.0401363745,
-0.0018897059,
-0.0659506917,
0.01940725,
0.0451861769,
-0.0236665495,
-0.0520365871,
0.0542096309,
0.0066149193,
-0.0105082439,
0.0044070436,
-0.0264215302,
-0.0382211469,
-0.0298443884,
0.0273202974,
-0.0312744528,
-0.0593189634,
-0.0590955056,
-0.0327621512,
-0.053760279,
-0.0120535744,
0.0360445231,
0.0042152349,
0.0144318799,
0.0125558088,
0.0746431127,
0.0109928511,
-0.0686282292,
-0.0181175787,
0.0034298883,
0.0098231537,
-0.0506816581,
-0.009028431,
-6.494262456e-33,
-0.0152116278,
-0.0031978379,
0.0204087757,
0.0010499026,
-0.0071779876,
-0.0305469874,
-0.0554190986,
-0.0178529732,
0.0617177784,
-0.0024350958,
0.0313883573,
-0.0023990234,
-0.0025044007,
-0.0427162647,
-0.00501457,
-0.0034376294,
0.0376043916,
0.022737287,
-0.0842747092,
-0.0171947535,
-0.0176427998,
-0.0211171303,
0.0226300862,
-0.0359737054,
0.0094183497,
-0.025115246,
-0.0105189011,
0.060496565,
-0.0270798933,
0.0309726801,
0.0332075544,
0.0042979722,
0.0005068837,
-0.0289411061,
-0.011918759,
0.0006034614,
-0.0349583961,
-0.0133510036,
0.0654083863,
-0.0100169368,
-0.0197069645,
-0.0206446089,
0.0814909637,
0.010411201,
-0.0587987453,
0.0596376024,
-0.0188304838,
0.0149545204,
0.0476610251,
-0.0234616715,
-0.066721648,
0.0266156308,
-0.0519510731,
-0.0154662421,
-0.0327371061,
0.0059061823,
-0.0117812026,
0.0097165005,
0.0335355327,
-0.001023515,
0.0656175464,
0.0198652633,
0.0852798596,
-0.0151843317,
0.0038275856,
-0.007621666,
-0.0086615393,
0.0435189083,
-0.0395952836,
-0.0018584942,
0.0146765737,
0.0144618778,
-0.0031230308,
0.0163797699,
0.0096168555,
-0.0158287939,
-0.0339186117,
0.0414423235,
-0.0384561196,
0.0483501591,
0.0081306314,
0.0012222059,
-0.0041162795,
-0.0327621698,
-0.0529228151,
0.0454485305,
-0.0443277434,
0.0043439656,
0.0282793976,
-0.0086604785,
-0.0398280583,
0.0191858951,
-0.027159391,
-0.0241120141,
-0.0101324553,
0.0117411641,
-0.048607856,
-0.0347538516,
-0.0153923389,
0.0292793065,
0.0835233778,
-0.0099922828,
0.0193422679,
-0.0527782924,
0.0658992603,
0.0162617303,
-0.0005727149,
0.0259943381,
-0.0481804311,
0.030049311,
-0.0421032272,
-0.0024701189,
-0.005229753,
0.0214978158,
0.013133605,
-0.0020781846,
0.0204540696,
0.047921475,
0.0084067332,
-0.0366251692,
-0.051387988,
0.0388988964,
0.0566974021,
0.0299403947,
-0.0055374857,
-0.0077495263,
0.0066238102,
0.0218842905,
0.0267812461,
-0.0007953727,
-0.0313333273,
0.0256389212,
3.226e-7,
0.0192395188,
0.0405345671,
0.0065208687,
0.0367976651,
-0.0226695407,
0.02639376,
-0.0254585464,
-0.0284583997,
0.0172222257,
-0.0097958455,
-0.0191605333,
0.0417869203,
0.041991584,
0.0219709296,
-0.041243948,
0.0147275608,
-0.010848904,
-0.0056017712,
-0.0735088661,
-0.0099683627,
0.0556927659,
0.0393712372,
0.0222131945,
0.0030705994,
0.0035634162,
-0.0637279525,
-0.0249761976,
-0.0263675991,
-0.0101620117,
0.0623152293,
-0.0553502999,
0.000183261,
0.0256452635,
0.0140468618,
0.0075701536,
-0.0249592364,
-0.0330076478,
0.1250246465,
-0.006293579,
0.107702896,
0.0318004079,
-0.0399902426,
0.0024721175,
-0.0603707954,
0.0391806252,
-0.0047528688,
0.0055247489,
-0.0374124609,
-0.0179560874,
-0.0475354083,
-0.0128927846,
-0.0434207059,
0.0348242335,
0.0140590817,
0.0036101597,
-0.0000525221,
-0.0306120571,
0.0077192183,
-0.0756812096,
0.0243851934,
-0.0182346646,
-0.0499487408,
-0.0169246923,
0.0436606519,
0.0088086613,
-0.0362548605,
0.0674814433,
3.538066264e-34,
0.0700887591,
-0.0186412353,
0.0286350232,
0.004766332,
0.0393707678,
-0.0005967466,
-0.0583003499,
0.037009839,
-0.0042010974,
-0.0118370857,
-0.0132861054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18049v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18049v1 | Improving Entity Recognition Using Ensembles of Deep Learning and Fine-tuned Large Language Models: A Case Study on Adverse Event Extraction from Multiple Sources | 2024-06-26T03:56:21 | 2024-06-26T03:56:21 | Yiming Li, Deepthi Viswaroopan, William He, Jianfu Li, Xu Zuo, Hua Xu, Cui Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Adverse event (AE) extraction following COVID-19 vaccines from text data is
crucial for monitoring and analyzing the safety profiles of immunizations.
Traditional deep learning models are adept at learning intricate feature
representations and dependencies in sequential data, but often require
extensive labeled data. In contrast, large language models (LLMs) excel in
understanding contextual information, but exhibit unstable performance on named
entity recognition tasks, possibly due to their broad but unspecific training.
This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of LLMs and traditional deep
learning models in AE extraction, and to assess the impact of ensembling these
models on performance. In this study, we utilized reports and posts from the
VAERS (n=621), Twitter (n=9,133), and Reddit (n=131) as our corpora. Our goal
was to extract three types of entities: "vaccine", "shot", and "ae". We
explored and fine-tuned (except GPT-4) multiple LLMs, including GPT-2, GPT-3.5,
GPT-4, and Llama-2, as well as traditional deep learning models like RNN and
BioBERT. To enhance performance, we created ensembles of the three models with
the best performance. For evaluation, we used strict and relaxed F1 scores to
evaluate the performance for each entity type, and micro-average F1 was used to
assess the overall performance. The ensemble model achieved the highest
performance in "vaccine", "shot", and "ae" with strict F1-scores of 0.878,
0.930, and 0.925, respectively, along with a micro-average score of 0.903. In
conclusion, this study demonstrates the effectiveness and robustness of
ensembling fine-tuned traditional deep learning models and LLMs, for extracting
AE-related information. This study contributes to the advancement of biomedical
natural language processing, providing valuable insights into improving AE
extraction from text data for pharmacovigilance and public health surveillance. | Improving Entity Recognition Using Ensembles of Deep Learning and Fine-tuned Large Language Models: A Case Study on Adverse Event Extraction from Multiple Sources: Adverse event (AE) extraction following COVID-19 vaccines from text data is
crucial for monitoring and analyzing the safety profiles of immunizations.
Traditional deep learning models are adept at learning intricate feature
representations and dependencies in sequential data, but often require
extensive labeled data. In contrast, large language models (LLMs) excel in
understanding contextual information, but exhibit unstable performance on named
entity recognition tasks, possibly due to their broad but unspecific training.
This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of LLMs and traditional deep
learning models in AE extraction, and to assess the impact of ensembling these
models on performance. In this study, we utilized reports and posts from the
VAERS (n=621), Twitter (n=9,133), and Reddit (n=131) as our corpora. Our goal
was to extract three types of entities: "vaccine", "shot", and "ae". We
explored and fine-tuned (except GPT-4) multiple LLMs, including GPT-2, GPT-3.5,
GPT-4, and Llama-2, as well as traditional deep learning models like RNN and
BioBERT. To enhance performance, we created ensembles of the three models with
the best performance. For evaluation, we used strict and relaxed F1 scores to
evaluate the performance for each entity type, and micro-average F1 was used to
assess the overall performance. The ensemble model achieved the highest
performance in "vaccine", "shot", and "ae" with strict F1-scores of 0.878,
0.930, and 0.925, respectively, along with a micro-average score of 0.903. In
conclusion, this study demonstrates the effectiveness and robustness of
ensembling fine-tuned traditional deep learning models and LLMs, for extracting
AE-related information. This study contributes to the advancement of biomedical
natural language processing, providing valuable insights into improving AE
extraction from text data for pharmacovigilance and public health surveillance. | [
0.0167277679,
0.0680321604,
0.0093114125,
-0.0060856845,
-0.0041493392,
0.0456447043,
-0.0029764397,
-0.0148303863,
0.0313550085,
-0.0299989823,
-0.0078206528,
-0.0557020605,
-0.0151984459,
0.0360514335,
0.0026413647,
-0.0405094363,
0.0404658616,
0.0182334632,
0.0062849023,
0.0214872882,
-0.0120341498,
0.0283359028,
-0.0179067478,
0.0396260656,
0.0449215211,
0.0140432389,
0.0069814003,
-0.0025101637,
0.073116295,
-0.0871593058,
0.0152030168,
0.0065963045,
-0.0152396299,
0.0841341242,
0.0000019216,
-0.0302725285,
-0.0346714035,
0.0112869302,
-0.0369954444,
0.0013844291,
0.011239877,
-0.0360412896,
-0.0083667617,
0.0065840641,
-0.0140267462,
-0.095518209,
0.0390742421,
0.0569481589,
0.0104905795,
0.0753082484,
-0.0097915232,
-0.0494100004,
0.0692309812,
-0.0056918818,
-0.006110793,
-0.0507327206,
0.0660257712,
-0.0435777754,
0.0141914794,
0.0150009459,
0.0405864269,
0.0394693539,
-0.0025266025,
0.0199821945,
0.0170595776,
0.0560148358,
-0.0427180827,
-0.0050240853,
-0.0041626128,
0.1070941687,
-0.0143688256,
0.0017131992,
0.0223293323,
-0.0171506107,
-0.0335399024,
-0.0323788561,
-0.0262332018,
0.0027518503,
-0.0362299308,
0.0328950882,
0.0032816348,
0.0165341813,
0.0662275255,
0.0183622148,
-0.0228040852,
0.0163613781,
0.0019061932,
-0.0343740061,
0.0189595334,
0.0078194775,
-0.0194323789,
-0.0388853848,
0.0742049813,
0.0290453602,
-0.0148834344,
0.0371672586,
-0.0085058054,
-0.0565054603,
0.0365833305,
-0.058581166,
-0.014173802,
-0.0091552949,
-0.0104998145,
0.0299370158,
-0.0452024341,
-0.0082890876,
-0.0158528909,
0.022207899,
0.0370218232,
-0.0023117794,
-0.0824910179,
-0.000465663,
-0.0064121815,
0.0660369545,
-0.0120925941,
0.0175866727,
-0.0697423071,
-0.0263069011,
0.0050365967,
-0.0015808302,
-0.0057004672,
0.0231462289,
-0.02560056,
0.0073270155,
0.0227528568,
0.0424873047,
-0.0007292277,
0.0017180071,
0.0084352223,
-0.0610412695,
0.0131442696,
-0.0451599546,
0.0340435095,
-0.0228382181,
0.0252193529,
0.0756483078,
0.0345837846,
-0.0844028294,
-0.0108562326,
0.0010522163,
-0.0361954011,
-0.0318720005,
-0.02482705,
-0.0396514237,
0.0612947755,
-0.0014037323,
-0.0099185081,
-0.0446186475,
0.0094205542,
-0.0288296062,
-0.0783779547,
0.0667634606,
-0.0461808741,
-0.0044373581,
0.0497139767,
0.0236496199,
0.0577886291,
0.0267130956,
0.0510348417,
0.0210361835,
0.0093173953,
-0.0068051405,
0.0192258861,
0.0168341529,
0.0047659269,
-0.040292047,
0.0161251072,
-0.0100865234,
-0.0187274665,
0.0384624526,
0.0008338143,
0.0407965109,
-0.0016528735,
-0.0045867153,
0.0554370657,
0.0212113652,
-0.0013109783,
-0.0206331443,
0.0062672347,
0.0053610513,
-0.0019004694,
-0.0290997587,
-0.0192810819,
-0.0148935439,
-0.0009433135,
-0.0091193775,
0.0260207597,
0.0484232381,
-0.022661997,
0.0020062537,
-0.0148029895,
-0.0043127709,
-0.0317874588,
0.0102084838,
0.0530957691,
-0.054541789,
-0.0821396634,
0.0395797715,
0.0538262799,
-0.0209191665,
0.0125668487,
-0.0257313643,
0.0020871363,
0.0746954009,
0.0196390375,
-0.0227215551,
-0.0564974546,
-0.0413444154,
-0.0181396883,
0.0040479549,
0.0152208079,
0.0127500463,
0.0506008677,
-0.0272421576,
0.0077597378,
0.0313462205,
0.0293465741,
0.0339816175,
-0.0027150149,
0.0430573002,
0.0009144843,
0.0369168036,
-0.0308790766,
0.0480974168,
-0.0084452964,
-0.069511354,
0.0074671702,
0.0174801387,
0.0500508286,
0.0324343629,
-0.0000224449,
-0.0022478132,
0.0393018201,
-0.0645588711,
-0.0385564305,
-0.0276759304,
-0.0284078158,
-0.0310110431,
0.0015903311,
-0.0080327643,
-0.0206841063,
-0.004444927,
-0.0592856966,
-0.01491661,
-0.0279846992,
-0.0013631415,
-0.0137822488,
-0.0041842475,
0.0155004784,
0.0002742353,
0.0296480246,
-0.0322110541,
0.0456970111,
-0.0059863944,
0.0017195478,
-0.023779761,
-0.050043121,
-0.0053896084,
-0.0479566418,
-0.016232634,
0.0414350368,
-0.0067769596,
-0.0247480385,
-0.0161247049,
-0.0262464508,
-0.046420563,
-0.00274742,
-0.0927349404,
0.0447818115,
0.0076666237,
0.0482608378,
0.01906606,
0.0395336561,
-0.0236956887,
-0.0069887647,
-0.001046181,
-0.060475301,
0.0046086102,
0.0229441412,
0.0435420796,
0.0332632288,
-0.0242622867,
-0.0322859362,
0.0012159116,
-0.0692731589,
0.032134831,
0.0016336435,
-0.0846498981,
-0.0228205677,
-0.0038049233,
0.007648549,
-0.0036126492,
0.0059646508,
-0.0338424966,
-0.0102855135,
0.0257197246,
-0.0014591037,
0.063664861,
-0.0074769165,
0.0522266701,
0.0050879358,
-0.0106540872,
-0.0202714596,
0.0373416208,
-0.0316837803,
0.0043731253,
0.0158217307,
-0.0268670823,
0.0050510522,
0.0762964785,
-0.0057240534,
0.033790499,
-0.025039902,
0.0099125188,
-0.0237194523,
-0.0128338635,
-0.016656464,
-0.0410419665,
-0.0387381315,
-0.0155555699,
-0.0228611957,
-0.0200606342,
0.0541160814,
0.0089528235,
0.0017277518,
-0.0423596837,
-0.0098980712,
-0.0423238538,
0.0125217112,
0.0209805109,
-0.0060760658,
0.0130989831,
-0.0519323871,
0.0337664187,
0.0130389854,
-0.0211535152,
-0.0530548804,
0.014809099,
0.0099515859,
0.0277005415,
-0.0164502393,
-0.0224276222,
-0.0469902046,
-0.0513452962,
-0.0368728116,
0.0168104451,
-0.0007699206,
0.01594254,
-0.0596233085,
0.0472853333,
-0.0036711574,
0.0304049123,
0.0030120963,
-0.0007869983,
-0.002385803,
0.0404379107,
0.0247858856,
-0.0265160222,
0.0465288572,
-0.0252237506,
0.0245938469,
0.033001326,
0.0283077788,
0.0291625988,
-0.03858402,
-0.0103260307,
-0.0171322897,
-0.0666233078,
-0.0021970724,
-0.006366367,
0.0743574649,
-0.0755029693,
0.0198513716,
0.0936444253,
-0.0002542672,
-0.0358857103,
0.0170174632,
0.0606248491,
-0.0210724827,
-0.0350195654,
0.01436006,
-0.0418851934,
-0.0369721986,
0.0189372618,
0.001234366,
-0.0318729542,
-0.0893756375,
0.028673999,
-0.0556401834,
0.0125230849,
0.001671569,
-0.0590129681,
-0.0361506566,
-0.0679071099,
0.022737734,
-0.0249433704,
0.0265898351,
-0.032326743,
-0.0196766984,
-0.0038346453,
0.0220377911,
-0.0493570678,
-0.1025485024,
0.0272806045,
-0.0530323386,
0.0187778324,
0.0556300431,
0.0238501094,
-0.0257829148,
0.0113323545,
-0.0249256063,
-0.0247283876,
-0.0474439822,
0.0107961046,
0.0839832276,
-0.0154619217,
-0.0210850984,
-0.0338026285,
0.0200013444,
-0.0480748229,
-0.0174656082,
-0.0076567498,
0.066874221,
-0.0102570439,
-0.0485804938,
-0.0239571128,
-0.0254587792,
0.016068561,
0.0707072318,
0.0208574701,
-0.017675776,
-0.0108156558,
0.0489615686,
0.0217617545,
-0.0903092548,
-0.0092531499,
0.032981433,
-0.0175773557,
-0.0760067254,
-0.038339857,
-0.0491558872,
0.0478199311,
-0.0042713801,
-0.0114875752,
0.0209796857,
0.0140272724,
0.0289190747,
-0.0256929621,
0.059516564,
0.0022010715,
-0.011495118,
-0.0349467248,
-0.0004941217,
0.0137203569,
0.0593962148,
-0.0338067263,
0.0523160249,
-0.0506555364,
-0.0514047854,
0.0180004966,
-0.027464455,
0.0132099846,
-0.0075339666,
0.0202178955,
-0.0291339122,
0.0573438294,
0.072176531,
-0.023368381,
-0.0551745631,
-0.0303800441,
-0.0290590543,
-0.0158101227,
0.0126972497,
-0.0181460306,
0.0400741845,
0.0168383941,
0.0220255386,
-0.0136341052,
-0.0194917656,
0.0045677251,
0.0172948036,
0.0356314182,
-0.0111096902,
-0.0703852773,
-0.0590263493,
0.0132790217,
0.0470301695,
0.0403389893,
-0.0018553649,
0.0001883159,
0.0303486288,
-0.021468211,
-0.0514498912,
0.0390224233,
0.0027481138,
0.0081590991,
-0.0573946014,
0.0500258282,
0.0047674198,
0.0469008386,
0.0474077202,
-0.0224231854,
-0.0185363311,
0.0288196281,
0.0345989317,
0.0092804916,
-0.0549509786,
-0.0332951583,
-0.0073830248,
0.0212741625,
-0.0056561027,
0.0394974463,
-0.053839922,
-0.0071761874,
-0.0407379717,
0.0442936383,
0.0747252405,
-0.0231001042,
0.0346142016,
-0.0075152363,
-0.0113571836,
-0.0317393281,
0.0194844808,
-0.02256562,
0.0419135317,
0.0335259922,
0.0291751381,
-0.0437423438,
-0.0147112459,
0.0589627773,
0.0219828319,
0.0833413377,
0.0506900065,
-0.0044460515,
-0.0377034806,
0.0085331937,
0.0241388995,
0.0074205068,
-0.0567948855,
0.0077864449,
-0.0255432632,
-0.0179012176,
0.0607859641,
-0.0672774017,
-0.0144241974,
0.0120942527,
0.0112805134,
0.0287192129,
0.026081996,
0.0095483353,
-0.0074828644,
0.0274397321,
-0.005774898,
-0.0381451286,
-0.0125865135,
-6.145632505e-33,
-0.0009422938,
-0.0153288413,
0.0026267353,
-0.037829306,
-0.0115873609,
0.023693094,
-0.0391699336,
-0.0271114595,
-0.0244026072,
0.0005302965,
-0.0066023306,
-0.0147416685,
0.0201316141,
0.0172182303,
-0.0007897794,
-0.0301508997,
0.0469826981,
0.0280603394,
-0.0013249849,
0.0477038436,
0.0218667556,
0.0948355719,
0.0745838508,
-0.0853582174,
0.0152570866,
0.0065600504,
0.0269816294,
-0.0268744864,
0.0411539078,
0.0855278894,
-0.0439310446,
0.025541123,
0.0428149365,
-0.0308562331,
0.0101275947,
0.0431471355,
-0.0904216319,
0.0054757395,
-0.0358906649,
-0.0032201554,
-0.0189209934,
-0.0728844181,
0.0912618637,
0.0221721549,
0.0085433591,
-0.0131067056,
0.0250608511,
-0.0143531272,
-0.018903736,
-0.0561911017,
-0.0639107153,
0.0520121269,
-0.0014673733,
0.0245872103,
0.0311236046,
-0.0182269439,
-0.0113674849,
0.1093434095,
-0.0211318526,
-0.0492019244,
0.0164752565,
0.0069256811,
0.0226652343,
0.006583666,
-0.0157047119,
0.0619897619,
0.0123902569,
-0.0154805258,
-0.0657944381,
-0.0159207806,
0.0075133294,
0.0448878407,
0.0037008785,
0.0394185334,
0.0482524186,
-0.0123866685,
-0.1378639489,
0.0245302673,
-0.0253028013,
0.0262706447,
0.0031455124,
-0.0025517256,
-0.0510274395,
0.0444863588,
-0.012860192,
0.0029930666,
-0.0203598477,
0.0051149819,
0.0096568391,
-0.0198070947,
-0.0295190234,
0.0589708425,
0.001710795,
-0.0196601637,
-0.0613378398,
0.0015250572,
0.0587404668,
-0.0023772866,
0.0019057406,
0.0228474662,
-0.0646854192,
-0.0324210078,
-0.008309667,
-0.0021840024,
0.0307631902,
-0.0108098993,
0.0503106639,
-0.0345271528,
-0.0502660088,
-0.0091465404,
-0.0029467596,
0.0407980047,
-0.042741999,
0.0842031613,
0.0347051471,
0.007172415,
0.0204709023,
0.0362235047,
0.0168477148,
0.0164925922,
0.0146289095,
-0.0317819826,
0.0086867316,
0.0359853469,
-0.0016228495,
-0.0135318413,
0.0152285853,
0.0243581552,
0.0053197327,
-0.0661865026,
0.0037666075,
-0.0225572735,
2.743e-7,
0.0862659439,
0.0547135845,
0.0213068146,
-0.0477283373,
0.0072214645,
0.0193466749,
0.005565925,
0.0199885741,
-0.0263153762,
-0.024129767,
0.0066169854,
0.0153592089,
0.0360769406,
0.0290598217,
-0.0882708579,
-0.0093045691,
-0.0784115717,
0.0259036142,
-0.0592498183,
0.0009812799,
0.0405722968,
0.0983965546,
0.002121978,
-0.036487449,
-0.0102363452,
-0.0008090671,
0.0294091422,
-0.0102010099,
-0.0033034466,
0.0566144586,
-0.0109983739,
0.0558892973,
-0.0257772133,
0.0488271751,
-0.0102852695,
0.006246828,
-0.0166490134,
0.0636480227,
-0.0309340805,
0.0062170308,
0.0036990645,
-0.0335066877,
0.0087562213,
-0.0177171901,
0.0794258192,
-0.0613482967,
-0.0453655683,
0.0083212946,
-0.0485677049,
0.0077526835,
0.0368666947,
-0.0028290981,
0.0067780395,
0.054062549,
-0.0127338264,
-0.0397386327,
-0.0383611061,
-0.0837728083,
0.0314896144,
0.0407847464,
-0.033958748,
-0.0266608875,
-0.0066543366,
-0.0127288662,
0.0281171091,
-0.0385712124,
0.0218444318,
2.461692489e-34,
0.0012039109,
0.0092457328,
-0.0199026726,
0.0351406299,
-0.0163570587,
-0.0122267054,
-0.0135913277,
0.0047290092,
-0.0349263437,
-0.0416546278,
0.0254102666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18045v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18045v2 | PharmaGPT: Domain-Specific Large Language Models for Bio-Pharmaceutical and Chemistry | 2024-06-26T03:43:09 | 2024-07-03T12:56:40 | Linqing Chen, Weilei Wang, Zilong Bai, Peng Xu, Yan Fang, Jie Fang, Wentao Wu, Lizhi Zhou, Ruiji Zhang, Yubin Xia, Chaobo Xu, Ran Hu, Licong Xu, Qijun Cai, Haoran Hua, Jing Sun, Jin Liu, Tian Qiu, Haowen Liu, Meng Hu, Xiuwen Li, Fei Gao, Yufu Wang, Lin Tie, Chaochao Wang, Jianping Lu, Cheng Sun, Yixin Wang, Shengjie Yang, Yuancheng Li, Lu Jin, Lisha Zhang, Fu Bian, Zhongkai Ye, Lidong Pei, Changyang Tu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized Natural Language Processing
(NLP) by by minimizing the need for complex feature engineering. However, the
application of LLMs in specialized domains like biopharmaceuticals and
chemistry remains largely unexplored. These fields are characterized by
intricate terminologies, specialized knowledge, and a high demand for precision
areas where general purpose LLMs often fall short. In this study, we introduce
PharmGPT, a suite of multilingual LLMs with 13 billion and 70 billion
parameters, specifically trained on a comprehensive corpus of hundreds of
billions of tokens tailored to the Bio-Pharmaceutical and Chemical sectors. Our
evaluation shows that PharmGPT matches or surpasses existing general models on
key benchmarks, such as NAPLEX, demonstrating its exceptional capability in
domain-specific tasks. This advancement establishes a new benchmark for LLMs in
the Bio-Pharmaceutical and Chemical fields, addressing the existing gap in
specialized language modeling. Furthermore, this suggests a promising path for
enhanced research and development in these specialized areas, paving the way
for more precise and effective applications of NLP in specialized domains. | PharmaGPT: Domain-Specific Large Language Models for Bio-Pharmaceutical and Chemistry: Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized Natural Language Processing
(NLP) by by minimizing the need for complex feature engineering. However, the
application of LLMs in specialized domains like biopharmaceuticals and
chemistry remains largely unexplored. These fields are characterized by
intricate terminologies, specialized knowledge, and a high demand for precision
areas where general purpose LLMs often fall short. In this study, we introduce
PharmGPT, a suite of multilingual LLMs with 13 billion and 70 billion
parameters, specifically trained on a comprehensive corpus of hundreds of
billions of tokens tailored to the Bio-Pharmaceutical and Chemical sectors. Our
evaluation shows that PharmGPT matches or surpasses existing general models on
key benchmarks, such as NAPLEX, demonstrating its exceptional capability in
domain-specific tasks. This advancement establishes a new benchmark for LLMs in
the Bio-Pharmaceutical and Chemical fields, addressing the existing gap in
specialized language modeling. Furthermore, this suggests a promising path for
enhanced research and development in these specialized areas, paving the way
for more precise and effective applications of NLP in specialized domains. | [
0.0533000454,
0.0637567416,
0.0148267969,
0.0173885655,
-0.0077602072,
0.0143560246,
0.0185505208,
0.0100845313,
0.0359651819,
-0.0522797145,
-0.0296317153,
-0.0319062658,
-0.025775969,
0.0533350259,
0.0476140082,
0.0209055021,
0.0231551155,
-0.0203388855,
0.0209808182,
-0.0010606097,
0.0080649378,
0.022892002,
0.0100679304,
0.0404991619,
0.0198046695,
-0.0263517983,
0.0570245758,
-0.0271059442,
0.0055126133,
-0.0259890836,
0.008082157,
0.0266407505,
-0.0033656,
0.0478293821,
0.0000016884,
-0.0641190559,
-0.0319934338,
0.0379781872,
-0.0166086033,
0.030242078,
0.0731461719,
-0.0297371335,
-0.0039306842,
0.0096971532,
-0.0180448554,
-0.0019514775,
0.0482781529,
0.052195549,
0.0110171027,
0.0583287328,
-0.0141464202,
-0.0499699153,
0.0323910266,
-0.0447415933,
-0.0110764001,
-0.0408037789,
0.0615242831,
-0.0279610455,
0.050107047,
0.0020748624,
-0.006022301,
0.035007637,
-0.0467858836,
-0.0024677957,
0.0057060048,
0.0230910555,
-0.0344184525,
-0.0488483906,
0.0015861008,
0.0751559511,
-0.054803919,
-0.0256157052,
-0.0144041218,
0.0045687929,
-0.0331019387,
0.0009562045,
-0.0245612189,
0.0099777579,
-0.002303557,
0.0440900922,
0.0494965017,
-0.0059053656,
0.0292244032,
0.0209870208,
-0.0211067535,
0.0516068451,
0.0166514106,
0.0074004014,
0.016788289,
-0.0222048853,
-0.0626330376,
-0.0122754648,
0.0404879339,
-0.0124537945,
-0.0146423196,
0.0248098802,
0.0233371109,
-0.0301836841,
0.082270585,
-0.0817145407,
-0.0151214795,
-0.0113600604,
-0.0183427073,
0.0687438771,
-0.0420821346,
0.0158924405,
-0.0345618427,
0.0014232191,
-0.037285842,
-0.0309645664,
-0.0588158034,
-0.0042270478,
-0.0248658638,
0.0216904655,
-0.0234490521,
-0.0339196771,
-0.0687198192,
-0.0104511939,
-0.0110798087,
-0.0112573393,
0.0184313916,
0.0488696657,
0.0099133458,
-0.0228324682,
0.0079976618,
0.0489706285,
0.0113578811,
0.0053266115,
-0.0498282462,
-0.0630422086,
-0.001360196,
0.0043739369,
-0.0051742201,
-0.0300560873,
0.0340783782,
0.1057685539,
0.017756382,
-0.0454989336,
-0.0093470532,
-0.0327548198,
-0.0164567474,
-0.0526206754,
-0.0305491369,
-0.0635127947,
0.0681107938,
0.0030693007,
0.0286685079,
-0.0616470687,
0.0111346925,
-0.0077983895,
-0.0590733476,
0.0888145566,
0.0175220277,
-0.0348806381,
0.0084258197,
-0.0104803722,
0.0075082933,
0.0143898614,
0.0076414426,
-0.0088811349,
0.0268323217,
-0.0094442442,
0.007990283,
0.0197206251,
-0.0212962534,
-0.02857605,
0.0040332489,
0.0144366091,
0.0307147205,
0.0528669395,
-0.0042771786,
0.0315591171,
0.0005448615,
-0.0289375596,
0.0482061394,
0.0813108757,
0.0341145247,
0.0224778242,
0.0218298901,
0.0027116742,
0.0021851663,
-0.0811948925,
-0.0200406816,
-0.0322995409,
-0.0087959701,
0.0207785424,
0.0321726799,
0.0376915485,
-0.0005607384,
0.000664276,
-0.0209363736,
-0.0223428067,
-0.0166852269,
-0.023247242,
0.0615910888,
-0.0392524935,
-0.0648544058,
0.0692444369,
0.0563609861,
-0.0231791995,
0.0062800543,
-0.0257623252,
0.0084199728,
0.0715224668,
0.0465174019,
-0.0504111052,
-0.0206424799,
-0.0156718977,
-0.022689553,
0.0285737775,
0.0161344949,
-0.0079892436,
0.0261641294,
-0.0267710574,
0.0186605118,
-0.0207699947,
0.0201934483,
0.0097320704,
-0.01353506,
0.0374616832,
-0.0153814787,
-0.0231407434,
-0.0212000236,
0.0206353292,
-0.0449650586,
-0.0374144316,
0.0215503331,
-0.0216422454,
0.0159647148,
0.0442698896,
-0.0108467825,
0.0316258147,
0.0433780886,
-0.0887861028,
-0.0102414927,
-0.0223650262,
0.0431223586,
-0.0126173645,
0.0338470004,
-0.0132355848,
0.0173342004,
-0.0236427058,
-0.0427653641,
-0.0223322455,
0.0235058293,
0.0041093328,
0.0482657738,
-0.0201589689,
0.0253769662,
-0.0209810473,
0.0602964014,
-0.0442674048,
0.0038090684,
0.0182445515,
0.0122153247,
0.0135497237,
-0.0262040496,
0.008501173,
-0.0155838691,
-0.0064373803,
0.0378714688,
0.0165940933,
0.0193672124,
0.0143030081,
-0.0195062496,
-0.0157932062,
-0.0056899958,
-0.0550262667,
0.0100023607,
0.0069687599,
0.0254476406,
0.0045094774,
0.0055892933,
0.0007192935,
-0.007169723,
-0.0216001868,
-0.0462935828,
-0.0180414375,
0.0100671463,
0.0074997037,
0.0158791952,
-0.0308590252,
-0.0428575054,
-0.0187558942,
-0.0224899612,
0.0675531104,
-0.0210154317,
-0.04748559,
-0.0239090491,
-0.0141334692,
-0.0099984817,
0.0230809171,
0.0085162995,
-0.0009836826,
-0.0271513201,
-0.0080890637,
0.003656263,
0.0178687442,
-0.0137777328,
-0.0017575601,
0.0491002202,
0.0273959264,
-0.0093764877,
0.0002620658,
-0.040155407,
-0.0131097278,
-0.0103146462,
-0.0106229447,
0.0038854366,
0.0782349333,
-0.0167586375,
-0.0119927032,
-0.0301328003,
0.0052825576,
-0.0286125522,
-0.0089866947,
-0.0282182489,
0.0214395914,
0.0054129749,
-0.0013375523,
0.0086500701,
-0.0473196357,
0.068661347,
-0.0479100309,
0.0224273894,
-0.0767860115,
-0.017795315,
-0.0337710865,
-0.0038730453,
0.020886723,
0.0238316152,
0.0213440545,
-0.020361172,
0.0413615778,
0.0189129617,
-0.0222966224,
-0.027853271,
0.0777961388,
-0.0386676192,
0.0418715626,
-0.0010142785,
-0.0267331433,
0.0006181483,
-0.0211820938,
-0.0410625525,
0.0339380018,
0.057312157,
-0.0361973159,
-0.027620906,
0.0482665412,
-0.0216703247,
0.0229817089,
0.0166726839,
0.0075056064,
-0.0116898082,
-0.0034551439,
0.0639591515,
-0.0282330718,
0.0462882929,
0.0062460769,
0.0618763864,
0.0544636808,
0.0156072313,
-0.0147220129,
-0.0012234937,
0.0089197932,
0.0175111014,
-0.0578568913,
-0.0224218443,
-0.015366381,
0.0177937225,
-0.0332039669,
0.0043543088,
0.1262848377,
0.0289800987,
-0.0403907597,
0.0425003543,
0.0187501833,
-0.0386038013,
-0.0036675697,
0.0402914807,
-0.0730055571,
-0.0420329757,
-0.0284925755,
-0.0199116059,
-0.0048113093,
-0.0383296795,
-0.0229694862,
-0.0652563199,
0.0339675061,
0.0228844732,
-0.0331008397,
-0.014101347,
-0.0708904043,
-0.0344868824,
-0.0594579764,
0.0381394699,
-0.0074335178,
-0.0201027784,
-0.0308175236,
0.0088239489,
-0.0408042073,
-0.0840475112,
0.0476350151,
-0.0367333069,
0.0112172514,
0.03474712,
-0.0029500297,
0.0019893977,
0.0137789492,
0.0214467198,
-0.0144316088,
0.0024809013,
-0.0069281631,
0.0315231159,
0.0129687563,
-0.0316008441,
-0.0164409075,
0.029742144,
-0.0914975628,
-0.0121208942,
-0.0553041659,
0.1015735716,
-0.0000657718,
-0.0017945973,
-0.0389244482,
-0.0205199756,
-0.0212829039,
0.0490186512,
-0.0175349507,
-0.0452001058,
-0.0643102601,
-0.0135004893,
-0.019581832,
-0.0183586162,
-0.0303251967,
0.0072918753,
-0.0410313383,
-0.0225269962,
-0.0618012547,
-0.014805112,
0.073765263,
-0.0214280989,
-0.0043321364,
0.0624526516,
0.0305073019,
-0.035710793,
-0.0285565965,
0.0630750135,
0.0240730271,
0.0355759189,
-0.0705747083,
-0.0264960434,
0.0766017511,
0.0162791144,
-0.0291610472,
0.0415863357,
-0.0774333552,
-0.0993722081,
-0.0258422308,
0.0033741663,
0.0160403997,
0.0166400466,
-0.038591627,
-0.0603182539,
0.0685464814,
0.0328080207,
-0.0166225266,
-0.0377033539,
-0.0207141079,
-0.002279385,
-0.0151822437,
0.0216133669,
-0.0289768279,
0.0163435079,
-0.0054084035,
0.0550414361,
0.0119225951,
-0.018229194,
0.0443584323,
0.0086478125,
0.045841638,
-0.0191277713,
0.0137104457,
-0.0480124168,
0.0030953309,
-0.0071653323,
0.0228172354,
-0.0208356362,
-0.0072160373,
0.0582541227,
-0.0424353108,
-0.03066843,
0.0094065312,
-0.0425191782,
-0.0016105596,
0.0052316207,
0.0129381744,
-0.021366762,
-0.0254651569,
0.0756838024,
-0.0160326827,
0.0002318453,
0.0181194637,
-0.0489425734,
0.0014219944,
-0.0549234748,
0.0358997434,
-0.0307097211,
0.0300592426,
-0.0514362529,
0.0465489626,
-0.0068813493,
-0.0647783652,
-0.0387364551,
0.0467041321,
0.0760907009,
-0.051777415,
0.074428156,
-0.0200116001,
-0.0161803793,
-0.0585641786,
0.0324077122,
-0.0097971251,
0.0309035759,
0.0336023718,
0.0293846559,
-0.0379643291,
-0.0182116199,
0.1054576337,
0.0538699999,
0.032972578,
0.0116191097,
-0.0403406471,
-0.0044668838,
-0.032507658,
-0.0011688436,
-0.0076334262,
-0.0718080401,
0.0363933407,
-0.0427227318,
-0.0520937778,
0.0118156616,
-0.0231052972,
-0.0146836555,
0.0053197038,
0.00238044,
0.0682124421,
0.0264448263,
-0.0366717242,
-0.0702323839,
0.004785121,
0.0222895946,
-0.0467727855,
0.0008445014,
-5.658909885e-33,
0.0580079779,
-0.0062807784,
-0.0003662176,
-0.0228711963,
0.0230313204,
0.0101466132,
-0.0166470427,
-0.0092562484,
0.0050703399,
0.0469155163,
0.0074856197,
-0.0146041866,
-0.00302443,
0.0136989886,
0.0180845372,
0.0120427841,
0.0248025171,
0.0338709019,
0.0311363675,
0.0075409408,
0.0410988778,
0.0615555793,
0.0693324953,
-0.02535519,
0.0185165554,
0.0188142117,
0.0330930836,
-0.0070906687,
-0.0156798773,
0.0678974614,
-0.069851853,
0.0755791217,
0.0176097024,
-0.0577572361,
-0.0160360578,
-0.0199283939,
-0.0438903309,
0.0155843953,
0.0231538862,
-0.0069873775,
0.0065649012,
-0.030584285,
0.0518063195,
0.0031774912,
-0.0166761521,
0.0165724494,
0.0233676229,
-0.0289774071,
-0.0064027705,
-0.0307022855,
-0.0804363117,
0.0353000872,
0.0085789924,
0.0219371524,
0.0350347906,
0.0132671809,
-0.0220961664,
0.0766152069,
-0.0248834733,
0.0064688236,
0.0065307701,
0.0410146266,
0.0615042523,
-0.0091140494,
0.0000137273,
0.0533089675,
-0.0071695526,
0.0272803232,
0.0296964534,
0.006423743,
-0.0184455495,
0.057162676,
0.0130063556,
0.0193269644,
0.0381592289,
-0.0001300349,
-0.0874309838,
0.0060609397,
-0.0434818529,
0.0383544005,
0.0096327253,
0.0188388601,
0.0131035848,
-0.0122426804,
-0.0187558159,
0.0626569539,
-0.0323601514,
-0.0045266002,
0.0027963738,
-0.012929,
-0.0159507375,
0.0275374558,
0.0115825012,
-0.0565639287,
-0.0510573797,
0.0006954117,
0.0176391471,
0.0193409529,
-0.0069677504,
0.0430670157,
-0.0797549039,
-0.0284975879,
-0.0241498351,
-0.057280954,
-0.0081874495,
-0.0276835505,
0.0127117662,
-0.0170679316,
-0.0421967767,
0.0077064415,
-0.0428768881,
-0.0142448628,
0.0192264859,
0.0652018115,
0.0188566949,
0.0373275392,
0.0155948661,
0.0761190206,
0.0330483019,
-0.0252658296,
0.0184144974,
0.0154222874,
0.0431045257,
0.0194482356,
-0.0513381958,
0.0080965012,
-0.0368157253,
0.0215095524,
0.0294461958,
-0.0544201359,
-0.0204210021,
-0.0315249227,
2.494e-7,
0.083843939,
0.0450035743,
0.0078931302,
-0.007840991,
0.0252021272,
0.0280044712,
-0.0160249975,
0.0539807342,
-0.0527849756,
-0.002988823,
0.0007894273,
-0.0260438025,
0.0228709504,
0.0025078717,
-0.0678271726,
0.0142511623,
-0.0525441207,
-0.0339663774,
-0.0871812552,
-0.019615652,
0.0157886855,
0.1341020167,
-0.0111749433,
-0.0213881712,
0.0215875767,
-0.05032745,
0.056712348,
-0.0456736088,
-0.0287042446,
0.0671277866,
0.0086272471,
-0.0040346631,
0.0047602612,
0.0182364527,
-0.0210462864,
0.009641883,
0.0151530551,
0.0826358274,
-0.0552659929,
-0.0114290528,
0.0394033268,
-0.0465563461,
0.0116024008,
-0.040639475,
0.0213774648,
-0.0212714467,
-0.0497337878,
-0.0672870278,
0.0069799111,
0.0065555866,
0.0624057613,
-0.0404809788,
0.0175234638,
0.0380557179,
0.0143054752,
0.0009002985,
-0.0167638678,
-0.0750649199,
-0.0199472699,
0.0350898653,
-0.042787455,
0.0078226188,
-0.0113416323,
-0.0123068513,
0.040072754,
-0.0459185205,
0.0210119411,
2.196560886e-34,
0.062388096,
-0.0202588402,
0.0244281106,
0.0418811813,
0.0544824675,
-0.0147057278,
-0.0210987274,
0.0245484058,
-0.0315809324,
-0.1108609512,
0.0005864941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18034v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18034v1 | LLMs for Doctors: Leveraging Medical LLMs to Assist Doctors, Not Replace Them | 2024-06-26T03:08:24 | 2024-06-26T03:08:24 | Wenya Xie, Qingying Xiao, Yu Zheng, Xidong Wang, Junying Chen, Ke Ji, Anningzhe Gao, Xiang Wan, Feng Jiang, Benyou Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The recent success of Large Language Models (LLMs) has had a significant
impact on the healthcare field, providing patients with medical advice,
diagnostic information, and more. However, due to a lack of professional
medical knowledge, patients are easily misled by generated erroneous
information from LLMs, which may result in serious medical problems. To address
this issue, we focus on tuning the LLMs to be medical assistants who
collaborate with more experienced doctors. We first conduct a two-stage survey
by inspiration-feedback to gain a broad understanding of the real needs of
doctors for medical assistants. Based on this, we construct a Chinese medical
dataset called DoctorFLAN to support the entire workflow of doctors, which
includes 92K Q\&A samples from 22 tasks and 27 specialists. Moreover, we
evaluate LLMs in doctor-oriented scenarios by constructing the
DoctorFLAN-\textit{test} containing 550 single-turn Q\&A and DotaBench
containing 74 multi-turn conversations. The evaluation results indicate that
being a medical assistant still poses challenges for existing open-source
models, but DoctorFLAN can help them significantly. It demonstrates that the
doctor-oriented dataset and benchmarks we construct can complement existing
patient-oriented work and better promote medical LLMs research. | LLMs for Doctors: Leveraging Medical LLMs to Assist Doctors, Not Replace Them: The recent success of Large Language Models (LLMs) has had a significant
impact on the healthcare field, providing patients with medical advice,
diagnostic information, and more. However, due to a lack of professional
medical knowledge, patients are easily misled by generated erroneous
information from LLMs, which may result in serious medical problems. To address
this issue, we focus on tuning the LLMs to be medical assistants who
collaborate with more experienced doctors. We first conduct a two-stage survey
by inspiration-feedback to gain a broad understanding of the real needs of
doctors for medical assistants. Based on this, we construct a Chinese medical
dataset called DoctorFLAN to support the entire workflow of doctors, which
includes 92K Q\&A samples from 22 tasks and 27 specialists. Moreover, we
evaluate LLMs in doctor-oriented scenarios by constructing the
DoctorFLAN-\textit{test} containing 550 single-turn Q\&A and DotaBench
containing 74 multi-turn conversations. The evaluation results indicate that
being a medical assistant still poses challenges for existing open-source
models, but DoctorFLAN can help them significantly. It demonstrates that the
doctor-oriented dataset and benchmarks we construct can complement existing
patient-oriented work and better promote medical LLMs research. | [
0.0764166489,
0.0348533057,
-0.014561424,
-0.0036556849,
-0.0175022949,
0.0013680938,
0.0027785318,
0.0332120582,
0.0046411804,
-0.0032452438,
-0.0254424997,
-0.0400383659,
0.0033915513,
0.0166074149,
0.0363069177,
-0.0605636425,
0.0184955169,
0.0073048109,
0.0340454429,
-0.0083721383,
0.0150448876,
0.0139170308,
-0.0523268543,
0.0651104972,
0.0362131484,
-0.0154415676,
0.0166312456,
-0.0017986866,
0.0274242032,
-0.0327280611,
0.0018316923,
0.0296324119,
-0.0090803616,
0.0011635042,
0.0000021077,
-0.0417138413,
0.0195560362,
0.0103661083,
-0.0660271943,
-0.03405945,
0.0175295062,
-0.0276273601,
-0.0077259066,
0.0371164866,
-0.039674826,
-0.0239432771,
0.0075262175,
0.040091332,
0.057156872,
0.0715801567,
-0.0047824476,
0.0362756625,
0.0017085067,
-0.0246590823,
0.0334928297,
-0.0637372956,
0.0183314886,
0.0102587892,
0.0516390279,
-0.0096413381,
0.0285557564,
0.0233078729,
-0.0214122832,
-0.0108238272,
-0.0084766354,
0.0440654643,
-0.0099856136,
-0.0028834261,
-0.010418077,
0.0726929307,
0.015439501,
-0.0006595133,
0.0106900977,
0.0067168502,
0.0084731989,
-0.0060934178,
-0.053057272,
0.0131687857,
-0.0186731443,
-0.02027441,
-0.0025893294,
-0.0131207099,
0.0350125283,
0.0059636757,
0.0111838924,
-0.0186587125,
-0.0059588496,
-0.0232192371,
-0.0135436272,
-0.0182038397,
0.0280397162,
-0.0398632437,
0.0473564342,
0.0516623668,
-0.0844675004,
0.0174062867,
-0.0119544221,
-0.0160696618,
0.0800097883,
-0.0293684937,
0.0414712168,
0.0235084016,
-0.0058355494,
0.0396827832,
0.0130453398,
-0.0072324988,
-0.0198685452,
0.0296126511,
-0.0446090959,
-0.0195138324,
-0.052466929,
0.0021578956,
-0.0194220506,
0.0084789721,
0.005666934,
0.0129095744,
-0.0579666235,
-0.0061485516,
-0.0137720173,
0.0525842868,
0.0298407339,
0.0413716361,
-0.03736002,
-0.0035920218,
-0.0193843897,
0.0226630028,
0.004435949,
0.040040005,
0.0073686466,
-0.0491235144,
0.0177476779,
0.0044882945,
0.0035645256,
0.0173940957,
0.0017417643,
0.0540334173,
0.0019000525,
0.0029608537,
0.0025571533,
-0.0469988137,
0.0007809942,
-0.0079678418,
0.0130810197,
-0.0608962476,
0.030745659,
0.0106133912,
0.0135978451,
-0.0299940165,
0.0277764723,
0.0344958864,
-0.0399784967,
0.0531324632,
-0.0512754656,
0.0523302369,
0.0381476693,
0.0630877763,
0.0006556032,
0.0306102987,
0.0281461347,
-0.0381723866,
0.03132727,
-0.0151131721,
0.0403568968,
0.0279537421,
0.0081431894,
-0.0032655308,
0.0297873598,
0.0326993279,
-0.0075302268,
0.0800736621,
-0.0289188512,
0.0518180765,
-0.0144049693,
0.0058286488,
0.0334452875,
0.0527064428,
0.0135049541,
-0.0071864715,
-0.0000195499,
-0.026519997,
0.0033143573,
-0.0361887813,
-0.0134430174,
0.0132437041,
-0.0081391856,
-0.0210935697,
-0.0367255025,
-0.0086709335,
-0.0618598759,
-0.0401751883,
-0.0501381196,
-0.024019653,
-0.0588341318,
0.0029114077,
0.0216454435,
-0.0205489956,
-0.0141949272,
0.0836039409,
0.0257526338,
-0.0799262971,
-0.033086028,
-0.0631944165,
-0.0147060221,
0.0984209329,
0.0660306737,
-0.0533739701,
-0.0475180186,
-0.0215385277,
0.0166929532,
0.0277168583,
0.0642613769,
-0.0259238575,
-0.0000964573,
-0.0544879995,
-0.0089722434,
0.0341092274,
0.0045019616,
-0.0307350289,
-0.004706176,
0.0445650741,
-0.0116692921,
-0.0409877487,
-0.0502924025,
0.0251687746,
-0.0947713181,
-0.0077038542,
0.0158929769,
0.0003327166,
0.0305782445,
0.0553052202,
-0.0060196514,
0.0437339917,
0.0260801874,
-0.0302072838,
-0.0072723865,
0.0393323377,
-0.0333777852,
-0.0046911207,
0.0232658759,
-0.0370799452,
-0.0067592473,
-0.0004187068,
-0.0299014375,
-0.0439816266,
-0.0419984087,
-0.0575024933,
0.0403067023,
0.0052854689,
0.0274120197,
0.0469184965,
-0.0041874489,
0.0057580369,
-0.0147257354,
-0.033722952,
0.0080977343,
0.0133562647,
0.0186744649,
0.0040914542,
-0.0556159504,
-0.0051435465,
0.0097607113,
0.0110437199,
0.0323665254,
-0.0222258233,
0.0271722265,
-0.0352626964,
-0.0475250632,
-0.1230032295,
-0.0304199774,
-0.0016146749,
-0.0049172295,
0.0379596278,
0.0311103296,
-0.0051438883,
-0.0224948619,
-0.0739469603,
0.0237631369,
0.0312887877,
-0.0044619231,
0.0248072241,
0.0244783107,
0.0127436165,
-0.0415204801,
0.0129271848,
-0.0364156924,
-0.0346296728,
0.0107115591,
-0.0219988097,
-0.0328946039,
-0.0143227242,
-0.0420607999,
-0.0098762326,
-0.0342893712,
-0.0470678285,
0.0174610075,
-0.0105444891,
0.0068549858,
0.0148339821,
-0.0065742275,
-0.0067915954,
0.0423794799,
-0.0041424832,
-0.0174991339,
0.0107073532,
0.0163369291,
-0.045030117,
0.0081331292,
-0.069232814,
-0.0128294416,
0.0546701662,
0.0126668308,
0.0236966498,
-0.0090099275,
-0.0114904977,
-0.0187212303,
0.0275367703,
-0.0167135969,
0.0341026112,
-0.0341242403,
0.0535349883,
0.0041002296,
-0.0197970588,
0.0715936348,
-0.0127559453,
0.0149734067,
-0.0655428618,
-0.0491034538,
-0.0546989143,
0.0114555005,
-0.0571460612,
0.0092024961,
-0.0018743338,
-0.0214577839,
-0.0052859187,
0.0375259332,
-0.0360161886,
-0.0816567615,
0.0594394654,
-0.0360821486,
0.0045260135,
-0.0203189291,
-0.0312804766,
-0.0567494929,
-0.0141984383,
-0.0611874759,
0.0179338548,
0.0160102583,
-0.0002674717,
-0.0624945536,
-0.0014602947,
0.0029419521,
0.0856752992,
0.0520663001,
-0.0081687402,
-0.0056051719,
-0.0063633523,
0.0265338831,
0.0254777875,
-0.0130229173,
-0.0167740993,
0.0577223115,
0.0731582344,
0.046254389,
-0.0052446262,
0.0263668839,
-0.0466783531,
0.0277336016,
-0.0201250426,
-0.0132731451,
0.0287773926,
0.0444096178,
-0.052922599,
-0.0148986485,
0.1106747314,
0.0216558054,
-0.0793101639,
0.0300103184,
-0.0512533076,
-0.0414825641,
0.0063773589,
0.0100817541,
-0.1006983519,
-0.027366003,
-0.0252382327,
0.0446111932,
0.004929001,
-0.0096663637,
0.0306525026,
-0.0814812705,
0.0505570769,
0.003959517,
-0.0250394437,
-0.0268464535,
-0.0267961174,
0.0144487424,
0.0090726065,
0.0279773567,
-0.0096491147,
-0.0099781891,
-0.0267823283,
-0.0019799918,
-0.0485643037,
-0.058950901,
0.058390554,
-0.0107378531,
0.059880197,
0.076308392,
0.0379002579,
-0.0124018472,
-0.0577204376,
-0.0360315405,
0.0215803981,
0.0163665358,
0.0092513189,
0.0733918548,
0.0046366043,
0.0039264476,
-0.0134105086,
0.0404140018,
-0.0910484418,
0.0051643657,
0.0631754026,
0.0568873696,
-0.0367255621,
-0.020193344,
-0.0442706533,
0.0516888388,
0.0488550849,
0.052654516,
0.0013129571,
-0.0112137077,
-0.0098302057,
0.0062644854,
0.0390969142,
0.0126442648,
-0.0189966038,
0.0283382908,
-0.0126000959,
0.0007236854,
-0.0712913796,
-0.0377941765,
0.0450056978,
-0.011898078,
0.0192106068,
0.0312430002,
0.0179569181,
0.0143756308,
-0.0320004746,
0.0025896588,
0.00118905,
0.052299004,
-0.0786261335,
-0.0602341779,
0.0591196045,
0.0071328757,
0.0272201654,
-0.0072760684,
-0.0279313419,
-0.0303815305,
-0.0092651779,
0.0555248484,
0.0211208817,
0.0059006969,
-0.0197159853,
-0.03772166,
-0.0032700964,
0.0383548476,
-0.0574430302,
-0.0057553309,
0.0124256415,
0.0286767464,
0.0006926642,
0.0195874758,
-0.0352801383,
-0.0119256778,
0.010187326,
0.0267092045,
-0.0533158742,
-0.0738963038,
0.0060666525,
0.0497751608,
0.0204402152,
0.0064983116,
0.0159806963,
-0.0218859855,
0.0511514135,
-0.0450602584,
0.0009141243,
-0.0437647812,
0.0015927262,
-0.010554784,
-0.055558458,
0.0395839624,
0.0134095447,
-0.0824395418,
-0.0485863015,
-0.0677738786,
0.0391097143,
-0.0001691999,
-0.0076928148,
0.0304602254,
-0.0248158891,
-0.0057742656,
-0.0027887686,
0.0154191516,
0.0157838371,
0.0286283605,
0.0878581554,
-0.0163049474,
0.0139779644,
0.0096732182,
0.0467827469,
-0.0408348739,
-0.106341064,
-0.0029390561,
0.0614493564,
0.054852888,
0.0106342109,
0.0353042483,
-0.0440764129,
0.0320786163,
-0.0285511091,
0.0261438601,
-0.0379095636,
0.0133605842,
0.0677028149,
0.0119306948,
0.0134481164,
-0.0120304199,
0.1151314601,
-0.0367123336,
0.051554475,
0.0038892755,
-0.0229642317,
-0.0547059551,
-0.02427819,
0.0545672961,
0.0269738249,
-0.0632098168,
0.0115776975,
-0.0607560612,
-0.051455345,
-0.0105532687,
-0.0188687295,
-0.0268455055,
-0.0355762243,
0.0490253828,
0.0421775356,
0.0135217328,
0.0038889074,
-0.037025068,
0.0510671884,
-0.0379551984,
0.0019541446,
0.0316462703,
-5.945213657e-33,
0.0114410389,
-0.0413684025,
0.0411998816,
-0.0149561372,
0.0189690329,
0.0278678667,
-0.0327018127,
0.0158672854,
-0.0342442282,
0.0220233276,
-0.0513167493,
0.0232047066,
0.0129354633,
0.0301903673,
0.0207555182,
-0.012463497,
0.033741504,
0.0149688609,
-0.0000087301,
0.046988856,
-0.0120521327,
0.0314946771,
0.0317717083,
-0.0921682939,
0.0139847538,
-0.0289775282,
0.0218591485,
0.0261011645,
-0.0464487001,
0.0564671867,
-0.0083406959,
0.0498864353,
0.0464035384,
0.0152982688,
-0.0158436224,
0.0029859152,
-0.0340729244,
-0.0153008541,
0.0132708987,
-0.0066341977,
-0.0577764176,
-0.0189026389,
0.0155613702,
-0.0194830317,
-0.0062109563,
-0.0003327789,
0.0276460126,
-0.0413164161,
-0.0178080089,
0.0060310406,
-0.0053548184,
0.0269434042,
-0.0039211055,
-0.0345959365,
-0.0500401929,
-0.0077448706,
-0.0336565599,
-0.0040696426,
-0.0508581586,
0.0121591548,
0.0347165912,
0.0258824471,
0.0214940589,
-0.0343494155,
-0.0197285842,
0.0239361767,
0.0177583657,
0.0139936479,
-0.0434639119,
0.0102094077,
-0.0654944479,
0.0628412068,
0.0420072041,
0.0372231789,
-0.0055739866,
-0.0335079879,
-0.0580110997,
0.0392053314,
-0.015058266,
0.0679908544,
0.0002631136,
0.0114991609,
-0.0607640073,
-0.0050637769,
-0.0067757326,
0.0028289971,
-0.0194634851,
-0.025284186,
0.0215450712,
0.005879364,
0.0139254574,
-0.0168502219,
-0.0236807559,
-0.0163808577,
0.0319178067,
-0.0245300978,
0.0218176171,
0.0003471643,
-0.0418360308,
-0.0174811278,
-0.1086352244,
-0.0038166957,
-0.0103065856,
0.0036055113,
0.0374836065,
0.0504550673,
0.0124913007,
-0.0283984933,
-0.0434470475,
-0.0055000451,
0.005051008,
-0.0066888784,
0.0024271605,
0.0062775919,
0.0320422091,
-0.0148641756,
-0.0102439811,
0.0687406287,
-0.0047488734,
-0.0248301011,
-0.0634227321,
-0.0698725581,
-0.0042611477,
-0.0155406296,
-0.083901614,
0.0125752157,
-0.0494654924,
0.0527174622,
0.0644052252,
-0.0143906428,
-0.0072329873,
-0.0301136337,
2.863e-7,
0.0485923924,
0.0323781148,
0.0099794772,
0.0148678925,
0.0303370282,
0.0137369521,
-0.0188322794,
0.022864813,
-0.0117841633,
0.0033095775,
0.0302400198,
-0.0126740159,
0.0564955063,
0.0409160256,
-0.078242287,
-0.0268615447,
-0.0902081132,
-0.0122215888,
-0.0092764264,
-0.0419278368,
0.029362319,
0.0611629561,
-0.0317819342,
-0.0341462232,
-0.0035634195,
-0.0120960902,
0.042565614,
-0.0400753021,
-0.0019522618,
0.0639704615,
0.0826055706,
-0.0028739802,
0.0153369699,
0.032792829,
-0.0335329846,
-0.0164211858,
0.018640317,
0.1219064742,
-0.0712663829,
0.0118308533,
0.0349319726,
-0.0075093023,
0.0178498719,
-0.0409677178,
0.0235241596,
-0.0191875845,
-0.0557402968,
0.0037679092,
0.0050900448,
-0.0281865783,
0.0528959371,
-0.0190916676,
-0.0309046991,
0.0311582536,
0.0124896253,
0.0258491058,
-0.0467517525,
-0.0463942289,
-0.020109728,
-0.0002086685,
-0.0238048583,
-0.058260601,
0.0479175486,
-0.0411975868,
-0.0470971726,
-0.064846307,
0.0080445716,
2.025830204e-34,
0.0023483755,
0.0242131799,
0.0037393447,
0.0663161352,
0.0146375652,
-0.0118015604,
0.0355164781,
0.0392734408,
0.0384304933,
-0.0182089061,
-0.0374385752
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18027v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18027v1 | Automated Clinical Data Extraction with Knowledge Conditioned LLMs | 2024-06-26T02:49:28 | 2024-06-26T02:49:28 | Diya Li, Asim Kadav, Aijing Gao, Rui Li, Richard Bourgon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The extraction of lung lesion information from clinical and medical imaging
reports is crucial for research on and clinical care of lung-related diseases.
Large language models (LLMs) can be effective at interpreting unstructured text
in reports, but they often hallucinate due to a lack of domain-specific
knowledge, leading to reduced accuracy and posing challenges for use in
clinical settings. To address this, we propose a novel framework that aligns
generated internal knowledge with external knowledge through in-context
learning (ICL). Our framework employs a retriever to identify relevant units of
internal or external knowledge and a grader to evaluate the truthfulness and
helpfulness of the retrieved internal-knowledge rules, to align and update the
knowledge bases. Our knowledge-conditioned approach also improves the accuracy
and reliability of LLM outputs by addressing the extraction task in two stages:
(i) lung lesion finding detection and primary structured field parsing,
followed by (ii) further parsing of lesion description text into additional
structured fields. Experiments with expert-curated test datasets demonstrate
that this ICL approach can increase the F1 score for key fields (lesion size,
margin and solidity) by an average of 12.9% over existing ICL methods. | Automated Clinical Data Extraction with Knowledge Conditioned LLMs: The extraction of lung lesion information from clinical and medical imaging
reports is crucial for research on and clinical care of lung-related diseases.
Large language models (LLMs) can be effective at interpreting unstructured text
in reports, but they often hallucinate due to a lack of domain-specific
knowledge, leading to reduced accuracy and posing challenges for use in
clinical settings. To address this, we propose a novel framework that aligns
generated internal knowledge with external knowledge through in-context
learning (ICL). Our framework employs a retriever to identify relevant units of
internal or external knowledge and a grader to evaluate the truthfulness and
helpfulness of the retrieved internal-knowledge rules, to align and update the
knowledge bases. Our knowledge-conditioned approach also improves the accuracy
and reliability of LLM outputs by addressing the extraction task in two stages:
(i) lung lesion finding detection and primary structured field parsing,
followed by (ii) further parsing of lesion description text into additional
structured fields. Experiments with expert-curated test datasets demonstrate
that this ICL approach can increase the F1 score for key fields (lesion size,
margin and solidity) by an average of 12.9% over existing ICL methods. | [
0.0225942433,
0.0497610867,
0.0245044399,
0.0310858339,
-0.0132240411,
0.0142612057,
-0.0454547592,
0.0660628825,
0.0002679226,
-0.021308979,
-0.0120373927,
-0.0165618695,
0.0027075452,
0.0370211005,
-0.0169721618,
-0.032580696,
0.0128476489,
0.0112122903,
0.0638020188,
0.0390217751,
-0.0096191615,
-0.0024553959,
0.0070632035,
0.0001520275,
0.0082673412,
-0.0110361483,
0.0185359139,
-0.0288747717,
0.0459575951,
-0.0504755005,
0.0181865729,
-0.0077613615,
-0.0097674858,
0.0026081016,
0.000002175,
-0.0527849533,
-0.0601332784,
0.042678453,
-0.0252267253,
-0.0425550602,
0.041991286,
-0.084171854,
-0.0080913808,
-0.0327307954,
-0.052232895,
-0.0004368245,
0.0120873768,
0.0750220865,
0.0589730367,
0.0663659573,
-0.0339351632,
0.0133487079,
0.0209433883,
0.0142169986,
0.0034147678,
-0.0344353579,
0.0541060865,
0.0465556011,
-0.0076565864,
-0.0232721884,
0.0389356539,
0.0626331121,
-0.0202626362,
0.0038468374,
0.0206887908,
0.0579183586,
-0.0125274798,
0.0031455962,
0.0035112146,
0.0416784436,
-0.0410111323,
0.010635769,
0.0199135132,
-0.0433964618,
-0.0136826541,
0.0098770233,
-0.0302004423,
0.0004835888,
-0.054593645,
-0.0029121616,
0.0283129122,
-0.0016802684,
0.0121077113,
-0.0184568577,
-0.0377559625,
0.0138259595,
-0.0364013389,
-0.0220753159,
0.0368959829,
0.0184743237,
-0.0065074572,
-0.0472383052,
0.0393149033,
0.0520040914,
-0.0029115095,
0.0283557307,
-0.0083245663,
-0.0319252051,
0.0855147317,
-0.0629082173,
-0.0152710564,
-0.0348567888,
-0.0406007841,
0.0606338866,
-0.0321199186,
-0.02679733,
-0.025562603,
0.0449119508,
-0.0207464322,
0.0304241087,
-0.0190967843,
-0.0317294933,
-0.0010466392,
0.0397776738,
-0.0158799998,
0.0254814941,
-0.0474308021,
-0.0059527135,
-0.0266462117,
0.0584503151,
0.0444404855,
-0.0141300531,
-0.0509449467,
0.0255071241,
-0.0232165735,
0.0252419263,
0.0243541691,
0.0021843405,
-0.0171357486,
-0.0050676079,
0.0150034949,
0.0184008796,
0.0327089205,
0.0005036718,
0.0142982258,
0.0442368947,
0.010944508,
0.0031528678,
-0.0389206596,
-0.075724043,
-0.0065483418,
-0.0130172595,
0.0072118118,
-0.0731810778,
0.0104536256,
0.0072767311,
0.0040802117,
-0.055991739,
0.0060271439,
-0.0088333935,
-0.0167314447,
0.0495213307,
-0.0807990879,
-0.0232477318,
0.0102300122,
0.0202254951,
0.0024740603,
0.0123607917,
-0.0011484621,
-0.044049453,
-0.0040051052,
0.0102224397,
0.0306211952,
0.028124705,
0.0184652675,
-0.0648218021,
-0.0387274362,
0.030396454,
0.0137222512,
0.0195138305,
0.0133956587,
0.0377591029,
0.0099522462,
0.013037133,
0.0202520229,
0.0509308763,
0.0524344705,
-0.0166632328,
-0.0035854024,
-0.0030845909,
0.0086178519,
-0.012040657,
0.0221438389,
-0.0099887531,
0.0180473235,
0.0357423536,
-0.0385291614,
0.0101945447,
0.0163867008,
-0.0668150857,
-0.0300905984,
0.0010828458,
-0.022014806,
0.0252619535,
0.0764745101,
-0.0074569006,
-0.0276266579,
0.0192323793,
0.0582145452,
0.0030882256,
-0.0347215347,
-0.0437183939,
-0.0105958926,
0.085684754,
0.0535514094,
-0.0705417544,
-0.0452701226,
-0.0325494409,
-0.0370033272,
0.0009147461,
-0.0219043586,
-0.0286417324,
0.0258481205,
-0.0144770062,
-0.0112319477,
0.0312342402,
0.0109198997,
-0.0399475358,
0.0071401526,
-0.0044276607,
-0.0404548608,
-0.0439727642,
-0.0379884429,
0.0692504272,
-0.0692289323,
-0.0177876502,
-0.0307678692,
0.012790422,
0.0083550755,
0.0066087409,
-0.0261300169,
-0.0118384184,
0.0398816057,
-0.0211311169,
-0.0487968028,
0.0188980307,
-0.0613733493,
-0.0434089825,
0.0354295224,
0.0054939389,
-0.0364223197,
-0.0834738314,
-0.0201783367,
0.0314419828,
-0.0583027937,
0.0033929592,
0.0678154305,
-0.0089248959,
0.014097291,
0.0490903966,
-0.0248810481,
-0.0590896904,
0.064691633,
-0.0149750924,
-0.0257059634,
0.0049036457,
-0.077846922,
0.0120838135,
-0.0110429591,
-0.0132732093,
0.0200299174,
-0.0008287239,
0.0159963835,
-0.0105626527,
0.0138319703,
-0.0278219264,
-0.0311150607,
-0.0756595284,
0.0008286308,
0.0100469226,
-0.0073519833,
0.0254532099,
0.0227354188,
-0.0085405828,
-0.0368658192,
-0.0432973877,
-0.0509704351,
0.0288767982,
-0.0294796601,
0.0748125538,
0.0650317743,
-0.0227388423,
-0.0445858017,
0.0234830528,
-0.0462201647,
-0.0009370383,
0.0536310449,
-0.0618761294,
-0.0198371336,
0.1011869609,
-0.0266116001,
0.0399237871,
-0.0257585086,
0.0196223091,
0.0007957304,
-0.0559059493,
-0.0463105403,
0.0831077397,
-0.0218458306,
0.0417788588,
0.0371884257,
-0.0161866099,
-0.0574992485,
0.0164600592,
-0.0163337104,
-0.0132279461,
-0.0288365334,
-0.0261985641,
0.031730637,
0.0629625618,
0.008510083,
0.005998156,
-0.0031502156,
0.0096855201,
-0.019913638,
0.0111170448,
-0.0513465405,
-0.0078801997,
-0.0089912461,
0.0506481603,
-0.0170820467,
-0.0289387479,
0.0934240669,
-0.0180010535,
0.0379485488,
-0.0659360811,
-0.0012179686,
-0.0353076793,
0.032734938,
-0.0136631113,
0.0127986614,
0.023306448,
-0.017793268,
0.0180853624,
0.0106069669,
0.0326875187,
-0.0850237459,
0.0662030205,
-0.0316764228,
0.0532136448,
0.0255890526,
-0.0283265151,
-0.0613189153,
0.0091902297,
0.0087081445,
-0.0012888616,
-0.0246293508,
0.0162132476,
-0.0309326407,
0.0286591053,
0.0207422692,
0.0604283288,
0.0396121182,
-0.024913514,
-0.0031049701,
0.0197942667,
0.0246982966,
-0.0257441401,
-0.0408528708,
-0.02302159,
0.0200674552,
0.0850498602,
-0.0382650718,
0.0252397489,
0.0124167483,
0.0029730443,
-0.0146700582,
-0.0249252375,
0.017460173,
0.0138254594,
0.0480585434,
-0.083060354,
-0.0312044173,
0.0993877426,
0.0324798599,
-0.0403491519,
-0.0041860612,
-0.0115045728,
-0.0778540745,
-0.0110993944,
0.0353079028,
-0.0327317156,
0.0148295164,
0.0175765045,
0.0148747936,
-0.0230728164,
-0.0500461198,
0.0375856385,
-0.0594202206,
0.0512029231,
-0.0015626283,
-0.0548811741,
-0.0635730773,
-0.0617523901,
0.0015320993,
-0.0066930172,
-0.0291066505,
-0.0006100956,
-0.0148541499,
-0.0207142178,
0.0013606694,
-0.0412870273,
-0.0867006928,
0.0187102482,
-0.0397851691,
-0.0014000009,
0.0617659874,
0.0171797965,
-0.0351239629,
-0.0349482596,
0.0037042743,
0.055354964,
-0.0084329369,
-0.0052907462,
0.0730771124,
0.0004745358,
-0.0072417366,
-0.0351473205,
0.0178502388,
-0.0061556087,
-0.0104834335,
0.0103018666,
0.0752373934,
-0.0391263962,
-0.0058865044,
-0.0191920046,
0.0018934993,
0.0313568674,
0.0527111962,
-0.0075420761,
0.0091786673,
0.0056069978,
-0.0335788019,
0.0507364087,
0.007986322,
-0.0172517113,
0.0733435974,
-0.0568496585,
-0.0144806579,
-0.0638552606,
-0.0199606288,
0.0636565909,
-0.0044038193,
0.0385554433,
0.0436530598,
0.0057983925,
-0.0113921138,
-0.1001529843,
0.036845766,
0.0220137239,
0.0011095938,
-0.0178062189,
-0.0335161388,
0.0329403579,
0.0016738027,
-0.0191431697,
0.030339634,
-0.0109241148,
0.0115466891,
0.0049515101,
0.0185172185,
0.0181895886,
0.0448562019,
-0.0040330505,
0.0290694013,
0.0736767873,
0.0258807335,
-0.0819035172,
-0.0310353525,
-0.0102033708,
-0.0276767183,
0.0135170333,
-0.010741693,
-0.0251898654,
0.0230966583,
0.0185361691,
0.0358235613,
-0.0449018702,
-0.0017337115,
0.0572383255,
0.0592527986,
0.0232084077,
0.0170884337,
-0.0278300345,
-0.0449820235,
0.0133862831,
-0.0213503744,
-0.0140866563,
-0.0266781133,
0.0250351131,
0.0089867096,
0.0027784309,
-0.0103333211,
0.0397936888,
-0.0240039639,
-0.0102052633,
-0.0318130367,
0.0529280193,
0.0370404832,
0.0044147759,
0.0768625811,
-0.0185294021,
-0.0098729953,
-0.0356218889,
0.039106857,
0.0442982428,
-0.001084843,
0.0301051401,
0.0200058036,
0.0429337993,
-0.0389318317,
0.0112787914,
-0.0107402094,
0.0395488888,
-0.0640403703,
-0.0162408575,
0.001828387,
-0.0159685928,
0.0321141705,
-0.0472935736,
0.0073706266,
-0.0119852992,
0.0280326102,
-0.0217284206,
-0.0030962212,
0.0527009107,
0.020537708,
-0.0085738432,
-0.0598717779,
0.0638158247,
-0.0260364898,
0.04877498,
-0.0687474087,
-0.0542699434,
-0.0755207762,
0.0082829949,
0.0326319262,
0.005622949,
-0.0558305159,
0.0021976053,
-0.049260661,
-0.0401020795,
0.0341249667,
0.0090274867,
-0.0401219502,
-0.0093027661,
0.0037345644,
0.0778468773,
0.0256007295,
-0.0575319268,
-0.0280748624,
0.0412344374,
0.0052543078,
-0.025482187,
0.0124939969,
-6.066216841e-33,
-0.0177664105,
-0.0560604706,
0.0477007292,
0.0071517583,
0.0131699201,
0.0433705673,
-0.0290718414,
-0.0395320728,
0.0149017451,
0.0219620802,
-0.0303835999,
-0.0235439371,
0.016369639,
-0.0017331017,
0.0255263075,
-0.0119239548,
0.0262336489,
0.0054201563,
-0.0086072758,
-0.0346633494,
0.0051799077,
0.07072898,
0.0698442757,
-0.1182882488,
0.0158710256,
0.0420494415,
0.0177220758,
0.0089122271,
0.0116958302,
0.0502031669,
-0.039557334,
-0.0031324243,
0.0436553359,
-0.0318194665,
-0.0066981991,
-0.020309126,
-0.1149700284,
0.0041609011,
-0.0048162299,
0.0110887671,
-0.0158960875,
-0.010439638,
0.059654586,
-0.023711348,
0.0460925773,
-0.0176901538,
0.0484550372,
-0.041894801,
0.0038574135,
-0.0533932969,
-0.0548453704,
0.0758248642,
0.0154998973,
0.0320877247,
0.018976612,
-0.0400328115,
-0.0059685586,
0.0425951853,
-0.0203414503,
-0.0123907095,
0.0442539155,
0.0461411327,
0.0033290517,
0.0121906754,
-0.0150231831,
0.0871463045,
0.023691982,
-0.0173831265,
-0.0269044004,
-0.004491922,
-0.002226172,
0.0483284518,
-0.0344973058,
0.0121077606,
0.020485146,
-0.0025932258,
-0.0931464136,
0.0581110492,
-0.0489929691,
0.0292887539,
-0.0124399103,
-0.0244497601,
-0.0544007793,
0.0086519867,
0.0073097693,
-0.0050115725,
0.0012656482,
-0.008018082,
0.0162243489,
0.0278364625,
0.0049171033,
0.0277120005,
-0.0128319338,
0.0076662125,
0.0067250505,
-0.0453484766,
0.0543233715,
0.0136442678,
-0.0604082383,
-0.0191284604,
-0.0336451419,
-0.0259876009,
-0.0161776915,
0.0076638493,
0.0543641374,
0.00741272,
0.0636891723,
-0.0174116921,
-0.0757220536,
0.0092186611,
-0.0107712848,
0.0161755141,
0.0007243024,
0.0407169312,
0.0403457209,
0.031065058,
-0.0230410937,
0.0348667242,
0.0039746715,
-0.0099505382,
-0.0305968579,
-0.0146377617,
-0.0037092285,
-0.0106645888,
-0.0432331376,
-0.0370529778,
0.0022994252,
-0.0123478882,
0.0636032149,
-0.0343679525,
0.0163114872,
0.0073324069,
2.906e-7,
0.1124250814,
0.0457593054,
0.0353050791,
-0.0190527905,
0.0160462707,
-0.0049836366,
-0.0363474749,
-0.0306777097,
0.0010556636,
-0.0012669575,
0.0339021236,
-0.0039127255,
0.0006975412,
0.0619222149,
-0.088620849,
-0.0303605366,
-0.0120637584,
-0.0638985112,
-0.0028840778,
-0.0132024847,
0.0390669927,
0.0412706286,
-0.0404958352,
-0.0303074177,
0.0075552086,
-0.0388538502,
0.0114976503,
-0.0390422642,
0.0218345206,
0.0326948352,
0.0270593818,
-0.0127810044,
0.0247254297,
0.0680279657,
-0.0066062259,
0.017829638,
0.002330693,
0.1095741168,
-0.0228422247,
0.0177593101,
-0.0034593875,
-0.0119920922,
0.0332661197,
-0.0230970271,
0.0213017333,
-0.0425831564,
-0.0249415599,
-0.0154917641,
-0.0162750576,
-0.019966213,
-0.0050092442,
-0.0252589546,
-0.0171883181,
0.065323025,
0.0058378088,
0.0324113667,
-0.0343262665,
-0.0643806458,
-0.0321075544,
0.0252255984,
-0.0036224241,
-0.0288286377,
0.0682998225,
-0.0260247551,
-0.0199671257,
-0.0584218018,
0.0370240547,
2.932582669e-34,
0.0228755362,
0.0173556246,
-0.0335112736,
0.0448010974,
0.0191350542,
-0.0046852366,
0.0022551317,
0.0366326049,
-0.0296791103,
-0.0356180854,
0.0112595893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01599v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01599v1 | JailbreakZoo: Survey, Landscapes, and Horizons in Jailbreaking Large Language and Vision-Language Models | 2024-06-26T02:20:23 | 2024-06-26T02:20:23 | Haibo Jin, Leyang Hu, Xinuo Li, Peiyan Zhang, Chonghan Chen, Jun Zhuang, Haohan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CV, cs.LG | The rapid evolution of artificial intelligence (AI) through developments in
Large Language Models (LLMs) and Vision-Language Models (VLMs) has brought
significant advancements across various technological domains. While these
models enhance capabilities in natural language processing and visual
interactive tasks, their growing adoption raises critical concerns regarding
security and ethical alignment. This survey provides an extensive review of the
emerging field of jailbreaking--deliberately circumventing the ethical and
operational boundaries of LLMs and VLMs--and the consequent development of
defense mechanisms. Our study categorizes jailbreaks into seven distinct types
and elaborates on defense strategies that address these vulnerabilities.
Through this comprehensive examination, we identify research gaps and propose
directions for future studies to enhance the security frameworks of LLMs and
VLMs. Our findings underscore the necessity for a unified perspective that
integrates both jailbreak strategies and defensive solutions to foster a
robust, secure, and reliable environment for the next generation of language
models. More details can be found on our website:
\url{https://chonghan-chen.com/llm-jailbreak-zoo-survey/}. | JailbreakZoo: Survey, Landscapes, and Horizons in Jailbreaking Large Language and Vision-Language Models: The rapid evolution of artificial intelligence (AI) through developments in
Large Language Models (LLMs) and Vision-Language Models (VLMs) has brought
significant advancements across various technological domains. While these
models enhance capabilities in natural language processing and visual
interactive tasks, their growing adoption raises critical concerns regarding
security and ethical alignment. This survey provides an extensive review of the
emerging field of jailbreaking--deliberately circumventing the ethical and
operational boundaries of LLMs and VLMs--and the consequent development of
defense mechanisms. Our study categorizes jailbreaks into seven distinct types
and elaborates on defense strategies that address these vulnerabilities.
Through this comprehensive examination, we identify research gaps and propose
directions for future studies to enhance the security frameworks of LLMs and
VLMs. Our findings underscore the necessity for a unified perspective that
integrates both jailbreak strategies and defensive solutions to foster a
robust, secure, and reliable environment for the next generation of language
models. More details can be found on our website:
\url{https://chonghan-chen.com/llm-jailbreak-zoo-survey/}. | [
0.0698621422,
0.078648977,
-0.0055694249,
0.0488077924,
-0.0809420198,
-0.0188770182,
0.0305150189,
-0.0020183546,
0.0740283355,
-0.0371022336,
-0.0234739929,
-0.003870446,
0.0116106812,
0.0406741388,
0.029882513,
0.0076726526,
0.0523399226,
-0.0362896584,
-0.015668299,
0.0028455204,
0.0142310709,
-0.0078733573,
0.0557678007,
0.0072194324,
-0.0052653095,
-0.014048188,
-0.0289014839,
0.0146877393,
0.0064293798,
-0.0213122945,
-0.0163655113,
0.0122164674,
0.0030801145,
0.0801119655,
0.0000023205,
-0.0435899906,
-0.0519994348,
0.04224528,
0.0094321882,
0.0356620029,
0.019474471,
-0.095088847,
-0.021063108,
-0.0175648052,
-0.052269496,
0.0188254882,
0.0446519926,
0.055016771,
0.0785369948,
0.0377043448,
-0.0041346396,
-0.0252892543,
0.0583946221,
0.0050092745,
-0.0199231505,
-0.0630326122,
0.0193949789,
-0.0197651871,
0.0003103226,
0.0166486874,
-0.0013923276,
0.0133566409,
0.0353509858,
-0.0247587115,
-0.0509560592,
-0.0151769826,
-0.0415756404,
-0.0562589541,
-0.0051853247,
0.0283594504,
-0.0407408215,
-0.0245035198,
0.0103792381,
0.0311450977,
0.0177453831,
0.0199557468,
0.0067658266,
0.0625897273,
-0.0067010159,
-0.0185305309,
0.0494309142,
-0.0201475285,
0.044227384,
0.012837342,
0.0023612368,
0.0009841217,
0.0146592101,
-0.0384371281,
-0.0090086386,
-0.0447801128,
-0.0069677075,
-0.0569421165,
0.0182295181,
-0.0018588399,
0.0265138578,
0.0052309735,
-0.09240973,
-0.0256277397,
0.0147539489,
-0.0574272051,
-0.0022321525,
0.0134009542,
-0.0146687534,
0.0175672527,
0.0157540552,
0.0099316314,
-0.0423879735,
0.0239046197,
0.0111832088,
-0.0107452255,
-0.0064783082,
-0.0475328192,
-0.0000359722,
0.0667138249,
-0.0407428406,
-0.0063029914,
-0.0103420103,
0.0243165325,
-0.0462892801,
0.0292365383,
-0.0596559346,
0.0188458953,
0.0271499027,
0.01140022,
0.0410353877,
-0.0392018184,
0.0037747249,
-0.0272282287,
-0.0147177186,
-0.0642106012,
-0.0058761071,
-0.0018751579,
-0.0951455459,
-0.0033379043,
-0.0113988221,
0.125031203,
0.043387372,
-0.0089395642,
-0.08182735,
-0.0920694247,
-0.0345970131,
-0.0426036008,
0.0191018246,
-0.075708203,
-0.0246129036,
-0.0379214026,
-0.0032718491,
-0.0481105782,
0.0209302418,
-0.0037745631,
-0.0583458804,
0.0390489325,
-0.0190935973,
-0.0160213746,
0.002812322,
0.0524011962,
0.0678068697,
0.0384374112,
0.0019962322,
0.0510342419,
0.071314089,
-0.0094599677,
0.0614498071,
0.0291973613,
-0.0298800822,
0.0082336105,
-0.0471945032,
-0.0010519086,
0.0447792672,
-0.0125235468,
-0.0565499924,
0.0477840491,
0.0034026331,
-0.0419208929,
0.0963315815,
0.1058846414,
-0.0465030186,
0.0276456941,
-0.0139706237,
-0.0468206555,
0.0442313813,
-0.0145117249,
-0.0476513132,
0.0071634548,
-0.0626756623,
-0.0393394902,
-0.0855514407,
0.0577564351,
0.0063029639,
-0.011443655,
0.0120819611,
-0.0413779505,
-0.0127771739,
0.0272053238,
0.0126163829,
0.0135338269,
0.040264152,
0.0104424991,
0.0065337582,
-0.0428550318,
-0.0354818776,
-0.0932925344,
-0.0032414969,
0.0803096145,
0.0429561995,
0.0210563075,
0.004897601,
0.0070887776,
-0.0143842818,
0.0042298087,
-0.0156897344,
0.0173592232,
0.0151745658,
-0.0012859516,
0.0075017214,
-0.0333015993,
0.0161097348,
0.0099263191,
-0.0271645412,
-0.0071699196,
-0.0111993114,
-0.0228281934,
-0.0355921052,
0.0032694044,
0.0252657253,
0.0242037084,
0.0105629293,
0.0220370796,
-0.0122449892,
0.023355484,
-0.0558384135,
0.0262191761,
0.0750222579,
-0.0066928389,
0.0684677139,
-0.0034341221,
-0.0140011674,
0.0215023216,
0.0276116375,
-0.0631549656,
0.0304747913,
0.0896018371,
-0.0279370993,
0.0024137604,
0.0457386263,
-0.0395474993,
0.0218152292,
-0.0195030458,
0.0281431489,
-0.0351553112,
0.0161748268,
-0.0422740541,
-0.0036548735,
-0.0342317224,
-0.0327318087,
-0.021975683,
0.0176363848,
0.0345467031,
0.0182321742,
-0.0462727509,
0.0467437878,
-0.0239847004,
0.0141443741,
0.0061599491,
0.0205622241,
-0.0050143823,
-0.0407425873,
-0.0233796947,
-0.0182617903,
-0.0123255746,
0.0101329871,
0.025304364,
0.0138965454,
-0.0272232946,
-0.0258102175,
0.0052163573,
-0.0204863138,
0.0068757967,
-0.0000634995,
-0.0096932817,
-0.0216230247,
-0.05075147,
0.0144359171,
-0.0218195803,
0.0078164376,
0.030132547,
-0.0256648213,
-0.0359483622,
-0.0106607853,
-0.0198507309,
-0.0223873127,
0.0184306353,
-0.0087749055,
-0.0071414285,
0.0277909432,
0.0093645863,
-0.0383997709,
0.0718492791,
0.0087224003,
0.0691370741,
0.0565689802,
0.0021644717,
-0.0007335056,
-0.0535054281,
0.0771679133,
-0.0429907404,
-0.0409244336,
-0.0442831218,
0.0181417093,
0.0105706388,
0.0196915492,
-0.0009755462,
-0.0159593131,
0.0590246506,
-0.0041110474,
-0.0511592776,
0.026324993,
-0.0482233912,
-0.0370238423,
-0.0103849825,
-0.0258382969,
-0.0873170346,
0.0562043898,
-0.0587708838,
0.0230813101,
0.0050217672,
-0.0649505854,
-0.0271047074,
0.0602176636,
0.0125891762,
0.0457116216,
0.0542802364,
-0.0246097315,
-0.0277032126,
-0.0015573623,
-0.0047616963,
-0.0274291039,
0.0412797444,
-0.0604092441,
-0.0243853964,
-0.0160399806,
-0.0332250968,
-0.025879534,
-0.0392866582,
-0.0089674219,
-0.0086414889,
0.0352545381,
-0.0371753462,
0.0214507002,
-0.0301765595,
0.0430276394,
-0.0209523588,
0.0016964636,
-0.0030820579,
-0.0367028303,
0.0252352878,
0.0044201491,
-0.0589243472,
-0.0074228477,
0.0312342271,
0.0369080119,
0.0922902077,
0.0499881916,
0.032650549,
0.0265528318,
0.0596053936,
0.0360883661,
0.0281891301,
-0.0239977222,
0.0064491793,
0.0158046596,
-0.0222784169,
-0.0154888397,
0.0317485221,
0.0198495165,
-0.0176889673,
0.0304817893,
0.0131992074,
-0.0052762409,
0.0177946966,
0.0276709944,
-0.0738637671,
0.0010652078,
0.0112085938,
0.0704801679,
-0.0494519807,
-0.02278159,
-0.0409948416,
-0.0731552318,
-0.0044095474,
0.0448555984,
0.0046513951,
-0.0196322054,
-0.0291211773,
-0.0462399572,
0.0238818731,
0.0027114295,
-0.031393908,
-0.0096482038,
0.0011661425,
0.0187937487,
-0.0465130061,
0.0276727602,
0.0177801978,
-0.0182464365,
0.0422555394,
0.0913966298,
-0.0058460608,
-0.0435853377,
0.0274659153,
0.0132448785,
0.0218205284,
0.0092977611,
0.0057074642,
-0.0179810245,
-0.0057291798,
-0.0159690809,
-0.0048570996,
0.0484729074,
0.0238717087,
-0.0527887605,
0.0374089479,
0.0411937311,
-0.021182077,
-0.0276165418,
-0.0290606301,
-0.047192242,
-0.0092172362,
0.0280221626,
0.0018594145,
-0.0363982059,
-0.0672904179,
-0.0538393371,
-0.0402458198,
-0.0584179759,
-0.0176775288,
0.0185660012,
0.0307124425,
-0.0315751284,
-0.0215290133,
0.0028125329,
-0.0291185621,
0.0346010737,
0.0579993017,
-0.0119942175,
0.0047482643,
-0.0028420913,
-0.0302960817,
-0.0220951866,
0.0023363479,
0.0453025103,
-0.0213877242,
0.0353965089,
-0.0085181976,
-0.0205961186,
0.0051651336,
0.0171290133,
-0.025999194,
-0.0546134599,
0.0416466855,
0.0669005513,
0.0191732645,
-0.0245355181,
-0.0334704071,
-0.0442845821,
0.0394281074,
0.0918294713,
-0.0412357114,
0.0361655392,
0.0625011548,
-0.0251962114,
0.0128588201,
0.0133232968,
0.0007912036,
-0.0273375995,
0.0827575028,
-0.0005923709,
-0.058768332,
0.0119749987,
0.0147587359,
0.0509181209,
-0.0293706395,
-0.0129783507,
0.0438306034,
0.0439813435,
0.0230308138,
-0.0067583355,
-0.0336982012,
-0.0275326576,
0.0080649843,
0.049921006,
0.0024842818,
0.0313670896,
0.0411073267,
0.0325298421,
-0.0451073572,
0.0147526283,
0.030636372,
0.0301627796,
0.0520126,
0.0415348001,
0.0390441343,
-0.0336132683,
0.0653791949,
-0.0417633988,
0.0392101891,
-0.0218504965,
0.0594511442,
-0.0039884318,
-0.0148482639,
-0.0378174558,
0.079940781,
-0.0782578737,
-0.0477646142,
0.0100802304,
0.1137196422,
-0.0142414672,
0.0266687237,
-0.0282380488,
-0.016859306,
0.0079101464,
-0.043464534,
-0.0348282792,
0.0021577559,
-0.0563358888,
-0.0110052712,
0.0064246305,
-0.0203765333,
0.0243912265,
0.0478101447,
0.0397013314,
0.0498300306,
0.0137780868,
-0.0095093995,
-0.017743187,
-0.001835975,
0.0674258396,
-0.0108945053,
-0.0400017649,
-0.0394192487,
-0.0752403364,
-0.0771218166,
-0.0096623013,
0.0115700355,
0.0356933661,
-0.0028772259,
-0.0430594534,
0.0538196675,
0.0368365906,
0.0112687517,
-0.0634869635,
0.0119190048,
-0.0090451585,
-0.0544304587,
0.0362846367,
-5.615267454e-33,
0.0404971279,
-0.0339400135,
-0.0667208806,
-0.0250565633,
-0.0074421465,
0.0007042529,
0.0049607926,
0.004731731,
-0.0318867266,
-0.0441887416,
-0.0230971035,
-0.0096206069,
-0.0101067666,
0.0133234421,
-0.0369441062,
-0.0215887278,
-0.0255189706,
0.019574469,
-0.0014644908,
0.0110112149,
0.03802168,
0.0212083757,
0.011847374,
-0.0366354287,
0.0663529932,
-0.0251551084,
-0.0244086124,
0.0363264941,
-0.0531381592,
0.0527448803,
0.014436054,
0.0060874834,
0.0109853139,
-0.0142334066,
-0.0114622647,
0.0891413763,
0.0081940368,
0.0233085621,
0.0102504557,
0.0123659,
-0.0010088575,
-0.0367895924,
0.0096855722,
-0.0068958295,
0.0024854373,
-0.0016022443,
-0.0270059109,
-0.0368220508,
-0.0175567195,
0.0115896212,
-0.0000576561,
-0.0208585896,
-0.0455783978,
0.01632379,
0.0212864485,
-0.0442961045,
-0.0123511665,
-0.0012021422,
-0.008933844,
0.05045316,
0.0414116159,
-0.0253963061,
0.057243973,
0.0004543072,
-0.0013567489,
0.0518258736,
0.0088528385,
-0.0500706583,
-0.0026460662,
-0.0259334724,
-0.011319506,
0.0836079046,
0.0587347709,
0.0712533146,
0.0162589457,
-0.0132317208,
-0.0415466614,
-0.0368986204,
0.0016504374,
0.0318564437,
0.0305738356,
-0.0067903879,
-0.0319392234,
0.0044418885,
-0.0154554313,
-0.0309276078,
-0.0375060551,
-0.010345432,
0.0239449125,
0.0049268622,
-0.0406130962,
-0.0069495211,
0.0099909082,
-0.0927559137,
0.0112237697,
0.0106896898,
0.0139897503,
-0.0034702185,
-0.0146065066,
0.0351470858,
-0.0137662115,
0.0024008558,
0.0134316776,
-0.031728439,
0.0437899344,
-0.018550938,
0.029936092,
0.0186560992,
-0.0308979992,
0.0004700374,
0.0017598988,
0.0417567715,
0.0286416858,
-0.0000393663,
0.0141192125,
-0.0290139448,
-0.0025923613,
-0.0262964144,
0.0320388451,
0.0152128944,
-0.0500423871,
0.0285111591,
-0.0458385795,
0.0295181312,
0.022447234,
0.0183970109,
-0.0063776583,
0.0353211574,
0.0497109853,
-0.0349565856,
-0.0007234908,
0.0143954745,
3.133e-7,
-0.0423265435,
-0.0331620239,
0.0101030627,
-0.0493264571,
0.0180396345,
0.0755407885,
0.002652742,
0.0773704723,
-0.033388447,
-0.0288408007,
-0.0387165509,
-0.0116433501,
0.0689482242,
-0.0079965899,
-0.0061212122,
0.0469171144,
-0.0337713324,
-0.0277011208,
-0.0680200681,
0.0198938083,
0.0288303569,
0.0526443273,
-0.0092510711,
-0.0440995581,
-0.0010224548,
-0.0820604414,
-0.0174423307,
0.0060093501,
-0.0102095073,
-0.0325374305,
-0.0066986987,
0.0604028143,
0.0032310858,
-0.0012793372,
-0.016524842,
-0.023356868,
-0.0398043618,
0.0296257213,
-0.0072153299,
-0.0048721964,
-0.0574367978,
-0.0391827673,
-0.0320773125,
-0.0478357002,
0.0686268732,
0.0322059244,
-0.0375057384,
-0.0136899576,
0.0408507697,
-0.0399248488,
0.0023463154,
-0.0341549516,
0.0226382222,
0.0041432665,
0.0315243974,
0.025927119,
0.0214032643,
-0.0766609162,
0.0064508864,
0.0121829249,
0.0140185198,
-0.0301221721,
-0.0048648915,
0.0563892536,
0.0557434633,
-0.0130756469,
-0.0043644239,
2.963256643e-34,
-0.0278221276,
-0.0609511957,
0.0178880338,
0.0342987292,
0.018834075,
0.0177970398,
-0.0160909463,
0.0156163611,
-0.0009677608,
-0.0256516635,
-0.0065287696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18002v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18002v1 | Decoding with Limited Teacher Supervision Requires Understanding When to Trust the Teacher | 2024-06-26T01:16:12 | 2024-06-26T01:16:12 | Hyunjong Ok, Jegwang Ryu, Jaeho Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | How can sLLMs efficiently utilize the supervision of LLMs to improve their
generative quality? This question has been well studied in scenarios where
there is no restriction on the number of LLM supervisions one can use, giving
birth to many decoding algorithms that utilize supervision without further
training. However, it is still unclear what is an effective strategy under the
limited supervision scenario, where we assume that no more than a few tokens
can be generated by LLMs. To this end, we develop an algorithm to effectively
aggregate the sLLM and LLM predictions on initial tokens so that the generated
tokens can more accurately condition the subsequent token generation by sLLM
only. Critically, we find that it is essential to adaptively overtrust or
disregard the LLM prediction based on the confidence of the sLLM. Through our
experiments on a wide range of models and datasets, we demonstrate that our
method provides a consistent improvement over conventional decoding strategies. | Decoding with Limited Teacher Supervision Requires Understanding When to Trust the Teacher: How can sLLMs efficiently utilize the supervision of LLMs to improve their
generative quality? This question has been well studied in scenarios where
there is no restriction on the number of LLM supervisions one can use, giving
birth to many decoding algorithms that utilize supervision without further
training. However, it is still unclear what is an effective strategy under the
limited supervision scenario, where we assume that no more than a few tokens
can be generated by LLMs. To this end, we develop an algorithm to effectively
aggregate the sLLM and LLM predictions on initial tokens so that the generated
tokens can more accurately condition the subsequent token generation by sLLM
only. Critically, we find that it is essential to adaptively overtrust or
disregard the LLM prediction based on the confidence of the sLLM. Through our
experiments on a wide range of models and datasets, we demonstrate that our
method provides a consistent improvement over conventional decoding strategies. | [
-0.0070892451,
0.0758449063,
0.0219942015,
0.0297140777,
0.007445985,
0.0087307338,
0.0200376939,
-0.0103850653,
-0.041102279,
-0.0085482122,
-0.0036673564,
0.0045237723,
0.0042673051,
-0.0328044891,
0.0361328274,
-0.005507193,
0.0122816181,
-0.0636858493,
-0.0008140132,
-0.0200005379,
-0.0377829857,
0.0179063305,
-0.0145087214,
0.0289139096,
-0.0347037986,
-0.0034426122,
-0.0133494884,
0.0505507626,
0.0270577427,
-0.0146667548,
-0.0138773657,
0.0505408123,
0.0310886148,
0.024912443,
0.0000018635,
-0.0111424262,
-0.0342618451,
-0.0161737744,
-0.0406052917,
0.0076551507,
0.0092518823,
-0.0383105874,
-0.0362799391,
0.013376018,
-0.0338633098,
0.0086129401,
0.0334650837,
0.0071738269,
0.038995076,
0.0764878839,
0.0144290756,
-0.0248736218,
0.0217234287,
0.0292200483,
0.022285521,
-0.0454889387,
0.0239116047,
0.0060184165,
-0.0566064529,
-0.0287432857,
-0.0412347391,
0.0469147451,
0.033137694,
-0.0236241221,
0.0160304531,
0.0198945142,
0.0041483659,
-0.030834334,
-0.0413202047,
0.0087058162,
0.013914315,
-0.0565815978,
0.0058533149,
0.0030656138,
0.0244460516,
-0.0193821471,
-0.0434987918,
0.0643825457,
-0.0343101583,
0.0737520903,
0.0336285718,
0.0246924553,
0.0226427075,
-0.0167724155,
-0.0255245492,
0.0559152178,
0.0218005963,
-0.0303254053,
-0.0130095789,
0.0625705943,
0.0181420781,
-0.0104232263,
0.0004616867,
0.0250591543,
-0.0355437733,
0.0343359932,
-0.0676131621,
-0.0358442403,
-0.0021260271,
0.0617880523,
0.0073878206,
0.0216524582,
-0.0227930415,
0.0021879633,
-0.0155876642,
0.0214444529,
0.015133976,
0.0572637059,
-0.038181752,
-0.0077064936,
-0.02255385,
-0.0096337376,
-0.0215419792,
0.0387972631,
-0.0267424341,
0.0329010822,
-0.0565072559,
0.0107510686,
0.0213389099,
0.0248980131,
0.0071958276,
-0.0121493386,
-0.0502966046,
-0.0021537109,
0.0205814783,
0.018795846,
0.0088928528,
0.0398417935,
0.0184082892,
-0.0785918981,
-0.0241461862,
0.0249600131,
0.0128456689,
0.0113152536,
-0.0426646993,
0.0596797094,
-0.0317498781,
-0.0059387204,
-0.0934546068,
-0.0653233752,
-0.0178431459,
-0.0363300703,
0.016496053,
-0.0826330036,
0.0152513068,
-0.0204854235,
0.0169817694,
-0.0325729623,
-0.0181474965,
-0.027577322,
0.0375372395,
0.0287741777,
-0.0479635037,
0.0061002998,
-0.011220688,
0.0119079622,
-0.0085322559,
0.0874292254,
0.0015580991,
0.0531372391,
0.021964049,
0.0080378912,
0.0219547059,
0.0607975274,
0.0547227748,
0.0357547924,
0.0111621208,
-0.0344565772,
0.0088640377,
-0.0077230176,
0.0608566962,
0.0503502116,
-0.071424298,
-0.0024780619,
0.0725022554,
0.0720148981,
0.0290665831,
0.007943538,
0.0343969427,
0.0128673445,
0.012567332,
0.0626185462,
-0.0221789461,
0.0000152936,
-0.0226054583,
0.0123511218,
0.0239269435,
0.0313456655,
-0.016017735,
-0.0725349262,
-0.0091348849,
-0.045298662,
-0.0288340934,
-0.0000845235,
0.0601440035,
0.022061564,
-0.0439630002,
0.0613714345,
0.0241968073,
-0.0661711395,
0.0167555921,
-0.0801725537,
0.0257841945,
0.0593485609,
0.0451391004,
0.0163519476,
-0.0271247476,
-0.0106413122,
0.039449133,
0.0464733429,
-0.0216566734,
-0.0061198641,
0.0496998057,
-0.0550064929,
-0.0560022928,
0.0592428111,
0.0233723726,
0.0330989882,
0.0216330178,
-0.0058392617,
-0.0007189691,
-0.035182301,
-0.0297583397,
0.0560128018,
-0.0063988464,
-0.0435939059,
0.0070141093,
0.010099696,
0.0408444852,
0.0465350784,
0.0039855503,
0.014748442,
0.0493927486,
-0.0407264605,
-0.0358034186,
-0.0247686841,
-0.0706774145,
-0.0686608776,
0.0273656808,
-0.0562874377,
-0.0308300145,
0.001873867,
-0.0221091863,
-0.0516275167,
-0.0037271881,
-0.0572372489,
0.0629566908,
-0.0554015338,
0.0127197793,
0.0247636251,
-0.0160875097,
-0.0264872871,
0.0252139363,
-0.033122234,
-0.0261666495,
0.0284797698,
0.0133071095,
-0.0041876542,
-0.0703773797,
0.0290284045,
-0.000899661,
-0.0492534637,
0.0365190618,
-0.0067767203,
0.0475833416,
-0.0501839556,
-0.0674663484,
-0.0308268573,
-0.0509814546,
-0.0526305884,
0.0235142577,
-0.000498666,
-0.0476508439,
-0.0178037751,
-0.0103282183,
-0.0464134626,
-0.0383249708,
-0.0169047769,
-0.0301933419,
-0.0041678506,
-0.0224583335,
-0.0401837528,
-0.0194779057,
-0.0111291893,
0.0077860397,
0.0270364042,
0.0104966098,
-0.0311716348,
-0.0716351345,
0.0291678868,
-0.0184476189,
-0.0165277924,
0.0069907201,
-0.0241384897,
0.0461300798,
-0.0423737504,
0.0138731804,
0.0206089951,
-0.0232447069,
0.0065750219,
0.0238319784,
-0.0175067596,
-0.0835939646,
-0.0147167901,
0.0036324295,
-0.0549247563,
-0.060829442,
-0.0240795556,
0.0227665361,
0.0395788997,
0.0509981476,
-0.0009344296,
-0.0587831847,
-0.0098798061,
0.0029930067,
-0.0858339593,
0.0118402671,
0.0011129939,
-0.0122123193,
0.0402142294,
0.0081444699,
-0.0868213102,
0.0483437702,
-0.0422301441,
-0.0188158937,
-0.0149163334,
-0.0113441264,
-0.0315494351,
0.0084308162,
-0.057380259,
0.0184296966,
-0.0237092394,
-0.0675998926,
-0.0201453138,
0.0105397711,
0.0071161608,
-0.0388353057,
0.024215525,
-0.0544486567,
0.0102520119,
-0.024629565,
-0.0145164691,
-0.0494019315,
0.0126683433,
-0.0139785325,
-0.0063317241,
0.0060179569,
-0.0322223566,
-0.0260077473,
-0.0386995748,
-0.0294775069,
-0.0075797006,
-0.0200751871,
0.0035694933,
-0.0319677293,
-0.0017640588,
0.0069343783,
-0.0008694656,
0.003510738,
-0.0696863607,
0.0366373174,
0.0622605458,
0.0611479096,
0.0282292385,
-0.0244483966,
0.0177857969,
0.0618923455,
0.0199089926,
0.0465613678,
0.0579041131,
0.0466753058,
-0.0205972642,
0.0136878183,
0.1252538711,
0.0163909644,
-0.0360304005,
-0.0181983691,
-0.0151453279,
0.0420545563,
-0.0087214997,
-0.0222409926,
-0.0742485896,
-0.0300380532,
0.0149600627,
0.071193926,
-0.0001828582,
-0.0094826249,
-0.0193130951,
-0.0603436157,
0.0542697497,
0.0669595972,
-0.0529392771,
-0.0157498047,
-0.0399900936,
-0.0687310398,
-0.0121298507,
0.0614588484,
0.0257422123,
-0.0057864604,
0.0069078645,
0.0517930537,
-0.0160850529,
-0.0384293161,
-0.0464638844,
-0.0325237587,
0.0736461654,
0.0602204576,
-0.0060784509,
0.0097046513,
-0.0502864532,
0.019497199,
0.0019977754,
-0.0307658724,
-0.027172735,
0.019654708,
-0.0334925391,
0.0085831983,
-0.0088101486,
0.0885502622,
-0.0509853177,
0.010349323,
0.016672628,
0.0532552451,
-0.0090072835,
-0.0347113945,
-0.0004469127,
0.0020658944,
0.027039364,
0.0870554,
0.0536275133,
-0.0104561262,
0.0090990458,
-0.0369685814,
0.0154860038,
-0.0528009832,
-0.0058175665,
0.058561936,
-0.0030374997,
-0.0209932271,
-0.0577840321,
-0.0255321153,
0.0372248851,
0.0301022734,
-0.0154495388,
0.0447287373,
-0.021077184,
-0.0592444502,
-0.0274924506,
-0.0005163691,
-0.0406158082,
0.0016669942,
-0.0824583322,
-0.0158139598,
0.0030954198,
-0.0399865173,
0.0281742364,
0.0065496806,
-0.1015740037,
-0.0732183531,
-0.0097800521,
0.029645795,
0.0257113241,
0.0288838185,
-0.004021652,
-0.0205833856,
0.0912611559,
0.0572097413,
-0.0048218775,
0.0387002379,
0.0642454848,
0.0262201186,
0.0158584304,
0.0443309955,
-0.0524943061,
0.0048872815,
0.043732658,
0.0328548253,
-0.0347346403,
0.0280933101,
0.0424221121,
0.0292085838,
0.0142067987,
-0.0586144403,
0.0043328688,
-0.0175004359,
0.0468099043,
-0.0081608053,
0.0246588998,
-0.03588783,
0.0232764743,
0.0268831626,
-0.004511361,
0.0127484975,
0.0021355203,
0.0034323279,
0.0511741489,
-0.0245092381,
0.0222023576,
-0.0145942336,
-0.0210893806,
0.0236553662,
-0.0159377493,
-0.021467302,
0.0254006162,
0.0002026784,
0.0077048927,
0.0400970131,
-0.0221883785,
0.0093751177,
0.0650918782,
0.0011940394,
-0.00246646,
-0.0486036465,
-0.0541299209,
-0.0211126655,
0.0263101235,
0.0659852475,
0.0428090841,
0.0611939058,
-0.0180078652,
0.0308416691,
-0.0343794338,
0.0193616617,
-0.0209510308,
0.0071941796,
0.0342852101,
-0.0060378546,
-0.0127886878,
-0.0180435106,
0.0505751148,
0.0151866069,
0.0568447374,
-0.0466348641,
0.0292586964,
-0.0445719585,
-0.0423421934,
0.0303072277,
-0.0150119746,
-0.015567177,
-0.0209443532,
-0.0276767537,
-0.0490873605,
0.0138405096,
0.0259520598,
0.0210802183,
0.0004062839,
0.0351151191,
0.0310078971,
-0.0522232428,
0.0120856967,
0.0077559673,
-0.0476358086,
0.0574898385,
-0.0473634973,
-0.0009885668,
-6.086191062e-33,
-0.034287326,
-0.047280211,
0.0379962251,
0.01173825,
0.0287535284,
0.0373226367,
-0.0123703294,
-0.0171312988,
0.0502408184,
0.0139353368,
-0.0031592203,
0.0045873164,
0.0465807915,
0.0460353568,
0.0202066079,
-0.0061207269,
0.0562217236,
-0.0246302914,
-0.0173423477,
-0.0189037155,
0.0241054539,
0.036437761,
0.0505365171,
-0.0195308458,
0.0427537449,
-0.0179088172,
-0.0157787669,
-0.0064206747,
-0.030638136,
0.0712854266,
0.0000031872,
0.0241524521,
0.0157144815,
-0.0045940494,
-0.0618642978,
0.00252072,
-0.0694240853,
-0.0119292736,
0.0002563344,
0.0070982534,
-0.0349519849,
-0.0457038172,
0.0244311728,
0.016111169,
-0.0775902495,
-0.0189357828,
0.0099378908,
-0.0269703139,
-0.0381875522,
-0.0826586112,
-0.0143356519,
0.0298644993,
0.0052862894,
0.000870403,
0.0480440073,
-0.0012568312,
-0.0103998277,
0.006749826,
-0.0030142197,
0.067332983,
0.050460007,
0.0254194196,
0.0845933333,
0.0104260789,
-0.03243443,
0.0554265566,
0.0324838832,
-0.0357277691,
-0.0252801348,
-0.009364468,
0.0299645606,
0.0521385111,
0.0157583114,
0.0284875203,
0.0236315448,
0.0099062799,
-0.0469982624,
0.0406634733,
0.0088885948,
0.0195772015,
-0.0059790136,
0.0393774137,
-0.0140592977,
-0.0160960145,
-0.044394251,
-0.0362046212,
-0.0031814689,
0.0018164566,
0.0249005686,
0.0388386175,
-0.0450946391,
-0.0624080338,
0.038563475,
-0.0334686488,
-0.0067327432,
-0.02301584,
0.0273566227,
-0.0287499484,
-0.037490055,
0.0020887,
-0.0318573229,
-0.0269630328,
0.0724284351,
-0.0428229943,
0.0063588084,
0.0042475318,
0.0490260907,
0.0167142283,
-0.0531740673,
0.0152639924,
-0.0333764441,
0.0147357294,
0.0491286255,
-0.0310781673,
0.0495656244,
-0.0552432276,
-0.0080834841,
0.013680934,
-0.008427117,
0.0248117335,
-0.0122149186,
0.0290526617,
-0.0047880383,
0.0128616672,
-0.0379481688,
-0.0014892713,
-0.0057148742,
-0.0387121327,
0.0508485511,
-0.0137624973,
-0.008136645,
0.0110080438,
2.446e-7,
0.0130252643,
0.0281630978,
0.0735992491,
-0.0185921285,
0.0210175179,
0.005235312,
-0.0354592428,
0.0136793274,
-0.0257346854,
-0.0415628925,
0.0005071357,
0.0363225378,
0.0615135133,
0.0474074483,
-0.0907196924,
0.0168792345,
-0.0057676402,
0.0224469937,
-0.0368203335,
-0.0022425579,
0.0644051433,
0.0336565264,
-0.014181409,
-0.055038508,
0.044179488,
-0.0010286525,
0.0118922107,
-0.0014251537,
-0.010082054,
0.006073344,
0.0579720512,
-0.036774423,
0.0329445153,
0.0045800069,
-0.0097506521,
-0.016750142,
-0.0201160107,
0.0494382419,
0.0200234242,
-0.0513515733,
0.0209194999,
0.0061508645,
-0.0068867831,
0.0396826714,
0.0300059114,
0.0133723179,
0.0076984745,
0.0340377949,
-0.0257309936,
-0.0146786273,
-0.0178655107,
-0.0340400115,
0.0155252432,
0.0531275086,
0.0107672932,
0.0171500836,
0.0028603559,
-0.0382147878,
-0.0207366049,
-0.0939743593,
-0.0521586016,
-0.0955674797,
-0.0150134768,
0.0691648424,
0.0023876817,
-0.0556027666,
-0.0112214191,
2.208558276e-34,
0.0425596945,
-0.0210199729,
0.039541591,
0.0657616556,
0.0021923543,
-0.0330870077,
-0.0609309338,
0.0462374613,
0.0023149971,
-0.0243990179,
-0.017774431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17992v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17992v1 | Catching Chameleons: Detecting Evolving Disinformation Generated using Large Language Models | 2024-06-26T00:21:39 | 2024-06-26T00:21:39 | Bohan Jiang, Chengshuai Zhao, Zhen Tan, Huan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite recent advancements in detecting disinformation generated by large
language models (LLMs), current efforts overlook the ever-evolving nature of
this disinformation. In this work, we investigate a challenging yet practical
research problem of detecting evolving LLM-generated disinformation.
Disinformation evolves constantly through the rapid development of LLMs and
their variants. As a consequence, the detection model faces significant
challenges. First, it is inefficient to train separate models for each
disinformation generator. Second, the performance decreases in scenarios when
evolving LLM-generated disinformation is encountered in sequential order. To
address this problem, we propose DELD (Detecting Evolving LLM-generated
Disinformation), a parameter-efficient approach that jointly leverages the
general fact-checking capabilities of pre-trained language models (PLM) and the
independent disinformation generation characteristics of various LLMs. In
particular, the learned characteristics are concatenated sequentially to
facilitate knowledge accumulation and transformation. DELD addresses the issue
of label scarcity by integrating the semantic embeddings of disinformation with
trainable soft prompts to elicit model-specific knowledge. Our experiments show
that \textit{DELD} significantly outperforms state-of-the-art methods.
Moreover, our method provides critical insights into the unique patterns of
disinformation generation across different LLMs, offering valuable perspectives
in this line of research. | Catching Chameleons: Detecting Evolving Disinformation Generated using Large Language Models: Despite recent advancements in detecting disinformation generated by large
language models (LLMs), current efforts overlook the ever-evolving nature of
this disinformation. In this work, we investigate a challenging yet practical
research problem of detecting evolving LLM-generated disinformation.
Disinformation evolves constantly through the rapid development of LLMs and
their variants. As a consequence, the detection model faces significant
challenges. First, it is inefficient to train separate models for each
disinformation generator. Second, the performance decreases in scenarios when
evolving LLM-generated disinformation is encountered in sequential order. To
address this problem, we propose DELD (Detecting Evolving LLM-generated
Disinformation), a parameter-efficient approach that jointly leverages the
general fact-checking capabilities of pre-trained language models (PLM) and the
independent disinformation generation characteristics of various LLMs. In
particular, the learned characteristics are concatenated sequentially to
facilitate knowledge accumulation and transformation. DELD addresses the issue
of label scarcity by integrating the semantic embeddings of disinformation with
trainable soft prompts to elicit model-specific knowledge. Our experiments show
that \textit{DELD} significantly outperforms state-of-the-art methods.
Moreover, our method provides critical insights into the unique patterns of
disinformation generation across different LLMs, offering valuable perspectives
in this line of research. | [
0.0303570889,
0.0293432828,
-0.0218203384,
0.0617221668,
-0.0240811165,
0.0034576773,
-0.0071037877,
-0.0130919246,
-0.0118137319,
-0.051656045,
0.0077871205,
-0.0187409371,
0.0118580209,
0.0535772592,
0.0259188283,
-0.0109657561,
0.0902048722,
-0.0063282666,
0.0313881226,
-0.0301075056,
0.031769421,
0.0191513039,
0.0039913789,
0.0275991727,
-0.0354624093,
-0.0297166742,
0.0203132685,
0.0023056709,
0.0237767082,
-0.013529432,
0.0310705639,
0.0390508063,
0.0469369069,
0.113761805,
0.0000018568,
-0.0171290748,
-0.0055975667,
0.0081539042,
-0.0631179512,
0.0387899131,
0.0637786537,
-0.0398332141,
-0.0109236669,
0.0124021433,
-0.0205808915,
-0.0216264371,
0.0348739438,
0.0529988706,
0.0941913947,
0.0838366225,
0.0124714365,
-0.0087071415,
0.0081497766,
-0.0280217156,
-0.0193036068,
-0.0097047482,
0.0548196137,
-0.0328500234,
-0.0651482418,
0.0359281935,
0.0043161362,
0.0067979163,
0.0208407659,
-0.0074235755,
-0.0463558994,
0.0190110784,
0.0056299684,
-0.0327506438,
-0.0232091565,
0.0649783313,
-0.0313447081,
-0.0556642935,
0.0041301199,
-0.0050103655,
0.0351204015,
0.0183587223,
0.0236025918,
0.0230285991,
-0.00813042,
0.0050931871,
0.0245062057,
-0.0205926485,
0.0580350496,
0.0319836996,
-0.0085244821,
0.0422206745,
0.0075180777,
-0.0294522792,
-0.0071057831,
-0.0532561392,
-0.0090506021,
-0.0867701024,
-0.0179094393,
0.0118017327,
-0.0379581824,
0.02526737,
-0.0867680386,
-0.0256444495,
0.04469008,
-0.0680850148,
-0.0051388415,
-0.0118513899,
-0.0235799197,
0.030301135,
-0.0232792851,
0.030564623,
-0.0231194738,
0.0215963777,
-0.0059385081,
-0.0080278683,
-0.002374894,
-0.0034957121,
-0.0006221746,
0.0357533656,
0.0065851435,
0.0095542241,
-0.0168442894,
0.0082723126,
-0.0382907353,
0.0380933434,
-0.0478274934,
0.0091949878,
-0.0217050444,
-0.0232769288,
-0.0280824918,
0.0510488339,
-0.0065481151,
0.0051586176,
0.0027894266,
-0.0442657694,
-0.0174011178,
0.0280550029,
-0.0567083955,
0.015904827,
-0.0133700315,
0.0158581808,
-0.0147940228,
0.0180768427,
-0.0448425598,
-0.0402040146,
-0.047933653,
-0.0463847592,
-0.0038834584,
-0.0597197451,
0.0011639398,
-0.031331256,
-0.0214023832,
-0.0631007701,
0.0099275419,
0.0009513276,
-0.0565110445,
0.0735741928,
-0.0410184711,
-0.006790502,
0.0753275901,
0.034490224,
0.0082299598,
0.0825106502,
-0.0182167124,
0.0586772636,
0.0513815358,
0.0096989004,
0.0120468885,
0.0136195878,
0.052900143,
0.0754500777,
0.004735033,
-0.0079030152,
0.0252678599,
-0.0132799447,
0.024108341,
0.0418779962,
-0.0143605834,
-0.0667815655,
0.0791049972,
-0.0494008586,
-0.0345730931,
-0.0246969238,
0.0591002628,
0.03556576,
-0.0249716192,
0.0212384798,
-0.0455465652,
-0.0211761948,
-0.0597484522,
-0.0319527574,
0.011044085,
0.0583369322,
-0.004412292,
-0.0362496972,
-0.014248224,
-0.0092222374,
0.0008863329,
-0.0100580119,
-0.0120966975,
0.038542904,
-0.0244349614,
0.0875790492,
0.0620064735,
-0.0016624588,
-0.004078744,
-0.0551234372,
0.0168726537,
0.040143691,
0.0432569981,
-0.0131768361,
-0.0386514366,
-0.0439445861,
0.0190549269,
0.0406162776,
0.0668822601,
-0.0342178307,
-0.0285340194,
-0.001700762,
-0.0010771777,
-0.0357660055,
0.0451161005,
0.0207613539,
0.020603884,
0.0147350943,
0.010250818,
-0.0349697024,
-0.0496079326,
0.0355973989,
-0.0024917887,
-0.0160174146,
-0.0039591552,
0.021811299,
0.0215557814,
0.0107672401,
-0.0167680196,
-0.0085414955,
0.0479550436,
-0.0042245006,
-0.0381917246,
-0.0249081254,
-0.0087518869,
-0.0318951569,
0.0509362929,
0.021133028,
-0.0298102368,
0.005604913,
-0.0431831814,
0.0135450996,
0.0254294612,
-0.0337572619,
0.033825621,
-0.0312945731,
0.0090798596,
-0.0288489629,
0.0286995489,
0.0048169228,
0.0673153698,
-0.0527915694,
-0.0194732603,
0.0240059532,
0.0193962604,
0.0024687515,
0.0181817934,
0.0059217019,
-0.0009436868,
-0.0035189113,
0.0015710149,
0.0349593461,
-0.0178127214,
0.0033303357,
-0.0329711884,
-0.0084542567,
-0.0244740136,
-0.0340099968,
-0.0240164772,
0.0476033166,
-0.0386138409,
0.0067292717,
0.0144178942,
-0.0201507732,
-0.0022444758,
0.0037419365,
0.024891939,
0.0137092276,
0.004282136,
-0.035841953,
-0.0229804553,
0.0458094515,
-0.0140714701,
0.0488069504,
0.0125864474,
-0.0263144374,
-0.0532454289,
-0.0167813171,
-0.0638976544,
0.044048883,
-0.0337450393,
-0.0332011469,
0.0124099022,
0.0393466428,
0.0478157476,
0.001434489,
0.0417133495,
0.0628507733,
0.0583309084,
0.0163754728,
-0.0272387583,
-0.022521954,
-0.036137633,
0.0014848842,
-0.0556437522,
-0.0619271584,
0.0265170261,
0.0588620715,
0.0382283852,
-0.0229984485,
-0.0211585853,
0.0462284423,
-0.0172092021,
-0.0689963475,
0.0307319015,
-0.0544704571,
-0.0196839161,
0.0240494683,
-0.0395959988,
-0.0558740646,
0.0835269094,
-0.0519770049,
0.0409727804,
-0.0255461372,
-0.0097658588,
0.020979099,
0.0111545818,
-0.013867815,
0.0435242914,
0.0364916362,
0.0108537963,
-0.0518081374,
-0.0303706396,
0.0467624031,
-0.0255890545,
0.0177893192,
-0.0527524576,
0.0223461054,
0.0392788872,
-0.0206814576,
-0.0790617839,
-0.1047935113,
0.0184861142,
-0.0083238054,
0.0068873432,
-0.0297598019,
-0.0560092218,
-0.0501221791,
0.0193666331,
0.006862923,
0.0008563882,
0.0116112847,
-0.0150083806,
0.0046722284,
0.0568210855,
-0.0156723522,
0.0843723342,
-0.0392533503,
0.0198909435,
0.0495122746,
-0.0240751542,
0.0090835383,
-0.0096247708,
-0.0667041019,
0.0072829169,
-0.0213743597,
0.0072436696,
0.0184516646,
0.0103430403,
-0.0638907477,
0.001058348,
0.0928115845,
0.0191998519,
-0.0158588979,
0.0065294579,
0.0160934366,
0.0247290656,
0.0330239572,
-0.0150056612,
-0.0942199901,
-0.0054513942,
0.0127602946,
-0.0087823756,
-0.0374329053,
-0.0106647536,
-0.0409275666,
-0.1061412916,
0.0110501163,
0.0080738906,
-0.0010438695,
-0.0274691861,
-0.0241899025,
-0.0240896847,
0.0530635342,
0.0248042364,
-0.0126121957,
0.0306164511,
-0.025965156,
-0.010172681,
-0.0327142514,
-0.0631402507,
0.0028129471,
0.0123688476,
0.0640969202,
0.0543632768,
0.0203908253,
-0.0058253487,
-0.0574053116,
0.0513019301,
0.0070646042,
-0.0472933948,
-0.0186891612,
0.0565463752,
-0.0358360037,
-0.0249632057,
0.0059867366,
0.0231090859,
0.0333049446,
0.0102325911,
-0.0195857715,
0.0347688086,
0.00372957,
-0.0564076342,
-0.0147388121,
0.0117504103,
0.0629246235,
0.0593641736,
0.0148323383,
0.0014467076,
-0.0005315805,
-0.0440017506,
0.020994382,
0.0270135384,
-0.0189847387,
0.0286180805,
0.0009399334,
-0.0435463041,
-0.0580843426,
-0.0050029173,
-0.0099734683,
-0.00960798,
0.0270753354,
0.0068024611,
-0.0002957715,
-0.0221965648,
-0.01596017,
-0.032886494,
-0.0510620996,
0.0468633361,
-0.0285603367,
-0.0167267751,
0.0004784648,
0.0081111547,
-0.0137515366,
0.0315318517,
-0.089793019,
-0.0861143097,
0.0260311887,
0.0265226066,
0.0111163938,
0.0622285791,
-0.0376142301,
-0.0468579531,
0.101308912,
0.0286299121,
-0.0063731456,
0.0348093845,
0.0391561724,
-0.0146702854,
0.0200487413,
0.0457588583,
-0.0223281924,
0.0278814044,
0.0218635891,
-0.0257990528,
-0.0633555278,
-0.0226590782,
0.0364045352,
0.0067298086,
0.0463967472,
-0.0185519923,
0.0049426672,
-0.039650593,
-0.0045643169,
-0.0081796367,
-0.0604990721,
0.0130890962,
0.0279060118,
0.0221580621,
-0.0080130063,
0.0361549594,
0.0291186329,
-0.0268426295,
0.0376879387,
-0.0112388572,
-0.0456001647,
0.0077360291,
0.0369119756,
0.0619508587,
-0.0099772168,
-0.0058466396,
0.0393946841,
0.0008423454,
0.0130190263,
0.0025406065,
0.0107329264,
0.0224901065,
-0.025153771,
-0.0092683192,
-0.0164789725,
-0.0094304541,
-0.0335771367,
-0.0173691865,
0.0231901091,
0.0404653661,
0.0438632369,
0.0329233445,
0.005271215,
-0.032665804,
-0.0155643662,
-0.0210947804,
0.0112983519,
-0.0401306525,
0.039813742,
-0.0057552676,
-0.0543076806,
0.034940023,
0.0699863359,
0.0099100564,
0.0605605468,
-0.003156445,
-0.0357962325,
-0.0273421872,
-0.0314654633,
-0.010031742,
0.0313388817,
-0.0153837828,
0.018200295,
-0.0953384042,
-0.0656384379,
0.0164040569,
0.0115972804,
-0.0081035849,
0.009010274,
-0.0178080704,
0.0719604418,
0.0061442261,
0.0081934445,
-0.0567345545,
-0.002565936,
0.0210539568,
-0.0221397504,
0.0350736044,
-6.517400593e-33,
-0.0015466112,
-0.0609430633,
-0.027840104,
-0.0379114673,
-0.020128008,
0.0352310985,
0.0011696642,
-0.0261966046,
-0.0360170715,
0.0611459427,
0.0574783199,
0.033149343,
-0.0184097271,
-0.0024698286,
-0.0511578843,
-0.0364914685,
0.0876847282,
0.0009369199,
-0.0507532805,
0.027216807,
0.0669368133,
-0.0072793663,
0.0141326841,
-0.0656853244,
0.0636744276,
-0.0104571497,
-0.0499170125,
0.037417464,
-0.04146,
0.0252526831,
-0.00009935,
0.072999157,
0.0045487867,
-0.0571653321,
-0.0176315829,
0.0112591628,
-0.0135505022,
-0.0198146719,
0.0406919122,
-0.0210579522,
0.0068296352,
-0.0187074281,
0.0350023583,
0.0041208253,
-0.0062768711,
0.0231696442,
0.0126735177,
-0.0125618717,
0.0025099837,
0.0178199131,
-0.0698893815,
-0.0054226145,
0.0126173189,
-0.0222556964,
-0.0402722023,
0.0265885293,
0.0382824913,
0.022880204,
-0.1037770882,
0.0162980389,
0.0272065364,
0.0092475088,
0.0385263301,
-0.0069272318,
-0.0140912477,
0.0734506696,
0.0196463168,
0.0642140433,
-0.0110163912,
-0.0098676309,
-0.0005043977,
0.0214717574,
0.0440408587,
0.0799906105,
-0.0053542908,
-0.0493124239,
-0.0748951808,
-0.0074234917,
0.0222558342,
-0.0103958715,
0.0041050171,
-0.0317732506,
-0.005844688,
-0.022192128,
-0.0685764104,
0.0170017779,
-0.0222655628,
0.0013252263,
0.0160742868,
0.0491075404,
-0.0245975461,
0.0290014911,
-0.0011347883,
-0.038415499,
-0.0156598557,
0.0124738179,
-0.0110627217,
-0.0391330309,
0.0224066935,
0.0486158319,
-0.0540900715,
0.0057579838,
0.0333859622,
-0.0321147107,
-0.0106256334,
-0.0016480507,
0.0571061037,
-0.0047912174,
-0.0680166334,
0.03368273,
-0.0114879478,
0.0445675552,
-0.0063156383,
-0.0403768905,
0.0328833871,
-0.0081735635,
-0.0246628858,
-0.007158157,
0.0447500125,
0.0076152398,
-0.0110952631,
0.0457924828,
-0.0348975807,
0.0545030981,
-0.0421563871,
0.0056791101,
-0.0286489688,
0.0389015228,
0.015581388,
-0.0799793899,
-0.0029613143,
-0.0471804291,
2.675e-7,
-0.0020584629,
0.0563703179,
-0.014095637,
-0.0022148022,
0.0458426662,
0.0653516054,
0.0123908035,
-0.0141598433,
-0.0305257924,
-0.081305027,
-0.0333133824,
0.0431367867,
0.0052338,
0.0483800359,
-0.0174817629,
0.024804797,
-0.0538207665,
0.00788166,
-0.0596262962,
-0.021375984,
0.0168702696,
0.0928511694,
0.0412424579,
-0.0303299911,
-0.0095629003,
-0.0191226397,
0.0627545267,
0.0255836509,
-0.0391345657,
0.0307699032,
0.0329672955,
-0.0129782474,
0.0065271719,
0.0085418308,
-0.0346364751,
0.0020747124,
-0.0588440523,
0.0178687554,
0.0096769733,
-0.0115942415,
-0.0483664386,
-0.0246326346,
-0.0101387808,
-0.0534581207,
0.0778727531,
-0.039764218,
-0.0038598801,
-0.0683681294,
-0.026613716,
0.0090146754,
0.0095529705,
-0.0370642506,
-0.0576819964,
0.0228533316,
-0.0134999938,
0.0563942716,
0.0117555913,
-0.0603254735,
0.0040616263,
0.0238491129,
-0.0484929793,
-0.0496378168,
0.0132019632,
-0.0258946232,
0.0397567675,
-0.0110558253,
0.0662020668,
2.553680662e-34,
0.0608994365,
-0.0206708629,
0.0008632141,
-0.0129754478,
0.0446423069,
0.0016602906,
-0.0348325484,
-0.0258412044,
0.0138588063,
0.0016761402,
0.0017279497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17990v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17990v1 | Explicit Diversity Conditions for Effective Question Answer Generation with Large Language Models | 2024-06-26T00:12:08 | 2024-06-26T00:12:08 | Vikas Yadav, Hyuk Joon Kwon, Vijay Srinivasan, Hongxia Jin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Question Answer Generation (QAG) is an effective data augmentation technique
to improve the accuracy of question answering systems, especially in
low-resource domains. While recent pretrained and large language model-based
QAG methods have made substantial progress, they face the critical issue of
redundant QA pair generation, affecting downstream QA systems. Implicit
diversity techniques such as sampling and diverse beam search are proven
effective solutions but often yield smaller diversity. We present explicit
diversity conditions for QAG, focusing on spatial aspects, question types, and
entities, substantially increasing diversity in QA generation. Our work
emphasizes the need of explicit diversity conditions for generating diverse
question-answer synthetic data by showing significant improvements in
downstream QA task over existing widely adopted implicit diversity techniques.
In particular, generated QA pairs from explicit diversity conditions when used
to train the downstream QA model results in an average 4.1% exact match and
4.5% F1 improvement over QAG from implicit sampling techniques on SQuADDU. Our
work emphasizes the need for explicit diversity conditions even more in
low-resource datasets (SubjQA), where average downstream QA performance
improvements are around 12% EM. | Explicit Diversity Conditions for Effective Question Answer Generation with Large Language Models: Question Answer Generation (QAG) is an effective data augmentation technique
to improve the accuracy of question answering systems, especially in
low-resource domains. While recent pretrained and large language model-based
QAG methods have made substantial progress, they face the critical issue of
redundant QA pair generation, affecting downstream QA systems. Implicit
diversity techniques such as sampling and diverse beam search are proven
effective solutions but often yield smaller diversity. We present explicit
diversity conditions for QAG, focusing on spatial aspects, question types, and
entities, substantially increasing diversity in QA generation. Our work
emphasizes the need of explicit diversity conditions for generating diverse
question-answer synthetic data by showing significant improvements in
downstream QA task over existing widely adopted implicit diversity techniques.
In particular, generated QA pairs from explicit diversity conditions when used
to train the downstream QA model results in an average 4.1% exact match and
4.5% F1 improvement over QAG from implicit sampling techniques on SQuADDU. Our
work emphasizes the need for explicit diversity conditions even more in
low-resource datasets (SubjQA), where average downstream QA performance
improvements are around 12% EM. | [
0.0530610122,
0.0509117655,
-0.0071520451,
0.0152883595,
-0.0006215092,
-0.0102417702,
0.0374410599,
-0.0187421925,
0.0142333582,
-0.0454719551,
-0.0122885117,
-0.0430126116,
-0.0048163035,
0.0205946378,
0.036644727,
-0.0283785388,
0.0585170165,
-0.0148631949,
-0.0437916815,
-0.0396436676,
-0.0003432177,
0.0186363067,
0.0036886733,
0.0284672044,
-0.0161589775,
-0.0255436525,
-0.0395487659,
-0.0008469417,
0.0157360379,
-0.0263788961,
0.0244048033,
0.0591152124,
0.0153787769,
0.0227974337,
0.0000019254,
-0.0114490027,
-0.0245834608,
0.0066091577,
-0.0282170679,
0.0074190614,
-0.0492004044,
0.0248075761,
0.0506125018,
0.0368290879,
-0.0514552742,
-0.0240534935,
0.0557455495,
0.0289659016,
0.0904615745,
0.0540677086,
-0.0042568371,
0.0012123366,
0.0130454814,
-0.0053513059,
0.0404936597,
-0.0160167851,
0.0118167298,
-0.0066307727,
0.0330226831,
0.0600931905,
-0.004638562,
0.0157391261,
0.0283287857,
0.010727332,
0.0038339107,
0.046330817,
-0.0157847088,
0.0214019213,
-0.0084097879,
0.1009919271,
0.0138485041,
-0.0067003407,
-0.001804598,
-0.0052496572,
0.0083753597,
0.020194646,
-0.0465184189,
0.0127289528,
-0.0182867646,
-0.0085222572,
0.0096109742,
0.016965311,
-0.015726272,
0.0010076187,
-0.0230136979,
0.0411918201,
0.0527733974,
-0.027249625,
-0.0530578941,
0.0340273306,
-0.0366557315,
-0.0553044714,
0.0011237339,
0.0572745316,
-0.0551872775,
0.0190486182,
-0.0695687681,
-0.0443105698,
0.0236878023,
0.0117620071,
0.0245707128,
0.0210369769,
0.0090018865,
0.0121705243,
0.0050927196,
0.0377494842,
-0.0325398035,
-0.014314767,
-0.0893673822,
-0.0583355241,
-0.0076723052,
-0.0318439119,
-0.0512560755,
0.0427819528,
-0.0877210349,
-0.0224357843,
-0.0267471336,
0.0320453048,
0.0155650759,
-0.0433374085,
-0.0216029044,
0.068969503,
-0.0601562969,
-0.0060533308,
0.0065566967,
0.0108059738,
-0.0646806508,
0.0260136053,
0.0341860615,
-0.0860432386,
-0.0261958558,
0.0221153554,
0.0462842733,
-0.039320223,
-0.0289610196,
0.0304578692,
-0.0273766853,
-0.0173084065,
0.0020306038,
-0.0369412825,
-0.0330970809,
-0.0420293808,
0.011124826,
-0.0646789968,
0.0553774498,
0.0074531869,
-0.0317266546,
0.0091723269,
0.0171770807,
0.033160679,
-0.0121284062,
0.0240231641,
-0.0360455923,
0.0356501974,
0.0608979091,
-0.0085600335,
0.0360242091,
0.0725478306,
0.0022441256,
-0.0080187786,
0.0271456055,
0.02100881,
0.0198990647,
0.0149242925,
0.0474490896,
0.0374677964,
0.0128282253,
0.0553349964,
0.0133536113,
0.0323802121,
0.0157963112,
0.0504997224,
-0.0528400466,
-0.0084000695,
0.0369578414,
0.026213089,
0.0348591246,
0.0134164644,
0.0586033426,
0.0194093045,
-0.0030994327,
-0.0100830141,
-0.0048874519,
0.0485500582,
-0.0161179285,
0.009154005,
0.0663233101,
0.0563475601,
-0.0569125861,
-0.0153784305,
0.008864644,
0.0309443697,
-0.0433325432,
0.0375269465,
0.0058090189,
0.0199689474,
-0.0169840828,
0.0889056846,
-0.0065908283,
-0.0454734489,
-0.0027390646,
-0.017584255,
0.0583110601,
0.0346667469,
0.0337639675,
0.0031810617,
-0.0542901643,
-0.0071830996,
0.0003737484,
0.0407067016,
0.0551273189,
-0.0209744573,
0.0101873949,
-0.0541014634,
-0.045463834,
-0.0087210368,
0.0062620216,
0.0449720807,
0.0582035668,
0.0414122157,
0.0332914628,
-0.0414914489,
-0.0118932705,
0.0250993259,
-0.0390555188,
-0.0353534818,
0.0434030332,
0.0041400366,
-0.0059756991,
0.0277944896,
0.0010493386,
0.023401361,
0.0098377103,
-0.0244035944,
-0.0312294867,
0.0023029395,
-0.0540437438,
-0.0899158344,
0.0126374671,
-0.0428344756,
-0.0006445438,
0.0408218727,
-0.0286726523,
-0.0473617949,
-0.0097952057,
-0.0644245669,
-0.0462344401,
-0.06322328,
-0.0198406093,
0.0445880964,
0.0345713161,
-0.0584099852,
0.0662115216,
-0.0046199956,
0.0137631726,
0.0174004938,
0.0498434789,
0.0423011631,
-0.0732683167,
0.0142824491,
-0.0176314712,
-0.0062865675,
0.027131794,
-0.0080458792,
0.0321176201,
-0.0447546355,
-0.0135612898,
-0.0701180398,
0.0219308939,
-0.0305688605,
0.0046916027,
0.0294247586,
0.0427883714,
-0.0207193047,
-0.0139111625,
-0.0816728249,
-0.0140360715,
0.0506451987,
0.0479646884,
0.0326656066,
0.0115826624,
0.0275657754,
-0.0240378827,
-0.0182516482,
0.0093443394,
0.0480444245,
0.0168554243,
0.0190630648,
-0.058574222,
-0.0002431811,
-0.0412091166,
0.0179400276,
0.0257201325,
-0.0087997504,
0.026012525,
-0.0251376517,
0.0494988114,
-0.0068937652,
0.0381033309,
-0.0345827527,
0.0157672372,
0.0159881432,
-0.0642849505,
0.0407228842,
-0.0471341647,
0.0180073865,
0.0260796919,
-0.0488596559,
0.0345398225,
0.0035585021,
0.0271733515,
-0.0400114134,
-0.0393905044,
0.0537228957,
0.015801318,
-0.05693857,
-0.0410947353,
0.0022425242,
-0.0040636719,
0.0215628892,
-0.0261215735,
-0.0157792699,
0.0266693179,
-0.0147983329,
0.0108489897,
-0.0863435492,
0.0199422464,
-0.0563268587,
0.0214697588,
-0.029327495,
0.0261789411,
-0.0027084905,
-0.0132596102,
-0.0385823771,
0.0059441524,
-0.0362556837,
-0.0379546583,
0.0481094122,
-0.0193669628,
0.0140149854,
-0.0173013452,
-0.0272018518,
-0.0919629782,
-0.0412457325,
0.0373276845,
-0.0084924232,
0.0226314776,
0.0005752966,
0.0167494416,
0.0203052703,
0.0269374251,
0.0357538313,
-0.0729445368,
-0.0016061374,
-0.0275047421,
0.105637826,
0.0987448618,
0.0875712484,
0.038104333,
-0.026924435,
-0.0050706142,
0.0295116566,
0.0251121987,
-0.0033765945,
0.027070608,
0.0021576623,
0.0154772131,
-0.0114653222,
-0.0108598424,
0.01000378,
0.0764241591,
-0.015674755,
-0.0656859577,
0.0759274364,
0.0550321266,
0.0025349006,
0.0045858081,
-0.0206475854,
0.0382581614,
0.0241146069,
0.0630894676,
-0.0722446442,
-0.0121763907,
-0.0458384231,
0.0161894336,
0.0011744575,
-0.019026367,
-0.0332885049,
-0.1438507587,
0.039413698,
-0.0215586927,
-0.0929550603,
-0.040623989,
0.0096108764,
-0.0099996598,
0.0300420411,
0.0202330351,
0.007129651,
-0.0037210246,
0.0389875881,
0.0333061181,
0.0300862323,
-0.0366555192,
-0.0064125373,
-0.0404822603,
0.0328742377,
0.0449577346,
0.0204692893,
0.0152662629,
-0.0074653011,
-0.0063094269,
-0.0729187354,
0.0107264128,
0.0009818185,
0.0312433261,
0.0112646688,
-0.017233165,
-0.0072539803,
0.031030545,
-0.0162675809,
0.0059081758,
0.0493135564,
0.0502024218,
-0.0259022079,
0.0240883175,
-0.0337830745,
0.0297613423,
0.0612232164,
0.0681609437,
0.0433743596,
-0.0349558443,
-0.0235112272,
-0.0257578865,
-0.0086954534,
-0.1073597148,
0.0002332186,
0.0400695913,
0.0090532573,
0.0245627463,
-0.0964707732,
-0.0685945079,
0.0238110926,
0.0489935502,
-0.02683069,
0.0057306364,
-0.0363701992,
-0.0132570602,
-0.0060325596,
0.0233763345,
-0.0359759815,
-0.0132443374,
0.0061818422,
-0.0170520041,
-0.0234101135,
-0.0899116322,
-0.0086868275,
0.0156075889,
-0.0815370902,
-0.0378280692,
0.004487168,
0.0286342856,
0.0134482337,
0.0461856425,
-0.0255871341,
-0.0053676176,
0.0612844527,
0.068800956,
-0.0192952286,
0.0254726596,
-0.0068205809,
-0.0092860404,
-0.0111690192,
0.0399128869,
-0.0446558073,
0.0064449096,
0.0197145417,
0.073946178,
-0.0131354332,
-0.0291188098,
0.035129901,
0.0257511195,
-0.0302220937,
-0.0115850251,
-0.0038965885,
-0.026496077,
0.0230461322,
-0.033952672,
-0.0113464165,
-0.039064128,
0.010100781,
-0.0083517935,
-0.0199619941,
0.0062646372,
-0.0023646364,
-0.0063265781,
0.0690679923,
-0.050228145,
-0.033278726,
0.0030320177,
0.001510535,
0.0115155885,
-0.0123684471,
-0.0282167662,
0.0185406487,
-0.0011166735,
0.043470528,
0.0041613155,
0.0347707011,
0.0019085949,
-0.0091408417,
-0.0415330864,
0.016941553,
-0.0742724836,
-0.07243938,
-0.0369149372,
0.0346877836,
0.0253810864,
0.0103457272,
0.0236703325,
-0.0061296537,
-0.0083411885,
-0.0100699756,
-0.0120233968,
0.021856891,
-0.0116384272,
0.0411902703,
0.0110380929,
-0.0106624514,
-0.0088590775,
0.0812616423,
-0.0064214249,
0.0511819385,
-0.0174728259,
0.019605618,
-0.0345122702,
-0.0195047054,
0.0014478412,
0.0053551388,
-0.02322427,
0.0189490244,
-0.0373502523,
-0.0357153788,
0.0129085947,
0.002010108,
-0.0143225808,
0.014859858,
0.04471967,
0.0454169288,
-0.0184569191,
-0.0189053603,
-0.0467279181,
0.043447569,
-0.051324185,
-0.0213434491,
0.0154632973,
-6.651967513e-33,
-0.0331507251,
-0.0500569791,
0.0573255271,
-0.0940835252,
-0.0286210887,
0.0241768956,
-0.0121190315,
-0.034950316,
-0.0316402875,
-0.025791185,
-0.0195830874,
0.0014050745,
0.0079515483,
0.0513706394,
0.0048636664,
-0.0229102038,
0.0164986178,
-0.0074312217,
-0.0117686968,
0.0451650247,
0.0423989929,
0.0023503057,
0.003181247,
0.008902166,
-0.0166636873,
-0.0494484641,
-0.0060763108,
0.0144310053,
-0.0539239496,
0.0659452677,
-0.0460090451,
0.0343869068,
0.0198804904,
-0.0480297655,
-0.0146768959,
0.0201270059,
-0.044399552,
-0.0522828288,
0.0007706884,
-0.0223900583,
-0.0604008585,
-0.0405120812,
0.002678246,
-0.0164377596,
0.0251342952,
-0.012099077,
0.0223625004,
-0.0183425359,
-0.0132869584,
-0.0248378478,
-0.043551743,
0.0068237875,
0.0122622671,
-0.0007968259,
-0.0841102377,
0.0781189203,
0.0082476158,
0.000679217,
-0.0122822728,
0.0353713706,
0.0936826766,
0.01487354,
0.0311314203,
0.0250703972,
-0.0014112268,
0.012275232,
0.0190963801,
-0.0321400911,
0.0058313254,
-0.0090682013,
-0.02950521,
0.0016623271,
0.0368085504,
0.0859927312,
0.0077635739,
0.0359817445,
-0.0672919601,
0.0565241501,
-0.0221266542,
-0.0393166505,
0.0242878739,
-0.0464623831,
-0.0334715247,
-0.0006599742,
-0.0154920854,
0.0436373167,
-0.0270680916,
-0.0301875882,
0.0684142858,
0.0227661747,
-0.0452352166,
0.0054283454,
0.057088647,
-0.0257391427,
-0.0174900852,
0.0203993395,
-0.0283047874,
-0.0087562148,
-0.0049298164,
0.0349618606,
-0.0478076451,
0.0036312013,
0.0562878661,
0.0008305998,
-0.049509801,
0.0462689362,
0.002805514,
-0.0034065067,
-0.058099024,
0.0127477134,
-0.0192648694,
0.037087936,
-0.0303488728,
0.0087549295,
0.0164380968,
0.0002151873,
-0.0058909692,
0.0450808406,
0.006242868,
-0.0012415769,
-0.005818645,
-0.0513414182,
-0.0011142647,
0.0440020636,
-0.0247980338,
0.0610910319,
-0.0342252813,
-0.0385734588,
-0.0303929541,
-0.050996542,
-0.0133757489,
0.0235907342,
2.614e-7,
0.0431904644,
0.0069803088,
0.0320523456,
0.03210181,
-0.0012004117,
0.009846014,
0.0322834328,
0.0462692752,
0.0076160207,
0.0426460281,
0.0046580043,
0.035354007,
0.0156507399,
0.0269850958,
-0.0675493628,
0.0447113849,
-0.053702224,
-0.0044513317,
-0.063694492,
-0.0449389368,
0.0583842434,
0.0731575787,
-0.03163369,
-0.0237789769,
-0.0181944873,
-0.0068475204,
0.047232613,
0.0470807068,
-0.0516518764,
0.0437795967,
0.0434447117,
-0.0162678901,
0.0195061285,
0.0114783077,
-0.0154687818,
0.0110717881,
0.0410962887,
0.0354579985,
0.0142848538,
-0.0670009404,
-0.013501591,
-0.0182437208,
0.0045412784,
-0.0613601655,
0.0740704387,
-0.036973536,
0.0181722492,
-0.009919499,
-0.053092774,
0.0039987117,
0.0149797136,
-0.042166464,
-0.0072176321,
-0.0064140158,
0.0048099747,
0.0053029768,
0.0074961428,
-0.0396782644,
-0.0034648245,
-0.0114563005,
-0.0429439768,
-0.0405109636,
-0.039873451,
0.0043139425,
0.027136052,
-0.0451421775,
-0.0069672358,
2.520492691e-34,
-0.0003452345,
0.0166952964,
0.0127411084,
0.0021131122,
-0.0080768829,
-0.0243097823,
-0.0190507099,
-0.0148571748,
0.0275195576,
-0.0675269365,
-0.0380280018
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17987v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17987v1 | Multi-step Knowledge Retrieval and Inference over Unstructured Data | 2024-06-26T00:00:45 | 2024-06-26T00:00:45 | Aditya Kalyanpur, Kailash Saravanakumar, Victor Barres, CJ McFate, Lori Moon, Nati Seifu, Maksim Eremeev, Jose Barrera, Eric Brown, David Ferrucci | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) and Generative AI has
revolutionized natural language applications across various domains. However,
high-stakes decision-making tasks in fields such as medical, legal and finance
require a level of precision, comprehensiveness, and logical consistency that
pure LLM or Retrieval-Augmented-Generation (RAG) approaches often fail to
deliver. At Elemental Cognition (EC), we have developed a neuro-symbolic AI
platform to tackle these problems. The platform integrates fine-tuned LLMs for
knowledge extraction and alignment with a robust symbolic reasoning engine for
logical inference, planning and interactive constraint solving. We describe
Cora, a Collaborative Research Assistant built on this platform, that is
designed to perform complex research and discovery tasks in high-stakes
domains. This paper discusses the multi-step inference challenges inherent in
such domains, critiques the limitations of existing LLM-based methods, and
demonstrates how Cora's neuro-symbolic approach effectively addresses these
issues. We provide an overview of the system architecture, key algorithms for
knowledge extraction and formal reasoning, and present preliminary evaluation
results that highlight Cora's superior performance compared to well-known LLM
and RAG baselines. | Multi-step Knowledge Retrieval and Inference over Unstructured Data: The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) and Generative AI has
revolutionized natural language applications across various domains. However,
high-stakes decision-making tasks in fields such as medical, legal and finance
require a level of precision, comprehensiveness, and logical consistency that
pure LLM or Retrieval-Augmented-Generation (RAG) approaches often fail to
deliver. At Elemental Cognition (EC), we have developed a neuro-symbolic AI
platform to tackle these problems. The platform integrates fine-tuned LLMs for
knowledge extraction and alignment with a robust symbolic reasoning engine for
logical inference, planning and interactive constraint solving. We describe
Cora, a Collaborative Research Assistant built on this platform, that is
designed to perform complex research and discovery tasks in high-stakes
domains. This paper discusses the multi-step inference challenges inherent in
such domains, critiques the limitations of existing LLM-based methods, and
demonstrates how Cora's neuro-symbolic approach effectively addresses these
issues. We provide an overview of the system architecture, key algorithms for
knowledge extraction and formal reasoning, and present preliminary evaluation
results that highlight Cora's superior performance compared to well-known LLM
and RAG baselines. | [
0.0547376052,
0.0854258835,
-0.0337433703,
0.0290511735,
-0.0527970344,
0.0081210472,
0.012830548,
0.0098395869,
0.0214371961,
-0.0001060583,
0.0186451171,
0.0368270725,
-0.0349054821,
0.0707079247,
-0.0001281729,
0.0003959525,
0.0402353816,
-0.008671985,
0.0948852599,
0.0035981324,
-0.0186181739,
0.0211366247,
-0.0245229844,
0.0005476804,
-0.0321310945,
-0.0043257466,
0.0054992535,
-0.0295273419,
0.021213131,
-0.0585470535,
-0.0295771379,
0.0357356854,
0.0553317964,
0.0432677194,
0.0000023676,
-0.0713421181,
-0.0307889767,
0.0060487217,
-0.021569455,
-0.0488511957,
0.0136741446,
-0.0245670211,
0.0159127079,
-0.0033067209,
-0.0595306531,
0.0330905728,
0.0293924864,
0.0203326438,
0.009973756,
0.0413611904,
-0.0193594787,
-0.0185403079,
0.0126509154,
-0.0257878583,
-0.0034964925,
-0.0050062705,
0.0526322536,
0.0162678696,
0.0289292429,
-0.0253446475,
0.02777512,
0.0385684967,
0.0180083588,
-0.0013745697,
-0.0262425523,
0.0385890268,
-0.0553750768,
-0.0252101067,
-0.0272809118,
0.0695366785,
0.0473401062,
-0.0119740786,
0.0375561267,
0.0204501208,
-0.0239114426,
0.0042357487,
-0.0395418294,
0.0648564771,
-0.0405076407,
-0.0006655681,
0.0121547049,
-0.0028605496,
0.043756716,
0.0348423421,
-0.041751679,
0.0926436111,
-0.0054105772,
-0.0288318768,
0.0222924352,
-0.0245620254,
-0.0348451473,
-0.0216946639,
0.0509579144,
0.0562036894,
-0.0342714414,
0.0422825292,
0.0017839674,
-0.0432254337,
0.0465681627,
-0.0356919952,
0.0099388771,
0.0298810434,
0.0226010662,
0.0554892831,
-0.0325298198,
-0.003487291,
-0.0353585109,
0.0483123064,
-0.0086039081,
-0.0109226825,
-0.0432640351,
-0.0207987241,
-0.029045118,
0.0467319936,
-0.0473911799,
-0.0281993169,
-0.0235431772,
-0.0090439525,
-0.0379874595,
0.0568229295,
-0.0083558289,
0.0370266326,
-0.0024443937,
-0.0251227543,
-0.0643755794,
0.0050626802,
-0.0439815894,
0.0298230909,
0.0084225014,
-0.0070717637,
0.0070896107,
-0.0024412393,
0.0060928175,
-0.0196259618,
0.023902107,
0.0795681328,
0.0310226548,
-0.0149018513,
-0.0436613485,
-0.0510788187,
0.0038982495,
-0.1013061255,
0.0133276097,
-0.0576060787,
0.0774914548,
0.012530541,
-0.0486284606,
-0.0819399208,
0.0302198827,
0.0028593377,
0.0124184974,
0.0391380191,
-0.0135313813,
-0.0346768089,
0.0364396647,
0.0164167397,
-0.0052892449,
0.0252821632,
0.0534502938,
0.0325381607,
0.0260965712,
0.0277842674,
-0.0385482647,
0.0027196582,
0.0215702076,
-0.0305156223,
-0.0132835694,
0.0204050113,
-0.0156292114,
0.0458736047,
-0.0271678306,
0.0555812232,
0.0026516444,
-0.0193547606,
0.0451880917,
0.0766318887,
0.0267633591,
0.010208738,
0.0354150645,
-0.0188897084,
0.0079920515,
-0.0770289004,
-0.0319732651,
0.0345995314,
-0.0465957113,
-0.0019388386,
-0.016770428,
0.0697334558,
0.0022204339,
-0.0574811958,
-0.0209608022,
0.0174013376,
-0.0064875102,
0.0101063494,
0.0759987012,
-0.0379583947,
-0.0074168416,
0.0140534872,
0.0406111553,
-0.0185160898,
-0.0238365401,
-0.0209343825,
0.0614645183,
0.0510397255,
0.0670102537,
-0.0557249524,
-0.0190232862,
0.0052643986,
-0.0407414772,
0.0559484325,
-0.000776578,
-0.0015091691,
-0.0138610722,
-0.032044176,
-0.0129644666,
0.0141975004,
0.0130795697,
0.0363994651,
0.023938559,
0.0307804663,
-0.0102859763,
-0.0173770674,
-0.0060433024,
0.044358436,
-0.0564055443,
-0.0261829887,
-0.0086501697,
0.0168624483,
0.0462343469,
0.0100699347,
0.0068465672,
0.0325674824,
0.0239543654,
-0.0356334522,
-0.0534889065,
0.0192057062,
0.0016848979,
-0.0166120995,
0.0315393806,
-0.0277978536,
-0.0107721714,
-0.011847862,
-0.0458858721,
-0.0221745037,
0.0462213196,
-0.0022796111,
-0.0069397087,
-0.0450026132,
-0.0253006648,
0.0374682955,
-0.024341736,
-0.0197136551,
0.0889435634,
0.0173611026,
-0.0264273975,
0.0465763099,
-0.0258968491,
0.0067238975,
-0.043888256,
-0.0024851442,
-0.0149156917,
-0.0096503105,
-0.0125521729,
0.0035463579,
-0.0490354635,
-0.0368622541,
0.0040828241,
-0.0473194346,
0.0563888401,
0.0179518685,
0.0172901787,
-0.0238203406,
-0.015747454,
-0.009922076,
-0.005462708,
-0.0228109658,
0.0307270903,
0.0211954527,
-0.0062923632,
0.0326439254,
0.0520510897,
-0.01175295,
-0.0346674211,
0.0009614346,
-0.0682138354,
0.0293992404,
0.0532974042,
-0.0086808382,
-0.0145055605,
0.0077874046,
-0.0706184655,
0.0565316342,
-0.0255862884,
0.022763744,
-0.001136633,
-0.0353362486,
-0.0273304209,
0.057208471,
-0.0013305825,
0.0151899867,
0.0489575788,
-0.0084061958,
-0.0569293573,
0.0448623523,
-0.0413210057,
0.0516541824,
0.0066468739,
-0.0021901249,
0.018717818,
0.0566455275,
0.0083392346,
0.0018085899,
-0.0332519189,
0.0348922275,
0.0101560429,
-0.004497075,
-0.028528804,
0.0046436135,
0.0267857611,
0.0616455376,
-0.0231183488,
-0.043362543,
0.1052986309,
-0.0018034246,
0.0441192612,
-0.0448093005,
-0.0281067807,
-0.0683065727,
0.0725930333,
-0.0061815991,
0.0156779308,
0.0138101485,
0.0161093641,
-0.0092224432,
-0.0124125173,
0.0074402741,
-0.0426198058,
0.0285509303,
-0.0678559989,
0.0395498425,
0.0083548399,
-0.0568798073,
-0.031190969,
-0.004213592,
-0.0335373022,
0.0192272998,
0.0235692319,
-0.0215705652,
-0.0490427092,
-0.0014548376,
0.0220408905,
0.0312352907,
0.0015859471,
-0.0106881279,
-0.0399393961,
0.0013029908,
0.0709342584,
0.0036108815,
0.0348611511,
-0.009740456,
0.0080153095,
0.0485433638,
-0.0110663101,
-0.0116968555,
-0.0438998342,
0.0075559183,
-0.0093924887,
-0.0416169725,
0.0428087413,
0.0385740139,
-0.0406715535,
-0.0742702708,
-0.007394908,
0.0761131272,
0.0352759622,
-0.0309431199,
0.0003025019,
-0.0358155482,
-0.0055388738,
0.0117005371,
0.0716324002,
-0.1264135391,
-0.0283010565,
-0.0056134542,
-0.0029930635,
-0.0093891099,
-0.067657873,
-0.023523014,
-0.0946722478,
0.0629123524,
-0.0140891531,
-0.0296524148,
-0.0131232413,
-0.0429350957,
0.0102127185,
-0.0086850571,
-0.0462664552,
0.0148763582,
-0.0057946052,
-0.0173455607,
-0.0129566835,
-0.0083648516,
0.0034291144,
0.023324037,
-0.0490252301,
0.0084551424,
0.0149337687,
0.0327901319,
0.0010292727,
-0.0257219784,
-0.0325477943,
0.0165473111,
0.0229447465,
-0.03280003,
0.0164874867,
0.0176853202,
0.0112559674,
-0.0543240309,
0.0579084121,
-0.0605428554,
-0.0341311209,
0.0280201957,
0.0832171589,
-0.0442234837,
-0.0108309835,
-0.0505948104,
0.0073933462,
0.0079747997,
0.0749880224,
-0.0469385944,
0.0136393085,
-0.0714437962,
0.0087821633,
0.0056835744,
-0.0382150151,
0.0034256403,
0.0118035842,
-0.0211513545,
0.0298863165,
-0.0664453879,
-0.0063617188,
0.0414402969,
0.0334760435,
0.0153930662,
-0.0145611726,
0.0422250256,
-0.0191964097,
-0.0600427836,
0.0585877225,
-0.0462495759,
0.015611128,
-0.0053467965,
0.0232133195,
0.0010323859,
-0.0523986146,
-0.0339565836,
0.0388649069,
-0.04526316,
-0.0445110314,
-0.043117594,
0.0460463092,
0.0250714254,
0.0228428394,
-0.0237325076,
0.0261828415,
0.0422754139,
0.0511418544,
-0.0285122581,
-0.0348163061,
-0.0177820567,
0.0118920961,
-0.0173134133,
0.0036455342,
-0.0332570858,
0.0292309765,
-0.0108445249,
0.0760593712,
-0.0394411981,
-0.0156475008,
0.0299746599,
0.0399855301,
0.0334880948,
0.010778592,
-0.0339155644,
-0.040690355,
0.0041702571,
-0.0296779145,
-0.0157437548,
-0.0192845389,
0.0110376356,
-0.0169055909,
-0.0047302204,
-0.0033128762,
-0.0045689228,
0.0286041442,
-0.0087329708,
-0.0253283437,
0.0044533554,
0.031515643,
-0.0017267553,
0.0187345762,
-0.0367388614,
-0.0038888673,
0.0353125967,
-0.011104282,
0.0742357597,
-0.033319924,
0.0650923848,
0.0369057097,
-0.0128778461,
-0.0619389862,
-0.0008635251,
-0.0378167443,
-0.0407073125,
0.015893966,
-0.0126463957,
0.0170055218,
0.0262607653,
-0.0015021291,
-0.0767567605,
0.0037841368,
0.0179318972,
0.0030156577,
-0.0156403687,
-0.0253246352,
0.0512056574,
0.0284531265,
-0.0000649909,
-0.024641633,
0.0372448303,
-0.0236022063,
0.0589501783,
-0.0272624604,
-0.0470021442,
-0.0249033738,
-0.0628419891,
-0.0027885807,
-0.0126282806,
-0.0332606956,
-0.0307663325,
-0.0785877034,
-0.0354328007,
0.0112994965,
0.0513794273,
-0.0248699524,
-0.0074071344,
0.023637224,
0.0441474095,
0.0194721092,
-0.0625394732,
-0.0055389437,
0.0184483472,
-0.0689847022,
-0.0252696276,
-0.0079479404,
-6.791372327e-33,
0.0130710499,
-0.03828419,
0.0809435099,
-0.0110761141,
-0.0098986859,
-0.002167704,
-0.0593787879,
-0.0342853256,
0.0009691204,
0.0200186707,
-0.0049003651,
0.005422072,
-0.001445792,
0.0084618498,
0.0226742066,
0.0106425956,
-0.0204497334,
0.0352143571,
-0.028453121,
-0.0244801585,
0.0785466656,
0.0190097447,
-0.0059121228,
-0.0346766114,
-0.007724646,
0.0243276302,
0.0174412634,
0.0340364911,
-0.0645813271,
0.0407300554,
-0.0101923738,
0.0258111954,
0.0024775141,
-0.0236449465,
0.0332740098,
0.0274232868,
-0.0840241686,
-0.0444226488,
0.0111279497,
-0.0506724082,
-0.0416827388,
-0.030240085,
0.0400056764,
-0.0010285885,
0.01250224,
0.0053928718,
0.0367382243,
-0.0486509465,
0.0081420746,
-0.114199169,
-0.0855216309,
0.0262517743,
-0.0205886438,
0.0320828333,
0.0006067313,
0.0238938667,
-0.0118422089,
0.0471678413,
-0.0479487516,
0.0242847055,
-0.0284699257,
-0.0248207748,
0.0558128431,
-0.0242676698,
0.0052280049,
0.0468506366,
-0.0355814993,
-0.0189149715,
-0.0497307926,
0.0236116834,
-0.0098651014,
0.107654199,
0.0261196047,
0.0307499077,
0.0303022321,
0.0294834245,
-0.1082524881,
0.0476660207,
0.0317235291,
0.08439105,
0.036906641,
0.0196230225,
-0.037537951,
0.0009742327,
-0.0187399015,
0.0134236524,
-0.0467226431,
-0.0261717588,
0.019823378,
-0.0004527015,
-0.0168711487,
0.0286464114,
0.0021507193,
-0.0259719342,
-0.0009649115,
0.0240014493,
0.0439795181,
-0.0047285687,
-0.0247691516,
0.0284524299,
-0.050279323,
-0.0363902301,
0.0035576972,
-0.0136157926,
0.0319760777,
0.0216443632,
0.0243108347,
0.0008323431,
-0.0044519771,
-0.0056354254,
-0.022993926,
0.0109997774,
0.0067858826,
-0.0217049941,
0.0199651606,
0.0421175398,
0.0071484828,
-0.0081675397,
0.0232443623,
0.0312525705,
-0.0149428593,
0.0368981101,
0.0138173671,
-0.0082475217,
-0.0121194823,
-0.002096964,
-0.0422616079,
0.0421558134,
0.0035224955,
-0.07387916,
0.0134036466,
0.0567005761,
3.23e-7,
0.0325917751,
0.0573463328,
0.0328045599,
0.0228127856,
0.0220563449,
0.0052253036,
0.0010233565,
-0.0171028953,
-0.0056917085,
-0.0333466455,
0.0332317427,
0.0535753742,
0.0224537626,
0.058403071,
-0.043956276,
-0.0019664899,
-0.0350101218,
-0.0577229112,
-0.0876759216,
0.0017213298,
0.0493855476,
0.049650602,
0.0202343613,
-0.0237879083,
0.0072722794,
-0.0394338034,
0.0472239628,
-0.0167448483,
0.0352594554,
0.0157568417,
0.0175441168,
-0.0366861634,
-0.0050003896,
0.0442519225,
-0.0031119408,
0.0284029972,
-0.0428463295,
0.0713870451,
0.0007633721,
0.0088122999,
0.0092181247,
-0.0339840204,
0.0142407333,
-0.0381434485,
0.0706655756,
-0.0686179698,
-0.0493355319,
-0.0008391235,
-0.0242491569,
-0.0229744241,
-0.0167208519,
-0.0038008294,
0.025843367,
-0.0066648717,
-0.0129376035,
-0.0064710751,
-0.0109182587,
-0.090070799,
0.01490629,
0.0342406966,
-0.058937002,
0.0040270886,
-0.0229378473,
0.0065926658,
0.032893002,
-0.0876318514,
0.0153091112,
2.952581915e-34,
0.0028161239,
0.0147438142,
-0.0181817673,
0.013379978,
0.0632762387,
0.0161308814,
-0.078224808,
0.0347586609,
0.0048387023,
-0.1020809785,
-0.0116387336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17982v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17982v1 | EDEN: Empathetic Dialogues for English learning | 2024-06-25T23:36:16 | 2024-06-25T23:36:16 | Li Siyan, Teresa Shao, Zhou Yu, Julia Hirschberg | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue systems have been used as conversation partners in English learning,
but few have studied whether these systems improve learning outcomes. Student
passion and perseverance, or grit, has been associated with language learning
success. Recent work establishes that as students perceive their English
teachers to be more supportive, their grit improves. Hypothesizing that the
same pattern applies to English-teaching chatbots, we create EDEN, a robust
open-domain chatbot for spoken conversation practice that provides empathetic
feedback. To construct EDEN, we first train a specialized spoken utterance
grammar correction model and a high-quality social chit-chat conversation
model. We then conduct a preliminary user study with a variety of strategies
for empathetic feedback. Our experiment suggests that using adaptive empathetic
feedback leads to higher perceived affective support, which, in turn, predicts
increased student grit. | EDEN: Empathetic Dialogues for English learning: Dialogue systems have been used as conversation partners in English learning,
but few have studied whether these systems improve learning outcomes. Student
passion and perseverance, or grit, has been associated with language learning
success. Recent work establishes that as students perceive their English
teachers to be more supportive, their grit improves. Hypothesizing that the
same pattern applies to English-teaching chatbots, we create EDEN, a robust
open-domain chatbot for spoken conversation practice that provides empathetic
feedback. To construct EDEN, we first train a specialized spoken utterance
grammar correction model and a high-quality social chit-chat conversation
model. We then conduct a preliminary user study with a variety of strategies
for empathetic feedback. Our experiment suggests that using adaptive empathetic
feedback leads to higher perceived affective support, which, in turn, predicts
increased student grit. | [
0.0564788394,
-0.0215368364,
-0.0513057634,
0.008278613,
-0.0237103496,
0.026714839,
-0.0166413356,
-0.036661759,
0.0356718153,
-0.0169675723,
-0.0084185377,
0.0430875868,
-0.01544022,
-0.0126243765,
0.0290091466,
-0.0777556524,
0.0334555842,
0.0219691377,
0.0342847556,
0.0116442209,
0.0492649898,
0.0249298271,
-0.0444328189,
0.066154398,
-0.043109104,
-0.0337239355,
-0.0561996549,
0.0125661576,
0.0076222112,
0.0039332486,
0.0914875716,
0.0344046764,
-0.0192183312,
0.0212728884,
0.0000018665,
-0.0164835136,
-0.0201732162,
-0.0526886359,
-0.0365568399,
-0.0126293264,
0.0490809195,
0.0427362174,
-0.0251450464,
0.045106709,
-0.0393503793,
0.0214966331,
0.0467140935,
-0.0209583063,
0.0823878646,
0.0539714061,
-0.0134119261,
-0.0008736208,
-0.0026534644,
0.0257709362,
-0.0181074739,
0.0156580377,
-0.0258032884,
0.0242531002,
0.0417498164,
-0.0210035462,
-0.0293520633,
0.0304586943,
0.0095069902,
-0.0571753457,
0.0310148876,
0.0164618567,
-0.0469942428,
-0.0482620709,
-0.005047326,
0.0418221466,
0.0388770625,
0.0131202657,
-0.0099044628,
0.011180439,
0.0751108453,
-0.0173210632,
-0.0587668903,
-0.0049295775,
0.0074946433,
0.0164259728,
-0.0055709826,
-0.0562573746,
-0.0657513142,
0.0239174645,
0.0568576977,
-0.0421753787,
-0.0110133896,
-0.0209218767,
-0.0290533956,
0.0470228121,
0.0078928154,
-0.0650333464,
0.0390589684,
0.0362735465,
-0.0370929725,
0.0258942582,
-0.0348221399,
-0.0123223849,
-0.0160515029,
-0.0114108883,
-0.0498912893,
0.0714417771,
-0.014568897,
-0.0003298833,
0.0450954735,
0.0253177993,
0.0830123425,
0.0596612021,
0.0053874631,
0.0034592743,
-0.0429235138,
-0.0103551168,
-0.0386221968,
0.044686269,
0.0115276901,
0.0000449816,
-0.0817890391,
0.0089962892,
0.0037181862,
0.0258402806,
-0.0306034442,
-0.0245142244,
-0.0238554925,
0.0149774775,
-0.0218389798,
0.0315764323,
-0.0377820432,
-0.0088547952,
0.0339911059,
-0.0709913447,
-0.0003295966,
-0.0045422902,
0.0186623577,
-0.0159672983,
-0.011877995,
0.0051234327,
-0.0113113523,
-0.0545127168,
-0.0057417946,
0.0169437323,
-0.0053945514,
-0.0450939611,
-0.0107799526,
-0.0176504031,
-0.0247262102,
0.0017510342,
0.0112558007,
-0.0448792614,
-0.000425347,
0.0200402029,
0.0040388317,
0.0219603498,
-0.0428374037,
0.011633887,
0.0495830774,
0.0064441245,
0.0305597596,
0.0208273288,
0.0235351697,
-0.0247030612,
0.029403124,
-0.0394581221,
0.0183226112,
0.0179700777,
-0.0156194679,
-0.0408340544,
0.0299191084,
-0.0463710278,
0.0072407988,
0.0254348535,
-0.0004082256,
0.0243824422,
-0.0238605607,
0.0199795291,
0.054074306,
0.0681784898,
-0.0073594199,
0.0610523969,
-0.0390451252,
0.0034135298,
0.0399146974,
0.0267265085,
-0.0178519133,
0.0134427501,
-0.0036244479,
-0.0336094126,
0.0157039352,
-0.0126345856,
-0.0032860006,
-0.052704528,
-0.0296007581,
-0.0227740575,
0.0365266688,
0.0276346561,
0.0213716719,
-0.0097026881,
-0.0043154326,
-0.0157566462,
0.0438312441,
-0.101958558,
-0.0194501374,
-0.0519425496,
0.015638886,
0.1071770191,
0.035286732,
-0.029469315,
-0.0550494827,
0.0066538216,
-0.0087734759,
0.0210061651,
0.066838555,
-0.0208917353,
0.0284856092,
-0.0168863218,
0.0212440137,
-0.0214819964,
0.0013293088,
-0.030091919,
-0.0108777098,
0.0374858975,
-0.0405832976,
0.0538502559,
-0.0447790101,
0.0093179317,
-0.040477749,
-0.0122251641,
-0.0416212752,
0.005502949,
-0.0147760659,
0.0271842703,
-0.004313672,
-0.0288944896,
-0.0160953645,
0.0297605451,
0.0037172853,
0.074889794,
-0.0219713729,
-0.0451899245,
0.0592200346,
-0.0001054993,
-0.0229461975,
0.029420007,
0.0178378932,
-0.0049099945,
0.0603109114,
-0.0543277003,
0.0909997672,
0.0126353139,
0.0563501418,
-0.0772295743,
-0.0007500852,
-0.0395071581,
-0.0435280427,
0.0425683074,
-0.0097913826,
-0.0159898493,
-0.024411466,
-0.0297476165,
-0.0386876911,
-0.0198755786,
0.0166025925,
0.003515068,
-0.0115421163,
-0.0002443074,
0.013195483,
-0.1159928665,
-0.0362101309,
-0.1031500176,
-0.0081083812,
0.0190838855,
-0.0234695617,
0.0052860533,
-0.0131142,
-0.0291251633,
-0.0336753167,
-0.0363744684,
0.0595199391,
0.0175570324,
-0.022620758,
0.0271203909,
-0.0376583673,
-0.0132367425,
-0.1015908644,
-0.0090440577,
-0.036016278,
-0.0130780833,
0.0533107147,
0.0208282545,
-0.0386447348,
0.0451799482,
-0.0037056028,
0.005924284,
0.0128161535,
-0.0898966342,
0.0353299491,
-0.0154882306,
0.0488814637,
0.072672911,
0.0176656041,
0.0516110398,
-0.0046842513,
-0.0460345112,
-0.0621361434,
0.0285498984,
0.0251407977,
-0.0136279995,
-0.0192539878,
-0.0519836843,
-0.0410832874,
0.0078858053,
0.0298194159,
0.0118846316,
-0.0496857092,
0.046614781,
0.0193399116,
-0.0049420265,
-0.0121930297,
-0.0148187755,
-0.0064256862,
-0.0284114368,
0.018986512,
-0.0392451175,
0.0618858226,
0.0351633802,
-0.0330651253,
-0.0558383837,
-0.0110720498,
0.0228683352,
0.0257317238,
-0.0609157197,
0.0114726443,
0.0585615709,
-0.0250564702,
-0.0057420661,
-0.0264447909,
0.0353541933,
-0.0561197959,
-0.0041702311,
-0.0282902457,
-0.0457316488,
0.0486365743,
-0.0142657673,
-0.0465574004,
-0.0294729378,
-0.0536119379,
-0.0158325639,
0.0297804028,
-0.0100169061,
-0.0276528187,
-0.0599923655,
0.0233441032,
0.0146392025,
-0.038767796,
-0.0277898256,
0.0334688425,
-0.0481434278,
0.0161957368,
0.0481514893,
0.0385922194,
-0.0178978499,
0.112632513,
0.0346007608,
0.0511090569,
0.0162061602,
0.0185460486,
-0.0193853769,
0.0359281711,
-0.0003977797,
-0.0346504413,
-0.019167304,
0.08981096,
-0.0313433595,
-0.0330269076,
0.122531496,
0.0096892621,
-0.0271618254,
-0.0019658003,
-0.0544173643,
0.0233642459,
0.0110081108,
0.0238547008,
-0.012074179,
-0.0219143964,
0.004712359,
0.0482772402,
0.0064340942,
-0.0108873295,
0.0184632,
-0.0561369471,
0.0345350988,
0.0013087798,
-0.020382354,
-0.0148030622,
-0.0193081144,
-0.0080883382,
0.0205885656,
0.0299699828,
-0.0075587975,
-0.0028847465,
0.0132018467,
0.0171580054,
-0.0004662271,
-0.0067041041,
0.0167699866,
-0.0433303416,
0.0743592754,
0.0282607563,
0.0597633682,
0.019250989,
-0.0041829688,
0.0166541692,
0.0671823323,
-0.0123306802,
-0.0083917435,
0.0604920164,
-0.0141571248,
-0.0059223156,
-0.047565423,
0.0343698822,
-0.0113792028,
-0.0092747277,
0.0696450919,
0.0294408835,
0.0074362061,
0.0311263148,
0.0070873396,
0.0297819842,
0.0236786027,
0.0327891856,
0.0208634827,
-0.0657058358,
0.0058181793,
-0.0249357969,
0.009747724,
0.014574076,
-0.0698847249,
0.007754487,
-0.0238888189,
0.0272831898,
-0.0560431518,
-0.0658483133,
0.0565223768,
0.0150569957,
0.0241281893,
-0.0357260406,
0.020301627,
0.0485585853,
0.0094673056,
-0.0132209444,
0.0134502519,
0.0309371147,
-0.0591974854,
-0.0395735577,
0.0029807761,
-0.0190644991,
0.0234612767,
-0.0367095694,
-0.0089009935,
-0.0477945469,
0.0150522431,
0.0389588885,
0.0137528544,
0.0106067536,
0.0188565403,
-0.0623757243,
-0.0796657726,
-0.0114354705,
-0.0149734952,
0.0403998308,
0.0321270227,
0.0334325433,
0.0158888455,
0.005778884,
0.0043662195,
-0.0343285389,
-0.0009967895,
0.0086908424,
0.0190317612,
-0.0286656842,
0.0487832129,
0.0469131172,
0.0081021991,
-0.0013320541,
-0.0420928597,
-0.0241816398,
0.0179031584,
-0.0532788634,
-0.0086092353,
-0.0323381834,
-0.0226866826,
-0.0269606691,
-0.0046897945,
-0.0014362662,
-0.0659553632,
-0.0805946216,
0.0097728958,
-0.0613466874,
0.0396816246,
-0.0104811424,
-0.0152986525,
-0.0225273389,
0.0161320958,
0.0031151418,
-0.0016180385,
0.0197847411,
0.0465724207,
0.0036477856,
0.0921758711,
-0.0171478186,
-0.0429940857,
0.0603942387,
-0.0058421497,
-0.0341261066,
-0.0196207929,
0.0096759805,
0.0625916198,
0.0136366468,
0.0133043434,
0.0275339466,
-0.0392894261,
0.0285106655,
-0.0068097105,
0.0234700255,
-0.0186322015,
-0.0284839496,
-0.0224718563,
-0.0244972315,
-0.0123524787,
-0.0203472134,
-0.0007041281,
-0.0452385619,
0.0504594445,
-0.0177167505,
-0.0119094141,
-0.0303368066,
0.0021875063,
0.0359645113,
0.0116604446,
0.0127681717,
0.0412670039,
-0.0300408453,
-0.0418004096,
-0.033788424,
0.028619824,
0.0192563646,
-0.0596067235,
0.0112938797,
0.0350978449,
-0.0636734813,
0.0017871422,
-0.0497744866,
0.0325601362,
-0.0466767475,
-0.0075538526,
-0.0059022228,
-5.299945135e-33,
-0.0240248386,
-0.0039732517,
-0.018411126,
0.0655130967,
-0.0428000689,
-0.0073926747,
-0.0559834167,
0.0565394647,
-0.0056637069,
0.0124815023,
-0.0409009196,
0.0895692855,
-0.0040121777,
-0.0125218984,
0.0534005649,
0.0126392376,
0.0289312415,
0.0063651851,
0.0207459442,
0.0054391632,
-0.010733394,
0.0249130093,
0.0695776269,
-0.0616211072,
0.0419483259,
0.0122706508,
0.0038747068,
-0.014943325,
0.0257366542,
0.0255358126,
0.0156368334,
0.0377628952,
-0.0107090808,
0.0273977686,
-0.0155117577,
0.0036932882,
-0.0127690649,
-0.0481447838,
-0.0271786898,
0.0251949392,
-0.0314509124,
-0.0279981345,
0.0111376485,
-0.0102895014,
-0.0396951847,
0.0046908245,
0.028025968,
0.0039165793,
0.0565892309,
0.0586730465,
-0.0441930071,
-0.0082775494,
-0.0546469651,
-0.0841316655,
-0.0349366739,
0.0675702468,
0.013984248,
-0.0439966321,
0.0099990368,
0.059743233,
0.0018745436,
-0.0039370386,
0.0279062875,
-0.0318215415,
-0.0127721215,
0.0645198822,
0.02262518,
0.0457891189,
0.0216036756,
0.0084578609,
0.058382567,
0.0094778836,
0.0643642023,
0.0629600734,
-0.034432359,
-0.0587877482,
-0.0182602312,
0.0390045866,
0.1050227061,
0.0147812301,
-0.0331185535,
0.0381795354,
-0.0525015593,
-0.0103843082,
-0.0159728713,
-0.0091696596,
0.0141207566,
-0.0277363807,
0.0252942964,
-0.0228625424,
0.0046780137,
-0.0910632834,
-0.0399635509,
-0.0290855207,
0.0089571625,
0.0076648337,
-0.0614478178,
0.0282419566,
-0.0264404137,
-0.0109852524,
0.0070168399,
-0.0265592802,
-0.0103327865,
0.0329720303,
0.0558513552,
0.0242149197,
-0.0283228401,
0.0544938408,
-0.0178793799,
-0.0060718362,
-0.023425635,
0.0586708821,
0.0125388885,
-0.0610001832,
-0.0210215952,
0.0150726885,
-0.0090118283,
0.0314670876,
0.0203271061,
-0.0094634863,
-0.0744791403,
-0.0539748073,
0.026955111,
-0.0182357468,
-0.0432325192,
-0.0423611253,
-0.0206789691,
0.014700071,
0.0021916223,
-0.0578349307,
-0.0255443472,
-0.0432909094,
2.634e-7,
-0.0367499255,
0.0648830682,
-0.0020054486,
-0.0235843565,
0.0188443065,
0.0478038453,
-0.0156761799,
0.0246652737,
0.0426358022,
0.0189702958,
-0.0131897591,
-0.0003831361,
0.0639375448,
0.0211829729,
-0.0631917939,
-0.0347412005,
-0.0202485304,
-0.0037287192,
0.0003269569,
0.0120606543,
0.0869523287,
0.0168182515,
0.0556819327,
-0.002204692,
0.0031658334,
0.0208616219,
-0.0176581591,
-0.028184602,
0.0134075349,
0.0199903809,
-0.012257901,
-0.0136131775,
0.0235431921,
0.0108574508,
0.0062626484,
0.0076048318,
0.0123647153,
0.0756592229,
-0.0016766178,
-0.0069036926,
0.0400609337,
0.0523346178,
-0.0330973789,
-0.0428187065,
0.0031096698,
-0.046869006,
-0.0051204539,
0.0088506546,
0.0138276191,
-0.0489652045,
0.0355049074,
-0.0327613689,
-0.0467277169,
0.0278462768,
-0.0219912156,
-0.0087627079,
0.0199043918,
-0.0170392022,
0.0141060632,
-0.0055473475,
-0.0310666114,
-0.0561709739,
-0.0134980101,
-0.0425776504,
-0.035089545,
0.0040518129,
0.0054887296,
1.444883562e-34,
-0.0280931853,
-0.0030028634,
0.0652540177,
0.0694048628,
0.0526831299,
0.0204667021,
0.0608579181,
0.0330101214,
0.0557263829,
-0.007392887,
-0.052549582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17975v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17975v1 | Inherent Challenges of Post-Hoc Membership Inference for Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T23:12:07 | 2024-06-25T23:12:07 | Matthieu Meeus, Shubham Jain, Marek Rei, Yves-Alexandre de Montjoye | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) are often trained on vast amounts of undisclosed
data, motivating the development of post-hoc Membership Inference Attacks
(MIAs) to gain insight into their training data composition. However, in this
paper, we identify inherent challenges in post-hoc MIA evaluation due to
potential distribution shifts between collected member and non-member datasets.
Using a simple bag-of-words classifier, we demonstrate that datasets used in
recent post-hoc MIAs suffer from significant distribution shifts, in some cases
achieving near-perfect distinction between members and non-members. This
implies that previously reported high MIA performance may be largely
attributable to these shifts rather than model memorization. We confirm that
randomized, controlled setups eliminate such shifts and thus enable the
development and fair evaluation of new MIAs. However, we note that such
randomized setups are rarely available for the latest LLMs, making post-hoc
data collection still required to infer membership for real-world LLMs. As a
potential solution, we propose a Regression Discontinuity Design (RDD) approach
for post-hoc data collection, which substantially mitigates distribution
shifts. Evaluating various MIA methods on this RDD setup yields performance
barely above random guessing, in stark contrast to previously reported results.
Overall, our findings highlight the challenges in accurately measuring LLM
memorization and the need for careful experimental design in (post-hoc)
membership inference tasks. | Inherent Challenges of Post-Hoc Membership Inference for Large Language Models: Large Language Models (LLMs) are often trained on vast amounts of undisclosed
data, motivating the development of post-hoc Membership Inference Attacks
(MIAs) to gain insight into their training data composition. However, in this
paper, we identify inherent challenges in post-hoc MIA evaluation due to
potential distribution shifts between collected member and non-member datasets.
Using a simple bag-of-words classifier, we demonstrate that datasets used in
recent post-hoc MIAs suffer from significant distribution shifts, in some cases
achieving near-perfect distinction between members and non-members. This
implies that previously reported high MIA performance may be largely
attributable to these shifts rather than model memorization. We confirm that
randomized, controlled setups eliminate such shifts and thus enable the
development and fair evaluation of new MIAs. However, we note that such
randomized setups are rarely available for the latest LLMs, making post-hoc
data collection still required to infer membership for real-world LLMs. As a
potential solution, we propose a Regression Discontinuity Design (RDD) approach
for post-hoc data collection, which substantially mitigates distribution
shifts. Evaluating various MIA methods on this RDD setup yields performance
barely above random guessing, in stark contrast to previously reported results.
Overall, our findings highlight the challenges in accurately measuring LLM
memorization and the need for careful experimental design in (post-hoc)
membership inference tasks. | [
0.01495991,
0.1391713321,
-0.023866253,
0.0533307642,
-0.0542635582,
0.0041412972,
0.0241355281,
-0.0256790835,
0.0011719387,
-0.0553536527,
-0.0013607751,
-0.0650284439,
0.0104936063,
-0.0170778129,
0.0125235692,
0.032733053,
0.0672267079,
-0.0525487401,
-0.0322337449,
-0.0486888327,
-0.0258436818,
-0.00273772,
0.0031732195,
0.0042242217,
-0.0041058403,
-0.001017804,
-0.0121407267,
-0.0036130743,
0.0068711946,
-0.0196913742,
0.0480940491,
0.1043960825,
0.013540579,
0.1133909523,
0.0000021565,
-0.0357908495,
-0.0523572527,
0.0224234033,
-0.0535851344,
0.0166980904,
0.0060290699,
-0.0010478731,
0.0270276424,
0.01381128,
-0.0008323616,
-0.0092654973,
0.0682884455,
-0.0136825005,
-0.0132311732,
0.0915874541,
0.0041902279,
-0.0320335962,
-0.0031136291,
-0.0196786132,
0.0126017798,
-0.0017090373,
0.031112548,
-0.0489667431,
-0.007227465,
-0.0467259772,
-0.0311766453,
0.0226882752,
0.0132078398,
0.0383017957,
0.0013345005,
0.0510805286,
-0.0830036327,
-0.0241864659,
0.0041467617,
0.0379234403,
0.0084159859,
-0.0288546588,
-0.0026249271,
0.0225157831,
0.0018720191,
0.048863776,
-0.0232027527,
0.0091727199,
0.0135276131,
0.0162470061,
-0.0108867232,
0.0190369114,
0.0499505587,
0.0131070521,
-0.0660118237,
0.0381760597,
0.0224870592,
-0.0327522121,
-0.010835249,
-0.0088695334,
-0.0462994091,
-0.0248001982,
-0.0327529833,
-0.0272874217,
-0.013618229,
0.0281328205,
-0.0310416408,
-0.0290553458,
0.0252819415,
-0.0380373411,
0.0344858989,
0.0143287042,
-0.0158107933,
0.0291668698,
-0.0199361239,
0.018323794,
0.0265417118,
0.029607391,
-0.0242413413,
0.011510306,
-0.033533752,
0.0032698216,
0.0400396734,
0.0304762684,
0.0295391381,
-0.0012314419,
-0.0522126667,
0.004419636,
-0.0276105329,
0.0043300223,
-0.0389201604,
-0.0132744471,
-0.0175734479,
0.0167322867,
0.0080686845,
0.0108873332,
0.0035146854,
0.0205393303,
-0.0111287627,
-0.0568747446,
-0.0296672825,
0.0081891995,
-0.0176285766,
-0.0324772298,
0.0176969655,
0.0651756823,
0.0079064714,
-0.085594818,
-0.0290843714,
-0.0119185178,
-0.0297995079,
-0.0951278508,
0.0319275558,
-0.0820012763,
0.0351799615,
0.0161795691,
0.0002768301,
-0.0385047905,
0.0050540329,
0.0115148546,
-0.0601128675,
0.0841689408,
-0.0149156218,
0.0097503336,
-0.0341504142,
-0.0009593507,
0.0192695316,
0.1128140688,
-0.0040347902,
-0.0015469565,
0.0664328858,
0.0110679306,
-0.0015393613,
0.0322285369,
0.0318059735,
0.0147774201,
-0.0320508815,
-0.0154678058,
0.038849514,
-0.0348858237,
-0.0066704294,
0.0173481312,
-0.0011674071,
-0.0219336729,
0.0741749331,
0.0527908057,
-0.0151540823,
-0.003974475,
-0.0206499957,
-0.0075390446,
-0.0098111024,
0.0148091614,
-0.0837555155,
-0.040608827,
-0.0782747567,
-0.0136373825,
0.0269213375,
0.0338871256,
-0.010262033,
-0.0166464467,
-0.0243434105,
-0.0114057558,
0.0087309899,
0.0384409837,
0.0594955459,
-0.0206771828,
0.017799357,
0.0651724637,
0.0624731705,
-0.0413830206,
-0.0045843283,
-0.0532663539,
0.0369133428,
0.0057420791,
0.0396587588,
-0.0513618663,
0.0172841791,
0.0010559261,
0.0522782691,
0.0009828282,
0.0315606333,
0.0138381859,
0.0304427911,
-0.0364979729,
-0.0245234054,
0.0278197769,
0.0616959408,
0.0381411351,
0.0583860762,
-0.0019793164,
0.0142436624,
-0.0554093346,
-0.0222706534,
0.0445427187,
-0.0147770057,
-0.0182248,
0.0209483672,
-0.00845055,
0.0402959622,
-0.0093183815,
-0.0519536287,
-0.0158930812,
0.0178419519,
0.0030784726,
-0.0059359558,
-0.0239686407,
0.0215654466,
-0.0336886644,
0.0332037471,
0.0181977581,
-0.0085316589,
0.0655523986,
-0.050626833,
-0.0128500154,
0.0199847072,
-0.0159866456,
0.0383522846,
-0.034731511,
0.0324798264,
-0.0378080569,
0.0517993681,
-0.0300588515,
0.050159581,
-0.0226084776,
0.0256578308,
-0.0018599764,
-0.0233816113,
0.0128243277,
-0.0435322113,
-0.0802083388,
0.0511272773,
-0.0224472135,
0.0152542563,
0.0193390828,
-0.0310455132,
-0.0136759691,
-0.0144212591,
-0.0545298532,
0.0221056063,
-0.0395490602,
0.0022693702,
-0.0243189074,
-0.0212165136,
-0.0369939953,
-0.0159735121,
0.0106542939,
-0.0023772928,
-0.0294467267,
0.0533251241,
-0.0194896124,
-0.0180993099,
-0.0398493111,
-0.0201387722,
-0.0216250774,
-0.0032139844,
0.0947839022,
-0.005453852,
0.0091437194,
-0.0149619468,
-0.0028045687,
-0.0544527136,
0.0149988718,
-0.0086061265,
-0.0408658944,
-0.0027945405,
-0.0084777158,
0.0070740995,
0.0409065448,
0.0163955819,
0.0095172534,
0.077857241,
-0.0158447046,
-0.0207849685,
-0.0189386476,
-0.0205020402,
-0.0140970154,
-0.0167773422,
-0.0340797938,
-0.0038380856,
0.0594427548,
-0.002914872,
-0.0394221209,
0.0050965729,
0.014437139,
-0.0279356204,
-0.0042632795,
-0.0194530878,
0.0135224853,
-0.0291221067,
0.0223320853,
-0.0107020624,
-0.0852332041,
0.0404613949,
-0.0408204906,
0.0212312918,
-0.0334153399,
-0.0299353711,
0.007362105,
0.0435012989,
0.0329707712,
0.0105363615,
0.0494821444,
0.0037992424,
-0.0460895672,
-0.0209094267,
0.0486699417,
-0.0341773443,
0.0336736329,
-0.0574233048,
0.0416497365,
-0.0058468934,
-0.0005394626,
-0.0681163594,
-0.0697681755,
-0.0062506916,
-0.0056885146,
-0.0274014864,
-0.0283289831,
-0.0273562931,
-0.0021036873,
-0.0015257604,
0.0070073199,
-0.0169824064,
0.0203540009,
0.0061098128,
0.0143610276,
0.0326999091,
-0.0123851905,
0.0356006585,
-0.0739572793,
-0.0112447152,
0.0444169976,
0.019239787,
0.0405908339,
-0.0185750779,
-0.0293264296,
0.0431838334,
-0.0206744745,
-0.0079211574,
0.0296535846,
0.0235291142,
-0.0489507467,
0.0023379175,
0.1017261297,
0.0259846654,
-0.0643710569,
0.0121497195,
0.0355937146,
0.1020279378,
0.0071827322,
0.0023822756,
-0.0742704868,
-0.0044544763,
0.0258932319,
0.0238257982,
-0.0474774092,
-0.0403646752,
-0.0115541779,
-0.1190766022,
0.0382211134,
0.0114675248,
-0.0834714845,
0.0192710534,
-0.0382378846,
0.0333784632,
-0.0205175895,
0.0233631171,
-0.0024376742,
-0.0216745064,
-0.0128641985,
0.0136116268,
-0.0665415376,
-0.075166367,
-0.0014316157,
-0.0368397534,
0.0732629225,
0.0293464419,
0.0159357674,
-0.0458528884,
0.0135160852,
0.0798939914,
-0.0042490256,
-0.0546375997,
0.0126490975,
0.0806012154,
-0.0159356836,
0.0073724878,
0.0158849191,
0.0300437231,
-0.0021370626,
-0.0343445577,
0.0073135579,
0.0457757749,
-0.0027721373,
-0.0291073192,
0.0009844142,
0.004210474,
0.0046423562,
0.0815752521,
0.0210696515,
-0.0176717937,
-0.010781019,
-0.0328085348,
-0.0021048014,
0.0275471322,
-0.0280857608,
0.0312147085,
-0.0396079086,
-0.0647671893,
-0.0091535663,
-0.0202350542,
0.0362888835,
0.0338893719,
-0.0105435643,
0.0391446315,
-0.0381163359,
0.0106418766,
-0.0210878663,
0.0091589093,
-0.0669350326,
0.0293328632,
-0.0312477164,
-0.0091618197,
-0.019926589,
0.0139748324,
-0.0147911143,
-0.0182824377,
-0.0884718895,
-0.0832222477,
0.0392618626,
0.0348722711,
0.023547437,
0.0444344282,
0.0072818073,
-0.0578111485,
0.0794762298,
0.0465969332,
0.0097558768,
0.0271606911,
0.0389128514,
-0.0441012271,
-0.0044577359,
0.0353539735,
-0.0217074342,
0.0117952283,
0.0652145371,
0.0075731263,
-0.0200627483,
0.0323426984,
0.007463498,
0.0064219404,
0.0564254038,
-0.0376246013,
-0.0114023136,
-0.0318165906,
0.0307544172,
-0.0195557512,
-0.0219668206,
-0.0005948565,
-0.0448643193,
0.0296080373,
0.0284676291,
-0.0302878264,
-0.0412606858,
-0.0267352443,
0.0735951439,
-0.0257036593,
0.0318159983,
0.0553644486,
-0.0089865811,
0.0565735176,
0.0066852779,
-0.0088069923,
0.0117836241,
0.0082973968,
0.0428638682,
-0.0022361667,
0.0454527885,
-0.0049977354,
-0.0339676552,
-0.0497802012,
-0.0044195089,
-0.0647490174,
-0.0209916104,
-0.0025413691,
0.0411229208,
0.0242913254,
-0.0394004621,
0.0068873288,
0.0073194108,
-0.0084285717,
-0.0465672351,
0.0270405337,
-0.0135554606,
-0.0217144322,
0.0167017765,
0.0190088525,
-0.0259733107,
0.0484344997,
0.0750616118,
0.0391614325,
0.0187251586,
-0.0313790701,
-0.0165436082,
-0.0155117819,
-0.0289532896,
0.030125346,
-0.0013845504,
-0.0467752069,
-0.0069815926,
-0.1052562296,
-0.0892194211,
-0.0107136508,
-0.0313801393,
0.0425611064,
0.0309128333,
-0.0153984511,
0.0429465435,
-0.0345430598,
0.0323495567,
-0.0406452008,
-0.0230102949,
0.0013946644,
-0.0037830512,
-0.017300155,
-6.929595034e-33,
0.0019039351,
-0.0175919719,
-0.0171827655,
-0.0206414331,
-0.0133144027,
0.017124664,
-0.0027594368,
0.0210410077,
-0.0112997731,
-0.0191682074,
-0.0217128173,
-0.0035920392,
0.0194829516,
0.0312840231,
-0.0204556677,
-0.0237383656,
0.0333090611,
0.0125716999,
-0.0354376845,
-0.0108551597,
0.0598989986,
0.0234230198,
0.0447140634,
-0.0224507954,
0.0244465489,
-0.0226320755,
0.0092110196,
0.0238160752,
-0.0301663242,
0.0217242371,
-0.0007899217,
0.0568087623,
0.0187035352,
0.0241580475,
0.011147975,
-0.0041752597,
-0.0196612738,
-0.0108480519,
-0.0000541412,
0.0106885759,
0.0467569195,
-0.0142350998,
0.0037604438,
-0.0196976718,
0.0219583418,
-0.0428097174,
0.0277733207,
-0.0237976033,
-0.0325692594,
0.0226350464,
-0.0294335056,
0.0427029803,
-0.0079486696,
-0.0019524444,
0.0149537455,
0.0169280693,
0.0368657224,
-0.014817073,
-0.0467339791,
0.0151823405,
0.0380133651,
-0.0007601357,
0.0449445285,
0.0581564568,
0.0068463357,
0.0609635897,
0.0682533085,
0.050840728,
0.0237847138,
-0.0103783226,
0.0686835274,
-0.0107247997,
0.0378875285,
0.0640656129,
0.0843809992,
-0.0229283106,
-0.0771389082,
-0.0294880792,
-0.012001764,
-0.0016501,
0.0601422824,
0.0104269162,
-0.059490297,
-0.0479488857,
-0.0317201801,
-0.0135871181,
-0.0370113142,
-0.034266755,
0.0293312725,
0.0167671479,
-0.0502093844,
-0.0444827676,
0.0663808361,
-0.0499362536,
-0.0145221855,
0.008145228,
0.0006532851,
-0.0010589,
-0.0163991284,
0.0011303345,
-0.054854136,
-0.0208141003,
0.0013857255,
-0.0203578696,
0.0161305424,
-0.0263599679,
0.0551658385,
0.0343252346,
-0.0544595905,
-0.0000524587,
-0.022503417,
0.0211253501,
0.0256353524,
0.0490729772,
0.0386577211,
0.0126455585,
0.0143590253,
-0.0076121408,
0.0438816138,
0.0143760946,
-0.0423240103,
0.0500695035,
-0.0570465736,
-0.0047328025,
-0.0057092151,
0.0053870105,
0.0023497038,
0.0112311924,
0.0411234237,
-0.0670416206,
0.0131708179,
-0.0404254831,
2.899e-7,
0.0242431518,
0.0030091007,
-0.0298747122,
-0.0163661484,
-0.008567946,
0.0005993302,
-0.033038348,
0.0349173024,
0.0186077673,
0.0027619295,
-0.0247087516,
0.0323504955,
0.0726935714,
0.0448662899,
-0.0835119411,
-0.0152234258,
-0.0348493569,
0.0122373858,
-0.0741032138,
-0.0228759535,
0.0181911588,
0.09421321,
0.0377183259,
-0.0072404752,
-0.0350454226,
-0.0474693328,
0.0454485007,
-0.0446313322,
-0.0469172746,
0.0295768604,
0.0472739488,
0.0015642943,
0.0185335875,
0.0576964729,
-0.0291439705,
0.0299716108,
-0.0127695864,
0.010824793,
0.0285110828,
0.0067456448,
-0.0428319946,
-0.0197298173,
-0.0062917545,
-0.0414531082,
0.0790361464,
-0.062370494,
-0.0247872416,
0.0004401722,
-0.0262178648,
-0.0500947312,
0.0568547472,
-0.0143041704,
-0.00913426,
0.0518391356,
0.0091931149,
-0.013495761,
0.0250729751,
-0.060703665,
0.003857235,
-0.0111993253,
-0.0513580367,
-0.0619453229,
0.0320819579,
-0.027550729,
0.0199986454,
-0.0126938969,
0.0004805911,
3.01930775e-34,
0.0397973135,
0.0009436142,
-0.0269808322,
0.0339184403,
0.0547051914,
-0.0365719385,
0.0672821403,
0.0188619513,
0.0017196097,
-0.0710442811,
0.0120208869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17974v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17974v1 | Evaluating Fairness in Large Vision-Language Models Across Diverse Demographic Attributes and Prompts | 2024-06-25T23:11:39 | 2024-06-25T23:11:39 | Xuyang Wu, Yuan Wang, Hsin-Tai Wu, Zhiqiang Tao, Yi Fang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Large vision-language models (LVLMs) have recently achieved significant
progress, demonstrating strong capabilities in open-world visual understanding.
However, it is not yet clear how LVLMs address demographic biases in real life,
especially the disparities across attributes such as gender, skin tone, and
age. In this paper, we empirically investigate \emph{visual fairness} in
several mainstream LVLMs and audit their performance disparities across
sensitive demographic attributes, based on public fairness benchmark datasets
(e.g., FACET). To disclose the visual bias in LVLMs, we design a fairness
evaluation framework with direct questions and single-choice
question-instructed prompts on visual question-answering/classification tasks.
The zero-shot prompting results indicate that, despite enhancements in visual
understanding, both open-source and closed-source LVLMs exhibit prevalent
fairness issues across different instruct prompts and demographic attributes. | Evaluating Fairness in Large Vision-Language Models Across Diverse Demographic Attributes and Prompts: Large vision-language models (LVLMs) have recently achieved significant
progress, demonstrating strong capabilities in open-world visual understanding.
However, it is not yet clear how LVLMs address demographic biases in real life,
especially the disparities across attributes such as gender, skin tone, and
age. In this paper, we empirically investigate \emph{visual fairness} in
several mainstream LVLMs and audit their performance disparities across
sensitive demographic attributes, based on public fairness benchmark datasets
(e.g., FACET). To disclose the visual bias in LVLMs, we design a fairness
evaluation framework with direct questions and single-choice
question-instructed prompts on visual question-answering/classification tasks.
The zero-shot prompting results indicate that, despite enhancements in visual
understanding, both open-source and closed-source LVLMs exhibit prevalent
fairness issues across different instruct prompts and demographic attributes. | [
0.0334349796,
0.0686057582,
-0.0227391236,
0.0590490401,
-0.010020908,
0.0270507634,
0.0650924817,
-0.0026422855,
0.0166586116,
-0.0732216015,
-0.0180113353,
-0.0317106284,
0.0204920359,
0.0088465745,
0.0060352515,
-0.0591703281,
0.0245578047,
-0.014722337,
0.0231562201,
-0.0431994647,
0.008070698,
-0.0049856342,
0.0198457316,
0.0506581329,
-0.0036028423,
-0.0312532485,
0.0371903405,
0.0257470645,
0.0151809882,
0.0142826103,
0.0106238807,
0.0725840926,
-0.0082544759,
0.0335166268,
0.0000018072,
-0.0632679015,
0.0530369319,
0.0069668381,
-0.0239354484,
0.0204744898,
0.0199006125,
-0.0183491651,
0.0190397203,
0.0198386423,
-0.0229140315,
-0.0064922455,
0.0568584092,
0.0052911192,
0.030336678,
-0.036958877,
0.0031104987,
0.0221858341,
-0.0434203334,
-0.0122508956,
0.0164786745,
-0.0044752941,
0.0066940645,
-0.0236681607,
-0.0514725335,
-0.036245577,
-0.053448081,
0.0415876731,
0.0622243583,
-0.0140107153,
0.0378549844,
0.0365770124,
-0.052240409,
-0.0494664572,
-0.0290234163,
0.0990745798,
0.0080738282,
0.020796096,
-0.0362654403,
-0.0034216184,
0.0406607129,
-0.021161316,
-0.0695559606,
0.0553763583,
0.0030910543,
-0.0081771193,
-0.0707323551,
0.0082181776,
0.0225801878,
0.0154323475,
0.0277338382,
0.0404217876,
0.0115958117,
0.0012194378,
-0.0101436488,
0.0428697541,
-0.0149708278,
-0.0410204418,
-0.0193962548,
-0.0209955815,
-0.0303349961,
-0.0206369516,
-0.0386712141,
-0.0020989317,
0.0261065345,
0.0040434003,
0.0596298501,
0.0309859738,
-0.0556280203,
0.0315256044,
0.0157690179,
0.0857142806,
0.0315569527,
0.0312976092,
-0.0265038498,
-0.0268162806,
0.0266244952,
-0.011278403,
-0.006697508,
-0.0230596252,
-0.0626854151,
0.0303798299,
-0.0457601175,
-0.0053378572,
-0.0521768592,
-0.0056353901,
0.0156237548,
0.0459913649,
-0.018388385,
0.0108900759,
-0.0565674156,
0.008896268,
-0.0299273431,
-0.0216869358,
-0.0141739082,
-0.1069306806,
-0.0104404921,
0.0121514909,
-0.0329019055,
-0.041775398,
-0.0137183154,
0.0356393866,
-0.0060792291,
-0.0189427696,
-0.0170574766,
-0.0267481785,
0.015507197,
-0.0253605582,
0.0089902924,
-0.0587874837,
0.0076444112,
0.005135552,
0.018340461,
0.0116879027,
-0.0173870157,
0.0295999665,
-0.0202025566,
0.0793792903,
0.0312239528,
-0.0145792533,
0.0160050895,
0.0190465245,
-0.005661143,
0.0845795572,
0.010897615,
-0.0070207519,
0.057431072,
-0.0011468633,
-0.0003554913,
0.030655032,
0.00767919,
0.0158882458,
-0.0596078001,
0.0475276001,
0.0120173218,
0.0365845598,
0.0618200637,
0.0325445011,
0.0047644041,
-0.0895379335,
0.062910594,
0.0745119601,
0.0203268919,
-0.0302865803,
0.0227950513,
-0.0181368086,
-0.0181853194,
-0.0028025489,
-0.0903209373,
0.0318499655,
-0.0235647019,
-0.034663219,
-0.0169113912,
0.0516463183,
-0.0347170867,
-0.0361068547,
-0.0060593556,
0.00674095,
-0.0027643768,
0.062924467,
0.0083815167,
-0.0094097089,
0.0223599765,
-0.0010934435,
0.0393409878,
-0.0439847223,
0.0018873016,
-0.0792182088,
0.0405705087,
0.0457191281,
0.0138917444,
0.0116809169,
0.0057708276,
-0.0154612353,
0.020120021,
0.0416674688,
0.066172719,
0.006565039,
0.0364862569,
-0.0578527898,
-0.0532931723,
0.0067212707,
0.0034847627,
0.0237794463,
0.0220624227,
0.0119747967,
0.0101040713,
-0.0401932225,
0.0003021879,
0.0234966818,
0.008890436,
-0.0119396234,
0.0232059024,
0.0142044462,
-0.0001779277,
0.0077246078,
-0.0281889439,
-0.0016969034,
-0.0237324797,
-0.0182287917,
0.0072457073,
-0.0069576972,
-0.0779513642,
-0.0164348893,
0.031865567,
-0.0711231008,
-0.039270103,
0.0512266234,
0.000832865,
0.0203003641,
0.0264289025,
0.0079702139,
-0.0535439476,
-0.0308209695,
-0.010868663,
-0.0121413507,
0.0226182416,
-0.059649054,
0.03856498,
-0.026581049,
-0.0178347714,
0.0399161503,
-0.0262085926,
0.0093421871,
-0.0647469983,
-0.0221448112,
0.0298661664,
0.0010644883,
0.0087380596,
0.0002889817,
0.0319648199,
-0.0421216562,
0.0365383141,
-0.084109053,
-0.0035681031,
-0.0364844315,
-0.0392517895,
-0.0185267255,
0.0243780762,
-0.021649586,
-0.0606688783,
-0.0343234092,
0.0210276973,
0.0115102483,
0.0377362147,
0.0113724582,
-0.0271053258,
0.0052129943,
0.0012320636,
-0.0702342093,
0.0008886983,
0.0806138813,
0.0625831038,
0.0528486259,
-0.0084005091,
-0.0321906395,
-0.0421204045,
0.0586551279,
-0.0218040124,
0.0117130773,
0.0212546214,
0.0137863485,
0.0116310734,
0.1068231985,
0.0265624262,
0.0387967788,
0.0402157865,
0.0034181157,
-0.0424708612,
0.009111003,
0.0248834919,
-0.0059892349,
0.0056299604,
-0.0421405174,
-0.01742425,
0.011931859,
-0.0006019801,
-0.0169355068,
-0.0826207399,
0.0592579208,
-0.0459417775,
-0.0866826028,
-0.1032113209,
0.0130157135,
0.0120131699,
0.0464842431,
-0.0478868224,
-0.0922971591,
0.0616979748,
0.0040507475,
-0.0083375741,
0.0078255162,
-0.002190914,
-0.0669478327,
0.079396069,
-0.0173248872,
0.0181670133,
0.0126430374,
-0.0268903002,
-0.087497443,
-0.0279744025,
0.0255466774,
-0.0359101631,
0.0847363994,
-0.0615315363,
-0.0049042567,
-0.0519163273,
-0.0493792295,
-0.0544973686,
-0.0561290197,
-0.0110780764,
0.0265696701,
-0.0399936959,
-0.0237028413,
-0.0186327919,
0.0110772243,
0.02070136,
0.007908605,
-0.0251191128,
0.0038183625,
0.0093618594,
-0.0224043243,
0.048228927,
0.0476910621,
0.0246131085,
-0.0501749776,
0.0279371776,
0.052608449,
0.0339142866,
0.0092810923,
0.0135768186,
0.0400258154,
0.050661359,
0.0083036274,
-0.0172896963,
0.01263957,
0.0666579679,
-0.033630047,
0.0469013825,
0.0975553021,
0.0186694562,
-0.078656204,
-0.0078162756,
-0.0238763299,
0.0378652997,
0.0346993618,
-0.0155477421,
-0.0972157717,
-0.0146742463,
0.0098639568,
0.0429342613,
-0.021236239,
-0.0372732095,
-0.0048348214,
-0.0970656574,
0.0537361577,
-0.0057405923,
-0.027169954,
-0.0313845053,
0.0390648656,
0.0063379086,
-0.0169648174,
0.0524849668,
-0.0092055975,
-0.0031547849,
0.0194176435,
-0.0088476567,
-0.0011301194,
-0.0007912295,
0.0705893859,
-0.0597704612,
-0.0035931861,
0.0552276969,
-0.0148934983,
0.0169517715,
-0.0604237951,
0.010144921,
-0.0451996215,
0.0213876311,
-0.0285834745,
0.0565232038,
-0.031974785,
-0.0338892043,
-0.0523638315,
0.0310512632,
0.0118473042,
0.0038265572,
0.0163503941,
-0.0094052861,
0.0066734958,
-0.0306810122,
-0.0662884042,
-0.00877205,
-0.0292062741,
0.0452927127,
0.0228564609,
-0.0415101573,
-0.0445910282,
-0.0612073354,
-0.0180176813,
-0.0292809345,
-0.0634722933,
0.0351663642,
0.0432645828,
-0.0464963987,
-0.0183700453,
-0.0392345339,
0.0396708585,
0.010610857,
-0.0250733122,
-0.0814349353,
-0.0149058094,
0.0100281872,
-0.048905611,
0.076480113,
-0.0507410616,
0.0559619851,
-0.0319992453,
-0.0024833991,
-0.0352073722,
-0.0391506329,
-0.0201459341,
-0.01703736,
-0.0333858468,
-0.0160693731,
0.0127236936,
0.0447326191,
0.0189862959,
0.0326716639,
0.0079240557,
-0.0547168627,
0.0299563594,
0.0565562434,
0.0391528532,
0.0516525432,
-0.0124642868,
-0.0163197033,
0.018479405,
0.0285434574,
-0.0219131578,
-0.0098749846,
0.0025939322,
0.0182801802,
0.0078019518,
-0.0360302366,
-0.0023795997,
0.0250829216,
0.0464946665,
0.0047928356,
0.0019118827,
-0.0154946931,
0.0058866693,
0.0123864384,
-0.0080753034,
-0.0516574793,
-0.0159967672,
0.0162441395,
0.0084163984,
0.0008350718,
0.0030548384,
-0.0163729917,
-0.0130381593,
-0.0747290403,
0.0102091692,
0.0192386601,
0.0105858259,
0.0210657902,
0.0344361514,
-0.0043568756,
0.015986437,
-0.0097992709,
0.0491996631,
0.0490689464,
0.0538723581,
0.021927122,
0.0031644655,
-0.0190463085,
0.0181929842,
-0.0407385044,
-0.0199326072,
0.03524689,
0.046516262,
0.0380556993,
0.0074241045,
-0.0127501898,
0.025424445,
-0.0002897606,
-0.0049451706,
-0.009019712,
0.0410818011,
-0.0314530134,
0.0875645578,
0.010797387,
0.0042200531,
-0.0303947367,
0.0453876369,
0.0311872326,
0.0236255266,
-0.0187570974,
-0.0126681374,
-0.0145742865,
-0.0233286843,
0.0617616698,
-0.0198280755,
-0.0111561362,
0.0284538325,
-0.0901448578,
-0.0445015766,
-0.0246782377,
0.038184084,
0.0238674991,
0.0079213744,
0.0264062136,
0.0512264371,
-0.0038635,
-0.0862882286,
-0.0065130405,
0.0010735494,
-0.0613773912,
-0.0248392504,
0.0177937187,
-5.997447483e-33,
-0.0275221579,
-0.011799641,
0.0029730098,
-0.0325202793,
-0.0166018736,
0.0129109677,
0.0147975348,
0.0020257165,
-0.0339126512,
0.0018308042,
0.0107709905,
0.0160301439,
0.0075435783,
0.0313722789,
0.0013176708,
-0.0585457161,
0.0407938324,
0.0092898309,
-0.02491487,
-0.02133983,
-0.0484755337,
0.0031148961,
0.0207577739,
-0.0289602857,
0.0517791919,
0.0104105547,
0.0377752632,
0.0322741158,
-0.0277513769,
0.0628118962,
-0.0137212751,
0.0825619623,
0.0381396599,
0.0198294837,
-0.0180504024,
0.0430683531,
-0.0538323298,
-0.0235237814,
0.0176870301,
0.0342624038,
-0.069821991,
0.0171067938,
0.0057349168,
0.0401112624,
-0.027207464,
-0.0787249058,
0.0512974374,
0.007337607,
0.0099254968,
0.0365398936,
0.0234478917,
0.0069273924,
-0.027455885,
-0.008088639,
-0.0002829875,
0.0318506695,
0.007355704,
0.0512704588,
-0.0108935637,
0.0214618333,
-0.0025644954,
-0.0307653267,
0.0884776562,
0.0599396527,
0.025525799,
0.0325573161,
0.0719190165,
-0.0003332202,
-0.0584961213,
-0.0715053231,
0.0322571173,
-0.0252913889,
0.0351758562,
0.0752118528,
0.0308525823,
0.0270854086,
-0.053633634,
-0.0050701811,
-0.0111720348,
0.0342978649,
0.0024659375,
-0.0063175657,
-0.0428496413,
-0.0228740666,
-0.0573945493,
-0.0148213999,
-0.0561354384,
0.0101516973,
0.0749734566,
-0.0010297126,
-0.0163745061,
0.0155026233,
0.0180135705,
-0.0445064269,
-0.0182513557,
0.0043794974,
0.0172269512,
0.0016487424,
0.0279957224,
0.0261721741,
-0.0397067629,
0.0537309162,
0.0372707769,
0.0057531041,
-0.0163353793,
0.0219662972,
-0.0088708876,
0.0046400828,
-0.0561375432,
-0.0046510929,
-0.0334636793,
0.0205218792,
-0.0199260805,
0.0216364712,
0.0172304697,
0.0119461576,
-0.0227795802,
0.0280751269,
-0.0119203338,
-0.030914247,
-0.0393312238,
-0.0227015931,
0.0063206782,
0.0153922178,
-0.0206044782,
-0.0109576089,
-0.0089352392,
-0.0090934532,
0.0449424163,
-0.0182736553,
-0.005928067,
-0.014904649,
2.191e-7,
-0.0083246389,
0.0187353622,
0.0060611055,
0.0306684822,
0.0001606626,
0.0604452118,
0.0164200291,
0.0458465293,
0.0538647957,
-0.0160352495,
-0.0421071202,
0.0534007922,
0.0135736074,
-0.0025893759,
-0.025311511,
0.0195884015,
-0.0404608995,
0.005723197,
-0.0302915424,
0.0217387881,
0.0387741067,
0.0273087919,
-0.0040114713,
-0.0133625614,
0.0410912558,
-0.0432456285,
0.0252466369,
-0.0485802293,
-0.0058966605,
-0.0462242551,
0.018239107,
-0.0065079215,
0.0420979522,
0.0689751506,
0.0170422308,
-0.0073340093,
0.0130515778,
0.024138568,
-0.0241064131,
0.0027370621,
-0.0401053466,
0.0191488899,
-0.0253930092,
-0.0594578311,
0.0816347301,
0.0264873691,
-0.048954837,
-0.0487830453,
-0.0094248513,
-0.0260108039,
0.0719131976,
-0.0134332655,
-0.0326316953,
-0.0038325547,
0.030163452,
-0.0239079148,
-0.0085971821,
-0.0690132231,
-0.0182992276,
-0.0720488206,
-0.013158503,
-0.0617928989,
-0.0407516398,
0.0382670686,
0.0014545855,
0.0170181841,
-0.009514966,
1.756923588e-34,
0.0198619869,
0.0327801891,
0.0466382653,
-0.0406185426,
-0.0179415029,
0.0045206468,
-0.0038182,
-0.0338469334,
0.0436029248,
-0.0207815617,
-0.0012726922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17972v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17972v1 | LABOR-LLM: Language-Based Occupational Representations with Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T23:07:18 | 2024-06-25T23:07:18 | Tianyu Du, Ayush Kanodia, Herman Brunborg, Keyon Vafa, Susan Athey | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, econ.EM | Many empirical studies of labor market questions rely on estimating
relatively simple predictive models using small, carefully constructed
longitudinal survey datasets based on hand-engineered features. Large Language
Models (LLMs), trained on massive datasets, encode vast quantities of world
knowledge and can be used for the next job prediction problem. However, while
an off-the-shelf LLM produces plausible career trajectories when prompted, the
probability with which an LLM predicts a particular job transition conditional
on career history will not, in general, align with the true conditional
probability in a given population. Recently, Vafa et al. (2024) introduced a
transformer-based "foundation model", CAREER, trained using a large,
unrepresentative resume dataset, that predicts transitions between jobs; it
further demonstrated how transfer learning techniques can be used to leverage
the foundation model to build better predictive models of both transitions and
wages that reflect conditional transition probabilities found in nationally
representative survey datasets. This paper considers an alternative where the
fine-tuning of the CAREER foundation model is replaced by fine-tuning LLMs. For
the task of next job prediction, we demonstrate that models trained with our
approach outperform several alternatives in terms of predictive performance on
the survey data, including traditional econometric models, CAREER, and LLMs
with in-context learning, even though the LLM can in principle predict job
titles that are not allowed in the survey data. Further, we show that our
fine-tuned LLM-based models' predictions are more representative of the career
trajectories of various workforce subpopulations than off-the-shelf LLM models
and CAREER. We conduct experiments and analyses that highlight the sources of
the gains in the performance of our models for representative predictions. | LABOR-LLM: Language-Based Occupational Representations with Large Language Models: Many empirical studies of labor market questions rely on estimating
relatively simple predictive models using small, carefully constructed
longitudinal survey datasets based on hand-engineered features. Large Language
Models (LLMs), trained on massive datasets, encode vast quantities of world
knowledge and can be used for the next job prediction problem. However, while
an off-the-shelf LLM produces plausible career trajectories when prompted, the
probability with which an LLM predicts a particular job transition conditional
on career history will not, in general, align with the true conditional
probability in a given population. Recently, Vafa et al. (2024) introduced a
transformer-based "foundation model", CAREER, trained using a large,
unrepresentative resume dataset, that predicts transitions between jobs; it
further demonstrated how transfer learning techniques can be used to leverage
the foundation model to build better predictive models of both transitions and
wages that reflect conditional transition probabilities found in nationally
representative survey datasets. This paper considers an alternative where the
fine-tuning of the CAREER foundation model is replaced by fine-tuning LLMs. For
the task of next job prediction, we demonstrate that models trained with our
approach outperform several alternatives in terms of predictive performance on
the survey data, including traditional econometric models, CAREER, and LLMs
with in-context learning, even though the LLM can in principle predict job
titles that are not allowed in the survey data. Further, we show that our
fine-tuned LLM-based models' predictions are more representative of the career
trajectories of various workforce subpopulations than off-the-shelf LLM models
and CAREER. We conduct experiments and analyses that highlight the sources of
the gains in the performance of our models for representative predictions. | [
0.0094538769,
0.1390409172,
-0.0136197004,
-0.0349908993,
0.0044883783,
-0.0054745148,
0.0429925881,
0.0012979503,
-0.0051673008,
-0.0034865479,
0.0417472981,
-0.0022957562,
0.0027442032,
-0.0104521019,
0.0218045134,
-0.0287623983,
0.0099941911,
0.003954771,
-0.0071351486,
-0.015128714,
-0.0367523767,
0.0328131467,
0.0038292508,
0.0939177945,
-0.0163545776,
-0.0073035737,
0.0216235146,
-0.0085918242,
0.0188260246,
0.0122960964,
0.0326935574,
0.0223574247,
0.0383805409,
0.0023307686,
0.0000020834,
-0.0210255142,
-0.0248371325,
0.0117194178,
-0.0266586151,
-0.0877987221,
0.0421281382,
-0.0450614132,
-0.0067245299,
0.0384790227,
-0.0131728547,
-0.0091163982,
0.0493434966,
0.0170088988,
0.0434555523,
0.0161792506,
-0.0069601918,
-0.0685232952,
-0.0416914634,
-0.0324486755,
0.0181834772,
-0.0284421314,
0.0580888242,
-0.0447908156,
-0.0739038736,
-0.0140454937,
-0.0495257527,
-0.0177736413,
-0.0170154888,
-0.0387796387,
0.0061987196,
0.0683068782,
0.0032804974,
0.0189771578,
0.014890546,
0.0160594918,
-0.0365498066,
-0.0468068235,
-0.0172251053,
-0.0158807542,
0.0455648154,
0.0486220904,
-0.0452579558,
0.0216095597,
-0.0062544392,
0.0257545784,
0.0288692303,
0.0401481166,
-0.0025600474,
-0.0100178942,
-0.0287953634,
0.1111982018,
-0.0156462118,
-0.0079526957,
0.0507550351,
0.0148684382,
0.0868657455,
-0.0221982189,
0.0254728124,
-0.0002058688,
-0.0330333412,
0.0203349534,
-0.0257873368,
0.0123980306,
-0.0225902442,
-0.0072093811,
-0.0124909859,
0.0443484224,
-0.0333711207,
0.0450052693,
0.008856765,
-0.0154110799,
0.0083086025,
-0.0240766574,
-0.0382071696,
-0.0395738184,
-0.0773435757,
-0.0234568641,
-0.0445905253,
-0.0352668017,
-0.0007336328,
0.0485838056,
-0.0217458215,
-0.0055784094,
-0.0201610457,
-0.0123785436,
0.0106499996,
0.0239081811,
-0.0426733047,
0.0272244476,
-0.0666593239,
0.0492069647,
0.0281631723,
0.0546375699,
0.0158067271,
0.0242548268,
0.0317257792,
0.0055880519,
0.0099903243,
-0.0204895642,
0.0381968021,
0.045095697,
0.0295654051,
0.0503613837,
-0.0320135839,
-0.0379359834,
-0.0068908976,
-0.0158612747,
0.0205967743,
-0.0649761111,
0.0481186025,
-0.0036943255,
0.0072563281,
-0.0651456937,
0.0110378833,
0.0195416473,
-0.0480927117,
0.0381405279,
0.02897273,
0.0097226035,
0.0379364043,
-0.025453588,
-0.0108380122,
0.0218872,
0.0429018661,
0.0416530818,
-0.0068001756,
-0.0802479461,
0.0343967415,
0.0561646186,
-0.0303480141,
0.0061858874,
-0.0043046437,
0.0154241053,
0.0276946854,
0.0054776873,
0.0743194148,
-0.0337345451,
0.0099012926,
-0.0005081933,
0.0456320941,
0.0628941134,
0.0387630463,
0.0420766287,
0.05123486,
0.0322406478,
-0.0203739218,
-0.047400225,
-0.0224696212,
0.0163244177,
-0.0232936181,
-0.0264386199,
-0.0681686625,
0.005403433,
-0.0192369074,
0.0002966415,
0.0505917333,
0.0117667597,
-0.0074242451,
0.0090692956,
0.0441662185,
0.0151511161,
-0.0330378674,
0.0962455496,
0.0411811583,
0.0073238024,
-0.0056552961,
-0.0273709707,
-0.0118807321,
0.0760682896,
0.000047369,
0.0035059813,
-0.006134178,
-0.0554920845,
0.0514058843,
0.0255316216,
0.0294096023,
-0.0002318823,
0.0156823024,
-0.014008713,
-0.0212193187,
0.0628249496,
0.0270372573,
0.015438511,
-0.0047099688,
-0.0036163242,
0.0075003644,
-0.0677227154,
-0.0335876606,
0.0316032469,
-0.075424701,
-0.0076460796,
0.0640221536,
-0.0049884901,
-0.0258353408,
-0.0360371061,
0.0001914813,
-0.0010821579,
-0.0144608598,
-0.0136203608,
0.0006422815,
0.0220240336,
-0.0382582173,
-0.0035168189,
-0.0212383438,
-0.014318129,
0.0044635786,
0.0076022861,
-0.0607655384,
0.0050682374,
0.0053160368,
0.0206203777,
0.0214642193,
0.0195302684,
0.0220010318,
-0.0130445939,
0.0146496901,
-0.0124384826,
0.0252043996,
0.0356197953,
-0.004096223,
-0.029914014,
-0.0263579842,
0.0026358499,
-0.0987248793,
0.0185512882,
-0.0299697667,
-0.0089317719,
0.0194480233,
-0.0098163811,
0.0123023838,
-0.0140823461,
-0.0263209306,
-0.0649122223,
0.0159246661,
0.0270607676,
0.0036463146,
0.0056631439,
-0.0365995467,
0.0046891719,
0.0084987581,
-0.0436791778,
0.0160659812,
0.0254034176,
-0.0216065757,
0.0120379049,
-0.0154128596,
-0.0172901861,
-0.0392811783,
-0.0540194735,
-0.0395601839,
0.0424381644,
0.0193408616,
0.0213742126,
-0.0436025299,
-0.0435301624,
-0.0148138301,
0.0052657104,
-0.0199167896,
0.0178016331,
-0.0397085361,
-0.0146077629,
-0.0089186355,
0.0327579379,
-0.0055671297,
0.0379072726,
0.0410339125,
-0.0332699195,
-0.0280197784,
0.0070022689,
-0.0248451196,
0.0133712227,
-0.0450860821,
-0.0580124632,
-0.0231059026,
0.0234652217,
0.0345731266,
-0.0260246173,
-0.0204963405,
0.0193156954,
-0.0262753777,
0.0079004001,
-0.0633230582,
0.0589453578,
-0.0109235542,
0.0443800874,
0.0082975244,
-0.0124066491,
-0.0136944205,
-0.0071277232,
0.0469809175,
-0.0022909413,
-0.0742177814,
-0.0462591462,
0.0309106819,
-0.0053366874,
-0.0199857727,
0.0418591946,
-0.0123106195,
-0.0723631382,
0.0505353808,
-0.021944046,
-0.0288195144,
-0.0222997312,
-0.0488156714,
-0.0018388496,
0.0236276388,
-0.0360725895,
-0.0383301191,
-0.0948436558,
-0.0312077925,
0.0489202328,
0.0221224781,
-0.0009609342,
-0.0760659799,
-0.0057684765,
-0.0152384033,
0.0266023222,
0.0188751332,
-0.0296138935,
-0.017187966,
0.009407104,
0.054836262,
0.0532420576,
-0.0283976328,
-0.0572638735,
-0.0036864132,
-0.0224694051,
-0.0148859499,
0.0438257568,
-0.0197376404,
0.0049653761,
0.0391563438,
-0.041195143,
0.0090147257,
0.0359849222,
-0.0179083291,
-0.0522850379,
-0.0050411327,
0.0920412019,
-0.0105397077,
-0.0020446738,
0.0021779269,
0.0215057619,
-0.0148034059,
0.0293506552,
0.0698485672,
-0.0469669737,
0.0000083054,
0.0113314828,
0.0309856627,
0.0088366056,
-0.0300756246,
-0.0099343332,
-0.106550552,
0.0714468136,
-0.0113805272,
-0.0325246193,
-0.0000573518,
-0.0419828296,
-0.0040605902,
-0.0458155051,
-0.0249288641,
-0.0360396281,
-0.0274458192,
0.0111220535,
0.0471832491,
-0.044584848,
-0.0273662005,
0.06471356,
-0.0313145854,
0.0134951798,
0.0412982255,
0.0489191748,
-0.0407036766,
0.0134873316,
-0.0093904408,
0.0055837175,
-0.0010918631,
0.0435705408,
0.0383400805,
-0.0173672363,
-0.0219636969,
-0.0076398975,
0.0045679547,
-0.0262013543,
0.0009949855,
0.0449661091,
0.0735815465,
0.0009356037,
-0.0562793948,
0.0092920382,
0.0282450262,
-0.0070550037,
0.072099641,
-0.0374268629,
-0.0759566426,
-0.0025238337,
-0.0408326536,
-0.0125560351,
0.0297733676,
-0.0607644394,
0.0395565443,
-0.0397550948,
0.001535793,
0.0159178637,
-0.0055430192,
0.0643368587,
0.0137991821,
0.0046936534,
0.0129585126,
0.0468571745,
-0.0355095603,
-0.0568783842,
0.003798445,
-0.0844152346,
0.0422578938,
-0.033441823,
-0.0116284415,
0.0162543003,
-0.0316445678,
-0.0603774525,
-0.0508038886,
-0.1136767045,
-0.0128878765,
-0.0080993213,
0.015529111,
0.0173358005,
0.0199012365,
0.0005779678,
-0.0259691775,
0.0692905784,
0.0891548172,
-0.0111769205,
0.0007796112,
-0.0106942831,
0.0012659632,
-0.0348526724,
-0.0130105009,
-0.0521713793,
0.0033264679,
0.0214516427,
-0.0205057804,
-0.0157435499,
-0.0544980802,
-0.0227036569,
-0.0293571055,
0.02750469,
0.003032306,
-0.0379103683,
-0.0485935882,
-0.0147171197,
0.0261214487,
-0.0117141521,
-0.029344229,
-0.0297229402,
0.1076539755,
0.0351923071,
0.0421556346,
0.0046228045,
0.0423381664,
0.0258092843,
-0.0702747181,
0.0279108565,
-0.0356577486,
0.027713079,
0.0044016684,
-0.0091986572,
0.0125576314,
-0.0372715257,
0.0447367169,
0.0405478962,
0.0367156267,
0.0174370483,
0.0059257802,
0.0336669236,
0.0075864838,
-0.0179285947,
-0.0400260426,
-0.0819973424,
-0.0339772776,
0.0191553663,
0.0301696025,
-0.0878981724,
0.0174566843,
-0.0177352298,
0.0061886348,
-0.0204640478,
-0.007510778,
0.0304332823,
0.002861968,
0.0751599595,
-0.0254169572,
-0.0188574046,
-0.0091600334,
0.0360332131,
0.1026585475,
0.0319076963,
-0.0326310247,
-0.0509625897,
-0.0288856532,
0.0040222751,
0.0336210392,
0.0195435379,
0.0030361041,
0.0135483826,
-0.0617243759,
-0.0429591052,
0.0190165192,
-0.0560309701,
-0.0162854549,
-0.0287017394,
-0.0119988844,
0.0278277732,
-0.0267849527,
-0.0000179933,
-0.0429321416,
-0.020247696,
-0.0063696201,
-0.0110049061,
-0.0708419606,
-5.836679529e-33,
-0.0238498058,
-0.0262172632,
0.0396942198,
-0.0009379613,
-0.003755148,
-0.0125742471,
0.0057634213,
-0.0292148627,
-0.0069353646,
-0.0217291266,
-0.0332545042,
0.003102025,
0.0236394424,
0.0496464819,
0.0407431796,
-0.0023930157,
0.0452091657,
0.0374659374,
0.0135661196,
-0.0103311297,
-0.0086443191,
0.0358803011,
0.0851894915,
-0.0740861967,
0.0163906924,
0.0160036664,
0.0030578407,
0.0179849081,
0.0032541582,
0.0377776884,
-0.0022824358,
0.0350870639,
0.0142999068,
-0.0857232958,
0.0013589443,
0.0108443834,
-0.0636457652,
-0.0119277202,
-0.0207425971,
0.0233579781,
0.0583566092,
-0.0163089614,
-0.0086780172,
0.0258030854,
-0.0040414617,
-0.0614033043,
0.0730381906,
-0.0318360925,
0.0418356508,
0.0043733288,
-0.0377750657,
0.0147429816,
-0.0118618626,
0.0196831692,
-0.0015713637,
0.0523588173,
0.0090201302,
0.0312420614,
-0.1116719246,
-0.016785156,
-0.0020830478,
0.0229155142,
0.0151812462,
0.0269231368,
0.0168329403,
0.0262647662,
0.0499921255,
0.0194059815,
0.0229812507,
0.0066186204,
0.0222089048,
0.0487065651,
-0.0064284452,
0.0252293367,
0.0576525852,
-0.0434776507,
-0.0270509776,
0.0037453345,
0.01442823,
-0.0122663407,
0.021279607,
0.0209678542,
0.0079370281,
-0.0643904284,
-0.0562489107,
-0.0406707898,
0.0231702179,
0.0153624536,
0.038808234,
-0.0044610845,
0.0324528702,
0.0148699582,
0.0165753886,
-0.0593001842,
-0.0466129445,
0.0059774397,
-0.0603189878,
0.0001007649,
0.0199594721,
0.0043934593,
-0.0810042173,
-0.0208189283,
0.0006750728,
-0.009159985,
0.0482853875,
0.0658312961,
0.0208171494,
0.0333120935,
-0.0657583326,
-0.0175315142,
-0.0152075738,
0.0074769179,
-0.0118472334,
0.0231721625,
0.0472789928,
-0.0001042525,
0.0377488397,
0.003119421,
0.0128571838,
0.0136507358,
0.0295073278,
-0.0218356866,
0.0153710749,
-0.0087984176,
-0.0134716826,
-0.0337831639,
-0.0001775394,
-0.0238851644,
0.0330496542,
-0.0436848477,
-0.0268541519,
-0.0072739455,
2.618e-7,
0.0494438522,
0.0212674718,
-0.0591801591,
0.0191731919,
0.0172032639,
0.0252585225,
-0.0124806846,
0.0325437523,
0.0648375824,
0.025924759,
0.0078210123,
-0.0062680109,
0.048931282,
-0.014126271,
-0.1019211039,
-0.033679191,
-0.0265375264,
-0.0192133784,
-0.0580946654,
0.0054236939,
0.0847891644,
0.0897402391,
0.0526648797,
-0.0347015448,
0.019928949,
0.0074261548,
0.0582564846,
-0.0456268787,
0.0093121072,
-0.0013737291,
-0.0200720169,
0.0296256095,
-0.0234803874,
0.039132759,
-0.0335603394,
0.0493624173,
0.0193995908,
0.0576032139,
0.0048751258,
0.0543811396,
-0.0036424964,
0.0231086146,
-0.0137732392,
-0.0346378386,
0.0597311333,
-0.0619121678,
-0.0265761595,
-0.0483670533,
-0.0805788785,
0.0234363154,
-0.0045587583,
0.0132817244,
-0.0268136542,
-0.0598899983,
0.0333928578,
0.0229738783,
-0.0452765673,
0.0128343171,
0.0043105939,
0.0555737354,
-0.0602614023,
-0.0422383361,
0.0336084515,
0.0302986689,
0.02244821,
-0.0440737382,
0.0253592357,
2.529474432e-34,
0.0342487358,
0.063925378,
-0.0027624744,
-0.0363049507,
0.0246891864,
0.0193767976,
0.0438794009,
0.0374714136,
0.0081867808,
-0.0484125987,
-0.0071460162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17969v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17969v1 | Encourage or Inhibit Monosemanticity? Revisit Monosemanticity from a Feature Decorrelation Perspective | 2024-06-25T22:51:08 | 2024-06-25T22:51:08 | Hanqi Yan, Yanzheng Xiang, Guangyi Chen, Yifei Wang, Lin Gui, Yulan He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | To better interpret the intrinsic mechanism of large language models (LLMs),
recent studies focus on monosemanticity on its basic units. A monosemantic
neuron is dedicated to a single and specific concept, which forms a one-to-one
correlation between neurons and concepts. Despite extensive research in
monosemanticity probing, it remains unclear whether monosemanticity is
beneficial or harmful to model capacity. To explore this question, we revisit
monosemanticity from the feature decorrelation perspective and advocate for its
encouragement. We experimentally observe that the current conclusion by
wang2024learning, which suggests that decreasing monosemanticity enhances model
performance, does not hold when the model changes. Instead, we demonstrate that
monosemanticity consistently exhibits a positive correlation with model
capacity, in the preference alignment process. Consequently, we apply feature
correlation as a proxy for monosemanticity and incorporate a feature
decorrelation regularizer into the dynamic preference optimization process. The
experiments show that our method not only enhances representation diversity and
activation sparsity but also improves preference alignment performance. | Encourage or Inhibit Monosemanticity? Revisit Monosemanticity from a Feature Decorrelation Perspective: To better interpret the intrinsic mechanism of large language models (LLMs),
recent studies focus on monosemanticity on its basic units. A monosemantic
neuron is dedicated to a single and specific concept, which forms a one-to-one
correlation between neurons and concepts. Despite extensive research in
monosemanticity probing, it remains unclear whether monosemanticity is
beneficial or harmful to model capacity. To explore this question, we revisit
monosemanticity from the feature decorrelation perspective and advocate for its
encouragement. We experimentally observe that the current conclusion by
wang2024learning, which suggests that decreasing monosemanticity enhances model
performance, does not hold when the model changes. Instead, we demonstrate that
monosemanticity consistently exhibits a positive correlation with model
capacity, in the preference alignment process. Consequently, we apply feature
correlation as a proxy for monosemanticity and incorporate a feature
decorrelation regularizer into the dynamic preference optimization process. The
experiments show that our method not only enhances representation diversity and
activation sparsity but also improves preference alignment performance. | [
0.0240752716,
0.0668296814,
-0.0110686002,
0.0280555356,
-0.0579100065,
0.010792587,
0.0294835344,
-0.0473267883,
-0.0602705441,
0.0226441082,
-0.0564397611,
-0.075721927,
0.0391083397,
0.0394579247,
0.0359034128,
-0.0183704495,
0.0804702267,
-0.0185279846,
0.0022536409,
-0.0436441414,
0.0125454543,
-0.0185257513,
0.0000714795,
0.0244967639,
-0.0066777058,
-0.0471853837,
-0.0110695865,
-0.0001848942,
-0.0152070466,
-0.0098347999,
-0.0228355788,
0.0647953898,
0.0245584883,
0.0179954637,
0.0000020157,
-0.0540635139,
0.0253108758,
-0.0030863739,
-0.0266758073,
-0.004683665,
0.001700249,
-0.0120914439,
0.0267586671,
-0.0336652361,
-0.0060353796,
0.0359419137,
0.0534155853,
0.0434771739,
-0.0106481006,
0.0470581576,
-0.0115181599,
-0.0328652598,
0.0147455083,
-0.038200777,
-0.0148367127,
0.010046388,
0.0258911271,
-0.0586708821,
-0.0055644778,
0.0323183723,
-0.0489894226,
0.0126232719,
-0.0007692054,
0.0232048463,
0.0370287187,
0.0179895554,
0.0244531073,
-0.0187027827,
0.0231199823,
0.0488831922,
-0.0113343447,
0.0189390033,
-0.0216809046,
-0.0056046173,
0.0040405523,
-0.0076724375,
-0.0271746945,
-0.0286606308,
0.0255392361,
0.026902562,
0.0081285015,
-0.0521677211,
0.0446155891,
0.0110371057,
-0.0368795283,
0.0618891306,
0.0190892834,
-0.0447848402,
0.0095882034,
-0.0078313546,
-0.0482018739,
-0.0062493961,
0.013485495,
-0.0236773528,
-0.004436776,
0.0052336804,
-0.0108123617,
-0.0158013459,
0.0189408567,
-0.0784822181,
0.0271911435,
0.0602925085,
-0.0101133063,
0.0286597274,
-0.0215112586,
0.0830012336,
-0.0358084701,
0.0286037102,
-0.0510904565,
0.0269197468,
-0.0098543083,
-0.0442332812,
0.0225806478,
0.0637777224,
0.0486066192,
-0.0261608195,
-0.0401851088,
0.0309607461,
-0.0014304341,
-0.0132346964,
-0.0496089719,
0.0237023886,
-0.0022850723,
-0.011366698,
-0.047622934,
0.0805389583,
-0.0335754976,
0.0265834499,
0.0035854625,
-0.0095140319,
-0.0164136384,
0.0205143094,
-0.0197728723,
-0.0847158432,
0.0127109038,
0.0482996814,
-0.0203224588,
-0.0230529867,
0.0124866655,
0.0226619318,
-0.0722936541,
-0.0245558098,
0.017895082,
-0.0597420298,
0.0226893164,
0.0332233571,
-0.021604348,
-0.0652884245,
-0.0162260905,
-0.0493266396,
-0.0534192398,
0.0347461887,
-0.0067300512,
0.0194656029,
0.0096230488,
-0.0235617328,
0.0217300281,
0.071840249,
0.0507024974,
0.0123307528,
0.0098791448,
0.0070361439,
-0.0683472231,
0.0102037601,
-0.0189661663,
-0.0070018489,
-0.0817014277,
-0.027209498,
0.0265399497,
0.0359249413,
0.0794968903,
0.0363378897,
-0.0367997363,
-0.0724288151,
0.0812739432,
0.0443582423,
0.0215720627,
0.0040695146,
0.0015515197,
-0.0235714298,
-0.0078267409,
0.057818085,
-0.033400137,
0.0599314459,
0.0029020708,
0.030820474,
0.0410647392,
0.0544881113,
-0.0352684446,
-0.0252624955,
-0.014045896,
-0.0069900956,
0.0125061693,
-0.0199990142,
0.0402820744,
-0.0426428393,
-0.0124713629,
0.0188792441,
-0.0012867785,
0.0098015321,
0.005184717,
-0.0455912575,
0.0157457553,
0.0740521252,
0.0090599908,
0.0175526403,
-0.0500434674,
0.014102947,
-0.0468692295,
0.0682029799,
0.0272050425,
0.0161651503,
0.062179368,
-0.0437062234,
-0.0320655294,
-0.034774188,
0.0019960282,
0.0178981367,
-0.0198915955,
-0.0172118787,
-0.0075578927,
0.0236110799,
0.0220327545,
0.0116369464,
0.0136600658,
-0.0022692205,
0.0233106129,
0.0044659362,
0.0135598406,
-0.012976842,
-0.0206580963,
0.0358422957,
-0.0052269315,
-0.0277273525,
0.0045762714,
-0.0128453262,
-0.110463284,
-0.0303102657,
0.0472335666,
0.0378697664,
-0.0071817227,
0.0329557545,
0.0112018976,
-0.036681883,
0.0145470062,
0.0235393234,
0.0027446065,
-0.0243832022,
0.0211374424,
0.0016452479,
0.0506525487,
-0.0608568713,
0.0409589261,
-0.0146766491,
-0.0009123532,
-0.0160257015,
-0.0182422083,
0.0363855325,
-0.0293942839,
-0.0590163842,
0.0050847051,
-0.0092239948,
0.0158907417,
0.0125808688,
-0.0325158574,
-0.0069239335,
-0.0460761823,
-0.06406831,
-0.0042721103,
-0.0020979838,
-0.0044392059,
-0.0071765915,
0.0131148621,
0.0212790854,
0.0221488923,
-0.0229805484,
-0.0017726055,
-0.0348434374,
0.0735488683,
0.0330656134,
0.0078758104,
-0.0249421243,
-0.05932476,
-0.0356121734,
-0.0113881901,
0.0402222797,
-0.0557055511,
-0.008569777,
-0.0065539638,
0.0346039683,
-0.0373200327,
-0.0142123243,
0.0041032587,
-0.0226481613,
0.0317405313,
-0.0074639167,
0.0667369962,
0.0509048663,
0.0054869838,
0.0075967982,
0.0700976774,
0.0333922915,
-0.0257129278,
0.0022758655,
-0.0358862244,
0.0334206335,
-0.0513081886,
0.0076297573,
-0.0447194017,
0.1044813395,
0.0219850186,
-0.0507862531,
-0.0474060141,
-0.0154325552,
0.0159736332,
-0.0406265333,
-0.0283050276,
0.00106732,
-0.0416552089,
0.0154481549,
-0.0423903875,
-0.0491806976,
0.0575228781,
0.0112017822,
0.0161968414,
-0.0048337588,
0.0069558495,
-0.0265117157,
0.0509759039,
0.0399306081,
0.0238192417,
-0.0080865612,
-0.016387742,
-0.1028238386,
-0.0109852171,
-0.0015628664,
0.0074703638,
0.0972296372,
-0.0125597231,
0.0097645586,
-0.0015825762,
-0.0500361286,
-0.0332733728,
0.0047223852,
0.0110584013,
0.0295880158,
0.0587267205,
0.0106259137,
-0.041500628,
-0.0183951408,
0.0334028788,
0.0335730761,
-0.0238751229,
0.0045621768,
0.0193298142,
0.0288328305,
0.0531767607,
0.0694134161,
0.0086442111,
-0.038860444,
0.0157183278,
0.0216243993,
-0.0173463207,
0.0170233846,
-0.0290924981,
0.0219276641,
0.018630892,
-0.0206879284,
-0.0439607091,
-0.0103989374,
0.0400728732,
-0.0242997929,
0.0098169735,
0.0859355703,
0.0092757149,
-0.0459510162,
0.0193193574,
-0.0476552807,
0.0816745684,
0.0373687334,
0.0051944647,
0.0005761692,
-0.0011183042,
-0.0226161461,
-0.0387764126,
0.0323111713,
0.0177675523,
-0.0112157632,
-0.0527139977,
-0.0371873751,
0.0263201743,
-0.0421933979,
0.0072188401,
-0.0071633891,
-0.0097681209,
-0.0358625352,
0.0527010001,
0.0406778492,
0.0002504202,
-0.0143325897,
0.0237948336,
-0.0389442742,
-0.0280894022,
0.0048176721,
-0.0342144556,
0.030737197,
0.0840650648,
-0.0116949435,
-0.0214903969,
-0.0038590673,
0.0009565013,
0.0475883111,
0.0340506546,
0.0107755614,
0.0241533965,
0.0162208062,
-0.0153987566,
-0.0285147633,
-0.0071306447,
0.0073912214,
-0.0289125089,
-0.056078352,
0.0291097537,
0.0013810487,
0.0010883247,
-0.0302184727,
-0.0158666391,
-0.0510941781,
0.0540055148,
0.0271076392,
-0.0980009809,
-0.0046665492,
-0.0117063355,
-0.0390963852,
-0.0418173186,
-0.0320928581,
0.0156646688,
0.0632225052,
-0.0189149734,
-0.0524990708,
0.0078224847,
-0.0103285192,
0.0218587611,
-0.00850417,
0.022172654,
-0.0475175381,
-0.0348407663,
-0.0299464092,
0.0100048799,
0.0395340025,
0.0037837615,
-0.0619240142,
0.0086817769,
0.0189022105,
-0.0204977654,
-0.010589581,
-0.036072202,
-0.0887949988,
-0.0795290023,
0.023537932,
0.0178909823,
0.0112643875,
0.0275369752,
0.0222373009,
-0.0298402384,
0.0458499379,
0.0654348731,
0.00806743,
0.0481376611,
0.0126022575,
-0.0048607248,
-0.0246834978,
0.0312642157,
-0.0132455472,
-0.0159129482,
0.0200727116,
0.0570729896,
0.0017159608,
-0.0145331239,
0.0135316337,
-0.0091205155,
0.0327702463,
0.0033717719,
0.0832648277,
-0.0270929746,
0.0171089899,
0.0153722772,
0.0165766198,
-0.0109519958,
-0.0623236112,
0.0728413388,
0.0054441993,
-0.0209175088,
-0.0212551393,
0.0424576923,
0.0188604742,
0.0362121239,
-0.0455050655,
-0.0601535663,
-0.0200782716,
0.0206060335,
0.0434412695,
-0.0137827052,
0.0917030573,
-0.0380797833,
-0.015730761,
-0.0105963405,
0.020514572,
0.0132899005,
0.0218924787,
-0.0343483649,
-0.0040748157,
-0.0452029184,
-0.0405732542,
-0.0151697556,
-0.046666,
0.0378162265,
-0.0081321625,
0.0735770687,
-0.0134301959,
-0.001145061,
-0.043691352,
0.0039969976,
-0.0315695964,
0.0085035972,
0.0427281372,
0.0471951067,
-0.0140322661,
-0.0181700327,
0.0761310682,
-0.0070749042,
-0.0006429576,
-0.0035804517,
0.0293769538,
0.0014467494,
-0.0177466031,
0.0277113672,
0.0340410434,
-0.0612076931,
-0.0018484602,
-0.0539800525,
-0.0475878753,
0.0460714325,
0.00738513,
0.0359915867,
0.0006601403,
0.0289699882,
0.0291962568,
-0.029226942,
-0.0229102336,
-0.0076494222,
-0.0410259068,
0.0308104157,
-0.0104956925,
0.01740635,
-6.911859028e-33,
-0.0423492752,
-0.0010211479,
0.003903975,
-0.0387796015,
-0.0163723323,
-0.0811300501,
0.0039477423,
0.0571183525,
-0.0448330194,
0.0086024608,
-0.0131080924,
-0.0009602954,
-0.006422814,
0.0195147339,
0.0712751076,
0.0069547147,
0.0326965488,
0.0024130514,
0.0042694025,
-0.0408015922,
0.0657344162,
0.0209148321,
0.0603343248,
-0.0710287914,
-0.015364171,
0.0348774418,
-0.0036192141,
-0.0098906616,
-0.0223314818,
0.0619132742,
-0.0281255711,
0.0166129041,
0.0344287492,
-0.0162447803,
-0.0251807272,
-0.0723637417,
-0.0296289008,
-0.0621047802,
0.0448601767,
0.0046521528,
-0.0216765106,
-0.0489228182,
0.0528086238,
0.0016173638,
-0.0023638743,
-0.0464100167,
0.0349825546,
-0.0324412212,
-0.0679957122,
0.0307497177,
-0.0818978995,
0.0123764519,
-0.0039208769,
0.0292890109,
-0.005570997,
-0.0143088922,
-0.0194228273,
0.0189186409,
-0.0277244113,
0.0243048891,
0.0052384506,
0.0809855461,
0.0320960358,
0.0493830293,
0.0302321333,
0.0529530682,
0.0566555969,
0.0015558578,
0.0223705713,
-0.0279525053,
0.055870045,
0.0256686918,
0.0341983773,
0.0273079351,
0.0824161619,
-0.013470781,
-0.0496929511,
-0.0067044864,
0.0342326798,
0.0123947114,
0.0332750157,
0.0342638232,
-0.0172118526,
-0.0356387869,
-0.0141360639,
-0.005046471,
-0.0698371828,
-0.1035255194,
0.0131551353,
-0.0166060869,
0.0226772875,
0.0214910619,
0.0499629006,
-0.0147152767,
-0.0386960544,
0.0549682304,
-0.0669217706,
0.0174519531,
0.0197824202,
-0.0173687097,
-0.0670324787,
-0.0263922215,
-0.0224073771,
0.0258977395,
-0.0036081693,
0.0435452238,
0.0391735397,
0.0265182741,
-0.0545251481,
-0.0330155268,
-0.0098677976,
-0.0875299051,
0.0271099415,
-0.0036871862,
0.0408799276,
-0.0122170355,
-0.0172938332,
0.0623427704,
-0.0012955344,
-0.0254427828,
-0.0784521401,
-0.0342673473,
0.0074299686,
0.0406913497,
0.017612271,
-0.014103814,
-0.0281261243,
-0.0057188408,
0.0265235621,
-0.051463794,
-0.0374478363,
0.0216186456,
2.846e-7,
0.0216865018,
0.0253923032,
-0.0085379062,
-0.0026201003,
0.0289194565,
0.0347899497,
-0.0543476567,
0.0185964126,
-0.0343338959,
-0.0240740683,
0.0242901929,
0.0564875714,
0.019741172,
0.016760001,
-0.0587106012,
0.0562961809,
-0.0208627637,
0.0605928339,
-0.0224328432,
0.0144022191,
0.0172935445,
0.0998390764,
-0.0085925953,
-0.0026520186,
0.0121805677,
-0.0070761768,
0.0771676376,
-0.0208843648,
0.0037229229,
0.0338298045,
0.0055614701,
-0.0602911226,
-0.033711195,
-0.0137378722,
0.012071982,
0.0523670502,
0.0117329955,
0.0696674138,
-0.026505474,
-0.0389843807,
-0.0009672754,
0.0238906108,
-0.0263297111,
-0.0145209227,
0.0445401259,
-0.0368694775,
-0.0583977848,
-0.0253650118,
0.0364892744,
0.0254308116,
0.0315012708,
-0.0198143609,
-0.0081253713,
-0.0134941675,
0.0009347434,
-0.0095706154,
-0.0272860881,
-0.0652571768,
-0.0263468977,
0.0550753176,
-0.0612803586,
-0.0214492846,
-0.0580795258,
0.0309923869,
0.0793670788,
0.0116828736,
-0.0285356473,
2.511636535e-34,
0.0349927396,
-0.0380920582,
0.0217414908,
0.0384594873,
-0.0257633757,
-0.0481201746,
-0.0453334115,
0.0075128577,
0.0186017696,
-0.0758946911,
-0.0380253233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17967v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17967v1 | Unmasking the Imposters: In-Domain Detection of Human vs. Machine-Generated Tweets | 2024-06-25T22:49:17 | 2024-06-25T22:49:17 | Bryan E. Tuck, Rakesh M. Verma | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid development of large language models (LLMs) has significantly
improved the generation of fluent and convincing text, raising concerns about
their misuse on social media platforms. We present a methodology using Twitter
datasets to examine the generative capabilities of four LLMs: Llama 3, Mistral,
Qwen2, and GPT4o. We evaluate 7B and 8B parameter base-instruction models of
the three open-source LLMs and validate the impact of further fine-tuning and
"uncensored" versions. Our findings show that "uncensored" models with
additional in-domain fine-tuning dramatically reduce the effectiveness of
automated detection methods. This study addresses a gap by exploring smaller
open-source models and the effects of "uncensoring," providing insights into
how fine-tuning and content moderation influence machine-generated text
detection. | Unmasking the Imposters: In-Domain Detection of Human vs. Machine-Generated Tweets: The rapid development of large language models (LLMs) has significantly
improved the generation of fluent and convincing text, raising concerns about
their misuse on social media platforms. We present a methodology using Twitter
datasets to examine the generative capabilities of four LLMs: Llama 3, Mistral,
Qwen2, and GPT4o. We evaluate 7B and 8B parameter base-instruction models of
the three open-source LLMs and validate the impact of further fine-tuning and
"uncensored" versions. Our findings show that "uncensored" models with
additional in-domain fine-tuning dramatically reduce the effectiveness of
automated detection methods. This study addresses a gap by exploring smaller
open-source models and the effects of "uncensoring," providing insights into
how fine-tuning and content moderation influence machine-generated text
detection. | [
0.0733409673,
0.044694066,
-0.0299805757,
0.0383860283,
-0.0499101579,
0.0188977122,
0.0272992775,
0.0236452688,
0.0322231688,
-0.0312825181,
0.0224562027,
-0.0339960717,
-0.0168621726,
0.0374411494,
0.0458197966,
0.0020132775,
0.0252923667,
-0.0138163762,
0.0061935754,
-0.0052188975,
0.0342380926,
0.0443055518,
0.0223544799,
0.0334128663,
-0.0006593284,
0.0020113238,
0.0260612834,
0.0267047696,
0.0047542048,
0.0075878426,
0.035046488,
0.0843489096,
0.0119352629,
0.1047967449,
0.0000021557,
-0.0337373391,
-0.02317762,
-0.0117164645,
-0.0153527623,
0.0535023026,
0.1045107096,
-0.0097002089,
-0.030777622,
0.0432299897,
-0.0536525957,
0.0445202552,
0.0361253768,
0.0248808544,
0.0514179058,
0.0732509196,
-0.0226411428,
0.0126544135,
0.0336790793,
-0.0138041126,
-0.0112653468,
-0.003051572,
0.0318106711,
-0.021413805,
0.0003753744,
0.0230845455,
0.0399602242,
0.0370893814,
0.0032129306,
-0.0326300152,
-0.0140358889,
-0.0039856187,
-0.0325612463,
-0.0490314439,
0.003346619,
0.0363382809,
-0.0246288851,
-0.0636407882,
0.0307530779,
-0.0164355449,
0.019449994,
0.0447158292,
0.002537427,
0.0369832478,
-0.019025933,
-0.0051505254,
-0.0116063487,
-0.0069426089,
0.0314926468,
0.0436873548,
0.0135339219,
0.010036408,
0.0122750904,
-0.0499298833,
-0.0217853095,
0.0029076058,
-0.0380474553,
-0.0622864477,
0.0237935856,
-0.0054953843,
-0.0073542758,
-0.0071966848,
-0.0732964873,
-0.0438769348,
0.038533289,
-0.0354369693,
0.0309407581,
0.018267991,
-0.000181884,
-0.0030851557,
-0.0318353027,
0.0567046888,
-0.044375658,
0.0013475827,
0.0141379656,
-0.0039204224,
-0.0193400178,
-0.018167451,
-0.015019835,
-0.0217345674,
-0.0188500546,
-0.0050337589,
-0.0578085519,
0.0310182832,
0.002297,
-0.0287613086,
-0.0226705894,
-0.0356186591,
-0.0089103309,
0.0029162606,
-0.0043995264,
-0.0056339544,
0.0240431856,
0.0178430285,
-0.0035986495,
-0.1150321215,
0.0030178891,
0.0498650745,
0.0312833562,
-0.0246160552,
0.0014188737,
0.0226018708,
-0.0066948542,
-0.0470419861,
-0.0226838887,
-0.0480623282,
-0.0114943944,
-0.0579379313,
-0.0126848835,
-0.0820408762,
-0.0044284649,
0.0194672737,
-0.0080758166,
-0.034831807,
0.0130422907,
0.0648638457,
-0.0287584383,
-0.0099380463,
-0.0602804758,
0.0482877754,
0.0221512578,
-0.0004210211,
0.0034497997,
0.0647285879,
0.0186876189,
0.0789111033,
0.0398329198,
-0.0266482588,
0.0553108789,
0.0643987432,
0.0183732696,
0.0146302739,
-0.0066599813,
-0.0429479629,
-0.0280695856,
-0.0052039316,
0.0119105736,
0.0686402619,
-0.0096551478,
0.0114504127,
0.1055358797,
0.049461931,
-0.0168225449,
0.0037519359,
0.0850764066,
0.0640632138,
0.0377922095,
0.0016588119,
-0.0344024934,
-0.0194505397,
-0.0403923541,
-0.0201591793,
0.0138379131,
0.0558637455,
0.0007006678,
-0.0089906463,
-0.0125872195,
-0.0100677991,
0.0115205068,
-0.023818206,
0.0043839389,
-0.0053081266,
-0.0534534454,
0.0052217888,
0.0042795697,
-0.0616080984,
-0.0126846787,
-0.0566241331,
0.0143288029,
0.07990852,
0.0347877033,
0.0587583035,
0.0541289747,
-0.048999913,
0.0510556959,
0.0861694589,
-0.0000889565,
0.0101271858,
-0.0140881352,
-0.0286186785,
-0.0082328757,
-0.0241707526,
0.0094030667,
-0.0044961656,
0.0475310534,
-0.0069137299,
0.0309658032,
-0.0120849591,
-0.0564924069,
0.0085545164,
-0.0493070073,
-0.0083038695,
-0.0262558237,
0.0043532392,
-0.0114173936,
0.030970566,
-0.0093090758,
-0.0158412289,
0.0174117703,
-0.0078882603,
-0.0188554171,
-0.0003946603,
-0.0202366579,
0.0432423949,
0.0266053528,
-0.0143103963,
-0.0366821699,
0.0311508533,
-0.0106174611,
-0.0027758221,
0.0474346988,
-0.0530434698,
0.0223560128,
-0.0708502531,
0.0172062553,
-0.0716007352,
0.0391764194,
0.016136229,
0.0594952479,
-0.0345770456,
-0.0054129143,
0.0592051223,
-0.0303579792,
0.0153884785,
0.0010382466,
-0.0102037713,
-0.0256685372,
-0.0331720114,
0.0389674306,
0.0224920399,
0.0075411396,
-0.0245378129,
-0.038242884,
-0.0496913642,
-0.0020478,
-0.0520245247,
-0.000830573,
0.0499191508,
0.0108215827,
-0.0402073711,
0.0442168936,
-0.0102610337,
-0.0401581526,
0.0546369664,
0.0238512494,
0.0167067759,
-0.0507193282,
-0.0231159292,
-0.0235836152,
0.0078754947,
-0.0262681339,
0.0169481672,
0.02042941,
-0.0507918112,
-0.0140914004,
0.0404013395,
-0.0046911221,
0.0096593527,
-0.0027055647,
-0.0605211034,
0.006995399,
-0.0176021978,
0.0399319902,
0.0322980881,
0.0364598222,
0.0266834255,
0.0082266638,
0.0207196046,
-0.0181027688,
-0.0291717686,
-0.0178375468,
-0.0517956726,
-0.0314335823,
-0.0750520974,
0.0212282855,
0.0583780967,
0.0141079957,
0.0011075268,
-0.0463500991,
0.0488058813,
-0.0254549775,
-0.0376732722,
0.0133730434,
-0.0221681166,
-0.0325444676,
0.02797186,
-0.0364421271,
-0.0825760812,
0.0341805369,
-0.0387991555,
0.0224933829,
0.000009713,
-0.0612348691,
0.0088827601,
-0.0317854173,
0.0391512476,
0.0369497016,
0.0323611982,
-0.0036518325,
0.0300112367,
0.0250574816,
0.0304193888,
-0.038552396,
-0.0140391197,
0.0060818223,
0.0162967518,
0.0197030287,
0.0045691309,
-0.0350789987,
-0.062396653,
-0.0170973353,
-0.0092078447,
0.0541686118,
-0.0486758463,
0.0073290402,
-0.0121545214,
0.0156298224,
0.0088996235,
-0.0390347503,
-0.0010544675,
-0.0384509638,
0.0243019499,
0.0215599593,
-0.0323209018,
0.0278219953,
-0.0521202348,
0.0118973926,
0.0399996825,
0.0009743196,
-0.0276158396,
-0.011784574,
-0.0249216482,
0.0138075538,
0.0093058133,
0.0005262239,
0.0341569856,
0.0777354166,
-0.0209297519,
0.0174489692,
0.1118760407,
0.0212489292,
0.0037352743,
-0.0077942731,
-0.0032904965,
0.0337964371,
0.0109387469,
-0.0072940518,
-0.0935214683,
-0.008739586,
0.0016124189,
0.0470617898,
-0.0688342527,
-0.0119668292,
-0.0246083103,
-0.1108273566,
0.0546030626,
0.0058028889,
-0.0131183518,
-0.012107214,
-0.0265465733,
-0.0178779438,
0.0049344678,
0.0125811435,
-0.0138033871,
-0.0387859866,
0.0160465166,
0.0133838579,
-0.0399492756,
-0.0921265632,
-0.0039324239,
-0.0424578972,
0.0222695414,
0.0440990403,
0.0227455255,
-0.0055377143,
-0.0542965904,
0.0309250448,
-0.0262267292,
0.0077578006,
-0.0118258651,
0.0468649305,
-0.0108114397,
-0.0007531781,
-0.052726537,
0.0388520733,
-0.0323186703,
0.0051375255,
-0.0388518907,
0.0410794616,
0.0117943808,
-0.050982561,
-0.0088009704,
-0.0002840692,
0.0431858003,
0.0640116557,
0.0618648119,
-0.0379992649,
-0.0437698402,
-0.033030577,
0.032365609,
-0.0300928187,
-0.0641975626,
-0.0152830891,
0.0046280511,
-0.0527046025,
-0.0472527817,
-0.0259783845,
-0.0105637582,
-0.0193684436,
-0.0089487517,
0.0248107947,
-0.0079826964,
-0.034734901,
-0.0294471867,
0.0074334564,
-0.0538167357,
0.0600135624,
-0.053071253,
0.0001382836,
-0.0082697412,
-0.014300948,
0.018764127,
0.0276649781,
-0.0935084671,
-0.0829042196,
0.0158264246,
0.0206611231,
0.0236889496,
0.0059140529,
-0.0197546482,
-0.0679691732,
0.0448695011,
0.0488365814,
-0.0239088107,
0.045502618,
0.0182501003,
-0.0052966583,
0.0041889604,
0.0180523973,
-0.002547998,
0.0177524164,
0.0309880264,
-0.0294366218,
-0.0216651745,
-0.0052864049,
0.0175558478,
0.0379811823,
0.0260892175,
-0.0108965589,
-0.0060677784,
-0.0219900329,
-0.0644586459,
-0.0283506345,
-0.000217932,
-0.0450547859,
-0.0088649644,
0.0295862909,
0.0194913726,
-0.0039400049,
0.0154886553,
-0.0643485636,
0.0582509711,
-0.0583109222,
0.0321568102,
-0.0335430056,
0.0647489354,
0.0295636375,
-0.0095246453,
-0.0073803961,
0.0380062833,
-0.0115725193,
0.0219641197,
0.0190112535,
0.0382348076,
-0.0388751067,
-0.0076337517,
0.0328493193,
0.0467924736,
-0.021137407,
-0.0140204486,
-0.0585461035,
0.0232739393,
0.0531865805,
-0.0196381547,
0.1014972851,
0.0019079613,
0.0120815588,
-0.0202818234,
0.0134371649,
-0.0139550306,
-0.0386958048,
-0.0096248882,
-0.0206536762,
-0.0465839058,
0.031847585,
0.0816241577,
0.0310317539,
0.0491254479,
0.0054813232,
-0.0132358745,
-0.0108890804,
-0.0195294674,
0.0176290944,
0.0076414747,
-0.0075768121,
0.009746558,
-0.0488728546,
-0.0694387481,
0.0109168207,
-0.0337155201,
0.0067859306,
-0.0023822433,
-0.0195806585,
0.0725045353,
-0.0221612286,
0.0037163678,
-0.0646370873,
-0.0202108473,
0.0079633472,
-0.0422051847,
0.0049092863,
-7.075581147e-33,
0.0318074226,
-0.0656777844,
-0.0196266286,
-0.0327433124,
-0.0009681582,
0.0000630288,
-0.0123992749,
-0.0042021987,
-0.0083974823,
0.0022089346,
-0.0147778168,
0.0295802951,
0.0058468264,
0.0071335933,
-0.0211536288,
0.0304717775,
0.0492298342,
-0.0165675543,
-0.0372755975,
0.0494489074,
0.0515241213,
-0.018980097,
0.0070372182,
-0.0933161378,
0.0350864753,
-0.0669070333,
-0.0278296266,
0.004240375,
-0.0077777812,
0.0480264574,
-0.0215938352,
0.0606140681,
0.0375059955,
-0.0157114249,
-0.0144764287,
0.0502186343,
0.0090833437,
0.0045920648,
0.0189866461,
-0.0220614597,
0.0098608537,
-0.090508379,
0.0434337407,
-0.0413250402,
-0.0538388789,
0.0333341807,
0.0174581893,
0.0042259693,
0.0479282029,
-0.0435542092,
-0.0494149886,
0.0367994234,
-0.0055265208,
-0.0124653392,
0.0095745428,
0.0722367167,
0.0170114301,
0.0204753876,
-0.0620847829,
0.048367694,
0.0256789736,
-0.0110664684,
0.071631521,
-0.026672665,
-0.0183697883,
0.0199350622,
0.0170857869,
0.0280593336,
-0.0105639482,
0.0125829158,
-0.0208496191,
0.0366937555,
0.0536114573,
0.0942416415,
0.0134491399,
-0.0632677972,
-0.0410059839,
0.0155746276,
0.0007735353,
0.002892277,
0.0504330322,
-0.0237939879,
-0.0463430956,
-0.0254206695,
-0.0140450662,
-0.0634381995,
-0.0368109792,
-0.0323571339,
0.0188203938,
0.0019601765,
-0.0413122438,
-0.0252706576,
0.0429558791,
-0.0608644336,
-0.0052509117,
0.0174671076,
-0.0616262406,
0.0294684861,
0.0152564822,
0.045410376,
-0.0503848195,
-0.0221232325,
0.0559884012,
-0.0104043484,
0.0146327168,
-0.0005499961,
0.0197492465,
0.0317297466,
-0.0505256392,
0.0192916896,
-0.0029785288,
0.0596626066,
-0.0108464267,
-0.0098933782,
0.0255122427,
-0.0130900564,
-0.0086139608,
-0.0069494951,
0.0447643325,
-0.0072024236,
-0.0289684888,
0.0002417214,
-0.0401183926,
0.008108723,
-0.0306216609,
0.0157349817,
-0.0351877697,
0.0216531325,
0.0375689492,
-0.0477244072,
-0.0054972935,
-0.0321472362,
2.959e-7,
0.0005271136,
0.0803425536,
0.0008996273,
-0.014047889,
0.0541681163,
0.036987029,
0.0278130956,
0.0158476103,
0.0039959257,
-0.0325175337,
-0.038397897,
0.0253076591,
0.080673866,
0.0018393911,
-0.0380883217,
0.0239017028,
-0.0629510358,
0.0123404348,
-0.0685692206,
0.0007685002,
0.0363378748,
0.0406400934,
0.0083462168,
-0.0313265473,
-0.014340179,
-0.0735974759,
0.0583312213,
-0.0076295668,
-0.02254113,
0.0367453098,
0.0797832906,
-0.0011076081,
0.0208447296,
0.0025324542,
-0.018803997,
0.025733579,
0.0029666268,
0.0677963197,
0.0363379531,
0.0516709872,
0.0138487034,
-0.0658079982,
0.0069225607,
-0.0553078875,
0.0664011315,
-0.0150322979,
-0.0478643961,
-0.0672271773,
-0.0321631469,
-0.0536561869,
0.0139492592,
-0.0413343683,
-0.0327013768,
0.030368289,
-0.002795218,
0.0202885307,
-0.0285128802,
-0.0162381511,
-0.0146847917,
-0.0607236437,
-0.0358473882,
-0.0516301915,
-0.0560480915,
-0.0006511126,
0.044555176,
0.0009283327,
0.0695631281,
2.685429472e-34,
0.0217798501,
-0.0262993984,
0.039009247,
-0.0050659063,
0.0422273129,
0.0435930677,
0.0084310379,
0.0218863804,
-0.0035498876,
-0.0610003769,
0.0265820697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17962v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17962v2 | SimsChat: A Customisable Persona-Driven Role-Playing Agent | 2024-06-25T22:44:17 | 2024-06-30T21:15:47 | Bohao Yang, Dong Liu, Chen Tang, Chenghao Xiao, Kun Zhao, Chao Li, Lin Yuan, Guang Yang, Lanxiao Huang, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) possess the remarkable capability to understand
human instructions and generate high-quality text, enabling them to act as
agents that simulate human behaviours. This capability allows LLMs to emulate
human beings in a more advanced manner, beyond merely replicating simple human
behaviours. However, there is a lack of exploring into leveraging LLMs to craft
characters from several aspects. In this work, we introduce the Customisable
Conversation Agent Framework, which employs LLMs to simulate real-world
characters that can be freely customised according to different user
preferences. The customisable framework is helpful for designing customisable
characters and role-playing agents according to human's preferences. We first
propose the SimsConv dataset, which comprises 68 different customised
characters, 1,360 multi-turn role-playing dialogues, and encompasses 13,971
interaction dialogues in total. The characters are created from several
real-world elements, such as career, aspiration, trait, and skill. Building on
these foundations, we present SimsChat, a freely customisable role-playing
agent. It incorporates different real-world scenes and topic-specific character
interaction dialogues, simulating characters' life experiences in various
scenarios and topic-specific interactions with specific emotions. Experimental
results show that our proposed framework achieves desirable performance and
provides helpful guideline for building better simulacra of human beings in the
future. Our data and code are available at
https://github.com/Bernard-Yang/SimsChat. | SimsChat: A Customisable Persona-Driven Role-Playing Agent: Large Language Models (LLMs) possess the remarkable capability to understand
human instructions and generate high-quality text, enabling them to act as
agents that simulate human behaviours. This capability allows LLMs to emulate
human beings in a more advanced manner, beyond merely replicating simple human
behaviours. However, there is a lack of exploring into leveraging LLMs to craft
characters from several aspects. In this work, we introduce the Customisable
Conversation Agent Framework, which employs LLMs to simulate real-world
characters that can be freely customised according to different user
preferences. The customisable framework is helpful for designing customisable
characters and role-playing agents according to human's preferences. We first
propose the SimsConv dataset, which comprises 68 different customised
characters, 1,360 multi-turn role-playing dialogues, and encompasses 13,971
interaction dialogues in total. The characters are created from several
real-world elements, such as career, aspiration, trait, and skill. Building on
these foundations, we present SimsChat, a freely customisable role-playing
agent. It incorporates different real-world scenes and topic-specific character
interaction dialogues, simulating characters' life experiences in various
scenarios and topic-specific interactions with specific emotions. Experimental
results show that our proposed framework achieves desirable performance and
provides helpful guideline for building better simulacra of human beings in the
future. Our data and code are available at
https://github.com/Bernard-Yang/SimsChat. | [
0.0605549701,
0.0405835584,
-0.0435984954,
0.024680756,
-0.0062871003,
0.0060907239,
0.0193379633,
-0.0141471596,
0.0425119996,
0.0177973025,
-0.0253438968,
-0.0476705208,
-0.0138226599,
0.0553234331,
0.0061233742,
-0.0685062781,
0.0190761294,
-0.0299715642,
0.0341091938,
-0.0008900288,
0.0080448827,
0.0492918603,
-0.0149660585,
0.0613056272,
-0.009716033,
-0.03199194,
-0.0219664648,
0.0084649436,
0.0396439619,
-0.0217297506,
0.0329408683,
0.0057150209,
0.0227127839,
0.0047044419,
0.000002078,
-0.0203564409,
0.0158260707,
-0.0306511503,
0.001758443,
-0.0111453682,
0.0833933502,
0.0631205812,
-0.0172105152,
0.0374593809,
-0.0435849428,
0.0006949027,
0.0482754521,
0.0446971767,
0.1018838286,
0.0762471035,
-0.0204117745,
-0.0314195678,
-0.0539549924,
-0.0165028777,
0.0248320866,
-0.032440491,
-0.0009778868,
0.045287136,
0.0561832003,
-0.0106945047,
-0.0049061934,
0.0131195318,
-0.0143762911,
-0.0241498947,
-0.0171556845,
0.0436742567,
0.0134590315,
-0.0159067027,
0.0192844588,
0.0700075701,
0.0083830971,
-0.0040075867,
0.0313660391,
0.0136088226,
0.0423049144,
0.0144898519,
-0.0160410982,
0.0350863263,
-0.0097538391,
-0.0076608979,
-0.0161715224,
0.0359499753,
-0.0022897171,
-0.0141745135,
-0.0117462734,
-0.0037312317,
0.0089520719,
-0.0130843911,
-0.0561574772,
-0.0247723311,
0.0213966072,
-0.0716009364,
-0.012091035,
0.009571637,
-0.0520498119,
0.0393304043,
-0.0695887581,
0.0546337217,
-0.0093418565,
-0.0214598235,
0.0258452799,
0.0458676666,
0.0053911707,
0.024355853,
0.0445639491,
0.0144536132,
0.014328056,
-0.0214762352,
-0.0217577629,
-0.0043045538,
-0.0337535962,
-0.0335354097,
-0.0332732312,
0.0384489782,
-0.0368617177,
-0.0320464224,
-0.0388095006,
0.0719148889,
-0.0282158777,
0.0247268807,
0.0084360344,
0.0173885636,
-0.0351930819,
0.0189476926,
-0.056007009,
0.0000701096,
-0.0372171141,
-0.013670207,
0.0099924775,
-0.0555845983,
0.0372516215,
-0.016196942,
0.0065401108,
0.0101475595,
0.0320814401,
0.0907070711,
-0.0059257764,
-0.0120752482,
0.0387945622,
-0.0268639363,
0.0287597757,
-0.0566010438,
-0.0411453806,
-0.0428413935,
0.0506534353,
-0.0300042238,
0.0207885113,
-0.0446323752,
0.0103220521,
0.022465203,
0.0136606032,
0.0762322545,
0.0027052287,
0.0317078754,
0.0317610241,
0.0301278587,
-0.0062821633,
0.0266080927,
0.0426631048,
0.0284580868,
0.0060873758,
-0.0070247068,
0.0532953814,
0.044739984,
-0.0592023358,
-0.0237772092,
0.0178830102,
-0.0044102981,
0.0035956209,
0.0596736223,
0.0096274139,
0.0347144306,
-0.0606191643,
-0.0238404498,
0.0748976991,
0.0616992079,
0.0147865489,
0.0361689292,
0.0420511626,
0.0728142709,
0.0319511592,
-0.0384429842,
-0.0017081538,
0.0442707539,
0.0396065004,
-0.0230729114,
-0.0731835887,
0.033426594,
-0.0203426667,
-0.0214417484,
0.0448033474,
-0.0238678511,
0.0295106694,
0.0184243098,
-0.0093214856,
-0.0129488092,
-0.0423377715,
0.0278732609,
0.0276970249,
-0.0880405232,
-0.0157852937,
-0.0539190546,
0.0327332392,
0.1489654332,
0.0429341383,
-0.0356905647,
-0.0502507202,
-0.0200995598,
-0.0213639103,
0.0426726267,
0.0143613797,
-0.027977908,
0.0208284892,
-0.0398391932,
0.0287381578,
0.0020318134,
-0.0182710495,
0.0571186133,
-0.0002021938,
-0.0071500274,
-0.0174981207,
0.0607828423,
0.0211008471,
0.0066516208,
-0.0805476829,
-0.0012188834,
-0.010240254,
0.0087377522,
0.0104581369,
0.0034787208,
-0.0106198015,
-0.0407998227,
0.0126424283,
-0.0115882251,
-0.0119390804,
0.0811494216,
-0.0412500501,
0.0022043989,
0.0489017069,
-0.0544339158,
-0.0162026919,
0.0337955914,
0.0093789417,
-0.0054922444,
0.0135884723,
-0.0404304005,
0.0437269993,
-0.0043100724,
0.0273271501,
-0.0173616335,
0.0570695996,
-0.004003061,
0.0292463563,
0.0199334826,
-0.0381634682,
0.0091788182,
0.0254953168,
-0.0213974919,
-0.0647957772,
0.0113077667,
-0.0010236428,
0.0011887469,
0.0207717568,
0.0203003027,
0.0018105201,
-0.0548549183,
-0.0543533005,
-0.0914560407,
0.0066955923,
0.0390101671,
-0.0323530622,
0.0337708332,
0.0311570857,
-0.055315353,
-0.0140881445,
-0.0688097849,
0.0042198254,
0.0133816302,
-0.0264044851,
0.0391683914,
-0.0074931681,
-0.0098314574,
-0.0547402501,
0.0067485739,
-0.0059695025,
0.0255477764,
-0.0269048102,
0.0355505906,
-0.0154501507,
0.0025203156,
-0.0358122624,
0.0361062773,
-0.031456314,
-0.0645240918,
0.0369422659,
-0.0323248804,
0.0358735621,
0.0279931836,
0.0394406244,
0.0417520814,
0.0185924862,
-0.0315593146,
-0.0489708818,
0.024236802,
0.0063416492,
0.0180715881,
-0.0513222143,
-0.0593222268,
0.0280326027,
0.0456957929,
-0.0118907355,
0.0338466987,
-0.0768667459,
0.0474701673,
0.0471461266,
-0.0389173217,
0.0503772758,
0.0018656716,
-0.018149877,
-0.0179281924,
-0.0074356166,
0.0193289742,
0.0393553898,
-0.0063358513,
-0.0281285495,
-0.0043270946,
-0.005290173,
-0.0132035874,
0.0801776201,
-0.0047382587,
0.0147070726,
0.0050042165,
-0.017782893,
-0.0155631592,
-0.0273622759,
0.0161706973,
-0.0484742895,
0.0160371196,
-0.0565144904,
-0.0268414468,
0.0359355584,
-0.0080752224,
-0.0355063565,
-0.0481398292,
-0.0400363952,
-0.0407900102,
0.0284496434,
-0.0417769291,
-0.0422073342,
-0.01968343,
-0.0036362505,
0.0130692497,
-0.0011142142,
-0.0117762927,
-0.0304052383,
-0.0267357323,
0.0841982514,
0.0255288072,
-0.0218080264,
-0.0199296437,
0.0894201025,
0.0267462749,
-0.074181132,
-0.0245728679,
-0.001961031,
-0.0082347086,
0.0244894642,
-0.0340835713,
-0.0002826766,
0.0084304186,
0.0302751102,
-0.0414967611,
-0.0081360172,
0.12496759,
0.0082520293,
-0.0082433373,
0.0264567267,
-0.0076581291,
0.033637166,
0.0221195165,
0.0481842011,
-0.0636265203,
-0.007388161,
-0.0046212785,
0.0205603987,
-0.0249682982,
-0.0439071395,
-0.0174216386,
-0.090874739,
0.0237727836,
-0.0000868369,
-0.0597524978,
-0.0078375554,
0.0104608294,
0.0036754452,
-0.0193536021,
-0.0063204113,
-0.0183348749,
0.0122595411,
-0.0136050535,
-0.0225888602,
-0.0584147051,
-0.0238607991,
0.0604930259,
-0.046500776,
0.1188957393,
0.0286459941,
0.0978531688,
0.0279907007,
-0.0157655589,
-0.0553719886,
0.0661952868,
-0.0018958374,
0.0137536414,
0.0448725447,
-0.0189956129,
-0.0363768339,
-0.0640350357,
0.02271308,
-0.0057139397,
-0.0082701221,
0.021402508,
0.0240149517,
-0.0170267671,
-0.0243509244,
-0.0325689651,
0.0144757722,
0.0343215056,
0.0453820974,
-0.0391050279,
-0.0905622616,
-0.0174445771,
-0.0170747899,
0.0070557711,
-0.0457327403,
-0.0890569314,
-0.0190595686,
0.0064879181,
-0.0156522933,
-0.0627221912,
-0.0610625073,
0.0156124625,
0.0267756451,
-0.0050563398,
-0.0332504734,
0.0043675322,
0.0314356014,
-0.0049178656,
-0.023238631,
-0.0678155348,
0.0220543947,
-0.0138578508,
-0.0669208542,
0.0430462956,
-0.0935238302,
0.0216058828,
-0.021248119,
-0.0424923003,
-0.0293241944,
0.0192833152,
0.0394270644,
0.0175479576,
0.0433462448,
-0.0057377825,
-0.0536317565,
0.0041922065,
-0.0000931905,
-0.0687586516,
0.0024104009,
0.0043299343,
0.0570657179,
0.0043156836,
0.0028586921,
-0.0228990726,
0.0366532169,
-0.0395056531,
0.0160754584,
-0.0476007946,
-0.0629059076,
0.0074306014,
0.0227651168,
-0.0563810505,
-0.0189246442,
-0.0181381758,
-0.0065735555,
-0.000530423,
-0.0756257698,
-0.0051898924,
-0.0303568132,
-0.0278847776,
0.0258956291,
-0.0026342641,
0.0107661793,
-0.0441157483,
-0.0401202217,
-0.0097612524,
0.00083789,
0.0008697563,
0.0108440146,
0.0073658726,
0.0106144501,
0.0182207227,
0.0067012357,
0.0260355715,
-0.0338642076,
0.0408947729,
0.0105209295,
0.0274963677,
-0.0347558744,
-0.0611290671,
0.0035765595,
0.0592516847,
-0.0380783118,
-0.0441589504,
0.0289209075,
0.0278385989,
0.0263804477,
0.0111807361,
0.0373818278,
-0.0363520607,
0.019292457,
-0.0063475715,
0.011876245,
0.0064662327,
-0.0484154969,
-0.0333987251,
0.0280262064,
-0.0220485702,
-0.0327156484,
0.0203111507,
0.0036722329,
0.0406013764,
-0.0105945114,
-0.0412072688,
-0.0664574876,
-0.0042139115,
0.0233909842,
0.0146935331,
-0.0342013426,
-0.011635025,
-0.0886713862,
-0.0313309878,
0.0050643482,
0.064501524,
-0.0115338368,
-0.0390408151,
0.0173274633,
-0.0053858822,
-0.0049580289,
0.0325516872,
-0.0643025637,
0.0314572006,
-0.037295524,
0.0122151766,
0.0003012656,
-5.294537493e-33,
-0.0293096006,
0.0006492891,
0.0395832807,
0.0220877808,
-0.0551408455,
-0.0273096059,
-0.037639413,
-0.0054121893,
0.0112219378,
-0.0030149829,
-0.0104520191,
0.0060774814,
-0.0024496661,
0.0049033272,
0.0005049513,
-0.0129209217,
0.0612947308,
0.0184412543,
-0.0187031981,
0.0373468436,
0.020636864,
0.0007347291,
0.0171153583,
-0.1024905816,
-0.0221239496,
-0.0371604413,
-0.0317977183,
0.0010784407,
0.0403084569,
0.0592821427,
-0.0030346066,
0.0038045885,
-0.0021742061,
0.0001654367,
-0.0042418158,
0.0229436178,
-0.0550749227,
-0.0091250017,
-0.0037933146,
0.0170875713,
-0.0018897168,
-0.0487645492,
-0.0137919765,
-0.011749899,
0.0165629908,
-0.0184987001,
0.0504662618,
-0.0206264723,
0.039744433,
0.0234057046,
-0.0736382306,
-0.0068558473,
-0.0493660644,
-0.0533675216,
-0.0063967588,
0.0468633138,
-0.006960223,
-0.01262201,
-0.0499481335,
0.0482969247,
-0.0183775015,
-0.01651242,
-0.0010121389,
0.05059205,
0.0451568961,
0.0784237087,
0.0598801747,
0.0422901437,
-0.0312214531,
0.0055375085,
0.0332776383,
0.0634146705,
0.0147542935,
0.0706528649,
-0.0246579479,
-0.0441123769,
-0.0005184321,
0.0274507497,
0.0702795759,
0.0031547511,
0.0370045528,
0.034484271,
-0.0383309238,
0.0167563502,
-0.017306149,
0.0404492877,
0.004618099,
-0.0546459667,
0.0126446737,
-0.0114633795,
-0.0467614159,
-0.020053912,
0.0106112137,
-0.0499848127,
-0.0006009773,
-0.0017013358,
-0.0457023829,
0.0113842553,
-0.0103676068,
0.0105188927,
-0.0086028203,
-0.0324055664,
0.0477664396,
-0.0153966239,
0.0388012789,
0.060519129,
-0.0306636263,
0.062472228,
-0.0431646705,
-0.0222162809,
-0.0123754134,
0.0395272858,
-0.0212540179,
0.0232228599,
-0.0077774059,
-0.0130956788,
-0.0440779664,
-0.0254591815,
-0.000958245,
-0.0099506313,
-0.0201977734,
0.0080698542,
-0.0045924811,
-0.0140567441,
-0.0269584842,
0.0097411955,
-0.089062959,
0.0437423065,
0.0339614302,
-0.0349195115,
-0.0079926187,
-0.0167671163,
2.825e-7,
-0.0497314259,
0.0176372044,
0.0037755782,
0.0426507816,
0.0316147916,
0.0585747845,
0.0008840626,
0.0296872985,
0.0155478455,
-0.0287562069,
0.0362307541,
0.053689234,
0.0374762006,
0.0110433325,
-0.0981372148,
0.0108843567,
-0.0013665397,
-0.0106982654,
-0.0260655172,
0.0076548546,
0.0791282058,
0.0714581758,
0.0557733588,
-0.006925425,
0.030626975,
0.0452129059,
0.0286942814,
-0.0579956397,
-0.0242998227,
0.0333643481,
-0.0189574379,
-0.004812574,
-0.0229264442,
-0.00036194,
0.0097221956,
0.0113965217,
0.0091272769,
0.0534198992,
-0.0303474776,
0.0117525253,
0.00515889,
0.0017094023,
-0.0248589125,
-0.006916035,
0.0315709561,
-0.0085755903,
-0.0347914547,
-0.0452253483,
-0.0267458204,
0.0022929909,
-0.0186291635,
-0.0268243849,
-0.0580986701,
0.0040386454,
-0.0091108959,
-0.0205513835,
0.0079941116,
-0.0677260309,
-0.0012261404,
-0.0224774424,
-0.0596641041,
-0.0340041704,
-0.0291298572,
0.0051259245,
0.014508618,
-0.0204918236,
0.04749671,
1.976410539e-34,
-0.0310869552,
0.0575834848,
-0.0181390792,
0.0168098751,
0.0500247106,
0.0218377691,
0.0555998906,
0.0404518694,
0.052374769,
-0.046554286,
-0.0132380333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17961v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17961v1 | NormTab: Improving Symbolic Reasoning in LLMs Through Tabular Data Normalization | 2024-06-25T22:40:03 | 2024-06-25T22:40:03 | Md Mahadi Hasan Nahid, Davood Rafiei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.IR | In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable
capabilities in parsing textual data and generating code. However, their
performance in tasks involving tabular data, especially those requiring
symbolic reasoning, faces challenges due to the structural variance and
inconsistency in table cell values often found in web tables. In this paper, we
introduce NormTab, a novel framework aimed at enhancing the symbolic reasoning
performance of LLMs by normalizing web tables. We study table normalization as
a stand-alone, one-time preprocessing step using LLMs to support symbolic
reasoning on tabular data. Our experimental evaluation, conducted on
challenging web table datasets such as WikiTableQuestion and TabFact,
demonstrates that leveraging NormTab significantly improves symbolic reasoning
performance, showcasing the importance and effectiveness of web table
normalization for enhancing LLM-based symbolic reasoning tasks. | NormTab: Improving Symbolic Reasoning in LLMs Through Tabular Data Normalization: In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable
capabilities in parsing textual data and generating code. However, their
performance in tasks involving tabular data, especially those requiring
symbolic reasoning, faces challenges due to the structural variance and
inconsistency in table cell values often found in web tables. In this paper, we
introduce NormTab, a novel framework aimed at enhancing the symbolic reasoning
performance of LLMs by normalizing web tables. We study table normalization as
a stand-alone, one-time preprocessing step using LLMs to support symbolic
reasoning on tabular data. Our experimental evaluation, conducted on
challenging web table datasets such as WikiTableQuestion and TabFact,
demonstrates that leveraging NormTab significantly improves symbolic reasoning
performance, showcasing the importance and effectiveness of web table
normalization for enhancing LLM-based symbolic reasoning tasks. | [
0.0261214729,
0.055632174,
-0.0390479304,
0.014897326,
-0.0535171665,
0.0439601243,
0.0019634061,
0.0320287682,
0.0226896163,
-0.0304871239,
0.0117782066,
-0.0266424585,
-0.0126315095,
0.0312022083,
0.0116162067,
0.0175897274,
0.0508345775,
-0.0196599551,
-0.014311539,
0.0262827557,
-0.0102652358,
0.0024281964,
-0.014847571,
0.0093600564,
0.0057474924,
-0.0101810414,
-0.0019706092,
0.0051256712,
-0.0018084047,
-0.0108970851,
-0.0262541436,
0.0547695532,
0.0033259213,
0.0061851065,
0.0000021086,
-0.025068013,
-0.0516708456,
-0.0206824988,
-0.010189238,
0.0112791397,
0.0175777078,
-0.031106934,
-0.0231341571,
0.0364688076,
-0.0368778892,
0.0078412155,
0.0059278915,
0.0097314846,
0.0318454988,
0.0508663319,
-0.0012497806,
-0.0365049727,
-0.0108464658,
0.0539572053,
0.0520358235,
-0.0039168582,
-0.0179997683,
0.0490621142,
0.0128541337,
-0.0571512803,
0.0406083651,
0.0407193489,
0.0394948944,
-0.0223562643,
-0.021290794,
0.0318823345,
-0.0402773209,
0.010233731,
0.0000453431,
0.0611593127,
0.0171822477,
-0.0271273497,
0.0366047435,
0.0160236862,
0.0127292778,
0.0103742871,
-0.0505835451,
0.0497919507,
-0.0250463728,
0.001969611,
0.0326739214,
-0.0193102602,
0.016653236,
-0.0069241235,
-0.0658473447,
0.0984633341,
-0.004647492,
-0.0222676992,
-0.0349082537,
-0.0573639199,
-0.017704891,
-0.0606710054,
0.0431754179,
0.0893474743,
-0.008187321,
0.0395573974,
-0.0160114486,
-0.0204593278,
0.0400629193,
-0.0565716587,
0.0402923934,
0.0733581185,
0.0097629977,
0.0233336575,
-0.0355131589,
0.0491832122,
0.0047677793,
0.0558783747,
-0.0542176329,
-0.0183631442,
-0.062191315,
-0.0158051867,
-0.0264236573,
0.037795227,
-0.0385890603,
0.012783289,
0.0271807816,
0.0378452204,
-0.0057004127,
0.0589404367,
0.0187851954,
-0.0207678583,
0.0208324473,
-0.0090244627,
-0.0149378423,
0.0105424374,
-0.0300426707,
-0.029431073,
-0.032283701,
-0.0661820024,
0.0057582171,
-0.0226781927,
0.0105987415,
-0.0122035164,
0.0438566469,
0.0988170207,
-0.0156475492,
0.0360312425,
-0.0621682815,
-0.0497330055,
0.0108613484,
-0.0485912226,
-0.0128763607,
-0.0706671327,
0.027641397,
0.0590318739,
-0.0256482698,
-0.0496806614,
0.015573347,
0.0442068502,
0.0065271067,
0.0545966513,
-0.0108804721,
0.0288222842,
-0.0004297076,
-0.0062500094,
-0.0351005942,
0.0549460053,
0.0539144613,
0.0100116152,
-0.0181848239,
-0.0158247706,
-0.0180128254,
0.0434128344,
0.0038088902,
-0.0166444667,
-0.0740788579,
0.0416880883,
0.0412143879,
0.0307979751,
-0.0148350112,
0.0417276546,
-0.0027653009,
0.0245167892,
0.0182531811,
0.0831784979,
-0.00417034,
0.0419668965,
-0.0018739138,
-0.017069811,
0.0362314172,
-0.0084490813,
-0.0499520488,
0.0295240916,
-0.0445788912,
-0.004551583,
-0.0318484418,
0.0581261665,
0.0038584396,
-0.0605754778,
-0.0415982045,
0.0077221915,
0.018253509,
-0.0103378156,
0.0301526804,
-0.0197820365,
-0.0081032971,
0.0508686379,
0.0220511835,
-0.0807047933,
-0.0207244381,
-0.0114861643,
0.0411413275,
0.0661915168,
0.0614308305,
-0.0501562208,
-0.0458687283,
-0.0124307731,
0.0005652469,
-0.0167613495,
0.0296814311,
-0.0396720134,
-0.0445606187,
-0.0154634137,
-0.0289660152,
0.0420369618,
0.0076797912,
-0.0074179638,
-0.005601217,
0.0019567327,
0.024018731,
-0.095055528,
-0.0350623876,
0.0271283947,
0.0176466629,
0.0172543731,
-0.0242587831,
0.020815691,
0.0038862179,
0.0277854744,
0.0056462279,
0.0375759788,
0.0090508498,
-0.0486545861,
0.0008137823,
-0.0072953478,
-0.0276709255,
-0.0105588073,
0.0758353099,
0.0020041657,
-0.0324410163,
0.0194472838,
-0.0310790744,
-0.0249145776,
0.0405037738,
-0.0078716353,
-0.0123358164,
-0.0060405438,
0.0127560291,
-0.0175579675,
-0.0299509391,
-0.0097263902,
0.0580290854,
-0.0196991023,
0.0112902848,
0.0236247722,
-0.0579362884,
0.0232909843,
0.0324786827,
0.0399581529,
0.0389454886,
-0.0179386418,
0.0242883042,
-0.0180348009,
0.027490098,
-0.0510790609,
-0.0063930689,
-0.0834673196,
0.0303312186,
-0.0226476602,
0.0463108644,
0.0468416587,
0.0223481394,
0.0018033665,
-0.0108740218,
-0.0656997263,
-0.0079457201,
0.0038117301,
-0.0078426404,
0.0653132573,
-0.0196102541,
-0.0624578856,
-0.0097404001,
-0.0052835271,
-0.0650773346,
0.0193027221,
-0.0087046847,
0.0031887041,
0.000293526,
-0.0013520446,
-0.0199904796,
0.0064085112,
0.007384121,
-0.0218746271,
0.0008804657,
-0.0451713502,
0.0209821668,
0.0437821485,
-0.0305715352,
0.0171423629,
0.0333041884,
-0.0165713895,
-0.0738107637,
-0.0045400052,
0.0608315356,
0.0242005475,
-0.0079868743,
-0.0866655558,
0.0102468655,
0.0840604082,
-0.0310195722,
0.0054442687,
-0.0122283781,
0.0185657088,
-0.0076518091,
0.0394892804,
-0.0682566017,
0.0372856185,
-0.0078000445,
0.042670399,
-0.0175488032,
-0.0409814641,
0.0486589596,
-0.0359201916,
0.0126761962,
-0.0402105004,
-0.005258684,
-0.0417531021,
0.0950826705,
-0.026813969,
0.012108881,
-0.022410946,
-0.0542135797,
-0.0423508212,
0.002948449,
0.0183659997,
-0.049453672,
0.1123668179,
-0.0618336387,
0.0163165312,
-0.0244692061,
-0.009109593,
-0.0300163347,
-0.0049434998,
-0.0190770943,
0.0158764794,
0.0128536737,
-0.0054903049,
-0.0050141118,
-0.0030774337,
0.0315114483,
0.0369235128,
0.0027392188,
-0.0112712374,
-0.0269290041,
0.0122306962,
0.0011801822,
-0.0230114348,
-0.008470661,
0.01365826,
0.0180741772,
0.0482715815,
0.0221209116,
-0.0419009551,
-0.0070887748,
0.0255651176,
0.0175848491,
-0.0483018644,
-0.01198838,
0.0607000776,
-0.0219825879,
-0.0639658645,
0.0121772913,
0.1125045121,
0.0672201589,
0.007266087,
0.0097444635,
-0.0325210616,
0.0079278341,
0.029163558,
0.0484960675,
-0.1008514389,
-0.0264094435,
0.0180199724,
-0.0092717819,
0.0182921626,
-0.0506622195,
-0.0166553147,
-0.0744473562,
0.0033415784,
0.0134703731,
-0.0399605781,
-0.0527043939,
-0.0213907547,
-0.0058692247,
-0.0010486142,
0.0348851345,
0.1008149534,
-0.0227342136,
0.0095442748,
0.0128048612,
-0.064508304,
-0.0438430123,
-0.0032366239,
-0.0459770113,
0.0347517468,
0.0227361042,
0.0204017367,
0.001484688,
-0.0361934379,
0.0238241926,
0.0319471322,
0.0129279662,
-0.0496930405,
-0.006454011,
0.0415205099,
-0.0015891626,
-0.0266902652,
-0.0012274787,
-0.0659148395,
-0.005904675,
-0.000242954,
0.0932439342,
-0.0415203422,
-0.0013959067,
-0.0075176777,
-0.0634871125,
-0.0346376039,
0.0632722452,
0.0315510668,
0.0125114815,
-0.063283056,
-0.0607278123,
-0.0923530832,
-0.0297944918,
0.024991041,
0.0169290453,
0.0201779995,
-0.0213030111,
-0.0610661246,
-0.0137365041,
0.073182866,
0.0373832621,
-0.0005848366,
0.0071651218,
-0.0196948424,
-0.018709885,
-0.0771856681,
-0.0156761296,
-0.062242046,
0.0373803228,
0.0153325973,
0.0037899311,
-0.0082745021,
-0.0444508418,
-0.0196119696,
-0.0025377965,
-0.0257788543,
-0.0369216166,
-0.0332890786,
0.0170409307,
0.0285014454,
0.003511535,
-0.001828976,
-0.0281843469,
-0.0357575789,
0.0067914044,
-0.0644034892,
-0.0556026325,
-0.0013269583,
0.0101709338,
0.0406852663,
0.031631723,
-0.0238692779,
-0.0069321292,
-0.0271335468,
0.0436740555,
-0.0022283497,
0.0599089451,
0.03904384,
0.0733405724,
-0.049132511,
0.0440348238,
-0.0588036962,
0.0114031024,
0.0376462899,
-0.0655908659,
-0.0564560257,
-0.006278045,
0.0544772074,
0.0012885814,
0.0036788564,
-0.008145405,
-0.0313232578,
-0.0034877216,
0.0374739915,
-0.0064174975,
0.0488173962,
0.0336971991,
0.0172301866,
0.053238105,
-0.0535580665,
-0.0086338082,
-0.0156178484,
0.0102843139,
0.0218969658,
-0.0431901775,
0.0132783195,
0.0117072472,
-0.018607175,
-0.0629900396,
0.0200340897,
-0.0384437814,
-0.0682863444,
0.0392879732,
-0.0095033636,
0.009445006,
0.0418550856,
0.0270475484,
-0.0210459027,
0.0023804908,
0.026104968,
-0.002621057,
0.032684043,
0.0093058841,
0.0380596519,
0.0118034035,
-0.0096893664,
-0.0658653527,
0.0723451823,
-0.0277327336,
0.0224166512,
-0.0305547137,
-0.0246612541,
-0.0442166813,
0.019416621,
0.0352529772,
-0.0091035422,
-0.043280527,
-0.029174177,
-0.0440102555,
-0.0564263947,
0.0268246811,
0.0548022427,
-0.0120824547,
-0.0084772455,
0.0038122309,
0.0738793015,
0.058327239,
-0.0095479283,
-0.0171272513,
0.0243513659,
-0.0270228144,
-0.0396047048,
-0.0185681991,
-6.342103529e-33,
-0.033798907,
0.0007745799,
0.0257584602,
-0.0383411944,
0.0161953699,
-0.0466977805,
-0.0367006324,
-0.0129502472,
0.0131356129,
-0.0128391264,
-0.0255741421,
0.0405589268,
0.0177510139,
-0.0275625773,
0.0440695286,
-0.0705368891,
0.0123786908,
0.0061407443,
-0.0249411874,
-0.0148159126,
0.0016489585,
0.0247333143,
0.0533287376,
0.0009193568,
0.0224788375,
-0.0034003123,
-0.0036182182,
-0.0145357335,
0.0055724075,
0.0229328573,
-0.0057355049,
0.018932268,
0.0230515245,
-0.007137306,
-0.0267695468,
0.0129816104,
-0.0915192887,
-0.0422798395,
0.0351649262,
0.0223063398,
0.0044425083,
-0.0409226753,
0.054701522,
-0.0184919592,
-0.0147538688,
-0.0090878801,
0.0165689643,
-0.0450815037,
0.024449762,
-0.0262960736,
-0.0155892624,
0.030171955,
-0.020822417,
0.0361297801,
0.0310217254,
0.0024453648,
-0.0020501777,
-0.0276986808,
-0.0024202629,
0.0103743812,
0.0322757214,
0.0315740742,
0.0789079294,
-0.0275751762,
0.0064608627,
0.0172910299,
0.0198104903,
-0.0205455739,
-0.0469677001,
0.0367481709,
0.0034260326,
0.0249485206,
0.0417477787,
0.0026567918,
0.040881332,
-0.0073961406,
-0.0618560985,
0.0680703744,
0.0325142108,
0.0263032503,
-0.0200836845,
0.0055150772,
-0.0284456369,
-0.0089023579,
-0.0231885985,
0.0069783134,
-0.0392700657,
-0.0304346625,
0.0213759411,
-0.0437882915,
0.002846627,
-0.0263952725,
0.0037335893,
-0.0229579601,
-0.0548480451,
0.0561437197,
0.0216648448,
0.0118690897,
0.001691154,
0.0068674474,
-0.0007093535,
-0.0375546403,
-0.0056317723,
-0.0344476253,
0.0516470671,
0.0672859401,
0.0076765888,
0.0382886045,
-0.0748257488,
-0.01094779,
-0.0670128018,
0.0081117526,
0.0233765878,
0.0124828918,
0.0347108804,
-0.001687945,
0.0121231768,
0.0181274805,
0.0157389957,
-0.016350532,
-0.0407623947,
0.0380325727,
-0.0150288381,
0.0114354296,
0.0030406869,
-0.0109776268,
-0.0465926416,
0.0255467463,
0.0389960445,
-0.0283109862,
-0.0027450891,
0.0164294448,
2.78e-7,
0.0630563051,
0.0384395495,
0.0239178482,
0.0535012633,
-0.0100903166,
-0.0017078611,
-0.0219680928,
-0.0336125158,
-0.0191384405,
-0.046188239,
0.0299539026,
-0.0012517627,
0.0379038826,
0.0533090495,
-0.0247516669,
0.0055878139,
-0.0453942455,
-0.0380967781,
-0.0457732715,
0.0463034697,
0.0617955327,
0.0386973359,
-0.0195474047,
-0.0328903496,
-0.0035579232,
-0.0302343722,
-0.0197715145,
-0.0564916432,
0.0564075448,
0.0243938118,
0.0289320126,
-0.045405671,
0.0281869136,
0.040551085,
0.0034169238,
0.0147067485,
-0.0142648909,
0.0595966391,
-0.0159429237,
0.0713055581,
-0.0062231836,
-0.1333393604,
0.0125023052,
-0.0788890645,
0.1120581701,
-0.0064080311,
0.0104258945,
0.0624051653,
-0.0082079507,
-0.0173821542,
-0.0298228655,
0.0070517845,
0.0153711969,
0.0578597672,
0.0067405328,
-0.0251907855,
0.029177608,
-0.0542685539,
-0.0422249697,
0.0258588064,
-0.0087019177,
-0.0163243432,
-0.0211631469,
-0.0093426537,
0.0069427034,
-0.0482133217,
-0.0252190866,
3.068848178e-34,
0.0462592654,
-0.0225286689,
0.0392224304,
0.0590400361,
0.0635938272,
-0.0048000477,
-0.0317766108,
0.0047386196,
0.0054363208,
-0.0935609043,
-0.009672639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17947v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17947v1 | Do they mean 'us'? Interpreting Referring Expressions in Intergroup Bias | 2024-06-25T21:47:53 | 2024-06-25T21:47:53 | Venkata S Govindarajan, Matianyu Zang, Kyle Mahowald, David Beaver, Junyi Jessy Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | The variations between in-group and out-group speech (intergroup bias) are
subtle and could underlie many social phenomena like stereotype perpetuation
and implicit bias. In this paper, we model the intergroup bias as a tagging
task on English sports comments from forums dedicated to fandom for NFL teams.
We curate a unique dataset of over 6 million game-time comments from opposing
perspectives (the teams in the game), each comment grounded in a non-linguistic
description of the events that precipitated these comments (live win
probabilities for each team). Expert and crowd annotations justify modeling the
bias through tagging of implicit and explicit referring expressions and reveal
the rich, contextual understanding of language and the world required for this
task. For large-scale analysis of intergroup variation, we use LLMs for
automated tagging, and discover that some LLMs perform best when prompted with
linguistic descriptions of the win probability at the time of the comment,
rather than numerical probability. Further, large-scale tagging of comments
using LLMs uncovers linear variations in the form of referent across win
probabilities that distinguish in-group and out-group utterances. Code and data
are available at https://github.com/venkatasg/intergroup-nfl . | Do they mean 'us'? Interpreting Referring Expressions in Intergroup Bias: The variations between in-group and out-group speech (intergroup bias) are
subtle and could underlie many social phenomena like stereotype perpetuation
and implicit bias. In this paper, we model the intergroup bias as a tagging
task on English sports comments from forums dedicated to fandom for NFL teams.
We curate a unique dataset of over 6 million game-time comments from opposing
perspectives (the teams in the game), each comment grounded in a non-linguistic
description of the events that precipitated these comments (live win
probabilities for each team). Expert and crowd annotations justify modeling the
bias through tagging of implicit and explicit referring expressions and reveal
the rich, contextual understanding of language and the world required for this
task. For large-scale analysis of intergroup variation, we use LLMs for
automated tagging, and discover that some LLMs perform best when prompted with
linguistic descriptions of the win probability at the time of the comment,
rather than numerical probability. Further, large-scale tagging of comments
using LLMs uncovers linear variations in the form of referent across win
probabilities that distinguish in-group and out-group utterances. Code and data
are available at https://github.com/venkatasg/intergroup-nfl . | [
0.036218863,
0.0376335084,
-0.0231784917,
0.0131481942,
0.0133059481,
0.0442698523,
-0.0232793652,
-0.0116231963,
0.0038414977,
-0.097073257,
-0.0371561833,
-0.024290707,
0.0385512933,
-0.0276990738,
0.0507676005,
-0.0378563665,
0.0212653968,
0.013976803,
0.0627827868,
-0.0529590845,
0.0350790396,
0.0094431257,
-0.0177984983,
0.0545456484,
-0.0797432289,
0.0239688922,
0.0546194054,
-0.012682857,
-0.0199972652,
-0.0332504287,
0.0306548532,
0.0318740606,
-0.0300733093,
-0.0280717537,
0.0000018626,
-0.0527144708,
0.0186715703,
-0.0248182975,
0.0478950329,
0.0128063709,
0.0353149138,
0.0265694242,
0.0416452847,
-0.0239157584,
-0.0374822505,
-0.000406534,
0.066110082,
-0.0247619487,
0.020246122,
0.0103458017,
-0.0085837059,
-0.0011244421,
-0.1032507569,
-0.0093467515,
0.0130505124,
-0.0563071668,
0.0587258339,
-0.008590579,
-0.0869506747,
-0.0673996434,
-0.004104184,
0.0157873537,
-0.0096314466,
0.0212811157,
0.0071038781,
0.0032592933,
-0.0265668742,
0.0134892529,
0.0016570989,
0.0001939535,
0.0691675916,
-0.018446248,
-0.0264504924,
0.0221161209,
-0.0055213938,
0.0109394994,
0.0039295447,
0.0262742061,
-0.0211913157,
0.0076118801,
-0.0328785703,
0.0572377034,
-0.0109967282,
0.0139413355,
-0.0302442387,
0.0886634886,
0.0220273342,
0.0249955263,
-0.0648750216,
0.0796256885,
-0.0280879997,
-0.0231001414,
0.0317910388,
0.011232188,
-0.0283941366,
0.0092329085,
0.0005631371,
-0.0241239108,
0.0029352636,
-0.0389196835,
0.0379421189,
-0.0038646748,
-0.0277787969,
0.0203485005,
-0.0215743091,
-0.0432488285,
0.013833886,
-0.0447578877,
0.0287016835,
-0.0579332598,
-0.0114858346,
0.0031625074,
0.0166169759,
0.0009603598,
-0.0279582944,
0.0519973226,
-0.043200843,
-0.0246909577,
-0.0577265248,
-0.0053607356,
-0.0170966629,
-0.0203936622,
-0.0171616916,
-0.0195758007,
-0.0759775788,
0.0262250099,
-0.0648956597,
0.0222672448,
-0.0505083352,
-0.1064751148,
0.0225463193,
0.0245290827,
-0.0225031804,
-0.0299389083,
-0.0073110973,
0.023124408,
0.0436580926,
0.0328213274,
-0.0188111253,
-0.0219051167,
-0.0208877772,
-0.0389544144,
0.0007145126,
-0.0510222241,
0.0237191133,
0.0155754127,
0.0127832144,
-0.0633412302,
0.0214450639,
0.03352575,
-0.0238337126,
0.0676615238,
-0.0382697023,
0.0341156274,
0.0357527249,
0.0138497949,
-0.0216169413,
0.03867203,
0.0102471821,
-0.0216886364,
0.0521181636,
-0.0093666576,
-0.0103595546,
0.0392753892,
0.0014053927,
-0.0265515987,
-0.040038038,
0.008529257,
0.0156999193,
-0.0379186422,
0.0263298228,
0.0576128401,
-0.0022070715,
-0.0381697863,
0.0691844821,
0.0852426738,
-0.0533152595,
-0.0111524509,
0.0501310267,
0.0258207638,
-0.0312931389,
-0.0216125473,
-0.0587951206,
0.0298210792,
0.0113179693,
-0.0258548614,
0.0467733964,
0.0194139928,
-0.0128694139,
-0.0503349639,
-0.0066759884,
0.0018646835,
0.0340312012,
-0.0066388501,
0.0411411934,
-0.012380749,
0.0356737077,
0.0636688843,
0.0481841229,
-0.001079759,
-0.0128801903,
-0.0562703535,
0.0213913489,
0.0195874125,
-0.022511363,
-0.0220615249,
-0.0132914707,
-0.0197910219,
-0.0089622363,
0.0417616405,
0.035582561,
-0.0014979072,
-0.0154521102,
-0.0015173397,
-0.0099733369,
0.0365759768,
0.0338907577,
0.0545354337,
0.0245535821,
0.0130391233,
-0.0008344025,
-0.0092944866,
-0.0249571558,
0.0170071293,
0.0017245017,
-0.0142996283,
-0.0016220066,
-0.0039359266,
0.0120010767,
0.0513243936,
-0.0254797172,
0.0028146021,
-0.015450702,
-0.0147692692,
-0.008788242,
0.0468198694,
-0.014439051,
0.0538763031,
0.0257979035,
-0.085064888,
-0.0735867769,
-0.0154286418,
0.0116929337,
-0.0070940689,
0.0381852873,
-0.0043678498,
0.0344942212,
-0.02425473,
-0.058109168,
-0.0297994427,
0.0279999003,
-0.001079726,
0.0188551396,
0.0145344343,
-0.012698357,
0.0117006283,
-0.062802352,
0.0624391995,
-0.0028205428,
-0.0474860296,
0.0048980652,
0.0145948362,
-0.0063086017,
0.039538566,
-0.0300601125,
-0.0707919747,
0.0405096449,
-0.1014101133,
-0.0030451091,
-0.0046306825,
0.0030451869,
0.0158240478,
0.0287026837,
-0.0300052278,
-0.0288923811,
0.0278042536,
-0.0564974546,
-0.0304838791,
0.0429252684,
0.0194337554,
-0.0020773078,
0.0343199186,
-0.0262469631,
-0.0160285663,
-0.0370603167,
0.0243636612,
0.0255994629,
-0.0483570248,
-0.0708967447,
-0.0690821037,
-0.0678276196,
-0.027103439,
0.0020753746,
0.0036419407,
0.0492903963,
0.0296611879,
0.035300605,
0.063726604,
0.0318116136,
0.0239225477,
0.010098272,
-0.0718296021,
-0.0158275105,
-0.0241256915,
-0.0287745651,
-0.0409322716,
-0.0365088843,
-0.0732246786,
0.0166352019,
0.0834097192,
0.0339601785,
-0.0031873572,
-0.0595912859,
0.0523788668,
-0.0563515946,
-0.0331490226,
-0.0026255515,
-0.0396966338,
-0.0250360817,
0.0210630484,
0.001925687,
-0.0198238455,
0.0269061383,
0.0014616663,
0.0205798056,
-0.00328257,
-0.0261123534,
-0.0122220237,
0.0654186979,
0.0139815081,
0.0182891283,
0.0274799876,
-0.0265632551,
0.0183373783,
-0.0324064158,
0.0488376617,
-0.0092086308,
0.0355376266,
-0.0010925485,
0.0081030251,
0.0096193915,
0.0144097134,
-0.008792093,
-0.0362663604,
-0.0781583488,
-0.0452600643,
0.0375105999,
-0.0186048411,
0.0169470515,
0.0442990251,
0.0238222219,
-0.0928791091,
0.0057788729,
-0.0184654538,
0.0190361962,
-0.0243800841,
0.0201874673,
0.0174963772,
0.0163807906,
-0.0370762087,
-0.0453784093,
0.050435096,
0.0311938375,
0.0280315708,
-0.0222819764,
-0.0103448378,
0.0088393679,
-0.0125109674,
-0.0070153023,
-0.0022566991,
0.0876843929,
-0.0275716819,
0.0493195951,
0.0874443799,
0.0174430199,
-0.0335448869,
0.0069983089,
0.0101320799,
0.0196374673,
0.036385335,
-0.0031487735,
-0.0988788456,
-0.0167007465,
-0.0073540797,
0.022087181,
-0.0114386873,
-0.0668098405,
-0.0179848522,
-0.0852129236,
-0.013339798,
0.0110271126,
0.0289932992,
-0.0041288594,
-0.012670964,
0.0542808995,
0.0045267739,
-0.0170200989,
-0.0070848935,
0.0182836074,
0.0457236171,
0.0304535273,
-0.0644969195,
0.0047388659,
0.0294715129,
-0.0443593413,
0.0860300586,
0.0142616499,
0.0328900702,
-0.0001830649,
-0.013470605,
0.0272451025,
-0.022498304,
-0.0185099021,
-0.0373837501,
0.0294534117,
-0.0396721214,
0.013706293,
-0.0052118874,
0.0022075053,
-0.037314523,
0.0265516695,
0.0197376404,
0.0203460082,
0.0159844644,
-0.0193251539,
-0.0245218333,
0.0205245614,
0.0188596956,
0.05121319,
0.0349675529,
-0.0298599657,
0.0252489354,
-0.0667982101,
0.0205878988,
0.0169649962,
-0.0867207646,
0.0034928406,
-0.0249864012,
-0.0451997668,
-0.0079936162,
-0.031624537,
0.0296728425,
-0.0070327972,
0.0111182528,
0.0234026611,
0.0203440003,
-0.0438590646,
-0.0358901024,
0.0427537672,
-0.0530066937,
0.0302141625,
0.0554336123,
-0.0399518237,
0.0571758114,
0.0332541279,
-0.0448983684,
0.0741002336,
0.0079216342,
-0.020326063,
0.0492899455,
0.0620425195,
0.0184926391,
0.0031042364,
0.0227282401,
-0.038476333,
-0.0018377298,
-0.0048027462,
0.0340138152,
0.0305438451,
-0.0182609688,
0.0342994407,
-0.006037741,
0.0370109379,
-0.0111985113,
0.0810034201,
0.0077120187,
-0.0053055952,
-0.0546766296,
-0.0528848916,
-0.0070247068,
-0.0283221025,
0.0536013618,
-0.0103800436,
-0.0234240256,
0.0084974049,
-0.0258498788,
-0.0157281756,
-0.0203323737,
0.0305111781,
-0.0581247285,
-0.0245857593,
0.006067941,
-0.0515119061,
-0.0226477943,
-0.0454274081,
0.0569525175,
-0.0067969211,
0.0840637386,
0.0694495738,
0.0294984877,
0.000069257,
-0.01135178,
0.0175459776,
0.0356506594,
0.01936909,
0.0512260795,
0.0223966092,
-0.0133587467,
0.0303892344,
-0.0138201294,
0.0118139582,
-0.0360415541,
0.0069511179,
-0.0103532188,
0.0293196533,
-0.0457933098,
0.0256546959,
-0.0323347822,
0.034195818,
0.0005205778,
-0.0085989144,
0.0247222744,
0.0173862092,
0.0046719764,
0.0004022948,
0.0093179904,
-0.0039132144,
-0.0168641526,
0.0461227745,
0.0550971739,
-0.0023332748,
0.0242930055,
0.0042428905,
-0.0831912383,
-0.040758729,
-0.0173026677,
0.0111867534,
-0.0053457445,
0.0006953177,
0.0341993421,
-0.0781227127,
-0.0340066999,
0.0190741122,
-0.0255951509,
0.0207745153,
0.0030103028,
0.0200358219,
0.0359155983,
0.0277507734,
-0.0038181951,
-0.0114607718,
0.0463538468,
-0.0532047339,
-0.0136761591,
-0.0369598232,
-6.310298325e-33,
-0.0315401405,
-0.1017540619,
-0.0050076754,
-0.0036506215,
-0.0364423096,
-0.0059108911,
-0.0386095755,
0.0048513371,
0.0107891057,
0.0362047292,
0.0047085881,
0.0150445551,
0.0135658551,
-0.0135848448,
0.060638018,
-0.0476743355,
0.0277655497,
-0.0210793689,
0.00468142,
-0.0053893486,
0.0284732152,
0.0188852381,
0.0286051091,
-0.1159260944,
0.0789307952,
-0.0110329371,
-0.0370686315,
0.0128013976,
0.0839480311,
-0.0067476057,
-0.0134199532,
0.0366695821,
0.0276760124,
-0.0495389551,
0.0058460054,
0.0721859708,
-0.0092984904,
-0.0203193687,
0.0269384943,
0.0213265121,
0.0571827665,
0.0273960121,
0.038537167,
0.0115196956,
-0.048796244,
-0.0010394554,
0.0592699274,
-0.0292171426,
0.0706932992,
-0.0173233375,
-0.0371845551,
0.0375638492,
-0.0113294655,
0.0618718751,
0.0274679903,
0.0041298042,
-0.0104344757,
0.0487907827,
-0.0513075553,
0.0509540997,
-0.0546581559,
-0.0036303424,
0.0224763155,
0.0439853854,
0.0417107865,
0.0178785659,
0.0613962039,
0.0601239055,
-0.0203443337,
-0.0398647934,
0.0038093741,
-0.0187017769,
0.0055608763,
0.0654092953,
0.0189928412,
0.0176984202,
0.0135140186,
-0.0286833104,
0.0556027852,
-0.000123696,
0.0322238617,
0.0048505529,
-0.0871559232,
0.0015982563,
-0.0151421335,
-0.0697284192,
0.0056498582,
-0.0848369747,
-0.0061457311,
-0.0507951491,
-0.0475706905,
0.0099248337,
0.0474085584,
-0.0115948711,
-0.0551363975,
-0.0241205972,
-0.011217894,
0.0006394929,
-0.0081909578,
0.013723298,
-0.0517440513,
0.0227617491,
-0.0252184868,
0.0115574906,
0.042738717,
0.0264939759,
0.0018885202,
-0.0024372865,
-0.0747431964,
-0.0082419328,
0.0230779499,
-0.004836238,
-0.0463121161,
-0.0125098825,
0.0269299187,
0.0489001274,
0.0047590267,
-0.0269562695,
0.0275392905,
-0.0005306525,
0.0262333676,
0.0057001305,
-0.0683663934,
0.0187531933,
-0.0363541357,
-0.0207150374,
0.0018732765,
-0.0065002646,
0.0197542999,
-0.0222915336,
-0.0212704651,
-0.0609407686,
2.542e-7,
0.066335991,
0.0949637741,
-0.0262059756,
0.0169175938,
0.0338906087,
0.0776726231,
0.0069076917,
-0.0085779261,
0.0358818285,
-0.0330091305,
0.0066608819,
0.0428018756,
0.0171710942,
0.0541442744,
-0.0592534877,
-0.0087401588,
-0.0334254317,
0.025530044,
0.005587121,
0.0114342635,
0.0107529992,
0.0154553512,
0.0607430451,
-0.0043193838,
-0.0520222858,
-0.0495009571,
0.0145642404,
-0.0814161599,
-0.0204728488,
0.0533228777,
0.0147653036,
-0.0144106708,
-0.0250875149,
0.045313701,
-0.0159804709,
-0.002091988,
0.0339919329,
-0.0499064438,
-0.0175112803,
-0.0020163185,
-0.0457777642,
-0.0112131443,
0.0144629441,
-0.0180047825,
-0.0034062697,
-0.0345195234,
-0.0373716056,
-0.0496195108,
-0.0469978191,
-0.0379389711,
0.0040148459,
-0.0195241719,
-0.0175045822,
-0.0195886642,
0.0218039788,
0.0335663296,
0.0073119863,
-0.0531642102,
-0.0047499067,
0.0032586155,
-0.0273131132,
-0.027270684,
0.0001995905,
0.0361889303,
-0.0086713405,
0.000823734,
0.0360819176,
1.980962825e-34,
0.0326328203,
-0.0016335041,
-0.0096134348,
0.0292671435,
0.0641723946,
-0.0070811417,
-0.0554972254,
-0.0201255903,
0.0742040947,
-0.0004826417,
-0.0232907441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17935v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17935v1 | Sequential Editing for Lifelong Training of Speech Recognition Models | 2024-06-25T20:52:09 | 2024-06-25T20:52:09 | Devang Kulshreshtha, Saket Dingliwal, Brady Houston, Nikolaos Pappas, Srikanth Ronanki | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) traditionally assumes known domains, but
adding data from a new domain raises concerns about computational
inefficiencies linked to retraining models on both existing and new domains.
Fine-tuning solely on new domain risks Catastrophic Forgetting (CF). To address
this, Lifelong Learning (LLL) algorithms have been proposed for ASR. Prior
research has explored techniques such as Elastic Weight Consolidation,
Knowledge Distillation, and Replay, all of which necessitate either additional
parameters or access to prior domain data. We propose Sequential Model Editing
as a novel method to continually learn new domains in ASR systems. Different
than previous methods, our approach does not necessitate access to prior
datasets or the introduction of extra parameters. Our study demonstrates up to
15% Word Error Rate Reduction (WERR) over fine-tuning baseline, and superior
efficiency over other LLL techniques on CommonVoice English multi-accent
dataset. | Sequential Editing for Lifelong Training of Speech Recognition Models: Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) traditionally assumes known domains, but
adding data from a new domain raises concerns about computational
inefficiencies linked to retraining models on both existing and new domains.
Fine-tuning solely on new domain risks Catastrophic Forgetting (CF). To address
this, Lifelong Learning (LLL) algorithms have been proposed for ASR. Prior
research has explored techniques such as Elastic Weight Consolidation,
Knowledge Distillation, and Replay, all of which necessitate either additional
parameters or access to prior domain data. We propose Sequential Model Editing
as a novel method to continually learn new domains in ASR systems. Different
than previous methods, our approach does not necessitate access to prior
datasets or the introduction of extra parameters. Our study demonstrates up to
15% Word Error Rate Reduction (WERR) over fine-tuning baseline, and superior
efficiency over other LLL techniques on CommonVoice English multi-accent
dataset. | [
-0.0038060404,
0.0754957348,
-0.0040951339,
-0.0128230955,
-0.0063646464,
0.0147690373,
0.0058790124,
-0.0461251102,
-0.0068528377,
-0.00675327,
-0.0530883074,
-0.0473468304,
0.0326144174,
0.0195848402,
-0.0010532343,
-0.0659690499,
0.0322353654,
-0.0364763625,
-0.027481569,
-0.0237209089,
-0.0152735021,
-0.0432790816,
-0.0283734798,
0.0166184101,
0.0114684189,
0.009937631,
-0.035660252,
-0.0034672213,
0.0302138645,
-0.0195339806,
0.001818085,
0.0323929563,
0.0370677114,
-0.0098623754,
0.0000023612,
-0.0418973677,
-0.0424729176,
0.0082348781,
-0.0671636835,
-0.0152095277,
0.0253525879,
0.0244912449,
-0.0301359445,
0.0222402737,
-0.0226442404,
-0.0191798825,
0.0633772612,
0.0303424615,
0.0535869673,
0.0429745913,
-0.0002461515,
-0.0649994537,
0.0234608091,
-0.0378941931,
-0.0323786177,
-0.0273734368,
0.0403918698,
0.0015410879,
-0.0695433542,
-0.0465459004,
-0.0379533693,
0.0391624421,
0.0046793632,
-0.0100062592,
0.002335489,
0.0062471754,
0.014083609,
-0.0156134581,
-0.0048219161,
-0.0030593472,
-0.0079988455,
0.0001713982,
0.0100909621,
0.0298088193,
-0.0171102397,
-0.0455299094,
-0.0159427524,
0.0014978454,
-0.0076226825,
0.0007665341,
-0.0191785637,
-0.0528125316,
0.0176971294,
-0.0243733134,
-0.0538636819,
0.012088811,
0.013236993,
-0.0500719845,
0.0097196829,
-0.0330374986,
-0.0462521017,
0.0015985582,
0.0335453153,
0.0146541819,
-0.0016147582,
0.0297246743,
-0.0466605388,
-0.0275751129,
-0.0176772363,
-0.0102228783,
0.0297767185,
0.0436208546,
-0.0195568614,
0.0100811543,
-0.0115577225,
0.0321538709,
0.0548836067,
-0.0507941581,
-0.0183279514,
0.0385812037,
-0.0954967141,
0.0002706095,
-0.0518698916,
0.0748095363,
0.0024517633,
0.0170123354,
-0.0376181118,
0.020044202,
-0.0150757339,
-0.0077460222,
0.0143363709,
-0.0278454665,
-0.0620957129,
-0.0033981388,
0.0193855874,
0.0439416729,
0.0281181093,
0.053975895,
0.0050288034,
-0.0097949374,
-0.0252801143,
-0.0247448999,
0.0374187194,
0.0012306498,
0.0178372841,
0.0757233202,
-0.0122831743,
-0.0339139439,
-0.0644036606,
0.0039659478,
-0.0224497337,
-0.0371214375,
-0.0175469648,
-0.0229581706,
0.0302018207,
-0.0458627939,
-0.009872702,
-0.093669191,
-0.006890378,
-0.0280372705,
0.0064108572,
0.0921148509,
-0.0202139765,
0.022443153,
0.0564865805,
-0.0083788782,
-0.0168871842,
0.0631094575,
0.0013642274,
-0.0372726843,
0.0101804333,
-0.0184415821,
-0.0109058209,
0.0349960029,
0.009628606,
0.0231770147,
-0.0312747508,
-0.0348831937,
0.0260812696,
0.0236294437,
0.0360628068,
-0.016974166,
-0.0469943918,
0.0407404676,
0.0684554875,
0.0085041169,
0.0446107052,
0.0326625742,
0.0154320616,
-0.0245209616,
0.0319104865,
0.009969742,
-0.0560831763,
-0.0294041615,
0.0122813303,
0.037386097,
-0.0131231109,
-0.0064493068,
-0.0176218208,
-0.0335588939,
0.0059554838,
-0.0267939288,
0.0039933082,
0.0086313961,
0.0549761318,
0.0288674813,
-0.0325410366,
0.0557266064,
0.0071785874,
-0.0638871938,
0.0251758676,
-0.0285171233,
-0.0341592021,
0.0675686523,
0.0167329088,
-0.0555068031,
-0.0662584603,
-0.0446321703,
0.0184713192,
-0.0211225599,
-0.0058669676,
-0.0130878408,
0.0771942139,
-0.0660547391,
-0.0361968465,
0.0517302044,
0.0034705366,
0.0319346748,
0.011142035,
0.0223303959,
0.004875802,
-0.0169181656,
-0.0244281329,
-0.0013622598,
-0.0546141937,
-0.0358801,
0.0471190475,
0.0188016426,
0.0318702199,
0.0088642174,
-0.0518854894,
-0.027238505,
0.0134876445,
-0.0146923773,
-0.0065703481,
0.0289641544,
-0.0693455786,
-0.0006288352,
0.0790139735,
-0.0011900529,
0.0194191467,
0.0000519856,
0.0030173853,
-0.0794105083,
-0.0061723506,
-0.0198848434,
0.0552611575,
-0.0353102237,
0.0769281909,
-0.0003703001,
-0.0231708866,
-0.0191576965,
0.0060256333,
-0.0008275772,
-0.0344625153,
0.0096121682,
0.0109750936,
-0.0120545961,
-0.079012163,
-0.0131430849,
0.0015243986,
-0.0160013661,
0.0215407964,
-0.0000430476,
-0.0051114867,
-0.0288645905,
-0.0366294086,
-0.0715230405,
-0.010462366,
-0.0276634116,
0.0326785035,
-0.0012687881,
0.0241008885,
-0.0170254894,
-0.0365139507,
0.0135908416,
-0.0025541938,
-0.058728274,
0.0146141909,
-0.0283302795,
0.0071393633,
-0.0193026084,
-0.0035146333,
0.0050237509,
0.04509544,
0.0061605568,
-0.0580657832,
-0.0233342163,
-0.077391088,
0.0232888646,
-0.0040256749,
0.0353912525,
0.0037323933,
-0.0209731013,
-0.0577860773,
0.0141676692,
0.0578289665,
0.0457562134,
0.0035839861,
0.0119186789,
0.0434676781,
-0.0309594348,
-0.0018603038,
0.0074805315,
-0.0232557803,
-0.012999434,
0.0159490407,
0.0343123078,
-0.0351375602,
0.0219059046,
0.009350813,
0.0107984459,
-0.0175830629,
-0.0290439501,
-0.0281715598,
-0.0152647961,
-0.0474520996,
-0.0285429973,
-0.0475363284,
-0.014842446,
0.0003796015,
-0.0288351048,
0.0491927229,
-0.0127013484,
0.0041055926,
-0.0721472129,
-0.0556181818,
0.001095084,
0.0143385716,
-0.0210060086,
0.0146187069,
0.0451781899,
-0.0592335314,
-0.0315592624,
0.0041570715,
0.0565660372,
-0.0336284786,
0.0758590326,
-0.0571896918,
-0.0032024782,
-0.0128326425,
-0.0430909321,
-0.0504950061,
0.0314181671,
-0.0148909725,
0.0176976118,
-0.0279411525,
-0.0114012212,
-0.0478139371,
-0.0014856166,
0.049338568,
0.089986071,
-0.0027870943,
-0.01597731,
-0.0053227912,
0.032326676,
0.0284702573,
0.06066126,
-0.0180057697,
-0.0108869793,
0.0609566867,
0.0034531117,
0.0561922714,
-0.0423066616,
-0.025909204,
0.0106293084,
0.0102645848,
-0.0323939994,
-0.0026266098,
0.0065228343,
0.0104605258,
-0.0548017435,
-0.0158621781,
0.072477214,
0.0230717026,
-0.025359327,
-0.0068341852,
-0.0199704375,
0.0438503362,
0.0312910266,
-0.0060715778,
-0.0453738756,
-0.0417462252,
0.0786361247,
0.0729275271,
0.0122208809,
-0.0068212994,
-0.0121094957,
-0.0809386671,
0.0282952711,
0.0362313949,
-0.0347890556,
0.0000844276,
-0.0439651683,
-0.0237060171,
-0.0430615507,
0.0349083208,
0.0417311378,
-0.0342805944,
-0.0227920711,
0.0442015491,
-0.0531583391,
-0.0728794485,
-0.0090520009,
-0.0144464001,
0.0561932996,
0.0471589491,
-0.0124071874,
-0.003228962,
-0.0191577077,
0.0722113028,
0.0052524116,
0.0366576314,
-0.0162409917,
0.0495221503,
0.0398575589,
-0.0083655939,
0.0304450244,
0.0298847426,
0.0149691505,
-0.035807278,
0.0656598136,
0.058025118,
-0.0264154244,
0.0409591906,
0.0395758338,
-0.0397088341,
-0.0053329584,
0.0037365935,
0.0008214417,
-0.0435549878,
0.017694829,
-0.0031586958,
0.0203597918,
-0.0236497056,
0.0114762252,
0.0147914141,
-0.0769185275,
-0.0255928002,
-0.0227113906,
-0.0024817523,
0.0145363333,
0.043674726,
0.0545427352,
0.0077166455,
0.0006135794,
0.0339592099,
-0.0716538131,
-0.0133930957,
-0.0316446684,
0.0078316787,
-0.0815931335,
0.0053044637,
0.0689409822,
-0.0551726259,
-0.0107614584,
-0.0300466381,
-0.0252184123,
-0.0640394986,
0.0547175892,
0.0285869967,
0.0134998169,
0.0962646008,
0.0051527279,
-0.0416729823,
0.0739583373,
0.0296696872,
-0.0203610174,
0.0541674607,
0.0764405653,
-0.0319537148,
-0.0155573273,
0.0181629304,
-0.0456479602,
0.0219588336,
0.0009595891,
0.0165414084,
0.0157945119,
-0.0246607494,
0.0113969184,
0.0285552386,
0.0456971601,
-0.0108502116,
-0.0035974709,
-0.0421386436,
0.080889374,
0.0355215222,
0.0337850749,
-0.0227011852,
0.0246363711,
-0.0013302439,
0.0370599739,
-0.0014037529,
0.0233599916,
0.0045950529,
-0.0300723761,
0.0015462305,
0.0321775228,
-0.0019371051,
0.0476051494,
0.0417267866,
0.0282953847,
-0.0243985187,
0.0371117927,
0.040994022,
0.0095834043,
0.0036846162,
0.0276845936,
0.0090541197,
0.0192510821,
-0.0486256853,
0.0259031728,
-0.0361168385,
-0.0331315994,
-0.0399228297,
0.0097473776,
0.0659490451,
0.0082392925,
0.0166503266,
-0.003812857,
0.007983339,
-0.0431070998,
0.011298405,
-0.0120930141,
0.0184579063,
-0.0007576222,
0.0014872774,
-0.0058191861,
0.0551525578,
0.062295571,
0.0022045767,
0.0678426176,
-0.0360908508,
0.0379014611,
-0.0466219559,
-0.0219999347,
-0.0143887298,
0.0029361192,
-0.0267451201,
-0.0318682864,
0.0046333591,
-0.069444105,
0.0464599356,
-0.0337095372,
0.0119492551,
-0.0202687457,
0.0360968187,
-0.0117491111,
-0.0397476889,
0.0225949846,
0.0183553472,
-0.011970927,
0.0315957293,
0.0072942092,
0.0361605883,
-6.623223737e-33,
0.0023430106,
0.0302606057,
0.0382935181,
0.0282505285,
-0.0713542625,
0.0043961159,
-0.0236267876,
0.0279914625,
0.0363571867,
-0.0154925315,
-0.0275749099,
0.0012016097,
0.0292191096,
0.001970462,
0.0257435273,
-0.0039676991,
0.1045231223,
-0.0006922213,
0.0015045896,
-0.0152648669,
0.0227948111,
0.0664871484,
0.0358401686,
-0.0580850206,
-0.0420182943,
0.0794253722,
0.0017808005,
0.0143458946,
0.0307010803,
0.0480159968,
0.0182021465,
0.029855717,
-0.025085859,
-0.071115844,
-0.0664060786,
-0.0333215073,
-0.1071897671,
-0.0048042382,
-0.0254103784,
0.0306788385,
0.005360357,
-0.0422320142,
0.0282859895,
0.0197136048,
-0.0326032527,
-0.0166647453,
0.0158952959,
-0.0705501735,
-0.0523580201,
-0.0292552765,
-0.0148388669,
0.0373467393,
0.0161287263,
-0.0278324094,
0.0485907495,
-0.0069265538,
-0.0111467456,
-0.0745299309,
-0.0873370394,
-0.0042479974,
0.0581081323,
0.0458451062,
0.0057636439,
0.0164017994,
-0.0010087269,
0.0168302506,
0.0273885261,
-0.021188695,
0.0392528661,
-0.0286048483,
0.0249151886,
0.0015992246,
-0.0172859021,
0.0033578565,
0.0462274104,
-0.0734418035,
-0.0194691792,
-0.0042603123,
-0.03357777,
0.061745014,
-0.0174744241,
0.0367828123,
0.0211951602,
-0.0087149525,
-0.0672033951,
0.0394271724,
-0.0371898115,
-0.0028854981,
0.0609018989,
0.0488514379,
-0.0171032716,
-0.0251074079,
0.041004546,
-0.0185324512,
0.0214876607,
0.0099252248,
-0.0008756748,
0.0017571293,
-0.0016884743,
-0.003743316,
-0.0075350329,
-0.028178867,
0.0135057233,
0.0391289145,
0.0039358153,
-0.046328295,
0.0562596507,
0.1119722128,
-0.0493553393,
-0.0033486071,
0.0208220072,
0.029494483,
0.0404809937,
0.0440779217,
0.03544816,
0.0202638991,
0.013392604,
0.0483403131,
0.0519646853,
-0.0224101692,
-0.0495456159,
0.0747946873,
0.0545673482,
0.0535741113,
-0.006707788,
0.0005505683,
0.0077556432,
-0.0363697559,
0.0121338405,
-0.0665823221,
-0.011782499,
0.0088519622,
3.139e-7,
-0.0502694175,
0.0208249856,
0.0342626013,
-0.0658673942,
0.0433561914,
0.039558921,
-0.0349521972,
-0.0269785374,
-0.0151862744,
0.0673796609,
0.0376159735,
-0.016442338,
0.0525201522,
0.0026149144,
-0.1041223183,
-0.0263886936,
-0.004782937,
0.0265355632,
-0.016014671,
-0.0013917788,
-0.0260769054,
0.0745787472,
-0.007728131,
-0.0251417328,
0.0037508239,
-0.0240806695,
0.0545058958,
0.0242391303,
0.0399204493,
-0.0312261172,
-0.0335992388,
0.0424221568,
-0.016507227,
0.0296307001,
-0.0578233451,
0.0181753803,
-0.0213969667,
0.0508393683,
-0.044466652,
-0.0288655721,
0.036762882,
0.0485913567,
-0.0204233807,
0.0317929238,
0.0516564101,
-0.0539454073,
0.0118640605,
-0.0190692768,
-0.0464281663,
-0.0099954195,
0.0078817364,
0.0081243524,
0.0305312071,
0.0170664582,
-0.0018565907,
0.0547017157,
-0.0304643437,
-0.0626762882,
0.0328896269,
0.0267900918,
-0.020268796,
-0.0218275413,
-0.0391002037,
-0.0124940835,
0.0292108841,
-0.0652379915,
0.0218095314,
2.749872965e-34,
0.0105550736,
-0.0571407489,
0.0411260128,
0.0554312952,
-0.0128157241,
-0.0504334755,
-0.0048785284,
0.022570027,
0.0150480429,
-0.0703709275,
-0.0459950827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17926v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17926v1 | FASA: a Flexible and Automatic Speech Aligner for Extracting High-quality Aligned Children Speech Data | 2024-06-25T20:37:16 | 2024-06-25T20:37:16 | Dancheng Liu, Jinjun Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) for adults' speeches has made significant
progress by employing deep neural network (DNN) models recently, but
improvement in children's speech is still unsatisfactory due to children's
speech's distinct characteristics. DNN models pre-trained on adult data often
struggle in generalizing children's speeches with fine tuning because of the
lack of high-quality aligned children's speeches. When generating datasets,
human annotations are not scalable, and existing forced-alignment tools are not
usable as they make impractical assumptions about the quality of the input
transcriptions. To address these challenges, we propose a new forced-alignment
tool, FASA, as a flexible and automatic speech aligner to extract high-quality
aligned children's speech data from many of the existing noisy children's
speech data. We demonstrate its usage on the CHILDES dataset and show that FASA
can improve data quality by 13.6$\times$ over human annotations. | FASA: a Flexible and Automatic Speech Aligner for Extracting High-quality Aligned Children Speech Data: Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) for adults' speeches has made significant
progress by employing deep neural network (DNN) models recently, but
improvement in children's speech is still unsatisfactory due to children's
speech's distinct characteristics. DNN models pre-trained on adult data often
struggle in generalizing children's speeches with fine tuning because of the
lack of high-quality aligned children's speeches. When generating datasets,
human annotations are not scalable, and existing forced-alignment tools are not
usable as they make impractical assumptions about the quality of the input
transcriptions. To address these challenges, we propose a new forced-alignment
tool, FASA, as a flexible and automatic speech aligner to extract high-quality
aligned children's speech data from many of the existing noisy children's
speech data. We demonstrate its usage on the CHILDES dataset and show that FASA
can improve data quality by 13.6$\times$ over human annotations. | [
-0.0487929955,
0.0918983147,
0.0295730364,
0.0281372461,
0.0056420099,
-0.0091560967,
0.0321530066,
-0.0465188809,
-0.0684890971,
0.0548242219,
-0.0614322238,
-0.0502848104,
0.0762623399,
-0.0226770844,
-0.0071440665,
-0.0695271268,
0.0268419851,
-0.0233333986,
0.0245112795,
0.0071112346,
0.019421,
0.0185328666,
-0.0335989147,
0.0255329497,
-0.0526862107,
-0.0365913622,
-0.0141400946,
0.0328656919,
0.0475026965,
0.0156084774,
0.0125666391,
0.0007459568,
-0.0106707783,
0.0708453804,
0.0000016286,
-0.0134808663,
-0.0022606223,
0.0216676369,
-0.0753996223,
0.0203163754,
-0.0003468038,
0.0096408119,
-0.0472389273,
0.0328873917,
-0.0063861185,
-0.0160987489,
0.0773068741,
0.0073336242,
0.0409200825,
0.0537635274,
-0.0059780711,
-0.0134779895,
0.0257218704,
0.0002007826,
-0.0464719534,
-0.0145981992,
-0.0026594154,
0.0157108456,
-0.0104244286,
-0.0675824285,
0.0317806005,
0.038054511,
-0.000897716,
-0.0391282439,
0.0206985977,
-0.0418303274,
-0.06502112,
-0.0524782091,
-0.016712714,
0.0911961645,
0.0008780507,
0.0042435853,
0.0180390459,
-0.0325945653,
-0.0232924782,
-0.0185860936,
-0.0262028407,
0.0254475679,
0.013703973,
0.022007063,
-0.011796074,
0.0034393058,
0.0389485806,
-0.0367854536,
0.0156855173,
0.0263539683,
-0.0006473006,
-0.0349667557,
0.0049579949,
0.0064946478,
0.0200818013,
-0.0175525919,
0.0288365502,
-0.0066600554,
-0.0461664908,
-0.0074144891,
-0.1069415659,
-0.0537047908,
-0.0300096199,
0.0051963646,
-0.0104178414,
0.0085121393,
-0.0521942861,
0.0220327601,
0.0518204495,
0.0553387441,
-0.0423761234,
0.0273945369,
-0.012177282,
-0.0278544016,
0.0397712663,
0.0275173429,
0.007482904,
-0.006346934,
-0.0029124569,
-0.0106917731,
-0.0622860566,
0.0177018046,
-0.0402535796,
0.0543564223,
0.0462645553,
0.0252925139,
-0.0468891338,
-0.0367945544,
0.0243607704,
0.0708948523,
0.0046759355,
0.0357860625,
0.0395137072,
-0.0479194559,
-0.0085716862,
0.0374264047,
0.0765775666,
0.0118962191,
0.000513471,
0.0208940711,
0.0114025334,
0.0413919427,
-0.017945081,
0.041034054,
-0.0294033699,
-0.046232529,
0.0092923269,
-0.0479848124,
0.0346056521,
-0.0243263934,
-0.0283672344,
-0.0671969429,
-0.0163514167,
-0.0383018926,
0.0230092872,
0.014815392,
-0.0545026623,
0.0306533445,
0.0081215883,
-0.0354879647,
0.013062302,
0.0305761471,
0.0773182064,
-0.0450853147,
0.0147161316,
-0.0326478072,
-0.0402409621,
0.0970781296,
0.0014545521,
-0.0077173379,
-0.0071248286,
-0.0211930275,
-0.0198246054,
0.0616700314,
0.0634513348,
0.0244252738,
0.0169743616,
-0.0024813511,
0.0721408576,
0.0315275341,
0.0182061028,
0.0310010742,
-0.0097754067,
0.0282653458,
0.0355955474,
0.0078084138,
-0.0315800309,
0.0272964127,
0.0379243866,
0.0034374839,
0.0384161249,
0.0524222404,
-0.0066091483,
-0.0259199031,
-0.0309677403,
-0.0302362479,
-0.0184039343,
0.0249455143,
-0.0018545588,
-0.0269479081,
-0.0362762958,
-0.0101445327,
-0.0014658211,
-0.0606496222,
0.0203738343,
-0.0233188868,
0.015758669,
0.040216621,
-0.0163277928,
-0.0451749153,
-0.074905023,
-0.0164265148,
-0.0436575152,
0.0425680988,
-0.0253348257,
0.0120665729,
0.0575389452,
-0.0740178972,
-0.0361916758,
0.0608093478,
-0.0069567231,
0.0004448902,
-0.0153196836,
-0.0256793946,
0.0028130221,
0.0162865855,
-0.0005687426,
0.0162277669,
-0.0259286407,
0.0078159533,
0.0203992128,
0.0674765036,
0.0572946556,
0.0580189042,
-0.0091007371,
-0.0275941212,
0.0457259454,
0.0024637128,
0.0656665191,
0.0149416598,
-0.0370256566,
0.0244307537,
0.0598287098,
-0.0547019765,
-0.0553670973,
0.0744194314,
-0.0034980502,
-0.0736456364,
0.0003138329,
-0.0310282949,
0.0026748204,
-0.0086451424,
0.0506971292,
0.0035802221,
-0.0127076302,
0.0117132179,
-0.0025198769,
0.0286221821,
-0.0318288617,
0.015914198,
-0.0280641038,
-0.0246777069,
-0.064614594,
-0.0062695355,
-0.0082343305,
-0.0319810398,
0.0700713173,
-0.0000946973,
-0.0314763226,
-0.0526902676,
0.0134845376,
-0.0510906242,
0.0518999845,
-0.0206016935,
0.0139817446,
0.0271270052,
0.0197623875,
0.0052923788,
-0.0050898218,
-0.0589406118,
0.0064897267,
0.0011768388,
-0.0298850387,
0.0188228395,
-0.036165636,
-0.0239994489,
-0.070258528,
0.012734591,
-0.0071974713,
-0.0314303674,
-0.0195976254,
-0.0299582519,
0.0059263133,
-0.006198131,
-0.0304337163,
0.0279528406,
0.0111494251,
-0.026267305,
0.0019835255,
0.0410501175,
0.0105599789,
0.0715928674,
-0.028880883,
-0.0388599373,
-0.0172633547,
-0.0020938767,
-0.0510324948,
0.0111904833,
0.026231356,
0.0547064058,
-0.0022407649,
0.0282212608,
-0.019228952,
0.0266375765,
0.0218362212,
0.0387928449,
-0.0371180698,
0.0207423829,
0.0215867702,
0.0378597677,
0.0179875735,
-0.0518033728,
-0.0480704904,
0.005489965,
-0.038505055,
-0.0460101031,
-0.0039267503,
-0.0547410548,
-0.0549601093,
-0.012936973,
-0.0334869772,
-0.0059250649,
-0.0147060119,
-0.0412168391,
-0.00189861,
-0.0238647051,
-0.0305886958,
-0.0677745715,
0.0018907845,
0.0365188643,
-0.0615837649,
0.0755926594,
-0.0121928379,
0.0122474311,
-0.0309971999,
-0.0433897562,
-0.0536561571,
-0.0100497324,
-0.0367397889,
0.0109372744,
-0.010232388,
-0.0866370872,
-0.0406210497,
-0.042886544,
0.0192526318,
0.0546954535,
-0.0101364339,
0.0613182224,
-0.0125537496,
0.0558902621,
0.0492554195,
0.0281409435,
-0.0024154156,
-0.0165441707,
0.0063012452,
0.0132694272,
0.0280751102,
0.0301394612,
-0.0613515377,
-0.0471318699,
0.0241284259,
0.0388668366,
-0.0122860996,
-0.0061649675,
0.067478545,
-0.0382949002,
0.0565799028,
0.0414353944,
-0.0137427589,
0.0111997155,
-0.0285426192,
0.0125521729,
0.0484261811,
-0.0097592026,
-0.0633716732,
-0.0476058349,
-0.0266478974,
0.0772471428,
0.0366645306,
0.0528759435,
0.024132438,
-0.0083704852,
-0.0437378772,
0.0155064603,
0.0368614085,
-0.0407241248,
-0.0559704751,
-0.0165521521,
0.0020896769,
-0.0392567925,
0.1111878082,
0.0225190967,
-0.003498283,
-0.0304766595,
0.0362995863,
-0.0398846418,
-0.0547844283,
-0.0278094709,
-0.0622802041,
0.1344997883,
0.0459377654,
0.0127568562,
-0.0042637447,
-0.0394485779,
0.0240831561,
0.0061182082,
-0.0548374802,
0.0385362804,
-0.0050330344,
-0.0068951808,
-0.0477083474,
-0.0102325091,
0.0607875884,
0.0048912559,
0.0353144109,
0.0104977377,
0.0359780416,
0.0083080865,
0.0423336625,
0.0012948384,
0.0272631627,
0.0092725363,
0.0638804436,
0.0114042154,
-0.0218222197,
0.0295572281,
0.0260391515,
0.0307958834,
-0.0291252229,
0.0011095698,
0.0643772557,
-0.0203757193,
-0.036357142,
-0.0693763793,
0.0203389451,
-0.0020235076,
-0.0129594207,
0.0247548167,
-0.0623997673,
0.0175004117,
0.0003550062,
-0.0226113126,
0.0587133765,
-0.00464838,
0.0022016449,
-0.062915124,
-0.0146921985,
-0.015091571,
-0.0288534928,
0.0053315251,
0.0300249662,
-0.0865540579,
-0.0641407073,
0.0347619317,
-0.0330237001,
0.018524671,
0.0657574087,
-0.0040639164,
-0.0125854872,
0.0267804414,
0.0234967414,
-0.0101415291,
-0.050395973,
0.046921324,
-0.0254234523,
0.0117609669,
0.0280803107,
-0.0643288344,
0.0039738477,
-0.0389463753,
0.0043616355,
-0.0346236303,
-0.0683351904,
0.0032984787,
0.0276339259,
0.0689690858,
0.0088640777,
-0.0178478733,
-0.0575524569,
0.0191706792,
-0.022725923,
0.0211916789,
-0.0293283872,
-0.0287448112,
0.0164177027,
0.0307721868,
0.0097261025,
0.0253140181,
-0.0273135956,
-0.0223417748,
-0.0245422795,
0.056274958,
-0.0191202331,
0.0142464666,
-0.0035251521,
0.0298459847,
-0.0050562979,
0.0461020991,
0.0303265415,
0.0520353653,
-0.0042949044,
-0.0200415254,
-0.0011941121,
0.0284162499,
-0.0207067132,
0.0175675601,
0.0027831104,
-0.0079221306,
-0.0303620026,
-0.0088011222,
0.0311764944,
-0.0123483166,
0.0579076,
0.0208241791,
0.0178606361,
-0.020882491,
0.0124448026,
-0.0186201837,
0.0243192371,
0.0017589303,
-0.0180534329,
-0.0405629501,
0.0276713334,
0.0108778886,
-0.0247054566,
-0.0102536296,
-0.046271693,
0.05908297,
-0.0370302312,
-0.0194983836,
0.0055178045,
-0.0378117785,
-0.0478323326,
-0.0609167404,
0.0347940959,
-0.0345899239,
-0.0191283543,
0.0315312482,
-0.0135999219,
-0.0232024342,
0.0284052137,
-0.0180334263,
-0.0908877403,
0.0051898067,
0.0433273315,
-0.061490383,
-0.0040516127,
-0.0494479872,
-0.0039113034,
-6.112127977e-33,
0.0090801604,
0.0151291313,
-0.0016604307,
0.0030935479,
-0.0499848835,
0.0377477519,
-0.0091630658,
0.0259897001,
-0.0226941146,
0.0035682283,
-0.0039652614,
-0.0060295081,
0.0404066779,
0.0294022653,
-0.0254050326,
-0.0406213403,
0.0792637989,
-0.0281649996,
-0.0192734152,
-0.033202894,
-0.0019229685,
-0.0088431127,
0.0106260199,
-0.058561936,
-0.0114750946,
-0.0137356473,
-0.0284942836,
0.0081457421,
0.0288923569,
0.0705896392,
0.0404422022,
0.010377489,
-0.0152441217,
0.0190894641,
0.0115344534,
0.0463851467,
-0.0937939584,
0.0276039857,
0.0126845399,
0.0482806005,
-0.0352531448,
-0.0228014197,
0.0766762719,
0.0005938698,
-0.0087662758,
-0.0436848551,
0.0520917252,
-0.0263282973,
0.005041956,
-0.0319290757,
-0.0138389925,
0.0169943795,
-0.0387681872,
-0.0214494113,
0.0661778599,
0.0601862259,
-0.0117999269,
-0.0158694666,
-0.0729724988,
0.0186868794,
0.0496985875,
0.0640166402,
0.0548903085,
0.0334571898,
-0.013151085,
0.0421416648,
0.0575327873,
-0.0547024794,
0.0119951991,
-0.0202694479,
0.0063261716,
0.0202033576,
0.0149997473,
0.0217538029,
0.0375265814,
0.0096946117,
-0.0569229983,
0.0091311447,
0.0087995222,
0.0049887616,
-0.0354129896,
0.0200913362,
-0.0440165587,
0.036040321,
-0.0141545758,
-0.0203378797,
-0.017265439,
0.0056081866,
0.0077662277,
-0.0209155697,
-0.0377944857,
0.0009651934,
0.0263446271,
-0.0079185152,
0.0461913832,
0.0075741853,
0.0284863189,
-0.030166911,
-0.0190438684,
0.0010647837,
-0.0370116606,
-0.0604505613,
0.0324191637,
0.0538707227,
0.043337509,
0.0045473147,
0.0398891121,
0.0413500555,
-0.0667970181,
0.0100075835,
0.0062947432,
0.0489098839,
-0.0438122563,
-0.0006910271,
0.066424489,
-0.0328910798,
0.015058618,
0.0554322079,
0.0053936443,
0.059365958,
0.0025939643,
-0.0069815139,
0.0236090198,
-0.0362329632,
-0.0393280499,
0.0255039837,
0.0089976341,
-0.0087693203,
0.0224591717,
-0.0261957347,
0.0160729401,
-0.0356843136,
2.289e-7,
-0.0462581776,
0.0365614481,
0.0689742267,
-0.0265101604,
0.0425062329,
0.0146664092,
-0.0055599967,
-0.0422785506,
-0.0027731371,
0.0162262991,
0.0499926209,
-0.0429197922,
0.1033926606,
0.0352809206,
-0.0665413216,
-0.0265944041,
-0.0856194124,
0.0011569503,
0.008141811,
0.0180255119,
-0.0010864375,
0.0845322385,
0.0084249265,
-0.0572121516,
0.0248831715,
0.0172348227,
-0.0459604412,
-0.007633172,
0.0093147438,
-0.0206720792,
0.001984603,
0.0163663737,
-0.0086556301,
-0.0092884526,
-0.0268094763,
0.0683218464,
-0.003134778,
0.0578056797,
-0.0338254459,
-0.0406723469,
-0.0205374677,
0.0143784927,
-0.0204018466,
0.0020182584,
0.0460871831,
0.0036494697,
-0.0011958189,
-0.0194499623,
-0.0720232502,
0.0178810004,
-0.0013651833,
0.0083610741,
0.0167542305,
0.0250033513,
0.0281655844,
-0.0287583321,
-0.0382889584,
-0.0020123064,
-0.0321474485,
-0.0038907116,
-0.0429885574,
-0.0128683615,
0.0036317168,
-0.0192517117,
0.0092699192,
-0.0006863973,
0.0404278524,
1.356145677e-34,
0.0054440284,
-0.046290163,
0.0788374543,
-0.0121735232,
-0.0191319976,
-0.0439183712,
0.0232585054,
0.0148948561,
0.007510649,
0.0147560872,
-0.0215520654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17923v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17923v1 | PAFT: A Parallel Training Paradigm for Effective LLM Fine-Tuning | 2024-06-25T20:11:37 | 2024-06-25T20:11:37 | Shiva Kumar Pentyala, Zhichao Wang, Bin Bi, Kiran Ramnath, Xiang-Bo Mao, Regunathan Radhakrishnan, Sitaram Asur, Na, Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable abilities in diverse
natural language processing (NLP) tasks. The LLMs generally undergo supervised
fine-tuning (SFT) followed by preference alignment to be usable in downstream
applications. However, this sequential training pipeline leads to alignment tax
that degrades the LLM performance.
This paper introduces PAFT, a new PArallel training paradigm for effective
LLM Fine-Tuning, which independently performs SFT and preference alignment
(e.g., DPO and ORPO, etc.) with the same pre-trained model on respective
datasets. The model produced by SFT and the model from preference alignment are
then merged into a final model by parameter fusing for use in downstream
applications. This work reveals important findings that preference alignment
like DPO naturally results in a sparse model while SFT leads to a natural dense
model which needs to be sparsified for effective model merging. This paper
introduces an effective interference resolution which reduces the redundancy by
sparsifying the delta parameters. The LLM resulted from the new training
paradigm achieved Rank #1 on the HuggingFace Open LLM Leaderboard.
Comprehensive evaluation shows the effectiveness of the parallel training
paradigm. | PAFT: A Parallel Training Paradigm for Effective LLM Fine-Tuning: Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable abilities in diverse
natural language processing (NLP) tasks. The LLMs generally undergo supervised
fine-tuning (SFT) followed by preference alignment to be usable in downstream
applications. However, this sequential training pipeline leads to alignment tax
that degrades the LLM performance.
This paper introduces PAFT, a new PArallel training paradigm for effective
LLM Fine-Tuning, which independently performs SFT and preference alignment
(e.g., DPO and ORPO, etc.) with the same pre-trained model on respective
datasets. The model produced by SFT and the model from preference alignment are
then merged into a final model by parameter fusing for use in downstream
applications. This work reveals important findings that preference alignment
like DPO naturally results in a sparse model while SFT leads to a natural dense
model which needs to be sparsified for effective model merging. This paper
introduces an effective interference resolution which reduces the redundancy by
sparsifying the delta parameters. The LLM resulted from the new training
paradigm achieved Rank #1 on the HuggingFace Open LLM Leaderboard.
Comprehensive evaluation shows the effectiveness of the parallel training
paradigm. | [
0.0488101542,
0.0250965487,
0.0106262639,
0.022329133,
-0.0385594331,
0.0245424043,
-0.0273460411,
-0.014608386,
-0.0161372852,
-0.0584242493,
-0.056008555,
-0.0193923749,
0.0420058109,
-0.0077188294,
0.0111773666,
-0.0409964211,
0.0575883873,
-0.0023462169,
0.0007667802,
-0.0002799721,
0.0227778107,
0.0332440697,
0.0024456477,
-0.0037975598,
0.0378585197,
-0.013189204,
0.0073822546,
0.0245597027,
0.0353117883,
0.0096805627,
0.0267194025,
0.0653642341,
0.0099993823,
0.0475839861,
0.0000020418,
-0.0627609417,
-0.034015391,
0.0200814661,
-0.005214815,
0.0238223411,
0.0406183638,
0.0189314857,
-0.0049730754,
0.0319929942,
-0.0266948324,
0.0010140586,
0.0415021665,
0.0699818805,
0.0495666228,
0.0860074759,
-0.0074410476,
-0.0557974763,
0.0364532396,
-0.0274825152,
-0.0841122642,
-0.0249321274,
0.0372222662,
-0.0255678855,
-0.0136216255,
-0.0073626158,
0.0064674658,
0.0077647921,
-0.0406152159,
0.056325227,
0.023923425,
0.0039142966,
-0.0393882208,
-0.0412660576,
-0.0407707356,
0.0603329986,
-0.0970495641,
-0.0072932858,
0.0155858705,
-0.0330073945,
-0.0247206148,
-0.0081022177,
-0.0250701103,
-0.0188694168,
0.0012435097,
0.0668160841,
0.051679261,
-0.0468604751,
0.026035469,
0.0280735586,
-0.0539322272,
0.0305568203,
0.0307244211,
-0.0394837894,
0.0131658837,
-0.0364823192,
-0.0782086328,
-0.0206541438,
0.0031298061,
-0.0208491143,
-0.0545137674,
0.0208327696,
-0.0569663122,
-0.0237397999,
0.0532024577,
-0.0915495604,
0.0637378693,
0.0490325354,
0.0058354228,
0.0271429364,
-0.0267784782,
0.0414633825,
-0.0148495417,
0.0286271125,
-0.0601825565,
0.0166949295,
-0.0396837555,
0.0048268312,
-0.0029387095,
0.0441493765,
-0.0705359429,
-0.0403656624,
-0.0447105728,
0.0165897515,
0.0166900717,
-0.00452821,
0.0610538386,
-0.0178247299,
-0.0143927587,
-0.0160040241,
-0.0246610139,
0.0710852742,
0.012687658,
0.0252942964,
-0.0524130017,
-0.035407234,
-0.001414791,
0.0068647182,
-0.0065217912,
-0.0286721699,
0.0202661399,
0.034642186,
0.0025287853,
-0.026994722,
-0.0511443205,
0.0205528643,
-0.0084929559,
-0.0763862506,
-0.028342193,
-0.0488007888,
0.0436927825,
-0.0194854476,
0.0294383056,
-0.0280498322,
0.0188948456,
0.0007980803,
-0.0491028763,
0.072940737,
-0.0420760848,
0.0171116535,
0.0152374292,
-0.0202159323,
0.0446619503,
0.0956159905,
0.0209514387,
0.0089380695,
0.0343264602,
-0.0230415296,
-0.0639968738,
0.0374096446,
-0.0178612955,
0.005939519,
-0.0447936282,
0.0018840842,
0.0387408361,
0.0085763475,
0.0319753699,
0.0538571328,
-0.0105616786,
-0.0053708847,
0.0458657779,
0.0154143125,
0.0643359348,
-0.0026363782,
-0.0165741052,
0.0286353882,
-0.02054804,
0.0433749668,
-0.0272935815,
-0.0183793884,
-0.0563575774,
0.0377307497,
0.0587081909,
0.0848836526,
-0.0055827005,
-0.0177912749,
-0.0341919251,
-0.0005926106,
-0.0456833057,
0.0018836788,
0.0456352159,
-0.0190230515,
-0.0762778893,
0.0360028818,
0.0473018214,
-0.0057357959,
-0.0332471319,
-0.0251756459,
-0.0235039238,
0.078303583,
0.023268275,
-0.0283784438,
-0.0554844327,
-0.0071203504,
-0.0403521284,
0.0346825607,
0.0431613699,
0.0228630174,
0.0171411633,
-0.0649140924,
-0.0576779023,
0.0154250544,
0.0025875005,
0.0026677137,
0.0434418134,
-0.0132520888,
0.014154885,
0.0224207062,
-0.0536522493,
0.0486172885,
-0.0025385779,
-0.0265628844,
0.0223072432,
0.0052949805,
0.0676868483,
0.0234932564,
-0.0035800531,
-0.0077567776,
0.0616710186,
-0.0044843443,
0.0022131496,
-0.0293146223,
-0.0144174295,
-0.0103345728,
0.0724674463,
0.0304153059,
-0.009626084,
0.0509035848,
-0.0592728108,
-0.0545187034,
-0.0476924889,
-0.0053419289,
0.0453339666,
-0.0331872851,
0.0659221187,
-0.0072900183,
0.0215302054,
-0.077237919,
0.0558093227,
0.0000105432,
0.0343971141,
-0.0057216147,
0.0143984361,
0.0184800643,
-0.0294567589,
-0.0354020596,
0.0214028899,
-0.0069785458,
0.0157784689,
-0.0029096929,
-0.0011647551,
-0.0551204197,
-0.0468136668,
-0.0713018253,
0.0673218593,
-0.0107007883,
0.0282436926,
0.035124518,
0.0300814901,
-0.0075064464,
-0.00520512,
0.0130747464,
0.0105578033,
0.0127051948,
0.0088191181,
0.0212743748,
0.0059948042,
-0.0467958562,
-0.0407432877,
-0.0088062445,
0.0132304672,
0.0058153137,
-0.025068054,
-0.028765399,
-0.061750751,
0.0467313677,
-0.0125915296,
0.0516883321,
0.0063254819,
-0.0173378233,
-0.0179293696,
-0.014536567,
0.0303593036,
0.0568798669,
0.019075077,
-0.0147323338,
0.0365444757,
-0.0019057781,
-0.0320100859,
0.0066701351,
-0.0424016714,
-0.0061433222,
-0.0541774109,
0.0054225479,
0.0023417075,
0.0644244775,
-0.0108924313,
-0.0022544989,
-0.0429321863,
-0.0335827135,
0.0081676077,
-0.0011193111,
0.0208584629,
0.0028700125,
-0.0255864244,
0.0062160096,
-0.0314056315,
-0.0688884258,
0.0553615279,
-0.0440456159,
0.017050406,
-0.0744398162,
-0.0214820225,
-0.0569027551,
0.0145689156,
-0.0135768764,
0.0055369139,
-0.0349292569,
-0.026644852,
-0.034123078,
-0.0231826808,
0.0055510844,
-0.0207252484,
0.0357349217,
-0.0312334541,
0.0274127293,
-0.0475865602,
-0.0247417632,
-0.0319772772,
-0.0690810308,
-0.0217518322,
0.0138409352,
0.0338538177,
-0.0321257226,
-0.0376533531,
0.0311578009,
-0.0241528377,
0.0226190481,
-0.01228402,
0.0163497608,
-0.0463131256,
0.0140904216,
0.0670661256,
0.0138175329,
0.0134707615,
0.0113060232,
0.0006708018,
0.0119573502,
0.0376989059,
-0.0268367399,
-0.0301701985,
-0.0104809841,
0.0488385595,
-0.0750218481,
-0.0234878957,
-0.0121864509,
0.0064378562,
-0.053328868,
0.0444827974,
0.1204554364,
0.0359320529,
-0.0058423979,
-0.0076826909,
0.0198567659,
0.062066026,
0.032701198,
0.0228652339,
-0.0538119413,
-0.036569912,
-0.0083653657,
0.0120523954,
-0.0016709839,
0.0366433151,
-0.0359760858,
-0.121402815,
-0.0028881209,
0.0439311266,
-0.0200209431,
-0.0072063394,
-0.0595495477,
0.0057896846,
-0.0327958427,
0.0379303619,
0.0098020853,
-0.0339166783,
-0.0084982775,
0.0101083545,
0.0237932857,
-0.0517930761,
-0.0168811325,
-0.0307166353,
0.0537409969,
0.0433699116,
0.0067839674,
0.0189538803,
-0.0327290781,
0.0634151176,
-0.0179552417,
0.0121510094,
-0.0653660074,
-0.0015904298,
-0.0391601957,
0.0046954723,
-0.0191750284,
0.0075850729,
-0.0235282071,
-0.01202399,
-0.0198424477,
0.0696180239,
-0.0102304043,
0.0198076069,
0.0155168669,
-0.0032176855,
-0.03392848,
0.0414697714,
-0.0361599624,
-0.0252739936,
-0.0275094695,
0.0315205194,
-0.0309760142,
-0.0123867188,
0.0184648838,
0.0219158679,
-0.0585426837,
-0.0328964405,
-0.0209287573,
0.0315967314,
0.0376749896,
0.0171016902,
0.0304051358,
0.0615963042,
-0.0139267175,
-0.0047136848,
-0.0344590172,
0.0371032991,
0.0001513154,
0.0035125811,
-0.0734866485,
0.0113187432,
0.0597171485,
0.0029266474,
-0.0071966993,
0.0118701207,
-0.065826878,
-0.0928675011,
0.002944947,
0.0293257814,
0.0165851377,
0.0576520264,
0.0074257343,
-0.0543720759,
-0.0088232178,
0.0607449189,
-0.0390359908,
0.0200483259,
0.0051503438,
-0.0340832509,
-0.0062217857,
0.0086517232,
-0.0091706729,
-0.0099465996,
0.0086318152,
0.0195135847,
-0.01062652,
-0.0935209319,
0.0125748087,
0.0328311808,
0.0639614761,
-0.0237634387,
-0.0088596642,
-0.0513111502,
0.0551321059,
0.0245444514,
-0.0046095331,
-0.0168445893,
-0.0185883623,
0.0223928224,
-0.0107175102,
-0.0040594698,
0.0232927296,
-0.0178776868,
0.0014588536,
-0.0165088847,
0.0161977988,
-0.0212753229,
-0.0412360206,
0.0155544085,
0.018420618,
-0.0147246867,
0.051092688,
0.0339293629,
0.0167311542,
-0.0343485735,
0.0275545418,
0.0181349069,
0.0496816188,
-0.051662419,
0.0346366465,
-0.0417302251,
-0.0605214685,
-0.0399362221,
-0.017549675,
0.078560032,
-0.025175713,
0.0828139335,
0.0110498955,
-0.0217183698,
-0.0163510591,
0.0157611351,
-0.0262373369,
0.0363842882,
0.0249756146,
0.0106149381,
-0.0444401689,
0.022395296,
0.0650156364,
0.0008202499,
0.0335798822,
-0.0024419392,
-0.0096623786,
-0.0461587608,
-0.0443980955,
0.0214212164,
0.0647088885,
-0.0449380726,
-0.0104492689,
-0.003517793,
-0.026227938,
-0.0000931183,
-0.0224476326,
-0.0071172002,
-0.0205516331,
0.0358747877,
0.0179465041,
-0.0248461962,
-0.008978501,
-0.0220948998,
-0.040948946,
0.0241845697,
-0.0218235049,
0.0060837702,
-6.887474133e-33,
-0.0468988493,
0.0095565291,
0.0000814059,
-0.0106574316,
-0.063291952,
-0.0234631095,
0.0372545011,
-0.0220385585,
-0.0193136372,
-0.0367775001,
-0.0249363817,
-0.0009905621,
0.0279280785,
0.0067372224,
-0.0074182996,
0.0267379116,
0.0748299062,
-0.0011878876,
0.0192656126,
-0.0276841242,
0.0233726762,
0.052300781,
0.0358649567,
-0.0446119979,
-0.0280793849,
0.0215383824,
-0.0204021651,
0.0170752574,
-0.0399285406,
0.0375889204,
-0.0129332701,
0.0082480218,
0.0236038454,
-0.0147961667,
-0.0232447032,
0.0174268298,
-0.060452044,
0.0119014801,
0.0778970718,
0.0258640964,
0.001632079,
-0.0096185245,
0.0561232641,
0.0072666751,
-0.0090595083,
-0.0295577329,
0.0256718379,
-0.0484227017,
-0.0318165757,
0.0332858413,
-0.0562576465,
0.0433763079,
0.0117827402,
0.008726852,
0.064250946,
-0.0303006824,
-0.0039755115,
0.0418865606,
-0.0264484584,
0.0095359664,
0.0373367891,
0.076866284,
0.0584282316,
0.0492265411,
0.0085741775,
0.0395636223,
-0.0060921083,
-0.0336436182,
0.0496573672,
-0.0302628502,
0.0183898956,
0.080724977,
0.0085809473,
0.0264024269,
0.0444977731,
-0.0347943045,
-0.0647360533,
0.0222476609,
0.0043032612,
0.0096368585,
0.0219686292,
0.0576547049,
0.0045451615,
-0.0185968168,
-0.0440505631,
0.0019430631,
-0.0452896617,
-0.0027612248,
0.0157697126,
0.0349263623,
-0.0062910141,
0.0265521836,
0.006934287,
-0.0618059412,
0.0221508909,
-0.0131013431,
-0.0174533557,
0.0136339292,
-0.0165476706,
0.0055787526,
-0.0862689391,
-0.0816387832,
-0.0058751334,
-0.0026576584,
-0.0097606303,
-0.0238104109,
0.0280501917,
-0.0163358133,
-0.0801641345,
0.0338140391,
-0.003885437,
-0.0012930601,
0.0136831775,
0.0711199045,
0.0434631109,
-0.0216123499,
-0.0014360319,
0.0535096936,
0.0232626181,
-0.0006833444,
-0.0236329045,
-0.0117195491,
0.0029721241,
0.0280888062,
0.0086151157,
0.0351312831,
0.0098935645,
0.0062154932,
0.0111309718,
-0.0245700292,
-0.0304995291,
0.0283804182,
2.837e-7,
0.0280751698,
0.0468679965,
0.0227152798,
-0.0109961787,
-0.0087144151,
0.0183964763,
-0.0070536397,
0.013769675,
0.0107788807,
0.0248669218,
0.0235539041,
0.0031925812,
0.0334992036,
-0.019371653,
-0.0890473202,
-0.0118696159,
-0.0382314399,
0.0388551615,
-0.0625109002,
0.0033825596,
0.0350501314,
0.1087398753,
0.0139166173,
-0.0146325743,
-0.005144591,
0.0249710232,
0.0356769934,
-0.0282025877,
-0.0070031635,
0.0570965596,
-0.0196586158,
0.0032857107,
-0.0361485891,
0.026964182,
-0.0378036425,
0.0539337136,
-0.0290707983,
0.1036699116,
-0.0267581977,
-0.02087388,
0.0385037027,
0.0149213793,
-0.0230368469,
-0.0644438639,
0.075370416,
-0.0191806909,
-0.0490577035,
-0.0600327067,
-0.0136487642,
-0.0192297827,
0.046433188,
-0.0185429715,
0.0064451192,
0.0295321196,
0.029898379,
-0.0071128299,
-0.0726207346,
-0.0688439682,
-0.020518627,
0.0243469123,
-0.0348394699,
-0.0332419313,
-0.011368067,
0.0180626977,
0.0402133875,
-0.0353845693,
-0.0029623264,
3.095333765e-34,
0.0322080553,
-0.0107728792,
0.0299658086,
0.0292716846,
-0.0097444961,
-0.0213100314,
-0.0201153643,
0.0550421663,
-0.017724121,
-0.0942324772,
0.0016246967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17911v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17911v2 | X-ray Made Simple: Radiology Report Generation and Evaluation with Layman's Terms | 2024-06-25T19:52:01 | 2024-06-30T21:53:56 | Kun Zhao, Chenghao Xiao, Chen Tang, Bohao Yang, Kai Ye, Noura Al Moubayed, Liang Zhan, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Radiology Report Generation (RRG) has achieved significant progress with the
advancements of multimodal generative models. However, the evaluation in the
domain suffers from a lack of fair and robust metrics. We reveal that, high
performance on RRG with existing lexical-based metrics (e.g. BLEU) might be
more of a mirage - a model can get a high BLEU only by learning the template of
reports. This has become an urgent problem for RRG due to the highly
patternized nature of these reports. In this work, we un-intuitively approach
this problem by proposing the Layman's RRG framework, a layman's terms-based
dataset, evaluation and training framework that systematically improves RRG
with day-to-day language. We first contribute the translated Layman's terms
dataset. Building upon the dataset, we then propose a semantics-based
evaluation method, which is proved to mitigate the inflated numbers of BLEU and
provides fairer evaluation. Last, we show that training on the layman's terms
dataset encourages models to focus on the semantics of the reports, as opposed
to overfitting to learning the report templates. We reveal a promising scaling
law between the number of training examples and semantics gain provided by our
dataset, compared to the inverse pattern brought by the original formats. Our
code is available at \url{https://github.com/hegehongcha/LaymanRRG}. | X-ray Made Simple: Radiology Report Generation and Evaluation with Layman's Terms: Radiology Report Generation (RRG) has achieved significant progress with the
advancements of multimodal generative models. However, the evaluation in the
domain suffers from a lack of fair and robust metrics. We reveal that, high
performance on RRG with existing lexical-based metrics (e.g. BLEU) might be
more of a mirage - a model can get a high BLEU only by learning the template of
reports. This has become an urgent problem for RRG due to the highly
patternized nature of these reports. In this work, we un-intuitively approach
this problem by proposing the Layman's RRG framework, a layman's terms-based
dataset, evaluation and training framework that systematically improves RRG
with day-to-day language. We first contribute the translated Layman's terms
dataset. Building upon the dataset, we then propose a semantics-based
evaluation method, which is proved to mitigate the inflated numbers of BLEU and
provides fairer evaluation. Last, we show that training on the layman's terms
dataset encourages models to focus on the semantics of the reports, as opposed
to overfitting to learning the report templates. We reveal a promising scaling
law between the number of training examples and semantics gain provided by our
dataset, compared to the inverse pattern brought by the original formats. Our
code is available at \url{https://github.com/hegehongcha/LaymanRRG}. | [
0.0326596126,
0.0697698668,
0.0403918587,
-0.0080308467,
-0.0059831962,
0.0165301654,
0.0300583728,
0.0449650027,
-0.0607360639,
-0.0212373547,
-0.0389189832,
-0.0534482822,
0.0179488026,
0.0552174225,
0.0476547852,
-0.1057389826,
0.0117679862,
0.0049078222,
-0.0065812096,
-0.0065234238,
0.0157306548,
0.0250960179,
-0.009090892,
0.0328540951,
-0.0711000189,
-0.0062678647,
0.024743462,
0.0209767651,
0.0234123468,
-0.0376103222,
-0.036531277,
0.0519200563,
0.0217153747,
0.0116172172,
0.0000019898,
-0.020379195,
-0.0051795784,
0.0353621021,
0.0420645252,
-0.0050501991,
0.0891580805,
-0.0814995244,
-0.0122551294,
-0.0100933453,
-0.0154539794,
-0.0507804677,
0.0464903601,
0.0475498028,
0.0576882176,
0.0545061566,
-0.0279189087,
-0.0162619855,
-0.0092548691,
-0.0505453385,
0.0482215211,
-0.024717221,
-0.0102070281,
0.0239418373,
-0.0161303058,
0.017873941,
-0.0441663787,
0.0414984226,
0.0109527558,
0.0103394873,
0.0237873886,
0.0713847652,
0.0239762627,
-0.019491462,
0.0054188739,
0.0751729161,
-0.002859765,
0.018308308,
-0.0086202091,
-0.0142463818,
-0.0061240634,
0.0041199396,
-0.0644726157,
0.0518641621,
-0.0103330752,
-0.0069099688,
-0.0278090406,
0.0081090452,
0.0076817414,
0.0268214662,
0.0235243663,
-0.042268049,
0.0182069913,
0.0161173902,
-0.0077872495,
0.0102848615,
-0.0044799605,
-0.0510888547,
0.0001519622,
0.0265023578,
-0.0384015329,
0.0183927771,
-0.0583513677,
0.0110215573,
0.066848807,
-0.0139148664,
0.013336611,
-0.0110491822,
-0.0576294623,
0.045455303,
-0.0099301869,
0.0013440162,
-0.0096936384,
0.0500112362,
-0.0319028385,
0.0058272765,
-0.0269341152,
-0.0118450141,
-0.0364740752,
-0.000221158,
0.0068817837,
-0.0191086512,
-0.0876914859,
-0.0153953964,
0.0028386188,
0.0140217645,
0.0336702801,
0.0779837444,
-0.1156737879,
0.0200706981,
-0.0260861814,
0.0353918411,
-0.0272715818,
-0.005663699,
0.041801963,
-0.0245076455,
0.0106685869,
0.0378971137,
-0.0071052518,
0.0035085483,
-0.0183406249,
0.0400986932,
-0.0258247815,
-0.0025410522,
0.0341387466,
-0.0790545195,
-0.0289109778,
-0.0439592637,
0.0446162298,
-0.0875725225,
0.0340748355,
-0.0042150379,
0.0149545893,
-0.0076293573,
0.0038470011,
0.006606156,
-0.0124818543,
0.0648498684,
-0.0052479897,
-0.0133484825,
0.0335883386,
0.0357722491,
0.0237324666,
0.0295647737,
0.0205423739,
0.0330371112,
0.0125644179,
0.001970636,
0.0097710202,
0.0098279342,
0.0102910511,
-0.0080596013,
-0.0325505398,
-0.0264098551,
-0.0197879095,
0.0899359062,
0.063288115,
0.0535698906,
-0.0457929485,
-0.0204698667,
0.0201333947,
0.0111605795,
0.0161749702,
0.0192264635,
0.0653691441,
-0.0253441501,
-0.0305964854,
0.0191927589,
0.0019767811,
0.0530083515,
0.0169351175,
0.0185522251,
0.0044847783,
0.0110087255,
-0.0532657541,
-0.0244063344,
0.0017195046,
0.0032933869,
-0.0063768821,
-0.0302047953,
0.0422699489,
0.0314026102,
-0.0506465174,
0.0442138128,
0.0536453538,
-0.0459060967,
0.0052323495,
-0.0649146885,
-0.0109608574,
0.0358411409,
0.0997849107,
0.0158700515,
-0.0315391161,
0.0127125392,
0.0329892114,
0.0696505383,
0.0256773885,
-0.0150722964,
0.0281909779,
-0.0527207814,
-0.0436354727,
-0.0039319531,
0.0109173516,
0.030123122,
-0.0028435972,
0.0095787738,
0.0102286423,
-0.0550979488,
-0.0356623717,
0.0321641974,
-0.030480044,
-0.024687564,
0.0077253585,
-0.0015611504,
0.0136776399,
-0.005279908,
-0.031431146,
0.0172454044,
-0.0005588004,
-0.0207976718,
0.0078074089,
0.0132870823,
-0.0527298786,
-0.0307710394,
-0.0001255147,
-0.0807981342,
0.0087707983,
0.0017379171,
-0.0558654033,
-0.00927113,
-0.0167258121,
-0.0483859815,
0.0117115863,
-0.045650024,
-0.0139551461,
0.0879335329,
0.0047790883,
-0.0037891776,
0.0547918193,
-0.0288757663,
0.011377505,
0.025994027,
0.0270593874,
-0.0010450721,
-0.0446722507,
-0.0032208958,
0.0205256473,
0.0042192298,
0.0139055755,
0.0018617355,
0.0361710079,
-0.0297581665,
0.0014894797,
-0.0641607791,
-0.0215456113,
0.022837352,
-0.0316363126,
0.0421299301,
0.0078545865,
0.0255660191,
-0.0193478968,
-0.0528881997,
-0.0016395493,
0.0521524064,
0.0169767197,
0.0523375161,
0.0226017889,
0.0156400818,
-0.0262590721,
-0.0266027339,
-0.0001068052,
0.0137180509,
0.0371488519,
0.0012845455,
-0.0151659874,
0.0286828298,
-0.0614107922,
-0.0067233061,
-0.002454001,
-0.073277697,
0.0476669446,
-0.0422228836,
-0.0078230435,
0.0336823016,
0.0381031483,
0.0287832022,
0.023145292,
-0.0119290566,
-0.0297603998,
-0.0141342189,
-0.0540263988,
-0.017450003,
0.0445222557,
-0.0818722174,
-0.0083278408,
0.0386196487,
0.0246475916,
0.0374531373,
-0.0297650956,
0.0004250513,
-0.0054225116,
-0.0480100997,
-0.02977084,
0.0356542468,
-0.0151440166,
0.019652281,
-0.0075688669,
-0.0387417823,
0.0610251427,
-0.0050274464,
0.0040110219,
-0.0342217535,
0.0185851436,
-0.0041463021,
0.0489026606,
-0.0000929117,
0.0540505797,
0.0262772106,
-0.0143679539,
-0.0567617752,
0.0004726148,
0.0568711832,
-0.0425808132,
-0.0139995571,
-0.0164177064,
-0.0050297854,
-0.0267831236,
-0.0254274495,
-0.0331643857,
-0.0259486698,
0.0523788519,
-0.0004945554,
0.0021754,
-0.0192459058,
-0.0596188754,
0.0373344608,
0.0070185019,
0.0239184666,
-0.0121340808,
-0.0388200954,
0.0091412803,
0.0754652992,
0.047575634,
0.0200112648,
-0.040872179,
-0.0466067903,
-0.0338311642,
0.0708560124,
-0.0112053063,
0.032092344,
-0.0189839806,
-0.0026235045,
-0.0178173613,
0.0488238409,
0.0126127554,
0.0272186492,
0.038500756,
-0.0343757272,
-0.0399208702,
0.0669189841,
0.0204137061,
-0.0062238527,
-0.0019100815,
0.0439305194,
0.0284488574,
-0.0054787048,
-0.0050018192,
-0.0362307653,
-0.0089443047,
-0.027144013,
0.0445540026,
-0.011660343,
0.0076512182,
-0.0022187175,
-0.0560057424,
0.0588055514,
0.0122677572,
-0.0648723766,
-0.0362517498,
-0.0156208444,
-0.0181573108,
-0.0053086914,
-0.0361426324,
-0.006905769,
-0.0164563414,
0.0036205521,
0.0378657766,
-0.0318874791,
-0.0899583772,
0.0147926118,
-0.0445189364,
-0.0121545214,
0.0692969188,
0.0367992446,
-0.0194679573,
-0.0387190692,
-0.0131680919,
0.053725794,
0.004246939,
-0.000820316,
0.0791086629,
0.0042704409,
-0.0218666568,
-0.0341929123,
0.0520462133,
0.0124132112,
-0.0015030315,
-0.0426787026,
0.0112009523,
-0.0140956333,
-0.0022670641,
-0.0821725428,
0.0591771305,
0.0254915226,
0.0444763713,
0.0065086209,
0.0003069002,
-0.0289584547,
-0.0142255612,
0.0857664496,
-0.0736360475,
-0.0404476337,
0.0260631628,
-0.0639772788,
-0.0773215592,
-0.0834090784,
-0.0448250696,
0.0129503505,
0.0646844581,
-0.0414588004,
-0.0330590047,
-0.0525661036,
-0.0151640326,
-0.0338522829,
0.0414735712,
0.013513797,
-0.0123778107,
-0.0344222672,
-0.0672798306,
0.0375222415,
-0.0089944731,
-0.027977312,
0.0687617883,
-0.0645189211,
0.0080365352,
-0.0190579277,
0.058343932,
0.0223134607,
0.009597715,
0.0024855104,
-0.0173213277,
0.0890026242,
0.0883928016,
-0.0003641233,
0.00880061,
0.0129812369,
-0.0143369585,
-0.0250814036,
0.0061807111,
-0.0404447578,
0.0296483785,
-0.0010551006,
0.0460669175,
-0.0206435826,
-0.0199340414,
0.0366201177,
0.0147347022,
0.0165752433,
-0.0872292891,
0.0070102615,
-0.0357646681,
-0.0408938229,
-0.0308673158,
-0.0050107972,
-0.0555012561,
0.0160854068,
0.0337316357,
-0.0058030104,
-0.0037812823,
0.0234996099,
-0.0383636691,
0.0342730656,
-0.0512624681,
0.004049364,
0.0257971324,
-0.0491344258,
0.0122383358,
0.0052425708,
-0.0275653489,
-0.0386851653,
-0.0249951761,
0.0008988017,
-0.0099000223,
0.0593087934,
0.0394243188,
0.0520984307,
-0.0138760805,
0.0285851099,
0.0057513523,
-0.023739256,
-0.0730499178,
0.0220923461,
0.0344996937,
0.022742752,
0.0190065093,
-0.054551281,
-0.0167220384,
-0.0218015723,
0.0568927936,
-0.0078587858,
-0.0165253319,
0.0475889817,
0.0021741868,
0.0475235097,
-0.0321679786,
0.1156670004,
-0.0035620029,
0.0246661622,
-0.0309461225,
-0.0460138507,
-0.0570167117,
-0.0266614761,
0.0249739811,
-0.0108848149,
0.0021775498,
0.0168196224,
-0.0602719709,
-0.0606548637,
-0.037051104,
0.0164757352,
-0.0137338722,
0.0063799089,
0.0836929753,
0.0688548982,
-0.0022909101,
-0.0009300351,
-0.0197661091,
0.0400470458,
-0.0123150367,
-0.0303677488,
0.0273075812,
-5.890095461e-33,
-0.0208832752,
-0.0279828366,
0.0287729148,
-0.0537797362,
-0.0017802058,
0.0399895534,
-0.0293314625,
-0.0059413291,
0.0429552905,
0.0223674066,
-0.0051221158,
-0.0279699396,
0.0193370264,
0.0469821244,
0.0163120795,
0.0341902301,
0.0392194092,
-0.0236015581,
-0.0437734909,
0.0418399796,
0.0071021044,
0.0133838924,
0.0608067773,
-0.0843214542,
-0.0276089981,
0.0226694159,
-0.0372061618,
-0.0319472775,
0.0294249468,
0.0594986826,
-0.0506711788,
0.0128429495,
0.0122805284,
-0.0288359243,
-0.0232398212,
0.0012175123,
-0.0843753144,
-0.0016143316,
0.0020401222,
-0.0028487006,
-0.0970471501,
-0.0004129265,
0.0373792201,
-0.0347171575,
0.0087427078,
-0.0417411551,
0.0398667119,
-0.0107522635,
-0.023194911,
-0.0194094926,
-0.0484234132,
0.0429819562,
0.0079279067,
-0.034703996,
-0.0206759721,
0.0060550645,
-0.0271884333,
0.0150659615,
-0.0226209257,
0.0219855346,
0.0493340939,
0.044035241,
0.0516275242,
0.0042296518,
-0.028453799,
0.0426568314,
0.0329115465,
-0.019076556,
0.015043675,
0.031482961,
-0.0232841298,
0.059801504,
-0.011030484,
0.0678119361,
0.0596594028,
0.0056084273,
-0.0585301891,
0.0695841014,
-0.0122488318,
0.0663748011,
0.0296793543,
-0.0201696474,
-0.0276667234,
0.0043757688,
0.0209966786,
-0.0068663051,
-0.0174011532,
-0.0457250252,
0.0299281869,
0.0387456305,
-0.0219487604,
0.0256858692,
0.0299334358,
0.0108646601,
-0.0099731041,
-0.0158942081,
-0.0027391794,
0.0259364489,
-0.0368129425,
-0.0319990851,
-0.0372036174,
-0.012608761,
0.0579276867,
0.0100087021,
0.0320814699,
0.0218433514,
0.0409208238,
0.031940598,
-0.0449843928,
0.0153443655,
-0.0245431643,
-0.0192316212,
-0.0293153618,
0.0167239588,
0.0278348066,
-0.0185981859,
-0.0519836284,
0.0019302557,
-0.0258922391,
0.001080435,
-0.0220607668,
-0.0815738887,
0.0058104303,
0.0218103118,
-0.061289411,
-0.000639236,
-0.0332904682,
-0.0626904964,
0.0929208994,
-0.0103429798,
-0.0414802432,
0.019899385,
2.629e-7,
0.0415118746,
0.0135627259,
0.0153076816,
0.0442494862,
0.0094491197,
0.0180165377,
-0.0172584876,
0.0529555045,
-0.0254128613,
-0.0260426067,
0.0212230459,
-0.0041793422,
0.0063605644,
0.0455699265,
-0.0352128856,
-0.0026970543,
-0.0601326562,
0.0173157509,
-0.002818438,
-0.0441204533,
0.0539884008,
0.0668671504,
-0.0308713317,
-0.0673664883,
0.0258016828,
-0.0105952015,
0.0665925369,
-0.005488574,
-0.0190442763,
-0.0008930973,
0.0275030434,
0.0365536772,
0.0081613474,
0.008025324,
-0.0041070334,
-0.0602515265,
0.0580833852,
0.0435129851,
-0.0241334308,
-0.0226589348,
0.0294641722,
0.0021041995,
0.0032824681,
-0.0162343234,
0.0182597525,
-0.0138279516,
-0.0087055657,
-0.0142535679,
-0.0234485753,
0.0406161807,
0.0345826671,
-0.063874647,
-0.0748023242,
0.0245781448,
0.0344711095,
0.0182889774,
-0.0396420062,
-0.0598933324,
-0.0087285209,
0.0224074982,
-0.0306117591,
-0.0601006374,
0.0079459734,
0.0020226594,
-0.0159054734,
-0.0555042811,
-0.0450379178,
2.340498792e-34,
0.0399244055,
0.0202186834,
-0.0204838011,
-0.0272339135,
0.0124089867,
-0.0038151974,
-0.0054661306,
-0.0060143853,
0.0127997659,
-0.0325973183,
-0.0457595252
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17903v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17903v1 | Mapping the Past: Geographically Linking an Early 20th Century Swedish Encyclopedia with Wikidata | 2024-06-25T19:34:00 | 2024-06-25T19:34:00 | Axel Ahlin, Alfred Myrne, Pierre Nugues | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DL | In this paper, we describe the extraction of all the location entries from a
prominent Swedish encyclopedia from the early 20th century, the \textit{Nordisk
Familjebok} `Nordic Family Book.' We focused on the second edition called
\textit{Uggleupplagan}, which comprises 38 volumes and over 182,000 articles.
This makes it one of the most extensive Swedish encyclopedias. Using a
classifier, we first determined the category of the entries. We found that
approximately 22 percent of them were locations. We applied a named entity
recognition to these entries and we linked them to Wikidata. Wikidata enabled
us to extract their precise geographic locations resulting in almost 18,000
valid coordinates. We then analyzed the distribution of these locations and the
entry selection process. It showed a higher density within Sweden, Germany, and
the United Kingdom. The paper sheds light on the selection and representation
of geographic information in the \textit{Nordisk Familjebok}, providing
insights into historical and societal perspectives. It also paves the way for
future investigations into entry selection in different time periods and
comparative analyses among various encyclopedias. | Mapping the Past: Geographically Linking an Early 20th Century Swedish Encyclopedia with Wikidata: In this paper, we describe the extraction of all the location entries from a
prominent Swedish encyclopedia from the early 20th century, the \textit{Nordisk
Familjebok} `Nordic Family Book.' We focused on the second edition called
\textit{Uggleupplagan}, which comprises 38 volumes and over 182,000 articles.
This makes it one of the most extensive Swedish encyclopedias. Using a
classifier, we first determined the category of the entries. We found that
approximately 22 percent of them were locations. We applied a named entity
recognition to these entries and we linked them to Wikidata. Wikidata enabled
us to extract their precise geographic locations resulting in almost 18,000
valid coordinates. We then analyzed the distribution of these locations and the
entry selection process. It showed a higher density within Sweden, Germany, and
the United Kingdom. The paper sheds light on the selection and representation
of geographic information in the \textit{Nordisk Familjebok}, providing
insights into historical and societal perspectives. It also paves the way for
future investigations into entry selection in different time periods and
comparative analyses among various encyclopedias. | [
0.0591724664,
0.0051165889,
-0.0146976141,
-0.0019435985,
-0.0237176586,
0.0152775152,
0.0243367739,
-0.0066446541,
0.0446034037,
-0.0588803217,
0.0279927496,
0.0093387254,
0.0501387641,
-0.0422385931,
-0.0170748439,
-0.0373417363,
0.0136391316,
-0.0089686289,
-0.0435534604,
-0.0143202068,
-0.0490040295,
0.049573984,
-0.0328537151,
0.0290863365,
0.057112962,
0.0265788306,
0.0034146749,
0.0109280711,
0.0215153247,
-0.0327285752,
0.0168323871,
-0.0058322535,
0.007996548,
0.0178657435,
0.0000017788,
-0.022205798,
-0.0133998236,
-0.0315536894,
-0.0081419451,
0.0333383195,
0.0030031018,
0.0014393949,
-0.0082709827,
-0.0815456659,
0.0363776088,
-0.0268428531,
0.0251474902,
-0.0085550928,
-0.0268905498,
0.0132404538,
0.012110753,
-0.0517607406,
0.0407899916,
0.0473405123,
0.0216983724,
0.0100543983,
0.0057421653,
0.0576406009,
0.0563375317,
0.0393606462,
0.0000919712,
0.0508176051,
-0.0434091389,
0.0117775248,
0.0124524916,
0.0485386923,
-0.039458368,
-0.0014770456,
0.0182605833,
-0.0184469298,
0.1108962893,
-0.0319136269,
0.0429294519,
0.0343072601,
-0.0341621116,
0.0562147461,
-0.0083520338,
-0.0394839272,
-0.0356653929,
0.0050281677,
0.0315228105,
-0.0184691045,
0.004771193,
0.0375945456,
-0.0129760038,
0.0861075819,
-0.0192382243,
-0.0020159509,
0.0069552595,
-0.0067331041,
-0.0051061003,
-0.0771214962,
-0.0042352253,
0.0201961845,
0.051908154,
-0.0097607421,
0.0184811112,
0.0049284543,
0.0093791299,
-0.0224671271,
-0.0648418218,
-0.0289897192,
-0.0099171242,
0.0495029539,
0.0592181906,
-0.0125099933,
0.0189744849,
-0.0275990218,
-0.0201823376,
0.006086492,
-0.0530153438,
-0.0104760295,
0.0035322704,
-0.0009582225,
0.0190606024,
-0.0145148989,
-0.0092555285,
-0.022363754,
0.0404239595,
0.0368752964,
-0.0498236492,
-0.0178614482,
0.010509437,
-0.0123629905,
-0.0534498058,
0.0014474085,
-0.0370989367,
0.0167399719,
-0.0814953297,
0.0808106437,
0.0793038309,
0.01076716,
0.0620340742,
-0.0162617564,
0.007039255,
-0.004504798,
0.0373566672,
-0.0002894225,
-0.0537088327,
-0.0112317773,
0.0231289715,
-0.0108646071,
0.0310555864,
-0.0428552032,
0.0094885975,
0.0353485756,
-0.0162080508,
-0.0531633012,
-0.0116750086,
-0.0121047888,
-0.0863194019,
0.0133353546,
-0.0356493816,
0.0184362512,
0.0986382589,
-0.0080994861,
0.027891187,
0.0162611548,
0.0127059454,
0.0107802786,
0.0633966774,
0.0420938693,
0.0348712057,
0.0144247301,
-0.0044670627,
0.0058506746,
-0.0018844582,
0.0184005331,
-0.0582293831,
-0.0165593605,
0.0069679013,
-0.0153004555,
-0.0233432129,
0.0266776122,
0.0435655862,
0.0639067888,
0.0403758846,
0.004561007,
0.0072782631,
0.0345950201,
-0.0344298035,
-0.0280737597,
-0.0267018285,
-0.0354643203,
-0.0042911363,
0.0149691282,
0.0065328842,
-0.0046313838,
0.0379424505,
-0.0134903528,
-0.0018979213,
0.0457510985,
-0.0006394265,
0.0079640783,
0.0389243364,
-0.0395779423,
0.0069454159,
0.0885064229,
0.0082779368,
0.0202107523,
0.0433309413,
0.0698144361,
0.025388401,
0.0707712844,
0.0452266745,
0.0114892228,
0.0257742498,
-0.005851984,
0.0261212196,
0.0173391942,
0.0350175872,
-0.0068716528,
-0.0190984197,
-0.0076922285,
-0.023914203,
0.0515750609,
-0.00292053,
0.0000747,
0.009714704,
0.0864883661,
0.0119564757,
-0.0702692121,
0.0213833079,
-0.0152684376,
-0.0105899209,
-0.0072420142,
-0.0457061566,
0.0203709379,
-0.0447817743,
0.0514715016,
-0.0120561915,
0.0093357852,
0.0304026771,
-0.0440978706,
0.012543804,
0.0063041644,
0.081656903,
0.058912389,
0.0074594985,
-0.0543911047,
-0.0080700237,
-0.0440912433,
0.0320705809,
-0.0217058565,
-0.0025562095,
-0.00004192,
0.0076382528,
0.0434126258,
0.0099772057,
0.0041862074,
0.0038189178,
-0.0287201405,
0.0711458102,
-0.0154957678,
0.0209791809,
-0.0160639472,
-0.0720884874,
0.0135590313,
-0.0090075294,
0.0113674626,
-0.0010999693,
-0.013236315,
0.0141936941,
0.0300705172,
-0.0619888976,
-0.0011692924,
-0.0070846593,
-0.0408012569,
0.0071075424,
-0.0213811342,
0.0298093241,
-0.0069355322,
-0.0187990107,
0.0037584309,
0.027125366,
0.001653546,
0.0510458574,
-0.0323939584,
0.0003755626,
-0.0017114754,
-0.0038610508,
0.0076461351,
-0.0181553904,
-0.0112029137,
-0.0142690176,
0.0311926641,
0.030216774,
-0.0478039905,
-0.0613837615,
-0.0037129752,
-0.0597940758,
0.0017462492,
-0.0196610633,
0.0035465092,
-0.0010184225,
-0.0044434532,
-0.0087105474,
0.0100737195,
-0.0281515662,
-0.0528783053,
0.0039677811,
-0.0464928858,
-0.0297552645,
0.0085102702,
-0.0214661229,
0.089025788,
-0.019882137,
-0.056038782,
0.0143025322,
-0.0662309453,
-0.0132195763,
0.023018999,
0.0250237081,
0.0189856589,
-0.0490810461,
0.03796288,
-0.0842703208,
-0.0538627654,
0.0184958484,
0.1469365805,
0.0129862418,
-0.003523573,
-0.0321450457,
-0.0033707051,
0.0554016121,
-0.0447697155,
-0.0137445806,
0.0127441538,
0.0935602114,
0.0108591188,
0.0334751196,
-0.0205921978,
-0.0379888117,
0.0063280747,
-0.0172118694,
0.0237316862,
-0.0174328368,
0.0215551239,
0.0146854399,
-0.013357739,
-0.0019383503,
-0.0186579432,
0.0019069744,
-0.0308182351,
-0.0421720333,
-0.047505457,
-0.0015378582,
-0.0363183543,
0.0022555131,
0.0491416752,
0.0286725648,
0.0349162892,
0.0302302819,
0.0243134741,
-0.0038438807,
0.0248346906,
0.0478777438,
0.0274692141,
-0.0254396014,
0.0563447066,
-0.0852998942,
-0.0168561041,
-0.022996515,
0.0196027812,
0.0787365213,
-0.015542658,
0.0289102346,
-0.0637461767,
-0.0963201523,
-0.0478446148,
0.0124547249,
-0.045224756,
0.0161850583,
0.0343051888,
0.0574776456,
-0.0295516849,
0.0003483458,
0.0129485698,
-0.0569409765,
0.0125454441,
0.0220364481,
-0.0490897186,
0.0724383965,
0.0063273017,
0.0036921075,
-0.0532893911,
-0.0322399065,
0.0076237987,
-0.0486020558,
0.0137055507,
0.0052173673,
-0.0544821434,
-0.0348925553,
-0.0165435057,
-0.0481414385,
-0.0245559346,
-0.0587041825,
-0.0036948642,
-0.006291287,
0.0169658214,
-0.0358921699,
-0.0968062654,
-0.0007631873,
0.0238159876,
-0.0431069396,
0.0287798643,
-0.0038074506,
0.084514901,
-0.0284075327,
-0.0489213541,
-0.0098649142,
-0.0125473188,
-0.0332490355,
-0.0144951055,
0.094335705,
0.0052762148,
0.0138845677,
-0.0295978244,
0.0124175688,
0.0251644794,
-0.0247673485,
0.0252309497,
0.0133128054,
0.0309453625,
0.0200066473,
0.0250241682,
0.0151581196,
0.0734773502,
-0.0177616794,
-0.0190492868,
0.0085784439,
0.0054616039,
-0.0483907983,
0.046295274,
0.0190635826,
-0.0302050114,
0.0392520577,
-0.0157379191,
-0.0806401893,
-0.0704666227,
-0.0499925353,
-0.0225334503,
0.0787707716,
0.0558599047,
0.0094265565,
0.0331962518,
-0.0260935277,
-0.0507998765,
-0.0139829423,
-0.0055796984,
-0.0166130923,
0.0349331647,
0.0043282192,
0.0491467044,
-0.0026973167,
-0.016964158,
0.002835935,
0.0387553722,
-0.0415870398,
0.0289933868,
-0.0015629806,
0.0251961965,
0.029302299,
-0.0276057534,
-0.0300661419,
0.040598426,
0.0068517858,
-0.0200568903,
0.0083287908,
-0.0246355217,
0.0635768473,
-0.0086578634,
0.00038035,
-0.035910625,
0.0282286108,
-0.0255701654,
-0.0485900566,
-0.0246195942,
0.0131204054,
-0.0337043703,
0.0021967161,
0.0486480445,
-0.0473556705,
-0.0002229352,
-0.0065554227,
-0.0095143309,
0.0197924078,
0.0030278906,
0.0334250294,
-0.0345841646,
0.0162563175,
-0.0261473823,
-0.0554152839,
0.0534440354,
-0.0137578342,
0.049462717,
-0.0594188459,
0.0122487471,
0.0569034107,
0.0649541691,
0.0009450682,
0.0089661758,
-0.0223818645,
0.0273375083,
0.0249004178,
0.0793787986,
-0.036217235,
-0.0383216888,
0.0043538818,
-0.0366010703,
-0.0490056351,
-0.037593361,
-0.0598258637,
-0.0000265176,
0.0362375006,
-0.0117845377,
0.0397271216,
-0.0294423588,
0.0661099404,
0.0082053877,
-0.024598496,
0.0228153057,
-0.0015687109,
0.0171444248,
-0.037075188,
-0.0072430223,
0.0132691199,
-0.024250241,
0.069869861,
-0.0385842845,
0.0005214026,
0.0256481711,
0.0602429993,
-0.0516175553,
-0.0208542049,
0.0149697205,
0.0201033019,
-0.0230999775,
-0.0158218537,
-0.0041536447,
-0.0664577335,
-0.0066872663,
-0.0169686899,
0.0133325709,
-0.0381318629,
0.0168242902,
-0.0038724202,
0.0147327557,
0.0266175196,
-0.0302128941,
-0.0588219203,
0.0471303836,
-0.1471533179,
-0.0311244875,
0.0010320242,
-5.874101759e-33,
0.0147966035,
-0.0547721162,
0.0420462638,
-0.0016551663,
-0.0314439908,
-0.0467905514,
0.010943695,
-0.0069084424,
-0.0398361497,
-0.0084278863,
-0.0260155872,
-0.0348033756,
0.0181115977,
-0.0417716391,
-0.0216054339,
0.0010310692,
-0.0171181764,
0.0281669013,
-0.0119089978,
-0.0171874948,
0.0409288034,
-0.0172569733,
0.076366432,
-0.0874282494,
0.0383785255,
-0.0066709672,
-0.0236281734,
-0.0116434125,
0.1176823154,
0.0248859897,
-0.020143427,
-0.0180080924,
0.004621462,
-0.0199835524,
0.0368130617,
-0.0093943644,
-0.0679851323,
-0.0161182173,
0.019361157,
0.0397983342,
0.0872881114,
-0.0410667956,
0.0425403193,
0.0122781554,
0.0021558029,
0.0345980562,
0.0442378931,
0.0192389674,
-0.0669060871,
0.0322624147,
-0.0307170618,
-0.0032152203,
-0.0178067163,
0.0392824821,
0.0325360037,
0.0255874265,
0.0290038381,
-0.0431593172,
-0.0801891014,
0.0272573084,
0.0468755811,
0.0007240924,
0.0211792327,
-0.0527540632,
0.010563774,
0.0318569392,
0.0040636659,
0.0224902313,
-0.0672060326,
-0.0079311905,
0.0446993224,
-0.0082987826,
-0.0312986597,
0.0638510436,
-0.0154615641,
-0.030620046,
-0.0461017713,
0.0356971137,
-0.0338843055,
-0.000579647,
-0.00624375,
-0.0289588384,
-0.0571949966,
-0.0294879153,
-0.0097208321,
-0.046571549,
-0.0005503976,
-0.0279842597,
0.0065016197,
-0.0326648727,
-0.0486485586,
0.0509826168,
-0.0299462527,
-0.0458063371,
-0.104140453,
0.0363979526,
-0.0291065071,
0.0034786463,
-0.0336219519,
-0.0212681461,
-0.0201789215,
-0.0224990454,
-0.0261277258,
0.0589838326,
0.0105052982,
0.0415234379,
-0.0169558283,
0.0250942521,
-0.0318352543,
-0.0073773963,
0.0277332123,
-0.0291579328,
-0.01956545,
-0.0614839047,
0.0406847522,
-0.0120932441,
0.0322134048,
-0.0471519455,
0.0723896474,
0.0221413635,
0.0216613673,
-0.0412159301,
0.0110309348,
0.0180715844,
-0.0047274195,
0.003520122,
0.0152403796,
0.0559026934,
0.0251238886,
0.0254176054,
0.0127194487,
-0.0419657826,
2.601e-7,
0.0385088995,
0.0674271733,
-0.0087180939,
-0.0210227612,
-0.0136908665,
-0.0267266445,
0.0370424576,
0.0109229293,
-0.0411059186,
-0.0101825222,
0.0536074601,
-0.0057618967,
-0.0115442593,
0.0871026367,
-0.1131827086,
-0.0186802279,
0.0115247387,
0.0079361591,
-0.0763972774,
0.0009274062,
0.0263580158,
0.0192267466,
0.0146960113,
-0.0053009177,
-0.0093065351,
-0.0185666792,
-0.0222727712,
-0.072269462,
0.0070476197,
-0.0064697675,
0.0548385233,
0.0060317181,
0.0169896241,
-0.0230409596,
-0.0112977456,
-0.0020612541,
0.0071677663,
0.0057373447,
0.0056663761,
0.0129411723,
-0.0253876373,
-0.0389390588,
0.0087549621,
-0.0838002115,
0.0513436608,
-0.0045106472,
-0.0284794606,
0.0575672761,
-0.0104216058,
0.0252963323,
0.0207780991,
-0.007019416,
-0.01801374,
0.0059376745,
0.002756886,
0.0196053106,
0.0217520762,
-0.0269604623,
0.0023656485,
0.0308504831,
0.0146281412,
-0.0199183021,
-0.0261820238,
-0.0129289236,
-0.0333978795,
0.0143502587,
0.0313260145,
1.82551311e-34,
-0.0224836711,
-0.0251316465,
-0.0698371157,
-0.0062403642,
0.011105773,
-0.0026393086,
0.0070715994,
0.0290585924,
0.0173150208,
-0.0169268008,
0.0039116722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17901v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17901v1 | Script-Agnostic Language Identification | 2024-06-25T19:23:42 | 2024-06-25T19:23:42 | Milind Agarwal, Joshua Otten, Antonios Anastasopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language identification is used as the first step in many data collection and
crawling efforts because it allows us to sort online text into
language-specific buckets. However, many modern languages, such as Konkani,
Kashmiri, Punjabi etc., are synchronically written in several scripts.
Moreover, languages with different writing systems do not share significant
lexical, semantic, and syntactic properties in neural representation spaces,
which is a disadvantage for closely related languages and low-resource
languages, especially those from the Indian Subcontinent. To counter this, we
propose learning script-agnostic representations using several different
experimental strategies (upscaling, flattening, and script mixing) focusing on
four major Dravidian languages (Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, and Malayalam). We find
that word-level script randomization and exposure to a language written in
multiple scripts is extremely valuable for downstream script-agnostic language
identification, while also maintaining competitive performance on naturally
occurring text. | Script-Agnostic Language Identification: Language identification is used as the first step in many data collection and
crawling efforts because it allows us to sort online text into
language-specific buckets. However, many modern languages, such as Konkani,
Kashmiri, Punjabi etc., are synchronically written in several scripts.
Moreover, languages with different writing systems do not share significant
lexical, semantic, and syntactic properties in neural representation spaces,
which is a disadvantage for closely related languages and low-resource
languages, especially those from the Indian Subcontinent. To counter this, we
propose learning script-agnostic representations using several different
experimental strategies (upscaling, flattening, and script mixing) focusing on
four major Dravidian languages (Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, and Malayalam). We find
that word-level script randomization and exposure to a language written in
multiple scripts is extremely valuable for downstream script-agnostic language
identification, while also maintaining competitive performance on naturally
occurring text. | [
0.0125886453,
0.067239292,
-0.0227795485,
0.0449290834,
-0.0620191097,
0.029164087,
0.0140951779,
0.0629899651,
0.0490732193,
-0.0039109327,
-0.0120156994,
-0.0493550189,
0.0245351642,
0.0436066948,
0.0406960137,
-0.0015852863,
0.0034534694,
0.0008126332,
0.0183574744,
0.0246229246,
0.0109805735,
0.0269646943,
-0.0132283382,
-0.003853878,
-0.0284003168,
-0.0074507133,
-0.0072533982,
0.0229743347,
-0.00444867,
0.0073311175,
-0.0147718629,
0.0498419814,
0.0425235294,
0.1029859558,
0.0000012312,
-0.0325564854,
-0.0100996941,
-0.0392885171,
-0.0054197386,
0.0013721721,
0.0732858628,
-0.0153160663,
0.0149607286,
0.0199781954,
0.0006500728,
-0.0094710896,
0.1021235734,
-0.0155164227,
-0.0164624173,
0.0818453357,
-0.0257604495,
-0.0197753217,
-0.027942149,
-0.0122807166,
-0.0100325905,
0.0231912397,
0.0065927166,
-0.0226198826,
0.0051273634,
-0.0437050462,
-0.0383498557,
0.0077328859,
-0.025273094,
-0.0140751218,
0.0002871189,
0.0153226051,
-0.0233234297,
-0.0056639398,
0.0679637566,
0.0404772051,
-0.0692716017,
-0.0597712025,
-0.0007605918,
-0.0132549284,
-0.0539945923,
-0.0087085739,
-0.0270952415,
0.0269849468,
-0.0480221659,
0.0727126822,
0.0407132804,
0.0261740871,
0.0345058218,
-0.0049301041,
0.04141175,
0.0293280482,
0.0188029353,
0.0010407275,
-0.0575477071,
0.031677831,
0.0338158235,
-0.0314829051,
0.0119115124,
-0.0007612474,
0.0139245214,
0.0095193675,
-0.0046304069,
-0.0544311814,
0.0099593196,
-0.0011075559,
0.0788964704,
0.0624227114,
-0.0321396515,
0.0126980487,
-0.0545312688,
0.0517836213,
-0.0097895162,
0.0264044311,
0.0120593095,
0.0233868659,
0.0526572689,
-0.0402096026,
0.023409402,
-0.0143657755,
-0.0192069188,
0.039360635,
0.0103154788,
0.0266110897,
0.0178749505,
-0.027475819,
-0.0170620978,
-0.0547167622,
-0.0443883613,
-0.0019582175,
0.0205089599,
0.0085579995,
-0.0177947599,
0.0326403752,
-0.0007154312,
-0.0949488878,
-0.0455739386,
0.0700245798,
0.0084040239,
0.0183015652,
-0.0095763365,
0.073838599,
-0.0622387305,
-0.0553084463,
-0.054544013,
0.0442409478,
0.004783723,
-0.0270234477,
0.0196326934,
-0.078990601,
0.0674337372,
0.0206218362,
-0.0015740504,
-0.0580365956,
-0.0002824913,
0.0146006411,
-0.005144624,
0.0452376939,
0.0392708033,
-0.0193245057,
0.0349397473,
0.006793844,
0.0578518026,
0.0447941236,
0.0020450221,
0.0229275394,
0.0292237569,
-0.0220732521,
0.0193672646,
0.0321778655,
-0.0323271379,
0.0290421862,
-0.0319843665,
-0.0238261186,
0.0562519431,
0.011646294,
0.0133335628,
0.0161667708,
0.0061927182,
-0.0119760809,
0.0080542043,
0.0324864872,
-0.02353031,
0.0100447657,
0.0053563998,
0.0080310088,
0.0085065588,
0.062724404,
0.0008423689,
0.0197889283,
0.0203377437,
-0.0090489844,
0.0379526988,
0.0109273344,
-0.0370943062,
0.0334450938,
-0.0209477525,
-0.0403849781,
0.0400950834,
-0.035492748,
0.0550198741,
0.0295486487,
-0.0331372619,
-0.0527220145,
0.0991255641,
-0.0387763977,
0.0560318232,
-0.0353690386,
0.0358996801,
0.0088664955,
0.0226339791,
-0.0548192076,
0.0203988552,
0.0190687031,
-0.0012176617,
0.1026594713,
-0.0360881351,
-0.0162038058,
0.0489048362,
-0.0384153239,
0.0308883078,
0.0372761525,
-0.0039711567,
0.0471615121,
-0.0209438726,
0.0108852275,
0.0024058474,
-0.0310501363,
-0.0214997996,
0.0490767807,
-0.0584775433,
-0.025090564,
0.0199835114,
0.0063149198,
0.0308894366,
-0.0308721084,
-0.042041678,
-0.0164709035,
-0.0075554494,
-0.0399095044,
-0.001932657,
-0.0080369217,
-0.0222822819,
-0.039676372,
-0.0013003867,
-0.0448628627,
0.0140312184,
0.0454208925,
-0.008663971,
-0.0515925065,
0.0395992622,
-0.0199877433,
0.0376842059,
-0.0249026548,
0.0261729695,
-0.053867057,
-0.0173484217,
-0.0474234261,
0.0477898307,
0.0213089865,
0.0348855369,
-0.0076852725,
-0.032506682,
0.072865583,
-0.0432591215,
-0.0207194425,
0.0128405103,
-0.0054746023,
0.0369865373,
0.0023645307,
-0.0172674526,
-0.0241759829,
-0.0587257631,
-0.0695287362,
-0.0501834005,
-0.0232703276,
0.0107287187,
-0.0072302371,
0.0246492233,
0.0102128917,
-0.0492005534,
-0.0490580052,
-0.0135029769,
0.0677396208,
0.0221393332,
0.0341019332,
-0.0206549931,
0.024285648,
-0.0100108199,
-0.066143468,
-0.0355167761,
0.0946159959,
0.0002387664,
-0.0343078896,
-0.0571352653,
-0.006108765,
-0.0332007334,
-0.003626494,
-0.0283444654,
-0.0466762036,
-0.0109792473,
-0.0282426625,
-0.0117539,
0.0554016083,
-0.018361954,
-0.0392575487,
0.0449764803,
0.0001076681,
0.0223622024,
-0.0670181662,
0.0030484335,
0.0166049991,
-0.0043469192,
-0.0363676734,
-0.0186209995,
0.049331028,
0.0060269325,
0.0056485892,
-0.0424250551,
-0.0404495522,
-0.019143546,
0.0464418791,
-0.0065083755,
0.0146071957,
-0.0437029786,
0.0569423102,
-0.0157252327,
-0.0629601777,
0.0817690194,
-0.0380897075,
-0.0230077934,
-0.0670572966,
0.0029951229,
-0.0250931643,
-0.0126290191,
0.0331466645,
0.0175338835,
-0.0486597456,
-0.0540277362,
-0.0688586906,
0.0414323807,
0.0204459261,
-0.0155305183,
0.0331437401,
-0.0093907621,
0.0199460667,
-0.0443044528,
-0.0482109524,
-0.0390185155,
-0.0922212303,
0.0376261435,
0.0134799378,
0.0226883423,
-0.0413681231,
0.0156810433,
0.0323665291,
0.0072314036,
0.0655715466,
-0.0041611046,
0.0243397262,
-0.0156189576,
0.0390026793,
0.0125249019,
-0.0084071476,
-0.0028447025,
0.0088886255,
0.0080662444,
-0.0235254616,
0.0567425787,
0.0005519647,
0.022350993,
0.0361059457,
0.0172313079,
-0.0162165724,
0.0016599658,
-0.0088293469,
-0.005891134,
0.0494174547,
-0.0044554751,
0.0326211452,
0.0155284209,
-0.0676728636,
-0.0100941164,
-0.0580380745,
0.0329591818,
0.0228163693,
0.0221276507,
-0.0493759289,
0.0143540641,
0.0137222707,
-0.0008715764,
0.0104319509,
-0.0202590805,
-0.0153318048,
-0.072945796,
-0.0373359285,
0.0165294334,
-0.0259289388,
-0.0282647349,
-0.0458827913,
-0.0105577894,
0.000735239,
0.0003091365,
0.0611632019,
-0.0436004512,
-0.0240248572,
0.0338652059,
-0.0067094276,
-0.0319127552,
-0.0318538919,
-0.0239808615,
-0.0193422474,
-0.0128111541,
-0.0285467114,
-0.0676928684,
-0.0008206514,
-0.0158793721,
-0.0518213995,
-0.0293450579,
0.008395073,
0.0625158176,
0.0247176439,
-0.046955619,
-0.0215620063,
0.014810265,
-0.0409174971,
-0.0369842276,
-0.0566939488,
0.041812636,
0.0095657855,
-0.0282386951,
0.0484146774,
-0.012305609,
0.0089505184,
-0.0150476201,
0.0451466516,
-0.0401926525,
0.0099980719,
-0.0335157663,
0.040899571,
0.0264292173,
-0.0260089319,
0.0524454154,
-0.0015223161,
-0.057550244,
-0.0378655083,
-0.0327422209,
0.0002937123,
0.0414094627,
0.0428466499,
0.0238572266,
0.0005928545,
-0.0429574773,
-0.0544293821,
-0.0296084881,
-0.0329998881,
0.0039043687,
-0.0402065143,
-0.0282827076,
0.0256963745,
-0.031543687,
-0.0130128004,
-0.0199981146,
-0.0759255439,
-0.0905880406,
0.0383350998,
-0.012351092,
0.0235018786,
-0.0088668326,
-0.0222469177,
-0.0505723469,
0.0460569523,
0.0011004767,
0.0002585125,
0.0319548734,
0.0057784859,
-0.0264386013,
-0.0245697033,
0.0508199595,
-0.0298759304,
-0.0154658528,
0.0248598009,
-0.0472370051,
-0.0362820104,
0.0160323046,
0.009065534,
0.0487016253,
0.0284348894,
-0.0610979423,
0.0178662799,
-0.0598132499,
-0.002447424,
0.013162503,
0.0072863181,
0.0080157919,
-0.0437251627,
0.0310699623,
0.0530420728,
-0.0022701682,
0.0522877797,
0.0211791378,
0.025537841,
0.0202150568,
0.0440109521,
0.0198973697,
0.0702780932,
0.0092705451,
0.0471519604,
-0.0148414252,
0.0534369536,
-0.0561106019,
0.0384671241,
-0.0005329076,
0.0225243494,
0.018852694,
0.0219450668,
0.0077018202,
0.0243430305,
0.0304658357,
-0.0194980409,
-0.0146533297,
-0.0211425442,
0.0451918878,
-0.0633305088,
0.0269102789,
-0.0214316193,
0.0257981643,
-0.0455319993,
0.022325756,
-0.0060305409,
-0.0238075349,
0.0157229882,
-0.0086525138,
-0.0442607775,
0.0232780371,
0.1139028445,
0.0371311791,
-0.0145842079,
0.0136444354,
0.0157420412,
-0.0150121013,
-0.0284143388,
0.0225043464,
0.037392199,
0.0328845419,
-0.0046283323,
-0.0220121406,
-0.0712033734,
-0.0045091165,
-0.0530658029,
0.0371228494,
-0.0299303569,
0.0139833838,
0.0395559967,
0.0430178195,
0.0527779944,
-0.0158261582,
0.0343219675,
0.005206279,
-0.0168541223,
-0.0123856561,
-5.115143831e-33,
0.0072113592,
0.000960681,
-0.0725122988,
0.0286535863,
0.0373505838,
0.0109591288,
-0.034744177,
0.0270650666,
-0.0214542244,
0.0032129518,
-0.0264004823,
0.0376354121,
0.0120504666,
0.0251782741,
0.0188299902,
-0.0306295622,
0.0227676667,
0.0241980888,
-0.0357562527,
0.0166768786,
0.0987806097,
-0.026010979,
0.1023292392,
-0.0351120867,
-0.0115552843,
-0.0785356238,
0.0030869152,
0.0144030452,
-0.0065239943,
0.0079973675,
-0.0453645326,
0.0310541205,
0.0399820097,
0.041968476,
-0.0160183907,
0.016738141,
-0.0185746308,
-0.014143521,
-0.0026889432,
0.0782342404,
-0.0272081215,
-0.0276482254,
0.039916385,
-0.0591168813,
-0.0383740924,
0.0167367067,
0.0101679983,
0.0278179441,
-0.022497138,
0.0110290358,
-0.0578281134,
0.0418615639,
0.0110105034,
0.0051140944,
0.0381269827,
0.0118159214,
0.0249925442,
0.0108016208,
-0.0556283332,
-0.0119500821,
-0.0667924955,
0.0590129681,
0.0387503207,
0.0468268916,
-0.057990741,
0.0497799926,
0.0047351653,
-0.0234221723,
0.0010641147,
-0.0179913305,
0.028415123,
-0.0357409194,
0.0221385267,
0.0166797098,
0.0391397327,
-0.0821524709,
-0.0360265449,
0.0104900505,
0.0711107776,
-0.0386074856,
0.0339880213,
0.0053818426,
-0.0383900106,
-0.049633041,
0.0041327295,
-0.0558024831,
-0.0294580273,
-0.0157051422,
0.0182733182,
-0.0235652551,
0.0188202858,
0.000195469,
0.0559586808,
-0.0339899138,
0.0324285477,
0.0283290464,
-0.0469285697,
0.0454745404,
0.0311330222,
-0.010280801,
-0.030076718,
-0.0503616333,
-0.013078968,
0.0032423977,
0.0130556952,
-0.0085106092,
0.0583208203,
0.005937451,
-0.0688009337,
0.0239437316,
-0.0161634218,
0.0228585843,
0.0545125157,
0.0599531606,
0.0328087285,
-0.0149806123,
0.013914872,
-0.0303982534,
0.0803074688,
0.0213413686,
0.0108609423,
0.0239775181,
-0.0414954051,
0.0160205886,
-0.0198727399,
0.0025496532,
-0.0430019088,
0.0245893858,
0.0169374123,
-0.014024864,
0.0211329758,
0.0207031649,
2.087e-7,
-0.0119504994,
0.0060001854,
0.0531806387,
-0.0384884402,
0.0300149769,
0.0135239381,
-0.0543212369,
0.0256321114,
-0.0396243632,
-0.0099389292,
-0.0437944271,
0.0056870896,
0.0790551156,
0.0297347568,
-0.0763279274,
0.0271252487,
-0.1026995853,
0.0264312439,
-0.0254849754,
-0.0311947744,
-0.051202938,
0.0958590955,
0.0157014579,
-0.0169883482,
-0.010940847,
-0.0537552536,
0.0616714358,
0.0097793322,
0.0227393638,
0.0084333066,
-0.0503843315,
-0.0248887613,
-0.0220720507,
-0.003193455,
-0.0233953167,
-0.0081735794,
0.0472459719,
0.033080738,
-0.0342856459,
0.0478722714,
0.0120694479,
0.0100179436,
-0.0134295393,
-0.0425028391,
0.0264015589,
0.0836032778,
-0.0672332719,
-0.007403519,
0.0200614352,
0.0016941606,
0.0493345372,
0.0189028811,
-0.0310375839,
0.0337487496,
0.0169260669,
-0.0334165618,
-0.0072156214,
-0.0232915115,
-0.0545862429,
0.0317225605,
-0.0385108814,
-0.0414337441,
-0.005131003,
-0.0049638059,
0.0700995922,
-0.0286115352,
0.0265639089,
1.95660851e-34,
0.0096403193,
0.0131272767,
0.0046610651,
0.0039756345,
0.0133946883,
-0.0218465962,
-0.0047543249,
0.0285217557,
0.0243552439,
-0.0762094483,
-0.0015471175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17888v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17888v1 | CTBench: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Evaluating Language Model Capabilities in Clinical Trial Design | 2024-06-25T18:52:48 | 2024-06-25T18:52:48 | Nafis Neehal, Bowen Wang, Shayom Debopadhaya, Soham Dan, Keerthiram Murugesan, Vibha Anand, Kristin P. Bennett | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | CTBench is introduced as a benchmark to assess language models (LMs) in
aiding clinical study design. Given study-specific metadata, CTBench evaluates
AI models' ability to determine the baseline features of a clinical trial (CT),
which include demographic and relevant features collected at the trial's start
from all participants. These baseline features, typically presented in CT
publications (often as Table 1), are crucial for characterizing study cohorts
and validating results. Baseline features, including confounders and
covariates, are also necessary for accurate treatment effect estimation in
studies involving observational data. CTBench consists of two datasets:
"CT-Repo," containing baseline features from 1,690 clinical trials sourced from
clinicaltrials.gov, and "CT-Pub," a subset of 100 trials with more
comprehensive baseline features gathered from relevant publications. Two
LM-based evaluation methods are developed to compare the actual baseline
feature lists against LM-generated responses. "ListMatch-LM" and
"ListMatch-BERT" use GPT-4o and BERT scores (at various thresholds),
respectively, for evaluation. To establish baseline results, advanced prompt
engineering techniques using LLaMa3-70B-Instruct and GPT-4o in zero-shot and
three-shot learning settings are applied to generate potential baseline
features. The performance of GPT-4o as an evaluator is validated through
human-in-the-loop evaluations on the CT-Pub dataset, where clinical experts
confirm matches between actual and LM-generated features. The results highlight
a promising direction with significant potential for improvement, positioning
CTBench as a useful tool for advancing research on AI in CT design and
potentially enhancing the efficacy and robustness of CTs. | CTBench: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Evaluating Language Model Capabilities in Clinical Trial Design: CTBench is introduced as a benchmark to assess language models (LMs) in
aiding clinical study design. Given study-specific metadata, CTBench evaluates
AI models' ability to determine the baseline features of a clinical trial (CT),
which include demographic and relevant features collected at the trial's start
from all participants. These baseline features, typically presented in CT
publications (often as Table 1), are crucial for characterizing study cohorts
and validating results. Baseline features, including confounders and
covariates, are also necessary for accurate treatment effect estimation in
studies involving observational data. CTBench consists of two datasets:
"CT-Repo," containing baseline features from 1,690 clinical trials sourced from
clinicaltrials.gov, and "CT-Pub," a subset of 100 trials with more
comprehensive baseline features gathered from relevant publications. Two
LM-based evaluation methods are developed to compare the actual baseline
feature lists against LM-generated responses. "ListMatch-LM" and
"ListMatch-BERT" use GPT-4o and BERT scores (at various thresholds),
respectively, for evaluation. To establish baseline results, advanced prompt
engineering techniques using LLaMa3-70B-Instruct and GPT-4o in zero-shot and
three-shot learning settings are applied to generate potential baseline
features. The performance of GPT-4o as an evaluator is validated through
human-in-the-loop evaluations on the CT-Pub dataset, where clinical experts
confirm matches between actual and LM-generated features. The results highlight
a promising direction with significant potential for improvement, positioning
CTBench as a useful tool for advancing research on AI in CT design and
potentially enhancing the efficacy and robustness of CTs. | [
0.0341914967,
0.0756905377,
-0.0192269739,
-0.0242245998,
-0.0243775304,
0.0208011065,
0.071753785,
0.0120807076,
-0.011140896,
0.0038926164,
-0.0147846732,
-0.0505289957,
-0.0056777154,
0.0771829039,
0.0144705046,
-0.0309538767,
0.0131591083,
0.0019572678,
0.0563207082,
0.0140008926,
-0.0389234349,
0.0025511163,
-0.0222866684,
0.0511494279,
0.0047053206,
-0.0197427701,
0.0430521443,
-0.0079397177,
-0.0176839568,
-0.0628404841,
0.0042569963,
0.0680394247,
-0.0148774376,
0.0306352973,
0.0000022159,
-0.0905337185,
-0.0238326192,
0.0547323637,
-0.0360464752,
-0.0155102508,
0.0427501835,
-0.0020905447,
0.0230113957,
0.0073267017,
-0.0024875994,
0.0003001198,
0.054423105,
0.0217079353,
0.0090541271,
0.0622982308,
-0.0286918804,
0.0118649285,
0.0317558646,
-0.0489570573,
0.0172999706,
-0.0188161898,
0.0177911948,
-0.0292122439,
0.0303079672,
-0.0133354422,
0.0137721039,
0.0201764591,
0.0203935672,
0.0151913585,
0.0276607331,
0.0364012495,
-0.0563330501,
-0.0421245173,
-0.0049047717,
0.0363325216,
0.038207233,
0.0253060348,
-0.003829458,
-0.0277357064,
0.0505188182,
-0.003145199,
-0.0419027582,
-0.0174984876,
-0.0268248674,
-0.0285738278,
0.0098455567,
-0.0230919383,
0.0008203477,
-0.037046209,
-0.0042560156,
0.0300340001,
0.0061176876,
-0.0091308663,
0.0297157448,
0.0128258131,
-0.0010675407,
-0.0330138579,
-0.0131121157,
0.0064102965,
-0.0487550497,
0.0058370708,
0.0343899578,
-0.044862479,
0.0949405432,
-0.0560828857,
0.0462405197,
0.0061939424,
-0.0482289158,
0.0035554781,
-0.0240444802,
0.0763537362,
0.0032353913,
0.0477878526,
-0.0383026972,
0.0480201356,
-0.0162976403,
0.0065170415,
-0.0124134906,
0.0227757208,
0.0028059569,
0.0062274965,
-0.0632433221,
0.0036531377,
-0.0039785253,
-0.0005793672,
0.0035000546,
0.0110396361,
-0.0352547467,
0.0295529347,
0.0077498937,
-0.0174645502,
-0.0123401731,
0.0293434914,
-0.0030779187,
-0.0987271816,
0.0205086004,
-0.0103252809,
-0.0103519494,
-0.0558442585,
0.0313966833,
0.0536379144,
0.0111975381,
-0.0169239715,
0.0030645821,
-0.0054606623,
-0.0385302752,
-0.0598364659,
0.0032766187,
-0.0941651762,
0.0411215946,
0.0087011326,
0.0120143993,
-0.0554232858,
-0.0360451825,
-0.0061836513,
-0.0432339795,
0.0336932056,
-0.0424055606,
-0.0084495079,
0.0114945751,
-0.0022808809,
-0.0268960688,
0.035697937,
0.0466952547,
0.005648735,
-0.0059435768,
-0.0248402562,
-0.0083718942,
0.0142145166,
0.041222319,
-0.0077486564,
-0.03009299,
0.0128193153,
0.0270324573,
0.0557815209,
-0.0480367765,
0.0299959555,
-0.0050452584,
0.0108647598,
0.0432560667,
0.0455508232,
0.03560929,
0.0631712005,
0.0012603491,
-0.0749338418,
0.0159760732,
-0.0269900765,
-0.027579397,
-0.0030422898,
-0.025535496,
-0.0154132126,
-0.0021778704,
0.0109326551,
-0.0270922203,
-0.0367941819,
-0.0276353396,
-0.0144672329,
-0.0062330407,
-0.0064842738,
0.0297724307,
-0.0417864509,
-0.0237118863,
-0.0400949605,
0.0065094866,
-0.0044937069,
-0.0495747738,
-0.0618125126,
-0.0302423518,
0.0464180484,
0.0348661281,
-0.0353996381,
-0.0229005888,
-0.0335837901,
0.0123057272,
-0.0015011732,
0.0361298583,
0.0177206341,
0.0314262845,
0.0202323701,
-0.028100865,
-0.0118231485,
0.0136341397,
0.0170880277,
-0.0206420012,
0.010192913,
-0.0473299511,
-0.0436324067,
-0.04885244,
0.0602572188,
-0.0547512844,
-0.0503049195,
0.0188190602,
-0.0303502902,
0.0491724014,
0.0043440433,
-0.0307607986,
0.0343801975,
0.0035605102,
-0.0275609996,
-0.0110013047,
-0.0094609959,
0.0293559674,
-0.0431033634,
0.007804581,
-0.034734305,
0.0088998629,
-0.0080179032,
-0.042045936,
0.0050070123,
0.0173088964,
-0.0336006545,
0.0147885559,
0.0298131146,
0.0308394786,
-0.0187671576,
0.0235275701,
-0.0579841919,
0.0207700748,
-0.0038989279,
-0.0069883345,
0.0399638675,
-0.0732381791,
0.0248551872,
-0.0382074118,
-0.0442322828,
0.031096885,
-0.0200937819,
-0.0193506461,
-0.0019814519,
0.0258230381,
-0.0257091075,
-0.0356350578,
-0.1033574566,
0.0326191038,
0.0189346671,
0.0266638231,
-0.0135425786,
-0.0200984795,
-0.0184533857,
-0.0165172145,
-0.0323646143,
-0.030847881,
0.0327148549,
0.0482349694,
0.0201402847,
0.0525330417,
-0.0573512018,
-0.0796044022,
-0.0320135057,
-0.0595776066,
0.064618215,
0.0512916967,
-0.0407880098,
0.0396053344,
0.0088945776,
-0.0085240211,
-0.0060056681,
0.0080750724,
-0.001019582,
0.034435153,
0.0176458508,
0.014769149,
0.0623742789,
-0.02800004,
-0.0043082237,
0.0431654193,
-0.0137036201,
-0.0313624255,
0.0013860653,
-0.0262916125,
-0.0636612326,
0.0123758065,
-0.0741388574,
0.0274786223,
0.0729548559,
0.0199269522,
0.0152566889,
-0.0522183888,
-0.008197221,
0.0128726382,
-0.0090255188,
-0.0529496297,
-0.0030896943,
-0.0472121201,
0.0384674482,
-0.0346123725,
-0.0808364674,
0.1035536975,
0.0002450657,
0.0443494432,
-0.0628963336,
0.0452455729,
-0.0374187529,
-0.020195879,
0.0119232051,
-0.0068483148,
0.0525164306,
0.0165330805,
0.0103894742,
-0.0143350372,
0.0101523744,
-0.036706306,
0.0631595477,
-0.0483478606,
0.0450502709,
0.0173866525,
-0.0202427488,
-0.0305760633,
-0.0182378609,
-0.0105839316,
0.0193493143,
0.0193896759,
0.0352931246,
-0.0223300364,
-0.0052200472,
-0.0123137636,
0.0463409163,
-0.0271056239,
-0.0006254901,
0.0224355962,
-0.0466905981,
0.0311738905,
-0.0229706317,
0.0305348299,
-0.033381097,
0.0521252416,
0.0001658151,
0.009361051,
0.0280123502,
-0.0325393826,
0.0652260631,
0.0034656103,
-0.0252065212,
-0.0288178697,
0.0579075031,
0.0233681742,
-0.0258229151,
0.0118532041,
0.1106526181,
0.0211081784,
-0.0722102076,
-0.0091026407,
-0.0147434669,
0.0187582504,
-0.0165532138,
0.0035468573,
-0.0455975346,
0.0014794369,
-0.0020367943,
0.0541228242,
-0.043660298,
-0.0300530717,
-0.0132447788,
-0.0304994583,
0.0319438651,
0.0041996245,
-0.0770604685,
0.0154073006,
-0.0690118223,
0.0185477659,
-0.0430560485,
-0.0254639834,
0.0014483858,
0.022851998,
-0.0220092125,
0.0217810851,
-0.088997595,
-0.0824803934,
0.0368411168,
-0.0273499768,
0.0878796354,
0.0671746507,
0.0049946653,
-0.0139297023,
0.0031669752,
0.0173491612,
-0.005021669,
-0.0077113737,
-0.0068503167,
0.095652245,
0.0318542235,
0.0342151821,
-0.0309072621,
0.0406908393,
-0.0361609943,
-0.0067142751,
-0.0064736982,
0.0983502716,
-0.0457407385,
-0.0156071009,
-0.0203657392,
0.009038222,
0.0162936635,
0.0409341715,
0.0449333228,
-0.0157973506,
-0.0042780936,
-0.0232685208,
0.0228318833,
-0.0398058556,
0.0068755383,
0.0124187581,
-0.0370259546,
-0.0190034024,
-0.0379893109,
-0.0461801849,
0.0565834381,
-0.0489615612,
0.0035964937,
0.0442168191,
-0.0349595509,
-0.0220090486,
-0.0182007216,
0.0687083304,
0.0355310962,
0.032162603,
-0.0726945847,
-0.0313823298,
-0.0002444135,
-0.021236835,
-0.0050863149,
0.0458461866,
-0.034527909,
-0.0271770805,
0.0031926865,
0.0754669011,
0.0202781204,
-0.0232528225,
0.0082981726,
-0.0212221332,
0.0406701975,
-0.0089315558,
0.0307356194,
-0.0398689136,
-0.0317638628,
-0.0282075629,
-0.0156782642,
-0.0207754001,
-0.0307490397,
0.0322595835,
-0.0083072521,
0.0089117279,
0.0106616495,
-0.0222781599,
0.0553137995,
0.061606463,
0.0532696433,
-0.0310325529,
-0.0064472319,
-0.0322667398,
-0.0078242412,
-0.0256713685,
0.035822317,
-0.0238614827,
-0.0051272572,
0.0242600385,
0.0027544834,
-0.0289360713,
-0.0301052853,
-0.1251944304,
-0.0110877492,
-0.0684926286,
0.0980833396,
-0.0006627684,
0.0376045592,
0.0399936996,
0.018071657,
0.0076282988,
0.011138849,
-0.019030951,
0.0315917879,
-0.0078557227,
0.0305204317,
-0.0113922199,
0.0271963011,
0.010768543,
0.0648810193,
-0.021385204,
-0.0287875608,
-0.0435417369,
-0.0156445652,
0.0316375941,
0.0136683481,
0.0570890419,
-0.0133510539,
0.0152646471,
-0.0680920109,
-0.0022023045,
0.0094582932,
0.0194349606,
0.028352676,
-0.0017784167,
-0.0143052414,
-0.0773367435,
0.0899097472,
0.0396234728,
0.0210704673,
-0.0418829769,
-0.0218161959,
-0.0414394513,
-0.018263191,
0.0482946299,
-0.0211968198,
-0.0707646981,
-0.0179787204,
-0.0617100038,
-0.0257832315,
0.0307007264,
-0.0228679236,
0.0076618679,
0.0060350467,
0.0022275492,
0.0344769657,
-0.0164428987,
-0.0138578713,
-0.0118733598,
0.0118301278,
0.0066035269,
-0.0645272285,
-0.027899256,
-5.820621174e-33,
0.0115501713,
0.0046300502,
0.0075724102,
0.0002020684,
0.0010944019,
0.0118921511,
-0.0705951378,
0.0181125216,
0.0196319912,
0.0265095495,
-0.0125047518,
0.0013854422,
-0.0040022573,
-0.0028043049,
0.0154595012,
-0.0380485095,
0.0037852828,
-0.0164682698,
-0.0153617878,
0.0047536017,
-0.0681377277,
0.0169006567,
0.0490210839,
-0.0585143417,
0.0531467162,
0.0374943949,
-0.0050116456,
-0.0219606087,
-0.0304576457,
0.0720743462,
-0.0030662012,
0.0411762521,
0.0460860841,
-0.0267426763,
0.0033619057,
-0.0155361444,
-0.02168715,
-0.032202106,
0.0178320967,
-0.0229581315,
-0.0005361686,
-0.0260038152,
0.0421955995,
0.0039652786,
-0.0464433208,
0.0124372886,
0.0225448422,
-0.0490762144,
0.0063230665,
0.0048472136,
-0.021338569,
0.0274428148,
-0.0438211262,
-0.023503812,
-0.0026953544,
0.0582641549,
-0.0181511007,
0.0356329083,
-0.0133104827,
0.0239277612,
0.0548642986,
-0.0259485506,
0.0250193365,
-0.0012587289,
0.0035307196,
0.0324470624,
0.0132546704,
0.0109170359,
-0.0130642941,
-0.002840274,
0.0086344127,
0.0498254523,
0.0836992487,
0.0226289686,
0.0235914364,
0.0013618227,
-0.0898219571,
0.0507240109,
-0.0288616251,
0.0028742375,
0.0290763266,
-0.0163115729,
-0.0204759724,
-0.0300284158,
-0.0538939647,
-0.0248083491,
-0.0490957275,
-0.0263212305,
0.0452760793,
-0.0207088962,
-0.0062280386,
-0.0313948095,
0.0726858899,
-0.00646429,
0.0061049866,
-0.0170880016,
0.0144208809,
0.0268941652,
0.0165449549,
0.0317944475,
-0.0372809507,
0.0004072503,
0.0486673042,
0.0109065715,
0.0823583901,
-0.0112431981,
0.0206915699,
-0.0301338844,
-0.0445904396,
0.0169636458,
-0.0193724148,
0.0175920576,
0.0230549704,
0.0098173264,
0.0230437834,
0.0288995728,
0.008118636,
0.0702157766,
0.0068356972,
-0.032304395,
-0.046568878,
-0.0149562489,
-0.0084647452,
0.0158194918,
-0.0119367307,
0.0160653275,
-0.0110353017,
0.0403106064,
0.0499127284,
-0.0284722131,
-0.0265627708,
-0.0185811911,
2.905e-7,
0.0890007615,
0.0616091602,
0.0047758264,
-0.0196721926,
0.0349562578,
0.0008644848,
-0.0223867074,
0.0131485285,
0.0439569205,
0.0200796481,
0.0714659914,
-0.0005165625,
0.0571873859,
0.0094717881,
-0.0191356894,
-0.0362533592,
-0.0678237006,
-0.0112518147,
-0.0610965267,
-0.0053683841,
0.0736560076,
0.0303545948,
-0.0498163179,
-0.034876518,
-0.0053779203,
0.0171405189,
-0.014794698,
-0.0751244277,
-0.0154549265,
0.0580585524,
0.0060740192,
-0.0210947096,
0.0364276804,
0.084401153,
-0.0158520173,
-0.01744074,
-0.0131283691,
0.075608246,
-0.0364637822,
0.0071738833,
0.0433897488,
-0.0026269443,
0.0240555517,
-0.0594065711,
0.0395386405,
-0.0175944455,
-0.0403839834,
-0.0094487378,
-0.0236129742,
-0.0213909447,
0.1411234885,
-0.0651970655,
0.0181204192,
0.0233953446,
0.0302589927,
0.0385865346,
-0.0156196728,
0.0250628814,
-0.0103597194,
0.056076169,
-0.0531705432,
-0.0224675201,
-0.0136587182,
-0.0198018998,
-0.0296953954,
-0.0481719561,
0.040717613,
2.906223586e-34,
0.0561637357,
-0.021447897,
0.056331981,
0.0171795003,
0.0594046079,
-0.0118416296,
0.0143289035,
0.0260344762,
-0.0143203633,
-0.0827704817,
0.0127318334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17876v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17876v1 | ET tu, CLIP? Addressing Common Object Errors for Unseen Environments | 2024-06-25T18:35:13 | 2024-06-25T18:35:13 | Ye Won Byun, Cathy Jiao, Shahriar Noroozizadeh, Jimin Sun, Rosa Vitiello | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.RO | We introduce a simple method that employs pre-trained CLIP encoders to
enhance model generalization in the ALFRED task. In contrast to previous
literature where CLIP replaces the visual encoder, we suggest using CLIP as an
additional module through an auxiliary object detection objective. We validate
our method on the recently proposed Episodic Transformer architecture and
demonstrate that incorporating CLIP improves task performance on the unseen
validation set. Additionally, our analysis results support that CLIP especially
helps with leveraging object descriptions, detecting small objects, and
interpreting rare words. | ET tu, CLIP? Addressing Common Object Errors for Unseen Environments: We introduce a simple method that employs pre-trained CLIP encoders to
enhance model generalization in the ALFRED task. In contrast to previous
literature where CLIP replaces the visual encoder, we suggest using CLIP as an
additional module through an auxiliary object detection objective. We validate
our method on the recently proposed Episodic Transformer architecture and
demonstrate that incorporating CLIP improves task performance on the unseen
validation set. Additionally, our analysis results support that CLIP especially
helps with leveraging object descriptions, detecting small objects, and
interpreting rare words. | [
-0.0058590905,
0.0476428233,
0.0302292053,
0.0426887199,
0.0322624147,
0.0193085782,
0.0040638493,
0.0016593103,
-0.0820650086,
-0.0119090481,
-0.0096782949,
-0.0144342547,
-0.0140032284,
0.0565626211,
0.0352806859,
-0.0633809417,
0.0085049588,
-0.0210157838,
0.0001233451,
0.0106850239,
0.0009321324,
-0.0275526438,
-0.0056614713,
0.0338738561,
-0.0252960417,
0.0080806799,
-0.0569069646,
0.0081202853,
0.0450532623,
-0.0182321817,
0.0072900681,
0.0079391692,
0.0105254045,
0.0236811861,
0.000001856,
-0.0130678965,
0.0088431491,
0.007912566,
-0.0175491832,
-0.0663062185,
-0.0119431373,
-0.0617702454,
0.0075719818,
0.0061128396,
0.0030647714,
-0.0523499437,
0.0553189665,
0.0779811814,
0.0334511809,
0.0650432706,
-0.030992901,
-0.0010677454,
0.0060898247,
-0.0288360976,
0.0465875342,
-0.0220884923,
0.0251954962,
-0.0503251776,
-0.0425805934,
-0.0023273213,
-0.0242542084,
0.0046989848,
0.0599753968,
0.0135478536,
0.0490401275,
0.0358971171,
-0.0653231293,
-0.0491094925,
-0.0229511037,
0.0265581217,
-0.0528272204,
0.0234084204,
-0.0352840796,
-0.0146045042,
0.0265280567,
-0.0251830462,
-0.0237568021,
0.042203296,
-0.0068549733,
-0.0015867921,
-0.0678268373,
0.0253258664,
0.006578614,
-0.0223791339,
-0.0499863625,
-0.0152908796,
0.0196616407,
-0.0135685038,
0.0294908602,
0.0634635687,
-0.0476477593,
-0.0472241007,
0.0496833511,
0.0164855085,
-0.0112444069,
-0.0305166058,
-0.0596553683,
-0.0035807127,
-0.0210541524,
-0.0131341079,
0.0617155321,
-0.0079298913,
-0.0709771439,
0.0457268842,
-0.0526038222,
0.0636739731,
-0.0222746879,
0.0294911396,
-0.0052840882,
0.0170777924,
0.0101403352,
0.0110764215,
-0.0497486405,
0.0210584421,
-0.0303634498,
-0.0294465199,
0.0191057585,
-0.0423060767,
-0.0352142826,
0.0263810214,
0.0259345397,
0.0330663137,
-0.0568426214,
-0.0226433948,
0.0077684685,
-0.0172749851,
-0.0274503436,
0.0416720994,
0.0022503219,
-0.051590234,
-0.0286099371,
0.0138182985,
0.0303374436,
-0.0127787786,
-0.0030728402,
0.0839444771,
-0.0021195333,
-0.0866383314,
0.0015845906,
0.0433670022,
-0.0251635201,
-0.0045129503,
0.0578058474,
-0.0191474482,
-0.0097709736,
-0.0309429839,
0.0191348381,
-0.0252351891,
0.0124573028,
-0.002859534,
0.0042927745,
0.0612508431,
-0.0333042145,
-0.0260289777,
-0.0110600442,
0.0261777546,
-0.0207421817,
0.0522334017,
-0.0197465215,
0.0402527861,
-0.0069753276,
0.062190555,
0.0709079579,
0.034289103,
0.0008031628,
0.0083519313,
-0.0390454903,
-0.0241714288,
-0.0431800261,
0.0081605101,
0.0621960759,
0.0368131511,
-0.0308959931,
-0.038177494,
0.0261618774,
-0.0021082887,
-0.0223617237,
0.0078949677,
0.0529969931,
0.0048593609,
-0.0116330748,
0.0167888068,
-0.0246312376,
0.0199972074,
-0.0362256616,
-0.0215242784,
-0.0315488316,
0.002290946,
-0.0581254214,
-0.0133334501,
-0.0031781935,
-0.0252492055,
-0.0218906719,
-0.0098445425,
0.0755767599,
0.0364586636,
-0.0411690734,
0.0172891356,
-0.0378673673,
-0.0254703667,
-0.0199723281,
-0.0510127209,
0.0208895896,
0.0031187946,
0.0070196833,
0.0196302421,
-0.0278711189,
0.0021681304,
-0.0113205109,
0.0580071062,
-0.0058054668,
-0.0230763294,
0.0733067319,
-0.020107612,
-0.0576668121,
-0.0345538929,
0.0163595323,
0.0096925683,
0.052583281,
0.0319007002,
0.0261359569,
-0.0435989052,
-0.0004420237,
0.0446521305,
0.0013387832,
-0.0274307709,
-0.0332363509,
0.0298142526,
-0.0031031407,
-0.0064470223,
-0.0259586424,
-0.0188950412,
0.0181481466,
-0.032627061,
-0.0048465915,
0.00660322,
-0.0538403019,
-0.0489209741,
0.0034216112,
-0.0950774178,
-0.0113066612,
0.0617239326,
-0.0192071106,
-0.0362348109,
-0.0215407945,
-0.0325594731,
0.066657044,
-0.0121923974,
0.0142734433,
-0.0128723327,
0.0322881304,
0.0277617648,
0.0285999868,
-0.0183655955,
-0.0153964153,
0.010746046,
-0.0116838217,
-0.0081713134,
-0.0314738452,
-0.0515999757,
-0.0226829778,
0.0026091922,
-0.0133998552,
0.036886476,
0.0408568308,
-0.0226585288,
0.0182930175,
-0.0532135293,
-0.0099452296,
-0.0272051841,
-0.0292480253,
-0.0036541356,
-0.0151001392,
-0.0122386953,
-0.03893473,
0.0191583075,
0.0098241344,
-0.0157290623,
-0.0002315576,
-0.018660102,
0.0099901948,
0.0097293211,
-0.004730464,
-0.0185485967,
0.0549677275,
0.0450803638,
-0.0011790167,
-0.0502041131,
-0.0322898999,
0.0617644414,
0.0073161004,
0.0144267306,
-0.0018966555,
0.0368482023,
0.0240362696,
-0.034630619,
0.0289361477,
0.0646704212,
-0.0174001716,
0.0437927879,
-0.036571987,
-0.003281673,
-0.0269860271,
-0.0128203966,
0.0231296737,
-0.0208692718,
0.0037252065,
0.0207303967,
-0.0029017152,
0.0256907605,
-0.059019018,
0.0017888409,
-0.0490911156,
0.0159839503,
-0.0181860477,
-0.0829573199,
-0.0888499618,
-0.0274018105,
0.0019773184,
0.0006411647,
-0.0564638339,
-0.0048189363,
-0.0145262135,
-0.0140391914,
-0.0073359748,
0.0170049947,
0.0255414471,
0.0166350082,
0.0325481892,
0.0460107997,
0.0044049369,
0.0163091179,
-0.0538687631,
-0.0267264713,
0.0145213483,
-0.0436406881,
-0.0034280287,
0.0236875731,
-0.0278039966,
-0.0090632271,
-0.0184907783,
-0.0151433609,
-0.0355259553,
0.0048961155,
-0.023444701,
0.0085447989,
-0.0512207486,
-0.0118332719,
-0.0622676834,
0.0187476203,
-0.0159549955,
0.0819792971,
-0.028820049,
-0.0399805717,
-0.014622476,
0.0419653468,
0.0318071693,
0.0021442131,
0.0477197394,
-0.1030852273,
0.0186024047,
0.0495556369,
-0.0148153901,
-0.0064073978,
-0.0834607258,
0.0357939079,
0.0186941978,
0.0212732069,
-0.0035931899,
0.0119337756,
0.0650519729,
-0.0496351235,
-0.0280677136,
0.0356311016,
-0.0013052524,
-0.0877301395,
-0.0333459079,
-0.0180768222,
0.003226537,
0.0442554727,
0.0183306281,
-0.0245207585,
-0.0335249305,
0.0434935763,
-0.0257158522,
0.0312873945,
0.0057078972,
0.0115036331,
-0.0776394531,
0.0506483614,
-0.0110655138,
-0.0655328929,
-0.0543326922,
0.0368545465,
0.051006183,
-0.0443152376,
0.0011979573,
-0.0004144878,
-0.0163603183,
-0.0196988713,
0.0020161683,
0.0389189906,
-0.0622370355,
-0.0433346145,
-0.0375589989,
-0.0268090107,
0.0315473191,
-0.0018599859,
-0.0177902989,
-0.0302644782,
0.0073871845,
0.0270627718,
0.0129329618,
0.0343588851,
0.0713569447,
-0.032856483,
-0.0094005894,
0.0277958531,
0.0096129188,
-0.0175246932,
-0.0512281694,
0.0047309822,
0.0170686059,
-0.0040037408,
-0.0293038506,
-0.0510948263,
-0.0245994665,
0.0369719788,
0.0415150672,
0.0301277991,
0.012784563,
-0.0160140097,
0.023425065,
0.0135611184,
-0.0445655845,
-0.0156376753,
0.0031170247,
0.0217738152,
-0.044517044,
-0.0213429686,
-0.0316404589,
0.0734134614,
0.0756184533,
0.0055776048,
-0.111306712,
-0.0213394929,
0.0101593388,
-0.0488208607,
0.0394898355,
-0.0314742178,
0.0003378661,
-0.0180479549,
0.0420456901,
0.0158523265,
0.003426742,
-0.0165355783,
0.0192644931,
-0.0529552288,
0.0082837148,
0.0175167955,
0.0778193399,
0.0219456162,
0.0463961884,
-0.0235192236,
-0.0109635144,
0.1054010689,
-0.0066004209,
0.0017995065,
0.0377751142,
0.0579068437,
-0.0978184566,
-0.0245548747,
-0.0035367014,
-0.0388954878,
0.0412898138,
-0.0065182238,
-0.0020230804,
-0.0112093175,
0.0149078239,
0.0159840174,
-0.0801366419,
0.0457225367,
-0.0189695936,
0.0568469577,
-0.0424033925,
0.0300642867,
0.041974403,
0.0397636294,
-0.0528090149,
0.0595798232,
-0.0043418128,
0.0307917893,
-0.0007000138,
0.0619124547,
0.0045667738,
-0.0176754128,
-0.0670015588,
-0.0368333273,
0.0199399982,
-0.013646639,
-0.0069349562,
0.0318190977,
0.0040634349,
0.0139202038,
-0.0039083026,
0.0492489077,
0.0044139223,
0.01705206,
0.0212405045,
0.010721378,
-0.0070471321,
0.0153060649,
0.0081552994,
-0.0154556893,
-0.09803316,
0.0710370019,
0.026124863,
-0.0481539406,
0.0345465727,
-0.0145326406,
-0.0274495129,
0.0034205229,
-0.0228923205,
0.0086614061,
-0.0568254404,
0.0125854556,
0.0053818491,
0.0192832816,
-0.0339182913,
0.0292629525,
-0.007492872,
0.0266603995,
-0.0267985668,
0.0169364363,
-0.0386014134,
-0.0078611886,
0.07202553,
-0.0274994876,
0.0149928015,
0.004182233,
0.0441332571,
-0.0448608212,
-0.0282822307,
0.0247805938,
-0.0052052764,
0.0310321394,
0.0452881195,
0.0280292667,
-0.0028674752,
-0.0218057632,
0.029950792,
-0.0370138437,
0.0147931594,
0.0407404676,
0.0227607097,
-5.687025506e-33,
-0.0575507805,
-0.0004539683,
0.0240582265,
-0.0089885741,
0.0006734058,
0.0360801965,
-0.023138864,
0.0143350344,
0.0305931345,
0.043151509,
-0.011708119,
0.0627011657,
0.0280142892,
0.0161307622,
0.0296103004,
0.0026872046,
0.0627245381,
0.0062583247,
-0.0206860881,
-0.0192591213,
-0.0052289865,
0.0520241223,
0.0905458778,
-0.018169608,
-0.0084009189,
0.0426570103,
-0.0330250859,
0.0068645314,
0.0197343808,
0.0027790042,
-0.0169251841,
-0.0318986662,
-0.0121774729,
-0.059323132,
-0.0551581308,
0.0211687256,
-0.0680046901,
-0.0163856689,
-0.0360217653,
0.0510112718,
-0.0742491856,
-0.0333923101,
0.0461363681,
0.0129175531,
0.0291972887,
-0.0059876512,
0.0342345051,
-0.0354707018,
0.0173581764,
-0.018409254,
-0.0471647047,
0.0220119338,
-0.0025996324,
-0.0148859778,
0.058975473,
0.0615088753,
0.010535419,
-0.0487548485,
-0.0309742521,
0.007977766,
0.0394008085,
0.002654732,
0.0071486994,
0.0497720055,
-0.0325419828,
0.0945792198,
0.0064183576,
-0.0613531843,
0.0011150659,
-0.0286405478,
0.0131338062,
0.039046362,
0.0068949512,
0.0084696747,
0.0704962835,
0.0388560183,
-0.0032450375,
0.0438793786,
-0.0944678858,
0.0837186798,
0.0422511101,
-0.0026906389,
0.0197724663,
0.0067578265,
0.0137579292,
-0.0105224978,
-0.0253769495,
-0.0131859677,
0.0379199907,
0.0704567805,
-0.0436133929,
0.0582429655,
0.0430394113,
-0.0128251286,
0.0573973656,
-0.0066732508,
-0.0044151889,
0.0345669612,
0.0003675766,
0.0008059255,
-0.0314287618,
-0.0319296233,
0.0603199154,
0.0516064987,
0.0151501112,
0.0095739961,
0.0724225119,
0.0688321441,
-0.0230987519,
-0.0226523578,
-0.0384717956,
0.0291059911,
0.0110370573,
0.055866491,
0.0448998511,
-0.0032474166,
-0.0321233012,
0.0414417274,
-0.055531811,
-0.0032734659,
-0.0522191823,
0.0208328534,
0.029938845,
0.0523220673,
-0.0281480812,
-0.024568554,
-0.0431197174,
-0.023776399,
0.0296762437,
-0.0793264732,
-0.0229089931,
0.011770485,
2.595e-7,
-0.0139926132,
-0.020184841,
0.0694055706,
-0.0121351723,
-0.0048574181,
-0.0037279588,
-0.015820846,
0.0446804799,
-0.0208269171,
-0.0042553302,
0.0493605137,
0.0603350215,
0.0192538444,
0.0205217749,
-0.0469459221,
-0.0162255336,
-0.0453689173,
0.0042482698,
-0.0385795645,
-0.0411135852,
0.020973647,
0.0997318253,
-0.0134474989,
-0.0248124264,
0.0346751139,
0.0110245468,
0.0674107969,
-0.0006443894,
0.0481313169,
-0.021368457,
0.0056747217,
0.1082251072,
0.0218989849,
0.0296167787,
0.0050981785,
0.019910641,
0.068611823,
0.0255072284,
-0.0258098617,
0.0025935741,
-0.0001835596,
0.086776562,
0.0053484426,
-0.0099604791,
0.0615141802,
-0.0954507291,
-0.0001007949,
-0.0359956324,
-0.0569212399,
0.0048223282,
-0.0183535665,
-0.0211498328,
0.0258202497,
-0.0041183378,
0.032482069,
0.0043481328,
-0.0502831452,
-0.0639595166,
0.0236049667,
0.0303100813,
-0.0077085863,
-0.0119372457,
-0.0480992012,
-0.0587834753,
-0.0191954896,
-0.036603,
-0.0739639774,
1.535977372e-34,
0.0070965299,
0.0293727536,
-0.0134004354,
0.0004145871,
-0.0021843766,
-0.032391984,
0.0027019351,
-0.0362819508,
-0.0321221761,
0.0145933889,
-0.0454046577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17875v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17875v1 | Cloaked Classifiers: Pseudonymization Strategies on Sensitive Classification Tasks | 2024-06-25T18:30:25 | 2024-06-25T18:30:25 | Arij Riabi, Menel Mahamdi, Virginie Mouilleron, Djamé Seddah | cs.CL | cs.CL | Protecting privacy is essential when sharing data, particularly in the case
of an online radicalization dataset that may contain personal information. In
this paper, we explore the balance between preserving data usefulness and
ensuring robust privacy safeguards, since regulations like the European GDPR
shape how personal information must be handled. We share our method for
manually pseudonymizing a multilingual radicalization dataset, ensuring
performance comparable to the original data. Furthermore, we highlight the
importance of establishing comprehensive guidelines for processing sensitive
NLP data by sharing our complete pseudonymization process, our guidelines, the
challenges we encountered as well as the resulting dataset. | Cloaked Classifiers: Pseudonymization Strategies on Sensitive Classification Tasks: Protecting privacy is essential when sharing data, particularly in the case
of an online radicalization dataset that may contain personal information. In
this paper, we explore the balance between preserving data usefulness and
ensuring robust privacy safeguards, since regulations like the European GDPR
shape how personal information must be handled. We share our method for
manually pseudonymizing a multilingual radicalization dataset, ensuring
performance comparable to the original data. Furthermore, we highlight the
importance of establishing comprehensive guidelines for processing sensitive
NLP data by sharing our complete pseudonymization process, our guidelines, the
challenges we encountered as well as the resulting dataset. | [
0.02866368,
0.0843037292,
-0.0416712053,
0.0251110867,
-0.0303871073,
0.0110882334,
0.1178310886,
0.007570155,
-0.0022109796,
0.0027941703,
0.0077896025,
-0.002199332,
-0.0090569546,
-0.0005184836,
0.0124301165,
-0.0414646529,
0.0256094504,
-0.0175567381,
-0.0316865481,
-0.0526924953,
-0.0174158514,
0.0143422717,
0.007861767,
0.0444941707,
0.0150796799,
-0.015080546,
0.0113267228,
-0.0488065779,
0.0377020352,
0.0279430728,
0.0077438094,
0.0369535498,
0.0093374643,
0.0782423466,
0.00000149,
-0.0294723064,
-0.0291775819,
0.0043807942,
-0.021119291,
-0.0483114533,
0.0406262055,
-0.0383507349,
0.025858311,
0.0079258587,
-0.0677996352,
0.0081373155,
0.0189645365,
0.0531776957,
0.0558721013,
0.051129289,
-0.0037703742,
-0.0540777408,
0.0036945322,
0.0196278468,
0.0131264376,
0.0373435207,
0.0172985867,
-0.0748507753,
-0.082316719,
0.0068248203,
0.0279814526,
0.0528869331,
-0.008635981,
0.019729726,
-0.0303486474,
0.005417672,
-0.0223093592,
-0.0091576437,
0.0402845964,
0.0244445112,
-0.0142904054,
-0.0276264735,
0.0328151844,
0.0440795161,
0.0232459754,
0.0065611312,
0.0043446324,
0.0219720956,
-0.0077710124,
0.0038344031,
0.0118336463,
0.0242368057,
0.0409043729,
0.0244282223,
0.0221147891,
0.0072505083,
-0.0342852622,
0.0210528746,
-0.0322686285,
-0.0534581728,
-0.0289234426,
-0.0219773855,
0.04225583,
-0.0063612866,
0.0151515324,
-0.0025512748,
-0.0914601237,
-0.0802786797,
0.0158971269,
-0.0821173191,
0.0168129541,
0.0128929531,
0.0429932363,
0.0046928348,
-0.0378267728,
0.003438924,
0.0104714399,
0.0515507013,
-0.006725607,
-0.0025775905,
-0.0570002422,
-0.0043923794,
-0.010679529,
0.0586642586,
-0.0327067599,
0.0262618456,
-0.0711531192,
0.0044082161,
-0.0708789378,
0.0081352452,
-0.0345160253,
0.0079235323,
0.0026460765,
0.0104924804,
0.0169007964,
-0.0425488278,
0.0030111209,
0.0315952338,
-0.0152374972,
-0.0366511941,
0.0261703786,
0.003133951,
-0.0106842481,
-0.0011893918,
0.0088110194,
0.079012461,
0.0321188048,
0.0061667864,
-0.0289559495,
-0.0425272398,
0.0381068215,
0.0072139916,
-0.0059902845,
-0.022840064,
0.0551721379,
-0.0426112972,
0.0048238346,
-0.0596017949,
-0.0006157864,
0.0113485307,
0.0146801416,
0.1195304766,
0.0085085034,
-0.0152079612,
0.0180084482,
0.0126059204,
-0.0042503346,
0.0133057935,
0.0210203677,
0.018569693,
0.0463668518,
-0.0280226655,
0.0527287833,
-0.0158993304,
0.0243805367,
-0.0162458327,
0.0037245313,
0.0041758278,
-0.009256267,
-0.0320812277,
0.0054589035,
0.0121294064,
-0.0117726428,
-0.0799925923,
0.0276446063,
0.0422087312,
-0.0080422871,
0.0200882964,
-0.0304380041,
0.0384652354,
-0.0468209721,
-0.0322402194,
-0.0072364882,
-0.0171400364,
-0.0848953798,
-0.0473308936,
-0.053307876,
0.0482108295,
-0.0221269373,
-0.036004629,
-0.0019174726,
-0.0276557431,
0.0667206943,
0.0251846276,
-0.0193491895,
0.0353356749,
0.0351335667,
0.014673668,
0.0138228694,
-0.0294749737,
0.019107867,
-0.0544701554,
-0.042128779,
0.0464717336,
-0.010880312,
-0.0150540015,
0.0220663194,
-0.0836320966,
0.0283352919,
0.0033037337,
-0.0503402986,
-0.0155246435,
0.0514366552,
-0.0187758859,
-0.0353564918,
0.0172279812,
-0.0053077168,
0.0255994387,
0.0480984077,
-0.0203644708,
0.0036998992,
-0.0526934005,
-0.0269787591,
0.0205982756,
-0.0167414695,
-0.0613086559,
0.0467581563,
0.0330003463,
0.0500947423,
0.032616172,
0.0025147884,
-0.008304094,
0.0080857417,
-0.0086806128,
-0.0420622267,
-0.0227196552,
0.0805999637,
0.0163148046,
-0.0208224654,
-0.0440624319,
0.0141025614,
0.0606331863,
-0.0178765971,
0.0094338823,
0.0295233522,
0.0022946449,
-0.0237835981,
-0.00190163,
0.0071486235,
-0.0281858891,
0.0826635361,
-0.0121785831,
0.0198153928,
-0.0351847634,
0.039507024,
-0.0453861915,
-0.0526359417,
0.0329819731,
0.0001658781,
-0.0038245586,
-0.0216688327,
-0.0286654737,
0.0352897607,
-0.0023749636,
-0.0275542419,
0.0153922122,
-0.0357207693,
0.0014827489,
-0.0110070342,
-0.0094786175,
0.0074626049,
-0.0136041753,
0.0016465652,
-0.0061124698,
-0.0150822848,
-0.0189040154,
-0.0382615142,
-0.0417176001,
0.042671524,
0.0179805402,
-0.0152983069,
-0.0325961262,
0.0571581535,
-0.0104653584,
0.0071135806,
0.0536271371,
-0.0187747944,
-0.0707048625,
0.0122015746,
-0.0261210445,
-0.0387447625,
0.0296755433,
-0.0419147015,
-0.0144066606,
0.0177575331,
0.0299310759,
-0.0286737215,
0.023058299,
0.0310674608,
0.0386614464,
0.0485453568,
0.0630347356,
-0.0345118269,
-0.0312618464,
-0.0235757623,
-0.0048196823,
-0.0326586999,
-0.0464059971,
-0.0015358925,
-0.0445298553,
0.0349981487,
-0.0457608849,
-0.0260873009,
0.0226078499,
-0.0368602127,
-0.0552544892,
-0.0510871671,
-0.0035037962,
0.0058268798,
0.0047368808,
-0.0005536085,
-0.0256014187,
0.0622024685,
0.0102600399,
0.039701324,
0.0151173612,
-0.0480328016,
-0.0014546844,
0.0298904777,
0.0054738089,
0.0373868309,
0.0490513444,
-0.0412779897,
0.0370820127,
-0.001490807,
0.0211679954,
-0.0397659242,
-0.0454191081,
0.0303948764,
-0.0035631557,
0.012618538,
-0.0186859015,
-0.0705191344,
-0.0673143268,
0.0243049692,
-0.0048599872,
-0.0048987721,
-0.0469163135,
-0.0386296734,
-0.0067768749,
0.0633766204,
0.0150818797,
0.0237761531,
-0.0066995132,
-0.009770331,
-0.0342244692,
-0.0456799008,
-0.0545615889,
0.0326414816,
-0.0015589303,
0.003150278,
0.0605944917,
0.046144221,
-0.0151691567,
0.0147857331,
-0.0115905851,
0.029743975,
-0.042527914,
-0.0049516768,
-0.0251864567,
-0.0025804392,
-0.001396552,
0.0494553149,
0.0515254065,
0.0057809013,
-0.0187510867,
0.0123331985,
0.0624212995,
-0.0134315221,
0.0190500375,
-0.0173614342,
-0.0940780044,
0.0388188809,
0.0192901548,
0.0768906176,
-0.109800227,
-0.063125439,
-0.009111248,
-0.0168103166,
-0.007165262,
-0.0114434827,
-0.0533402301,
-0.0113127604,
-0.0685254782,
-0.0212339554,
0.0092056319,
0.0232964605,
-0.0742084458,
0.0122565916,
-0.0075782686,
0.0126949726,
-0.0479869209,
-0.028921999,
-0.0304794945,
-0.0137309404,
0.0405111164,
-0.0291281696,
0.0344149917,
-0.0109197386,
0.0033906414,
0.0029945036,
0.001580436,
-0.0209912546,
-0.0300175156,
0.1108132526,
0.0040682731,
-0.0285936501,
-0.0142414514,
0.0519395061,
-0.0215679072,
-0.0165654775,
0.015705701,
-0.005513628,
-0.0190999676,
-0.0111120949,
0.0170443859,
-0.0054988996,
0.0422020741,
0.0380749181,
-0.02254772,
-0.0162556712,
0.0376773141,
-0.0460581109,
0.0177049972,
-0.0430509523,
-0.0472364202,
0.0130936839,
-0.0104338266,
-0.0652060285,
-0.0012302793,
0.0019899467,
0.0016600916,
0.0326735526,
0.0333106928,
0.0285102818,
-0.0058930567,
-0.0050210487,
-0.0643273667,
0.0039722384,
-0.0054431045,
0.0358877964,
-0.0045546736,
-0.026242638,
0.003435123,
0.0077825435,
-0.0089057237,
0.0166779868,
-0.0414439738,
-0.0634801686,
0.0605707131,
-0.0102689657,
0.0185198635,
0.039372392,
-0.0308333915,
-0.0677413121,
0.1039874032,
0.0556978323,
0.0200239886,
-0.0105245952,
0.0555392168,
0.0084991604,
-0.0151715754,
0.023759244,
0.0347548947,
0.0007835938,
0.0561480559,
-0.076089859,
-0.0981066972,
0.0307384022,
-0.0115706502,
0.0102186622,
0.0299340989,
-0.0110600162,
-0.0183964334,
-0.0082067885,
-0.0026430462,
-0.0289333779,
-0.0241702981,
0.0398320146,
-0.0266213007,
0.0604222044,
0.0247151162,
0.0255642384,
0.0289542358,
-0.0134573961,
-0.0164180323,
-0.0530795306,
0.0115966173,
0.0118695386,
0.0368993171,
-0.006796353,
0.0298406016,
-0.008313504,
0.067901969,
0.0329015292,
0.0188835468,
-0.0076532029,
-0.0499305949,
0.0165531803,
0.0255842097,
-0.0201235749,
0.0316445604,
-0.0477119721,
-0.058005292,
-0.0262460336,
0.0267955549,
-0.0364169292,
0.032136552,
-0.0141011877,
-0.0055076769,
-0.0149556203,
0.0050891223,
0.0089726197,
-0.0334716588,
-0.0475268289,
-0.0082975375,
-0.0078744916,
-0.0301968101,
0.0596187972,
0.0488613769,
0.0109203476,
0.0209410209,
0.0248473641,
-0.0388918407,
-0.0254345816,
-0.010668071,
-0.0065317042,
0.0524678119,
-0.0174681284,
0.0137487464,
-0.0062407125,
-0.0485519916,
0.0182738546,
-0.0317317247,
0.0193061251,
0.0084753642,
-0.0103991749,
0.0135910921,
-0.0046340609,
-0.0039952914,
-0.0959377512,
0.0288439635,
0.013861862,
-0.0447683409,
0.023562856,
-4.645823671e-33,
0.035001114,
-0.0169872157,
-0.0282255206,
0.0387013219,
0.0448394679,
0.027963588,
0.0512541644,
0.0140947588,
-0.018174028,
-0.0063680806,
-0.0223217197,
-0.0007024615,
0.001699271,
0.0317466296,
-0.0422676429,
-0.0393149666,
0.0363112241,
0.0026883753,
-0.0089392075,
-0.0007321718,
0.0946629792,
0.0162640978,
0.0508310013,
-0.1160299554,
0.0648704022,
0.0507067405,
-0.0501870364,
0.0114909597,
-0.0229751375,
0.0460812449,
-0.0265388489,
0.0683044121,
0.005799579,
0.0284537021,
-0.0036356153,
0.0420344323,
-0.0525441431,
0.0051882025,
-0.02818406,
0.0452137478,
0.0555101931,
-0.0676902905,
0.0281564556,
-0.0455848798,
-0.036919076,
0.0049515544,
0.0251107216,
-0.0213809106,
-0.0188626777,
-0.0382095203,
0.0092747388,
-0.0201335922,
-0.0468103923,
0.0286644157,
0.0594156533,
0.027142765,
0.0384325199,
-0.0257023852,
-0.1110614911,
0.0283253025,
-0.0350169279,
-0.0338645391,
0.0485190786,
0.0172001291,
0.0279838983,
0.035995651,
0.045136001,
0.0387456305,
-0.0036375397,
0.0380832143,
0.0071894769,
-0.0007949431,
0.0578450337,
0.0748460889,
0.0024431904,
-0.0570871085,
-0.0219485797,
0.0115938047,
0.0163836777,
-0.0492546149,
0.0500821583,
-0.0009278005,
-0.0679831579,
-0.022718586,
-0.0529620461,
-0.0649236441,
-0.0320264697,
0.0098118205,
-0.0296399854,
-0.0164284203,
-0.068340227,
0.0046474524,
0.0038377666,
-0.0189768039,
-0.0382765569,
0.0002876416,
0.0670480132,
0.0547350422,
0.0151789812,
0.0039303727,
0.038925495,
-0.0216603726,
0.0369272679,
-0.0339387432,
0.0571753904,
-0.034848623,
0.0788780898,
0.0084314588,
-0.0637873635,
-0.0179293249,
0.0058785821,
0.0692078322,
0.0377343148,
0.0476307459,
0.01358815,
0.0267655589,
-0.0113147022,
-0.0306286253,
0.0476528592,
0.0303625613,
0.0101770619,
0.0191221964,
-0.0384435579,
-0.0094584469,
0.0289355591,
-0.0106727071,
-0.0050063552,
0.0275307465,
0.0795483962,
-0.0313974209,
-0.0138306748,
-0.0482962951,
2.383e-7,
0.006586967,
-0.0090426691,
-0.0038544089,
-0.0258637294,
-0.0198953152,
0.0405578241,
0.0789900795,
0.0603710786,
-0.0189356823,
-0.0248707756,
-0.042175822,
0.0160697252,
0.0279393718,
0.0120083727,
-0.0611237586,
-0.0860519931,
0.060639333,
0.0197433047,
-0.0704536363,
0.0402725562,
0.0021386868,
0.0571089238,
0.0822603405,
-0.0150136817,
-0.0312350541,
-0.0192326214,
-0.0123091666,
-0.0633616522,
-0.0470507517,
-0.0048829545,
0.0509572364,
0.0149726607,
0.0382556319,
0.0244344901,
-0.0319169462,
-0.0067501822,
-0.0079666264,
0.0279389042,
0.0303093418,
0.0006747468,
-0.0303174257,
-0.0677560121,
-0.0117059676,
-0.0144625222,
0.0403375141,
0.0196858663,
-0.0529067032,
-0.0024014318,
-0.020268986,
-0.0109123914,
0.0679592416,
-0.0122871269,
-0.0086983507,
0.0249867644,
0.0498036817,
0.0074880156,
0.0170173869,
-0.0545215681,
-0.0058326954,
-0.0428278893,
-0.0292660054,
0.0090988316,
0.0564833544,
0.0316014253,
0.0244572144,
0.0280039608,
0.0418997332,
2.247809226e-34,
-0.0170217529,
0.0193876047,
-0.0075546172,
-0.0092212744,
0.0386792384,
0.0128901973,
0.0302339774,
-0.0019721545,
0.0080683166,
-0.0392566174,
-0.0029937082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17873v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17873v1 | Improving Arithmetic Reasoning Ability of Large Language Models through Relation Tuples, Verification and Dynamic Feedback | 2024-06-25T18:21:00 | 2024-06-25T18:21:00 | Zhongtao Miao, Kaiyan Zhao, Yoshimasa Tsuruoka | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Current representations used in reasoning steps of large language models can
mostly be categorized into two main types: (1) natural language, which is
difficult to verify; and (2) non-natural language, usually programming code,
which is difficult for people who are unfamiliar with coding to read. In this
paper, we propose to use a semi-structured form to represent reasoning steps of
large language models. Specifically, we use relation tuples, which are not only
human-readable but also machine-friendly and easier to verify than natural
language. We implement a framework that includes three main components: (1)
introducing relation tuples into the reasoning steps of large language models;
(2) implementing an automatic verification process of reasoning steps with a
local code interpreter based on relation tuples; and (3) integrating a simple
and effective dynamic feedback mechanism, which we found helpful for
self-improvement of large language models. The experimental results on various
arithmetic datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our method in improving
the arithmetic reasoning ability of large language models. The source code is
available at https://github.com/gpgg/art. | Improving Arithmetic Reasoning Ability of Large Language Models through Relation Tuples, Verification and Dynamic Feedback: Current representations used in reasoning steps of large language models can
mostly be categorized into two main types: (1) natural language, which is
difficult to verify; and (2) non-natural language, usually programming code,
which is difficult for people who are unfamiliar with coding to read. In this
paper, we propose to use a semi-structured form to represent reasoning steps of
large language models. Specifically, we use relation tuples, which are not only
human-readable but also machine-friendly and easier to verify than natural
language. We implement a framework that includes three main components: (1)
introducing relation tuples into the reasoning steps of large language models;
(2) implementing an automatic verification process of reasoning steps with a
local code interpreter based on relation tuples; and (3) integrating a simple
and effective dynamic feedback mechanism, which we found helpful for
self-improvement of large language models. The experimental results on various
arithmetic datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our method in improving
the arithmetic reasoning ability of large language models. The source code is
available at https://github.com/gpgg/art. | [
-0.0099420957,
0.0940594673,
-0.018350549,
0.0657866523,
-0.029823998,
0.0135783283,
0.0059478045,
-0.0123023866,
0.0020910779,
-0.0503075831,
-0.0013968344,
0.0207605921,
0.027004255,
0.0233551227,
0.0229209531,
-0.0526956059,
0.0293316767,
-0.0704473034,
0.0272787232,
-0.0042703566,
-0.0098028583,
0.0133560803,
-0.020589726,
0.0024449404,
0.00098344,
-0.0713911057,
0.0068692574,
-0.0533824898,
0.0093613304,
-0.0050564744,
-0.0396549143,
0.0566132292,
0.0053731552,
0.0308041051,
0.0000021459,
-0.0413536094,
-0.0330906138,
0.0301221088,
-0.0680427924,
0.0401594862,
0.0096551115,
-0.0074395002,
0.0004056338,
0.0319125913,
-0.0564103983,
-0.0115171121,
0.0284209643,
-0.0150741767,
0.1012681499,
0.0664177909,
-0.0003364614,
-0.0674352646,
0.0230751634,
0.0374478027,
0.0142688612,
-0.0203711074,
0.0182046201,
0.1094552577,
0.0361986049,
0.0131493574,
0.0050013722,
-0.0077721002,
0.0506078675,
-0.0394605659,
-0.0299693849,
-0.0020291195,
-0.0171240047,
-0.0041389447,
0.0003969081,
0.0275228433,
0.0196878184,
-0.0326567218,
-0.0163735282,
0.0148084294,
-0.0023698746,
0.0200581048,
-0.0561947785,
0.034275841,
-0.0014789896,
0.0190902688,
0.0129613876,
-0.0107972044,
0.0204981137,
0.0016016879,
-0.0773796961,
0.0851325765,
0.0042317775,
-0.029448539,
-0.0410152376,
-0.0436658785,
-0.0459771864,
-0.0518444702,
0.0280546006,
0.0943562165,
-0.0278082937,
0.0290452596,
-0.0131818131,
-0.0159437079,
0.0065158173,
-0.0886808261,
0.021032529,
0.0633715466,
0.0182781871,
0.0549148433,
-0.0163652357,
0.0764939189,
-0.0285291765,
0.0019157411,
-0.0079883914,
0.0330255292,
-0.0184502415,
-0.01806028,
-0.0515900142,
0.0270115845,
0.0202766862,
0.0350233503,
-0.0396309383,
0.023214601,
-0.0340713039,
0.0568479039,
0.0101211108,
-0.0594788603,
0.0491641089,
-0.0237091593,
-0.0190124176,
-0.0088167209,
-0.0417317636,
-0.0315782055,
-0.0265607294,
-0.0413414426,
0.0064371154,
-0.0259276945,
-0.0052860747,
-0.0270936154,
0.007415581,
0.0708790943,
0.039385058,
0.0103746708,
0.0149759855,
-0.0359145328,
0.0427272432,
-0.051998049,
-0.0018604839,
-0.096118547,
0.0072848802,
0.0412420444,
0.0004711763,
-0.0474839732,
0.000029303,
0.0217549857,
-0.0089774868,
0.0597145632,
-0.0206187069,
0.0234994739,
-0.0280345362,
-0.0105805965,
0.0085163945,
0.0091404207,
0.0770320371,
-0.0429639816,
0.0305306036,
-0.0208283123,
0.0081850188,
0.0350559987,
0.0127347484,
-0.0237265266,
-0.0809006095,
0.0261475928,
0.0017594828,
-0.0019174856,
-0.0339508839,
0.0484144725,
-0.0304878242,
-0.025914181,
-0.024687374,
0.0038613714,
0.0239301082,
0.0450542755,
0.0281580985,
0.0166831091,
0.0366312228,
-0.0111220675,
-0.0387283564,
0.0206761062,
-0.0411820747,
0.0054813619,
-0.0010404369,
0.0138194002,
0.0140294144,
-0.0795672983,
-0.0318076648,
0.0092581399,
0.035053283,
0.0266764946,
0.0579080842,
0.003026204,
-0.000808735,
0.0553900972,
0.030147884,
-0.0480116121,
-0.0398230702,
-0.0602919273,
0.0543500334,
0.0241026841,
0.0482323915,
-0.064225167,
0.0028169439,
-0.0223552566,
-0.0171637051,
-0.0149813686,
0.0118373735,
-0.0237915963,
-0.039645277,
-0.0298137721,
-0.0139754144,
0.0170499943,
0.0117361154,
-0.0146511849,
0.0364935733,
-0.0142629463,
0.0089022769,
-0.0299617574,
0.0181330554,
0.0043319934,
-0.0172720458,
-0.0086982204,
-0.0246721897,
0.020960601,
-0.0129171852,
0.0357132554,
0.0020086416,
0.0593486652,
0.0283705443,
-0.0023525658,
-0.0041461526,
-0.0049033025,
-0.0146397315,
-0.0264008455,
0.0622513667,
0.0188460909,
-0.0496941693,
0.0078304503,
-0.0383040942,
0.003862448,
0.0563972928,
-0.0483558178,
0.0043026307,
0.0071386723,
0.0275290981,
-0.0111438464,
-0.038151715,
0.0020175888,
0.0723070428,
0.0025166557,
0.0187785327,
-0.0012214328,
0.0132007403,
0.030157309,
-0.0003377083,
0.0244033951,
0.0251876563,
-0.0065393341,
0.0198069662,
0.0256201327,
0.0069468934,
0.0023358979,
0.0093491171,
-0.0154872397,
-0.0246918183,
-0.0112205595,
0.0488294885,
0.0123750195,
-0.0046342034,
0.0020667573,
-0.0141428532,
-0.0174565986,
-0.0203637257,
0.0076473784,
-0.010731305,
0.0354430191,
-0.0182343312,
-0.0532227829,
-0.005673293,
-0.0448066331,
-0.0618923344,
0.0757725835,
0.0143611766,
0.0128818713,
-0.0468712635,
0.0314045064,
-0.0129667828,
0.0028697476,
0.0016665836,
-0.0120099997,
0.0138853891,
-0.0351205468,
0.0231140982,
0.0286631566,
-0.02944538,
0.0348904692,
0.036735028,
-0.0040725484,
-0.0459405966,
0.0028097297,
0.011969028,
-0.0059155063,
0.0080672912,
-0.0283797551,
-0.0515963994,
0.0855588689,
-0.0335772,
-0.0153733622,
-0.0282962788,
0.0364831872,
-0.0039643771,
0.0612907745,
-0.0439042002,
-0.0020374996,
0.0080741867,
0.0504160747,
-0.0001616589,
-0.0660745427,
0.0545534603,
-0.0039217961,
-0.0136962608,
-0.051277902,
0.0082960064,
-0.0668043196,
0.0987275988,
-0.0015830477,
0.0169595275,
-0.03027739,
-0.0192604624,
-0.0081911935,
-0.0284664109,
0.0576133616,
-0.0425174609,
0.062482737,
-0.0268692318,
0.0190415736,
0.0034560701,
-0.0208702572,
-0.0457202531,
0.0325637348,
-0.0565067939,
0.0321567766,
-0.0268625468,
-0.0164352003,
0.0273447931,
0.0090367561,
0.0350040942,
0.0222028084,
-0.0048317728,
-0.0154360486,
-0.0230404735,
-0.0079240063,
-0.0139260022,
-0.0054172976,
0.007957533,
-0.0135832485,
0.0306090508,
0.0087363888,
0.0506700426,
0.0096575581,
-0.0598605648,
0.0096649565,
0.0152841927,
-0.0364987291,
-0.0152102709,
0.0516641177,
-0.0188962705,
-0.0906685442,
-0.0021334549,
0.1117873564,
0.0435141772,
-0.0033417821,
0.0369960479,
-0.0614653863,
-0.0090034837,
0.0508022197,
0.0558036715,
-0.0921758935,
-0.0023102118,
-0.0123587605,
-0.0383588262,
0.0253682379,
-0.0344570652,
-0.000172741,
-0.1087220758,
0.0288129747,
0.0389039107,
-0.0218467638,
-0.0489924811,
-0.0388964005,
-0.0284090638,
0.0042956346,
-0.0359250158,
0.0698548853,
-0.0278351791,
-0.002329164,
0.0037408066,
-0.0198189244,
-0.0212981589,
0.0537297316,
-0.0112967147,
0.0055720233,
0.0527743027,
0.0252342392,
-0.004113799,
-0.0311313514,
0.0346702822,
0.0676261336,
-0.0201268978,
-0.0165798794,
-0.0138094593,
0.0170742348,
-0.0147515796,
-0.0141558051,
0.0140250204,
-0.0585220307,
-0.0381692499,
0.0062345853,
0.121304065,
-0.0102321766,
-0.0001295897,
-0.0162020698,
-0.0153386965,
-0.0121492632,
0.0260833278,
0.0075177541,
0.0231563766,
-0.034709949,
-0.0670409501,
-0.0428140014,
0.003623924,
-0.0377927385,
0.0106028551,
0.0219921451,
-0.0155880991,
-0.0279612467,
0.0093500139,
0.0515243076,
0.0232236013,
-0.0119328471,
-0.0191613436,
0.0807410926,
0.0009626138,
-0.0663620755,
-0.0044322042,
-0.0423134863,
0.054844223,
0.0021238278,
0.0093560005,
-0.0048478623,
0.0050846799,
-0.029107172,
-0.023459509,
-0.0543748736,
-0.0263188649,
-0.031334132,
0.0657971352,
0.0262720417,
-0.0085756015,
-0.0129495636,
-0.0448595285,
-0.0274150614,
0.0015675675,
-0.0566088669,
-0.0338968486,
0.0138736721,
0.0105979238,
0.0095384642,
0.0204732958,
-0.0151997693,
0.0055350726,
-0.0228229482,
0.0304016825,
-0.060323149,
0.0133515168,
0.0533376299,
0.0534953736,
-0.0159918908,
0.0373919792,
0.0059140217,
-0.0013078303,
0.020013025,
-0.0761136413,
-0.0446331501,
-0.0595538355,
0.0702522472,
-0.0189372711,
-0.0288887788,
0.002597251,
-0.0585766137,
0.0051878248,
0.0010812868,
0.0217802264,
0.0687999874,
-0.0012934287,
0.0324115902,
0.046736639,
-0.0462198108,
0.0181563143,
-0.0067338408,
-0.0090193553,
0.0111318538,
-0.0087298807,
0.0473740399,
0.0257503204,
0.0140024647,
-0.0276586544,
-0.0403793231,
0.0189509559,
-0.0898103416,
0.0071254419,
0.0172908939,
0.0318037495,
0.0401665308,
0.0129466141,
-0.0601922162,
-0.0048715323,
-0.0117192529,
0.0540152378,
0.0351585932,
-0.0371803902,
0.0093992883,
0.0526581779,
-0.0011541928,
-0.0507022738,
0.0575412922,
-0.0361633226,
0.0092179691,
0.0119832773,
-0.0309367478,
-0.0445787571,
-0.0474232249,
-0.0249845348,
-0.0345938914,
-0.0292526912,
0.0158779304,
-0.0694619492,
-0.1090310812,
-0.0588663481,
0.0348309018,
0.0176198799,
-0.0041200714,
0.0331691355,
0.0485240668,
0.0012215794,
-0.0055861082,
-0.0278765261,
0.0327534787,
-0.0487136133,
-0.0289971605,
-0.023196388,
-5.372772153e-33,
-0.032448329,
-0.036032021,
0.0461373776,
-0.0334482156,
0.0435741022,
-0.0362235457,
-0.0470618978,
0.0260576345,
0.0015239333,
0.0231909137,
0.0192858838,
0.0336296484,
-0.004469383,
-0.0313004516,
-0.0052749584,
-0.0112737715,
0.0315632671,
-0.0065453267,
-0.030432811,
-0.0184220243,
0.0159480646,
-0.0232946221,
0.0649286583,
-0.0682595968,
0.0353479795,
-0.0274862442,
-0.0240320005,
0.0548152551,
-0.055076208,
0.0802011415,
0.0111248177,
0.0053859795,
-0.0045302836,
-0.0131467599,
-0.032260865,
0.0123417508,
-0.0672326908,
-0.0249192789,
0.0260691401,
0.0145502109,
-0.0314192139,
-0.0256737694,
0.0295602828,
0.0036529691,
-0.033459194,
-0.0133343572,
0.0155235734,
-0.0440392159,
0.0040132068,
0.0127251623,
-0.0520099774,
0.0426410995,
-0.0371782593,
-0.0088081555,
0.0138116656,
0.0133654736,
-0.0391982682,
-0.0248968061,
-0.0064796628,
0.0220084954,
0.0523773767,
0.0138830161,
0.0530025996,
-0.0348609798,
0.0134764053,
-0.0012997456,
-0.0031078602,
-0.0110948384,
-0.0242879,
0.0172708221,
0.0147183128,
0.051130753,
0.048360493,
-0.0010906699,
0.0763414651,
0.0125176487,
-0.0568266138,
0.0014033075,
0.0213947557,
0.0565804578,
0.0238138884,
0.0046839146,
-0.0527581349,
-0.0239771362,
-0.0356227383,
0.0375786573,
-0.0567641966,
-0.046231132,
-0.0089207394,
-0.0246078856,
-0.0451055802,
0.0359880291,
-0.0021772967,
-0.0579576418,
-0.0650911927,
0.0421688855,
-0.017246386,
0.0013458682,
-0.0143791987,
0.0344747119,
0.0223020185,
-0.0151321255,
-0.04635204,
-0.0531301461,
0.0461919904,
0.058728952,
0.0018436147,
0.0325785503,
-0.0559556596,
-0.014130515,
-0.034632951,
-0.0318699777,
0.0169231277,
0.0091855396,
0.0292231143,
0.0179352518,
0.0240598023,
0.0683301017,
-0.0025531841,
-0.0229368564,
-0.021173384,
0.0717357844,
-0.0054512164,
0.0286924932,
0.0185174178,
-0.0771688595,
-0.0547884442,
0.0229625534,
0.0525100641,
-0.0146514932,
-0.0135743804,
0.0085105393,
2.776e-7,
0.0366674997,
0.0731463805,
0.0432369076,
0.0979199633,
0.022631133,
0.0246897824,
-0.0047991774,
-0.0108597055,
0.0174239576,
-0.0360070802,
-0.0075083547,
0.0300335269,
0.0281471759,
0.0365226604,
0.0050697811,
0.0022151263,
-0.0218872242,
-0.0393370464,
-0.05384681,
0.0141593358,
0.0490969792,
0.0436811484,
0.0525032952,
0.0314688496,
-0.0025374901,
-0.0336408094,
0.028316237,
-0.0055014095,
0.0083917864,
0.0147487354,
-0.0119493166,
-0.0312854536,
0.0169923101,
-0.0083732745,
0.0163577665,
0.0275874808,
0.0087714521,
0.0874571279,
-0.0085342256,
0.0811576992,
-0.0166601166,
-0.063348271,
-0.0077316253,
-0.0324155465,
0.0484223403,
-0.0552490503,
-0.0493526682,
-0.0249434114,
0.0298184678,
-0.0376664288,
0.0049097962,
0.0128843617,
0.0090047875,
0.0146821672,
0.020077087,
-0.0269544832,
-0.0012740793,
-0.0421417393,
-0.0544915535,
0.0178398658,
-0.0333554968,
-0.027646713,
-0.0142296264,
-0.0054911114,
-0.0001378662,
-0.0255249087,
0.0186309014,
2.886586402e-34,
0.060362462,
-0.0072483653,
0.0242708568,
0.0482465364,
0.0773725733,
-0.0275059752,
-0.0187129434,
0.0589584634,
0.0690758377,
-0.0343117192,
-0.0247288737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17764v1 | BMIKE-53: Investigating Cross-Lingual Knowledge Editing with In-Context Learning | 2024-06-25T17:48:56 | 2024-06-25T17:48:56 | Ercong Nie, Bo Shao, Zifeng Ding, Mingyang Wang, Helmut Schmid, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) possess extensive parametric knowledge, but this
knowledge is difficult to update with new information because retraining is
very expensive and infeasible for closed-source models. Knowledge editing (KE)
has emerged as a viable solution for updating the knowledge of LLMs without
compromising their overall performance. On-the-fly KE methods, inspired by
in-context learning (ICL), have shown great promise and allow LLMs to be
treated as black boxes. In the past, KE was primarily employed in English
contexts, whereas the potential for cross-lingual KE in current English-centric
LLMs has not been fully explored. To foster more research in this direction, we
introduce the BMIKE-53 benchmark for evaluating cross-lingual KE on 53 diverse
languages across three KE task types. We also propose a gradient-free KE method
called Multilingual In-context Knowledge Editing (MIKE) and evaluate it on
BMIKE-53. Our evaluation focuses on cross-lingual knowledge transfer in terms
of reliability, generality, locality, and portability, offering valuable
insights and a framework for future research in cross-lingual KE. Our code and
data are publicly accessible via the anonymous repository at
https://anonymous.4open.science/r/MIKE. | BMIKE-53: Investigating Cross-Lingual Knowledge Editing with In-Context Learning: Large language models (LLMs) possess extensive parametric knowledge, but this
knowledge is difficult to update with new information because retraining is
very expensive and infeasible for closed-source models. Knowledge editing (KE)
has emerged as a viable solution for updating the knowledge of LLMs without
compromising their overall performance. On-the-fly KE methods, inspired by
in-context learning (ICL), have shown great promise and allow LLMs to be
treated as black boxes. In the past, KE was primarily employed in English
contexts, whereas the potential for cross-lingual KE in current English-centric
LLMs has not been fully explored. To foster more research in this direction, we
introduce the BMIKE-53 benchmark for evaluating cross-lingual KE on 53 diverse
languages across three KE task types. We also propose a gradient-free KE method
called Multilingual In-context Knowledge Editing (MIKE) and evaluate it on
BMIKE-53. Our evaluation focuses on cross-lingual knowledge transfer in terms
of reliability, generality, locality, and portability, offering valuable
insights and a framework for future research in cross-lingual KE. Our code and
data are publicly accessible via the anonymous repository at
https://anonymous.4open.science/r/MIKE. | [
0.0129268169,
0.0136744902,
-0.0068948241,
0.073510319,
-0.0556188338,
-0.0002736509,
0.0008471209,
-0.0184002221,
-0.0261767264,
-0.0463827327,
-0.1156246886,
-0.0150086572,
0.0343141891,
-0.0085986517,
0.0282921921,
-0.0518577397,
0.0536368266,
-0.0349563435,
-0.0435356908,
0.0162140001,
-0.0345839448,
-0.0001707257,
0.0014453093,
0.0151356263,
0.0122707775,
-0.0188727695,
-0.0033199743,
0.0270482916,
0.0475719236,
0.0034822747,
0.0349639282,
0.0410274155,
-0.006999854,
0.0379902236,
0.0000022439,
-0.0545279905,
-0.0270663109,
0.0015824198,
0.0134093622,
0.037368156,
0.0127144214,
-0.0536686517,
-0.0490065515,
-0.0233448148,
-0.0249580797,
0.020285828,
0.0505827554,
0.0115881702,
0.0559503809,
0.0882433578,
-0.0064757089,
0.0202060845,
0.0370704345,
-0.0515838712,
0.0123514384,
-0.0316405781,
0.05657392,
0.0103545506,
-0.0678579137,
0.0021741688,
-0.041599229,
0.0680032745,
0.0112993661,
-0.0144895064,
0.0125936409,
-0.0074425605,
-0.028311763,
0.0161853954,
-0.0227177404,
0.0730098784,
-0.033476159,
-0.0049538198,
-0.0269216467,
-0.0010221655,
0.0117747039,
-0.0200352911,
-0.0406565182,
-0.0098296497,
0.0280042049,
0.0076924548,
-0.0081442771,
-0.0560397394,
0.0614829846,
-0.0026384692,
0.0013316077,
0.0499646403,
0.0360388085,
-0.0277769342,
0.0009248179,
0.0097407065,
0.0066240369,
-0.0826528817,
-0.0219070222,
0.0156049384,
-0.0086326487,
0.01095792,
-0.0671219453,
-0.006830554,
-0.0045545129,
-0.0600361302,
0.0538394488,
0.0465140715,
-0.0431286097,
0.0696598962,
-0.0164947398,
0.026390139,
-0.0003429692,
0.0187209845,
-0.0271582939,
-0.0111049786,
-0.0490654111,
0.0180919562,
-0.0179015994,
-0.0089339875,
-0.0546402223,
0.0202341676,
-0.0605769791,
0.01565044,
-0.0280338246,
0.0068358392,
0.0125411116,
-0.0423079468,
-0.0357550159,
-0.013548445,
-0.0094823865,
0.0414064825,
0.0179671105,
0.0203105062,
-0.0015238214,
-0.0295169167,
0.0025675485,
-0.0147337643,
0.0010501754,
-0.0677988604,
0.0351673923,
0.0668000132,
-0.0557731614,
-0.0271677841,
-0.0629528016,
-0.0172167607,
-0.0096442224,
-0.0773203298,
-0.0145549886,
-0.0711513236,
0.0408545658,
-0.0194574129,
-0.0130583281,
-0.0578064919,
0.0029530008,
-0.007735752,
-0.0290448461,
0.0842651948,
-0.0013147498,
0.0250400044,
0.0312951915,
0.0224619024,
-0.0474391654,
0.0879601315,
0.017082775,
-0.0284430571,
0.0790090114,
0.0030285744,
-0.0208742227,
0.0582698174,
0.0389529206,
0.0492477901,
-0.0201544873,
-0.001886268,
0.0469475091,
0.0226853639,
0.0365022272,
-0.0031113091,
-0.021883402,
0.0078960825,
0.0988916457,
0.0117720859,
0.0177253634,
0.0217169784,
0.0514738299,
-0.034456715,
0.0069894306,
-0.0245215502,
-0.0568379648,
0.0285214558,
-0.0192756169,
-0.0011321941,
0.013824637,
0.0434775986,
-0.0191678237,
-0.0292245019,
0.0196791869,
-0.0088604456,
0.0127321295,
0.0068678036,
0.0596751496,
0.0381852165,
-0.0178640038,
0.0330378115,
0.0480085723,
-0.0195699148,
0.0217871647,
-0.0088454289,
-0.0067242724,
0.0597305857,
0.027256025,
-0.0224200226,
-0.0416843705,
-0.0258301627,
0.0188665725,
0.005719108,
0.0320316292,
-0.0301813651,
0.0403114967,
-0.0345151238,
-0.0205995459,
-0.0446359143,
0.0136097381,
0.0080581643,
0.0559160113,
0.0503301173,
0.021328764,
-0.0415970646,
0.0172680747,
0.007466984,
-0.0717876554,
-0.0080043338,
0.0039637201,
0.0137529885,
0.0105167972,
-0.0143790077,
-0.0104857991,
-0.023784779,
-0.0120054884,
-0.0283588525,
0.0028402703,
0.0286445636,
-0.0353062265,
-0.0564282499,
0.0524023883,
-0.0194200426,
-0.0373306125,
-0.001458735,
-0.0430793017,
-0.0217162129,
0.0005267932,
0.0249705426,
0.0538528152,
-0.0379202664,
0.0351800993,
-0.0042712241,
-0.0054909182,
0.0175275449,
0.0303806029,
-0.0010453978,
-0.0202045497,
0.0346631519,
-0.0146720055,
-0.0147780972,
-0.0099787032,
-0.0068072523,
0.0340951942,
-0.0194726717,
-0.0134948306,
-0.0143757053,
0.033308316,
-0.0407699682,
0.0156408641,
-0.1171920896,
0.0105481744,
-0.0191725083,
0.0077509009,
0.0420049727,
0.0487001166,
-0.0145526296,
-0.0134005845,
-0.0162523687,
-0.0034687696,
-0.0203779228,
0.0458700508,
0.0125589045,
0.0187902171,
0.0251070671,
-0.0486699417,
0.0039332551,
0.0310511794,
0.0397251509,
-0.0310616475,
-0.0205784924,
-0.0520436652,
0.0316991918,
-0.0705444291,
-0.0011586931,
-0.0119143724,
-0.024211213,
-0.0468300097,
0.0018380001,
0.0901577249,
0.0507329293,
-0.0402479097,
-0.0179536603,
0.0667926818,
-0.0612336434,
-0.0274333991,
0.0221252944,
0.0289077293,
-0.0190799888,
-0.0538577288,
-0.0187543035,
0.0061414065,
0.0627427697,
-0.0181930214,
-0.0393716954,
-0.0510151237,
0.0008311583,
-0.0115822395,
-0.0237840805,
-0.0891912133,
0.0248494837,
-0.005238337,
0.0409953967,
-0.0511772968,
-0.0364497006,
0.0583652444,
-0.0191154871,
0.0121573852,
-0.0282093547,
-0.0230309516,
-0.0163465142,
0.0536242798,
-0.0516748577,
0.0361446217,
-0.03563191,
0.0222774334,
-0.0788481385,
-0.0199557506,
0.0373590998,
-0.0039277291,
0.0613143221,
-0.089791663,
0.0044070883,
-0.0076917671,
-0.0365119278,
-0.0124798249,
0.0165748466,
-0.0113482559,
0.0073623955,
-0.0031664958,
-0.0320812836,
-0.0152114099,
-0.0259195194,
0.0677707344,
0.0693733096,
-0.0003442902,
-0.013609115,
-0.0021299573,
0.0205838121,
0.0146830017,
-0.0008714375,
0.0031157655,
-0.0205274373,
0.0113683427,
0.0464839935,
0.012975703,
-0.0547165535,
0.0094113424,
0.0068198899,
0.0049830335,
-0.0447921343,
-0.0161464736,
-0.0149221225,
0.0787094906,
-0.0616702139,
-0.0315915681,
0.0618826672,
0.0070643225,
-0.0493284874,
0.0149233583,
-0.0455505028,
-0.0138494372,
0.0343143493,
0.0373160131,
-0.0820666328,
-0.0338804312,
0.0249862596,
0.004913378,
0.0182987191,
-0.0375966355,
-0.01232062,
-0.109757483,
0.0186768044,
0.0146713722,
-0.0971476287,
-0.0525492094,
-0.0449287407,
0.0167866256,
-0.0081106992,
0.014259018,
0.0187952016,
0.0092662396,
-0.0139330532,
-0.034076754,
-0.0008683249,
-0.0933344141,
0.0480528139,
-0.0347038992,
0.0313446671,
0.0216919109,
0.0282220393,
0.0122157559,
-0.0322187096,
0.0538033321,
-0.0042233388,
-0.0058145244,
-0.0240657069,
0.0275207516,
-0.0065350146,
-0.0118702063,
0.0435182825,
0.0316716023,
-0.0265032053,
-0.0401419438,
0.0400554799,
0.1006269231,
0.0163244307,
0.010992582,
0.0370574296,
-0.0495768562,
0.032790903,
0.0585995242,
0.0180761609,
-0.0319716744,
0.015069169,
-0.0360043645,
-0.0335135683,
-0.0208259448,
-0.0022467924,
-0.0209816974,
-0.067036517,
0.0018961694,
-0.0912339389,
-0.0453682579,
0.0474555455,
0.0021280635,
0.0351379812,
0.0123925311,
-0.0091296965,
-0.0075356509,
-0.0438754633,
0.0087318439,
-0.0551848672,
0.0406106412,
-0.0359108001,
-0.0169389471,
0.0241935123,
-0.0376652628,
-0.0053073592,
0.0036949096,
-0.051102519,
-0.0726489127,
-0.0251081493,
0.0838304386,
0.0076966672,
0.0858085528,
0.0015223169,
-0.0069580381,
0.059306547,
-0.0024663447,
-0.0039378814,
0.0585648976,
0.0384121425,
0.0294037536,
-0.002312978,
0.0597515479,
-0.0667411834,
-0.0161086805,
0.052299913,
0.0413268842,
-0.0182505716,
-0.0126197087,
-0.0190213546,
-0.0144382063,
0.0039944043,
0.0148147522,
-0.0336834192,
-0.0390313976,
0.0534804501,
-0.0209455118,
-0.029604163,
-0.0329252258,
0.0001271103,
0.0337412804,
-0.0068254243,
-0.012345654,
0.0409600325,
0.0148931639,
-0.0074057169,
-0.0114856819,
-0.0093413908,
0.0168270636,
0.0420214385,
0.0418183319,
0.0259223506,
-0.0007960905,
0.0200527236,
0.0078560868,
0.0168464072,
-0.0398268029,
0.0188268647,
0.0171445645,
-0.0239125807,
-0.0254565962,
0.0260070525,
-0.0433795825,
-0.0057489579,
-0.0245597549,
0.0194691345,
0.0917146578,
0.0085083591,
0.0625836998,
-0.0329486839,
-0.0521864444,
-0.0322569609,
0.054341998,
-0.0054728724,
-0.002845177,
0.0180707593,
-0.0204491913,
-0.0043728538,
0.0516195744,
0.0895608589,
-0.0328164846,
0.0967167392,
-0.0109207127,
-0.0067698844,
-0.0406799503,
-0.0212753993,
0.031926062,
0.0142983673,
-0.0301070996,
-0.0144613422,
0.0027002813,
-0.0727327988,
0.0149159459,
-0.0060252193,
-0.0572096929,
0.0296728425,
0.0050602802,
0.0666476637,
0.0121159051,
0.0009812944,
-0.0253079887,
0.0048207045,
-0.0032725981,
-0.0157715883,
0.0191411786,
-6.488697225e-33,
-0.0078528682,
0.0215491392,
0.0341055989,
0.0131819369,
-0.0281029511,
-0.0004869425,
-0.048104357,
-0.0013986892,
0.0131035326,
0.0115895616,
-0.0078795552,
0.0014520057,
0.0003327837,
0.0224602129,
0.0132703008,
0.0011554252,
0.0565353669,
0.0327698067,
-0.0118931774,
0.0340260155,
0.0335505009,
0.0606387332,
0.1133025885,
-0.0340800434,
0.0459763557,
0.0341550037,
0.0025149409,
0.0290071815,
-0.0202371497,
0.0308950767,
-0.008041936,
0.01902036,
0.0117107155,
-0.0143733686,
-0.026516743,
-0.0327448696,
-0.0582902804,
-0.0127947088,
0.0069286535,
0.0369148813,
-0.0213370938,
-0.0713730901,
0.0227054544,
-0.0102894185,
-0.0018848927,
-0.025009403,
0.0161065441,
-0.0543414354,
-0.0070625064,
-0.0240550004,
-0.0803412423,
0.0062355492,
-0.0062564695,
-0.0240454953,
0.0087205106,
0.0283378474,
0.0179832559,
-0.027683381,
-0.0919314697,
0.0137781082,
-0.0136924898,
0.0410737284,
0.0888793543,
-0.0091587203,
0.0079722973,
0.0120241409,
-0.0007797921,
0.0051070508,
0.0302161407,
-0.0112587688,
0.0340163745,
0.0468575284,
0.0173839778,
0.0852610469,
0.010254466,
0.0038743434,
-0.0847146809,
0.028537225,
-0.0189750139,
0.0246551093,
-0.0204791762,
0.0442798026,
0.0367589593,
-0.0002872293,
-0.0436708741,
-0.0196832214,
-0.0315844417,
-0.0342321433,
0.0282626078,
0.006090309,
-0.0122667691,
0.016436331,
0.043145135,
-0.0274838619,
-0.0143137798,
0.0328019559,
-0.0077724257,
0.036825899,
0.0079082279,
-0.0155027648,
-0.0604646653,
0.0076900525,
0.0072857672,
0.0120673403,
0.0157095138,
-0.0146916658,
0.0784153864,
0.0371325798,
-0.04885583,
0.0077986545,
-0.0300206579,
0.0400294028,
0.0005022796,
0.0309066996,
-0.0026576668,
0.0078526838,
-0.0248443205,
0.0187478643,
0.0551220775,
-0.019511478,
0.0088837501,
-0.0061250022,
-0.0052042282,
0.018913148,
-0.0105438214,
0.0141802225,
-0.0303800143,
-0.0072092973,
0.041463647,
-0.0371499136,
-0.0142055964,
0.0215905551,
2.903e-7,
0.0418476984,
0.0355919898,
-0.0072656684,
-0.0243998747,
0.0243860353,
0.0261847544,
-0.0596393794,
0.01715515,
0.0055122995,
-0.0002716265,
0.0109399417,
0.0517614782,
0.0632026196,
0.0357839577,
-0.0583711714,
-0.0061268397,
-0.0330330767,
0.0118420888,
-0.0446741432,
-0.0220911317,
-0.0337312669,
0.0385683849,
0.0234077647,
-0.0156037295,
0.0015986665,
-0.031122921,
0.0883857086,
-0.0825952813,
-0.0091644712,
0.0057229805,
-0.0052543911,
0.0505463518,
0.0069588409,
0.0263513066,
-0.0514926426,
-0.0097243339,
0.008038193,
0.0798617527,
0.0121105583,
0.0005240453,
-0.0096695842,
0.0435068011,
-0.0161014833,
-0.0720800906,
0.0630304292,
-0.0432199165,
0.0204653144,
-0.0364681967,
-0.0014213343,
-0.005485503,
0.047281675,
-0.0450178944,
-0.0173305608,
0.0265006796,
0.0487569571,
0.0488133505,
-0.0665087253,
-0.0235324576,
-0.0274328124,
0.0210771598,
0.0036278467,
-0.0585648529,
-0.0489405282,
-0.0251591522,
0.0009006417,
-0.057055708,
0.0110329445,
2.334821751e-34,
-0.0092857024,
-0.0023007828,
0.0172630176,
0.0272371043,
0.0182883348,
-0.0180827975,
-0.0273450688,
0.0008335115,
-0.0275747571,
-0.0464672148,
-0.007240037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17761v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17761v2 | CaLMQA: Exploring culturally specific long-form question answering across 23 languages | 2024-06-25T17:45:26 | 2024-07-03T16:33:55 | Shane Arora, Marzena Karpinska, Hung-Ting Chen, Ipsita Bhattacharjee, Mohit Iyyer, Eunsol Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) are used for long-form question answering
(LFQA), which requires them to generate paragraph-length answers to complex
questions. While LFQA has been well-studied in English, this research has not
been extended to other languages. To bridge this gap, we introduce CaLMQA, a
collection of 1.5K complex culturally specific questions spanning 23 languages
and 51 culturally agnostic questions translated from English into 22 other
languages. We define culturally specific questions as those uniquely or more
likely to be asked by people from cultures associated with the question's
language. We collect naturally-occurring questions from community web forums
and hire native speakers to write questions to cover under-resourced,
rarely-studied languages such as Fijian and Kirundi. Our dataset contains
diverse, complex questions that reflect cultural topics (e.g. traditions, laws,
news) and the language usage of native speakers. We automatically evaluate a
suite of open- and closed-source models on CaLMQA by detecting incorrect
language and token repetitions in answers, and observe that the quality of
LLM-generated answers degrades significantly for some low-resource languages.
Lastly, we perform human evaluation on a subset of models and languages. Manual
evaluation reveals that model performance is significantly worse for culturally
specific questions than for culturally agnostic questions. Our findings
highlight the need for further research in non-English LFQA and provide an
evaluation framework. | CaLMQA: Exploring culturally specific long-form question answering across 23 languages: Large language models (LLMs) are used for long-form question answering
(LFQA), which requires them to generate paragraph-length answers to complex
questions. While LFQA has been well-studied in English, this research has not
been extended to other languages. To bridge this gap, we introduce CaLMQA, a
collection of 1.5K complex culturally specific questions spanning 23 languages
and 51 culturally agnostic questions translated from English into 22 other
languages. We define culturally specific questions as those uniquely or more
likely to be asked by people from cultures associated with the question's
language. We collect naturally-occurring questions from community web forums
and hire native speakers to write questions to cover under-resourced,
rarely-studied languages such as Fijian and Kirundi. Our dataset contains
diverse, complex questions that reflect cultural topics (e.g. traditions, laws,
news) and the language usage of native speakers. We automatically evaluate a
suite of open- and closed-source models on CaLMQA by detecting incorrect
language and token repetitions in answers, and observe that the quality of
LLM-generated answers degrades significantly for some low-resource languages.
Lastly, we perform human evaluation on a subset of models and languages. Manual
evaluation reveals that model performance is significantly worse for culturally
specific questions than for culturally agnostic questions. Our findings
highlight the need for further research in non-English LFQA and provide an
evaluation framework. | [
0.0680054724,
0.0485052615,
-0.0244154129,
0.0313690491,
-0.0218670219,
0.0153665207,
0.0361575261,
-0.0090736141,
0.0032182871,
-0.0394330658,
-0.015077672,
-0.0798303261,
0.0132622859,
-0.003461343,
0.0227079876,
-0.0490896776,
0.0014458514,
-0.0313457102,
0.030184757,
-0.0137475701,
0.0173514392,
0.021993285,
0.0246106349,
0.0206966549,
-0.0046968306,
-0.025760863,
0.0084739225,
-0.0217556506,
0.0055976328,
-0.0157133378,
0.0223739762,
0.0527569875,
-0.0382161364,
0.0042216592,
0.000001951,
-0.0540453866,
0.0549769737,
-0.0217018351,
0.007570467,
0.0829428509,
0.0212359913,
0.0102170752,
0.0245481469,
0.014363097,
-0.0280493759,
-0.0003962919,
0.025990203,
0.0202390887,
0.0458642729,
0.0321945883,
0.017833909,
0.0062599196,
0.0112963608,
-0.0303004831,
-0.001233195,
-0.0149901239,
0.0245846044,
0.0281165801,
0.0114745516,
-0.0111085996,
-0.0257357135,
0.0240757838,
0.0485972725,
-0.0120803686,
-0.0127198528,
-0.0201032627,
-0.0493804514,
-0.0326399505,
0.0434928909,
0.0594396554,
0.0159369223,
-0.027047161,
0.0064634965,
0.0244134963,
-0.0291075073,
0.016010318,
-0.0527282208,
0.0437106639,
0.0016949805,
-0.0173923131,
0.0181638505,
0.0115074264,
0.0015196908,
0.0325369798,
0.0295942891,
0.0574787818,
0.0254988354,
-0.0040438836,
-0.0425218828,
-0.0195281599,
0.0014724944,
-0.0952441394,
0.0143490313,
0.0514711812,
-0.0254463069,
0.0114194006,
0.0026176986,
0.0002610231,
0.0729003549,
-0.0541200452,
-0.0136098228,
0.0240978766,
-0.0326260589,
0.0412068553,
-0.0379402675,
0.0590881445,
-0.0271980148,
-0.0186691657,
-0.0428234413,
-0.0433537439,
-0.0022412837,
-0.0600700155,
0.0084020486,
-0.0278214794,
-0.0078859525,
0.0099165905,
-0.0265632309,
0.0027178072,
-0.0186531544,
-0.0267717838,
-0.0193900168,
-0.0019624904,
-0.0048511983,
-0.012794774,
-0.0283856224,
0.0605844893,
-0.0775983408,
0.0104289763,
0.0012567916,
-0.0803330839,
0.0220587794,
0.0147835417,
-0.0460508093,
-0.025353536,
0.0141335372,
0.0052041993,
0.0012916891,
0.0223082677,
-0.0452031121,
-0.0204331893,
-0.0039041785,
-0.0433495231,
-0.0214081313,
-0.1198404506,
0.0457248464,
0.0190437343,
-0.0055763726,
-0.0339207426,
0.0344440453,
0.0445746444,
-0.0247653816,
-0.0007118118,
0.0260636359,
0.0551549941,
0.1107416749,
0.0287636388,
0.0434967205,
0.036991138,
0.0343728252,
-0.0028628027,
0.0838601887,
-0.020600047,
0.0217065848,
0.0477470979,
0.005032273,
0.0208202358,
0.0086613586,
0.0924832225,
0.0230480302,
-0.0157922693,
0.0493924543,
0.0558524281,
0.014578254,
-0.0034030816,
0.0130978283,
0.0622491352,
-0.059462212,
0.0362561494,
0.0520628653,
-0.0122952461,
0.0342772938,
0.0031055866,
-0.0229554065,
0.0459400825,
0.0134565039,
-0.012348081,
0.0155671667,
0.070835337,
-0.0529419146,
-0.0436097085,
-0.0180133469,
-0.0013167199,
0.0163343623,
0.0396959297,
0.0019140891,
0.0098937368,
0.0241999701,
0.0541538261,
0.0265439786,
-0.0519655272,
0.0250191577,
-0.0263199452,
0.0718368217,
0.0349130034,
0.0041071745,
-0.0066807671,
0.0182130542,
-0.0275784805,
0.0810784549,
0.0358708017,
0.0479277074,
-0.013281038,
-0.0086309761,
-0.0089750616,
0.0040636831,
0.0216693431,
-0.0119972415,
-0.0043819542,
0.056490235,
0.048083242,
0.0501096323,
-0.0476236679,
-0.0338168852,
0.0064473096,
-0.0517774373,
-0.025138,
0.0117020402,
-0.0069989017,
0.0194836352,
0.0294966586,
-0.0014387349,
0.0230911989,
-0.0027721431,
-0.0388243757,
-0.0350305699,
-0.0143523971,
-0.0527940094,
-0.002944832,
0.0398724601,
-0.0420413353,
-0.0151004065,
0.0274892878,
-0.0201736297,
-0.0351572819,
-0.0041704341,
-0.0384702235,
-0.0171401091,
-0.0571447797,
-0.0397467427,
-0.0008521129,
-0.0055527003,
-0.0413827263,
0.0600956753,
-0.0049902927,
0.0373234227,
0.0338096544,
-0.0276357606,
0.0347605124,
-0.0380175263,
-0.0166399162,
0.0225686077,
0.0002891542,
-0.0213840771,
0.0600279607,
0.0210454687,
-0.03584411,
-0.0168900806,
-0.1017870158,
-0.0018489714,
-0.0173385274,
0.0245835781,
0.0186753478,
0.0402431339,
-0.0216132179,
-0.0185631737,
-0.0992295295,
-0.0481578857,
0.0482004285,
0.0220486503,
0.025462117,
0.0026350929,
0.0019169371,
-0.0325649828,
-0.0376896299,
0.0112518826,
0.0353497714,
-0.0009567931,
-0.0032823309,
-0.041875422,
-0.0169396009,
-0.0660460964,
-0.0415596962,
0.00630495,
-0.0713022202,
-0.0488849916,
0.0204474442,
0.0448152013,
0.0524202622,
0.0404967144,
-0.083080925,
0.0136883911,
0.0172069836,
-0.0227277614,
-0.011289835,
-0.0037891495,
-0.0027640115,
0.0093755545,
-0.0822702199,
0.0094967848,
0.0405713357,
0.0104326764,
-0.0055527142,
-0.0110350456,
-0.0063718492,
-0.0548602082,
-0.0242291931,
-0.0163561758,
-0.0237224028,
-0.0055035544,
0.0741937235,
-0.0176762473,
-0.0190355647,
0.0631868169,
-0.0051219375,
-0.0269728694,
-0.0217647292,
0.0130628161,
-0.0730437487,
0.0486608595,
-0.0314406678,
0.0362269841,
-0.0211587287,
-0.0009315489,
-0.0395297222,
-0.0231286492,
0.0282457992,
-0.0434430987,
0.0346592292,
-0.0276939757,
-0.0110125216,
-0.0321458578,
-0.0460616611,
-0.0372643284,
-0.0454756804,
-0.0223870557,
0.0071452409,
-0.0052863806,
0.0144580239,
0.0400114581,
0.0052959551,
0.0434655137,
-0.0611276999,
-0.0417473167,
0.0194927864,
0.0295942891,
0.0866020992,
0.0632470623,
0.0151215056,
0.0421982557,
-0.0146746896,
0.0334350877,
0.0180241801,
0.0431787521,
0.0103433076,
0.0358096622,
-0.0217788704,
0.0176944509,
-0.0059835128,
-0.0434002019,
0.0053471373,
0.0725440755,
-0.0615821332,
0.0040972908,
0.0957089961,
0.0402588993,
0.0086760679,
0.0012366844,
-0.0837906599,
0.0568697006,
0.0313712545,
0.0626029074,
-0.0790596604,
-0.0041374597,
-0.0145518966,
0.0244265068,
-0.0071681011,
-0.001949092,
0.0270606223,
-0.1280364096,
-0.0029125442,
0.0099356417,
-0.0310816858,
-0.0087523106,
-0.035802938,
-0.040747188,
0.0005743556,
-0.0118070384,
0.0301214196,
-0.0458963141,
0.0195051916,
0.0210036542,
-0.0686697662,
-0.0107152332,
0.0513555184,
-0.0244652312,
0.0230116062,
0.0396568701,
0.0082305316,
-0.0411034673,
-0.017725518,
0.0211280957,
-0.0629550591,
-0.024674071,
0.0129433516,
-0.0109639317,
0.048157908,
-0.0284703225,
-0.0532480329,
0.0550816469,
-0.0200370178,
0.009134545,
0.066858761,
0.0845395699,
0.0233757719,
-0.0208860803,
-0.0134933749,
-0.0089087766,
0.0123387948,
0.0808904693,
0.0359816812,
-0.0630904064,
-0.0431808047,
-0.0059224018,
-0.0358501188,
-0.0186720043,
-0.0615755431,
0.0278423894,
0.0040035676,
0.0065925689,
-0.072726354,
-0.0778523535,
0.0277001765,
-0.0165416636,
0.0096077714,
-0.0017041572,
-0.0199948847,
0.0070917411,
-0.032741908,
0.0350722671,
-0.0397143215,
0.0461736694,
-0.0511601195,
0.0107690711,
-0.0119592864,
-0.0263654068,
0.0090658534,
0.0009834677,
-0.0980503261,
-0.0130108865,
0.000805183,
0.0674286038,
0.0065768603,
-0.0285821818,
0.008839584,
-0.0650174692,
-0.0071627353,
-0.0178929158,
-0.031376861,
0.0120154731,
0.0091660684,
0.023583211,
0.0042744726,
0.0564682446,
-0.0470031053,
0.0220101755,
0.018817205,
0.038354896,
-0.01618612,
-0.0356807262,
0.0000080839,
0.0283265207,
-0.0676925406,
-0.0262521803,
-0.0037417095,
-0.0156760626,
-0.0147370379,
-0.0093769114,
-0.0148280161,
-0.0099308463,
0.0191280022,
0.0140150189,
-0.0186284706,
0.0176470131,
0.0066759931,
-0.0063726897,
0.0150328856,
-0.0502872616,
0.0407952331,
0.0500676781,
-0.007151105,
-0.0164069775,
-0.0007097791,
-0.0373410508,
0.0158774499,
-0.0188545808,
0.0499510951,
-0.028130671,
0.0630206242,
-0.0089817671,
-0.0080170427,
0.025193464,
-0.0237192959,
-0.0153008178,
-0.0572547875,
0.0447912402,
0.0265656523,
0.0575807355,
-0.0219379906,
0.0479355864,
0.0260740761,
-0.0230345074,
-0.0359169245,
-0.0069671003,
0.0254717488,
-0.0290121231,
0.0439489633,
0.0252149049,
-0.0482743233,
0.0115303127,
0.0847780183,
-0.0069088885,
0.0189054366,
0.0234274343,
-0.0103949709,
-0.00589944,
-0.010719521,
-0.0019501161,
-0.0172644183,
-0.0129038682,
0.0073673157,
-0.0609457642,
-0.0380357057,
-0.0039919498,
-0.0155297974,
-0.0097126933,
-0.0052469657,
0.0069111325,
0.0517340899,
0.0108641814,
-0.0123563437,
-0.076766558,
0.0423984639,
-0.0445562601,
-0.003430692,
-0.0063508307,
-6.135199625e-33,
0.0042775446,
-0.0361681543,
-0.008355801,
-0.0054670214,
-0.0011983915,
-0.0185673777,
-0.0233704522,
0.0026842144,
-0.0325543322,
0.0392220803,
-0.0337153859,
-0.0258716941,
0.0030818419,
0.0502881408,
0.0410905853,
-0.0197581295,
0.0035642916,
0.0178605989,
-0.0316020474,
0.0346759483,
0.0275731049,
-0.0015769748,
0.0066320933,
-0.0140734818,
0.0542030446,
-0.0745315328,
0.0183745753,
0.0354406461,
0.0151696093,
0.1071387976,
-0.0251920614,
0.031314306,
0.0402747504,
-0.0148921032,
-0.0054969206,
0.0515173748,
-0.1009291485,
-0.020722501,
0.0276429709,
-0.0029260027,
-0.0363617577,
-0.0440464132,
0.0086235609,
-0.0161286108,
0.0086376155,
-0.0044948449,
0.0340597145,
-0.0459828451,
0.0311132316,
-0.0416712202,
-0.0377136357,
0.0323842429,
0.0117860408,
-0.0101489071,
-0.0540688224,
0.1229932532,
-0.0425558761,
-0.0105726216,
-0.0280907601,
-0.0149365086,
-0.0168662407,
0.04538792,
0.0592430457,
0.0131676551,
-0.0108693717,
0.0294481013,
0.0083222426,
0.0023388283,
-0.0063361982,
-0.0009823011,
-0.0341150686,
-0.0276684687,
0.0597113408,
0.0790740103,
0.0140602654,
-0.015969675,
-0.0738138556,
0.0013331564,
0.0177935995,
0.0140294489,
0.0121789053,
-0.0482370257,
-0.0123843271,
-0.0257082917,
-0.045686923,
0.0352569185,
-0.0237685218,
-0.022297442,
0.0576695874,
-0.0031912497,
-0.0135996388,
-0.0211155321,
0.055256784,
-0.0283119027,
0.0107815573,
0.0343848951,
-0.0036461428,
0.0009503079,
0.0452609621,
0.0405884609,
-0.0400633812,
0.0577564016,
-0.0227500331,
-0.0216913577,
-0.0014693908,
0.0102694752,
0.0311182346,
0.0038973799,
-0.0772892162,
0.0133895902,
-0.0088965474,
0.0284485277,
-0.0239965748,
0.0311521906,
0.0217388831,
0.012417092,
-0.0088149281,
0.0069528283,
0.0093537532,
-0.0201934669,
-0.0344368964,
-0.0473675244,
-0.001592485,
0.0202170629,
-0.0465695001,
0.0194900557,
-0.0433856659,
0.0582792647,
-0.0395665541,
-0.0129171126,
0.0015482814,
0.023414949,
2.437e-7,
0.0415504575,
0.0165869817,
0.0019050643,
0.0155602871,
0.0288725086,
-0.0129147163,
0.0089911809,
-0.0155099314,
0.0057045971,
-0.0017200357,
-0.0308272112,
0.0170138106,
0.0737769827,
0.0464595519,
-0.0895252973,
-0.0088266637,
-0.0875120386,
0.0087885801,
-0.0487364903,
-0.0482420661,
-0.0003641035,
0.0780459121,
-0.0055831927,
-0.0171708316,
-0.0673211887,
-0.058558736,
0.0616970994,
-0.0037101449,
-0.0225391649,
0.0191170722,
0.0146636683,
-0.007872411,
0.0538387187,
-0.009236712,
-0.0272183418,
-0.0146646816,
0.0531303287,
0.0819675177,
0.0172267258,
-0.0041130907,
-0.0135380067,
-0.023475593,
-0.0052392948,
-0.1104890928,
0.0834636763,
0.011556155,
-0.0177173354,
-0.0308226459,
0.0089001833,
-0.0232530497,
0.0428504944,
-0.0059146057,
-0.0061380174,
0.0331206508,
0.034040764,
-0.0117852772,
0.0057104556,
-0.0062029185,
-0.0370973013,
0.0020357443,
-0.0127818696,
-0.0313028619,
-0.0141151492,
-0.0033030843,
-0.0469135419,
-0.0073697339,
0.0201422274,
2.016199875e-34,
0.0291310828,
0.007650116,
0.0042156675,
0.0336701013,
0.0272347033,
-0.0244321749,
-0.0059001488,
0.000329566,
0.028426405,
-0.0616571419,
-0.002466761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17755v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17755v1 | Accelerating Clinical Evidence Synthesis with Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T17:41:52 | 2024-06-25T17:41:52 | Zifeng Wang, Lang Cao, Benjamin Danek, Yichi Zhang, Qiao Jin, Zhiyong Lu, Jimeng Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic medical discovery by AI is a dream of many. One step toward that
goal is to create an AI model to understand clinical studies and synthesize
clinical evidence from the literature. Clinical evidence synthesis currently
relies on systematic reviews of clinical trials and retrospective analyses from
medical literature. However, the rapid expansion of publications presents
challenges in efficiently identifying, summarizing, and updating evidence. We
introduce TrialMind, a generative AI-based pipeline for conducting medical
systematic reviews, encompassing study search, screening, and data extraction
phases. We utilize large language models (LLMs) to drive each pipeline
component while incorporating human expert oversight to minimize errors. To
facilitate evaluation, we also create a benchmark dataset TrialReviewBench, a
custom dataset with 870 annotated clinical studies from 25 meta-analysis papers
across various medical treatments. Our results demonstrate that TrialMind
significantly improves the literature review process, achieving high recall
rates (0.897-1.000) in study searching from over 20 million PubMed studies and
outperforming traditional language model embeddings-based methods in screening
(Recall@20 of 0.227-0.246 vs. 0.000-0.102). Furthermore, our approach surpasses
direct GPT-4 performance in result extraction, with accuracy ranging from 0.65
to 0.84. We also support clinical evidence synthesis in forest plots, as
validated by eight human annotators who preferred TrialMind over the GPT-4
baseline with a winning rate of 62.5%-100% across the involved reviews. Our
findings suggest that an LLM-based clinical evidence synthesis approach, such
as TrialMind, can enable reliable and high-quality clinical evidence synthesis
to improve clinical research efficiency. | Accelerating Clinical Evidence Synthesis with Large Language Models: Automatic medical discovery by AI is a dream of many. One step toward that
goal is to create an AI model to understand clinical studies and synthesize
clinical evidence from the literature. Clinical evidence synthesis currently
relies on systematic reviews of clinical trials and retrospective analyses from
medical literature. However, the rapid expansion of publications presents
challenges in efficiently identifying, summarizing, and updating evidence. We
introduce TrialMind, a generative AI-based pipeline for conducting medical
systematic reviews, encompassing study search, screening, and data extraction
phases. We utilize large language models (LLMs) to drive each pipeline
component while incorporating human expert oversight to minimize errors. To
facilitate evaluation, we also create a benchmark dataset TrialReviewBench, a
custom dataset with 870 annotated clinical studies from 25 meta-analysis papers
across various medical treatments. Our results demonstrate that TrialMind
significantly improves the literature review process, achieving high recall
rates (0.897-1.000) in study searching from over 20 million PubMed studies and
outperforming traditional language model embeddings-based methods in screening
(Recall@20 of 0.227-0.246 vs. 0.000-0.102). Furthermore, our approach surpasses
direct GPT-4 performance in result extraction, with accuracy ranging from 0.65
to 0.84. We also support clinical evidence synthesis in forest plots, as
validated by eight human annotators who preferred TrialMind over the GPT-4
baseline with a winning rate of 62.5%-100% across the involved reviews. Our
findings suggest that an LLM-based clinical evidence synthesis approach, such
as TrialMind, can enable reliable and high-quality clinical evidence synthesis
to improve clinical research efficiency. | [
0.0550547503,
0.0644917637,
-0.0041427845,
-0.0219923593,
0.0029928559,
0.0059361663,
0.0023057987,
0.0114285164,
-0.0313055627,
-0.0095003452,
-0.0119622378,
-0.0142991459,
0.0104143238,
0.0804185644,
0.0102917738,
-0.026838487,
0.0067767762,
-0.0020998551,
0.1029759347,
0.0202546325,
-0.0355502591,
0.0010604342,
0.000574324,
0.0633113459,
0.0166085903,
-0.0167300515,
0.026507562,
-0.0382069722,
0.0156212868,
-0.0750550777,
-0.0272807945,
0.0393085741,
0.0069867033,
0.0401471071,
0.0000020001,
-0.0505708642,
0.0000921359,
0.0606065355,
0.0006987966,
-0.0169239081,
0.0670269132,
-0.0194532257,
0.0019734921,
0.0039141523,
-0.0338174701,
-0.0549294986,
0.0575953424,
0.0414005853,
0.0128267696,
0.0465287417,
-0.0194334034,
-0.0155058019,
0.0484548211,
-0.0412949733,
0.036128372,
-0.0116995024,
0.0434018783,
0.0197142921,
0.0543342866,
0.0039940812,
0.042380739,
0.0224934872,
-0.0030082748,
-0.0363842994,
0.0089933751,
0.0710001364,
-0.0415872261,
-0.0356467254,
0.022118384,
0.06351877,
-0.0020227025,
-0.0329512581,
0.0209819898,
-0.0001483139,
0.0123889372,
0.0457081422,
-0.0662181899,
0.0552720577,
-0.0283759255,
-0.0211970173,
0.0423249602,
-0.014418073,
0.0438114293,
-0.0090854736,
-0.0032924374,
0.0203910917,
0.0053047449,
-0.000458291,
0.0105297547,
0.0194621794,
-0.0053654225,
-0.0638783053,
0.0012859871,
0.0121016521,
-0.0415537953,
-0.0067828097,
0.0222986247,
-0.0340596549,
0.0911434963,
-0.0343614481,
0.0340676345,
-0.0218067579,
-0.0195443146,
0.0494537987,
-0.0103370138,
-0.0323536284,
-0.0325268544,
0.0351160355,
-0.027948115,
0.0154039785,
-0.0535065718,
-0.0224463399,
-0.0206488315,
0.0129119894,
-0.0120693222,
0.0010222322,
-0.0522515923,
-0.0019623071,
-0.0267624836,
0.0107581308,
0.0355080515,
0.0229804646,
-0.0494975857,
0.0002207331,
-0.0155830011,
0.0230108909,
-0.0130519969,
0.0372199342,
-0.0079037994,
-0.014494583,
0.0076483125,
0.0041680438,
0.0058453879,
0.0039317929,
0.0224683955,
0.0358627588,
0.0226135999,
-0.0243682768,
0.0114394287,
-0.0275208931,
-0.0281524472,
-0.065498583,
0.0013241533,
-0.0965854004,
0.0456601828,
-0.0046943729,
-0.0031482852,
-0.028972419,
-0.0092358217,
0.0219175927,
-0.0283760391,
0.0334952958,
-0.08913102,
-0.0063038282,
0.0302335378,
-0.0041265478,
-0.0337828137,
0.0285881236,
0.0344321318,
0.0123580555,
-0.0023706965,
-0.0133550679,
0.025826849,
-0.0216613319,
0.0157396104,
-0.0196701288,
0.0023302417,
0.0118930032,
-0.0003150414,
0.071034275,
-0.0264929105,
0.0595916845,
-0.0403593406,
0.0010628225,
0.0316106826,
0.0720629767,
0.0099648517,
0.0494478308,
0.032258112,
-0.0531143025,
0.0306953005,
-0.0553855971,
-0.0106203444,
0.0253571775,
-0.0120501574,
0.0058960598,
-0.0041695195,
0.0199404135,
-0.0059164315,
-0.0401992127,
-0.0154219633,
-0.0047159698,
-0.0392223038,
-0.0176894497,
0.0363492183,
-0.0084529696,
0.0050658141,
-0.0345766023,
0.0493211634,
0.002328269,
-0.0250664018,
-0.0399212725,
-0.0016785483,
0.0393090993,
0.0689347759,
-0.0492256023,
-0.0014625184,
-0.0455069467,
-0.0055086114,
0.0202570669,
0.0215229727,
-0.0316543989,
-0.0051145968,
-0.0114138341,
-0.0290750396,
-0.0213375185,
0.0158173181,
0.0100923916,
-0.0040265867,
0.0207137596,
-0.0389163867,
-0.0861637741,
-0.0639463291,
0.0352457017,
-0.062610887,
-0.0189014189,
0.0413144007,
-0.0633189902,
0.0466164127,
0.0194165949,
-0.0414737351,
0.0449287407,
0.0403185748,
-0.0484329648,
-0.0496835262,
0.0224642418,
0.0288414564,
-0.0240907725,
0.0357783213,
-0.0671430901,
-0.0206414461,
-0.0427000746,
-0.0589163005,
-0.025144903,
0.0008661638,
-0.0252442248,
0.0267368052,
0.0149692614,
-0.0112945559,
0.0171347987,
-0.0036507174,
-0.0428536572,
0.0534241237,
0.0081539406,
-0.0392213725,
0.0428227633,
-0.083875902,
0.0126858735,
0.0025778783,
-0.0212739818,
0.0495151989,
0.0062873024,
-0.0049416833,
0.0209364202,
-0.0134426998,
-0.0052312217,
-0.016199341,
-0.1014909819,
0.0282659214,
0.0317766666,
0.0048871557,
0.0060609756,
-0.0133573683,
-0.0050994945,
-0.0068672514,
-0.0326247104,
-0.0275395177,
0.0081956247,
0.0207072441,
0.0389551669,
0.072928153,
-0.0130866319,
-0.0949261636,
-0.0239677858,
-0.0351079665,
0.0640744492,
0.0528371371,
-0.0057523539,
-0.0042939,
0.0097458242,
-0.0121411989,
0.0245248526,
-0.0051499559,
0.0183414444,
0.0331362709,
-0.0256355703,
0.011107943,
0.0450922027,
-0.017676549,
0.0113803372,
0.0906406641,
0.0073605548,
-0.0303600486,
0.0112653887,
-0.0308201686,
-0.0118542286,
0.0234984551,
-0.0374577306,
0.0432268828,
0.0457149334,
0.0142202759,
0.0088104596,
-0.0201053005,
0.0077762003,
0.0002182104,
-0.0057753911,
-0.0295982286,
-0.018404562,
-0.0043126219,
0.0305334404,
-0.0186742526,
-0.0571767762,
0.1122331992,
-0.0098101189,
0.0371509306,
-0.0688710809,
0.0251759142,
-0.0326051787,
0.0023283372,
0.0133711528,
0.0044148592,
0.0065291212,
0.0289827939,
-0.0010834443,
-0.0089977803,
0.0359138958,
-0.0213954914,
0.0469339788,
-0.0542841814,
0.0468729958,
0.008245104,
-0.02518766,
-0.0239046738,
-0.0074480255,
-0.0419662111,
0.0042395252,
0.030532008,
-0.0070624207,
-0.0680645555,
0.0058161607,
0.031988427,
0.0641167387,
-0.0214835051,
-0.0204703342,
-0.0024414377,
-0.0316539891,
0.0652839765,
-0.0667579249,
0.0134036206,
0.000688453,
0.0616201386,
0.0567226075,
-0.0093389889,
0.0334663168,
-0.0455705822,
-0.0107430182,
-0.0349224769,
-0.0610146001,
-0.0083393473,
0.0207396448,
-0.0155800106,
-0.0259435046,
0.0037004412,
0.1036733612,
0.0236148853,
-0.1070361808,
-0.0150884772,
-0.0345005356,
-0.0160347614,
-0.0163538717,
0.0262683071,
-0.0731342286,
-0.0195284691,
-0.0071975705,
0.0163016915,
-0.0065117534,
-0.0406273864,
0.0074968426,
-0.0486292094,
0.0467557274,
0.0084036961,
-0.0299595315,
-0.0253142118,
-0.069808729,
-0.0010757484,
-0.0349819064,
-0.0426284149,
-0.0114180669,
-0.0006220508,
0.0180004202,
-0.0100889318,
-0.0422496945,
-0.0995017737,
0.0327536017,
-0.0533735864,
0.0685955063,
0.0466049165,
0.0421773084,
-0.0169882756,
-0.0016128535,
0.0031136177,
0.0063601378,
-0.0052638366,
-0.0093372269,
0.0970463902,
0.0308023971,
0.0346443541,
-0.025678575,
0.0363642313,
-0.0469553024,
-0.0356841199,
0.0357986726,
0.1093226746,
-0.0427466482,
-0.0461233631,
-0.0630160943,
0.0108513385,
0.0033099004,
0.0519247018,
0.0115978466,
0.0086000888,
-0.0025118685,
-0.0118511301,
0.0420819893,
-0.0045676245,
-0.0165810436,
0.0256618802,
-0.0164188836,
0.0102775171,
-0.0646491051,
-0.0245130602,
0.0781356543,
-0.0166260079,
0.0272563193,
0.0382298231,
0.023790434,
-0.0227167681,
-0.04175511,
0.0660204142,
0.0267981347,
0.0193458442,
-0.0373747014,
-0.0382321179,
0.0672149658,
-0.0055557154,
0.0126970122,
0.0454642698,
-0.0115180165,
-0.0125205824,
-0.0456663109,
0.0664247721,
0.018801488,
0.003703871,
-0.0051527554,
-0.021395335,
0.0307485349,
0.0153786847,
0.0157868285,
-0.0679203942,
-0.018628493,
-0.0304898135,
0.0036989965,
-0.0364819169,
-0.0464419276,
0.0393252522,
-0.0110239601,
0.0093374997,
-0.0083056791,
0.0067960061,
0.07018736,
0.0417666882,
0.0527351126,
-0.0519346148,
0.0048134211,
-0.031769149,
-0.0254073255,
-0.0555386432,
0.0141912159,
-0.0359728821,
0.03088893,
0.0265498236,
-0.0029110142,
-0.0053907982,
0.0086082574,
-0.078156516,
-0.0172408652,
-0.0470248759,
0.0503653921,
0.0036039036,
0.0433860794,
0.0639300421,
-0.0257479474,
-0.0095240995,
-0.0356723182,
-0.0428453535,
0.0186656546,
-0.0243400279,
0.0119466437,
0.0058397613,
0.0031788372,
-0.0272411145,
0.0479375087,
-0.0545858219,
-0.0357718468,
-0.0256977566,
-0.0079066288,
0.040358834,
0.01699402,
0.0454714186,
-0.0418099985,
0.0019314107,
-0.0457261577,
0.0189199075,
0.0024418579,
0.0146983778,
0.0170968454,
0.0158959236,
-0.0384905152,
-0.0620862171,
0.097750105,
0.0154285552,
0.0378483608,
-0.0196319204,
-0.0618828535,
-0.0265497826,
-0.0340341441,
-0.0136242239,
0.0331226699,
-0.0459138192,
-0.0169456974,
-0.0598367751,
-0.0221532732,
-0.0152652031,
0.0197501946,
-0.0182718318,
0.0036394882,
-0.0105440076,
0.0399226435,
0.0087934593,
-0.0284096766,
-0.032344386,
0.040828038,
-0.0155777624,
-0.055516798,
-0.0328604467,
-5.44202677e-33,
0.0338255242,
-0.0265162736,
0.0144347185,
-0.0219768006,
0.0253557749,
0.0225048345,
-0.075468123,
-0.0095652817,
0.0202283058,
0.0862068236,
-0.0309866443,
0.0089875041,
-0.0109587861,
0.0122154178,
0.0441203192,
0.0217652302,
0.0414545238,
-0.0096063688,
-0.0060549397,
0.0479482226,
-0.0243332908,
-0.0091471188,
0.0222917702,
-0.039626345,
-0.0079636481,
0.0548369847,
0.0073827296,
-0.0205229763,
-0.0258625634,
0.0720872208,
-0.0266087111,
0.0373300388,
0.0248081312,
-0.0103882225,
-0.0286492482,
-0.0305870157,
-0.0531233065,
-0.0267118737,
0.009181357,
-0.0603526905,
-0.0171098374,
-0.0132471174,
0.0365527011,
-0.010207233,
-0.0077622226,
0.014811689,
0.0389842503,
-0.0599599816,
-0.044740703,
-0.0533732511,
-0.0615028776,
0.0490253419,
-0.0167928226,
0.0145596927,
-0.0213791449,
0.018498905,
-0.007130614,
0.0303157046,
-0.0279153269,
0.0361935087,
0.0238951892,
-0.0054356861,
0.0052600806,
-0.039508231,
-0.002173553,
0.0734420568,
-0.0033880777,
0.0253275,
-0.0018287784,
0.0159823652,
-0.0282544978,
0.0430880077,
0.0430368893,
0.022754062,
0.0304067805,
0.0132007506,
-0.0809401348,
0.07728111,
-0.0592279211,
0.0371057354,
0.0520222746,
-0.0055682096,
-0.0068844105,
-0.0222487878,
-0.014822497,
-0.0341784135,
-0.0221430324,
0.0047449898,
0.024716096,
0.0009493873,
0.0113721322,
-0.0325846933,
0.0431674495,
-0.0158125143,
0.01333375,
0.0369069763,
0.0015336544,
0.0267658904,
-0.0039267768,
-0.0153786289,
-0.0461179614,
-0.0091949189,
0.0365304388,
0.0156450104,
0.0446388349,
0.0207407437,
0.0188301317,
-0.0222072117,
-0.0505512431,
0.0017922686,
-0.0153449364,
0.0161985289,
0.0002489898,
-0.0149226543,
0.0004863843,
0.0194252562,
0.0080850767,
0.0451753624,
0.0187425129,
0.0003838785,
-0.023329908,
0.0112179797,
-0.0057684113,
-0.0117637692,
-0.0134519786,
-0.0009417936,
-0.0293151997,
0.0173536446,
0.0624234602,
-0.0629820675,
-0.008786899,
-0.0134372208,
2.746e-7,
0.097168155,
0.0602273606,
0.0005854247,
-0.0175344255,
0.0497567169,
0.0198042654,
0.0040450073,
-0.0286217742,
0.0301738475,
0.0225128494,
0.0619614013,
0.0177954044,
-0.002823778,
0.0492421165,
-0.0468548909,
-0.0284849871,
-0.0687858388,
-0.042112425,
-0.0543608852,
-0.0473671444,
0.021921128,
0.0525635183,
-0.0276081618,
-0.0128617007,
0.0066108168,
-0.0319198631,
0.0226722695,
-0.0399576053,
0.0176413879,
0.0563249588,
0.043264579,
-0.0138183013,
0.0306230187,
0.0371638238,
-0.0357293487,
0.0058781044,
-0.0194194205,
0.0497085154,
-0.0273004659,
0.0621694401,
0.0436175764,
-0.0177793279,
0.0624557026,
-0.0402474068,
0.0355095454,
-0.0847982988,
-0.0549285561,
-0.0500103459,
-0.0183344148,
-0.0083648991,
0.070773907,
-0.0360788889,
-0.0020886674,
0.0377697758,
-0.0064732186,
0.04327875,
-0.0283974968,
-0.0381741934,
-0.0046509905,
0.0635048524,
-0.0482436791,
-0.0111071309,
-0.0046620485,
-0.0694679692,
-0.0089819515,
-0.0480484404,
0.052691713,
2.517123706e-34,
0.0663231388,
-0.0109794885,
0.0169102289,
-0.005180405,
0.0709240362,
0.0065249014,
-0.0188908968,
0.0171854869,
0.0145796137,
-0.0852677152,
-0.0078071984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17753v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17753v1 | Measuring and Benchmarking Large Language Models' Capabilities to Generate Persuasive Language | 2024-06-25T17:40:47 | 2024-06-25T17:40:47 | Amalie Brogaard Pauli, Isabelle Augenstein, Ira Assent | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We are exposed to much information trying to influence us, such as teaser
messages, debates, politically framed news, and propaganda - all of which use
persuasive language. With the recent interest in Large Language Models (LLMs),
we study the ability of LLMs to produce persuasive text. As opposed to prior
work which focuses on particular domains or types of persuasion, we conduct a
general study across various domains to measure and benchmark to what degree
LLMs produce persuasive text - both when explicitly instructed to rewrite text
to be more or less persuasive and when only instructed to paraphrase. To this
end, we construct a new dataset, Persuasive-Pairs, of pairs each consisting of
a short text and of a text rewritten by an LLM to amplify or diminish
persuasive language. We multi-annotate the pairs on a relative scale for
persuasive language. This data is not only a valuable resource in itself, but
we also show that it can be used to train a regression model to predict a score
of persuasive language between text pairs. This model can score and benchmark
new LLMs across domains, thereby facilitating the comparison of different LLMs.
Finally, we discuss effects observed for different system prompts. Notably, we
find that different 'personas' in the system prompt of LLaMA3 change the
persuasive language in the text substantially, even when only instructed to
paraphrase. These findings underscore the importance of investigating
persuasive language in LLM generated text. | Measuring and Benchmarking Large Language Models' Capabilities to Generate Persuasive Language: We are exposed to much information trying to influence us, such as teaser
messages, debates, politically framed news, and propaganda - all of which use
persuasive language. With the recent interest in Large Language Models (LLMs),
we study the ability of LLMs to produce persuasive text. As opposed to prior
work which focuses on particular domains or types of persuasion, we conduct a
general study across various domains to measure and benchmark to what degree
LLMs produce persuasive text - both when explicitly instructed to rewrite text
to be more or less persuasive and when only instructed to paraphrase. To this
end, we construct a new dataset, Persuasive-Pairs, of pairs each consisting of
a short text and of a text rewritten by an LLM to amplify or diminish
persuasive language. We multi-annotate the pairs on a relative scale for
persuasive language. This data is not only a valuable resource in itself, but
we also show that it can be used to train a regression model to predict a score
of persuasive language between text pairs. This model can score and benchmark
new LLMs across domains, thereby facilitating the comparison of different LLMs.
Finally, we discuss effects observed for different system prompts. Notably, we
find that different 'personas' in the system prompt of LLaMA3 change the
persuasive language in the text substantially, even when only instructed to
paraphrase. These findings underscore the importance of investigating
persuasive language in LLM generated text. | [
0.0463254713,
0.0483291745,
-0.0057436181,
0.0175687317,
-0.0338355377,
0.002426987,
0.0135555305,
0.0009108237,
0.0085552298,
-0.0441887043,
-0.0078761913,
-0.0268836133,
0.0130818039,
0.0037754567,
0.0435895175,
-0.0739563778,
0.0070382534,
-0.002345168,
0.0669151992,
-0.015384445,
0.0461261123,
0.0313906856,
0.0206090249,
0.0629093647,
-0.0128494808,
-0.0395357981,
0.0418510959,
0.0247796904,
0.0143961282,
-0.0439762659,
0.0206793696,
0.0413589589,
0.0157612376,
0.0109674549,
0.0000018508,
-0.0503958352,
0.0256023314,
-0.0084854905,
-0.0315633751,
0.0665245205,
0.1282641888,
-0.0024529919,
-0.0168586019,
0.0216978658,
-0.0307355542,
0.0365238301,
0.0609529354,
0.0474782661,
0.0581615493,
0.0629293695,
-0.0078612324,
-0.0110185323,
0.0120599987,
-0.0321217701,
-0.0161887947,
0.0045274976,
0.0215580333,
-0.031838499,
-0.0270065572,
0.0523269102,
0.0253276303,
0.0247087162,
-0.0049915994,
-0.0064096544,
-0.0016764754,
-0.0002403195,
-0.0085325278,
-0.0062135607,
-0.0173853096,
0.0381936952,
-0.0074076317,
-0.0245259628,
0.0349188298,
0.0031521157,
0.0362112857,
0.0330476686,
-0.0273727179,
0.034961272,
0.0198238492,
0.0177924335,
0.01105751,
0.014562008,
0.0404247753,
0.0230488069,
0.009107531,
0.0343118273,
0.0066824281,
-0.035560105,
0.0488608554,
-0.0181212258,
0.0020758319,
-0.0724312142,
-0.0333016999,
-0.0234612543,
-0.0182342976,
0.0397104323,
-0.0317252204,
-0.0184246115,
0.0499057695,
-0.1132888943,
0.0444492586,
-0.0005265719,
0.0080898497,
0.0128934523,
-0.0124579454,
0.0129446974,
-0.0256261621,
0.0228489898,
0.0096824402,
0.0387320444,
-0.0371368937,
-0.022769846,
-0.0254671723,
0.0015375949,
0.0155522693,
-0.0121285245,
-0.0710593164,
-0.0027691536,
-0.0331476219,
0.0074144537,
-0.0487015396,
0.0121345604,
-0.0135937147,
-0.025608195,
-0.007233053,
0.0637979433,
-0.0465976335,
0.0225691982,
0.0228142366,
-0.0300420355,
0.0310359411,
0.0383793078,
-0.0175515004,
-0.0046492252,
0.0096620908,
0.0408283286,
-0.0068845944,
0.004753632,
-0.0451456271,
-0.023877304,
-0.037697088,
-0.051817622,
-0.0216725916,
-0.062917009,
-0.0046274667,
0.0098258629,
0.0276517682,
-0.0653775632,
0.0314471014,
0.0174557026,
-0.0298534259,
0.0443854108,
0.0193647724,
0.0295343492,
0.0374184996,
0.0309771691,
-0.0158241391,
0.0617363341,
0.0480844788,
0.0847966671,
0.0514960587,
0.0043967413,
0.0339171439,
0.0348198153,
0.0015678866,
0.0245800428,
0.0178785902,
-0.0178519953,
-0.0284161717,
0.0038584436,
-0.0165099297,
0.0667004958,
-0.0035811553,
0.0218247641,
0.099723883,
0.0438503847,
-0.011875594,
-0.0012848901,
0.0321294591,
0.0295264032,
0.0109017976,
0.0058048894,
-0.0264124032,
-0.0274082087,
-0.0316458791,
-0.0091846287,
0.0373408236,
0.0175942685,
-0.017808279,
-0.0367857404,
-0.0159694571,
-0.013744303,
0.0120602865,
-0.0114712361,
0.0076680584,
0.0082369139,
-0.0521117859,
0.0143622924,
0.0549348891,
-0.0432908945,
-0.0105356593,
-0.0254520662,
0.0125657264,
0.0406667218,
0.0112564275,
0.0091876276,
0.0566828586,
-0.0556290187,
0.0475982241,
0.0824928656,
0.0496921316,
-0.0229879599,
-0.0468677133,
-0.0175507031,
-0.0144188069,
-0.0626869127,
0.0295980964,
0.0491316989,
0.0055808853,
0.0198074821,
0.022040749,
-0.0071253804,
-0.0475952961,
0.015580086,
0.0051087961,
-0.0187817756,
-0.0093057826,
0.0229364932,
0.0416599102,
0.0173247308,
-0.0317329131,
0.0027520019,
0.0114811948,
-0.0413719825,
-0.0273940265,
-0.0043428624,
-0.0075649866,
0.0356716886,
0.0080097774,
-0.0219705496,
-0.0110161211,
0.0221884903,
0.0086445296,
0.020711828,
0.0250686556,
-0.0620040707,
0.0736528113,
-0.0075468216,
0.0179199427,
-0.0300841257,
-0.0054339161,
-0.0332824998,
0.0322011933,
0.0335587971,
-0.0257336888,
0.0263678487,
-0.0271263532,
0.0143593773,
0.0192680545,
-0.0043945001,
-0.0281905904,
0.0087097809,
0.014052161,
0.0447369553,
-0.0480613187,
-0.0251508988,
-0.0555697978,
-0.0585024133,
-0.0378789268,
-0.014923838,
0.0064546117,
0.0142357918,
-0.0138344234,
0.0015862242,
0.0542315356,
-0.0691582039,
-0.0503935553,
-0.0093472824,
0.0429900624,
0.02619607,
-0.0002786979,
-0.0202928372,
-0.0187664684,
0.0285812542,
-0.0217014309,
0.0438078344,
0.0552522205,
-0.0372922644,
-0.0346576348,
0.0414691903,
-0.0326927863,
-0.0495841876,
-0.0210167486,
-0.0505375825,
0.0151742026,
0.0408898108,
0.0837626234,
0.0521663837,
0.0403047316,
0.0257389341,
0.0187864136,
0.0453533903,
-0.0646405444,
-0.0370865837,
-0.0430675745,
-0.0010285109,
-0.0626973137,
-0.0818268135,
0.0520766601,
0.0132547831,
0.041181393,
0.0219011959,
-0.0395994037,
0.0678253844,
-0.0050248979,
-0.0458820276,
-0.0134773934,
-0.0348490812,
-0.0139864665,
0.047289744,
-0.0217719525,
-0.0800902694,
0.0431800447,
-0.0341919288,
0.0164195392,
0.012780779,
-0.0188811515,
-0.0110787274,
0.0219180863,
-0.0161333922,
0.0427050106,
0.0038798051,
-0.0100221494,
-0.0083405366,
-0.0711459294,
0.0243739672,
-0.0458490998,
0.0373894162,
-0.0161488205,
0.0011645369,
0.0539219975,
-0.0446291678,
-0.0272715539,
-0.0877831802,
-0.0219204407,
-0.0273366868,
0.0518246517,
-0.0187727772,
-0.034658514,
-0.0225458667,
0.0524766371,
-0.0039775898,
-0.0177332833,
0.0002430378,
0.0027237684,
-0.0218321569,
0.0285462346,
-0.0232950002,
0.0020273787,
-0.0709234402,
0.0138410432,
0.0024183285,
-0.0245460402,
-0.022456944,
-0.0445036292,
-0.047947038,
-0.0156703163,
-0.0143073006,
0.0084773675,
0.010768339,
0.0382652469,
-0.0359592587,
0.0469031036,
0.0714117214,
0.0058472119,
-0.0267017987,
0.0163605995,
-0.0092725176,
0.0330643766,
0.0066368608,
0.0116720041,
-0.0596021749,
-0.0090028886,
0.0004761645,
0.0192135461,
-0.0376048945,
0.0291015115,
-0.0297883786,
-0.0869439021,
0.0477898903,
0.027012594,
0.0414227881,
0.0005436904,
-0.0479148626,
-0.0236408133,
-0.0003869941,
-0.0122346599,
-0.0299136061,
-0.0152034648,
-0.0182003081,
-0.0056588026,
-0.0350614451,
-0.0297087114,
-0.0295833033,
-0.0152503345,
0.0384518877,
0.0944782645,
0.0474640056,
-0.0111003676,
-0.0530426241,
0.0393705517,
0.0279955193,
-0.012668306,
0.0006861974,
0.0608565696,
-0.0092351278,
-0.0053559309,
-0.0261712354,
0.0307303686,
0.0169235617,
-0.0184932016,
0.0218446329,
0.0318196565,
0.0248927604,
-0.0452831909,
0.0119302031,
0.0280079879,
0.0410582945,
0.082781218,
0.037047971,
-0.0535754338,
-0.0006651263,
-0.0545264035,
0.0007323793,
0.0049609011,
-0.0729220808,
-0.0521771684,
-0.0307825189,
0.0121297939,
-0.0584550463,
-0.0242099706,
-0.0157758389,
0.0059221033,
0.0574282221,
0.032532461,
-0.0090077696,
0.0093018487,
0.0254229829,
0.0140524507,
-0.0554548763,
0.0477956459,
-0.059902899,
-0.0373837501,
0.001717633,
-0.0205411278,
-0.0173588339,
-0.0141479727,
-0.0200266,
-0.0770380199,
-0.0135446871,
0.0363132581,
0.0224675257,
0.0222720671,
0.0389278904,
-0.0491112582,
0.074893415,
0.0526525341,
-0.0175442845,
0.0308692083,
0.0369897671,
0.0428484753,
0.0189882871,
0.0153097166,
-0.0036383539,
0.0435369946,
0.0467519052,
-0.0177194308,
-0.0317023247,
-0.0165379047,
0.0320627876,
0.0539821759,
0.0187879559,
-0.0284900349,
-0.0108279791,
-0.0242008511,
-0.0129778013,
-0.0295571964,
-0.0305560566,
-0.0208268203,
0.0108728316,
0.038299799,
0.0060057072,
0.0057889395,
0.0008183248,
-0.0535315573,
0.0274145342,
-0.0233338121,
0.0140499333,
-0.0640883967,
0.0418928638,
0.023172386,
0.0017823048,
-0.0130988462,
0.0503063016,
-0.0144637739,
0.028058216,
0.0212310068,
0.0289583039,
0.0133746536,
-0.0179576464,
0.0086099105,
0.0295560844,
-0.042443309,
-0.0427886173,
0.0058534769,
-0.0081171282,
0.0072290893,
0.0104882875,
0.0801902115,
-0.0316774212,
-0.0034608108,
-0.0235150028,
0.0264186282,
0.0035510939,
-0.0310987681,
0.022641588,
-0.021709105,
-0.0540933646,
0.0075323791,
0.047993511,
-0.0561311096,
0.0369182453,
0.0264356509,
-0.0251190439,
-0.0434102193,
-0.0480256937,
0.036595419,
0.0125526134,
-0.0013721235,
-0.0121910376,
-0.0691613257,
-0.0112328473,
-0.0039769858,
0.0003454699,
0.0005131696,
-0.0341205597,
0.0148449931,
0.0244790595,
-0.0587368757,
0.0201972704,
-0.0555304289,
0.0088141952,
-0.0172088593,
-0.0050880918,
-0.0017453542,
-5.87991017e-33,
0.0082403896,
-0.0110102585,
-0.0331444554,
0.0283314232,
-0.0184541214,
0.00497049,
-0.0134106996,
0.0378752649,
-0.0016119331,
0.0713287368,
-0.0008390378,
-0.0101140356,
0.0073884632,
-0.0060136165,
-0.0341363885,
-0.0113012763,
0.0621061027,
-0.0039410801,
-0.055752486,
0.0450157411,
0.03886142,
-0.0199362133,
-0.0135305729,
-0.0998440608,
0.057693176,
-0.014973294,
-0.0544951074,
-0.04205795,
-0.0050752298,
0.0217743348,
-0.0036689271,
0.0491489358,
0.0130059123,
-0.0370002091,
-0.0062200068,
0.1169186682,
0.0218537785,
-0.0086143734,
0.0773452595,
-0.0551035367,
-0.0186659284,
-0.0651715174,
0.0197074842,
-0.0258633476,
-0.043732699,
0.0295187794,
0.0319905728,
-0.0362290405,
0.0157610644,
-0.0105811441,
-0.0730112046,
0.0046722088,
-0.0268587768,
-0.0171116944,
-0.0417598002,
0.0701295659,
-0.0168073494,
0.0758594051,
-0.0093760137,
0.0523976795,
0.0196677595,
0.0237076972,
0.0330987386,
-0.0168239232,
0.0036275405,
0.0871365964,
0.0007049259,
0.0214482117,
-0.0345811397,
-0.0065156464,
-0.0077945115,
0.0274003036,
0.0727309659,
0.0903863311,
0.0120912967,
-0.0314172357,
-0.0554405935,
-0.0069437991,
0.0511129722,
-0.0525934435,
0.050249245,
-0.036316026,
-0.0247394983,
-0.0372186936,
-0.0631626099,
-0.0406754352,
-0.0202829614,
-0.0683585852,
0.0238208864,
0.0147867585,
-0.0321779475,
0.0298045631,
-0.0094840219,
-0.0395905189,
-0.0332130268,
0.0165149178,
-0.0298496112,
0.0189573076,
-0.0097062783,
-0.012581028,
-0.0644396842,
0.0242633931,
-0.0126858009,
0.0069290069,
0.0329146683,
-0.0021396566,
0.044980213,
-0.0260793176,
-0.0877990127,
0.0148652066,
-0.0208087768,
0.0219434984,
0.0045248885,
-0.0325048044,
0.0171947926,
0.0029491882,
0.0090063214,
-0.0006949167,
-0.0127838207,
-0.0469032004,
0.0037995181,
-0.0140646109,
-0.0204340946,
0.0465853699,
-0.0557472147,
-0.0213670135,
-0.0369017608,
0.0163504314,
0.0450768173,
-0.0602328032,
-0.0174147356,
-0.0650661737,
2.57e-7,
0.011979308,
0.089820236,
-0.0228937659,
0.0267452691,
0.0031667647,
0.0536253117,
-0.0149793662,
0.0028252094,
0.0150469067,
-0.0647202283,
-0.0340207145,
-0.003735336,
0.0503877252,
-0.0051109781,
-0.1048541144,
0.0010537531,
-0.0550784171,
0.0026907981,
-0.0759747326,
0.0072378945,
0.0664748698,
0.0595696531,
0.0456294455,
-0.006442239,
-0.0155119766,
-0.0221178383,
0.0825791061,
-0.0870044902,
-0.0288469773,
0.0468592755,
0.002346175,
-0.0306049418,
-0.0047843428,
0.0161592942,
-0.0108942194,
-0.0099147446,
-0.030782165,
0.0933076292,
0.0351752229,
-0.0103882048,
-0.0071280389,
0.0014254596,
-0.0305243377,
-0.0239810254,
0.025798155,
-0.0389676318,
-0.0363917649,
-0.0518488958,
-0.022650864,
-0.0087760212,
0.0171917677,
-0.0382094495,
-0.0329057276,
-0.017368421,
0.0133182723,
0.0096937036,
-0.0018588343,
-0.0331669748,
-0.0015708121,
-0.0198730379,
-0.0137138152,
-0.0808691233,
-0.0372140668,
0.0327103361,
0.0123602552,
-0.0633338615,
0.0304676276,
2.21358581e-34,
0.0657182857,
-0.0388681404,
0.020866625,
-0.0168346465,
0.0369583108,
0.0326648355,
0.0368766263,
-0.0084683606,
0.0090680355,
-0.0754501969,
0.0280447956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17746v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17746v1 | Recite, Reconstruct, Recollect: Memorization in LMs as a Multifaceted Phenomenon | 2024-06-25T17:32:16 | 2024-06-25T17:32:16 | USVSN Sai Prashanth, Alvin Deng, Kyle O'Brien, Jyothir S V, Mohammad Aflah Khan, Jaydeep Borkar, Christopher A. Choquette-Choo, Jacob Ray Fuehne, Stella Biderman, Tracy Ke, Katherine Lee, Naomi Saphra | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Memorization in language models is typically treated as a homogenous
phenomenon, neglecting the specifics of the memorized data. We instead model
memorization as the effect of a set of complex factors that describe each
sample and relate it to the model and corpus. To build intuition around these
factors, we break memorization down into a taxonomy: recitation of highly
duplicated sequences, reconstruction of inherently predictable sequences, and
recollection of sequences that are neither. We demonstrate the usefulness of
our taxonomy by using it to construct a predictive model for memorization. By
analyzing dependencies and inspecting the weights of the predictive model, we
find that different factors influence the likelihood of memorization
differently depending on the taxonomic category. | Recite, Reconstruct, Recollect: Memorization in LMs as a Multifaceted Phenomenon: Memorization in language models is typically treated as a homogenous
phenomenon, neglecting the specifics of the memorized data. We instead model
memorization as the effect of a set of complex factors that describe each
sample and relate it to the model and corpus. To build intuition around these
factors, we break memorization down into a taxonomy: recitation of highly
duplicated sequences, reconstruction of inherently predictable sequences, and
recollection of sequences that are neither. We demonstrate the usefulness of
our taxonomy by using it to construct a predictive model for memorization. By
analyzing dependencies and inspecting the weights of the predictive model, we
find that different factors influence the likelihood of memorization
differently depending on the taxonomic category. | [
-0.0145433759,
0.0112044932,
-0.0447326452,
0.0228190403,
-0.0550800674,
0.0135329803,
-0.0640933514,
0.006180427,
-0.0227598324,
-0.0260270331,
-0.0129064787,
-0.0530650802,
0.0602273829,
-0.0132455537,
0.0318234712,
-0.0440001152,
0.0341428109,
-0.0599135011,
-0.0180647932,
-0.0135714058,
-0.0230452083,
-0.0385360457,
-0.027386494,
-0.0050677354,
-0.005071613,
0.0120856054,
-0.0145892026,
-0.0298844073,
-0.0304767825,
-0.029706724,
-0.0083533777,
0.0358020365,
0.0241961312,
-0.00849149,
0.0000016356,
-0.0615269877,
-0.0082351556,
-0.0565352961,
-0.0256765317,
0.0171526838,
-0.0099303434,
0.0168428142,
0.0055454089,
-0.0198186859,
-0.008882652,
-0.0110560125,
0.023674408,
0.0108402744,
-0.0317378864,
0.0348056629,
0.0094937887,
-0.0040853773,
0.0158642884,
-0.0084232949,
0.0431177504,
0.0289206021,
0.028476093,
0.0199548583,
-0.0239461213,
-0.0318229869,
-0.0388106778,
0.0266063232,
0.0003309899,
0.0849445984,
0.0262862109,
0.0409160927,
0.0809480399,
0.0151673658,
0.0001306682,
-0.0030295146,
0.0394907109,
-0.038951654,
0.017574355,
0.025296079,
0.0030125189,
0.0395300649,
-0.0729059428,
0.0404627696,
-0.0143863214,
-0.0002889335,
0.0149271823,
-0.0013056828,
0.0343973972,
0.0007030996,
0.0019193841,
0.0204461217,
0.0241614375,
-0.0286566876,
-0.0270957444,
0.010413412,
0.0349694081,
-0.0464873239,
-0.0033359975,
0.063826099,
0.0082673905,
0.0564925857,
0.0350644328,
-0.0220849887,
0.0665486231,
-0.0069626626,
0.0674850941,
0.0207923241,
0.0160725471,
-0.0141364411,
-0.0627927259,
0.0733458698,
0.0169793162,
0.0032461591,
-0.0125876842,
0.0311933961,
-0.0762258917,
-0.0326761305,
0.0063004182,
0.0620809458,
0.0912994072,
0.0094414083,
-0.0439214669,
0.0221662559,
0.0273301639,
-0.0278846808,
-0.0275860038,
-0.0101297097,
0.0003850048,
0.0099604223,
-0.0363084637,
0.0046033314,
-0.0306890402,
0.0479337126,
0.0307580158,
-0.0426922888,
-0.0270553827,
-0.0143391239,
-0.0233355667,
0.0039382405,
-0.0267457217,
0.0121884625,
-0.0058480492,
-0.0413234271,
-0.058821205,
-0.0584229231,
-0.02260332,
-0.0429569148,
0.03544816,
-0.0535642542,
-0.0161019769,
0.0151743796,
0.0210370254,
-0.0163505655,
-0.024705058,
-0.001675093,
-0.0079923412,
0.0188380349,
0.0886571109,
0.0350961573,
0.0222517587,
0.0345922485,
-0.0016237175,
0.0212667603,
0.023545213,
-0.0001319859,
0.0095382938,
-0.0267217327,
0.0351033174,
0.0363709293,
0.0059006209,
-0.0099484129,
-0.0297150072,
-0.048551593,
0.0178103987,
0.0235046726,
0.0726174489,
0.039485272,
-0.0410720222,
-0.0231386758,
0.0579612926,
0.085110262,
0.0313198008,
0.0056644175,
0.0256777015,
-0.0357472301,
0.0336953998,
0.0689772069,
-0.0149305575,
0.0396228768,
-0.0043454752,
0.056288369,
0.0021501465,
0.0075540296,
-0.0438480526,
-0.0025269401,
-0.019859327,
-0.0374496654,
-0.0086517921,
-0.0100609986,
0.020971518,
0.0195461605,
-0.0421593599,
0.0681140795,
0.0040487074,
-0.0541402176,
0.0230105836,
-0.0562499799,
0.0567550436,
0.0556509271,
0.0351249166,
0.0123912469,
-0.0057871914,
0.034731742,
-0.0374897085,
-0.0259573981,
0.0053683366,
-0.011362046,
0.001842898,
-0.041306451,
-0.0157282185,
0.0381749272,
0.0290417317,
0.0468487516,
0.0015413879,
-0.0033343304,
-0.0140239894,
-0.0168255027,
0.0115540382,
0.0183038488,
-0.0455945991,
-0.0437605307,
-0.0237734914,
-0.0068872222,
0.0398501009,
-0.0001009783,
0.0409251787,
0.0394797251,
0.0631930083,
0.0086470209,
0.0055386182,
-0.0050610453,
-0.1015075222,
-0.0273931287,
0.0205459371,
0.0148268864,
0.0301707573,
0.0240545943,
0.0242139213,
-0.0675623566,
0.0356088243,
-0.0400052033,
0.1018435359,
-0.0219935086,
0.0416410603,
0.0048044045,
-0.0032762715,
-0.0450566523,
0.0517901517,
-0.0593685061,
0.0390800014,
0.0202138796,
-0.0245501474,
-0.0142480824,
-0.0766101927,
-0.0116659608,
0.0101380283,
-0.0150318937,
0.0205269568,
0.0071030492,
-0.0697810501,
-0.067171149,
-0.0291889552,
-0.0351609364,
-0.0226253681,
0.0026628245,
0.0240162909,
0.0148505969,
-0.0248970669,
-0.0130203664,
0.0036977322,
-0.0305945911,
0.0123134209,
-0.0010924541,
0.0726722032,
-0.0005763568,
-0.0276903547,
-0.0131901316,
-0.0362313204,
-0.0288711879,
-0.0150993848,
0.0235801674,
-0.0258468725,
-0.008898708,
-0.0344087817,
0.025149215,
-0.0347298346,
-0.03371346,
-0.0146824075,
0.0225957092,
0.0339179337,
-0.0015644751,
0.1079012901,
0.0583263859,
0.0067899004,
0.014604331,
0.0576368943,
-0.0514966547,
-0.040865317,
-0.0637618229,
-0.0591282845,
-0.0416217893,
0.0035305333,
-0.0467646345,
-0.0038549695,
0.0893548951,
0.0597361363,
0.0152828926,
0.0116951233,
-0.04084884,
-0.0158145241,
0.010318392,
-0.0243256297,
-0.0330555923,
-0.0919920802,
0.0464947596,
0.0010003782,
-0.0664238855,
0.0246144272,
-0.035209246,
0.020751385,
0.0056705442,
0.0213154517,
0.0186044406,
0.0413812585,
-0.0016529392,
-0.0160641205,
0.0144897886,
-0.0540470742,
-0.0495895594,
-0.0151821338,
0.0357026979,
-0.0589110889,
0.0405667238,
-0.0391607247,
-0.0183787942,
0.0244931243,
0.0249196682,
-0.0583576411,
0.084158577,
-0.0054794531,
0.0068721687,
-0.0390326083,
0.0167068541,
-0.0430599451,
-0.019401066,
0.0557139181,
-0.0132035334,
0.0029402489,
-0.0107838735,
-0.0071483655,
0.0466953963,
0.0454416387,
0.0031817346,
-0.0047094095,
-0.0364944339,
-0.0129552828,
0.0403885171,
0.0549423806,
0.0275875293,
-0.0029457167,
0.0392335206,
0.0424408428,
-0.0352505706,
-0.0271777827,
0.0755461752,
-0.0146175213,
-0.0410485528,
0.0090897689,
0.075659588,
0.0076711923,
-0.0476876572,
0.0107336743,
-0.0327440463,
0.0887401551,
0.0034329789,
-0.0442018583,
-0.0230517071,
0.0123872217,
0.0380045362,
-0.0022624012,
-0.0138489855,
-0.0094630206,
0.0025489696,
-0.0817268938,
-0.020662548,
0.032289803,
-0.0659126118,
-0.0157861672,
-0.0603747405,
-0.0150022572,
0.0114245722,
0.0066278949,
0.0589837059,
-0.0392024815,
0.0253468044,
0.0507110693,
-0.0613977127,
-0.0214338526,
0.0283146035,
-0.0107170437,
0.0421702974,
0.0458932221,
-0.0180952251,
0.0180945471,
-0.0660913661,
0.0122547457,
-0.0479949377,
0.0227606334,
-0.0103923092,
0.0278350823,
0.0180381872,
0.0220388621,
-0.0453908928,
0.0307717714,
-0.0351690762,
-0.0180435311,
0.0068187951,
0.0878808424,
-0.0114495112,
-0.008305693,
-0.0008738612,
-0.013804893,
-0.0287989657,
0.0890121534,
0.0672698021,
0.008222403,
0.0077293958,
-0.0068591805,
0.0394849591,
-0.0329969339,
-0.040139813,
0.0043372228,
-0.0291899219,
-0.0240601804,
-0.0984917879,
-0.0435063094,
0.0043421099,
0.0202816781,
0.0297738239,
0.0559199043,
0.0112115592,
-0.060048271,
-0.0516548567,
0.003588459,
-0.0523311719,
-0.0081293834,
-0.0617239773,
-0.0499877818,
0.0286946986,
-0.0311286151,
0.000442981,
-0.0088866949,
-0.0709355921,
-0.0469534025,
0.0269322004,
0.0690722466,
0.0317300893,
0.0423779078,
0.0697188154,
-0.0223479308,
0.0471179858,
-0.0512611754,
-0.002752058,
0.037885122,
-0.0056730662,
-0.0044647944,
-0.0169102345,
0.0059284004,
-0.0076110023,
-0.0077058887,
0.0122015858,
0.0180673786,
-0.0239249002,
-0.0352323391,
0.0247802064,
-0.0080101807,
0.0458447412,
-0.0019291475,
-0.0086970301,
-0.005936611,
-0.0168423504,
0.0285173934,
0.0334037915,
0.0176506937,
0.0099815056,
0.0321087353,
0.0332025997,
-0.005910296,
-0.0865213722,
-0.0295067243,
0.0298510771,
0.0110345101,
-0.0268683769,
-0.0134967435,
-0.0058643054,
0.0056652511,
0.0466726385,
-0.0247362647,
0.029324621,
-0.06180197,
0.0326366015,
0.0261872597,
0.0255253222,
-0.0198270734,
0.0277543664,
-0.0325901322,
-0.0371514894,
-0.039747376,
-0.0161580946,
0.0057823821,
-0.0275194757,
0.0291068405,
-0.0711598098,
0.0463249423,
-0.0552192777,
0.0497338697,
-0.0597003996,
-0.0034757094,
-0.011604242,
0.006488469,
0.0284103286,
0.0279943701,
-0.0036745595,
0.016711574,
0.1001646668,
-0.0174233299,
0.0245965607,
-0.0131078297,
-0.0065506524,
-0.0323607326,
-0.05400341,
0.0533726253,
0.0221887771,
-0.0250037946,
-0.0543002337,
-0.0532223135,
-0.0520386547,
0.0483600013,
-0.0279793702,
0.058204446,
-0.0442179218,
0.0527799204,
0.0429021791,
-0.0532421134,
0.0309324078,
-0.0268049054,
0.04047212,
-0.0058039767,
-0.019490594,
-0.0181750022,
-5.698405026e-33,
-0.00679253,
-0.0058941008,
0.0594297536,
0.0242539924,
-0.0205825716,
0.0148250945,
-0.0463015325,
0.0570462085,
-0.0016694841,
-0.0453825481,
0.0066631832,
-0.0428523943,
0.0201746896,
0.0259041972,
0.0607208908,
0.0014638044,
0.0128235184,
-0.0099973567,
-0.0320286416,
0.0043721679,
0.0607328825,
0.0349644348,
0.0487132296,
0.0127388416,
0.0363282077,
-0.0335340872,
0.0439649001,
-0.0201541372,
-0.0454652868,
0.0649954528,
-0.0499371402,
0.0321153961,
0.0512276664,
-0.038076546,
-0.0700193718,
0.0150426226,
-0.0706627741,
-0.0239146538,
0.0622177869,
0.0030143745,
-0.0114460774,
-0.0373875611,
0.0646689162,
-0.033426892,
-0.031342607,
-0.0042753932,
0.027224917,
-0.0356836319,
-0.0976982936,
-0.000360132,
-0.0217240583,
-0.0210910998,
0.032618992,
-0.0350292325,
0.0088173589,
0.0030190367,
-0.0215513036,
0.0371640436,
-0.0603735521,
0.0715049058,
-0.0192519855,
0.080568105,
0.0314284116,
0.0509696789,
0.0258853119,
0.0573869869,
0.048503194,
-0.0365242809,
0.0056498991,
0.0050357538,
0.0350710377,
0.0015690298,
0.0225290246,
0.0038087687,
0.0805866793,
-0.0103470739,
0.0194115359,
0.0154457763,
0.0056278063,
0.0309772156,
0.0379895493,
0.0276458897,
-0.0252969991,
-0.0321873687,
-0.023350453,
0.0332625732,
-0.028856013,
-0.0206585508,
0.0199696198,
0.0030773082,
0.01478111,
-0.0312114004,
0.0605429225,
0.0079152854,
-0.0034002757,
-0.0262541547,
-0.0048912615,
-0.0022524248,
-0.0142807607,
-0.007690568,
-0.0703209788,
-0.0028250183,
0.0014714735,
-0.0052237092,
-0.0239546653,
0.0537225865,
0.0166382995,
0.0188261978,
-0.0441939645,
-0.0229655821,
-0.0338881463,
-0.0403549448,
0.0222418178,
-0.0227267388,
0.0428084917,
-0.0003768174,
-0.0058190287,
0.0359925292,
-0.02277321,
-0.0712836087,
-0.0271902401,
-0.0011250427,
-0.062387336,
0.0315273069,
-0.0198065564,
-0.0082494989,
-0.0264039952,
0.0149402115,
0.0454606973,
0.0175747797,
0.0340614207,
-0.0138577055,
2.371e-7,
-0.0019806609,
-0.0057415352,
0.0174049735,
-0.017143961,
0.0342964008,
-0.0038826261,
-0.054498788,
-0.0079286611,
0.0300936792,
-0.0324397758,
0.0196980163,
0.0444137603,
0.0504530966,
-0.0291144028,
-0.0483121909,
-0.0235947296,
-0.0470330268,
0.0214264989,
-0.0196201392,
0.0120975161,
-0.0020869568,
0.0258573629,
0.0161520373,
-0.0259676743,
-0.0133841792,
-0.0146851679,
0.0642909333,
-0.0545063913,
-0.0086770784,
-0.0224457625,
0.0467158034,
0.0284263548,
0.0232353806,
0.0293174051,
-0.0036703392,
-0.0206485055,
-0.0017175542,
0.0146992654,
0.0380424075,
-0.0595624149,
0.0054466212,
0.0062772674,
-0.02719176,
-0.0169072878,
-0.0001537177,
-0.0084019089,
-0.0067219902,
0.0169846676,
0.0016689888,
0.0292834751,
0.0207677949,
0.0307486523,
-0.0171523411,
0.0110446448,
-0.0241228361,
0.0412067696,
-0.0003080792,
-0.0481240861,
0.0052502109,
0.0111498898,
-0.054840114,
-0.0601724461,
-0.0249340851,
-0.0303138886,
0.0230600461,
-0.0733152851,
-0.0447654314,
1.664586785e-34,
-0.002074759,
-0.0188425146,
0.0482756719,
0.0585234836,
-0.0079895994,
-0.0649355799,
-0.0089699263,
0.0714004487,
0.0190412384,
-0.0578757375,
-0.0298308972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17744v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17744v1 | Following Length Constraints in Instructions | 2024-06-25T17:29:52 | 2024-06-25T17:29:52 | Weizhe Yuan, Ilia Kulikov, Ping Yu, Kyunghyun Cho, Sainbayar Sukhbaatar, Jason Weston, Jing Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aligned instruction following models can better fulfill user requests than
their unaligned counterparts. However, it has been shown that there is a length
bias in evaluation of such models, and that training algorithms tend to exploit
this bias by learning longer responses. In this work we show how to train
models that can be controlled at inference time with instructions containing
desired length constraints. Such models are superior in length instructed
evaluations, outperforming standard instruction following models such as GPT4,
Llama 3 and Mixtral. | Following Length Constraints in Instructions: Aligned instruction following models can better fulfill user requests than
their unaligned counterparts. However, it has been shown that there is a length
bias in evaluation of such models, and that training algorithms tend to exploit
this bias by learning longer responses. In this work we show how to train
models that can be controlled at inference time with instructions containing
desired length constraints. Such models are superior in length instructed
evaluations, outperforming standard instruction following models such as GPT4,
Llama 3 and Mixtral. | [
0.0547591336,
0.026830608,
-0.0030776972,
0.0122395763,
-0.011256773,
0.0137352673,
0.0047924113,
-0.003930314,
-0.0043463842,
-0.0281171557,
-0.0217548218,
-0.0581691377,
-0.0092038121,
-0.0192984901,
0.0044334265,
-0.0772672743,
0.0421232916,
-0.0250414666,
-0.003878773,
0.0091280183,
0.0266778655,
-0.0020609559,
-0.0251885019,
0.019900769,
0.0051579094,
-0.0201220661,
-0.0629594028,
0.0225042962,
-0.0176677871,
-0.0394131504,
0.0337836593,
0.0422224663,
0.0162983593,
0.0106620258,
0.0000017722,
-0.0395868272,
0.0022149901,
-0.015159376,
-0.0609531216,
0.0436426774,
0.0056137117,
-0.0011182426,
0.0088779982,
0.0343738869,
-0.0201310571,
0.0371109657,
0.0563199595,
0.0533879139,
0.0404976159,
0.0689573586,
0.011047177,
-0.0239136834,
0.00708126,
-0.0679877773,
0.0403513499,
-0.0384130068,
-0.0089470344,
-0.0212658569,
0.0480699465,
0.0522762798,
-0.0369908474,
-0.0081061451,
0.0466685295,
0.0306865573,
-0.0286028497,
0.0158016142,
0.0136066852,
-0.0009810246,
-0.0459891334,
0.0719851479,
0.0011894058,
0.0223736148,
0.0117878634,
-0.0349588245,
0.0319846347,
-0.0208327342,
-0.0284614004,
-0.0172228143,
-0.0267132632,
-0.0086554214,
-0.0204481818,
0.0385137312,
-0.0137412157,
-0.0514744781,
-0.0023816666,
0.0699894503,
-0.0137234619,
-0.0619359612,
-0.0190510582,
-0.0229128897,
0.0096648037,
-0.0311194621,
-0.0262407903,
0.0562995449,
-0.033257246,
0.0213231165,
-0.0261611715,
0.0250506289,
0.0297110435,
-0.0308744125,
0.0470281802,
0.0628958493,
-0.0072626104,
0.0060236203,
-0.023282513,
0.0869209766,
-0.0253057685,
0.0184792485,
-0.0651944652,
0.0880911946,
-0.0400717817,
-0.0023066278,
-0.0348854251,
0.0233664121,
-0.0591067448,
-0.0064630085,
-0.0557343662,
0.0449015684,
0.0028942132,
0.032716047,
0.0190315284,
0.0097998977,
-0.0491165742,
0.0070654578,
-0.0525146164,
0.0253489725,
-0.0593960062,
0.0034760777,
0.002959426,
-0.0238218587,
-0.0129028196,
0.000665235,
-0.0201768205,
-0.0228320509,
0.0258407127,
0.1005897969,
-0.0054091751,
-0.0116140069,
-0.025858514,
-0.0362492092,
-0.0089597031,
-0.0528324507,
0.0214640256,
-0.027357582,
0.0396924987,
-0.0161319412,
-0.0057728798,
0.0161003117,
0.0080228364,
0.0406833403,
-0.002799947,
0.0623783991,
0.057284195,
0.0005098333,
-0.0133999996,
0.0225373935,
0.0121477731,
0.0442411266,
0.0238386691,
0.0561820976,
0.0327056199,
-0.0318367518,
0.0339926369,
0.039448943,
0.0116970455,
-0.0048328936,
0.0286339391,
0.0265575424,
0.0078321248,
-0.0094396109,
0.0440551527,
0.0477864891,
0.0038578007,
-0.0442875735,
0.0257037189,
0.0468816981,
0.0298995059,
-0.0332631208,
0.0813705996,
0.0006638647,
-0.0379132368,
0.078667447,
-0.072601527,
0.0347481184,
0.003274566,
0.0493115522,
0.0267182067,
0.0032483856,
-0.0458174124,
-0.0498444587,
-0.0120873498,
-0.0201330874,
0.0006179293,
0.0079504224,
0.0080780452,
-0.0426694453,
-0.0889063925,
0.0191085413,
0.0125814378,
-0.0209922828,
-0.0421628915,
-0.066339381,
0.0109479297,
0.0872298926,
0.0095185647,
-0.0233619008,
-0.0375082158,
-0.0100022787,
0.0012262763,
0.0195762366,
0.0333995149,
-0.0219691936,
0.0272160526,
-0.0365811102,
-0.0342939571,
-0.0287031289,
0.0063378466,
0.0252293143,
0.024204677,
-0.0140872775,
0.0366983078,
0.0029743612,
-0.0043301512,
0.0323336571,
-0.0005545683,
-0.1076067239,
-0.0436244421,
0.0368498527,
0.0364539996,
-0.0050237472,
0.0149654113,
0.0113127697,
0.0299079325,
-0.0102171721,
0.0395411104,
-0.0323248431,
-0.0787420347,
-0.0342358686,
0.021765653,
-0.000321091,
0.0476997681,
0.0093040243,
-0.0373909585,
-0.0277664643,
0.0089185331,
-0.049742844,
0.0432868451,
0.0393858626,
0.0191996396,
0.0304277409,
-0.0315996408,
-0.0497907512,
0.0326822065,
-0.0402565561,
0.0192725472,
0.0321685039,
-0.0180684309,
0.0212540869,
-0.064759396,
-0.0018237151,
0.0133450041,
0.0001659818,
-0.0221906248,
0.0188233294,
0.0153597519,
-0.0174016245,
-0.0305258427,
-0.0816256255,
0.0188310463,
-0.0115099037,
0.0456958562,
0.0034688746,
0.0243281275,
-0.0130355759,
-0.042480953,
-0.0401519313,
-0.0669034272,
0.002946411,
0.0059771626,
0.0103260726,
0.0535546951,
-0.0771089494,
-0.0505495556,
-0.0210959651,
-0.0280778501,
-0.0040313345,
-0.0197610334,
-0.0067317877,
-0.0640308186,
0.0010943174,
0.0097903376,
0.0555444434,
-0.031667985,
-0.0476627387,
0.0261303429,
0.0149897765,
0.0330469497,
0.1064897999,
0.0009608476,
0.041462291,
0.0066007604,
0.006065595,
-0.040780928,
0.0594900325,
-0.0397712439,
-0.031059185,
-0.0094736172,
-0.048212219,
0.0232648123,
0.0820238516,
-0.0006352683,
0.0387527198,
-0.0887127221,
-0.0390306413,
0.0206679199,
-0.0094422372,
0.0194658674,
-0.0169560462,
-0.0392881297,
0.0092308093,
-0.0316219367,
-0.0928780138,
0.0612648465,
-0.054409463,
0.0014291082,
-0.0200746134,
-0.0056965598,
-0.0137932496,
0.0571601391,
0.0263809934,
0.0043381695,
-0.0138500379,
-0.0142870992,
-0.0462909266,
0.0171023812,
0.0172188208,
-0.0382482558,
0.0318447426,
-0.0288037099,
-0.0188082978,
-0.0325391255,
-0.0239476468,
-0.0292356946,
-0.0460814312,
0.0248635802,
-0.0189192519,
0.0437341332,
-0.0104816724,
-0.0055668484,
0.0224843211,
0.015802715,
0.0421594866,
-0.0295695066,
0.0197287444,
-0.0311283953,
-0.0476171337,
0.0581241325,
-0.0148249445,
-0.0462993421,
-0.0557188019,
0.0201528054,
0.0232900232,
0.0361844152,
-0.0166620426,
-0.0370780863,
0.0053553726,
0.014656825,
-0.0315549038,
-0.0155701106,
0.0742675513,
0.0870371088,
-0.0316779576,
0.0248600002,
0.082797192,
0.0267625134,
-0.0302266944,
0.0197492782,
-0.01155023,
0.0409023948,
0.0181277413,
0.0444479622,
-0.0779809356,
-0.0284879319,
-0.0122839483,
0.0609829687,
-0.001141596,
0.0105226794,
-0.0201325472,
-0.1127380952,
-0.0033670394,
0.0039057154,
-0.0166122541,
-0.0532690585,
-0.0261940286,
-0.0085913604,
0.0125543987,
0.0112278592,
0.0216789246,
-0.0478988402,
0.0026869194,
0.0576262474,
-0.0164174642,
-0.0224494915,
0.0342849456,
-0.011585501,
0.0646040514,
0.0774799734,
-0.0332638398,
0.0279810093,
-0.0433490388,
0.011440455,
-0.0171995983,
0.0356572531,
0.0040300069,
0.061556235,
-0.0233273935,
0.0146984737,
-0.0140911518,
0.0407056548,
-0.0043468117,
0.0260559674,
0.0300265588,
0.0499537252,
-0.0147160925,
0.0093259513,
-0.0378110744,
0.006540745,
0.0348810889,
0.0463701636,
0.015512039,
-0.0358672999,
-0.048030246,
-0.0357514545,
-0.0363990776,
-0.0705287978,
0.0328095146,
0.0052267853,
-0.0564363748,
0.0119944299,
-0.033367496,
-0.0745992735,
-0.0061691618,
0.0515521392,
0.0272128265,
-0.0182629246,
-0.0032405837,
0.0109002115,
-0.0134026008,
0.0032075755,
0.0134875104,
0.0330154151,
-0.0982082114,
-0.0236415137,
0.0095343208,
-0.0111311907,
0.0108257197,
0.0107951155,
-0.088333793,
-0.0656496584,
-0.0396759883,
0.1065542325,
0.0289581437,
0.0652515814,
0.0147537515,
0.0056224153,
-0.0425310768,
-0.0029979974,
-0.0256212559,
0.016026428,
0.0310832672,
0.0063290703,
-0.0215724893,
-0.0207807999,
-0.0446137749,
0.0422836095,
0.0066408631,
0.011614236,
-0.0541088954,
-0.0348374657,
0.019396523,
0.0021286849,
-0.0178605095,
-0.0144353621,
-0.0092766024,
0.0126336552,
0.0729631484,
-0.0165144764,
0.0159831606,
-0.0223045927,
0.0056671854,
-0.0104058823,
-0.0250033978,
0.019698197,
-0.0781973675,
-0.0446623564,
-0.0183670484,
-0.0614188984,
0.0523647033,
-0.0088474602,
0.0047818865,
0.0155652193,
0.0061615431,
-0.0248564277,
0.0244759899,
0.0095971385,
0.055071827,
0.0207281727,
0.0799008012,
0.0273882169,
0.0437122881,
-0.0320938006,
0.0403442234,
-0.0223627407,
0.004942535,
-0.0455135815,
-0.0254159719,
0.0138508985,
-0.0427446216,
-0.016183177,
0.0371395536,
0.0384222306,
-0.0193689689,
0.0556934439,
-0.0078254575,
-0.009275428,
0.016936373,
0.0535639301,
0.0180995315,
-0.0404519141,
0.0758239105,
0.0152233345,
0.0499734096,
-0.0160827525,
-0.018922409,
-0.063043341,
-0.0374672972,
0.0263969433,
0.0149839884,
-0.0032347883,
-0.0063487636,
-0.0174935888,
-0.0322147347,
-0.0347607508,
0.0272962842,
0.0466343611,
-0.021915134,
0.0660392269,
0.0385114141,
-0.0068858415,
-0.0689945891,
-0.0008863414,
-0.0421900749,
-0.0087036509,
0.0058569536,
-0.0493831933,
-5.499216406e-33,
-0.0296285134,
-0.0020107545,
0.0457201973,
-0.0078873783,
-0.0432191417,
-0.0086276662,
-0.0094763506,
-0.0007928602,
0.0015483897,
-0.042149581,
-0.0058616786,
-0.0210440997,
0.0234062616,
-0.0159866624,
0.0224527922,
-0.0149193723,
0.0432872288,
-0.0173171274,
-0.0605230927,
0.0236596651,
0.0120979575,
-0.017329162,
0.0226688553,
-0.0221017245,
0.0290189516,
-0.00865799,
0.0145926988,
-0.0089180646,
-0.0427253954,
0.0901856497,
-0.0009751751,
-0.0043500769,
0.0391562134,
-0.024507273,
-0.006190144,
0.0516868792,
-0.032682322,
-0.0371279195,
0.0359581113,
0.0215010773,
-0.0364400558,
-0.0438754335,
0.0132544935,
-0.0050036982,
-0.0341528095,
-0.0026997658,
0.0281200837,
0.0126779582,
0.0179009326,
0.0271542333,
-0.0554227754,
-0.0060152188,
0.0019289033,
-0.0584004149,
0.0077808658,
0.0605237894,
0.0262075216,
-0.0206652377,
0.0045088688,
0.0015374662,
0.0641283095,
0.0704763681,
0.0516081378,
0.0472306907,
-0.008039332,
-0.0047209035,
-0.0288143065,
-0.0084146177,
-0.0371370316,
-0.0098906076,
-0.0237176586,
0.0173854679,
0.0165075287,
-0.0264626518,
0.0598077849,
-0.0027115252,
-0.029406026,
0.0355995633,
0.0257095098,
0.0584999807,
0.0160185136,
0.0064448644,
-0.0965977907,
-0.008454835,
-0.002510211,
0.0146990679,
-0.0039093876,
-0.0627394766,
0.0689534992,
0.0520737469,
-0.0059044277,
0.007186017,
0.0656661242,
0.025602337,
-0.0105039375,
-0.0115723247,
-0.0033038876,
0.03057882,
-0.0201293975,
-0.0154882157,
-0.040415924,
-0.0364309251,
0.0488714017,
0.0005481715,
0.0222009178,
0.0053335326,
0.0109511325,
0.0322041214,
-0.0619177334,
0.0013999338,
-0.0307486597,
0.0211017821,
0.0024278401,
0.0207582712,
0.0439736694,
0.0049529322,
-0.0254739486,
0.0768847167,
-0.0647577122,
-0.0685037822,
-0.0433811881,
-0.0280661099,
0.0179504268,
0.0231819041,
-0.0503422618,
0.0028855142,
-0.0106888153,
0.0204736013,
-0.0520959422,
-0.0455548577,
-0.0109632369,
0.0251281429,
2.54e-7,
-0.0078487117,
-0.0096171219,
0.086513862,
0.041414313,
-0.0153256375,
0.0089356555,
0.0165675934,
0.0255414285,
-0.0156280492,
-0.0355128199,
0.0099359676,
0.0133622652,
-0.0040469728,
-0.0133439526,
-0.0428534523,
-0.0051576965,
-0.0424132273,
0.0475790985,
-0.0454269238,
0.0005398868,
0.0677705631,
0.0580672584,
-0.0008515508,
0.0321142375,
0.0050605,
0.0093149003,
0.0044561038,
-0.0078592002,
0.0219557714,
0.0021106235,
0.0202584192,
-0.0282525551,
-0.0177231263,
0.0412731878,
-0.0111933863,
0.0101622269,
-0.0371062867,
0.0898389667,
-0.0232647993,
-0.0282765757,
0.0175014399,
0.0005216917,
-0.0153051969,
-0.0203328766,
0.0394347608,
0.0073851175,
0.0153308539,
0.0046955864,
-0.0181353688,
-0.0148154851,
-0.0234463047,
0.007154264,
0.0354758054,
-0.0004059112,
0.0188553929,
-0.0327749401,
0.0101914741,
-0.0585736595,
0.0114918984,
0.0224293321,
-0.0289943572,
-0.0458670855,
-0.056472294,
0.0108737135,
-0.0076037217,
-0.0818823799,
-0.0485118441,
2.350899621e-34,
0.0097311875,
-0.0501372293,
0.0498563461,
0.0349404849,
0.0094233947,
-0.0152918519,
-0.0184490401,
0.0466655232,
0.09389323,
-0.0747403577,
-0.0513251945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17739v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17739v1 | Find Parent then Label Children: A Two-stage Taxonomy Completion Method with Pre-trained Language Model | 2024-06-25T17:25:02 | 2024-06-25T17:25:02 | Fei Xia, Yixuan Weng, Shizhu He, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Taxonomies, which organize domain concepts into hierarchical structures, are
crucial for building knowledge systems and downstream applications. As domain
knowledge evolves, taxonomies need to be continuously updated to include new
concepts. Previous approaches have mainly focused on adding concepts to the
leaf nodes of the existing hierarchical tree, which does not fully utilize the
taxonomy's knowledge and is unable to update the original taxonomy structure
(usually involving non-leaf nodes). In this paper, we propose a two-stage
method called ATTEMPT for taxonomy completion. Our method inserts new concepts
into the correct position by finding a parent node and labeling child nodes.
Specifically, by combining local nodes with prompts to generate natural
sentences, we take advantage of pre-trained language models for
hypernym/hyponymy recognition. Experimental results on two public datasets
(including six domains) show that ATTEMPT performs best on both taxonomy
completion and extension tasks, surpassing existing methods. | Find Parent then Label Children: A Two-stage Taxonomy Completion Method with Pre-trained Language Model: Taxonomies, which organize domain concepts into hierarchical structures, are
crucial for building knowledge systems and downstream applications. As domain
knowledge evolves, taxonomies need to be continuously updated to include new
concepts. Previous approaches have mainly focused on adding concepts to the
leaf nodes of the existing hierarchical tree, which does not fully utilize the
taxonomy's knowledge and is unable to update the original taxonomy structure
(usually involving non-leaf nodes). In this paper, we propose a two-stage
method called ATTEMPT for taxonomy completion. Our method inserts new concepts
into the correct position by finding a parent node and labeling child nodes.
Specifically, by combining local nodes with prompts to generate natural
sentences, we take advantage of pre-trained language models for
hypernym/hyponymy recognition. Experimental results on two public datasets
(including six domains) show that ATTEMPT performs best on both taxonomy
completion and extension tasks, surpassing existing methods. | [
0.0416950844,
0.0355267748,
-0.0172756966,
0.0041202521,
-0.0252685212,
-0.0118327141,
-0.0441421755,
0.0247969981,
-0.0021549729,
-0.0903560221,
-0.0187542941,
-0.0174772274,
0.0044078487,
0.0076411343,
-0.0121472916,
-0.0710083246,
0.0509655438,
-0.0018890146,
0.0137187587,
-0.0128507456,
-0.0349610746,
0.0282886717,
0.0062614693,
0.015587802,
-0.036204014,
-0.0263139568,
-0.0389848538,
0.0194722041,
0.0017319804,
-0.0500302427,
0.014150966,
0.041450005,
0.0201083384,
0.0777638331,
0.0000017823,
-0.092423588,
-0.037676692,
-0.0309792683,
-0.011051923,
-0.0317522846,
0.0441919565,
0.0008453475,
0.0307447389,
-0.0253431927,
0.003567341,
-0.030974485,
0.0336745605,
0.0247527696,
0.0224696416,
0.0057899808,
0.0129904216,
-0.0529947244,
0.0334860831,
-0.0047068391,
0.0028746142,
-0.045625031,
0.0171818081,
0.0352959521,
0.0113538364,
0.0280532744,
0.0012554314,
0.0086603891,
-0.017359674,
-0.0313589387,
0.0189223997,
0.0010596069,
0.0173195004,
-0.0240433086,
-0.0088426927,
0.0728395283,
-0.049407687,
-0.0013639948,
0.0164734386,
-0.015802918,
-0.0043265028,
0.0346213579,
-0.0162775479,
0.0212253127,
0.0004136738,
-0.0364396051,
0.0277924649,
-0.0392591394,
0.0455115661,
0.0289867334,
-0.0093186637,
0.1065070778,
0.0483163744,
-0.0221142136,
0.0032725723,
0.009137678,
-0.0000429068,
-0.0855170637,
0.0181249436,
0.0625716597,
-0.020717049,
0.0614954904,
-0.059825711,
0.0416123718,
0.0267861858,
-0.037095204,
-0.0265319459,
-0.0050107255,
0.0067016589,
0.0519218594,
-0.0202281736,
-0.0398138575,
0.0161549356,
-0.0105687631,
-0.048834499,
-0.0161423385,
-0.0651840493,
-0.0263558663,
-0.0641713217,
0.0542701669,
-0.0366426744,
-0.0209308155,
-0.0449253023,
0.0150613599,
0.0033013483,
0.0069364212,
-0.0050575356,
-0.0279275123,
-0.0355482846,
-0.0305770934,
-0.0402533971,
-0.010498873,
-0.0449412689,
0.0617589019,
0.0220469441,
0.0318658538,
0.0172224473,
0.0240024906,
0.0475510284,
0.0327374041,
0.0015108775,
0.039324265,
0.0592288077,
-0.0385026634,
-0.0691844225,
-0.0510645695,
-0.0155461831,
-0.0160229411,
0.0095009981,
-0.0634508505,
0.0039268374,
-0.0392924882,
-0.0095765954,
-0.0032784047,
0.0265811402,
0.0176650994,
-0.0460140631,
0.0767250359,
-0.095102258,
-0.0081698578,
0.0739182606,
-0.0031821893,
0.0112225395,
0.0304633938,
0.0216307845,
0.030359121,
0.0799278468,
-0.0046383073,
0.0080910353,
0.0045025381,
0.0002571727,
-0.0117380675,
-0.0009531518,
-0.0342481881,
-0.0454619192,
0.0609103516,
-0.0150593501,
0.0312949456,
0.0134411594,
0.0351252109,
0.0326781571,
0.0501551777,
0.0296991877,
-0.009748186,
0.0725807101,
-0.0097469902,
-0.0367274806,
-0.0128325112,
-0.0309683755,
-0.0257866401,
-0.0616703779,
0.0307889488,
-0.0142772049,
0.0112160556,
-0.0151671134,
-0.0443329029,
-0.0223228447,
-0.0279730167,
-0.0241007563,
-0.021264879,
0.0927860364,
0.0594816357,
0.0096174078,
0.0406065993,
0.0636410788,
-0.007165438,
0.0604081191,
-0.00931066,
0.0413565151,
0.0636132658,
0.013291507,
-0.0650144592,
-0.0404372849,
0.0096876584,
-0.0107741375,
0.0442067087,
-0.0126105594,
-0.0494299978,
-0.0387718081,
-0.0170699023,
-0.0273470487,
0.030236721,
0.0165758058,
0.0274637621,
0.0117499456,
0.0146489944,
0.0523665845,
-0.063805379,
-0.0288771149,
0.0462570377,
-0.0206143092,
0.0021149775,
0.0112323267,
0.0271902382,
-0.0183426272,
0.0380876213,
-0.0133924028,
-0.0007367375,
0.0216055624,
0.0229838472,
-0.0752818808,
-0.0193575881,
-0.0095691606,
-0.0561771803,
0.0483629145,
-0.0034406951,
0.0033156872,
-0.0149065442,
-0.0206237175,
-0.0283814501,
-0.00095241,
-0.0056568412,
0.0481552519,
-0.0490790084,
0.0568140559,
-0.0039896709,
-0.051997114,
-0.0304145813,
0.0898912996,
0.019512916,
0.0449750461,
-0.0601390079,
-0.0012632323,
0.0010624563,
0.028458355,
-0.0270516984,
0.0205305051,
-0.0317354351,
0.0258516222,
0.0324155986,
0.0154004758,
-0.0586382672,
0.0317687057,
-0.0604432933,
-0.0070258318,
0.0163412821,
0.0265012421,
0.0029126045,
-0.0006257475,
-0.0074098292,
-0.0293438081,
0.0169974193,
0.077196151,
-0.0151786525,
0.0157546178,
0.034097977,
-0.0013828805,
-0.0457711369,
-0.0280791484,
-0.003508572,
-0.0091777677,
0.0505562201,
0.036030855,
0.0113223093,
-0.0137414932,
-0.0122582763,
-0.0665590242,
0.0239050686,
0.0418828428,
0.0087847393,
-0.0142830731,
-0.0049616699,
0.0025197295,
-0.0294775553,
-0.011234357,
-0.0201767348,
0.0633453652,
0.0188479926,
0.0002997391,
-0.0260951221,
-0.0407428816,
-0.0224383418,
0.0196954142,
0.0228360947,
0.0277287737,
0.0938919485,
-0.0262527056,
-0.035447944,
0.0031202752,
0.0180886369,
-0.03427146,
0.0317110904,
-0.0594294034,
-0.0350252688,
-0.014733444,
0.0711568743,
-0.0091090919,
-0.0532673411,
0.0667503625,
-0.0341917984,
0.0114686824,
-0.0318757072,
-0.0100645153,
-0.0198696889,
0.0803416595,
0.0117678335,
0.0596237332,
0.0868442804,
-0.0922102705,
-0.0332004428,
0.0451253355,
0.0105763227,
0.0009746773,
0.0334092863,
-0.0500633195,
0.013479813,
0.019539332,
0.0273284074,
-0.0380179919,
-0.022200346,
-0.0076133832,
0.0293399971,
0.0001749806,
-0.0274163503,
0.0231047105,
-0.0167683456,
-0.0106162177,
0.0731428415,
0.029856978,
-0.0297927503,
-0.0376334824,
0.06831377,
0.0445977524,
-0.0043790732,
-0.0160889011,
0.018576568,
0.0200854708,
0.0116318073,
-0.0179573856,
0.0016973224,
-0.0036289725,
-0.0032925433,
0.0218650643,
-0.0944198146,
-0.052515313,
0.0126157263,
-0.0284190942,
-0.0131001277,
0.0056012999,
0.1174455062,
0.0700430945,
-0.0172382798,
0.0264023878,
-0.0216211006,
0.0210222974,
0.0558582172,
-0.0065479935,
-0.0816676468,
0.0139065692,
0.0238331296,
-0.0088724038,
0.0243034158,
-0.0397045538,
0.0300303288,
-0.1048875153,
-0.0056968746,
-0.0085227992,
-0.0549402535,
0.013929517,
-0.0212740395,
-0.0081936568,
0.0614541993,
-0.0279534943,
-0.0046601156,
0.0061366912,
-0.0108103156,
-0.0106286481,
-0.0161515158,
-0.0401866287,
0.0641755387,
-0.041619394,
0.0124500738,
0.054431051,
0.0409575477,
-0.0406168997,
-0.0000311542,
0.019816706,
-0.0141883772,
-0.031586621,
-0.0065320381,
-0.0075653978,
-0.0094996979,
0.0122873466,
0.0101698246,
-0.0129195871,
-0.0455755815,
-0.0055294726,
0.0480960868,
0.1031811684,
0.0220134631,
-0.013972979,
-0.0147005841,
-0.0039030677,
0.0093316343,
0.0559468977,
0.0121572101,
-0.0342465751,
0.0286401045,
-0.0175536908,
-0.0082362778,
0.0247282181,
0.0170000177,
0.0302142855,
-0.0729932487,
-0.0108603146,
-0.1002536565,
-0.0435816459,
0.0598264448,
0.0392035618,
0.0266898256,
-0.0001446654,
0.0133311329,
0.0101346327,
-0.0504929163,
0.034913145,
-0.0215179399,
0.0015958252,
-0.0240586121,
-0.0211566556,
0.0612449124,
-0.0108097997,
-0.0487076864,
-0.0057916455,
0.0410139859,
-0.0389171019,
-0.0438460186,
0.0138592301,
0.0140058529,
0.0144848153,
-0.0423793346,
-0.029352041,
0.0214151423,
0.0089468025,
-0.0324871503,
-0.0137804402,
0.0094816424,
0.0335246921,
-0.0134161441,
0.0484023169,
-0.0569392964,
0.0408921726,
-0.0032589277,
0.0576933548,
0.0125144804,
-0.0583740883,
0.0423119217,
-0.0040538502,
0.0765933841,
-0.0595418289,
-0.0049383771,
-0.0190399569,
-0.0094650034,
-0.0158678032,
-0.061346937,
-0.0016646605,
0.0013354396,
0.023395123,
0.0219519585,
0.0188014563,
-0.0276941527,
-0.0329455733,
0.0161556993,
-0.0007810433,
-0.0519553944,
0.0068542748,
0.0486084633,
0.0139794834,
0.0053617293,
-0.0181947872,
-0.0481087416,
-0.0319268666,
0.0065018386,
-0.0691377297,
0.0230578389,
-0.0102924081,
-0.0187538471,
-0.0715842098,
0.0019544293,
0.0058574663,
-0.0197963808,
-0.0436962284,
0.0340125449,
0.0773245618,
0.0201945044,
-0.042426236,
-0.0411010198,
-0.0291897487,
-0.0081423791,
0.0192302205,
-0.0002085413,
-0.0900573805,
0.0365140699,
0.015866451,
-0.0408526435,
-0.004666422,
0.0589995645,
0.0397690013,
0.0357645303,
-0.0115942201,
-0.0076097581,
-0.0019495105,
0.0057771443,
-0.0187783446,
0.0642958581,
-0.0466069989,
0.0278453287,
-0.0454056337,
-0.0745211765,
0.0031397187,
0.0181656778,
-0.0117548471,
0.0472409129,
0.0664808154,
0.065827325,
0.0079341233,
-0.0266258772,
-0.035848897,
0.0086538391,
-0.0102259479,
0.0051218788,
0.0098065911,
-5.48316099e-33,
-0.0606188625,
-0.0722756311,
0.015931543,
-0.0121574188,
-0.0011987201,
-0.0003318224,
-0.0300740749,
0.0454742201,
0.0155793903,
0.0401504375,
0.0293309633,
-0.0105694793,
0.0033655127,
0.0379551426,
0.0311429277,
0.0214894302,
0.0122338254,
0.009717199,
0.0074967169,
0.0139634181,
0.0225860346,
0.0279138908,
0.075700745,
-0.0392305292,
0.014500415,
0.0046979478,
0.0216531213,
0.0198670868,
0.0011204216,
0.0406598151,
0.0009076038,
0.0772267208,
0.0119596301,
-0.011570801,
0.0105550792,
0.0102598462,
-0.0679410249,
-0.029270418,
-0.0088769011,
-0.0177023262,
-0.0461680777,
-0.0181755163,
0.0237388834,
-0.0015921127,
0.0278697945,
0.0156212514,
0.0424591899,
-0.0197625719,
-0.0570088066,
-0.0469356999,
-0.1083008647,
0.0124152768,
0.0239443742,
-0.0050705103,
-0.0103289243,
0.0240940247,
0.0100630084,
-0.0029769642,
-0.0226642005,
0.0367540233,
0.0409559719,
0.0160761718,
0.0314428098,
0.0412328839,
-0.0264029149,
0.0483785905,
0.0023637768,
0.0075008422,
0.0087198382,
0.0544813573,
0.0181963407,
0.0319157243,
-0.004194384,
-0.0101405075,
-0.0090867486,
-0.014809181,
-0.0241002124,
0.0117868641,
-0.0505558737,
-0.0107830092,
-0.0364463516,
0.0125488937,
-0.0075151566,
-0.0138001572,
-0.0559978783,
-0.0074082189,
-0.0409343578,
-0.0525302887,
0.0128754647,
0.0033197319,
-0.0099844206,
0.0181694925,
-0.0413754731,
-0.0016324811,
-0.0575368665,
-0.0284532383,
0.0293838326,
0.0401785187,
-0.0380912945,
0.0699756294,
-0.0196519755,
-0.0768764094,
-0.0095968517,
-0.0231264234,
-0.0188387334,
0.007075638,
-0.0126971733,
-0.0014614888,
-0.0470059402,
0.0243471432,
0.0127537129,
-0.0542446934,
-0.0015864416,
-0.0269195698,
0.0486155041,
0.0136342393,
0.0073826425,
0.0602919906,
0.0498780124,
-0.0310181603,
-0.0336920805,
0.036542587,
-0.0075587188,
0.0135719515,
-0.0062256395,
-0.0081755584,
-0.0080607375,
-0.0280669872,
0.020890709,
-0.0297254622,
0.0008767958,
-0.0325483531,
2.606e-7,
0.0171873476,
0.0490323193,
-0.0240897834,
0.0076599168,
0.0152825555,
-0.0080395564,
0.0313607901,
0.0228096545,
-0.0328974836,
-0.0430661589,
-0.0106421988,
-0.0722049624,
-0.0035960607,
0.0035417469,
-0.1092090905,
-0.0382921584,
0.011985166,
0.0013681545,
-0.0844780058,
0.006183987,
0.0598282889,
0.0788267776,
0.0156562645,
0.0021344,
-0.0433655865,
-0.0488353707,
0.0346694812,
0.0131515162,
-0.0029702012,
0.0572510548,
0.004696779,
0.0610029772,
-0.0000748618,
0.0345971473,
-0.0349886566,
0.0391532853,
0.016214788,
0.0263506025,
-0.0240165982,
0.0151451174,
-0.004531431,
-0.0130490223,
0.0327499285,
-0.0682788715,
0.0333611518,
-0.0610891506,
0.0091783516,
0.019514136,
-0.0206489842,
0.0050584031,
-0.0378971547,
-0.0469167344,
-0.0099832062,
0.0023273742,
0.0076512075,
0.0235503521,
-0.0129322428,
-0.0949984118,
0.0345759541,
0.0768938661,
-0.0431291163,
-0.0312617682,
0.0349239744,
-0.0210400335,
0.0021838231,
-0.024492912,
0.0097478945,
2.152454364e-34,
0.0094201025,
0.0021329124,
-0.0096861646,
0.053157106,
0.0250239596,
-0.0081912884,
0.0180920977,
0.0153338648,
0.0295983404,
-0.0532089621,
-0.0012547713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17737v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17737v1 | LLM Targeted Underperformance Disproportionately Impacts Vulnerable Users | 2024-06-25T17:24:07 | 2024-06-25T17:24:07 | Elinor Poole-Dayan, Deb Roy, Jad Kabbara | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | While state-of-the-art Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown impressive
performance on many tasks, there has been extensive research on undesirable
model behavior such as hallucinations and bias. In this work, we investigate
how the quality of LLM responses changes in terms of information accuracy,
truthfulness, and refusals depending on three user traits: English proficiency,
education level, and country of origin. We present extensive experimentation on
three state-of-the-art LLMs and two different datasets targeting truthfulness
and factuality. Our findings suggest that undesirable behaviors in
state-of-the-art LLMs occur disproportionately more for users with lower
English proficiency, of lower education status, and originating from outside
the US, rendering these models unreliable sources of information towards their
most vulnerable users. | LLM Targeted Underperformance Disproportionately Impacts Vulnerable Users: While state-of-the-art Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown impressive
performance on many tasks, there has been extensive research on undesirable
model behavior such as hallucinations and bias. In this work, we investigate
how the quality of LLM responses changes in terms of information accuracy,
truthfulness, and refusals depending on three user traits: English proficiency,
education level, and country of origin. We present extensive experimentation on
three state-of-the-art LLMs and two different datasets targeting truthfulness
and factuality. Our findings suggest that undesirable behaviors in
state-of-the-art LLMs occur disproportionately more for users with lower
English proficiency, of lower education status, and originating from outside
the US, rendering these models unreliable sources of information towards their
most vulnerable users. | [
0.0385592505,
0.0766503215,
-0.0388005786,
0.0200502332,
-0.0161413606,
0.011904249,
0.0549075082,
-0.008985227,
0.0416241065,
-0.0577895716,
0.0055669649,
-0.0481768027,
0.0063178297,
-0.0192792844,
0.0007331275,
-0.0280754566,
0.0347205065,
-0.0204158928,
0.0160220247,
-0.0462333485,
-0.0063822703,
0.0299924575,
-0.0075221234,
0.0658017769,
-0.0087618819,
-0.029398134,
0.0380068459,
-0.005426826,
-0.0117420228,
-0.0253775958,
0.0408060551,
0.0710853711,
-0.0165564287,
0.0544663034,
0.0000019642,
-0.0494065657,
0.0199376047,
-0.0060038799,
-0.0416780896,
0.038137719,
0.0424570665,
-0.0036438005,
-0.0004450391,
0.0469901264,
-0.0326826312,
0.0101448763,
0.0212661866,
0.0431817174,
0.0182559825,
0.025360316,
-0.0012094539,
0.000645722,
0.0165178217,
-0.0029185528,
0.0260118991,
-0.0049310718,
0.0232064743,
-0.0003242029,
-0.0235188585,
-0.0469876789,
0.0178936999,
0.0373335034,
0.0017042145,
-0.0006152194,
-0.0348821878,
0.0225410126,
-0.0516662896,
-0.0421068482,
0.0082739471,
0.0499824062,
0.0033914116,
-0.0154941687,
-0.0043009249,
-0.0140058985,
-0.0019320018,
0.0331656188,
-0.0235332642,
0.0372199453,
-0.015610422,
0.0039980672,
-0.0040369462,
-0.0286649968,
0.0432984494,
0.0217237473,
-0.0076274271,
0.0582721457,
0.0029602365,
-0.0407273397,
-0.001523249,
0.0046288087,
0.0315011628,
-0.061642196,
0.0280755647,
-0.0231216624,
-0.0574373752,
0.0154352244,
-0.0191536509,
0.0063612433,
0.0569959357,
-0.0727650821,
0.0161906797,
0.0433334447,
-0.0207864176,
0.0212776754,
0.0025894637,
0.0317027271,
0.0016637015,
0.0393501073,
-0.0003154113,
0.0137629937,
-0.0029421193,
-0.0107962918,
0.0228742212,
-0.0150777623,
-0.02074017,
0.0231016744,
-0.0555073284,
0.0193988383,
-0.0110718273,
0.0146452831,
-0.0212132372,
-0.0022275182,
-0.0133653451,
-0.0313631594,
-0.0755030736,
0.0650473237,
-0.0202622525,
0.0293204747,
0.0108184656,
-0.0800098553,
0.0334234573,
0.0020332541,
-0.0362806097,
-0.0323129967,
0.0025008291,
-0.001440202,
0.0219909418,
-0.0173068382,
-0.0705942214,
-0.0222001467,
-0.023379432,
-0.0678900257,
-0.0280944835,
-0.0622243024,
0.014774411,
0.0405702479,
-0.0040146671,
-0.075796783,
0.009101213,
0.0432154387,
-0.0432841927,
0.0359873176,
-0.0099735931,
0.029518187,
0.0414451137,
0.0299754683,
0.0081731118,
0.0679320022,
-0.0002253518,
0.0340306647,
0.0319704376,
-0.0508118384,
0.0286622047,
0.0417059548,
-0.0083728367,
0.0402936935,
-0.0135115357,
-0.0075587495,
-0.0228584725,
-0.0001522456,
0.0403304771,
0.0374325365,
0.0058941096,
0.0147438403,
0.1142865941,
0.0498903096,
0.0163970999,
0.0095970612,
-0.0249680467,
0.0421136245,
0.0103118252,
-0.0079568382,
-0.0647414848,
-0.0147760557,
-0.0291885529,
0.0014963843,
0.0478200205,
0.064314343,
-0.0149041573,
-0.0386890396,
-0.0252313279,
-0.0133423842,
0.0207195338,
0.0696633086,
0.0064307861,
-0.0312831812,
-0.0135445436,
0.0591498315,
0.054749392,
-0.028822409,
-0.0048241625,
-0.0623375289,
0.0153972283,
0.0773385018,
0.022317091,
0.0041002845,
0.034803573,
-0.0381500125,
0.0329640284,
0.0834963396,
0.0635315329,
0.0249533132,
-0.017079955,
-0.0396437831,
-0.0150276767,
0.0327718742,
0.0114620086,
0.0118453363,
0.0192637574,
0.019658912,
0.0199150462,
-0.0466710292,
-0.0539469682,
0.0150594842,
-0.0268938299,
-0.0101134926,
-0.0262549538,
0.0019491839,
0.0190708414,
-0.0046402584,
0.0051523233,
0.0069470056,
-0.0082673458,
0.0079514822,
0.001399031,
-0.0172684416,
-0.0522819534,
0.0123702111,
0.0240962934,
-0.0131723499,
-0.0003774491,
0.0212439634,
0.0162032805,
-0.0044478141,
0.0184292998,
-0.0224597398,
0.0640704259,
-0.0367607139,
0.0321337432,
-0.0194922872,
0.0218875632,
-0.0291609094,
0.0630492046,
-0.0550472364,
0.0343120769,
-0.009302929,
-0.0465504639,
-0.0176357739,
-0.0161931179,
-0.0518580563,
0.0309407189,
-0.0019002067,
0.0314246081,
0.0210341495,
-0.0070821089,
-0.0436444804,
0.0043178569,
-0.0652659833,
-0.0133820176,
-0.022054391,
0.0015854571,
0.0072169448,
-0.0155110518,
-0.0336707346,
0.0040922929,
-0.0464524738,
-0.0239317846,
0.0256718397,
0.0410994329,
-0.0178496502,
-0.0138349291,
-0.0139564229,
-0.0307358,
-0.0185490493,
-0.0101132933,
0.0053222724,
-0.0112735257,
-0.0405372716,
-0.0338271186,
0.0086862324,
-0.032617189,
0.0127881933,
-0.0145599591,
-0.0235077627,
0.0126840156,
0.0369688682,
0.0236601196,
0.0163679738,
0.0207737852,
0.0289411321,
0.0584760644,
0.0074803727,
-0.0844141841,
-0.0123628555,
0.0133747021,
-0.019464219,
-0.0395372957,
-0.0798400193,
0.0098975962,
0.0649441928,
0.0505980924,
0.0286252312,
-0.0363346972,
-0.0043167626,
-0.0590297431,
-0.0581600964,
-0.0044538891,
0.0069765942,
-0.0449415222,
0.0437223352,
0.0021061581,
-0.0619601868,
0.05649212,
-0.0176246818,
0.0188739933,
-0.0112205446,
-0.0168280546,
0.014040322,
0.0206253678,
-0.0013430637,
0.0398287624,
0.0152434334,
-0.0415677652,
-0.0199063607,
-0.0259025842,
0.0093715806,
-0.0642712712,
0.0601357855,
-0.0313876756,
0.0024502096,
0.0227807947,
-0.0309597515,
-0.054563988,
-0.0878408775,
-0.0263710804,
-0.0444528088,
-0.0016621413,
-0.0327266231,
-0.0517654754,
-0.0212455895,
0.0490457378,
0.0263603088,
-0.0136249317,
-0.0177825801,
0.0096703647,
-0.0541317649,
0.0506171398,
0.0223445669,
0.0730973184,
-0.0415142961,
0.0374416895,
0.0527502745,
0.0375222415,
0.0206134245,
0.0378085747,
-0.0355056748,
0.0456213728,
-0.0093826298,
-0.0356840789,
0.0540907383,
0.0483602323,
-0.0458413623,
0.0138002485,
0.0988990068,
0.0296736974,
-0.0463890769,
0.0049239509,
-0.0818336159,
0.0589330569,
0.0356856249,
0.0050042709,
-0.0918268263,
-0.0106954426,
0.0029454227,
0.0558526069,
-0.0482058898,
-0.002034392,
-0.0079619335,
-0.1006293893,
0.0210229401,
0.0062340805,
0.0313549824,
0.0038842519,
-0.0211383961,
-0.0094142193,
0.0409513749,
0.0884429067,
-0.0192228425,
-0.0044933208,
-0.0279076397,
0.0089658741,
-0.1034289226,
-0.0639335439,
0.050217893,
-0.0151242474,
0.0496193282,
0.0453462228,
0.0107267825,
-0.0394472443,
-0.0589398965,
0.0525574051,
0.0008913784,
-0.0146996537,
-0.0064812824,
0.0279488005,
0.0096866218,
0.0065102307,
-0.0557849184,
0.019161161,
-0.0096275648,
0.0014034755,
0.0287156682,
0.0410354957,
-0.0243347622,
-0.0175969396,
0.0102629103,
0.0092630414,
0.0198432095,
0.0775540471,
0.0286171082,
-0.0723688751,
-0.0184606835,
-0.0532717854,
-0.017395772,
0.0092287483,
-0.0590152517,
0.0801245943,
0.0293687172,
-0.0120603414,
-0.0375929363,
-0.0419941097,
0.0286764633,
-0.0081178136,
0.0070278239,
0.0114725539,
0.0196802486,
-0.0411192626,
0.0390443504,
0.0432997234,
-0.045271758,
0.0473413505,
-0.0698991716,
0.0159076005,
-0.0200362317,
-0.0195004903,
0.0225270409,
-0.0069625634,
-0.0183559265,
-0.0521369241,
0.0580313653,
0.0170672387,
0.0307614952,
0.0302187186,
-0.0045291344,
-0.0778350011,
0.0462429971,
0.0135093825,
-0.0386787355,
0.0151976962,
0.0289066788,
0.0060414439,
-0.0182829592,
0.041311685,
-0.0104989652,
-0.0063808821,
0.0041190698,
0.0219167043,
-0.0422722399,
-0.0143399807,
0.0349684097,
0.023262931,
0.0192302484,
-0.0234235618,
-0.0064004478,
-0.0216945969,
-0.0071150707,
-0.0284131318,
-0.0136479,
0.0055027199,
-0.0349345058,
0.021942379,
-0.0153066004,
0.0203483552,
-0.0247406792,
-0.0519290678,
0.0023587272,
-0.0588824823,
0.0530017242,
-0.0304820482,
0.0189979412,
0.0302125197,
-0.012603729,
-0.0378074087,
0.038568005,
0.0184036605,
0.0537071638,
0.0084238313,
0.0920078158,
-0.0260119569,
-0.0226280093,
0.0088914428,
-0.0033244547,
0.010063855,
-0.0787945613,
0.0046051722,
0.0112589253,
0.0139591666,
-0.0003635469,
0.0668615997,
0.0010366405,
0.0107896943,
-0.0218658559,
-0.019876644,
0.0304998774,
-0.0279954094,
0.0494882278,
-0.0103066945,
-0.0422791876,
0.0035636127,
0.0620524697,
0.0097270822,
0.0296686273,
-0.0262393635,
-0.012848598,
-0.0263960492,
-0.0592464879,
-0.0216309279,
0.0195525996,
-0.0649673492,
-0.0343907848,
-0.0946377441,
-0.0449581183,
-0.043465551,
-0.0016099354,
-0.0188392904,
-0.0568739884,
-0.0113835288,
0.0567377508,
-0.0167401731,
-0.0267667677,
-0.0579354651,
-0.0111214602,
0.0025989711,
0.0003552266,
-0.0076011135,
-6.39230375e-33,
-0.0021700067,
-0.0284572244,
-0.0004444259,
-0.0557575002,
0.0114531051,
-0.0057829362,
-0.0009402742,
0.0457382947,
-0.0419811159,
-0.0123099145,
-0.0147545198,
0.0044591082,
0.0270541385,
0.0223893598,
0.0120386668,
-0.0167316925,
0.032455489,
0.0196159277,
-0.0309126843,
0.0178814437,
0.0290970001,
-0.0121715348,
0.0460593142,
-0.0708892271,
0.0844185874,
-0.0205465667,
-0.0152584333,
-0.0076394705,
-0.0284608547,
0.0573001467,
-0.026063256,
0.087121442,
0.0129226008,
-0.0454883091,
-0.0097216796,
0.0286769811,
-0.0097906021,
0.0006595354,
0.0559545681,
0.0112147061,
0.0250310935,
-0.0276538134,
0.0343547985,
-0.0068551828,
-0.0372508056,
0.0063841846,
0.0213820338,
-0.0150742754,
0.0054815281,
0.0204199236,
-0.0390576944,
0.0091677671,
-0.0086204866,
0.0268834326,
-0.0587159321,
0.1052613929,
-0.0217615161,
-0.0076290094,
-0.0614831708,
0.0278696753,
0.0263321437,
0.0081257671,
0.091798991,
-0.023154987,
0.0043822606,
0.0850317404,
0.0148483254,
0.0182757229,
-0.0197209381,
-0.041285526,
0.0366865546,
0.0098603815,
0.0219210554,
0.0579020195,
-0.0062595312,
-0.0608080588,
-0.0393903926,
0.0048942766,
0.0334255882,
0.0337494425,
0.0655050352,
-0.025454659,
-0.0799442753,
-0.0635517016,
-0.0392564461,
0.0324941613,
-0.0271959081,
-0.0417501256,
0.0626204461,
-0.0086871972,
-0.0022454571,
-0.0079709105,
0.0309883859,
-0.0280103963,
-0.0604677536,
-0.0130079733,
-0.0075709349,
-0.0039621992,
-0.0046182228,
0.0517445691,
-0.0629328266,
0.0015207713,
-0.0491660871,
-0.0006841926,
0.016544342,
0.0307216682,
0.00459912,
-0.0148476446,
-0.0866910964,
0.0188337192,
-0.0173535645,
0.0390584432,
0.022926772,
-0.0084357103,
0.0602228045,
-0.0317794643,
-0.011815994,
0.02727223,
0.0086214067,
-0.0228054617,
-0.0536085851,
-0.031048907,
-0.0228235219,
0.0621776134,
-0.0365749374,
-0.0113348262,
-0.0527864583,
0.0144887082,
0.0665855482,
-0.028977247,
-0.0213725474,
-0.0405675136,
2.499e-7,
0.0226734243,
0.0611780174,
-0.0454702228,
0.0112017719,
-0.014309736,
0.0413782187,
0.0107904868,
0.0126789846,
0.0549441278,
-0.0010479362,
-0.035699252,
-0.0076830257,
0.0429352894,
0.0468265787,
-0.0612021163,
0.0125879589,
-0.0601613596,
0.0414195955,
-0.0781517774,
0.0178880356,
0.0232046638,
0.0688962713,
0.0029074196,
-0.0270618573,
-0.0251136683,
-0.0599669963,
0.0344609171,
-0.0491343439,
-0.0442268327,
-0.0035728025,
0.0563437045,
0.011655652,
0.0339898504,
0.0380273648,
-0.0157618839,
0.0014482499,
-0.0210555159,
0.0489160679,
0.0150259687,
-0.0226280931,
-0.016481895,
-0.0294773467,
0.0149986623,
-0.0837155282,
0.0619679503,
0.0022002601,
-0.0156574883,
-0.0047863284,
0.0131055089,
-0.0437763929,
0.039489869,
-0.0422095321,
-0.0324099623,
0.0027093284,
0.0316109322,
0.0051902407,
-0.0062939841,
-0.0133195613,
-0.0176369734,
0.0058116252,
-0.0121346489,
-0.0742815211,
-0.0160591397,
0.0457255654,
-0.0277264211,
-0.0339827649,
0.035304226,
2.319889988e-34,
0.0305302162,
0.0475695617,
0.0473625772,
-0.0115177324,
0.0440440476,
0.0481585674,
0.0668870881,
0.0130462609,
-0.0026551117,
-0.0551494658,
-0.0031500463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17716v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17716v2 | ViANLI: Adversarial Natural Language Inference for Vietnamese | 2024-06-25T16:58:19 | 2024-07-01T15:19:51 | Tin Van Huynh, Kiet Van Nguyen, Ngan Luu-Thuy Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The development of Natural Language Processing (NLI) datasets and models has
been inspired by innovations in annotation design. With the rapid development
of machine learning models today, the performance of existing machine learning
models has quickly reached state-of-the-art results on a variety of tasks
related to natural language processing, including natural language inference
tasks. By using a pre-trained model during the annotation process, it is
possible to challenge current NLI models by having humans produce
premise-hypothesis combinations that the machine model cannot correctly
predict. To remain attractive and challenging in the research of natural
language inference for Vietnamese, in this paper, we introduce the adversarial
NLI dataset to the NLP research community with the name ViANLI. This data set
contains more than 10K premise-hypothesis pairs and is built by a continuously
adjusting process to obtain the most out of the patterns generated by the
annotators. ViANLI dataset has brought many difficulties to many current SOTA
models when the accuracy of the most powerful model on the test set only
reached 48.4%. Additionally, the experimental results show that the models
trained on our dataset have significantly improved the results on other
Vietnamese NLI datasets. | ViANLI: Adversarial Natural Language Inference for Vietnamese: The development of Natural Language Processing (NLI) datasets and models has
been inspired by innovations in annotation design. With the rapid development
of machine learning models today, the performance of existing machine learning
models has quickly reached state-of-the-art results on a variety of tasks
related to natural language processing, including natural language inference
tasks. By using a pre-trained model during the annotation process, it is
possible to challenge current NLI models by having humans produce
premise-hypothesis combinations that the machine model cannot correctly
predict. To remain attractive and challenging in the research of natural
language inference for Vietnamese, in this paper, we introduce the adversarial
NLI dataset to the NLP research community with the name ViANLI. This data set
contains more than 10K premise-hypothesis pairs and is built by a continuously
adjusting process to obtain the most out of the patterns generated by the
annotators. ViANLI dataset has brought many difficulties to many current SOTA
models when the accuracy of the most powerful model on the test set only
reached 48.4%. Additionally, the experimental results show that the models
trained on our dataset have significantly improved the results on other
Vietnamese NLI datasets. | [
0.0532222465,
0.0701498464,
-0.0249648578,
0.043488428,
-0.0438763648,
0.0248614959,
0.0128460312,
-0.0255510546,
0.0743760243,
-0.040447522,
-0.0222140979,
-0.013193219,
0.0185943283,
0.0178447403,
0.0355065949,
-0.0456946939,
0.032540001,
-0.0056112744,
0.0033132709,
-0.0118832514,
0.0014593628,
0.0047119386,
0.0049158488,
0.0253731441,
0.0059419526,
-0.013983272,
-0.0060317996,
0.028428359,
0.0020874976,
-0.0544022135,
-0.0028405453,
0.0551858321,
-0.0097632315,
0.050122153,
0.0000020416,
-0.0368092693,
0.0107030561,
-0.018056456,
-0.0306928977,
0.018484408,
0.0436071493,
-0.0590620823,
-0.0016393366,
0.0228052866,
-0.0521699376,
-0.0513469875,
0.0514575168,
0.0573855191,
0.0588481948,
0.0575133525,
-0.0236268882,
-0.0492214151,
0.0101142395,
-0.0624510311,
-0.042976208,
-0.0369724929,
0.0353823677,
-0.010629138,
-0.0268402137,
-0.033687219,
-0.0132722417,
0.0327576362,
0.048484087,
0.0253242478,
-0.0456602052,
0.0150650721,
-0.0221807472,
-0.0238147601,
-0.0079592532,
0.0693180785,
-0.0151586328,
-0.0287250001,
-0.0332102999,
0.0036379939,
-0.0040757689,
0.0167799499,
-0.0044014947,
0.0172865726,
-0.0182645041,
0.0290462729,
0.0908903554,
0.0199040174,
0.0260289647,
0.03939588,
0.0106559442,
-0.0199245065,
0.0006226411,
-0.0357300006,
0.0276009478,
0.0146661531,
-0.087952666,
-0.0340187475,
0.0079854606,
-0.0119322799,
0.0090380218,
0.0109603517,
-0.0288131312,
-0.0300876275,
0.0452547558,
-0.0846699327,
0.0239568017,
0.0149098067,
-0.0644500256,
0.0511031039,
-0.0122344326,
0.0040317406,
-0.0450794511,
0.0129325772,
-0.0379269049,
-0.0300539043,
-0.0027149289,
0.0038639696,
-0.0375389792,
0.0359514691,
-0.0356832407,
-0.0033454422,
-0.0407221094,
-0.0027714483,
-0.0180610716,
-0.011313444,
-0.0049487096,
0.024995653,
-0.0683238879,
-0.0108406171,
-0.0027132137,
0.002191935,
-0.0336160697,
0.0662658364,
-0.0153402453,
-0.0835216641,
-0.0067121312,
0.0509020239,
-0.0107174618,
-0.0430516638,
0.0183066968,
0.0646056458,
0.0116878254,
0.007636894,
-0.0566420145,
0.0154277738,
0.0105418731,
-0.0582282394,
0.0036833251,
-0.0445577502,
0.0172620453,
-0.005444909,
0.0204166509,
-0.0580402166,
-0.0000664345,
-0.0008069406,
-0.0178434197,
0.1101502478,
-0.0062426073,
-0.0194659662,
0.0262390748,
0.0075513846,
-0.0165078007,
0.0804732218,
-0.0090463161,
0.0463888198,
0.031587746,
0.0054080207,
-0.0210336372,
0.0248829033,
0.0152025316,
-0.0024882876,
-0.0094325943,
0.0361020118,
-0.0179190449,
0.0227862205,
-0.0020573901,
0.0626069084,
-0.0231829491,
-0.0341207199,
0.0340849608,
0.0270838924,
-0.0058323275,
0.0340522528,
0.0447002277,
0.0083143516,
0.0323030315,
0.0176931396,
-0.0524635278,
0.0107915606,
-0.0487769246,
-0.0202469248,
0.0219621081,
0.0312383249,
-0.0328595899,
-0.0747493804,
-0.0156514943,
-0.0386597626,
0.006633359,
-0.0032209987,
0.0568728,
0.0675907359,
-0.0146119315,
0.014502624,
0.0495520048,
-0.0224728193,
-0.0359597765,
-0.0435851663,
0.0045798095,
0.0031525323,
0.0285403114,
-0.0259316992,
0.0270584952,
-0.0015568679,
0.0088190157,
0.0790495053,
0.0597154461,
-0.0235212725,
0.0173827745,
-0.0209496766,
0.0237570275,
0.0042256638,
0.0489620194,
0.0703914165,
0.0219679885,
0.0166138317,
0.0228122026,
-0.0139605924,
-0.0376323089,
0.0531693548,
-0.0144894579,
-0.0329100825,
0.0249158684,
0.0347959325,
0.0471992902,
0.0150784114,
-0.014489268,
-0.0020269686,
0.0375131927,
-0.0536923781,
0.0158065595,
0.0033592265,
-0.0003241176,
-0.0887214541,
-0.008705535,
-0.0612463392,
-0.0279828086,
0.0806176513,
-0.0679379255,
0.0000570348,
0.0203703493,
-0.0080110254,
-0.0136940535,
-0.0794048086,
-0.0206618104,
0.0174935628,
0.0627068207,
-0.0063818116,
0.0837716088,
-0.0230182502,
-0.0082186619,
0.0414755307,
0.0186507311,
0.0194912851,
-0.0276250634,
-0.0381206162,
0.0436127111,
-0.0023925889,
-0.008530369,
0.0010981341,
-0.0158873647,
0.0090573058,
-0.0172720999,
-0.0914943293,
0.0081261015,
-0.04239057,
0.00008445,
0.0172419157,
-0.0053307922,
-0.0296078194,
-0.0661575049,
0.007304023,
-0.0202094968,
0.0042829025,
0.0287249926,
0.0070420527,
-0.015445794,
0.0171256159,
-0.0322194956,
-0.0257819351,
0.0012565835,
0.0431444757,
0.0069765998,
-0.0571139492,
-0.0331611149,
-0.0105213616,
-0.0148089649,
0.0312269703,
-0.0206280071,
-0.0611149967,
0.0178037584,
0.0048320554,
-0.0385157466,
0.0939797238,
-0.0062814085,
0.0201198272,
0.0252691209,
0.0137885325,
-0.0042278795,
0.0118225468,
-0.0143459598,
0.0095256045,
-0.0329622924,
-0.0254322905,
-0.0422460102,
0.0651000589,
0.0298702996,
-0.0089603001,
-0.0260406937,
0.0215928536,
-0.0275179036,
-0.0210394561,
0.0155413793,
0.0114863226,
-0.0169243719,
0.0102737425,
-0.0229542963,
-0.0316586755,
0.1175079867,
0.0096536539,
0.0054116054,
-0.0541393012,
-0.0002353899,
-0.0372162908,
0.0961872041,
0.0305671692,
-0.018286122,
0.0225226264,
-0.0122160185,
-0.0257200599,
0.0135847554,
0.0378352553,
-0.0240637455,
0.0234461892,
-0.0384950563,
-0.0124699622,
-0.0133611625,
-0.0290306676,
-0.0787529871,
-0.0285005271,
-0.0448326543,
0.0002641311,
-0.0088740727,
0.030474497,
0.0020247446,
-0.0075015258,
-0.0573977679,
0.0174781345,
0.0061585866,
0.0272042118,
-0.0353983082,
0.0383114927,
0.0422788411,
-0.0259983838,
0.0085939663,
0.0151920384,
0.0619816408,
0.0561135225,
-0.0335540399,
0.0192007553,
-0.0137502914,
0.0179499779,
0.0170090273,
-0.0133764539,
-0.0052575907,
-0.0020476109,
0.004561469,
-0.0437360741,
0.0322058462,
0.0720449537,
0.0168458,
0.0060096704,
0.0292130932,
0.0334439203,
0.0147663457,
0.003634054,
0.004135638,
-0.0792259127,
-0.0406254195,
-0.0056554209,
-0.0095804054,
-0.0188485645,
-0.0199481826,
-0.0205658879,
-0.1146165058,
0.0118183261,
-0.0222347323,
-0.035855718,
-0.0238273982,
-0.0555989705,
-0.0017762921,
-0.0622338988,
0.0257282052,
-0.0160556175,
0.0242196806,
-0.0081600314,
0.0125551578,
-0.0285377447,
-0.0441882387,
0.0435548536,
-0.0376506634,
0.0199461654,
0.0458145216,
0.0465440266,
-0.0093860067,
0.0004093865,
0.0320482515,
-0.0209358688,
0.0058084093,
-0.0082959039,
0.0707199648,
-0.0034666173,
-0.001555839,
-0.0231732,
0.0531149358,
-0.0344461426,
-0.0098450035,
0.0166155323,
0.0663337335,
-0.0064996658,
-0.0152602959,
-0.0019866547,
0.0242973175,
0.0046454123,
0.0824966058,
0.0277880169,
-0.0411395654,
-0.0359233692,
-0.0377694517,
-0.0236973371,
-0.0344448686,
-0.0304348152,
0.0420297831,
-0.0132641261,
-0.076050587,
-0.0754292011,
-0.0829653144,
-0.0005077263,
0.0390184112,
0.0113496799,
0.0380634852,
-0.0099485442,
0.0035249263,
-0.0158083364,
0.029201841,
-0.0092461761,
0.0036829973,
0.0387157947,
-0.0239851456,
0.0186399445,
-0.0392639302,
-0.0031901014,
0.0293716863,
-0.0768173337,
-0.0741761923,
0.0284060929,
0.0427105688,
0.0221876092,
0.08534237,
-0.0395302847,
-0.0307533462,
0.0022933898,
0.0524672046,
0.0053016124,
-0.0389283299,
0.0467063934,
-0.0324949473,
0.006470798,
0.065897353,
0.0112222964,
0.0132089294,
0.0490097739,
-0.0095804669,
-0.0369304419,
-0.00227872,
0.0268497374,
0.0180386733,
0.087313734,
-0.0196490288,
-0.0434936136,
-0.0487043411,
0.0222246256,
-0.0281725284,
-0.034914881,
-0.0132065937,
0.0119408295,
0.0175464209,
0.0173356142,
-0.0383851081,
-0.0227535218,
-0.0224709641,
0.0092407148,
-0.0049853562,
0.0232750177,
0.0487398021,
0.0880601183,
-0.0042671645,
0.0019517874,
-0.0285146311,
-0.0052411682,
0.0038465299,
0.0563819595,
0.0082889432,
0.0349231623,
0.0290323868,
-0.0069449688,
0.012601058,
0.0036055471,
-0.0430395529,
-0.013513891,
-0.0447015576,
0.0303534362,
0.0674112737,
-0.0300514251,
0.0220830645,
-0.0547787324,
0.0096350955,
0.0022812267,
0.0339325219,
-0.0030013244,
-0.0372125208,
0.0236320719,
-0.0141595993,
-0.0162226222,
0.0047378978,
0.0526013374,
0.0187667999,
0.0686153322,
0.0171637032,
-0.007238525,
-0.0461308733,
-0.0373573862,
0.0243537035,
0.0127528552,
-0.030133279,
0.0305708461,
-0.0336306803,
-0.0900589004,
-0.0043848408,
0.0254910514,
0.0242460668,
0.0427691042,
-0.0018056373,
0.0658719614,
0.026390966,
-0.0227202307,
-0.0505727977,
0.0144060748,
-0.0488795266,
0.0008401834,
-0.0223522857,
-6.562610106e-33,
-0.0285681114,
-0.0099051809,
0.0009169983,
-0.0296406746,
0.0089160167,
-0.0047330586,
-0.0382688642,
-0.0053608995,
-0.0531265028,
0.0094457129,
-0.0172120035,
0.0123563157,
0.0290586948,
0.0289105326,
-0.0060178502,
-0.0463648513,
0.0061353934,
0.0344627798,
0.0092768921,
-0.0348619111,
0.0027439038,
0.022465501,
0.0843596682,
-0.0713451058,
0.0436625779,
0.0050389394,
-0.0102042574,
0.0057619419,
-0.0497305207,
0.046354726,
-0.0244078059,
0.0420095325,
0.0256617051,
0.0025319003,
0.0111299232,
-0.0221354943,
-0.0810828879,
-0.0653789937,
0.0497631058,
0.0632084757,
-0.0528411753,
-0.0276812557,
0.0109545551,
-0.0176830813,
-0.0007084918,
0.0140584158,
0.0236288607,
-0.0534117781,
0.0293701198,
0.0269759111,
-0.0400071777,
0.038163662,
0.0227914788,
-0.0066244272,
-0.0079216938,
0.059786588,
0.0078717377,
-0.0399739444,
-0.0977504775,
0.0192494784,
0.0016969651,
-0.0129261855,
0.0326165259,
-0.0068673864,
0.0448873155,
0.0268013999,
0.0465275273,
-0.0161331091,
-0.0493009463,
0.0070817866,
0.0015173682,
0.0455191061,
0.0669098496,
0.0833396986,
0.093143627,
0.005592796,
-0.094871901,
-0.0119802374,
0.0242768861,
0.0271151848,
0.0056691389,
-0.0038992674,
-0.0857218429,
-0.0375026017,
-0.017540941,
-0.1029223427,
-0.0162331946,
-0.0605633445,
-0.0019333025,
0.0219082888,
-0.0563741289,
0.0286954492,
0.0124753909,
-0.0598941222,
-0.0018593837,
-0.0030855099,
-0.010232524,
-0.0351025723,
-0.0065852245,
0.0436370894,
-0.0585320331,
-0.0074220817,
0.0141201951,
-0.0182186086,
0.0185102653,
0.0079835868,
0.0723984763,
-0.0049639787,
-0.0396874622,
0.0106081897,
-0.0298399553,
-0.0088898027,
0.0021502441,
0.0140918018,
0.054673966,
0.0382592753,
-0.0000492162,
0.013773161,
0.027502019,
0.0199705232,
-0.0679306313,
0.0164787024,
-0.0011709203,
0.0063353465,
-0.0332958698,
-0.0064290673,
-0.0224201735,
-0.0135821793,
0.008230147,
-0.0674963817,
-0.0140824402,
0.0168717541,
2.668e-7,
0.0463004448,
0.0027634064,
0.0548869111,
0.0100778947,
-0.0102758547,
0.0305737015,
0.0003647005,
0.0024476689,
0.0072250427,
-0.0187413264,
0.0276928023,
0.042413123,
0.0651179701,
0.0423473045,
-0.0866612718,
0.0101986155,
-0.0584563091,
0.0153593589,
-0.0306063425,
-0.037420895,
0.0506559387,
0.1298654079,
0.0071230987,
-0.0132118491,
-0.0290203933,
-0.0215010755,
0.0478152484,
0.0135597838,
-0.0208163615,
0.0072326432,
0.0431726947,
-0.0136270775,
0.0063664084,
0.0265203677,
-0.0195492133,
-0.037617825,
0.0339725055,
0.0163792353,
-0.0090472363,
-0.0277131572,
-0.0308867898,
-0.0134507669,
-0.0118109668,
-0.0267723426,
0.0920797139,
-0.0251341127,
-0.0552655272,
-0.0151283126,
-0.0043874304,
0.0414394848,
0.0586065501,
-0.0062387278,
-0.0274964776,
0.0125306258,
0.0421874486,
-0.0315079354,
-0.0286680888,
-0.0149299363,
-0.0387464166,
-0.0344790965,
-0.0319245569,
-0.0000983689,
-0.0055137272,
0.0231464822,
0.0411032401,
-0.0162911676,
0.0053443168,
2.065351151e-34,
0.0235221256,
0.0062209554,
0.0052044899,
-0.0205016974,
0.0559040084,
-0.0294372272,
-0.002876546,
-0.0067831995,
0.0056237667,
-0.0440899655,
-0.0149436546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17706v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17706v1 | FedBiOT: LLM Local Fine-tuning in Federated Learning without Full Model | 2024-06-25T16:45:47 | 2024-06-25T16:45:47 | Feijie Wu, Zitao Li, Yaliang Li, Bolin Ding, Jing Gao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DC | Large language models (LLMs) show amazing performance on many domain-specific
tasks after fine-tuning with some appropriate data. However, many
domain-specific data are privately distributed across multiple owners. Thus,
this dilemma raises the interest in how to perform LLM fine-tuning in federated
learning (FL). However, confronted with limited computation and communication
capacities, FL clients struggle to fine-tune an LLM effectively. To this end,
we introduce FedBiOT, a resource-efficient LLM fine-tuning approach to FL.
Specifically, our method involves the server generating a compressed LLM and
aligning its performance with the full model. Subsequently, the clients
fine-tune a lightweight yet important part of the compressed model, referred to
as an adapter. Notice that as the server has no access to the private data
owned by the clients, the data used for alignment by the server has a different
distribution from the one used for fine-tuning by clients. We formulate the
problem into a bi-level optimization problem to minimize the negative effect of
data discrepancy and derive the updating rules for the server and clients. We
conduct extensive experiments on LLaMA-2, empirically showing that the adapter
has exceptional performance when reintegrated into the global LLM. The results
also indicate that the proposed FedBiOT significantly reduces resource
consumption compared to existing benchmarks, all while achieving comparable
performance levels. | FedBiOT: LLM Local Fine-tuning in Federated Learning without Full Model: Large language models (LLMs) show amazing performance on many domain-specific
tasks after fine-tuning with some appropriate data. However, many
domain-specific data are privately distributed across multiple owners. Thus,
this dilemma raises the interest in how to perform LLM fine-tuning in federated
learning (FL). However, confronted with limited computation and communication
capacities, FL clients struggle to fine-tune an LLM effectively. To this end,
we introduce FedBiOT, a resource-efficient LLM fine-tuning approach to FL.
Specifically, our method involves the server generating a compressed LLM and
aligning its performance with the full model. Subsequently, the clients
fine-tune a lightweight yet important part of the compressed model, referred to
as an adapter. Notice that as the server has no access to the private data
owned by the clients, the data used for alignment by the server has a different
distribution from the one used for fine-tuning by clients. We formulate the
problem into a bi-level optimization problem to minimize the negative effect of
data discrepancy and derive the updating rules for the server and clients. We
conduct extensive experiments on LLaMA-2, empirically showing that the adapter
has exceptional performance when reintegrated into the global LLM. The results
also indicate that the proposed FedBiOT significantly reduces resource
consumption compared to existing benchmarks, all while achieving comparable
performance levels. | [
-0.0048592244,
0.0779442266,
-0.0237358473,
0.0560917258,
-0.0504147969,
-0.0037646382,
0.0498327315,
-0.0111038545,
0.0086029246,
-0.0084636789,
-0.0761822686,
-0.0275226831,
0.0204450749,
0.0323803276,
-0.0073936344,
0.0083681475,
0.0415510461,
-0.0152878631,
-0.03088101,
-0.0401250012,
-0.0359721668,
-0.00170876,
0.0250069611,
0.0040306798,
0.0306915175,
-0.0414599776,
-0.0151846381,
0.0177129135,
0.0048980243,
0.026680192,
0.0398769639,
0.0411745049,
0.0135127967,
0.0768393055,
0.0000021781,
-0.0275452342,
-0.0444030911,
0.0214960705,
-0.0315661132,
0.0884731114,
0.0171573851,
-0.0026801541,
-0.023031259,
0.0357158706,
-0.0339746326,
-0.0118508162,
0.0291574895,
-0.013328963,
0.0836292803,
0.0783935562,
0.002079969,
-0.0354283117,
0.0054081697,
-0.0394620784,
-0.1231549233,
-0.0456108563,
0.0142975412,
-0.024460068,
-0.041829206,
-0.0257883128,
-0.0311601143,
0.0070526553,
0.0142368488,
0.0308112595,
-0.0118654827,
-0.0013838911,
-0.0614461266,
-0.0292152334,
-0.0222826265,
0.04694492,
0.0056478581,
-0.0084203184,
0.0130263222,
-0.0187958758,
-0.0224419031,
0.0046699601,
-0.0011252976,
0.0161448009,
0.026967857,
0.0424503349,
0.0122225303,
-0.0290237814,
0.0319492109,
0.0071174749,
-0.0110217454,
0.0940016508,
0.001840096,
0.0144025199,
-0.0529506952,
-0.0101598771,
-0.0166083779,
-0.0614272989,
0.0328903683,
0.0411407389,
-0.0254514534,
-0.0144900652,
-0.0879801959,
-0.0629331097,
0.0198128242,
0.0206349306,
0.077003397,
0.0092163254,
0.0016887725,
0.049253691,
-0.0204693377,
0.0113523155,
-0.0314116552,
0.031520538,
-0.0171666183,
0.0071278308,
-0.0166101214,
0.0290494971,
-0.0032895894,
0.0390895195,
-0.0660323799,
0.0027491809,
-0.0163723566,
0.0320257731,
0.0079858974,
0.0360128395,
0.0086442381,
-0.0273082871,
-0.0376617312,
-0.0077328105,
0.0123097207,
0.0249084737,
-0.0340063646,
0.0110372882,
0.0330291651,
-0.0531443916,
-0.0121554872,
-0.0089877313,
-0.0347755887,
-0.0120460466,
0.017598452,
0.0558258407,
0.0130969556,
-0.0018284456,
0.0069967853,
-0.0522624515,
0.0560681857,
-0.083925657,
0.0021034875,
-0.0376315191,
0.0185860731,
-0.0069952291,
0.014403698,
-0.0440674573,
-0.0205747839,
-0.031347353,
-0.0283818021,
0.0520656183,
-0.0467091352,
0.0020855498,
-0.006950004,
0.007328792,
0.0156223318,
0.1055157855,
0.0208958611,
0.0044786823,
0.0431455187,
0.0073680379,
-0.0485515557,
0.038286373,
0.0635784566,
0.0591339692,
-0.0257362146,
0.0102038458,
0.0004083851,
0.0444412492,
0.000901557,
0.0209667943,
-0.0055425428,
-0.0196575224,
0.0447392352,
0.0562537909,
0.0580508485,
0.0135324914,
-0.052569177,
0.0194785483,
0.0042490968,
0.0319096036,
-0.0671754926,
0.0241221748,
-0.0199645944,
-0.0287271086,
0.023230467,
0.1122396961,
-0.0285616256,
-0.0313866846,
-0.0145038962,
-0.0438196845,
-0.048316054,
0.0156210037,
0.0208959542,
-0.001072711,
-0.0122614084,
0.0757944509,
0.044709444,
-0.0228977595,
-0.0194397457,
-0.0339147411,
-0.0090482347,
0.0621905699,
0.0779167563,
-0.0022941725,
-0.0512866415,
-0.0066783461,
0.030149851,
0.0212613344,
0.0175523423,
0.0213818904,
0.0186304022,
-0.0539132021,
-0.0708050728,
0.0230709706,
0.0120267924,
-0.004592163,
-0.0049790088,
-0.0065308618,
-0.0317543708,
-0.0229081884,
-0.0008113403,
0.0306892227,
0.0111068804,
-0.0055415961,
0.0104770605,
0.0237823911,
0.0485531501,
-0.0292618573,
-0.0143924607,
-0.0387563594,
0.0127569214,
-0.0096647572,
-0.0123731932,
-0.0386433043,
-0.0017101022,
0.000277902,
0.021600645,
0.0136301592,
0.0361969657,
0.0430855453,
-0.0885092616,
-0.0310972463,
-0.0037948077,
0.0083532026,
0.0246819649,
-0.0140170464,
0.024366226,
-0.0233891625,
0.0448675752,
-0.0248881318,
0.0036470401,
-0.0412857607,
-0.0237967614,
-0.013348449,
-0.0189353842,
0.024378825,
-0.0172537453,
0.0345636047,
0.009196315,
0.0141121438,
0.0167898219,
-0.0264852885,
0.0235959925,
-0.0066431854,
-0.0009206834,
0.017083738,
0.0384967998,
-0.0348162577,
0.0566481613,
0.0293682776,
0.0200860426,
-0.021164747,
-0.0203384925,
-0.0129317017,
0.0693890527,
-0.0432379395,
0.026446905,
0.0201309174,
0.0092244074,
-0.0490336046,
-0.0167273693,
-0.0307609905,
0.0319129266,
0.0136635881,
-0.0329365581,
-0.0078113703,
-0.0808898807,
0.0256010797,
-0.0613693707,
0.04438667,
0.0028519575,
-0.0382315181,
-0.0192874279,
0.0319681689,
-0.0112804715,
0.0824697167,
-0.0276308097,
-0.0103338929,
0.0650032908,
0.0266649574,
-0.0786962211,
0.0097454321,
-0.0152013618,
-0.0422890857,
-0.0609007515,
0.0421498418,
0.0149004953,
0.0659607947,
-0.0595748648,
-0.0298260599,
-0.0223426502,
0.0407281034,
-0.0156034073,
-0.0216618702,
-0.0259589832,
0.0358872749,
0.0047325594,
0.0566601157,
0.0142477052,
-0.0942550004,
0.0891349167,
-0.0302351546,
0.0142117282,
-0.0083092386,
-0.0475892052,
-0.0642460138,
0.0148713998,
-0.0132498033,
0.026521476,
-0.0220167059,
-0.0445896126,
-0.0478586257,
0.0274894126,
0.0341458172,
-0.0379616395,
0.006371785,
-0.0037751065,
-0.0107953716,
-0.0505428836,
-0.0617613047,
0.0147716878,
-0.0257610995,
-0.0456287898,
0.016195219,
-0.016866684,
-0.0327722356,
-0.0380271003,
0.0087737255,
-0.0095960936,
0.0055052149,
-0.0121820299,
0.0199069753,
-0.0367223471,
-0.0247369856,
0.011483537,
0.0021573086,
-0.0066580204,
-0.0289660115,
-0.0295327138,
0.0387945212,
0.0394981429,
-0.0225336831,
0.0336841568,
-0.0328572243,
0.0605951026,
-0.0177509878,
-0.0229444858,
-0.0111629767,
0.0599131472,
-0.0471421108,
-0.0091594998,
0.0727721974,
0.0090728439,
-0.0452684946,
-0.0000766489,
-0.0353846513,
0.0668171123,
0.0148674194,
0.039814204,
-0.0799084082,
-0.0312825441,
0.0467523783,
0.0550565571,
0.032198038,
-0.0207434371,
-0.0217898749,
-0.1102538481,
0.0181704555,
0.0236415882,
-0.0030314759,
-0.0363989286,
-0.0365218706,
0.0219419096,
-0.0031644544,
0.0230117161,
-0.0165316146,
0.0290210731,
-0.0072053149,
0.0156077305,
0.0076189782,
-0.0493630804,
-0.0080258362,
-0.0153990397,
0.0794083402,
0.0261316076,
0.001214503,
0.0348806344,
-0.0742888898,
0.0166076366,
0.0417421795,
-0.0169339981,
-0.0388242193,
-0.0125070568,
0.0042925142,
-0.0218081102,
0.0196294412,
0.0127569139,
0.0172999594,
-0.0016436682,
0.0068159159,
0.0948340818,
-0.009884988,
0.0257968884,
0.0034181727,
-0.0416125581,
0.0153706037,
0.0410055742,
0.0276146345,
-0.0182290971,
-0.0220053494,
0.0117024528,
-0.0107076894,
-0.0042504529,
0.0038277507,
0.0249028876,
-0.0255648363,
0.0208410509,
-0.0115132332,
0.0324248374,
0.0050407117,
0.052899722,
0.0146063231,
0.010039011,
0.0276722796,
-0.0039447867,
-0.0449175611,
0.0010107268,
-0.0874509513,
0.0329597034,
-0.0721437559,
-0.0289233681,
0.0392431468,
0.0162815321,
-0.0180755891,
0.0164516177,
-0.0643320456,
-0.0785219893,
0.0214662012,
0.0251253955,
0.0219608843,
0.0493227392,
-0.0185845196,
-0.0693139806,
0.0637907311,
0.0589190982,
-0.0780178905,
0.0477843545,
0.0372642353,
-0.0751656517,
0.0167381205,
0.0599391535,
-0.0646961182,
-0.0015001385,
0.0570605397,
-0.0006134315,
0.0080878921,
-0.0982145965,
-0.0481443331,
0.0663151368,
0.0581548773,
-0.0112431925,
-0.027447708,
-0.0067507029,
0.0649567395,
0.010362125,
0.0104434872,
-0.031957183,
-0.0220330302,
-0.0061641973,
-0.0272179246,
0.0287409853,
0.0083018159,
0.0561129004,
0.0091601368,
-0.010808384,
0.0121895811,
-0.0102972016,
-0.0434983149,
0.0641680062,
0.0173855219,
0.0269009378,
0.0234778617,
0.0564440899,
0.0709505454,
-0.0361748263,
0.0090670316,
-0.0135993976,
0.0545612164,
-0.0602390319,
0.0403406844,
-0.0141523341,
-0.1076711193,
-0.002864049,
0.0346512198,
0.0353397503,
0.0429203324,
0.0102020642,
-0.0178970248,
-0.0107923718,
-0.014152525,
0.0025052754,
-0.0439040028,
-0.0308106504,
0.0427479371,
-0.0168477371,
-0.0049831914,
0.0513196588,
0.0826515332,
-0.0017098489,
0.0411212966,
-0.0548186339,
0.031598065,
-0.0474952757,
-0.0204734355,
0.0020065235,
0.032523144,
-0.033204779,
-0.0225548223,
-0.0267668236,
-0.0611489825,
0.0047201738,
0.004700948,
-0.0089828102,
-0.0261596981,
0.0151256882,
0.0285031665,
0.0067163208,
-0.0018641717,
-0.0539518185,
0.0010385173,
0.0130746271,
-0.0025105465,
0.0446324907,
-6.80466276e-33,
-0.0471461713,
0.0095692445,
0.0080269258,
0.031926211,
-0.0238636695,
0.0302441157,
-0.0028946083,
-0.0235801972,
0.0178913046,
-0.0246592388,
-0.0531205758,
0.0157247223,
0.0334450342,
0.0160576776,
-0.0147411656,
-0.028428616,
0.0347482301,
-0.0521970876,
-0.0527257286,
0.0173565596,
0.0329854377,
0.0475543961,
0.0223673545,
-0.0337275192,
-0.0335301012,
-0.0178137198,
-0.0060019293,
0.045063816,
-0.0376977399,
0.0235969815,
-0.0167743694,
0.0188087504,
-0.0020199073,
-0.0265491959,
-0.0250990279,
-0.0334345847,
-0.0460328162,
0.0043059643,
-0.0071305414,
0.0189931914,
-0.0391189344,
-0.0395536497,
0.053948421,
0.0165435746,
-0.0352658965,
-0.0247118175,
0.0015344921,
-0.0078818509,
-0.0365006216,
-0.0275616515,
-0.0277978089,
-0.0100370608,
0.0305565149,
-0.0052451449,
0.0465166681,
-0.0335891247,
0.0154024046,
-0.0062638004,
-0.0397628918,
0.0112922769,
0.0202231389,
0.0371573046,
0.0808152631,
0.0221233442,
-0.0040774262,
0.0399142504,
0.0472314283,
0.0107017942,
-0.0128891878,
0.0328080095,
0.0275288951,
0.0214244835,
-0.0144751007,
0.0462500788,
-0.0133843794,
-0.0380245708,
-0.0457194969,
-0.0072702565,
0.0410922915,
-0.0165007822,
-0.0115408599,
0.0350688845,
0.0048564775,
-0.0087651657,
-0.0352448896,
0.0181172416,
-0.0197049454,
0.00666897,
-0.0123264361,
0.0113642346,
-0.0279489085,
-0.0516183749,
0.0350867324,
-0.0392209366,
-0.0011246947,
-0.0034281239,
0.0586569309,
0.0049328841,
0.016947262,
0.0232064128,
-0.0731453598,
-0.0469097346,
-0.0289867353,
-0.0360321999,
0.0272656232,
0.00717569,
0.0670188069,
0.0304992497,
-0.0654753521,
0.0053106439,
-0.0352407545,
0.0118604209,
0.0251016952,
0.023380788,
0.0530019961,
-0.0307091512,
0.0171631612,
0.0218624622,
0.0083921589,
0.0050579025,
-0.0116726793,
-0.0090181101,
0.0061502578,
0.0201351419,
-0.0060270559,
0.0034674162,
-0.0532445163,
0.0355967321,
0.0389978923,
-0.0261360966,
-0.005236702,
-0.0379410163,
2.951e-7,
0.0230782069,
0.0459817164,
-0.0163958278,
-0.0325500295,
0.032961335,
0.0350381844,
-0.0435267352,
0.0375269465,
0.003140897,
0.0275102668,
0.0053067878,
0.0284658037,
0.055885423,
0.0031728102,
-0.0434296057,
0.0308244713,
-0.0300398935,
0.0530871302,
-0.0502500609,
-0.0587280877,
-0.0531337745,
0.0817480907,
0.039936237,
-0.0442282148,
0.0181043763,
-0.0143603226,
0.0293186512,
-0.0330685377,
-0.052238293,
0.0131101878,
0.0201983694,
0.102790229,
-0.0298428182,
-0.0360503085,
-0.0110679371,
0.0236746259,
-0.061740566,
0.08435563,
0.0336946845,
0.024307223,
-0.0029612437,
-0.0398774333,
-0.0484066382,
0.0243485048,
0.0469119735,
-0.0270132385,
-0.0257130265,
-0.018204106,
0.039255619,
-0.067603521,
0.0409304388,
-0.0040403116,
0.0201132838,
0.0275081899,
-0.0004583366,
-0.0254764128,
-0.0420671813,
-0.0688579157,
-0.0054213987,
-0.0199031755,
-0.0243356302,
-0.0499996841,
-0.0333599262,
0.0229147915,
0.0205625109,
-0.0317941383,
0.0116256,
2.836496797e-34,
0.0240344778,
-0.0253707413,
0.02832748,
0.0407824367,
-0.025119083,
-0.0362560786,
0.001029058,
0.0181054156,
-0.0129285129,
-0.0379336588,
0.0079593761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17692v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17692v1 | From Distributional to Overton Pluralism: Investigating Large Language Model Alignment | 2024-06-25T16:32:33 | 2024-06-25T16:32:33 | Thom Lake, Eunsol Choi, Greg Durrett | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The alignment process changes several properties of a large language model's
(LLM's) output distribution. We analyze two aspects of post-alignment
distributional shift of LLM responses. First, we re-examine previously reported
reductions in response diversity post-alignment. Our analysis suggests that an
apparent drop in the diversity of responses is largely explained by quality
control and information aggregation. Alignment suppresses irrelevant and
unhelpful content while shifting the output distribution toward longer
responses that cover information spanning several responses from the base LLM,
essentially presenting diverse information in a single response. Finding little
evidence that alignment suppresses useful information, it is natural to ask the
opposite question: do aligned models surface information that cannot be
recovered from base models? Our second investigation shows this is not the case
and the behavior of aligned models is recoverable from base models without
fine-tuning. A combination of in-context examples and lower-resolution semantic
hints about response content can elicit responses from base LLMs that are as
similar to alignment-tuned LLM responses as alignment-tuned LLM responses are
to each other. Taken together, these results indicate that current alignment
techniques capture but do not extend the useful subset of assistant-like base
LLM behavior, providing further evidence for the Superficial Alignment
Hypothesis. They also show that in-context alignment can go surprisingly far as
a strategy for imitating aligned LLMs without fine-tuning. Our code and data is
available at https://github.com/thomlake/investigating-alignment. | From Distributional to Overton Pluralism: Investigating Large Language Model Alignment: The alignment process changes several properties of a large language model's
(LLM's) output distribution. We analyze two aspects of post-alignment
distributional shift of LLM responses. First, we re-examine previously reported
reductions in response diversity post-alignment. Our analysis suggests that an
apparent drop in the diversity of responses is largely explained by quality
control and information aggregation. Alignment suppresses irrelevant and
unhelpful content while shifting the output distribution toward longer
responses that cover information spanning several responses from the base LLM,
essentially presenting diverse information in a single response. Finding little
evidence that alignment suppresses useful information, it is natural to ask the
opposite question: do aligned models surface information that cannot be
recovered from base models? Our second investigation shows this is not the case
and the behavior of aligned models is recoverable from base models without
fine-tuning. A combination of in-context examples and lower-resolution semantic
hints about response content can elicit responses from base LLMs that are as
similar to alignment-tuned LLM responses as alignment-tuned LLM responses are
to each other. Taken together, these results indicate that current alignment
techniques capture but do not extend the useful subset of assistant-like base
LLM behavior, providing further evidence for the Superficial Alignment
Hypothesis. They also show that in-context alignment can go surprisingly far as
a strategy for imitating aligned LLMs without fine-tuning. Our code and data is
available at https://github.com/thomlake/investigating-alignment. | [
0.0208503269,
0.0410461277,
-0.0365810096,
0.0338490047,
-0.055195339,
-0.0038789667,
-0.0095026102,
-0.020132171,
-0.0649216101,
-0.0211254749,
-0.0502667464,
-0.0430250913,
0.0366390757,
-0.0142103862,
0.0351996571,
-0.0137910787,
0.0539601967,
-0.0134565914,
-0.0012004658,
-0.0293155331,
0.0103800325,
0.0274328291,
-0.0043067443,
0.0366836973,
0.0085573923,
-0.0236731432,
-0.0238660891,
0.0122575285,
0.0172105264,
0.0053221397,
-0.0181067362,
0.0378015749,
0.0068998951,
0.0395847112,
0.0000016722,
-0.066036135,
0.0102968039,
0.0050027776,
-0.0382374041,
0.0360615142,
0.0003741868,
-0.0172513202,
-0.0017390569,
-0.0059662238,
-0.0343357138,
0.0049414812,
0.076004371,
0.0121422233,
-0.0125820301,
0.0515366644,
-0.0002210025,
-0.0467795953,
0.0380872153,
0.00038673,
-0.0155455926,
-0.0044935602,
0.0000984098,
-0.0022730313,
0.0051726433,
0.0124341734,
-0.0348500684,
0.0186481811,
-0.0003012073,
0.0094309421,
0.0105055794,
0.0251222048,
-0.0177083798,
-0.0567025803,
0.0014354453,
0.0542086884,
0.0175981093,
-0.0210974962,
-0.0324239545,
-0.0347287282,
0.0341577381,
0.0425495319,
-0.0409240611,
0.0268246159,
0.0106904386,
0.0346472338,
0.0209690332,
-0.0327730253,
0.0166461747,
0.0040682023,
-0.0196624808,
0.0683159977,
0.0321325175,
-0.0495073125,
-0.0173618458,
0.0077703148,
-0.0242383461,
-0.0551988259,
-0.0363948345,
0.0201320108,
-0.032705389,
0.0323304012,
-0.0221975483,
-0.0194709506,
0.0421864428,
-0.0221219081,
0.0554126129,
0.0699386224,
-0.0167757459,
0.0073492215,
0.0166646633,
0.072594665,
-0.0634132996,
0.0269606691,
-0.049926728,
0.0151434727,
-0.0038122907,
-0.0364057422,
0.0267358664,
0.0341105945,
-0.0393144786,
-0.014262381,
-0.0389534347,
0.0563029014,
0.0067612207,
0.0132018132,
-0.0257427916,
0.0039032879,
-0.0237116572,
-0.0037489401,
-0.0260383952,
0.0959757343,
-0.0370902307,
0.0286955424,
0.0156647321,
-0.0382838249,
-0.0019966853,
0.0241885353,
-0.0270410366,
-0.0486921035,
-0.0256935433,
0.0348318629,
-0.0145107415,
-0.0049583078,
0.0139053054,
-0.0092743831,
-0.045647379,
-0.0617478676,
-0.0071664471,
-0.0766205937,
0.0371082202,
0.0636866763,
-0.0221193712,
-0.0502082147,
-0.0059205112,
-0.0205274113,
-0.0323378704,
0.0299008414,
0.0045683216,
0.0585635193,
0.0129387742,
-0.0224921294,
0.0157930572,
0.0747436434,
0.0125176553,
-0.0245921873,
0.0329640619,
-0.0411867276,
0.0026179401,
0.0544021018,
-0.0118411882,
0.0159851536,
-0.0290665664,
0.0058329203,
0.0091257179,
0.0338252373,
0.078836374,
0.0300156716,
0.0058484222,
-0.0248450954,
0.0865386501,
0.0464152694,
0.0135763995,
0.0072593554,
0.0045694201,
0.0062964852,
-0.0035105657,
0.0616622977,
-0.0729219317,
0.0127910469,
-0.0374829099,
0.0627677664,
0.0190025866,
0.0561929233,
-0.0309861377,
-0.0217643492,
-0.0518724211,
0.0243490543,
-0.0092807347,
0.0100910692,
0.0361108556,
-0.0278712679,
-0.0087049948,
0.0450880602,
0.0429246426,
-0.0355517603,
-0.0045323055,
-0.0421328768,
0.0578463525,
0.0106047578,
0.014862841,
-0.0144028841,
-0.0457501225,
0.0310500339,
-0.0283576343,
0.0972952321,
0.057390634,
0.0251754466,
0.0105369454,
-0.0231297668,
-0.0233825035,
-0.0337590873,
0.0086604245,
0.0004605264,
-0.006738591,
-0.0266847033,
-0.0195211004,
-0.041853562,
-0.0098629091,
0.0247526746,
-0.0106290597,
-0.0063329423,
-0.0612291396,
0.0090958821,
0.0314220414,
0.0050576292,
-0.0002006701,
0.0287330076,
0.0146253137,
0.0003736414,
0.0251825619,
-0.002715423,
-0.037593253,
-0.0091425767,
0.0505595878,
0.0146090621,
-0.0185633209,
0.0428926013,
-0.0000459363,
-0.0330460332,
0.0068746861,
-0.0100841094,
0.044724144,
-0.0038538401,
0.0540025309,
-0.0193479005,
0.0254370254,
-0.0599037074,
0.0489343889,
0.0111266263,
0.0232095215,
0.0060284054,
-0.0023749336,
-0.0072392407,
-0.0190556049,
-0.018708868,
0.032077577,
-0.0271735378,
0.0065167407,
0.040556971,
-0.0453318357,
-0.0492518246,
-0.0272729602,
-0.0552696735,
0.0419531912,
-0.0116373682,
0.037681289,
0.061457593,
0.0208428819,
-0.0172197763,
0.0391605347,
-0.0491861477,
-0.0027184102,
0.0286800396,
0.0546178445,
0.0382775404,
-0.017387718,
-0.0395479389,
-0.0640740246,
-0.0134185636,
-0.0262476951,
0.0324501172,
-0.0173776168,
0.0014267068,
-0.0823405609,
0.0168036632,
-0.0657658428,
-0.0012659405,
-0.0121856453,
-0.0447705165,
0.0217402261,
0.0173270162,
0.0631330535,
0.0388722159,
0.0099395886,
0.030041052,
0.0587585196,
0.0200667493,
-0.0764452964,
-0.0045871139,
-0.0436014682,
-0.0462123528,
-0.0610982031,
-0.0496175662,
-0.0130082099,
0.0903572962,
0.0279721152,
0.0028508946,
-0.0490370467,
-0.0080317194,
0.0000285556,
-0.0479758605,
-0.0043390333,
-0.0370754264,
-0.0398857556,
0.0434292182,
-0.0280360561,
-0.0791531652,
0.0427758619,
-0.0125269927,
-0.0245892666,
-0.0150918327,
-0.0028983187,
-0.0338053182,
0.053820882,
-0.0184481665,
0.0159889348,
-0.0131337149,
-0.031066753,
-0.08901117,
-0.0229841582,
0.008459473,
-0.025267873,
0.1113638356,
-0.0422107726,
-0.0025077683,
-0.0354113504,
-0.0276030656,
-0.0321173333,
-0.0483438186,
0.006878552,
0.0226776693,
0.0002949252,
0.0055235652,
-0.0609727055,
0.0095650349,
0.0662076995,
-0.0121956058,
-0.0330403484,
0.0190635715,
-0.026491167,
0.0168014802,
0.0644613653,
0.063975513,
0.0441538729,
-0.0429942161,
0.0030359651,
0.0204771385,
0.0133414567,
0.0204207804,
-0.0238449257,
-0.0384101383,
0.0688051358,
-0.0355427526,
-0.036561273,
0.0261200219,
0.0942706317,
-0.008615844,
0.0100418944,
0.1040039435,
0.0223014783,
-0.0267395247,
0.0166364554,
-0.0537148155,
0.0619782396,
0.013652185,
0.0028504913,
-0.0519204326,
0.0156205855,
0.0065245447,
-0.0309118591,
0.0004192878,
0.0148893353,
-0.0113604488,
-0.1476614028,
-0.0002591842,
0.0256497189,
-0.0640689358,
-0.0269542579,
0.0018552145,
0.0653943345,
0.016408246,
0.0514136478,
0.049232617,
-0.020121349,
-0.0081003029,
0.0134565504,
0.0154567482,
-0.0361021534,
-0.0207530744,
-0.0537290536,
0.0612235703,
0.0601336509,
0.0082308818,
-0.0186215583,
-0.0345043838,
0.0433240794,
-0.0357429348,
0.0236428138,
0.0224100836,
-0.0063384324,
0.0210635047,
0.0169018395,
-0.0185308736,
0.0169398561,
-0.0101668928,
-0.0116439089,
-0.0067265746,
0.0495238602,
-0.0118979421,
-0.0092266584,
-0.0423174873,
0.0116017843,
-0.0252789985,
0.0777931362,
0.0318572707,
-0.030666152,
-0.0104379291,
-0.0023578936,
-0.0151961735,
0.0390702225,
-0.0193968602,
0.0324431285,
-0.0040860418,
-0.0177710652,
-0.0429043286,
-0.0484387614,
-0.0209233314,
-0.0086202975,
0.0218774732,
-0.0022821152,
-0.0348139144,
-0.0463088267,
0.0166086163,
0.0461026914,
-0.0077485135,
0.0220214315,
-0.0481983498,
0.0008452333,
-0.0151120834,
-0.044065658,
0.0013992133,
-0.0144793103,
-0.0508498885,
-0.1121155694,
0.0200855937,
-0.012563386,
0.0314468779,
0.0415874198,
0.0396147035,
-0.0405946225,
0.0189115591,
0.0407688729,
-0.0201353561,
0.0716517717,
0.0023135392,
-0.0003957976,
-0.0057446701,
0.0451032631,
-0.0419990197,
-0.005347068,
0.0528348349,
0.0618474223,
-0.0065655569,
-0.0514384396,
0.0298018698,
0.0178369675,
0.0479648449,
-0.0142804887,
0.0050513139,
-0.0208403058,
-0.0050053187,
-0.0260278918,
-0.0127161676,
0.0078477338,
-0.0551756918,
0.0311871804,
0.0019513069,
0.0176472608,
0.0356609225,
-0.0071319863,
0.0622177236,
-0.0603221655,
-0.0013843094,
-0.0217702519,
-0.0336729586,
0.0178555585,
0.0553295724,
-0.0303749405,
0.0350539349,
-0.0295235571,
0.0330884419,
0.0132580716,
0.0703006759,
0.0137092397,
0.0077567515,
-0.0358885303,
0.0123798857,
-0.0482160971,
-0.0225909688,
0.0152465198,
-0.0119322743,
0.0256731194,
-0.0191382244,
0.074149847,
-0.0044669015,
-0.0042239442,
-0.0354264714,
0.0318193249,
-0.0239496678,
0.0173345841,
0.0668972582,
0.0317682587,
-0.0349109285,
-0.0304632559,
0.0351455808,
-0.033162389,
-0.0010977724,
-0.0218369048,
0.0174788218,
-0.0068660807,
-0.0484237857,
0.0313737206,
-0.0016816903,
-0.0375055447,
-0.0121549005,
-0.080522947,
-0.0459704399,
0.009818757,
0.0039374824,
-0.0051324465,
-0.0496963486,
0.0090554282,
0.0789122134,
-0.0201565493,
-0.038241975,
-0.0149101382,
0.0060919863,
-0.0413215905,
0.0179208983,
-0.0462339744,
-5.960456512e-33,
-0.0347836986,
-0.0066757435,
0.017610075,
-0.0521509908,
-0.060333401,
-0.0011600044,
-0.0168194324,
0.0465368815,
-0.0535397194,
0.0077965921,
-0.0119874505,
-0.0128134321,
0.0122957611,
0.0073721362,
0.0307678767,
-0.0199361611,
0.0177653525,
0.031347163,
-0.0578498095,
-0.0309012271,
0.0302208476,
-0.0334943756,
0.0713022128,
-0.0499660671,
0.0365485474,
-0.0245192908,
0.0021998009,
-0.0020288869,
-0.0309371296,
0.0843579397,
-0.0100659914,
0.0694457293,
0.0334584378,
-0.0143422512,
-0.0108668124,
0.0403449424,
-0.0058466904,
-0.0372415595,
0.1130781621,
0.0031079771,
-0.0078074737,
-0.0364862718,
0.0529242642,
-0.0062052123,
-0.0433909968,
-0.0422644056,
0.0383023061,
-0.0263678003,
-0.0258787256,
0.0112815648,
-0.1014884487,
0.0033544046,
-0.0039219367,
0.0026817033,
-0.0355532616,
0.0287378188,
0.019576218,
0.0469313301,
-0.0255194418,
0.0177870337,
0.0245078448,
0.0408831313,
0.1011369228,
0.0541198477,
0.0119711841,
0.0331236459,
-0.013072269,
0.008718349,
-0.0282636397,
-0.0475127436,
0.0213988032,
0.0012256166,
0.0289787296,
0.0691116154,
0.0016141381,
0.0074449074,
-0.0234694481,
-0.0033315138,
0.0130541343,
0.0177020822,
0.0370838605,
0.0506150499,
-0.052085638,
-0.0113747288,
-0.031647142,
0.0089354003,
-0.0450217947,
-0.0264530126,
0.0247631297,
-0.0391138084,
0.0203212462,
0.0129728122,
0.0430274382,
-0.0227586385,
-0.0130747166,
0.0212263595,
-0.0405852646,
0.0392897837,
-0.0070841783,
0.0104590068,
-0.0443307348,
-0.0168487802,
-0.0212657619,
0.0054790149,
-0.002407725,
0.0498511046,
0.0116939303,
0.0065402361,
-0.0686344951,
0.0050022923,
-0.0371096209,
-0.0290114153,
0.0031913826,
-0.0538116507,
0.0565835126,
0.0005552942,
-0.0124805756,
0.044365719,
0.0373341553,
-0.0142319361,
-0.0472383536,
0.0044397968,
-0.0299766362,
0.0067036436,
-0.0332679302,
0.0090148607,
-0.0146175399,
0.0173139237,
0.0420181938,
-0.016360756,
-0.0399884954,
0.0144193545,
2.381e-7,
0.0713907033,
0.0052164299,
0.0269725304,
0.035301663,
0.0106407478,
0.0096564814,
-0.0122171305,
0.0310438983,
0.033545319,
-0.0196575392,
-0.0170700606,
0.006497975,
0.0407030247,
0.005590193,
-0.0237304363,
0.0393055305,
-0.0827264786,
0.0397056527,
-0.0513903014,
0.0522447005,
0.0186159406,
0.0921752155,
0.0035204908,
0.0088892076,
-0.0322229452,
-0.0230080653,
0.0576788411,
-0.0378372669,
-0.0066232341,
0.0435363017,
-0.0209785532,
-0.0334315635,
0.0237273294,
0.00451884,
0.0218677819,
0.0481475443,
-0.0214359686,
0.0557246357,
-0.0108366804,
-0.0017892036,
-0.0105595151,
-0.0261545423,
-0.0052122399,
-0.0895145088,
0.0410461463,
-0.0514144674,
-0.0502229966,
-0.0391989015,
-0.0215049498,
-0.0070217829,
0.0169722214,
-0.0221916661,
0.0224323645,
0.0322514735,
0.0270697232,
-0.0060418337,
-0.0484828576,
-0.038324412,
-0.0722208768,
0.0253342483,
-0.0536781959,
-0.072999157,
-0.0007642579,
0.0006960919,
0.0120698083,
-0.0686959252,
-0.0113438684,
2.189606643e-34,
0.0067587728,
-0.0054057427,
0.0400150903,
0.048755046,
-0.0018236203,
-0.0428137258,
-0.0132044666,
0.0463404097,
0.0280351844,
-0.0843844563,
-0.0190648064
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17681v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17681v2 | VarBench: Robust Language Model Benchmarking Through Dynamic Variable Perturbation | 2024-06-25T16:13:53 | 2024-06-26T15:21:49 | Kun Qian, Shunji Wan, Claudia Tang, Youzhi Wang, Xuanming Zhang, Maximillian Chen, Zhou Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models achieve impressive scores on traditional benchmarks,
an increasing number of researchers are becoming concerned about benchmark data
leakage during pre-training, commonly known as the data contamination problem.
To ensure fair evaluation, recent benchmarks release only the training and
validation sets, keeping the test set labels closed-source. They require anyone
wishing to evaluate his language model to submit the model's predictions for
centralized processing and then publish the model's result on their
leaderboard. However, this submission process is inefficient and prevents
effective error analysis. To address this issue, we propose to variabilize
benchmarks and evaluate language models dynamically. Specifically, we extract
variables from each test case and define a value range for each variable. For
each evaluation, we sample new values from these value ranges to create unique
test cases, thus ensuring a fresh evaluation each time. We applied this
variable perturbation method to four datasets: GSM8K, ARC, CommonsenseQA, and
TruthfulQA, which cover mathematical generation and multiple-choice tasks. Our
experimental results demonstrate that this approach provides a more accurate
assessment of the true capabilities of language models, effectively mitigating
the contamination problem. | VarBench: Robust Language Model Benchmarking Through Dynamic Variable Perturbation: As large language models achieve impressive scores on traditional benchmarks,
an increasing number of researchers are becoming concerned about benchmark data
leakage during pre-training, commonly known as the data contamination problem.
To ensure fair evaluation, recent benchmarks release only the training and
validation sets, keeping the test set labels closed-source. They require anyone
wishing to evaluate his language model to submit the model's predictions for
centralized processing and then publish the model's result on their
leaderboard. However, this submission process is inefficient and prevents
effective error analysis. To address this issue, we propose to variabilize
benchmarks and evaluate language models dynamically. Specifically, we extract
variables from each test case and define a value range for each variable. For
each evaluation, we sample new values from these value ranges to create unique
test cases, thus ensuring a fresh evaluation each time. We applied this
variable perturbation method to four datasets: GSM8K, ARC, CommonsenseQA, and
TruthfulQA, which cover mathematical generation and multiple-choice tasks. Our
experimental results demonstrate that this approach provides a more accurate
assessment of the true capabilities of language models, effectively mitigating
the contamination problem. | [
-0.0150005706,
0.1116496101,
-0.0259464495,
0.0310791228,
-0.0432360657,
-0.0094744908,
0.0038597914,
-0.0031800929,
-0.0331641398,
-0.0497521535,
-0.0142905368,
-0.0362251848,
0.0062289061,
0.0440837033,
0.0593248419,
-0.0316394828,
0.0546100922,
-0.031656649,
-0.0094251512,
0.0012431161,
-0.0156355333,
-0.0292780735,
0.0090763541,
0.0307900403,
-0.0153251952,
-0.0120109087,
-0.0029631308,
-0.0134279942,
0.0042276834,
-0.0157259423,
0.0189361684,
0.086811766,
-0.0110086845,
0.0482972302,
0.0000022189,
-0.0321116075,
-0.0042703515,
0.018118402,
-0.0277917907,
0.0383180603,
0.0553713404,
0.0139472447,
-0.0041151703,
0.0350958817,
-0.0287874248,
-0.0367510989,
0.0255647264,
-0.0523133241,
0.0598448068,
0.0645267069,
0.0037368487,
0.0410202332,
-0.0149122048,
-0.0381702483,
-0.0146474838,
-0.0618139729,
0.0127279181,
-0.0004120886,
-0.0059971907,
-0.0083906958,
-0.0222581699,
0.0350564048,
0.0339754,
0.0123624504,
-0.0268246382,
0.0291573051,
-0.0801339969,
-0.0134306354,
-0.0034993687,
0.0695848018,
-0.0181836989,
-0.0374907702,
0.0039143632,
-0.0177208986,
0.0041732322,
0.0134037687,
-0.0381792113,
0.0042415094,
0.0120575568,
-0.0080447076,
-0.0103897145,
-0.0106412806,
0.0357470624,
-0.0037155342,
0.002060306,
0.0562815033,
0.0436856188,
-0.0294029936,
-0.0081769526,
0.0133023495,
-0.0318605751,
-0.0433262251,
0.0073524499,
-0.0070650219,
-0.0054865717,
0.0342294425,
-0.0742054358,
-0.0759078339,
0.0258021392,
-0.0513422675,
0.0580790229,
0.0304986574,
-0.0060030813,
0.0090436721,
-0.0019927246,
0.0913252309,
0.0209992826,
0.046464853,
-0.0423918441,
0.0276933182,
-0.0105054751,
-0.0127305267,
-0.0009873082,
0.0197684858,
-0.0116957007,
0.0144218579,
-0.0401749313,
0.0053563747,
-0.0272722803,
0.0126510253,
-0.0033804437,
0.0029988538,
-0.0407758653,
0.007235019,
0.0133593539,
-0.0039467309,
-0.041985631,
0.0213803258,
0.0241100173,
-0.0727919564,
-0.0171163939,
0.0075604143,
-0.019491829,
-0.0231603552,
0.0076423353,
0.0796656907,
0.0140208015,
-0.0182952024,
0.0130877197,
-0.0481301397,
-0.0205754172,
-0.0652957261,
-0.0056566042,
-0.0713842213,
0.0170875993,
0.0053638397,
-0.0144343218,
-0.0217530373,
-0.0014927647,
0.0315453,
0.0095184827,
0.0254119001,
0.0198675077,
-0.0085956473,
-0.0159869213,
0.0056999275,
-0.0051875142,
0.0812697038,
0.035773851,
-0.0073501309,
0.0464624763,
-0.0226261355,
0.0052493126,
0.0692391694,
0.0445082411,
0.0039487686,
-0.0591361634,
0.0092503857,
0.0571270138,
0.0227361675,
-0.0041710394,
0.0511348844,
-0.0397168063,
-0.0145758875,
0.0794371143,
0.0466596559,
-0.0194981527,
-0.0054037306,
-0.0152543737,
-0.027131252,
0.0318849348,
0.0019630766,
-0.0595036075,
-0.0337958932,
-0.0190618839,
0.0166723114,
-0.0013295941,
0.0307437349,
-0.0157106053,
-0.048756931,
-0.0280640759,
-0.0112611102,
0.0142906317,
0.0103841117,
0.0528182052,
0.0059428168,
-0.0223862436,
0.0632253438,
-0.0008274455,
-0.0750767365,
0.0162018053,
-0.0420055315,
0.0040440587,
0.034697447,
0.0695381612,
-0.0071123084,
-0.0267381743,
-0.0125446795,
0.02553159,
0.031247152,
0.0666941106,
-0.0147052528,
0.0348661654,
-0.0269140303,
-0.0240795203,
-0.0003536675,
0.0305932779,
0.0204890072,
0.0300960485,
0.0123301698,
0.0136900954,
-0.0749322549,
-0.0388797037,
0.0503801517,
-0.0443048999,
-0.0373188965,
0.0174803603,
-0.0235055052,
0.0199482273,
-0.0019412852,
-0.0239248984,
0.0275620576,
0.0242175106,
-0.0101986649,
0.0096382555,
0.0066680596,
-0.0392044,
-0.0295260344,
0.0524618886,
-0.0264669303,
-0.006503596,
0.0841541439,
-0.0427382961,
-0.0229186993,
0.0350478627,
-0.0034978869,
-0.0251780357,
-0.0241257884,
0.0456495546,
-0.0427286029,
0.0220367592,
-0.0303267837,
0.0493191518,
-0.0090149585,
0.0364490561,
-0.0278344378,
0.0563285984,
0.0222728569,
-0.0095287403,
-0.0361311622,
0.002985314,
-0.0220506229,
0.0386708975,
0.0079149762,
0.007243346,
-0.0369620994,
-0.0291347448,
-0.0627688095,
-0.002315178,
-0.0274257101,
0.0292571038,
0.0220629778,
-0.0132725155,
0.002858686,
0.008482418,
-0.0335273966,
-0.0308154561,
0.02419338,
0.0193805546,
0.0153885558,
0.0090159299,
-0.0069368058,
-0.0581392758,
-0.0253978949,
-0.0317989551,
0.0836160034,
-0.0035789746,
0.0469658449,
-0.0263228621,
0.0255531427,
-0.0412241518,
0.0174809135,
0.0055799703,
-0.0268051028,
0.0249293651,
-0.0010886687,
0.0323594697,
0.0793883726,
-0.0044901194,
-0.0056865574,
0.0586036779,
-0.0097452849,
-0.0669040978,
-0.0116389086,
-0.0105077811,
-0.0229575764,
-0.0049871271,
-0.0223275926,
0.0178447887,
0.0442577451,
0.0088172909,
-0.0222712681,
-0.0438296981,
0.0621283799,
-0.0390918776,
-0.0305798519,
-0.0461938605,
0.0054722363,
-0.0585680604,
0.0391399078,
-0.0287081301,
-0.078489095,
0.0704375952,
-0.0293859448,
0.0172852725,
-0.0449134894,
0.0200427808,
-0.0207151715,
0.0273029227,
-0.0038484689,
-0.0101985922,
0.0007816466,
0.003252421,
-0.0383763537,
-0.0073073744,
0.0412640199,
-0.066391319,
0.0533013232,
-0.0565831028,
0.004465498,
0.0038821106,
-0.0571076609,
-0.0476159267,
-0.0338936038,
0.0211412087,
0.0241322741,
0.0338170603,
-0.0107840607,
-0.0023634434,
-0.0079764919,
0.0032452948,
0.0692456216,
-0.0394908935,
0.0068585933,
-0.0188614689,
0.0194277726,
0.0429304093,
-0.0222208034,
0.0229375567,
-0.0656190589,
0.0128953522,
0.0498627983,
0.0735425279,
0.0287000425,
-0.0242731478,
0.0154654104,
0.0074511194,
-0.0032718738,
-0.0014089154,
0.0344440565,
0.0290937852,
-0.0641912818,
-0.0453309231,
0.0856520087,
0.0280429255,
-0.0004436657,
0.0221029818,
-0.0321916379,
0.0829609632,
0.0348059349,
0.0314081721,
-0.0857224762,
0.00591473,
0.022814149,
0.0603389032,
-0.0028602732,
-0.0324148089,
-0.0151160983,
-0.1450094134,
0.0116185071,
0.0201666281,
-0.0665871426,
0.0245358758,
-0.0340634771,
-0.001510903,
-0.0236962195,
0.0456111915,
0.0153512442,
0.0148344794,
0.0076166489,
0.0332733393,
-0.025789123,
-0.1098464206,
0.0232538376,
-0.0434703901,
0.0461340994,
0.0525779948,
0.0106808273,
-0.0374902524,
0.003453935,
0.0537255742,
0.0032032044,
-0.0367178209,
0.0269100573,
0.045141317,
0.0158351343,
-0.0231130142,
0.0106365774,
0.0117321592,
-0.028282417,
0.0048524756,
0.0111027481,
0.0656312481,
0.0245219562,
-0.0241197888,
-0.0002721481,
-0.0308362022,
-0.0015874733,
0.0752604231,
0.0464575551,
-0.0471014827,
-0.0282278918,
-0.045884937,
-0.0070635588,
-0.0587450974,
-0.0154911401,
0.0079395203,
0.019570034,
-0.0317193717,
-0.0685616359,
-0.0403601788,
0.0249529779,
0.063045986,
-0.0030967854,
0.0086336965,
0.0060259034,
-0.0195679236,
-0.0422464386,
0.0445066169,
-0.0140153533,
0.0240508467,
-0.0608028956,
0.0034713282,
0.0024864089,
0.0351435244,
-0.035793025,
0.0577671826,
-0.1281450093,
-0.1100882366,
0.0172838848,
0.0823279098,
0.022504814,
0.0308031645,
-0.0069826627,
-0.0595959648,
0.0351918414,
0.0099934237,
-0.013271247,
0.0363402218,
0.0181010012,
-0.0719899982,
0.0099422205,
0.0174752027,
-0.0328649394,
0.0036350072,
0.0163812209,
0.0319962949,
-0.0061946074,
-0.0110225463,
0.0125455596,
0.0315395147,
0.0158415772,
-0.0152010862,
-0.0167123936,
-0.0161840711,
0.0084763961,
-0.0483587608,
-0.0173135288,
-0.0351204388,
0.0167514551,
0.0117349457,
0.006368787,
-0.0061714044,
-0.0149577186,
-0.012881659,
0.0673577636,
-0.0355792157,
0.0131307393,
-0.0160299744,
0.0580479912,
0.0303623155,
-0.0019974594,
-0.0143812448,
-0.0009966849,
-0.0293052476,
0.073018305,
-0.0363870673,
-0.002613148,
0.0135958157,
0.0220568515,
0.0205709264,
0.0099404119,
-0.0618358403,
-0.0522265658,
-0.0445397831,
0.0077645769,
-0.0015300803,
0.0339977667,
0.0404692367,
-0.0266770981,
-0.0178928226,
-0.0418184623,
-0.0121920751,
-0.0077181263,
-0.0409083404,
0.0268821456,
0.0185573455,
-0.0202850346,
0.0148645472,
0.0827505961,
0.0503537506,
0.0343274772,
-0.0239906814,
0.0314177908,
-0.0459287278,
-0.0099594835,
0.0032145714,
0.000411326,
-0.0247242991,
-0.0241437107,
-0.0543032847,
-0.1045504361,
0.0388551652,
0.0342499204,
0.0284438152,
-0.0035191318,
0.0039269738,
0.0532322191,
-0.0227503143,
0.0066461246,
-0.0282312538,
0.004271518,
0.0066057811,
-0.0296054296,
-0.0278171822,
-6.91079741e-33,
-0.0222538207,
-0.0154750003,
0.0054915375,
-0.0465563908,
0.0007611893,
0.0180234239,
-0.0308355466,
0.0306542944,
-0.0116138384,
-0.0030870403,
-0.0166510846,
0.0158966724,
0.0183380339,
0.0249072053,
-0.0017875403,
-0.0297643896,
0.0368947499,
-0.043481376,
-0.0650424883,
0.0154188592,
0.0120654209,
0.0324322283,
0.0761905462,
-0.0734236389,
0.007009645,
0.006283382,
-0.0356108546,
-0.0012548582,
-0.0349100977,
0.0728232339,
0.0085065356,
0.035237316,
0.0026712522,
-0.0296842884,
-0.035773281,
-0.0121857459,
-0.0310466141,
-0.0321369283,
0.0122338459,
0.0258731358,
-0.0064754412,
-0.0063077891,
0.0523440726,
-0.0150974542,
-0.0487431549,
-0.0108551262,
0.0080656577,
-0.0329450704,
-0.0599128753,
-0.0148727531,
-0.0272394717,
0.0278572422,
-0.0052410145,
0.022927383,
-0.0019272942,
0.0690585151,
-0.0257264022,
-0.002643307,
-0.0414127633,
0.0104251532,
0.0567870475,
0.053061787,
0.0722322166,
0.0316204838,
0.0221053381,
0.0767420158,
0.0231788754,
0.0143848807,
0.0325137228,
-0.0094374428,
0.090106301,
0.01391852,
0.075557746,
0.0668181404,
0.0455976427,
-0.0196038242,
-0.0600700565,
0.0129183475,
0.0146272853,
-0.0055950382,
0.0357813425,
-0.0328718089,
-0.0679443628,
-0.03366993,
-0.0915003717,
-0.0103012221,
-0.0581916012,
-0.0171520822,
0.0721701533,
0.0035163076,
-0.037418332,
-0.0106078126,
0.0328541324,
-0.0325018689,
-0.0368002988,
0.0517481938,
-0.0209370274,
0.0290527157,
-0.0121189859,
0.042982094,
-0.0294722859,
-0.0144446902,
0.0038709952,
0.0274844896,
0.040311221,
-0.0025197545,
0.0069389311,
0.0322791636,
-0.0646598265,
0.0108351922,
-0.0345462076,
0.020309424,
0.0334128663,
0.0459102727,
0.0577238239,
-0.0283446573,
0.0100845825,
0.0376649462,
0.0263839066,
-0.0000474951,
-0.0441730022,
0.0094200335,
0.0289062355,
0.0441186354,
0.0055846712,
-0.0242365915,
-0.0242096111,
-0.0091111064,
0.0557927005,
-0.0309463721,
-0.0053840065,
0.0112893591,
2.868e-7,
0.0447458997,
0.0598571599,
0.005418241,
0.0286996309,
-0.0218247734,
0.0181656014,
-0.0606483966,
0.0191356,
0.0081975628,
0.0041463673,
-0.0282914285,
-0.002338683,
0.0758820474,
0.036670547,
-0.056013152,
-0.0156421103,
-0.0640190542,
0.017447792,
-0.0650358498,
-0.0344630554,
0.019829547,
0.0890927017,
0.0057084793,
-0.0154089304,
-0.0226286631,
-0.0388958938,
0.0551089644,
-0.0261649694,
-0.0302051678,
0.0303664953,
0.0260091219,
0.0287681632,
0.0177735351,
-0.0143785691,
-0.0397435203,
0.0201772805,
-0.0224491246,
0.0696376711,
0.0176258963,
-0.0310600474,
0.011010942,
-0.0245178305,
-0.0246251021,
-0.0357716158,
0.042904187,
-0.0298957117,
-0.0044120993,
-0.0465602577,
-0.0277455971,
-0.0330225155,
0.0551450588,
-0.0442583784,
-0.0182515904,
0.0222013202,
0.0243553873,
-0.0024606187,
-0.0070953686,
-0.0405334719,
-0.049166292,
-0.001793657,
-0.0454338565,
-0.0376821719,
-0.028249152,
0.0277636871,
-0.01122416,
-0.0277185086,
0.0282794945,
3.183853311e-34,
0.0538518392,
-0.0300196446,
0.0319730751,
0.0254127961,
0.0408509858,
-0.0093601476,
0.0028013536,
0.0049259663,
0.0074428348,
-0.0610949844,
-0.0179279353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17675v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17675v1 | Quantifying AI Psychology: A Psychometrics Benchmark for Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T16:09:08 | 2024-06-25T16:09:08 | Yuan Li, Yue Huang, Hongyi Wang, Xiangliang Zhang, James Zou, Lichao Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional task-solving
capabilities, increasingly adopting roles akin to human-like assistants. The
broader integration of LLMs into society has sparked interest in whether they
manifest psychological attributes, and whether these attributes are
stable-inquiries that could deepen the understanding of their behaviors.
Inspired by psychometrics, this paper presents a framework for investigating
psychology in LLMs, including psychological dimension identification,
assessment dataset curation, and assessment with results validation. Following
this framework, we introduce a comprehensive psychometrics benchmark for LLMs
that covers six psychological dimensions: personality, values, emotion, theory
of mind, motivation, and intelligence. This benchmark includes thirteen
datasets featuring diverse scenarios and item types. Our findings indicate that
LLMs manifest a broad spectrum of psychological attributes. We also uncover
discrepancies between LLMs' self-reported traits and their behaviors in
real-world scenarios. This paper demonstrates a thorough psychometric
assessment of LLMs, providing insights into reliable evaluation and potential
applications in AI and social sciences. | Quantifying AI Psychology: A Psychometrics Benchmark for Large Language Models: Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional task-solving
capabilities, increasingly adopting roles akin to human-like assistants. The
broader integration of LLMs into society has sparked interest in whether they
manifest psychological attributes, and whether these attributes are
stable-inquiries that could deepen the understanding of their behaviors.
Inspired by psychometrics, this paper presents a framework for investigating
psychology in LLMs, including psychological dimension identification,
assessment dataset curation, and assessment with results validation. Following
this framework, we introduce a comprehensive psychometrics benchmark for LLMs
that covers six psychological dimensions: personality, values, emotion, theory
of mind, motivation, and intelligence. This benchmark includes thirteen
datasets featuring diverse scenarios and item types. Our findings indicate that
LLMs manifest a broad spectrum of psychological attributes. We also uncover
discrepancies between LLMs' self-reported traits and their behaviors in
real-world scenarios. This paper demonstrates a thorough psychometric
assessment of LLMs, providing insights into reliable evaluation and potential
applications in AI and social sciences. | [
0.0188376829,
0.0682794005,
-0.0549192056,
0.0054753134,
-0.0668005645,
0.0313297398,
0.0168988351,
-0.0259659998,
0.031778533,
0.0036778103,
-0.0636041462,
-0.0316019319,
-0.0074516293,
0.0451932997,
0.0032755774,
-0.0282987058,
0.0187542401,
-0.0011429776,
0.0543668233,
0.0052549741,
-0.0359095149,
0.0400601849,
-0.0093163149,
0.0200012121,
-0.0027239136,
-0.0212626364,
0.0079687191,
-0.0319207422,
0.0359672941,
-0.0366268679,
0.0033264449,
0.0271658357,
0.00861682,
0.0217129868,
0.0000019374,
-0.0861850008,
0.0136568295,
-0.0117822057,
-0.0201844536,
-0.025819812,
0.0583159029,
0.0296978168,
-0.0015603751,
0.0352091156,
-0.071577765,
0.0071731769,
0.0068808165,
0.0469818451,
0.0233230833,
0.060669709,
-0.0166185126,
-0.0017599144,
0.0409489386,
0.003466598,
0.0119263995,
-0.0397579148,
0.0309807155,
-0.0276461318,
-0.030020697,
-0.0433659852,
0.0297681559,
-0.0154328635,
0.0231373254,
0.0168541502,
-0.0290816985,
-0.001590955,
-0.056172464,
-0.0231601484,
0.0031791085,
0.0506765358,
0.0327131599,
0.0017713383,
-0.0091412282,
-0.0075631728,
0.0182351861,
-0.0029004773,
-0.0319816209,
0.0300640017,
0.001707125,
-0.0123768831,
0.0646202639,
0.0302181039,
0.0206522588,
0.0101796985,
-0.0211366024,
0.0615188666,
-0.0045302785,
-0.0420655757,
0.0350857303,
-0.0065416796,
-0.0169478059,
-0.0597178712,
-0.0124851028,
0.0264140218,
-0.039295584,
0.027449213,
-0.0377973877,
-0.015691936,
0.0218868293,
-0.0474747531,
0.0662583634,
0.0273528174,
-0.025813397,
0.0258389544,
0.0374331214,
0.0923016369,
0.038402658,
0.0319671258,
-0.0333316028,
-0.0169094838,
-0.0722775012,
0.0088230884,
0.0236003902,
0.0172546618,
0.053911373,
0.0014065998,
-0.0395429507,
0.0185039677,
-0.0303148925,
0.0087828971,
-0.0076632979,
-0.0128241768,
0.0153452139,
-0.0038279134,
-0.0558357127,
0.0147903338,
-0.0441084839,
0.0115996199,
0.0188892446,
-0.0463980138,
0.0482561551,
-0.0011531475,
0.0183448624,
-0.0377508067,
0.0575547777,
0.0592981838,
0.0305856448,
-0.0595479794,
-0.0413034633,
-0.0157209095,
0.0213517454,
-0.0882495716,
-0.0031143462,
-0.0365425088,
0.0401210748,
0.0323088653,
-0.0211844631,
-0.058894366,
-0.0098054027,
0.0273781437,
0.0003135357,
0.0359042771,
0.0276830383,
0.0215643756,
0.0211240035,
0.0172229446,
-0.0082306871,
0.0294226967,
0.0280622188,
0.007888183,
0.0656713843,
-0.0331558399,
0.0300430041,
0.0122880088,
-0.0433081761,
0.0029725896,
-0.0252571627,
0.0136388978,
-0.0171026569,
0.0123590799,
0.0256499555,
0.0552342273,
0.0180507936,
-0.0164122377,
0.0621292032,
0.0863106623,
0.0069460594,
0.0287920069,
0.0163364857,
0.0082024941,
0.0744948089,
-0.0044374978,
-0.0556252487,
0.0225505307,
-0.0302228592,
-0.0077565783,
0.0042881859,
0.0462410711,
-0.020881623,
-0.0611510277,
-0.0210275277,
-0.0185776185,
0.0247254577,
0.0394943245,
0.03495517,
-0.0545621887,
-0.0073014465,
-0.0504014753,
-0.0050343261,
-0.0572161749,
-0.027458312,
-0.0743572861,
0.0125048179,
0.0797366351,
0.0238518156,
-0.0249077305,
-0.0256708562,
0.0069541433,
-0.0314445458,
0.0145725543,
0.0579033233,
-0.0228946805,
-0.0096394988,
-0.0210897941,
0.0138038602,
-0.0044707111,
0.0083329529,
0.0108554037,
-0.0174205229,
0.030376073,
-0.0050078114,
-0.036850594,
-0.0312413592,
0.0296842083,
-0.0829395726,
-0.0369887389,
-0.0126102632,
0.0133419596,
0.0590054654,
0.031067526,
-0.0125941942,
0.0139673101,
0.02458735,
-0.005036036,
0.0162201803,
0.0276842341,
0.0092219459,
0.06126865,
0.0430428758,
0.0251291748,
-0.0089296512,
0.0579525977,
0.0294688214,
-0.0224750135,
0.0027236138,
-0.0192203056,
0.0222836882,
-0.0069917492,
0.0512621105,
-0.0571732745,
0.0514675863,
0.0004744215,
0.0584812127,
-0.0170548018,
0.0329642445,
0.0193191916,
-0.0074556149,
0.036028225,
-0.0330524966,
-0.0085062068,
-0.0252306443,
0.0016065763,
0.0168650839,
0.0292824879,
-0.0103134708,
-0.0608037375,
-0.0395763703,
-0.0898556858,
-0.0129352482,
0.0147470478,
0.0231220257,
0.0125614321,
-0.019797232,
-0.052049499,
0.0274453629,
-0.0544890575,
0.0085249767,
0.0485477187,
0.0463723354,
0.0135665257,
-0.0282219108,
-0.0121163912,
-0.0704337135,
0.0033004729,
-0.0318738297,
-0.0143820038,
0.0030142141,
0.0558945015,
-0.0316339172,
0.0503299497,
-0.0442415848,
0.0119649386,
-0.0270672292,
-0.0589866154,
0.0479677096,
0.007000824,
0.0320192948,
0.1233093292,
-0.0010626682,
0.0282171164,
0.0636031255,
0.0175687559,
-0.041122783,
-0.0123544978,
0.0113971224,
0.0056726127,
-0.0335663036,
-0.0678236037,
0.0182233658,
0.0532616712,
-0.0060890205,
0.0148147503,
-0.0207009707,
0.0473425761,
-0.0191905852,
-0.0512557141,
0.0048077083,
0.0116618825,
-0.0210710522,
0.1059692055,
0.003247801,
-0.0500656739,
0.0545117557,
0.0039431201,
0.0235124398,
-0.0177321509,
-0.0476437919,
-0.0359089263,
0.0844005942,
-0.0018220939,
-0.0173305236,
0.0126990844,
0.0187254753,
-0.0535471588,
-0.0165338293,
-0.0361937098,
-0.0569808036,
0.0128757833,
-0.0184710193,
-0.0336364992,
0.0239222236,
0.0061511132,
-0.050244458,
-0.039940998,
-0.0503911488,
0.0034560938,
0.025385445,
-0.064918533,
-0.0374028198,
-0.0513493232,
0.0651984662,
-0.0117092403,
-0.0049130232,
-0.021483358,
0.0174817257,
-0.0329125151,
0.0880290568,
-0.0000494725,
0.0572115183,
-0.0411589779,
0.0356282778,
-0.0113550145,
0.0194196068,
0.0223866794,
0.0048443135,
0.0049707331,
0.0192509666,
-0.0015087075,
-0.0047763819,
0.0435683392,
0.0202009492,
-0.0082863318,
-0.0118929371,
0.1442836523,
0.0383723713,
-0.0462394431,
0.0200268589,
-0.0172129255,
-0.0035922872,
0.0396333784,
0.0367093645,
-0.0293124765,
0.0204934217,
0.0006664585,
0.0188948289,
-0.0549142472,
-0.0543462373,
-0.0057549416,
-0.0984215066,
0.016221175,
-0.0220627766,
-0.0056811911,
-0.0277906116,
-0.0532017648,
0.0296839569,
-0.0072018807,
0.0173034407,
-0.0341135934,
0.0071253078,
-0.0298641082,
-0.0043942989,
-0.0402005054,
-0.0518030189,
0.1095785797,
-0.0354112312,
0.072129108,
0.0675022379,
0.0594542101,
-0.0295667462,
-0.0556334667,
-0.0390499495,
0.0242338069,
-0.0090929624,
0.0443409644,
0.0460974462,
-0.0285363104,
0.0132324165,
-0.033714965,
-0.0019653363,
-0.0545907989,
0.0037825864,
0.0150309037,
0.0789054781,
0.0070378319,
-0.0379006192,
-0.0016682722,
-0.0278082602,
0.0016029548,
0.1022463292,
-0.0016060503,
-0.0673030764,
0.0064908173,
-0.0022711542,
-0.0039477935,
-0.0198322143,
-0.0625922978,
0.0247611329,
0.0096558677,
0.0085434346,
-0.0338900089,
-0.0851332694,
0.0397213139,
-0.019551402,
-0.0116766226,
-0.0109167388,
0.0179886967,
0.0040349104,
-0.0580516569,
0.0018309095,
0.0017469901,
0.027461797,
-0.042248331,
-0.0209505633,
0.0324231572,
-0.0386116095,
0.0025473402,
-0.0192641597,
-0.0293510184,
-0.0298524909,
0.0483219065,
0.0190509707,
0.0221724529,
-0.0287244748,
0.001041838,
-0.0532843433,
-0.0068558259,
-0.0304011125,
-0.0421909764,
0.0382949375,
-0.0072398996,
0.0521969981,
0.0086745648,
0.0315122269,
-0.0503328629,
0.0222766455,
-0.0078900363,
-0.0308431685,
-0.0084033282,
-0.0793432742,
0.0183414351,
0.0423684493,
-0.0021774897,
-0.0108213024,
-0.0080683194,
-0.0190314129,
-0.0505895466,
-0.0638416633,
-0.0221845284,
-0.0249961726,
-0.0665364042,
0.0396379568,
0.0150904292,
-0.0156395547,
-0.0411743373,
-0.0257733092,
-0.0134890536,
-0.0304469932,
0.0242648032,
-0.0417450815,
0.0362599753,
-0.0053680963,
0.0191971362,
-0.0161433015,
-0.0352125056,
-0.0147790937,
0.0468479171,
0.0235627461,
0.0766034499,
-0.0136353858,
-0.0008287685,
0.0167288315,
0.0475025587,
-0.0551339462,
-0.0454797447,
0.0519781671,
-0.0044666384,
0.0016951944,
-0.0145391999,
0.0569383092,
-0.0442784317,
0.0287828874,
-0.0377192609,
-0.0083268182,
0.0045656343,
-0.0106352763,
0.0044585085,
0.0147586968,
-0.016406633,
0.002273584,
0.0590231195,
0.0058353469,
0.0375576392,
-0.0160908736,
-0.0175703894,
-0.0358795226,
0.0275862813,
-0.0198448449,
0.0391011685,
-0.0320066288,
-0.0087437397,
-0.0797638446,
-0.0825992227,
0.0337442309,
0.0079606911,
0.0070458725,
-0.0407322273,
-0.0022411477,
0.0739539415,
-0.0448741131,
-0.0085645504,
-0.0271267127,
-0.0362380892,
-0.0654638261,
-0.0127176195,
-0.0370288715,
-6.094006997e-33,
-0.0008659495,
-0.0159471687,
0.017342627,
-0.000397565,
-0.0092071211,
-0.0256824959,
-0.0276742242,
0.0320179388,
-0.0558067039,
-0.0086140269,
-0.0478286296,
0.0196017381,
0.0041138213,
-0.0085078049,
0.0295873806,
0.0025049024,
0.0027404306,
-0.0561720245,
-0.0231778473,
0.0019435047,
0.0064098928,
-0.0210419334,
0.0603494383,
-0.1006532833,
0.0425844863,
-0.0130532067,
0.0174812227,
0.0143864919,
0.000164154,
0.0576640405,
-0.0126800416,
0.0553973727,
0.0528015085,
0.0039397837,
0.0035457909,
0.0213676244,
0.0001251903,
-0.0661022216,
0.0163044147,
0.0143801998,
0.0008083562,
-0.0624884255,
0.0015846243,
-0.0093092555,
-0.0595912524,
-0.0140292402,
0.0363631397,
-0.0239283182,
0.0541363694,
0.0229340252,
-0.0507730842,
-0.0101824515,
-0.0140966428,
-0.033793401,
-0.0066374801,
0.0343163088,
-0.0301645435,
-0.0128457611,
-0.0585328564,
0.0286975373,
-0.0094878087,
-0.0089343041,
0.0610179491,
-0.0159052722,
0.0188496411,
0.0546836294,
0.0861287788,
0.0555898547,
-0.0127712023,
-0.012937801,
0.041845981,
0.0582273528,
0.0418459661,
0.038534645,
-0.0002678001,
-0.017354209,
-0.0062291822,
0.0303760916,
0.0810101405,
-0.0103477668,
0.0440656506,
0.0000959875,
-0.0449654311,
-0.0202341639,
-0.0266957637,
-0.0072588795,
-0.021128986,
-0.0113951918,
0.0489711873,
-0.0295317098,
0.033472091,
-0.0428159535,
0.0436331443,
-0.0329576172,
0.0151187088,
0.0321496166,
-0.0485798568,
0.0661664084,
0.0188804567,
-0.0079834107,
-0.0663905665,
-0.0002711247,
-0.0076057091,
0.0480997376,
0.0672387481,
0.001447573,
-0.0052706786,
0.0356653966,
-0.0402552076,
-0.0107645504,
-0.0075629493,
0.0088105798,
0.0296100192,
0.0034634285,
0.0061657592,
-0.0112984516,
0.0024285575,
-0.0134809995,
0.0093828691,
-0.0186878089,
-0.0621935837,
-0.0015671754,
-0.0086017558,
-0.0103451367,
-0.0084186587,
-0.014299727,
-0.0674014986,
0.0093361298,
0.0345470496,
-0.0031361822,
0.0138309514,
-0.0212512296,
2.742e-7,
-0.0218456164,
0.0769092068,
-0.0273201689,
0.0582003295,
-0.0064141164,
0.0544417724,
-0.0252343249,
-0.0061751571,
0.0323981233,
-0.0169244166,
0.016054783,
0.0203158595,
0.0523779318,
0.0222432204,
-0.0401504785,
-0.0081101377,
-0.0081667723,
0.0122647258,
-0.0402798429,
0.0260430127,
0.0643899888,
0.0400401652,
0.0289019551,
-0.0077565513,
-0.0290513653,
-0.0091282818,
0.0085327011,
-0.041241698,
0.0054501812,
0.0100738993,
0.0214843769,
0.0231666248,
0.0139302611,
0.0486598909,
0.009233064,
0.0183050409,
-0.0231437534,
0.0442724712,
-0.0214534383,
-0.0344703794,
0.0137911718,
-0.0017562358,
-0.0311295297,
-0.046279341,
0.0617787018,
-0.0302550439,
-0.0868686363,
-0.0465793684,
-0.0081062764,
-0.0198704973,
0.0345642492,
0.0036338498,
-0.019712327,
0.0046093827,
0.0240686126,
-0.0375384651,
-0.0080000935,
-0.0436089411,
0.0224651955,
0.0055554076,
-0.0066833035,
-0.059940923,
-0.0407823585,
0.0193076171,
0.0162325241,
-0.0657705367,
0.0245939605,
2.2513628e-34,
-0.0118006207,
0.0214720536,
0.023687996,
-0.000479621,
0.0752018243,
0.0055571916,
-0.0435977727,
0.0305873062,
0.0185544323,
-0.0956120417,
0.0060741492
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17667v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17667v1 | This Paper Had the Smartest Reviewers -- Flattery Detection Utilising an Audio-Textual Transformer-Based Approach | 2024-06-25T15:57:02 | 2024-06-25T15:57:02 | Lukas Christ, Shahin Amiriparian, Friederike Hawighorst, Ann-Kathrin Schill, Angelo Boutalikakis, Lorenz Graf-Vlachy, Andreas König, Björn W. Schuller | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Flattery is an important aspect of human communication that facilitates
social bonding, shapes perceptions, and influences behavior through strategic
compliments and praise, leveraging the power of speech to build rapport
effectively. Its automatic detection can thus enhance the naturalness of
human-AI interactions. To meet this need, we present a novel audio textual
dataset comprising 20 hours of speech and train machine learning models for
automatic flattery detection. In particular, we employ pretrained AST,
Wav2Vec2, and Whisper models for the speech modality, and Whisper TTS models
combined with a RoBERTa text classifier for the textual modality. Subsequently,
we build a multimodal classifier by combining text and audio representations.
Evaluation on unseen test data demonstrates promising results, with Unweighted
Average Recall scores reaching 82.46% in audio-only experiments, 85.97% in
text-only experiments, and 87.16% using a multimodal approach. | This Paper Had the Smartest Reviewers -- Flattery Detection Utilising an Audio-Textual Transformer-Based Approach: Flattery is an important aspect of human communication that facilitates
social bonding, shapes perceptions, and influences behavior through strategic
compliments and praise, leveraging the power of speech to build rapport
effectively. Its automatic detection can thus enhance the naturalness of
human-AI interactions. To meet this need, we present a novel audio textual
dataset comprising 20 hours of speech and train machine learning models for
automatic flattery detection. In particular, we employ pretrained AST,
Wav2Vec2, and Whisper models for the speech modality, and Whisper TTS models
combined with a RoBERTa text classifier for the textual modality. Subsequently,
we build a multimodal classifier by combining text and audio representations.
Evaluation on unseen test data demonstrates promising results, with Unweighted
Average Recall scores reaching 82.46% in audio-only experiments, 85.97% in
text-only experiments, and 87.16% using a multimodal approach. | [
0.034656778,
0.0612476021,
-0.027323192,
0.0237244722,
-0.0117347278,
0.005310236,
-0.0082539152,
0.0070892754,
-0.0374903567,
-0.0513358153,
-0.0844535753,
0.0055534705,
0.0026811061,
0.0130112395,
0.0380510874,
-0.0165573079,
0.0247216746,
0.0274254456,
0.0277221147,
-0.0114603927,
0.0532845259,
0.0120180296,
-0.0008517693,
0.0321612991,
-0.0576925837,
-0.004152216,
0.0071665687,
0.0324978456,
-0.0200461708,
0.0024122836,
0.0171628986,
0.0479908027,
0.0304582231,
0.0490994826,
0.0000017853,
-0.0130144469,
0.0162866265,
0.0043925988,
0.0064802854,
-0.0146151194,
0.0847164541,
0.0108249439,
-0.0128203817,
0.03103365,
-0.0184742697,
0.0131998919,
0.0223175455,
0.0357416458,
0.1126413122,
0.0594555922,
0.0006896472,
-0.007179602,
0.0079355277,
-0.0104558188,
0.0330123082,
-0.0156122008,
-0.0112420246,
-0.0360558107,
-0.0063788034,
-0.0039477278,
-0.0033986981,
0.0255345497,
-0.0385139324,
-0.0234138947,
0.0421034284,
0.0276977029,
-0.0190422218,
-0.0345098861,
-0.0230303314,
0.0436813608,
0.0249390025,
-0.0260380656,
-0.0074810651,
0.0330764502,
0.0216794424,
-0.0299005099,
-0.0172616057,
-0.0251517873,
0.0233477633,
-0.0159411076,
-0.0815043375,
0.0187241081,
0.0004754295,
0.0286473706,
0.0505968928,
-0.0119411191,
-0.0391471945,
-0.0465850309,
0.0413843915,
0.0031045598,
0.0256782398,
-0.0475501791,
0.0272038262,
0.0216565635,
0.0270122793,
-0.0568902045,
-0.0343775302,
-0.0535661466,
0.0282311514,
-0.0135011841,
0.0506004356,
-0.0129817082,
-0.0832481906,
0.0101512978,
-0.0044944584,
0.032646358,
-0.001550398,
-0.031516619,
-0.0019697859,
-0.0100634471,
-0.038342908,
0.0133462511,
-0.0146307684,
0.0157242492,
-0.0053422912,
-0.0297660232,
-0.0133367619,
-0.0151961958,
-0.0612339266,
0.0200876258,
0.0012368249,
-0.0004803751,
-0.0168733075,
0.0209693797,
0.0284116529,
0.0358100757,
-0.0314364769,
0.0312559046,
-0.0374172032,
-0.01351019,
-0.0107491873,
0.0349663459,
0.0526159033,
0.0035064677,
0.0307147782,
0.0377818458,
-0.0010047003,
-0.0854148194,
0.0141344238,
0.0142129436,
-0.0504761338,
-0.0723424256,
0.0093768844,
-0.0093856426,
0.0497713499,
-0.0328722335,
-0.0412810743,
0.0505698696,
0.0163538978,
0.0068106637,
-0.0323478021,
0.0303633697,
-0.0263924971,
0.0293016434,
0.0368035138,
0.0222274661,
-0.0256675314,
0.0004289378,
0.0515821613,
0.0371742658,
0.0591336079,
0.0001539771,
0.0508286059,
0.0303586517,
0.0300932899,
-0.0113409655,
0.0306729488,
-0.0111775063,
-0.0721366853,
-0.0077794967,
0.0443341136,
0.0242826249,
0.0139177218,
-0.0231749322,
0.0833118036,
0.0370218046,
-0.0186140947,
0.0512506925,
0.0140866395,
0.0735871419,
-0.0143025061,
-0.0230634864,
-0.0280210916,
-0.0087529644,
-0.0624841973,
-0.0533588901,
0.0539978631,
-0.0285279583,
-0.0048915232,
-0.0193991642,
-0.0077849426,
-0.0429431722,
0.0049561989,
0.0053734956,
0.0285561625,
0.0093300873,
-0.0521655828,
-0.0046583023,
0.0280009657,
-0.080677703,
0.0068858028,
-0.0239010137,
0.0431821942,
0.0459622256,
-0.00097817,
-0.0211009178,
0.0461181067,
-0.0599498563,
-0.0232750829,
0.0118163582,
0.0202841293,
-0.0152033856,
0.0348104313,
-0.0099131884,
0.0301936269,
0.0114336489,
0.007830522,
0.0088179829,
-0.0105590979,
0.0508203171,
-0.0264111962,
-0.0106044225,
0.0084735733,
0.0036261133,
0.0728844702,
-0.0098014977,
0.028049048,
0.023792563,
0.030977264,
0.0651343688,
-0.0627781004,
-0.0409167707,
0.0099525824,
-0.0003088051,
-0.0441909954,
0.0167911481,
-0.0317334086,
-0.0110584106,
-0.0077458923,
0.0031359764,
-0.0101635503,
0.0484530404,
-0.0029989758,
0.0029021963,
0.0674158707,
-0.0434384421,
0.0624521151,
-0.0139819551,
0.0113312863,
-0.0404214934,
0.0349740274,
0.0279468615,
-0.0167390853,
0.0107807359,
-0.0445234254,
-0.0294297058,
0.0064817378,
0.0267776549,
0.0265276562,
-0.0710620508,
-0.017299911,
0.0117504671,
0.0155165512,
-0.003994449,
-0.0026008615,
0.0070589618,
-0.0431971401,
-0.1343955249,
-0.0226410329,
0.0002777495,
-0.0357557498,
-0.0124383653,
-0.0217290279,
0.0324077867,
0.0127154412,
-0.0510341078,
0.0140414322,
0.0138455732,
-0.0293697566,
-0.0243292935,
-0.0196608119,
0.0071506505,
-0.0450208858,
0.0197476149,
-0.0268044323,
-0.000633129,
0.0036951932,
-0.0016513894,
-0.0034641011,
-0.018639138,
-0.0279017892,
0.0702793375,
-0.0148783242,
-0.0362485088,
-0.0118849864,
0.0151184695,
-0.0000210277,
0.0546087772,
0.0646405295,
0.0315547697,
0.0404205769,
0.0079636443,
-0.0103114164,
0.0391867198,
0.0183795206,
0.0225414615,
-0.0520406887,
-0.0227578878,
-0.0134883141,
-0.0011945716,
0.0413786098,
0.0331585668,
-0.0153995659,
-0.013580801,
0.0162312984,
-0.0262625962,
0.0089197578,
-0.0284600202,
0.0022368559,
0.0031016907,
0.0264512207,
-0.0521406941,
0.0240387488,
-0.0631123558,
-0.0766334832,
0.00036552,
-0.0181443188,
0.0087706754,
0.0560607724,
-0.0210449472,
0.0285352357,
0.0207880381,
-0.0026008876,
0.0139692845,
-0.0549430028,
0.0222909208,
-0.0218939688,
-0.0378445424,
0.0181715023,
-0.0101329368,
0.0414085388,
-0.0489812493,
-0.0228468925,
-0.0281004366,
-0.0267392471,
-0.024559252,
-0.0344981253,
-0.0330502912,
-0.0265237149,
-0.0028851421,
-0.0075093051,
-0.0130109498,
-0.0196781587,
0.0090910429,
-0.0095329005,
0.0260313973,
0.0504553653,
0.0252214782,
-0.0199561529,
-0.002539665,
-0.0414280109,
0.0141014,
0.0019955651,
0.0510431454,
-0.0174896829,
-0.0377130844,
0.0256081298,
0.0358028151,
0.0248396453,
-0.0312447455,
0.022389723,
0.0309144184,
-0.0201262645,
0.0946215466,
-0.0003396645,
-0.0545745455,
0.016139213,
0.0496268496,
0.0051375846,
0.0203707945,
0.0038989463,
-0.0733344853,
-0.0273118354,
0.025100207,
0.0150597906,
0.0040237219,
0.0255877934,
-0.0083873579,
-0.0919764787,
0.0269542132,
-0.0087239947,
-0.0493086763,
-0.0262599848,
0.0077868933,
-0.0427260511,
0.008681722,
0.0049834778,
-0.0082709724,
-0.0038374383,
-0.0207932517,
-0.0251436941,
-0.0377874896,
0.0006735132,
0.0641744509,
-0.0409568809,
0.0686524585,
0.0503225736,
0.086146988,
-0.0253268424,
-0.0247116443,
-0.0323927291,
0.0514810458,
0.0100215618,
-0.0040877154,
0.0751825422,
-0.035935808,
0.0266139228,
0.0108483313,
-0.0107395602,
0.0045996383,
0.0572722778,
0.0437745713,
0.0141564952,
-0.0303728525,
-0.0516616255,
-0.0244450979,
0.0776313171,
0.0301801208,
0.0613423139,
-0.0017104198,
-0.0707283467,
0.0073778322,
0.0492903851,
0.0122846495,
0.0043424196,
-0.035553176,
-0.0040322919,
0.0250812061,
-0.0441082828,
-0.080209814,
-0.0243743509,
-0.0663032457,
-0.0068049426,
0.0146442195,
-0.0147930728,
-0.0055665253,
0.0297584161,
-0.0448296703,
0.012888073,
0.0336806886,
0.0547623187,
-0.0273988321,
-0.0599507838,
0.0274219885,
-0.0300355107,
-0.0235344581,
-0.0076318504,
-0.0436675102,
-0.0149405301,
-0.0300909411,
0.059478581,
0.0150454957,
0.0690073669,
-0.0109650064,
-0.0493041575,
0.0259763822,
0.0026851494,
-0.0733643472,
0.0316022113,
0.0589102618,
-0.0059375186,
-0.0202231109,
0.0216871146,
-0.0320682749,
0.0462089591,
0.0033939213,
-0.0691846907,
0.0536765717,
-0.035413146,
-0.0384643227,
-0.0541238971,
0.0322218537,
0.0128915478,
0.0084776971,
-0.0119103082,
0.0015918408,
0.0044004344,
0.0124278897,
-0.070625551,
-0.0149715096,
-0.0273618586,
0.0233898684,
-0.0324265063,
-0.091909878,
-0.0534453765,
0.0105131883,
-0.0476111919,
0.0518327504,
0.0366875306,
0.0039015829,
0.0146740563,
0.0164743699,
-0.0253991019,
0.0038099606,
0.0463468209,
-0.0155400857,
0.0075956346,
0.0531346537,
0.0154553289,
-0.0233390126,
-0.0038606727,
0.0712936819,
-0.012283735,
0.0207228009,
-0.0446740054,
0.0047602509,
0.0259284265,
0.0047485721,
0.0659581944,
0.0015789912,
0.0280855577,
0.0108974632,
0.066853784,
-0.0719483569,
-0.044440072,
-0.0043937718,
-0.0074635055,
-0.0230133981,
0.0329101384,
0.0081882309,
-0.061639227,
0.003049776,
0.0089491848,
-0.0090862596,
-0.0413513146,
-0.0142597156,
0.0445525087,
0.0470647253,
0.0118004903,
0.0295429938,
-0.0366595052,
-0.0674947649,
0.046811007,
-0.020945888,
0.0193225425,
0.0005799762,
0.0503994711,
0.043380633,
-0.0006087341,
0.013610594,
-0.0129716685,
-0.0685857087,
-0.0305191465,
0.0008856133,
-0.0275032036,
-5.057805421e-33,
0.0279756915,
-0.0051729209,
-0.0354736969,
0.0849834532,
-0.04772247,
0.0074919001,
-0.0230368003,
0.007716794,
0.0176292155,
-0.0010910435,
-0.0162718669,
0.0320150778,
-0.0120792035,
-0.0084959334,
-0.0037540528,
0.0242587086,
0.0550197177,
-0.0321196578,
-0.0311388224,
0.0513817407,
0.0480896421,
0.0335989967,
0.0622879788,
-0.1261321753,
-0.0136731239,
0.0030221415,
-0.0507756621,
-0.0212196037,
0.0187482797,
0.0314444341,
-0.0311426632,
0.0740615353,
-0.0162898265,
0.0432824716,
0.0330359563,
0.0557153523,
-0.042366717,
0.0037964087,
-0.015138397,
0.013405838,
-0.0006654261,
0.0048354464,
0.0272497386,
-0.0164497606,
-0.0582583435,
0.018849507,
0.0621978976,
0.0118137896,
0.0620768443,
-0.0375140682,
-0.0819505379,
-0.0261358451,
-0.0142875612,
-0.0660875142,
-0.0052731507,
0.0433642343,
0.03388061,
0.0070885904,
-0.0674664304,
0.055630967,
-0.0198929571,
-0.0073787305,
-0.0241105761,
-0.0347632915,
0.0229548812,
0.0887935758,
0.0704820678,
-0.005744447,
0.0433750413,
0.0067534237,
0.0455398448,
0.0473174155,
0.0496052168,
0.0191991683,
0.0068619563,
-0.0624972507,
0.0025004861,
0.0022005227,
0.0637353733,
-0.0302368701,
0.0139228031,
-0.0204752125,
-0.059239123,
-0.0103549231,
0.0009974982,
-0.056024272,
-0.0336978212,
-0.0234748237,
0.0240188316,
0.017060142,
0.0197769813,
-0.0005097008,
0.0252494514,
-0.0603965372,
-0.0328421891,
-0.0015617716,
-0.0197334681,
0.0017071912,
0.0050742552,
-0.0485010408,
-0.0153694404,
-0.0330327451,
0.0379700363,
0.0161169227,
0.0407453217,
-0.0093125748,
0.0456443764,
0.0644740835,
-0.0518803485,
0.0043748962,
0.0069971075,
0.0310712997,
-0.014837346,
0.0282131061,
-0.0000825335,
0.026022654,
-0.0259409454,
0.032154046,
-0.0280225761,
0.0444862582,
-0.0828767493,
0.00855383,
-0.0020717534,
-0.0117124366,
-0.0705750957,
-0.0372374617,
-0.0066950819,
-0.0676874816,
0.0129105337,
-0.0450550206,
0.0118874237,
-0.0606046915,
2.536e-7,
-0.0543984622,
0.0575659163,
0.011030891,
-0.0155103821,
0.0474034511,
0.0671140328,
-0.0260569695,
0.0265400801,
0.001320114,
0.0735047013,
0.0179869756,
-0.0501055308,
0.0522938669,
0.0424769036,
-0.0795988441,
-0.0288759824,
-0.1009272635,
-0.0208911709,
-0.02262724,
-0.0525134914,
0.044212278,
0.0677066371,
0.0488703065,
-0.0474769548,
0.0059292763,
-0.0111896116,
0.0146125797,
-0.0413869806,
0.0317374617,
-0.0466466919,
-0.0291560069,
-0.0457462668,
-0.0277522914,
0.0331960469,
-0.0183044709,
0.0186759774,
0.0003710386,
0.0748940781,
-0.016224172,
-0.0581858121,
-0.0155447004,
0.0709402636,
-0.0225386079,
-0.0047587277,
0.0087218815,
-0.0133437756,
-0.0232633818,
-0.0376148596,
-0.0222902186,
-0.0159911048,
-0.0069234753,
0.0263922028,
-0.007811653,
0.0411743559,
-0.0024111476,
0.0078148795,
0.0003171864,
-0.0817073733,
0.057299789,
-0.0110549619,
-0.0350479111,
-0.0455179736,
0.0147855496,
0.0042042024,
-0.0213296544,
-0.0295781288,
0.029769171,
1.824293879e-34,
0.0071105589,
-0.050416518,
0.0388724729,
-0.0057345033,
0.0362524278,
0.0257872976,
0.0575264506,
-0.047629904,
0.0224139132,
-0.017222669,
-0.0209356416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17663v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17663v1 | LLM-ARC: Enhancing LLMs with an Automated Reasoning Critic | 2024-06-25T15:52:15 | 2024-06-25T15:52:15 | Aditya Kalyanpur, Kailash Saravanakumar, Victor Barres, Jennifer Chu-Carroll, David Melville, David Ferrucci | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LO | We introduce LLM-ARC, a neuro-symbolic framework designed to enhance the
logical reasoning capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs), by combining
them with an Automated Reasoning Critic (ARC). LLM-ARC employs an Actor-Critic
method where the LLM Actor generates declarative logic programs along with
tests for semantic correctness, while the Automated Reasoning Critic evaluates
the code, runs the tests and provides feedback on test failures for iterative
refinement. Implemented using Answer Set Programming (ASP), LLM-ARC achieves a
new state-of-the-art accuracy of 88.32% on the FOLIO benchmark which tests
complex logical reasoning capabilities. Our experiments demonstrate significant
improvements over LLM-only baselines, highlighting the importance of logic test
generation and iterative self-refinement. We achieve our best result using a
fully automated self-supervised training loop where the Actor is trained on
end-to-end dialog traces with Critic feedback. We discuss potential
enhancements and provide a detailed error analysis, showcasing the robustness
and efficacy of LLM-ARC for complex natural language reasoning tasks. | LLM-ARC: Enhancing LLMs with an Automated Reasoning Critic: We introduce LLM-ARC, a neuro-symbolic framework designed to enhance the
logical reasoning capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs), by combining
them with an Automated Reasoning Critic (ARC). LLM-ARC employs an Actor-Critic
method where the LLM Actor generates declarative logic programs along with
tests for semantic correctness, while the Automated Reasoning Critic evaluates
the code, runs the tests and provides feedback on test failures for iterative
refinement. Implemented using Answer Set Programming (ASP), LLM-ARC achieves a
new state-of-the-art accuracy of 88.32% on the FOLIO benchmark which tests
complex logical reasoning capabilities. Our experiments demonstrate significant
improvements over LLM-only baselines, highlighting the importance of logic test
generation and iterative self-refinement. We achieve our best result using a
fully automated self-supervised training loop where the Actor is trained on
end-to-end dialog traces with Critic feedback. We discuss potential
enhancements and provide a detailed error analysis, showcasing the robustness
and efficacy of LLM-ARC for complex natural language reasoning tasks. | [
0.0237939749,
0.0593535192,
-0.0096962415,
0.0518842787,
-0.0394435786,
0.0131506752,
0.0250257161,
-0.0232799407,
0.0368763953,
-0.0266831964,
-0.0021258907,
0.0128378738,
-0.0612236746,
0.0480502583,
0.0215275884,
0.0144498385,
0.068071112,
-0.0413533896,
0.0419452712,
-0.0144788111,
-0.0166395754,
0.0328988358,
-0.0151121952,
0.0038510603,
-0.0223175157,
-0.0208200626,
-0.0213685408,
-0.0049623786,
-0.0062569482,
-0.0473691821,
-0.0118929045,
0.0370745473,
0.0401354767,
0.0255272314,
0.0000021432,
-0.0506645851,
0.0097161597,
0.002178648,
-0.0580819435,
-0.0016658765,
-0.0080970367,
0.0403855592,
0.0054859542,
0.0261460412,
-0.033160869,
0.0125130564,
-0.0065818788,
0.0468524881,
0.0842827037,
0.0870032981,
0.0137134567,
-0.0314922333,
0.0213992056,
-0.0102162426,
0.0204511508,
-0.032838013,
0.0170442108,
0.0356874578,
0.029591877,
-0.0105529204,
0.0000948083,
0.0116414977,
0.0815070719,
-0.0303230193,
-0.0362405702,
0.0317925289,
-0.0370994173,
0.0042620935,
-0.0178368259,
0.0659455061,
0.0306752641,
-0.0282540489,
-0.0414783694,
-0.0047213137,
0.0002832698,
-0.0413908549,
-0.0040159803,
0.0391887091,
-0.02115505,
-0.0015951007,
0.0410050377,
-0.0285870228,
0.0337206982,
0.0305598509,
-0.0475301445,
0.0908560455,
-0.0093489373,
-0.037414927,
0.0504582413,
-0.003105147,
-0.0224896371,
-0.0428983942,
0.0236603208,
0.0716747791,
-0.0649792999,
0.0298812445,
-0.004985502,
0.0013391154,
0.0245146118,
-0.0142309796,
0.0499116629,
0.0587275401,
0.0189498495,
0.0550039746,
-0.0470745601,
0.0589636341,
-0.0024208408,
0.0811350569,
-0.024186207,
0.0090380739,
-0.0418754183,
-0.0273810271,
-0.0183106922,
0.0430319905,
-0.0377566479,
0.008447499,
-0.0144645385,
0.0239561014,
-0.0162730664,
0.0405590944,
-0.0041611986,
0.0264071729,
0.02745777,
-0.0237452611,
-0.0822956413,
0.0226452518,
-0.0715905875,
0.0211015474,
0.0234668814,
-0.0274731535,
-0.0217163861,
-0.0025149037,
-0.0275758542,
-0.0280565973,
0.0535941124,
0.0882518664,
-0.0140860369,
-0.0073708291,
-0.0382504426,
-0.0292537827,
0.0077034878,
-0.0806385651,
0.0026642403,
-0.0660256669,
0.0488545187,
-0.0141264712,
-0.0480648428,
-0.0418291986,
0.0160960741,
0.0201077964,
0.0414309539,
0.0766749457,
-0.0091025336,
-0.0059403093,
0.0247410443,
0.0115326634,
-0.0186591595,
0.052448757,
0.0357292816,
0.0030933812,
0.0034612147,
0.0025182609,
-0.0100064762,
0.0185818486,
0.032831341,
-0.0035952376,
-0.0097049326,
0.0530481786,
-0.0566132031,
0.0451469831,
-0.0022090613,
0.0481527746,
-0.0388024449,
-0.0632359684,
-0.0044950955,
0.0357948579,
0.0133792358,
0.0104878992,
0.0167113338,
-0.0207254104,
0.026290819,
-0.0497584343,
-0.0792068839,
0.0438891537,
0.0017519982,
-0.0063311523,
-0.0236567706,
0.0008907609,
-0.0254599024,
-0.0676762164,
0.01854554,
0.0286574867,
0.0104824901,
0.0332379974,
0.0288317092,
0.0217524488,
-0.0466673896,
0.0519597679,
0.0039736582,
-0.0419712365,
-0.0246499851,
-0.0620875992,
0.06122756,
0.0425279737,
0.0469227731,
-0.0389455482,
-0.0627786815,
-0.0268454943,
-0.014045571,
0.0406193994,
0.0178946331,
-0.0126517452,
0.0168842506,
-0.0261144489,
-0.0083278017,
-0.0459528156,
0.0042952485,
0.0517332107,
0.0352074727,
-0.0151249887,
-0.0012236802,
-0.0079216268,
-0.0036560479,
0.0378234722,
-0.0294428878,
-0.0432857126,
0.0076870262,
-0.0075542131,
0.03257294,
0.0082039395,
0.0046956008,
0.0162559468,
0.0132202152,
-0.0106302127,
-0.0551228784,
-0.0235957652,
-0.0648325756,
-0.0504130311,
0.0813225731,
0.0076140934,
-0.0462160185,
0.0139166722,
-0.0707495809,
-0.033563517,
0.0311949812,
-0.010992323,
-0.0302959923,
-0.0470340848,
0.004141211,
0.031150911,
-0.0272231381,
-0.037327826,
0.0668175891,
0.0033969902,
-0.0082104355,
-0.0035175707,
0.0810733736,
0.0310281478,
-0.0466486961,
0.019158965,
-0.0034198638,
-0.0306779221,
-0.0046091755,
-0.0012039426,
0.0297305826,
-0.055167418,
-0.0306936968,
-0.0442420468,
0.0121199097,
0.0031574308,
0.0129096471,
-0.0053898538,
-0.0303073358,
-0.0039226501,
0.0019363811,
-0.035958644,
-0.0130500821,
0.0464958809,
-0.0068419771,
0.0242166594,
-0.0065603298,
-0.0194519963,
-0.015231967,
-0.0111552998,
-0.041818127,
0.0060737166,
0.0267961826,
0.0493569225,
-0.0228235591,
-0.0228469186,
-0.0559842885,
0.0300865881,
0.0063537573,
-0.0268365499,
0.0526332073,
-0.011237314,
-0.0374537855,
0.0831261277,
-0.0145309493,
-0.0084603457,
0.0350903198,
-0.0018959327,
-0.0559090413,
0.0923991427,
0.0064264839,
-0.0006622211,
-0.0311369766,
-0.0068654465,
-0.026364699,
0.0523491763,
-0.0051736399,
0.0204835385,
-0.0190842822,
0.0370793231,
0.0195913315,
-0.0343291573,
-0.0176066775,
-0.0256392956,
-0.0078488495,
0.0438669883,
-0.0330076627,
-0.0087576052,
0.0952281207,
-0.0024477828,
-0.0107193431,
-0.0475758128,
-0.0079277353,
-0.0637593344,
0.0854667202,
-0.0046066195,
-0.0171984248,
-0.0120299533,
-0.0092058862,
-0.0184892919,
-0.0622415878,
0.0120465886,
-0.0406645611,
0.0706611052,
-0.0355814919,
0.0047189468,
0.0131401485,
-0.0475621335,
-0.0459754206,
-0.0169165861,
-0.0666894838,
-0.0085829245,
-0.0395723246,
-0.0102389241,
0.0212061778,
-0.0267398674,
-0.0165988281,
0.0232240818,
-0.0157676563,
-0.012687251,
-0.0233613215,
-0.0003582486,
0.008923348,
0.0407686383,
0.0228288099,
-0.0074265446,
0.0532927625,
0.0481795073,
0.0122882817,
-0.0137596764,
-0.0697419569,
0.0439214297,
-0.0262870509,
-0.0287559722,
0.0355696306,
0.0045410395,
0.0472467691,
-0.0973452404,
-0.0061011394,
0.1136375368,
0.0377192535,
0.0135675911,
0.0055253757,
-0.0435847305,
0.0421971269,
0.0423379131,
0.0650299489,
-0.0905273706,
-0.0480147526,
-0.0025607932,
-0.0018640985,
0.0034508996,
-0.0487141982,
-0.0122984899,
-0.1097633168,
0.0313720815,
0.0068548932,
-0.0222157035,
0.0100730127,
-0.0376228094,
0.0051450687,
-0.0197391901,
0.0007839164,
0.0524009131,
0.00480839,
0.0041125165,
-0.0080721118,
0.0072760372,
0.042338077,
0.0842638463,
-0.0318475887,
0.0512278266,
0.0368074737,
0.0025139714,
0.0025389178,
-0.010278861,
0.0548583716,
-0.0168812387,
0.0278513022,
-0.054037746,
0.0359101333,
0.0073270625,
-0.0068012956,
-0.0240107775,
0.0262724664,
-0.0337998942,
-0.0307299793,
0.0337145962,
0.0698427036,
-0.0163573381,
-0.0126064252,
-0.0264205411,
0.0173249952,
-0.0273074098,
0.0410809629,
0.0137925195,
0.002571038,
-0.0830768868,
-0.0562538654,
-0.0437442586,
-0.0754078031,
-0.0098836375,
-0.000053835,
0.0195078366,
0.0265782848,
-0.023006862,
-0.036769364,
0.0287079643,
0.0199138708,
-0.0221185498,
-0.0336244293,
-0.0114704808,
-0.0116048176,
-0.0273952447,
0.0205017645,
-0.0472857207,
0.0457580164,
0.0012117584,
0.0379645601,
-0.0102846865,
-0.0278547816,
-0.0215032827,
0.0292990915,
-0.0547096282,
-0.0494134873,
-0.0296016745,
0.0557507165,
0.0211706404,
0.0450751297,
-0.0230225399,
-0.0106030693,
0.0235920493,
-0.0026489329,
-0.0347884931,
-0.0105577493,
0.0463286713,
0.0196265839,
-0.0058962656,
0.0203261524,
-0.0273462497,
0.0286530666,
0.0075630248,
0.0695623234,
-0.0163197294,
-0.0242572594,
0.0462111235,
0.0367301032,
-0.0299495291,
0.0309545714,
0.0263048001,
-0.0245539974,
0.0295297839,
-0.0330636874,
-0.0107563417,
-0.0103584463,
0.017245559,
-0.0044610999,
-0.0621830598,
0.0052136304,
-0.0544038489,
-0.0073370002,
0.0261353515,
0.0232953243,
0.0138149401,
0.0357824564,
0.0174124818,
-0.0146911778,
-0.0214363076,
-0.0287551153,
0.016455492,
0.006578628,
0.053654667,
-0.0106117344,
0.0632527843,
0.0489104316,
0.0062457495,
-0.038779337,
-0.0291983131,
-0.052952759,
-0.0453520715,
0.02760203,
0.0071972106,
0.0273446962,
0.0206393581,
-0.0178531352,
-0.0449142344,
0.0016903993,
0.0204240326,
0.0029880526,
0.0030964836,
-0.0272097643,
0.0663806871,
0.0327802449,
0.0196204521,
-0.0487795994,
0.0192182511,
0.0077149854,
0.0471569896,
0.0184427202,
0.025886571,
-0.0641208813,
-0.0615622066,
-0.0514093116,
-0.0250304714,
-0.0103121689,
-0.0058727548,
-0.0235825274,
-0.0958912596,
-0.0032074847,
0.0543603636,
-0.0043544215,
0.0041949097,
0.0056874887,
0.0423052646,
0.0323596969,
-0.0574882589,
0.0104884626,
0.0136905778,
-0.0319356993,
-0.0177082475,
-0.0356963724,
-5.909314427e-33,
-0.0240136031,
-0.0342744403,
0.0861508027,
-0.0150460871,
-0.0244649947,
-0.0305774435,
-0.0599071234,
-0.010870209,
-0.0188932214,
0.035081014,
-0.0229347255,
0.0375137143,
0.0005057336,
0.015613718,
-0.0000222276,
-0.0413553603,
0.0036016707,
0.0071503539,
-0.0194866098,
0.0079266923,
-0.0266578607,
-0.0129058026,
0.0054387189,
-0.0512193367,
-0.026330648,
0.0208770409,
-0.0204655603,
0.0554875545,
-0.1006832719,
0.0479050502,
0.0288069975,
0.0206330568,
0.0164778531,
-0.0239498466,
0.0066978293,
-0.0050227349,
-0.0884276554,
-0.0695569366,
0.0401047766,
-0.0299134273,
-0.0721425489,
-0.0221132934,
0.0292644706,
0.0046656807,
-0.0026102082,
-0.0272053406,
-0.0135908611,
-0.0188209787,
0.0159552526,
0.0085051488,
-0.0144961542,
0.0161234438,
-0.0292821862,
-0.0150842546,
-0.0278705712,
0.032490667,
-0.0035153541,
-0.0239087027,
-0.0379816294,
-0.0066713579,
0.0196481552,
-0.0190256648,
0.052115716,
0.026699435,
-0.0148628755,
0.0308359489,
0.0261713024,
0.0028587379,
-0.0744841248,
0.0092272907,
0.0041521466,
0.069046855,
0.0575262792,
0.0227978304,
-0.0064648436,
0.0220603757,
-0.0694405213,
0.0019599916,
0.0237372909,
0.0919936523,
0.0127491634,
0.0054682693,
-0.0222672913,
-0.001056074,
-0.067285791,
0.039334286,
-0.0365063809,
-0.0403572842,
0.0331210904,
0.0028056568,
-0.0135878157,
-0.0295301341,
-0.0182482321,
-0.0244377479,
0.0109220613,
0.0390374959,
0.0002700079,
-0.0063593308,
-0.0030618128,
0.0425726064,
-0.0433116294,
0.0146248452,
0.0058301473,
-0.0065444335,
0.0078103999,
-0.0021122592,
0.0180758387,
0.0257047787,
-0.0487170331,
-0.0086517902,
-0.0407811254,
0.029949788,
-0.0033399304,
0.0210187677,
0.0108955614,
0.0355296321,
-0.0197857544,
0.0371944532,
-0.0215191171,
-0.0062053395,
-0.0367096625,
0.0302395001,
0.0252264068,
0.0448310301,
-0.0216464438,
0.0053431182,
-0.045799125,
0.0122158192,
-0.0214745477,
-0.0932767168,
0.0066491044,
0.0287544262,
2.752e-7,
0.039696794,
0.0457961112,
0.0459674448,
0.0931871831,
0.0295904167,
0.0328971259,
-0.0137670171,
-0.0250344966,
0.0295181256,
-0.0530381054,
0.0037350589,
0.0896766707,
0.0118344668,
0.0429147966,
-0.0167473592,
0.026270736,
-0.0486807674,
0.0052905018,
-0.054623697,
0.0226029176,
0.0846205577,
0.0790662691,
0.0306748636,
-0.0468197241,
0.0014565928,
-0.057682734,
0.0422333553,
0.0086366544,
0.0062460112,
0.0196862165,
-0.0016033418,
-0.0022636147,
0.0301222708,
0.0620620325,
0.0126541005,
0.0074059274,
-0.0572095066,
0.0569161475,
-0.0082016289,
-0.0401793495,
-0.0261757616,
-0.0352849215,
0.0195668228,
-0.0508653335,
0.0772218108,
-0.0446220301,
-0.0346604176,
-0.0111268368,
-0.0145793203,
-0.0362062789,
0.0075221993,
-0.0037407016,
0.0033737768,
0.0065793502,
0.0088864025,
-0.0143983029,
0.0001979961,
-0.0720245764,
-0.0506649651,
-0.0014696107,
-0.0230796393,
0.0155602964,
-0.0426952429,
0.0250486266,
0.0275782291,
-0.0655626506,
-0.0088137211,
2.590949802e-34,
0.0354650207,
-0.0279021692,
0.0215025451,
0.0422590822,
0.0773367509,
0.0145078534,
-0.0234273393,
0.0090012094,
0.0298096053,
-0.0574819185,
-0.0272742677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17650v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17650v1 | ELIZA Reinterpreted: The world's first chatbot was not intended as a chatbot at all | 2024-06-25T15:41:40 | 2024-06-25T15:41:40 | Jeff Shrager | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC | ELIZA, often considered the world's first chatbot, was written by Joseph
Weizenbaum in the early 1960s. Weizenbaum did not intend to invent the chatbot,
but rather to build a platform for research into human-machine conversation and
the important cognitive processes of interpretation and misinterpretation. His
purpose was obscured by ELIZA's fame, resulting in large part from the
fortuitous timing of it's creation, and it's escape into the wild. In this
paper I provide a rich historical context for ELIZA's creation, demonstrating
that ELIZA arose from the intersection of some of the central threads in the
technical history of AI. I also briefly discuss how ELIZA escaped into the
world, and how its accidental escape, along with several coincidental turns of
the programming language screws, led both to the misapprehension that ELIZA was
intended as a chatbot, and to the loss of the original ELIZA to history for
over 50 years. | ELIZA Reinterpreted: The world's first chatbot was not intended as a chatbot at all: ELIZA, often considered the world's first chatbot, was written by Joseph
Weizenbaum in the early 1960s. Weizenbaum did not intend to invent the chatbot,
but rather to build a platform for research into human-machine conversation and
the important cognitive processes of interpretation and misinterpretation. His
purpose was obscured by ELIZA's fame, resulting in large part from the
fortuitous timing of it's creation, and it's escape into the wild. In this
paper I provide a rich historical context for ELIZA's creation, demonstrating
that ELIZA arose from the intersection of some of the central threads in the
technical history of AI. I also briefly discuss how ELIZA escaped into the
world, and how its accidental escape, along with several coincidental turns of
the programming language screws, led both to the misapprehension that ELIZA was
intended as a chatbot, and to the loss of the original ELIZA to history for
over 50 years. | [
0.0888182893,
-0.0070734401,
-0.0291803163,
-0.0199835598,
-0.0197573379,
-0.0003069343,
0.0046123802,
0.0191156752,
0.0572040826,
-0.0238992274,
0.0013818785,
0.0083404323,
0.0065135355,
0.0213212743,
-0.0206557363,
-0.0360484533,
-0.0072699795,
0.0196642857,
-0.0036677395,
0.0302545596,
0.0118348403,
0.0305656809,
-0.0300253648,
0.0825071782,
-0.0500980318,
-0.0405422151,
-0.047125861,
0.0079449583,
-0.0197997335,
0.027595466,
-0.0109831588,
-0.016199477,
0.0004314744,
0.0135388933,
0.0000018336,
-0.0337222889,
0.0111815725,
-0.001469353,
-0.0762031749,
-0.0667979345,
0.0124924434,
0.0320892185,
-0.0158392936,
0.007724863,
-0.0392715968,
0.0680469796,
0.043534331,
-0.0001346433,
0.0348382182,
0.0636758432,
-0.0145490449,
0.0547722876,
0.020911172,
0.0265628267,
0.0593302809,
-0.0771634579,
-0.0111224279,
0.0210460052,
0.0502226092,
-0.014634734,
-0.0140171032,
-0.0045289081,
0.0304576978,
-0.0217310321,
-0.0225095656,
0.0194235947,
-0.0010518258,
-0.07828179,
-0.0218767188,
0.0125892665,
0.0614685379,
-0.0041532228,
0.0322114304,
0.0555459931,
0.0209339913,
0.0010396198,
0.0074724816,
0.0064857458,
-0.0069756797,
-0.0339758284,
0.0063109202,
-0.0513132289,
-0.0017989354,
0.0215848833,
-0.0222924575,
0.0264604148,
-0.019571783,
0.025175089,
-0.0154929142,
-0.0191945322,
0.0293122213,
-0.0561218895,
0.0168169215,
0.0582649708,
-0.0151919024,
-0.022180995,
-0.0193631817,
0.0191362668,
-0.0373174511,
-0.0521319471,
-0.0445962586,
0.0476782545,
0.0191543009,
0.0459530577,
0.054703299,
0.0768170655,
-0.0094398716,
0.0277754944,
-0.0263926182,
-0.0097664176,
-0.0649436861,
-0.0196878389,
-0.0481027737,
0.0459012166,
0.0419589207,
-0.0210553594,
-0.0056198756,
0.0580989346,
0.0166080184,
-0.0157383252,
-0.0674842224,
-0.0111051779,
-0.0118407132,
-0.0013989261,
-0.0289957337,
-0.0310568381,
-0.0433499515,
0.0079125138,
0.0253800377,
-0.0837153047,
-0.0285388865,
-0.0059397086,
-0.032281395,
-0.014435878,
-0.0116994372,
0.0802351609,
0.0122120138,
-0.0560678802,
0.0150965853,
-0.0096926028,
-0.014692165,
-0.0736380965,
0.0067330473,
-0.0152590005,
-0.01046173,
0.0292367879,
0.0206739269,
-0.048315078,
0.0090965992,
-0.0160060246,
-0.0230116434,
0.0002213668,
-0.0289678778,
0.004083727,
0.0601454005,
0.0263109244,
-0.0556666814,
0.0284923054,
0.0326062068,
0.0256868117,
0.0133304661,
0.024177894,
0.0838552564,
0.013683999,
-0.0307561066,
-0.0514675565,
0.0307231769,
0.0006229611,
-0.0277959444,
-0.001301376,
-0.0186752845,
0.0019338136,
-0.0276062004,
0.0495568924,
0.0064560049,
0.0768327862,
-0.0465292372,
0.0428945497,
0.0430448949,
-0.004848728,
0.0342738144,
0.0123435762,
-0.0307062231,
0.0041832938,
-0.0423229448,
-0.0507313795,
-0.0239055865,
-0.0296631251,
-0.0068135937,
-0.0423677862,
0.0421604328,
-0.0243876111,
0.0221311189,
-0.0088051744,
0.0274969172,
0.0123603269,
0.0055661211,
-0.0147072626,
-0.0249343663,
-0.0350558087,
-0.0510504059,
-0.0833599791,
-0.0297483671,
0.1099418998,
0.0450396724,
-0.0058230455,
0.0147668328,
0.0059462823,
-0.0049504964,
0.036217615,
0.0325581431,
0.016593596,
-0.0078023816,
0.0105975047,
0.0060168337,
-0.0118704392,
-0.009569034,
0.0130548645,
-0.0587452352,
0.0232340582,
-0.0166883375,
0.0699493736,
0.0073062661,
0.0058254581,
-0.0100487713,
-0.0290496256,
-0.0680754334,
0.0054184152,
-0.0029420743,
0.043342609,
-0.017938504,
0.0228866152,
0.0260643791,
0.0065196496,
-0.0005810889,
0.0369556323,
0.0085309967,
0.0246324651,
0.0249395166,
-0.0954691991,
-0.0148810539,
0.0801263899,
0.0167981293,
-0.0055693975,
0.0410287119,
-0.074442625,
0.0610819794,
-0.0096499864,
0.0436020605,
-0.0428607911,
0.0003537349,
-0.0225765109,
0.0260002762,
-0.0043209046,
-0.0455341376,
0.025695052,
-0.0011854111,
-0.0142165385,
-0.0210967492,
-0.0322669595,
0.0236553438,
0.0188525263,
0.0168000422,
0.0262101237,
-0.0322925523,
-0.0488788001,
0.0012873275,
-0.0851641074,
-0.0253168605,
0.0163165443,
-0.0288797691,
0.0159116071,
0.0087815979,
0.0009501367,
-0.0504590869,
0.0058675124,
0.0562807843,
-0.0366148204,
0.0083290692,
0.0577369332,
0.0093946261,
-0.0546824709,
-0.0455018729,
0.0212545376,
-0.0298493803,
0.008933858,
0.0586789213,
-0.0441381708,
-0.0371799693,
0.0403164215,
-0.0158737916,
0.0174310282,
-0.026775999,
-0.0134306001,
0.0415732674,
-0.0141520659,
0.003504354,
0.0390091985,
-0.0002316865,
0.1051971391,
0.0309669096,
0.0316287838,
-0.0121744163,
-0.0005012767,
0.0191378631,
0.0060110753,
-0.0010545321,
-0.0420465469,
-0.0114798946,
0.0268670917,
-0.0292973202,
0.0297329091,
-0.0151932621,
0.0722380355,
-0.0047219009,
-0.0397282131,
-0.026343694,
-0.0331414491,
-0.0234281011,
0.0647395402,
-0.0099287303,
-0.0319113806,
0.0601968355,
0.0103278887,
-0.0102749681,
-0.0045965677,
-0.0275072381,
0.024778489,
0.0827722698,
-0.0532323979,
0.0099871578,
0.0122773126,
-0.0046779858,
-0.0321461521,
0.0031425436,
0.0093965866,
-0.0596259162,
-0.0252602044,
-0.0192612,
0.0166497398,
0.019277269,
-0.0161613151,
-0.0365900286,
-0.0692882985,
-0.0485093892,
-0.0226295143,
0.0362408087,
-0.0063420068,
-0.0646349713,
-0.0121686282,
0.006179614,
0.0420231558,
0.0455735885,
-0.02043649,
-0.0100553408,
-0.0895815268,
0.0101169776,
0.0341245607,
0.0111070583,
0.0245522391,
0.056295678,
0.0282018371,
0.0143716745,
-0.0100213606,
0.0211306605,
-0.0441143326,
0.0010938308,
-0.0053158016,
-0.0484656394,
0.0118845636,
0.0236376803,
-0.0470008813,
-0.0214003064,
0.0634113476,
0.0214673113,
-0.0590408035,
-0.0021198015,
-0.0237867441,
-0.0465842783,
0.0209896564,
0.0535979234,
-0.0853899866,
0.0183822811,
0.0277044326,
-0.0097481199,
-0.0339739546,
-0.0325338319,
-0.0107396236,
-0.0779208913,
-0.001300416,
-0.0188204255,
-0.0417315364,
-0.0339031331,
-0.0190242417,
-0.0410566814,
0.0262766443,
0.0142769488,
0.0255091116,
0.007832882,
0.008941927,
-0.0235491022,
-0.0264800396,
0.0633795336,
0.0285960566,
-0.0158070419,
0.0752830058,
0.0563876219,
0.0588972531,
0.0077751591,
0.0673372149,
-0.0179978851,
0.0737306252,
0.0247323737,
0.0167568829,
0.045320075,
0.0017017593,
-0.0255146492,
-0.0278766826,
-0.0217538122,
0.00983107,
0.0296039265,
0.0495076925,
-0.0107184704,
-0.0579611249,
0.0041834116,
-0.0277182143,
-0.0089244563,
0.028683573,
0.0069275443,
0.026287606,
-0.0347120278,
-0.0741492957,
-0.0402064808,
0.0295445789,
0.0264917426,
-0.0934232101,
0.0120706279,
0.0030725929,
-0.0734496787,
-0.0921212211,
-0.0417195484,
0.0042310492,
0.0433637537,
0.0682950988,
-0.0280854478,
0.005267208,
0.0453993641,
-0.0264346376,
-0.0021844234,
0.010550906,
-0.0276646186,
-0.0155941881,
-0.0048352196,
-0.0043089897,
-0.0672971085,
0.0045046187,
0.0157257859,
0.025367979,
-0.0031435834,
0.0227126032,
0.0307031292,
0.0359033272,
0.0003026737,
-0.0226186458,
0.006286961,
-0.0059293984,
-0.004194329,
-0.0144908298,
0.0247869231,
0.0292322747,
0.0665143132,
0.0023269677,
0.030681856,
-0.0726237223,
-0.0242084898,
-0.0273399577,
-0.0193471555,
-0.0083113583,
-0.0254477803,
0.0492032543,
0.0430410467,
-0.0008983595,
0.0129669011,
0.0383186303,
0.0468453765,
0.000673514,
-0.0356721021,
0.000673759,
-0.0168098658,
-0.0112948176,
-0.0352386199,
-0.0129901571,
0.0633360445,
0.0122080734,
-0.0332402736,
0.0129423141,
0.0065147323,
-0.0012858255,
-0.0100046759,
0.0949237272,
-0.0098225186,
-0.0002018104,
0.0019345448,
0.0577733181,
0.0022599117,
0.0521666482,
0.0354036801,
0.0535974316,
-0.0038178507,
-0.0163231865,
-0.0129197566,
0.0279776677,
-0.1191446111,
-0.1191550195,
0.0593911894,
0.0717958584,
0.0329326726,
0.0350687653,
0.0441464745,
-0.0134030608,
0.0106759639,
-0.0163495354,
0.0211346708,
0.021035688,
-0.007371265,
-0.0656151399,
0.0087052733,
-0.0001630935,
-0.0032731371,
0.0054545733,
-0.0397017077,
0.0770922601,
0.0162853245,
-0.0162953921,
-0.037832357,
-0.0632820576,
-0.0079873195,
-0.0380125605,
0.0372319371,
-0.0211093631,
-0.0197241865,
-0.0267197266,
-0.0180619527,
0.0232693572,
0.011231577,
-0.0290351566,
0.0517122708,
0.0230505187,
-0.0027202519,
-0.0330218635,
-0.0511985831,
0.0103323329,
-0.0247641299,
0.018558925,
-0.0006754386,
-5.455179449e-33,
0.0149231935,
-0.0274733678,
0.0434405729,
0.045122046,
-0.0308301672,
-0.0243879538,
-0.0481502302,
0.0442650244,
-0.0675293058,
0.0028168755,
-0.0546453521,
0.0537495762,
0.0094619589,
-0.0568944588,
0.0118021592,
0.00453887,
0.0258968975,
0.00187471,
-0.0287906155,
0.0196053796,
0.0321452543,
0.0064808442,
0.0006252484,
-0.0300503448,
0.0673742294,
-0.0185010489,
-0.0295363665,
-0.0095847659,
0.0044968859,
0.0108585805,
0.0068419906,
-0.0017790321,
0.0112333829,
0.0274387468,
0.0025422412,
0.0366650261,
0.0008539427,
-0.0356118605,
-0.0157293286,
0.0183388088,
-0.0326932222,
-0.0446989574,
0.0182342939,
-0.0115566356,
-0.0309516285,
0.0289684217,
0.0307577159,
-0.0100208009,
0.0305424742,
0.0647943765,
-0.0571051911,
-0.0377157256,
-0.0721902698,
-0.0868159905,
0.0296652559,
0.0248540845,
-0.0133990878,
-0.0400987379,
-0.0091387928,
0.0638730228,
-0.0504511558,
-0.0412930958,
0.0215111393,
-0.0062737153,
0.0330960043,
0.0702103078,
0.1075878143,
0.044404339,
-0.0408697575,
-0.0350401737,
-0.0044243662,
0.0245405976,
0.0038839169,
0.0228432175,
-0.0237847604,
-0.0233208984,
-0.0581538305,
0.0085149091,
0.0465201065,
0.0041203271,
0.0142196668,
-0.0105650555,
-0.1152542979,
0.0022211673,
0.0090769585,
0.0277820211,
-0.021005867,
-0.0365710966,
-0.0074943956,
-0.0219990313,
-0.0118724192,
-0.0449898615,
-0.01413712,
-0.0911441967,
0.0134153571,
-0.024950834,
-0.0225137658,
-0.0034831029,
0.024301311,
-0.0073990854,
0.0257990137,
-0.0359591059,
0.0039168941,
0.0468691438,
0.0679186136,
0.0174420848,
-0.0342595875,
0.0355861895,
0.0384376459,
-0.0445190854,
-0.0161121637,
0.0000349135,
0.016253924,
-0.0622873567,
0.0012250367,
0.0073318495,
-0.0194625109,
0.0535416566,
0.0369975418,
0.0286443233,
-0.0383800678,
0.0320257619,
-0.0105377166,
-0.0169422794,
-0.033927761,
-0.0412728079,
-0.0468156226,
0.0877517238,
0.0221436191,
-0.0595715232,
-0.0351612233,
-0.0103525873,
2.623e-7,
-0.0119256405,
0.0351881832,
0.0663904399,
0.0165696424,
-0.0014298392,
0.0198225416,
-0.0294401478,
0.0390429534,
0.0087059168,
0.0280188508,
0.008455947,
0.0238481555,
0.014190427,
-0.021037221,
-0.0597985722,
-0.0467435606,
-0.0246574022,
-0.0337421745,
-0.0253981482,
0.0316066369,
0.0635207668,
0.0285414569,
0.0190543178,
-0.0211962871,
0.0224222448,
0.011430718,
-0.0165588409,
-0.0334101059,
0.0256469753,
0.00919847,
-0.0671070442,
0.0494672246,
-0.0142031899,
0.0162114091,
0.0272765439,
-0.0178844556,
0.016873654,
0.0364914574,
-0.0091378326,
0.0024745828,
0.0208063424,
0.0180063173,
-0.0033485934,
-0.0035070542,
0.0472288094,
-0.0335435122,
-0.0665096417,
-0.0079505341,
0.0079211174,
0.014779333,
0.0397281647,
0.0081020193,
-0.0176643934,
0.0114167901,
-0.0279066414,
0.001386915,
-0.0044358969,
-0.0209321082,
0.0202112198,
-0.0130852778,
-0.0461454913,
-0.1013464704,
-0.0197092928,
-0.0095706489,
0.0375376977,
-0.0169218909,
0.0327012464,
1.253696294e-34,
-0.0175665766,
-0.0207649656,
0.0229218062,
0.0789197832,
0.0263353307,
0.0321657546,
0.0339728519,
-0.0006001741,
0.0553039014,
0.0162634123,
-0.0385346413
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17647v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17647v1 | Variationist: Exploring Multifaceted Variation and Bias in Written Language Data | 2024-06-25T15:41:07 | 2024-06-25T15:41:07 | Alan Ramponi, Camilla Casula, Stefano Menini | cs.CL | cs.CL | Exploring and understanding language data is a fundamental stage in all areas
dealing with human language. It allows NLP practitioners to uncover quality
concerns and harmful biases in data before training, and helps linguists and
social scientists to gain insight into language use and human behavior. Yet,
there is currently a lack of a unified, customizable tool to seamlessly inspect
and visualize language variation and bias across multiple variables, language
units, and diverse metrics that go beyond descriptive statistics. In this
paper, we introduce Variationist, a highly-modular, extensible, and
task-agnostic tool that fills this gap. Variationist handles at once a
potentially unlimited combination of variable types and semantics across
diversity and association metrics with regards to the language unit of choice,
and orchestrates the creation of up to five-dimensional interactive charts for
over 30 variable type-semantics combinations. Through our case studies on
computational dialectology, human label variation, and text generation, we show
how Variationist enables researchers from different disciplines to effortlessly
answer specific research questions or unveil undesired associations in language
data. A Python library, code, documentation, and tutorials are made publicly
available to the research community. | Variationist: Exploring Multifaceted Variation and Bias in Written Language Data: Exploring and understanding language data is a fundamental stage in all areas
dealing with human language. It allows NLP practitioners to uncover quality
concerns and harmful biases in data before training, and helps linguists and
social scientists to gain insight into language use and human behavior. Yet,
there is currently a lack of a unified, customizable tool to seamlessly inspect
and visualize language variation and bias across multiple variables, language
units, and diverse metrics that go beyond descriptive statistics. In this
paper, we introduce Variationist, a highly-modular, extensible, and
task-agnostic tool that fills this gap. Variationist handles at once a
potentially unlimited combination of variable types and semantics across
diversity and association metrics with regards to the language unit of choice,
and orchestrates the creation of up to five-dimensional interactive charts for
over 30 variable type-semantics combinations. Through our case studies on
computational dialectology, human label variation, and text generation, we show
how Variationist enables researchers from different disciplines to effortlessly
answer specific research questions or unveil undesired associations in language
data. A Python library, code, documentation, and tutorials are made publicly
available to the research community. | [
0.0099772671,
0.1126901284,
-0.051938761,
0.0076595419,
-0.0335743688,
0.0143539738,
0.0160572361,
-0.0157431755,
-0.006177533,
-0.0265450738,
0.0033157058,
-0.0197177865,
0.0396965407,
0.0560765639,
0.0286747701,
-0.0642423704,
0.0418245196,
0.0294444468,
0.0290063638,
0.0229830295,
0.026499439,
0.0397438966,
-0.0169566255,
0.0445907936,
-0.0587831475,
-0.0271158591,
-0.0087941997,
0.009272676,
0.0413098037,
-0.0254123528,
0.043821156,
0.0711932182,
-0.0201794673,
0.0308029838,
0.0000021604,
-0.0527968258,
-0.0040788008,
-0.0254290886,
0.0037992476,
0.0137398867,
0.1156984121,
-0.0053891344,
-0.0034531753,
0.0198233332,
-0.030915983,
-0.0029120946,
0.07809183,
0.0031633209,
0.0245995726,
0.0046649072,
-0.0096471049,
0.0119525986,
-0.066743508,
-0.0058189598,
0.0037291618,
0.0559029877,
-0.0001634337,
-0.0437219515,
0.0062819342,
-0.0021608633,
-0.0174390413,
0.0049812212,
-0.0093860794,
-0.0064049512,
-0.0123079419,
0.0014669133,
-0.0390342586,
-0.0502580926,
0.0149610722,
0.0315552019,
0.0405504555,
-0.0350428484,
0.0124172904,
-0.0307777729,
0.0157679673,
0.0271962415,
-0.039121706,
0.0096365279,
0.0044807447,
-0.0175318457,
0.0159860831,
-0.0024304911,
-0.0154968267,
0.0253232177,
-0.0025814148,
0.022747241,
0.0347137824,
0.0090336725,
0.0159334503,
0.0346879549,
-0.0120419106,
-0.0629331246,
0.0089671379,
-0.0129887164,
-0.0700021535,
0.0039552012,
-0.0205526352,
-0.0908234119,
0.0529415719,
-0.0090053817,
0.0527805649,
0.0022359607,
-0.0379363261,
-0.0331751741,
0.0678007007,
0.025766965,
0.0105719613,
-0.0115342084,
-0.003006069,
-0.020131072,
0.0038116204,
-0.0353927575,
-0.0048333006,
-0.0618591681,
0.0218615029,
0.050472863,
-0.0360060968,
-0.0083380789,
-0.0676568151,
-0.009948276,
-0.0042764167,
0.0469008125,
-0.0317598432,
0.021561211,
-0.0378011055,
0.0378518663,
-0.0899940208,
0.0295214858,
-0.0127085503,
-0.0437125079,
0.0010460981,
0.0431031026,
0.0028010109,
-0.0449240729,
-0.014857267,
0.0015298364,
0.0095351087,
0.0060631465,
-0.007612709,
-0.0341514312,
-0.0737481043,
-0.0190549791,
-0.0330300927,
-0.0963981599,
0.020451149,
0.0368605219,
-0.000042781,
-0.0484731793,
-0.0180586874,
0.0266925097,
-0.0348273441,
0.0219310336,
-0.0204965752,
-0.0074621085,
0.0285265632,
-0.0171126574,
0.0030977717,
0.0552779362,
0.0271108113,
-0.0117576728,
0.0417736694,
-0.0382655971,
-0.023958141,
0.02332622,
-0.0041269027,
0.0069237435,
-0.0713358819,
-0.0381513201,
-0.0254869442,
0.0145464335,
0.0390028134,
0.0527332798,
-0.0089296885,
-0.0364202857,
0.0514973029,
0.052628804,
0.0253313016,
-0.0121203754,
0.0251254998,
0.0453856736,
-0.0038548454,
-0.0008163406,
0.0161027685,
0.0113632903,
0.0453315303,
-0.0042995703,
-0.0253138356,
0.0730856881,
0.0170302913,
-0.0480890498,
-0.0422183871,
0.0144705586,
0.0292054657,
-0.0357250012,
-0.0022764872,
0.0267667044,
0.037210457,
0.0510705635,
0.0592323653,
-0.0661348179,
0.0031249039,
0.0130792372,
0.0217155889,
0.0497686379,
0.0056077372,
-0.0199558455,
0.0302893464,
-0.0254432075,
0.0188030954,
0.0826788396,
0.0605859235,
-0.0098426417,
-0.0072517223,
-0.0449796729,
0.0013448931,
-0.029701177,
0.028219454,
0.0355054997,
0.0057035387,
0.0285078082,
-0.0083457623,
-0.0818261057,
-0.0243947506,
0.032293994,
0.0105008772,
0.015134817,
0.0335051343,
-0.009575977,
0.0094998479,
0.0466239378,
-0.0237388648,
0.0340303443,
-0.0124045806,
-0.0151191661,
0.0060178079,
0.0556180924,
0.0213365778,
-0.0061358018,
0.0234271288,
-0.0831537247,
-0.0358041748,
-0.0029453011,
-0.0036691735,
-0.0339149162,
0.0388031676,
-0.0629651845,
0.0255148988,
-0.0184109993,
-0.0336393528,
0.0002166394,
0.0441139452,
-0.0481088087,
0.0547108725,
0.0100433128,
0.01676297,
0.0176894329,
0.0123169096,
0.0418244451,
0.021188302,
0.0115378443,
0.0059290295,
-0.0126764625,
0.0027988586,
0.0424813144,
-0.0122896452,
-0.0681779757,
-0.0188824069,
-0.1253567189,
-0.0008616679,
-0.0203504022,
0.0051729977,
0.0132250329,
0.0017387042,
-0.0107897045,
0.0092143025,
-0.0242141467,
-0.0046266927,
0.0108660404,
0.0341410488,
0.0603421517,
-0.0464342013,
0.0290929731,
-0.0289675742,
0.0091657797,
-0.0317377076,
0.0333168171,
0.0233497154,
0.0331865586,
-0.0120272748,
-0.0338958502,
-0.0578644313,
-0.0567121543,
0.0215900578,
-0.0239840895,
0.0528462976,
0.0334640704,
0.1148019508,
0.023047151,
0.0447097719,
0.0577564649,
0.0633214563,
-0.0319248959,
-0.0385580584,
-0.0251023788,
-0.0275716074,
0.0394297577,
0.0363854878,
-0.0681824312,
0.0057446095,
0.0896073729,
0.0633188188,
-0.0115524307,
-0.0461249873,
0.0544050187,
-0.0372587927,
-0.0163771696,
-0.016052749,
0.0148646887,
-0.0406564064,
0.0484002829,
0.0061819316,
-0.0510834195,
0.0460806116,
0.0123338848,
0.0169820935,
-0.0327182375,
-0.0421728045,
-0.0296843983,
0.0532877669,
0.0030749319,
0.0122912517,
0.001857915,
-0.0378912836,
-0.0567217954,
0.0262996405,
0.0398302115,
-0.0157724172,
0.0351737998,
-0.0853289366,
-0.0194976665,
0.0057017221,
-0.0125960959,
-0.0257222503,
-0.0305062253,
-0.0139705865,
-0.0347442031,
0.061849732,
-0.0438920744,
0.014597659,
-0.0496926159,
0.0305068158,
0.016677402,
-0.0302560758,
0.0075361929,
-0.0012809536,
0.006271448,
0.0465724021,
0.0360671915,
0.0100854998,
-0.0192986913,
-0.0287402347,
0.0436217301,
-0.0505202711,
0.0548345558,
-0.008844859,
0.0235327613,
0.0007190346,
-0.018690411,
-0.0141419219,
0.0248035695,
0.0577858984,
-0.019043101,
-0.0032970756,
0.0805718303,
0.0320821963,
-0.0253733061,
0.0387313738,
-0.0686283484,
0.1109674796,
0.0246534329,
0.0142563144,
-0.104306832,
0.0029010777,
-0.0297429804,
0.0203600023,
-0.0374646224,
-0.0435431786,
-0.0225078557,
-0.0829179212,
0.0328940265,
0.0112682218,
-0.0527309999,
0.0424183682,
-0.0432502888,
-0.0004832455,
-0.0187154301,
0.0156175513,
-0.0264020488,
0.0170317292,
0.0290121753,
0.0385963842,
-0.0174175594,
-0.0509816892,
-0.0307245553,
-0.0311838295,
-0.0016885503,
-0.0091249272,
0.0528111868,
-0.0360529572,
-0.0167529285,
0.0068871793,
-0.0032096102,
-0.023871541,
-0.0073064463,
0.0729421899,
0.0274074897,
-0.0284480359,
-0.0651622415,
0.0245587751,
-0.0116173169,
-0.036875546,
-0.0042035556,
0.043530263,
-0.0076878956,
-0.007001224,
-0.0480861254,
-0.0036924488,
0.0088928891,
0.0577376038,
0.053000506,
-0.0564286821,
-0.0041930024,
-0.0421687514,
0.0292036999,
-0.0383852609,
-0.0477768444,
0.0439976007,
0.0018198701,
-0.0768123642,
-0.0664748773,
-0.0454331972,
0.0239130463,
0.0072701843,
0.0115451384,
-0.0305059385,
0.0053958953,
-0.0405241102,
-0.0921955854,
0.0431968383,
0.0207328219,
0.0272661168,
0.0104258321,
-0.0632235706,
0.0039342209,
-0.0125879636,
-0.0101234112,
0.0429240204,
-0.0982782841,
-0.068448253,
0.0560512617,
-0.0078879828,
0.0152371041,
0.0285516959,
0.0160017498,
-0.0535585135,
0.0018164462,
0.0519730859,
0.032349892,
0.0101838065,
-0.0434647836,
-0.008696218,
0.000776578,
-0.0092179123,
-0.009167823,
0.0012529814,
-0.0268450603,
0.0133789517,
-0.0385486297,
-0.0144529808,
0.0144773554,
-0.0408110321,
0.0033356063,
-0.040460784,
-0.0220735185,
-0.064427115,
-0.0651125088,
-0.0360304117,
-0.0520465635,
-0.0078950552,
-0.034831088,
0.0114685846,
-0.0086097317,
-0.040677622,
0.0224117301,
-0.0368252844,
0.0455205925,
-0.0070393044,
0.0435381904,
-0.0039719576,
0.0591140091,
0.0154847093,
0.0078863623,
-0.0053010392,
0.0442634337,
-0.0370611325,
0.0842681676,
0.01594452,
0.0371500403,
0.0040663676,
-0.0167303868,
0.0342434645,
-0.0034226805,
-0.0282298718,
-0.0390065685,
0.0113462983,
-0.0365843959,
-0.0018933057,
-0.0456389971,
0.0921281353,
-0.0301720109,
-0.0088699115,
-0.0128177218,
0.034660019,
0.0120114246,
-0.008727584,
0.01583956,
-0.0025628866,
-0.0433763824,
-0.0282844491,
0.0637251735,
-0.0019670837,
0.0136227291,
-0.0351977386,
-0.0315185487,
-0.0181444138,
-0.0147051737,
0.0296645481,
0.0322775356,
0.0095133595,
-0.0073135104,
-0.0967418626,
-0.0700723976,
0.0059249601,
-0.0147907818,
0.0294783972,
-0.0007841883,
0.0172313638,
0.052012004,
-0.0231697895,
-0.0131980861,
-0.0208023563,
0.024388114,
0.0030398478,
-0.0333985686,
-0.0361024998,
-6.696482749e-33,
-0.0304057356,
-0.1019663215,
-0.0279526021,
-0.0750388056,
-0.0033561059,
-0.0144951418,
-0.0241751485,
0.0482840538,
-0.01129713,
0.0414833054,
0.0160102788,
0.0111723822,
0.0169498306,
0.0195808578,
0.0669104755,
0.0087084165,
0.0255604107,
0.0189480968,
-0.011347048,
-0.0163206682,
0.0492277332,
-0.0162406527,
0.0750032738,
-0.0726421699,
0.0660718605,
0.0152343269,
-0.0041637602,
-0.0128081692,
0.0011611474,
0.0142397685,
-0.00005773,
0.0764534771,
0.0232406333,
0.0025651429,
-0.0277060475,
-0.0028217346,
-0.004501319,
-0.0953772441,
0.012444593,
0.0338345207,
-0.0043410803,
-0.0253680032,
0.0400316156,
-0.0066419421,
-0.0307019986,
0.0097831059,
0.0525618494,
0.0072803604,
0.0252144374,
0.0259736758,
-0.0455825031,
0.0316604003,
-0.045071885,
0.0385822169,
-0.0278825276,
0.0078312429,
-0.0102340989,
0.016554419,
-0.038586814,
0.0503799841,
0.0308540519,
-0.0032036533,
0.0511492491,
0.0133162057,
-0.0081964312,
0.0454665571,
0.025690956,
0.0277833715,
0.0102525726,
0.0149671379,
0.0317824855,
0.017621126,
0.0232139863,
0.0948631465,
0.0180540085,
-0.0349539071,
0.0003340993,
-0.0014807107,
0.0467628166,
-0.0191369411,
-0.0339218937,
-0.0082646711,
-0.0395480134,
-0.048616074,
-0.0233048499,
-0.0465040468,
-0.0217778999,
-0.0270943847,
0.0369358025,
-0.0583141558,
-0.0001069311,
-0.0099451384,
-0.0019729852,
0.0082152067,
-0.039190907,
0.0281022452,
-0.047548756,
0.017572213,
0.0178668573,
0.0060328045,
-0.0273861047,
0.0087091904,
0.0068779252,
0.0238657519,
0.0543930493,
0.019860778,
-0.0020830699,
-0.0187847763,
-0.0587567873,
0.0171909221,
0.0081066769,
-0.021769898,
-0.0247542467,
0.0088402797,
0.0330494978,
0.0089921076,
-0.0187505409,
0.0342309736,
0.0566395819,
0.0085914303,
-0.0437444448,
-0.0472757965,
-0.0313764252,
0.0165666696,
-0.0100682089,
-0.015665004,
-0.0131292492,
-0.0255528949,
0.0662664697,
-0.0283234864,
0.0011727177,
-0.0569250584,
2.8e-7,
0.0525891371,
0.082961008,
-0.009590731,
0.0502250306,
0.0212496985,
0.020128632,
0.0280167498,
0.0128301932,
-0.0210848469,
-0.0242606793,
-0.0178712346,
-0.0071375538,
0.0593620054,
0.0789876878,
-0.0232700408,
-0.0080173537,
-0.0384259894,
-0.0046463436,
-0.0790308565,
0.0201041847,
0.076182425,
0.0448438078,
0.0154010458,
0.0125550795,
-0.0027681419,
0.0183667187,
0.0304865483,
-0.0255171638,
0.0003364876,
0.0113560529,
0.0134364143,
-0.0443874709,
0.0311809499,
0.0070975679,
-0.0314763747,
-0.0144502232,
-0.0052188323,
0.0213218182,
0.0053301868,
-0.0069697397,
-0.0062230132,
-0.0071690534,
-0.0110056512,
-0.0801481754,
0.0328545533,
0.0303200502,
-0.0161372852,
-0.0317195579,
0.0109423185,
0.0117676528,
0.0518501103,
-0.0463701524,
-0.0293667614,
0.0036835559,
0.0165659878,
0.0056857266,
-0.032031104,
-0.0155395158,
-0.0624818541,
0.0247769654,
-0.0234865844,
-0.0329165086,
-0.0089146569,
0.0386096947,
0.0190301854,
-0.0173811298,
0.0241864268,
2.711625547e-34,
0.0339373723,
0.0119184246,
0.0352354981,
-0.0149547765,
0.0609359555,
-0.0097238058,
-0.0065266103,
0.0321616605,
0.0317477062,
-0.0189143661,
-0.0261431132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17642v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17642v1 | Banishing LLM Hallucinations Requires Rethinking Generalization | 2024-06-25T15:31:01 | 2024-06-25T15:31:01 | Johnny Li, Saksham Consul, Eda Zhou, James Wong, Naila Farooqui, Yuxin Ye, Nithyashree Manohar, Zhuxiaona Wei, Tian Wu, Ben Echols, Sharon Zhou, Gregory Diamos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite their powerful chat, coding, and reasoning abilities, Large Language
Models (LLMs) frequently hallucinate. Conventional wisdom suggests that
hallucinations are a consequence of a balance between creativity and
factuality, which can be mitigated, but not eliminated, by grounding the LLM in
external knowledge sources. Through extensive systematic experiments, we show
that these traditional approaches fail to explain why LLMs hallucinate in
practice. Specifically, we show that LLMs augmented with a massive Mixture of
Memory Experts (MoME) can easily memorize large datasets of random numbers. We
corroborate these experimental findings with a theoretical construction showing
that simple neural networks trained to predict the next token hallucinate when
the training loss is above a threshold as it usually does in practice when
training on internet scale data. We interpret our findings by comparing against
traditional retrieval methods for mitigating hallucinations. We use our
findings to design a first generation model for removing hallucinations --
Lamini-1 -- that stores facts in a massive mixture of millions of memory
experts that are retrieved dynamically. | Banishing LLM Hallucinations Requires Rethinking Generalization: Despite their powerful chat, coding, and reasoning abilities, Large Language
Models (LLMs) frequently hallucinate. Conventional wisdom suggests that
hallucinations are a consequence of a balance between creativity and
factuality, which can be mitigated, but not eliminated, by grounding the LLM in
external knowledge sources. Through extensive systematic experiments, we show
that these traditional approaches fail to explain why LLMs hallucinate in
practice. Specifically, we show that LLMs augmented with a massive Mixture of
Memory Experts (MoME) can easily memorize large datasets of random numbers. We
corroborate these experimental findings with a theoretical construction showing
that simple neural networks trained to predict the next token hallucinate when
the training loss is above a threshold as it usually does in practice when
training on internet scale data. We interpret our findings by comparing against
traditional retrieval methods for mitigating hallucinations. We use our
findings to design a first generation model for removing hallucinations --
Lamini-1 -- that stores facts in a massive mixture of millions of memory
experts that are retrieved dynamically. | [
0.0063720159,
0.0764822364,
-0.0311836004,
0.0300194677,
-0.0202681292,
0.0020635303,
-0.0304014347,
0.0218647812,
-0.0078918338,
-0.0131092211,
-0.0401335992,
-0.06183419,
0.0037447521,
-0.0091330139,
0.0227004662,
-0.0131437564,
0.0405968241,
-0.0522313304,
0.0236879922,
-0.0233793445,
-0.0123402607,
-0.0069627105,
0.0060313395,
0.0364275463,
-0.0097687133,
-0.0123493215,
0.0017315334,
-0.0157541614,
-0.0191846583,
0.0000513005,
0.009628444,
0.0430173799,
0.0182079338,
0.0406882092,
0.000002103,
-0.0322698615,
0.0146176266,
-0.0357910916,
-0.0368012451,
-0.0029955369,
-0.0082230531,
0.003756095,
-0.0001373773,
-0.004779147,
-0.039848648,
-0.0130322427,
0.0391225219,
0.0684159622,
0.0593387112,
0.0778365359,
0.0132788857,
-0.0457053557,
0.0805977061,
0.0185497645,
0.0762622803,
0.0107165687,
0.0347536653,
0.0295711067,
-0.0197993573,
-0.0437987,
0.0000016911,
0.0297588073,
0.0211757254,
0.0329441354,
0.0206365921,
0.0433188863,
-0.0935419947,
-0.0299676452,
-0.0172203686,
0.058963567,
-0.0331532992,
-0.0524008162,
0.0203876235,
0.0334028266,
0.0200800207,
-0.0092948405,
-0.0636300147,
0.0515563861,
-0.0186292268,
0.0001997667,
-0.0217601061,
0.0000244138,
0.081193924,
-0.0018643251,
-0.0470726788,
0.0401201509,
0.0014172086,
-0.0404692255,
0.0179784205,
-0.0040771202,
-0.0070266002,
-0.0304956548,
0.0159413181,
0.0219861679,
-0.0263880678,
0.0138087319,
-0.0207953416,
0.0037812022,
0.024873754,
-0.0984134823,
0.0048951246,
0.0224183947,
-0.024924539,
0.043923784,
-0.042953603,
0.006229355,
-0.0288142432,
0.0668304786,
0.0257171653,
0.0024870522,
-0.0676332563,
-0.02930074,
-0.0156109473,
0.0499192588,
0.0479853526,
-0.0274832174,
-0.0142826457,
0.0121173179,
-0.0348506942,
0.0308136847,
-0.0441202484,
0.0385339297,
0.0335646905,
-0.0307769291,
-0.0276790187,
0.0061514457,
-0.0070438315,
-0.0104276147,
0.0397920571,
-0.082787402,
-0.0263351798,
0.0033096629,
-0.0117001161,
0.0164009277,
0.0140153291,
0.0708847493,
0.0057671415,
-0.0210114345,
-0.0632883236,
-0.0343425833,
-0.0014233709,
-0.0599677637,
0.0269972626,
-0.0502266921,
0.0337185152,
-0.0021686328,
-0.010645452,
-0.0483012907,
0.0183842685,
0.0244100261,
-0.0599135607,
0.0604479164,
-0.0023839022,
-0.0038358558,
0.0541948415,
0.0448743552,
-0.0219299886,
0.0535503216,
0.0177850835,
0.0087739415,
0.0194150899,
-0.0072886846,
0.0568822026,
0.0184770525,
0.0294223893,
-0.0214038156,
-0.043563351,
0.0009369812,
0.032810349,
0.0218837466,
0.0159836765,
0.0679231659,
-0.0390800238,
-0.035520032,
0.0950049534,
0.0275764503,
-0.0338072665,
0.0537208915,
0.013426492,
-0.0137083242,
0.023584608,
0.0202439353,
-0.0718837529,
0.0362590775,
-0.0261556841,
0.0143840164,
0.0699488074,
-0.0024498287,
-0.0474876203,
-0.0192935001,
-0.0063082138,
-0.0099161081,
0.0063422029,
0.0242447704,
0.0189812873,
0.0120723005,
-0.0407415405,
0.1053100452,
0.0212524887,
-0.0196178909,
0.000369932,
-0.0570217967,
0.0107480055,
0.0658193976,
0.0509282425,
-0.018833112,
-0.0023683661,
-0.0288277585,
0.02617562,
0.0260947347,
0.0313750952,
0.0128275556,
0.025757188,
-0.0655530542,
0.0416023359,
-0.0077195158,
0.0433982722,
0.00204722,
0.0005024176,
-0.0038963943,
-0.0038531953,
-0.0189273506,
-0.0314890482,
0.0191849992,
-0.0388205722,
-0.0337856412,
-0.0208454281,
-0.0211571511,
0.0143575026,
-0.0110102957,
-0.0183158014,
0.0394586921,
0.0206828751,
-0.0407965109,
-0.0592876486,
-0.009795676,
-0.0611070953,
0.0022647753,
0.0304797143,
0.0005525344,
0.016660545,
-0.0194695704,
0.0044881576,
-0.0279177465,
0.0465907827,
-0.0643122792,
0.0846927688,
-0.033313565,
0.0352570899,
0.0065799141,
0.0446545817,
0.0157230552,
0.0784094557,
-0.0410397127,
0.0072103371,
0.0201493241,
0.0050397804,
-0.0024757828,
-0.0377877951,
-0.0056523019,
0.0168094765,
-0.0074791904,
0.0483580232,
-0.0067873239,
-0.067072019,
-0.0582961701,
-0.0280416682,
-0.0764869004,
0.003463432,
-0.0232588612,
-0.0242041219,
0.0126357926,
-0.0318095833,
-0.0026355975,
-0.0123471292,
-0.0382237919,
0.0142648071,
-0.0136865396,
0.0481746979,
0.0106150936,
0.009074891,
-0.0300384872,
-0.0214438513,
-0.0064707082,
-0.0034700662,
0.0597648025,
-0.0335462838,
-0.0245262608,
-0.0474763289,
0.013290788,
-0.0649649277,
0.0064917346,
-0.0244076438,
0.0011065368,
0.0176026244,
-0.043526046,
0.042550005,
0.0908655897,
0.0169977732,
-0.0224251803,
0.0553336814,
-0.0302093644,
-0.0457296297,
-0.0148540577,
0.0057611461,
-0.0233442206,
-0.0026216549,
-0.0180960484,
-0.0110800667,
0.0483584329,
0.027080873,
0.0315032117,
-0.0489598922,
0.0473325811,
-0.0016837863,
-0.0437611304,
-0.021504065,
-0.0146159679,
-0.0310031027,
0.0376654901,
-0.0240842346,
-0.0622854978,
0.0796478838,
0.0063930382,
-0.0025035243,
0.0113782585,
-0.0148665868,
-0.0048137619,
0.0145742288,
-0.0091415616,
-0.0041901888,
-0.0066719335,
-0.0189910736,
-0.0630320013,
-0.036175523,
-0.0345622115,
-0.0572038256,
0.034796048,
-0.0216428116,
0.002227006,
0.0256109256,
-0.0444639288,
-0.066969052,
-0.0183998682,
-0.0229914393,
-0.0044102799,
-0.0183086656,
-0.0000899051,
-0.0468350723,
-0.0310406294,
0.0376213007,
0.012448376,
-0.0125807561,
-0.0337857604,
0.0222697929,
0.0086144907,
0.0402321257,
-0.0082658567,
0.0398098379,
-0.036272753,
0.0349646285,
0.0814492181,
0.0322442353,
0.0172573682,
-0.0221349187,
-0.0018532611,
0.0056625591,
-0.0040295385,
-0.0215879343,
0.0350817367,
0.0246479101,
-0.0573704466,
-0.0312258285,
0.0969337299,
0.0242004283,
-0.0672437772,
-0.0108114332,
-0.0291473009,
0.0518224426,
0.0059051649,
-0.0094970968,
-0.0512273125,
-0.0106437821,
0.0051464611,
-0.0029623711,
-0.0151170604,
-0.0256250128,
-0.0044997139,
-0.0814094469,
-0.010526292,
0.040999569,
-0.0220601819,
-0.0094041731,
-0.0211490709,
-0.0345061719,
0.01550656,
0.0485139191,
0.0129643539,
0.0096656149,
-0.0255383048,
-0.0034143261,
-0.0432223603,
-0.0078303507,
0.0503267795,
-0.0211986788,
0.0775025412,
0.0645428449,
0.0196008701,
-0.0052459901,
-0.0775699541,
0.0306005143,
0.0009483126,
0.0064827083,
0.0166689083,
0.0681425035,
0.0160847753,
0.0019291709,
0.0085292561,
0.0287129506,
-0.0480141416,
-0.0213075932,
0.0048641125,
0.0612315685,
-0.0330143906,
-0.0581526384,
-0.0045922403,
0.0350471288,
-0.0028797609,
0.072588563,
0.0254148617,
-0.0200612918,
-0.0391421095,
-0.0398751795,
0.0249524862,
-0.0176912844,
-0.0543431826,
0.0340532102,
0.0761759579,
-0.0198341701,
-0.065635331,
-0.0294722319,
-0.0040633078,
0.0183661021,
0.0070050899,
0.0123677356,
-0.0128046395,
0.0069715097,
-0.013177366,
0.0249349456,
-0.046331685,
-0.0280973651,
-0.0338386074,
0.0240466651,
0.0191289894,
-0.0289437305,
0.0243926495,
0.0153866122,
-0.0928306356,
-0.0797463879,
0.0265390221,
0.0582476035,
0.0328693651,
0.044128105,
0.008734365,
-0.0657137185,
0.0696107447,
0.0492607318,
-0.0541605912,
0.0106115686,
0.0221121814,
0.0247619171,
0.0255812332,
0.0397332907,
-0.0259965155,
0.0063604163,
0.0199027676,
0.0015883613,
-0.0234633833,
0.0413610153,
0.0401523039,
-0.0154937468,
-0.0069593317,
0.00499749,
0.0097954068,
-0.0013335105,
0.0149066029,
-0.0013632163,
0.0109292278,
-0.006831063,
-0.0013802118,
0.0370048136,
-0.0131516391,
-0.0020997152,
-0.034880612,
0.013455783,
0.0045760218,
0.0174900498,
-0.0509447195,
0.0084113879,
-0.0021252823,
0.0538268276,
-0.0177691355,
-0.0572176017,
0.0377033539,
-0.0182502978,
0.0511984192,
-0.0098920316,
0.0594879724,
-0.0071079405,
-0.0163847134,
-0.0255243126,
0.007843107,
-0.0681001693,
-0.128442511,
0.0250555426,
0.0423422493,
0.056278266,
0.0030130588,
0.0042153238,
-0.0341399014,
0.0203901418,
-0.0304699577,
-0.011709773,
0.0242372025,
-0.0188307669,
-0.0259039402,
0.0264550634,
-0.0500280149,
-0.006679575,
0.0613240525,
-0.0323241539,
0.034007214,
-0.0040211612,
-0.0068802461,
-0.0267484747,
-0.0376031063,
-0.0123125073,
0.0217561591,
-0.0184189584,
-0.0340188816,
-0.0512883179,
-0.0663126186,
-0.0012163839,
0.0048897518,
0.0237059742,
-0.0233896747,
-0.00121783,
0.0566454306,
-0.0205345862,
0.0180275477,
-0.003155112,
0.0180481877,
0.0196882132,
0.0099274535,
-0.0425179601,
-6.878929024e-33,
0.0387589447,
0.0026133414,
0.0332155935,
-0.0279619042,
0.0084056035,
-0.0154017778,
-0.0251771118,
0.0248589236,
-0.0383043699,
-0.0139509831,
-0.0230400451,
0.0400062799,
0.0123206722,
0.0193478726,
0.0285590682,
-0.0464617051,
0.0317545868,
-0.0100185461,
-0.0124599738,
0.0369621888,
0.0625103042,
0.0337067991,
0.0474417359,
-0.0662762374,
0.0364034213,
-0.0189443585,
0.0015644076,
0.0151676126,
-0.0115184337,
0.0236853678,
-0.0412992686,
0.0469923094,
0.0116021158,
-0.0196455363,
-0.0367390327,
0.0001158764,
-0.0119969612,
-0.0235942211,
-0.004816175,
0.0145922005,
0.0158337727,
-0.0272416212,
0.0727774426,
-0.0388151817,
0.0061278865,
-0.0074375439,
0.0204335321,
-0.0328808837,
-0.0633593276,
0.01456689,
-0.0177183505,
-0.0098689096,
0.0134292664,
0.0068220589,
-0.0197876282,
-0.0005504072,
-0.0196837131,
-0.0119084679,
-0.1136138067,
0.0330453739,
-0.0337107405,
0.0023231304,
0.0297131613,
-0.0040905443,
0.0190405659,
0.0972537324,
0.0903108567,
0.0549101196,
-0.0481310301,
-0.0257932618,
0.0337670259,
0.0497307181,
0.0407070294,
-0.0055050887,
0.0933358595,
-0.0369349085,
-0.0370230302,
-0.0367952287,
-0.0052305399,
0.0133227445,
0.0783360526,
-0.0039742882,
-0.0546515472,
-0.0551751927,
0.0028439106,
0.0351752229,
-0.0477394499,
-0.0353906751,
0.0198827125,
0.0210852772,
0.0155597692,
-0.0405648053,
0.0293396357,
-0.0557875037,
0.0271224156,
0.040854875,
-0.0144074196,
-0.0023687552,
-0.0121506229,
-0.0111936182,
-0.0362255685,
-0.0158410445,
-0.0195240397,
0.0129786432,
0.0208220016,
0.0437664427,
0.0435926057,
0.0113237053,
-0.0557710007,
-0.0194412619,
-0.0532589741,
0.0166813694,
0.0263190027,
0.0036451276,
0.0452560931,
0.0087331347,
-0.0115310708,
-0.015896203,
0.0150730778,
0.0128100608,
-0.0108525362,
0.0267448556,
-0.0201224927,
0.0078684781,
-0.0135755669,
-0.0217626188,
-0.0612862557,
-0.0078934692,
0.0317859203,
-0.0712701529,
0.0044173542,
-0.0136973634,
2.872e-7,
-0.031346947,
0.0406859629,
-0.0063335267,
0.0152073475,
0.0293070618,
0.0159911104,
-0.0164426286,
0.0122725628,
0.022945486,
-0.0805295035,
-0.0147137232,
0.0518012457,
0.0564617701,
0.0622196086,
-0.1100768074,
-0.025837725,
-0.0660861805,
-0.0010490202,
-0.0495676845,
-0.0431121811,
0.0196739417,
0.0778786987,
0.0404218361,
-0.0248570405,
0.0229567327,
-0.0957703367,
0.0982067958,
-0.0138162728,
0.0156286452,
0.0180199984,
0.0625414476,
0.0427555442,
-0.0203947835,
0.0257668663,
-0.0033516297,
-0.0218093935,
-0.0267420281,
0.0306424107,
0.0081166923,
-0.0639264882,
-0.0185489487,
-0.0134553779,
0.0017478698,
-0.0288604815,
0.05107297,
-0.045621112,
-0.0422733203,
0.0090607256,
0.0047845314,
-0.0211422481,
0.0473972596,
0.0065145572,
-0.0068052593,
0.0119855693,
-0.0183024257,
0.0375009701,
0.035218928,
-0.0822376683,
-0.0245981161,
0.0202004015,
-0.0556203648,
-0.0529842675,
-0.0245088991,
0.0010124976,
0.0132074477,
-0.0494430177,
0.0346402153,
2.685309627e-34,
0.0400599018,
-0.0167173482,
0.0394766405,
0.0539950579,
0.0257029254,
-0.0066775135,
0.0557594746,
0.0187180918,
0.0277404785,
-0.0414204933,
-0.0117425956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17639v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17639v2 | Mitigate the Gap: Investigating Approaches for Improving Cross-Modal Alignment in CLIP | 2024-06-25T15:24:02 | 2024-06-26T10:58:48 | Sedigheh Eslami, Gerard de Melo | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Contrastive Language--Image Pre-training (CLIP) has manifested remarkable
improvements in zero-shot classification and cross-modal vision-language tasks.
Yet, from a geometrical point of view, the CLIP embedding space has been found
to have a pronounced modality gap. This gap renders the embedding space overly
sparse and disconnected, with different modalities being densely distributed in
distinct subregions of the hypersphere. In this work, we aim at answering two
main questions: 1. Does sharing the parameter space between the multi-modal
encoders reduce the modality gap? 2. Can the gap be mitigated by pushing apart
the uni-modal embeddings via intra-modality separation? We design AlignCLIP, in
order to answer these questions and show that answers to both questions are
positive. Through extensive experiments, we show that AlignCLIP achieves
noticeable enhancements in the cross-modal alignment of the embeddings, and
thereby, reduces the modality gap, while maintaining the performance across
several downstream evaluations, such as zero-shot image classification,
zero-shot multi-modal retrieval and zero-shot semantic text similarity. | Mitigate the Gap: Investigating Approaches for Improving Cross-Modal Alignment in CLIP: Contrastive Language--Image Pre-training (CLIP) has manifested remarkable
improvements in zero-shot classification and cross-modal vision-language tasks.
Yet, from a geometrical point of view, the CLIP embedding space has been found
to have a pronounced modality gap. This gap renders the embedding space overly
sparse and disconnected, with different modalities being densely distributed in
distinct subregions of the hypersphere. In this work, we aim at answering two
main questions: 1. Does sharing the parameter space between the multi-modal
encoders reduce the modality gap? 2. Can the gap be mitigated by pushing apart
the uni-modal embeddings via intra-modality separation? We design AlignCLIP, in
order to answer these questions and show that answers to both questions are
positive. Through extensive experiments, we show that AlignCLIP achieves
noticeable enhancements in the cross-modal alignment of the embeddings, and
thereby, reduces the modality gap, while maintaining the performance across
several downstream evaluations, such as zero-shot image classification,
zero-shot multi-modal retrieval and zero-shot semantic text similarity. | [
-0.0385551266,
0.0596274659,
0.0174322352,
0.0479889587,
-0.040716894,
-0.01166711,
0.0372344814,
-0.0024257374,
-0.0847809985,
-0.0456418172,
-0.0974812359,
-0.0301979017,
0.0268390309,
0.0430643298,
0.0218666736,
-0.0384461023,
0.0313609466,
0.0069858688,
-0.0323454179,
-0.0017686086,
0.0290400609,
-0.0052950014,
-0.0257307477,
0.019968491,
0.0036294907,
-0.0019730909,
-0.029474292,
-0.0015691731,
0.0352342203,
-0.012128341,
-0.0164365452,
0.0390502065,
0.0491584577,
0.0193275642,
0.0000017254,
0.0013124341,
0.0312345866,
0.0222930722,
0.0078272307,
-0.007323259,
0.0506880283,
-0.070423305,
0.0219613872,
-0.0158485658,
-0.0071820845,
-0.0727281347,
0.0836183131,
0.042020075,
0.0283044185,
0.0684457719,
-0.0474121198,
-0.0069144405,
0.0114890551,
-0.0317668654,
0.0133610126,
0.014140157,
-0.0063610449,
-0.0131583977,
-0.0112451455,
0.0295590125,
-0.0584094264,
0.0416524038,
0.007756527,
0.0232001189,
-0.0259166267,
0.0500517525,
-0.0241084322,
-0.0267689694,
-0.0290658828,
0.0949219093,
-0.0106873941,
-0.0114302058,
-0.0418375023,
0.0007325916,
-0.0008618569,
0.0300708041,
-0.0265162904,
0.0320459008,
0.0244021583,
0.0446959026,
-0.0343453512,
0.0306258928,
0.0163354184,
-0.0359617099,
0.0056366669,
-0.0304381568,
0.0406714119,
-0.0007257715,
-0.0274103377,
0.0194088817,
-0.0019978629,
-0.0250917822,
-0.0079758819,
0.0008486839,
0.0000735911,
-0.0245760288,
-0.0759448931,
-0.0078827906,
-0.0059187743,
0.0268387832,
0.0522572361,
0.052849628,
-0.0591201968,
0.0538148656,
-0.0289977808,
0.0237785317,
-0.0240088757,
0.0776508674,
-0.0357540362,
-0.0180679634,
-0.0118763382,
-0.0069658705,
0.0074811741,
-0.0131243942,
-0.0502358824,
-0.0504870601,
-0.0082780095,
0.0008043865,
-0.0221452471,
0.0082875816,
-0.0088310875,
0.0179732945,
-0.0401922837,
-0.0284525063,
0.0100283427,
0.0730513036,
0.0012608739,
0.0551451109,
-0.0351434238,
-0.0372608602,
-0.0203444976,
0.0526568815,
0.020349618,
-0.0257803202,
-0.0142847998,
0.0728635639,
-0.0495614558,
-0.0442570969,
0.0022620447,
0.0090734465,
-0.0357888415,
-0.0346338376,
0.0362764075,
-0.0294065457,
0.0469269976,
0.0117988437,
-0.0309870038,
-0.0091933021,
-0.0106329303,
-0.0166995712,
-0.0081102997,
0.1020955071,
0.0064513502,
-0.0211410951,
-0.0070400331,
0.0012797209,
-0.0069025038,
0.059057273,
0.0035462086,
-0.0096334415,
0.0123512736,
0.0293249283,
-0.0115101179,
0.0330004841,
0.0211375989,
0.0202157237,
-0.0728412271,
-0.0245802272,
0.0125097129,
0.0204258915,
0.0602327809,
0.0049933158,
-0.0549679026,
-0.0399544798,
0.0316788778,
0.0326724499,
0.0173130874,
-0.0046902313,
0.0219339188,
0.0175266825,
-0.0337174982,
-0.0027797152,
-0.0384936184,
0.0174345486,
-0.0151312258,
0.0160891004,
0.0196626671,
0.0434931926,
-0.0560308471,
-0.0057721492,
0.0201951899,
-0.0269327387,
0.0030975547,
-0.015914306,
0.0701473802,
-0.030731149,
-0.0292179659,
0.0559089184,
0.0428476892,
-0.0490898229,
0.0182474274,
0.0062592477,
-0.0244459305,
-0.0185294375,
-0.0161262099,
-0.0125969537,
-0.0509348959,
0.0226364993,
-0.0040295138,
0.0463774092,
-0.0073227943,
-0.0104336226,
0.0514021926,
-0.0491175056,
-0.0851776525,
-0.0558604896,
-0.0056714853,
0.0283110552,
-0.0253865942,
0.0323616602,
0.0193104427,
-0.0172058009,
0.0750669092,
0.0211886596,
0.0214527845,
0.022209486,
-0.042844791,
0.0468594804,
0.0251131747,
-0.0140446313,
-0.043603465,
-0.009048623,
0.010255238,
-0.058346618,
0.0207595266,
0.0376248732,
-0.0592223331,
-0.067961812,
0.0487529896,
-0.0928893909,
0.0204165597,
0.0251019634,
-0.0211431514,
-0.0437157638,
0.0173821915,
0.0180427786,
0.0578181297,
-0.0407846086,
0.0014284025,
-0.0215418022,
0.0051032789,
0.0001615301,
0.0247909371,
-0.0009529009,
0.00409543,
0.0582801029,
0.0420164466,
0.0536888875,
0.0304152351,
-0.037239369,
0.0139024965,
-0.0084945215,
0.0217859,
0.0199216865,
0.0007993897,
-0.0256661419,
-0.0081371451,
-0.1193065941,
-0.0080174049,
-0.0148731833,
0.0263969004,
0.0354379751,
-0.004609481,
-0.0142148025,
-0.0518507063,
-0.039051868,
0.0149865849,
0.0131800901,
0.0118245929,
0.0169000346,
0.0326341651,
0.0074252877,
0.0033035625,
0.0001011155,
0.0221269727,
0.0517623238,
-0.0245807506,
-0.0016546389,
-0.0221003201,
0.0615608506,
-0.0246052444,
0.0209080968,
-0.027069157,
-0.0287440401,
-0.0003372665,
-0.0079600615,
0.0474515334,
0.0250381343,
-0.0291349422,
0.005656661,
0.0448757075,
-0.0112827895,
-0.0442839302,
-0.0214473847,
0.0051852507,
-0.0036950654,
-0.0232610572,
0.040503215,
-0.0327294841,
0.0441114828,
-0.0272429101,
0.0233328808,
-0.0650217086,
0.0082023218,
0.0113350144,
-0.0186860152,
-0.0440514535,
0.0213731714,
-0.0132436138,
0.0232977867,
-0.0454928949,
-0.0442666374,
0.0339690261,
-0.041044604,
-0.0206199437,
-0.0134049989,
0.0014202218,
-0.0078383321,
0.0399076901,
-0.0175280776,
0.0289367251,
0.0126097295,
-0.0454452261,
-0.0679962561,
0.0004919155,
0.0098423595,
0.0109295724,
0.0479493067,
0.0122736171,
0.004682967,
-0.063791953,
-0.0532379411,
-0.0136397444,
-0.0689248443,
-0.0136089586,
0.0086246906,
-0.030324379,
-0.0047433064,
-0.0459596254,
0.0127592906,
0.0131558254,
0.0306392275,
-0.0393132493,
0.0139670325,
-0.0181556679,
0.082877636,
0.0118026342,
0.0117809093,
-0.0350550972,
-0.0265528914,
-0.0437973328,
0.0370589904,
0.0225244612,
0.0295129344,
-0.0249308385,
0.0222718567,
0.0513255298,
0.0511684008,
-0.0250913911,
0.020801058,
0.0780705288,
-0.0008559256,
0.0024786536,
0.0622095689,
-0.0089674862,
-0.0859280974,
-0.0517675541,
0.0052966285,
0.0490082167,
0.0148045607,
-0.0032947939,
-0.0584728532,
-0.0629200265,
-0.0175173283,
-0.0392427444,
0.0473558083,
0.0431267545,
-0.0220088325,
-0.0889828354,
0.0085395146,
0.0117562562,
-0.0431505106,
-0.0544931479,
-0.0192243867,
0.0288482644,
0.001288739,
0.0104733519,
-0.0407094173,
-0.0213281605,
-0.0194426682,
0.0071254103,
0.0743589401,
-0.0901874527,
-0.0319769047,
-0.0335274264,
0.0169722084,
-0.0072969054,
0.0233054329,
-0.0204657577,
-0.0822349563,
0.0046938118,
-0.0191198513,
0.0021391816,
0.0183577612,
0.0551617518,
-0.0355530009,
-0.0238939822,
0.0010454095,
0.0251303911,
-0.0252778698,
-0.018076973,
-0.0527519695,
0.0484943874,
0.0000927934,
0.0411734916,
-0.0182747655,
0.0191109926,
0.0060213222,
0.0380194858,
0.0001809757,
-0.0032545084,
-0.0049557383,
0.0156904366,
0.0194636863,
-0.0166371502,
-0.0186323319,
0.0067690481,
0.0061337641,
0.0132288327,
-0.0135298027,
-0.0228270497,
-0.0046009542,
0.0581945442,
-0.0084138326,
-0.0571496971,
-0.04480391,
0.0085004559,
-0.0541474409,
0.0583553128,
-0.039125815,
0.0062084561,
-0.0169656165,
0.0304273274,
0.0325197726,
-0.0191924274,
-0.0280560236,
-0.0253190231,
-0.0730733126,
-0.0642375723,
-0.0563618056,
0.0208327491,
0.0026956236,
0.081773296,
0.0297749098,
0.0080920896,
0.1050246656,
0.0215157997,
0.0019388287,
0.0158339422,
0.0423012078,
-0.0620292164,
0.0026105475,
0.0194229539,
-0.0368654057,
-0.0059942049,
0.0305879116,
0.0030766509,
0.0282508228,
-0.0419930704,
0.0156906433,
-0.0443435796,
0.0723844841,
-0.0238592904,
0.0582260452,
-0.0477235951,
-0.0137036666,
-0.0300151184,
-0.0000162471,
-0.0325527303,
-0.0138027063,
0.0038915293,
-0.0195966996,
0.0222706497,
0.0791600719,
-0.0022304,
0.0300996453,
-0.0339520276,
0.0311019029,
0.0346437842,
-0.0190042034,
-0.0210639387,
0.0442092009,
0.0018870056,
0.0079767136,
0.0007066087,
0.0188424215,
-0.0554482266,
0.0814388916,
0.0337239243,
-0.0120972786,
-0.0577831157,
0.0759395063,
-0.0158049315,
0.0299266595,
-0.0152445938,
0.0054162527,
0.0488435738,
-0.0293325167,
0.0181934368,
0.0079637477,
-0.0323745087,
0.00214079,
0.042896226,
-0.0241623726,
-0.0050471597,
0.0578787476,
0.0009349035,
-0.0096720094,
0.0163510554,
0.0631263182,
-0.0388230346,
0.005499843,
0.0011775128,
0.0156902168,
-0.0180570539,
-0.0005009493,
0.0854855776,
0.0233423673,
-0.027691897,
-0.0136380261,
-0.0120773995,
-0.0479865521,
0.0122420285,
0.0185360685,
-0.0521467663,
0.0384397581,
0.0328463539,
0.03670872,
0.0018959283,
-0.0137434248,
0.0110870171,
-0.0251569916,
0.0176851414,
0.023903504,
-0.0085762655,
-5.573221857e-33,
-0.0256085638,
0.0368373431,
0.0115708066,
-0.0387414284,
-0.0423778445,
0.0537800118,
-0.0181444231,
0.0154226953,
-0.0113003589,
0.0184387937,
0.0332004391,
-0.0062822015,
0.0160430875,
0.0390450731,
-0.0008171732,
0.0064430437,
0.0413918234,
-0.0102685653,
-0.0290128719,
-0.010879932,
0.0245962758,
0.005573954,
0.0539902337,
-0.0428803042,
0.0018428252,
0.0149367889,
0.0036762683,
0.0130965766,
0.0671936497,
0.0649371073,
-0.0245161448,
0.0259664878,
0.0112867728,
-0.010108823,
-0.0176005997,
0.033913631,
-0.0356823169,
-0.0283250902,
0.0017419882,
0.0276473183,
-0.0602493323,
-0.0200153645,
0.0257274322,
-0.0333458669,
-0.0159992334,
-0.0589568578,
0.0464580096,
0.0110184448,
0.002354525,
0.0205121599,
-0.0528300256,
0.0128830932,
-0.0126599651,
-0.0499222204,
0.0616904013,
0.0610179342,
0.0610297993,
0.0186339207,
-0.0497220308,
0.0347156376,
-0.03404947,
0.0198141281,
0.0733154863,
0.0579641536,
0.0177070145,
0.0739013702,
0.0074229292,
-0.0693867728,
0.0065039191,
-0.0305771846,
0.0485739075,
-0.0042903377,
-0.0186992958,
0.1028881893,
0.0623428188,
0.016159106,
-0.03111808,
0.0262424592,
-0.050021138,
0.0105764316,
0.0005444636,
0.045857206,
0.0080700805,
-0.0095743416,
-0.0293612927,
-0.0703542531,
-0.0357648917,
-0.0496190637,
0.0173471719,
0.0216391087,
0.0013194935,
0.0376476645,
0.0980772525,
-0.0192112178,
0.0060804291,
0.0366580337,
-0.0278525464,
0.0500884503,
-0.014229496,
0.0066288887,
-0.0444367304,
-0.0343645439,
0.0574803539,
-0.0099755879,
-0.0011121548,
-0.0056890338,
0.0495224446,
0.0309867654,
-0.0445392579,
-0.0221862867,
-0.0197772887,
-0.0572133549,
0.0074664704,
0.0623515248,
0.0595589727,
0.0296105687,
-0.0242033508,
0.0445410721,
0.0168413762,
0.018812079,
-0.0181368291,
-0.0565546788,
0.0065363962,
0.0142197041,
0.0084845303,
0.0232500415,
-0.0742770135,
-0.0303730667,
0.0178647432,
-0.053245645,
-0.028006969,
0.0083239488,
2.459e-7,
0.0130660255,
-0.008477076,
0.0316102915,
-0.0511874296,
0.014791688,
0.0444585755,
-0.0191127229,
0.0388957448,
-0.0145226391,
-0.0447655767,
0.0132945245,
0.0263134614,
0.0243445393,
0.0110545075,
-0.00700119,
0.0379628055,
-0.0456370078,
-0.0182140023,
-0.0179987289,
0.0313441046,
0.0799404457,
0.120052807,
-0.0261917505,
-0.0001989045,
0.0165534988,
-0.0268511642,
0.0870765224,
-0.0261701196,
-0.0175312925,
-0.0034413682,
-0.0580840558,
0.0162428655,
-0.0175801143,
0.0062654344,
0.005820828,
0.0294847284,
0.0311988723,
0.0279564336,
-0.0228269212,
-0.0281509943,
-0.0306715705,
0.0514018349,
-0.0450681709,
-0.0187798236,
0.0672516972,
-0.0864263102,
-0.0422942936,
-0.0839109793,
-0.046379067,
0.0356538929,
0.0255331676,
-0.0083712162,
-0.0319680348,
0.0169736929,
0.0314646251,
-0.0157443155,
-0.0449555628,
-0.0625921115,
-0.0232636463,
0.0357444733,
-0.0345050991,
0.0147421891,
-0.0229547787,
-0.0629999116,
0.0754748657,
-0.0446875058,
-0.0189995505,
1.802983796e-34,
-0.0259150676,
-0.019212326,
0.0230517089,
-0.0387871265,
-0.0115303099,
-0.0286990367,
-0.0113611454,
-0.0314237177,
-0.0090776132,
-0.0300694108,
-0.0067888102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17633v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17633v1 | Knowledge Distillation in Automated Annotation: Supervised Text Classification with LLM-Generated Training Labels | 2024-06-25T15:20:25 | 2024-06-25T15:20:25 | Nicholas Pangakis, Samuel Wolken | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Computational social science (CSS) practitioners often rely on human-labeled
data to fine-tune supervised text classifiers. We assess the potential for
researchers to augment or replace human-generated training data with surrogate
training labels from generative large language models (LLMs). We introduce a
recommended workflow and test this LLM application by replicating 14
classification tasks and measuring performance. We employ a novel corpus of
English-language text classification data sets from recent CSS articles in
high-impact journals. Because these data sets are stored in password-protected
archives, our analyses are less prone to issues of contamination. For each
task, we compare supervised classifiers fine-tuned using GPT-4 labels against
classifiers fine-tuned with human annotations and against labels from GPT-4 and
Mistral-7B with few-shot in-context learning. Our findings indicate that
supervised classification models fine-tuned on LLM-generated labels perform
comparably to models fine-tuned with labels from human annotators. Fine-tuning
models using LLM-generated labels can be a fast, efficient and cost-effective
method of building supervised text classifiers. | Knowledge Distillation in Automated Annotation: Supervised Text Classification with LLM-Generated Training Labels: Computational social science (CSS) practitioners often rely on human-labeled
data to fine-tune supervised text classifiers. We assess the potential for
researchers to augment or replace human-generated training data with surrogate
training labels from generative large language models (LLMs). We introduce a
recommended workflow and test this LLM application by replicating 14
classification tasks and measuring performance. We employ a novel corpus of
English-language text classification data sets from recent CSS articles in
high-impact journals. Because these data sets are stored in password-protected
archives, our analyses are less prone to issues of contamination. For each
task, we compare supervised classifiers fine-tuned using GPT-4 labels against
classifiers fine-tuned with human annotations and against labels from GPT-4 and
Mistral-7B with few-shot in-context learning. Our findings indicate that
supervised classification models fine-tuned on LLM-generated labels perform
comparably to models fine-tuned with labels from human annotators. Fine-tuning
models using LLM-generated labels can be a fast, efficient and cost-effective
method of building supervised text classifiers. | [
0.0465122163,
0.0571201332,
0.0077259089,
0.000175944,
-0.028061593,
0.0340343527,
0.0706859306,
-0.0116423415,
0.0471397899,
-0.1074874476,
-0.0166809522,
0.0051544346,
-0.0466479808,
-0.0170024242,
0.031637378,
-0.0112535274,
0.0275900308,
-0.0109264357,
0.0079099797,
-0.009094758,
-0.0248459727,
0.0083295638,
0.0451833494,
0.0209162775,
0.0148313688,
-0.0376415215,
0.0031630183,
-0.0110277096,
0.0189660564,
-0.0330047272,
0.0418825857,
0.0886411816,
0.0367598645,
0.0562503263,
0.0000020025,
-0.0481911749,
-0.0214555003,
0.0436819308,
-0.0309915133,
0.0448551029,
0.0470426157,
-0.0342157818,
0.0119302301,
0.0063522318,
-0.0545496754,
-0.0345804468,
0.028772369,
0.0312328432,
0.0489580929,
0.0696472749,
0.0079361461,
-0.0631700382,
0.0454625897,
-0.0489745997,
0.0282765403,
-0.0665379912,
0.0667912886,
0.0130281243,
-0.0281841867,
0.07390102,
0.004346699,
0.0172850452,
0.0035835828,
-0.0138927251,
0.0378796682,
0.0299833976,
-0.0527727827,
-0.0005836997,
0.0112083675,
0.0248775724,
0.0317540877,
-0.0391694047,
0.0393267013,
-0.0056765713,
0.006344202,
0.0376281515,
-0.0143907145,
0.0430698618,
-0.027160719,
0.0113138035,
0.0398393571,
-0.0223867521,
0.038951166,
0.0320612267,
0.0291704405,
0.045599144,
-0.0164393168,
-0.0280167721,
0.0410777815,
-0.0023766349,
-0.0394845642,
-0.0576022863,
-0.0020085596,
-0.0137917502,
0.031328097,
0.0094476892,
-0.0326545089,
-0.0267717615,
0.034595944,
-0.0380373038,
0.0035501067,
-0.0053852783,
-0.00644481,
0.0362989344,
0.0082563134,
-0.007250783,
0.009051322,
0.0172594097,
0.0193361081,
-0.0008767621,
-0.093989253,
-0.023042839,
-0.0170834977,
0.0337460302,
-0.027211966,
0.0097616278,
-0.0631773472,
0.018931631,
-0.0115888249,
0.0106053585,
0.0233849455,
-0.0161815453,
-0.01789877,
0.0146062756,
-0.009966189,
-0.0349549577,
-0.003433889,
0.0277938005,
-0.009923324,
-0.0359133109,
0.0148664918,
0.015030453,
0.0039725653,
-0.0329899564,
0.016740784,
0.0252552498,
0.0058765616,
-0.0466761626,
-0.0585462376,
-0.010795177,
-0.0390789732,
-0.0445786938,
0.0093759177,
-0.059419658,
-0.0061535649,
0.006682232,
0.0055485838,
-0.0818926543,
0.0014383348,
0.0128174275,
-0.0240499303,
0.0676328987,
-0.0204614978,
-0.0200954806,
0.059344586,
0.0199837368,
-0.0004074882,
0.0500468835,
0.0191533584,
0.0508405827,
0.039153669,
-0.0339620039,
0.0542678796,
0.0234842245,
0.0003528683,
0.0132002467,
-0.0084403818,
-0.0031146198,
0.0118597541,
-0.027113419,
0.0176637769,
0.032728646,
-0.0169011038,
0.0105586536,
0.0812616646,
0.0638249442,
-0.0044248085,
0.033922717,
0.0248701852,
0.0359456949,
0.0062651439,
-0.026009243,
-0.0285398383,
-0.0152014839,
-0.0328092501,
-0.0221075509,
0.0214042868,
-0.0005767003,
-0.0045477976,
-0.0231011789,
-0.0148519995,
0.0025890248,
0.0052129561,
0.0156472698,
0.0734201372,
0.0071842405,
-0.0039782766,
0.0061882059,
0.0419809297,
-0.009694132,
-0.0056055272,
-0.0471742488,
0.0211453643,
0.044048842,
0.0151866022,
-0.0208366681,
0.0389954187,
-0.0508827157,
0.0482964665,
0.0123106744,
0.0242749359,
-0.0242706295,
-0.0216159988,
-0.0256124083,
-0.0352979042,
-0.0273739509,
0.0422968641,
0.0131578501,
0.0330662243,
-0.004352977,
0.0344836973,
-0.0535943843,
-0.0653041378,
0.068968527,
-0.0196877941,
-0.0572150722,
0.0126866177,
-0.0059413384,
0.052597411,
0.0219954886,
-0.0221048538,
-0.0155576877,
0.0273840483,
-0.0099534513,
-0.0050845924,
-0.0504737012,
0.0354535468,
-0.0137978662,
-0.0044792253,
-0.0085837692,
-0.0068073254,
0.0026119486,
-0.0524448641,
-0.0118935108,
-0.0292208437,
0.0056594135,
0.0211575702,
-0.0867067277,
0.0054840068,
-0.0399364233,
0.0040991143,
-0.0622528642,
0.0726017058,
0.0182952844,
0.0090693738,
-0.0522071719,
-0.0442060195,
0.0049097883,
0.0065092454,
-0.0185802858,
-0.0239256304,
0.0058328183,
0.0153254662,
0.0290654153,
-0.0042730356,
-0.0298485644,
-0.0312928148,
-0.0799603015,
0.0239350609,
-0.0201500319,
0.0171419103,
-0.0116362106,
-0.0289258044,
-0.0114279669,
0.0292900726,
-0.0212575831,
-0.0420408733,
-0.0415460356,
0.0267364122,
0.0119237062,
-0.0150380936,
0.0154271517,
-0.0074543203,
0.0079723727,
-0.0038919484,
0.0450146198,
0.0151316049,
-0.0091555119,
-0.034838818,
0.0177220274,
0.0100437161,
0.0088398121,
-0.0153065594,
-0.0188060757,
-0.0038934911,
0.0308709443,
-0.0202815477,
0.0512626581,
0.0105617745,
0.0483615659,
0.0307530575,
0.037698552,
-0.0326893702,
-0.0021741679,
-0.0255237054,
-0.0363709703,
-0.0330053046,
-0.0149715049,
0.0009117819,
0.0391837545,
0.0058688191,
-0.0295788348,
-0.0267714281,
0.0342976339,
-0.0066628531,
-0.0363633521,
-0.0386585407,
-0.0128638837,
-0.0176960304,
0.0334963538,
-0.0077158203,
-0.0461153127,
0.0250236113,
-0.009822268,
0.0355741419,
-0.0325242095,
-0.0445953831,
-0.0180740394,
0.0598524734,
0.0125651127,
0.0022036517,
0.0276070163,
0.0088595282,
-0.0165873282,
0.0067509264,
0.0367418826,
-0.025282206,
0.0026881169,
-0.0319982395,
0.0162834097,
-0.0189359728,
-0.048734732,
-0.0338391885,
-0.083440043,
-0.0384255797,
0.0352707505,
0.0447607897,
-0.0118642133,
-0.0083756503,
0.018560892,
0.0132753989,
0.0523034148,
-0.0115944659,
-0.0298403632,
-0.012641116,
0.0134533616,
0.0231525768,
-0.0506061763,
-0.0315555297,
-0.011132584,
-0.0029056617,
0.0321871415,
0.0030874165,
0.0247014835,
-0.0147936018,
0.0025032342,
0.0292866472,
-0.0590331517,
-0.0333109573,
0.0090185627,
0.0398993269,
-0.0573739596,
-0.0034245604,
0.1094403118,
0.0292256232,
-0.0557742566,
-0.0126972357,
0.0301299468,
0.0114154592,
0.0249705017,
0.0076396344,
-0.102135241,
-0.0189325847,
0.0111726578,
0.0445082858,
-0.0377389342,
-0.0517733023,
-0.015032107,
-0.1083165407,
0.0570128523,
-0.0107210493,
-0.0492438003,
0.0296292584,
-0.0718442053,
-0.0061179716,
-0.0304905977,
-0.0321220197,
-0.0118064173,
-0.0093150148,
0.0274214428,
0.0503100902,
-0.0354731232,
-0.0774137825,
0.0267490186,
-0.0199725237,
0.0578104667,
0.0363713056,
0.0413370989,
-0.0232815258,
-0.0288699586,
0.0613985173,
-0.0187508482,
0.0009845822,
0.0062159034,
0.0635435879,
-0.0285684951,
0.0078133876,
0.014653692,
0.0806675255,
-0.0122331819,
-0.0347559676,
0.0401863717,
0.0530175492,
-0.0115613444,
-0.0127140945,
0.009514289,
-0.0361111425,
0.0060831597,
0.0754059181,
0.0121306647,
-0.0592175089,
-0.0094015626,
-0.0187321156,
0.0407448672,
-0.021157993,
-0.0245192498,
0.0453901254,
-0.0594643764,
-0.0642217025,
-0.0385400355,
-0.0289694667,
0.030523004,
0.0252715386,
0.0290347636,
0.0403009914,
0.013231812,
0.0020462777,
-0.0451012999,
0.0172453709,
-0.0724897757,
-0.0217944086,
-0.0117871258,
-0.0325416923,
0.0489110462,
-0.0265064407,
-0.0432582945,
0.0090678213,
-0.0707792938,
-0.0655828416,
0.0211400278,
0.001373945,
0.0223363396,
0.0275199413,
-0.0044040862,
-0.0820372477,
0.0788381249,
0.1034948379,
-0.0087443488,
-0.0125958929,
-0.0041743559,
-0.0042928271,
-0.0206620079,
-0.0008037836,
-0.0425185226,
0.033864297,
0.038351126,
-0.025664553,
-0.0570451096,
0.0039663208,
-0.0037654843,
0.0135031184,
0.0835413784,
-0.0651226491,
-0.0124014663,
-0.0224181581,
-0.0067150323,
0.0017540725,
-0.0194899049,
-0.0101954564,
-0.0094456198,
0.033382684,
-0.0075030741,
-0.0408499353,
0.0540857352,
0.0059164721,
0.0651044026,
-0.068368338,
-0.0066630766,
0.0243481398,
0.0329612866,
0.0057201996,
0.0003430673,
-0.014830417,
0.0141904633,
0.0138718355,
0.0440548323,
-0.0050568916,
0.0276842695,
0.0093551567,
0.0326279737,
0.009928056,
-0.0032143786,
-0.0736090094,
-0.023099333,
-0.0472258031,
0.0590159483,
0.0522629656,
-0.0088233585,
0.0148659898,
-0.0359358341,
-0.0456302539,
-0.0264704656,
0.0213806089,
0.0127611076,
-0.0186941326,
0.0023928082,
0.0049393298,
-0.0753917322,
0.0227785371,
0.0732867941,
0.0720528662,
0.0390678011,
0.0187251437,
-0.0689429864,
-0.0337129794,
-0.0136706121,
0.0007141979,
0.0301619247,
0.0173443425,
-0.0119483918,
-0.0556100421,
-0.0468319021,
-0.000919894,
-0.0277505331,
-0.0066806534,
-0.0104956822,
0.0134516573,
0.0613367744,
-0.0315298848,
-0.0266477205,
-0.0804135352,
-0.0053580543,
0.0111138541,
-0.0285441149,
-0.0076958714,
-6.880133905e-33,
0.02086775,
-0.0447402187,
-0.0002580621,
0.0212800317,
-0.0039385576,
-0.0044964957,
0.0144062992,
-0.0329219401,
0.0069599207,
0.0378020629,
-0.0200987589,
-0.0082827592,
0.0048432811,
0.0490807667,
0.0342044383,
0.0050112098,
0.0359438583,
-0.011438028,
-0.0168784261,
0.0380073972,
0.0454746075,
0.0069563747,
0.0441167913,
-0.1046309322,
0.0675067678,
0.0005055683,
-0.0185995195,
-0.0067273318,
0.0186182093,
0.0275019333,
-0.0262798276,
0.0511711761,
0.0328505188,
-0.0576267801,
0.0431025438,
0.0323343426,
-0.0777548328,
-0.0086611751,
0.0139465416,
-0.0278621018,
0.0296200253,
-0.0611190498,
0.0403753445,
-0.010919475,
-0.0163125023,
0.0222935099,
0.05567744,
-0.0140306214,
-0.053601779,
-0.1230171844,
-0.0357833691,
0.0286772531,
-0.021939259,
0.0148897255,
0.0235092472,
0.0069944058,
0.0009836031,
0.0646994784,
-0.0672383383,
0.0024035648,
0.02818349,
-0.0129896831,
0.0175570808,
0.0372568034,
0.0194902308,
0.0539234653,
0.0150311068,
0.0253044143,
-0.0103644421,
-0.0127662746,
0.0225728452,
0.0058632051,
0.0016743864,
0.0943515226,
0.0481503941,
-0.0584196784,
-0.0820355341,
0.0177206788,
0.0012869649,
-0.0426096097,
0.0565675385,
0.0046209092,
-0.0314375088,
-0.0427813195,
-0.0721071437,
-0.0330547765,
-0.0121737365,
0.0129842786,
-0.0025249389,
0.000208644,
-0.051733721,
0.0322811268,
0.0165157616,
-0.0265532024,
-0.0541842729,
0.0070822597,
-0.0068762191,
0.0132173188,
-0.0050267489,
-0.016488893,
-0.0689053908,
-0.0223009977,
0.0153618585,
0.0330438986,
0.037804354,
-0.0095147043,
0.0897523388,
-0.0051342156,
-0.0727668256,
0.0104124052,
-0.0109700691,
0.0498068966,
0.0169484019,
-0.0004328645,
0.0312203839,
0.009936302,
0.0271278378,
0.0146946134,
0.0756371468,
0.0189400222,
0.0248400103,
0.0036879962,
-0.006617988,
-0.012028316,
0.0160844624,
0.0045824265,
0.0470863879,
0.015996689,
0.0441454686,
-0.0313747972,
0.0144802472,
-0.0132637415,
2.839e-7,
0.0610301122,
0.0704688355,
-0.0365063138,
-0.0515829697,
0.0247435048,
0.0503662266,
0.0329140089,
0.0124999601,
0.0013376505,
-0.061699871,
0.0211705193,
0.005981178,
0.0743765309,
0.0231404901,
-0.0847544074,
-0.0155923124,
-0.0621509291,
0.0025278332,
-0.0645913258,
0.0103032198,
0.0347770005,
0.0678824484,
0.0459001623,
-0.0126910703,
-0.0195465311,
-0.0462584868,
0.0574705526,
-0.0257468801,
-0.0073176264,
0.0386499017,
0.0123901321,
0.0399971791,
-0.0027154849,
0.0416021831,
-0.0436285883,
-0.0001178838,
-0.0137977777,
0.0715053231,
0.0026421524,
0.0164278597,
-0.004300769,
-0.0089496719,
0.013254948,
-0.054495357,
0.0904177651,
-0.0729797781,
-0.0529326908,
-0.0305253733,
-0.0289854277,
-0.0532480441,
0.0360408388,
-0.0233121961,
0.0396176055,
0.0265647434,
-0.0233411063,
-0.0071117105,
-0.0174724292,
-0.0694988668,
-0.0035536611,
0.0240768883,
-0.0364629701,
-0.0513084345,
0.0243199673,
0.0089146756,
0.0114036957,
-0.0427058712,
0.0525861233,
2.618552568e-34,
0.0291768182,
-0.0072799795,
-0.0080590788,
0.002427167,
0.0341612101,
0.0391906127,
-0.0125968261,
0.0162350386,
0.0015188075,
-0.0635468066,
0.0305667836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17626v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17626v1 | CoSafe: Evaluating Large Language Model Safety in Multi-Turn Dialogue Coreference | 2024-06-25T15:13:02 | 2024-06-25T15:13:02 | Erxin Yu, Jing Li, Ming Liao, Siqi Wang, Zuchen Gao, Fei Mi, Lanqing Hong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As large language models (LLMs) constantly evolve, ensuring their safety
remains a critical research problem. Previous red-teaming approaches for LLM
safety have primarily focused on single prompt attacks or goal hijacking. To
the best of our knowledge, we are the first to study LLM safety in multi-turn
dialogue coreference. We created a dataset of 1,400 questions across 14
categories, each featuring multi-turn coreference safety attacks. We then
conducted detailed evaluations on five widely used open-source LLMs. The
results indicated that under multi-turn coreference safety attacks, the highest
attack success rate was 56% with the LLaMA2-Chat-7b model, while the lowest was
13.9% with the Mistral-7B-Instruct model. These findings highlight the safety
vulnerabilities in LLMs during dialogue coreference interactions. | CoSafe: Evaluating Large Language Model Safety in Multi-Turn Dialogue Coreference: As large language models (LLMs) constantly evolve, ensuring their safety
remains a critical research problem. Previous red-teaming approaches for LLM
safety have primarily focused on single prompt attacks or goal hijacking. To
the best of our knowledge, we are the first to study LLM safety in multi-turn
dialogue coreference. We created a dataset of 1,400 questions across 14
categories, each featuring multi-turn coreference safety attacks. We then
conducted detailed evaluations on five widely used open-source LLMs. The
results indicated that under multi-turn coreference safety attacks, the highest
attack success rate was 56% with the LLaMA2-Chat-7b model, while the lowest was
13.9% with the Mistral-7B-Instruct model. These findings highlight the safety
vulnerabilities in LLMs during dialogue coreference interactions. | [
0.0425913073,
0.0203616433,
0.0000658428,
0.0682321936,
-0.0604173392,
-0.0240807254,
0.0278404988,
-0.0208182037,
0.0473102406,
-0.0556697622,
-0.037393596,
-0.0043935729,
-0.0089428304,
0.0283086095,
0.0452695861,
0.0037747344,
0.0826611072,
-0.0772488192,
-0.0167935155,
0.0021311885,
0.0198444091,
-0.0175725278,
-0.0479325019,
0.0565008558,
-0.0060564512,
-0.0276388042,
-0.0427769087,
0.0224389341,
0.0161089562,
-0.0151159652,
-0.0089931488,
0.0415951423,
-0.0148037309,
0.0640776232,
0.0000020777,
-0.0768809617,
-0.0361884944,
0.0325749442,
-0.0549935438,
0.0188633706,
-0.0089934943,
0.0306453425,
-0.0286506638,
0.0469034277,
-0.0076724091,
0.0306208804,
0.0283772945,
0.0658689961,
0.1071688682,
0.0671061277,
-0.000545509,
0.0166334622,
0.035873577,
-0.0199530683,
-0.0517949648,
-0.0802627876,
0.0171649735,
-0.0053163739,
0.0072124237,
0.0486062914,
-0.0078540724,
-0.0053293626,
0.0174732786,
-0.037229348,
-0.0763223544,
0.0031660644,
-0.0836030096,
-0.0264532771,
-0.0154823065,
0.0703656673,
-0.0081238225,
0.0298666824,
0.0007348029,
0.020319514,
-0.0029055681,
0.0038275768,
-0.0145240361,
0.0096900035,
-0.0221232548,
-0.0447762907,
0.0035552713,
-0.0182352811,
0.0051629534,
-0.0051640011,
-0.0043173935,
0.0743569657,
0.0232753512,
0.0034674052,
0.0190351866,
-0.0479950607,
0.0021506958,
-0.0647435784,
-0.0129339229,
0.0003069236,
-0.063357383,
0.023565501,
-0.0455989949,
0.0333523229,
0.0654324815,
-0.0682930648,
0.0120032299,
0.0390785448,
-0.0219151825,
0.0192504656,
0.0242549051,
0.0310969595,
-0.0130245173,
0.0286903549,
0.0261739474,
-0.0072046705,
-0.0023727408,
0.0080404459,
-0.0096110087,
0.0294865835,
-0.0091386475,
0.0052813063,
-0.0381892323,
0.0586608611,
0.0084414827,
0.0668217167,
0.0084951418,
-0.0207193233,
-0.0071198377,
-0.0018901505,
0.0207420774,
-0.0001062259,
0.015614111,
-0.0015570384,
0.0032757334,
-0.1201345101,
-0.0193928294,
0.0292229783,
-0.0482582673,
-0.0386570692,
-0.0414880402,
0.1207010597,
0.0150955878,
-0.0210749302,
-0.0127168437,
-0.1132553443,
-0.0360564291,
-0.0170962699,
-0.0118295839,
-0.0605115108,
-0.0024060633,
-0.0030249485,
-0.0114255929,
-0.0358560495,
0.0379371457,
0.0190221034,
-0.0316825509,
0.042716518,
0.0048151221,
-0.0134747168,
0.0057613598,
0.0547861382,
-0.0425330587,
0.065981999,
0.0054472904,
0.0175758284,
0.0554991737,
-0.01019355,
0.0319720805,
0.0684650764,
-0.0113517009,
0.02698089,
0.0309697855,
0.0496021807,
0.0152353877,
-0.0262344442,
-0.0183837675,
0.0816227645,
-0.0050565032,
-0.0620995536,
0.101676546,
0.060649395,
-0.039721366,
-0.0032664824,
-0.012916049,
0.0001021337,
0.0078832563,
0.0104555804,
-0.0519065335,
0.004398372,
-0.0678570122,
-0.0439435318,
0.0251799244,
0.0198341999,
-0.0194405653,
0.0066357995,
-0.0128754303,
0.0064720092,
-0.017686639,
0.001070661,
-0.0031568529,
0.0021788138,
-0.0198543742,
0.0486197807,
0.0011516864,
-0.047789339,
-0.0534198508,
-0.0498288125,
-0.0435872115,
0.0260906182,
0.0654532239,
0.0058047776,
-0.0912823603,
-0.0559950471,
0.0103097884,
0.0269738343,
0.0395541377,
0.0189983882,
0.0251749959,
-0.0171801411,
-0.021730952,
0.0166144185,
-0.001906656,
0.0014434276,
0.0079088314,
0.0026939816,
-0.0087592285,
0.0332623497,
-0.0134519264,
0.0049713645,
-0.0014522927,
-0.0261010695,
-0.0066538528,
0.0198327769,
0.0390417278,
0.0066552558,
0.0042177001,
0.0094907098,
0.0457467251,
0.0318689458,
-0.0051598288,
0.0286036562,
-0.0430312864,
-0.0126209548,
0.0267589781,
-0.0064209546,
-0.0085415263,
0.0040900805,
-0.021240091,
-0.0046981084,
0.0354493447,
-0.051769387,
0.0240034927,
-0.0069663329,
0.0207812302,
0.0129483696,
0.0050030109,
-0.0209843554,
-0.0133890873,
-0.0292993374,
-0.0051141744,
-0.0113557912,
-0.0043680705,
0.0185001399,
-0.0476352684,
-0.0288103558,
0.0283421911,
-0.0335269235,
0.0236416832,
-0.0053064926,
0.0145154791,
-0.0498575494,
-0.0151243219,
-0.0572470613,
-0.0149638327,
-0.0161766782,
0.0419564806,
0.0177865848,
0.0301569253,
-0.0178368744,
-0.0066626635,
-0.0024709492,
-0.0088461377,
0.0117417984,
0.0337425955,
0.0084089153,
-0.0011119262,
-0.0742120072,
-0.0310946163,
0.0133341011,
-0.0169716477,
0.0481778122,
-0.0246970374,
-0.0083467839,
-0.0338698141,
0.0324283727,
-0.0094825486,
0.0301827788,
-0.0226505678,
-0.0399714969,
0.0317327194,
0.0149714677,
0.0172261372,
0.0337609798,
0.0233636722,
0.0340200253,
0.0283930376,
-0.0527367331,
-0.0638106838,
0.0009805236,
0.0369489789,
-0.0859868601,
-0.0360298902,
0.0070803985,
0.0226915125,
0.0507003181,
0.0150330551,
-0.0034943647,
0.0067388727,
-0.0241859797,
-0.0135005098,
-0.0306000877,
-0.0002494855,
-0.0505548976,
-0.0391330495,
0.0309582688,
0.0049834736,
-0.0474271439,
0.0452408902,
-0.0577011146,
0.0076394654,
-0.0327084661,
-0.0399142168,
-0.0100494195,
0.051144205,
-0.0539496914,
0.005185517,
0.0753074065,
-0.0599066988,
-0.0460051522,
-0.0474723168,
0.036079362,
-0.0386893339,
0.0508873984,
-0.0554201566,
-0.0034702376,
-0.0183475316,
-0.0181685518,
-0.077259995,
-0.0277892072,
-0.0398028418,
-0.0155236833,
-0.0056131827,
-0.0110196173,
-0.0161536671,
-0.004278596,
0.0258382503,
-0.018358564,
-0.0084632179,
-0.0028380719,
-0.0230705328,
0.0271067433,
0.030131828,
-0.0469541401,
-0.0016170074,
-0.0188174639,
0.0697158054,
0.1089668348,
0.032724537,
-0.0171087179,
-0.0092307348,
-0.0449327789,
0.0429041572,
-0.0328151882,
-0.0167510677,
0.0274434686,
0.0607725121,
-0.0444099344,
-0.0318725146,
0.0786883906,
0.0299675371,
-0.0254694056,
-0.0007136902,
-0.0574380681,
0.010528137,
0.0040660514,
0.0062447763,
-0.0559000708,
-0.020018829,
0.0305990707,
0.0340373628,
0.0051047737,
-0.0285504144,
-0.0136320461,
-0.1095084548,
0.023945339,
-0.0089614429,
-0.0436734855,
-0.0086646248,
-0.0163391009,
0.0166279711,
0.0239866674,
0.0787612274,
0.0062144287,
-0.0012064909,
-0.0166817289,
0.0126598524,
-0.0576187633,
-0.0071070623,
0.0313429236,
-0.0491914004,
0.0506070629,
0.0698753297,
-0.0007142385,
-0.0134145133,
0.0020067645,
0.0722547472,
0.0011447041,
-0.0155098001,
-0.0068191364,
0.0276699346,
0.0052637099,
-0.0077013373,
0.0155006796,
0.0257063042,
0.0163591485,
-0.0061454326,
0.062510483,
0.0163079146,
-0.052305501,
0.0271456279,
-0.021150643,
0.0333474837,
0.0416111015,
0.0562366135,
0.0342543833,
-0.0271813162,
0.0192627292,
-0.0555758253,
0.0072811572,
-0.0179565027,
-0.0584236979,
-0.0082600173,
0.0394764878,
-0.0153671559,
-0.0596318208,
-0.009442905,
-0.004150535,
0.017395556,
0.0134514505,
-0.0056628063,
0.0024730163,
0.040409822,
0.0102417273,
-0.0288816504,
-0.0707923397,
0.0532021709,
-0.0902446657,
0.0804683864,
0.0341530442,
0.025146015,
-0.0057414863,
0.0664648935,
-0.0465597883,
-0.081236124,
0.0021076242,
0.0613991357,
0.0265851691,
-0.0076227635,
-0.0304375906,
-0.0417037681,
0.0128274374,
0.0168668218,
-0.0527098998,
0.0030380283,
0.0653131679,
0.0208004918,
0.0148065761,
0.0283003822,
-0.0392127931,
-0.0289680976,
0.0102670966,
0.0138733247,
-0.0556704663,
-0.1173601151,
-0.0308425892,
0.0523366816,
0.0456532352,
0.0209492892,
0.074765712,
0.0222829636,
0.0530362017,
-0.045587685,
-0.0298544336,
0.0058515472,
0.0503136329,
-0.0323597752,
-0.0320547894,
0.0497497767,
0.0036922605,
-0.0443091281,
0.0542087555,
-0.0001660332,
0.0330533795,
0.0347468629,
0.0283291955,
0.01847215,
0.0003864594,
-0.0120569495,
0.0256938487,
0.0329408273,
0.0374242924,
0.0125966379,
0.0717416033,
-0.029979242,
-0.0179179031,
0.0210715402,
0.0470430516,
-0.0520959869,
-0.0748482719,
0.0422763564,
0.0248251595,
0.0266438592,
0.0435738675,
0.0393377244,
0.0002385185,
0.0132349087,
-0.0344689749,
0.0102430647,
-0.0135939438,
-0.044352971,
0.0336850435,
0.0087821921,
-0.0029714429,
0.0366603658,
0.077657491,
-0.0039278795,
0.0281746611,
0.0161124766,
-0.0275108833,
-0.0524480157,
-0.0328268632,
0.0412500985,
0.0186010133,
-0.0395597629,
-0.0489517413,
-0.0781446323,
-0.0643326566,
0.0422347337,
-0.0129881436,
0.0193478018,
0.0350891054,
0.0067590671,
0.0249080621,
0.0369892977,
0.0064706206,
-0.0556530058,
0.0032174003,
0.0112884818,
-0.0444383174,
0.0125417868,
-6.08479957e-33,
-0.0007972004,
-0.0423662104,
-0.003334316,
0.0149205169,
-0.0102679534,
0.0084670233,
-0.0235803779,
0.0329720601,
-0.0484628305,
-0.0172138661,
-0.0096040051,
0.0134578599,
0.0237086825,
0.0122129871,
-0.0184106994,
-0.0259463005,
-0.0044279774,
-0.0011842657,
-0.0069147456,
0.0352462046,
0.063971214,
-0.0191761423,
0.0197948553,
-0.1256084144,
0.0486930236,
0.0089858118,
-0.0307885129,
0.0277841464,
-0.0439356379,
0.0412535444,
-0.0028561442,
0.0352229849,
-0.0220633484,
-0.0462759249,
0.0093448404,
0.0250726938,
0.0003588962,
-0.0391834341,
0.0123692323,
-0.0062984056,
-0.001991672,
-0.0410876721,
-0.006103449,
-0.0083639063,
0.007232442,
-0.0169948488,
-0.0143270008,
0.0145372069,
-0.0084934141,
-0.0035764838,
-0.0118904468,
0.0135270339,
-0.0280911345,
-0.0387599058,
-0.0237802118,
0.0542271659,
0.0407515168,
-0.0445928238,
-0.0346957929,
0.0433941893,
-0.0379989743,
-0.0019846417,
0.0583897382,
0.008701154,
-0.004587864,
0.0432808585,
-0.030383328,
0.0095731551,
0.0068756221,
-0.0022134264,
-0.0238602255,
0.0657630414,
0.0236724708,
0.0754872486,
-0.053956639,
-0.0064740586,
-0.0761276633,
0.029443251,
0.0294222236,
0.0688368604,
0.0239864103,
-0.0088600433,
-0.0817769915,
-0.0059795198,
-0.0224751234,
0.0005473988,
-0.0346440412,
-0.0335213952,
0.0204038508,
-0.0116145611,
-0.0099412519,
0.0133440951,
0.0469822437,
-0.0202373471,
0.0022542863,
0.0121934768,
0.0050188857,
-0.0261735227,
-0.0182223767,
0.0290661491,
0.0028211277,
0.0213097427,
0.021397965,
-0.0496325828,
0.0299001187,
-0.0106461309,
0.0038154649,
0.0284152813,
-0.0754739493,
-0.0204143431,
-0.0160289556,
0.0469546951,
-0.0213676281,
0.016688684,
0.0309440419,
-0.0234693177,
-0.0106679965,
0.0379475802,
0.0408072956,
-0.0140695125,
-0.0536986813,
0.0033824355,
-0.0179364774,
0.011205717,
-0.0073811091,
0.0100960825,
0.0145674739,
0.0058138473,
0.0310299192,
-0.0213917848,
-0.0076067839,
-0.0602001771,
2.857e-7,
0.0137084704,
0.0267162099,
0.0299259908,
0.03570823,
0.0208392441,
0.0710989833,
-0.0078930603,
0.0603781268,
0.0385156199,
-0.0410165302,
-0.0220420491,
-0.0018595051,
0.0355024636,
0.0620078631,
-0.0569007285,
-0.0400716923,
-0.0584899597,
-0.0008128046,
-0.0468982682,
-0.0325802714,
0.0596086122,
0.0672671422,
0.009871413,
-0.0262228232,
-0.032522358,
-0.0288416501,
0.0010671709,
-0.015520989,
-0.0368277766,
-0.0000135124,
0.0348379873,
0.0263016131,
0.0159439556,
0.0463612862,
-0.0066345059,
-0.0180696584,
-0.0163077209,
0.0603494681,
0.0197347067,
-0.0546133369,
-0.0242815297,
-0.0562540703,
0.007535744,
-0.0361934006,
0.0556757674,
-0.0294871032,
-0.0098910239,
-0.0142495958,
-0.0307367705,
-0.0203436892,
0.031251736,
-0.0308909621,
-0.0075999419,
0.0367669463,
-0.010559462,
0.0121995928,
0.0044860509,
-0.0321351103,
-0.0331925601,
-0.0398122557,
-0.0010354011,
-0.0732648745,
0.0264973398,
-0.0030374622,
-0.0519277304,
-0.0104679251,
0.0129913697,
2.647622864e-34,
-0.0128077734,
-0.011917307,
0.0085001029,
0.0266995318,
0.046567522,
0.0086420914,
0.0046564471,
0.0105221607,
0.0135382144,
-0.0110995788,
-0.0394475162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17624v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17624v1 | Self-assessment, Exhibition, and Recognition: a Review of Personality in Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T15:08:44 | 2024-06-25T15:08:44 | Zhiyuan Wen, Yu Yang, Jiannong Cao, Haoming Sun, Ruosong Yang, Shuaiqi Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As large language models (LLMs) appear to behave increasingly human-like in
text-based interactions, more and more researchers become interested in
investigating personality in LLMs. However, the diversity of psychological
personality research and the rapid development of LLMs have led to a broad yet
fragmented landscape of studies in this interdisciplinary field. Extensive
studies across different research focuses, different personality psychometrics,
and different LLMs make it challenging to have a holistic overview and further
pose difficulties in applying findings to real-world applications. In this
paper, we present a comprehensive review by categorizing current studies into
three research problems: self-assessment, exhibition, and recognition, based on
the intrinsic characteristics and external manifestations of personality in
LLMs. For each problem, we provide a thorough analysis and conduct in-depth
comparisons of their corresponding solutions. Besides, we summarize research
findings and open challenges from current studies and further discuss their
underlying causes. We also collect extensive publicly available resources to
facilitate interested researchers and developers. Lastly, we discuss the
potential future research directions and application scenarios. Our paper is
the first comprehensive survey of up-to-date literature on personality in LLMs.
By presenting a clear taxonomy, in-depth analysis, promising future directions,
and extensive resource collections, we aim to provide a better understanding
and facilitate further advancements in this emerging field. | Self-assessment, Exhibition, and Recognition: a Review of Personality in Large Language Models: As large language models (LLMs) appear to behave increasingly human-like in
text-based interactions, more and more researchers become interested in
investigating personality in LLMs. However, the diversity of psychological
personality research and the rapid development of LLMs have led to a broad yet
fragmented landscape of studies in this interdisciplinary field. Extensive
studies across different research focuses, different personality psychometrics,
and different LLMs make it challenging to have a holistic overview and further
pose difficulties in applying findings to real-world applications. In this
paper, we present a comprehensive review by categorizing current studies into
three research problems: self-assessment, exhibition, and recognition, based on
the intrinsic characteristics and external manifestations of personality in
LLMs. For each problem, we provide a thorough analysis and conduct in-depth
comparisons of their corresponding solutions. Besides, we summarize research
findings and open challenges from current studies and further discuss their
underlying causes. We also collect extensive publicly available resources to
facilitate interested researchers and developers. Lastly, we discuss the
potential future research directions and application scenarios. Our paper is
the first comprehensive survey of up-to-date literature on personality in LLMs.
By presenting a clear taxonomy, in-depth analysis, promising future directions,
and extensive resource collections, we aim to provide a better understanding
and facilitate further advancements in this emerging field. | [
0.0759177878,
0.0330460258,
-0.0718101189,
0.0355531946,
-0.0304182712,
0.0176601261,
0.026431324,
-0.0057423725,
0.0387227871,
-0.0131422896,
-0.0748141706,
-0.0093603227,
-0.0012417767,
0.0085774409,
0.0266640149,
-0.0721409395,
0.0270870104,
-0.0183594357,
0.0398286022,
-0.0104236351,
0.0295521077,
0.051314082,
0.0218071975,
0.0314039998,
0.0057136156,
-0.0487742908,
0.0285249986,
-0.0279498268,
0.0204859376,
-0.0319156758,
0.0139395688,
0.0785391107,
0.004117189,
0.022744365,
0.0000022138,
-0.0288038328,
-0.0006149836,
-0.0423504226,
-0.00910962,
0.0180808231,
0.079066731,
0.0404632837,
0.0185714625,
0.0245595183,
-0.0690362528,
-0.0393895134,
0.0070653679,
0.0340218917,
0.0547429062,
0.0015506571,
0.0053565903,
-0.0056035086,
-0.0123168146,
0.0169035606,
-0.0059883446,
0.003653045,
0.0114724366,
-0.0237401277,
-0.0168426596,
0.0187668093,
0.0284461137,
0.0167230871,
-0.0024460603,
0.0020207709,
-0.0000512081,
-0.00611478,
-0.0259010028,
-0.0218705628,
-0.0113310777,
0.0462103449,
0.0691910014,
-0.0238639843,
-0.0178754907,
-0.0087938942,
0.0240627415,
0.0359670594,
-0.0083341207,
0.0326458849,
0.014571798,
-0.0412210636,
0.0059785079,
0.0473767631,
-0.018273063,
0.0157067254,
-0.0053756353,
0.0146926213,
-0.0098904269,
-0.0094954027,
-0.017682327,
-0.0064463289,
0.0039100512,
-0.0892639682,
0.012178787,
0.0342989005,
-0.0060840733,
0.0261734929,
-0.0385022201,
-0.0301657952,
0.0314617455,
-0.0737307668,
0.0069752452,
0.0143698696,
-0.016395377,
-0.0002530128,
0.0560540743,
0.0537739471,
0.0294847414,
0.0367746763,
0.0015941139,
0.0033474925,
-0.0501834415,
-0.0142915072,
0.0208244734,
0.0044492781,
0.0584483519,
-0.0064234878,
-0.054552827,
0.0343944244,
-0.0231668688,
-0.0086488845,
-0.0176050588,
-0.0173667874,
0.0192656703,
0.0183845982,
-0.0560007989,
0.0013780775,
-0.0517489426,
-0.0330216102,
-0.0235073213,
-0.050364498,
0.0624199323,
-0.006050711,
0.0080670249,
-0.0193069018,
0.030488288,
0.0608531833,
0.0316126123,
-0.0704910383,
-0.0192000866,
-0.0504026935,
-0.0302929562,
-0.070495978,
-0.0233980902,
-0.0396170132,
0.0182741284,
0.0354502276,
0.0050891722,
-0.0513488017,
-0.0056462721,
0.0278415382,
0.0256476309,
0.0419115722,
-0.0076203542,
0.0306484923,
0.0199032426,
0.0397074372,
0.024399044,
0.0177388098,
0.0098845046,
0.0065381406,
0.0426952094,
-0.0419534445,
0.0350283682,
0.0395352878,
-0.0298143234,
-0.0264288019,
-0.0123031391,
0.0045695207,
0.024987461,
-0.0012486756,
0.012004545,
0.0552266613,
-0.0237576533,
-0.0082447948,
0.1075075567,
0.071429722,
0.0018008457,
0.0377761163,
-0.0227766279,
0.0547190197,
0.0543199591,
-0.0088617243,
-0.0153462719,
0.0355530158,
0.0103709456,
-0.0136028696,
-0.0015128363,
0.0204018243,
0.0000107675,
-0.0524732471,
-0.0315233171,
-0.0003523058,
0.0289275516,
0.0533196628,
-0.0232526623,
-0.0042654984,
0.0102626858,
-0.0234744661,
0.0349378288,
-0.0551802181,
-0.0115356799,
-0.0628599375,
0.010010873,
0.1259111762,
0.0350792855,
0.0083640767,
0.0079494715,
-0.0233882144,
-0.031885922,
0.0493974574,
0.035686411,
-0.0219357349,
-0.0227446929,
-0.017092986,
0.0344242863,
-0.0056619272,
-0.0094552245,
0.0189017635,
0.0090916436,
0.0331546962,
-0.0258441586,
0.0214653295,
-0.0207476169,
-0.0106319338,
-0.0680665225,
-0.0624996088,
-0.0080946973,
0.0365652218,
0.0161306337,
0.0343863592,
0.0056585912,
-0.0184623245,
-0.0069693453,
0.0265154839,
-0.0004235948,
0.0346547477,
-0.0048514297,
0.0157279689,
0.0084147556,
0.0074668904,
-0.0422702581,
0.0079029221,
0.0567565188,
0.0118173519,
-0.0054300525,
-0.0366003066,
0.0459735133,
-0.0147658968,
0.0129234903,
-0.0703433752,
0.0629007891,
0.0000744514,
0.0351250395,
-0.0015443483,
0.0146105951,
0.0405232012,
-0.0212442856,
-0.0311382953,
-0.0469099432,
-0.0396695137,
-0.0352829285,
0.004784958,
0.0254069623,
0.0067013563,
-0.0109302597,
-0.0503708348,
-0.0454659872,
-0.0922911689,
-0.0293484833,
0.0195074826,
0.0136794373,
0.0437664241,
-0.0249679442,
-0.0520597473,
0.0072942623,
-0.0334644765,
-0.0203919336,
0.0234193075,
0.0233875476,
0.0352851786,
-0.0229045264,
0.0004751935,
-0.0518292375,
0.0034628019,
-0.0333636887,
0.0225681644,
-0.0049702851,
0.0298695192,
-0.0189771205,
0.0119184442,
-0.0550454669,
-0.0263664592,
-0.0067057661,
-0.0499168932,
0.0393485576,
-0.0015934006,
0.029985154,
0.044900503,
0.0543893538,
0.0518251806,
0.0289133228,
-0.0350099802,
-0.0451075621,
-0.026439514,
0.0034508777,
0.0298539307,
-0.0056745992,
-0.0966644362,
-0.0041640047,
0.0120301265,
0.0116399648,
0.0361766629,
-0.0283899326,
0.04949544,
0.0007706881,
-0.0575339124,
0.0223608427,
0.0154515086,
-0.0124539305,
0.0490827858,
0.0339898057,
-0.0367217213,
0.0675095096,
-0.0189440381,
0.0115673579,
0.0094280476,
-0.0533865504,
-0.0254307743,
0.0917823985,
-0.0090406444,
-0.00791586,
0.0418510735,
-0.0187068544,
-0.0267899167,
-0.0533489808,
0.008315444,
-0.0375683345,
0.0152813597,
0.0022809061,
-0.0573326983,
0.0595069975,
-0.0188085064,
-0.0317503139,
-0.0702359453,
-0.039155785,
-0.0400959887,
0.0356241018,
-0.0212106388,
-0.0264483914,
-0.0031900357,
0.0416152887,
-0.0483528636,
-0.0167456642,
-0.0171299223,
-0.0030797245,
-0.0130936988,
0.049042128,
0.0248087607,
0.0494939834,
-0.0557055622,
-0.0010963021,
0.0178751871,
-0.0218206663,
-0.0089831101,
0.0084323734,
-0.00420313,
0.0434590876,
-0.0014229275,
-0.0199315362,
0.0206201989,
0.041130282,
-0.0250310823,
0.0165750962,
0.1282985061,
0.0323430561,
-0.0187853128,
0.0106544429,
-0.0194855519,
0.0182013288,
0.0144162541,
0.042970214,
-0.0044779046,
0.0013587122,
-0.0324849971,
-0.0003066144,
-0.064940922,
-0.0185990501,
-0.0225413069,
-0.0651799962,
0.013353399,
0.0112303179,
-0.0330564566,
0.032748878,
-0.0059730965,
0.0185053162,
0.0127011752,
0.0120129948,
-0.0402280688,
-0.032055486,
-0.0215745568,
-0.017336715,
-0.0691246837,
-0.0246479958,
0.0760875195,
-0.0446058512,
0.0340683274,
-0.006232576,
0.0393307395,
0.0073596276,
-0.0563931875,
-0.0792280883,
0.0182137843,
0.0234938562,
0.0242428482,
0.0447036065,
-0.0508593135,
0.0305419359,
-0.1125479117,
-0.0230846871,
0.0041451515,
0.003298477,
0.0225576777,
0.0412845761,
-0.0027206219,
-0.033027593,
-0.0247973632,
0.0035738158,
0.0340228714,
0.0359984487,
-0.0009262016,
-0.0935707539,
-0.0012738849,
0.0052295881,
0.0189162884,
0.0237503741,
-0.0909099206,
-0.0231091585,
0.0438409448,
-0.0144966356,
-0.0348953865,
-0.1043621153,
-0.0158024877,
0.0081414906,
0.0055354116,
-0.0032878958,
-0.0170034636,
0.0109858681,
-0.0197936464,
0.0097768968,
-0.0381841995,
0.0499187186,
-0.0298260953,
-0.0286232848,
0.0320190862,
-0.0579087548,
0.023823332,
0.0152075812,
-0.0369658917,
-0.0312305298,
0.0193911362,
0.008822741,
0.0171673577,
-0.010139836,
0.0407968685,
-0.0869734585,
0.0273983348,
-0.0063203806,
-0.0282762088,
0.0534919687,
-0.0251509864,
0.022328997,
-0.0117639238,
0.0169741642,
0.0104418965,
0.0199928321,
-0.0114726136,
-0.0405936651,
-0.0202957895,
-0.0974629149,
-0.0029802273,
0.0175762568,
-0.0043704538,
0.0007387624,
-0.0273025315,
0.0018792683,
-0.0429477319,
-0.0391462818,
-0.0243470315,
0.0303831138,
-0.0790168047,
-0.0186090823,
0.0097062346,
-0.0223314017,
-0.0171862897,
-0.0286184605,
0.0210944023,
-0.0353632532,
0.0305286255,
0.0059703044,
0.0077300384,
-0.0269975513,
0.0222582836,
-0.0116293021,
-0.0046184617,
0.0062730559,
0.034691602,
0.0072404989,
0.0869661048,
-0.0331856608,
-0.024408631,
-0.008429681,
0.0568143986,
-0.0319724195,
-0.0304306075,
0.0324118398,
0.0100893946,
-0.0270134732,
0.0007322484,
0.0560632087,
-0.0414315835,
0.0154801365,
-0.0305306669,
0.0160961617,
-0.0252120476,
-0.0548771881,
0.0167319104,
0.0050187139,
-0.0101411389,
-0.0250324868,
0.007234381,
0.0190493129,
-0.010391999,
-0.0240606293,
-0.0433254689,
-0.0358861387,
0.0248264838,
0.0192674976,
0.0179630797,
-0.0254967213,
-0.030435957,
-0.1035016775,
-0.0935059786,
0.0509764068,
0.0237858798,
0.0050719227,
-0.0575234406,
0.0193374753,
0.0514884144,
-0.0069177034,
-0.0259602834,
-0.0481461994,
0.0228220392,
-0.04057936,
-0.0052389237,
-0.0159261972,
-5.893426519e-33,
-0.0147955138,
-0.0607268065,
0.0285705701,
-0.010449525,
-0.0095076887,
-0.0544572808,
-0.0177438892,
0.0509663559,
-0.0086771194,
-0.027918661,
-0.0382041,
0.0024715266,
0.0091115283,
-0.0372461863,
0.0095678456,
0.0120402928,
0.0484024957,
-0.0108588785,
-0.0294948928,
0.0220789984,
0.0201159436,
-0.030784253,
0.0439225435,
-0.0792063251,
0.0560141318,
-0.0730682388,
0.0052409377,
-0.0284717288,
0.0333616696,
0.0753232986,
-0.0205031335,
0.0452043191,
0.0305164568,
0.0150826694,
-0.0237797517,
0.0768360496,
-0.0389436968,
-0.0461664349,
0.0078109102,
0.0456002764,
-0.0043237945,
-0.043691542,
0.0139593128,
-0.0210683215,
-0.0832714438,
-0.0091675008,
0.0555435829,
0.0161278825,
0.0504891351,
0.0772153884,
-0.0186201688,
0.0073440918,
-0.0115308315,
-0.0120982938,
0.009763225,
0.015498017,
-0.0159085579,
0.0018833865,
-0.0837999955,
0.0718208253,
-0.0418598242,
-0.0254018232,
0.0500697382,
0.0275144409,
0.0125506315,
0.0553311035,
0.0616321936,
0.0921938047,
0.022397358,
-0.0301498212,
0.0614302792,
0.0260848645,
0.0261727534,
0.0782231018,
-0.0198466964,
-0.0384630039,
0.0296549201,
0.0040039015,
0.0741862357,
-0.0608596951,
0.0598563589,
0.0006029178,
-0.0604307391,
-0.0376713164,
-0.0070160269,
0.0050947876,
-0.0321407169,
-0.0330171622,
0.024391856,
-0.0358010419,
-0.0231370721,
-0.0226317085,
0.0433049537,
-0.0590523146,
-0.0713657588,
0.0167448632,
-0.059879411,
0.0666495413,
0.0003820082,
-0.0071742376,
-0.0177236143,
0.0074946447,
-0.0115337716,
-0.0003419053,
0.0436213911,
0.0325408205,
-0.0167086292,
0.0260524694,
-0.0569669195,
-0.0069287037,
0.0390769728,
0.009522208,
-0.0098857898,
-0.0061859591,
0.0368015058,
0.0003587898,
-0.0100790253,
-0.000434155,
0.0031849374,
0.0010179055,
-0.0556384698,
-0.0008408843,
-0.0133392345,
-0.0182833467,
0.0029625678,
0.0007847068,
-0.0719532445,
0.018998038,
0.0497610047,
-0.0221004207,
0.0314232744,
-0.0143410424,
2.778e-7,
-0.0572994798,
0.0659524426,
-0.0421139151,
0.0446595326,
0.0344117917,
0.0584162101,
0.0126460968,
0.0231238995,
0.0572682396,
-0.0343160219,
-0.016574882,
0.0244178958,
0.049092304,
0.0508197732,
-0.0466485843,
0.0309789274,
-0.0196097307,
0.0493255593,
-0.0301303864,
0.0223955363,
0.0591326393,
0.0207346808,
0.0407492816,
-0.000966927,
-0.0311049782,
0.0101505443,
0.0353515223,
-0.0134169599,
-0.0075552985,
0.0255990643,
-0.0176687371,
-0.0055124778,
0.0099088401,
0.0575343035,
0.0060715592,
0.0064176372,
-0.0137279462,
0.0484123193,
-0.0039263302,
0.0300840568,
0.0287082382,
0.0155053297,
-0.02056369,
-0.0454822704,
0.029804958,
-0.0260196459,
-0.0452951938,
-0.0274553224,
0.0200113021,
-0.0654494315,
0.046186883,
-0.0014033617,
-0.0402355492,
0.0475113764,
0.0223613214,
-0.0457520373,
-0.0076142382,
-0.0457869358,
0.0257546082,
-0.0402298942,
-0.0282055568,
-0.0494446717,
-0.0425454192,
0.0162971802,
0.0235253312,
-0.0564121008,
0.0427341275,
2.261985871e-34,
-0.0333797224,
0.0402150154,
-0.0128676072,
-0.0083437031,
0.0600803159,
0.0323539339,
0.0172983669,
0.0186676644,
0.0569714159,
-0.0681179017,
-0.0068110479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17618v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17618v1 | Towards Building an End-to-End Multilingual Automatic Lyrics Transcription Model | 2024-06-25T15:02:32 | 2024-06-25T15:02:32 | Jiawen Huang, Emmanouil Benetos | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Multilingual automatic lyrics transcription (ALT) is a challenging task due
to the limited availability of labelled data and the challenges introduced by
singing, compared to multilingual automatic speech recognition. Although some
multilingual singing datasets have been released recently, English continues to
dominate these collections. Multilingual ALT remains underexplored due to the
scale of data and annotation quality. In this paper, we aim to create a
multilingual ALT system with available datasets. Inspired by architectures that
have been proven effective for English ALT, we adapt these techniques to the
multilingual scenario by expanding the target vocabulary set. We then evaluate
the performance of the multilingual model in comparison to its monolingual
counterparts. Additionally, we explore various conditioning methods to
incorporate language information into the model. We apply analysis by language
and combine it with the language classification performance. Our findings
reveal that the multilingual model performs consistently better than the
monolingual models trained on the language subsets. Furthermore, we demonstrate
that incorporating language information significantly enhances performance. | Towards Building an End-to-End Multilingual Automatic Lyrics Transcription Model: Multilingual automatic lyrics transcription (ALT) is a challenging task due
to the limited availability of labelled data and the challenges introduced by
singing, compared to multilingual automatic speech recognition. Although some
multilingual singing datasets have been released recently, English continues to
dominate these collections. Multilingual ALT remains underexplored due to the
scale of data and annotation quality. In this paper, we aim to create a
multilingual ALT system with available datasets. Inspired by architectures that
have been proven effective for English ALT, we adapt these techniques to the
multilingual scenario by expanding the target vocabulary set. We then evaluate
the performance of the multilingual model in comparison to its monolingual
counterparts. Additionally, we explore various conditioning methods to
incorporate language information into the model. We apply analysis by language
and combine it with the language classification performance. Our findings
reveal that the multilingual model performs consistently better than the
monolingual models trained on the language subsets. Furthermore, we demonstrate
that incorporating language information significantly enhances performance. | [
0.0027447152,
0.0500481501,
-0.0136723453,
0.0649301186,
-0.0281420033,
-0.0051537356,
0.0532878451,
-0.0430490747,
-0.0271094199,
0.045981314,
-0.0843025893,
-0.0440554321,
0.0236617234,
0.0006069824,
0.0253492016,
-0.0176939126,
0.0101845535,
-0.0620078184,
0.0408104472,
-0.0292242356,
-0.0321289003,
0.0245579928,
-0.0027712074,
0.0344678201,
-0.0345545709,
0.0272170845,
0.0029505165,
0.0212086886,
-0.0092170732,
-0.0103973774,
-0.0419213548,
0.0167883541,
-0.0021691355,
0.0206095669,
0.0000017302,
-0.0476323403,
-0.0246505905,
0.0149333645,
-0.0053120623,
-0.0502613783,
0.0241217054,
-0.0164062344,
-0.0227308646,
0.0141939279,
-0.0005586116,
-0.0456005745,
0.0691910535,
-0.0049958341,
0.0515368171,
0.0743800253,
0.0070573865,
-0.0669000521,
0.0221720096,
-0.0555575006,
-0.0127462484,
-0.0533339903,
-0.0038944371,
0.0129203806,
0.0211227369,
-0.0382047072,
-0.0096067097,
0.0965586454,
-0.0046368935,
0.0099371932,
-0.0094244713,
0.0174302384,
-0.073251009,
-0.0549620241,
0.0281245112,
0.0121313231,
-0.000945947,
0.003147451,
-0.0110992696,
0.0121083083,
-0.0046423599,
-0.0281531643,
-0.0151271373,
0.0054097171,
0.0245399196,
0.0079324013,
0.0315563269,
0.0141575998,
0.0498138368,
-0.0218864791,
0.0031107746,
0.0056079682,
0.0305709857,
-0.0607932806,
0.0466615185,
0.0221025702,
0.0386314131,
-0.0387113728,
0.0307590533,
-0.0229890551,
-0.0082518114,
0.0035655205,
-0.032094229,
-0.0563980974,
-0.0147158317,
-0.0549179167,
0.0560922287,
0.0228184983,
-0.0366083309,
0.0635801554,
-0.028648071,
0.0139567452,
-0.0222801343,
0.005463358,
-0.039513085,
-0.0560379289,
0.0071903793,
-0.0084548378,
-0.0506129526,
-0.0393142216,
0.0156454891,
-0.0005741414,
-0.033444088,
-0.0247655436,
-0.008455785,
0.0297378879,
0.0190184209,
-0.0660557747,
-0.0355095491,
0.0028587419,
0.0637427345,
0.0198544022,
0.0072748512,
0.0316058584,
-0.0221177936,
-0.0351988003,
0.0118853636,
0.0110457232,
0.0315887481,
0.0045050061,
0.0749029592,
0.0762347579,
0.0513221398,
-0.0554136746,
-0.0299939942,
0.013911563,
-0.052964516,
-0.0667829365,
-0.0017375586,
-0.0925994441,
0.0972236395,
-0.0208257232,
0.0071065086,
-0.0173687637,
0.0032576784,
-0.0284016188,
-0.011336985,
0.060491886,
0.0177216586,
0.0320592485,
0.0080760829,
-0.0192399435,
-0.0156713631,
0.0531441271,
0.074324958,
0.0007729947,
0.0713888332,
-0.043470405,
0.0179555323,
0.0988670364,
-0.0008665696,
0.0111911371,
-0.0464926921,
-0.0174423791,
0.0085325334,
0.0322111994,
0.0202129874,
0.0276586022,
0.0320429206,
-0.0328691229,
0.0214618444,
0.0194801819,
0.0179226901,
0.059472166,
0.0323370025,
-0.0130302394,
0.0100495331,
-0.0114493025,
0.0196155962,
0.0428426154,
0.0666599348,
0.0256463606,
0.0860086232,
0.0436681882,
-0.0176511407,
0.0185154304,
-0.025160199,
-0.0274396557,
-0.0168595966,
0.0355429947,
0.0607739612,
0.0103176227,
-0.0149668818,
0.0151932314,
0.0290874243,
-0.0658993647,
0.0125194276,
-0.0254653599,
0.001265162,
0.0517739616,
0.031024063,
-0.0060546915,
0.0351341404,
-0.0190372989,
-0.0284990892,
0.0507145934,
-0.0045235036,
-0.0304643437,
0.0561281256,
-0.0160430204,
0.0070918305,
0.0113809248,
-0.0122238575,
0.0466068871,
-0.0301990658,
0.0312870853,
-0.0263691805,
-0.0265298467,
-0.0244379938,
-0.0267719124,
-0.0224878509,
-0.0009617429,
0.0348495692,
0.0406450033,
0.0546562485,
0.0605596863,
-0.0621772707,
0.0177090392,
0.0037490579,
-0.0404345095,
-0.0000256392,
0.0249179155,
-0.0213836916,
-0.063358061,
0.0525980853,
-0.0215277281,
-0.004048279,
0.0026918463,
0.0161671657,
-0.0728992,
0.0602188967,
-0.0119616417,
0.0411975533,
-0.0060148453,
0.0109221647,
-0.0286250748,
-0.012606184,
0.0420214236,
-0.0273047592,
0.0345393047,
0.0270971581,
-0.0218495298,
-0.0622369461,
0.0576580763,
-0.0287939999,
-0.0470744185,
0.0780901909,
0.0202527214,
0.0085922768,
-0.0001044802,
-0.0047678617,
0.0320817679,
-0.0396693051,
-0.0825815424,
0.003613991,
-0.0284103211,
-0.0088330936,
-0.0015564633,
0.0229513161,
-0.0216608085,
-0.0314163826,
-0.0247015934,
-0.0317119993,
0.0125867911,
0.0375931673,
-0.0571245961,
-0.004979379,
-0.0513389744,
-0.0265274644,
-0.0287670419,
0.0071322569,
-0.0121973045,
-0.0316294283,
-0.0379096866,
-0.0211432762,
-0.0256738141,
-0.0514236465,
0.0035389145,
0.0097526945,
-0.0035747248,
-0.0268124547,
-0.0295934472,
0.0411286429,
0.024391884,
-0.0676976219,
-0.0447738618,
0.0969569832,
-0.0059717922,
0.0107443482,
0.025411129,
0.0307264179,
0.0144180013,
-0.0065585673,
-0.0369886979,
-0.0378102288,
0.0381543264,
0.0622191392,
-0.0346245989,
-0.0079273237,
-0.007222916,
-0.0673659295,
0.028092226,
-0.0304050632,
0.0409638807,
-0.0255524032,
0.0477170236,
-0.0110091092,
-0.0241614375,
0.0575583875,
-0.0543410853,
-0.048303429,
-0.0538713001,
-0.0463183895,
-0.0331095569,
0.0191626605,
-0.0494033583,
0.0323279649,
-0.0320100896,
-0.012144383,
-0.0141724143,
0.0432290919,
-0.005326841,
-0.044811029,
0.0513908751,
-0.0142982509,
-0.0023246859,
-0.0191832576,
-0.0490588099,
0.0120830666,
-0.0162866563,
-0.0297601484,
-0.0086084334,
-0.0180185381,
-0.0380871557,
0.0221053623,
-0.0131460996,
0.0286903474,
0.0537379794,
-0.0084787635,
0.0326235853,
0.020058997,
0.0276074111,
-0.0020823833,
-0.0424302891,
-0.0398316421,
-0.0399116278,
0.0095292237,
-0.0424499661,
-0.0020538031,
0.0135678574,
0.0027289088,
-0.0121446569,
0.0437926129,
0.0475187637,
0.0059657679,
-0.0118739894,
0.0054783467,
-0.0419987924,
0.0236910656,
0.0795392022,
-0.0038362679,
-0.0290599409,
-0.0279124323,
-0.0043396722,
0.0220966898,
0.0287072435,
0.0180476084,
-0.0549244173,
-0.0041418374,
0.0318586864,
0.0468131751,
0.0468271002,
0.0303614903,
-0.0266215019,
-0.0492063798,
-0.011344987,
0.0049503352,
-0.0817475393,
-0.023283897,
-0.0460679419,
-0.034580376,
-0.0440824218,
-0.0154562145,
-0.0185161494,
0.0190460458,
0.0068891337,
-0.0225355905,
-0.0025638961,
-0.0480021089,
0.0416126251,
-0.0586879253,
0.0772290304,
0.0573529527,
0.0556462891,
-0.0464717411,
-0.0366931595,
0.0019499224,
0.0268354956,
-0.0172591079,
0.0182211269,
0.0259776637,
0.0511928536,
-0.0232753772,
0.0391194038,
0.0036914921,
-0.0293690339,
0.0374373049,
0.0294869579,
0.0531864129,
0.0142479315,
0.0171805881,
0.0245302152,
0.0280096903,
0.0259650145,
0.0794310942,
0.0293522608,
-0.0682886019,
0.0241112374,
-0.0038903558,
-0.0058004791,
-0.0922333747,
0.0141765177,
0.0161357932,
-0.0322866961,
-0.0545720607,
-0.0151669821,
-0.0212670974,
-0.0072353967,
-0.0190995373,
0.0581968315,
-0.0090138735,
-0.0246682502,
-0.0165339019,
-0.0213789642,
0.0036114273,
-0.0175516102,
0.0639716536,
-0.0271482524,
-0.0544607826,
-0.0025507712,
-0.02387725,
-0.0145240603,
-0.013541053,
-0.0673867017,
-0.0421550721,
0.0190227553,
0.0213090666,
0.0125939911,
0.0624367148,
-0.0100912703,
-0.0097199241,
-0.0296643693,
-0.0303264111,
0.0370949693,
-0.0019355885,
0.0589946769,
-0.0094586294,
-0.0046480373,
0.0351367965,
-0.0477374308,
0.0475903712,
0.0285381489,
0.022229122,
0.0128920609,
-0.0449649394,
-0.006064747,
0.0101680383,
0.0028725401,
-0.0297138896,
-0.0350575522,
-0.0766262412,
-0.0145389568,
-0.0265732147,
-0.00420056,
-0.0230438579,
-0.0074366145,
0.0913606435,
0.0280400794,
-0.0205506142,
-0.0206810813,
0.0030415426,
-0.0416716635,
-0.032487575,
0.047684513,
0.0811596587,
-0.0459588356,
0.021542795,
0.0266538598,
-0.0239993129,
0.0399289988,
0.0412775353,
-0.0061600911,
0.0001965234,
-0.0325267278,
-0.0097231325,
-0.0448148884,
0.0135740144,
0.0113051357,
0.0052533736,
0.0086194407,
0.025654953,
0.0135335065,
0.0800170228,
-0.0152076492,
0.0536103323,
0.0179600045,
-0.0130000329,
-0.0100050187,
0.0279551297,
0.007023674,
-0.0428546295,
-0.0207191166,
-0.0003063953,
0.0076479902,
0.002366619,
0.0718962774,
-0.0186961368,
0.0194500219,
-0.0200756248,
-0.0020132931,
0.0196146537,
0.0246195253,
-0.0214208644,
-0.0318323709,
-0.0175451729,
0.0179050975,
-0.0314679667,
-0.0696814954,
0.0015480078,
0.019094808,
0.0106598074,
0.0153187932,
-0.0185133554,
0.0483795702,
-0.0054887095,
0.0138254669,
-0.0324503072,
-0.0539127402,
0.0147148734,
-0.0074490025,
0.0025996123,
-5.301295851e-33,
-0.012751949,
0.0552662872,
-0.0192268975,
0.0163715258,
-0.0086051151,
-0.0033657262,
-0.0631378293,
0.0137191219,
-0.0189561378,
-0.0182381198,
0.006814593,
0.0024738873,
0.0079381298,
0.0032103902,
0.0540994145,
0.0205373392,
0.0548207574,
0.0064538904,
-0.0437703431,
0.0315804072,
0.0764844865,
0.0635910556,
0.0453939512,
-0.0697662756,
0.0399788953,
-0.010405913,
0.0300000329,
0.0336996578,
0.0188136958,
0.0367595293,
-0.0115800314,
0.023293145,
0.0150899608,
-0.0348505639,
-0.0318980254,
0.0044628042,
-0.0412790552,
-0.0256976523,
0.0076574767,
0.0703754649,
0.0396090746,
-0.0104634594,
-0.0145670967,
-0.031721402,
-0.0158915985,
-0.0052340846,
0.0410812087,
-0.0462972037,
-0.0051403935,
-0.0465300381,
-0.0311083738,
0.0097335624,
-0.0131695597,
-0.0322171599,
0.0852508917,
0.0643647984,
0.0022796909,
0.0114746448,
-0.0396281146,
0.0243470538,
-0.0369592942,
0.023569515,
0.0461865775,
0.0399812162,
-0.0338420495,
0.0139202103,
0.0046180906,
-0.0484336093,
0.0138907991,
0.0347150639,
0.0127781769,
0.0140878968,
0.0185016766,
-0.0026616757,
0.0496141538,
-0.0306919459,
-0.0403218083,
-0.0151219787,
-0.0074461978,
-0.0571225956,
0.0032235549,
0.0312592275,
-0.0512853004,
-0.0123848664,
-0.0200104769,
-0.0698694959,
-0.0252165869,
-0.0152003011,
0.0203360096,
-0.0120946597,
-0.017382063,
0.0180445723,
0.0287416335,
-0.0213481225,
-0.0288134217,
0.0196065512,
-0.0255845897,
-0.0056579132,
-0.0098894797,
0.0374398828,
-0.0527269579,
-0.0199222676,
0.0222752392,
0.0123441853,
0.0419884808,
-0.0093818782,
0.0831690878,
0.0876243487,
-0.070832558,
0.0028416237,
-0.031109903,
-0.0002156819,
0.0025898672,
0.0346741155,
0.0463179573,
0.0179917756,
-0.0025346701,
0.0617854334,
0.0513083674,
0.0379094891,
-0.0248320699,
-0.0422019921,
-0.0148126194,
-0.0146978162,
0.0039821337,
0.0114215286,
-0.0013528088,
-0.0284103882,
0.0103510823,
-0.0479998179,
-0.0178466402,
0.0121708121,
2.607e-7,
0.0337843783,
-0.0283074956,
-0.0031498782,
0.0096423682,
0.0289601739,
0.0264155529,
-0.1163787469,
-0.0043699117,
-0.0067065493,
0.0458892956,
0.0054909284,
-0.0280687604,
0.1128008217,
0.0692627206,
-0.1047140658,
0.0022554919,
-0.0667740107,
0.0075955023,
-0.0731684119,
-0.0335383266,
0.0078932308,
0.0855149329,
0.012176414,
-0.0265166387,
-0.0301460698,
-0.04919957,
0.0231514145,
-0.0098860543,
0.001154836,
-0.0666631237,
-0.0017232571,
0.0259282645,
-0.0003966416,
-0.0005946953,
-0.0799742937,
0.0828907937,
0.0418300368,
0.0420972109,
0.0204839464,
0.0172242485,
0.0556129701,
0.0333433822,
-0.0471363179,
-0.0207562149,
0.0400045551,
0.0199469049,
-0.0369271711,
-0.0209495295,
0.0207445547,
0.0436250418,
0.0360827148,
-0.0377565324,
-0.0260054506,
-0.0291517954,
0.0375606157,
-0.0421829559,
0.0161462948,
-0.0136803901,
-0.0098988144,
0.0382258072,
-0.0390808098,
-0.0007114505,
0.0093195457,
-0.01991155,
-0.0127893491,
-0.0555505753,
0.0187241919,
1.852853915e-34,
0.0651146993,
-0.0542197302,
0.0063606151,
-0.0088272458,
0.0217203815,
-0.0566271096,
0.0190623626,
-0.0186511558,
-0.0429719239,
-0.0194950141,
-0.0620152354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17600v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17600v1 | "Seeing the Big through the Small": Can LLMs Approximate Human Judgment Distributions on NLI from a Few Explanations? | 2024-06-25T14:42:17 | 2024-06-25T14:42:17 | Beiduo Chen, Xinpeng Wang, Siyao Peng, Robert Litschko, Anna Korhonen, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human label variation (HLV) is a valuable source of information that arises
when multiple human annotators provide different labels for valid reasons. In
Natural Language Inference (NLI) earlier approaches to capturing HLV involve
either collecting annotations from many crowd workers to represent human
judgment distribution (HJD) or use expert linguists to provide detailed
explanations for their chosen labels. While the former method provides denser
HJD information, obtaining it is resource-intensive. In contrast, the latter
offers richer textual information but it is challenging to scale up to many
human judges. Besides, large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used as
evaluators (``LLM judges'') but with mixed results, and few works aim to study
HJDs. This study proposes to exploit LLMs to approximate HJDs using a small
number of expert labels and explanations. Our experiments show that a few
explanations significantly improve LLMs' ability to approximate HJDs with and
without explicit labels, thereby providing a solution to scale up annotations
for HJD. However, fine-tuning smaller soft-label aware models with the
LLM-generated model judgment distributions (MJDs) presents partially
inconsistent results: while similar in distance, their resulting fine-tuned
models and visualized distributions differ substantially. We show the
importance of complementing instance-level distance measures with a
global-level shape metric and visualization to more effectively evaluate MJDs
against human judgment distributions. | "Seeing the Big through the Small": Can LLMs Approximate Human Judgment Distributions on NLI from a Few Explanations?: Human label variation (HLV) is a valuable source of information that arises
when multiple human annotators provide different labels for valid reasons. In
Natural Language Inference (NLI) earlier approaches to capturing HLV involve
either collecting annotations from many crowd workers to represent human
judgment distribution (HJD) or use expert linguists to provide detailed
explanations for their chosen labels. While the former method provides denser
HJD information, obtaining it is resource-intensive. In contrast, the latter
offers richer textual information but it is challenging to scale up to many
human judges. Besides, large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used as
evaluators (``LLM judges'') but with mixed results, and few works aim to study
HJDs. This study proposes to exploit LLMs to approximate HJDs using a small
number of expert labels and explanations. Our experiments show that a few
explanations significantly improve LLMs' ability to approximate HJDs with and
without explicit labels, thereby providing a solution to scale up annotations
for HJD. However, fine-tuning smaller soft-label aware models with the
LLM-generated model judgment distributions (MJDs) presents partially
inconsistent results: while similar in distance, their resulting fine-tuned
models and visualized distributions differ substantially. We show the
importance of complementing instance-level distance measures with a
global-level shape metric and visualization to more effectively evaluate MJDs
against human judgment distributions. | [
0.0694849268,
0.0391089506,
-0.0296425242,
0.034589231,
-0.0173592456,
0.0082021551,
0.0054564644,
-0.0035156384,
-0.0220301002,
-0.0604306757,
-0.0594497174,
-0.0219274126,
0.0036897468,
-0.0183298644,
0.0408798866,
-0.0561299324,
-0.0036842988,
-0.0395193696,
0.0414502062,
-0.0060824747,
0.0301572643,
0.0045832405,
-0.0121910935,
0.0714194849,
-0.0115247816,
0.0218108427,
-0.0149983745,
0.0056661554,
0.0384291597,
-0.0120438077,
0.0055220528,
0.0670954213,
0.0444224626,
-0.0033257238,
0.00000194,
-0.0258554649,
0.0475187339,
0.000520558,
-0.0175613705,
0.0411838666,
0.0096746581,
0.0035405078,
0.0312835649,
-0.0199480075,
-0.0129164374,
-0.0153753133,
0.0524339527,
0.0297022983,
0.0541704334,
0.0192867741,
0.0169374254,
-0.0528449193,
-0.0454799645,
-0.0277586505,
0.005718594,
-0.0790459365,
0.0020258168,
0.0157314483,
-0.0126705803,
0.0370596685,
0.0029739994,
-0.00086818,
-0.0101937726,
0.0001122102,
0.0219418686,
0.0092473598,
-0.0102233188,
-0.0327605531,
0.0165899992,
0.0682984069,
0.0497385263,
-0.0344328322,
-0.0385565311,
-0.0208042171,
0.0330300517,
0.0407858938,
-0.0023479429,
0.0323792323,
-0.0184046533,
0.0179459713,
0.0129736299,
0.0412070602,
0.0311000179,
0.023483675,
0.0287759341,
0.0589499697,
-0.0145858265,
-0.0056484747,
0.0030626724,
0.0465276539,
-0.0489852466,
-0.031845361,
0.0046728468,
-0.0008552946,
-0.0401367098,
-0.0093850736,
-0.0024048341,
-0.0213119145,
0.0284090396,
-0.0320023783,
0.0264780689,
-0.0008779748,
-0.0180741046,
0.0481818989,
0.0242677424,
0.025640754,
-0.0083886292,
0.0309845712,
-0.0320079885,
-0.0474227034,
-0.05157502,
0.0139894774,
-0.0039780843,
-0.0078035342,
-0.0392714888,
0.0310199615,
-0.0523890778,
-0.0126948943,
-0.0672012269,
-0.0340444073,
0.036952205,
0.0324719176,
-0.0027100823,
0.0004842735,
-0.0996373296,
0.0133974832,
-0.0966742337,
0.0380537808,
-0.0000325644,
-0.0236430503,
0.0121684317,
0.0280201212,
0.0171783455,
-0.0015886405,
-0.0028240869,
0.0680477247,
0.029744219,
0.0063971188,
-0.0425661914,
-0.0307801217,
-0.0327039398,
-0.0425414145,
-0.0343990885,
-0.0597690716,
0.0211772174,
0.0094462037,
-0.010415744,
-0.0446235165,
-0.0140903918,
-0.0116321743,
-0.0541289039,
0.0783176944,
-0.0108771548,
0.0203808397,
-0.003611733,
-0.008970811,
-0.0389460325,
0.0411937162,
0.0136400172,
0.0207400974,
0.027500771,
-0.0230473392,
0.026690701,
0.0050904271,
0.0039971354,
0.0383118689,
-0.0253035296,
-0.0050738733,
-0.0395210087,
0.0274947099,
0.0417633094,
0.0439670049,
-0.0361642987,
-0.0099518057,
0.0560907349,
0.0597299114,
-0.0010548818,
-0.0130971428,
0.0555978231,
0.0308114532,
-0.0120819891,
0.0104561504,
-0.0540695898,
0.0270513445,
-0.028501844,
-0.017944077,
0.0483136959,
-0.0011059231,
-0.0119569506,
-0.0491859578,
-0.0241849404,
0.0065103248,
-0.0087735038,
0.003245634,
0.0416092761,
-0.0020812252,
0.0374139175,
0.0690881461,
0.0926489308,
-0.0357343629,
0.0004868336,
-0.0589971244,
0.0373246297,
0.0482439585,
0.0054019662,
0.0022902351,
0.0233318619,
0.0237372238,
-0.0425318964,
0.0206861403,
0.0701423064,
-0.0076530525,
-0.0128240474,
-0.0205153581,
-0.0423411019,
-0.0134045547,
0.0492246039,
0.0215153657,
0.0262779333,
-0.0292006135,
0.0216792449,
-0.1264790595,
-0.0261241645,
0.0223616064,
0.0362121649,
0.0117919696,
-0.0059786313,
0.0233130939,
0.043623995,
0.0094684837,
0.0004155316,
0.0104475338,
-0.0044017904,
-0.0055946172,
0.0000426855,
-0.0219818465,
-0.0192484204,
-0.0287841279,
0.0095625268,
-0.0592748113,
-0.0340757556,
-0.029806966,
-0.0517739207,
-0.0118468739,
-0.0125193717,
-0.0190886147,
-0.0297723226,
-0.0445325375,
-0.0134307072,
-0.0130649665,
-0.0079894029,
-0.0549128465,
0.0816282853,
0.021965852,
0.0203912258,
-0.0220038835,
0.0309183486,
0.0144007485,
-0.002766266,
-0.0261344165,
-0.0299270805,
0.0114856493,
0.0126332864,
0.0318367258,
0.0079973117,
-0.0311590862,
-0.0316118002,
-0.0736700073,
-0.0260040164,
-0.0050777653,
-0.0163202472,
0.0099947546,
-0.0210911408,
0.0183661114,
-0.0083483132,
-0.0301169679,
-0.0159059558,
-0.046844095,
0.0426735915,
0.0387858339,
-0.0040110792,
-0.0097864829,
-0.0389753208,
-0.0110676056,
-0.0176071059,
0.0493169688,
0.0529489741,
-0.0320041068,
-0.0962400064,
-0.0055411784,
-0.0559595972,
0.0091202529,
-0.0038006285,
-0.0412630774,
0.0452934727,
0.0190438833,
0.0576687753,
0.0633712336,
0.0127537791,
0.028623715,
0.0553429313,
0.0126145231,
-0.0587246828,
-0.0023429089,
-0.0111043323,
-0.0337196328,
-0.0427342616,
-0.0562378913,
0.0010941153,
0.0602949075,
0.0139547205,
-0.0173966605,
-0.0717559755,
0.0275420956,
-0.0164122451,
-0.0290995259,
-0.0326842442,
-0.0216219518,
-0.0106494827,
0.0779732391,
0.0034274289,
-0.0588868037,
0.0931687728,
-0.021430593,
0.0436990447,
0.0038344918,
-0.0317806862,
-0.0513183773,
0.0657740533,
0.0063431701,
-0.0076656537,
-0.0298253968,
0.0144445039,
-0.0319553092,
0.0223602187,
0.0668089911,
-0.0050643859,
0.0184845924,
-0.067573972,
0.0024641594,
-0.0172810238,
-0.0271827914,
-0.0057244077,
-0.0574548654,
-0.0729473233,
-0.0167370345,
0.0738038868,
-0.0022414245,
-0.0296714399,
0.0376319662,
0.0270158108,
-0.0136254951,
-0.0018893864,
0.0286372118,
-0.0210279673,
-0.0110793822,
0.0143226516,
0.0309134927,
0.0204048734,
-0.059811037,
-0.035921894,
0.0189161599,
-0.0200738125,
0.0060743592,
-0.0181894079,
-0.0036023303,
0.0264168046,
0.0252814386,
-0.0229859501,
0.0495995432,
0.1088109985,
-0.0126017826,
0.016268203,
0.0934909061,
-0.0036455591,
-0.0712240711,
0.0199646875,
-0.0047536963,
0.0570686683,
0.0115645342,
-0.0226197429,
-0.048577521,
-0.0642154962,
0.0088841049,
0.0130082294,
-0.0024769162,
-0.0241814405,
0.020201413,
-0.0920035914,
0.0339971446,
-0.0021726969,
-0.0448960513,
-0.0068385848,
-0.0583824366,
0.0576746836,
-0.0159790739,
-0.0310867392,
-0.0143321902,
0.0471128337,
0.025078563,
0.0361265317,
-0.0034195704,
-0.0342336372,
0.0652958155,
-0.0695138648,
0.0582230352,
0.0120651992,
0.020734638,
0.0092684152,
-0.0940504,
0.0285413265,
-0.0023722248,
0.0444406532,
0.0173466112,
0.0747895911,
-0.0018559137,
-0.0119410316,
-0.0609124787,
0.0268240161,
-0.0094092879,
-0.0095479162,
-0.0115156472,
0.043197494,
-0.0038704681,
-0.0223354232,
-0.0263554342,
0.014798644,
-0.0203865971,
0.0783982724,
0.0530880168,
-0.0674961135,
-0.0323521271,
-0.0079311254,
-0.011280491,
-0.0009579191,
-0.0835195333,
0.0533242561,
-0.0067211594,
-0.0757828951,
-0.0191482715,
-0.018246185,
0.0014920271,
0.0213219579,
0.0104271211,
-0.0166049879,
0.0194639601,
0.0174519755,
0.0390167758,
0.082097508,
-0.0512715913,
0.0242357552,
-0.0285082124,
-0.0100841206,
0.0216736328,
-0.0040958901,
-0.0322975256,
0.0432294011,
-0.0866602808,
-0.0481518731,
-0.0090947058,
0.0046591307,
0.01617782,
0.0364536121,
0.000938033,
-0.0826204792,
0.0004584893,
0.0450690165,
-0.0199257191,
0.0163900238,
-0.001275464,
0.0167851094,
-0.0039856704,
0.0415563397,
-0.0325085409,
0.0373102725,
0.0462471992,
0.0145731056,
-0.0357206687,
-0.1001605019,
0.0179815292,
0.0143789919,
0.0546100587,
-0.0258422494,
-0.0318252034,
-0.0288668294,
-0.0343967564,
0.0146049308,
-0.0511785187,
-0.02879861,
-0.0279653911,
0.0219428316,
-0.0459106639,
-0.0038212072,
-0.0004596575,
0.0151756657,
0.0478687771,
-0.0149725387,
0.0096626971,
0.0655436069,
0.0379714482,
0.003329593,
-0.0036555559,
-0.0309359152,
-0.0254939329,
-0.0380435437,
0.0492247716,
0.0164963361,
0.0367253795,
0.0247571431,
0.0021114668,
-0.0103391716,
-0.0062282565,
-0.0488672741,
-0.0328336768,
0.0013613165,
0.0192885362,
0.012669012,
-0.0009168687,
0.0243524984,
0.0241328385,
-0.0171111152,
0.0007839007,
0.0477847196,
-0.0018090692,
0.0177834108,
0.0538267605,
0.0153684197,
-0.0200837851,
-0.0070882868,
0.0465504415,
0.0254486706,
-0.0109005328,
-0.0385360122,
-0.0325016342,
-0.0207141992,
0.0011732405,
-0.0333836973,
-0.0015943524,
0.0101505192,
0.024578901,
-0.0818642601,
-0.0563155338,
-0.0414016843,
0.018720232,
-0.0143000046,
-0.0014628116,
0.0139756519,
0.0737018362,
-0.0190819874,
-0.0465829,
-0.0404632352,
-0.0048040501,
0.0331040546,
0.0356560126,
-0.0611983761,
-6.697910975e-33,
-0.0204062611,
-0.0628981814,
-0.0337667018,
-0.0592981242,
-0.0009377168,
-0.0073150112,
0.0099686896,
0.0107115358,
-0.0300503206,
0.0632680655,
0.0157902632,
-0.0012654272,
0.0157927871,
-0.0109202247,
0.01737695,
-0.0278419908,
0.0316354595,
0.0314366221,
-0.0269902516,
0.0253594369,
0.0050013661,
-0.0352488719,
0.0596816167,
-0.1094119102,
0.0900680646,
0.0248856787,
0.0032498103,
0.035347227,
-0.0249430723,
0.0314772725,
0.0143067567,
0.0510182977,
0.020691745,
-0.0312245432,
-0.0023302585,
0.010499266,
-0.0681732818,
-0.0143476827,
0.0608612783,
-0.0056483857,
-0.0465822965,
-0.0187174957,
0.0455887429,
0.0157402139,
-0.0102267014,
-0.0070193489,
0.0775970966,
-0.029291397,
-0.003335601,
-0.0070859389,
0.0158419367,
0.0426564664,
-0.0257005934,
0.0004022178,
-0.0235373303,
0.0182179753,
-0.0167510007,
0.0631002858,
-0.0689476281,
0.0270134509,
0.0336782858,
-0.0097298436,
0.0327430815,
0.0099522853,
-0.0078190053,
0.0667802542,
0.0056452267,
0.0287804361,
-0.0606276318,
-0.0931281894,
-0.0054766014,
0.0639901906,
0.0498283096,
0.0648485869,
0.0235556848,
0.0156332124,
-0.0409887359,
0.0115885632,
-0.0297408234,
0.0153594902,
0.0413095169,
0.0185557399,
-0.0659466311,
-0.0285056774,
-0.0516779087,
-0.0472689644,
-0.0502930097,
0.0328006037,
0.0134722935,
-0.0299646296,
-0.0172226485,
-0.0155087141,
0.0097816,
-0.0302675534,
0.015675405,
-0.0164368413,
0.0067095063,
0.0027923675,
-0.0072575207,
-0.0028833975,
-0.030587947,
-0.0103282314,
-0.0090723345,
0.0175580923,
0.0199721288,
0.0032687027,
0.0553823449,
-0.0337260365,
-0.0238141641,
-0.0036012984,
-0.037027467,
-0.0484618805,
-0.051082775,
-0.0226081535,
0.0649963766,
0.0238913503,
-0.0330904759,
0.0451215766,
0.0192942861,
0.0268272106,
0.0268176198,
-0.0245694313,
-0.0205457006,
0.0015110696,
-0.0242799483,
-0.0103097102,
-0.0203233361,
-0.0407260433,
0.0332423449,
-0.0103927376,
-0.0131735634,
0.0322224908,
2.656e-7,
0.0385097452,
0.0407970101,
-0.0105798077,
0.0073963623,
0.0183157437,
0.0797776058,
0.0412600711,
-0.0295092091,
0.0538302958,
-0.0673114583,
0.0120143509,
0.0431395136,
0.0394073464,
0.0257420037,
-0.0386047959,
0.011308765,
-0.0653052926,
-0.0154333543,
-0.0019837618,
0.013900185,
0.0623279102,
0.061263077,
0.057866063,
-0.0049221916,
-0.007798837,
-0.0376417525,
0.0556445271,
-0.0304828361,
-0.0106427157,
0.0325707495,
0.0543429218,
-0.025275223,
0.0396640413,
0.0568121709,
0.0239007622,
-0.0106358882,
0.0164430272,
0.0272143371,
-0.0292903259,
0.0036048207,
-0.0347517617,
-0.0265179165,
0.0253717098,
-0.0327380821,
0.0550297014,
-0.04132393,
-0.0622735545,
-0.0082478784,
-0.010976065,
-0.0256191287,
0.0024393173,
0.0023095736,
-0.0133085037,
0.025769081,
-0.0089324554,
-0.0100407256,
-0.0375936516,
-0.0512433983,
-0.0455545299,
0.0191299282,
-0.0510634892,
-0.0518210866,
-0.0016316627,
0.0037761235,
0.0315157063,
-0.0431117564,
0.0321044773,
1.943926258e-34,
0.0450142398,
0.0136491274,
0.0136752101,
-0.0135034891,
0.090540193,
0.0339445472,
-0.040355783,
-0.025666682,
0.044977773,
-0.0444294214,
-0.0073674652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17588v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17588v2 | LongIns: A Challenging Long-context Instruction-based Exam for LLMs | 2024-06-25T14:31:26 | 2024-06-26T13:28:04 | Shawn Gavin, Tuney Zheng, Jiaheng Liu, Quehry Que, Noah Wang, Jian Yang, Chenchen Zhang, Wenhao Huang, Wenhu Chen, Ge Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The long-context capabilities of large language models (LLMs) have been a hot
topic in recent years. To evaluate the performance of LLMs in different
scenarios, various assessment benchmarks have emerged. However, as most of
these benchmarks focus on identifying key information to answer questions,
which mainly requires the retrieval ability of LLMs, these benchmarks can
partially represent the reasoning performance of LLMs from large amounts of
information. Meanwhile, although LLMs often claim to have context windows of
32k, 128k, 200k, or even longer, these benchmarks fail to reveal the actual
supported length of these LLMs. To address these issues, we propose the LongIns
benchmark dataset, a challenging long-context instruction-based exam for LLMs,
which is built based on the existing instruction datasets. Specifically, in our
LongIns, we introduce three evaluation settings: Global Instruction & Single
Task (GIST), Local Instruction & Single Task (LIST), and Local Instruction &
Multiple Tasks (LIMT). Based on LongIns, we perform comprehensive evaluations
on existing LLMs and have the following important findings: (1). The
top-performing GPT-4 with 128k context length performs poorly on the evaluation
context window of 16k in our LongIns. (2). For the multi-hop reasoning ability
of many existing LLMs, significant efforts are still needed under short context
windows (less than 4k). | LongIns: A Challenging Long-context Instruction-based Exam for LLMs: The long-context capabilities of large language models (LLMs) have been a hot
topic in recent years. To evaluate the performance of LLMs in different
scenarios, various assessment benchmarks have emerged. However, as most of
these benchmarks focus on identifying key information to answer questions,
which mainly requires the retrieval ability of LLMs, these benchmarks can
partially represent the reasoning performance of LLMs from large amounts of
information. Meanwhile, although LLMs often claim to have context windows of
32k, 128k, 200k, or even longer, these benchmarks fail to reveal the actual
supported length of these LLMs. To address these issues, we propose the LongIns
benchmark dataset, a challenging long-context instruction-based exam for LLMs,
which is built based on the existing instruction datasets. Specifically, in our
LongIns, we introduce three evaluation settings: Global Instruction & Single
Task (GIST), Local Instruction & Single Task (LIST), and Local Instruction &
Multiple Tasks (LIMT). Based on LongIns, we perform comprehensive evaluations
on existing LLMs and have the following important findings: (1). The
top-performing GPT-4 with 128k context length performs poorly on the evaluation
context window of 16k in our LongIns. (2). For the multi-hop reasoning ability
of many existing LLMs, significant efforts are still needed under short context
windows (less than 4k). | [
-0.008756944,
0.0393693522,
-0.0178143103,
0.0712118447,
-0.0639229789,
0.0205875449,
0.0233527031,
0.0000782907,
0.010602436,
-0.0510865375,
-0.0230490286,
-0.0680123791,
-0.0181226414,
-0.0335265584,
0.0272367056,
-0.0160022564,
0.0572472997,
-0.0598413013,
-0.0157929398,
-0.016233705,
-0.0273962282,
-0.0035994323,
-0.0085784923,
0.0005072865,
0.0215920657,
-0.0402635112,
-0.0179761332,
-0.0050822813,
0.0088022863,
-0.0406950973,
0.0073521989,
0.0354670323,
0.0210027117,
0.0204507988,
0.0000020535,
-0.0406385623,
-0.008557627,
0.0109704537,
-0.048360832,
0.0430591255,
0.0055205002,
0.0254028197,
-0.0082403347,
0.0291301366,
-0.0297550075,
0.0121528637,
-0.0021587117,
0.0096679619,
0.0562571809,
0.07900206,
0.0193193089,
-0.0399192944,
0.0406697616,
-0.0280306377,
0.042307537,
-0.0569529422,
0.013653622,
0.0051157959,
0.046384804,
0.0136248991,
-0.0100099426,
0.0156360343,
0.0630648434,
0.0354490727,
-0.0683071166,
0.0240508318,
-0.0406129621,
0.0421399623,
0.0102070495,
0.057660643,
0.0107815452,
-0.000196664,
-0.0168569405,
0.0124993008,
-0.007061997,
-0.0317923687,
-0.0457911603,
0.0542175248,
-0.0074128127,
-0.0000924718,
0.0389230587,
-0.0069053206,
0.0358605012,
0.0062818374,
-0.0577939749,
0.0949274823,
0.0383404754,
-0.0461428091,
-0.0020651007,
-0.0134083163,
-0.0444475524,
-0.032709416,
-0.0245983806,
0.0525162816,
-0.0262314826,
0.0269800927,
-0.0149222519,
0.0261321831,
0.0346287824,
-0.0086141899,
0.0167036392,
0.0389569774,
-0.0190531109,
0.054635819,
-0.035191074,
0.0745846853,
-0.0127291577,
0.0277931057,
-0.0425950028,
-0.0237185191,
-0.0404325016,
0.0128232446,
-0.0191443637,
0.0302745681,
-0.0472916663,
0.0155194206,
-0.0428402387,
0.0286917817,
-0.0297008194,
0.0258935224,
0.0110343182,
-0.0289780963,
-0.0148341376,
0.0025075711,
-0.0407073312,
0.0085847154,
-0.0414382704,
-0.0027915109,
0.0112986024,
-0.0556816384,
-0.0270706695,
0.0166569706,
-0.0088154739,
-0.0612959862,
0.037236236,
0.0667760372,
0.0093640024,
-0.0319103114,
-0.0447971635,
-0.0320075937,
-0.020392945,
-0.097627297,
0.0133394431,
-0.0705432296,
0.0173723232,
0.0109887291,
-0.011378428,
-0.0055438858,
0.0061324062,
0.0390963852,
0.0235322844,
0.0535473749,
0.0363610536,
-0.0068374304,
0.0020362462,
0.0401367284,
0.0099420259,
0.0734296963,
0.0052783331,
0.0242819078,
0.0431580059,
-0.0124984924,
-0.0236450117,
0.0332693718,
0.031687893,
0.0259941574,
-0.0119410418,
0.0626710206,
0.0342070982,
0.0127018895,
-0.0061618723,
0.065374434,
-0.0180592369,
-0.0375041217,
0.0224171225,
0.059181381,
0.030345073,
-0.0208323449,
0.0535691306,
0.0100382473,
-0.0015827247,
0.0155601446,
-0.0629665107,
0.0137571264,
-0.0375567712,
0.0383378081,
0.0334848873,
0.0108903032,
-0.0307534747,
-0.0290322322,
-0.0228982419,
0.0049041635,
-0.0220701043,
0.0453128405,
0.0462755002,
-0.0347225592,
-0.0377041548,
0.0677417591,
0.0228993762,
-0.0481169149,
-0.0253183693,
-0.0553668588,
0.0226771049,
0.0414085351,
0.0386361554,
-0.0290840212,
-0.0662818104,
0.0116918469,
0.0305069201,
0.0242536739,
0.0450690761,
-0.0085281795,
0.0179223772,
-0.0309834108,
-0.0172022898,
-0.0402811244,
0.0035677981,
0.0097235413,
0.0527694933,
0.0194609594,
0.0333182923,
-0.0627456233,
0.0244037788,
0.0169769619,
-0.0456182659,
-0.0425724201,
-0.0322485305,
0.0144036869,
0.0361790992,
0.0139675597,
-0.0075713908,
0.014796216,
0.0478153415,
-0.0305875335,
0.0172254834,
-0.0395713225,
-0.0656304508,
-0.0420026593,
0.0523796752,
-0.0163913276,
-0.0189839471,
0.0223635118,
-0.0406511799,
-0.064055033,
0.0080168182,
-0.0127608404,
0.0225912724,
-0.0288252067,
0.0124931,
-0.0032043783,
0.0047017094,
-0.0452444255,
0.0739120916,
-0.0011413641,
0.0426856801,
0.0356635451,
0.0488521643,
0.0291294195,
-0.0642824993,
-0.0498282202,
0.0176232494,
-0.0075952983,
-0.0076137194,
-0.0123526668,
0.0305464957,
-0.0620917976,
-0.0302004553,
-0.1167945415,
0.0484376326,
-0.039816808,
0.041439008,
0.0153960856,
-0.0107996054,
-0.0033427405,
0.0212249346,
-0.0616352037,
-0.0184136722,
0.0136330128,
0.0357365906,
0.0017513183,
0.0257424582,
-0.0261620358,
-0.0216033608,
-0.0338916518,
-0.0224403925,
0.027379889,
-0.0422618128,
0.0237399265,
-0.0328803174,
0.032088507,
-0.0157792419,
0.0140581308,
-0.02579269,
-0.0098306397,
0.0276974626,
-0.0425519422,
0.0266566146,
0.0545651391,
-0.0112782568,
0.0098385429,
0.0334461443,
-0.0276276823,
-0.0502929017,
0.0497004688,
0.0224278048,
-0.0369188488,
-0.0389242396,
-0.0143154934,
-0.0274098571,
0.0706664324,
-0.0195937566,
-0.0240081977,
-0.0179173201,
-0.0099084647,
-0.0224139113,
0.0021644386,
-0.0227805153,
0.0315582342,
0.0046901489,
0.030540416,
-0.0298007242,
-0.0568563752,
0.0591589622,
-0.0508684218,
0.0034233588,
-0.0375570878,
-0.0090691783,
-0.0630840436,
0.0990723744,
-0.0044968752,
-0.0156450104,
-0.0394463539,
-0.0105000976,
-0.0417423286,
0.0055145202,
-0.0055799186,
-0.0470112413,
0.0777600557,
-0.0502384938,
0.0171257611,
-0.034506619,
-0.0498129986,
-0.0384751149,
0.0251653977,
-0.0052148062,
0.0315679051,
0.0038538596,
0.0009246236,
-0.0086273653,
-0.0035369536,
0.0128963487,
0.032975968,
-0.0258818176,
0.027281614,
-0.0181197897,
0.020458268,
0.0373051576,
0.0015497233,
0.0075834235,
-0.052998852,
0.0442812033,
0.0570832901,
0.0672489107,
-0.0101921335,
-0.0065455656,
0.0091894977,
0.0259291008,
-0.0513440296,
-0.0235037133,
0.0457294025,
0.0749292523,
-0.0899500847,
-0.0339889042,
0.1282634288,
0.0231233519,
-0.0457432792,
-0.0056799855,
-0.0066683851,
0.0134186363,
0.0332278237,
0.0391867757,
-0.0944440588,
-0.0400458463,
0.0151622733,
-0.0039444873,
-0.0097712195,
-0.0207210351,
-0.0051253033,
-0.1264143437,
0.0223266874,
0.0050728396,
-0.0517845713,
-0.0144969653,
-0.0328031182,
-0.0084456336,
0.0231588427,
0.0457157902,
0.0374412946,
-0.0103145763,
-0.0136632035,
0.0031536673,
0.0034175718,
-0.0258003939,
0.1032355055,
-0.0099879857,
0.0470782593,
0.0125212185,
0.0020875293,
-0.0049355146,
-0.0538559891,
0.0551228374,
-0.0614138469,
0.0089896973,
-0.0048920726,
0.0206169244,
-0.0098983347,
-0.0024373871,
-0.0041046343,
0.0173823517,
-0.041457314,
-0.0031214948,
0.0550138094,
0.1041707471,
-0.0307792556,
0.003462371,
-0.0220160484,
-0.0203814749,
-0.0127435196,
0.0719383135,
0.0145612061,
-0.0097015221,
-0.0535434671,
-0.0337005518,
-0.0420623459,
-0.0497026667,
0.001600444,
0.0283350721,
-0.0013364041,
0.0353105739,
-0.0211802293,
-0.0433222577,
0.047088895,
0.0554656945,
-0.0138740307,
0.0149512626,
-0.0109446235,
0.0099835601,
-0.0765535906,
0.0430238135,
-0.060710106,
0.0396494232,
-0.084752813,
0.0036612041,
0.0200222284,
-0.0041825268,
-0.0158854909,
0.0318747014,
-0.1109751016,
-0.0474541113,
-0.0306989178,
0.0265130699,
0.0219976958,
0.0418521613,
-0.013705791,
-0.0144870747,
0.0394381471,
-0.0414318107,
-0.0288321115,
0.0276569147,
0.0245095398,
0.0012769068,
0.0015094703,
0.0295505635,
-0.0412166044,
0.0146455355,
0.0354482494,
0.0406186357,
-0.0023901972,
-0.011084076,
0.0138155799,
0.0363672525,
0.0085672801,
0.0309996866,
-0.0142012173,
0.008280389,
0.0597014278,
-0.028606372,
-0.0080742072,
-0.014784487,
-0.0045448048,
0.0227550417,
-0.0470863134,
0.0162228644,
-0.0130961565,
0.0197781157,
0.0156544261,
-0.0286990106,
0.0419958048,
-0.003881742,
0.0033645721,
0.022000771,
-0.011179762,
-0.0307010226,
-0.0221353266,
-0.0095636714,
0.0607822947,
-0.0206315294,
0.0838188529,
0.0044631884,
0.013087024,
-0.004666178,
0.0177969243,
-0.0788806304,
-0.0215798523,
0.0099528246,
0.0205415972,
0.0482550673,
0.0016733295,
0.0131463716,
-0.0053999866,
-0.0002344466,
-0.0305494741,
0.0069304504,
0.0058785737,
-0.0401971526,
0.035498675,
0.0765486211,
0.0095561827,
0.0250199772,
0.0739615932,
0.020115871,
0.0420428105,
0.0414630473,
0.012268723,
-0.0377647057,
-0.0450057536,
-0.0130435228,
0.0233245082,
-0.0029126843,
0.007897499,
-0.0444701761,
-0.0857856274,
0.0075944327,
0.0214790236,
-0.0018114115,
-0.0126345782,
0.0184460394,
0.0726207718,
0.0031060041,
-0.0521870442,
-0.028061945,
0.0089737559,
-0.0109351007,
-0.011613097,
-0.0042556846,
-6.102021665e-33,
-0.0273647122,
-0.0228336249,
0.07232517,
-0.0349714719,
-0.0244775265,
0.0185380466,
-0.0258416664,
-0.0102242874,
-0.0150057673,
-0.0097745908,
-0.0289050601,
0.0279488564,
0.00351978,
0.0435197949,
-0.0071994197,
-0.0297085345,
0.0038655177,
0.0145628406,
0.0010291593,
0.037665043,
0.0152172009,
-0.0089056306,
0.0403932929,
-0.0086296033,
0.0206867363,
-0.0100840004,
0.0307196863,
0.0147227151,
-0.0682726279,
0.0779491439,
-0.0048784399,
0.0398653783,
0.0377700105,
-0.0585708618,
0.0033454667,
-0.0145801883,
-0.0583185814,
-0.0399568006,
0.0287233889,
-0.0137059484,
-0.0362796709,
-0.0541314706,
0.0159348585,
0.0131646395,
-0.0199718345,
-0.0454413258,
-0.0033970671,
-0.0330736674,
-0.0276342984,
-0.0040127346,
-0.0157264899,
0.0316472426,
-0.0012437222,
0.0013789788,
0.0131282713,
0.0152086336,
0.0004297846,
0.0203957818,
-0.030388331,
0.0066861496,
0.0027966714,
0.0645319894,
0.0751880109,
-0.0078831008,
0.0136417728,
0.0304863602,
0.0078054434,
0.0246225391,
-0.0025032551,
-0.0201091245,
0.010122275,
0.066372402,
0.0362585858,
0.0178631973,
0.0366685502,
0.0078893173,
-0.0879472643,
0.0088393772,
0.0337452479,
0.0451774076,
0.0258324724,
-0.0068588112,
-0.0514773615,
-0.0143019883,
-0.0483028181,
0.034833964,
-0.0391149893,
-0.0120328795,
0.0558625348,
-0.0137017574,
0.0154420733,
-0.010903039,
0.0388823785,
-0.037284568,
-0.003241041,
0.0238190144,
0.0000583303,
0.0105988597,
-0.0040404699,
0.0626343861,
-0.025247328,
-0.0319432169,
0.0024387012,
-0.0144909965,
0.0198962055,
-0.0132811926,
0.0210191049,
0.0087855533,
-0.0569310524,
-0.0371780843,
-0.07637804,
0.0170005895,
-0.0241308212,
0.0179470815,
0.0439521968,
0.0249297898,
0.0221905895,
0.081963025,
-0.023308685,
-0.0277785286,
-0.0230190642,
-0.0215828829,
-0.0028324185,
0.0029775789,
-0.0116878003,
0.0085522179,
-0.0314331278,
0.0245712791,
-0.0034393533,
-0.0422187112,
0.0111653293,
0.042641934,
2.709e-7,
0.0229737405,
0.028732311,
0.0237745661,
0.0422878265,
0.0139839463,
-0.0033937343,
-0.0344628841,
-0.0113118282,
0.0015284496,
-0.0271919034,
-0.0080100289,
0.043321304,
0.0496073477,
0.0400661044,
-0.064110741,
0.0216659438,
-0.0141195478,
-0.0148741966,
-0.0545942448,
0.0254526064,
0.0642057508,
0.0960313156,
-0.0122724306,
-0.0051670116,
0.0042330124,
-0.0497326627,
0.0258140229,
-0.045075357,
-0.0322349593,
0.0190734547,
0.0146187581,
0.0125944568,
0.016530415,
0.028379865,
0.0060107964,
0.0096459175,
-0.0308993291,
0.0810730234,
0.0223817937,
-0.0592429712,
-0.0066535827,
-0.0531218834,
-0.0251156017,
-0.0374221727,
0.1145654172,
-0.0271150749,
-0.0390402637,
-0.0204871055,
-0.0123860398,
-0.0468808934,
-0.0130816111,
0.0190590248,
0.01309318,
0.0052369693,
-0.0028999508,
-0.0513741374,
0.0075016231,
-0.0901015326,
-0.0132518243,
0.0248233993,
-0.0415627621,
-0.0637463927,
-0.0555144846,
-0.0058997958,
0.0297820382,
-0.0696131736,
-0.0325225778,
2.970708175e-34,
0.0397830829,
-0.0292854067,
0.0302004181,
-0.0005787369,
0.0398381092,
-0.0181042608,
-0.0568653829,
0.0031590473,
0.0015138277,
-0.0928453356,
-0.0190568026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17574v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17574v1 | Beyond Text-to-SQL for IoT Defense: A Comprehensive Framework for Querying and Classifying IoT Threats | 2024-06-25T14:14:35 | 2024-06-25T14:14:35 | Ryan Pavlich, Nima Ebadi, Richard Tarbell, Billy Linares, Adrian Tan, Rachael Humphreys, Jayanta Kumar Das, Rambod Ghandiparsi, Hannah Haley, Jerris George, Rocky Slavin, Kim-Kwang Raymond Choo, Glenn Dietrich, Anthony Rios | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recognizing the promise of natural language interfaces to databases, prior
studies have emphasized the development of text-to-SQL systems. While
substantial progress has been made in this field, existing research has
concentrated on generating SQL statements from text queries. The broader
challenge, however, lies in inferring new information about the returned data.
Our research makes two major contributions to address this gap. First, we
introduce a novel Internet-of-Things (IoT) text-to-SQL dataset comprising
10,985 text-SQL pairs and 239,398 rows of network traffic activity. The dataset
contains additional query types limited in prior text-to-SQL datasets, notably
temporal-related queries. Our dataset is sourced from a smart building's IoT
ecosystem exploring sensor read and network traffic data. Second, our dataset
allows two-stage processing, where the returned data (network traffic) from a
generated SQL can be categorized as malicious or not. Our results show that
joint training to query and infer information about the data can improve
overall text-to-SQL performance, nearly matching substantially larger models.
We also show that current large language models (e.g., GPT3.5) struggle to
infer new information about returned data, thus our dataset provides a novel
test bed for integrating complex domain-specific reasoning into LLMs. | Beyond Text-to-SQL for IoT Defense: A Comprehensive Framework for Querying and Classifying IoT Threats: Recognizing the promise of natural language interfaces to databases, prior
studies have emphasized the development of text-to-SQL systems. While
substantial progress has been made in this field, existing research has
concentrated on generating SQL statements from text queries. The broader
challenge, however, lies in inferring new information about the returned data.
Our research makes two major contributions to address this gap. First, we
introduce a novel Internet-of-Things (IoT) text-to-SQL dataset comprising
10,985 text-SQL pairs and 239,398 rows of network traffic activity. The dataset
contains additional query types limited in prior text-to-SQL datasets, notably
temporal-related queries. Our dataset is sourced from a smart building's IoT
ecosystem exploring sensor read and network traffic data. Second, our dataset
allows two-stage processing, where the returned data (network traffic) from a
generated SQL can be categorized as malicious or not. Our results show that
joint training to query and infer information about the data can improve
overall text-to-SQL performance, nearly matching substantially larger models.
We also show that current large language models (e.g., GPT3.5) struggle to
infer new information about returned data, thus our dataset provides a novel
test bed for integrating complex domain-specific reasoning into LLMs. | [
-0.0100571951,
0.0795632824,
-0.0079133594,
0.0268057492,
-0.0587800108,
-0.0195292793,
0.0060460125,
0.0056741703,
0.0422976017,
-0.0695841163,
0.0443086103,
0.0229053386,
-0.0243227091,
0.0337019078,
0.0596829839,
0.0150076458,
0.0611094981,
-0.0128849801,
-0.010458136,
0.0603797883,
0.003914217,
0.0244474653,
-0.002485848,
0.0072540208,
-0.008166167,
-0.0024600863,
-0.0333219767,
0.0215474404,
0.0202801153,
-0.0512565561,
0.002367422,
0.0156544074,
0.0466859452,
0.0171400607,
0.0000016931,
-0.0475457273,
-0.0657954589,
0.0052601793,
-0.0337176695,
-0.0428242311,
0.029058015,
-0.0366328098,
0.0139750037,
0.0630579069,
-0.0565735102,
-0.0073319948,
0.0286606234,
0.0790305883,
0.0227332246,
0.1003995538,
-0.0307520535,
-0.0192445591,
0.0340566523,
-0.0064706956,
0.0410431288,
-0.0094843525,
-0.0010651388,
-0.0293947645,
0.0271165837,
0.011504082,
0.037411239,
-0.0368211269,
0.0046169795,
0.0178671237,
-0.0123883402,
0.0234071799,
-0.0278978888,
0.0669077635,
-0.0419161655,
0.026164202,
-0.0052539078,
-0.0304177478,
0.0408122838,
-0.0065316409,
-0.0234096367,
-0.0316607617,
0.0025384186,
-0.0297011621,
0.0159756932,
0.028366074,
0.005488622,
0.006004408,
0.0553846173,
0.0244958177,
-0.0495188646,
0.0799290612,
-0.0270498674,
-0.0131988181,
0.0174960215,
-0.0596915744,
0.0129984831,
-0.0301665161,
-0.0201351196,
0.0678005293,
-0.0164882988,
0.0047438801,
-0.0451444872,
0.0126180612,
0.0103826523,
-0.0264859777,
-0.0285412353,
0.0123467445,
0.0214470588,
0.0365638919,
0.0172076561,
-0.0007504809,
-0.0064911018,
0.0347232558,
-0.0194419622,
-0.0401917435,
-0.0740602985,
-0.0357091501,
-0.0086759618,
0.0545872822,
-0.002385119,
-0.0062985192,
-0.0177800134,
0.0172864981,
0.0034390122,
0.0282748546,
-0.0314144865,
0.0117052626,
0.0046237851,
-0.0109395673,
-0.0127127813,
-0.0347280987,
-0.0021235358,
0.051363457,
-0.0274291448,
-0.0853062943,
-0.0347207747,
0.0166802648,
-0.0051311981,
-0.0587451756,
-0.0333723798,
0.0972475037,
0.0138819283,
-0.0227332041,
-0.0846805051,
-0.0801815763,
0.0209090058,
-0.0111022955,
0.0035846166,
-0.0299562197,
-0.0020689501,
-0.008581643,
-0.0056028487,
-0.0599806271,
-0.012607906,
0.0095936032,
-0.0046358067,
0.0796269402,
-0.0481031202,
-0.0005769819,
-0.0047094319,
0.0045084385,
0.0338040404,
0.0360222794,
0.056781996,
0.0194252357,
0.0009752513,
-0.0031751022,
0.0189111177,
0.0042827083,
0.052926112,
-0.0169847924,
-0.0326450244,
0.0663026124,
-0.0461758152,
-0.0076637929,
-0.0397974364,
0.0119449785,
0.0299002603,
0.0021551352,
0.0439159013,
0.0228914544,
0.0035011228,
0.0205321703,
-0.015378844,
0.0842347518,
-0.0141050452,
-0.0330536179,
-0.0767917559,
-0.003283106,
-0.0579739027,
-0.0262410603,
0.0113115367,
-0.0389820747,
-0.0186853483,
-0.0455603302,
-0.0226521231,
-0.0318535417,
0.0270961504,
-0.0019628133,
0.0285815652,
0.0309406873,
-0.00586322,
0.0162537694,
-0.019494161,
0.0000467157,
-0.0162629355,
-0.0500896983,
-0.0161798391,
0.0636864305,
0.032088507,
-0.086316891,
-0.0050763683,
-0.0244932976,
-0.0049821609,
0.0045875991,
0.0037511601,
0.0151641527,
0.0226185061,
-0.0120579191,
-0.0132770063,
0.0280597489,
0.0551772565,
-0.0429316685,
-0.0230109822,
-0.0096034063,
0.0270340797,
-0.0622362643,
-0.045988854,
0.0273485184,
0.0319167301,
-0.067556195,
0.0508699678,
0.0347840786,
0.0458576381,
-0.0057946858,
0.013377727,
0.0284787454,
0.0497196838,
0.0007073157,
-0.083690688,
0.0015713032,
0.0363774411,
0.0240682829,
-0.0122500351,
0.0095018577,
0.022283379,
0.0072730291,
-0.0666389391,
-0.0157726277,
0.0585283488,
-0.0427381657,
-0.0031387075,
-0.0140693402,
-0.0543733463,
0.0255926438,
-0.0020913281,
-0.0159217771,
0.0218937974,
0.0254975036,
-0.0457859077,
-0.0095768496,
-0.0367404744,
0.0386646017,
-0.0451524444,
0.0332725421,
-0.0563449673,
-0.0361782163,
0.0275201481,
0.0081770141,
0.0403421633,
-0.0109527921,
0.0188960694,
-0.046194315,
0.0307385121,
-0.0231366586,
0.0666038245,
0.0055496097,
0.0261749402,
-0.0150641445,
-0.0269100312,
-0.0625338554,
-0.0318696648,
-0.0178541169,
-0.005089913,
0.0646046773,
0.0133626619,
-0.0012928639,
-0.0098429043,
-0.004760941,
-0.0485372879,
0.0538172312,
-0.0186217111,
-0.0144268218,
0.0189935192,
0.0190158077,
-0.0019055988,
0.0116596678,
-0.0276028384,
-0.0158119127,
0.0143603133,
-0.0420268029,
-0.0311776791,
0.02915271,
0.0253208075,
-0.0176597573,
0.0332708918,
-0.0245108232,
-0.0417215191,
0.0275692586,
-0.0362099819,
0.0150448363,
-0.033123143,
-0.0083144577,
0.0375332199,
0.0106184324,
0.0314929299,
-0.0190653913,
-0.0317259394,
0.035192892,
0.0598068833,
-0.009855995,
-0.0447336696,
0.0286869965,
0.0262778495,
0.0260068327,
0.0262698904,
-0.0686683506,
0.0818478614,
-0.0027740877,
0.0492419861,
-0.0436101481,
-0.0443302467,
-0.0354634449,
0.0823945254,
0.0097712912,
0.0062527708,
0.0127125168,
-0.0358657241,
-0.0234490708,
-0.0682533681,
0.005525582,
-0.0025912728,
0.0300128423,
-0.0564547107,
0.0164552107,
-0.0117834602,
-0.0206738971,
-0.0444141068,
-0.006959354,
-0.0408039354,
-0.0044577578,
-0.0487693362,
-0.0117318379,
-0.0010041419,
-0.0099250032,
-0.0181117672,
0.0264489092,
-0.0178451352,
-0.026763238,
0.0066200676,
-0.028231591,
0.0339804664,
-0.0029366233,
-0.0379835777,
0.0477743074,
-0.0072710724,
0.0441151373,
0.0619928204,
-0.0247488283,
-0.0647976473,
0.0115926852,
-0.0106119355,
-0.0135110458,
-0.007825518,
0.0487758182,
0.0047637532,
-0.0588209219,
-0.0034041794,
0.0884085372,
0.0082562473,
0.057801228,
0.0005039798,
0.020439364,
-0.0037088285,
-0.0091176713,
0.0169287454,
-0.0999218822,
-0.0601296686,
-0.0049108099,
0.0550436676,
-0.0071071805,
-0.0528848693,
-0.0538007468,
-0.0913310871,
0.0243168455,
0.0159244891,
0.0080974689,
-0.060964372,
-0.0449895822,
-0.0211094934,
-0.0402789228,
0.0141957207,
-0.0261493307,
0.028206652,
-0.0066169263,
0.0023880443,
-0.0476742275,
-0.0409160741,
0.0007365241,
-0.0048501613,
0.0140413893,
0.0398504697,
0.0522925779,
0.0148186134,
0.0215338524,
0.0259789005,
-0.0255479887,
-0.0080287252,
-0.0208689701,
0.0569091216,
0.0221371166,
0.0374798961,
0.0184085891,
0.0756396577,
-0.0431543738,
-0.0328147635,
0.046184618,
0.0590120591,
-0.1025707647,
0.0028904385,
-0.0335131884,
-0.0386462323,
0.0468575284,
0.0668923333,
-0.0384168774,
0.0027587181,
-0.0577099919,
-0.036177814,
-0.0226005428,
-0.0234153308,
-0.0328452848,
0.0187896676,
0.0002089736,
-0.0531793907,
-0.0258781575,
-0.0220740847,
0.0087727476,
0.0033046897,
0.0301752165,
0.0475698858,
0.0300779976,
-0.004249224,
-0.0553471372,
-0.0138485376,
-0.0133975269,
0.0370321795,
-0.0112522515,
0.0258625001,
0.0101356544,
-0.051255852,
-0.0341581404,
0.0332260877,
-0.0947687402,
-0.0478355512,
-0.0118051516,
0.0034953363,
0.0256850813,
0.0347429253,
-0.038414631,
-0.0232328083,
0.0314414538,
0.0760279596,
-0.0536186658,
-0.0834002569,
0.0498580039,
-0.009723871,
0.0181608386,
0.0424923636,
-0.0616274811,
0.0030600491,
0.0007354545,
-0.0341473669,
-0.0482057594,
0.0127276452,
0.0534042045,
0.0397759825,
0.0772907212,
0.038572073,
-0.0030866098,
-0.0076798578,
0.0281732194,
-0.0220113583,
-0.0197023544,
-0.0058229361,
0.034294337,
-0.0024336462,
0.0184693001,
-0.0102309324,
-0.0106388079,
0.0077586486,
-0.004956631,
-0.0270998068,
-0.008632767,
0.04132808,
0.0392964371,
0.0411472246,
-0.042409949,
0.0230724066,
0.0469840877,
0.0272847489,
0.0383513011,
-0.0422488078,
-0.016394496,
0.0305754878,
0.0058016446,
-0.0472090803,
0.031224167,
-0.0463276692,
-0.0306639206,
0.0531387553,
-0.0020962541,
0.0186755266,
0.0054361289,
0.0152099868,
-0.0554585233,
0.0263957437,
-0.0248083305,
0.0493054613,
-0.0031044453,
0.013650924,
0.0321259126,
0.0063252193,
-0.0502865948,
0.0049177213,
0.0486564264,
0.0171073303,
0.0378072299,
0.0192466583,
-0.0756073147,
-0.0556061007,
-0.0165629201,
0.0046421764,
0.0107226539,
-0.0105129322,
0.0081341295,
-0.035083048,
-0.0187147316,
0.0081592062,
-0.0041140984,
0.0015301746,
-0.0009766473,
0.0430853702,
0.0687700734,
-0.0005486364,
-0.0203301013,
-0.0505071655,
-0.0124780405,
-0.0281564873,
-0.0550276898,
-0.0004080033,
-5.538227023e-33,
0.0215802267,
-0.0237337276,
0.0272295866,
0.0176647734,
0.018200865,
-0.019343609,
0.0044506369,
-0.0487771891,
-0.0317955464,
-0.0197467152,
-0.0299077649,
0.0457449183,
0.0158467088,
0.0376289226,
-0.0132221477,
-0.051089853,
0.0358213969,
-0.0155434022,
0.0041459529,
0.0165648125,
0.0706337392,
-0.00411072,
0.0498862229,
-0.0744038522,
0.0272783134,
-0.001106517,
-0.0349949412,
0.0338901952,
-0.051050093,
0.0329038836,
0.0022845464,
0.062947087,
0.0235721841,
0.0138838012,
-0.0223116912,
0.0076272148,
-0.0313741043,
-0.0280390121,
-0.0235369671,
-0.0050315675,
-0.0005752313,
-0.0619244687,
0.0581642799,
0.0034516528,
-0.0318803489,
-0.0029906654,
0.0357195251,
-0.0371706486,
0.0203033052,
-0.0297907591,
-0.0043681101,
0.0351830348,
-0.0496269129,
0.0152242957,
0.0053885523,
0.0056986054,
0.0299666803,
-0.0009540929,
-0.0859054774,
0.03424979,
0.0207576044,
0.0472262576,
0.0235309955,
-0.0169737618,
0.0010499819,
0.0099097891,
-0.0013285441,
-0.0534945652,
0.0118469298,
0.0534842834,
-0.0174765401,
0.0637344867,
0.013957236,
0.041505307,
0.0439158492,
-0.0427280255,
-0.1307906955,
0.0473757088,
-0.0163567998,
0.0216315072,
0.0270770937,
-0.0252134837,
-0.0453525707,
-0.0220076703,
-0.0020845735,
-0.013515438,
-0.0088482676,
0.008208557,
0.0084930565,
0.0000905138,
0.0188841242,
-0.0158680771,
-0.0134700844,
-0.011869804,
-0.0431006774,
0.0329205543,
-0.0333370268,
-0.0586166233,
0.0197353624,
0.0417003334,
-0.0205089133,
-0.0223985761,
0.0258545261,
-0.0038041414,
0.034072753,
-0.0130291209,
0.0399524271,
0.0794264823,
-0.0610436127,
-0.019179035,
0.0016733084,
0.0675752237,
-0.0544784032,
0.0246493071,
0.0145158535,
-0.0033376298,
0.0451476015,
0.0653215349,
-0.0308207832,
-0.0401905626,
-0.0043135672,
0.0338770598,
0.0010064841,
0.0099713337,
0.0046702251,
0.0082743149,
-0.0218329318,
-0.0119365854,
0.0528991073,
-0.0338885114,
-0.0046169832,
0.0222983379,
2.67e-7,
0.0406157076,
0.0105257723,
0.0117743472,
0.0759116709,
0.0237420369,
0.0874878019,
-0.0112671405,
0.0660476685,
-0.0024577181,
0.0175352674,
0.0240270812,
-0.0215927418,
0.0546423681,
0.0378421135,
-0.0436945483,
-0.0100076338,
-0.0336586721,
-0.0173646137,
-0.076979503,
0.0034353368,
0.1087805927,
0.1130377576,
0.0098885763,
-0.002885276,
0.0279642828,
-0.0728647634,
-0.012530827,
-0.0115898466,
0.009276229,
0.008246284,
0.0528858788,
0.030324392,
0.0161842816,
0.0543175191,
-0.0490781143,
0.0266903024,
-0.0641676262,
0.033287067,
0.0165531971,
-0.0058780247,
-0.0260076635,
-0.0670037344,
0.0233129412,
-0.0166285206,
0.0914152712,
-0.020114867,
-0.0117439386,
0.0545173101,
0.0187441632,
-0.0352568403,
-0.0062337066,
0.0051134918,
-0.0239746682,
-0.0541895777,
0.0202487502,
0.0023829786,
0.0331735499,
-0.0594314486,
-0.0001825032,
0.0095132152,
-0.0260596406,
0.0193822216,
-0.0250611454,
0.031519793,
0.0469944514,
-0.0023920075,
0.0023906645,
2.435380242e-34,
-0.0120948935,
-0.0021422787,
-0.0174072701,
-0.0220729541,
0.0331128724,
0.0162445791,
0.0013802639,
-0.0144805107,
0.016945621,
-0.0434067361,
-0.0288989004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17566v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17566v1 | FrenchToxicityPrompts: a Large Benchmark for Evaluating and Mitigating Toxicity in French Texts | 2024-06-25T14:02:11 | 2024-06-25T14:02:11 | Caroline Brun, Vassilina Nikoulina | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly popular but are also prone to
generating bias, toxic or harmful language, which can have detrimental effects
on individuals and communities. Although most efforts is put to assess and
mitigate toxicity in generated content, it is primarily concentrated on
English, while it's essential to consider other languages as well. For
addressing this issue, we create and release FrenchToxicityPrompts, a dataset
of 50K naturally occurring French prompts and their continuations, annotated
with toxicity scores from a widely used toxicity classifier. We evaluate 14
different models from four prevalent open-sourced families of LLMs against our
dataset to assess their potential toxicity across various dimensions. We hope
that our contribution will foster future research on toxicity detection and
mitigation beyond Englis | FrenchToxicityPrompts: a Large Benchmark for Evaluating and Mitigating Toxicity in French Texts: Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly popular but are also prone to
generating bias, toxic or harmful language, which can have detrimental effects
on individuals and communities. Although most efforts is put to assess and
mitigate toxicity in generated content, it is primarily concentrated on
English, while it's essential to consider other languages as well. For
addressing this issue, we create and release FrenchToxicityPrompts, a dataset
of 50K naturally occurring French prompts and their continuations, annotated
with toxicity scores from a widely used toxicity classifier. We evaluate 14
different models from four prevalent open-sourced families of LLMs against our
dataset to assess their potential toxicity across various dimensions. We hope
that our contribution will foster future research on toxicity detection and
mitigation beyond Englis | [
0.0238831881,
0.0805670917,
-0.0239410903,
0.0213706624,
0.0065387967,
0.0279656071,
0.0190036204,
0.016264027,
0.0576450713,
-0.0327187292,
-0.016068127,
0.0070245517,
-0.0272108223,
-0.0009474151,
0.0392999388,
0.005511885,
0.0530962348,
0.010543474,
-0.0113281338,
-0.0169098955,
0.0502894334,
0.0494557321,
0.0350458883,
0.0739874169,
-0.021789046,
-0.0228740703,
0.0623888634,
0.0209639762,
0.037294548,
-0.0500525832,
0.0062277406,
0.034152627,
-0.0442352518,
0.0455260016,
0.0000018137,
-0.0221001767,
0.011324835,
0.0023293267,
0.0045083743,
-0.0151853496,
0.0843210071,
-0.0168582462,
-0.0272402614,
0.0405861996,
-0.0044521624,
0.0014972088,
0.0562102906,
-0.0023618718,
0.0561106727,
0.0485026538,
-0.027092414,
0.0172131862,
-0.0122291381,
0.0035758161,
0.0150865037,
0.0474986359,
0.0677750334,
-0.0569194965,
-0.0092169885,
-0.0167807043,
-0.0455536917,
0.0290068332,
0.0166371241,
-0.034078449,
-0.0390972868,
-0.0203490369,
0.0114408489,
-0.0599271394,
0.0157315899,
0.0717734918,
-0.017232256,
-0.024445558,
-0.0126349833,
0.0070991656,
0.0111431936,
0.0044110185,
-0.0211794544,
0.0160091389,
0.0229295846,
0.0044513196,
0.0330238082,
0.005628984,
0.0342244357,
0.0249583274,
0.0326460339,
0.0451917164,
0.0195805617,
-0.020052297,
0.0518893749,
-0.0152668841,
-0.0270847362,
-0.0130119519,
0.0209859218,
-0.0422271453,
-0.0380127914,
0.0238703955,
-0.0280046295,
-0.0390676856,
0.0596265048,
-0.0973384082,
0.0044688983,
0.0097161559,
-0.0606461726,
0.0130932583,
0.0061678933,
-0.0269234031,
0.0004848116,
0.0112613337,
-0.0266095158,
0.0284880064,
0.021900991,
-0.0004208546,
0.0015777305,
-0.0429848246,
0.0100555494,
0.0386833511,
-0.012811874,
0.0043257447,
-0.0507071763,
-0.0040868348,
0.0322037153,
0.0125163877,
0.011158146,
0.0230381154,
-0.0006044963,
0.0215906724,
-0.0359363519,
0.0258886684,
-0.0160656944,
-0.0772074535,
0.0178542286,
0.0132409381,
-0.0484339669,
-0.0449158028,
0.0078660641,
0.1001277044,
0.0222459659,
0.0061325147,
-0.0161382928,
-0.0338506997,
-0.0646478832,
-0.034926679,
-0.0551491305,
-0.0697267801,
0.0035911149,
-0.0320219547,
0.0117674917,
-0.0937856957,
0.0266160071,
0.0264373943,
-0.0785806626,
0.030316554,
-0.0484676287,
-0.0123949144,
0.0405644774,
0.0386713445,
-0.0384984612,
0.0682226643,
0.0050196983,
0.0006273434,
0.0232440699,
-0.0202527791,
-0.0301644802,
0.0777862817,
0.0162073709,
0.0448942408,
-0.0341742486,
-0.0098734144,
0.007520359,
-0.0334808715,
0.0159760658,
0.0719193071,
0.0032126086,
-0.014910589,
0.0828988701,
-0.0045526982,
-0.0448903516,
0.026526155,
0.0269647744,
0.0081635481,
-0.0131054437,
-0.0221567713,
-0.0565603971,
-0.0385049805,
-0.0475912802,
-0.056688711,
0.0287737083,
0.0249238908,
0.0157544557,
-0.051372733,
-0.0063851452,
0.0293073393,
0.0630070418,
-0.0082924357,
0.0167878326,
0.0093393726,
-0.0071974802,
-0.0050210967,
0.0617730692,
-0.0751546398,
0.0291813239,
0.0455746762,
0.0358123407,
0.0823052675,
0.0444686413,
-0.0160234962,
0.0064796126,
-0.0596256368,
0.003230491,
0.0116394442,
0.0007243276,
-0.0180123616,
0.0026792993,
-0.0102378447,
-0.034705244,
0.0368075036,
0.0075353333,
-0.0170313567,
-0.0205412004,
0.0682438239,
-0.0224788245,
-0.0054530757,
-0.0912386626,
0.0361821093,
-0.0214930382,
-0.0552461147,
-0.0174217224,
0.0237244107,
0.0019565711,
0.0023581318,
-0.0344571061,
-0.0119185308,
0.0204135161,
-0.0227113366,
0.0021410726,
0.0166408308,
-0.0251059271,
-0.015870491,
0.0398951136,
-0.0390094109,
-0.0401839763,
0.0369988941,
-0.0113908192,
0.0148758162,
0.0114575215,
-0.0445545577,
-0.0050620562,
-0.0063083,
0.0046121147,
-0.0106359078,
0.0263426136,
-0.0198269971,
0.0368642285,
-0.021120904,
0.0378888994,
0.0191145912,
-0.0366873816,
-0.0128476769,
-0.0171758346,
-0.072937578,
-0.0182115436,
-0.024317896,
0.0152858077,
0.046165552,
0.0336286314,
-0.0159371812,
0.0139582651,
-0.0331808403,
-0.0403585024,
-0.0240928978,
0.0107739577,
0.020166371,
-0.0115969945,
-0.0278787073,
0.0056325309,
-0.0435812213,
-0.0504442006,
-0.0092472862,
0.0461939871,
-0.0261157267,
-0.0121503612,
-0.0179189015,
-0.0071926676,
0.0044349325,
-0.0372360051,
0.0583653152,
-0.0128762601,
-0.0281209927,
0.0043867393,
0.040141467,
-0.0277393181,
-0.0270729978,
0.0235457961,
-0.0677865595,
0.0118768858,
-0.0011035342,
0.0242252722,
0.038829349,
0.0236424319,
0.0427516699,
0.0473794043,
0.0040565911,
-0.0297956243,
-0.0169839729,
-0.0278831441,
-0.0271880124,
-0.0300998967,
-0.1002947167,
-0.0222533494,
0.0272765309,
0.0135978498,
-0.0043492597,
-0.0245159958,
0.067482166,
-0.0670204759,
-0.0495900922,
-0.0424081124,
-0.0273641758,
-0.017660277,
0.0074692559,
-0.0118314857,
-0.025295943,
0.041494403,
0.0166634321,
0.0203003231,
-0.0005783807,
-0.0091471151,
0.0422214568,
0.006900013,
0.0024316858,
0.0543945692,
0.0532905646,
-0.0220676139,
-0.0187539123,
0.0105951633,
0.0556914471,
-0.0077646379,
0.0388093144,
-0.0314413756,
-0.0256773066,
0.0188578311,
-0.067417644,
-0.0394950546,
-0.0366491415,
-0.0152120683,
-0.0244186632,
0.0337391347,
0.0142795527,
-0.0022429032,
-0.017872259,
-0.0011887562,
-0.0178364236,
0.0018647359,
-0.0179738011,
0.0404950604,
0.0007304335,
0.0433731452,
-0.0404014774,
0.0553279296,
-0.0193354432,
0.0608471744,
0.0953207389,
-0.0521931797,
-0.006371839,
0.0140939932,
0.0246957298,
0.0248385612,
0.0094032893,
-0.0191872679,
0.0070386496,
0.0175741334,
-0.0383004509,
-0.0278542433,
0.0623413101,
-0.0016312988,
-0.015314308,
0.0548748784,
-0.0063727782,
0.039148137,
0.0191727523,
-0.0337992907,
-0.099351421,
0.0057638795,
0.0152195469,
0.0051668724,
-0.0366683416,
-0.0221824497,
0.0417607538,
-0.0879073068,
0.0316162072,
0.0221822467,
-0.0603267848,
0.0291364603,
0.0011076282,
-0.0127390092,
-0.0639999509,
0.0198926851,
-0.0298196226,
0.0022699565,
-0.0406621099,
-0.0027098111,
-0.0453584827,
-0.0469133966,
-0.0195931755,
-0.0182366148,
0.0350910984,
0.0240499955,
-0.0003383678,
-0.0309032276,
0.0062408,
0.0535784997,
-0.0022922261,
-0.0336584039,
-0.0097295698,
0.0441444777,
0.0299816169,
-0.0244886186,
-0.0251347311,
0.0406905487,
-0.008028198,
-0.0193125755,
0.0307870638,
0.0777771845,
0.0140112117,
-0.0005272616,
-0.0358498655,
0.0204513092,
0.0395555273,
0.0760076195,
0.041017279,
-0.0669370964,
-0.0007002715,
-0.0752360821,
-0.0422965623,
-0.0347651988,
-0.0812290534,
0.0100255562,
-0.0286033507,
-0.0788264945,
-0.0656603277,
-0.0137234945,
0.0188755337,
-0.0242023524,
0.0347515717,
-0.0054394151,
-0.0312288199,
0.005722105,
-0.0056652152,
0.0451133028,
0.0256075654,
-0.0003111358,
-0.0674322471,
0.0109114395,
-0.0352571718,
0.0073870881,
-0.0145680429,
0.0296620317,
-0.0561565645,
-0.0860622674,
0.0283703841,
0.0824091211,
0.0086115664,
0.0041443207,
-0.003085797,
-0.0626507699,
0.0759112835,
0.0482754372,
-0.0173665248,
-0.0239890702,
0.0352775231,
-0.0223708227,
0.024961831,
0.0276256874,
-0.0460785218,
0.0262998901,
0.0324932337,
0.0317411348,
-0.0465084724,
-0.0120331952,
0.0158833098,
0.0331875756,
0.034483999,
-0.0614698678,
0.0067477757,
-0.0377702713,
-0.0193602759,
-0.0192923583,
-0.0158201158,
0.0234786011,
0.0501511469,
0.0323241241,
0.0031377203,
-0.0124892602,
-0.0097123561,
-0.0002799159,
0.0206713006,
-0.0506587029,
0.0314154178,
0.0358572789,
0.0179268606,
0.0666545033,
0.0419992507,
0.0021286823,
0.0267679654,
-0.0003628532,
0.0065487972,
-0.0253659301,
-0.0001286577,
0.021264432,
0.0281632151,
0.0469832756,
0.0322723836,
0.0092347488,
-0.0223900899,
-0.0338659175,
-0.0058388859,
0.0311865974,
-0.0347782038,
0.0803817511,
-0.0119767766,
-0.0216785204,
-0.0433790311,
-0.016065143,
-0.0091148205,
-0.0689964071,
-0.0075480728,
-0.0062792241,
-0.0376565121,
-0.0282531679,
0.0650673509,
-0.0125960791,
0.0474825837,
0.0509709045,
-0.0213719551,
-0.0163353011,
-0.0034855944,
0.0304499492,
0.0077152732,
-0.0503030606,
-0.0088520758,
-0.0671933368,
-0.0770881996,
-0.011014401,
-0.0139940633,
0.0041401689,
0.0158475153,
0.0009894849,
-0.0030050918,
0.0107085826,
0.0102063268,
-0.0273480993,
0.0390371159,
-0.0545031801,
-0.0436446331,
-0.0042628027,
-5.446778705e-33,
0.0351630747,
-0.0249142237,
-0.0466896147,
0.0242961869,
0.0178127531,
-0.0163077749,
-0.0023049056,
0.0086515089,
-0.0190451927,
0.0610277392,
0.0287274551,
-0.0210654754,
-0.0001172297,
0.0219481606,
0.0361887291,
-0.0318684578,
0.0321714878,
0.0130514326,
-0.0347165093,
0.0021778897,
0.0660915673,
0.040383283,
0.0378066339,
-0.093477577,
0.0330859013,
-0.0185958762,
-0.0482119508,
-0.0124090137,
-0.0303096808,
0.0835867748,
0.0097203981,
0.0979419425,
-0.0025154343,
-0.0159857906,
-0.003491092,
0.0553674661,
-0.0300523993,
-0.0350409523,
0.0167944767,
0.0106107462,
-0.0167010445,
-0.055293493,
0.0476222336,
-0.0095298411,
-0.0443475917,
0.0225361418,
0.0270282719,
-0.0523795299,
0.0104706828,
-0.0197729766,
-0.0665155798,
-0.0091660628,
0.0038467713,
0.0005918131,
0.0022545783,
0.1081764549,
0.017653672,
-0.0048850807,
-0.0453439876,
0.0166511927,
-0.033273425,
0.0213319696,
0.0305376314,
-0.0346070267,
0.0136189703,
0.0654602721,
0.0036319532,
0.0186531506,
-0.0030692499,
0.0226037111,
0.0339301452,
0.0021805034,
0.0614123531,
0.0814832225,
0.0112377387,
-0.0373149775,
-0.0673648268,
0.0123881968,
0.0279476829,
0.0117206462,
-0.0084143355,
-0.0396641493,
-0.0253804941,
-0.0468296148,
-0.0332765989,
-0.0142817842,
-0.0099882642,
-0.0168114677,
0.0380733274,
-0.0478798784,
0.0045812638,
-0.0357314534,
0.0063061472,
-0.0321125984,
0.0047982577,
0.0251452569,
0.0081001734,
-0.0139228506,
0.0202680361,
0.0447941497,
-0.050076846,
0.0402542129,
-0.0090816012,
-0.0317663141,
0.0320777781,
0.0135472165,
0.0769346282,
0.01854169,
-0.0550196506,
0.0149327898,
-0.0145674553,
0.0519796945,
0.0401455499,
0.0590081625,
0.0158219244,
-0.0345178694,
0.025483381,
-0.0051353555,
0.0812277868,
0.0340897813,
-0.0110647548,
-0.020004971,
-0.0150288483,
0.019024035,
-0.0318381749,
-0.0122194355,
-0.0256355293,
0.0317987651,
0.0590741113,
-0.0825632438,
-0.0206278935,
-0.056354709,
2.444e-7,
0.0640242919,
0.0367868282,
0.0074312617,
0.0232415888,
0.0085292738,
0.0213988163,
-0.0060974853,
0.0370546095,
-0.0132701602,
0.0032511684,
-0.0050282595,
-0.0279652067,
0.0524063148,
0.0640058741,
-0.0637790263,
0.0103954403,
-0.0986264348,
0.0239528436,
-0.04016684,
0.0017006106,
0.0204903539,
0.0926970765,
-0.0057326667,
-0.0229335502,
-0.0080707297,
-0.0277067963,
0.0188030712,
-0.0680662915,
0.0056507746,
-0.006171097,
0.0364919193,
0.0095848013,
0.0179561786,
-0.0106571279,
-0.0187898465,
-0.0582531169,
0.0127636986,
0.0055525457,
-0.0015419984,
-0.010135252,
0.0237258058,
-0.0657623708,
-0.0022184951,
-0.0597533323,
0.0354242958,
0.037125431,
0.0208690334,
-0.0365787596,
-0.0458863899,
-0.0326416008,
0.0954639167,
-0.0638937876,
-0.0314412341,
0.0052791722,
0.0452658571,
0.0243109241,
0.0122228507,
-0.0362980589,
-0.0335297175,
-0.0179325137,
-0.0032313096,
-0.0648385435,
0.0173906609,
0.0413777754,
-0.0682061091,
-0.0376515612,
0.0082753981,
1.961263652e-34,
0.0072582299,
-0.0281736292,
0.0007212755,
-0.028108811,
0.0364546701,
-0.0079240222,
0.0145768961,
0.0054314327,
-0.0281867757,
-0.0242992006,
-0.0117317243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17563v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17563v1 | Multi-property Steering of Large Language Models with Dynamic Activation Composition | 2024-06-25T14:00:42 | 2024-06-25T14:00:42 | Daniel Scalena, Gabriele Sarti, Malvina Nissim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Activation steering methods were shown to be effective in conditioning
language model generation by additively intervening over models' intermediate
representations. However, the evaluation of these techniques has so far been
limited to single conditioning properties and synthetic settings. In this work,
we conduct a comprehensive evaluation of various activation steering
strategies, highlighting the property-dependent nature of optimal parameters to
ensure a robust effect throughout generation. To address this issue, we propose
Dynamic Activation Composition, an information-theoretic approach to modulate
the steering intensity of one or more properties throughout generation. Our
experiments on multi-property steering show that our method successfully
maintains high conditioning while minimizing the impact of conditioning on
generation fluency. | Multi-property Steering of Large Language Models with Dynamic Activation Composition: Activation steering methods were shown to be effective in conditioning
language model generation by additively intervening over models' intermediate
representations. However, the evaluation of these techniques has so far been
limited to single conditioning properties and synthetic settings. In this work,
we conduct a comprehensive evaluation of various activation steering
strategies, highlighting the property-dependent nature of optimal parameters to
ensure a robust effect throughout generation. To address this issue, we propose
Dynamic Activation Composition, an information-theoretic approach to modulate
the steering intensity of one or more properties throughout generation. Our
experiments on multi-property steering show that our method successfully
maintains high conditioning while minimizing the impact of conditioning on
generation fluency. | [
-0.0118808877,
0.0510781184,
-0.0105659608,
-0.0085758669,
-0.0475663766,
-0.0008930812,
-0.029272547,
-0.0238879751,
-0.0428166017,
-0.0480308793,
-0.0086747538,
-0.0837073326,
-0.013752535,
0.0119614331,
0.041306451,
-0.0565765128,
0.0707159042,
-0.0515489131,
-0.0537863374,
-0.0294297524,
-0.0153108807,
-0.0044275038,
-0.0131000876,
0.0354350507,
-0.0212831683,
-0.0056855856,
-0.0117568308,
0.0052096602,
-0.0083844,
-0.0351501629,
-0.0074237785,
0.0573741496,
0.019163087,
-0.0191582162,
0.0000020137,
-0.0519807152,
-0.0251589064,
-0.0068437993,
0.0192664284,
0.0170147344,
0.0827391446,
-0.005095101,
-0.0315675102,
0.0225589387,
-0.0268171802,
-0.0019674543,
0.0604700372,
0.0344399959,
0.0206157733,
0.0553181395,
-0.0147251757,
-0.037972562,
-0.0014846264,
0.0006152036,
0.001213375,
0.0018786736,
0.026574038,
0.0311028622,
-0.0164022949,
-0.018462237,
-0.029118102,
0.0123287411,
0.0356709212,
0.0013724782,
-0.0146177756,
0.0381614044,
0.009138572,
-0.0126668941,
-0.0276679415,
0.0681514144,
-0.0211737417,
-0.0219744742,
-0.0075542624,
0.0008593245,
-0.0087667974,
-0.0257333722,
-0.0145668508,
-0.010486356,
0.0186431408,
0.0346318483,
0.0312547982,
0.0043172473,
0.0109462254,
0.0106049823,
-0.0512047745,
0.0591639206,
0.0522791632,
-0.0240908973,
-0.0470318235,
-0.0036765065,
-0.0005350685,
-0.0360189043,
-0.0474594571,
0.0113522727,
-0.0112182219,
0.0283488147,
-0.0705499575,
-0.0236606281,
0.0154358475,
-0.0479101688,
0.0432375818,
0.0457392372,
0.0064070625,
0.0056796661,
-0.0334070995,
0.0573165491,
-0.0379275233,
0.0169420149,
-0.0450750664,
0.0145823155,
-0.0443545803,
-0.0062635504,
-0.0441160314,
0.0403505489,
-0.006972834,
-0.0201984458,
-0.0703709573,
0.0389739163,
0.0111024063,
-0.0471601114,
-0.0333186202,
-0.0056782141,
-0.0538690425,
0.0103315394,
0.0211259443,
0.0096703721,
-0.0406909063,
0.0012274577,
0.0043871994,
-0.0440975875,
-0.01842352,
0.037656229,
0.0032687066,
0.0074425456,
-0.0189459808,
0.0759246126,
-0.0331803747,
-0.026352413,
-0.064470388,
-0.0539743826,
0.0043392023,
-0.0460453629,
0.0199087784,
-0.0506024137,
0.0127699198,
0.0065691597,
-0.0233072061,
-0.0741674602,
-0.0030391254,
-0.0002625515,
-0.0189078879,
0.0273295473,
0.0201990828,
0.0135976728,
-0.0174558498,
-0.0100806961,
-0.0117708892,
0.0988265723,
0.0421073847,
0.0053922483,
-0.0124427341,
0.0160676315,
-0.0140066231,
0.0501408055,
0.0359754339,
0.0431751423,
-0.0763537064,
-0.052109655,
0.0373316593,
-0.0058470936,
0.0494552366,
0.0606762134,
-0.0565885231,
0.0396755636,
0.0519433282,
-0.0317128748,
0.0295560565,
0.0337552503,
0.1000781432,
-0.0119614992,
-0.0338671096,
0.0670948476,
-0.0437414125,
0.000200507,
-0.0488209948,
0.0505305901,
-0.0036614726,
0.0772085413,
-0.0208300967,
-0.0361493751,
0.0012947208,
-0.0133192427,
0.0484831221,
-0.0545750037,
0.0291213561,
0.0520246327,
-0.0669428632,
0.0228000451,
0.0514833443,
-0.0413284637,
0.0240649153,
-0.030559117,
0.0141073233,
0.0766869113,
0.0466700532,
0.0304299109,
-0.016379578,
0.0370790958,
0.0280179959,
0.0452533104,
0.027886549,
0.0001547981,
0.0157811008,
-0.0880555809,
-0.0217373986,
-0.0042725219,
0.0371700786,
0.0422389917,
-0.0018195609,
-0.0058858367,
0.0073975804,
-0.0015875255,
0.0089616468,
0.0370113961,
-0.0099018291,
-0.0116495509,
-0.0124107543,
-0.0145850899,
0.0142798787,
-0.0267630294,
-0.0369632728,
0.0280551761,
-0.0050293608,
-0.0362795442,
-0.0150604816,
0.0532074198,
-0.0593285561,
-0.0320721008,
0.0132723078,
0.046980232,
0.0351256914,
-0.0691404566,
0.0046733469,
-0.0471115187,
0.0607700273,
-0.0240226686,
0.067900002,
-0.0288303886,
0.0425293706,
0.0118197305,
0.024334792,
-0.0247484203,
0.0666676909,
-0.0203767233,
-0.0261267573,
0.064357765,
0.0352622345,
0.0022509706,
-0.0339458063,
0.0224300101,
0.0237759855,
0.0040602945,
-0.0085722283,
-0.0047253533,
0.0185869951,
0.0042216829,
-0.0484641008,
-0.0301306956,
-0.02820554,
-0.0359142758,
0.0239842907,
0.0293561015,
0.0153072234,
0.0109412856,
0.0391190127,
-0.0531721674,
-0.0164645184,
-0.0092130024,
0.023368312,
0.0029424066,
-0.0119748963,
-0.0696305111,
-0.029872587,
0.0003524603,
-0.011662744,
0.0505869426,
0.0086315563,
0.0207065661,
-0.0567503907,
-0.0105835451,
-0.0246789698,
0.0523771085,
0.0184054598,
-0.0516182929,
-0.0116756335,
-0.0078636166,
0.088231951,
0.0078877611,
0.0063059768,
-0.0102294078,
0.0677886829,
-0.0209535565,
-0.0534374677,
0.0061158054,
-0.0576080829,
0.0283827297,
-0.0336827412,
-0.0187406968,
0.0048735277,
0.0847427845,
0.0215014331,
0.0025718836,
-0.0901835412,
-0.0008175813,
-0.0299885701,
-0.0568455681,
0.0387110785,
-0.0350749083,
-0.0220702775,
0.038000349,
-0.0187070183,
-0.0566289425,
0.0875502005,
-0.0669336617,
-0.0090054078,
-0.0556634068,
0.0377418995,
0.0003416736,
0.007093004,
0.0124754095,
0.0353846438,
0.0516357645,
0.0145749599,
-0.0627636239,
-0.0302601457,
0.0362084135,
-0.0079732426,
0.0201408137,
-0.035135895,
0.0224526674,
0.0359657966,
-0.0164516792,
-0.0554257706,
-0.0476392694,
0.0369159691,
0.0183452945,
0.0587583259,
-0.0354954936,
0.0183162708,
0.0278465301,
0.0068042567,
0.031271819,
-0.0051678238,
-0.0076465486,
-0.0254304092,
0.0222882275,
0.0610887557,
0.0008931627,
0.0197256319,
-0.0380128436,
0.0194524713,
0.0115957046,
0.0461746603,
0.0240325332,
-0.0311272945,
0.0348991714,
0.0236968379,
0.0058225463,
-0.0157585945,
0.027958788,
0.0281762406,
-0.0358634479,
-0.031372834,
0.0861331746,
0.0318209939,
-0.0346023142,
0.0396252908,
-0.0047193272,
0.0980108902,
0.0130145065,
0.0159065668,
-0.0817662179,
-0.0100342212,
0.0080291815,
0.0153374178,
-0.0250983369,
0.0170487165,
-0.0236849692,
-0.1076600403,
0.0376732163,
0.037066754,
-0.013810344,
-0.0276054572,
-0.0175239965,
-0.0112856273,
0.017404899,
0.0328007899,
0.0220782124,
-0.0104104234,
-0.0120561309,
0.0093502486,
0.0188123714,
-0.0659562796,
-0.0161089618,
-0.0164028369,
0.0447651222,
0.1165239364,
-0.0158958677,
0.0244404934,
-0.0467365794,
0.0506537035,
-0.0141327595,
0.0251566563,
-0.0017093533,
0.0186183378,
0.0180437341,
-0.0014102079,
0.00205099,
0.0408533104,
0.0042145494,
-0.0315285325,
-0.0578781292,
0.0379526131,
-0.0322692432,
-0.018853141,
-0.0290112458,
0.0241899677,
0.0400135927,
0.0587361604,
0.0418683812,
-0.0641885102,
0.0061828583,
0.001805159,
-0.0090216137,
-0.0763639882,
-0.0365541466,
-0.0126843555,
-0.0190349612,
-0.0321464762,
-0.1128859073,
-0.0195214245,
0.0119614536,
0.0394257568,
0.0055340752,
-0.0171549022,
-0.0008496013,
-0.0469416156,
-0.0012570252,
0.0105858687,
-0.0233858097,
0.006871623,
-0.0446216241,
-0.0442891009,
0.0594560318,
-0.0387173854,
0.0078053591,
0.026723437,
-0.0258965101,
-0.1113152504,
0.0179424994,
0.0269869138,
0.0181915145,
0.0756144449,
-0.0282244571,
-0.0254671127,
0.0277167615,
0.0067001772,
0.0046607223,
0.033195734,
0.0325850919,
-0.0204828903,
0.0058492124,
0.0340297446,
-0.0365659706,
0.0527007133,
0.0067152469,
0.0417122245,
-0.0125047844,
0.0191362705,
0.0396006666,
0.0044221291,
-0.0110474769,
-0.0578678995,
0.0377138443,
-0.031949345,
0.0066275401,
-0.0272539798,
-0.0181522835,
-0.0548314005,
0.0252887607,
0.0092833992,
0.0071472465,
-0.0013213266,
-0.0250710379,
0.0100747682,
0.0279103667,
0.0047617918,
-0.0050079697,
-0.0464688651,
0.0023847711,
0.0376028828,
0.0111820735,
0.0124890078,
0.0574550517,
-0.0543202981,
0.006058332,
-0.0311434697,
0.0501761325,
0.0436770804,
-0.0097019924,
-0.070834823,
-0.000590413,
-0.0081463745,
0.0149298022,
-0.0571803749,
0.0148056569,
0.0572745986,
0.016645696,
0.1053875536,
-0.0432490669,
-0.0055282726,
0.0135585014,
0.0315690376,
0.0291534401,
-0.0422929786,
0.0239821989,
0.0213570558,
-0.0277578421,
-0.0115622105,
0.0810421705,
-0.0147196976,
0.0702209398,
-0.0589933135,
0.0482192449,
-0.0086357761,
-0.0248501915,
-0.0120887635,
0.0090591572,
-0.0142500121,
0.0190919377,
-0.0802673027,
-0.0393838808,
-0.0038230231,
-0.0026394462,
0.0127961971,
-0.0168977287,
0.0721837729,
0.0315717384,
-0.0291448981,
-0.0036356917,
-0.0029684594,
-0.0736541077,
0.0243067816,
-0.0035519921,
-0.0339091457,
-6.500311109e-33,
-0.0512352921,
0.0202901494,
0.0190215837,
-0.0160940923,
-0.0249390434,
-0.0208291691,
-0.0357268229,
0.0042767571,
-0.0059182206,
0.010696101,
0.0234411303,
-0.0211316943,
0.0170762427,
0.0169721711,
-0.0048907897,
0.0166466478,
0.0602633022,
-0.0280045122,
-0.0496627502,
0.0225185156,
0.0336621813,
-0.0103498679,
0.0223212615,
-0.0725048333,
-0.0151588209,
0.0015499108,
-0.047512047,
0.0161986016,
-0.0424516574,
0.0620498769,
-0.0080781383,
0.020354433,
0.015713498,
-0.0575917475,
-0.0534170642,
-0.021385774,
-0.0268356297,
-0.0445967317,
0.0228062291,
-0.0052202535,
-0.0620357841,
-0.0308636408,
0.0514908843,
-0.0141277341,
-0.0075747948,
0.0138769401,
0.0108916713,
-0.0190395974,
-0.0157670546,
-0.0475150868,
-0.1047558561,
0.0216781851,
0.001886308,
-0.0410869122,
0.018141035,
0.0418839157,
-0.0086761713,
-0.006599023,
-0.0232054796,
0.0300017707,
0.0182608608,
0.0424048267,
0.0548556596,
0.0436707363,
0.0290777292,
0.0346005857,
0.0279117953,
0.0115389349,
-0.0289203841,
-0.0034149806,
0.0579321086,
0.00192403,
0.0073755109,
0.0214056671,
0.003700933,
-0.0212574992,
-0.0221961495,
-0.0161139369,
0.0328347646,
0.0101850731,
0.0300809648,
0.035567347,
-0.0352536552,
-0.0364506021,
-0.0802070126,
-0.0238343123,
-0.0164698884,
-0.0561417341,
0.0337034799,
0.0240811389,
-0.0295268577,
-0.0383961387,
0.0590934753,
0.0096690711,
-0.019072352,
0.0432015322,
-0.0589169078,
0.0382781588,
-0.0406124704,
0.0008041319,
-0.0126108099,
-0.0440172926,
0.0441635847,
-0.016913794,
-0.0155543536,
0.0250101183,
0.0035543987,
0.0557210259,
-0.0407562703,
-0.0033745961,
-0.0208242889,
0.0225609671,
0.0381735973,
0.0096706571,
0.0373070538,
0.0079006022,
-0.0140227647,
0.0290718004,
0.0453117453,
0.0169208683,
-0.0087383408,
-0.014579081,
0.0135075096,
0.0795240998,
-0.0461947992,
-0.0019937588,
-0.0434632562,
-0.0158888008,
0.0275626462,
-0.0266446248,
-0.0447130799,
0.0294080637,
2.793e-7,
0.024250878,
0.0326474011,
0.0385598727,
0.0568104461,
-0.0065633864,
0.0063556177,
0.0221515391,
-0.0102489758,
0.0151771093,
-0.0203987565,
-0.0125681739,
0.0448026545,
0.0250760429,
-0.004816893,
-0.0762507319,
0.0214639753,
-0.0318217091,
0.0181286931,
-0.0259845089,
-0.0390883349,
0.0511135124,
0.0829076618,
-0.0179404318,
-0.0053497609,
0.0297818463,
-0.0053301812,
0.0594900884,
0.015002735,
0.0064760577,
0.055846747,
-0.0061836606,
-0.000296099,
-0.0050119143,
0.0196583346,
-0.0250980239,
0.0292640738,
-0.0479949452,
0.0262927189,
-0.0277249441,
-0.0472538061,
0.0329728685,
-0.0131590143,
-0.0377372615,
-0.0144915925,
0.0500735082,
-0.0632297993,
-0.0144410776,
-0.0152677717,
-0.0124187618,
0.0263649672,
-0.0157331042,
-0.0095103066,
-0.0341348313,
0.0410040282,
0.0147279268,
0.038950745,
-0.036653962,
-0.0436152332,
-0.0413718186,
0.0155149642,
-0.0300730392,
-0.0434869677,
-0.0166527908,
-0.0168245099,
0.0064707766,
-0.0573908463,
-0.0354995281,
3.063148179e-34,
0.0435798913,
-0.0275068115,
0.0376943983,
0.0693662986,
0.0313715376,
-0.0117760338,
0.0372329988,
0.0191744715,
0.0356843062,
-0.073186025,
-0.0151990382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17557v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17557v1 | The FineWeb Datasets: Decanting the Web for the Finest Text Data at Scale | 2024-06-25T13:50:56 | 2024-06-25T13:50:56 | Guilherme Penedo, Hynek Kydlíček, Loubna Ben allal, Anton Lozhkov, Margaret Mitchell, Colin Raffel, Leandro Von Werra, Thomas Wolf | cs.CL | cs.CL | The performance of a large language model (LLM) depends heavily on the
quality and size of its pretraining dataset. However, the pretraining datasets
for state-of-the-art open LLMs like Llama 3 and Mixtral are not publicly
available and very little is known about how they were created. In this work,
we introduce FineWeb, a 15-trillion token dataset derived from 96 Common Crawl
snapshots that produces better-performing LLMs than other open pretraining
datasets. To advance the understanding of how best to curate high-quality
pretraining datasets, we carefully document and ablate all of the design
choices used in FineWeb, including in-depth investigations of deduplication and
filtering strategies. In addition, we introduce FineWeb-Edu, a 1.3-trillion
token collection of educational text filtered from FineWeb. LLMs pretrained on
FineWeb-Edu exhibit dramatically better performance on knowledge- and
reasoning-intensive benchmarks like MMLU and ARC. Along with our datasets, we
publicly release our data curation codebase and all of the models trained
during our ablation experiments. | The FineWeb Datasets: Decanting the Web for the Finest Text Data at Scale: The performance of a large language model (LLM) depends heavily on the
quality and size of its pretraining dataset. However, the pretraining datasets
for state-of-the-art open LLMs like Llama 3 and Mixtral are not publicly
available and very little is known about how they were created. In this work,
we introduce FineWeb, a 15-trillion token dataset derived from 96 Common Crawl
snapshots that produces better-performing LLMs than other open pretraining
datasets. To advance the understanding of how best to curate high-quality
pretraining datasets, we carefully document and ablate all of the design
choices used in FineWeb, including in-depth investigations of deduplication and
filtering strategies. In addition, we introduce FineWeb-Edu, a 1.3-trillion
token collection of educational text filtered from FineWeb. LLMs pretrained on
FineWeb-Edu exhibit dramatically better performance on knowledge- and
reasoning-intensive benchmarks like MMLU and ARC. Along with our datasets, we
publicly release our data curation codebase and all of the models trained
during our ablation experiments. | [
0.0425819568,
0.0559946746,
0.0001985187,
0.0338833444,
-0.0033952531,
0.0160738025,
0.0158506259,
0.0118710091,
0.0004883572,
-0.0447154902,
-0.0466959402,
0.0206590239,
-0.0241232347,
0.0385839045,
-0.0106556956,
0.0025936558,
0.023572769,
-0.0191273596,
0.004293629,
-0.0226322077,
0.0242743436,
0.0251837,
0.0143513242,
0.0064603537,
0.031615939,
-0.0161858387,
-0.0028835896,
0.0265131053,
-0.0164601263,
-0.0228681825,
0.0421079062,
0.0414914191,
0.0211625546,
0.0624252185,
0.0000022676,
-0.0392809995,
-0.0420425683,
-0.0185254514,
-0.0486188196,
0.0488613248,
0.0191843938,
0.0284037944,
0.009398913,
0.0366826989,
-0.0409213044,
-0.0160539523,
0.0173361078,
0.0337159894,
0.0623807795,
0.0666938499,
-0.004320221,
-0.0061543351,
0.0329884179,
-0.0121743111,
-0.0228374396,
-0.0048593101,
0.0380424038,
-0.0085980995,
0.0086520985,
0.0157785416,
-0.014236833,
0.0259227976,
0.0151735153,
-0.0087613668,
-0.0168882553,
0.0121843498,
-0.0714370757,
-0.0290007051,
0.0204358399,
0.1012538075,
-0.0142335873,
-0.0621451214,
0.0284021012,
0.0075477236,
-0.0404598638,
-0.0085149137,
-0.0450460985,
0.0326603539,
0.0122458227,
0.0590623431,
-0.0194224883,
-0.0204455871,
0.0500941649,
0.0367562771,
-0.0161477961,
0.0382360481,
0.0173061192,
-0.0251792502,
0.011499254,
0.0354464166,
0.0212249309,
-0.0629286468,
0.0357643031,
0.0003399992,
0.0039405259,
0.0028329496,
-0.0827368721,
-0.041413866,
0.0566529259,
0.0235416517,
0.0143365711,
0.021758534,
-0.0418483652,
0.0698577315,
-0.0171592738,
0.0151820574,
-0.0061985962,
0.0362696126,
-0.0392317176,
0.0089893434,
-0.0228356794,
0.0195386726,
-0.0268587153,
0.0644639134,
-0.0019548144,
0.0029315229,
-0.0198898669,
-0.0001700269,
0.0022009709,
0.0082649756,
-0.014230134,
-0.0235978812,
-0.0312651582,
-0.0093245571,
0.0056156269,
-0.0064647798,
-0.0300328601,
0.0321265757,
0.0040499354,
-0.0722777024,
-0.0197147205,
0.0064924872,
0.0440720096,
-0.0304797124,
0.041337762,
0.0121521922,
-0.0072922423,
-0.0410742983,
-0.0336502083,
-0.0407520942,
0.0138318958,
-0.0285145044,
-0.0059675868,
-0.0799419656,
0.0344010927,
0.0033135081,
0.0240713395,
-0.0527119488,
-0.0043688454,
0.0244269352,
-0.0168111064,
0.0461349785,
-0.0637978539,
-0.0159766171,
-0.0000080562,
-0.0048125,
0.0116282692,
0.0556413122,
0.0086803511,
0.0611460395,
0.081687592,
0.015255738,
-0.0027468202,
0.0469561778,
0.0530716889,
0.0273829252,
0.0090400372,
-0.0023472954,
-0.0037688729,
0.0061994987,
0.0433780439,
0.0340545177,
-0.0629392415,
-0.0222018491,
0.0429609269,
0.0405756421,
0.0127637964,
0.0161039121,
-0.0011340466,
0.0348493792,
0.0306509528,
-0.0107657742,
-0.0397070572,
-0.0193450786,
-0.0263722837,
-0.0139378691,
0.0593547635,
0.0461718217,
-0.031801071,
-0.0431631245,
0.0060114437,
-0.0113939214,
0.0076411278,
0.0291126482,
0.0548358597,
-0.0081018126,
-0.0167606194,
0.0417535715,
0.0472764708,
-0.0596591197,
0.0124645866,
-0.0492117889,
0.0130055351,
0.0752735808,
0.0952104256,
-0.0437467247,
-0.0546802096,
0.0143083353,
0.0760905072,
0.0384267569,
0.0370237865,
-0.0195717644,
0.0243558995,
-0.0711531863,
-0.086302191,
-0.0147917941,
0.0022800982,
-0.0128307948,
0.0524571426,
0.0138083035,
0.0225695893,
-0.0618724376,
-0.0285536163,
0.0453064628,
-0.0463196449,
0.0004365282,
-0.0422017239,
-0.0128576681,
0.0052628266,
-0.0090675633,
-0.0066653695,
-0.0154098235,
0.0627030879,
-0.0136908954,
-0.0000988658,
-0.0529853441,
-0.0058334633,
-0.0171778556,
0.0964859873,
-0.0567606427,
0.0123431357,
0.0644510835,
-0.0663616061,
-0.0292796623,
-0.0101844268,
0.0114503009,
0.0474257842,
-0.0222454444,
0.0339156762,
-0.0271569155,
0.0136930645,
-0.0073753111,
0.017964907,
0.0032604279,
0.0032027119,
-0.0101425266,
-0.0268881805,
0.0355856158,
-0.0237665158,
-0.0520611629,
-0.0157419518,
-0.036006555,
0.031367857,
0.0180839747,
0.0294543058,
-0.0816438049,
-0.0016348561,
-0.0832552984,
0.0150583591,
-0.0038103457,
0.0235860907,
0.0132528264,
-0.002001517,
-0.0008602898,
-0.021822881,
-0.0093522407,
-0.0229425244,
-0.0164080244,
-0.0005111304,
0.0173169039,
-0.0143130496,
0.0010400853,
-0.0572260804,
-0.0540553108,
0.0110203922,
0.0215205122,
-0.0111603783,
-0.0224255025,
0.0059430175,
0.0421814322,
-0.0387791917,
0.0086704381,
-0.0205573402,
-0.0477058142,
0.007818535,
-0.0279982239,
-0.0023547148,
0.0402724855,
-0.0262503438,
-0.0004783364,
0.0590933487,
0.0074857064,
-0.0686797574,
-0.0042883097,
-0.0061848606,
0.0075103785,
-0.0438285172,
-0.0071894191,
0.0017125971,
0.0262166187,
-0.0434939191,
-0.0174371544,
-0.0212540124,
0.0182166994,
-0.0112760738,
-0.0149189821,
-0.0481885597,
0.0006196303,
-0.0083606476,
0.030246716,
-0.0301670749,
-0.0304783564,
0.0485644974,
-0.029727051,
0.0252158418,
-0.0423319638,
0.0308716577,
-0.0236855429,
0.0187002718,
-0.0223829355,
0.007921624,
-0.0050933827,
0.0127299782,
-0.0317880437,
0.0205615815,
0.0274192598,
-0.0749194399,
0.0219777599,
-0.0196805317,
0.0294911899,
-0.0288963877,
-0.0554471798,
-0.0325403251,
-0.0352577679,
-0.034912765,
-0.017018564,
-0.0028219537,
0.0033048107,
-0.0744729191,
-0.030542912,
0.0073014153,
0.0609653555,
-0.0162029099,
-0.0014471562,
-0.0105946716,
0.0381240621,
0.051739186,
-0.0061946479,
0.0279451739,
-0.026125934,
-0.0022340622,
0.0966579542,
0.0692931563,
-0.0108876815,
0.0075150044,
0.0019642694,
0.0722485259,
-0.0392044708,
-0.0044101165,
-0.015287159,
0.0069518876,
-0.0503879897,
-0.0151740629,
0.1184980646,
0.0326804891,
-0.0747940913,
-0.0306168571,
0.0067648916,
0.0202449206,
0.0069513703,
-0.0052877539,
-0.1019394472,
-0.0501156785,
0.0423969813,
0.0425725468,
0.0328984931,
-0.0191249307,
0.0151128732,
-0.0893964022,
0.0031634099,
-0.005599115,
0.0158077348,
-0.001479881,
-0.0760980546,
-0.0018293672,
-0.0262322575,
0.0020017123,
0.0160744451,
-0.0150749506,
0.0246450752,
0.01977624,
0.0148482136,
-0.071278967,
0.0344027504,
-0.0326109082,
0.026702242,
0.0105304951,
0.0557503849,
-0.0002684678,
-0.0284676235,
0.060147129,
-0.0383820236,
-0.0584932379,
-0.0208230074,
0.0752868727,
-0.0076269535,
0.0015172376,
-0.0285122078,
0.0475810207,
-0.0632671639,
-0.0034049295,
0.0148799038,
0.0624157749,
-0.0093277479,
0.0014133697,
-0.0425806642,
-0.0390964001,
-0.0428430624,
0.0864907652,
0.0184906349,
-0.0364462845,
-0.0270515196,
-0.0222367775,
0.0030435158,
-0.0288124122,
-0.0133562824,
0.0118347183,
-0.044723507,
0.0127234459,
-0.0551932901,
-0.0270657986,
0.035569381,
0.017915966,
0.0147599764,
0.0059004351,
0.0095565766,
-0.0073265131,
-0.0677182153,
0.0633794963,
-0.0815582871,
-0.0041511096,
-0.0963924155,
-0.0116914222,
-0.011686231,
-0.0156657659,
-0.037611898,
0.0239463132,
-0.0814609751,
-0.0405794866,
0.0273299739,
0.0042520296,
0.0233177915,
0.0412487201,
-0.015262953,
-0.07001587,
0.0555608384,
0.0001577651,
-0.0454117842,
-0.002816987,
0.0297197681,
-0.0471278168,
0.0077604265,
0.0385659151,
-0.0681350306,
0.0183098167,
0.0408800542,
0.0156601779,
-0.0042464281,
0.0237293914,
0.0019694874,
0.0624073409,
0.0563061535,
-0.0125617012,
-0.0220047403,
-0.0496267825,
0.039930176,
0.0025547515,
-0.0170355216,
-0.0321119241,
0.0346868001,
0.052464094,
-0.0083787311,
-0.0199844595,
0.0402643085,
0.0093656443,
0.0469816066,
-0.0558314919,
0.018880818,
-0.0006948857,
0.0269212928,
0.0403627381,
-0.034417931,
-0.0205420684,
0.0199685395,
-0.0055690366,
0.0254089795,
-0.0539822765,
-0.0188258644,
0.0318575501,
0.0090409191,
-0.022722749,
0.0610896423,
-0.0468174368,
-0.0244688876,
-0.0342399999,
-0.0129531091,
0.0465780236,
-0.0023607397,
0.0742229,
-0.0062798616,
-0.0244325679,
-0.0312239043,
0.0058344053,
0.00577125,
0.000561435,
0.0007071274,
0.0170895196,
-0.026175376,
0.0465677232,
0.1005593464,
0.0006727574,
0.0404436588,
0.0474964604,
0.0055733733,
-0.0242309682,
-0.0109438663,
0.0180404708,
0.0505221561,
-0.0083301412,
-0.0434861556,
-0.0115946047,
-0.0439434908,
0.0070697614,
0.0066559566,
-0.0321404375,
0.0041879765,
0.0531143919,
0.0707482919,
0.021743983,
0.0031385771,
0.0024530126,
0.0065438165,
0.0033525457,
-0.0433928967,
0.0048936657,
-6.934017832e-33,
0.0293860249,
0.0076631042,
0.0139163602,
-0.0080120517,
-0.0177666992,
0.0306202415,
-0.021067854,
-0.0449300632,
-0.0437236652,
0.0067490833,
-0.0374035612,
0.0486938655,
0.0194847137,
0.0509156547,
-0.0084453775,
-0.0026602901,
0.0828161836,
-0.0120153427,
-0.0589152947,
0.055396717,
0.0247297529,
0.0376136862,
0.0392140672,
-0.0280179512,
-0.0268796086,
-0.021134343,
-0.0108071221,
-0.0029610021,
0.0157857444,
0.0678668693,
-0.0584818088,
0.0456061736,
0.0144983372,
-0.0094086211,
-0.0158500243,
-0.0172639433,
-0.0951573998,
-0.038458351,
-0.0035840797,
0.0132720293,
0.0116347885,
-0.0265693683,
0.045096878,
-0.0119007491,
-0.0084452527,
-0.0046578799,
0.0441839546,
-0.0129998289,
-0.0431111865,
-0.0350957997,
-0.0153249325,
0.0318863764,
-0.0203129705,
-0.0112902969,
0.0630390644,
0.000521239,
0.0057005761,
0.0665393993,
-0.0628941506,
0.0487824976,
0.0109415213,
0.04509129,
0.0424528457,
-0.0370953344,
0.0180703774,
0.070217669,
-0.0032951804,
0.0062627443,
0.0486768335,
0.0115899323,
0.066790916,
0.040135514,
0.0230487399,
0.0506884158,
0.0510229655,
-0.0217516832,
-0.0608133152,
0.0245590135,
-0.0063169277,
0.0422008522,
0.0107158776,
0.0036476403,
-0.0113476124,
-0.0225046668,
-0.0442990959,
0.0042613703,
-0.0305608902,
0.0092864018,
0.0239005052,
0.0194637161,
-0.0669819862,
-0.0387919992,
-0.0006128995,
-0.0530981347,
-0.0501324162,
0.0666991696,
0.0006151557,
-0.0040271003,
0.0044503827,
0.0042517739,
-0.0475049689,
-0.0345432349,
0.0271202568,
-0.0463192351,
0.009660936,
-0.0199977607,
0.0283078961,
0.0284909885,
-0.0544294454,
0.0210711733,
-0.0310980026,
-0.0132383266,
0.0286631603,
0.0184849799,
0.0395966582,
0.0104168374,
0.0219829474,
-0.0293845721,
0.0816812962,
0.0206041969,
-0.0438794941,
-0.0076714279,
0.0031984823,
-0.0001622432,
-0.0149948932,
-0.0125898467,
-0.052431684,
0.0165739041,
0.0163928661,
-0.1007341892,
-0.0134853357,
0.0149202403,
2.858e-7,
0.0315155089,
0.0728706643,
0.0283607431,
-0.009699069,
0.0106520914,
0.0198310614,
-0.0256769527,
0.0039713387,
0.0092136711,
0.0167411547,
0.00430643,
0.017803641,
0.0499257445,
0.0240751058,
-0.0718401074,
0.0358820148,
-0.0353670828,
-0.0240710359,
-0.0531747639,
-0.0505333841,
-0.0020890192,
0.094120957,
0.0371721573,
-0.0468319729,
-0.0043221144,
-0.0505383313,
0.0111129088,
-0.0255491957,
0.0072317747,
0.0296127144,
0.0359011218,
0.0332253128,
0.0071631577,
-0.0468742885,
-0.0359402075,
0.0145871667,
0.0013374218,
0.0550978221,
0.0096890358,
-0.0076218485,
0.0070969416,
-0.0472607836,
0.0005033482,
-0.071499452,
0.1067776978,
0.0257981922,
0.007694582,
-0.0116896508,
-0.0615797825,
-0.0441614278,
0.0013741052,
-0.0264108293,
-0.019572936,
0.0240940861,
0.0169304889,
-0.0062055001,
-0.0307466444,
-0.0866890997,
-0.0251312181,
-0.0157107003,
-0.0416684672,
-0.0657655969,
-0.0474255197,
-0.0103462879,
0.0158232804,
-0.0444677845,
0.02624272,
3.059242874e-34,
0.0475488566,
-0.0281007569,
0.0321423486,
0.0017611708,
-0.0045093317,
-0.0090106409,
-0.0047869319,
-0.0171342138,
-0.0240312964,
-0.0871180147,
0.0219110213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17553v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17553v1 | Retrieval-Augmented Code Generation for Situated Action Generation: A Case Study on Minecraft | 2024-06-25T13:43:24 | 2024-06-25T13:43:24 | Chalamalasetti Kranti, Sherzod Hakimov, David Schlangen | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the Minecraft Collaborative Building Task, two players collaborate: an
Architect (A) provides instructions to a Builder (B) to assemble a specified
structure using 3D blocks. In this work, we investigate the use of large
language models (LLMs) to predict the sequence of actions taken by the Builder.
Leveraging LLMs' in-context learning abilities, we use few-shot prompting
techniques, that significantly improve performance over baseline methods.
Additionally, we present a detailed analysis of the gaps in performance for
future work | Retrieval-Augmented Code Generation for Situated Action Generation: A Case Study on Minecraft: In the Minecraft Collaborative Building Task, two players collaborate: an
Architect (A) provides instructions to a Builder (B) to assemble a specified
structure using 3D blocks. In this work, we investigate the use of large
language models (LLMs) to predict the sequence of actions taken by the Builder.
Leveraging LLMs' in-context learning abilities, we use few-shot prompting
techniques, that significantly improve performance over baseline methods.
Additionally, we present a detailed analysis of the gaps in performance for
future work | [
-0.0065323124,
0.0412634984,
-0.0189778935,
0.0150125176,
-0.0291380137,
-0.0141973309,
-0.009763943,
-0.008005403,
0.0298926663,
-0.0588526763,
-0.0289496593,
-0.0230265055,
-0.0277933478,
-0.0063875858,
0.007668444,
0.011820971,
0.0164169725,
-0.0424654447,
-0.0086696586,
0.0103846537,
-0.0286227763,
-0.00539832,
0.0114338249,
0.0929207206,
0.0188883841,
-0.0370766446,
-0.0586677715,
0.0009104034,
0.004809272,
-0.034288682,
0.0051762285,
0.0507070683,
0.0200929102,
0.0229237191,
0.0000020262,
-0.0475606136,
-0.005978757,
-0.0306757744,
0.014355151,
-0.0321849734,
-0.0534839146,
0.0252651479,
-0.015550497,
0.0339054838,
-0.0564341024,
-0.021693185,
0.0572961122,
0.0114295958,
0.0458513647,
0.0477173105,
0.000905346,
-0.0287483633,
-0.0243559107,
-0.0074354243,
0.0564781427,
0.0038140386,
0.0243797936,
0.0592641421,
0.0674018189,
0.0694590434,
-0.0060853041,
0.0241257511,
0.0091789784,
-0.0052570505,
-0.0009356284,
0.0572610982,
-0.0034415494,
0.0295756906,
-0.0062551089,
0.0640099049,
0.0195042137,
-0.0035308325,
0.0561125316,
-0.0046398388,
0.0049376371,
0.0054254895,
-0.0591260418,
0.0446871072,
-0.0052821413,
-0.0010312657,
-0.020095285,
-0.0259426739,
0.0186579209,
0.0141884806,
0.0242857132,
0.0631908029,
-0.0114792632,
-0.0090136407,
-0.0968593061,
0.0022785184,
0.027999416,
-0.0231813472,
-0.0337941796,
0.0491547659,
-0.0613343529,
-0.0000312666,
0.0016396893,
0.0246039871,
-0.0177705884,
0.0034387512,
0.0765115023,
0.0457307734,
0.0053135836,
0.0604605041,
-0.0338548757,
0.0624464191,
0.0091288295,
-0.0063611683,
-0.0508761294,
0.0528136417,
-0.0868843645,
-0.0024563544,
-0.0497885682,
0.027210528,
-0.0634969398,
-0.019306412,
0.0018842077,
0.0413933508,
-0.0246213302,
0.029189609,
0.0054487507,
0.0268092789,
-0.0155746937,
-0.0092622573,
0.0123242876,
-0.0337747894,
-0.0005625645,
0.0091178874,
-0.0092233773,
-0.0539158545,
0.0002380795,
0.0114423865,
0.0029940254,
-0.0099594332,
-0.0002092357,
0.0511680171,
-0.0209567193,
-0.0212619305,
-0.0090664737,
-0.0598453693,
-0.0056946012,
-0.0462406538,
0.0022212518,
-0.0951136127,
-0.0291018337,
-0.0054338397,
-0.0230374299,
-0.0218810346,
0.0202772468,
-0.0064732782,
-0.0082402276,
0.0591479205,
0.0251159389,
0.0344919562,
0.0255464278,
0.0318893902,
0.0196530744,
0.0484890454,
0.0278146043,
0.0729643777,
-0.0082319826,
0.025653502,
0.0368348025,
0.0442585684,
-0.0433536768,
0.0057531493,
0.0191571489,
-0.001446259,
0.0262419619,
0.0542918183,
-0.0062373392,
0.0137272859,
-0.0218991246,
0.0444838665,
0.05099722,
0.0592886209,
0.0211781934,
0.0198609438,
0.0723889619,
0.0281970613,
-0.0507437289,
-0.045632571,
-0.0218516123,
0.0500913523,
0.0087729981,
-0.0079991193,
0.0132188406,
0.0261186212,
-0.0183523092,
-0.045195207,
0.0065306611,
-0.0070935879,
0.0040651858,
-0.0080351038,
0.0254228227,
-0.0127500435,
-0.0704619288,
0.0025112883,
-0.0301897805,
-0.0611800589,
0.0103382273,
-0.0624652281,
0.0527514815,
0.0899164453,
0.025977822,
-0.0360056534,
-0.0007926458,
-0.008914032,
0.013148699,
-0.0433966145,
0.0011627057,
-0.032423079,
-0.0018664572,
-0.0213521179,
-0.0517494343,
-0.0321658067,
0.0132514937,
0.0331076682,
0.0169280805,
-0.0166157242,
0.0290742666,
0.0206130259,
-0.0088456264,
0.0185966641,
-0.0236208253,
-0.0752846822,
0.0025856718,
0.0134478146,
0.0145015353,
-0.0051031336,
0.0007986416,
0.0077438713,
0.0492001921,
-0.0392743461,
-0.0320069194,
0.0235341322,
-0.0507115088,
-0.0623326451,
0.0177850276,
0.0156819355,
0.0228068922,
0.0012400018,
-0.0280364063,
-0.0207381491,
0.0484568737,
-0.0164435953,
0.039334543,
-0.012021671,
0.0116528822,
-0.0054144999,
-0.0567629747,
-0.0594867133,
0.0542146936,
-0.0081624156,
0.0126966918,
0.0335414708,
0.0247179884,
0.0041576987,
-0.0204685144,
0.0048453808,
0.0240988117,
-0.0155326938,
0.0473974198,
0.0377190821,
0.0395162106,
-0.0438968241,
-0.0262081381,
-0.1200146154,
-0.0217514709,
-0.0449837074,
0.0080159465,
0.0075936331,
0.0145606045,
-0.013966308,
-0.0235086232,
-0.0133248251,
-0.0148430457,
0.0168266781,
0.0137811303,
0.0003833299,
0.0260173958,
-0.0335935652,
-0.0466943197,
-0.0036655888,
-0.0068852101,
0.0538616218,
0.0069857142,
-0.010593473,
-0.0607321598,
0.0796484128,
0.0218338612,
0.0146483285,
-0.024088148,
-0.0340162925,
0.0617957376,
-0.083408691,
0.0745903701,
0.0589279197,
-0.0374117605,
0.032238882,
0.0749292076,
-0.0221803598,
-0.0892455801,
0.0100039691,
-0.0144992312,
-0.0516966879,
-0.0148376236,
-0.003873809,
0.0428590402,
0.0663810968,
-0.0030133871,
0.0105025098,
-0.0458834916,
0.0056632501,
0.0121081406,
-0.0350329466,
-0.0010262199,
-0.034430746,
-0.021784788,
0.0272206701,
-0.0092319781,
-0.065560244,
0.0340421163,
-0.0336648338,
-0.0315776207,
0.00465792,
0.0066081183,
-0.0147470729,
0.1008737385,
-0.0014279082,
0.0083746566,
-0.0030633383,
-0.0445231684,
-0.0431338064,
-0.0294073932,
0.033407826,
-0.0274289176,
-0.0186841134,
-0.0776280463,
0.0079333866,
0.0148907928,
-0.0619899966,
-0.0396454521,
-0.0056221602,
-0.0239542238,
-0.0014302551,
-0.0061161453,
-0.002257932,
-0.0092070345,
0.0133408522,
0.040029712,
0.0174007416,
0.0281943157,
-0.0397246107,
-0.0150141437,
0.0253888424,
0.0388152599,
0.0326993987,
-0.0735789686,
-0.0089011453,
0.0043400391,
0.0362129025,
0.0546741337,
0.0035231088,
-0.0829394832,
0.0116357366,
0.0627542436,
0.0174373575,
-0.0208314192,
0.0765715614,
0.0643830895,
-0.0438204966,
-0.0451540053,
0.0830882192,
0.0362503082,
-0.0320063941,
-0.0050052381,
-0.0280660465,
0.0162345413,
0.0091892509,
0.0117104677,
-0.0268837735,
-0.0331538208,
0.0043534758,
-0.0032367976,
-0.0023943374,
-0.0334838517,
0.0207143556,
-0.13525033,
0.0418504365,
0.023120556,
-0.0044967593,
-0.0501865782,
-0.0151211051,
0.0229031295,
0.0190658588,
-0.0739410669,
0.0218408778,
0.0017107226,
0.029928444,
0.0264796317,
-0.0396532603,
-0.0262229294,
0.0433892831,
-0.0469157137,
0.079757832,
0.1036083028,
0.0170394424,
0.0387230627,
0.0120858289,
-0.0126682585,
0.0386241265,
0.044979766,
-0.022486683,
-0.0130020464,
0.0062584518,
0.0025646896,
0.0137897348,
0.0369165726,
-0.0414595492,
-0.0608124249,
0.0191361737,
0.0701979399,
-0.0434594713,
0.011681444,
-0.0156035246,
0.0083088959,
0.0734417364,
0.0260328613,
-0.0043817037,
-0.0224528685,
-0.0306995977,
-0.0194107108,
-0.0046710996,
-0.0510101579,
-0.0385231115,
-0.0382126421,
0.0145881223,
0.0785655901,
-0.0863400921,
-0.0260254703,
0.0361138396,
0.0397579446,
-0.005345182,
0.004471363,
-0.0011259385,
0.0382765718,
-0.0656006038,
0.008127789,
-0.0216614194,
0.0254095439,
-0.0304608382,
0.0049673701,
0.0328330435,
-0.0641575605,
0.0155613404,
0.0131526142,
-0.0611438975,
-0.0584670231,
-0.0186629854,
0.0689921007,
0.0134861348,
0.0319997892,
0.0242921188,
-0.0291486047,
0.004318824,
0.0270648282,
-0.0308659468,
0.0191864148,
0.0240186118,
0.0279478319,
0.0037982948,
-0.0028988845,
-0.0501680821,
0.0026174036,
0.008115544,
0.0626023337,
-0.0548540428,
-0.0433434546,
0.0173812583,
-0.0215541013,
0.0433154888,
-0.0203849059,
-0.0035879209,
-0.0101939449,
-0.0059218383,
0.0019278444,
-0.0027025365,
-0.045347698,
0.0432611555,
0.0149678411,
-0.000387802,
0.0320153236,
0.0316075683,
-0.0072701485,
0.0359599404,
-0.0035763511,
0.0583415069,
-0.0057775765,
0.0084605897,
0.074498713,
0.0170508139,
-0.0255689174,
0.0289520193,
0.0128244935,
0.0367026441,
0.0037822418,
0.0338945277,
0.0257895626,
0.0104663614,
-0.0338495597,
0.0363224894,
-0.0286598336,
-0.0668515563,
-0.0017955529,
0.0135970945,
0.0751020759,
0.0033868039,
0.0071543395,
-0.0397812612,
0.0357201844,
-0.0420653857,
0.0408990681,
0.0271940511,
-0.0734468028,
0.0001934,
0.0546096414,
-0.009834446,
-0.0058944696,
0.0641075745,
0.003320181,
0.0163113587,
0.0007921645,
-0.0281614047,
-0.0215616543,
-0.0275987033,
0.0429278463,
0.0261530373,
-0.0393853411,
0.0031589654,
-0.0339466855,
-0.0127188573,
-0.0306132101,
0.043369364,
-0.0056935535,
-0.0234193895,
0.0300661791,
0.0835912004,
0.019410057,
-0.0195643473,
-0.0565575063,
-0.0098862257,
-0.0260381009,
-0.0177323688,
-0.0824011713,
-5.159370337e-33,
-0.0200102348,
-0.0851069093,
0.0740981847,
-0.0073472988,
-0.0023903896,
-0.0179068465,
-0.0656480789,
0.0209367778,
0.0091769211,
-0.042045936,
0.0011317227,
0.0006626719,
0.0034134747,
0.0126315532,
0.0624895915,
0.0157290027,
0.0402171724,
0.0122068627,
-0.0427347571,
0.0249633286,
0.0021670698,
0.0141429892,
-0.0038989868,
-0.0389514752,
-0.0088742031,
-0.0160968676,
-0.0044714329,
-0.0054581463,
0.0092055453,
0.0175540317,
-0.0110398727,
-0.0016998459,
0.0061449111,
-0.0091351159,
0.0031665484,
0.0346695371,
-0.0410506688,
-0.0049167094,
0.007993903,
-0.0212593079,
-0.0345842689,
-0.0467508323,
-0.0211598836,
0.000504796,
-0.0538469367,
-0.0069185272,
0.044678513,
0.0090663964,
-0.0555346347,
0.0025529407,
-0.0801878497,
-0.0048682611,
-0.0370374024,
-0.0476446413,
0.0158358235,
0.0151863499,
0.0255045351,
-0.0169819221,
-0.0413210988,
0.0551414564,
-0.0397536382,
0.0601009801,
0.0406038612,
0.0638067126,
0.0213734973,
0.056259945,
0.0202160273,
0.0234501772,
-0.0419938937,
0.0007534608,
0.0236404315,
0.0716985539,
-0.0001801921,
0.0467483625,
0.0058191339,
0.0573771484,
-0.0351427756,
0.0248747561,
-0.0207816157,
0.0682516992,
0.0462126918,
0.0427297503,
-0.0201558527,
-0.0151784448,
-0.0258024335,
0.0232944228,
0.0016290458,
-0.0272719022,
0.0422589295,
0.0328765623,
0.0035187798,
-0.052360002,
0.0607882068,
-0.0174414944,
0.0013607432,
0.0260938983,
-0.0519556738,
0.0117822895,
-0.0413004681,
0.0337530635,
-0.0273267925,
-0.0533046871,
0.0295955725,
0.0094626732,
0.0151012503,
0.0214807838,
-0.0388532691,
0.0698157027,
-0.0435848348,
-0.0198345464,
-0.0536708124,
-0.0245409086,
-0.0227178261,
-0.0113510517,
0.0192462988,
-0.0336991102,
-0.0123622837,
0.0097240414,
-0.0203443598,
-0.0530564673,
-0.0024447714,
-0.0473960079,
-0.0222303607,
-0.0222341251,
-0.0205438938,
0.0025135952,
-0.0783699527,
0.0507829972,
0.0624154732,
-0.0158711839,
-0.025316529,
-0.0022556945,
2.836e-7,
-0.0212068409,
0.0382679775,
-0.0243439116,
-0.0012382384,
-0.0285750888,
0.0533074513,
-0.0263961889,
0.0109024076,
0.0267519858,
0.039944645,
0.0556124933,
0.0279353969,
0.0409901962,
-0.0241773669,
-0.1008368284,
0.0249184426,
-0.0355007835,
-0.0083795572,
-0.0646656379,
-0.0123884706,
0.0456774607,
0.016761763,
0.0002658553,
0.0172356945,
0.0279195402,
-0.0947318822,
0.0365550369,
-0.0373192802,
0.0076935352,
0.0111215394,
-0.0226196814,
-0.0132166101,
-0.0161734745,
-0.0627652481,
-0.0125073735,
-0.0366860852,
-0.0064108046,
0.0496139899,
-0.0004109497,
0.020403279,
0.0075498498,
-0.0201979838,
0.003025529,
-0.0012148392,
0.0165853631,
-0.0735088885,
0.0223457702,
0.0244096983,
0.0068372963,
-0.0117294742,
-0.0394238718,
-0.0013247867,
0.0022845557,
-0.020903917,
-0.010861095,
-0.0238377545,
0.0059056506,
-0.0802552998,
-0.0165662058,
-0.0042359806,
-0.0541198142,
-0.0489406958,
-0.0341213755,
-0.0081330528,
-0.0103431623,
-0.0268536862,
0.0014499555,
2.48530638e-34,
-0.0259751193,
0.0064898506,
0.0203277897,
0.0549139343,
0.0346574225,
0.0068736775,
-0.0143452343,
0.0516420826,
0.0481809974,
-0.0612215251,
-0.0152088748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17542v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17542v2 | CDQuant: Accurate Post-training Weight Quantization of Large Pre-trained Models using Greedy Coordinate Descent | 2024-06-25T13:29:14 | 2024-06-26T07:44:42 | Pranav Ajit Nair, Arun Sai Suggala | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have recently demonstrated remarkable
performance across diverse language tasks. But their deployment is often
constrained by their substantial computational and storage requirements.
Quantization has emerged as a key technique for addressing this challenge,
enabling the compression of large models with minimal impact on performance.
The recent GPTQ algorithm, a post-training quantization (PTQ) method, has
proven highly effective for compressing LLMs, sparking a wave of research that
leverages GPTQ as a core component. Recognizing the pivotal role of GPTQ in the
PTQ landscape, we introduce CDQuant, a simple and scalable alternative to GPTQ
with improved performance. CDQuant uses coordinate descent to minimize the
layer-wise reconstruction loss to achieve high-quality quantized weights. Our
algorithm is easy to implement and scales efficiently to models with hundreds
of billions of parameters. Through extensive evaluation on the PaLM2 model
family, we demonstrate that CDQuant consistently outperforms GPTQ across
diverse model sizes and quantization levels. In particular, for INT2
quantization of PaLM2-Otter, CDQuant achieves a 10% reduction in perplexity
compared to GPTQ. | CDQuant: Accurate Post-training Weight Quantization of Large Pre-trained Models using Greedy Coordinate Descent: Large language models (LLMs) have recently demonstrated remarkable
performance across diverse language tasks. But their deployment is often
constrained by their substantial computational and storage requirements.
Quantization has emerged as a key technique for addressing this challenge,
enabling the compression of large models with minimal impact on performance.
The recent GPTQ algorithm, a post-training quantization (PTQ) method, has
proven highly effective for compressing LLMs, sparking a wave of research that
leverages GPTQ as a core component. Recognizing the pivotal role of GPTQ in the
PTQ landscape, we introduce CDQuant, a simple and scalable alternative to GPTQ
with improved performance. CDQuant uses coordinate descent to minimize the
layer-wise reconstruction loss to achieve high-quality quantized weights. Our
algorithm is easy to implement and scales efficiently to models with hundreds
of billions of parameters. Through extensive evaluation on the PaLM2 model
family, we demonstrate that CDQuant consistently outperforms GPTQ across
diverse model sizes and quantization levels. In particular, for INT2
quantization of PaLM2-Otter, CDQuant achieves a 10% reduction in perplexity
compared to GPTQ. | [
-0.0388786346,
0.1333447397,
0.0106212338,
0.0269220881,
0.0173252299,
0.0207526293,
-0.0043918444,
0.0395180471,
-0.0370271355,
-0.0139473919,
-0.0425520986,
-0.037397068,
-0.0010746699,
0.0076222187,
0.0017767652,
-0.0220315084,
0.037456397,
-0.0056540603,
-0.03322291,
-0.0251050405,
-0.0049516605,
0.0341088772,
0.0248563029,
0.0282600243,
-0.0055455067,
-0.0229030587,
-0.0236134343,
0.0144783808,
-0.0167919789,
-0.0227808356,
0.0028354381,
0.0810046718,
0.039821703,
0.0508287996,
0.0000023644,
-0.0097672269,
-0.0147610623,
0.0152448528,
-0.0457427949,
0.0963558778,
0.0272392891,
-0.0109787518,
-0.0199905448,
0.001098371,
-0.0237620063,
-0.0489858948,
0.0641434863,
0.0449462198,
0.0432429165,
0.0424425229,
-0.0033746297,
-0.0401005521,
0.002730309,
-0.0153808845,
-0.0211521722,
-0.0421193317,
0.0157776661,
0.019793218,
-0.0070869722,
0.0161750726,
-0.0052621569,
0.0291949362,
0.0261658374,
0.0328796022,
-0.031852711,
0.025284104,
-0.0449304879,
-0.015280474,
0.0061372984,
0.0530190691,
-0.0494467579,
-0.0403501801,
-0.0236252155,
0.0270190723,
-0.0217306968,
-0.0731722862,
-0.0325048566,
0.0000262064,
0.0279840324,
0.0440110788,
-0.0070693851,
-0.0332792699,
0.0628592446,
-0.016947018,
-0.0626314133,
0.0195345059,
0.0526406616,
-0.0087191202,
-0.0268390384,
-0.0141942715,
-0.0748976395,
-0.0261286013,
0.0142673785,
-0.0282080062,
0.003770442,
-0.0283995848,
-0.0362455286,
-0.0310592204,
-0.009747264,
0.0060510752,
0.058597669,
0.0435203575,
-0.0102337385,
0.0245017204,
-0.0088307578,
0.0370166674,
-0.025146421,
0.0100122942,
-0.0258451737,
0.0066032205,
-0.0341980308,
-0.0038175883,
-0.0620621368,
0.0344920233,
-0.0273108762,
-0.0159891304,
-0.001370925,
-0.0244154725,
0.0042781373,
-0.063523367,
0.054869052,
0.0344227515,
-0.0254782327,
-0.0074702976,
0.0347938612,
0.0391864032,
0.0202398729,
0.0265696999,
-0.0194747485,
-0.0312237311,
-0.0219356455,
0.017024301,
0.0213177297,
-0.0330538973,
0.0289211441,
-0.0003211404,
-0.003329122,
-0.0476263538,
0.036417108,
0.0235743243,
-0.0118306903,
-0.0471948646,
-0.0458240211,
-0.0622348338,
0.0097731687,
-0.0449053384,
0.0085328864,
-0.0105164293,
0.0174873993,
0.0004684036,
-0.0157659911,
0.0548986346,
-0.0284802765,
0.007293459,
0.0369425006,
0.0195777565,
0.019808732,
0.0606282838,
0.0087788729,
0.0150069101,
-0.0002320934,
-0.0258411691,
-0.0163879376,
0.0630563423,
0.0310304873,
-0.0040157307,
-0.0254816841,
-0.0209376346,
0.0039129192,
0.0352402665,
0.0753245056,
0.0699875578,
-0.087007381,
-0.0207836982,
0.0332580879,
0.0778674632,
0.0362071507,
0.0327482112,
0.0232154001,
0.0424291268,
0.0054113409,
-0.0320470333,
-0.0406978652,
0.000543704,
0.0015525491,
-0.012229383,
0.0162075832,
0.049150221,
-0.0375558026,
-0.0135060716,
0.0036079891,
-0.0216338206,
0.0224276073,
0.014275074,
0.0326459855,
0.0206123032,
-0.023775924,
0.0918908566,
0.0202865563,
-0.064295657,
-0.0076302299,
-0.0583437197,
-0.0174305178,
0.006774053,
0.0232496802,
-0.003752264,
0.0000817905,
0.0332895331,
-0.0052118041,
-0.0144566391,
-0.0164902769,
0.0117262416,
0.0584593676,
-0.0498692133,
-0.0174326673,
0.0411600508,
0.0336144082,
-0.0063450965,
0.0533284023,
0.0193093996,
-0.0019176519,
-0.0271166898,
-0.0168404095,
0.0275672004,
-0.012962956,
-0.0578399822,
0.0341891199,
-0.0035675776,
0.0219096784,
0.0037995684,
-0.0181883052,
-0.0036771926,
0.0652556345,
-0.0444114469,
0.0264012478,
-0.0428659283,
-0.0210537072,
-0.0630627275,
0.0695579797,
0.0102330483,
0.0081349602,
0.1005059183,
-0.0211418457,
-0.047111962,
0.019315334,
-0.0000471758,
0.0495120399,
-0.0786499158,
0.0068768193,
-0.0289652701,
0.0233981945,
-0.0191357955,
-0.0008376483,
0.0018238587,
-0.0092372317,
0.0232555401,
-0.0047924668,
-0.0149388667,
-0.0563057326,
-0.0013611824,
0.0090249144,
-0.0028909398,
0.0487566181,
0.0039932132,
0.0292289406,
0.022897888,
0.0088466415,
-0.1436016113,
0.0061353673,
-0.0403260514,
0.0043023801,
0.0337039083,
0.0370898955,
0.0022394464,
-0.007007062,
-0.0219632126,
-0.0318971686,
-0.0058727115,
-0.0072414316,
-0.0208993144,
-0.0230132714,
-0.0154732438,
-0.0374423824,
-0.0505371429,
0.030015802,
0.0492137857,
-0.0673102215,
-0.0322814658,
-0.0462271124,
0.0222959667,
-0.0222490653,
0.0351813063,
0.0164413303,
-0.0565037467,
0.0067013525,
-0.0294839647,
-0.01553463,
0.0468318462,
0.0138335442,
0.0176386368,
0.0571947619,
0.0105234226,
-0.0341811366,
0.0059523433,
-0.0401244424,
-0.0485069305,
-0.0238071214,
-0.0311514921,
-0.030242959,
0.0904968753,
-0.0229435358,
-0.0179847423,
-0.0537554771,
-0.0339735039,
-0.0161448866,
-0.0102404281,
-0.0512976609,
0.0103022205,
-0.0328296125,
0.0508151352,
-0.0040847068,
-0.0421521701,
0.0397279933,
-0.0455635861,
-0.0066093882,
-0.0370005295,
-0.0081062932,
-0.0274997782,
0.0651559457,
0.0088274041,
0.0474636517,
-0.0229048561,
-0.0047206907,
-0.0433618575,
0.0052352967,
-0.0222318191,
-0.0249758959,
-0.0363688171,
-0.0001944591,
0.0153301517,
-0.0163929351,
-0.0415021367,
0.0311670769,
-0.0113496501,
-0.0328637362,
0.0357869379,
0.0147797307,
-0.0477732942,
0.0278676804,
0.0329199657,
-0.0083166109,
0.042791184,
-0.0136874449,
0.0301168114,
-0.0047205617,
0.035975419,
0.0245511141,
0.0053322208,
0.0450261757,
-0.0068989936,
0.0264188405,
0.0321470015,
0.0204425398,
0.0289610829,
-0.0302440003,
0.0157449171,
0.0463439412,
0.0242411308,
-0.0332473852,
-0.0041191913,
0.059668228,
-0.0421168618,
-0.0020919747,
0.0926625133,
0.0140274493,
-0.0769259855,
0.0035387296,
0.0170255657,
0.0343697518,
-0.0031176677,
0.0025065818,
-0.089540042,
-0.043965809,
0.0139930909,
-0.0059997546,
0.0623552166,
0.0158039518,
0.0103861848,
-0.0626487583,
0.0389699191,
0.0557640418,
-0.000213179,
0.0099701909,
-0.0181091689,
-0.0188347623,
-0.0247943178,
0.0399520881,
0.0424263328,
-0.0041392366,
0.0222389977,
0.0218272414,
0.0071588722,
-0.0255187973,
0.0423149355,
-0.021154616,
0.0069596395,
0.0633858964,
0.0236172266,
0.0077716005,
-0.0156426262,
0.0381016172,
0.007669914,
-0.0390768461,
-0.0002874921,
-0.0167712532,
0.0174277108,
-0.0125958128,
0.0092493333,
0.0395419113,
-0.0198868793,
0.0036109532,
-0.0067560691,
0.081004858,
0.0095595662,
-0.0253429059,
0.0126755787,
-0.0366704501,
-0.0597907566,
0.0638159961,
0.0508796759,
-0.018497128,
-0.0401284359,
-0.0019419045,
-0.0126371393,
-0.0247109775,
-0.0387568362,
0.0233334042,
0.0066399393,
-0.0765173808,
-0.0439545102,
0.0029315895,
0.0210890584,
0.0140982186,
-0.0412344746,
0.0032851205,
-0.010120051,
-0.0002386693,
-0.1012367308,
0.0376276039,
-0.0231146906,
0.0131800221,
-0.0699158609,
0.0260326769,
-0.0054036244,
-0.0228287596,
-0.0139021855,
-0.0280288961,
-0.0966039076,
-0.0511505455,
0.0058213985,
0.0308827609,
0.0112869758,
0.0355152674,
-0.010087247,
-0.0496291965,
0.0220784359,
0.0335984342,
-0.0139781041,
0.0580517054,
0.0459832959,
-0.0744468421,
0.0013396183,
0.056540288,
-0.0170315579,
0.0419634394,
-0.0389824472,
0.0285001751,
-0.042816475,
-0.0767684951,
-0.0026181769,
0.0056644264,
0.0855455622,
-0.0125938114,
0.0160178915,
0.0053237602,
0.0226630401,
-0.0082190903,
0.0173917785,
-0.0584731773,
0.0114323702,
0.0395246856,
0.0214676708,
-0.0207762308,
-0.0087734871,
0.0387175865,
0.0029247121,
0.0021340216,
-0.0006133977,
-0.0501868911,
0.0063973693,
0.0621168911,
-0.0081935041,
-0.0189960841,
0.0184236653,
-0.0382594876,
0.0085847573,
-0.0428446867,
-0.0108969752,
-0.0183424279,
0.0305031631,
-0.0430596545,
0.0477146432,
-0.0210993625,
-0.1028636247,
-0.0527545959,
-0.0331329182,
0.0635225624,
0.0152427936,
0.0540274791,
0.0363177657,
-0.049667988,
-0.038066972,
0.0217292067,
-0.0164842922,
-0.0051740846,
0.0244780313,
0.0119373901,
-0.0261835866,
0.0070413509,
0.0686196238,
0.0424586274,
0.0201870222,
0.0110433064,
0.0012191649,
0.007745815,
-0.0108131133,
-0.0108621037,
0.0358378775,
-0.0314900577,
-0.0350493826,
0.0092807664,
-0.0723171458,
0.026694892,
0.0020873155,
-0.0483178832,
-0.0176107716,
0.044781357,
0.0019437443,
-0.0063179694,
-0.0071161594,
-0.0149252694,
-0.0331539325,
0.0044242674,
-0.0393208675,
0.0171920918,
-7.026570379e-33,
0.0016613071,
0.0417903736,
-0.0001897365,
-0.0209925734,
-0.0389096849,
0.0306670573,
-0.0136433551,
-0.0114023518,
-0.0022809056,
0.005073864,
-0.0114103584,
0.0301664583,
0.0035419585,
0.0215298869,
-0.0134807844,
0.0301581249,
0.0810539201,
-0.0260810331,
-0.0026214805,
0.0482275523,
-0.0035704237,
0.0433485061,
0.060901951,
0.0142579805,
-0.0639158785,
0.0205831807,
0.0043437593,
0.0151331155,
0.0045630173,
0.0420952663,
-0.0616284348,
-0.0143591706,
-0.0206463505,
-0.0004849815,
-0.0292167496,
-0.0168499947,
-0.0685700849,
0.0129896943,
-0.0016963714,
0.0020089771,
-0.0028808443,
-0.019706808,
0.0102052968,
0.0032668959,
-0.0444874354,
-0.0398047678,
-0.0244500339,
-0.0136773484,
-0.0475793891,
-0.0810580105,
-0.0061510676,
0.0349608921,
0.0130104776,
-0.0112615852,
0.0772849321,
-0.0123539455,
-0.0582133196,
0.0215054546,
-0.0476157032,
-0.0276034717,
0.0040004924,
0.0753552839,
0.034909226,
0.0316851623,
0.0389487706,
0.0394638926,
0.0437360704,
-0.0511696339,
-0.0123558436,
0.0383834653,
0.0604590662,
0.0311655719,
0.0566520281,
0.0313667767,
0.0982375517,
-0.008857321,
-0.076200828,
0.001275045,
-0.0502209552,
-0.0081089661,
0.0090941191,
0.0500712059,
0.0151679451,
-0.0267356467,
-0.0516468138,
-0.0206870232,
-0.0341937467,
-0.0252693947,
-0.0019780137,
0.0228900127,
-0.0555500947,
0.0140397009,
0.0459447429,
-0.0450551547,
-0.0089964904,
-0.0070127752,
-0.0334215499,
0.0072757532,
0.0183501635,
0.0380752385,
-0.0271665007,
-0.0096192323,
0.0197502971,
0.0029694559,
0.0147119416,
-0.0205301307,
0.0194853228,
0.0405147858,
-0.0534814149,
-0.0237424076,
-0.0287082307,
-0.0246754829,
0.0134347174,
0.0822302029,
0.0269777812,
0.0130447662,
0.0356178693,
0.0532883145,
0.0056792214,
0.0115043176,
-0.0570073351,
0.0143694719,
0.0368505009,
0.0528633669,
-0.0085915169,
0.0091091944,
-0.071874775,
0.0397602096,
0.037193086,
-0.0720091835,
-0.0504510775,
0.0400106385,
2.922e-7,
0.0474847034,
0.0169449877,
0.0130765904,
-0.0555499569,
0.002213808,
0.0116618518,
-0.0035686123,
0.0178662501,
-0.0113139059,
-0.0081968307,
0.0304943733,
0.0567066111,
0.0436773077,
0.0173676126,
-0.0801609382,
0.0088264728,
-0.0641720369,
-0.005833115,
-0.0526561774,
-0.0471505634,
-0.0034845499,
0.1345913112,
-0.0097855767,
-0.0244481973,
0.0497996174,
0.0151050352,
0.049198918,
-0.011244663,
0.0167298596,
-0.0024673259,
0.0027086949,
0.0047210534,
0.002632285,
-0.0786553025,
0.0020666528,
0.0115495864,
-0.0118954303,
0.0835891291,
-0.04227506,
0.0009502477,
0.0163313672,
0.0110316863,
-0.0298153851,
-0.0501452163,
0.0543610826,
-0.0234336797,
0.017293321,
-0.1060630381,
-0.0113858953,
-0.03471037,
0.0223437492,
-0.0306702666,
0.0336489007,
0.0484728515,
0.0238581933,
-0.0161002707,
-0.0114379246,
-0.0840304494,
-0.0296393335,
0.0245586503,
-0.0262591764,
-0.0152734667,
-0.0577025414,
-0.0060048383,
0.0275497027,
-0.0217178613,
0.0245037861,
2.999862502e-34,
0.0322520509,
-0.0107609555,
0.028450748,
0.0487391204,
0.0023376886,
-0.0510860905,
0.0227555726,
0.0191926379,
-0.0361656882,
-0.0657123998,
-0.0200853441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17535v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17535v1 | Disce aut Deficere: Evaluating LLMs Proficiency on the INVALSI Italian Benchmark | 2024-06-25T13:20:08 | 2024-06-25T13:20:08 | Fabio Mercorio, Mario Mezzanzanica, Daniele Potertì, Antonio Serino, Andrea Seveso | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly
enhanced their ability to generate and manipulate human language, highlighting
their potential across various applications. Evaluating LLMs in languages other
than English is crucial for ensuring their linguistic versatility, cultural
relevance, and applicability in diverse global contexts, thus broadening their
usability and effectiveness. We tackle this challenge by introducing a
structured benchmark using the INVALSI tests, a set of well-established
assessments designed to measure educational competencies across Italy. Our
study makes three primary contributions: Firstly, we adapt the INVALSI
benchmark for automated LLM evaluation, which involves rigorous adaptation of
the test format to suit automated processing while retaining the essence of the
original tests. Secondly, we provide a detailed assessment of current LLMs,
offering a crucial reference point for the academic community. Finally, we
visually compare the performance of these models against human results.
Additionally, researchers are invited to submit their models for ongoing
evaluation, ensuring the benchmark remains a current and valuable resource. | Disce aut Deficere: Evaluating LLMs Proficiency on the INVALSI Italian Benchmark: Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly
enhanced their ability to generate and manipulate human language, highlighting
their potential across various applications. Evaluating LLMs in languages other
than English is crucial for ensuring their linguistic versatility, cultural
relevance, and applicability in diverse global contexts, thus broadening their
usability and effectiveness. We tackle this challenge by introducing a
structured benchmark using the INVALSI tests, a set of well-established
assessments designed to measure educational competencies across Italy. Our
study makes three primary contributions: Firstly, we adapt the INVALSI
benchmark for automated LLM evaluation, which involves rigorous adaptation of
the test format to suit automated processing while retaining the essence of the
original tests. Secondly, we provide a detailed assessment of current LLMs,
offering a crucial reference point for the academic community. Finally, we
visually compare the performance of these models against human results.
Additionally, researchers are invited to submit their models for ongoing
evaluation, ensuring the benchmark remains a current and valuable resource. | [
-0.0231401492,
0.0242754333,
-0.0489689559,
0.0369844697,
-0.0370732099,
0.0074159214,
0.0325496793,
0.0218755547,
0.0260929503,
-0.0096810767,
-0.0339929387,
-0.033729922,
0.0047557582,
-0.0035595966,
0.0403592177,
-0.0423124656,
0.0448765121,
-0.0352432504,
-0.0343345515,
-0.0049927556,
-0.0012660667,
-0.0075117922,
-0.0222726688,
0.0333262384,
0.0052868887,
0.0171387419,
0.0298735853,
-0.0155240828,
0.0101466412,
-0.0195532069,
0.0160218365,
0.0378563032,
0.0007935312,
0.0063258996,
0.0000021896,
-0.0731602088,
0.0125661911,
-0.0355190895,
0.021172896,
0.0462145992,
0.045438908,
0.0409393311,
-0.0458347984,
0.0100775743,
-0.0314325579,
0.044784449,
0.0191752426,
-0.061909955,
0.015887009,
0.052670531,
-0.0061017969,
0.0029208742,
0.0349282511,
-0.0182070863,
-0.0383426137,
0.0004567564,
0.004412205,
0.0193034504,
0.0207885485,
-0.0056175729,
-0.0027199234,
0.024990093,
-0.0096990652,
-0.0023622136,
-0.0420036688,
-0.0058534257,
0.0046129511,
-0.023375392,
0.0044893599,
0.0272270311,
0.0197404139,
-0.0184402876,
0.0040965187,
0.0025089909,
0.0101004262,
0.031473998,
-0.0629304126,
0.0140569825,
0.0150660491,
0.0094182445,
0.050284896,
0.0160396639,
0.0017707775,
0.0059882682,
-0.0006792123,
0.0781994313,
0.0668595284,
-0.0517027341,
0.0435927361,
0.0060658087,
-0.0102884816,
-0.0452714898,
-0.0053880014,
0.0554597043,
-0.0288289879,
0.0063532135,
-0.0177531708,
-0.0181105379,
0.0728690699,
-0.0509782732,
0.0617252775,
0.0318852589,
-0.0152384182,
0.0262389611,
-0.004951091,
0.1052015871,
-0.0002942495,
0.0096149007,
-0.0442294516,
0.0114699397,
-0.0356636718,
0.0110557331,
-0.0152837522,
-0.0185331646,
-0.0431114584,
0.0300843287,
-0.0821313187,
-0.0039394186,
-0.0452509001,
0.0179353505,
-0.0050555891,
-0.0726507604,
-0.0034596741,
0.0371504277,
-0.0328783989,
0.0421082601,
-0.0476083308,
-0.0024539956,
-0.0179098733,
-0.063267,
0.042874746,
0.0255008023,
-0.0315301567,
-0.0210023057,
0.0279706381,
0.0448912457,
-0.0018813085,
-0.0137975439,
-0.0192885548,
-0.0214939024,
-0.0342815295,
-0.0861734375,
0.0206499137,
-0.0767357424,
0.0275020748,
-0.0078894803,
0.0066992962,
-0.0531922989,
-0.0041630589,
0.0343188085,
0.0354385115,
-0.0141935926,
-0.0281259418,
0.0041853539,
0.0264614578,
0.0122448066,
-0.0015418245,
0.0510774292,
0.0578209758,
-0.006699821,
0.0340448692,
-0.036911577,
0.0006898086,
0.0998582318,
0.0108806863,
0.045262266,
-0.0563146397,
0.0043594185,
0.0051186685,
0.0295848642,
0.0378423594,
0.0497963764,
0.0221400782,
0.0406230316,
0.0550751239,
0.0668292567,
0.0243199021,
-0.0003256761,
0.0491772927,
0.010981177,
0.0472383983,
-0.0094664525,
0.0068852203,
-0.0151120927,
-0.0092631923,
0.0156214023,
-0.0303469002,
0.0572358109,
-0.0096564898,
-0.0340709463,
-0.0104788048,
-0.0246509593,
0.0247840453,
0.0039404789,
0.0624493398,
-0.0263132267,
-0.0241809022,
0.0242102481,
0.0445988849,
-0.0705720931,
0.0417767763,
-0.0446353629,
0.024835486,
0.0857625902,
0.0319540873,
0.0042321575,
-0.015454377,
0.0197303463,
0.020094065,
0.0792076141,
0.0318368003,
-0.0104276314,
-0.0281230751,
-0.0572576448,
0.0131316893,
-0.0011440766,
0.0094898939,
0.0219204631,
-0.0017848233,
0.0313638337,
0.0075187706,
-0.0435543656,
-0.0390820168,
0.0165933911,
-0.0823300257,
0.0004896165,
-0.0409474708,
-0.0059191873,
-0.0135100521,
0.0279316567,
-0.0146114146,
0.0132684996,
0.0417940058,
-0.0287167076,
0.0160927996,
-0.0130017195,
-0.0317518339,
0.0272787735,
0.0423728861,
-0.0412529036,
-0.0133896824,
-0.0074019278,
0.0048016529,
-0.0313185155,
0.0054129818,
-0.024970239,
0.0108255297,
-0.0163431093,
0.0414814502,
-0.0534060933,
0.0213495307,
-0.0412901826,
0.0461030751,
-0.0182272084,
0.0629626513,
0.0172170009,
0.0209894814,
0.0254888646,
-0.0461649448,
-0.0614653118,
0.015958542,
-0.0122499093,
0.0137512377,
0.0034129524,
0.0489354543,
-0.0542941689,
-0.068059735,
-0.0942366794,
0.0055579888,
-0.0047572609,
0.0307623241,
0.0171797667,
-0.0225185975,
-0.0336540118,
0.0412286632,
-0.0381360836,
-0.0311975181,
0.0327625908,
-0.0007321917,
0.0308771469,
-0.0291328859,
-0.0581496023,
-0.0562146381,
-0.0114542563,
-0.0049128686,
-0.0053189923,
0.0279018469,
0.0196917206,
-0.0114563005,
0.0374889672,
-0.0422005542,
-0.0100243734,
-0.0012926679,
-0.0445329547,
0.0241437145,
0.0133694382,
0.063060008,
0.0400877595,
-0.0075554713,
0.010340862,
0.0496022925,
-0.0478651226,
-0.0540029183,
-0.016336225,
0.0242964495,
-0.0342350863,
-0.0930967182,
-0.104220286,
-0.001980057,
0.0494772904,
0.0047941012,
0.0192675292,
-0.0216902848,
0.0184111446,
-0.0805712789,
-0.026838759,
-0.0168678686,
0.0171048138,
-0.0366306305,
0.0704510361,
-0.018422503,
-0.0265981779,
0.0170457605,
-0.0433462113,
0.0316986293,
-0.0095229382,
-0.0095067425,
-0.0393472984,
0.0310188364,
-0.0141643845,
-0.0024820685,
-0.051499106,
0.0110012116,
-0.0449780039,
-0.0169171877,
0.0158068985,
-0.0785628334,
0.0608782172,
-0.080543831,
0.0026407749,
0.0183252301,
-0.017845802,
-0.0041786944,
0.0457624905,
0.0073277028,
0.0366642028,
0.0177643411,
-0.0219404455,
-0.0035035056,
-0.0201006699,
0.0112146186,
0.031420555,
-0.0148991849,
0.0272342861,
-0.0121082468,
0.0195219908,
0.0224999636,
0.0011679627,
-0.0157373026,
-0.0479677059,
0.0294724517,
0.0163212884,
0.0250098649,
0.0273862276,
-0.0219710041,
0.0280396212,
0.0396447964,
-0.0442583486,
-0.0289549381,
0.0328225978,
0.0392691568,
-0.0400759242,
-0.03130785,
0.1107157022,
0.0153490901,
-0.0172184482,
0.0169571601,
-0.0313178301,
0.0374013931,
0.032455463,
0.0199436545,
-0.0773376226,
0.0441707782,
0.0002105248,
0.0294617694,
-0.0341098383,
-0.0092586512,
-0.0040269583,
-0.094716683,
0.0621762201,
0.0026146551,
-0.0086022699,
0.0053016734,
-0.034335535,
-0.0113331089,
0.0177236721,
0.0299590081,
0.0112374173,
-0.0120538669,
-0.0053453296,
0.0264734551,
-0.0509115979,
-0.0693471283,
0.0550882854,
-0.0252617467,
0.0585060157,
-0.00255644,
0.0377708413,
-0.0537101738,
-0.0465323515,
0.03923776,
-0.0042451667,
-0.036047928,
-0.0120176263,
0.0059686354,
0.0421904773,
-0.0039685951,
-0.0501463525,
-0.0246724393,
0.01101318,
-0.0124825276,
0.0643395334,
0.0767262504,
0.0068559162,
0.0247931406,
-0.0068160468,
-0.0196662676,
-0.0003816272,
0.0547851287,
0.0561178997,
-0.0713691786,
0.0289581809,
-0.0004833268,
-0.0158870984,
-0.0360900275,
-0.058484152,
0.0386662818,
-0.0471651405,
-0.0023562438,
-0.0591964498,
-0.0318397135,
0.032611426,
0.0105080595,
0.0165892001,
-0.0212231539,
0.0066802809,
-0.0442568362,
-0.0348320641,
0.0402236953,
-0.0172937568,
0.0382728688,
-0.1086896956,
-0.0017494189,
0.0233639441,
0.0036148857,
-0.0387856625,
0.0023587688,
-0.0845037475,
-0.0542618446,
0.0075356816,
0.0674656779,
0.0277206693,
-0.0190183651,
0.0134575376,
-0.0467327982,
0.0263125617,
-0.0443679318,
-0.0033595155,
0.0556289181,
-0.0205507558,
-0.0111990254,
0.0173283108,
0.0023903267,
-0.0301373936,
0.0247909967,
-0.0055574379,
0.0487662889,
0.0021810625,
-0.0520659648,
0.0258222111,
0.0608432777,
0.00330355,
-0.0610309914,
-0.0134492302,
-0.0238060486,
-0.0096935565,
-0.0372250564,
-0.0019531139,
-0.0182723515,
-0.0121642165,
0.0655031875,
0.0157189239,
0.007844151,
-0.0212048814,
-0.0498277619,
0.0160473324,
-0.0063615721,
0.0469638221,
-0.0216610786,
0.0342417695,
0.0015771996,
0.0187849291,
-0.0150217554,
0.026615737,
-0.0454542674,
0.0785926729,
-0.01443044,
0.0629701614,
-0.0254042801,
0.0114648426,
0.0221694671,
0.030031886,
0.0303758774,
-0.0322934575,
-0.0130741429,
0.0333160944,
0.0674443021,
0.0250588898,
0.093245469,
-0.0207273029,
0.0075843371,
-0.0388639532,
-0.0136489505,
-0.0275641978,
-0.0284483451,
0.0180533957,
0.0050128065,
0.010566053,
0.0010355251,
0.0187781285,
0.0120210592,
-0.0006768675,
-0.0111606158,
0.0429156162,
-0.0185351465,
-0.0414818116,
-0.0006164422,
-0.0158759207,
-0.0324386097,
-0.0366415195,
-0.0855266824,
-0.0736348704,
0.0068674688,
0.0633486584,
-0.0119128935,
-0.0237250421,
-0.001960468,
0.0268342476,
-0.0379121341,
0.0221822914,
-0.0607706606,
0.001720174,
0.00922867,
-0.0419147834,
-0.0389846489,
-6.302465124e-33,
-0.0483882949,
-0.0276766866,
0.0668037161,
0.0071572866,
-0.0197526664,
-0.0225475244,
-0.0065328549,
0.0011173198,
-0.0185112171,
-0.0220539682,
-0.0112543739,
-0.0563936234,
0.0067537455,
0.00298868,
0.022060534,
0.0262833741,
-0.0098576937,
-0.0011392873,
-0.006653979,
-0.0293638557,
-0.0162389614,
-0.0301634762,
0.077845335,
-0.0387060493,
0.0608890727,
-0.0468846262,
-0.0356214046,
-0.0026258186,
-0.0027018117,
0.0787522942,
0.0123714386,
0.0341538154,
0.0318369679,
-0.0090260282,
0.0091394437,
0.0132029522,
-0.0318917632,
-0.0449986793,
0.0489899851,
0.0243953373,
0.023940444,
-0.0330970995,
0.0400785916,
-0.0053953598,
-0.0849154517,
0.006319731,
0.0241851714,
-0.0251488332,
-0.0031205181,
0.0013225535,
-0.0602029786,
0.0146835493,
-0.0182477199,
0.0160915218,
-0.0188316517,
0.0609380938,
-0.0243266467,
-0.0090000331,
-0.0371474326,
0.0379009284,
0.0140072228,
0.0335428864,
0.0777595416,
-0.0007145875,
-0.0117226159,
0.0606554709,
0.0536114164,
0.007603786,
0.0557839498,
-0.0208888352,
0.0853945464,
0.0270426571,
0.057610698,
0.0676229671,
0.0153557435,
-0.0120564783,
-0.0707769245,
0.0157530401,
0.0578989908,
0.0122850016,
-0.0444850363,
-0.0178783536,
-0.0446804166,
-0.0282260142,
-0.0659117848,
-0.0087798852,
-0.0029468886,
-0.0391045064,
0.0787746757,
-0.0698990449,
0.0485804714,
-0.0210296288,
0.0228859782,
-0.0203357823,
-0.0294018984,
-0.0222680196,
-0.0110769561,
0.0481115207,
-0.0179511663,
0.0614376105,
-0.0362691879,
-0.041527953,
-0.0248200502,
0.017943047,
0.0321864709,
0.0159448069,
0.0069011129,
-0.0228935424,
-0.0556139126,
0.0163807645,
-0.0192712769,
0.0021885391,
0.0107759861,
0.002594857,
0.0254843011,
-0.018844001,
0.006210858,
0.017224947,
0.0372562222,
-0.0247625411,
-0.0205339156,
-0.0269136261,
0.014253878,
0.0401026197,
-0.0151371062,
0.0189512447,
-0.0301706437,
0.040122319,
0.0388884544,
-0.0214582346,
0.0050839884,
-0.0086156595,
2.873e-7,
0.0503000356,
0.0681036413,
-0.0215466078,
0.0188505407,
-0.0215497799,
-0.0152297216,
-0.0610766374,
-0.0024118421,
0.0324090198,
0.0284533333,
0.0058384766,
0.0165038779,
0.0503052697,
0.0205796193,
-0.046819903,
0.0246855523,
-0.0415308438,
0.0083597768,
-0.0752430409,
0.0265365466,
0.0180994701,
0.0054837433,
0.0303770304,
-0.041604694,
-0.0653585121,
-0.0494708307,
0.0563594848,
-0.0341734774,
-0.060138315,
0.0514923632,
0.0311154332,
0.0273923483,
0.0287639033,
0.0304990951,
-0.0123052774,
0.0267565809,
0.0032381306,
0.0866099373,
0.008556121,
0.0276834257,
0.0448916331,
-0.0593469664,
-0.0408496484,
-0.0539176837,
0.0203703828,
-0.0006852243,
0.0113929436,
-0.0440085456,
-0.0687893853,
-0.0085285958,
0.0222120788,
-0.0595662184,
-0.028963577,
0.0190871917,
0.0361873545,
-0.02230273,
-0.0053288047,
0.0405570269,
-0.0178679209,
0.0147264833,
-0.0338290893,
-0.1040173396,
-0.0400948673,
0.0408352278,
-0.0176560413,
-0.0200436544,
0.0011044213,
2.766794114e-34,
0.0246123318,
-0.0038527742,
0.0394318514,
0.0352499411,
0.0343832187,
0.0084142555,
-0.040331807,
0.0406858586,
-0.0405046269,
-0.0295995474,
-0.0103156492
] |