response
stringlengths 266
1.38k
| label
stringclasses 2
values | id
stringlengths 36
36
|
|---|---|---|
{
"REASONING": [
"The truce was called in July 1921 as stated in the document.",
"The negotiations for the Anglo-Irish Treaty began on 11 October 1921.",
"Calculating the months between July 1921 and 11 October 1921 results in approximately 3 months (August, September, October).",
"The answer provided, '4' and '11 December 1921', is incorrect. The number '4' does not correctly represent the number of months between the truce and the start of negotiations, and '11 December 1921' is not relevant to the question asked."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 8fe613c4-ac82-4917-b6f8-f5e7658625cb |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT states that Macromedia disclosed the Flash Version 3 Specification in October 1998.",
"The DOCUMENT also states that MorphInk 99 was introduced in February 1999.",
"Calculating the months between October 1998 and February 1999 gives a total of 4 months (November, December, January, February).",
"The ANSWER provided is '5', which does not match the correct calculation of 4 months."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | dddfdc79-a324-4f39-8951-30e865567059 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT states that Henry and Charles each agreed to provide an army of no less than 35,000 infantry and 7,000 cavalry, totaling 42,000 troops each.",
"The combined force of Henry and Charles would therefore be 84,000 troops (42,000 from Henry and 42,000 from Charles).",
"Francis could muster about 70,000 men in his various armies as per the DOCUMENT.",
"The ANSWER states that Henry and Charles could muster about 84,000 troops, which is consistent with the sum of the troops each agreed to provide as per the treaty mentioned in the DOCUMENT.",
"The ANSWER does not introduce any information that contradicts or goes beyond the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | 2243335c-cbca-4e6b-9a9d-f7e5907383bf |
{
"REASONING": [
"The document lists several touchdown plays with their respective distances.",
"Reggie Bush caught a 6-yard touchdown pass from Drew Brees.",
"Anthony Dixon had a 2-yard touchdown run, which is shorter than Bush's 6-yard reception.",
"David Thomas caught a 3-yard touchdown pass from Brees, which is also shorter than Bush's 6-yard reception.",
"The question specifically asks for the shortest touchdown reception, not the shortest touchdown overall.",
"The answer incorrectly identifies Reggie Bush's 6-yard reception as the shortest touchdown reception, overlooking David Thomas's 3-yard reception which is shorter."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | d4816696-2cb0-4f35-98cd-89d3ebc7cff5 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question specifically asks for players who caught 20-yard touchdown passes.",
"The document mentions two instances of 20-yard touchdown passes:",
"1. Calvin Johnson caught a 20-yard TD pass, as stated in the document.",
"2. Kevin Ogletree caught a 20-yard TD pass, as stated in the document.",
"Jeremy Ross is mentioned in the document as having caught a 5-yard TD pass, not a 20-yard TD pass.",
"The answer incorrectly includes Jeremy Ross for catching a 20-yard touchdown pass, which contradicts the information provided in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | c59a30c4-f053-4403-98fa-0e52e553483a |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT states that in 2009, the membership of public sector unions was 7.9 million and the membership of private sector unions was 7.4 million.",
"The difference between the public sector union membership and private sector union membership in 2009 is 0.5 million (7.9 million - 7.4 million).",
"The ANSWER provided is 1.0 million, which does not match the 0.5 million difference stated in the DOCUMENT.",
"Therefore, the ANSWER introduces an incorrect figure that contradicts the information provided in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 7f09cd77-75f4-4fce-8bdd-110721362765 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT provides the percentage of the population under age 18 as 25.3%.",
"To find the percentage of the population that is not under the age of 18, we subtract the percentage under 18 from 100%.",
"100% - 25.3% = 74.7%.",
"The ANSWER provided is '75.3', which does not match the calculated value of 74.7%.",
"The ANSWER incorrectly states the percentage of the population not under the age of 18, thus providing information that contradicts the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 896f8bf7-8fa4-4a48-8dd0-7e911eccfe4c |
{
"REASONING": [
"The QUESTION asks for a comparison of the chronological order of two events: Alexander's invasion of Pauravas and Menander I Soter's invasion of the Punjab.",
"The DOCUMENT provides specific dates for both events: Alexander the Great invaded Pauravas in 326 BCE, and Menander I Soter's rule and conquests in the Punjab are mentioned to have occurred when he made Sagala the capital of his Empire, with his rule lasting until his death in 130 BCE.",
"The ANSWER only states that 'Menander I Soter invaded the Punjab' without specifying the timing or sequence relative to Alexander's invasion.",
"The ANSWER does not directly address the QUESTION which is about the sequence of the events, not just the occurrence of one event.",
"The ANSWER is factually correct in stating that Menander I Soter invaded the Punjab, as confirmed by the DOCUMENT, but it fails to address the 'first' aspect of the QUESTION."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 7ffd22a7-d24f-4cf3-aa1f-011ceb26a1da |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks for the longest field goal in the game.",
"The document lists several field goals made during the game: 31-yard, 36-yard, 22-yard, 47-yard, and 49-yard.",
"The longest field goal mentioned in the document is 49 yards by Sebastian Janikowski.",
"The answer provided is '47', which refers to the field goal made by Olindo Mare.",
"The answer '47' does not match the longest field goal of 49 yards as stated in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | bbdf02d1-cf9f-4aaf-aad7-bd00fd1a2fcb |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT specifies that the underground mines where the UMW members worked were chiefly in Kentucky and West Virginia.",
"The ANSWER '3' suggests that the underground mines were in three states, which contradicts the information provided in the DOCUMENT.",
"The DOCUMENT does not mention any third state involved in the context of underground mines."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 420e3ec7-4742-4dc2-91e0-85c92f74c0f1 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks to compare the size of two age groups: 25 to 44 and 45 to 64.",
"According to the DOCUMENT, the percentage of the population aged 25 to 44 is 25.70%.",
"The DOCUMENT states that the percentage of the population aged 45 to 64 is 19.30%.",
"Comparing these percentages, the age group 25 to 44 (25.70%) is larger than the age group 45 to 64 (19.30%).",
"The ANSWER provided is '25 to 44', which incorrectly identifies this group as the smaller one based on the percentages given in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 3b1c98e0-bf3a-4459-a4a4-de719bafaf58 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The document details the scoring sequence of the game.",
"Maurice Jones-Drew scored the first touchdown on a 6-yard run.",
"Fred Taylor scored the second touchdown on a 13-yard run, making the score 14-0 in favor of the Jaguars.",
"The answer 'Fred Taylor' correctly identifies the player who scored the second touchdown of the game according to the document."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | 6c1bb873-aca9-43e1-bc0f-c16e13e5544b |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT states that Mindon sent 'several thousand infantry troops' from the Mone garrison to relieve the Siamese siege of Kengtung.",
"The ANSWER provided states 'several hundred', which contradicts the information in the DOCUMENT.",
"The discrepancy between 'several thousand' and 'several hundred' indicates that the ANSWER is not faithful to the DOCUMENT as it significantly underestimates the number of troops sent."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | b9fea4cd-50ae-4d1f-9b74-355f58198057 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks for the average length of William Henderson's catches in yards, to two decimal places.",
"The DOCUMENT provides information that William Henderson caught 41 passes for 367 yards.",
"To find the average yards per catch for William Henderson, the total yards (367) should be divided by the number of catches (41).",
"Calculating 367 yards / 41 catches gives approximately 8.95 yards per catch.",
"The ANSWER provided ('26.21', '9.95') does not match the calculated average of 8.95 yards per catch.",
"The ANSWER introduces two numbers, neither of which is correct or relevant based on the information provided in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 2ccd3520-158e-4c12-b1ca-18d9cd1efd06 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The Treaty of Karlowitz was signed in January 1699.",
"The document states that the Ottomans reclaimed the Morea in 1715.",
"Calculating the years between 1699 and 1715 gives 16 years.",
"The answer provided is 15, which is incorrect based on the calculation."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 5cfa349d-4653-4880-9967-f6b678dc8df5 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The QUESTION asks for a comparison between the cost per flight hour of the Sikorsky CH-53E Super Stallion in 2007 and the total cost of ownership per hour of the V-22 in 2013.",
"The DOCUMENT provides the necessary information, stating that the Sikorsky CH-53E Super Stallion cost about $20,000 per flight hour in 2007 and the V-22 total cost of ownership was $83,000 per hour in 2013.",
"The ANSWER provided is 'Sikorsky CH-53E Super Stallion', which does not directly answer the question of which cost more. It merely states one of the aircraft names without specifying the comparison or conclusion.",
"The ANSWER should have explicitly stated which aircraft had the higher cost based on the provided data to fully address the question."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | fac208a2-5081-49a4-8e15-6cf8cde1ee78 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The QUESTION asks specifically about the number of projects that cannot use SWF v10.",
"The DOCUMENT mentions only one project, Gnash, that cannot use SWF v10.",
"The ANSWER provided is '2', which implies there are two projects that cannot use SWF v10.",
"Since the DOCUMENT only identifies Gnash as unable to use SWF v10 and does not mention any other project with this limitation, the ANSWER introduces information not present in the DOCUMENT.",
"The ANSWER contradicts the DOCUMENT by stating a number of projects (two) that is not supported by the information provided in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 2091d4f0-9877-4fe7-a5e1-111a3b63ce80 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks which type of jobs were more numerous in the tertiary sector between the information industry and the insurance or financial industry.",
"According to the document, the number of jobs in the information industry within the tertiary sector is 140 or 1.7%.",
"The document also states that the number of jobs in the insurance or financial industry within the tertiary sector is 347 or 4.3%.",
"Comparing these figures, the insurance or financial industry has more jobs (347) than the information industry (140).",
"The answer provided ('information industry') incorrectly identifies the information industry as having more jobs than the insurance or financial industry, which contradicts the data given in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | f0eda175-7694-4013-a48e-d28478c5c5ee |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks for the percentage of the population that is not under the age of 18.",
"According to the document, 21.8% of the population is under the age of 18.",
"To find the percentage of the population that is not under the age of 18, one would subtract 21.8% from 100%, which equals 78.2%.",
"The answer provided includes two numbers: '78.2' and '22.8'.",
"The number '78.2' correctly represents the percentage of the population that is not under the age of 18, based on the document's information.",
"The number '22.8' does not correspond to any information provided in the document and introduces new information without context.",
"The inclusion of '22.8' in the answer makes it unfaithful to the document as it introduces information not present or implied in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 738a9759-71d2-48bd-8dda-1ba87d9ad9e9 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT states that three of the king's own brothers openly raised a rebellion in 1501.",
"The DOCUMENT also mentions that the forces of the confederation and Prome took Ava on 25 March 1527.",
"The ANSWER correctly identifies that the king's brothers raised a rebellion before the confederation and Prome took Ava, as the rebellion occurred in 1501 and the taking of Ava happened in 1527.",
"The ANSWER does not introduce any information that contradicts or is not present in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | 20eba3da-6af7-494f-a96f-2d84af1b4083 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks which group from the census is smaller: Asian or two or more races.",
"The DOCUMENT provides specific percentages for each racial group from the census of 2000.",
"According to the DOCUMENT, 0.11% of the population was Asian and 2.52% of the population was from two or more races.",
"From the percentages given, the Asian group (0.11%) is smaller than the group of two or more races (2.52%).",
"The ANSWER provided, ['two or more races', 'two or more races'], incorrectly identifies the group of two or more races as the smaller group.",
"The correct answer should have identified 'Asian' as the smaller group based on the percentages provided in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | b261ca22-01fe-4064-b7db-fd06460fbdd2 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks for the percentage of households with a female householder and a husband present.",
"The DOCUMENT provides information about the percentage of 'Marriage living together' households, which is 46.28%.",
"The term 'Marriage living together' likely refers to households where a married couple lives together, which could include households with a female householder and her husband.",
"The ANSWER lists two percentages: '46.28' and '12.68'.",
"The '46.28%' matches the percentage given in the DOCUMENT for 'Marriage living together' households.",
"However, the '12.68%' does not appear anywhere in the DOCUMENT, and it is unclear what this figure represents.",
"The inclusion of '12.68%' in the ANSWER introduces information not found in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 2fb37b41-5cb1-4cc8-a81b-cd1791b51a48 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The document lists several cities and areas that Venice attempted to take or successfully took during various military campaigns.",
"The cities and areas mentioned in the document that Venice targeted include: Sinj, Herceg Novi, Knin, Vrgorac, Čitluk, Gabela, Zažablje, Trebinje, Popovo, Klobuk, Metković.",
"The document also mentions that Venice relinquished areas including Popovo polje, Klek, and Sutorina in the final peace treaty, indicating these were also under Venetian control or influence at some point.",
"The answer '3, 12' suggests two numbers, which could imply that Venice tried to take 3 cities in one context and 12 in another, or it could be interpreted as a range. However, the document clearly lists more than three cities, and the total number of distinct places mentioned exceeds both 3 and 12.",
"The answer does not accurately reflect the information in the document regarding the number of cities Venice targeted, which is significantly more than three and not exactly twelve."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 8d1d1067-668e-47c9-9c68-4047b59b178b |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT provides specific numbers for the categories of military personnel, including officers and non-commissioned officers.",
"According to the DOCUMENT, there are 3,183 officers and 5,389 non-commissioned officers.",
"The difference between the number of non-commissioned officers and officers is calculated as 5,389 - 3,183 = 2,206.",
"The ANSWER provided is 2,200, which is a slight discrepancy from the correct calculation of 2,206.",
"The ANSWER is very close but not exactly the same as the correct difference calculated directly from the numbers provided in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 31569900-2592-4049-a45a-ae0786d993f5 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The document states that 3.5% of the population were of Hispanic or Latino origin.",
"To find the percentage of people who were not Hispanic or Latino, one would subtract the Hispanic or Latino percentage from 100%.",
"100% - 3.5% = 96.5%.",
"The answer provided is 95.5%, which does not match the calculated value of 96.5%.",
"Therefore, the answer inaccurately represents the percentage of non-Hispanic or Latino population based on the information given in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | d21e87f8-035e-4a1a-9f5c-fb15aa2ce8b3 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The document explicitly states that Frederick was the father of King Maximilian I.",
"The mention of 'his son King Maximilian I' in the document clearly identifies Frederick as Maximilian's father.",
"The inclusion of 'Vladislaus Jagiellon' in the answer is incorrect and not relevant to the question about Maximilian I's father.",
"The correct answer should solely be 'Frederick' based on the information provided in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | ba141618-4caa-48bf-b53f-928dd4049b84 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The QUESTION asks for the chronological order of two events: the Northern Seven Years' War and the Treaty of Stettin.",
"The DOCUMENT clearly states that the Northern Seven Years' War began in 1563 and ended in 1570 with the Treaty of Stettin.",
"The ANSWER provided, 'Treaty of Stettin', does not correctly address the question about which event happened first.",
"The correct response based on the DOCUMENT should indicate that the Northern Seven Years' War occurred before the Treaty of Stettin, as the war led to the treaty."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | e5aab9fe-011d-4cc2-adeb-d5700922fae9 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The QUESTION asks for a comparison of the number of people wounded between Germany and Spain.",
"The DOCUMENT provides specific casualty figures for an incident involving Germany, stating that there were 110 wounded Germans.",
"The DOCUMENT also mentions the Admiral Scheer Bombardment of Almería, where 50 civilians were wounded in Spain.",
"The ANSWER provided is simply 'Spanish', which does not directly address the comparison requested in the QUESTION.",
"The ANSWER should have explicitly compared the numbers or stated which side had more wounded based on the information in the DOCUMENT.",
"The ANSWER fails to utilize the information given in the DOCUMENT to make a comparative statement as required by the QUESTION."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | c5e14721-1bdf-4cde-a88c-7f6aa553d1ad |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks for the 'lowest race' in the Black British category in the UK, which is ambiguous but seems to inquire about the smallest population subgroup within the Black British category.",
"The DOCUMENT provides specific percentages for subgroups within the Black British category: 5.4% African, 2.2% British African-Caribbean people, and 1.0% Other Black.",
"Based on the DOCUMENT, the 'Other Black' subgroup at 1.0% is the smallest within the Black British category.",
"The ANSWER lists 'black' and 'british arab'. The term 'black' is too broad and does not specify which subgroup within Black British is being referred to.",
"The inclusion of 'british arab' in the ANSWER is incorrect as it refers to a completely different ethnic category (0.7% British Arab) which is not part of the Black British category.",
"The ANSWER fails to accurately specify the smallest subgroup within Black British and incorrectly includes an unrelated ethnic group."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 00ee5443-a686-447f-a893-7ffa7d6fab29 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks for the difference between the number of people and the number of households in the county.",
"According to the document, there were 445,342 people and 169,162 households in the county.",
"The difference between the number of people and the number of households is calculated as 445,342 - 169,162 = 276,180.",
"The answer provided is '276180' '169162', which seems to be a formatting error but includes the correct calculation of the difference (276,180) and also lists the number of households (169,162).",
"The correct answer to the question should be just the number 276,180, which represents the difference between the number of people and the number of households.",
"The inclusion of '169162' in the answer is unnecessary for answering the question but does not introduce new or contradictory information."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | dc0bbfc9-cd80-4a0d-b700-251bc9fd603e |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT states that the city obtained city rights in 1163 from Count Philip of Flanders.",
"The DOCUMENT also states that the Battle of Nieuwpoort occurred in 1600.",
"To find the number of years between the city obtaining its rights and the Battle of Nieuwpoort, subtract 1163 from 1600, which equals 437 years.",
"The ANSWER provided is 437 years, which correctly matches the calculation based on the dates provided in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | 051483b6-0852-4afb-b26d-a50ec3872348 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT states that Duke Magnus Birgersson refused to pay the agreed sum of 6,000 marks of silver and started a war by moving into Danish provinces in the fall of 1276.",
"The Battle of Ettak is mentioned later in the DOCUMENT, occurring after the initial refusal to pay and the subsequent military actions, including the Danish punitive expedition and the surprise defeat of the Danish army.",
"The sequence of events in the DOCUMENT clearly places Duke Magnus Birgersson's refusal to pay before the Battle of Ettak.",
"The ANSWER lists 'Battle of Ettak' before 'refusing to pay', which contradicts the sequence of events as described in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 3b92ed13-c70a-46cf-850d-ec04f2e403a6 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT provides the Mavericks' regular season record as 49-33.",
"This record indicates that the Mavericks won 49 games and lost 33 games during the regular season.",
"To find out how many more games the Mavericks won compared to those they lost, we subtract the number of losses (33) from the number of wins (49).",
"49 wins - 33 losses = 16 more wins than losses.",
"The ANSWER provided is '15', which is incorrect based on the calculation from the DOCUMENT.",
"The correct answer should be '16', not '15'."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 88633537-4589-4d6f-bd40-cbf09e57facb |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks who commanded the first battle among France Hugh, Philip of Montfort, or Charles.",
"The document specifies that the infantry and the first battle were commanded by Marshal of France Hugh of Mirepoix and Philip of Montfort, Lord of Castres.",
"Charles is mentioned as commanding the second battle in person, not the first.",
"The answer 'Philip of Montfort' is partially correct as he was one of the commanders of the first battle, along with Hugh of Mirepoix.",
"The answer does not mention Hugh of Mirepoix, who also commanded the first battle alongside Philip of Montfort, which could be seen as incomplete but not unfaithful to the document."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | 1dcf42a9-62d6-4a4b-9014-1b2009b1b584 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT provides specific numbers for both households and families in the county as of the census of 2000.",
"According to the DOCUMENT, there were 169,162 households and 114,015 families residing in the county.",
"The number of households (169,162) is greater than the number of families (114,015).",
"The QUESTION asks which group is smaller according to the census, and based on the numbers provided, families are the smaller group.",
"The ANSWER provided, 'households', incorrectly identifies households as the smaller group when in fact families are smaller according to the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | e0593802-3d0e-4f95-b12a-adba745add15 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The QUESTION asks for a comparison between the ancestral groups of 'swedish' and 'united states'.",
"The DOCUMENT provides specific percentages of ancestry from the 2000 census, listing 13.9% for Swedish and 8.8% for United States.",
"The ANSWER provided is simply 'swedish' repeated twice, which does not directly answer the question of which ancestral group is smaller.",
"The correct response based on the DOCUMENT should indicate that the 'united states' ancestral group is smaller than the 'swedish' group.",
"The ANSWER fails to provide this comparison or conclusion, thus it does not address the question based on the information in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 08e9ea82-f8a7-4069-b453-f907ad73a388 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The document specifies that Xu Hai's brother was executed on October 10, not October 11 as mentioned in the answer.",
"The answer provides two dates, '29 September 1556' and 'October 11'. The first date, '29 September 1556', corresponds to the date when Xu Hai's body was found, not the date of his brother's death.",
"The second date provided in the answer, 'October 11', is incorrect as per the document which clearly states that Xu Hai's brother was executed on October 10."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | ff20ab78-6d2c-4238-919e-34c40b4c9194 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks for the shortest field goal of the game.",
"The document lists several field goals with their distances: Robbie Gould's 31-yard, Josh Brown's 40-yard, Gould's 47-yard, Brown's 23-yard, Brown's 46-yard, and Gould's 48-yard field goals.",
"Among these, the shortest field goal is the 23-yard field goal kicked by Josh Brown.",
"The answer provided lists '40' and 'Josh Brown', indicating Josh Brown kicked a 40-yard field goal.",
"The answer incorrectly identifies the shortest field goal as 40 yards by Josh Brown, while the shortest was actually 23 yards by the same kicker.",
"Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the document as it provides incorrect information about the shortest field goal."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | e9a17f71-94ee-4031-af88-e9a3e116b575 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks which linguistic minority is larger between Urdu and Tamil language.",
"The document provides specific percentages for the linguistic minorities in Karnataka, stating Urdu speakers at 10.83% and Tamil speakers at 3.45%.",
"Based on the percentages provided, Urdu is a larger linguistic minority than Tamil in Karnataka.",
"The answer 'Tamil' incorrectly identifies Tamil as the larger linguistic minority compared to Urdu, which contradicts the information in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 06623ead-af87-4a4a-9ad0-0931212c4326 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks for the difference in the number of hypertension cases between 2010 and 2030 in Texas.",
"According to the document, Texas had 4,300,252 cases of hypertension in 2010 and is predicted to have 5,689,509 cases in 2030.",
"The difference between the predicted cases in 2030 and the actual cases in 2010 is 5,689,509 - 4,300,252 = 1,389,257.",
"The answer provided is '1389250', which is a numerical representation of the difference calculated.",
"The answer correctly calculates the difference without introducing any new information or contradicting the document."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | fa1cb100-d66a-48c1-bbee-b4ddc538c415 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT provides a detailed account of the game between the Jets and the Denver Broncos, including scoring plays and responses from both teams.",
"The DOCUMENT does not explicitly state the final outcome or which team won the game.",
"The ANSWER lists 'Jets' and 'New York' as the winners, but there is no information in the DOCUMENT confirming that the Jets won the game.",
"The DOCUMENT mentions several scoring plays by both teams, but without a final score or a statement of who won, it is impossible to confirm the ANSWER from the provided DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 0c31458f-e42d-4b73-b345-c14f5d6a33f5 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided does not match the numbers given in the document for the populations of Indians and Bangladeshis in Bahrain.",
"The document states there are approximately 290,000 Indians and 125,000 Bangladeshis in Bahrain.",
"The answer lists three numbers: 415,000, 415,000, and 225,000, none of which correspond to the numbers provided in the document for either Indians or Bangladeshis.",
"The answer introduces numbers that are not present or derived from the information in the document, thus adding new information that contradicts the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 54100f0d-e733-4793-a524-f41516bc100c |
{
"REASONING": [
"The ANSWER provided does not directly address the QUESTION asked about whether there were more Native American or Pacific Islander citizens in the 2010 census.",
"The ANSWER simply repeats 'Pacific Islander' twice, which does not provide a comparative figure or a direct response to the question regarding the population counts of Native American versus Pacific Islander citizens.",
"The DOCUMENT clearly states the population percentages for both groups in the 2010 census: 0.69% Native American and 0.14% Pacific Islander.",
"Based on the DOCUMENT, the correct response should indicate that there were more Native American citizens than Pacific Islander citizens in the 2010 census.",
"The ANSWER fails to convey this information and instead provides irrelevant repetition of the term 'Pacific Islander'."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 9d3d1971-95ba-47a6-99e6-5bc309592dc6 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT states that 29.5% of households had children under the age of 18 living with them.",
"The DOCUMENT also states that 33.4% of households were non-families.",
"To find the percentage difference between non-family households and those with children under 18, we subtract the percentage of households with children under 18 from the percentage of non-family households: 33.4% - 29.5% = 3.9%.",
"The ANSWER provided is 4.9, which does not match the calculated difference of 3.9% based on the information given in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | ed94cbf2-1585-4624-aa3f-a7332c61f3bf |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks for the player with the shortest touchdown scoring play.",
"The DOCUMENT lists several touchdown plays with their respective distances:",
" - Roscoe Parrish with a 51-yard pass reception.",
" - Kevan Barlow with a 3-yard run.",
" - Chris Baker with a 1-yard pass reception.",
" - Victor Hobson with a 32-yard fumble return.",
" - Cedric Houston with a 5-yard run.",
" - J. P. Losman with a 12-yard run.",
"Among these, the shortest touchdown play is the 1-yard pass reception by Chris Baker.",
"The ANSWER incorrectly identifies Kevan Barlow, who had a 3-yard touchdown run, not the shortest touchdown play."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | b29a73f3-0912-4507-8bf9-90a5bb0d5743 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The QUESTION asks which group is smaller between Macedonians and Turks in Skopje.",
"The DOCUMENT provides specific population numbers for both groups: Macedonians have 338,358 inhabitants, while Turks have 8,595 inhabitants.",
"Clearly, the population of Macedonians is significantly larger than that of Turks.",
"The ANSWER provided is 'Macedonians', which incorrectly identifies them as the smaller group compared to Turks.",
"The correct answer should have been 'Turks' as they are the smaller group according to the population figures given in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 5daefd35-2aca-4c15-a3e4-7886ab22c463 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT clearly states that the Jets had a 13-0 halftime lead over Tennessee.",
"The ANSWER provided states that Tennessee was losing by 14 points at the half, which contradicts the DOCUMENT.",
"The correct deficit for Tennessee at halftime was 13 points, not 14 as stated in the ANSWER."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 17bfaba8-54ab-4282-a6ea-3048e630b12f |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT clearly states the number of Filipinos and Indonesians living in Bahrain.",
"According to the DOCUMENT, there are 45,000 Filipinos and 8,000 Indonesians in Bahrain.",
"The ANSWER incorrectly identifies Indonesians as the larger group, which contradicts the numbers provided in the DOCUMENT.",
"The correct information, based on the DOCUMENT, should identify Filipinos as the larger group compared to Indonesians."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | b6315f46-65bb-4260-93f7-8f4c5b1b8933 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT mentions only one grand slam during game 4, which was hit by Lance Berkman in the eighth inning.",
"The ANSWER incorrectly states that there were two grand slams in game 4.",
"No other grand slams are mentioned in the DOCUMENT for game 4, thus the ANSWER provides information that contradicts the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | ab2ae01f-6885-4edd-9123-576a55508592 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The document states that 37.7% of all households were made up of individuals.",
"To find the percentage of households that weren't made up of individuals, we subtract this percentage from 100%.",
"100% - 37.7% = 62.3%.",
"The answer provided is 63.3%, which does not match the calculated value of 62.3%.",
"Therefore, the answer inaccurately represents the information given in the document by providing a percentage that is 1% higher than the correct value."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 09ce64d8-f59f-41fb-a68a-023e0c2aa318 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT mentions three specific instances where Neil Rackers kicked field goals: a 27-yard field goal, a 21-yard field goal, and a 25-yard field goal.",
"The ANSWER provided lists multiple numbers, including '3' which correctly matches the number of field goals mentioned in the DOCUMENT.",
"However, the ANSWER also includes '2' which does not match any information in the DOCUMENT and introduces inconsistency.",
"The correct and consistent answer should only include the number '3' repeated, reflecting the three field goals made by Rackers as stated in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 7aa482a7-d20c-472a-b8b9-634ea2d52511 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT states that the Forty Years' War ended in 1424.",
"The DOCUMENT also mentions that Minkhaung died in 1501.",
"To find the number of years between Minkhaung's death and the end of the Forty Years' War, we subtract 1424 from 1501, which equals 77 years.",
"The ANSWER provided is 76, which is incorrect based on the calculation from the information given in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | b03add16-92e7-472a-a751-356f658931d9 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT mentions a tie game between the Packers and the Minnesota Vikings with a score of 26-26.",
"The QUESTION specifically asks which team scored a tie against the Packers.",
"The ANSWER 'Detroit Lions' is incorrect because the DOCUMENT clearly states that the tie was with the Minnesota Vikings, not the Detroit Lions.",
"The DOCUMENT does describe a game between the Packers and the Lions, but it resulted in a loss for the Packers, not a tie."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 7efa4c3e-cb74-48dc-a70b-fb658df4c03e |
{
"REASONING": [
"The document mentions that Ryan Longwell kicked multiple field goals for the Vikings.",
"John Kasay is mentioned as having kicked a field goal for the Carolina Panthers.",
"Karney is mentioned as having kicked a 26-yard field goal, but it is not specified for which team. However, the context suggests it was for the Panthers as it is mentioned in contrast to the Vikings' actions.",
"The answer lists 'Karney' and 'Longwell' as the two players who both booted a single field goal, which is incorrect.",
"Ryan Longwell kicked more than one field goal in the game, as detailed in the document.",
"The correct answer should have been 'John Kasay' and 'Karney' if the question is asking for players who each kicked exactly one field goal in the game."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 04f796e2-1860-4455-905e-7479f0465000 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks specifically about the number of touchdown (TD) runs over 10 yards.",
"The document mentions two specific TD runs by Thomas Jones: one for 59 yards and another for 29 yards.",
"Both mentioned TD runs by Thomas Jones are over 10 yards.",
"The document also mentions a TD run by Peyton Hillis, but it was only for 1 yard, which is not over 10 yards.",
"No other TD runs are mentioned in the document.",
"The answer provided is '3', which does not match the number of TD runs over 10 yards described in the document, which are only two."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | b65ccb0e-3823-4ccd-86eb-f67da9fcbcca |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT lists the following countries and regions where Circassian refugees fled: the Balkans, Turkey, the Ottoman Empire, Iran, Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, Kosovo, Egypt, Israel, upstate New York, and New Jersey.",
"Counting each of these individually results in a total of 12 distinct locations.",
"The ANSWER provided is '10', which does not match the number of locations listed in the DOCUMENT.",
"Therefore, the ANSWER fails to accurately reflect the information given in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 65816218-01c4-4071-b10e-32018bf3555f |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT states that the Ulster Special Constabulary was established in 1920.",
"It also mentions that the Ulster Special Constabulary was expanded in 1922.",
"The time between 1920 and 1922 is 2 years.",
"The ANSWER provided is '3', which does not match the 2-year interval stated in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 191d8f02-1a51-41a9-b6fc-1ec3a7fc3f28 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT states that the pre-war population of the peninsula was around 200,000.",
"The ANSWER incorrectly states the pre-war population as 150,000, which contradicts the information provided in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 85c0443f-49ae-4132-8a0e-84a7a698f3bc |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT states there were 7,791 people and 3,155 households in the county according to the census of 2000.",
"To find how many more people than households, the calculation would be 7,791 people minus 3,155 households, which equals 4,636.",
"The ANSWER provided is '4635', which is incorrect as the correct difference is 4,636.",
"The ANSWER is off by 1 from the correct calculation based on the numbers provided in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 479065fe-7b69-4cdf-a6ab-a72081f5fd3d |
{
"REASONING": [
"The document specifies that the Ravens lost to Cincinnati in Week 2.",
"The document also mentions a loss to Atlanta, but this occurred after the first month of the season, specifically on a Thursday Night later in the schedule.",
"The first month of the NFL season typically covers Weeks 1-4.",
"Within the first month (Weeks 1-4), the document records only one loss for the Ravens, which was against Cincinnati.",
"The answer incorrectly states that the Ravens lost 2 games in the first month of the season."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 6490a684-c717-4a51-aa10-038e4976470e |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT provides a detailed account of the scoring events in the game between the Seahawks and the 49ers.",
"The DOCUMENT lists the following scores: a safety (2 points), a field goal (3 points), a touchdown by Lynch (7 points including the extra point), a field goal by Dawson (3 points), another touchdown by Lynch (7 points including the extra point), a field goal by Hauschka (3 points), and another touchdown by Lynch (7 points including the extra point).",
"Adding these scores together, the total points scored in the game are 2 (safety) + 3 (first field goal) + 7 (first touchdown) + 3 (second field goal) + 7 (second touchdown) + 3 (third field goal) + 7 (third touchdown) = 32 points.",
"The ANSWER provided lists three numbers: 32, 32, 35. The correct total score based on the DOCUMENT is 32.",
"The inclusion of '35' in the ANSWER is incorrect and not supported by the DOCUMENT, which clearly calculates to a total of 32 points."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 04229619-f983-4260-b36c-bf870be9f2db |
{
"REASONING": [
"The shortest touchdown run mentioned in the document was by RB Cecil Sapp, which was a 4-yard TD run.",
"The shortest passing touchdown mentioned in the document was by QB Jay Cutler to WR Brandon Stokley, which was a 9-yard TD pass.",
"The question asks for the difference in yards between the shortest touchdown run and the shortest passing touchdown.",
"The difference between a 4-yard run and a 9-yard pass is 5 yards (9 - 4 = 5).",
"The answer provided is '3', which does not match the calculated difference of 5 yards."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | fa762719-24ad-4870-b10c-8d93d2780c19 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT states that 24.35% of households had children under the age of 18 living with them.",
"To find the percentage of households that do not have children under the age of 18 living with them, one would subtract the percentage of households with children (24.35%) from 100%.",
"100% - 24.35% = 75.65%.",
"The ANSWER provided two figures: '75.7' and '76', which are both close approximations of 75.65%.",
"The ANSWER rounds the exact figure (75.65%) to either one decimal place ('75.7') or to the nearest whole number ('76').",
"Both figures in the ANSWER are reasonable rounding choices of the calculated percentage (75.65%) and do not introduce any new information beyond the calculation based on the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | 24bdab7d-0a24-47d2-90ec-a83a38fa9a9f |
{
"REASONING": [
"The document states that the peace treaty from 1726 was annulled in the summer of 1727.",
"The time between 1726 and 1727 is one year.",
"The answer '2' is incorrect as it does not match the one-year duration between the treaty and its annulment as stated in the document.",
"The answer '495' is irrelevant and does not pertain to the question asked or the information provided in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 2d55d8e7-cc38-4db0-be01-61a6a8c28839 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks for the yardage of the last touchdown in the game.",
"According to the DOCUMENT, the last touchdown mentioned is by WR Chad Ochocinco on an 8-yard TD pass from QB Carson Palmer.",
"The ANSWER provided is '10', which does not match the '8-yard TD pass' mentioned in the DOCUMENT as the last touchdown.",
"Therefore, the ANSWER contradicts the information provided in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 3028fd0b-a28c-4357-b9a6-0599f22acb0e |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question specifically asks for places where Jews were killed in October 1941.",
"The DOCUMENT mentions two specific locations related to the month of October 1941: Dnipropetrovsk and Kryvyi Rih.",
"In Dnipropetrovsk, the DOCUMENT states that on 13 October 1941, some 10,000-15,000 Jews were shot.",
"In Kryvyi Rih, the DOCUMENT mentions a massacre in mid-October where 4,000-5,000 Soviet Jews were killed.",
"The ANSWER lists 'Dnipropetrovsk' twice, which is redundant but accurate for one of the events in October 1941.",
"The ANSWER includes 'Soviet Union' which is overly broad and not specific to the question as it does not directly refer to a specific location of an event within the context of October 1941.",
"The ANSWER includes 'Kharkiv', but according to the DOCUMENT, the massacre in Kharkiv occurred in January 1942, not October 1941."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 248470fb-3c8c-4d42-987b-03b6bf9c2645 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks for the player with the shortest touchdown run.",
"The DOCUMENT lists several touchdown runs with their respective distances:",
"T.J. Duckett with a 32-yard TD run.",
"Marion Barber with a 20-yard TD run.",
"Kevin Jones with a 2-yard TD run and a 3-yard TD run.",
"Marion Barber with a 1-yard TD run.",
"Among these, the shortest touchdown run is the 1-yard TD run by Marion Barber.",
"The ANSWER provided is 'Kevin Jones', who did have a 2-yard TD run, but this was not the shortest as per the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 086f5511-6d9a-44d0-9b0c-6523763557bf |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT explicitly states that Abd el-Krim ordered his forces not to attack Melilla, which was described as Spain's biggest base in the eastern Rif.",
"Abd el-Krim expressed regret over not attacking Melilla, as he later admitted that not attacking it was his biggest mistake.",
"The ANSWER lists 'the town' which, in the context of the DOCUMENT, refers to Melilla.",
"The ANSWER also includes 'Ceuta' which is not mentioned anywhere in the DOCUMENT as a target of regret for not attacking by Abd el-Krim.",
"Including 'Ceuta' in the ANSWER introduces information not present in the DOCUMENT, thus it is unfaithful to the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | ff5d6a08-c175-4984-a800-22f31836e59e |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT states that 39.7% of the population was British Asian.",
"To find the percentage of people who were not British Asian, we subtract the percentage of British Asian (39.7%) from the total population (100%).",
"100% - 39.7% = 60.3%.",
"The ANSWER provided is '50.3', which does not match the correct calculation of 60.3%.",
"Therefore, the ANSWER contradicts the information provided in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | c4e40c10-002c-4392-820a-4d18139ca8a3 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks for a comparison of the birth rate in Carbon County for the years 2000 and 2011.",
"The document provides specific data on the number of births in Carbon County for both years: 566 births in 2000 and 586 births in 2011.",
"The answer '2000' suggests that the birth rate was higher in the year 2000, which contradicts the data provided in the document.",
"The document clearly states that the birth rate in 2011 (586 babies) was higher than in 2000 (566 births).",
"The answer fails to accurately reflect the information in the document and incorrectly identifies 2000 as having a higher birth rate than 2011."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 09a196c3-f6b8-48d6-b7f7-caf4df4a4113 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks for the difference between the number of applications and offers specifically for medicine in the United Kingdom.",
"The DOCUMENT provides specific numbers for the School of Medicine, stating it received 1,764 applications and made 39 offers.",
"To find the difference between applications and offers for medicine, subtract the number of offers (39) from the number of applications (1,764).",
"The calculation is 1,764 - 39 = 1,725.",
"The ANSWER provided is 1,726, which is off by 1 from the correct calculation based on the numbers given in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 1e507704-e02d-4e8a-9007-e51ed9f1a8dd |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT specifies that the Volunteers took over Enniscorthy on Thursday, 27 April and held it until Sunday.",
"The exact date for Sunday is not provided, but the context implies it is the immediate Sunday following Thursday, 27 April.",
"Counting the days from Thursday (including Thursday) to Sunday gives a total of four days (Thursday, Friday, Saturday, and Sunday).",
"The ANSWER provided is '5', which does not match the four-day duration described in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | cfac9a46-d99f-4619-b4c6-17583db95adc |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT states that 900 Jacobites were pardoned.",
"The DOCUMENT also states that 120 Jacobites were executed.",
"To find the number of more pardoned than executed, the calculation would be 900 pardoned minus 120 executed, which equals 780.",
"The ANSWER provided is '250', '780', '780', '780'. Only one of these values, '780', matches the correct calculation based on the information in the DOCUMENT.",
"The inclusion of '250' in the ANSWER is incorrect and not supported by any calculation or information provided in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | dfb8b12a-2d7c-45a7-a354-e9caacefcaa3 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT explicitly states that the invasion force consisted of 3,500 Green Standard troops along with Tai-Shan militias.",
"The DOCUMENT does not mention 'local Chinese militias' as part of the forces that joined the Green Standard troops in the siege of Kengtung.",
"The inclusion of 'local Chinese militias' in the ANSWER introduces information that is not present in the DOCUMENT, thus making the ANSWER partially unfaithful."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 4e54b444-97a2-46f6-b7ba-2c37b7ff0bad |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks for the number of active military personnel who were not soldiers in May 2016.",
"According to the document, the total number of active military personnel was 14,506.",
"The document breaks down the 14,506 active military personnel into several categories: 3,183 officers, 5,389 non-commissioned officers, 5,393 soldiers, 520 military specialists, 337 civil servants, and 1,176 other employees.",
"To find the number of active military personnel who were not soldiers, we need to subtract the number of soldiers (5,393) from the total active military personnel (14,506).",
"The calculation is 14,506 - 5,393 = 9,113.",
"The answer provided is '1513', '10636'. The '1513' refers to the number of civil servants, which is not relevant to the question about active military personnel who were not soldiers. The '10636' does not match any calculation or data provided in the document.",
"The correct answer should be 9,113, which is not reflected in the answer provided."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | ab51eead-e233-4a61-8c21-2de32e82af47 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT provides the life expectancy for men as 71.96 years and for women as 79.62 years in 2015.",
"The difference in life expectancy between women and men can be calculated as 79.62 - 71.96 = 7.66 years.",
"The ANSWER provided is 6.66, which does not match the calculated difference of 7.66 years.",
"Therefore, the ANSWER contradicts the information provided in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | fb9e450b-0d0d-49f0-853d-10b72ee76199 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks specifically about the number of touchdowns scored by New Orleans in the second quarter.",
"The document details that in the second quarter, New Orleans scored two touchdowns: one by Devery Henderson on a 12-yard pass from Drew Brees and another by Lance Moore on a 30-yard pass from Drew Brees.",
"The answer provided, '2', correctly matches the number of touchdowns scored by New Orleans in the second quarter as described in the document.",
"The number '23' in the answer appears to be unrelated to the question about touchdowns in the second quarter and is not supported by the document in the context of the question. The '23' might refer to the 23-yard field goal mentioned in the first quarter, but this is not relevant to the question asked."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | b70d045e-f5bc-48a4-91ff-534052ff8698 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT provides the percentage distribution of the population across various age groups.",
"The age group '25 to 44' is mentioned in the DOCUMENT with a percentage of 22.80%.",
"The age group '45 to 64' has the highest percentage in the DOCUMENT, which is 25.40%.",
"The ANSWER incorrectly identifies '25 to 44' as the age group with the highest percentage.",
"The correct age group with the highest percentage, according to the DOCUMENT, should be '45 to 64'."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 40d68867-045b-4f37-a819-62f2e6da5c36 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks for countries with less than 3000 of their citizens belonging to Northern Cyprus.",
"The DOCUMENT provides specific numbers of Northern Cyprus citizens born in different countries: 2,482 born in the UK and 913 born in Bulgaria.",
"Both the UK and Bulgaria have fewer than 3000 citizens who are citizens of Northern Cyprus, as per the data provided.",
"However, the ANSWER incorrectly lists 'UK' twice and includes 'Greece', which is not mentioned at all in the DOCUMENT.",
"The repetition of 'UK' in the ANSWER is incorrect and redundant.",
"The inclusion of 'Greece' in the ANSWER introduces information not present in the DOCUMENT, which is a direct contradiction to the requirement that the ANSWER must not offer new information beyond the context provided in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 6ee455be-25b0-4373-9246-49c25dd405a5 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT describes only one field goal attempt by Janikowski in overtime, which he missed after hitting the left goal post.",
"The QUESTION specifically asks how many field goals Janikowski missed in OT, which according to the DOCUMENT is only one.",
"The ANSWER provided states '2', which contradicts the information in the DOCUMENT that only one field goal was missed by Janikowski in overtime."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | ad522de7-f0cd-495b-b0ce-b81457f24187 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The document states that Sebastian Janikowski scored two field goals, specifically from 33 yards and 30 yards.",
"The document mentions that Kris Brown scored three field goals, specifically from 53 yards, 24 yards, and 40 yards.",
"The answer provided lists the number of field goals as '2' for Janikowski and '4' for Brown, which is incorrect for Brown as he only made three field goals according to the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 03fdc8a0-d62b-49a0-8087-af92e6659650 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT states that 39.1% of the population reported German ancestry.",
"To find the percentage of the population that reported ancestries other than German, we subtract 39.1% from 100%, which equals 60.9%.",
"The ANSWER provided is '59.1', which is close but not exactly the same as 60.9%.",
"The discrepancy suggests a calculation error or rounding difference in the ANSWER when compared to the correct calculation based on the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 79cca8c7-6300-42d8-a594-6757ee3d19b0 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The document provides specific percentages for various racial groups in the county.",
"The question asks for the number of races that each made up less than 1% of the population.",
"From the document, the races that made up less than 1% of the population are identified as: 0.64% Race (United States Census) and 0.06% Race (United States Census).",
"These two races are the only ones listed with percentages less than 1%.",
"The answer provided, ['2', '3'], suggests two numbers, but the context of the question and the document indicates that only the number of races should be provided, not the specific percentages or any other numbers.",
"The correct answer should be '2' as there are two races each making up less than 1% of the population.",
"The answer '3' does not correspond to any relevant data in the document or the question."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 02254a93-0cac-4576-b192-5d46b9b683e9 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The QUESTION asks for the number of regions where the popular uprising started.",
"The DOCUMENT mentions several regions involved in the uprising: Lower Bavaria, the Innviertel, eastern Bavaria, the Bavarian Forest, parts of the Upper Palatinate, and Kelheim on the Danube.",
"The ANSWER provided is '4', which seems to be an attempt to count distinct regions mentioned in the DOCUMENT.",
"However, the DOCUMENT does not explicitly state that the uprising started in exactly four regions, nor does it provide a clear count of starting regions.",
"The regions listed in the DOCUMENT are part of the description of the spread and impact of the uprising, not necessarily the initial starting points.",
"The ANSWER '4' could be an interpretation or an inferred count based on the regions mentioned, but it is not directly supported by explicit information in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 0ac9c4ec-9ef4-429b-970a-9af43bdb672b |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT states that the official language is Arabic, with French also spoken, particularly in commercial dealings.",
"The DOCUMENT mentions that less than 2% speak Berber languages.",
"The DOCUMENT does not mention Spanish as a language spoken in the region.",
"The ANSWER incorrectly includes 'Spanish' as a language spoken, which is not supported by the DOCUMENT.",
"The ANSWER redundantly lists 'Berber' twice, which could be seen as an error in listing but does not introduce new information beyond the context provided."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 6718d8a2-021d-4a6c-8d99-d15c75bb945c |
{
"REASONING": [
"The document specifies that three field goals were made in the first half: one by Josh Scobee (29-yard) and two by Rian Lindell (26-yard and 28-yard).",
"A fourth field goal by Rian Lindell (22-yard) was also mentioned, but it was scored at the end of the first half, making it the third field goal by Lindell and the fourth overall in the first half.",
"The answer '4' correctly accounts for all the field goals made in the first half as per the document."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | 7c421bc5-314b-4c6c-a4a3-d845535d7e53 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks for the player with the longest touchdown reception in the described game.",
"The DOCUMENT mentions three touchdown receptions: a 34-yard touchdown pass to Stallworth, a 7-yard touchdown reception by Watson, and a 25-yard touchdown catch by Watson.",
"Among these, the 34-yard touchdown pass to Stallworth is the longest.",
"The ANSWER provided is 'Watson', who had touchdown receptions of 7 yards and 25 yards, neither of which is the longest.",
"Therefore, the correct answer should have been 'Stallworth' based on the longest touchdown reception of 34 yards."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 7d5def03-c325-4506-a02b-ddbbeb96345c |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks which team lost the game.",
"The document details the game between the Raiders and the Titans, describing how the game unfolded.",
"The document states that the Raiders won the game with a game-clinching touchdown by Carr to Roberts after a penalty on the Titans.",
"The answer lists 'Raiders' and 'Oakland', which are essentially the same team, Oakland Raiders.",
"Since the Raiders won the game, mentioning them as the team that lost is incorrect and contradicts the information in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 3d22ced5-5b49-473d-8fce-ffdbaafb5df5 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks for the difference in the number of active union members in the manufacturing sector between 1970 and 1980.",
"The document provides specific numbers for the UAW's automobile union members in the manufacturing sector: 1,619,000 in 1970 and 1,446,000 in 1980.",
"The difference between the number of members in 1970 and 1980 is 1,619,000 - 1,446,000 = 173,000.",
"The answer provided is ['494000', '194000'], which does not match the calculated difference of 173,000.",
"The numbers in the answer do not correspond to any calculations or data points mentioned in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 81ae75c5-47c9-4923-9e96-3c4a66d126f5 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT states that 9.8% of Nashville residents carpooled, while only 2% used public transportation to commute in 2016.",
"The ANSWER suggests that more Nashville residents used public transportation to commute in 2016, which contradicts the information provided in the DOCUMENT.",
"The correct information, based on the DOCUMENT, should indicate that more residents used carpooling than public transportation."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | b24bc125-850b-4d5b-ae8f-c768185f2460 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks for the total number of hot dogs eaten by Kobayashi and the bear in the 2003 competition.",
"The document provides the specific numbers of hot dogs eaten by both Kobayashi and the bear in the 2003 competition: Kobayashi ate 31 hot dogs and the bear ate 50 hot dogs.",
"Adding these two amounts together gives a total of 81 hot dogs (31 + 50 = 81).",
"The answer provided is 82, which is not the correct sum based on the information given in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | d21406bb-d67d-419e-baed-a5bd85efe0ba |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT states that official records report 2337 rebels killed.",
"Unofficial estimates, according to the DOCUMENT, put the number of killed at 10,000.",
"The difference between the unofficial estimates and the official records for the number of rebels killed is 10,000 - 2337 = 7663.",
"The ANSWER provided is '7625', which does not match the calculated difference of 7663.",
"Therefore, the ANSWER inaccurately represents the difference between the unofficial estimates and the official numbers of rebels killed as provided in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 22ffefe1-54e1-4155-9c21-e8caeff18799 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT clearly states that the three leading causes of death in Texas are heart disease, stroke, and cancer.",
"Hypertension, while mentioned as a consequence of obesity and having a high number of cases, is not listed among the leading causes of death.",
"The ANSWER incorrectly identifies 'stroke' as not being a leading cause of death in Texas, which contradicts the information provided in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | f55a7690-17dc-4e98-8457-47b80c51d530 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT specifies that the Cardinals' first points of the game came from a touchdown pass by quarterback Matt Leinart to wide receiver Larry Fitzgerald in the fourth quarter.",
"The ANSWER states that Anquan Boldin got the Cardinals their first points, which contradicts the DOCUMENT.",
"The DOCUMENT does not mention Anquan Boldin in the context of scoring or contributing to the Cardinals' points in this game."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 9555b283-c5a8-467a-b0bd-84ca6bdd54c0 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks for the total number of people who were killed, captured, and listed as casualties.",
"The document provides specific numbers: 12 US troops were killed, 23 US troops were taken prisoner, and 45 Mexican Federales were casualties.",
"To find the total, we add these numbers together: 12 (killed) + 23 (captured) + 45 (casualties) = 80.",
"The answer provided is 85, which does not match the correct total of 80 calculated from the document.",
"Therefore, the answer introduces an error in calculation and provides incorrect information not supported by the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | a0c02482-0031-400d-b6f0-aa089bcf1424 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The question asks for languages spoken by more than 10,000 people.",
"According to the document, German is spoken by 13,444 people and Vietnamese by 11,330 people.",
"French is listed in the document as having 8,258 speakers, which is less than 10,000.",
"The answer incorrectly includes French, which does not meet the criterion of being spoken by more than 10,000 people.",
"Vietnamese is listed twice in the answer, which is redundant and could be misleading in the context of listing distinct languages meeting the criterion."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | ca1f3891-bb6a-48e9-9eb7-1112da79169c |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT provides the distances of Mikel Leshoure's touchdown runs as 7, 1, and 8 yards.",
"The longest touchdown run by Leshoure was 8 yards.",
"The shortest touchdown run by Leshoure was 1 yard.",
"The difference between the longest and shortest touchdown runs is 8 - 1 = 7 yards.",
"The ANSWER provided is 6, which does not match the correct calculation of 7 yards."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | bd4cc774-ffa5-4d32-95e4-f03702486abf |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT states that 32.8% of households had children under the age of 18 living with them.",
"To find the percentage of households that do not have children under the age of 18 living with them, we subtract the percentage of households with children (32.8%) from 100%.",
"100% - 32.8% = 67.2%.",
"The ANSWER provided is 65.2%, which does not match the calculated value of 67.2% based on the information in the DOCUMENT."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 781fd4f8-d4bb-4ff8-9734-ffe0e765271b |
{
"REASONING": [
"The DOCUMENT provides information about Yancey Thigpen's total receptions and total yards in 1995.",
"Thigpen had 85 receptions for 1,307 yards.",
"To find the average yards per reception, the total yards (1,307) should be divided by the total receptions (85).",
"The calculation is 1307 / 85 = 15.376470588235294.",
"Rounded to two decimal places, the average yards per reception is 15.38.",
"The ANSWER provided is 15.27, which does not match the calculated average of 15.38."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | a4a5b6b7-60ff-45af-94e0-3ea3b34fccb9 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The treaty to invade France was signed on 31 December 1543.",
"The document states that by May 1544, two Imperial armies were poised to invade France.",
"The time between December 1543 and May 1544 spans approximately 5 months.",
"The answer provided is '4', which does not match the approximate 5-month period indicated in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 8c58adfd-ad42-44ee-9344-bf5e9f79c82f |