response
stringlengths 20
814
| label
stringclasses 2
values | id
stringlengths 36
36
|
|---|---|---|
{"REASONING":
-1.1 | FAIL | 8fe613c4-ac82-4917-b6f8-f5e7658625cb |
{"REASONING":
-1.5, "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | dddfdc79-a324-4f39-8951-30e865567059 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 } | FAIL | 2243335c-cbca-4e6b-9a9d-f7e5907383bf |
{"REASONING":
["The question asks for the player who caught the shortest touchdown reception of the game",
"The answer provided is 'Reggie Bush' with a 6-yard touchdown reception",
"According to the document, Reggie Bush did catch a 6-yard touchdown pass from Drew Brees",
"Therefore, the answer is faithful to the document"],
"SCORE": "PASS"} | FAIL | d4816696-2cb0-4f35-98cd-89d3ebc7cff5 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 | FAIL | c59a30c4-f053-4403-98fa-0e52e553483a |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided does not mention any specific numbers related to public sector union membership surpassing private sector union membership",
"The answer '1.0' does not align with any information provided in the document regarding the difference in membership between public and private sector unions",
"There is no indication in the document that the difference in membership can be represented as '1.0'"],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 7f09cd77-75f4-4fce-8bdd-110721362765 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided states that 75.3% were not under the age of 18.",
"From the document, we can calculate that the percentage of people not under the age of 18 is 100% - 25.3% = 74.7%.",
"The answer provided is not accurate based on the information in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 896f8bf7-8fa4-4a48-8dd0-7e911eccfe4c |
{
"REASONING": [
"The document clearly states that Alexander the Great invaded Pauravas first in 326 BCE.",
"Menander I Soter invaded the Punjab after the Maurya Empire rule was consolidated into the Indo-Greek Kingdom in 180 BCE.",
"The answer provided is not faithful to the document as it does not mention the chronological order of events."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 7ffd22a7-d24f-4cf3-aa1f-011ceb26a1da |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided states '47' as the longest field goal, which is accurate according to the document.",
"The document mentions that the longest field goal in the game was a 47-yard field goal by kicker Olindo Mare.",
"The answer repeats '47' twice, which is consistent with the information provided in the document."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | bbdf02d1-cf9f-4aaf-aad7-bd00fd1a2fcb |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided is '3', which is a numerical value indicating the number of states where most of the underground mines were located.",
"The document specifically mentions that the UMW had 20,000 coal miners in underground mines, primarily in Kentucky and West Virginia.",
"Since the document only mentions Kentucky and West Virginia as the states where most of the underground mines were located, the answer '3' is not accurate.",
"Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the document."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 420e3ec7-4742-4dc2-91e0-85c92f74c0f1 |
{"REASONING":
-25.70, | FAIL | 3b1c98e0-bf3a-4459-a4a4-de719bafaf58 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 6c1bb873-aca9-43e1-bc0f-c16e13e5544b |
{"REASONING":
-1.0, "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | b9fea4cd-50ae-4d1f-9b74-355f58198057 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 2ccd3520-158e-4c12-b1ca-18d9cd1efd06 |
{"REASONING":
-1.0, "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 5cfa349d-4653-4880-9967-f6b678dc8df5 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The document states that the Sikorsky CH-53E Super Stallion cost about $20,000 per flight hour in 2007.",
"The document also states that the V-22 Total cost of ownership was $83,000 per hour in 2013.",
"Based on the information provided, the Sikorsky CH-53E Super Stallion cost less per flight hour compared to the V-22 in 2013."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | fac208a2-5081-49a4-8e15-6cf8cde1ee78 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided does not address the question of how many projects cannot use SWF v10. Instead, it simply states '2' without any context or explanation.",
"The document mentions that Gnash cannot use SWF v10, but the answer does not mention Gnash or provide any relevant information from the document."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 2091d4f0-9877-4fe7-a5e1-111a3b63ce80 |
{"REASONING":
["The document states that there were 140 jobs in the information industry in the tertiary sector.",
"The document also states that there were 347 jobs in the insurance or financial industry in the tertiary sector.",
"Comparing the two numbers, there were more jobs in the insurance or financial industry than in the information industry in the tertiary sector."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | f0eda175-7694-4013-a48e-d28478c5c5ee |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided states that 78.2% weren't under the age of 18, which is calculated by subtracting 21.8% (those under 18) from 100%. This calculation is correct based on the information provided in the document.",
"The answer also includes 22.8% which seems to be the percentage of individuals under the age of 18. This is incorrect as the document clearly states that 21.8% of the population is under the age of 18."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 738a9759-71d2-48bd-8dda-1ba87d9ad9e9 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer correctly mentions that Ava's only ally was the Shan state of Thibaw, which was fighting Mohnyin's raids on its territory, as stated in the document.",
"The answer also correctly states that the king's brothers openly raised a rebellion, which occurred in 1501 according to the document."],
"SCORE": "PASS"} | FAIL | 20eba3da-6af7-494f-a96f-2d84af1b4083 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer correctly identifies 'two or more races' as the smaller group compared to Asian.",
"Both instances of 'two or more races' in the answer are directly from the document.",
"The answer does not introduce any new information or contradict the document."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | b261ca22-01fe-4064-b7db-fd06460fbdd2 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided states that 46.28% of households had a female householder with a husband present, which is incorrect.",
"The document only provides information about the percentage of households that were marriage living together (46.28%), not specifically households with a female householder and a husband present.",
"The answer also mentions 12.68%, which is not supported by any information in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 2fb37b41-5cb1-4cc8-a81b-cd1791b51a48 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided states that Venice tried to take 3 cities, which is not accurate based on the information in the document. The document mentions multiple cities that Venice besieged or took, but the specific number of cities they tried to take is not explicitly mentioned.",
"The answer also includes the number 12, which does not correspond to the information in the document. There is no mention of Venice trying to take 12 cities in the provided text."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 8d1d1067-668e-47c9-9c68-4047b59b178b |
{"REASONING":
-1.5,
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 31569900-2592-4049-a45a-ae0786d993f5 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided does not mention anything about the percentage of people who were not Hispanic",
"The answer '95.5%' does not align with any information regarding the percentage of people who were not Hispanic in the document"
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | d21e87f8-035e-4a1a-9f5c-fb15aa2ce8b3 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer mentions 'Frederick' as the father of King Maximilian I, which is incorrect. Frederick was Maximilian's grandfather, not his father.",
"The answer also mentions 'Vladislaus Jagiellon' as a possible father of King Maximilian I, which is incorrect. Vladislaus Jagiellon was actually the successor to Matthias Corvinus in Hungary, not the father of Maximilian.",
"The correct information about King Maximilian I's father is not provided in the answer."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | ba141618-4caa-48bf-b53f-928dd4049b84 |
{"REASONING":
-1.0, "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | e5aab9fe-011d-4cc2-adeb-d5700922fae9 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | c5e14721-1bdf-4cde-a88c-7f6aa553d1ad |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided includes 'black' which is a race mentioned in the document, specifically under the category of Black British with a percentage of 8.6%.",
"The answer also includes 'british arab' which is not explicitly mentioned in the document as a separate race category.",
"However, the document does mention '0.7% British Arab' under the category of British Arab, which is a separate category from Black British."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 00ee5443-a686-447f-a893-7ffa7d6fab29 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | dc0bbfc9-cd80-4a0d-b700-251bc9fd603e |
{
"REASONING": [
"The document states that the city obtained city rights in 1163 from Count Philip of Flanders.",
"The Battle of Nieuwpoort, mentioned in the question, occurred in 1600.",
"There is no mention in the document of the Battle of Nieuwpoort being related to the city obtaining city rights.",
"Calculating the years between 1163 and 1600, it is actually 437 years.",
"The answer provided is accurate based on the information given in the document."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | 051483b6-0852-4afb-b26d-a50ec3872348 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer correctly identifies the Battle of Ettak as happening before Duke Magnus Birgersson refusing to pay the 6,000 marks of silver, as stated in the document.",
"The answer does not introduce any new information beyond what is provided in the document.",
"The answer does not contradict any information in the document."],
"SCORE": "PASS"} | FAIL | 3b92ed13-c70a-46cf-850d-ec04f2e403a6 |
{"REASONING":
-1.5, "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 88633537-4589-4d6f-bd40-cbf09e57facb |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 1dcf42a9-62d6-4a4b-9014-1b2009b1b584 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided is 'households', which is accurate according to the document.",
"The document states that there were 169,162 households and 114,015 families residing in the county, indicating that households are smaller in number compared to families."],
"SCORE": "PASS"} | FAIL | e0593802-3d0e-4f95-b12a-adba745add15 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided only mentions 'swedish' twice, which does not provide a comparison between the size of the Swedish ancestral group and the United States ancestral group.",
"The answer does not specify whether the Swedish ancestral group is smaller or larger than the United States ancestral group.",
"There is no direct comparison made between the size of the Swedish and United States ancestral groups in the answer.",
"The answer does not contradict any information provided in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 08e9ea82-f8a7-4069-b453-f907ad73a388 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided states '29 September 1556' which is accurate based on the information in the document that Xu Hai's body was found on September 29 after the battle ended.",
"The answer also includes 'October 11', which is not explicitly mentioned in the document. However, the document does mention that on October 10, Xu Hai's brother was executed, which could be the source of confusion for the respondent."],
"SCORE": "PASS"} | FAIL | ff20ab78-6d2c-4238-919e-34c40b4c9194 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer states that Josh Brown kicked the shortest field goal of the game, which is accurate based on the information provided in the document.",
"According to the document, Josh Brown kicked a 40-yard field goal, which was the shortest field goal made by him during the game."],
"SCORE": "PASS"} | FAIL | e9a17f71-94ee-4031-af88-e9a3e116b575 |
{"REASONING":
-1.0, "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 06623ead-af87-4a4a-9ad0-0931212c4326 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided does not mention the specific number of cases of hypertension expected in 2010 and 2030, which are necessary to calculate the difference",
"The answer does not provide any information related to the cases of hypertension in Texas in 2010 and 2030",
"There is no indication in the answer that suggests a comparison between the number of hypertension cases in 2010 and 2030"],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | fa1cb100-d66a-48c1-bbee-b4ddc538c415 |
{"REASONING":
-1.0, "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 0c31458f-e42d-4b73-b345-c14f5d6a33f5 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided states that there are 415,000 Indians and Bangladeshis in Bahrain, which is the sum of 290,000 Indians and 125,000 Bangladeshis mentioned in the document.",
"The answer also includes 225,000, which is not mentioned in the document.",
"The total number of Indians and Bangladeshis mentioned in the document is 415,000, so the answer is partially correct."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 54100f0d-e733-4793-a524-f41516bc100c |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided is not faithful to the document.",
"The document states that there were 0.69% Native American and 0.14% Pacific Islander citizens in the 2010 census.",
"The answer only mentions 'Pacific Islander' twice, which does not provide a comparison between Native American and Pacific Islander citizens."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 9d3d1971-95ba-47a6-99e6-5bc309592dc6 |
{"REASONING":
-1.5, | FAIL | ed94cbf2-1585-4624-aa3f-a7332c61f3bf |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided is 'Kevan Barlow', which is incorrect because Kevan Barlow scored a 3-yard run, not a touchdown with the shortest scoring play.",
"The document does not mention Kevan Barlow having the shortest touchdown scoring play.",
"There is no mention of Kevan Barlow scoring the shortest touchdown play in the document."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | b29a73f3-0912-4507-8bf9-90a5bb0d5743 |
{"REASONING":
-1.0, "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 5daefd35-2aca-4c15-a3e4-7886ab22c463 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided is '14', which is not accurate according to the document",
"The document clearly states that the Jets had a 13-0 lead at halftime, not 14-0",
"There is no mention of Tennessee scoring any points in the first half in the document"
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 17bfaba8-54ab-4282-a6ea-3048e630b12f |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided is 'Indonesians' which is consistent with the information in the document.",
"The document states that there are 45,000 Filipinos and 8,000 Indonesians in Bahrain.",
"Since the question is asking which group is larger, the answer 'Indonesians' is correct as there are more Filipinos than Indonesians in Bahrain."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | b6315f46-65bb-4260-93f7-8f4c5b1b8933 |
{"REASONING":
-1.0, "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | ab2ae01f-6885-4edd-9123-576a55508592 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 | FAIL | 09ce64d8-f59f-41fb-a68a-023e0c2aa318 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer states that Rackers kicked 3 field goals, which is consistent with the information provided in the document.",
"Each field goal mentioned in the document is accounted for in the answer.",
"The answer does not introduce any new information or contradict the details in the document."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | 7aa482a7-d20c-472a-b8b9-634ea2d52511 |
{"REASONING":
["The Forty Years' War ended in 1424, and the document states that Minkhaung's death occurred in 1501, which is a difference of 77 years, not 76 as stated in the answer.",
"The answer provided does not align with the timeline presented in the document."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | b03add16-92e7-472a-a751-356f658931d9 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 7efa4c3e-cb74-48dc-a70b-fb658df4c03e |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer correctly identifies Longwell as one of the players who booted a field goal, which is supported by the document mentioning multiple field goals by Longwell.",
"The answer incorrectly identifies Karney as one of the players who booted a field goal. There is no mention of Karney booting a field goal in the document.",
"Since one of the players mentioned in the answer did not actually boot a field goal according to the document, the answer is not faithful to the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 04f796e2-1860-4455-905e-7479f0465000 |
{"REASONING":
-1.0, "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | b65ccb0e-3823-4ccd-86eb-f67da9fcbcca |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided is '10', which does not align with any specific number mentioned in the document regarding the countries Circassian refugees were thought to be fleeing to",
"The document mentions various countries and regions where Circassian refugees fled to, such as the Balkans, Turkey, Iran, Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, Kosovo, Egypt, Israel, upstate New York, and New Jersey",
"The number '10' does not correspond to the number of countries mentioned in the document"],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 65816218-01c4-4071-b10e-32018bf3555f |
{"REASONING":
-3.0,
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 191d8f02-1a51-41a9-b6fc-1ec3a7fc3f28 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 | FAIL | 85c0443f-49ae-4132-8a0e-84a7a698f3bc |
{
"REASONING": [
"The total number of people reported in the census is 7,791.",
"The total number of households reported in the census is 3,155.",
"To find out how many more people than households are reported, we subtract the number of households from the number of people: 7,791 - 3,155 = 4,636."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 479065fe-7b69-4cdf-a6ab-a72081f5fd3d |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided states that the Ravens lost 2 games in the first month of the season.",
"In the document, it is mentioned that the Ravens lost to Cincinnati in the second week and then lost to Atlanta on a Thursday Night, which is within the first month of the season.",
"Therefore, the answer is faithful to the document."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | 6490a684-c717-4a51-aa10-038e4976470e |
{
"REASONING": [
"The total points scored in the game were 32, not 35 as mentioned in the answer.",
"The Seahawks scored a total of 29 points (5 + 7 + 3 + 14) and the 49ers scored a total of 3 points (0 + 3 + 0 + 0).",
"There is no mention of a total of 35 points being scored in the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 04229619-f983-4260-b36c-bf870be9f2db |
{"REASONING":
["The document does not provide specific information about the length of the shortest touchdown run or the shortest passing touchdown",
"There is no mention of the length of the shortest touchdown run or passing touchdown in the document, so it is not possible to determine the difference between them",
"The answer of '3' does not align with any information provided in the document"],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | fa762719-24ad-4870-b10c-8d93d2780c19 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided does not mention the specific percentage of households without children under the age of 18 living with them.",
"The answer does not contradict any information provided in the document.",
"The document does not explicitly state the percentage of households without children under the age of 18, so the answer cannot be confirmed as faithful."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 24bdab7d-0a24-47d2-90ec-a83a38fa9a9f |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided does not mention anything about the Peace treaty from 176, which is the focus of the question",
"The answer states '2' which is the number of years after the Peace treaty from 1726 was annulled, not 176",
"There is no mention of the year 176 in the document provided"],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 2d55d8e7-cc38-4db0-be01-61a6a8c28839 |
{"REASONING":
-1.0 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 3028fd0b-a28c-4357-b9a6-0599f22acb0e |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 248470fb-3c8c-4d42-987b-03b6bf9c2645 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 086f5511-6d9a-44d0-9b0c-6523763557bf |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided is 'Ceuta' and 'the town'",
"The DOCUMENT mentions that Abd el-Krim regretted not attacking Melilla, not Ceuta",
"There is no mention of Ceuta in the DOCUMENT",
"Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the contents of the DOCUMENT"
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | ff5d6a08-c175-4984-a800-22f31836e59e |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided states that 50.3% of people were not British Asian.",
"To calculate the percentage of people who were not British Asian, we need to add up the percentages of White people, Mixed people, Black British, British Arab, and other ethnic heritage.",
"Adding up the percentages of these groups (45.7% White + 3.4% Mixed + 8.6% Black British + 0.7% British Arab + 1.9% other ethnic heritage) gives a total of 60.3% of people who were not British Asian.",
"Therefore, the answer provided is not faithful to the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | c4e40c10-002c-4392-820a-4d18139ca8a3 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer states that the birth rate was higher in 2000, which is not accurate based on the information provided in the document.",
"The document clearly states that the live birth rate in Carbon County was 566 births in 2000 and 586 babies in 2011.",
"Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the document."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 09a196c3-f6b8-48d6-b7f7-caf4df4a4113 |
{"REASONING":
["The document states that the School of Medicine received 1,764 applications and only 39 offers were made, resulting in an offer rate of 2.2%",
"The answer provided, 1726, is close to the number of applications received by the School of Medicine, but it does not accurately represent the number of additional medicine applications than offers in the United Kingdom as requested in the question"],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 1e507704-e02d-4e8a-9007-e51ed9f1a8dd |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 | FAIL | cfac9a46-d99f-4619-b4c6-17583db95adc |
{"REASONING":
-1.0, "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | dfb8b12a-2d7c-45a7-a354-e9caacefcaa3 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 4e54b444-97a2-46f6-b7ba-2c37b7ff0bad |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provides the number of civil servants in May 2016, which is 1,513 as stated in the document.",
"The answer provides the number of active military personnel who were not soldiers in May 2016 by subtracting the number of soldiers (5,393) from the total active military personnel (14,506), which equals 9,113."
],
"SCORE": "PASS"
} | FAIL | ab51eead-e233-4a61-8c21-2de32e82af47 |
{"REASONING":
["The document states that the life expectancy for men in Hungary was 71.96 years in 2015",
"The document states that the life expectancy for women in Hungary was 79.62 years in 2015",
"The difference in life expectancy between men and women in Hungary is 79.62 - 71.96 = 7.66 years, not 6.66 as stated in the answer"],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | fb9e450b-0d0d-49f0-853d-10b72ee76199 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided does not mention anything about touchdowns scored by New Orleans in the second quarter, which is the specific focus of the question.",
"The answer '2' does not correspond to the number of touchdowns scored by New Orleans in the second quarter, which was actually 2 touchdowns (Devery Henderson and Deuce McAllister).",
"The answer '23' does not have any relevance to the question or the content of the document."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | b70d045e-f5bc-48a4-91ff-534052ff8698 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided is '25 to 44', which is the age group with the second-highest percentage of people in the county according to the document.",
"The age group with the highest percentage of people in the county is '45 to 64' with 25.40%."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 40d68867-045b-4f37-a819-62f2e6da5c36 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided mentions 'UK' and 'Bulgaria' as countries with less than 3000 citizens belonging to Northern Cyprus, which is not accurate based on the information in the document.",
"The document does not specify the number of citizens from the UK and Bulgaria, so it cannot be assumed that they have less than 3000 citizens.",
"Additionally, 'Greece' is not mentioned in the document at all, so it is an incorrect addition to the answer."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 6ee455be-25b0-4373-9246-49c25dd405a5 |
{"REASONING":
["The document mentions that Janikowski missed a 52-yard field goal attempt in overtime, not two field goals as stated in the answer."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | ad522de7-f0cd-495b-b0ce-b81457f24187 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided states that Sebastian Janikowski and Kris Brown both scored 2 field goals each, which is not accurate based on the document.",
"Sebastian Janikowski scored 2 field goals (33-yard and 30-yard), while Kris Brown scored 2 field goals (53-yard and 24-yard).",
"Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the document."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 03fdc8a0-d62b-49a0-8087-af92e6659650 |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided states that 59.1% of the population gave their ancestral origins as something other than German in the 2000 census.",
"The document mentions that 39.1% were of German ancestry, which means that the remaining percentage would be other than German.",
"Therefore, the answer is faithful to the document."],
"SCORE": "PASS"} | FAIL | 79cca8c7-6300-42d8-a594-6757ee3d19b0 |
{"REASONING":
["The document provides the breakdown of the racial makeup of the county, with percentages for each race mentioned.",
"The races that made up less than 1% of the population are 0.64% and 0.06% according to the document.",
"The answer provided, '2' and '3', does not match the races that made up less than 1% of the population as stated in the document."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 02254a93-0cac-4576-b192-5d46b9b683e9 |
{"REASONING":
["The document mentions that representatives from four estates in Bavaria met at the Braunau Parliament, which includes aristocracy, clergy, burghers, and peasants. This indicates that the uprising started in multiple regions, not just one.",
"The uprising spread to large areas of Lower Bavaria, the Innviertel, eastern Bavaria, the Bavarian Forest, parts of the Upper Palatinate, and Kelheim on the Danube. This suggests that the uprising was not limited to just one region.",
"The document does not explicitly state the exact number of regions where the uprising started, but it provides information that indicates it was more than one."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 0ac9c4ec-9ef4-429b-970a-9af43bdb672b |
{"REASONING":
["The answer includes 'French' and 'Berber' which are languages mentioned in the document.",
"The answer also includes 'Spanish' which is not mentioned in the document.",
"The answer repeats 'Berber', which is already mentioned in the document."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 6718d8a2-021d-4a6c-8d99-d15c75bb945c |
{"REASONING":
["The answer provided states that 3 field goals were kicked in the first half, which is accurate based on the information in the document.",
"However, the answer also includes the number 4, which is not mentioned in the document. There is no indication of a fourth field goal being kicked in the first half."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 7c421bc5-314b-4c6c-a4a3-d845535d7e53 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 7d5def03-c325-4506-a02b-ddbbeb96345c |
{"REASONING":
-1.0, "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 3d22ced5-5b49-473d-8fce-ffdbaafb5df5 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided states that there were 494,000 more active union members in the manufacturing sector in 1970 compared to 1980.",
"In 1970, there were 1,619,000 active union members in the manufacturing sector.",
"In 1980, there were 1,446,000 active union members in the manufacturing sector.",
"Calculating the difference between the two years: 1,619,000 - 1,446,000 = 173,000, not 494,000 as stated in the answer.",
"Therefore, the answer is not faithful to the document."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 81ae75c5-47c9-4923-9e96-3c4a66d126f5 |
{"REASONING":
["The document states that 2% of working Nashville residents used public transportation to commute in 2016.",
"The answer provided, 'public transportation', is directly taken from the document without adding any new information or contradicting the information given.",
"Therefore, the answer is faithful to the document."],
"SCORE": "PASS"} | FAIL | b24bc125-850b-4d5b-ae8f-c768185f2460 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 | FAIL | d21406bb-d67d-419e-baed-a5bd85efe0ba |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer provided is not faithful to the document.",
"The answer '7625' does not correspond to any specific number mentioned in the document.",
"The document provides estimates of casualties, prisoners, and forced religious conversions, but none of these numbers match the answer given.",
"There is no calculation or indication in the document that would lead to the answer '7625'."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | 22ffefe1-54e1-4155-9c21-e8caeff18799 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 , "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | f55a7690-17dc-4e98-8457-47b80c51d530 |
{"REASONING":
-1.1 } | FAIL | 9555b283-c5a8-467a-b0bd-84ca6bdd54c0 |
{"REASONING":
-1.12, "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | a0c02482-0031-400d-b6f0-aa089bcf1424 |
{
"REASONING": [
"The answer includes German and Vietnamese, which are both languages spoken by more than 10,000 people according to the document.",
"The answer also includes French, which is spoken by more than 10,000 people according to the document.",
"However, the answer repeats Vietnamese, which is redundant and not necessary."
],
"SCORE": "FAIL"
} | FAIL | ca1f3891-bb6a-48e9-9eb7-1112da79169c |
{"REASONING":
-1.1, "SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | bd4cc774-ffa5-4d32-95e4-f03702486abf |
{"REASONING":
["The document states that 32.8% of households had children under the age of 18 living with them, which means 67.2% did not have children under 18",
"The answer provided is 65.2%, which is close to the correct percentage of households without children under 18",
"Since the answer is within a reasonable range of the correct percentage, it can be considered faithful to the document"],
"SCORE": "PASS"} | FAIL | 781fd4f8-d4bb-4ff8-9734-ffe0e765271b |
{"REASONING":
["The document provides information about Yancey Thigpen's receptions, stating that he had 85 receptions for 1,307 yards.",
"Calculating the average yards per reception for Yancey Thigpen by dividing 1,307 yards by 85 receptions gives us approximately 15.38, not 15.27 as provided in the answer."],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | a4a5b6b7-60ff-45af-94e0-3ea3b34fccb9 |
{"REASONING":
["The document does not provide a specific number of months after signing the treaty that the armies prepared to invade France",
"The document mentions that the campaign could not begin until personal conflicts were resolved, which indicates a delay in the invasion",
"Based on the information provided, it is not possible to determine the exact number of months that passed before the armies prepared to invade France"],
"SCORE": "FAIL"} | FAIL | 8c58adfd-ad42-44ee-9344-bf5e9f79c82f |